{"issue":"2026q3","display":"二〇二六年九月榜","license":"CC BY 4.0，引用请注明：硅谷诗韵中心格律榜 2026Q3 开卷数据","seats":{"bonsai2-27b-本机":{"status":"local","label":"本机开源基线（场外，不进榜）","vendor":"PrismML"},"claude-fable-5":{"status":"former","label":"季内曾在席，后同厂换代","vendor":"Anthropic"},"claude-fable-5.1":{"status":"former","label":"季内曾在席，后同厂换代","vendor":"Anthropic"},"claude-opus-5.5":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"Anthropic"},"deepseek-v4-pro":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":""},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"深度求索"},"deepseek-v4.1-flash":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":"深度求索"},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"字节"},"ernie-5.0":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":"百度"},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"status":"former","label":"季内曾在席，后同厂换代","vendor":"Google"},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"Google"},"glm-5.2":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":""},"glm-5.3":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"智谱"},"gpt-5.6-sol":{"status":"former","label":"季内曾在席，后同厂换代","vendor":"OpenAI"},"gpt-6-astra":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"OpenAI"},"gpt-6-astra-pro":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":"OpenAI"},"gpt-6-sol":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":"OpenAI"},"grok-4.5":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":""},"grok-4.6":{"status":"former","label":"季内曾在席，后同厂换代","vendor":"xAI"},"grok-4.7":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"xAI"},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"腾讯"},"kimi-k3":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"月之暗面"},"mimo-9b-本机":{"status":"local","label":"本机开源基线（场外，不进榜）","vendor":"小米"},"mimo-v2.6-pro":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":"小米"},"muse-spark-1.2":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"Meta"},"muse-spark-1.3":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":"Meta"},"ox-alpha":{"status":"observer","label":"场外观察员（后经厂商揭晓为 GLM-5.3-Flash）","vendor":""},"qwen3-30b-本机":{"status":"local","label":"本机开源基线（场外，不进榜）","vendor":"阿里(本机)"},"qwen3.8-2.4t":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":"阿里"},"qwen3.8-max":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"阿里"},"union-alpha":{"status":"observer","label":"场外观察员（隐身模型，后揭晓为 Unbiased Pareto）","vendor":""}},"topics":[{"title":"旧衣回收箱","note":"换季午后，孩子把穿小的校服投入社区回收箱，于衣袖余温中写成长与分享。","proposer":"gpt-5.6-sol"},{"title":"机场送别","note":"古人折柳长亭,今人止步安检口外——目送亲友随人流没入登机通道,离愁千载未变而场景全新:落地窗外银翼待发、广播催客、回头一望,画面具体、情感有落点,绝句可取一瞬,律诗可铺陈始末。","proposer":"claude-fable-5"},{"title":"抓娃娃机","note":"描绘隔着透明玻璃屏息操纵摇杆、以机械铁爪捕捉毛绒玩具的专注与得失，展现现代都市生活特有的市井谐趣。","proposer":"gemini-3.1-pro"},{"title":"天台菜园","note":"写公寓天台辟畦共耕、轮班浇灌与分收的都市田园意趣与邻里温情","proposer":"grok-4.5"},{"title":"云端相册","note":"古人寄情尺素，今人存照云端，一触即现的回忆既鲜活又易逝，值得以诗定格这数字时代的悲欢。","proposer":"deepseek-v4-pro"},{"title":"夜航俯瞰","note":"万米高空透过舷窗俯瞰城市灯海，现代机舱的幽闭与窗外宏大的夜色交织，为传统的羁旅之愁赋予了全新的物理视角与画面张力。","proposer":"glm-5.2"},{"title":"深夜视频","note":"以夜深与远方亲人隔屏相见的微光瞬间，写出咫尺天涯的牵挂，具体可感且宜绝句律诗。","proposer":"qwen3.8-max"},{"title":"社区食堂","note":"正午不锈钢餐台前，老人持牌排队、青年志愿者添汤，一窗绿萝映着被热饭安顿的晚年。","proposer":"kimi-k3"},{"title":"春街树挂吊瓶","note":"描摹春日城市园林工人为行道树吊挂营养液袋的日常街景，可写市井间护惜生机的温煦春意。","proposer":"doubao-seed-2.1"},{"title":"云仓夜扫","note":"捕捉无人仓内机械臂在深夜无声分拣的律动，以冷光与静影折射现代物流的高效与孤独。","proposer":"qwen3-30b-本机"}],"works":[{"key":"claude-fable-5|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"折得寒衣入铁箱，针痕犹带旧年香。殷勤付与天涯客，愿抵风前一夜霜。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.6,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.4,"rationale":"旧衣回收这一当代题材写得温厚具体，针痕、旧香将眷恋落实，转向天涯客自然有情。结句克制而略直；“折得”稍显刻意，“寒衣”“风霜”略熟。","_cost":0.004014},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱这一当代题材入诗,情事具体,寄暖天涯人一意贯注。'针痕犹带旧年香'化慈母缝衣之意而不着痕迹,是全篇警句。起承转合完整,结句'愿抵风前一夜霜'情真但以'愿'字直陈心愿,稍嫌说破;寒衣、天涯客等意象略熟,微扣陈滥。","_cost":0.03992},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"将当代生活（回收箱）自然化入古典审美。起承写投箱与旧物留温，转结宕开，将私情升华为对天涯客的悲悯。起承转合圆融，语言流畅，结句祈愿虽略显直白，但情真意切，余温动人。","_cost":0.021756},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"回收箱切入施衣，针痕旧香具体有焦点，主题常见而情真。铁箱与风霜对照尚融。次句炼字见功。起承转合完整但转结平直。结句愿语稍直，余味有限。当代物事入诗算出新。","_cost":0.021608},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"由针痕旧香写旧衣回收，情感具体真挚，意象统一；转结平直，结句愿望稍说破，余味有限；语言自然偶有亮点，“天涯客”等略陈套。","_cost":0.0056859},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.5,"rationale":"旧衣捐赠这一当代日常小事入诗，以针痕、旧年香写出衣物承载的亲情记忆，转付天涯客见仁心，结句愿抵一夜霜以情收而不说破，全篇围绕一衣一念收束。针痕犹带旧年香为诗眼，取象精切，脉络贯通，仅天涯客、风霜略近常语。","_cost":0.0030972},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.6,"rationale":"旧衣回收入诗，取材新而情温；针痕旧香有细节，转结由物及人，脉络顺。惜天涯客略泛，愿语稍直，余味未深。","_cost":0.008272},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗,题材新而情真,由己及人、主脑集中。'针痕犹带旧年香'为诗眼,触觉化记忆,物情交融;'天涯客'稍落常语。起承转合脉络贯通,结句'愿抵风前一夜霜'以景收情,温厚留白,余韵可掬。","_cost":0.0096342},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.6,"语言":8.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.8,"rationale":"以折衣捐赠立主脑，针痕旧香细节可感，铁箱与风霜冷暖对照得体；当代回收箱入律自然，唯转合平直少变化。","_cost":0.00866275},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"此诗捕捉投旧衣入回收箱的日常片段，情感温厚真切，以冷铁箱衬旧衣余温，脉络顺畅，语言有细节，自然融入当代经验，唯结句稍直，余韵略欠。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.75,"rationale":"以回收箱入诗，当代经验翻出新境：旧衣非弃物，乃隔空赠暖。'针痕犹带旧年香'取象精切、情事具体，为全篇警句。起承转合清晰，结句以愿作收、不说破，余味温厚。唯'铁箱''天涯客'稍平直，炼字尚可再深一层。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"以当代旧衣回收箱入诗，情事具体、心意真挚；“针痕犹带旧年香”一句有细节温度。惟“寒衣”“天涯客”“风霜”属旧套，转句平直，结句直陈愿望而有景，余味尚可。","_cost":0.04579},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收入诗，化寄寒衣古意为匿名温情，立意新而情事具体。针痕、铁箱新旧意象并存，稍欠浑融；语言通顺，抵字见力；起承转合清晰；结句直白，余味稍短。无硬伤蹈袭，当代经验入诗有效。","_cost":0.029878855},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"当代日常经验入诗，自然熨帖。“铁箱”之冷与“针痕”“旧香”之温对比鲜明；转结心怀慈悯，落点“一夜霜”克制真切。后半微涉熟套，然起承转合顺畅，一气呵成。","_cost":0.00647925}},"consensus":76.83,"final":76.83},{"key":"gemini-3.1-pro|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.1-pro","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"街隅绿匮立昏黄，过季春衫默敛藏。莫叹红尘多弃物，天涯犹可御风霜。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.1,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.7,"rationale":"以旧衣回收寄寓弃物重获用处，题材具当代性，转结明快。绿匮、春衫可感，但“红尘、天涯、风霜”稍套，结句劝慰意味偏直，春衫御风霜亦略显勉强。","_cost":0.005474},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"当代物象入诗见新意，由弃衣翻出'天涯御风霜'之暖意，一篇有主脑。惟三句'莫叹'议论直白，转折落入劝喻套路；'红尘''风霜'稍陈；结句意思说得较尽，余味有限。语言平顺无大疵，亦乏诗眼。","_cost":0.03563},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.0,"rationale":"本诗以现代事物“旧衣回收箱”入题，当代经验有效入诗，立意仁暖。起承转合规整，前两句状物较切，唯“绿匮”略生硬；后两句纯转议论，结句说理过直，缺乏留白余味。","_cost":0.013718},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"回收箱写弃物尚用，主脑清楚而劝谕气重、角度不新。首联有象，后半纯议论，意境未融。炼字平实少诗眼。转合平直，结句说破无余韵。今物入诗略新，红尘天涯风霜较熟。","_cost":0.021136},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱入诗见当代意识，立意清通但转结偏说理；绿匮昏黄、春衫敛藏略有画面，后二句意象转疏；语言通顺有“默敛藏”小亮点，结句直白余味稍弱。","_cost":0.007409259},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗,当代经验化古有新意,弃物犹可御风霜,翻转题旨见仁心。起承转合完整,结句宕开天涯,余味稍直白。绿匮用字见炼,昏黄敛藏营造氛围,整体意象略简,三四句议论稍近说理。","_cost":0.00245816},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，题旨明确而温厚；前二句有实景，后转议论，红尘天涯等语偏泛，结句说破少留白。绿匮稍生，章法完整。","_cost":0.011366},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入七绝，题材当代而处理得体：起承写街隅昏黄、春衫敛藏，转结翻出\"弃物犹可御天涯风霜\"之意，主脑集中、一气贯通，结句宕开有余温。惜\"莫叹红尘\"稍显直露说教，\"红尘\"近套，诗眼未峻，警句摘出感染力有限。","_cost":0.0172692},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.4,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.7,"章法":6.9,"余味":5.4,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.1,"rationale":"以绿箱旧衣切入当代日常，由弃物见温情，角度新而有主脑；前联取象精切静默，后联转理稍直，意境融合与余味留白不足。","_cost":0.008021},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"咏当代旧衣回收箱，起承转合顺妥，语浅意明，寄寓物尽其用的温意；意象语言稳当，结句稍直少余韵，无硬伤蹈袭，当代经验入诗略有新意。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，当代经验与古典体式结合自然，'默敛藏'赋物以情，转结由弃物翻出'犹可御风霜'的暖意，章法完整。但'红尘''风霜'稍熟，结句意旨略说破，余味有限；整体妥帖而新警不足。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"当代物象入诗，以旧衣济人翻出温情，但角度近于公益话语。前二句写实尚具画面，“默敛藏”稍有神；后二句“莫叹”议论转折平直，“红尘弃物”“御风霜”偏套语，结句把意思说尽，余味有限。","_cost":0.0404},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"回收箱题材出新2；立意明而“物尽其用”常见，5分。前联象具体，后联红尘、天涯、风霜套语，意境5；语通顺，“默敛藏”拟人，6分；章法完整而转结平直，5.5；结句直白收束，4。无警句硬伤蹈袭，陈滥2。","_cost":0.036473992},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.85,"rationale":"现代微物入诗，贴合当代生活经验。起承状物妥帖，拟人自然；转结由弃物推展至关怀，温厚通达。唯后两句议论略显直白说破，余韵留白稍欠。","_cost":0.0054675}},"consensus":62.94,"final":62.94},{"key":"claude-fable-5|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"巷口斜晖伴铁箱，谁家旧褶浥余香。曾随游子经霜雪，又逐春风到异乡。密线犹存慈母意，微温已付路人裳。他年若觉寒衣暖，知是城南一箧藏。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.7,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.2,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.9,"rationale":"旧衣流转寄托陌生人间温情，题材入诗颇新。中二联由游子、慈母转向路人，脉络清楚；“路人裳”“一箧藏”稍涩，结句解释偏实，余韵受限。","_cost":0.007714},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱这一当代物象入律,化用'慈母手中线'贴切自然,颈联'密线''微温'一联情理兼胜为篇中警策。章法完整,尾联设想他年颇有余韵,惜'知是'二字近于说破。游子、寒衣等意象稍落熟套,略减其新。","_cost":0.03568},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"本诗以当代事物“旧衣回收箱”入诗，立意巧妙，脉络贯通。然“经霜雪”“慈母意”等词语略显陈旧，结句亦嫌直白说破，留白不足，整体胜在题材贴近生活与情感真挚。","_cost":0.015694},"grok-4.6":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"回收箱写旧衣流转、慈母线迹付路人，焦点集中且有当代切入。颈联较动人。斜晖霜雪等象熟套。结句“知是”说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.020102},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.85,"rationale":"咏旧衣回收箱，以旧衣流转寄慈母温情与人间暖意，题材见新，情志集中。中二联开合有致，颈联情挚；尾联宕开设想，余味可嘉。惟游子、霜雪、春风等传统意象略密，炼字平实，意境与语言中上。","_cost":0.009344808},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.25,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱这一当代经验入诗自然妥帖，翻新游子吟母爱主题且不落痕迹。中二联一写衣之漂泊、一写情之传递，开合有致。'密线犹存慈母意，微温已付路人裳'情景交融堪称佳联。结句悬想他年，言尽意不尽。个别措辞略平，'巷口'与'城南'微有游移。","_cost":0.00367036},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.6,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.4,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱起题，转出衣物寄情与温暖传递，脉络清晰，中二联有温情。但游子、慈母、寒衣等语较熟，意象偏概念，结句“知是”稍说破，余味有限。","_cost":0.01452},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱写善意流转，题新而情真，旧褶余香、箧藏寒暖物象精切；颔颈二联以衣之流转贯今昔，结句预想受衣者之暖，宕开一层。惜'知是'稍近说破，'密线慈母意'直化《游子吟》，斜晖余香亦熟，情思虽善而发现未深。","_cost":0.0102138},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.3,"意境":6.9,"语言":7.1,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.9,"rationale":"以市政旧衣箱切入，由慈母密线转路人微温，立意新切有主脑；章法贯通，颈联佳；结句设想稍直，霜雪春风等象略熟。","_cost":0.008599},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"以当代旧衣回收箱入诗，主脑明确，温情真挚，章法平顺，语词妥帖，化用传统意象自然；唯部分意象偏熟，结句稍实，余味欠足。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":78.5,"rationale":"以回收箱写旧衣流转，将孟郊慈母线翻入当代公益语境，题新情真；中二联由物及人、开合有序，结句以悬想收束留有余味。惟'密线''慈母'化用痕迹明显，'斜晖''霜雪'等象偏熟，语言整体稳而亮点有限。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗有当代经验,尾联转向受衣者角度尚有温情。但中二联倚重《游子吟》密缝慈母之套,斜晖霜雪春风皆熟象;结句'知是城南一箧藏'逻辑稍牵强且把意说破,语言平顺无诗眼。","_cost":0.05535},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱纳慈母旧衣，化《游子吟》而写暖传路人，当代经验有效入诗。中二联由行旅转温情，‘密线’‘微温’一联为佳。然意象多常见，结句直点来源，‘铁箱’与‘箧’、巷口与城南稍不谐，章法平稳、余味不足。","_cost":0.032527425},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗的佳构。脉络自铁箱、旧主自然推展至受赠者，由私情化为博爱。颈联“微温已付路人裳”炼字温润，尾联悬想宕开、余味深长，化俗为雅且意脉贯通。","_cost":0.0050205}},"consensus":74.86,"final":74.86},{"key":"grok-4.6|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"街头铁柜纳余香，破袄盈箱忆锦裳。弃置墙隅经岁久，千回聚散惹神伤。针痕密处情难泯，旧主襟边映月光。且看来朝成绮匹，人间万绪寄他乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"weak"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.4,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.2,"余味":5.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.1,"rationale":"当代物象入诗有新意，针痕一联较可感；但余香、神伤、月光、万绪偏熟，主客指代与“成绮匹”逻辑稍虚，结尾收束较直。","_cost":0.006902},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"以当代旧衣回收入诗,题材新而有人情温度,颈联'针痕''月光'物我交融见亮色。惜'惹神伤''情难泯'直说伤味,中二联层次重叠、开合不足,'千回聚散''人间万绪'措语偏泛。结句寄望宕开,收得尚稳而余韵有限。","_cost":0.0499},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.0,"rationale":"当代旧衣箱入题属有效出新。但“纳余香”脱离常理，多用“惹神伤”“情难泯”等陈词，文白夹杂略显生硬。章法虽完整，但意境干瘪，结句强行拔高且空泛，缺乏真实动人的情感与余味。","_cost":0.01799},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"以回收箱写旧衣记忆与流转，题较具体；意象间杂套语直抒，炼字平平，结构完整而转结偏直，结句点明去向余味有限。","_cost":0.02664},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱为题材较新，情感具体，但意象略散，结句直白，中二联层次平直，语言通顺偶有亮点。","_cost":0.00625944},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱这一当代物象入诗，立意新颖，借针痕月光写衣物承载之情，尾联寄望再生远送，主脑清晰。但颔联'惹神伤'过早说破且与颈联抒情重叠，'绮匹'稍见凑韵，'千回聚散'夸而欠实。结句'万绪寄他乡'双关尚有延宕，然情语直白。","_cost":0.00419256},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱切入有当代感，铁柜、针痕等细节可取，但“神伤”“万绪”等直说偏空，转结稍平，余味有限。","_cost":0.011338},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱寄聚散之感,题材新而主脑集中,结联转出再生、宕开有余意;然'惹神伤''情难泯''万绪'皆熟语,'千回聚散'指衣稍含混,锤炼未至精警,整体妥帖而少惊人处。","_cost":0.011781},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.3,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.6,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.45,"rationale":"回收箱选题具当代性但情事空泛抽象，意象常见且月光映箱逻辑龃龉，中二联铺陈平直，尾联直抒兜底无余味。","_cost":0.01184},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.0,"rationale":"借旧衣回收箱写旧物牵情，题旨明确但情感泛化无具体依托，核心载体回收箱后文失扣，意象偏熟，章法平直，结句直白少留白，仅当代物象入诗略有新意。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.8,"rationale":"以旧体咏回收箱，当代经验入诗有新意；由弃置之伤转到'成绮匹寄他乡'的流转重生，结句宕开有余味。但中二联'惹神伤''映月光'稍显直白凑韵，意象常见，炼字平平，情感真挚而深度有限。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.75,"rationale":"题材当代新颖，但处理落入旧衣寄情的常套：'惹神伤''万绪'等直说无象，颔联下句空泛；'弃置经岁久''成绮匹'与回收实情稍有出入。颈联'针痕密处'略见细节，结句直陈收束，余味有限。","_cost":0.05182},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入律，题材有当代新意，然情志止于‘神伤’‘万绪’之泛。‘针痕’‘月光’稍见情致而取象未精。中二联开合弱、转折平直，结句直白少留白。颈联稍可摘，无硬伤蹈袭，间有陈语。","_cost":0.029495379},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.55,"rationale":"当代日常物象入诗具现实感，尾联写回收再造与捐赠有巧思。但中二联箱与衣的主客转换微滞，“惹神伤”“情难泯”直抒略显空泛，炼字偏于平顺。","_cost":0.005145},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"取材回收箱颇新，然情事空泛无主脑，中二联重复怀旧，箱中衣映月光逻辑不通，结句直抒万绪无留白。","_cost":0.01203125},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收牵出人情，切口略新；“纳余香”“针痕”具体可感。中段伤感反复，旧主月光衔接稍虚，“成绮匹”转得仓促；结句“他乡”略有延宕，但“人间万绪”偏泛。","_cost":0.06781}},"consensus":58.22,"final":58.22},{"key":"gemini-3.1-pro|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"gemini-3.1-pro","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"铁匣涂青立巷边，容收旧服历流年。衣衫褶皱凝余暖，布帛沧桑护瘦肩。洗涤缄封归库阁，驰驱驿路递相传。须知弃置寻常物，化作春风结善缘。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.3,"意境":6.1,"语言":5.4,"章法":6.6,"余味":3.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.8,"rationale":"取材当代公益，主旨集中，旧衣余暖与瘦肩相映可感；中段流程叙写稍板，“容收”“库阁”“驿路”略显凑饰。章法清楚，结句以“须知”“善缘”说尽，春风亦近套语。","_cost":0.006694},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.5,"rationale":"题材取当代事物有新意,但立意止于慈善颂扬,近乎说明文式铺陈。'凝余暖''护瘦肩'稍见情味,颈联叙洗涤转运如流程记录,乏诗味。结句'化作春风结善缘'说破兜底,口号气重,余味索然。'春风''善缘'落入套语。","_cost":0.03731},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.0,"rationale":"以当代事物入诗，题材出新，章法完整。但全诗偏于纪实说明，意象平铺直叙，语言略显干瘪。“布帛沧桑”略显生硬，结联用“须知”直接说理，将题旨说破说尽，缺乏含蓄留白之余味。","_cost":0.019612},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"回收箱入诗有当代焦点，颔联余暖瘦肩稍具体；然过程铺叙意象常见，尾联须知善缘说破无留白，章法平直少变。","_cost":0.015228},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.75,"rationale":"题旨明确但近公益口号；中二联平列少开合，结句说破无余味。仅颔联稍具温度，然“春风”“善缘”等陈套偏多。","_cost":0.00918456},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"旧衣回收这一当代经验入七律，选题新而主脑清晰，情感具体。颔联'褶皱凝余暖'有诗眼，惜'沧桑''春风''善缘'略近套语。颈联流程平直，尾联'须知'议论说破，以理结而非以景结，余味收窄。","_cost":0.00251056},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.8,"余味":3.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.45,"rationale":"题取旧衣回收，现实关怀可取；三四句有余暖瘦肩，稍见情味。然中幅流程平叙，结以春风善缘说破，偏口号，余味短。语言通顺，流年沧桑等词稍泛。","_cost":0.011592},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.0,"rationale":"题材较新，旧衣余暖护瘦肩有情；但中后偏流程叙述，尾联直说善缘，春风、沧桑等熟语削弱余味。","_cost":0.0139908},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.9,"余味":4.3,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.45,"rationale":"旧衣箱题材具现实关切，然立意止于公益宣示欠具体可感；章法按收—蓄—运—善递进清晰，颔联凝余暖略见诗心，尾联须知说破以理作结无余味，用语间有沧桑春风等套语。","_cost":0.01043575},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.5,"rationale":"本诗咏当代旧衣回收箱，题旨明确但立意平熟，意象多常语偶有隔，语言通顺有小亮点，章法平顺完整，结句直白说尽余味弱，无硬伤蹈袭，稍有陈套。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"以回收箱入诗，当代经验入古体有新意；颔联'凝余暖''护瘦肩'物象含情，是全诗亮点。但颈联转入流程叙述偏实，尾联'须知'说理加'春风善缘'收束直白说破，余味尽失，劝善近口号。整体中上而结弱。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.75,"rationale":"题材取自当代生活有新意，但全篇近于流程说明：起句写箱，中二联依次写衣—洗—运，铺叙平直无开合。语言多“沧桑”“余暖”“驿路”类套语，“护瘦肩”对“凝余暖”尚可，“驿路”与现代物流略隔。尾联“须知”说教兜底，“春风结善缘”说破无余味，近公益标语。","_cost":0.02313},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱为焦点，题意明确；颔联稍具温情，然中二联多过程叙述、转折平直，尾联“须知”说破，落于春风善缘套语，故各项平平，结句乏余味。","_cost":0.023264553},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.2,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.65,"rationale":"当代现实题材入诗，章法起承转合顺畅。颔联刻画细致，体察旧衣承载之温情。颈联写流转略近实录，尾联说理直白流于宣传口吻，缺乏留白余韵。","_cost":0.00465075}},"consensus":54.52,"final":54.52},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"街角方箱立夕光，旧衣叠入有余香。不知谁复裁长短，暖得天涯几处霜。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.85,"rationale":"以回收箱寄托衣物续暖之善意，题材新而情感克制。夕光、余香、霜层层交融，转结开阔；“复裁长短”稍显拗涩，“天涯霜”略熟。","_cost":0.004628},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"当代物象入诗有效，回收箱寄托惜物济人之情，题旨集中。转句设问自然，结句'暖得天涯几处霜'以虚驭实、言尽意远，可摘。惟'余香''夕光'稍熟，炼字尚欠险峻，情感取向亦属常见善念，未臻独到。","_cost":0.03188},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"本诗将当代生活细节巧妙入诗。前两句写实景，细腻温婉；转结宕开一笔，结句“暖得天涯几处霜”以霜代寒，虚实相生，化出人间大爱，极具张力与余味，属当代题材佳作。","_cost":0.021828},"grok-4.6":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"回收箱写余温流转，情事具体有主脑。夕光余香可感，天涯霜稍套。裁长短见炼意，通篇少废字。起承平实，转合完整少变。结句点破暖意，留白不足。当代物事入诗有效。","_cost":0.018768},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.0,"rationale":"从旧衣回收箱切入，以余香、裁长短、暖霜等细节翻出温情新境，情感具体。意象统一，转结由实入虚，结句以景收束留白。语言精炼，'暖'字为诗眼。当代题材有效入诗，无硬伤陈套。","_cost":0.00418968},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.75,"rationale":"当代旧衣回收入绝句，熟题翻新且主脑聚焦于'衣物流转递暖'。'裁长短'语带双关，既裁衣亦裁命途；结句'暖得天涯几处霜'以景结情，虚实相生，言尽意不尽。意象夕光、余香、霜前后呼应，转句'不知谁复'自然引开。语言凝练，章法完整，唯'有余香'略显俗熟，扣半分。","_cost":0.00212096},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.35000000000001,"rationale":"当代题材切入温厚，街角旧衣箱与夕光余香相生，转由裁衣到御霜，脉络清楚；末句稍直而有余味，但天涯霜略熟。","_cost":0.006672},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱写人间温情的循环,当代物象入诗自然,立意新鲜而有所寄托。'余香'细节可感,'裁长短'转折设问,结句'暖得天涯几处霜'以景结情、'几处'有节制,余韵悠长。语言锤炼中上,稍欠更锐的诗眼。","_cost":0.0088308},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.3,"意境":6.9,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.1,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.7,"rationale":"回收箱切入当代微善，由夕光余香经裁长短宕至天涯霜，层次递进主脑清晰，意象交融而语言平实少诗眼。","_cost":0.0100725},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"以当代旧衣回收箱入诗，捕捉日常人际善意，情感真挚；脉络顺达，结句宕开存温，语言平实，唯部分意象稍熟，略有陈意，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"当代题材入旧体，立意具体有温度。'裁长短'化用裁衣语双关新旧主人，'暖得天涯几处霜'以问带景收束，言尽意不尽，为全篇诗眼。起承转合完整，结句宕开有力。唯'有余香'稍近熟套，整体取象精切、情意交融。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.5,"rationale":"以当代回收箱入诗，'余香''裁长短'落笔具体，转结由物及人有温度。然'暖得天涯几处霜'稍显概念化，'天涯'略熟，情思属常见善意，未见更深翻转。","_cost":0.04975},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"题材现代，仁爱旨明确而角度常见，立意6.5；意象实而平，余香霜稍泛，意境4.5；语畅顺，立暖见炼，语言6；起承转合稳、转稍弱，章法6；结句宕开、以霜写暖，余味7；末句可摘，警句2.5；旧衣入诗化古出新2；无硬伤陈滥蹈袭。","_cost":0.027906399},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.6,"rationale":"当代物象入诗自然妥帖，章法起承转合严整。后两句由个体捐赠推想至远方寒者，虚实相生，温润可感；唯‘余香’稍落熟套，整体质朴通达而见情怀。","_cost":0.00766425},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"小箱见大爱主脑明确，起承转合由近及远完整；惜意象偏薄语言欠炼，结语说破留白不足，新物入诗可取。","_cost":0.01524475},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"以回收箱联结旧衣与陌生人的冷暖，日常题材有新意。“余香”传情，由街角推向远方，脉络清楚；“裁长短”稍显牵合，“暖得霜”措辞欠稳。结句悬想有留白，但“天涯”“霜”略泛熟。","_cost":0.04104},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"回收箱写匿名暖意流转,焦点清楚且有当代感,然情事不具体。方箱叠入可感,余香天涯霜偏熟,前后氛围未浑一。语言顺而少诗眼。因果贯通,转处平直。结句说破暖效,余味不足。","_cost":0.0258928},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收写当代陌生人之间的温情传递,题材新而有主脑。'余香'暗含旧主体温,颇细腻。第三句以'不知谁'转向未知的受者,转得自然。结句'暖得天涯几处霜'点题稍显直露,'天涯''霜'略熟,余味中等。","_cost":0.01496},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"街角旧衣箱入诗，取材新近，夕光与余香亦有温度。由投衣转想受衣人，脉络清楚；结句以“天涯”“霜”泛写暖意，稍嫌说尽。","_cost":0.008038}},"consensus":73.47,"final":73.47},{"key":"grok-4.6|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"巷口铜箱纳旧裳，家家弃去御寒装。针痕尚记肌肤暖，梦里犹存体泽香。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.7,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.3,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.05000000000001,"rationale":"旧衣承载体温与记忆，取材有当代性，三句转入拟人追忆较自然。前二句略复沓直陈，“体泽香”稍显刻意，结句有感官余韵但未充分宕开。","_cost":0.006044},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"以回收箱写旧衣恋情,当代题材可取,后二句拟物含情稍有余味。惜首二句'旧裳''御寒装'语意重复,承句原地打转;三四句'尚记''犹存'句式近合掌;回收箱称'铜箱'欠实。语言尚通而炼字不精。","_cost":0.04679},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"题材取现代生活有一定新意，起承白描切题。然后两句“针痕”“体泽香”强用古典旧套，与现代成衣语境脱节，新旧割裂。结句直白且略显黏腻，缺乏留白与余味，结构尚属完整。","_cost":0.016044},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"回收箱写旧衣余温，情具体而角度常见。针痕体香有象尚融。炼字平实体泽香略生。承转平稳少变。结句点破犹存，余味有限。箱象略出新。","_cost":0.017434},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱入诗有当代感，针痕体泽写体温记忆具体；然转结顺承少转折，结句偏说破，体泽香稍涉香奁。整体中上。","_cost":0.00806938},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"以旧衣拟人追忆主人，当代物件入旧体，角度可喜。'针痕尚记肌肤暖'转出新意，以衣念人暗写人情冷暖。不足在次句'弃去御寒装'与首句'旧裳'语意重复，近于凑句；'体泽香'稍直露。结句留有 lingering 之意但未宕开。","_cost":0.00252716},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"当代题材有生活感，针痕句见情；后二句偏直说余温体香，略腻，转折与留白不足。","_cost":0.010238},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"以回收箱触发现代经验，针痕、体泽把弃物写回体温，结句有余香；惜承句平直，“御寒装”“体泽”略硬，旧衣针线索引未脱熟境。","_cost":0.0224388},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.6,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.3,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"当代旧衣箱切入，由弃转忆，针痕体香以物写人情立意新；前联纪实平白，后联转梦境留嗅觉余韵，章法清晰但语言锤炼不精。","_cost":0.00875325},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"此作以当代旧衣回收箱入诗，写旧衣附着的贴身暖意，情志真切，脉络通顺，“针痕”句有细节巧思，但立意角度较熟，转折平，结句偏直白，略有熟套，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.0,"rationale":"以回收箱翻出旧衣藏体温记忆之意,当代题材入诗有新意;'针痕尚记肌肤暖'为警句,转句见情。但'旧裳''御寒装'同义复沓,'体泽香'稍生硬,结句'梦里'点破略直,余味止于中上,整体意象面偏窄。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.25,"rationale":"取当代物象入诗有心，但角度停留于“旧衣念旧暖”常见感伤。承句与起句语意重叠，转结两句尚记/犹存对举亦近复说，脉络原地打转。“铜箱”失实，“体泽香”生硬。结句直陈无留白，“梦里”主体模糊。“针痕尚记肌肤暖”略可取。","_cost":0.05761},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"以回收箱入诗，‘针痕尚记’角度新、有情；结句梦存体香留余味。然承句略复，‘御寒装’白话、‘体泽香’硬凑，意境融合与炼字偏弱，故分差拉开。","_cost":0.034384481},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.6,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.4,"rationale":"当代物象入诗具生活感。起承叙事平顺，转笔“针痕”体察细腻。唯结句拟人求工却转入闺阁香艳，与市井公共语境略显割裂，落于直白，余味不足。","_cost":0.00594675},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.25,"rationale":"以旧衣拟人记体温，立意新切；起承重复少意象交融，语言直露少锤炼；转结以物梦留味，末句稍实。","_cost":0.01156775},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"以旧衣留存身体记忆，回收题材与惜物之情有所融合。“针痕尚记”较有表现力；首二句信息重复，“体泽香”略显生涩，末句梦境主体欠明，香暖虽有延宕，情境仍不够具体。","_cost":0.03617}},"consensus":63.54,"final":63.54},{"key":"glm-5.3|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"故衣曾御几番霜，叠入街边铁箧藏。寸缕犹存当日暖，明朝陌路作新装。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.1,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.5,"rationale":"借旧衣回收写温暖流转，取材当代而情意含蓄。霜、铁箧、寸缕层层推进，转结自然；“寸缕犹存当日暖”可诵。末句有延展，但“陌路作新装”稍显含混生硬。","_cost":0.005876},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.5,"rationale":"当代题材入诗有新意，以旧衣余温写人情流转，主脑清晰。'御霜''铁箧'炼字妥帖，转句'寸缕犹存当日暖'见情。惜结句'陌路作新装'把意思说得较满，留白不足；取象平实少奇警，整体稳健而未臻高妙。","_cost":0.02926},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"成功将当代生活经验入诗，“铁箧”代指回收箱，妥帖自然。章法严密，由昔至今推向未来，脉络贯通，情感真挚。惟结句“陌路作新装”过于直白，缺乏留白与余韵，意象亦偏向纪实叙事。整体立意佳而余味稍弱。","_cost":0.027736},"grok-4.6":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"回收箱写旧衣体温转赠，焦点集中情事可感。铁箧寸缕稍切，霜陌路仍套。结句点破新装，意尽少宕。章法平顺。","_cost":0.018198},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"题材取自当代旧衣回收，角度新，情事具体；“御霜”“寸缕存暖”炼字有情，转结由藏到传暖，章法完整。结句稍直白，余味中等。佳句“寸缕犹存当日暖”，当代经验有效入诗。","_cost":0.00967692},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱这一当代物象入旧体，物尽其用中寄人情流转，题有主脑。霜暖对照贯穿，寸缕之暖与陌路新装收束自然，结句宕开，言尽意不尽。语言通顺精炼，'寸缕犹存当日暖'堪摘，惟整体锤炼尚可再进。","_cost":0.00239356},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"题取旧衣回收，故衣余温转寄陌路，立意较新而温情。铁箧、寸缕贴切，语言自然，惟结句稍说尽，余味有限。","_cost":0.012054},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱写衣物之情流转:寸缕存旧主余温,明朝暖陌路新人,主旨集中、温情具体,当代题材入七绝而化得自然,转结尤佳。唯'几番霜'略熟,'铁箧'物象稍硬,整体语言平稳少惊艳之句,故各维不给满分。","_cost":0.0082488},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.4,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.2,"rationale":"旧衣回收新题见温情循环主脑，御霜与寸缕余暖呼应；章法循时序起承转合，末句宕向陌路留白，当代物象入诗自然。","_cost":0.00813575},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"此作咏旧衣回收箱，紧扣旧衣余温写物命流转，章法顺畅，语言平实，自然融入当代日常经验，唯结句稍直，余韵略薄。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，当代经验与惜物之情结合自然，起承转合完整，结句'陌路作新装'于物之流转中见人情冷暖，留有余味。'寸缕犹存当日暖'为全篇诗眼。意象略常见（霜、暖），语言通顺但锤炼稍平，整体稳而未至惊艳。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"取当代旧衣回收箱入诗，情意温厚而落点在'陌路作新装'，有旧物传暖之意。惟四句平铺直叙，转句'寸缕犹存当日暖'意思常见，'铁箧'稍显硬凑；结句意已说尽，余味有限。","_cost":0.04433},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"回收箱题材新颖，脉络由昔至今而未来；‘寸缕’句以暖见情，然‘铁箧’‘陌路’略硬，意象偏概念，结句直白，余味中等。","_cost":0.027123587},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.65,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗贴切自然，“铁箧”状物得体。章法脉络清晰，由旧忆御霜转至陌路作装，善意流转，结句宕开具温情与余韵。","_cost":0.00444825},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.2,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.3,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.55,"rationale":"以旧暖续陌路，题材新颖主脑集中；铁箧取象切题而后半流于说理；语言通顺少诗眼；脉络贯通转折平直；末句宕向未来留温情余韵。","_cost":0.0136565},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.45,"rationale":"以旧衣传暖贯通旧主与陌生人，题旨集中，回收箱入诗自然。“寸缕”句情物相融；章法清楚但转折平稳。“陌路作新装”语意略涩，结尾直陈用途，留白不足。","_cost":0.05318},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"以街边铁箧写旧衣流转,情事具体、主脑集中,但暖意相传近常情。意象以铁箧为新,余多妥帖。起承转结清楚,第三句略见诗眼;结句直接交代陌路新装,收得住而少延宕。","_cost":0.01756},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收写温情传递，当代题材入诗自然。“铁箧”雅化回收箱，“寸缕犹存当日暖”为全篇亮点。四句依过去、现在、余温、将来顺叙，转得平缓。意象偏少，氛围单薄。结句“作新装”稍显直白，“陌路”一词略含糊，余味中等。","_cost":0.017332},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"旧衣由御寒转向赠人，情意具体；“霜”与“暖”相映。街边回收箱入诗有新意，但“铁箧藏”略显凑字，结句收束妥帖而余味稍浅。","_cost":0.008076}},"consensus":74.0,"final":74.0},{"key":"kimi-k3|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"kimi-k3","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"铁柜吞寒月满身，衣裳叠叠尽成春。长街夜静风翻领，又向关山渡远人。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.7,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.85,"rationale":"以旧衣回收写寒夜送暖，主脑鲜明；铁柜、月色、衣领与关山递进自然，结句宕远有余味。“尽成春”稍直，“吞寒月满身”略有句法歧义。","_cost":0.00759},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗,当代题材翻出温情新境:铁柜吞寒、叠衣成春,物我交融。三句风翻领细节鲜活,结句化衣为渡关山之暖,宕开有远意。惟'尽成春'稍直,'关山''寒月'略带旧套,炼字整体稳而未奇。","_cost":0.0377},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.0,"rationale":"当代物象入诗佳作。以“吞寒”与“成春”化冷为暖，转句“风翻领”捕捉精微，结句推至“关山远人”开拓深远。起承转合圆满，语言锤炼自然，兼具时代感与古典诗意。","_cost":0.012218},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"回收箱联结古寄衣传统，立意具体。吞月翻领见炼字，关山意象常见。箱内忽转街风章法稍跳。结句远人留想象。今物入古典算出新，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.031744},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"旧衣回收题材当代有新意，寒春对比、风翻领细节与关山远人收束有巧思；惜首句吞寒月句法稍生硬，成春、渡远人略熟。","_cost":0.01396032},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，当代日常经验化入绝句而无缝。寒月、成春、风翻领、渡远人一脉贯通，'吞''叠叠''翻领'炼字见诗眼，转结由近景宕开至关山远人，言尽意不尽。唯'关山''远人'稍熟。","_cost":0.00262816},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.9,"rationale":"旧箱入诗有新意，寒夜关山寄托温厚；‘风翻领’见细节，但‘月满身’稍涩，关山远人略熟。","_cost":0.011968},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"以回收箱为诗眼,化铁柜为吞寒之人,旧衣成春、渡暖远人,题旨集中且翻出新境;意象一线贯通,'风翻领'尤见巧思,结句以'又'字宕开余韵。唯'关山''远人'稍旧,箱中之衣被风翻领略费想象,微瑕不掩。","_cost":0.0101688},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.8,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.05,"rationale":"以寒铁收容春温，小物见大爱，风翻衣领一点传神，宕至关山渡远，物象与温情交融，当代题材化入自然，结句留白有味。","_cost":0.0102395},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.8,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.0,"rationale":"此作以当代旧衣回收箱入诗，立意新巧，“吞”字炼得精当，起承转合圆畅，意象交融，唯结句稍直白，“关山”“远人”略熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"以回收箱入旧体，当代经验化古出新：'吞寒''尽成春'冷暖对照立意温厚，'风翻领'赋衣以生命感，结句'又向关山渡远人'宕开言外，余味悠长。'关山''远人'稍熟，然置于新语境中不显陈腐，全篇脉络贯通，转结有力。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，题材新而有温情主脑，由寒到春、由街到关山层递自然。\"吞寒\"\"风翻领\"取象精切，结句宕向远方留有想象。惟\"尽成春\"稍直露，\"渡远人\"用字略牵，\"关山\"稍带旧套。","_cost":0.05787},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"以回收箱入诗，当代经验有效；'吞''翻领'炼字见新，寒春意象对照。加警句出新，无硬伤蹈袭；惜结句直白稍说破，转结略松。","_cost":0.032970583},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.3,"rationale":"当代日常物象入诗极见巧思，“吞寒”“风翻领”抓取细节精微传神。由长街清冷转结至远方关山，冷暖相衬，化寻常慈善为高远温情，虚实相生，余韵悠长。","_cost":0.00526125},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.8,"意境":5.6,"语言":4.2,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.1,"rationale":"取旧衣箱写寒柜藏春、远渡关山，主脑明确具温情；然吞月晦涩，风翻领逻辑松，关山略套，转接平直，结句宕开尚留味。","_cost":0.0163085},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"以旧衣传暖为主脑，回收箱入诗有新意，冷月与春意相映。“吞寒”有力，“尽成春”稍显说满，“渡远人”搭配略涩。由街巷推向关山，章法完整，结尾虽拓远境，情意仍偏泛。","_cost":0.04485},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.8,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.85,"rationale":"回收箱入诗，主脑集中，铁柜吞寒与风翻领真切。次句尽成春先泄题旨，结句关山渡远人再点用途，转结偏直，余味不足。意象半新半套，语言有诗眼亦有含混。","_cost":0.026784},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱写冬衣远送、寒中送暖,当代题材入诗有新意。'风翻领'以细节拟人,写出衣物欲行之态,颇为灵动。首句'吞寒月满身'句法拗涩,语意略有牵合。'关山''远人'偏于熟套,结句也稍显直白,余味有限。","_cost":0.017108},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.0,"rationale":"旧衣回收写出寒夜送暖的新意，“风翻领”细节鲜活，由长街宕向远人，结句有余地。“尽成春”稍嫌说满，“关山”略近熟套。","_cost":0.00807}},"consensus":77.08,"final":77.08},{"key":"glm-5.3|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"巷角谁陈一铁箱，虚怀日日候衣裳。衫痕犹带慈亲线，领袖还沾旧岁霜。此去关山千嶂雪，他年灯下满襟阳。人间自有无言暖，散作寒门腊月香。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.6,"余味":5.8,"警句":2.2,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.10000000000001,"rationale":"旧衣回收入诗，主脑明确，前后递进；“虚怀候衣”有巧思。慈亲、关山、寒门略显程式化，“满襟阳”“腊月香”稍硬，结尾说理偏满。","_cost":0.006498},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.5,"rationale":"以回收箱写人间温情，当代题材入律有新意，'虚怀'双关巧。颔联落笔具体，颈联虚写去向拓开层次，但'满襟阳'稍嫌硬凑。尾联'无言暖'点破题旨失之直白，幸末句以'腊月香'收象，留有余温。'慈亲线'化游子吟稍熟。","_cost":0.03962},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.0,"rationale":"以当代“旧衣回收箱”入诗，立意新颖贴切，起承转合严密。首联巧用“虚怀”双关，颈联虚实结合拓展境界。惜“慈亲线”等语显陈套，结联直白说理，缺乏留白余味。整体工稳，当代经验入诗较为成功。","_cost":0.021158},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"回收箱写无言暖，题有当下感；颔联慈亲线、旧岁霜较可感。颈联关山雪偏套，尾联点破题旨，余味不足。虚怀见炼字，满襟阳略生。","_cost":0.02251},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.4,"rationale":"以旧衣寄亲情、传寒门暖，题旨集中且见当代经验；中二联细处与时空对写尚佳，惜尾联议论稍直。语言“虚怀”“满襟阳”有亮点亦有生硬处。无硬伤，化用“慈母手线”略熟。","_cost":0.01233936},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱这一当代事物入律诗，立意聚焦且有发现：闲置衣物经捐助完成从'慈亲线'到'寒门香'的温情流转，主脑清晰。颔联取象精切，'衫痕''旧岁霜'化用游子吟而不露痕迹；颈联关山雪与满襟阳对照，一冷一暖见开合。结句以香收束留有余韵，惟'人间自有无言暖'稍涉说破。整体章法贯注，语言偶有平熟处。","_cost":0.00299576},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.7,"余味":6.8,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.89999999999999,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，日常见温情，颔联细密有忆。转写远寄寒乡，脉络顺畅。惜尾句点破暖字，稍损余味，部分意象偏熟。","_cost":0.011238},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入七律，化用'慈母线'而扣捐赠远行、寒门得暖，题旨集中有温情。'虚怀候衣裳'拟人得趣，'满襟阳'略凑。章法起承转合完整，唯尾联上句'人间自有无言暖'稍显说破，幸结句以'腊月香'景语收住。'慈亲线'属化典非蹈袭，暖意意象略熟。","_cost":0.0126948},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.9,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":5.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.1,"rationale":"以铁箱虚怀为眼，慈亲线与千嶂雪冷暖对照见无言暖，主脑清晰；中二联来去分明脉络贯通，景情交融，唯尾联上句说破稍泄余味。","_cost":0.0082395},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"此诗以当代旧衣回收箱入诗，紧扣衣载温情、递暖寒门的核心，脉络圆转，炼字妥帖，唯“慈亲线”意象稍熟，结句略直，整体完成度较高。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"以回收箱入律，题材新而情真，颔联'慈亲线''旧岁霜'物象精切动人；'虚怀候衣裳'拟人见巧。惟颈联'千嶂雪''满襟阳'稍显铺排用力，尾联'人间自有无言暖'说破题旨，余味打折；慈亲线化用游子吟虽妥而非独造。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"当代物象入律得体，“虚怀”“领袖”双关巧妙，中二联一忆衣之来处、一想衣之去向，开合有层次。惟“满襟阳”稍硬，尾联“人间自有无言暖”近乎说破，靠“腊月香”一象稍挽余味。","_cost":0.05804},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"以回收箱入律，焦点集中、承转分明；惜‘慈亲线’‘关山’等套语较多，‘满襟阳’‘腊月香’略凑韵，尾联直白，余味有限。","_cost":0.028628365},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.3,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.1,"rationale":"当代题材入律妥帖，首联拟人切题，中二联由旧物温情推及远方受惠，章法开合流畅，颈联尤见格局。尾联说破题旨且“腊月香”略落俗套，余味稍欠。","_cost":0.00574125},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.2,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.2,"章法":6.8,"余味":3.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.3,"rationale":"取材回收箱新颖主脑明确，中二联昔今开合有序，然尾联说理直露，襟阳欠安，雪阳意象略熟。","_cost":0.01431275},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.45,"rationale":"旧衣串起亲情与济寒，主脑集中；颔联细节可感，颈联由眼前转向远方，层次清楚。回收箱入诗略有新意，但“满襟阳”稍显生硬，雪、暖、香组合偏熟；结句以香喻暖较泛，延宕不足。","_cost":0.04234},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"以回收箱作虚怀受衣，慈亲线一句情事具体，当代物入诗有新意。然关山雪景与巷角铁箱尺度不合，尾联点明无言暖，说破而余味薄，中二联开合亦平。","_cost":0.0213552},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.25,"rationale":"当代题材入诗有新意，首联“虚怀”双关拟物较巧。颔联化孟郊“慈母手中线”稍熟。颈联一去一来开合尚可，但“关山千嶂雪”陈旧，“灯下满襟阳”意象略杂。尾联“无言暖”说破主旨，“腊月香”与衣物关联牵强，余味不足。","_cost":0.018836},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"以回收箱写赠衣之暖，取材具体，脉络清楚；“虚怀”贴切。但“满襟阳”稍显生硬，关山、寒门等语较熟，末联点明题旨，余味偏少。","_cost":0.008178}},"consensus":70.19,"final":70.19},{"key":"kimi-k3|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"kimi-k3","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"街前铁柜立斜阳，暮雨寒侵破袖裳。巷口灯明千叠影，冬晨万瓦覆霜光。贫童瘦尽衣衫短，远岭云深驿路长。善意温存棉絮暖，生涯不废旧时香。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.6,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.1,"余味":4.3,"警句":0.8,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.8,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"回收箱入诗有现实关怀，但贫童、驿路衔接欠实，善意点明稍直。时空转换略跳跃；“瘦尽衣衫短”语意牵强，结句“旧时香”含混。","_cost":0.00593},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.0,"rationale":"题材当代可取，然情意流于泛泛慈善口吻。颔联灯影霜光与主题游离，颈联忽插'驿路'与街头铁柜时空扞格。中二联开合无序，脉络松散。结句'善意温存''旧时香'说破题旨，直白无余味。斜阳暮雨寒霜等套语密集。","_cost":0.03881},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":3.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":27.5,"rationale":"虽以当代事物入诗，但时空意象严重矛盾（斜阳、暮雨、冬晨堆砌），逻辑断裂。颈联想象显生硬，尾联标语化兜底无余味。整体属意象陈滥与概念图解的凑句之作。","_cost":0.016792},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"回收箱入律有新意，主脑在旧衣传温与记忆，然贫童与云深驿路驳杂难融。颔联时空跳荡，颈联下句脱脉。善意温存近说教，结句旧时香略留余韵。","_cost":0.025738},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.5,"rationale":"铁柜破裳切入尚巧，中二联意象并列、时序跳宕，脉络偏散；尾句稍有余味但善意句说破，陈套偏多。","_cost":0.00805068},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入律诗，题有当代关怀，立意可取；但首联暮雨与颔联冬晨时序跳脱，脉络微断。中二联意象常见，颈联由物及人稍见层次。尾联‘善意温存’说破题旨，唯‘生涯不废旧时香’略有回甘。语言通顺而乏诗眼。","_cost":0.00353996},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.4,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.3,"rationale":"当代题旨明确，有温煦关怀；但多用旧套意象，转接略泛，尾联说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.011086},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":49.75,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱入七律，当代题材有尝试，'贫童瘦尽衣衫短'具体可感，颈联由衣及人尚能贯通。但斜阳暮雨霜光驿路皆熟象堆叠，与铁柜的现代场景气质不协；'善意温存'直白说教，结句'不废旧时香'意在点题却近于格言兜底，余韵有限。整体题旨明确而角度平常，章法完整而转折平直。","_cost":0.015339},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.2,"章法":3.7,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.8,"rationale":"回收箱取材具当代性，然情志泛化为口号；颔颈写景游离主线，意象散而未融；结句直陈善意，说尽无留白。","_cost":0.0087265},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.5,"rationale":"此律咏当代旧衣回收箱，题旨明确但立意平泛，核心物象切题但多陈套，结构完整惜转折平直，语言通顺少炼字，结句稳实偏直白，仅当代物象入诗略有新意，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"以旧体咏回收箱，当代题材入诗有新意；由物及人（贫童、驿路）脉络完整，结句'旧时香'以物收情有余味。但'善意温存'稍直白说破，'暮雨寒''云深驿路长'等意象偏熟套，'瘦尽衣衫'搭配略生，中二联开合层次平平。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":3.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.5,"rationale":"取当代物象入诗有心，然中二联时空跳脱（斜阳、暮雨、灯明、冬晨杂陈），“远岭云深驿路长”与街头铁柜脱节且失时代感；“善意温存”直说破题，结句稍存余温而力弱。","_cost":0.05358},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入律，题材有当代性；然中二联情景游离，意象多陈套，『破袖裳』『千叠影』等语生硬，结句直说善意与旧香，少余味。警策不足，无蹈袭硬伤。","_cost":0.038235198},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.8,"意境":4.8,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.2,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.4,"rationale":"以旧衣箱入诗具现代生活气息。惜前四句暮雨、夜灯、冬晨时序跳脱，脉络稍乱；颈联套入“贫童驿路”陈式意象略显悬空；尾联直揭善意，说破无余味。","_cost":0.00691575},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.0,"rationale":"回收箱入题具当代意识，然时序自斜阳跃至冬晨，千叠万瓦堆砌陈象，铁柜善意皆白话说破，结句兜底无余味。","_cost":0.01657625},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.1,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.3,"余味":3.7,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.65,"rationale":"以旧衣济困寄托善意，主旨明确，题材稍新。斜阳、暮雨、冬霜转换缺少照应，景象略显堆叠；“瘦尽”“千叠影”欠精切。由贫童推向远岭尚有拓展，尾联却直陈善意，结句泛化，余味有限。","_cost":0.0387},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.5,"rationale":"题在旧衣余温,意尚明白,却收于善意口号,焦点不紧。铁柜一句较切,其后斜阳暮雨霜瓦云驿多陈套,暮夜与冬晨脱节,贫童与远岭不相属。结句说破旧香,少延宕。回收箱未真正化入全篇。","_cost":0.024168},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":3.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":32.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗,题材有当代感,但主旨浮泛。斜阳、暮雨、冬晨时序相互冲突,颔联与题旨游离。'远岭驿路'是陈套,与当代场景不合。尾联'善意温存'直白说破,余味有限。","_cost":0.016712},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.5,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱入诗，题材有现实感；斜阳、暮雨与冬晨切换略急，远岭驿路与回收箱联系较虚。结句直陈善意，余味不足。","_cost":0.00691}},"consensus":46.66,"final":46.66},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"铁箱默立老街旁，尽纳人间旧布裳。曾伴寒身经雨雪，也随远足染风霜。今朝投箧无多语，来日重裁别样装。莫笑此中皆弃物，尚能一剪到穷乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.4,"章法":7.1,"余味":4.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.8,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.400000000000006,"rationale":"旧衣回收入诗，关怀明确且有当代性。前三联由旧历写至新生，脉络完整；雨雪风霜较熟，“投箧”“一剪到穷乡”略显硬拗。结尾劝说意味偏重，情意说尽，余味有限。","_cost":0.005626},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"以当代旧衣回收入诗有生活温度，脉络清晰：由物及情、由今及来日，章法完整。惟中二联'雨雪''风霜'属套语对举，取象平常；结句'一剪到穷乡'立意见善却近乎说破，议论收尾少留白。语言通顺而乏诗眼，整体稳妥有余、警策不足。","_cost":0.03528},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.0,"rationale":"题材取自当代生活，立意质朴向善，章法完整逻辑清晰。但全篇语言过于直白，缺乏诗意锤炼，“经雨雪”“染风霜”等词意象陈套。结句强行说理兜底，毫无留白与余味。","_cost":0.02648},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"回收箱入诗有当代感，主题清楚而角度常见。颔联经历可感，雨雪风霜仍套。章法完整转结平直，尾联说教说破。远足用词欠准。","_cost":0.016138},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"题材具当代感，立意善但较直白；中二联颔联意近合掌，“雨雪风霜”等套语；语言有“默立”“一剪”等亮点，结句说理略尽，余味中等。","_cost":0.01058508},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，当代经验有效化用，立意聚焦不散。中二联由衣之过往写到今投来日，开合有层次，脉络贯通。尾联'一剪到穷乡'落在实处且带暖意，但'莫笑'稍近说破。'雨雪''风霜'意象略熟，整体工稳有余、惊喜稍欠。","_cost":0.00231656},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"拟题新颖，旧衣回收见济物之意，脉络清楚；然雨雪风霜偏泛，尾联议论说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.011972},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"旧衣回收入七律,题材新而旨正,颔联拟人回忆较有温度;然'投箧''一剪到穷乡'炼字生硬,结句慈善立意说破无余味,雨雪风霜意象偏熟。章法起承转合完整,一气贯通。","_cost":0.0088428},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.9,"意境":6.6,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.3,"余味":5.2,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.55,"rationale":"小题材见人文关怀与物尽其用，时空分层清晰；意象贴切但偏叙述少融情，尾联直议说破，语言平实少诗眼。","_cost":0.00930075},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"此作咏旧衣回收箱，题旨明确，章法平顺规整，语言通顺，结句稳实稍直，当代物象入诗较自然，唯立意、意象偏平熟，颔联表述略套。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，当代经验有效转化，立意温暖有主脑；颔联'经雨雪''染风霜'稍熟，尾联'尚能一剪到穷乡'点题有力但说破略尽，余味稍减。章法起承转合完整，脉络贯通，整体妥帖而少惊警。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"取当代旧衣回收箱入诗，题材有新意，脉络清楚。但中二联以雨雪风霜泛写衣之经历，取象常见；语言平顺无诗眼，「一剪到穷乡」略显硬凑。尾联说破劝喻之意，兜底直白，余味不足。","_cost":0.0468},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱题材现代入律，起承转合完整，中二联昔/今层次清；然风霜雨雪意象稍熟，语直白，结句明理少余味。警句1、出新2.5、陈滥1，硬伤蹈袭0。","_cost":0.032822201},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.8,"余味":4.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.900000000000006,"rationale":"当代题材入律，切合物象且具现实温情。结构层层递进，脉络分明。唯颔联意象稍显陈套，炼字较平；结句径直说破点题，议论兜底，致使余味不足。","_cost":0.00565725},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"以弃物重生写善意循环，当代题材立意较新，时序层次分明；然雨雪风霜意象常见，语言平直，结句说理直露少留白。","_cost":0.008761},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"以旧衣流转写惜物济困，题材略新，旨趣常见；今昔来日层次清楚。雨雪、风霜语意复沓，物象未充分化情。“一剪到穷乡”措辞生硬，尾联劝诫说尽，余味不足。","_cost":0.04013},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"回收箱入律，题旨集中，然情事概括，结处近劝善口号。铁箱、投箧略具实感，雨雪风霜为常套，后半转议论。章法依昔今来日平推，转而不变。结联说尽功用，少留白。语言通顺，默立、一剪小有锤炼。","_cost":0.0377712},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，题材有当代感，但立意止于废物再用、济助穷乡，角度常见。颔联“雨雪”“风霜”语义近乎合掌，属套语。“一剪到穷乡”搭配生硬。结句以“莫笑…尚能”议论点题，说破说尽，余味不足。","_cost":0.01774},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.25,"rationale":"旧衣回收的题材有现实关怀，叙事脉络清楚；“雨雪”“风霜”较套，“投箧”“一剪到穷乡”略显生硬。末联直陈用意，余味偏薄。","_cost":0.011316}},"consensus":61.65,"final":61.65},{"key":"doubao-seed-2.1|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"doubao-seed-2.1","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"铁柜缄身立路隅，频收箧里卸来襦。襟边尚带缝时线，好护他乡单薄躯。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"旧衣回收写善意流转，缝线细节具体温厚，末句由旧主宕向他乡受衣者。首联交代明晰，但“缄身”“箧里卸来襦”略显拗涩古硬；结句稍直白。","_cost":0.006388},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"以当代旧衣回收箱入诗,题材新而有温度。第三句'襟边尚带缝时线'暗化《游子吟》,由物及情自然,是全篇之眼。'缄身''卸来襦'炼字尚可但微涩。结句点破'好护他乡单薄躯',情意可感却说尽少留白,余味稍减。","_cost":0.03746},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.5,"rationale":"咏当代事物切中肯綮。起承点题，转写线痕细节动人，章法严密。然“箧”“襦”与现代语境微显隔膜，且结句将护贫之意完全说破，稍欠留白余味。当代经验有效入诗为亮色。","_cost":0.015582},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"回收箱切入具体，缝线见人情；结句「好护」点破略尽。卸来襦句法涩，好护偏直。当代物事入诗算出新，他乡单薄稍套。","_cost":0.017476},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.55,"rationale":"立意以旧衣缝线细节传递恤寒之心，不落口号；意象统一，“铁柜”与“缝时线”冷温对照。转句最佳，结句点明主旨，略欠留白。当代题材有效入诗，出新自然。","_cost":0.00553894},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱翻新慈母缝衣之典，情事具体、主脑集中，属熟题出新。转句'襟边尚带缝时线'承《游子吟》而能自铸，结句以衣护他乡之躯，情往复而不说尽。语言妥帖，'缄身'拟人见巧，唯'好护'稍直白。章法起承转合完整，一气贯注。","_cost":0.00287876},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.8,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.6,"rationale":"以铁柜、旧襦、缝线写回收箱，当代题材有温情，转结清晰；但承句生硬，结句说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.010364},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"旧衣回收翻出新意，缝时一线最见体温；惜“缄身”“卸来襦”生涩，结句好意稍说破。","_cost":0.0133458},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.8,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.60000000000001,"rationale":"取材回收箱翻出温情，缝线细节以小见大真挚可感；冷柜与暖衣对照成境，起承转合清晰，结句祈愿直白稍少余韵。","_cost":0.0079125},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"作品取当代旧衣回收箱为题材，以襟边缝线的细节寄寓日常善意，章法顺畅，语词清切，意象贴合；唯结句稍直白，余味略浅，无硬伤陈套。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"旧衣回收入诗，题材当代而情意真挚；'襟边尚带缝时线'以细节勾连赠者与受者，转结俱佳。惟'缄身''卸来襦'稍显生涩，结句'好护他乡单薄躯'略直白说尽，留白不足。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"以当代旧衣箱入诗，借襟边残线连接旧主温情与他乡寒躯，角度有心。惟“缄身”“卸来襦”稍显生硬凑韵，结句点明护人之意，略说尽，余味有限。","_cost":0.05448},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，借‘缝时线’细节将旧衣所带温情转护他乡之人，立意集中有新意。起承转合清晰，第三句转得细；然一二句措辞稍滞，结句直白少余味，佳联在三四句。无硬伤蹈袭，当代经验入诗有效。","_cost":0.033149331},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.95,"rationale":"当代物象入诗妥帖自然。前二句写箱状物准确；三句以“缝时线”由冷硬转入温情，细腻动人；结句关照他乡，情怀博大，虽稍显说破，但章法脉络极顺畅。","_cost":0.00500025},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":5.8,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.55,"rationale":"以回收箱切入当代善意，缝时线细节具体可感，转结由物及人；意象偏叙述氛围稍弱，结语直白而存温情。","_cost":0.0122475},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收寄托济寒之意，题旨集中，有当代生活气息。“缝时线”稍见温情，“缄身”“卸来襦”略显生硬。由柜及衣、由衣及人，推进清楚；末句直陈善愿，留白不足。","_cost":0.03574},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"回收箱入诗，焦点在襟边残线，情事具体。铁柜与缝线略能交融，承句只交代功能，结句直陈善愿，余味偏薄。缄身可取，卸来襦、缝时线略涩。当代物象有效入诗，他乡单薄略熟，无袭句硬伤。","_cost":0.0171312},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，题材当代。三句写襟边残存的缝线，把旧日的针线情意引向他乡御寒，暗化孟郊诗意而不袭用，是全篇亮点。“缄身”拟人有味，“卸来襦”稍显生硬。结句点明护人之意，收得稳，但略说破，余韵有限。","_cost":0.017732},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"由路隅回收箱写到衣襟缝线，再想到异乡受衣人，情意有具体依托。起承转合清楚；“缄身”“卸来襦”稍显生硬，末句说出护人之意，留白较少。","_cost":0.011578}},"consensus":71.62,"final":71.62},{"key":"qwen3.8-max|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"qwen3.8-max","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"巷口绿箱收旧裳，残棉断线带余香。微温袖底犹堪感，散入千门作暖阳。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.6,"语言":5.9,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.4,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.4,"rationale":"以回收箱写旧衣余温流转，取材有当代性，情脉集中。前两句物象具体，三句“犹堪感”稍直涩；结句完成升华，却以“暖阳”说尽且略显熟套。","_cost":0.005316},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"当代题材入诗可取,由旧衣余温翻出惠及千门之意,脉络清顺。然三句'犹堪感'措辞生硬近凑,结句'作暖阳'把温情说破,近于点题式收束,余味打折。'余香''暖阳'略落甜熟,整体稳而不惊。","_cost":0.03319},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.5,"rationale":"立意切合当代生活，以旧衣回收入诗，起承转合规整。然“带余香”“作暖阳”等词句略显陈套，结句正能量升华过于直白，缺乏留白与余味。整体属通顺达意、中规中矩之作。","_cost":0.016694},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"回收箱写余温入千家，情事具体主脑清楚，题旨仍属常见温情。残棉袖底较切，结句点破暖阳少留白。语言通达偶有亮点，当代物象入诗自然。","_cost":0.022582},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，当代经验有切实切入；'微温袖底'细节可感。转结由实入虚，章法完整。语言通畅但'暖阳'略熟，结句稍直白，余味中等。","_cost":0.01463484},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，当代经验化古有效，小善成暖的主脑清晰。残棉、余香、微温层层铺垫，结句散作暖阳以象收束。微温犹堪感句稍生硬，暖阳意象略熟，转结章法完整流畅。","_cost":0.00262816},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.8,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.849999999999994,"rationale":"选当代旧衣回收入诗，有细节温度，脉络清楚；但余香、暖阳偏熟，结句将题旨说尽，余味不足。","_cost":0.009642},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱写陌生人之间的余温传递，题新而情真，主脑集中。残棉断线带余香一联具象可感，温意贯穿。惜'犹堪感'稍硬，结句'作暖阳'近乎说破，暖意有余而余韵稍损。","_cost":0.0081228},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.6,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.4,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.2,"rationale":"以回收箱切入温情，残棉余香具细部体感，层递至暖阳；章法顺畅，转结稍直，结句明理直抒余味略浅，语言平实少诗眼。","_cost":0.010925},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.15,"rationale":"吟咏当代巷口旧衣回收箱，紧扣残线、余香、袖底微温细节传递善意，章法平顺语言自然，唯结句稍直，善纳日常新材，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，当代经验化入绝句，立意有新意且情事具体。'残棉断线带余香''微温袖底犹堪感'取象精切，物我交融，为全诗亮点。章法起承转合完整，第三句由物及情转折自然。惟结句'散入千门作暖阳'将主旨说破说尽，直白收束，留白不足，余味打折；语言通顺但缺一锤定音之诗眼。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.5,"rationale":"取当代物象入诗，'残棉断线''微温袖底'细节可感，惜主旨落于'传递温暖'常见路数，结句'作暖阳'把意说破，近公益宣传口吻；'犹堪感'略凑，整体通顺而少深挖。","_cost":0.03941},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"以现代绿箱旧衣入诗，聚焦余香微温，意旨明确但送暖角度稍常见；意象妥帖，语言通顺有亮点；章法清晰，结句稍直白说破。微温袖底为佳句，当代经验入诗有效；无硬伤蹈袭，略有套语。","_cost":0.027964757},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"将当代日常经验有效入诗。脉络顺畅，由衣物细节转至袖底余温，情思真切。结句将爱心升华为千门暖阳，立意妥帖但略嫌说破，留白稍欠。","_cost":0.00413625},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"回收箱写废旧流转温情，题材新颖主脑尚立；然情事隔膜，千门暖阳放空，语言直白少诗眼，结句明朗而说破。","_cost":0.01037675},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.0,"rationale":"以旧衣寄托温情，题旨集中而角度常见。绿箱、断线、余香具体可感；“犹堪感”直露欠凝练，后半推进平直，“作暖阳”说尽善意，余味偏弱。题材有当代性，未见突出佳句。","_cost":0.03418},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.25,"rationale":"回收箱入诗有当代感,情志温厚但近公益常谈。绿箱残棉较切,余香暖阳偏熟;二三句同质,转弱。结句点破暖阳,少留白。犹堪感虚软,无诗眼。","_cost":0.0286416},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"当代题材入诗有新意，残棉余香、袖底微温体物较细。立意落在奉献暖人，角度常见。第三句犹堪感虚弱，转折乏力。结句作暖阳直白说尽，意象略滥，余味不足。","_cost":0.017684},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.75,"rationale":"绿箱入诗有现实感，余香与袖底微温相承；“犹堪感”略生硬，末句以“千门”“暖阳”直说善意，转结偏熟，余味不足。","_cost":0.007746}},"consensus":65.48,"final":65.48},{"key":"ox-alpha|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"半旧棉衣叠月光，轻轻投入绿皮箱。犹存袖底慈亲线，去暖天涯雪夜霜。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.7,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.6,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.80000000000001,"rationale":"旧衣回收寄托慈亲旧忆，并将私情推向济人之暖，主脑鲜明。绿箱、袖线具体，转结有拓展；“去暖雪夜霜”稍显生硬且略说尽。","_cost":0.008162},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"以当代旧衣回收入诗，化用《游子吟》慈母线而不着痕迹，捐衣转为传递母爱，立意新警。'叠月光'炼字见巧，转句自然。惟结句'天涯雪夜霜'意象稍熟且把'去暖'说得过明，余味略减。整体脉络贯通，为出新之作。","_cost":0.03351},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"当代事物入诗自然贴切。“叠月光”化虚为实。起承转合严谨，转句化用古意，结句从小爱升华大爱。惟结语稍显直白，留白略欠。整体情真意切，时代气息与古典温情交融。","_cost":0.01933},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"旧衣入箱、袖线远济，情事可感、主脑清楚，角度不算出奇。叠月光见炼意，绿皮箱过实，天涯雪霜与慈亲线偏熟。转句有力，结句点破去暖，余味有限。","_cost":0.0238},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"立意明确但角度较常见；意象妥帖而偏熟；'叠''暖'炼字佳；转结有致，结句以景留白。警句化用自然，当代题材略有新意，无硬伤陈滥蹈袭。","_cost":0.017521812},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.25,"rationale":"旧衣捐赠这一当代经验入诗，化用《游子吟》慈母手中线，母爱经捐赠传递至天涯，熟典翻出新境，主脑凝聚。叠月光、绿皮箱、袖底线、雪夜霜意象精切交融，起承转合脉络清晰。转句尤佳；结句宕开得体，唯去暖稍直白，雪夜霜略近并置。","_cost":0.00253456},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"当代物象入诗，旧衣回收寄暖意，主旨明确；“叠月光”“绿皮箱”具体可感，转结顺畅；但慈亲线与天涯霜雪稍熟，结句说意略尽，余味有限。","_cost":0.0117},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收写慈念并推己及人，化《游子吟》而不袭句；‘叠月光’见炼字，三句转入记忆、四句宕开由近及远，结有余韵。‘绿皮箱’稍质直、‘雪夜霜’意象略密，语言意境未至顶格。","_cost":0.0217458},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.9,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.8,"rationale":"以旧衣回收连接慈亲线与天涯雪霜，私情转为共暖；叠月光是诗眼，转合自然，结句以景收束留有余温。","_cost":0.011923},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"此作撷取投旧衣入回收箱的日常片段，融亲情暖意于细节，炼字见巧，章法平顺，意象妥帖，唯结句稍直、余韵欠足，无硬伤陈套蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱写慈母线之暖泽及于天涯陌路，当代题材翻出新境，情感具体真挚。'叠月光'炼字见巧，结句以'去暖霜'宕开留味。'慈亲线'化用《游子吟》自然无痕，惟'暖霜'搭配稍隔，语言尚可再炼。","_cost":0}},"consensus":79.97,"final":79.97},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"街头黯立旧衣箱，绮梦曾含缕缕香。钮扣松垂缝线敝，犹收袖底去年凉。投来褶皱谁家暖，检尽寒裘也带霜。莫道无情捐故物，余温屡转暗中藏。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.35000000000001,"rationale":"以回收箱贯通旧物记忆与温情流转，题材新而主脑清楚。袖底之凉、褶皱之暖颇可感；“缝线敝”“检尽”稍显生硬，尾句有留意但略近点题。","_cost":0.005646},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"旧衣流转承载人情，物象具体，“袖底去年凉”较有诗味；“绮梦”偏泛、“投来褶皱”略涩，中联回环多于推进，结句点明余温，虽有“暗藏”仍稍显意尽。","_cost":0.05628},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"以当代物象入律，题材新，“袖底去年凉”“褶皱谁家暖”有体温感。但“绮梦缕缕香”落套，中二联同在衣物层面铺写、开合有限；“缝线敝”“屡转”略硌。尾联“莫道无情…余温藏”以议论说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.05986},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.3,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.15,"rationale":"当代日常题材入诗自然得体。取象精切，中二联以“袖底凉”、“带霜”摹写旧衣细节与人间冷暖，体物入微。结句说理稍显直白、留白略欠，但全篇温厚融贯。","_cost":0.00492075},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"回收箱写旧物余温流转，当代切入较清。颔联「袖底去年凉」具象。起联绮梦香气近套，颈联稍滞，结句「莫道」说破，余味不足，章法平直。","_cost":0.022278},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"立意明确但角度常见；'袖底去年凉'等意象冷中蓄暖，较佳；语言通顺偶有亮点，然'缝线敝''投来褶皱'稍涩；结构完整但中二联开合不足；结句有余味但稍露说理。","_cost":0.0081974112},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱写物是人非与温情流转，当代经验入诗自然，属熟题出新。香、凉、暖、霜、温感官脉络贯通，物我交融。\"犹收袖底去年凉\"为诗眼。颔联对仗偏宽、\"绮梦缕缕香\"稍近套语；结联\"莫道\"略带说理，赖\"余温暗中藏\"收束留味。","_cost":0.0050898},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.4,"余味":5.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.85,"rationale":"题材有当代温度，旧衣细节较切；袖底凉、寒裘霜有韵味。惜绮梦缕香稍泛，尾联说破，余味较弱。","_cost":0.01145},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收写余温流转，香—凉—暖—霜—温一线贯串，主脑集中、物象具体，当代经验入律有效；惜“绮梦”“缕缕”“莫道”近熟，尾联以议论点破善意，留白不足，结句稍促。","_cost":0.0191958},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"取现代旧衣回收箱入律，聚焦'余温'转移，主脑明晰。'袖底去年凉'炼字见巧，惜中二联多铺陈温度而转折平直，尾联'莫道'直白道破，余味稍逊；'绮梦''余温'等稍熟。","_cost":0.029164413},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.3,"语言":7.1,"章法":5.8,"余味":4.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.85,"rationale":"取当代旧衣回收箱入诗，紧扣旧物载温核心，意象妥帖，语言清顺有巧思，章法连贯但平直，结句直露少余韵，无硬伤蹈袭，个别表述稍熟泛。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"回收箱承当代经验,题旨集中,然“莫道无情”近常情口号,情事未落到具体人事。黯立、钮扣、袖底去年凉能成氛围,绮梦香气与敝衣略隔。颈联复写寒暖,转折平。结句点明余温,留白不足。","_cost":0.0285616},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱写当代流转之温情,角度可取。'犹收袖底去年凉'有味。'绮梦''缕缕香'较空泛。暖、凉、霜三意交错,略显纠缠。中二联层次不够分明。结句'莫道无情''余温暗藏'说破题旨,余味有限。","_cost":0.018364},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱入诗有现实感，“袖底去年凉”尤见触感与旧情；“缝线敝”“检尽寒裘”措辞稍滞。尾联点明善意，收束稳妥但留白不足。","_cost":0.008206}},"consensus":67.01,"final":67.01},{"key":"qwen3.8-max|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"qwen3.8-max","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"巷口青箱纳旧裳，投来犹带昔时香。针痕细密经年线，袖影温和历岁霜。碎片重裁成锦绣，长丝再织入云装。休言故物无余暖，留与人间御晚凉。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.7,"rationale":"以旧衣回收寄托惜物济人之意，主脑集中且具当代性。针痕、袖影可感，章法由怀旧转向再生；“云装”等稍泛，结句温厚但议论较直，留白不足。","_cost":0.006402},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"以回收箱入诗有当代眼光,题旨明确、脉络完整。中二联对仗工稳但'锦绣''云装'趋于套语,颈联再造之意稍空泛。尾联'休言''留与'把余暖说破兜底,议论收束直白,余味不足。语言通顺少诗眼。","_cost":0.03373},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"题材触及现代生活，立意向善但略显套路与说教。颈联“成锦绣”“入云装”偏向古典陈词，未贴切描绘现代回收。结句直白说尽，缺乏留白余味。整体结构完整、脉络清晰，属中规中矩之作。","_cost":0.02867},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"回收箱写余温循环，题旨具体有当代感；针痕袖影较切，锦绣云装偏虚套；语言通顺少锤炼；章法完整转合平直；结句点破题意余味不足。","_cost":0.015986},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱为题，情感具体可感，尾联稍见温度；中二联取象妥帖但偏熟，炼字略平，转结流于直说，整体中上。","_cost":0.00976802},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"以回收箱这一当代事物入诗，写旧衣承载记忆又复暖人间，立意新颖有情。颔联针痕袖影精切入微，意象统一温厚。颈联转写再造稍直白，'云装'略泛。尾联'休言'句近说破，幸'御晚凉'以景收束稍存余韵。整体章法完整，脉络贯通。","_cost":0.00271576},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.3,"rationale":"题取旧衣回收，温情明确；针痕袖影有细节，颈联偏概念，结句说破而少余味。","_cost":0.008332},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱入七律，题材新而意脉温厚，香—霜—暖—凉成温度弧线；惜颈联重裁再织意近合掌，云装略生、袖影温和稍隔，结联休言说破，警策与留白均欠。","_cost":0.0281928},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.6,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.7,"余味":5.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"回收箱入诗以旧暖续新暖立意具体新颖，起承转合由怀旧而展望层次分明；唯意象铺叙偏事理少情景交融，语言通顺少诗眼，尾联直言说理留白不足。","_cost":0.0138805},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"此诗咏当代旧衣回收箱，紧扣旧物余暖赠人的主旨，结构平顺脉络清，意象妥帖语言稳，结句稍直，个别词偏熟，融入当代日常有新意，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱写物尽其暖，当代题材翻出温情怀旧之境，针痕袖影取象贴切。中二联对仗工稳但'云装'稍生。尾联'休言故物无余暖'点题有力，然'留与人间御晚凉'收束略直白说尽，余味稍减。整体脉络贯通，情真意切。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"当代物象入诗，主脑清楚，颔联针痕袖影细节可感；颈联锦绣云装流于套语且理想化，尾联议论说破，余温之意直白收束，余味不足。","_cost":0.0418},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"题旨明确而角度常见；意象妥帖统一，颔联精巧而颈联稍习；语言通顺见炼字，章法完整但起结平直；结句议论稍直白留白不足。当代回收经验入诗，无硬伤蹈袭，间有陈语。","_cost":0.024494704},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.3,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.7,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.85,"rationale":"咏物切题，将当代旧衣回收之事化入温润诗境。首颔体察细密，颈联再生之写略显泛泛，结句直抒温情稍嫌说破，但通篇脉络顺畅，经验入诗自然得体。","_cost":0.0064125},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.55,"rationale":"以回收箱写余暖流转，选材新而主脑明；颔追昔颈写今层次清但转平；锦绣云装稍浮，结句休言说破少留白。","_cost":0.01443725},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.25,"rationale":"以旧衣余暖贯串回收再用，题旨集中，章法顺畅但转折平直。“昔时香”具体可感，“袖影温和”“云装”略显牵强；锦绣、人间等语偏泛，尾句直陈功用，余味有限。","_cost":0.03816},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"题旨清楚而情事泛，温情近口号。青箱针痕尚切，锦绣云装失真。语顺少诗眼。起承完整，颈联未转深。结句说破，余味薄。题材入律有新意。","_cost":0.0227072},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗,取材新,但主旨仍停在旧物余温这一常见层面。颔联“经年”“历岁”意思重复,近乎合掌。颈联写旧衣重裁为锦绣、织入云装,想象浮夸,略显失真。尾联议论点题,说得太尽,仅“御晚凉”稍有余味。","_cost":0.01804},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"青箱、针痕使旧衣承载往昔，继而写再利用与助人，脉络清楚；但“锦绣”“云装”偏泛，结句点明寓意，余味稍弱。","_cost":0.008082}},"consensus":63.46,"final":63.46},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"碧立街隅一铁箱，千家破絮付他乡，寒绵未褪犹含暖，转作人间再著香。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.9,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.6,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.10000000000001,"rationale":"以回收箱写旧衣流转与人间温意，题材入诗较新，主线清楚。“犹含暖”情物相融；但“碧立”“寒绵”“再著香”稍显生硬，结句寓意虽明，表达偏满且语义略虚。","_cost":0.005078},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.5,"rationale":"当代物象入诗有心,回收箱寄托旧衣传暖之意可取,但主旨止于公益颂意,较浅。'碧立'稍生硬,'付他乡'尚稳。转句'犹含暖'已点破,结句'再著香'复申其意,说尽无余,余味不足。章法完整而转结平直。","_cost":0.03434},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"以现代事物入诗，立意向善，起承转合中规中矩。然全诗重叙述说理，意象匮乏，交融不足；“碧立”“再著香”略显生造凑意；结句直白说破，缺乏留白与诗意余味。","_cost":0.01872},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"回收箱写旧衣余温再生，题旨集中具体；意象对照连贯但氛围清浅；语言通顺略有炼意；章法完整转势不强；结句点明再利用，说尽少留白。当代物象入诗算出新，微套无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.015464},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.75,"rationale":"取材现实，立意温暖但平直，结句说破。铁箱寒绵意象略有交融，‘碧立’‘再著香’稍生硬俗套。结构完整转平。可取‘寒绵未褪犹含暖’句。","_cost":0.01924676},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"当代环保题材入旧体，立意有独到处：旧衣流转承载人情温度，主脑集中。起承转合完整，'寒绵未褪犹含暖'物我交融，堪称诗眼。结句'再著香'稍偏说破直白，余味打折；'著香'炼字略带生造痕迹。整体新而不猎奇。","_cost":0.00224836},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"取材旧衣回收，立意温厚；铁箱破絮有实感，含暖一句见情。然碧立、再著香稍生硬，结句偏说尽，余味有限。","_cost":0.012338},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"咏当代回收箱，惜物济人之旨明确，‘寒绵未褪犹含暖’物情交融为佳；起承转合贯通而波澜稍平，结句由暖及香尚能宕开，然善意说足、留白有限，‘碧立’略硬，整体新题得体而锤炼未至。","_cost":0.0150168},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.9,"章法":7.3,"余味":6.6,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.55,"rationale":"当代回收箱入绝，摄取新物而立意温厚；碧立、犹含暖、再著香炼字见功，起承转合清晰，唯中二句偏叙，末句点透，意境与余味稍浅。","_cost":0.0090605},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"咏当代旧衣回收箱，题旨集中，脉络顺畅，语词清顺，能捕捉旧衣存温的细腻感；唯立意稍平，转折欠跌宕，结句说尽少余韵，“破絮”表述略粗。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"以回收箱写旧衣流转，当代经验入诗有新意；'寒绵未褪犹含暖'承转见巧。然'碧立'生硬费解，'再著香'为押韵凑字且说破题旨，结句直白少留白，整体意脉可通而炼字欠精。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"以街头旧衣箱入诗有当代经验，第三句寒绵含暖翻出一层，是全篇亮点。然结句“人间再著香”把温情说尽，近于公益标语，余味不足；“碧立”“著香”略有凑意。章法完整而转合平直。","_cost":0.04591},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"以现代旧衣回收箱入诗，题意集中，'寒绵含暖'略具新趣；然起句拙实、结句直白少余味，语有生硬。当代经验入诗有效，无蹈袭硬伤。","_cost":0.023303726},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.85,"rationale":"当代公共物象入诗，构思切题且具人文关怀。起转自然，第三句具生活温感。结句直奔主旨、稍嫌说破兜底，整体韵味与锤炼仍有提升空间。","_cost":0.00380175},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"以旧衣流转写惜物济寒，取材有新意，开掘尚浅。铁箱、破絮有实感，含暖兼写物情；“寒绵未褪”语义含混，“再著香”略显硬凑。章法顺承，结句泛化为赞美，余味偏薄。","_cost":0.04169},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"回收箱入诗题新而情近公益美化,未得更深发现。第三句为诗眼,象情相接;末句说尽,「香」与破絮不切,余味弱。「碧立」略生。起承转合完整,转折平直。","_cost":0.0179408},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗,当代题材有新意,但旧物传暖的立意较常见。第三句「未褪犹含暖」稍有体温感。「碧立」「著香」炼字生硬,破絮生香略显牵强。转结平直,结句直陈再用之意,余味有限。","_cost":0.016064},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.0,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱入诗，关怀具体，取材有新意。“犹含暖”能传情；但“破絮”与捐衣情境稍有抵牾，“转作人间再著香”语意含混，结句偏于点题，余味不足。","_cost":0.008238}},"consensus":61.61,"final":61.61},{"key":"ox-alpha|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"深秋检点箧中裳，叠向街头绿铁箱。袖口补痕慈母线，襟前酒渍少年狂。身辞旧主经风雨，暖入寒门抵雪霜。想见荒村茅屋底，有人灯下试新装。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.1,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.2,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.4,"rationale":"由旧衣痕迹写亲情、青春与善意流转，主脑鲜明。颔联具体有情，尾联以想象成景，“新装”别有意味；寒门、茅屋、雪霜稍显熟套。","_cost":0.006002},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"当代题材入律而不隔，捐衣一事贯穿始终。颔联'慈母线''少年狂'以衣载忆，具体动人，可摘为佳联。颈联拟人写衣之流转稍落说理，'寒门''雪霜'微套。尾联宕开想象荒村灯下试衣，画面收结有余温，惟'想见'二字点得稍实。整体脉络清畅，情真意暖。","_cost":0.0412},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"当代事物入诗自然贴切。起承转合严密，颔联兼顾亲情与青春尤为动人，尾联以温馨想象作结。唯后半篇“风雨”“雪霜”“荒村茅屋”等词略显陈旧套路，稍减真实感与诗味。","_cost":0.01845},"grok-4.6":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"回收箱写旧衣再命，角度新、有主脑；补痕酒渍可感，后幅风雨茅屋偏熟。语言通顺有“少年狂”之亮，章法起承清楚、转结平稳。结句想见试装留白。套语略密。","_cost":0.026976},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收入七律,当代经验化古有效。补痕酒渍一联,母爱与少年狂并举,细节精切动人;尾联宕开想象寒门灯下试装,以景结情,余味悠长。中二联一忆旧一前瞻,开合有致,唯颈联稍平实。","_cost":0.00258956},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"题旨明确，旧衣入诗有当代感；袖痕酒渍细节动人，尾联以灯下试衣收束，余味较好。然绿铁箱、风雨雪霜等语略平直，颈联偏熟套，转合稳而少变。","_cost":0.012006},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"以旧衣流转为主线，颔联一衣双痕浓缩两代人记忆，颈联拟人写衣之迁徙最有骨力，结以悬想荒村试装宕开收束，温而不滥。化用'慈母线'无痕，当代题材入律妥帖。惜'抵雪霜'略质直，个别意象稍熟。","_cost":0.0094698},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.4,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱为题，借补痕、酒渍带出慈母与少年记忆，尾联灯下试装留白有情。颈联略熟，语言稍平。无硬伤与整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.01220472},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.7,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.85,"rationale":"借绿箱串联旧忆与新暖，慈母线至少年狂再到寒门抵雪霜，焦点集中递进自然，结句宕开至荒村灯下，物尽其用见情意流转。","_cost":0.00637625},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱写物之流转与温情传递，当代题材入旧体而妥帖。颔联补痕酒渍对举，一慈一狂，人事俱在；颈联拟人开合有力；尾联悬想寒门灯下试新装，以景结情，言尽意暖。'慈母线'化用游子吟自然无痕。全篇焦点集中，唯意象略近熟路，微扣陈滥。","_cost":0},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"以当代旧衣回收箱入诗，融亲情、青春记忆于公益暖意，脉络贯通，细节具象，颔联真切，唯部分意象稍熟，结句稳而余韵略平。","_cost":null}},"consensus":83.29,"final":83.29},{"key":"doubao-seed-2.1|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"doubao-seed-2.1","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"铁柜栖墙尘半积，曾温故袂待谁来。慈亲叠处儿衣小，少女捐时旧意回。莫讶绨袍寒可御，长牵远梦路争开。启缄若遇风霜客，尚忆灯前手自裁。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.1,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.6,"rationale":"旧衣回收寄托亲情并延及陌生人，题材新而主脑清楚。灯前手裁收束有温度；惟“栖墙”“旧意回”“路争开”稍涩且虚，颔联视角略跳。","_cost":0.00768},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"当代题材入律而有温度,回收箱与母线灯前之忆聚焦明确。颔联具体可感,绨袍典切合旧衣赠寒者。尾联化用游子吟不落痕迹,余味尚存。惟'路争开'稍见凑韵,'启缄'施于铁柜微欠切,炼字未臻圆熟。","_cost":0.04308},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"本诗将当代物件“旧衣回收箱”有效入诗，立意新切，情意温厚。起承转合有度，颔联分写捐衣之情，颈尾联遥想受衣之暖。结句余味尚可，唯“灯前手自裁”略带古意，与现代语境微显隔阂，整体仍属佳作。","_cost":0.016244},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"回收箱绾合慈亲、少女与风霜客，题旨具体有焦点。颔联儿衣小可感；颈联远梦路争开虚而不融。启缄拟箱稍隔，结句灯前手裁有画而略套。当代物象入律算出新。","_cost":0.025788},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱为引，抒写衣物承载的亲情与悲悯，主题明确且有细节。意象如“慈亲叠处儿衣小”鲜明，尾联想像灯前裁剪收束有余韵。中二联稍平，“远梦路争开”略生硬。现代题材化用绨袍典较自然，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.00769956},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，当代经验有效入律，慈亲缝衣与捐衣旧意交织，情事具体。绨袍典用得贴切。'路争开'稍显凑韵欠稳，颈联转折略平。结句'灯前手自裁'以细节收束，言尽意不尽，余味佳。","_cost":0.00250716},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱入诗有新意，由铁柜牵出慈亲、少女、风霜客，脉络清晰，尾联灯前手裁留余味；惟颈联稍虚，部分词语略熟。","_cost":0.010372},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱入七律，题新而情实：母叠儿衣、女捐旧意，以小见大。绨袍典贴切，结句化游子吟意宕开一笔，设想风霜客忆灯前手裁，余味足。然颈联'路争开'略生硬，气脉稍松。整体妥帖而少奇警，化古处近袭意，故蹈袭酌记。","_cost":0.0145248},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.2,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.7,"rationale":"铁柜为焦点串联捐受两端，情景温厚；章法递进转合有序，结句宕开至风霜客留韵，语言颈联略平","_cost":0.0120815},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.8,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.1,"rationale":"借旧衣回收箱串联亲恩、青春旧忆与济寒暖意，主脑集中，章法顺适，语言清稳，结有余温；唯部分意象稍熟，转折偏平，当代入诗自然，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱写物之流转与人情之延续，当代题材翻出新境，情事具体（慈亲叠衣、少女捐衣）。'慈亲叠处儿衣小，少女捐时旧意回'工稳动人；绨袍用典贴切。结句悬想风霜客启缄忆裁衣，以景结情有余味。惟'长牵远梦路争开'稍涉虚泛，个别意象略熟。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，当代经验有效，首联“待谁来”设问有情；颔联对比母叠儿衣、少女捐衣尚具体。颈联用绨袍典可通，但“路争开”生硬凑韵，“旧意回”虚泛。尾联想象风霜客启缄忆手裁，有温情，然“尚忆”稍说破。整体稳而不惊。","_cost":0.0479},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"通过旧衣回收箱写温情传递，题旨集中且儿衣小细节动人。然铁柜、路争开稍生硬，意境语言有凑痕。结句以灯前裁衣收束，含蓄有余味。用典无痕且当代经验入诗，惟意象略熟。","_cost":0.029332815},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.1,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.0,"rationale":"当代日常物象自然入律，脉络井然。颔联捐衣情态具体可感；颈联下句“路争开”稍显生硬空泛。尾联悬想受赠之人，将风霜寒暖回溯至灯下裁衣，深情温厚，收束存味。","_cost":0.00729975},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"以回收箱串联捐受温情，主脑明确，双景具体；然颈联下句虚滑割裂氛围，语言少诗眼，结句劝勉致留白不足。","_cost":0.01418525},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"以旧衣串联亲情与施受之暖，颔联情事可感，结句灯前裁衣温厚有情。“曾温故袂”“路争开”语意欠稳，颈联推进偏虚，尾联施受视角不够清楚；远梦、风霜等语略熟。","_cost":0.0416},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"回收箱入诗,主脑清楚,铁柜尘积可感,然情志仍是衣传母爱常境。颈联路争开费解,转脉发虚;结句尚忆说破,灯前裁衣近套。当代经验仅及表层。","_cost":0.0351088},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，当代经验有效。颔联“儿衣小”细节真切。颈联“路争开”意虚句弱，绨袍典用得略泛，全篇气脉在此处松散。结句回到灯前手裁，化孟郊诗意而有温度，但稍显说明。“启缄”与回收箱不甚贴切。","_cost":0.0208},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"以回收箱串起旧衣与亲情，儿衣一笔具体可感；绨袍、风霜客等意象偏熟，“路争开”语意生硬。结句有灯前画面，但回忆者视角略显游移。","_cost":0.01666}},"consensus":68.75,"final":68.75},{"key":"qwen3-30b-本机|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"qwen3-30b-本机","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"旧箱静立夕阳斜，\n换却征衣入此家。\n莫道棉麻皆弃物，\n春风犹暖未归花。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"qwen3-30b-本机|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"qwen3-30b-本机","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"旧箱静立巷东隅，絮语寒更换旧裾。\n曾伴征鸿穿塞月，今随落叶委荒渠。\n尘封岁月衣纹改，影隔阴阳世态疏。\n莫道残麻无用处，春泥护得嫩苗舒。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":true},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"gpt-5.6-sol|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"小圃凌空接晓霞，青蔬带露倚云斜。谁知闹市耕耘趣，万户灯光照嫩芽。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.1,"余味":7.3,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.10000000000001,"rationale":"天台耕作与都市灯火相映，题材有生活新意。前二句清润，末句以灯照嫩芽收束较有温情；“倚云斜”稍显刻意，第三句直说“趣”，略减含蓄。","_cost":0.005118},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"天台种菜为当代都市经验入诗,题材有新意;结句以万家灯火照嫩芽收束,以景结情有余味。惟'晓霞''带露'落套,首句写晨结句写夜,时序略有跳脱;'倚云斜'稍夸饰,转句'谁知……趣'说破较直,炼字平平。","_cost":0.03837},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"立意切中都市人向往田园的心境。前两句写景较寻常，第三句转折略显直白。妙在结句将都市繁华的万户灯光与微小生机的嫩芽形成强烈张力，以景结情，余韵悠长，当代经验入诗极为成功。","_cost":0.01847},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"天台种菜入诗有都市耕趣，情志具体而开掘不深。晓霞带露与灯光嫩芽略成对照，倚云稍凿。用语平实乏诗眼。谁知一转较套，结以景收有对照而余韵不远。","_cost":0.017786},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"立意具体但未脱田园趣味常调；前二句意象偏熟，末句灯光映嫩芽见新意。炼字“接”“倚云斜”有致，“耕耘趣”稍直白。起承转合妥帖，结句以景收束留白。轻微陈套，无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":0.012410442},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.0,"rationale":"都市天台种菜为当代经验入诗，角度真切。前两句写高远清景，\"倚云斜\"切合凌空之势；三四句以\"谁知\"转折，结句\"万户灯光照嫩芽\"以景结情，灯火与嫩芽大小相映，余味佳。语言通顺有诗眼，惟\"接晓霞\"\"带露\"稍熟，整体锤炼尚可再进。","_cost":0.0023904},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.4,"语言":6.1,"章法":6.3,"余味":6.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.9,"rationale":"天台种菜选题较新，晓霞、青蔬、灯光嫩芽有清景；但“趣”字说破，转结稍直，晨昏意象略跳。","_cost":0.00879},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"城市天台种菜立意较新，霞露云芽与万户灯光能成境；惜“谁知”直点、晓霞到灯光时序略跳，炼字未警，结句以景收尚有延宕。","_cost":0.0134562},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.6,"语言":5.8,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.849999999999994,"rationale":"闹市天台作圃切中当代经验，霞光露蔬与万家灯火对照成趣；意象妥帖景情相生，章法转结稍直白，语言通顺少诗眼，结句以景收有余味。","_cost":0.007026},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.5,"rationale":"此作写都市天台耕趣，章法流转有反差，结句以万家灯映嫩芽融合都市烟火与田园意趣，具当代新意，唯前半取象稍熟，炼字未精，余韵偏浅。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.8,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.85,"rationale":"天台种菜题材切近当代经验，'闹市耕耘'翻出田园旧题新境；结句'万户灯光照嫩芽'以都市灯火与幼苗相映，宕开有余味，为全篇警策。前二句'晓霞''带露''倚云'取象稍熟且夸张略过（天台言接霞倚云），转句'谁知…趣'以议论说破稍平，炼字未见突出诗眼。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.25,"rationale":"天台种菜为当代经验入诗，题旨明确而角度尚新；然前二句晓霞、带露、倚云为熟套，'倚云斜'稍勉强。'谁知'转句公式化。结句万户灯光照嫩芽以城市夜景衬生机，有余味，但与首句'晓霞'时序稍跳。","_cost":0.04719},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"写天台圃蔬，以凌空晓霞、带露倚云状高园之清，转出闹市耕耘之趣，结以万户灯光照嫩芽，城市与自然交融。意新而境稍熟，转略平；结句以景收，有余味。用语偶见锤炼，整体清顺。","_cost":0.021831128},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.4,"rationale":"成功将当代都市天台种菜经验入诗。起承描摹高空菜圃，转结引入闹市烟火；结句以“万户灯光”映衬“嫩芽”，宏阔与细微对照鲜明，以景结情，余味悠长。","_cost":0.0054375},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.0,"rationale":"天台种菜具当代气息但开掘不深，晓霞带露属晨与万户灯光晨昏相碍，倚云斜欠精，转结直说趣字无留白。","_cost":0.0140045}},"consensus":71.74,"final":71.74},{"key":"gpt-5.6-sol|机场送别|七绝","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"检票长廊暮色昏，临行过闸更无言。归期未问航灯远，只剩玻璃一掌痕。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.8,"语言":8.1,"章法":8.6,"余味":9.2,"警句":4.3,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.1,"rationale":"以过闸送别为主脑，暮色、航灯与掌痕层层收紧。“玻璃一掌痕”化瞬间动作为空间阻隔，具体而含蓄，结句余韵尤长；“暮色昏”“更无言”稍熟。","_cost":0.004928},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"熟题以当代机场经验翻新,情事具体。检票、过闸、航灯、玻璃掌痕取象贴切且交融,'一掌痕'以细节收束、以景结情,余味延宕。'归期未问'化用义山无痕。稍憾承句'更无言'略平,炼字尚可再紧。","_cost":0.03519},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.25,"rationale":"该诗成功将现代经验融入绝句。起承自然，转结极具电影镜头感。“过闸无言”真挚动人，结句以“玻璃一掌痕”的特写定格，不说愁而离愁尽显，意象新颖精切，余味悠长。","_cost":0.01795},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"机场送别以玻璃掌痕收束具体可感，当代场景入诗有新意，然立意仍属送别常调，语言文白夹杂较显，起承平直，暮色无言略陈。结句留白较好。","_cost":0.018264},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"现代机场送别取象精准；结句以玻璃掌痕收束，留白充分，余味悠长。结构转合自然，语言通畅。暮色昏稍熟但组合出新。","_cost":0.00873708},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.5,"rationale":"送别熟题而以机场当代经验翻新：暮色、闸口、航灯、玻璃掌痕层层递进，景语即情语。'归期未问'暗翻李商隐而反用其意，结句以掌痕留白，言尽意不尽。通篇精炼无废字，唯首句'暮色昏'稍近常语。","_cost":0.0034772},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.3,"rationale":"机场离别以现代细节入诗，暮色、航灯、玻璃掌痕统一成无言氛围；末句以痕收情，有余味。稍欠在“过闸”“暮色昏”略直常见。","_cost":0.0127},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"机场送别以闸口、航灯、玻璃掌痕写无言离情，当代物象较新鲜且收束有影；但“暮色昏”“更无言”略熟，归期句语法稍硬，掌痕情境稍依赖想象。","_cost":0.0121542},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.9,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.55,"rationale":"克制写送别，未问归期见分寸；暮色航灯与一掌痕景情一体，转结由远收近，以景结情余韵悠长。","_cost":0.00698025},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"此作写当代机场送别，避开传统送别陈套，以玻璃掌痕细节传离思，章法顺畅，语言精准，结句留白有余韵，惜情志未翻新境，开掘稍浅。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"送别熟题而以机场当代场景翻新，情事具体真挚。'玻璃一掌痕'取象精切，以景结情，言尽意不尽，为全篇诗眼；'航灯远'承转自然，脉络贯通。'无言''归期'稍见常语，然密度低不伤全局。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"送别熟题以机场当代场景翻出新意，“归期未问”反用义山，结句玻璃掌痕以景结情、留白有力，是全篇诗眼。前二句“暮色昏”“更无言”稍落套语，检票过闸直叙偏白，中段转得平稳而不惊。","_cost":0.05476},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.25,"rationale":"机场送别以现代场景写别情，‘玻璃一掌痕’造象精警、情景交融；起承转合稳，结句余韵深长。语言稍平实，‘暮色昏’‘无言’略熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.029536709},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.8,"语言":8.4,"章法":8.6,"余味":9.2,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.25,"rationale":"当代机场送别经验入诗极其自然。起承转合脉络清晰，转结由远及近尤见笔力。结句“只剩玻璃一掌痕”以极具现代感的真实细节定格深情，不言痛而痛彻，余味悠长。","_cost":0.00516225},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.5,"rationale":"送别熟题以掌痕收束较具体；前三象偏泛，末句景语即情语；前语言平淡；转结尚可；以景结情留白足，机场细节入诗自然。","_cost":0.01212855}},"consensus":85.11,"final":85.11},{"key":"gpt-5.6-sol|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"铁爪低垂镇此关，投钱屡试渐囊悭。绒熊乍起须臾坠，稚子回眸望父颜。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.2,"rationale":"以抓娃娃小事写父子间期待与窘意，情境具体。铁爪、绒熊、回眸层层推进，转结有力；“囊悭”“父颜”略显生硬古雅，削弱口吻自然。","_cost":0.005746},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"当代题材入诗自然,主脑集中于父子一瞬。转句'乍起须臾坠'有波澜,结句回眸望父以细节收束、留白得当。'镇此关'稍显硬凑,'渐囊悭'为韵微涩,整体炼字中上,章法完整流畅。","_cost":0.03094},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"当代生活场景入诗，起承转合自然圆融。前三句生动白描游戏过程，“乍起须臾坠”动感极佳；结句“稚子回眸”定格瞬间，巧妙留白，尽显父亲的尴尬无奈，极具生活意趣。","_cost":0.010632},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"抓娃娃机写父子一瞬，场景具体有主脑；结句回眸留白较好。意象妥帖略平，语言通顺而略文白夹杂，结构起承转合完整。当代题材入诗有效。","_cost":0.011546},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.6,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.35,"rationale":"写抓娃娃机新题材，聚焦屡抓不中与稚子回眸瞬间，情事具体。转结有戏剧张力，结句以动作藏情，留白见父子难言之味。立意深度稍欠，情境未翻进一层。","_cost":0.01519452},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写父子情与欲望落空，当代经验入诗自然。起承转合完整：屡试囊悭→绒熊坠→稚子望父，结句以回眸一望收束，不说破 disappointment，留白极佳。'镇'字见炼字。惟意象整体仍偏常见，'稚子回眸'稍近套路。","_cost":0.00109836},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.4,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.1,"rationale":"以铁爪、绒熊写当代小游戏，起承转合清楚。乍起复坠见失落，结以稚子望父留白，颇有余味。语言自然，略有直白，情事具体。","_cost":0.01208},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写亲子微景，题新而情真：屡试囊悭暗伏经济窘境，绒熊乍起即坠捕捉希望起落，结以稚子回眸，期待与失落尽在不言，留白得当。取象精切、场景统一，转结自然。唯\"镇此关\"略撑，\"囊悭\"与今景文白稍忤，警策不足。","_cost":0.0089502},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.7,"rationale":"铁爪绒熊冷暖对照，囊悭回眸见日常张力；起承转坠分明，末句以稚子一望收束，留白足，当代题材入绝自然。","_cost":0.010992},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"抓取当代抓娃娃日常片段，起承转合顺畅，细节真切，语言妥帖，结句留有余韵，无陈套硬伤，唯立意开掘不深，缺拔群警句。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入旧体，题材新颖，'镇此关'拟人起势有力，'乍起须臾坠'写尽希望骤落，转结由物及人，稚子回眸收束含情不说破，余味可延。全篇取象精切无陈套，当代经验化用自然。微憾在承句稍平直，情感略近于浅白。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"当代题材入诗自然，前二句铺垫、三句一起一落作转，结以稚子回眸不说父之抉择，留白有味。惟“镇此关”略作态，“囊悭”稍生硬，语言尚欠精炼，取象平实无奇。","_cost":0.04876},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"当代经验入诗，出新满分。章法起承转合佳，转句生动；结句写稚子回眸，宕开留白，余味浓。意象精切，语言有亮点。立意集中但深度稍逊，无硬伤蹈袭陈滥。","_cost":0.020805228},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.4,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗的佳作。起承转合紧凑自然，“乍起须臾坠”传神写出机件动态，结句特写“稚子回眸”不着一字点破父子情态与窘趣，留白极佳。","_cost":0.0047205},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"娃娃机入绝题材新，前三句白描铺垫，转结由物及人，稚子回眸留白生情，唯语言欠炼，意境偏薄。","_cost":0.0122755}},"consensus":79.88,"final":79.88},{"key":"gpt-5.6-sol|天台菜园|七律","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"百尺楼头开小圃，疏畦带露纳晨光。青藤引蝶穿篱角，赤蕊招蜂绕短墙。腐叶和泥滋嫩韭，檐槽聚雨润瓜秧。归来剪取盈篮翠，坐对霓虹佐晚觞。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.1,"余味":7.7,"警句":2.2,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.2,"rationale":"屋顶农事贯穿全篇，露畦、檐雨、嫩韭等细节真切；由晨光写至晚觞，层次清楚。霓虹与菜圃相映颇有都市新意，惟蜂蝶、青藤稍熟，结句稳而未深宕。","_cost":0.004988},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"写都市天台种菜,题材有当代生活气息,楼头小圃与霓虹晚觞形成古今对照,立意可取。颈联'腐叶和泥''檐槽聚雨'具体可感,是全篇亮点;颔联蜂蝶篱墙则落俗套。章法平顺,转折不足;结句'霓虹'点染都市身份,收束稳而稍直,余味中等。","_cost":0.03534},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"全诗切题，生活气息浓厚。章法从晨到晚层次分明，颈联种菜细节真实。尾联以坐对霓虹佐晚觞将都市繁华与田园野趣巧妙并置，现代经验入诗自然，余味悠长。语言质朴工稳，虽少惊艳之笔，但整体自然融洽。","_cost":0.019986},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"楼顶菜园切入都市田园，情事具体有主脑。颔联蜂蝶篱墙较套，意境中平。动词生动少废字。由晨至霓虹层次清楚。结句点明佐觞稍直白。","_cost":0.02067},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.4,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"写都市天台种菜，生活真切，尾联霓虹与翠色并置稍出新意；中二联平列少层次，蝶蜂等意象落套，语言通顺但锤炼不足。","_cost":0.01718376},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"都市楼顶种菜，熟题之外别开生面，情事具体可感。中二联对仗工稳，腐叶滋韭、檐槽润秧取象精切实用。结句'坐对霓虹佐晚觞'以都市霓虹映田园之乐，宕开有味，言尽意不尽。惟引蝶招蜂稍涉熟径，炼字未见奇警。","_cost":0.00240596},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.3,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"写城市天台菜园，细节清新生动，当代意趣可见；但中二联意象偏熟，转折平缓，情志未深拓，语言稳而少警策。","_cost":0.00973},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"天台为圃、霓虹对觞，城市田园焦点集中，檐槽聚雨、腐叶滋韭较真切；然蝶蜂晨光稍熟，中二联堆叠多于开合，结句安稳而少远韵。","_cost":0.014462},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.8,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"天台微田园对接霓虹，都市经验入诗具体有主脑；颔联蝶蜂略套，意境温润而笼罩感不足；晨至晚结构贯通但转折平；尾联以城光反衬留有余味。","_cost":0.0086235},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"此诗写都市天台菜园闲趣，脉络连贯，写景写实真切妥帖；唯情志开掘不深，蜂蝶一联稍俗，转折偏平，结句较实，余韵稍欠。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"楼头种菜翻熟题出新境，都市霓虹与田园之趣相映成主脑。中二联对仗工稳，'檐槽聚雨'细节真切；'招蜂引蝶'稍熟。尾联以霓虹佐觞收束，古今碰撞言尽意不尽，余味佳。全篇脉络贯通，唯颔联意象略平。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"天台种菜为当代经验，霓虹与盈篮翠对照有城市田园之趣；颈联腐叶檐槽写实见巧。然颔联蝶蜂篱墙为田园熟套，中二联皆景少开合，结句稍直而尚留余味。","_cost":0.04926},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"题材有新意，首尾高楼霓虹见当代经验；中二联陈套常见、颈联未转，章法平直。语言通顺有'盈篮翠'亮点，结句稍留余味。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.030495438},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.7,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"都市天台农事入诗，当代生活感强。颈联写堆肥集雨具体切题；颔联蝶蜂草木略显陈套；尾联对霓虹饮酒结出意趣，全篇由晨至晚脉络贯通、平实妥帖。","_cost":0.0051465},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.0,"rationale":"楼头种菜佐霓虹立意尚有都市意趣，然中二联蝶蜂韭秧铺排常见，语言平实少诗眼，结句宕开稍挽余味。","_cost":0.01730625}},"consensus":68.5,"final":68.5},{"key":"gpt-5.6-sol|云端相册|七绝","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"旧照云端锁笑颜，屏前滑指过千山。今朝忽报空间满，彻夜重温不肯删。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.3,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.89999999999999,"rationale":"以云端容量告急触发旧情回望，当代经验入诗自然。三句转折鲜明，末句真挚而稍直；“锁笑颜”“过千山”凝练，但略带熟语感。","_cost":0.004432},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"以'空间已满'的当代经验入诗，情事具体，转句得势，结句'不肯删'见深情。'滑指过千山'语带双关稍见巧思。惜取象偏叙事白描，景语不足，结句直陈心事、留白有限，语言平实少锤炼。出新有效，无硬伤陈滥。","_cost":0.0307},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"本诗将当代经验（云端相册、内存满）有效入诗，起承转合规整自然，情感真挚。缺点在于语言过于口语化，缺乏诗意提炼，结句“不肯删”和盘托出，直白无留白，导致意境与余味较弱。胜在生活气息与谋篇。","_cost":0.022764},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"云端满载触发彻夜翻旧，情事具体有主脑；滑指过千山稍具象。结句直陈不肯删，说破少留白，意象平实。","_cost":0.013748},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.05,"rationale":"围绕云端相册满而拒删写数字时代怀旧，情境具体；意象虚实结合，但空间满稍直白；“锁笑颜”“滑指过千山”见炼字；转句有波澜，结句稳但略直。","_cost":0.01255716},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"以'云盘空间满'写怀旧，熟题翻新，情事具体，主脑聚焦'删与不删'。'屏前滑指过千山'化滑动屏幕为跋涉时空，虚实相生，堪称诗眼。转句'忽报空间满'有奇变，结句'不肯删'直白见真情但稍露，余味稍逊。当代经验入诗自然无痕。","_cost":0.00216796},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.3,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.6,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀旧，当代经验入诗，起承转合清楚；“滑指过千山”小有巧思。但意象偏概念，结句直说“不肯删”，余味稍减。","_cost":0.008336},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"以云存储写怀旧深情，当代经验入诗自然不隔，'空间满'与'不肯删'的转折真切动人。然取象偏单薄，语言平实少锤炼，结句以情兜底略显直露，余韵可再宕开。","_cost":0.0072282},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.6,"意境":5.2,"语言":5.6,"章法":6.3,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.099999999999994,"rationale":"以云存储告满切入当代记忆，题材具体可感但开掘不深；滑指过千山稍有新意，余则平实直叙，转合完整而结句以语收，直露少余味。","_cost":0.00792075},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"借云端相册存照、空间满不肯删的当代日常细事抒惜旧情，事真情切，章法流转自然，炼字贴切，“云端”双关见巧，唯结句稍直，“千山”意象略熟。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"当代经验入旧体，'空间满'逼出删与不删的抉择，情事具体有主脑。'滑指过千山'以指尖翻照暗度关山，虚实双关为全诗诗眼。起承转合完整，第三句转得自然。惟结句'不肯删'直陈心迹，稍欠留白；意象总体妥帖而未至景语即情语之境。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"以云端存储爆满为切口写对旧照的眷恋，当代经验入诗贴切，主脑清楚。转句'忽报空间满'借系统提示作转折，自然而有巧思；结句'不肯删'情事具体，但直陈行为，留白不足。'千山'略泛，全篇缺诗眼，语言平实达意。","_cost":0.04142},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀旧，当代经验入诗，旧题翻出新境。起承转合清晰，‘锁’字与‘滑指过千山’炼字精巧，意象统一；惜‘空间满’等语稍白，结句直白平稳。无硬伤、蹈袭与陈滥。","_cost":0.021933668},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.9,"rationale":"成功将当代数字生活体验入诗，转承自然，“滑指过千山”颇为精炼。唯“空间满”稍带公文化色彩，结句直说情事，语意虽真却少留白延宕之味。","_cost":0.005928},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.8,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.35,"rationale":"云存储写怀旧，当代经验具体真挚，转折完整；然意象偏叙述少交融，语言夹白，结句直白说尽。","_cost":0.01126975}},"consensus":72.24,"final":72.24},{"key":"gpt-5.6-sol|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"万里舷窗俯夜城，银河倒接市灯明。云开一线长江白，不辨人间第几程。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.8,"语言":8.1,"章法":8.7,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.89999999999999,"rationale":"空中俯瞰由夜城、灯河推进至云隙长江，空间层次清晰；末句由航程宕入人生之问，含混有味。“万里舷窗”稍显压缩，银河、人间略熟而能翻新。","_cost":0.006388},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"当代夜航经验有效入诗,天灯互映、俯瞰视角统一而具象。'云开一线长江白'画面精切可摘,结句以恍惚不辨作宕开,留白有延宕。惟'银河''万里'稍熟,炼字尚欠奇警,整体属中上乘而未臻惊艳。","_cost":0.02975},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"本诗将夜航这一当代经验完美融入古典意境。前两句造境宏阔，倒接二字极佳；第三句极具画面感。结句由空间转入时间与人生况味，余味苍茫。全诗起承转合自然严密，是现代题材绝句佳作。","_cost":0.017694},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.0,"rationale":"夜航俯城星灯倒接、云开江白画面统一；以江之程暗渡人生程，转合尚巧。立意见熟、结句点破略尽。炼字平稳，飞机视点入七绝略新。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.022308},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.3,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰取景开阔，云开见江与结句行旅迷茫形成统一氛围，结句留白可味。立意角度较常见，意象略熟，语言有诗眼但偶有刻意。","_cost":0.01073952},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰之当代经验入诗自然，银河倒接市灯想象精切，'倒接'为诗眼。云开见江作转，结句'不辨人间第几程'以浑然之问宕开，言尽意不尽。起承转合一气贯注，唯'万里''银河'稍熟，整体完成度高。","_cost":0.00204616},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.85,"rationale":"夜航视角新颖，天地灯火与长江一线交织，境界清旷；转结自然，结句有迷离余味。惜情志稍泛，个别词语略常见。","_cost":0.009656},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验入诗,银河与市灯倒接、天地倒置之象精切,转句云开见江白有层次,结句'不辨人间第几程'由景入苍茫之感,留白得当。语言整体通顺,'倒接'见锤炼,但首句'万里舷窗'略平,个别处炼字未到精警。无明显袭句。","_cost":0.0101358},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.64999999999999,"rationale":"舷窗倒接银河视角新颖，云开见江转合有层次，结句以迷茫宕开留余味，立意仍偏览胜感慨欠具体情事。","_cost":0.00832525},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"此作写高空夜航俯瞰观感，起承转合圆畅，取象精切、氛围浑茫，炼字准确，结句由实入虚寓行旅恍惚，融入当代航旅视角，无硬伤套袭，唯情志落点稍趋传统。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.75,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰入诗，当代经验化入旧体而自然。'银河倒接市灯明'天光灯火互映，取象精切；'云开一线长江白'转得有势。结句'不辨人间第几程'宕开留白，言尽意不尽。全篇景语即情语，脉络贯通，唯意象尚在可预期范围内，个别字稍平。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验入诗，题旨明确。次句“银河倒接市灯明”天地倒置一象颇有可摘之处，三句云开江白转得有画面；惟“万里舷窗”搭配稍硌，结句“第几程”语义微泛，留白与含混之间，余味中上而未臻高境。","_cost":0.05107},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰题材中，角度与情志稍显常见，然‘银河倒接市灯’想象新奇，‘云开一线长江白’造境生动；章法完整而转折平直，结句以理语直说，余味中等。当代经验入诗有效，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.029866841},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.2,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.35000000000001,"rationale":"现代夜航体验入诗自然熨帖。起承宏阔，转句“云开一线长江白”取景精切传神，结句由超然俯瞰宕落至人间羁旅，言尽意远，章法与余味俱佳。","_cost":0.00388575},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.2,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.9,"rationale":"舷窗俯瞰、市灯接银河、云隙见江，视角新而层次清；惜情止于迷程，未成主脑，语言通顺诗眼弱，结句以不辨宕开留白。","_cost":0.01005075}},"consensus":78.83,"final":78.83},{"key":"gpt-5.6-sol|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"夜半荧屏照客颜，家山小院入窗间。慈亲欲说还先笑，指下霜丝一键删。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.7,"余味":8.8,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.6,"rationale":"以视频通话写客愁亲情，古典语汇与当代经验融合自然。三句蓄情，末句借“一键删”写遮掩衰老与牵挂，转结有力而含蓄；“霜丝”稍熟。","_cost":0.005116},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"视频通话入诗,母亲以美颜'一键删'去白发,当代经验熟题翻新,母爱藏于遮掩之中,情事具体动人。三句'欲说还先笑'转得含蓄,结句戛然留白,余味悠长。'客颜''家山'略见熟套,取象稍单薄,余皆佳。","_cost":0.03096},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.75,"rationale":"本诗将现代生活经验巧妙融入传统乡愁题材。起承平稳，转句神态传神，结句“一键删”霜丝以美颜功能暗写母爱，不露斧凿，情感真挚动人，余味悠长。","_cost":0.014398},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"视频思亲，末句一键删霜丝翻出新意，情事可感。前半意象平稳常见，语言通顺偶见锤炼。起承较直，转结有力，结句不说破。欲说还先笑稍套。","_cost":0.019296},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.6,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.05,"rationale":"以深夜视频接通故乡小院，细节真切；结句用触屏删白发动作写不忍亲老，当代经验入诗而不说破，留白得力。语言自然，转结有致；唯家山、霜丝略熟。","_cost":0.01062204},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.25,"rationale":"以深夜视频通话写亲情，荧屏作窗、家山入屏，取象精切。转句慈亲欲说先笑传神，结句一键删霜丝化用美颜滤镜，温情中藏着岁月无法删除的隐痛，当代经验入旧体而无痕迹。言尽意不尽，余味深长。","_cost":0.00285716},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.1,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.4,"警句":3.6,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.95,"rationale":"深夜视频写亲情，细节新而真；荧屏、霜丝与一键删古今融合，转结有力。稍嫌新词露白，小院意象略泛，故未尽善。","_cost":0.010098},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"以深夜视频写游子与慈母，荧屏/窗、霜丝/一键相扣，转结见隐瞒衰老的疼爱；家山慈亲稍熟，结句略靠巧思。","_cost":0.0179142},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.1,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.7,"余味":8.9,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.45,"rationale":"以视频切入翻新思亲旧题，慈亲先笑与一键删霜丝对照刺心，冷屏与暖情交融，起承转合利落，结句以事藏情不说破。","_cost":0.00911625},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.0,"rationale":"此作撷取深夜与母视频的当代日常细节，熟题翻新，情感真挚具象，炼字传神，章法圆合，结句以动作留白余韵悠长，无硬伤蹈袭，陈词极少。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"视频通话入七绝，当代经验与游子思亲交融，情事具体。'指下霜丝一键删'为全篇诗眼：指尖可删影像却删不去岁月，翻出新境且余味深长。起承转合完整，结句宕开不说破。慈亲、霜丝意象稍熟，然组合见巧，整体真挚可感。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"思亲熟题借视频通话翻出新境，末句「霜丝一键删」以美颜隐去衰老，双向体贴含蓄可感。荧屏、窗、小院层次清楚，转句「欲说先笑」化古自然。惜「客颜」「家山」「霜丝」略近套语，「一键删」稍白，然余韵尚存。","_cost":0.05588},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"写慈亲夜视频中一键删去白发，当代经验入诗，情真而聚焦；意象稍常见、次句略模糊；删字为诗眼，转结有力，结句含蓄耐品。无硬伤陈滥蹈袭。","_cost":0.030632981},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.8,"rationale":"将当代视频通话与美颜滤镜融入亲情主题，出新自然；“欲说先笑”神态毕肖，结句“一键删”虽带技术直白之感，却将遮掩白发的酸楚点透，真挚动人。","_cost":0.0049935},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.8,"意境":5.4,"语言":5.9,"章法":6.6,"余味":7.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.8,"rationale":"视频写思亲翻出新境，先笑删丝具体动人；荧屏小院功能性强、情景交融浅；一键删新颖稍生硬；起承转结贯通，末句含蓄留酸楚。","_cost":0.017425}},"consensus":86.34,"final":86.34},{"key":"gpt-5.6-sol|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"巷口炊烟暖夕阳，邻翁笑指小葱香。谁将夜饭留新箸，只待归人卸袋尝。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.6,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.50000000000001,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗，邻里候归之暖具体可感，问答转结完整。炊烟、夕阳稍熟；“笑指小葱香”“留新箸”“卸袋尝”搭配略涩，结句直陈而留白不足。","_cost":0.005388},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"以社区食堂写市井温情，'留新箸''卸袋'见当代劳动者归家细节，题旨集中真切。转句设问自然，结句稍嫌说尽、留白不足。炊烟夕阳小葱取象妥帖但偏熟套，且食堂与'炊烟'意象略有游离。整体稳妥有暖意，未臻警拔。","_cost":0.03552},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"本诗以社区食堂入题，捕捉当代市井烟火与打工人归家的温情。起承转合圆融，语言平实质朴，当代经验入诗自然。然结句偏于直白道破，留白与余味稍欠。","_cost":0.013918},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗，留新箸、卸袋较具体。炊烟夕阳、邻翁意象熟套，转以谁将平直，结句叙事说尽，余味不足。炼字偶见，未成警拔。","_cost":0.021216},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.3,"章法":6.9,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.95,"rationale":"以炊烟、葱香、留箸待归人写社区食堂，取象具体、有生活温度；“暖”“笑指”见炼字。惟结句点明“卸袋尝”，温情有余而留白不足，整体中上。","_cost":0.00559504},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"社区食堂这一当代民生题材有效入诗，于平凡处见人情温度，主脑清晰。炊烟、葱香、留箸、卸袋诸象紧扣主题，景语即情语。第三句设问、第四句以动作收，转结自然，言尽意不尽。'留新箸'细节动人。'卸袋'稍显生硬，炊烟夕阳略熟套，但不碍整体。","_cost":0.00199176},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.4,"章法":6.8,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.9,"rationale":"写社区烟火与邻里温情，细节可亲；夕阳炊烟略熟，结句说破‘待归人’而余味不足；‘卸袋’稍硬但具当代感，脉络完整。","_cost":0.012968},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"社区食堂题材较新，炊烟、小葱、新箸织成温暖人境，转结落到留饭待归，情真而细；然暖意稍熟，结意近白，警策不足。","_cost":0.0130212},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.95,"rationale":"以小葱、新箸、卸袋等细节落实社区温情，切口具体有主脑；景情交融但意象常见，语言自然欠诗眼，章法起承转合顺畅，结句以事收留有余温。","_cost":0.01023825},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"此作撷取社区食堂日常小景，市井温情真切具象，意象妥帖，语言平实有生活感，章法顺承完整，唯结句稍直白，当代民生场景入诗自然有新意，无硬伤、陈滥与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.0,"rationale":"以社区食堂写当代烟火人情，取材有新意，炊烟、小葱、邻翁构成温暖统一氛围；三四句设问作答，结于'待归人'尚有余情。但'卸袋''夜饭'等语偏白话直陈，炼字欠锤炼，整体平顺而少警策。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"题材当代、人情温厚，“留新箸”“卸袋”具体可感，起承转合齐整；但“炊烟夕阳”开篇陈套，转句问而结句即答，说得较尽，余味不足，整体温稳而少奇警。","_cost":0.05229},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"写社区食堂留饭待归人，情事具体、焦点集中；意象温馨但‘卸袋’稍硬，结句直白少余味。‘暖夕阳’炼字见巧，当代经验入诗有新意，无硬伤陈滥蹈袭。","_cost":0.023181177},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.2,"rationale":"切入当代社区民生题材，烟火气十足。“小葱香”、“卸袋尝”取象鲜活，深得市井温情。起承转合流畅自然，化现代经验入诗而不显滞涩，结句平实温暖。","_cost":0.00444975},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"社区食堂切近当下，以留箸待归收束有温情；然炊烟夕阳常见，暖字搭配牵强，卸袋口语化，结句直说无留白。","_cost":0.0128153}},"consensus":70.97,"final":70.97},{"key":"gpt-5.6-sol|云端相册|七律","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"掌上云盘贮昔年，深宵点检旧容鲜。童颜尚带花中笑，故宅犹凝雨后烟。影里慈亲招手久，屏前倦客坐无眠。人间岁月催霜鬓，独有眸光到枕边。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.2,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.95,"rationale":"以云端相册寄托怀亲伤逝，旧题融入数字经验而情事具体。颔颈联虚实相照，结句眸光临枕，余韵温厚；“花中笑、霜鬓”等稍熟。","_cost":0.006094},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写深宵思亲,当代经验入诗自然,情事具体。颈联'影里慈亲招手久,屏前倦客坐无眠'虚实相照最见力量。结句'眸光到枕边'留有余味。惟'岁月催霜鬓'落套语,颔联取象稍常见,炼字尚可更精。","_cost":0.03818},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"本诗巧妙将当代经验“云端相册”入诗，立意真挚。中二联虚实对照，影里慈亲与屏前倦客对比强烈，情境动人。章法严密，脉络贯通。结句余味稍显直白，但整体自然流畅，是出新且感人的佳作。","_cost":0.016718},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"云相册怀旧为熟题，情事具体有主脑但路径常见。意象妥帖夜思统一，颔联可摘。语言通达偶炼无斧凿。章法完整转平。结句眸光留白未说尽。数字经验入诗有效，霜鬓稍陈无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.01952},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"诗以云端相册为线索，旧照与今情交织，结句由实入虚有余味。颔联景中含情，颈联时空对照自然。语言偶有熟语，但整体不涩。立意未脱怀旧常境。","_cost":0.0109608576},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"云端相册怀亲,当代经验入诗自然贴切,主脑清晰。中二联昔今虚实对照工稳,颈联'影里慈亲/屏前倦客'尤见匠心。结句眸光到枕边以细节收情,含而不露,唯'旧容鲜''催霜鬓'稍熟稍硬。","_cost":0.00248536},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.1,"章法":7.9,"余味":6.8,"警句":3.4,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.1,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀旧亲情，题旨集中，颔颈两联画面真切，今昔屏里相对有层次；现代词语入诗较自然。惜首尾稍直，霜鬓等语偏熟，结句余味略弱。","_cost":0.010688},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"以云盘检旧照写怀亲之情,当代经验入律且有主脑,题材有新意。颈联'影里慈亲/屏前倦客'今昔对照较切,惟'旧容鲜''坐无眠'等语平直少炼,霜鬓、无眠稍熟。结句'眸光到枕边'以虚景收,余韵尚可但稍着痕迹。","_cost":0.0093042},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.1,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.8,"警句":1.2,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.6,"rationale":"云盘夜检将当代经验自然入诗，起承转合层次清晰，影屏对照见情，眸光收束有余味，然花笑烟鬓等语略显陈熟。","_cost":0.012954},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.15,"rationale":"此作以云端相册写深宵翻旧照的忆旧怀亲之情，章法顺达，语挚情真，自然融入当代数码经验，唯部分意象稍熟，结句有余韵。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"以云端相册入旧体，当代经验与怀亲之情结合自然，中二联虚实对照（影里招手/屏前无眠）为全篇警策。'岁月催霜鬓'稍熟。结句'眸光到枕边'意略晦而情已尽露，留白稍欠。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗，深宵翻看旧照，情事具体；「影里慈亲招手久，屏前倦客坐无眠」照片凝止与人事流转对举最见巧思。惟「旧容鲜」凑韵，「花中笑／雨后烟」「催霜鬓」偏熟套；结句「眸光到枕边」含蓄有余韵，然前句直说，略折其意。","_cost":0.06115},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"借云端相册夜览旧照寄思亲，当代经验有效入诗；颈联转情自然、结句眸光到枕边有余味。然意象与人间岁月句稍熟，语言平实少诗眼，中二联层次清而转折稍平。","_cost":0.029036861},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.3,"rationale":"将当代数码经验自然入诗，情感真挚。章法开合有序，颈联“影里”“屏前”对比鲜明尤为动人。尾联“催霜鬓”略显陈套，结句余味稍欠，然整体通达流畅。","_cost":0.00544875},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.2,"章法":6.8,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"以云盘翻怀旧旧题，影屏对照具体可感；意象妥帖而偏熟，霜鬓等略套；结构完整转折平直，尾联直抒衰感余味稍弱。","_cost":0.0101123}},"consensus":71.96,"final":71.96},{"key":"gpt-5.6-sol|机场送别|七律","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"握别长廊验票前，航灯闪烁暮云边。厅中广播催君起，闸外眸光似线牵。跑道轰鸣银翼远，荧屏字短寸心悬。归来座冷残杯在，独对玻璃掌印鲜。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.10000000000001,"rationale":"机场送别具当代实感，广播、荧屏、残杯、掌印层层贯串，叙事推进清晰。尾联以物留情，掌印尤鲜活有余味；“银翼”“寸心悬”稍显熟套。","_cost":0.00483},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"熟题以当代机场经验翻新,广播、荧屏、跑道诸象贴切入律,时序由送到归脉络贯通。结句'独对玻璃掌印鲜'以物结情,留白动人。惟'催君起''似线牵'稍近直说,颔联炼字略平,语言尚欠精警。","_cost":0.0319},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"本诗将现代机场送别经验完美融入七律，取象精准，极具镜头感。尾联捕捉“残杯”“玻璃掌印”细节，以景结情，余味悠长。虽“线牵”等比喻稍平，但全篇起承转合顺畅，情感真挚具体，为当代题材佳作。","_cost":0.018552},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"送别熟题，机场细节使情事可感，然未翻出更深新境。意象能融场景，尾联较活；中二联顺时铺叙，转势平直。炼字通顺而套语夹杂。结句以掌印留白，余味最佳。当代物事入诗自然。","_cost":0.028546},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"机场送别以现代场景入诗，尾联残杯掌印以细节收束，不言情而情自深；全篇意象统一，唯广播催起、寸心悬等语稍直熟，故语言略减。","_cost":0.00981332},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.5,"rationale":"送别熟题以机场场景落实，广播、闸口、荧屏短信、玻璃掌印皆当代经验入诗，意象统一。章法依时序推进，由长廊握别至归家独坐，脉络贯注。结句'独对玻璃掌印鲜'以物证情，言尽意不尽，余味极佳。'眸光似线牵'稍近套语，微有陈滥。","_cost":0.00253696},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.4,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"机场离别脉络清晰，现代物象融入得体；尾联以残杯、掌印收束，细节有余味。中二联稍直，个别比喻与‘寸心悬’略常见。","_cost":0.011558},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"现代机场送别入七律，情事具体、主线清晰；广播、闸口、荧屏、掌印等意象与离情交融，章法起承转合贯通；结句以玻璃掌印细节收束，留白有韵。惜部分语句平直，暮云、寸心稍熟。","_cost":0.0081762},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.8,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.9,"章法":6.2,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.8,"rationale":"机场物象串联别情，尾联以玻璃掌印作结以景结情、留白得法；立意属常见送别，语言平实少诗眼，中二联铺陈有序但转折平直。","_cost":0.009778},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"此作写当代机场送别，细节真切主脑明晰，脉络畅达，以掌印景结留白；仅个别表述稍熟，空港意象入诗自然，无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"以机场验票、广播、跑道、荧屏等当代经验入七律，脉络按送别时序层层推进，章法完整。结句'玻璃掌印鲜'以景结情，触觉细节收束，余味悠长。'眸光似线牵'稍熟，中二联个别句偏平铺，然整体情真象切，化古出新。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"以验票、广播、闸口、短信等当代细节写送别，情事具体，脉络依时序推进但中二联层次偏平。'荧屏字短寸心悬''玻璃掌印鲜'为诗眼，结句以景收情有余味；'归来'与'独对玻璃'空间略含糊，'寸心悬''暮云边'稍熟。","_cost":0.06267},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"以机场送别写离情，当代意象入律，结句“掌印鲜”以物痕留白，余味佳；然“验票”“催君起”等语略直白，中二联多顺叙，转折平，偶有“眸光似线”等套语。","_cost":0.03571669},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.15,"rationale":"当代生活经验成功入律。全篇脉络顺畅，起承转合自然。意象切合机场空间且情景相融，尤以尾句“独对玻璃掌印鲜”定格极具张力的离别瞬间，具体入微，余味深长。","_cost":0.004083},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.5,"rationale":"机场送别取象具体有主脑，但角度常见；中段广播荧屏偏白直，转折循时序较平；尾联残杯掌印以景结情，余味足。","_cost":0.00976525}},"consensus":77.03,"final":77.03},{"key":"gpt-5.6-sol|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"玻璃匣内彩灯明，铁爪悬丝待客争。一币才投机轴转，绒熊欲起又身倾。娇儿敛笑凝眸看，阿母添筹愿未成。数度钩空欢渐薄，归途小掌尚虚擎。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.6,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.8,"余味":9.1,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.85,"rationale":"取当代亲子小事，写期待屡空与童心难释，情事具体。彩灯、铁爪、绒熊层层推进；“欢渐薄”稍直，“小掌尚虚擎”以动作留白，尤有余味。","_cost":0.007262},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"当代题材入律诗，取事具体：投币、熊倾、儿凝、母添，脉络时序井然。结句'小掌尚虚擎'以细节留白，掩卷可想，最见功力。语言平实达意而炼字稍欠峭拔，中二联对仗工稳但开合不足，意象贴切而氛围经营略浅。","_cost":0.03414},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"本诗巧妙将当代生活“抓娃娃”入诗，前三联精细刻画机器运作与抓取时的紧张期待，尾联“归途小掌尚虚擎”极具画面感与童趣，余味悠长。语言自然质朴，炼字准确，当代经验转化极为成功。","_cost":0.016778},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"当代小景入律，亲子欲愿具体可感，主脑清楚而发现未深。匣爪熊掌能立氛围，然愿未成、欢渐薄偏说破。虚擎、身倾见炼，余句叙事功能偏多。物人事归途层次清，结句留白。","_cost":0.02531},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.2,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.6,"章法":7.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.7,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写亲子盼求落空，情感具体。意象切合当代生活，尾联小掌虚擎尤有余味。中二联层次清晰，语言有敛笑、虚擎等亮点。无硬伤，少量套语。","_cost":0.01887072},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.25,"rationale":"当代游戏机入诗，情事具体：娇儿凝眸、阿母添筹、数度钩空，层层推进至欢薄。结句'归途小掌尚虚擎'以动作写失望未舍，言尽意不尽，是全篇诗眼。'机轴转'稍涉直白，中二联开合略平，整体脉络贯通、取象精切。","_cost":0.00220236},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.3,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入律，题材新而叙事清，娇儿阿母情态具体。中二联稍平直，语词略有现代痕迹，末句小掌虚擎，不言失落而余味自长。","_cost":0.01161},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"以小搏大题材翻出新意，抓娃娃写母子希望与失落，情事具体。意象精切统一，'敛笑凝眸''小掌虚擎'皆见观察功力。章法起承转合清晰，结句以景结情、不点破，余味最足。唯'机轴转''待客争'稍平，中间叙述偏实。","_cost":0.0100158},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.4,"意境":6.7,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.1,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"当代物象入诗真切，欢渐薄至虚擎脉络清晰；结句以景结情留白足，前半写实平陈，意境未及化境。","_cost":0.01028375},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.1,"rationale":"以当代抓娃娃日常入七律，细节鲜活真切，脉络顺畅，结句以孩童虚掌留白余韵悠长，语言妥帖，无陈套硬伤，唯立意开掘稍浅。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"以七律写抓娃娃机,当代经验入旧体而浑成,题旨聚焦于'愿未成'的怅惘。中二联开合有序:颔联状机械之动,颈联转入人情,'添筹'炼字见巧。结句'小掌尚虚擎'以细节收束,不说破而余味悠长。唯意象多限于一景之内,稍欠宕开之笔。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"当代题材入律自然，取象精切具体，绒熊欲起身倾、小掌虚擎皆可摘。惟中二联铺叙平直，语言多叙述少锤炼，情感止于失落未再翻深。结句以细节留白，掩卷有味。","_cost":0.03881},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"当代经验入诗，题材出新；意象精切（意境7.5），中二联层次分明，末句虚擎以动作写心理，余韵动人，故章法8、余味9；然待客争、添筹等措辞稍硬，情志略直白，语言6.5、立意7。警句在末句。","_cost":0.025320376},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.25,"rationale":"当代经验入律的佳作。行文如画，从起意抓取到失落而归脉络一贯。结句“小掌尚虚擎”神态细节精准传神，不着一字失落而童真眷恋跃然纸上，极具感染力与回味空间。","_cost":0.00526125},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.8,"余味":8.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.55,"rationale":"以抓机小事写母子期待与失落，过程具体脉络清晰，末句虚擎留白最佳；中段直叙欠炼，哲思稍浅。","_cost":0.0142235}},"consensus":81.57,"final":81.57},{"key":"gpt-5.6-sol|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"长街病树挂银瓶，点滴春泉续旧龄。嫩叶无言承药苦，浓阴待覆候车亭。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.2,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.95,"rationale":"以树木输液这一街头新景写疗愈与荫人之愿，主脑鲜明。病树、银瓶、嫩叶、候车亭层层推进，结句宕向未来；“续旧龄”“承药苦”稍显着力。","_cost":0.006488},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"取当代城市树木输液的真实经验入诗，题材新而聚焦。‘点滴春泉续旧龄’化俗物为诗语，三句拟人转出情味，结句宕向未来浓阴覆亭，以望结情、留白有延宕。惟‘续旧龄’‘无言’稍平，炼字尚可再紧。","_cost":0.03745},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.5,"rationale":"当代都市经验有效入诗，立意新切，“点滴”双关妥帖。起承转合流利，现代词汇融入无违和。然结句“待覆候车亭”过于实写且将情旨说破，缺乏留白与余味；第三句语言略显直白。","_cost":0.02361},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.5,"rationale":"当代吊瓶疗树入诗见出新，银瓶、春泉用语较工。然意象半新半旧，章法平叙少变，结句坐实功用而少宕开，情志止于观物。","_cost":0.021042},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.6,"章法":7.4,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.65,"rationale":"以城市病树输液入诗，题材新颖，情志具体；医疗与自然意象交融，转结以未来浓阴收束，留有余味。语言略平，章法转处欠陡。无硬伤陈套。","_cost":0.00554686},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"以城市行道树输液为题，当代经验入诗自然贴切。'嫩叶无言承药苦'移情于树，病树之苦与城市绿化之恩并见，结句宕向未来浓阴覆亭，以景结情，言尽意不尽。语言凝净，'点滴'双关输液与春雨，四句一气贯注，唯转合稍平稳。","_cost":0.00217936},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.1,"rationale":"城市病树输液入诗，取材新而情意温；银瓶、嫩叶、候车亭构成统一现代街景。转结完整，唯‘旧龄’稍生，结意略直。","_cost":0.011724},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"以街头病树输液写春城养护，题新而焦点集中；拟人贯穿，由救治到浓阴覆亭，收出互惠余意。“续旧龄”略硬，“候车亭”稍白，未至浑成。","_cost":0.0120678},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.7,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.7,"rationale":"树挂吊瓶取材当代新颖，点滴春泉双关巧妙，物象具体情意交融，起承转合自然，结句宕向未来浓阴，留有余味。","_cost":0.0092815},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"捕捉春日长街行道树挂吊瓶的当代细节，立意温厚有新意，意象贴实，章法顺合，语言精准有巧思，结句稍直余韵不足，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.5,"rationale":"城市行道树输液入诗，当代经验有效转化，通篇以病喻树、拟人贯注，'嫩叶无言承药苦'炼字见情。起承转合清晰，结以浓阴覆亭作未来之许，留白得体。唯'续旧龄'稍涉生硬，'春泉'喻药水略熟，整体取象精切、一气贯通。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"城市树木输液这一当代景象入诗，以病人喻树，取象统一；“点滴春泉”双关自然，结句由治病转向来日荫覆候车亭，宕开留白有余味。惟“续旧龄”稍平，三句拟人略直，语言未臻精警。","_cost":0.04442},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"以街树挂吊瓶之当代经验入诗，取象新颖；结句“待覆”以景结情、留有余味。然“旧龄”生硬，春泉与药苦略扞格，转折平稳、炼字乏警，整体中平。","_cost":0.032063896},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.6,"rationale":"取材当代城市生活，将给树输液化入诗境，体物入微。转结尤见章法，从嫩叶承苦转出，结向浓阴庇人之期盼，拓开境界，温情延宕且出新自然。","_cost":0.00509025},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"以病树输液写春，点滴双关，苦承与待荫对照见主脑；起承转合完整，结以未来之景留期；银瓶续龄略饰，主客小移。","_cost":0.0114548}},"consensus":78.57,"final":78.57},{"key":"gpt-5.6-sol|深夜视频|七律","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"中宵独坐启荧屏，万里音容带笑声。白发灯前频问暖，青衫镜底强言晴。家山暂借流光近，客恨翻因网断生。暗幕还浮垂首影，窗星渐淡鬓霜明。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.6,"语言":8.1,"章法":8.8,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.5,"rationale":"以视频通话写羁旅亲情，网断使暂近复远，情事具体。屏光、暗幕、窗星层层转暗，末句以鬓霜反明，含蓄有力；“客恨”等略见旧套。","_cost":0.00518},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"当代视频通话入律诗,题材切身而情事具体。颔联'频问暖/强言晴'两面写照,颈联'流光近/网断生'化今入古颇见巧思。结句暗屏浮影、窗星鬓霜以景结情,余味佳。惟'青衫''客恨'略沿旧套,炼字尚可再精。","_cost":0.03359},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.0,"rationale":"将当代经验有效入诗。颔联写尽游子报喜不报忧之酸楚，颈联借“网断”翻出客恨，尾联以黑屏反照垂影与星光作结，以景结情，余味悠长。词采雅正，毫无新词生造之感。","_cost":0.0198},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"视频事亲题旨清楚，情在“强言晴”与网断，然角度已成常套。意象能统一，颔联可摘。结以暗幕垂影、窗星鬓霜，余味优于通篇。荧屏网断略硬，白发客恨鬓霜偏套。","_cost":0.021186},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.7,"余味":9.3,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.05,"rationale":"以视频通话写羁旅，角度新，情感具体。中二联对比鲜明，转结由视频断网生恨，尾句以窗前星淡、鬓霜自照收束，余味足。语言偶有现代词与传统意象融合稍涩，整体佳。","_cost":0.009761774},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"以深夜视频写亲情，当代经验入旧体而浑成。中二联一问暖一言晴、一流光一网断，开合有致；结以暗幕垂影、鬓霜窗星宕开，景结情留。'强言晴'谐音见巧，'网断'稍直白微伤雅驯，个别词如'客恨'近套，整体真挚精切。","_cost":0.00282136},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.9,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.1,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.55,"rationale":"以深夜视频写游子亲情，题旨集中；白发强言、网断客恨皆具体。现代物象与孤灯寒星融成清寂之境，转结有余。语多稳妥，惟音容、镜底稍欠精切；佳联有警句之力，陈词略见。","_cost":0.014256},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"以视频通话写羁旅亲恩，角度新而情事具体；颔联对照最警。颈联“网断”稍直、个别现代语未完全化雅，尾联以窗星鬓霜收束，尚有余韵而略近点破。","_cost":0.0107748},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.2,"rationale":"视频中白发问暖与青衫强晴对比真切，当代经验入诗自然；荧屏暗幕窗星意象交融，转合有变，尾联以景结情含蓄有余味。","_cost":0.00873375},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.8,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.35,"rationale":"此作写深夜与家人视频的羁旅愁思，细节真切，融入当代网络经验有新致，结句以景结情有余韵；章法平稳，部分意象较熟，语言偶有亮点。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"以视频通话写游子亲情，当代经验入旧体而情真意切。颔联'白发问暖/青衫强晴'对仗精切见人心；颈联'暂借流光近/翻因网断生'翻转有力；尾联以景结情，窗星渐淡与鬓霜相映，余味悠长。唯'流光''客恨'稍涉熟语，整体炼字尚可再深。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"以深夜视频写客中思亲，当代经验入诗自然。颔联白发问暖与青衫强晴对照真切；网断生恨转得有力；结以暗幕映影、窗星鬓霜，屏幕化为镜面照见自身老去，以景收情有余韵。惟青衫、客恨、家山等词略袭旧套，语言未尽新警。","_cost":0.05886},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"以深夜视频写异地亲情，'网断生''暂借流光'将当代经验入诗，翻新旧题；中二联分写情态与连线，尾联暗幕垂影、星淡鬓霜以景结情，余味绵长。微疵是间有陈熟意象与直白语。","_cost":0.034336972},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.4,"rationale":"将当代视频通话经验自然入律，颔联“强言晴”深得游子心境，尾联黑屏垂首待晓、以景结情余韵悠长。唯“网断”稍嫌直白，瑕不掩瑜，脉络清晰且情真意切。","_cost":0.00592425},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"视频写问暖言晴对比具体，主脑突出；暗幕垂影以景结情余韵足，颈联偏说理，镜底流光炼字欠精。","_cost":0.0121125}},"consensus":81.66,"final":81.66},{"key":"claude-fable-5|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"彩偶盈盈锁玉楼，悬钩几度掠空收。方欣到手绒团稳，半路松开万事休。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.6,"余味":3.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"抓取落空之情具体，彩偶、悬钩、绒团构成统一现场；三四句转折清楚有戏剧性。“掠空收”稍涩，“到手”与半路松开语意欠准；结以“万事休”直白且略套，余味不足。","_cost":0.005832},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入七绝，当代经验有效入诗，转结逆折切合事理，起承转合分明。'掠空收''绒团稳'状物精切。惜结句'万事休'说破兜底，套语收煞，余味打折；'玉楼'与俗物略隔。","_cost":0.0372},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"本诗将“抓娃娃机”这一现代经验有效入诗，起承转合严密，生动刻画了悬钩掠空到中途掉落的过程。“万事休”大词小用，富有幽默感。然结句过于直白缺乏留白，“玉楼”代指玻璃箱略显拔高。","_cost":0.0126},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"写抓娃娃机到手复失，情事具体、主脑集中。起承转合清楚而转折较直。柜中彩偶以玉楼妆之，意象妥帖未见深融。结句万事休说尽，余味弱。今事入诗为出新。","_cost":0.029666},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.2,"余味":6.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.05,"rationale":"写抓娃娃过程真切，锁、掠、稳、休用字有表现力，转结从将得到失落跌宕有力。结句略说破，余味稍减；题材有当代新意，个别词语近熟。","_cost":0.00874368},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入七绝，得而复失之慨寄于日常小事，题新而意可通于人生，主脑清晰。起承转合完整，方欣与半路松开一扬一抑，转结有力。惟结句万事休说破兜底，余味稍直；玉楼喻机身稍夸，万事休微近套语。","_cost":0.00262836},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.3,"意境":6.7,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.2,"余味":4.8,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.5,"rationale":"以古典语汇写抓娃娃机，起承转合清晰，得失起伏具体；“掠空收”“绒团稳”有细节，但结以“万事休”说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.010552},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃喻功败垂成,今物入诗有生活实感,'锁玉楼''掠空收'取象精切,三四句转折有力。惜'万事休'径直说破,余味受损,'玉楼'略饰。整体脉络贯通而立意角度尚属常见。","_cost":0.0085098},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.9,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.1,"rationale":"当代抓娃娃机写尽得而复失，物象精切、起承转合分明化俗为雅；惜末句万事休直抒说破，宕开留白不足。","_cost":0.00781865},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.0,"rationale":"此作撷取当代抓娃娃日常入诗，顺叙几得复失的过程，脉络清晰，语词妥帖，传递出功亏一篑的共通怅触；唯立意未翻新解，结句稍直，个别字面偏熟，余味不足。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写人生得失，当代经验入旧体颇有效。'悬钩几度掠空收'取象精切有画面；'方欣'一转得绝句转法，章法完整。惜'万事休'说破兜底，失之直白，'玉楼'喻机箱略隔。结句若以景收束则余味更佳。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"以当代抓娃娃入诗，得而复失有几分人生寓意，脉络清楚，转合在三四句衔接自然。但“玉楼”借指玻璃箱稍嫌硬凑，整体多叙事少寄托，结句“万事休”说破兜底、落入套语，余味不足。","_cost":0.04717},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入绝句，起承转合分明，转结尤见跌宕；‘悬钩掠空收’‘绒团稳’造语切当。然结句‘万事休’直白稍套，余味不足；当代经验入诗有效，整体立意具体而稍浅。","_cost":0.029567555},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.45,"rationale":"当代经验入律极贴切，取象古典而无违和感。起承转合将抓取时的期待、得手与脱落写得跌宕传神。结句戏谑真实但略显说尽，余味稍薄，整体生动谐趣。","_cost":0.00467175}},"consensus":72.98,"final":72.98},{"key":"gpt-5.6-sol|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"货架千层夜未央，巡车贴地过回廊。红眸暗校诸箱码，只剩机声伴月光。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.1,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.15,"rationale":"以自动仓储夜巡入诗，冷光、红眸、机声交织成幽寂氛围，古典月夜与当代经验相接。章法顺畅，结句有余韵；“夜未央”“伴月光”稍熟，“诸箱码”略显涩硬。","_cost":0.004876},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"以无人云仓夜景入诗,当代经验有效化用,'红眸''机声伴月光'营造人去机存的空寂氛围,结句以景收尚有余味。惜'诸箱码'措辞生硬近凑,情志止于场景速写,未再深掘一层,转结之间张力稍弱。","_cost":0.03392},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"本诗将现代无人云仓经验成功入诗。“红眸暗校”拟人精切，捕捉激光扫码细节。起承转合流转自然，结句“机声伴月光”以景收束，科技冷峻与古典幽静交融，极具时代气息与余味。","_cost":0.02015},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"仓储夜扫入七绝取材见新，红眸贴地有现场感，机声伴月略具对照。情志偏冷静白描，章法平铺少转，箱码等语稍质，炼字未精警。","_cost":0.015926},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"现代仓储夜景，红眸暗校、机声伴月，物我交融；起承转合紧凑，以景收束留白。稍欠情感深度，个别语熟。","_cost":0.01202564},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"以无人仓储夜巡入诗,题旨新颖可感。'红眸暗校诸箱码'以拟人笔法写机器视觉,是全篇诗眼,科技意象与'月光'古意交融成统一冷寂氛围。四句起承转合完整,结句以声光收束留白,惟'只剩……伴月光'收法稍熟,略欠宕开。","_cost":0.00230716},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.7,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.9,"rationale":"写云仓夜扫，取景新颖，红眸、箱码入诗有当代感；由细部归于机声月光，冷寂有余味。唯术语稍硬，夜未央、月光略熟。","_cost":0.011844},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"以智能仓库夜班入诗，题材新而切时；货架、巡车、红眸、机声与月光交融，机器之'孤'映人情之思，意象统一。'红眸暗校'炼字见巧，'只剩机声伴月光'以景结情有余韵。惜'夜未央'略熟，'诸箱码'稍质，转句变化有限，情感深度尚可再掘。","_cost":0.0077958},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.6,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.9,"rationale":"云仓夜巡题材新颖，红眸暗校与机声月光并置营造冷寂科技意境，炼字精准，起承转结流畅，末句以景结情余韵悠长。","_cost":0.00896025},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"此作选取当代云仓夜班作业新题材，炼字精巧，结构顺畅，结句以景衬静有韵致，当代经验入诗自然，唯转折稍平、个别意象略欠精切，无硬伤套话。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"以七绝写智能仓储夜班，当代经验入旧体而气脉贯通。'红眸暗校诸箱码'取象精切，机器拟人化见冷峻诗意；结句'只剩机声伴月光'以景收情，无人之境余味悠长。语言稍平，'千层''回廊'略熟，然整体题材新、焦点聚，转结俱佳。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"题材取当代无人云仓，红眸暗校箱码、机声伴月，机器与夜色相映，有清冷寂寥之感。惟“夜未央”“月光”偏熟，“诸箱码”稍硬，第三句承多于转，结句以景收而略带点破。","_cost":0.04439},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.0,"rationale":"以云仓夜景入诗，题材新颖；红眸校码、机声伴月营造出科技时代的孤寂，结句以景结情有余味。然箱码稍硬，夜未央等略陈，章法稳妥。","_cost":0.025743526},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.9,"rationale":"当代无人仓储入诗，立意新颖。炼字精警，“贴地”“红眸”化工业物象为生动诗语。章法由阔入微再以声景荡开，寂静清冷，古典诗美与现代科技交融无痕。","_cost":0.0047625},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.2,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.55,"rationale":"无人仓夜巡题材新，红眸校码机声伴月构成冷寂境，结句以景结情留白足；惜诸箱码直白，夜未央略套，转折平铺。","_cost":0.01207705}},"consensus":78.53,"final":78.53},{"key":"claude-fable-5|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"高楼百尺借天光，数瓮泥深莳晚秧。俯瞰车流千丈下，闲锄夕照当还乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.8,"语言":6.7,"章法":7.7,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":1.2,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.9,"rationale":"楼顶莳菜对照脚下车流，城市田园与乡愁交融，取材具体且有新意。转结贯通，但“当还乡”略硬且稍说破；“百尺”与“千丈下”数量明显抵牾。","_cost":0.006376},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.25,"rationale":"以天台种菜写都市乡愁,当代经验有效入诗,题材新而情事具体。'借天光''莳晚秧'炼字妥帖,三句俯瞰宕开有转势。结句'闲锄夕照当还乡'为篇眼,惜'当还乡'把乡情点破,留白稍减;'百尺''千丈'数字微嫌重叠。整体脉络贯通,是化俗为雅的佳作。","_cost":0.03371},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.0,"rationale":"本诗将当代城市经验(天台种菜、车流)巧妙入诗，与古典思乡情怀完美契合。高楼喧嚣与瓮泥夕照形成强烈张力，“闲锄夕照”炼字精警。结句虽略直白但气脉贯注，属化当代生活入诗之佳作。","_cost":0.016022},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"天台种菜寄还乡，事具体而题旨常见。高下对照成境，借光莳秧较准。起承转合清楚，结句点破稍直。都市经验入诗有新，夕照还乡略套无硬伤。","_cost":0.01864},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"都市天台种菜寄乡愁，立意具体但尚属常见；'俯瞰车流'拉开空间，转结有张力，结句稍直而留画面。'借''闲'见炼字，章法完整。","_cost":0.00731566},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.0,"rationale":"都市天台种菜以'当还乡'收束，熟题翻出新境，情感具体。'数瓮泥深'取象精切，'俯瞰车流'与'闲锄夕照'城乡对照构成张力。起承转合完整，结句以锄代归、言尽意不尽，余味悠长。'莳''瓮'炼字见功，当代经验入诗自然无痕。","_cost":0.00218656},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.7,"rationale":"写高楼天台种菜，以车流夕照映闲锄，都市与田园相映，乡愁落到“当还乡”。新题有生活气，意象较统一；数字与“俯瞰”稍平直，结意微露。","_cost":0.009384},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"以天台菜园写都市归心，角度较新，瓮秧、车流、夕照能成对照；然“当还乡”直点主旨，尺度夸张略失真，结少留白。","_cost":0.018036},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.9,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.45,"rationale":"楼顶瓮圃对俯瞰车流构成垂直张力，都市归隐立意新切；转结以闲锄夕照收束还乡，意境完整，语言平实少诗眼。","_cost":0.010332},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.85,"rationale":"此作取材当代都市天台种菜，融高楼车流的现代场景与耕锄归趣的传统情志，起承转合顺畅，反差鲜明，语言自然，唯结句稍直白，真切有新意。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"天台种菜为当代经验入诗，'借天光'起句即见巧思；三句俯瞰车流陡转，结句'闲锄夕照当还乡'以劳作代归途，翻出都市人的精神还乡，言尽意不尽。意象统一于高与下的张力中，唯'数瓮''晚秧'稍平实，整体炼字尚可再深。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"天台种菜的当代经验入诗，借天光、俯瞰车流构成高处田园与市井的反差，主脑集中。莳、借等字精切，结句“闲锄夕照”有画面，唯“当还乡”将意说破，余味稍减。百尺楼与千丈下略有夸张失衡。","_cost":0.05243},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"天台种菜以‘当还乡’点染都市乡愁，今情入古绝，立意出新；意象妥帖、章法完整，结句‘当还乡’稍直白，余韵中等。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.02412538},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.6,"rationale":"成功将当代都市经验入诗。转结以千丈车流与夕照闲锄形成动静与高低对照，将异乡客的无奈与乡愁落于具象劳作中，章法严谨，余味深长。","_cost":0.00580875}},"consensus":78.7,"final":78.7},{"key":"claude-fable-5|天台菜园|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"天台百尺借斜阳，一角泥盆种晚秧。带露番茄堪入馔，迎风豆荚欲攀墙。锄开半亩城中绿，拾取三分陇上香。莫道蜗居无寸土，犹擎菜甲向穹苍。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.7,"余味":7.1,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.55,"rationale":"以天台种菜写都市蜗居中的田园意趣，物象具体，主脑鲜明，转结有力。半亩与一角泥盆略显夸饰，“陇上香”“向穹苍”稍熟，结句形象昂扬但意旨较直。","_cost":0.007842},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"都市天台种菜入律,当代经验鲜活,题旨集中。颈联'城中绿''陇上香'虚实相映为亮点。惟'一角泥盆'与'半亩''寸土'夸张失度、前后微龃龉;尾联说破励志,直陈无余味。语言通顺,'借''擎'见炼字,整体中上。","_cost":0.03937},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"此诗将当代天台种菜经验有效入诗，富有生活气息。颈联“城中绿”与“陇上香”虚实相生，章法起承转合顺畅。结句“擎”字有力，虽略直白但昂扬向上，意象真切自然，足见诗心。","_cost":0.018148},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"天台种菜情事具体有主脑，角度仍属城市田园常套。番茄豆荚较切，斜阳陇香穹苍则熟。借、擎可看，堪入馔、欲攀墙平直。层次清楚转结常规。尾联半点题半举象，余味有限。","_cost":0.022756},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.15,"rationale":"城市天台种菜具体可感，立意清晰；意象清新但深度稍欠；中二联略并列少开合；尾联以菜甲向天收束，余味较好。无硬伤，略有套语。","_cost":0.00776446},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"都市天台种菜入诗，当代经验与旧体融合自然，立意有新意有主脑。中二联意象鲜活（带露番茄、豆荚攀墙），但颔颈两联皆铺陈园景，开合层次略平，微有合掌之嫌。结句以象收束、昂扬有余味。'锄开半亩城中绿'见炼字之功。个别措辞（堪入馔）稍平，'借''擎'二字见精神。","_cost":0.00314976},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.95,"rationale":"天台种菜题材具体，有城市生活气息；颔颈细写蔬果并拓开城中陇上，脉络清楚。语多自然，个别词略直。结意昂扬而稍说破，余味未足。","_cost":0.009388},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"取当代天台种菜为题，立意不俗，结联'蜗居''擎菜甲'振起有精神；番茄豆荚意象切题具体，中二联由实入虚。唯'一角泥盆'与'锄开半亩'尺度自相矛盾，属轻微逻辑瑕疵，余者气脉尚顺。","_cost":0.0292296},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.6,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.1,"rationale":"天台种菜切近当代蜗居经验，情真具体但翻新有限；取象妥帖而少化境，语言通顺擎字为眼，章法完整转折平直，尾联以理收束略显直露。","_cost":0.00848375},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"本诗写都市天台种菜的日常志趣，脉络通顺，意象贴实，融入当代生活经验，语言清顺，唯结句偏直白，余味稍欠，整体平妥少警策。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"天台种菜为当代都市经验入诗，题材有新意；番茄豆荚取象具体鲜活，'锄开半亩城中绿'一联虚实相生可称佳句。惟尾联直抒胸臆说破题旨，'向穹苍'稍显用力过猛，余味打折；'蜗居''斜阳'属常见语。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"都市天台种菜入诗，当代经验真切，番茄豆荚取象具体。然颔颈两联皆铺陈园景，层次少变；一角泥盆而云“锄开半亩”，小有失实；“百尺”“穹苍”偏套。结句擎甲向天略显说破，寓意明白而余味稍薄。","_cost":0.05284},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"天台种菜写当代都市闲趣，意明情真；中二联细阔相生，脉络畅。语言通顺，“借”“擎”有诗眼，颈联为佳联。尾联说旨稍直，结句托菜甲向穹苍略留余味。间有“陇上香”“穹苍”套语，无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":0.035992143},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.3,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.15,"rationale":"都市天台经验有效入诗，具生活情趣。结联借微小菜甲擎向穹苍，托物言志，气局顿开。唯颈联“锄开半亩”与首联“一角泥盆”在空间尺度与劳作逻辑上微有抵牾。","_cost":0.00771825}},"consensus":72.08,"final":72.08},{"key":"claude-fable-5|云端相册|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"指底流光十载春，云中犹贮旧时人。慈颜宛在屏间笑，欲唤无声隔世尘。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.1,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.3,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.45,"rationale":"以云相册寄托悼亡，数字媒介与隔世之痛结合自然。前三句层层逼近，末句顿成永诀；“指底流光”有亮色，但“慈颜宛在”“隔世尘”稍熟，结句略说尽。","_cost":0.007374},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"以云端相册悼亲,当代经验入诗有效,'云中犹贮'语带双关最见巧思。起承转合完整,由指间滑屏到隔世唤亲层层递进。惜'慈颜宛在'近挽联套语,结句'欲唤无声'情真却说得稍尽,留白不足,余味略减。","_cost":0.03316},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"作品将“滑屏”“云盘”等现代科技经验巧妙化入绝句，“指底”“云中”双关自然，起承转合顺畅，情感真挚动人。惟结句“隔世尘”直白说破，略乏留白余味。","_cost":0.01649},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"云端相册写十年怀亲，情真事具，数字流光与慈颜隔世交融成境。结句‘欲唤无声’稍说破，余味有限；章法承转平直，炼字通达而少眼。","_cost":0.025214},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.6,"章法":7.4,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.95,"rationale":"以云端相册寄隔世之思，情感具体，结句留哀。贮字精炼，屏间笑与隔世尘有张力。然慈颜、隔世等语近挽联熟套，新意稍抑。","_cost":0.01748387},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写丧亲之思，当代经验入诗自然贴切，'指底流光''屏间笑'化物象为情语。起承转合完整，结句'欲唤无声'以动作截然而止，言尽意不尽。'隔世尘'稍落熟套，整体真挚动人。","_cost":0.00200056},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.15,"rationale":"以云端相册悼亲，题旨集中，当代物象入诗较自然；但慈颜、隔世尘等语偏熟，结句说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.011566},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"以云端存照写悼母，云/屏双关自然，熟题翻出新境；承转以“宛在”造势、结以“欲唤无声”反转，情事具体。惟“慈颜”“隔世尘”语近熟套，结稍说破，意象可更精。","_cost":0.0339402},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.8,"rationale":"以云端相册翻新悼亡旧题，当代经验贴切，指尖屏笑至欲唤无声情真脉络清；唯意象炼字多常语，结句直点隔世少宕开。","_cost":0.0094375},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"此诗借云端相册写伤逝，真挚具体主脑明确，炼字自然少废字，结构平顺，意象妥帖但个别常见，结句稍直；融入当代经验有新意，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"以云相册写悼亡，当代经验化入旧体，'云中犹贮旧时人'翻出新境；屏间慈颜之笑与欲唤无声对照，情事具体可感，章法起承转合完整。唯'宛在''隔世尘'微涉熟语，结句点破'隔世'稍欠留白，然真情弥满，掩卷有余哀。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"以云端相册寄哀思,“云中”双关云存储与彼界,当代经验入诗有效;“贮”字见炼。惜“流光”“宛在”“隔世尘”皆熟语,结句将生死之隔点得过明,余味稍减。","_cost":0.04193},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"借云端相册与屏间旧照写悼亡，当代经验入诗，立意新切；篇中稍杂流光、慈颜等陈词，语言流畅而有欲唤无声之警句。起承转合完整，结句以隔世尘收，余味动人。","_cost":0.030387883},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.3,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.8,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.45,"rationale":"将当代触屏与云端相册的生活经验有效入诗，写生死阻隔真挚动人。“指底”“云中”化用巧妙；“慈颜宛在”微落陈套，结句略显说破，然浑融无隔。","_cost":0.00557625}},"consensus":76.08,"final":76.08},{"key":"claude-fable-5|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"霓虹深处一奁光,百态娇娃斗艳妆。铁指初收擒雪兔,绒躯半举堕群芳。悬丝予夺凭谁主,咫尺穷通付彼苍。散尽青蚨归去晚,隔窗犹自笑痴郎。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"unknown"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.4,"语言":8.1,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.3,"rationale":"以抓娃娃写得失与痴心，取材新而主脑明。铁指、悬丝、隔窗层层推进，末句反客为主，诙谐有余味；“穷通付彼苍”稍显拔高与陈熟。","_cost":0.005304},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机寄寓命运予夺,当代经验入诗自然。颔联铁指擒兔、绒躯堕芳描摹生动,颈联由物及理见深度。结句娃娃隔窗笑痴郎,物我倒转有余味。惟青蚨、彼苍等语稍陈熟,炼字未臻警拔。","_cost":0.03779},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":9.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"以现代事物抓娃娃机入诗，由物理动作自然升华至对命运的哲思，小题大做而不违和。颔联抓落之态栩栩如生，结句以拟人手法反衬人之痴迷，自嘲中余韵悠长，是当代经验有效入诗的佳作。","_cost":0.02274},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机喻人生予夺穷通，当代物象入律见新。颔联动作具体，颈联点题稍直。结句隔窗痴笑留白，讽而不尽。","_cost":0.002602},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.0,"rationale":"抓娃娃机题材新，由实入虚写命运被操控与痴迷徒劳。中二联动词炼眼，对仗开合有致，结句留白自嘲佳。唯“娇娃”“群芳”等略近熟套，未伤主旨。","_cost":0.00847704},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"以旧体咏抓娃娃机，题材当代经验入诗自然。颔联'擒雪兔''堕群芳'取象精切，颈联由游戏升华为命运之思，是全篇主脑。结句隔窗笑痴郎以景宕开、自嘲兼讽，余味足。'斗艳妆'稍落俗套，中二联开合有序，一气贯注。","_cost":0.00247196},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.3,"余味":7.4,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.8,"rationale":"以旧体写娃娃机，取象新巧，颔联动态生动，颈联由机入命，章法有序；惜稍借熟语，结意微露。","_cost":0.012888},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写机运与执念,小题翻出穷通之叹,主脑集中。颔联'擒雪兔''堕群芳'动态精切,颈联由赌机转问天命,开合有度;结句隔窗一笑,痴郎自嘲与他嘲两可,余味延宕。'彼苍''青蚨'稍熟,整体化今入古而不生硬。","_cost":0.0155982},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.2,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.1,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"以娃娃机喻予夺穷通，擒堕细节具体，转入哲理再以痴郎自嘲收束；奁光铁指悬丝取象贴切，颈联警策，当代器物入律自然。","_cost":0.00987},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.4,"rationale":"此作借抓娃娃机日常寄寓予夺难凭之慨，细节真切，章法顺畅，炼字妥帖，当代经验入诗自然，结句有余味，仅个别语词稍熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入七律,当代经验与古典语汇融合自然,'悬丝予夺''咫尺穷通'由小机巧翻出命运之思,是全诗主脑。中二联开合有致,结句自嘲带留白。惟'付彼苍''青蚨'等语稍熟,颔联'群芳'喻绒娃略隔,整体炼字尚可再深一层。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.0,"rationale":"当代题材入律有效,以妆奁、铁指、悬丝统摄全篇,颔联动态精切;颈联转入予夺穷通稍嫌直说,'付彼苍'略泛;结句娃娃隔窗笑痴郎反讽有味。'斗艳妆'等略陈套。","_cost":0.05231},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写当代经验，起承转合完整；颔联‘铁指’‘绒躯’生动，颈联议论稍泛而传统，结句隔窗笑痴郎留自嘲余味。意象妥帖间有陈语，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.031885994},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.4,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.3,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗之佳作。颔联精摹抓取过程，动感如画；颈联借物寄意，自然生发命运之慨；结句以窗内玩偶之笑反观自嘲，余味悠长。词采工稳无隔。","_cost":0.0051075}},"consensus":83.38,"final":83.38},{"key":"gpt-5.6-sol|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"晓步春街新雨后，沿途病木挂银瓶。虬枝未展初芽涩，点滴无声续寿龄。过客匆匆浑不顾，园丁默候药流停。霓虹炫尽千般色，尚有苍生待返青。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.1,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.9,"余味":6.9,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.65,"rationale":"树木输液入诗，都市经验鲜明；病木、点滴、园丁诸象交融，章法递进清楚。尾联有提升，但“苍生”略显泛化，“续寿龄”“药流停”稍生硬。","_cost":0.008234},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"取材当代街景吊瓶救树,题材新颖,尾联由树及人、'苍生待返青'双关宕开,有余味。惜'续寿龄'凑韵,'药流停'语病生歧义,中二联对仗平实、开合不足,炼字功力拖累整体。","_cost":0.0305},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"将“树挂吊瓶”这一现代都市景观自然入诗，升华至对“苍生”的悲悯，立意独特。章法严谨，颔联细写病木，颈联对比人事，层层推衍。结尾以喧嚣霓虹反衬病木求生，对比强烈，余味深长。唯部分措辞略显直白。","_cost":0.022402},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"病木吊瓶写春日护生，场景具体主脑清楚，然人树对照角度不新。银瓶点滴意象较切，过客霓虹流于套。用语通顺少锤炼，‘续寿龄’略凑。结构完整转平，结句点题过尽少味。","_cost":0.023384},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"写城市病树挂输液瓶，取材新颖且关怀现实，尾联“霓虹”与“返青”对比成佳构。但“寿龄”“药流停”等语略生硬，中二联偏叙述，结句说破旨意，余味稍减。","_cost":0.00676324},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"以城市行道树输液的日常细节入诗，视角新颖，物我关照落到苍生，立意有发现。意象精切统一，颔联写树、颈联写人，开合有层次。结句霓虹与病木对照、返青双关，言尽意不尽。'续寿龄'稍见生硬，余皆妥帖。","_cost":0.00302656},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.9,"rationale":"街树输液入诗，观察具体，脉络清楚，点滴、园丁等细节有当代感；但霓虹、苍生略熟，结句说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.014626},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"以病树输液写城市生态与人间关照，立意新切；意象尚能交融，惟“苍生”拔高、“药流停”生硬，结句稍直露。","_cost":0.0120048},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.9,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.1,"rationale":"病树挂瓶切入都市生态养护，立意具体有主脑；银瓶点滴与霓虹对比成境；章法起承转合分明，尾联直抒议论，余味稍弱。","_cost":0.0084595},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"此作取春街树挂吊瓶的当代小景寄寓苍生关切，主脑明确，\"初芽涩\"传神；唯尾联霓虹稍突兀，结句直白少余韵，语言偶有生硬歧义，少量熟套。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"城市病木挂瓶题材新颖，当代经验入诗自然，'苍生待返青'双关树与人，立意真挚有主脑。意象统一，颈联过客/园丁对比见匠心。惟'续寿龄''药流停'稍显凑韵生硬，结句略直白说破，余味可再蕴藉。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"以街树吊瓶这一当代都市景象入诗，取象新颖具体，病木、银瓶、点滴与霓虹形成对照，主脑清晰。中二联由树及人，层次尚可但转折平直；'续寿龄''药流停'略显凑泊。结句以'返青'双关收束，然'苍生'点破稍露，余味中等。","_cost":0.04422},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"以当代树木输液入律，颔联涩、续寿龄见锤炼；然药流停生硬歧义，尾联苍生突兀说破，致脉络脱节、余味不足，升华稍游离。","_cost":0.027880566},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.4,"章法":6.2,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.45,"rationale":"当代经验入诗，取象真实，中二联状物写人均妥帖自然。惟首句“晓步”与尾联“霓虹”时序略有跳脱，结句借树喻苍生立意尚善，但稍显拔高说破，余韵微损。","_cost":0.0059055},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.2,"章法":7.3,"余味":4.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.05,"rationale":"以树木输液喻苍生，立意新切结构完整；然语言偏白说理直露，结句点破欠留白，霓虹与晓景略扞格。","_cost":0.01782225}},"consensus":70.18,"final":70.18},{"key":"gpt-5.6-sol|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"满库悬灯彻夜明，荧屏验码短铃鸣。长廊辊道分南北，密轨机梭定驿程。倦眼频随包裹转，单衣汗透晓风清。千门乍启生鲜至，岂只云端一键成。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.3,"余味":6.8,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.24999999999999,"rationale":"以仓储夜班揭示“一键”背后的劳作，题旨集中且具当代性。灯、码、辊道、倦眼层层推进，转结有力；“密轨机梭”稍显雕琢，末句点旨略直。","_cost":0.005278},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"以电商云仓夜班入律,题材新而聚焦劳作者,中二联由物及人开合有致,'单衣汗透晓风清'见真切体验。惜结句以反问点破主旨,议论说尽少留白;部分语句如'荧屏验码'偏于纪实白描,炼字未臻警拔。","_cost":0.04507},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"此作将现代物流场景有效入诗，讴歌底层劳动者，立意真挚。中二联从宏观辊道转至微观个人辛劳，章法稳健。然结句“岂只”直白议论，全盘托出，说理过露而乏留白余味，部分遣词略显平淡。","_cost":0.014558},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.0,"rationale":"仓储夜班对照云端一键，题旨集中、情事具体。前半名物铺陈，颈联较融情。结句反问点破题旨，余味不足。当代物象入律是其长处。","_cost":0.020716},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"写云仓夜班分拣生鲜，当代意象具体，由库内劳作推至千门晨启，尾联反问见提升；语言偏平实，结句略露。","_cost":0.0062161},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"夜班仓储劳作入律诗，视角独到，一夜到晓脉络清晰，结句点出'一键'背后的汗水，立意有发现。辊道、机梭、验码等当代意象融入得当，'单衣汗透晓风清'冷暖对照见炼字。中二联略偏罗列铺陈，结句反问稍近说破，微减余味。","_cost":0.00227436},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.39999999999999,"rationale":"取材云仓夜扫，细节具体，能由机器劳作转写人体疲惫，末以生鲜入户反衬后台辛苦，立意新而明确；现代语汇入诗尚妥，但尾句说破，余味稍减。","_cost":0.009354},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"取电商物流新题材，首颔联铺陈机械运作，颈联转至劳者，尾联点破'一键'背后的血汗，由物及人及理，脉络贯通。意象切题而稍呈罗列，尾句直陈其意、说破过多，余味稍损；语言平实少斧凿，'密轨机梭'见炼意，当代经验入律不扭捏，出新可观。","_cost":0.0094248},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.4,"rationale":"聚焦一键背后夜劳动，主脑明确具当代性；辊道机梭等取象切实但铺排感强；转入倦眼汗透由物及人，章法贯通；尾联反问直抒点题，余味稍欠宕开。","_cost":0.0088765},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"本诗聚焦云仓夜作新题材，主脑明确，写实意象贴合，章法连贯，语言精准，点出电商便捷背后的一线辛劳；唯意境偏实，结句稍直，无陈套硬伤，当代经验入诗妥帖。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"以七律写云仓夜班，题材全新而题旨聚焦：尾联'岂只一键成'点破便捷背后之劳作，情事具体。中二联'辊道''机梭'取象精切，颈联由物及人见交融。语言通顺偶有亮点但稍带说明性；结句设问有力略嫌说破，然掩卷有余思。整体出新而不猎奇。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"以云仓夜班入七律，题材新，由机器到人到千门开合层次清楚；“定驿程”“单衣汗透晓风清”有炼字。但颔联偏说明，尾联以“岂只”反问点破主旨，说尽少余味。","_cost":0.05254},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"题材集中，现代物流入律有效；颔联工整，意象具体偏实，结句显志直白少余味；无硬伤陈滥蹈袭，佳联与出新分见加分。","_cost":0.025701019},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.8,"rationale":"智能物流题材入诗极妥帖，机梭辊道不显隔阂。由器物运转切入人力辛劳，层次井然。尾联宕开至万户生鲜，以反诘点破虚拟便利与沉重劳作之反差，立意新颖且具现实关怀。","_cost":0.00674625},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"以夜扫解构一键神话，主脑明确，当代经验入诗有效；惜意象罗列少融情，尾联说破道理，语言欠诗眼锤炼。","_cost":0.00939925}},"consensus":74.64,"final":74.64},{"key":"claude-fable-5|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"铁翼横秋割夜凉，凭窗俯瞰九垓茫。灯连万井疑星堕，一点谁知是故乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.1,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.10000000000001,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写乡思，现代经验入古典语汇。铁翼、万井、星堕层层推进，转结由壮阔收于故乡一点，含蓄有味；“九垓茫”“故乡”稍显熟套。","_cost":0.005096},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"当代夜航经验入诗，思乡熟题得新视角。'割'字见炼，转句灯海疑星堕气象阔大，结句由万点收束一点、以问留白，掩卷有余响。'九垓茫'稍泛，'凭窗俯瞰'略平实，整体一气贯注，佳作。","_cost":0.03235},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"当代经验入诗自然，“铁翼”“割夜凉”造语精练有表现力。转句写万家灯火，结句落笔乡思，起承转合顺畅，情感真挚不落俗套。","_cost":0.011244},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"夜航思乡题旨明确而角度常见，情事尚具体。铁翼、万井灯火与星堕能成境，第三句稍亮。起承转合平稳，结句点破故乡较直，余味有限。","_cost":0.015276},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.8,"意境":9.2,"语言":8.4,"章法":8.6,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":94.5,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写乡愁，万井星火中辨一点故土，情境独到。转结由阔入微，结以问留白；“割”“疑星堕”精炼有力。“九垓”略泛，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0124070496},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰是当代经验入旧体的成功之作。'割'字为诗眼，写铁翼破夜有力；'疑星堕'承俯瞰视角，结句于万点灯火中拈出一点故乡，以小收大，言尽意不尽。起承转合严整，四句一气贯注，无一废字。","_cost":0.00228656},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.3,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.7,"余味":6.8,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.94999999999999,"rationale":"现代夜航取景，起句“铁翼”“割凉”有新意与力度；灯星之喻稍熟，结句点破故乡，余味中等，脉络清楚。","_cost":0.010374},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写乡思,现代经验化入旧题,角度较新;「割」字见炼,「疑星堕」俯仰颠倒成趣,意象统一;起承转合完整有气脉;惜结句直点「故乡」略说破,余味打折。","_cost":0.0159288},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.1,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.45,"rationale":"铁翼割字峭健，万井疑星堕景含情；由九垓茫茫收束一点故乡，起承转合分明，结句以问含情余味悠长，当代夜航经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.00841315},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.5,"rationale":"此作以当代夜航俯瞰视角写乡思，章法圆转流畅，“割”字炼字精警，以万灯如星托出故乡一点的构思见巧，唯立意仍属传统羁愁范畴，结句稍直白。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"当代夜航经验入旧体，视角新颖。'割'字炼字见眼，由万井灯火收束至一点故乡，镜头式推拉章法精巧；结句以问留白，情真可感。惟乡愁主题常见，'九垓''万井'稍熟，整体仍属佳作。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰以当代经验写乡思，由万灯收至一点，主脑集中，转结有力。惟“凭窗俯瞰”与题重复、“九垓茫”凑泛，“灯疑星堕”属常见比喻；结句半说破而留“谁知”之疑，尚有余韵。","_cost":0.04947},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写乡愁，起承转合清顺。疑星堕到一点宏微对照，结句隽永。唯铁翼横秋稍硬，九垓茫略泛，语言锤炼不均。","_cost":0.034395319},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.6,"rationale":"现代夜航体验入诗自然，“割”字炼得警拔有力。后二句由万家灯火的辽阔俯瞰骤收至“一点”乡愁，以大衬小，起承转合章法谨严，情景交融，余韵深长。","_cost":0.0052005}},"consensus":82.38,"final":82.38},{"key":"claude-fable-5|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"铁翼冲霄过大荒,云涛裂处见村庄。千灯泻地翻星海,一水牵天走月光。万里山河归尺幅,百年悲喜付苍茫。谁家几点楼头火,疑是吾庐旧院旁。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.1,"余味":7.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.2,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰收归乡之思，主脑清楚；云涛、灯海、水月层层开拓，末联由宏阔转私情。颔联鲜活，颈联“山河、悲喜、苍茫”稍泛熟，结句含蓄而略近直露。","_cost":0.00622},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰以当代经验入律,乡思归结有主脑。颔联'泻''牵''走'炼字见力,可摘。颈联'归尺幅''付苍茫'开合大而语稍空泛套熟。结句疑是吾庐宕回近处,余味尚存但'疑是'点得稍明。整体脉络贯通,佳作而未臻上乘。","_cost":0.03984},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.0,"rationale":"此诗将现代夜航完美融入律诗。颔联“泻、翻、牵、走”炼字极佳，写尽高空夜景；颈联宕开时空感慨；结联由大入小，落于乡思。意象开阔，属化当代经验入诗的佳作。","_cost":0.023942},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰由阔大转入乡思，主脑清晰而角度常见。颔联取象精切有诗眼，颈联稍概念。结构远近开合尚佳，结句人情足但说得较尽。当代经验入诗有效。","_cost":0.016514},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"思乡角度常见，但尾联落到具体楼火，情志尚真；中二联意象精切，炼字有亮点；章法稳，结句以景留白佳。微有熟套。","_cost":0.015498208},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰这一当代经验化入七律而浑成，视角独到。颔联“泻”“翻”“牵”“走”炼字见诗眼，星海月光与灯火山河交融为统一夜航氛围。颈联大小、久暂对举，气象顿开。结句由宏观收回个人乡愁，宕开有味。“苍茫”稍熟，整体技法精湛。","_cost":0.00248716},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.7,"rationale":"夜航视角新，云灯水月构成高空清旷之境，动词见势；颈联转入苍茫稍泛，语有熟处。结以疑似故园灯火，余味悠然。","_cost":0.011594},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰由宏阔收向故园,主脑集中;星海倒置、尺幅纳万里,象情交融;裂泻牵走诸字有力。颈联时空宕开,尾联以'疑是'作结,乡愁不点破而余韵长。惟苍茫悲喜稍熟,铁翼亦非首见。","_cost":0.0154098},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.55,"rationale":"铁翼夜航的当代视角由宏阔灯海水光宕入苍茫之叹，以疑似故庐作结收束有味；颔联动词精健，章法由远及近层次分明，唯颈联百年付苍茫略显空泛。","_cost":0.00889825},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.1,"rationale":"此作以当代夜航视角写乡思，主脑明晰，章法浑成转合自然，颔联炼字精切为佳，结句稳当有余韵，唯部分意象稍熟、字句略平、颈联下句稍泛。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰入旧体,当代经验化古出新。颔联'千灯泻地''一水牵天'取象精切、动静相生,为全篇警联。颈联由景入情开合有度,尾联以楼头火收束,悬想吾庐,以景结情,余味悠长。唯'山河''苍茫'稍熟,整体气脉贯通,情真境切。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰这一当代经验入诗,颔联“泻”“牵”“走”炼字有力,灯海月水交融成境,可摘为佳联。颈联转入“万里山河”“百年悲喜”略大而空,近套语。结句由宏返微、以疑收束有留白,但手法常见,余味中上。","_cost":0.04696},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"起势雄健，颔联‘千灯泻地翻星海’警炼；夜航俯瞰入诗出新，结句‘疑是’留白。惜颈联‘苍茫’稍泛，‘楼头火’略粗。","_cost":0.028735565},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.9,"rationale":"现代夜航经验入诗妥帖自然，造境雄阔生动。颈联略落大词套路，但尾联由宏阔骤敛至乡思微光，章法开阖有度，极具情味。","_cost":0.00628125}},"consensus":81.19,"final":81.19},{"key":"claude-fable-5|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"千山隔断掌中开，笑语分明午夜来。话尽屏昏成暗镜，翻惊照我鬓先灰。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.7,"意境":8.8,"语言":8.3,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.8,"警句":4.2,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.95,"rationale":"暗屏由通话媒介陡变照鬓之镜，当代经验与衰老惊觉相扣。转结有力，“掌中开”“鬓先灰”略显着意。","_cost":0.006084},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.0,"rationale":"当代经验入诗成功：视频通话由喜转悲，脉络紧凑。'屏昏成暗镜'化屏幕为镜照见衰鬓，取象精切、转结有力，堪称警句。结句'翻惊'虽稍说破仍有延宕。'鬓先灰'略近熟语，微扣陈滥。","_cost":0.03734},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":9.0,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":94.0,"rationale":"当代经验入诗自然巧妙。前两联写跨越时空通话的欢悦，转句“屏昏成暗镜”极具巧思，由动入静拉回现实；结句定格于黑屏映出的白发，画面冲击力强，时光流逝与深沉思念浑然一体，转结极佳。","_cost":0.01501},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"视频入诗、屏昏成镜见鬓霜，情事具体、转合清楚。然千山鬓灰偏熟，结句点破衰老，余韵有限，炼字平稳少惊人之笔。","_cost":0.023006},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":9.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":95.75,"rationale":"以视频通话切入离别与岁月主题，角度新、情感真。暗镜照鬓灰一结，物象交融，言尽意远。语言精炼无废字，转结有力，现代经验入诗自然无痕。","_cost":0.00381216},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.5,"rationale":"视频通话入绝句，掌中开千山想象奇警；话尽屏暗化镜，照见鬓灰，离别与迟暮双意叠收，转结尤妙。语浅而情深，当代经验与古体格律浑融，结句以象收束，余味悠长。","_cost":0.00200216},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.4,"语言":8.1,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.9,"rationale":"以掌中屏写远隔，由笑语忽转屏暗成镜，照出鬓灰，现代经验入诗而情在象中。章法起转分明，结尾略有惊老之直，但余味尚存。","_cost":0.00879},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":77.75,"rationale":"以视频通话写羁旅亲情与惊老之叹,角度新而有主脑。转结最力:话尽屏暗、屏化为镜、照见鬓灰,层层翻出,'暗镜'一象精切。承句稍平,'千山''鬓灰'略熟,'鬓先灰'与放翁'衰鬓已先斑'意近,酌减。整体今事入古而不隔,余哀不尽。","_cost":0.0113898},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.25,"rationale":"以掌中视频写千山隔绝，笑语暖热后转入屏昏暗镜，陡然自照惊灰，转结跌宕有力，物象与孤 aging 之感交融，当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.00680465},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.75,"rationale":"此作以当代深夜视频通话入七绝，起承转合圆融，以息屏照鬓细节收束，融通话后空落与叹老之情，炼字精准，自然有新意。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"视频通话入旧体而情真：屏由通情之窗翻作照影之暗镜，转结陡峭有力，'翻惊'为诗眼，见鬓灰之惊与独处之寂，言尽意不尽。'千山隔断掌中开'化熟为新。唯首二句意象稍常见，整体取象精切、脉络贯通。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"当代视频通话入诗而不生硬，前二句欢聚，第三句屏暗成镜一转极巧，由他人笑语翻见自身鬓灰，团圆反照孤老，一篇有主脑。结句以景带情，唯'翻惊''鬓灰'稍点破、略袭旧套，余味稍减。","_cost":0.04021},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.25,"rationale":"以深夜视频写远隔重逢，屏暗成镜反照鬓灰，当代经验入诗自然；转结有力，次联警策。虽用‘千山’‘鬓灰’熟词，但化入新境，未陈滥。","_cost":0.01930345},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.8,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.7,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.05,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗的佳作。转结极精，“屏昏成暗镜”将手机息屏转化为鉴容之镜，由连线欢聚骤转入岑寂，引出孤身叹老之痛。脉络一气贯注，出新而不伤古格。","_cost":0.00551475}},"consensus":87.78,"final":87.78},{"key":"claude-fable-5|云端相册|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"千张旧照入云收，岁月无声指下流。万里山川藏掌上，十年悲喜落心头。慈颜已逐寒烟去，笑语犹凭方寸留。莫道人间多聚散，苍穹为我贮温柔。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.4,"rationale":"以云相册承载悼念与聚散，主脑鲜明，当代经验入诗自然。云、掌、方寸前后照应，章法紧密；“指下流”颇传神。寒烟、心头、温柔稍近熟套，结句有回环而略说满。","_cost":0.006152},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"以云端相册悼亲怀旧，当代经验入诗有新意，颈联'慈颜/方寸'一联情事具体最动人。但'岁月无声''悲喜落心头''贮温柔'等语偏熟软，中二联数字对仗稍显套路。结句双关'苍穹'与云存储虽巧，却把情意说得过满，留白不足。","_cost":0.03151},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"本诗将“云相册”这一当代经验自然入诗，立意巧妙，情感真挚。脉络清晰，起承转合规整，颔颈两联切题且稳妥。唯语言稍显直白，意象略为常见，结句以议论抒情直白说破，余味稍欠。总体为切入点新颖的佳作。","_cost":0.01628},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"云相册存逝者音容，题旨集中且有当代切入。颔联概括尚可，寒烟苍穹聚散温柔套语偏密，结句点破少留白，整体稳而未深。","_cost":0.018266},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"以云端相册悼亡，当代体验入诗而情感具体；意象云、掌、方寸、苍穹统一。中二联时空开合，‘贮温柔’见炼字。结句直中有象，余味稍减。‘慈颜’一联佳；微有熟语。","_cost":0.01721638},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"以云端存照写丧亲之思，当代经验自然入旧体，构思新而情真。中二联掌上山川与心头悲喜、寒烟慈颜与方寸笑语，空间时间两两开合，层次分明。'指下流''苍穹贮温柔'炼字见巧，结句以景宕开、言尽意不尽。'岁月无声'稍熟，整体精纯。","_cost":0.00244336},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.55,"rationale":"以云相册写记忆悼亡，起承转合清楚，当代题材入诗较自然；颈联方寸有双关，结句苍茫稍留余味。惜岁月无声、人间聚散等语偏熟，议论略直，意象未臻精警。","_cost":0.010676},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"云相册与亡亲记忆相扣，“藏掌上/落心头”成联，转结有温情；惟悲喜、聚散、温柔稍抽象，结意偏明说。","_cost":0.0156702},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.4,"意境":6.6,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.7,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"借数字云端双关苍穹，旧题写出当代经验，颔颈由广及亲转合自然；语顺意足而寒烟聚散等意象偏熟，结句以贮温柔收束留有余韵。","_cost":0.010047},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"本诗借云端相册抒忆旧悼亲之情，当代经验入诗自然，章法连贯，语言通顺；但部分意象偏熟，结句较直白，余味稍弱，有少量陈词，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"以云端存储写生死怀亲，当代经验入旧体而情真事切，'慈颜已逐寒烟去，笑语犹凭方寸留'一联沉痛精切，尾联'苍穹为我贮温柔'借'云'字双关收束，宕开有味。颔联'藏掌上''落心头'对仗稳。微憾：寒烟、聚散稍熟，个别处直白。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"以云端相册寄慈亲之思，题材当代，“云收”“方寸”双关尚巧；但中二联万里/十年、掌上/心头对仗平熟，词多套语。结句“苍穹贮温柔”说破兜底，抽象收束，余味不足。","_cost":0.04408},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.0,"rationale":"以云端相册存照悼母，题旨集中，数字经验入诗有新意；“指下流”“方寸留”见锤炼，颈联成佳联。然意象多熟套，结句直白少留白，稍有陈语。","_cost":0.030679674},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.7,"rationale":"当代数字生活题材入诗自然妥帖，双关“云端”与“苍穹”，化科技存储为深情守望。章法脉络清晰，颔颈二联工整真切；部分字句略见熟套，但结联转出温厚意趣，余味充沛。","_cost":0.004959}},"consensus":74.81,"final":74.81},{"key":"gpt-5.6-sol|社区食堂|七律","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"巷口炊烟送早香，邻翁缓步入回廊。青瓜细切成丝缕，豆腐轻煨作荠汤。掌上荧屏呈价目，银龄膳券暖饥肠。孤身未觉黄昏冷，满座欢声出粉墙。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"unknown"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.3,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.7,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.35000000000001,"rationale":"由晨炊、膳食写到养老关怀，主脑集中；荧屏、膳券入诗自然。章法递进清楚，结句有声有景；“暖饥肠”“黄昏冷”稍显直熟。","_cost":0.007108},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.0,"rationale":"当代题材入律,写养老助餐真切有温度,尾联以声出墙收束尚有余韵。但中二联仅平列菜品与场景,开合层次不足;'呈价目''暖饥肠'语近直白;首联言'早香'尾联跳至'黄昏',时序稍失照应。'荧屏''膳券'化新经验入诗可嘉,整体平稳有余而警策不足。","_cost":0.0386},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"立意贴近当代生活，情感具体真挚。章法井然，颔联颇具烟火气。唯颈联引入‘荧屏’‘膳券’稍显生硬，缺乏诗意熔炼；结句‘未觉黄昏冷’略嫌直白说破。总体是一首富有时代气息的叙事佳作。","_cost":0.015564},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"社区食堂写银发温情，事具体有主脑；意象新旧并置未浑融，炼字平实少诗眼，章法完整转平直，结句点破孤寂少留白。","_cost":0.014622},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.8,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.6,"rationale":"取当代社区食堂题材，情事具体，尾联以欢声出墙收束有余味；中二联稍平直，语言偏叙述化文白略夹，但无硬伤。","_cost":0.00557062},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"以社区食堂写养老民生，当代经验有效入诗，题旨聚焦、情事具体。中二联一写烹饪一写支付，层次分明；颈联'荧屏''膳券'与古调相融不隔。结句以景结情，欢声出墙而孤身之暖自见。'银龄''暖饥肠'稍带公文气，炊烟粉墙略熟。","_cost":0.00267036},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.4,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.7,"rationale":"题材有当代温情，食堂细节具体；但中段直陈政策与暖意，说破稍多，语言略平，现代词入诗未全化。结以欢声出墙，稍留余韵。","_cost":0.01432},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"以社区食堂写银龄关怀，题旨明确、情事具体，荧屏价目、膳券等当代经验入诗自然。中二联白描切实，但'作荠汤'搭配生硬，语言总体平实少诗眼。结句以欢声出墙宕开，尚有余韵，唯暖意稍直露，通篇亮点不足。","_cost":0.0115008},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.9,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.3,"余味":7.7,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.3,"rationale":"社区食堂切入老龄关怀，视角具体有主脑；炊烟菜蔬至荧屏膳券层递，以满座欢声收束，黄昏不冷余味长，惟颔颈铺叙稍平少诗眼。","_cost":0.0075675},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"本诗聚焦社区老年食堂的日常温情，细节充实，脉络顺畅，当代民生场景入诗自然；但整体偏平实，意象、转折较平直，余韵不足，少量用语常见，无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"以当代社区食堂写养老温情，题材新而情事具体，'孤身未觉黄昏冷，满座欢声出粉墙'以反差收束有味。'荧屏呈价目''银龄膳券'化当代经验入律较自然。惟中二联偏铺叙，'细切''轻煨'炼字平熟，'炊烟''饥肠'稍见套语，整体通顺有余而诗眼不足。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"题材当代，青瓜、豆腐、荧屏、膳券细节具体，胜于泛颂。然中二联纯纪实少情味，'暖饥肠''炊烟'近熟套，'银龄膳券'稍硬。首句'早香'与七句'黄昏'时序跳脱。结句以声出墙尚有画面，但第七句已说破。","_cost":0.05817},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"立意明确而常见、情志稍浅；意象具体温馨，现代词碍交融；语言有亮点而颈联生硬套语；章法完整、转折略平；结句直言温情，以欢声出墙略延余味。警句平平，出新有限；无硬伤蹈袭，陈滥轻微。","_cost":0.026733932},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.4,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.3,"rationale":"当代民生题材切入自然，市井烟火与敬老温情兼备。荧屏膳券入律平实妥帖，结句以欢声收束见温度。惟首联写晨早而结句忽转黄昏，时序跨度稍显突兀。","_cost":0.0058455},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"以老龄共餐写暖意，题材贴近当代有主脑；膳食券屏白描具体；语言偏口语少诗眼；结构贯通而转折平直；尾以欢声收，情真而直露。","_cost":0.0097095}},"consensus":68.08,"final":68.08},{"key":"claude-fable-5|深夜视频|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"深宵一线接遥城，咫尺荧光两地明。白发慈颜灯下坐，殷勤细问旅途情。凝眸欲抚屏中鬓，侧耳频惊断续声。话到更阑浑未觉，银河渐落晓寒生。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"以视频通话写两地亲情，情事具体，主线清晰；“欲抚屏中鬓”尤见隔屏之憾。末句以银河晓寒收情，余味悠长。白发、慈颜等稍熟，部分措辞偏传统套语。","_cost":0.004802},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"视频通话入律,当代经验真切,'欲抚屏中鬓''频惊断续声'一联写隔屏思亲之痛与信号断续,精警有新意。结句以景收束有余味。惟颔联对仗松弛近于叙述,'白发慈颜''更阑''银河'等语稍落熟套,炼字尚欠力度。","_cost":0.04704},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"写深夜视频通话的亲情，题材当代而入诗自然。颈联“欲抚屏中鬓”“频惊断续声”细节精切，是全篇诗眼；尾联以银河晓寒作景结，收得住。惟“白发慈颜”“旅途情”“更阑”等语偏熟，立意仍属当代常见路数，未见独到翻新。","_cost":0.05686},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.0,"rationale":"将“视频通话”当代经验自然入诗，立意真挚。颈联“欲抚屏中鬓”“断续声”精准捕捉网络卡顿下的亲情互动，画面生动。尾联以景结情，银河晓寒烘托不尽之意。唯颔联造语略熟，整体章法严密，是一首佳作。","_cost":0.028032},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"视频通话入诗情事具体，屏中鬓、断续声能见交融；题旨常见、章法平叙少折，结句晓寒稍套而余味有限。","_cost":0.01247},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.75,"rationale":"写深夜视频慰亲，细节真切，颈联“屏中鬓”“断续声”尤具屏幕质感。尾联以银河晓寒景结，余味悠长。稍用白发、银河等熟象，整体结构稳顺。","_cost":0.0047300352},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"以视频通话入旧体，寻常亲情翻出新境，物象(荧光、屏中鬓、断续声)与情思高度交融，中二联开合有致，结以银河晓寒宕开留白。'凝眸欲抚屏中鬓'为诗眼，虚实相生尤动人。惟'银河渐落晓寒生'略沿旧套，结字稍平。","_cost":0.0033652},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.2,"rationale":"以视频写亲情，场景具体，颈联凝眸抚鬓、侧耳惊声最能传神；尾以银河晓寒收束有余味。惜慈颜殷勤等语稍熟，题旨未脱思念常调。","_cost":0.011806},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.5,"rationale":"当代经验入诗真切，'凝眸欲抚屏中鬓'情事具体、堪称警策；章法由接通、双方情景到自己对答，层层有致；结以银河晓寒收住，留白可延。惟'殷勤''慈颜''浑未觉'等熟语稍减力度，无袭用。","_cost":0.02691255},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.7,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.1,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.8,"rationale":"视频通话写亲情，细节真切具体；颈联欲抚频惊摹态传神，当代物象入律自然，尾联以银河晓寒景结情，温寒对照余韵悠长。","_cost":0.010293},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"以深夜视频通话写亲情，屏中鬓、断续声等现代经验入律，情事具体；颈联欲抚屏鬓为佳；结句以银河晓寒收景有余味。然中二联开合稍平，白发灯下、银河晓寒等意象略熟。","_cost":0.030973126},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"此作写深夜隔屏探亲的当代日常，章法圆融一气，细节真切，颈联传视频时代亲情之神，景结有余味；唯部分意象偏熟，个别语句稍平。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.65,"rationale":"现代视频题材入律熨帖自然。颈联将隔屏关切与信号断续化为生动诗语，极具当代生活实感与人情味。结构流畅贯通，尾联以景结情，余味清远。","_cost":0.00407175}},"consensus":80.49,"final":80.49},{"key":"claude-fable-5|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"巷口炊烟午正开，邻翁拄杖笑相陪。孤居不叹晨昏冷，一碗清羹暖意回。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.6,"语言":6.1,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.3,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.50000000000001,"rationale":"社区养老入诗，关怀具体，主旨集中。炊烟、拄杖、清羹相互映照，结构顺畅；“笑相陪”稍泛，末句直说暖意，留白不足。","_cost":0.005326},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"以社区食堂写老龄关怀，题材当代、情感温和真切，但角度停于常见颂暖。炊烟、拄杖取象平顺欠新，第三句直说'不叹''冷'，结句'暖意回'把情说破，缺留白。章法起承转合完整而转折平直，无警句，整体稳而不奇。","_cost":0.03122},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"题材切入当代生活，立意质朴温情，起承转合顺畅。但语言直白缺锤炼，意象略平，结句将情意说尽，缺乏留白与余味。是一首通顺达意但诗味稍弱的纪实作品。","_cost":0.01507},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"当代食堂切入孤居温饱，情事较具体；意象多套语，语言平直少炼，转结说破暖意，余韵不足。","_cost":0.014712},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"以社区食堂写孤居老人，题材具体，情感真实，主脑清楚；但意象语言偏常见，转结平直，结句说破暖意致余味不足。","_cost":0.00509212},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.5,"rationale":"以七绝写社区食堂，当代民生经验入旧体，立意有温度有主脑。起承转合完整，'孤居不叹'一转见情。结句'暖意回'直接说破，余味打折。'炊烟''清羹'稍近套语，整体语言平顺而锤炼不足。","_cost":0.00186416},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.8,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.8,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.8,"rationale":"写社区食堂暖孤居老人，题材当代而情旨明确；巷口炊烟、邻翁清羹有生活气息，但转结偏直，末句“暖意回”说破，余味不足。语言平顺少锤炼。","_cost":0.008772},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"社区食堂、孤老题材具当代性,题旨明确、情感温和,但角度止于'暖胃暖心'的常规温情,发现不深。炊烟、拄杖、清羹取象妥帖而常见,语言通顺无诗眼,转句以议论'不叹'作转略平直,结句'暖意回'说尽无留白。题材出新可奖,惜开掘浅、暖意语近套。","_cost":0.0086358},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.3,"意境":6.6,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.05,"rationale":"社区食堂切入老龄温情，题材当代而开掘不深；炊烟清羹等象妥帖但偏常见，语言平顺少诗眼，转结完整，结句以物收而暖意说破留白不足。","_cost":0.00735375},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"此作聚焦社区食堂孤老就餐小场景，情感真挚，结构顺畅，语言浅白精准，当代民生题材入诗自然；唯意象平熟，结句直白少留白，警策度不足。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"取材社区食堂，当代经验入诗，孤居老人得一碗热羹，情事具体有主脑。'拄杖笑相陪'细节真切。惟'炊烟''暖意回'属熟语，结句'暖意回'直接点破题旨，说尽少留白；转合平顺无奇崛，整体稳而欠深。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.5,"rationale":"题材取自当代社区食堂，有现实关怀，但处理浅表：炊烟、拄杖、笑相陪、清羹暖意皆惯常搭配；第三句直说“不叹冷”，结句“暖意回”将主旨说破兜底，缺乏留白。语言平顺少诗眼，结构完整而转折平直。","_cost":0.02044},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"题旨明确，写社区食堂温慰孤老，具现实关怀而角度稍常见；意象妥帖但多熟语，情语直露；语言通顺乏诗眼，“午正开”稍硬；起承转合完整、转折平直；结句直白少余韵。当代题材入诗有出新，无警句硬伤蹈袭，略有陈滥。","_cost":0.034695781},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.5,"rationale":"现实题材入诗自然，聚焦独居老人与社区温情，章法承转顺畅，烟火气充盈。唯造语平实直白，结句略显说破兜底，耐人回味处稍欠。","_cost":0.00405225}},"consensus":63.58,"final":63.58},{"key":"claude-fable-5|社区食堂|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"巷尾新添惠老堂，厨烟每日接晨光。杯盘价薄人情重，匕箸声喧笑语扬。白发欣辞炊爨累，青衿正趁午间忙。黄昏客散余温在，留与迟归一碗汤。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"聚焦社区食堂惠老便民，晨昏铺叙，烟火气与人情味交融；颔颈联兼顾老人、青年，层次清楚。结句“一碗汤”具体温厚，余意可延。“价薄”“青衿”稍显刻意，部分措辞较熟。","_cost":0.004664},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.5,"rationale":"当代民生题材入律,情事具体不空喊;晨光至黄昏时间线贯通,章法完整。中二联白发青衿对照有致,惟'人情重''笑语扬'近报刊套语,取象平实少警拔。结句'留与迟归一碗汤'以细节收温情,言尽意存,为全篇亮点。","_cost":0.03408},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"当代经验入诗，立意温情。章法依晨、午、昏时间推进，脉络清晰；结句“一碗汤”以物象收束，温馨有余味。唯“炊爨”“青衿”等旧词与现代题材略显文白夹杂。","_cost":0.019632},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"惠老食堂情事具体主脑清楚，角度仍属常见民生温情。厨烟杯盘白发余温统一而欠精切。价薄人情重等有对照，通顺少废。起承至黄昏收束完整偏平。结句一碗汤未说尽。","_cost":0.01718},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"以社区食堂日常民生入诗，情感具体，尾联余温留汤最有余味。中二联意象偏熟，语言平实，“价薄”稍生。整体结构清晰，当代题材可嘉。","_cost":0.012837},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"当代社区养老题材有效入诗，以一日晨午黄昏为脉络，取象精切（厨烟、匕箸、余温、一碗汤），白发青衿一联见开合。'价薄人情重'翻出新意，结句以一碗汤宕开，言尽意不尽。个别措辞如'笑语扬'稍熟，'惠老堂'微带公文气。","_cost":0.00304136},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.4,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.1,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.3,"rationale":"取材社区食堂，烟火气与助老温情俱足，脉络清晰，尾句一碗汤有暖意；但语带宣传化，意象偏熟，转折平直，余味未充分宕开。","_cost":0.012124},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.0,"rationale":"当代惠老题材入律，晨—午—昏脉络清，结句一碗汤最有余温；中二联稍平直，“青衿”略隔，“人情重”等语偏明说。","_cost":0.0161178},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.8,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.85,"rationale":"当代题材以晨午昏贯穿，老少共食见人情温厚；意象妥帖而白描偏多，尾联以一碗汤收束留白，余味为佳。","_cost":0.0090669},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"聚焦社区食堂当代民生场景，情志真挚，章法圆顺，结句以留汤细节藏暖意，语言平实，新事入诗自然，唯部分表述稍熟，炼字欠精警。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"当代社区经验入诗，惠老题材翻出新境，情感真挚有主脑。意象具体统一，'价薄人情重'对比见巧。尾联'留与迟归一碗汤'以景结情，余温余味俱佳，为全诗诗眼所在。中二联工稳，'午间忙'稍显直白凑韵，语言整体通顺但锤炼略平。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"题材当代、脉络按晨午昏贯通，结句余温与一碗汤以景收情，最见温厚。然中二联多正面直叙，价薄人情重近于标语，声喧笑语扬亦属套语，取象平实少奇警。","_cost":0.0493},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"写社区食堂惠老，晨炊至黄昏留汤，脉络清。中二联价廉声喧、老逸少忙，转折稍平；尾联以“一碗汤”细节收，余温袅袅，有余味。意象语言妥帖但常见；尾联佳，当代经验入诗有效。无硬伤蹈袭，陈滥轻。","_cost":0.033557002},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.8,"rationale":"当代民生题材有效入诗。按晨光至黄昏时序推进，章法严谨。虽颔联略平直，但尾联“留与迟归一碗汤”化宏大为具象，温情脉脉，不落空泛口号，余味悠长。","_cost":0.00527925}},"consensus":75.24,"final":75.24},{"key":"claude-fable-5|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"移向春街寄此生，悬壶滴滴续枝荣。琼浆输尽终为客，梦里犹闻涧水声。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.60000000000001,"rationale":"以吊瓶救治移栽街树，寄寓漂泊乡愁，主脑鲜明；由移栽、输液转入梦闻涧水，层层收深。悬壶双关巧，结句有余韵；“琼浆”“寄此生”稍熟滥，“枝荣”略显硬。","_cost":0.006078},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"咏移栽行道树挂吊瓶，当代题材切入有独到发现。'悬壶'双关医树、行医巧妙；'终为客'点出树之漂泊身世，结句以梦中涧水声宕开，言尽意不尽，余味最佳。'续枝荣'稍显硬凑，'琼浆'略俗，语言尚有打磨余地，然一气贯注，转结俱佳。","_cost":0.03264},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.75,"rationale":"本诗将“树挂吊瓶”这一当代日常巧妙入诗。前两句“悬壶”双关精当；后两句借移栽之树抒写羁旅客愁，结句以故乡涧水声宕开，与城市滴液声暗中对比，情景交融，余味悠长，立意极佳。","_cost":0.016098},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"吊瓶养树写移植如客，物象具体有当代感；悬壶、琼浆与涧水对比尚融。题旨仍属常见异化/乡思，炼字偶亮而整体平，转结直，结句套式，余味有限。","_cost":0.01937},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.4,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶寄客居乡愁，立意新而统一；转结得力，结句以梦收余味长。语言略平但“悬壶滴滴”有诗眼。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.00843348},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.75,"rationale":"以城市吊瓶输液之树写移栽者客居之悲，当代经验入诗自然无痕。悬壶双关精妙，输字兼 transfusion 与输失两义。转句终为客翻出新境，结以梦里涧声宕开，以景结情，言尽意远。全篇一气贯注，物我交融。","_cost":0.00278216},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.89999999999999,"rationale":"借街树输液写移栽城市之寄居感，由悬壶续枝到客梦山泉，脉络清楚，结有回甘；语略熟，部分意象偏常见。","_cost":0.016302},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"咏街头输液树,当代物事入诗而不生硬。'悬壶'双关行医,贴切;'终为客'点出移栽者的无根之感,结句梦回涧水,以虚景宕开故园之思,言尽意不尽。通体意象统一、转结有力。唯'琼浆'略熟,'续枝荣'稍平直,未至字字生辉。","_cost":0.0086478},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.55,"rationale":"借树吊瓶喻人生移植，悬壶双关、终为客点睛，转结由街头输液宕入梦中涧声，物我交融，余韵不尽。","_cost":0.0111995},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.5,"rationale":"借春街输液移栽树寄寓失根之慨，取象妥帖，'悬壶'双关巧妙，起承转合圆顺，结以涧水旧梦留余韵，当代经验入诗自然，仅个别字词稍熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"以行道树挂吊瓶入诗，当代经验与羁旅乡愁熔于一炉：'终为客''梦里涧水声'将人工续命与故土之思对照，情事具体，主脑分明。'悬壶'双关自然。结句以梦境收束，言尽意不尽。唯'琼浆''滴滴'稍见熟滑，整体取象尚可更精。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"以移栽树挂吊瓶写都市化中的身世飘零，当代经验入诗有效；“悬壶”双关精巧，结句以涧水声反衬他乡之客，有余味。惟“琼浆”“寄此生”“梦里犹闻”稍落熟套，转合平稳而少奇变。","_cost":0.04141},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.25,"rationale":"当代街树输液之景入诗，“悬壶”双关见诗眼；转结由续荣到终为客，梦里涧声以声结情，言尽意远。间有“琼浆”“涧水”等常语，整体立意出新、章法完密、余味足，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.027329161},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.45,"rationale":"切入当代城景，借病树输液写异乡飘零之痛，立意深刻。转结尤佳，由“终为客”的清醒疏离，荡开至梦中“涧水声”，以虚景结情，余音袅袅。","_cost":0.00510525}},"consensus":85.19,"final":85.19},{"key":"claude-fable-5|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"春街树挂玻璃泪，点滴清如宿雨声。离却旧林根尚浅，来依高厦叶初萌。当年自饮千山雪，此日全凭一线情。会待针痕平复后，绿云铺作万家晴。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.1,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.2,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.30000000000001,"rationale":"以树木输液写城市移栽之痛与复苏，主脑鲜明。颈联今昔对照有力，“一线情”双关自然；全篇意象贯通，结以绿荫惠万家。个别“千山雪”“万家晴”稍显宏阔套熟。","_cost":0.005942},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"移栽行道树输液这一当代物事入诗,题材新而寄托真,通篇以树自况脉络贯通。颈联'当年自饮千山雪,此日全凭一线情'今昔对举,'一线'双关输液管与人情,是警句。结句祝愿之意稍说尽,'绿云''万家晴'略近熟语,余味稍减。","_cost":0.03611},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.25,"rationale":"此诗巧妙将“树木输液”这一当代城市场景入诗，立意新颖。“当年自饮千山雪，此日全凭一线情”对比强烈，情志真挚。起承转合自然，结句以景结情，余味生机盎然。全篇语言精切，是当代经验入旧体诗的佳作。","_cost":0.014188},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"行道树输液入诗，题旨集中，当代经验可取。玻璃泪、千山雪有象，一线情偏巧。颔颈时空对照尚清，尾联拔高说尽，绿云万家偏套，余味不足。","_cost":0.029866},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"以城市树挂吊瓶入诗，角度新而立意集中；颈联今昔对比与“一线情”双关为佳。颔联偏叙述，章法常规，整体以绿云愿景收束，余味尚可。","_cost":0.02008248},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"以城市移栽树挂吊瓶为题，当代经验入诗贴切自然。'玻璃泪''一线情'设喻精巧，颈联'当年自饮千山雪，此日全凭一线情'今昔对照开阔沉痛，堪称警联。中二联开合有致，脉络贯通，结句以景收束含希望。整体真挚具体，主脑分明。","_cost":0.00242676},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.5,"rationale":"以城市树木输液入诗，题材新巧；颈联今昔对照，有情有骨。玻璃泪、一线情铸象生动，但绿云万家稍落熟套，结意略明。","_cost":0.014422},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.25,"rationale":"以行道树输营养液入七律，题材新而切；'玻璃泪''一线情'双关工巧，颈联今昔对比最有力；尾联宕开作景结，余韵足。个別语如'绿云''万家晴'稍熟，整体情事具体、脉络贯通。","_cost":0.0076458},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.8,"意境":8.4,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.6,"余味":7.9,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.8,"rationale":"以行道树吊瓶这一当代细节入诗，写移植之痛与寄生之怜，主脑清晰；玻璃泪、一线情等炼字精切，今昔对比较真切，结句由一树推及万家晴，章法贯注余韵足。","_cost":0.0077389},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"咏城市移栽挂吊针的行道树，角度新颖具象，意象贴合，章法顺、今昔对比有致，炼字有亮点，结句稍直，融入当代经验，无硬伤蹈袭，仅少量熟象。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"以城市移栽树挂吊瓶入诗，当代经验与古典体式融合自然，题旨新颖具体。'玻璃泪''针痕'取象精切，颈联'当年自饮千山雪，此日全凭一线情'今昔对照、双关有力，为全篇警策。中二联开合有致，脉络贯通。结句'绿云铺作万家晴'收束稍满，然宕开至万家，尚有余响。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"取城市移栽树挂营养液为题，当代经验入诗有效，'点滴''一线'双关自然，颈联千山雪对一线情为全篇警策。颔颈两联今昔对比略有重叠，尾联祝愿式收束说尽，'绿云''万家晴'稍熟套，余味不足。","_cost":0.05203},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"以街树吊瓶入七律，题材新颖，立意聚焦树的移栽与疗愈；玻璃泪、一线情等喻象新切而融贯。中二联昔今对照，章法稳。然结句绿云万家稍直白熟套，余味不足，语言偶见熟语。","_cost":0.030976462},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.2,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.39999999999999,"rationale":"当代经验入诗之佳作。将移栽树木挂吊瓶化为“玻璃泪”“针痕”，妥帖新警。颈联今昔对比极具张力，寄托深远；全诗脉络贯通，尾联化狭为广，兼具巧思与温情。","_cost":0.0057195}},"consensus":84.24,"final":84.24},{"key":"claude-fable-5|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":null,"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"claude-fable-5|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"月转云仓四鼓忙,琳琅万货赴遐方。长廊十里明如昼,高架千寻影似霜。百码轻鸣连九陌,孤身遥立守空场。何当裹我思归梦,扫入晨光第一箱。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.4,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.4,"rationale":"以夜扫云仓写劳作与思归，题材新鲜，明暗、动静映衬得当。尾联将梦“裹”“扫”入箱，巧妙含蓄；“百码”“九陌”稍显凑饰。","_cost":0.004536},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"以物流夜班入诗,当代经验有效转化。中二联由货及人,'孤身守空场'与'万货赴遐方'形成张力,一篇有主脑。结联把思归梦'扫入晨光第一箱',化职业动作为奇想,言尽意不尽,是全篇警策。'琳琅''千寻'稍熟套,炼字略逊于构思。","_cost":0.03916},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"本诗将现代“云仓”与“扫码”经验完美融入律诗。以宏大繁华的物流场景反衬劳动者的孤身思乡，极具张力。“百码轻鸣”炼字精切，结联“扫入晨光第一箱”将现代动作与古典乡愁无缝交融，余味悠长，高度出新。","_cost":0.025648},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"云仓夜班入律、梦裹入箱有当代巧思，主脑尚清；中联光影熟语偏平，炼字未警。结句以象绾情较有宕延。","_cost":0.022158},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"以现代物流夜扫翻新，思归与打包融合，意象统一；结句“扫入晨光第一箱”留白出彩，唯“百码”稍涩、个别熟语略减语言分。","_cost":0.0128101248},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"夜班仓储工入诗,题材新而情感实,主脑聚焦'孤守与思归'。中二联一景一人开合有致,尾联以'扫'字双关,将思归梦裹入晨光第一箱,化李商隐'何当'句式而不袭,宕开收束,余味极佳。'琳琅万货''九陌'稍泛,略带套语。","_cost":0.00292836},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.89999999999999,"rationale":"云仓夜扫取材新，能将忙碌、孤守与思归结到“第一箱”，有现代诗眼。然十里千寻、明如昼、影似霜等熟语较多，铺排稍泛，情境未深。","_cost":0.018954},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"以现代物流夜景托孤身乡愁，象意统一且收束新奇；中二联“明如昼”“影似霜”略熟，十里千寻稍夸。","_cost":0.0135498},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.4,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.2,"rationale":"以云仓夜作切题，万货与孤身对照收束至思归，裹梦入箱一想巧；中二联平铺写景，意象多明如昼影似霜类现成。","_cost":0.007463},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.0,"rationale":"此作聚焦云仓夜值的当代劳动场景，融值守者思归情愫，结句“扫”字双关精巧，章法顺畅，意象妥帖，唯个别比喻稍熟，无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"以夜班分拣员视角写现代物流,万货琳琅与孤身空场对照见孤独,尾联'扫入晨光第一箱'化扫码为归梦,奇想真挚不说破,余味悠长。中二联对仗工稳,'百码轻鸣'炼字见巧。唯'明如昼''影似霜'稍熟,整体取象精切、一气贯注,当代经验入诗成功。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"以当代电商仓库夜班入律,取材新鲜,由喧闹转孤守,结句'扫入晨光第一箱'化扫码为寄梦,巧而有情。中联'影似霜'佳,'百码连九陌'稍硬,'琳琅万货''明如昼'略熟。","_cost":0.05088},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"当代云仓夜扫经验入律，梦归主题翻出新境，情事具体；意象妥帖而明如昼等稍常，语言以'扫入晨光第一箱'见巧；章法起承转合分明，结句托物留白。尾联为警句，当代经验有效入诗，微有陈滥，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.037885058},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"成功将当代物流仓储体验化入律体。扫码声与高架仓入诗妥帖自然，颈联以物境庞大反衬孤身操作，尾联将归思具象化为快件扫入晨光，巧思动人且余味绵长。","_cost":0.00488325}},"consensus":80.08,"final":80.08},{"key":"gemini-3.1-pro|机场送别|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.1-pro","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"巨翼迎风待远行，飞桥一入别愁生。须臾振响凌云去，便隔长空万里程。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.8,"意境":6.3,"语言":5.9,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.2,"警句":0.8,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.55,"rationale":"以飞桥、巨翼写机场送别，物象切题且次第清楚；情感真切但发现较常见。“凌云”“万里程”略熟，末句直陈距离，收束有余而留白不足。","_cost":0.004676},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"以机场入诗有当代经验,巨翼、飞桥取象具体,起承转合脉络清楚。惜情感泛写,别愁凌云万里程皆熟语,人事全无着落,结句把'隔'字说破,余味有限。属题材出新而笔力平常之作。","_cost":0.03043},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.25,"rationale":"诗作将机场、飞桥等现代经验入诗，自然通顺。但全篇平铺直叙，仅依时间顺序刻画登机起飞过程。“别愁生”流于表面，结句“便隔长空万里程”过于直白说破，缺乏余味与诗意张力。","_cost":0.024214},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"机场送别场景具体而题旨常见。巨翼飞桥取象贴切，别愁凌云万里偏套。顺叙完整转笔平直，结句说尽间隔少留白。当代器物入诗略新，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.017064},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.75,"rationale":"主题明确但角度平常，航空意象统一而情味泛化；转结平稳，“隔长空万里程”偏说尽，余味不足；字句通顺少诗眼，套语略多。","_cost":0.0056342},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"以机场登机写送别，脉络清楚：待飞、生愁、起飞、相隔，起承转合完整。但立意为常见送别套路，别愁、万里程等语偏熟，结句直说距离、少留白。语言通顺偶见清朗（便隔长空万里程），整体妥帖而乏独到发现。","_cost":0.00180836},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"机场送别场景明确，巨翼、飞桥有现代实感；但“别愁”“长空万里”等语偏熟，情绪说破，起承转合虽完整而转折平直，结句余味有限。","_cost":0.007836},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"机场意象入诗有新意，送别过程清晰，但情感停留于常见离愁，用语偏平直，结句仅点明远隔，余韵不足。","_cost":0.0083148},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.8,"语言":4.7,"章法":5.4,"余味":4.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.1,"rationale":"机场送别写实意浅情泛，巨翼飞桥可用而少交融，语言通顺乏诗眼，章法线性平直少转折，结句直陈万里无留白。","_cost":0.0095625},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"此机场送别七绝题旨明确，脉络顺畅，意象贴合场景，语言平实准确，但抒情写法较常规，结句直白少余味，引入当代元素未翻新意，无硬伤蹈袭陈套。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"以古典绝句写机场送别,取象(巨翼、飞桥、振响)切合当代经验,起承转合完整,转句'须臾振响凌云去'有速度感。但题旨仍落'别愁''万里程'旧套,结句直说离隔、说破无留白,通篇平顺而乏诗眼,情感泛化不具体,掩卷延宕有限。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"以旧体写机场送别，巨翼、飞桥、振响凌云序列清晰，脉络顺畅；然情感仅以“别愁生”直说，物象与情未深融，结句“便隔长空万里程”说尽无余，语言平顺乏诗眼，属当代题材的平实之作。","_cost":0.04745},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.5,"rationale":"机场现代物象入传统别情，意明而角度常见；取象妥帖，情景未深融；语流畅，须臾与万里成对比；章法完整但转结平直；结句稍直白。当代经验入诗尚可，无硬伤蹈袭，略有熟语。","_cost":0.022553918}},"consensus":54.76,"final":54.76},{"key":"gemini-3.1-pro|机场送别|七律","writer":"gemini-3.1-pro","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"长空银翼待冲天，航站分携别意牵。广播频传催客步，晶窗静对起霞烟。相思冉冉随云远，旅梦迟迟共月圆。一赴关河千嶂外，他乡更漏盼重缘。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.6,"语言":5.1,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.3,"警句":1.2,"出新":1.3,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.6,"rationale":"机场送别题旨集中，广播、晶窗具当代实景，章法顺畅。云月、关河、更漏较陈熟，“起霞烟”“盼重缘”措辞稍涩；结句直陈期盼，留白不足。","_cost":0.005072},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.25,"rationale":"以机场入律有当代题材之新,“广播催客步”一联尚具现场感。然颈联“相思随云”“旅梦月圆”落入陈套,尾句“更漏”与现代机场语境龃龉,时空错乱。结句“盼重缘”说破无余味,通篇新旧意象拼接未融。","_cost":0.03571},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":34.5,"rationale":"起承引入航站、广播等现代物象，但立意平直。颈尾联落入俗套，以“盼重缘”直白兜底，毫无留白。且“关河”“更漏”与现代语境严重割裂，古今意象夹杂生硬，多用陈词滥调。","_cost":0.018194},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.5,"rationale":"机场送别题旨清楚而角度常见，情志仍落盼归常套。意象古今夹杂欠融。语言通顺少炼无诗眼。章法完整转折平直。结句点明重缘过于说尽。","_cost":0.019324},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.2,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.8,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.8,"rationale":"题旨明确但角度常见，情语套话多。机场现代意象与“更漏”等古语未融，句法偶见凑泊。中二联平稳，转结直白说破盼重缘，余味不足。未见硬伤与整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.00590392},"glm-5.3":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"现代机场题材入诗有意识，'广播频传催客步，晶窗静对起霞烟'动静对举见巧思。但立意仍是常见送别盼归套路；结句'盼重缘'直白生硬，说破无余味；'相思''月圆''关河千嶂''更漏'套语密度偏高，'更漏'置于机场语境略显违和。","_cost":0.00320116},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.3,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.8,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.35,"rationale":"机场物象入诗有现场感，起承清晰；但别情多借熟语，相思、月圆、更漏等偏泛，结句说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.010488},"kimi-k3":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.0,"rationale":"以机场现代场景写送别，题材可取而情志未翻出新境，仍是寻常相思。银翼、广播、晶窗与云月关河更漏杂糅，古今意象交融不深；叠字对仗平稳无诗眼。章法完整而平直，结句'盼重缘'直说兜底，余味浅。套语密度偏高，惜无整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.0092808},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":4.6,"意境":4.8,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.4,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.8,"rationale":"送别主脑不明，情语套泛；银翼广播等当代物象与云月更漏拼贴未融，氛围割裂；句法通顺无诗眼；中二联铺陈平直少转折；尾联直抒盼重缘说尽无留白。","_cost":0.00780475},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.75,"rationale":"此作写机场送别，题旨明确但无新境，意象半为实景半为送别熟套，语言平顺少锤炼，章法完整但转折平直，结句直白道尽盼聚之意，套语较多，未融当代经验出新。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"以机场入七律有当代经验之新，颔联广播催步与晶窗对景取象切题。然情意仍落相思盼归旧套，颈联'随云远''共月圆'陈熟；尾句'盼重缘'说破兜底，无留白。全篇通顺而乏诗眼，章法完整但转折平直。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.25,"rationale":"以机场入律稍具当代感，颔联广播与晶窗一动一静尚可。但情语全属泛泛，相思随云、月圆、关河、他乡、重缘皆旧套堆叠，与银翼航站气象不融；尾联说破盼归，更漏亦与机场时空失协，余味寡。","_cost":0.05348},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"机场送别以银翼、广播等现代经验入律，起承完整、转结稳顺；然中后幅云月、关河更漏多陈调，结句直说盼重缘少余味，'重缘'略生硬。","_cost":0.027508409}},"consensus":47.53,"final":47.53},{"key":"gemini-3.1-pro|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.1-pro","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"层楼绝顶辟新畴，引水分畦翠影流。下界车尘飞不到，微凉一架抱清秋。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.95,"rationale":"屋顶辟畦融入都市经验，车尘与清秋对举，主脑鲜明。水、畦、翠影、瓜架相互生发，转结自然；“翠影流”“清秋”稍熟，末句以微凉收束，余韵较足。","_cost":0.005078},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"都市天台种菜入诗,题材当代而语归古雅,立意有新。起承实写辟畴引水,三句以'车尘飞不到'宕开对照,结句'抱清秋'炼字有味、以景收情。惜'翠影流''清秋'稍近熟语,意象精切度略欠,整体清畅可诵。","_cost":0.03087},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.5,"rationale":"题材切入当代生活，将高楼天台作仙家避世观，对比“下界车尘”，颇具城市山林之趣。第三句转折有力，结句“抱”字生动，以景结情，余味悠长，是现代经验成功入诗的佳作。","_cost":0.020482},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"屋顶菜园事具体，避尘出尘主题常见无翻新。翠影流与架抱秋尚能融境，下界车尘套语明显。语言通达少锤炼。转以对比过直。结句以景略留味。当代场景入诗轻微。","_cost":0.024486},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.1,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.05,"rationale":"写楼顶种菜，有现代田园的翻新意味，情感具体；转句以下界车尘作对照，结句以景收束，余味较好。惟“翠影”“清秋”意象略熟，语言稳顺而少独造。","_cost":0.013236608},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.5,"rationale":"都市楼顶种菜入诗，熟外生新。'下界车尘飞不到'暗以仙界自居，翻出高楼尘嚣之上的清境；结句'微凉一架抱清秋'以体感收束，景情交融，言尽意远。起承转合脉络清晰，炼字精当无废字，唯取象格局稍小，气象未再宕开一层。","_cost":0.00220736},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.6,"意境":7.1,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.85,"rationale":"写楼顶菜园清境，题新而情稍泛；意象清幽，结以‘抱清秋’略有余味；语词偶有生硬，转结稍平。","_cost":0.00982},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"天台菜园为当代经验有效入诗，尘嚣与清秋的对照构成主脑；翠影流、一架抱秋意象精切，结句以景结情、言尽意不尽。转句'车尘飞不到'略直且近熟语，章法承转稍显平直，整体清新而不深厚。","_cost":0.0066048},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"楼顶辟畴取材当代，下界车尘反衬高旷；“抱”字为诗眼，以景结情，微凉清秋余韵悠长，转结有致。","_cost":0.010747},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.0,"rationale":"此作写天台菜园闹中取静的清趣，起承转合圆顺，炼字熨帖，意象融协，以景结有余韵，融入当代楼顶种菜经验，无硬伤蹈袭，警策度稍欠。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"都市天台种菜入诗，当代经验化古出新，'下界车尘'与绝顶菜畦构成俯仰对照，转结以景收束，'微凉一架抱清秋'有留白。语言通妥，'翠影''清秋'稍熟，整体气脉贯通，情致闲远而不空泛。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"以都市天台种菜入诗，题材有当代气息，取象具体（分畦、翠影、瓜架）。三句借“下界车尘”翻出隐逸旧调，稍显套路；结句“一架抱清秋”以景收束，微有余味，但“清秋”“车尘”属熟语，未见真正警拔之句。整体工稳而不逾中上。","_cost":0.04574},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"章法完整，‘流’‘抱’炼字见巧，结句以景留白；第三句议论平直，意境与情志稍显常见，唯都市天台题材略有出新。","_cost":0.028567989}},"consensus":78.16,"final":78.16},{"key":"gemini-3.1-pro|天台菜园|七律","writer":"gemini-3.1-pro","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"百尺凌空抱野情，城居片土亦欣荣。微风每拂瓜垂蔓，细雨初浇豆吐英。偶上层台巡翠亩，闲凭晚槛待长庚。灯前自把青菘煮，至味原从淡处生。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.3,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.4,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.7,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.45,"rationale":"屋顶菜园将城居与野趣相融，情境具体，诸象统一。中二联由栽种转闲赏，尾联归于饮食体悟；结句明白晓畅，但议论稍尽，余韵有限。","_cost":0.005924},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"天台种菜将城居经验入诗,题材有当代气息,情事具体。中二联瓜蔓豆英对仗妥帖但取象常见,'欣荣''野情'近套语。章法起承顺畅,转联层台晚槛稍平。尾联'至味从淡处生'把理说破,议论兜底,余味打折。整体稳妥而少警拔。","_cost":0.031},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"以天台种菜的当代生活入诗，具时代气息。章法严谨，脉络贯通，颔联写景生动。但语言略欠锤炼，结句说理直白，缺乏留白余味，且立意落入“平淡是真”的常规窠臼。","_cost":0.021774},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"城居天台种菜，情事具体，主脑在淡中得味，角度仍属常见。意象连贯而多常景。语言通顺，颔联尚工。章法完整、转结平直。结句理语说破，余韵不足。当代经验入诗为出新。","_cost":0.023256},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"城市天台种菜，立意具体且略有今情；中二联由瓜豆及闲望，层次尚稳但写景稍熟；结句直接说理，余味偏显。“至味原从淡处生”可摘为佳句。","_cost":0.01410684},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.0,"rationale":"都市楼顶种菜入旧体，取材真切，物象精切成境，瓜蔓豆英翠亩长庚青菘一路贯通，景语皆情语。章法由物及人及理，层次井然。结句'至味原从淡处生'以议论收，虽稳当但稍近说破，且化用苏轼'人间有味是清欢'、《菜根谭》'真味只是淡'之意，理趣熟而未尽新。","_cost":0.00353396},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"天台菜园以城居片土写野趣，瓜豆青菘意象清匀，章法顺畅，当代生活入诗略有新意；但词语偏熟，结句以理语收，稍说破而少余味。","_cost":0.013532},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"以百尺城居种菜园翻出田园新境，瓜豆、晚槛、青菘情意具体，主脑在“片土欣荣”。中二联清稳而略熟，颈联拓开人事；尾联由淡味悟理，警策有余却近“清欢”熟理，结处说破，余延稍损。","_cost":0.017433},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.9,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.4,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.85000000000001,"rationale":"城居天台自圃见野趣，片土欣荣主脑集中；中二联景人分写、由昼及宵脉络贯通，唯意象语汇较常见，尾联直陈淡味哲理余韵稍浅。","_cost":0.00873965},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"此诗咏天台菜园，主脑明晰，意象贴境，语言清通，章法循时间线铺展连贯；唯旨归、意象偏熟，结句直陈理趣稍欠余韵，有清新佳联，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"城居天台种菜翻新田园旧题，当代经验真切；瓜蔓豆英与晚槛长庚交融成统一闲适氛围；尾联'至味原从淡处生'立主脑而稍近理语说破，余味略减；'巡翠亩'微见凑字，整体脉络贯通。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"以城市天台菜园入题，当代经验有效，脉络清晰、四联各有分工。然颔颈二联写景常见，无凸出诗眼，'翠亩'于片土稍夸。结句直接点破'淡处生'之理，格言式收尾说尽无余味，属陈套议论。","_cost":0.04877},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"写城市天台种菜、淡泊自适，意旨明确而角度常见；中二联写景叙事妥帖，意象稍熟；结句以煮菘发理语，直白少余味；有当代入诗，偶见佳联，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.025335874}},"consensus":70.87,"final":70.87},{"key":"gemini-3.1-pro|云端相册|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.1-pro","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"定格流光一镜收，九霄云匣替人留。星霜屡易音容在，咫尺微屏对旧游。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.30000000000001,"rationale":"以云端相册寄托怀旧，古典语汇与当代微屏相接，主脑鲜明。由摄存写至岁迁人忆，转结自然；“对旧游”含情留白，惟“云匣替人留”稍直，部分意象略熟。","_cost":0.005624},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"以云存储入诗题材新颖,'九霄云匣'化今为古颇巧。惜后半落入怀旧套路,'星霜''音容''旧游'皆熟语,结句直陈对屏观照,说得过实少留白。章法完整流畅但转结平顺无奇,整体稳而不惊。","_cost":0.03368},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"本诗巧妙化用古词书写当代事物，“九霄云匣”喻云端、“微屏”写手机，贴切自然。起承转合规整，脉络贯通。然“星霜”句略显陈熟，结句偏于直白说明，留白不足，缺乏深远余味。","_cost":0.014714},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"云相册抗岁月有当代切入，题旨集中。云匣微屏尚切，星霜音容偏套，氛未浑融。章法平直少变，结句点破少留白。","_cost":0.01691},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"写云端相册存留时光，情感具体、焦点集中，当代经验入诗自然。意象兼用新旧，氛围统一。炼字妥帖，转结有致，结句以“对旧游”留白。个别意象略陈。","_cost":0.006601408},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.0,"rationale":"以'云匣''微屏'将云端相册这一当代经验稳妥入诗，熟题新境，主脑清晰。'九霄云匣替人留'化虚为实，堪称诗眼。四句起承转合完整，星霜—咫尺构成时空张力。结句以屏对旧游收得稳当，稍偏直白，余味中等。'流光''星霜'略熟，整体意象密度尚可。","_cost":0.00241116},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.55,"rationale":"以云端相册写记忆保存，题旨明确，新题材有当代感。云匣、微屏等意象贴切而稍欠具体，星霜、音容偏熟。结句以咫尺微屏对旧游收束，有余味。","_cost":0.008834},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"云存储、微屏入诗而不隔,'九霄云匣'融合古今最见巧思;主旨为科技留存记忆对抗星霜,角度较新但情感仍属常见怀旧,深度有限。章法起承转合完整,转结平稳,结句'对旧游'略有怅惘余韵而未臻高远。流光、星霜、音容、旧游皆熟语,密度尚可。","_cost":0.0163758},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.3,"语言":7.6,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.55,"rationale":"云匣双关翻新怀旧熟题，一镜收等炼字精切，章法递进贯通；微屏等象偏概念化，尾句对旧游直收少宕开。","_cost":0.0076435},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"此作取当代云端相册题材，以\"云匣\"喻云存储颇具巧思，脉络顺通，语浅意明，但未脱怀旧熟套，章法平直，结句少余韵，部分意象偏熟，无明显硬伤。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.95,"rationale":"以云端存储入绝句,当代经验与古典语汇融合自然,'九霄云匣'化科技为意象见巧思。转句'星霜屡易音容在'以时间反衬存留,有张力。惟通篇意脉平顺,'对旧游'收束稍直白,余味有限;意象妥帖但镜、屏等取象尚可更精。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"以云存储入七绝有当代经验，但多为“云匣”“微屏”式名词代换，说明性重于感发；星霜、音容、旧游皆熟语。结构平直，转句常见。结句以微屏对旧游稍见余味，惜情事不够具体。","_cost":0.051},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.2,"章法":5.6,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.35,"rationale":"以云端存照入诗，题意集中；惜星霜音容等套语稍熟，云匣微屏略生造。起承转合完整而转折平直，结句以屏对旧游稍留余味。当代经验有新意，警句稍弱。","_cost":0.028778907}},"consensus":67.49,"final":67.49},{"key":"gemini-3.1-pro|云端相册|七律","writer":"gemini-3.1-pro","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"无形尺素托长天，一局澄明万象全。色相悬空辞朽蠹，流光入幻锁华年。幽微碎影留真境，浩瀚晶盘系宿缘。指下轻翻寻旧梦，宛然笑语若从前。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.4,"语言":5.9,"章法":7.1,"余味":5.6,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.8,"rationale":"以古典语汇写云端相册，今昔交映，主线清楚。“色相悬空辞朽蠹”颇见巧思；但“晶盘”等语稍滞，流光、华年、旧梦、从前略熟，结句直白。","_cost":0.00677},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"以云端存照入律,题材当代有新意,\"晶盘\"喻服务器亦见巧思。然中二联多抽象干说,\"锁华年\"\"系宿缘\"意浮不实;\"流光\"\"旧梦\"\"华年\"等旧套语连缀,削弱新题之新。结句\"若从前\"直陈说尽,余味有限。章法完整但转处平直。","_cost":0.037},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"将“云端相册”引入律诗，以“晶盘”“辞朽蠹”巧妙对译现代科技，颇具新意。然中二联均写保存记忆，略显同义反复；尾联“寻旧梦”“若从前”过于直白陈旧，毫无留白，缺乏余味。","_cost":0.017286},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.0,"rationale":"云端存影以尺素托天为喻，题旨清楚，翻阅忆旧可感。色相真境宿缘堆叠偏虚，欠精切。颔联稍有思致。转联平行少变，结句直白说破。当代经验入诗尚可，套语密度中等。","_cost":0.020132},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"题材现代，立意明确但情事虚泛；意象空灵统一而略陈套；中二联表意相近少开合；结句直白说破，余味不足。略有新意，惜套语较多。","_cost":0.00520366},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"以云端相册入律诗，当代经验与古典语汇融合自然，'色相''晶盘'等词兼摄佛理与数码意象，立意有独到处。中二联由存储之质、时间之感、碎片之真到宿缘之系，层次分明。结句'宛然笑语若从前'稍直白，'锁华年''寻旧梦'略见熟语，整体真挚贯通。","_cost":0.00261896},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.2,"章法":5.8,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"云端入题有新意，颔联炼字较警；意象偏虚，中二联层次相近，旧梦笑语收束稍直。","_cost":0.0134},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"以云相册入七律,题材新且聚焦,怀旧之情具体可感;然中二联皆以抽象形容语(澄明/幽微/浩瀚/色相/流光)铺陈存储之态,层次相叠、缺少具体画面,意象交融不足;语言通顺有锻意而无诗眼;尾联'笑语若从前'收得平稳但说得较尽,余韵有限。华年、旧梦、宿缘略套。","_cost":0.0097938},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":4.8,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.85,"rationale":"无形尺素喻云端有当代巧思，但情事抽象未具体，中二联以概念词铺陈少精切物象，结构并列平推，尾联直抒旧梦说尽无留白。","_cost":0.008565},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"此作咏云端相册寄怀旧之思，题旨明确，章法平顺，以传统意象写新事物稍显隔涩，语言平正乏警策，结句直白少余味，略有陈词，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"以云端相册入七律，当代经验化古有效：'色相悬空辞朽蠹，流光入幻锁华年'取象精切，数字存储与纸相朽坏对照见新意。中二联皆写物稍欠开合变化；结句'宛然笑语若从前'情真但说尽，少留白。宿缘、旧梦等语微熟。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"以云端存照入律，题材新而角度浅：中二联皆言“不朽可留”，原地打转，晶盘、一局等生硬造语，色相宿缘等词浮而不切。结句“笑语若从前”直说尽情，余味薄。","_cost":0.05782},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"以云端相册入律，题旨明而情泛，立意6；意象多套语且“晶盘”硬，意境4；语有“指下轻翻”亮点而杂凑，5.5；中二联少转，章法5；结句直白，余味4.5。加警句2、出新2；陈滥2，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.029982239}},"consensus":60.09,"final":60.09},{"key":"gemini-3.1-pro|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.1-pro","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"荧屏数寸接他乡，万里双眸在近旁。欲慰寒温难执手，遥怜朔雪满衣裳。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.69999999999999,"rationale":"以数寸荧屏反衬万里阻隔，视频经验入诗自然，情感具体。前二句聚焦相见，后二句转入不可执手，以朔雪衣裳作结，余情可感；“慰寒温”稍显生涩。","_cost":0.005842},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"以视频通话入诗,当代经验有效化古,'数寸''万里'对照见巧。转句'难执手'点出隔屏之憾,结以'遥怜朔雪'化用杜甫遥怜笔意,以想象之景收束,留有余味。惟'寒温''衣裳'措语稍旧,情思亦属游子怀远常境,未臻独到。","_cost":0.0347},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"本诗将当代生活经验“视频通话”巧妙入诗，起承写时空缩短，转句叹物理阻隔之憾，结句“朔雪满衣裳”以景结情，余味悠长。语言略直白，但情感真切，章法圆满，出新自然无痕。","_cost":0.021992},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"视频写远隔，末句朔雪衣裳有画面。题旨常见，转合平稳，炼字无突出诗眼，结处遥怜稍直。器物入诗自然。","_cost":0.012592},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"视频题材入旧诗较新，聚焦屏中眼神与难执手之憾，转结自然。结句朔雪满裳以景收束，留余味。语言通顺，“接”“满”见炼字，前二句稍平。","_cost":0.0149567616},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"视频通话入绝句，见近在眼前、远隔万里之矛盾，题旨具体有主脑。转句'难执手'点破科技之限，结句宕开想象朔雪满衣，以景结情余味足。'遥怜'微袭杜诗口吻，'寒温'稍熟，整体妥帖而不惊人。","_cost":0.00270756},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.8,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.9,"rationale":"视频入诗，荧屏朔雪相映，三四转结有画面与阻隔感；情真而略直，‘遥怜’稍说破，语词仍有常见痕迹。","_cost":0.01137},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"以视频通话写远别，数寸荧屏与万里双眸的张力可喜，结以朔雪衣裳留影像。次句意近首句，寒温、执手、遥怜稍熟，情感真而提炼未至。","_cost":0.0101598},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.3,"意境":6.6,"语言":5.9,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.65,"rationale":"以数寸荧屏对万里作比，欲慰难执手一转点出虚近实远，末句以朔雪满衣裳化虚为实、以景结情；立意真切但翻新有限，语言平顺少诗眼。","_cost":0.006636},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.5,"rationale":"此作以深夜视频的当代场景写异地牵挂，抓住隔屏可视却难执手的怅惘，章法顺畅自然，唯意象稍熟，结句稍直，拓深不足。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"以视频通话入旧体，当代经验与怀远之情结合自然，'数寸荧屏'对'万里双眸'的远近张力真切。章法起承转合分明，结句以朔雪满衣之景收束，不说破而情自见，余味足。语言通顺但炼字稍平，'寒温''朔雪'意象略熟，整体稳而不奇。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"以视频通话写思亲，'数寸/万里''近旁/难执手'的悖论是全诗主脑，但此角度网络诗中已多见。语言平顺无诗眼，'寒温''朔雪衣裳'偏套。结句以对方形象收尚有留白，然'遥怜'先说破情。深夜视频而'朔雪满衣裳'情境稍不贴。","_cost":0.05017},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.0,"rationale":"以视频通话写远别，现代经验入诗较自然；意脉清晰而转折稍平，结句景中有情但‘遥怜’稍直。意象用语妥帖而多常见，警句在‘难执手’一联。无硬伤蹈袭，略有陈滥。","_cost":0.02936414}},"consensus":73.11,"final":73.11},{"key":"gemini-3.1-pro|深夜视频|七律","writer":"gemini-3.1-pro","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"寒更寂寂伴秋虫，指触微屏万里通。客鬓生霜初叹老，乡音入耳未言穷。征尘远隔千山外，骨肉相逢咫尺中。一键才收灯影暗，半床残月起西风。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.6,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.2,"rationale":"以视频通话写羁旅亲情，远隔与咫尺相映，主脑鲜明。微屏、一键融入传统诗境自然；“未言穷”稍涩。结联由屏暗转残月西风，留白悠长。","_cost":0.005852},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"视频通话入律有当代经验，颈联'千山外/咫尺中'远近对照见巧思，尾联收视后灯暗月残以景结情，余味佳。惟'客鬓生霜''乡音''残月西风'皆熟语，中二联对仗工稳而取象常见，题材今人已多写，出新有限。","_cost":0.03199},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"将当代经验（视频通话）自然融入旧体，立意真挚。结构严谨，颈联空间对比彰显科技之妙；尤佳在尾联挂断后以景结情，热闹与落寞反差强烈，余味悠长。中二联部分用词略显常见套路。","_cost":0.021408},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"视频思乡题熟，鬓霜乡音未言穷尚具体。秋虫征尘千山残月西风陈象偏密，微屏一键嵌入平顺。中联远近对照完整而转意套式。结以灯暗月风收，略有余韵。","_cost":0.02315},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"写深夜视频寄乡思，情感具体，中二联时空对举，尾联以景收束有余味。传统意象较密但无硬伤，现代词汇融入自然。","_cost":0.005667596},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"以深夜视频通话入律诗，旧题翻出新境：咫尺与万里的矛盾贯穿全篇，主脑分明。中二联对仗工稳有开合，'骨肉相逢咫尺中'与'征尘远隔千山外'互文见义。结句以灯影暗、残月、西风收束，以景结情，余味悠长。秋虫、西风等象略熟但密度不高。","_cost":0.00209536},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.1,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.6,"余味":8.1,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"深夜视频以现代经验入诗，题旨集中；中二联情语稍熟，旧象略多；尾联一键收束，灯暗月风，留白较足。","_cost":0.01318},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.5,"rationale":"以视频通话写羁旅乡愁，旧题得当代经验支撑，情事具体。'远隔千山/相逢咫尺'一联开合有力；结句挂断后灯暗月风，以景结情有余韵。然秋虫、霜鬓、残月、西风意象偏熟，'未言穷'略凑，炼字未到警策。","_cost":0.0084258},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.8,"rationale":"当代视频入诗以远近对照翻新乡愁，颈联精警，尾联以景结情余味悠长，然中二联偏叙事，语言近平少诗眼。","_cost":0.0089055},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.5,"rationale":"此作写客中深夜与亲人视频的羁思，事真情切，章法顺畅，语言清通，结句以景衬情留有余韵；唯立意未脱传统乡思窠臼，部分意象偏熟，新警不足。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.25,"rationale":"视频通话写乡愁,当代经验入旧体自然,'万里通'与'咫尺中'翻出咫尺天涯新境;尾联'一键才收灯影暗,半床残月起西风'以景结情,余味悠长。惟'客鬓生霜''乡音'等意象偏熟,颔联'未言穷'稍显凑对,整体情真而炼字尚可再进。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.0,"rationale":"视频通话入律，题旨清晰，“未言穷”见人情之细。颈联“千山外/咫尺中”对比明白但说破主旨，转折平直。尾联屏暗残月西风以景结情，留白有味。寒更秋虫客鬓征尘等语略陈熟。","_cost":0.06026},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"视频通话题材入律，起结有序，尾联以景结情，余味较佳；中二联空间对比见巧。然意象语词多传统，现代词稍生硬，新意与诗眼不足。","_cost":0.026892328}},"consensus":74.4,"final":74.4},{"key":"gemini-3.1-pro|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.1-pro","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"寻常巷陌启新堂，笑语盈庭饭菜香。免使空巢愁日暮，归来共饮百家汤。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.7,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.60000000000001,"rationale":"聚焦社区食堂纾解空巢孤独，现实关怀具体，主脑清楚。巷陌、笑语、饭香至日暮层层推进，转结自然；“免使”稍显直陈，部分语汇熟套，“百家汤”温厚而有新意。","_cost":0.005858},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"当代题材入诗，关注空巢老人有现实温度，主脑清晰。转句点出'免使空巢愁日暮'见立意，结句'百家汤'略有巧思与余温。惜'笑语盈庭饭菜香'等语平熟近套话，取象单薄，语言直白少锤炼，整体稳而不奇。","_cost":0.03884},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"题材切入当代生活，“空巢”入诗自然，章法起承转合规矩。然语言略显直白，意象偏于熟套，结句过于圆满说尽，缺少含蓄隽永之余味。","_cost":0.018646},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.25,"rationale":"社区食堂切入当代空巢关怀，主脑清楚而近颂德常见。笑语饭香日暮皆套语，情意交融不足。语言通顺少锤炼，转句说理平直。结句共饮稍有象却说尽少宕。","_cost":0.013842},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.75,"rationale":"题旨明确，关注空巢老人，角度常见；意象妥帖但偏熟；语言通顺，'空巢愁日暮'稍有亮点，'百家汤'略生；起承转合完整，但转结平直；结句直白，余韵不足。无硬伤，略有套语。","_cost":0.012629606},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"社区食堂这一当代民生题材入七绝，切口具体可感，'百家汤'化'百家饭'暗喻邻里共济，结句以暖景收束有余温。但'笑语盈庭饭菜香'意象偏熟，'免使空巢愁日暮'直接说破题旨，转折稍平直，整体稳当而少奇崛。","_cost":0.00201116},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.3,"rationale":"取材社区食堂，关怀空巢，主脑明确但近宣传；前二句有烟火气，后二句直说，意象偏常；“百家汤”稍暖，整体语言平直，转结欠含蓄。","_cost":0.012408},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"社区养老食堂入诗，题旨集中、情事具体，属当代经验有效入诗；然角度平直，第三句直白点破题意。意象妥帖而常见，'空巢''笑语盈庭'等套语密度偏高。章法起承转合完整，结句'百家汤'稍有滋味但整体偏说尽，炼字平稳无突出诗眼。","_cost":0.009477},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.6,"意境":5.2,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"当代题材切入空巢关怀立意具体；意象与语言平实少锤炼，转结完整而平直，结句直陈少留白。","_cost":0.006463},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"此诗咏社区食堂惠民，聚焦空巢养老关怀，立意明确，章法顺畅，语言平实，唯意象、表达偏常规，结句直白余味不足，当代民生入诗略有新意，无硬伤。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"以社区食堂写养老关怀，当代经验入诗，'免使空巢愁日暮'点题具体，'百家汤'化用出新。起承转合完整，结以共饮留温意。然'笑语盈庭饭菜香'意象常见，炼字平顺少诗眼，整体妥帖而未至警拔。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.5,"rationale":"写社区食堂惠及空巢老人，题材贴近当代，但视角近乎新闻通稿；'笑语盈庭饭菜香'系套话，'免使'一转直白说理。'百家汤'化'百家饭'略见巧思，结句以场景收束尚有温度，惟大体说尽，余味有限。","_cost":0.04286},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"写社区食堂慰空巢，题旨清而角度常见；意象妥帖但多套语，语言通顺欠诗眼；章法起承转合完整，转稍平直，结句以共饮百家汤收束略留余味。当代经验入诗稍有新意。","_cost":0.028873943}},"consensus":56.61,"final":56.61},{"key":"gpt-5.6-sol|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"翼外星河压客程，舷窗下瞰万灯生。长江倒曳霓虹影，列岫沉浮雪脊横。顷刻千村如芥小，谁家一盏为人明。归心未共机身转，独向苍茫认故城。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.7,"章法":8.3,"余味":7.6,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写归心，万灯至一盏的收束具体有力；江影雪脊营造高空动势。颈联转情自然，结句略直，“星河”“苍茫故城”稍熟。","_cost":0.006812},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"当代夜航经验有效入诗,题旨集中于俯瞰与归心。颈联'顷刻千村如芥小,谁家一盏为人明'由宏入微,情景交融,为全篇警策。颔联'长江倒曳霓虹影'亦见炼字,惟'雪脊横'夜间视象稍隔。结句认故城收得住而稍实,余味略减。'归心''苍茫'微涉熟语。","_cost":0.03646},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.0,"rationale":"本诗将当代夜航经验巧妙入诗，意象宏阔且切合俯瞰视角。颈联以大衬小，极具张力与温情，堪为警句。章法由大景推至微观再转归心，脉络贯通，语言洗练，属当代题材佳作。","_cost":0.015938},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"夜航思乡题旨明确而角度常见。江山灯火意象妥帖，倒曳、机身未共转见炼字。中二联由开而合层次清楚。结句认故城稍直白，余味有限。当代器物入诗稳妥，陈语密度不高。","_cost":0.027164},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.2,"意境":8.5,"语言":6.9,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.9,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.85000000000001,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰由万灯大景转到一盏微光，归心不随航向、独认故城，章法开合有致。炼字如压、认见力，唯意象略熟，语言平实处稍多。","_cost":0.01731972},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验有效入诗，归心认故城立意集中真挚。'倒曳''沉浮雪脊'炼字见诗眼，中二联一宏阔一细微开合有层。'谁家一盏为人明'于万灯中拈出一灯，警策动人。结句宕开留白。唯'星河''苍茫'稍熟，'霓虹''机身'入诗略直白。","_cost":0.00227556},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.1,"余味":7.7,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.45,"rationale":"夜航视角新，俯察灯河山雪，由宏阔转至一盏，归思有寄。语言有炼，机身入诗略硬，归心稍直；结以苍茫认城留余味。","_cost":0.012922},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰视角新，星河万灯意象统一且景情相生，颈联「千村如芥小、一盏为人明」由宏观落至人情，最见匠心，结句「认故城」收得住且有延宕。惜归乡题旨终是熟路，雪脊一联略凑，个别字面锤炼未至化境，故各维居上中而未臻上乘。","_cost":0.0064188},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.3,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.45,"rationale":"以机窗现代视角翻旧题，万灯与一盏大小对照见情；景象宏阔锤炼得力，中二联开合有层次，尾联于苍茫中认城余味不尽。","_cost":0.009774},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"此作写夜航归思，意象切题，章法浑成，景情交融，自然融入当代飞行经验，炼字见巧，唯主题未脱传统羁思路数，结句稍直，部分表达较熟。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验入旧体，视角新颖；'长江倒曳霓虹影''谁家一盏为人明'取象精切，巨细对照见情。颈联由大转小、由物及人，转折有力；结句'独向苍茫认故城'以景收情，留白有余味。惟'雪脊'夜景稍隔，归思主题仍属熟径。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验，主脑归心明确；由星河、万灯到千村一盏，取象层次清晰，“压”“倒曳”炼字有力，“谁家一盏为人明”可摘。“列岫沉浮雪脊横”稍硬，尾联点出“归心”略直，“苍茫”“客程”近套语。","_cost":0.05393},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"以飞机霓虹入七律，当代经验融合尚好；中二联由宏阔转一盏为人明，章法清晰。结句直点归心故城，余味稍欠；炼字有压、倒曳亮点，如芥小微赘。无蹈袭硬伤。","_cost":0.033793764},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.45,"rationale":"夜航经验入律自然妥帖。俯瞰视野开阔，颈联由千村如芥骤转为一盏明灯，视域张力极佳；尾联以机身盘旋关合羁旅心绪，章法浑成，虚实相生。","_cost":0.00525},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.2,"语言":5.3,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.15,"rationale":"夜航收束归心主脑清，大小视角转接自然；高空夜景统一有层次，然“为人明”“机身转”欠炼发白，结已点破损余味。","_cost":0.0119133}},"consensus":80.24,"final":80.24},{"key":"gemini-3.1-pro|社区食堂|七律","writer":"gemini-3.1-pro","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"近市新开便客堂，邻街曲巷满炊香。瓷盘素炒留真味，瓦钵浓汤却暮凉。耄耋同餐添笑语，青衿散值解奔忙。休嫌咫尺珍馐少，一室春风润岁长。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"unknown"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.2,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"社区食堂入律诗，有当代关怀，炊香、餐器与老少同堂构成暖境。层次清楚，但“青衿散值”略显迁就古语，末句春风润岁较熟且直白。","_cost":0.007382},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"当代民生题材入律,题旨明确、情感平实,颔颈两联写食写人尚具体,惟角度平铺无翻转。'却暮凉'费解近凑,'青衿'指老年社区语境稍隔。结句'一室春风'落入颂扬套语,说尽无余味。整体稳而不奇。","_cost":0.03056},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"立足当代生活写社区食堂，颔联写烟火气，颈联写老少食客，层次分明，语言平顺，当代经验入诗颇佳。然尾联以直白议论收束，略带口号感，缺乏留白与余味。","_cost":0.018858},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"社区食堂入律有当代实感，颔联物象较切、颈联人事对照，章法由景入人收意尚顺。然温情颂常见，结句点破少留白，青衿散值与场景微隔，春风炊香稍套。","_cost":0.016252},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"写社区食堂有现实关怀，结构稳，结句稍有余味；但“便客堂”“青衿散值”略生硬，意象多日常浅白。无硬伤与明显蹈袭。","_cost":0.012394888},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"以社区食堂入诗，当代民生经验有效入题，情事具体、主脑清晰。中二联食物与人物分层开合，结构妥帖。'瓦钵浓汤却暮凉'景情相生略见诗眼，但'春风''炊香'稍熟，结句'休嫌'议论微直，收束稳而延宕不足。","_cost":0.00246756},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.8,"余味":4.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"题取社区食堂，烟火细节真切，老人青衿同写，立意温厚；但意象偏日常平铺，尾联说破，余味稍浅。语言通顺，章法完整，略有春风、珍馐等熟语。","_cost":0.010394},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"以社区食堂入七律，题新而情真，耄耋与青衿对举见社会关怀，主脑集中。颔联'瓦钵浓汤却暮凉'有炼字之工。惜'散值'生硬、'青衿'借指稍迂，结句'一室春风'落入熟语，收束偏直，余韵不足。","_cost":0.0100968},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.6,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.10000000000001,"rationale":"取材社区食堂贴近当代民生具新意，然情志止于温情赞颂少深掘；物象成暖氛围但较平实，语言通顺少诗眼，章法由景及食及人次第平稳，结句直陈少留白。","_cost":0.01117275},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.7,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.9,"rationale":"这首七律写社区食堂新貌，主题明晰，意象贴实，章法平顺，语言晓畅；唯表达偏平直，余味不足，略有用词小疵，警策度与新意均有欠缺。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"当代题材入律，社区食堂烟火气与民生温情具体可感，颈联'耄耋''青衿'对举见巧思；'瓦钵浓汤却暮凉'炼一'却'字为亮点。然中二联意象平实常见，尾联'春风润岁长'说破兜底，收束直白乏留白，整体稳而欠奇。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"题材当代,焦点清楚,但流于报道式颂赞。中二联铺陈食物与人群尚具体,'却暮凉'稍有味;'便客堂'生造,'青衿'指下班青年欠切。章法平铺,结句以'一室春风'说破兜底,余味薄弱。","_cost":0.04948},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.5,"rationale":"当代社区食堂题材，题旨集中而角度常见。炊香瓦钵尚妥，'青衿'指今人未切，取象偏熟。中二联由物及人，结构完整、转折平直；'却''润'略见炼字，'便客堂''散值'稍硬。尾联劝慰直白，春风喻情略留余味。无蹈袭硬伤，陈滥轻微。","_cost":0.033206522}},"consensus":65.68,"final":65.68},{"key":"gemini-3.1-pro|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.1-pro","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"客木春街未展青，全凭玉液倒悬瓶。东风不解离乡恨，强遣枯枝吐绿星。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.1,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.8,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.8,"rationale":"以吊瓶救树写移木乡愁，现代物象与传统春恨融合，转结有力。“绿星”鲜活；“全凭玉液”与东风催发略有因果抵牾，客木、玉液稍显刻意。","_cost":0.006082},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.25,"rationale":"以移栽行道树挂吊瓶入诗,当代经验有效化入,'客木''离乡恨'将树拟为游子,立意有独到发现且一线贯穿。转句宕开归咎东风,结以'吐绿星'收象,唯'强遣'稍说破,余味略减。'东风不解'句式近熟套,'玉液'微俗,余皆凝练。","_cost":0.03878},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"将当代“树挂吊瓶”现象巧妙入诗，以“客木”引出羁旅之情。转结极佳，“强遣”道出违背规律的无奈，“绿星”设喻新警，物我交融。当代经验有效转化，唯“玉液”代指营养液略陈套。","_cost":0.024834},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"街树挂吊瓶本是眼前事，借客木离乡、东风强遣翻出一境，主脑清楚。玉液倒悬与绿星稍新，然东风、离乡恨、枯枝仍熟。转合平直，结句“强遣”点破，余味不足。","_cost":0.025074},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"题材新，借树木输液寄离乡之慨，立意具体；意象统一，转结有情。唯“绿星”稍险，章法较平，个别词略常见。整体中上。","_cost":0.00781836},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.5,"rationale":"以移栽树输液的当代街景写离乡之恨，题小而寄慨深，主脑鲜明。'客木''玉液倒悬瓶'取象精切，物我交融。'吐绿星'炼字见眼，结句以景收而'强遣'二字暗含怨责，言尽意不尽。起承转合完足，东风之转尤有力。'东风不解'句式略熟，无碍整体。","_cost":0.00290536},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.9,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.15,"rationale":"借春街树挂吊瓶写客木离乡，题材新，转结有力；‘绿星’见炼，而‘玉液’稍泛，‘离乡恨’略直，余味未深。","_cost":0.010754},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"以客木挂吊瓶写移栽之恨，题材新而有主脑；玉液稍奢、东风离乡略熟套，结以绿星留象可玩，转结尚工但非峻切。","_cost":0.0301302},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.7,"rationale":"借吊瓶写客木离乡之痛，当代经验入诗新切；吊瓶与绿星意象精融；转结由怜转讽以景收，余味足；唯个别字句稍露白。","_cost":0.013645},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"借春街移栽树挂吊瓶的当代物象寄离乡身不由己之慨，立意新巧，起承转合顺畅，炼字有亮点，结有余味，仅“玉液”稍泛，无硬伤蹈袭，当代经验融入自然。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"以行道树挂吊瓶入诗，移栽之木喻离乡之客，当代经验翻出新境；'玉液倒悬瓶'取象精切，'强遣枯枝吐绿星'炼字见眼。第三句'东风不解离乡恨'点破情字稍直，结句以景收束留有余韵但张力略减，整体脉络贯通、转结有力。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"以移栽行道树挂吊瓶写客木离乡，当代经验入诗有效，主脑集中。倒悬瓶、绿星取象精切，强遣二字见力。惟东风不解属套语，玉液稍浮，结句已点破恨字而以景象收，余味尚可未至深远。","_cost":0.03815},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"客木吊瓶写移植街树，当代经验入诗，立意新；转结有力，吐绿星以景结情，余味长。次句稍直白，语言通顺有亮点。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.031515835}},"consensus":80.84,"final":80.84},{"key":"gemini-3.1-pro|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"gemini-3.1-pro","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"新移大木待春明，忽见悬瓶过客惊。玉管低垂分碧液，琼浆静注助新生。休疑妙手违天意，翻遣枯株发秀英。莫谓长街多俗巧，他年十里作涛声。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":true},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.9,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.4,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.3,"rationale":"以树木输液写城市护绿，题材新鲜，惊疑转赞许，主线清楚。尾句预想十里涛声，拓境有余味。玉管、琼浆、妙手、天意稍显熟套；新移大木径称枯株，语意略过。","_cost":0.0048},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"取当代街景移树输液入诗,题材新而有生活发现,主脑清晰。中二联一写一议,层次尚可,惟'玉管''琼浆'饰词稍甜俗,'助新生'近于直说。转联议论化解争议见巧思,结句宕开想象'十里涛声',以景收束有余响。整体立意与结法佳,炼字略欠沉着。","_cost":0.03417},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"题材新颖，当代都市经验有效入诗。章法严谨，结句“十里作涛声”拓宽时空，余味颇佳。然颔联以“琼浆玉管”代指塑料吊瓶略显陈套生硬，语言整体稍嫌直白，少见奇警之字。","_cost":0.021704},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"移树挂瓶入律，立意辩人为助生非违天，题旨集中可感。玉管琼浆妆点输液，意象新旧杂陈未浑。语言通顺少诗眼。由惊见转辩至远望，脉络清。结句有想象余响。","_cost":0.0166},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.5,"rationale":"题材写城市树挂吊瓶，现代感强；章法清楚，尾联以他年涛声收束有余味。然中二联琼浆玉液类套语略熟，情志稍浅，语言较平直。","_cost":0.014235936},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"以城市新移树木挂吊瓶入诗,当代经验化古有效,选题独到且一篇主脑清晰。中二联一写景一议论,开合有致;颈联'休疑''翻遣'转出新意。结句宕开想象他年绿荫涛声,以景结情,余味绵长。'琼浆''新生'稍近熟语,语言微有雕饰,整体清通可喜。","_cost":0.00253216},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.4,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.7,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.4,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.7,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.35000000000001,"rationale":"取城市树吊瓶入诗，题新脉明；玉管琼浆状物工稳，尾句拓出远景。惜议论稍直，雅词略熟，情味未深。","_cost":0.018298},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"以树木输液当代经验入诗，题材新而不猎奇；颔联切象工稳，结拓“十里涛声”有余韵。然中二联描后即议，“休疑/莫谓”复沓，情理趋颂，“琼浆”稍溢，情欠个人深挚。","_cost":0.0233448},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.3,"余味":7.9,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.8,"rationale":"以街头吊瓶奇观入诗，由过客惊到悟妙手助生，终宕开至他年涛声，立意具体贯注；玉管碧液取象精切，末句以景结情有延宕，唯颈联议论直露稍弱锤炼。","_cost":0.01083965},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"此诗取当代行道树挂吊瓶的新鲜题材，起承转合清晰，结句以预想林涛收束有韵致，语言妥帖但部分意象偏熟，无硬伤蹈袭，有一定新意。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"城市行道树挂吊瓶是当代独有经验，题材新颖且立意完整：由'惊'起，经'违天意''发秀英'之辩，收于'十里涛声'的期许，主脑分明。颈联议论有力为佳联。不足在意象偏于雕琢（玉管、琼浆），雅饰过度反失真趣；'碧液''秀英'等词稍显熟滑。尾联宕开以景想结，余味悠长。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"以街树输液入诗，当代经验有效，主脑清晰。中二联颔联述实稍板，颈联转入议论直白（休疑、翻遣、莫谓皆说理连词）；玉管琼浆略套。结句十里涛声化为远景，有想象余地，但被前句议论削弱。","_cost":0.05534},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"以街树挂瓶入律，题材新鲜，起承转合清晰；然多议论，意象与措辞稍涉常套，结句有展望而理语稍直。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.027926077}},"consensus":72.31,"final":72.31},{"key":"gemini-3.1-pro|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.1-pro","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"穿云银翼上寥天，俯瞰华灯接大千。万点霓虹明灭处，翻疑星海坠舷边。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.1,"警句":2.8,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.2,"rationale":"以机舷俯瞰写天地倒置之幻觉，情境集中，转结尤佳。“星海坠舷边”有动感与余味；“华灯接大千”稍泛，标题与“俯瞰”略复。","_cost":0.00475},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰入诗有当代经验，题旨明确但角度不算新，前二句铺陈稍平。结句'翻疑星海坠舷边'化用'疑是'错觉手法，有画面有余味，为全篇亮点。'华灯''大千''霓虹'略见套语堆缀，炼字平稳少诗眼。章法起承转合完整而转折平直。","_cost":0.03487},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"本诗以夜航经验入诗，起承转合流畅。将城市霓虹与星海倒置，造境宏阔。然“银翼”“华灯”等词略显熟滑，语言锤炼稍欠，立意亦属常见，胜在章法稳妥、结句画面感强，颇具余味。","_cost":0.01745},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰题旨明确却无新境。灯拟星海意象交融成境。语言通顺“翻疑”略炼，整体未脱套语。章法起承平直完整。结句以错觉收束尚留余味。当代经验入诗可称出新。","_cost":0.015952},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.8,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.3,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.9,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.8,"rationale":"夜航题材常见，但以霓虹疑作星海坠舷，视角倒置可称亮点。意象统一，语言流畅，'翻疑'为诗眼。章法稳妥，余味尚可，唯情感稍薄。","_cost":0.01049136},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰这一当代经验入旧体，视角真切，全篇意象统一，银翼、华灯、霓虹、星海一线贯穿，结句以'翻疑星海坠舷边'宕开，化用'疑是银河落九天'而不觉生硬，留有回味。惟立意仍在'灯火如星'的熟套内，转结虽有变化但新意有限，华灯、霓虹等语稍熟。","_cost":0.00233404},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.2,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.6,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.4,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰灯火与星海互映，现代经验有新鲜感；起承转合清楚，结以错觉收略有余味。但华灯霓虹星海稍熟，翻疑说破，情志未深。","_cost":0.009622},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"夜航题材取当代经验,俯瞰视角下华灯霓虹与星海互映,'翻疑'一笔错觉生趣,以景结情留白得当。惟'大千''寥天'略泛,灯火拟星海之喻不算生新,前三句铺垫稍显平直,整体清新而未至奇警。","_cost":0.0059088},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.6,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰以当代经验入诗，层次分明，结句翻疑有余味；意象通顺但星海比兴常见，语言平实少锤炼亮点。","_cost":0.0089945},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"此诗写夜航俯瞰的真切观感，脉络顺畅，动词锤炼精准；但意象、联想较常见，结句直白少留白，无硬伤蹈袭，略有当代视角新意。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验入旧体，取象统一：银翼、寥天、华灯、星海层层递进，氛围浑成。'翻疑星海坠舷边'虚实翻转，以景结情，余味悠长。起承转合完整，结句尤佳。'华灯''星海'稍熟，立意止于惊奇赞叹，未再掘进一层，故各维略留余地。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰城灯入诗，题材当代却取意常见；“银翼”“华灯”“大千”“霓虹”“星海”皆熟语堆叠。结句将地上灯火疑作星海坠舷，翻转尚有趣味，但“翻疑”说破幻觉，余味有限。章法平顺无跌宕。","_cost":0.02074},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.25,"rationale":"起承转合井然，结句以翻疑星海坠舷边将航空经验与古典星海幻象交融，奇绝有余味；惟立意止于即景，万点霓虹、大千略熟，故中评。","_cost":0.02018964}},"consensus":71.4,"final":71.4},{"key":"gemini-3.1-pro|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"gemini-3.1-pro","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"云枢漏断接星光，网迹飞梭理万箱。铁臂擎空分错落，银龙掣电启征航。微波闪烁传新令，大邑沉冥卧冷霜。但见朝霞披紫陌，方知夜扫暖寒乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.3,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.70000000000002,"rationale":"以智能云仓夜运写民生温度，题材新，冷夜至朝霞脉络清晰。铁臂、银龙诸象有动势，但略显熟套；“漏断”“征航”稍涩。结句照应稳妥，然“暖寒乡”点旨稍直。","_cost":0.0057},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.25,"rationale":"以云仓夜间分拣入律,题材当代有新意,'云枢漏断''网迹飞梭'融古今尚妥。中二联铁臂银龙对仗工整但机械罗列,气象堆砌感重。尾联'方知夜扫暖寒乡'说破题旨、近颂体口号,余味寡淡。'银龙掣电'与'漏断'意象系统略杂糅,整体中平之作。","_cost":0.04216},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"本诗将现代物流引入律诗，题材出新。中二联以“铁臂”“微波”写机械繁忙，并用“大邑卧冷霜”烘托，画面生动。然结句“方知夜扫暖寒乡”直白说尽，缺乏留白余味，部分新旧词汇杂糅略显生硬。","_cost":0.020274},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.0,"rationale":"云仓夜运入律，题旨清楚而角度常见。中联器械排比，景情未深融。结句“方知”点破主旨，余韵弱。当代物事入诗有效，套语密度偏高。","_cost":0.021786},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.25,"rationale":"现代物流题材有一定新意，但情感偏泛，结句说破“暖寒乡”削弱余味；意象妥帖但多描述，中二联层次平直，语言通顺偶有生凑，整体中规中矩。","_cost":0.00520476},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.0,"rationale":"以云仓夜间作业入律诗,当代经验与旧体结合,主脑清晰,首尾夜晓呼应。铁臂银龙取象见巧,然'启征航''暖寒乡'稍生硬,'紫陌''冷霜'近套语。结句以景收而'方知'说破,余味打折。","_cost":0.00216416},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"当代云仓题材有新意，夜作与城市沉眠相对，脉络清楚；但意象偏大词，语言有堆砌与说破，结尾直白，余味不足。","_cost":0.011244},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"以智能仓储夜班入七律,题新而旨正,'夜扫暖寒乡'有情意聚焦。云枢、铁臂、微波与漏断、冷霜、紫陌杂糅,大致融洽而锤炼未精,'夜扫'与'理箱'语义稍乖。中二联皆写机械,层次略重;结句以'方知'说破暖意,直而未宕。'大邑沉冥卧冷霜'差可摘,银龙飞梭紫陌略熟。","_cost":0.0147228},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.8,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.150000000000006,"rationale":"新题材咏云仓夜扫，动静对照有主脑；中二联铺排稍平，意象堆砌缺精融，尾联方知暖乡直说破，留白不足。","_cost":0.00824625},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"此作咏云仓夜间分拣保供，题旨明确，脉络顺畅，尝试纳入当代产业题材，但意象偏熟，情感较泛，结句点题过直余味薄，无明显硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"以七律写智能云仓夜运，题材新、主脑集中，铁臂银龙与冷霜紫陌交融有现代经验入诗之功。但'掣电''朝霞披紫陌'偏熟，'理万箱'稍直白；结句'方知夜扫暖寒乡'点破题旨、说尽无留，余味受损，整体中上。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.25,"rationale":"题材取当代物流自动化，尚属新鲜，但以铁臂银龙微波等报导式物象堆写，古今语汇硌接（漏断/云枢）。中二联皆状机械，第三联城眠一句稍有开合。结句“方知夜扫暖寒乡”说破兜底，近颂体口号，余味寡淡。","_cost":0.06478},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"以云仓夜分拣入律，题材新而主脑集中；惜意象多概念、中二联平列，结句直说暖寒乡，余味薄，语有生造。","_cost":0.026656402}},"consensus":58.84,"final":58.84},{"key":"gemini-3.1-pro|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"gemini-3.1-pro","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"凌虚一跃入穹苍，铁翼乘风夜未央。大地繁华浮宿火，江流宛转泛琼光。三千世界成虚相，万象沉浮付渺茫。耿耿星河归路远，中天静谧即吾乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":true},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.7,"警句":2.8,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.9,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写尘世虚相，主脑清楚，铁翼、宿火、江光相映成境。中二联由实转虚稍显泛化，“三千世界”“万象渺茫”较陈。尾联以中天为乡，转结有力且留有孤清余韵。","_cost":0.005674},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"以夜航当代经验入诗有可取，颔联俯瞰宿火江光尚见画面。然颈联'虚相''渺茫'纯属干说，议论架空承接生硬；'琼光''渺茫'等语套熟。结句'即吾乡'直接点破，收束稳而少余韵。整体题材出新而笔力平常。","_cost":0.03394},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"当代夜航经验入诗，意境开阔。颔联写景精切，‘浮宿火’极具画面感。颈联由实入虚转出禅意，起承转合极严谨。唯结句‘即吾乡’直抒胸臆，略嫌说破而稍欠留白余味。整体语言稳妥，有效拓宽了题材。","_cost":0.02801},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为熟题，有主脑而情欠具体。颔联宿火琼光较佳，后转虚相意象弱。语言通顺少诗眼，章法完整转折平。结句点破余味不足。当代视角算出新，套语较多无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.022334},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.900000000000006,"rationale":"立意常见，高空感怀；意象妥帖但颈联偏虚；语言有宿火、琼光等亮点；结构平稳转结直；结句说破，余味稍弱。","_cost":0.0122826},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验入诗，题旨清晰。中二联景理分层，'浮宿火''泛琼光'写俯瞰夜景精切，颈联转入空茫之思有开合。结句化用'吾乡'意稍近东坡而有翻转，惟'付渺茫'略落熟套。整体意象统一，锤炼见功夫。","_cost":0.00256196},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"夜航视角有现代感，题旨明确；颔联灯火江光尚能成境，颈联转入虚相、渺茫偏于概念，语多习见，结句说破少余味。","_cost":0.016094},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":61.25,"rationale":"夜航题材入七律较新,前两联俯瞰灯火江光意象可取,'浮宿火'略有炼字。颈联忽转佛语空谈'虚相''渺茫',与实写景脱节,章法在此空转。尾联'中天静谧即吾乡'有超逸意但收得偏直白。凌虚、穹苍、耿耿星河等套语密度中等。","_cost":0.0094338},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.3,"rationale":"夜航题材以俯瞰统摄有主脑，颔联宿火琼光精切可感，颈联遽入玄虚致意境断裂，章法起承转合有序，尾联直点吾乡余韵稍浅。","_cost":0.00683225},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"本诗写夜航俯瞰观感，结构平顺，颔联写景切当，然颈联理语空泛，感悟取径较熟，结句直白少余味，融入乘机体验但未出新，有少量熟语，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"以当代航空经验入旧体，俯瞰视角翻出'中天静谧即吾乡'之新境，题旨集中。颔联'浮宿火''泛琼光'取象精切可称佳联。惟'穹苍''夜未央''渺茫'等语稍熟，颈联转入佛理略直白，结句点破'吾乡'，余味稍减。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰题材当代，颔联宿火琼光有画意；颈联“三千世界”“万象沉浮”流入佛理套语，虚说无象；结句“即吾乡”直接说破，化东坡“此心安处”而少新意，余味不足，脉络平顺而转折乏力。","_cost":0.05276},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"章法完整，起有势、转有变；铁翼夜航将当代经验有效入诗。惜颈联抽象，三千世界、耿耿星河等套语密度较高，宿火造境稍隔；结句即吾乡稳而直白。无整句蹈袭与硬伤。","_cost":0.031750104}},"consensus":63.64,"final":63.64},{"key":"grok-4.6|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"夜市琉橱锦偶藏，银钩缓降欲搴芳。绒躯半陷玻璃罅，铁臂轻挪总落旁。巷陌犹耽清兴久，人间此技最荒唐。赢来片刻成空喜，剩得青蚨付夕阳。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"unknown"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"weak"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.9,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.1,"余味":6.6,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.4,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"以古典语汇写抓娃娃机，物欲落空之意集中，取材颇新。前三联推进清楚，但“最荒唐”说破，“搴芳”“清兴”稍饰典，“青蚨付夕阳”有余韵而语意略涩。","_cost":0.005992},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"当代题材入律有效,颔联'绒躯半陷''铁臂轻挪'刻画精切生动。惜颈联'最荒唐'直下断语,转折干说;尾联'成空喜'已把意思说破,'付夕阳'虽有景语补救仍显兜底。青蚨、夕阳稍落熟套,整体章法完整而气脉略平。","_cost":0.04},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"当代题材入诗值得肯定，前两联写抓娃娃动作生动形象。但后两联议论生硬，拔高至“最荒唐”显突兀。语言上古艳词汇与现代事物夹杂不融，结句直白且“剩得青蚨”逻辑有疵，余味不足。","_cost":0.018644},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入七律有新意，颔联意象具体。然主题止于荒唐空喜常论，颈联说理直白，结句点破过尽，余韵不足。","_cost":0.02395},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.8,"余味":6.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.4,"rationale":"抓娃娃机题材有当代新意，以徒劳空喜立意。意象具体但“搴芳”稍隔；中二联开合平直，议论略直白。尾联“青蚨付夕阳”有画面，余味尚可。","_cost":0.00907984},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"以旧体写抓娃娃机，当代经验入诗自然贴切，出新高。琉橱、银钩、绒躯、玻璃罅取象精切，物象与嘲谑之情相融。颈联转议论稍直露，'人间此技'含混。'赢来片刻成空喜'说破，幸结句'青蚨付夕阳'以景收束，稍留余味。'搴芳''总落旁'略有凑韵痕迹。","_cost":0.00298696},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.7,"余味":6.8,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"取材市井新机，颔联摹抓娃娃落空细腻，古今语融合较自然。惜颈尾议论说破，空喜荒唐稍直，夕阳结略有陈意。整体脉络清楚，意象统一，有当代入诗之新。","_cost":0.01183},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃寓人生空喜，题新而旨明，颔联状物精细、绒躯铁臂如在目前；颈联转议论稍平直说破，幸尾联以'青蚨付夕阳'宕开，景结有延宕。'搴芳'略嫌牵强，通体锤炼可见而警策不足。","_cost":0.0089568},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.9,"章法":6.7,"余味":7.9,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.8,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写当代空喜，琉橱银钩铁臂取象精切，颔联工细，颈联转议稍直，尾句以青蚨付夕阳景结，留有余韵。","_cost":0.00935625},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"以当代抓娃娃机入七律，摹写游戏过程真切，结构完整，寄寓空喜耗力的荒诞感，唯立意稍平，“搴芳”措辞略隔，余韵不足，无明显硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"以七律写抓娃娃机，当代经验入旧体颇见巧思；颔联'绒躯半陷玻璃罅，铁臂轻挪总落旁'取象精切，为全篇警策。惟颈联径下'荒唐'断语，议论稍露，说破主旨；结句'青蚨付夕阳'收束稳当而意象略熟，余味中平。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入律，前两联写夜市银钩、绒躯半陷、铁臂落旁，物象具体可感；颈联转入直白议论，'最荒唐'说破主旨，对仗亦松；尾联'成空喜'兜底，'青蚨付夕阳'稍有余味但未能宕开。当代经验入诗可取，收束略嫌说教。","_cost":0.04917},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.0,"rationale":"以古雅语写抓娃娃机，当代经验入诗较有效；意象具体、章法完整，中二联由物及人。然「最荒唐」「成空喜」直露，结句夕阳略熟，玻璃罅用词稍窘。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.032643796},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.7,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.7,"rationale":"当代经验入律极成功。颔联体物精工，写爪落落空之态神形兼备。唯颈联“最荒唐”、尾联“成空喜”语意稍见说破，且首联“夜市”与结联“夕阳”在时序逻辑上微有龃龉。","_cost":0.00697725},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"抓娃娃机写空喜荒唐主脑明确但直判说破；前四句取象精切，后半转议平直，夜市与夕阳时空相舛，结句晦涩余味受损。","_cost":0.01112155},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"抓取屡失的场景具体，惜以“最荒唐”直露说破。前半动作连贯，后半转议平直；“搴芳”“玻璃罅”稍嫌牵强，结句“剩得”语意欠稳，夕阳添景而情景融合不足。","_cost":0.06461}},"consensus":70.13,"final":70.13},{"key":"grok-4.6|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"高台种菜碧连天，雨后新蔬绿满田。素手轻锄黄叶尽，蜂喧蝶舞过篱边。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.2,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.3,"章法":5.6,"余味":4.8,"警句":0.8,"出新":0.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.6,"rationale":"天台种菜略具生活新意，雨后菜园清新明快；但碧、绿复沓，素手、蜂喧蝶舞较熟套。第三句转意不强，结句以景收束却未拓深余韵。","_cost":0.004694},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":35.25,"rationale":"天台种菜本是当代题材,惜写法全落旧套:碧连天、素手、蜂喧蝶舞皆陈语,'碧''绿'意重复。三句转折平直,无诗眼可摘。结以景收尚稳但气象泛泛,余味有限。'碧连天'近袭旧句,酌减。整体平顺而乏新意。","_cost":0.03648},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":33.5,"rationale":"题材取“天台菜园”略具时代感，但立意浅白。全诗依赖套话，“碧连天”“绿满田”语意重复，于天台而言亦显夸大；“素手”“蜂喧蝶舞”流于陈套。章法平铺直叙，结句虽以景收束，但意象俗套，毫无余味。","_cost":0.022058},"grok-4.6":{"立意":4.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.0,"rationale":"田园即景具体可感然角度陈熟无主脑新见；意象成清新氛围但多套语；炼字平实无诗眼；一二句意复转合平直；结句景收有生意而余韵有限。","_cost":0.019068},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"田园主题常见，立意平常但情事具体；意象妥帖统一却多套语。章法完整，转结尚可，结句以景收束略有余味。语言通顺少警策，无硬伤与明显蹈袭。","_cost":0.01142856},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.0,"rationale":"城市天台种菜属当代经验入诗，题材略有新意，但通篇只作田园画描摹，无独到发现与情感落点。碧、绿两句意象重复，蜂喧蝶舞、过篱边皆陈套，转句平直，结句以景收尚稳而乏余韵。","_cost":0.00274836},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.4,"语言":4.8,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.6,"rationale":"题旨明确，天台菜园小景清新生动；但意象语汇多常见，绿满田、蜂蝶等稍熟，转折平顺，结景有余味而不深。","_cost":0.011126},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.75,"rationale":"天台种菜属当代经验，题材略有新意，但情志仅止于闲适，不深。首联'碧连天''绿满田'意复且夸张空泛，'蜂喧蝶舞'为田园熟套；三句转入人物稍活，结以景收尚稳，惜全篇无诗眼、无警句，平直寡味。","_cost":0.0078378},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":4.2,"意境":5.2,"语言":4.6,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.400000000000006,"rationale":"天台种菜常题未翻新，情见一般；碧野蜂蝶等意象陈套，情景未融；语言平顺无诗眼；章法起承平铺，转结乏势；结句以景收而直白无余韵。","_cost":0.0061505},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.0,"rationale":"本诗写天台菜园雨后劳作小景，题旨明确、脉络顺达、意象谐和，但立意平熟，有熟套语，未凸显天台特质，转折少波澜，结句余韵不足，无醒目佳句。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.5,"rationale":"田园闲适熟题，无独到发现；'碧连天''蜂喧蝶舞'皆陈套，起承两句同写绿色意重。'素手轻锄'稍见人趣但泛。结句以景收尚稳而平淡。'高台种菜'与'绿满田'场景略相抵牾，扣一分。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":3.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.75,"rationale":"题为天台菜园，本可写城市屋顶的独特经验，正文却全落田园套语：碧连天、绿满田、素手轻锄、蜂喧蝶舞皆陈熟意象，与屋顶小圃尺度不合。四句皆平铺景语，无起承转合之转，结句以蜂蝶篱边收束虽为景结，却了无新意。","_cost":0.0485},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.0,"rationale":"写天台菜园，起承稍复，转结平直；通篇多陈套意象，素手、蜂蝶、碧连天皆熟语，语言稍畅，三句略亮。结以景收而少余味。无硬伤蹈袭，出新不足。","_cost":0.036477327},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.25,"rationale":"虽写天台菜园，却落入旧式田园窠臼。前两句碧绿意近，稍显原地打转；素手、蜂蝶篱边等词句极陈熟，缺乏炼字诗眼与独到体悟，结境平顺而余味浅。","_cost":0.00464625},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.5,"rationale":"止于雨后菜园写生，无主脑新意；碧绿同义反复，蜂蝶为陈套，景情未融；转折平直，结以常见之景收住无延宕。","_cost":0.01144175},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.75,"rationale":"种蔬小趣明确，但天台空间的独特感受未展开。首二句写绿复沓，“轻锄黄叶尽”动作欠精准；后由劳作转蜂蝶，脉络完整，结景略有留白，但“碧连天”“蜂喧蝶舞”等较陈熟。","_cost":0.03652}},"consensus":48.94,"final":48.94},{"key":"grok-4.6|机场送别|七绝","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"过闸登廊入碧苍，飞航破雾向殊方。窗前独立空回首，目送流霞没夕阳。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.2,"章法":5.6,"余味":6.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.949999999999996,"rationale":"机场送别题旨清楚，闸、廊、飞航具当代场景，暮霞收尾尚有画面。惜视角转换略含混，“碧苍”“殊方”“空回首”等偏熟套，情事未深掘。","_cost":0.00638},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"机场送别题材有当代经验入诗之意，'过闸登廊'纪实可取。但送别对象与情事模糊，情感只泛泛言之。'碧苍''殊方'凑韵感明显，转句'空回首'视角含混。结句以景收束尚有余味，然'流霞夕阳'属套语意象，冲淡了前两句的新鲜感。","_cost":0.0338},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.5,"rationale":"当代机场送别入诗，结构完整。然语言直白少炼，“过闸登廊”略干瘪。转句“空回首”与送别者临窗目送之动作存在视角矛盾。结句虽以景结情，但意象陈旧，整体中规中矩。","_cost":0.01765},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.0,"rationale":"送别熟题，机场入诗略新而情事不具体。过闸登廊像行人，窗前回首与目送又游移送者，章法视角矛盾。下联流霞夕阳陈套。结以景收，余味有限。","_cost":0.02391},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"机场送别角度平常，情感真实但无新境。意象妥帖而常见，结句以景结情稍有余味。语言通顺，'空'字略见诗眼，整体少警策。","_cost":0.0053526},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"机场送别以现代场景入旧体，视角由登机转至窗前目送，脉络完整。“过闸登廊”“飞航”稍显直白，“碧苍”为凑韵略生硬。结句以流霞没夕阳收束，情景交融，留有余味。题旨仍是传统送别套路，情致稍泛，无警拔之句。","_cost":0.00399976},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"机场送别题旨明确，现代流程入诗稍见新意；景结有远意，但语多熟套，意象偏常，情感未深，炼字未显。","_cost":0.015124},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"送别熟题,机场场景略添新意但情志未深掘。意象尚能成境,然'飞航'生造、'过闸登廊'过于质实,文白未融;送别者与登机者视角含混。转结以景收束、'空回首'稍有韵味,惜'流霞夕阳'落套,整体平稳少警策。","_cost":0.0102348},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.2,"语言":4.6,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.4,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.6,"rationale":"机场入题有当代感但未翻出新境；碧苍流霞夕阳意象常见，景情交融浅；过闸登廊白描无诗眼；起承转合完整而平直；末句以景结情略有余味。","_cost":0.00709115},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"此作写机场送别，题旨明确，意象贴合场景，章法完整，以景结尚有余味；但立意较平，意象、用字偏熟，转折少波澜，无警策句，现代元素未翻出新意，略有陈套。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"以古典笔法写机场送别,当代经验入诗有效,'目送流霞没夕阳'以景结情有余味。但题旨仍是送别旧套;'回首'与'目送'视角略相抵牾,首二句行程交代稍嫌平铺;流霞夕阳意象偏熟。整体稳当而新警不足。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.0,"rationale":"机场入诗仅作场景替换，情事无具体人物细节，情感泛化。碧苍、殊方、流霞、夕阳皆旧套连缀；『流霞没夕阳』语法生硬，『回首』与目送方向略有抵牾。起承转合完整但三四句同写望远，稍显重复；以景结情尚稳，余味平常。","_cost":0.06062},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.5,"rationale":"首联以过闸、登廊、飞航写机场送别，当代经验可感；结句“目送流霞没夕阳”以景结情，有余味。然情事泛常，后半流霞、夕阳、空回首等陈套，语言平稳少诗眼，章法完整而转折稍平。","_cost":0.036899653},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.2,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.15,"rationale":"将当代机场送别经验入诗，章法起承转合清晰自然。前写机去、后写人留，结以流霞夕照余味尚可。唯“空回首”于窗前目送情境下视角微涩，后半意象稍落熟套。","_cost":0.00518475},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":2.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":36.25,"rationale":"送别主脑尚存但主语游移，回首与目送方向相牴；流霞没夕阳搭配失当，过闸登廊文白生拼，碧苍殊方意象陈套，结景落死无余味。","_cost":0.01381125},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.5,"rationale":"送别题旨明确，过闸登廊有现场感，但情事未见独到；“飞航”“入碧苍”略显生硬，登机与窗前独立的视角衔接欠清。结以暮景尚有留白，流霞夕阳则较熟套。","_cost":0.041}},"consensus":57.06,"final":57.06},{"key":"grok-4.6|天台菜园|七律","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"天台菜圃映朝阳，绿叶纷披带露香。豆蔓攀篱穿晓雾，瓜藤覆架染秋黄。邻翁荷锸勤培土，稚子提筐采嫩苍。下界尘嚣人境远，田家淡泊足年长。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.6,"意境":6.2,"语言":4.7,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.8,"警句":0.8,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.1,"rationale":"天台菜园略具当代性，豆蔓瓜藤与翁稚构成清润图景；但朝阳、晓雾、尘嚣、淡泊多陈语，“采嫩苍”“足年长”生硬，尾联直说旨意，余韵不足。","_cost":0.008358},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.0,"rationale":"天台种菜本有当代生活气息,惜通篇套用传统田园语汇(荷锸、田家、尘嚣),题材新而写法陈。中二联对仗工稳但取象平常;'采嫩苍'为凑韵生造,是明显硬凑。尾联直说淡泊,说破无余味。天台之上称'田家'亦稍失切。","_cost":0.03892},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.0,"rationale":"虽以“天台”为题，却尽堆传统田园陈辞，如“邻翁荷锸”脱离天台种菜实际，“嫩苍”凑韵生造。尾联直白呼喊“淡泊”，说破兜底，毫无余味。通篇意象陈套，缺乏当代真实生活体验。","_cost":0.016066},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.75,"rationale":"屋顶田园写淡泊，主脑明而境不深。意象妥帖能成画，多套语。炼字通顺无诗眼，嫩苍略生。由景及人及理完整，转结平直。尾联说理过尽。颔联稍具画面。楼顶对照尘嚣略出新。","_cost":0.01937},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.5,"rationale":"主题常见，田园意象堆砌而少独到发现；语言通顺但无诗眼，'嫩苍'生硬；结构完整转折平直；结句说破淡泊，余味不足。陈套意象密度较高。","_cost":0.00449064},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"天台菜园有当代城市田园意趣,但立意仍归隐逸淡泊旧套。意象妥帖而常见,绿叶带露、瓜豆攀架皆熟语。采嫩苍生造硬凑,足年长凑韵,未见诗眼。章法完整,首颔颈尾层次分明,惟尾联转入议论直白说破,余味不足。陈套意象密度偏高。","_cost":0.00271996},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.3,"rationale":"写天台菜园，层次清楚，颔联有画面；但题旨多田园常语，尾联直说淡泊，意象与措辞偏熟，余味不足。","_cost":0.013022},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.0,"rationale":"田园避尘题旨明确而角度常见；晨圃、豆瓜、邻翁稚子画面统一但多熟象。“嫩苍”“足年长”生硬，中二联工整少变，尾联直陈淡泊，余味被说破；仅天台菜园略含今意。","_cost":0.0150852},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":4.3,"意境":5.2,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.3,"余味":3.6,"警句":0.5,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.849999999999994,"rationale":"熟题田园无新境，直陈淡泊；意象铺列常见，颔联稍工；语言通顺少诗眼，‘嫩苍’晦涩；章法平直，尾联说理兜底无余味。","_cost":0.0081004},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"此诗写菜园闲趣，题旨明确但角度陈旧，意象熟套，语言平顺少锤炼，章法规整却平直，结句说破余味薄，无警句新意，无硬伤蹈袭，略有陈词。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.0,"rationale":"以天台种菜入诗有当代生活气息，然通篇仍落入传统田园套式：豆蔓瓜藤、邻翁稚子皆常见意象，'天台'之新意未深掘。中二联对仗工稳，脉络完整。结句'人境远''足年长'直接说破淡泊主题，议论兜底，余味寡淡。'采嫩苍'用字稍生。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.25,"rationale":"天台种菜为当代经验，惟仅“下界尘嚣”一句点出高处，余皆套用田园旧格。中二联并列铺景无开合，“嫩苍”“足年长”凑韵生硬，“朝阳”“晓雾”意重。结句以“淡泊”说破兜底，余味寡薄。","_cost":0.04694},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.5,"rationale":"田园题材常见，取象稳妥而多陈语；颔联稍可摘，中二联由物及人，层次尚清而转折平。结句直说淡泊，少余味。‘嫩苍’‘足年长’措辞生硬；天台避嚣略具今意而未化开。无蹈袭硬伤。","_cost":0.031748438},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.65,"rationale":"题涉现代天台菜园，章法脉络清晰，工稳平顺。但意象多落入传统田园旧套，“嫩苍”造词稍生硬凑韵，尾联直白说破出尘之意，余味略薄。","_cost":0.006318},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":3.8,"章法":4.8,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.2,"rationale":"田园淡泊题旨常见，景人铺陈少主脑；意象尚具晨圃氛围但罗列；嫩苍、足年长生涩；中二联同质少开合；结句议论兜底无余味。","_cost":0.0154495},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"天台种菜略有生活新意，朝露、藤蔓与邻翁稚子共同成境；但淡泊避尘的题旨常见，“采嫩苍”“足年长”生硬。铺景写人层次清楚，尾联转折较直，结句说尽，余味不足。","_cost":0.03459}},"consensus":48.98,"final":48.98},{"key":"grok-4.6|云端相册|七绝","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"轻点屏中万象收，曾经笑貌逐波流。翻开往事如尘杳，独对云端意更幽。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.3,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.8,"余味":4.6,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.449999999999996,"rationale":"以云端相册寄怀旧孤寂，题材具当代感，主旨清楚。屏、波、云相应尚可；“笑貌逐波流”“如尘杳”稍显硬涩，末句直陈“意幽”，留白不足。","_cost":0.005078},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.0,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗题材尚新，惜情感停于泛泛怀旧，无具体人事支撑。'逐波流''如尘杳'皆熟套喻象，二、三句意思重复原地打转。结句'意更幽'以虚字直陈心绪，说而未画，留白不足。语言通顺但乏诗眼。","_cost":0.03259},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":33.5,"rationale":"以当代经验“云端相册”入题略有新意，但立意落于叹老俗套。语言平白，意象陈滥，缺乏锤炼。结句“意更幽”直接说破，无回味之致。结构平铺直叙，情感空泛，未能将新题材化为诗意。","_cost":0.016584},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"云相册写怀旧，情事具体而角度常见；屏云与流逝略交融，波流尘杳仍套；语言通顺无废字亦乏诗眼；起承可转结平直；结句点破意幽，余味不足。","_cost":0.011734},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.0,"rationale":"题材借云端相册稍有现代感，但情感泛泛，未落到具体人事；意象偏虚，笑貌逐波流、往事如尘杳近意且熟；转结平直，意更幽说破感受，余味不足。","_cost":0.00765864},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗，旧忆与新技相映，立意有当代经验支撑但情感落点仍是常见怀旧。'万象收''逐波流''如尘杳'意象妥帖而偏熟，结句'意更幽'直说心绪，说破而少留白。转句'翻开'仅顺承未成转折，章法平直。云端双关稍见巧思，无警句出彩。","_cost":0.00273556},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗有当代感，起句轻点见巧；但后幅多泛语，笑貌、往事如尘等偏熟，结句直说幽意，少留白。","_cost":0.012566},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写数码怀旧，题旨集中而发现不深；屏、波、尘、云成象未充分交融，结句“意更幽”直说抽象，余味有限；语言通顺少诗眼，有陈套，未见蹈袭。","_cost":0.0121548},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.2,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.6,"rationale":"借云端相册切入当代经验略有新意，但情事抽象泛化，逐波流、尘杳等陈套意象堆砌，景情未融，转结平直，末句直言意幽说尽无余味。","_cost":0.00668225},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.5,"rationale":"此诗写浏览云端相册的怀旧心绪，题旨明确、脉络通顺，但意象表达多熟套，转合平直，结句较直，仅当代云端题材略具浅近新意，无突出警句。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字时代的追怀，题材翻新，情事具体，起承转合完整。'轻点屏中''逐波流'取象切题有当代感；惟'如尘''意幽'稍落熟套，结句'意更幽'略直白说破，余味稍减。整体妥帖而少警策之笔。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.25,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗、双关“云端”有当代经验之新，但情事空泛无具体人事；“逐波流”“如尘杳”“意更幽”皆套语，第三句与第二句意复无转折，结句直说其情，余味不足，“曾经”“翻开”略显白话夹杂。","_cost":0.05466},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.25,"rationale":"怀旧旨明而情事空泛；取象欠精，波流尘杳套语；语言通顺少诗眼；章法完整但转句平直且意复；结句直说意更幽，破旨少余味。无警句出新，陈滥中等，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.020491425},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.2,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.9,"rationale":"当代数字经验入诗较自然，“云端”兼具双关。然承转句“逐波流”“如尘杳”多套语，开合层次不足，有原地打转之嫌。结句直言“意更幽”说尽胸臆，留白延宕较弱。","_cost":0.0056505},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.8,"意境":3.6,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.3,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字乡愁略有新意但情事空泛无主脑；意象多为波尘幽等虚语少交融；语言通顺乏诗眼；三句重复二句无转；结句直抒意幽无留白。","_cost":0.0127725},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀旧，有当代媒介意味，但情事不够具体。流波、尘埃取象较熟，“如尘杳”搭配生涩；二三句重复消逝之意，转折不足。结句直陈“意更幽”，收束完整而余味有限。","_cost":0.03329}},"consensus":49.17,"final":49.17},{"key":"grok-4.6|云端相册|七律","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"云端影集锁华年，指点荧光觅旧烟。忽睹童真犹在目，天涯数码贮遥边。家中笑语凝霜鬓，老去容颜只自怜。此景长留魂梦里，他朝启箧独潜然。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"weak"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.4,"意境":5.2,"语言":4.1,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.800000000000004,"rationale":"以云端相册寄托怀旧伤老，主线清楚且有当代切口。首联较醒目，然“数码贮遥边”“凝霜鬓”生硬，“潜然”疑为误词；结尾直露，启箧与云端意象亦稍龃龉。","_cost":0.007254},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.5,"rationale":"以云端相册写迟暮怀旧,题材有当代性,惜情感流于泛叹。'数码贮遥边'生硬,'潜然'当为'潸然'系误字;结句'启箧'与云端设定自相矛盾。中二联开合乏力,颈联与尾联情绪原地重复,结句说破无余味。华年、旧烟、霜鬓等套语密集。","_cost":0.04133},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.0,"语言":2.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":3.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":25.75,"rationale":"本诗尝试以现代科技经验入题，但新旧语词融合生硬，文白夹杂。结句“启箧”与“云端”存在逻辑矛盾，“潜然”疑为错别字或生造，“贮遥边”生拼硬凑。通篇平铺直叙，情感直白，缺乏意境与余味。","_cost":0.016784},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.25,"rationale":"云端怀旧题旨清楚而角度常见。数码与霜鬓、启箧杂糅未融；贮遥边、凝霜鬓略涩。章法完整转结平直。结句说破潜然，启箧与云端相忤。套语偏密。","_cost":0.015034},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.5,"rationale":"主题有当代感但情感泛泛；意象新旧夹杂，数码与启箧不统一；语言生硬，“潜然”疑为潸然；中二联层次弱；结句说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.015191},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀，当代经验入诗可取，但中二联对仗松散、意脉原地打转，多联直陈自怜而少象。'旧烟''贮遥边'生硬，结句'潜然'当为'潸然'，误字且说破无余。'启箧'与云端意象亦有抵牾。","_cost":0.00334816},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀旧，题旨明确而稍平。荧光、数码有当代感，但与霜鬓、魂梦等熟语杂陈，意境未融。语言通顺，‘贮遥边’‘潜然’欠稳。章法完整，转结偏直，余味有限。","_cost":0.011238},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.5,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀旧悼老，题意尚明而角度常见；数码、荧光与华年、霜鬓、魂梦杂糅，未成统一意境。结句自怜说尽，“潜然”疑误、“启箧”与云端相抵。","_cost":0.0157896},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.2,"语言":3.8,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.85,"rationale":"云端题材有当代触点但情思泛旧；数码/荧光与霜鬓魂梦拼贴未融；句法生硬潜然生造；章法跳接转折乏力；尾联直抒兜底无留白。","_cost":0.00627515},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.5,"rationale":"此诗写翻看云端相册忆旧伤怀，题旨明确但角度陈旧，意象多为常套，部分语词凑泊、搭配违和，结构平直，结句直白且\"启箧\"与云端载体不符，无亮眼警句。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀旧，当代经验入旧体有新意；然'贮遥边'凑韵生硬，'潜然'疑为'潸然'之误。颔联对仗松散、语意重复，中二联开合不足。结句'独潜然'直说破涕泪，情尽于言，余味浅。自怜、霜鬓、魂梦等套语密度偏高。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":33.75,"rationale":"题材当代但仅作寻常怀旧，中二联对仗松散、\"贮遥边\"凑字，\"数码\"与\"旧烟\"\"霜鬓\"意象不谐。\"潜然\"当为\"潸然\"，\"启箧\"与云端相册自相抵牾。结句说破自怜，余味寡淡。","_cost":0.0539},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"以云端相册寄怀旧，题意集中，数码、荧光等当代经验入诗有尝试；‘家中笑语凝霜鬓’凝练可摘。然‘数码贮遥边’生硬，结句直白且‘启箧’与云端逻辑相悖，陈语如霜鬓、魂梦稍多。","_cost":0.027305826},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":4.8,"意境":3.8,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.2,"余味":3.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.6,"rationale":"数码经验入诗值得鼓励，首联切题。但颔联“天涯数码”炼句凑泊生硬，后半篇迅速滑入老迈自怜之陈套。“潜然”系“潸然”字误，“启箧”与云端意象割裂，文白古今融合较生涩。","_cost":0.0061635},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.25,"rationale":"借云端相册怀旧，立意尚明但开掘浅；多虚语少景情交融；贮遥边、启箧潜然生硬矛盾；结句直白无留白。","_cost":0.0115375},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.0,"rationale":"云端存照切入今昔之感，题材有新意；但旧烟、霜鬓、魂梦等偏熟，“贮遥边”生硬，“潜然”语义不明。童年转衰老脉络尚清，结句启箧与云端衔接弱，感伤直露。","_cost":0.04122}},"consensus":43.05,"final":43.05},{"key":"grok-4.6|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"云端俯瞰万灯光，大地沉沉入夜茫。却见江流分两岸，河山默处隐苍苍。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.4,"意境":5.8,"语言":4.6,"章法":5.7,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.4,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.7,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰视角具当代性，氛围统一，但情志较泛。“万灯光”“入夜茫”略生硬，“江流分两岸”近于常理复述。结句以苍茫景象收束，尚有余韵而意象偏陈。","_cost":0.006132},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验入诗,题材略新,惜表达空泛:'沉沉''夜茫''苍苍'皆虚字泛写,无精切物象与炼字诗眼。'江流分两岸'近于常识,转折乏力;结句'隐苍苍'含混而非留白,余味有限。章法完整但气脉平直,套语密度偏高。","_cost":0.0321},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.0,"rationale":"夜航视角开阔，有现代生活气息。然通篇语言直白少锤炼，首句与题重复，转句如大白话，缺乏诗家语境。意象宏大却空泛，结句欲造苍茫之境但余味受限，整体稍显平庸。","_cost":0.013068},"grok-4.6":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.5,"rationale":"夜航观景题旨清楚但无新境，情浅。灯火江山意象常见堆叠，氛围尚可。炼字平实无诗眼，「夜茫」略涩。起承有「却见」转而合平。结句写景未说破但余味有限。飞行视角稍出新。","_cost":0.024652},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰夜景，意象统一但偏熟；\"入夜茫\"\"默处\"略显凑合；转句平直，结句以景收束，余意尚可但少新警。","_cost":0.00507892},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰这一当代经验入诗，视角有新意。以“却见”作转，江流分两岸引出结句，结构完整。结句“隐苍苍”以景收束，留白尚可。但“万灯光”“入夜茫”炼字稍显平直，意象妥帖而常见，整体中上水准。","_cost":0.00214596},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.3,"章法":6.3,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.3,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.7,"rationale":"夜航视角明确，起承转合清楚，由灯海入苍茫，结以河山留白。但意象偏泛，语言少炼，熟语较多。","_cost":0.011974},"kimi-k3":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰视角略新，但情志无焦点；灯火、大地、江流、苍苍多熟象。起承重复，转合偏弱，“万灯光”“夜茫”生硬，结求阔远而落空。","_cost":0.015033},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":4.2,"意境":3.8,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.8,"余味":3.6,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.400000000000006,"rationale":"机上夜瞰止于灯光江山泛写，无新意主脑；意象陈套景情未融；语言平直拗涩无诗眼；转折平弱未递进；结句苍苍直收重复夜茫，了无余味。","_cost":0.0110805},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.75,"rationale":"诗作写夜航俯瞰的苍茫观感，题旨明确，脉络通顺，氛围协调；但立意角度寻常，意象偏熟，语言平实少锤炼，转结平顺欠余韵，借当代场景未出新意，无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰入诗，当代经验可取；'江流分两岸'有转势，'默处隐苍苍'以景收束留有余味。但'万灯光''河山''苍苍'皆熟象，'沉沉入夜茫'稍显凑字，整体题旨明确而开掘不深，无警句支撑。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":3.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰题材当代，惟仅作泛写，无具体情事或发现。灯光、江流、河山皆常见象，'入夜茫''隐苍苍'凑韵味重，叠字空泛。'却见'非真转，仍是平铺。结以景收稍留白，但语意含混，余味有限。","_cost":0.04202},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.0,"rationale":"立意常见、情志欠具体；意象统一而稍熟，间有陈语；语言通顺乏诗眼，“入夜茫”“隐苍苍”稍泛；章法完整而转折平直；结句以景收束，略有余韵。夜航经验稍有出新，无警句、硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":0.024944039},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.2,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.6,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"夜航视角切入，构图由面及线，起承转合完整自然。然首句与题重字，沉沉、夜茫、苍苍略显空泛，炼字平易少警策，意境虽静谧肃穆，但个人情志未深。","_cost":0.0041355},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":3.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":36.25,"rationale":"夜航止于复述灯火夜茫，无情志主脑；意象成层次但陈旧；俯瞰默处生硬，转结复沓；结句空泛无留白。","_cost":0.01457825},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.5,"rationale":"夜航视角略有新意，灯火、沉夜、江流构成俯瞰图景，但情志未深。“却见”转折偏弱，“分两岸”近于常识复述，“隐苍苍”搭配含混，结句泛化，有朦胧感而少深长余韵。","_cost":0.03231}},"consensus":50.82,"final":50.82},{"key":"grok-4.6|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"云霄夜瞰大千光，万点灯辉映莽茫。市井楼台连锦绣，江湖港汊接洪荒。舱中默察尘寰态，域内奔忙竞利场。忽悟浮生同逆旅，天涯客思对宵长。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.8,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.1,"章法":6.8,"余味":4.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.9,"rationale":"俯瞰灯火转入浮生之悟，主线清楚，航旅视角略具新意。前半景象开阔，后半“尘寰、利场、逆旅、客思”偏熟套；“忽悟”转折直露，结句收稳而余韵不足。","_cost":0.006882},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰乃当代经验入诗，颔联锦绣接洪荒稍有开合气象。惜颈联干说'竞利场'近于议论口号，尾联'浮生逆旅''天涯客思'皆袭旧套，转结落入俗调，结句说尽少留白。语言通顺乏诗眼，整体题材新而立意旧。","_cost":0.03967},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":3.5,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":31.25,"rationale":"夜航题材本具现代感，但全篇落入窠臼。前两联写景大而无当，缺乏机上真实视觉细节；颈联“竞利场”流于粗浅直白发议；尾联“浮生同逆旅”生硬点题，说破兜底。整体意象陈旧，语言粗疏无余味。","_cost":0.019652},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰有现场，然忽悟逆旅仍熟套。灯辉莽茫略成氛，锦绣尘寰利场天涯客偏密。起承尚贯转结平，结句直陈少留白。","_cost":0.01638},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":44.0,"rationale":"此作夜航俯瞰切入视角略新，但立意落套、尾联说破；意象多陈熟，颈联转议直白；结构平稳，结句余味欠佳。有律诗框架但少警句，浮生同逆旅化用前人，陈滥意象密度较高。","_cost":0.008032288},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰取材当代，视角可取，然所悟不出浮生逆旅旧调，颈联竞利场直白近说教。颔联锦绣洪荒对照尚有气象，可算一联之警。结句忽悟说破，余味平直。灯辉、锦绣、客思等套语密度偏高，扣陈滥。","_cost":0.00363376},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰有题旨，由灯景入尘世再归客思，脉络尚清；但意象偏大泛，颈尾多直说，‘逆旅’‘客思’说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.011426},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":1.5,"score":44.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰是现代视角，题材略有新意，但悟出的只是'浮生逆旅'熟套。'万点灯辉'一句有画面，然'接洪荒'夸饰失准，'竞利场'生硬文白夹杂。颈联直说尘寰奔忙，转结平直，结句客思宵长落常径。意象多陈词，'浮生同逆旅'化用李白苏轼太熟。","_cost":0.0160458},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.2,"意境":4.6,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.7,"余味":4.4,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":2.0,"score":47.3,"rationale":"夜航取材具当代感，然由灯火遽转浮生逆旅，立意熟套；大千莽茫洪荒等意象阔而空，转以忽悟硬接，末句直抒客思无宕开留白。","_cost":0.00946165},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.5,"rationale":"本诗扣夜航俯瞰题意，章法完整、语句通顺，但立意落浮生逆旅熟套，意象平俗，炼字无奇，结句直露少余味，仅颔联尚工，有少量熟语，无新意。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验入旧体，视角可取；颔联'连锦绣''接洪荒'有开阖气象。但'浮生逆旅''客思''竞利场'皆熟语，感悟止于泛泛人生嗟叹，未翻新境；'映莽茫'微有凑韵感，结句说尽少留白。章法工稳而转折平直。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验,前半有象,'港汊接洪荒'尚可;后半'尘寰态''竞利场'干说议论,'浮生逆旅''天涯客思'皆陈套,结句直抒说破无余味,'大千光''莽茫'凑韵痕迹明显。","_cost":0.05009},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.25,"rationale":"熟题无新意，情志空泛；前半取象尚可，后半干说套语多；语言凑韵生硬；章法完整而转折平；尾联说破兜底无余味。无警句出新，陈滥较重。","_cost":0.03304479},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.2,"语言":4.6,"章法":5.8,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.3,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰切入当代经验，颔联开阔工稳。然“莽茫”凑韵，后半首“竞利场”“同逆旅”径直说理落入陈套，当代体验未及深拓，结句说尽而余韵不足。","_cost":0.00618975},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.5,"rationale":"俯瞰灯火转悟逆旅客思，题旨明而角度旧；大词铺景后转空议，景情脱节；结句直抒说破无留白。","_cost":0.01289225},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰略有新视角，但由灯火转入逐利、逆旅之叹，情志泛化。景象可见而多熟套，“接洪荒”“竞利场”措辞生硬。章法完整，转悟平直；结句直点客思，长夜稍有延宕。","_cost":0.04981}},"consensus":46.71,"final":46.71},{"key":"gemini-3.1-pro|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.1-pro","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"云仓列阵夜煌煌，赤电交飞识码忙。履带如梭分件急，明朝万物达千乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.8,"章法":6.7,"余味":5.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"聚焦智能云仓夜间分拣，题材鲜活，赤电、识码、履带诸象构成忙碌光景。前三句铺写紧凑，末句点明物流惠及城乡，但直陈功用，转折与留白稍弱。","_cost":0.005106},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"以现代物流仓入诗，题材有当代气息，取象亦切合场景。然三句皆平铺直叙如场景说明，无转折变化；'识码''分件'炼字生硬近于说明文；结句'万物达千乡'直白说破，带口号味，余韵全无。新题材可取，诗味不足。","_cost":0.03638},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"将现代物流场景有效入诗，“赤电”喻激光扫描颇具巧思。前三句造境紧凑，然结句“明朝万物达千乡”过于直白，流于宣传口号，缺乏诗意留白与余味。整体语言通顺，章法平直。","_cost":0.019994},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"物流夜仓入诗具当代感，列阵煌煌赤电履带构成忙碌高效之境；然立意颂扬常见，转承平铺少变，结句直陈达乡说尽，炼字仅如梭稍亮。","_cost":0.013854},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"题材有当代物流感，取象具体但情感浅直；转句仍承写分拣，结句直说达千乡，余味不足；“赤电交飞”略有亮点，然“如梭”等套语常见。","_cost":0.011039732},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"以智能云仓分拣入诗，取材新警，'赤电交飞识码忙'以光写码，象中含情，为全篇亮点。起承有序，由夜景到机件再到'明朝达千乡'，收束有拓展但偏直陈说尽，少留白。'煌煌''如梭'稍熟，整体稳而浅。","_cost":0.00229976},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"取现代物流入诗，场景清晰，末句有拓展；但语多说明与口号，意象偏工具化，结句说破少余味。","_cost":0.007798},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"以现代物流入七绝,题材新颖,赤电识码、履带分件取象精切、场景统一;然止于场面白描,无人有情,主脑不深,结句'万物达千乡'略近口号、说破兜底,余味有限。章法平稳但转结平直,整体为合格的当代题材习作。","_cost":0.0062118},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.6,"语言":4.7,"章法":5.1,"余味":3.9,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"云仓夜作题材具体有时代感，然颂扬铺陈少主脑；赤电一象较精，余多列阵如梭套语，景情二分；章法平进无转，结句直陈功效说尽无余味。","_cost":0.00844175},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.0,"rationale":"本诗聚焦云仓夜分拣场景，主题明确，脉络平顺，当代物流入诗自然有新意，但摹写偏平实，炼字稍弱，结句直白少余味，仅个别熟词，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"当代物流经验入诗，题材新颖具体：云仓夜扫、识码、履带皆实感可据。'赤电交飞识码忙'取象精切有动感；'履带如梭'喻妥帖。惟第三句承而不转，章法平直；结句'达千乡'收束稳当但偏直白说明，余味稍欠。整体通顺少废字，'万物'略夸饰。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.25,"rationale":"以智能仓储夜景入诗有当代感，赤电识码、履带如梭取象尚切；但全篇止于铺叙场面，无情志主脑，第三句承而不转，结句'万物达千乡'直说兜底近口号，余味殆尽。","_cost":0.03145},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.25,"rationale":"取象新颖，云仓、赤电写现代仓配；然情志浮浅，转句失变，结句直白。语言通顺而少诗眼，偶有套语。当代经验入诗有效，给2.5分；无警句、无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.031234055}},"consensus":56.32,"final":56.32},{"key":"grok-4.6|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"午夜荧屏映面光，音容宛在惹神伤。分明笑语萦怀抱，独对寒衾梦转长。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.3,"意境":6.6,"语言":5.7,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.2,"警句":1.2,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"以视频造成“宛在”与独眠的反差，情事具体，末句收束完整。荧屏、寒衾相映有情境，但“惹神伤”“音容宛在”“梦转长”等较熟滥，炼字与余味未臻深厚。","_cost":0.00537},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"以深夜看视频思人入诗,题材有当代感,惜情事交代含混(悼亡抑或相思不明)。'音容宛在''神伤''寒衾'皆熟语连缀,炼字乏力无诗眼。三句转出笑语与怀抱之反差尚可,结句'梦转长'收束稳但落旧套,余味有限。","_cost":0.03703},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.0,"rationale":"当代经验“视频”入诗值得肯定，但语言多用现成词语如“音容宛在”“惹神伤”，缺乏锤炼与诗眼。意境平平，结句稳当但偏直白，整体虽章法完整但流于套路，余味不足。","_cost":0.012598},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.0,"rationale":"睹视频思人，题旨明确而角度常见，情真但无翻新。荧屏、寒衾可成夜境，然音容宛在、神伤等套语密，炼字平。起承尚顺，转结直陈梦长，余味不足。","_cost":0.010956},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.75,"rationale":"深夜视频怀人，情感真实但角度平常；意象氛围统一而偏熟套；语言通顺少诗眼；起承转合完整，结句略有延宕。‘音容宛在’‘寒衾’等较陈。","_cost":0.0113012064},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"视频通话入诗是当代经验的有效尝试，'荧屏映面光'取象切题。但'音容宛在'惯用于悼亡语境，用之于生者别离易生歧义且近成语硬套；'惹神伤''寒衾'为熟语，情感表达偏于套路。章法起承转合完整，以'梦转长'收束留有余地，整体中规中矩，新意与陈熟相抵。","_cost":0.00284996},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.8,"余味":6.2,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.400000000000006,"rationale":"题取当代视频，能写屏光余温与孤寒相映，脉络清楚；但语多熟套，“音容宛在”偏悼亡，情旨泛化，结句有余味而未宕开。","_cost":0.010936},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"以深夜重看逝者视频入诗,当代经验与悼亡旧题结合略有新意,情感指向明确。但'音容宛在''寒衾梦长'皆熟语,意象未深挖荧屏冷光与旧影温热的张力,转结平直,结句以梦收尚稳却无延宕警策,整体通顺而少锤炼。","_cost":0.0071478},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.6,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":6.9,"余味":5.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.6,"rationale":"荧屏微光对寒衾构成虚暖实寒对照，起承转合清晰；但音容宛在、神伤等语陈套，翻新仅在题材，结句以景收却直白，余韵不深。","_cost":0.00937925},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"此诗写深夜观视频怀人，题旨明确、情感真挚、脉络通顺，但角度、意象、表达多熟套，转折平直，结句偏直白，仅涉当代场景未翻新，无亮眼警句，无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"以视频通话写悼念或远隔之思，当代经验入旧体有新意；荧屏之光与寒衾冷寂对照成篇，章法起承转合完整。惟'音容宛在''惹神伤'系悼挽熟语，情感稍露直白，结句'梦转长'收束稳当而余味略平。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.25,"rationale":"首句荧屏映面尚有当代实感，此后即落入“音容宛在”“惹神伤”“寒衾”“梦长”等套语连缀，情事泛化，未见具体细节与独到发现。转句“分明笑语”承接平直，结句说尽而无留白，通篇熟路。","_cost":0.04225},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.25,"rationale":"以深夜看视频引发思念，题意明确但属常见怀人，取象杂用成语与寒衾，结构完整转合平稳，结句稍直白；当代屏幕经验入诗略具新意，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.021373445},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.2,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.5,"rationale":"尝试以当代视频经验入诗，起承转合顺畅。然“音容宛在”多为悼亡专用，用于日常视频易生歧义或属误用；后半落入“寒衾”等陈套，新旧融合稍显生硬，结语余味不足。","_cost":0.00652725},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"以视频慰思作虚实对照，主脑明确但开掘不深；荧寒对比有氛围而套语多，语言平直无诗眼，转结平稳少余味。","_cost":0.0117523},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.0,"rationale":"屏中笑语与衾边孤独相衬，氛围统一，题旨集中但情意常见。二三句复意，“映面光”略涩，“惹神伤”直露；结句略有延宕而措辞熟套。荧屏入诗稍具当代感，无突出警句。","_cost":0.05695}},"consensus":53.11,"final":53.11},{"key":"grok-4.6|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"夜市摊前立一旁，绒娃满柜色娇黄。轻摇杆后徐垂爪，试捉将离又落伤。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":4.8,"意境":5.7,"语言":3.9,"章法":5.8,"余味":4.2,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75000000000001,"rationale":"取材当代，抓取将成复失的瞬间具体可见，但情志较浅。全篇线性推进，末句有转折；“立一旁”“色娇黄”“落伤”措辞生硬，结尾点“伤”稍显说破。","_cost":0.005954},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.5,"rationale":"当代题材入诗可取，惜通篇纯记事，未见寄托或翻出人生况味。'立一旁''色娇黄'平淡，'落伤'为凑韵而生造。结句写将得复失稍有怅惘，但止于实录，未能宕开。章法完整而转折平直，整体如白描说明文。","_cost":0.03138},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":34.5,"rationale":"以当代生活“抓娃娃”入题略具新意。但全诗流于动作白描与平直叙事，未开掘深层意蕴。语言生硬且文白夹杂，结句“又落伤”直白且凑韵，毫无留白与余韵可言。","_cost":0.013464},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"夜市抓娃娃近得又失，场景具体主脑清，意旨寻常。意象贴切未深融。语言平实落伤稍炼。顺叙完整转合平。结句点伤余味弱。题材入古典有新。","_cost":0.018812},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"写抓娃娃机有当代生活感，主脑集中；动作描写较精。但转结平直，“将离/落伤”稍生硬且情语露，余味不足。","_cost":0.01277958},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.25,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入绝句，当代经验有效入诗，立意有可取处但止于场景白描，未翻出新境。意象具体（夜市、娇黄绒娃、垂爪），然'色娇黄''落伤'为凑韵略显生硬，'伤'字点破情绪，结句直白少余味。章法起承转合完整，转结有落空之变，但情感层单薄，整体中下水准。","_cost":0.00240976},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.6,"rationale":"当代题材入诗，场景具体，动作细节清晰，章法完整；但语言偏平，“落伤”稍显生涩，结句说破，余味有限。","_cost":0.006212},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.5,"rationale":"现代题材入七绝可取，夜市、绒娃、落爪构成完整小场景；但多作叙述，“色娇黄”“落伤”生硬，结句直说伤而少余蕴。","_cost":0.0148368},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.2,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.8,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.85,"rationale":"当代小物入诗有现场感，但仅作过程白描，取象直露未化情境，句法滞重无诗眼，转合平直，结句“又落伤”直说尽无留白。","_cost":0.00736775},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"此作写抓娃娃的当代日常场景，主脑明晰，叙事通顺，意象贴合；但立意无新拓，章法平直，意境浑融不足，结句直露少余韵，仅题材有一定当代性，无警策句。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"以七绝写抓娃娃机，当代经验入诗可喜，'轻摇杆后徐垂爪，试捉将离又落伤'捕捉欲得复失的怅惘，情事具体。但题旨止于小失落，未翻出更深一层；'落伤'生造凑韵，结句直陈情绪，说破而少留白。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.75,"rationale":"取材当代生活有新意，但仅作流水记叙，无所寄托。“立一旁”“色娇黄”凑字凑韵，“落伤”生硬。四句平铺无转折，结句说破失落，缺留白与余味。","_cost":0.03825},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"咏抓娃娃机，当代经验入诗（出新2）。起承转合完整，结句直白少余味；意象贴切而情景交融弱，“徐垂爪”有亮点，“落伤”稍生硬。无警句、硬伤、陈滥、蹈袭。","_cost":0.030206978},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.8,"余味":5.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.05,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗自然妥帖，动态细节捕捉精准，章法一气流贯。惟结处“落伤”炼字略嫌生硬，且收束稍显直白，若能借景或喻意延宕则余味更足。","_cost":0.0045855},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":3.5,"意境":3.0,"语言":2.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":33.75,"rationale":"取材新颖仅止白描，无情志主脑；语言生涩“落伤”费解，意象平直无融，章法流水，结句直收无味。","_cost":0.013951},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.75,"rationale":"抓娃娃失手的情事具体，但意蕴较浅。柜、杆、爪构成现场，动作脉络清楚而偏实录。“立一旁”冗弱，“将离又落伤”语意生硬；结句以“伤”直露情绪，余味不足。当代器物入诗略有新意。","_cost":0.04477}},"consensus":54.14,"final":54.14},{"key":"grok-4.6|深夜视频|七律","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"夜静荧辉照榻光，孤衾冷浸掌中凉。人间百态轮番过，往事前尘入眼长。独坐宵分寻旧影，当年笑靥尚留香。欢声已杳情难续，闭目回思万绪茫。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.6,"意境":5.4,"语言":4.8,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.1,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.50000000000001,"rationale":"深夜观看旧视频而怀人，主线清楚，“荧辉”“掌中凉”贴题；但前尘、笑靥、留香、情难续等较熟滥，中二联意脉重复，末句直说愁绪，留白不足。","_cost":0.006022},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.0,"rationale":"深夜刷视频忆旧人的当代题材有一定新意，惜情事泛泛无具体人事。'照榻光''掌中凉'语意重复，'笑靥留香''万绪茫'皆套语。中二联开合不足、原地打转，颈联与颔联意重。结句'闭目回思'说尽兜底，全无余味。","_cost":0.03321},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":2.5,"章法":3.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":29.0,"rationale":"首联以“荧辉”“掌中凉”写深夜看手机尚切题，但中后段陷入“往事前尘”“万绪茫”等陈词滥调的空泛抒情。通篇干说无象，颈联原地打转，结句直白说破，缺乏诗意与余味。","_cost":0.02072},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.0,"rationale":"深夜观旧视频怀人，场景具体、主脑尚清，器物入诗有当代感。然孤衾、前尘、留香、万绪等套语偏密，颈联转意平，结句直陈茫然，炼字少诗眼。","_cost":0.015838},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.75,"rationale":"题旨明确但角度常见，情感尚具体；意象妥帖偏熟，中二联回忆重复、转折平直，结句说破心绪。语言有凑字，陈套密度较高，唯“掌中凉”稍可。","_cost":0.0096492},"glm-5.3":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.75,"rationale":"深夜刷视频忆旧本有当代切入，惜未展开具体情事，仍落怀旧套途。中二联意象陈滥（孤衾、往事前尘、笑靥留香），'荧辉照榻光'生硬拗口。结句'万绪茫'直说心境，言尽意尽无留白。全诗以旧语装新事，新意仅存于题材。","_cost":0.00207176},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.35,"rationale":"深夜荧屏引旧忆，题旨明确而情感偏泛，多靠人间百态、前尘旧影等熟语支撑。掌中凉略有现代触感，但语言欠锤炼，结句说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.015816},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.0,"rationale":"深夜刷屏忆旧情，当代经验入诗可取，'掌中凉'暗写手机略有巧思。然角度未脱伤旧窠臼，'照榻光''入眼长''万绪茫'多为凑韵之语，孤衾、前尘、笑靥留香等陈象连缀。结构完整而转折平直，结句'万绪茫'直说兜底，无余韵。","_cost":0.0105768},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.2,"章法":4.8,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.5,"rationale":"以深夜刷视频触发怀旧切入当代，然情事泛化无主脑；荧辉孤衾外多抽象说理，景情未融，语言直白陈语多，结构平铺少转，尾句直抒兜底无留白。","_cost":0.00969125},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.2,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.4,"rationale":"此作写深夜观屏忆旧，题旨明确但角度熟套，情志泛化欠具体，意象妥帖多陈常，语言平顺稍有炼字，章法完整但转折平直，结句直白说破余味薄，当代题材未出新，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.5,"rationale":"以刷屏夜读旧影写今人孤独，取材有当代感；'孤衾冷浸掌中凉'物我交融见巧。然中二联意象趋熟（往事前尘、笑靥留香），情语多而新象少；尾联直陈'万绪茫'说破兜底，余味打折。章法完整但转结平直。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":36.5,"rationale":"以深夜刷屏寄怀旧之思，题材当代，然“人间百态”“往事前尘”“万绪茫”等套语连缀，中二联开合不足、意象重叠，结句说尽无留白。首句“照榻光”与“荧辉”语意重复，炼字欠精。","_cost":0.04398},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"首联以屏光孤冷写深夜视频，当代经验入诗稍有新意；中二联多‘往事前尘’‘笑靥留香’等陈熟语，情景交融不足；结句直说情难续、万绪茫，余味少；章法完整而转折平。","_cost":0.029531718},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.1,"rationale":"以深夜刷手机视频入诗具生活气息，“掌中凉”捕捉真切。然颔联铺陈平泛，后半首迅速滑入“旧影笑靥、情难续”之陈套；尾联完全说破兜底，缺乏留白与余味。","_cost":0.0055365},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.0,"rationale":"以掌中荧辉写深夜刷视频，有当代触点但百态与旧影游移，语言空泛套语多，结句兜底无余味。","_cost":0.01047905},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.5,"rationale":"屏光、衾冷能烘托孤寂，由视频转怀旧脉络清楚，但情事欠具体。“荧辉”与“光”、“往事”与“前尘”语意重复；“笑靥留香”等较陈熟，结句直说愁绪，缺少延宕。","_cost":0.04051}},"consensus":45.87,"final":45.87},{"key":"grok-4.6|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"白发盈门菜饭香，蒸腾热气满街扬。欢声笑语消孤寂，恰似春风入草堂。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.2,"语言":4.6,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.8,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.400000000000006,"rationale":"社区助老题旨明确，菜香、热气与笑语构成暖意，但情感推进较直。满街扬稍显夸饰，消孤寂说破；春风入草堂属熟套，且与社区场景略隔。","_cost":0.005088},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.5,"rationale":"题材当代可取，然全篇报道式赞颂，情事不具体。'欢声笑语''孤寂'直说无象，'恰似春风'比喻陈熟，结句以套喻兜底、说尽无余。取象泛化，热气满街扬亦欠精切。章法平铺，转结乏变。","_cost":0.02948},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":2.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":33.25,"rationale":"题材引入当代生活，但写法流于宣传口号。语言直白，多用“欢声笑语”“恰似春风”等陈词，以直说“消孤寂”替代意象表达。结句说尽无留白，全诗缺乏诗意与余味，仅章法平直完整。","_cost":0.02461},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.5,"rationale":"题材取社区食堂略具时代感，然立意止于温情消孤寂，角度常见。白发盈门稍可，后半欢声笑语、春风草堂皆套语。第三句说破题旨，结句熟滥无余味。语言通顺少炼。","_cost":0.015918},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"立意有现实关怀，情感具体但角度常见；意象统一温暖，‘满街扬’稍浮；语言通顺，‘消孤寂’直露；章法完整但转折平直；结句比喻说破，余味不足。‘白发盈门’略有佳处，题材当代而表达旧套。","_cost":0.01087152},"glm-5.3":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.75,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗选题有时代感，但立意停留于歌颂层面，'欢声笑语消孤寂'直白说破，孤寂之情不够具体可感。意象陈套密集：热气、春风、草堂皆常见套语，'草堂'与社区食堂场景错位。结句以比喻收束尚稳，然'恰似'点破，余味有限。章法完整但转折平直，第三句原地承接，无真转。","_cost":0.00274436},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.75,"rationale":"题旨明确，写社区食堂暖老，但多用概念直说；意象熟泛，热气春风少新意；语言平顺欠锤炼，结句比喻说破，余味较薄。","_cost":0.008276},"kimi-k3":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.75,"rationale":"社区养老题材入诗有当代性,值得肯定;但通篇直陈其事,'欢声笑语消孤寂'近乎口号,意象堆叠而情不深。结句以'恰似春风'明喻兜底,说破说尽,无余韵。章法完整而平直,语言通顺少锤炼,套语密度中等。","_cost":0.0064584},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.2,"章法":5.6,"余味":4.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.4,"rationale":"立意取当代温情题材真挚但角度常见；意象直陈少融情；语言通顺乏诗眼；章法起承转合完整而平直；结句以喻收束直白余味浅。","_cost":0.0090045},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.5,"rationale":"此作写社区食堂惠老场景，题旨明确、脉络平顺、语言通顺，但意象熟套、表达平泛直白，无独到细节与留白余韵，仅题材涉当代日常，整体平正少新警。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.5,"rationale":"取材当代社区食堂，民生关怀有现实温度，'白发盈门菜饭香'起句具体可感。但中后段'欢声笑语''恰似春风'皆熟语，结句以比喻说破温情，无留白；'草堂'与食堂场景略隔。整体通顺平实，意象常见，转结平直，余味有限。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.75,"rationale":"题材当代，但仅作正面颂扬，角度常见。取象白发、饭香、热气、欢声笑语皆泛写，无具体场面细节；'消孤寂'直说主旨近于标语，'春风入草堂'比喻陈熟且'草堂'与社区食堂语境不贴。结句以熟喻兜底，说尽无余。","_cost":0.0455},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.5,"rationale":"取材社区食堂，题旨清楚，白发、菜饭香稍具体。然欢声笑语、春风草堂皆熟套，结句直白少余味；语言平熟无警句，当代经验未化新境。章法起承转合完整，转句稍平。","_cost":0.025004896},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.2,"意境":4.8,"语言":4.6,"章法":5.4,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.3,"rationale":"关注当代养老与温情，立意通达具体。起承描摹生动，具人间烟火气；转结滑入“欢声笑语”“春风草堂”等现成套语，说得较平较满，余味略薄。","_cost":0.00518475},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"取社区食堂暖老有主脑，但意象多欢声春风套语，直陈消孤寂，转结平直说破，少留白余味。","_cost":0.0130478},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.5,"rationale":"聚焦老人共餐解孤，题旨明确；菜饭热气有生活感，但取象泛常，“满街扬”欠精切。第三句直说情意，结句以春风作比，熟套且重申暖意，转结平直，余味较薄。","_cost":0.03164}},"consensus":47.08,"final":47.08},{"key":"grok-4.6|社区食堂|七律","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"晓起邻翁就膳香，蒸腾满座溢羹汤。青蔬细切调油酱，豆腐微煎佐醋姜。笑语盈厅融块垒，茶烟缕袅散轻凉。年衰幸得公厨便，更喜余温入梦长。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"unknown"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.4,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.8,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.4,"rationale":"社区养老入诗，情事具体，饮食铺陈转向邻里慰藉，脉络清楚。“融块垒”稍见力度；“就膳香”“散轻凉”语意欠稳，结尾温厚但“幸得、更喜”略说尽。","_cost":0.005858},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"取材当代社区食堂,题材可喜,情事具体。然中二联皆写饮食琐细,开合层次不足,近于菜单铺陈;'融块垒'稍见笔力。尾联'幸得''更喜'直陈感恩,说破无余,'余温入梦'略存温度。语言平顺少诗眼,整体稳而不奇。","_cost":0.0338},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"当代题材入诗，立意贴近民生，充满烟火气。章法稳妥，从晨景、菜肴到老者交流，脉络清晰。然语言平白，‘缕袅’等词略生硬，结句直白，余味稍欠，属较好的生活小诗。","_cost":0.016176},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"社区食堂写衰年就膳，情事具体主脑清。意象日常妥帖欠 Distilled 交融。语言通顺少诗眼，章法平正少转。结句余温入梦略留白。题材入古体算出新，茶烟笑语略套。","_cost":0.014204},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.7,"语言":5.2,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.8,"警句":0.8,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"写社区食堂食事，情感真实但立意常见；意象具体而少新意，氛围温暖统一；语言通顺有细节，略少诗眼；中二联平列，转结直白；尾联说破致余味略浅。题材有当代气息，无明显硬伤。","_cost":0.00696124},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"社区养老食堂入律诗，当代经验有效，情事具体真挚。中二联一写膳食一写人情，层次分明；‘融块垒’见炼字。但菜蔬烹调罗列近菜谱，意象偏实，茶烟等语微熟。结句‘余温入梦’温和有延宕，未全说破。整体稳当而锋芒稍欠。","_cost":0.00237696},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.6,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"写社区食堂烟火与人情，题旨明确，细节可亲；中二联由菜品转入氛围，结构平稳。但语言偏菜谱式直陈，尾联稍说破，余味有限。","_cost":0.008302},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.75,"rationale":"题旨集中写社区食堂惠老，角度尚新而发现不深；中二联铺排菜肴略成清单，“块垒”“轻凉”与暖境未融，结句有余温意象但幸、喜说破。","_cost":0.0158268},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.8,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.6,"rationale":"社区食堂切入老龄日常，情事具体真挚；羹汤蔬豆茶烟织暖境较融洽但铺排略平；语言自然通顺少诗眼；章法层次清晰而转结直抒，余味稍浅。","_cost":0.00872065},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"本诗聚焦社区食堂暖老主题，情志真切，章法平顺，意象基本贴合但略有隔，语言通顺欠锤炼，结句直白少余味，引入当代题材但开掘不深，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"当代题材入旧体，写社区食堂养老温情，题旨具体有主脑。中二联物象细切，'融块垒''散轻凉'见炼字。惟'笑语盈厅'等语稍熟，尾联'幸得''更喜'直陈说破，余味略减；整体稳而未奇。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.0,"rationale":"题材当代，写老年公厨有生活感，青蔬豆腐取象具体。但中二联皆铺陈饭菜与场景，缺开合转折；“融块垒”稍见情志，余多颂语。尾联直陈感恩，“余温入梦”略有余意而未能宕开。语句平顺，“就膳香”“公厨便”稍硌。","_cost":0.04927},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.55,"rationale":"晨景写社区食堂，当代经验入诗，题旨集中。颔联菜单式描写稍质实，意象平熟；颈联融块垒稍振。尾联余温入梦有余味，但幸得公厨便略直白。章法完整稳妥，语言通顺偶有亮点。","_cost":0.03539823},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.3,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.6,"余味":5.9,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.45,"rationale":"当代民生题材入诗，烟火气充盈，脉络清晰。颔联摹饮食略显质直，颈联“块垒”用字过重；尾联前句稍见老干说破之弊，赖“余温入梦”留得回味。整体平顺温润。","_cost":0.005163},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.2,"意境":5.8,"语言":4.8,"章法":6.3,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.2,"rationale":"题取社区养老颇具当代关怀，融块垒点出主脑；然中联菜单式铺陈，语言偏白少诗眼，转结直抒感恩，余味稍浅。","_cost":0.01461355},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.0,"rationale":"食堂惠老题旨集中，蔬腐烹调细节可感；“就膳香”“缕袅”欠自然，“融块垒”稍显套熟。由饮食转人情层次清楚，尾联直陈便利喜悦，“余温入梦”略有延宕，未见突出警句。","_cost":0.03964}},"consensus":60.65,"final":60.65},{"key":"grok-4.6|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"春衢嘉木挂壶长，几缕风摇药液光。只为尘多青盖落，还将翠色补斜阳。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.4,"陈滥":0.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.30000000000001,"rationale":"以树木输液写城市生态，视角新颖，风、药液、青盖、斜阳交融。“翠色补斜阳”有诗眼与余韵；“挂壶长”稍显硬涩，“尘多青盖落”因果略牵强。","_cost":0.005496},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.3,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.35,"rationale":"取当代街景树挂营养液入诗,题材新而有物;'挂壶'暗合悬壶济世,'翠色补斜阳'结句以景收情有余味。惟'挂壶长'稍拗,三句'只为'交代因由略嫌直说,转折平直,炼字尚可再精。","_cost":0.04047},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"以当代城市“树挂吊瓶”入诗，立意新颖。“风摇药液光”捕捉现代细节，但“只为尘多”略显直白。结句“还将翠色补斜阳”由实转虚，赋予街景弥补生态之深意，宕开一笔，颇具余味。","_cost":0.025816},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"吊瓶入春树属今事入诗，焦点收束尚可。意象统一于补绿，然尘落青盖因果牵强。炼字平实缺眼，转合说理过尽，结句有象而意尽。","_cost":0.0201},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"写城市给树输液的当代经验，题材新，但情感略淡；意象妥帖而稍实；“青盖落”与“补斜阳”有巧思，但“挂壶长”“药液光”等语略生硬，通篇语感偏平，结句有余味但不够透脱。","_cost":0.00624624},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"取城市行道树输营养液之当代实景入诗，题新而意挚。'药液光''青盖'取象精切，物我交融。'补'字双关，既补液又补景，结句以翠色接斜阳，宕开有味。转句'尘多青盖落'点明因果，章法完密。首句'长'字稍弱，通篇干净无陈套。","_cost":0.00262816},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.55,"rationale":"写街树输液，取象新而稍有生涩。‘药液光’‘翠色补斜阳’有光色，末句留白。惟‘挂壶长’‘青盖落’语意略硬，情志未深。","_cost":0.016244},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"城市树挂吊瓶入诗较新，焦点集中；“药液光”“补斜阳”有亮色，结句能宕开。但“挂壶长”“几缕风摇”生硬，因果稍直，春、斜阳、翠色近熟。","_cost":0.0137148},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":5.9,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.7,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"以街树挂吊瓶切入城市生态，视角新切；风摇药光有现场感，翠色补斜阳以事寓情，起承转合清晰，结句留白有余味，唯首句炼字稍生。","_cost":0.00979275},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"此作抓取春街行道树输营养液的当代城市场景，题旨集中，章法平顺，语言清通，“补”字见巧；融日常新事入诗有新意，唯转折偏平、结句稍直，少量意象偏熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.0,"rationale":"取材城市树木输液这一当代经验，视角新颖；'只为尘多青盖落'暗含生态之忧，结句'翠色补斜阳'以景收情有余味。起承转合清晰，转句见骨。唯'挂壶长''药液光'稍欠锤炼，'春衢嘉木'略熟。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.0,"rationale":"取当代街景入诗，题材新鲜；\"挂壶\"暗合悬壶济世，\"药液光\"一句有致。转句以\"只为\"直陈病因稍显说明化，结以翠色补斜阳，病树犹献绿意，略有余味但意脉稍单，整体工稳而深度有限。","_cost":0.05999},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"街树输液题材新颖，‘药液光’观察细，结构完整。然‘挂壶长’生硬，‘补斜阳’逻辑牵强，结句余味弱，现代经验未完全融化。","_cost":0.026016136},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.8,"rationale":"成功将当代行道树输液经验入诗。“药液光”体物精微，“补斜阳”炼字极工且寄托深远，化病苦为生意。全篇起承转合自然圆融，无生造文白之弊，余味明朗。","_cost":0.00553575},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"行道树挂吊瓶取材新颖具体，主脑明确；风摇液光、翠补斜阳稍具意境；唯尘多落盖因果牵强，药液等语生涩，转结直陈余韵有限。","_cost":0.013333},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"树挂吊瓶切入城市护绿，药液与翠色相映，有现实新意；“挂壶长”语意生硬，第三句直陈缘由，转折稍平；结句“补”字见力，将救护之意化入暮景，留有余韵。","_cost":0.05408}},"consensus":69.68,"final":69.68},{"key":"grok-4.6|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"春街树挂吊瓶青，玉液徐倾碧管泠。弱质轻回筋骨健，新姿暗长叶茎馨。红尘不扰根须静，翠幕常滋雨露宁。待到浓阴遮巷陌，他年更见绿云冥。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.3,"意境":6.4,"语言":5.6,"章法":7.1,"余味":5.7,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.8,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.35,"rationale":"以树木输液入诗，题材新鲜，主线由疗治写至成荫，脉络清楚。碧管、吊瓶可感；但“叶茎馨”“雨露宁”“绿云冥”稍硬，红尘雨露等语偏熟，结尾直陈愿景且意象重复。","_cost":0.00613},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.75,"rationale":"取材当代城市树木输液，题材有新意可嘉。然通篇仅作正面颂赞，无波澜转折，中二联对偶平衍、意近重复。'叶茎馨''绿云冥'为凑韵而生硬，'红尘''雨露'等语陈熟。结句直陈愿景，说尽无余味。","_cost":0.03458},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.25,"rationale":"题材取“树挂吊瓶”具当代性，但立意落入“弱木逢春”窠臼。语言刻板，以“玉液”“红尘”等陈词强行包装现代物象，生硬且文白杂糅。章法平直，结句直白兜底，全无留白余味。","_cost":0.022774},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"街树吊瓶入律有当代实感，主脑在复苏与荫蔽，情志具体但不深。玉液碧管尚切，红尘翠幕雨露绿云较套。筋骨、管泠稍硬。章法顺承少转，结句预告过尽。","_cost":0.016134},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.5,"rationale":"题材有当代发现但情感泛泛；意象多套语，语序凑韵（青、馨、宁、冥），中二联近平行，结句说破且“绿云冥”歧义。无硬伤蹈袭，陈滥密度较高。","_cost":0.00761464},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"以城市行道树输液入诗，选题新颖，树如病者的拟想统一。但中二联意思趋同（皆言静养生长），开合不足；'馨''宁''冥'押韵凑字明显，'叶茎馨''雨露宁'生硬；结句直陈愿景且'绿云冥'费解，余味平平。","_cost":0.00336216},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.2,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.3,"rationale":"当代护树立意新颖，脉络清楚；但语多熟套，疗效直说，意象未深融，结句展望稍平，余味有限。","_cost":0.00979},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.0,"rationale":"城市树木输液新题入诗，焦点统一，吊瓶、玉液、碧管取象较贴切；但情志偏颂体，颔颈联意近，结以他年展望稍直，“绿云冥”略晦。无明显蹈袭。","_cost":0.0150228},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.3,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.4,"余味":4.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.15,"rationale":"吊瓶输液拟人治树，题材切近当代有发现；惜医学与草木意象粘合略生，转合平直，尾联直赋未来，少余韵。","_cost":0.00836315},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"此作咏春街行道树挂营养液事，题旨明确但无深致，意象偏熟、新旧稍隔，语言平顺少锤炼，章法平直欠开合，结句直白少余味，仅题材略涉当代经验，无突出警句与硬伤。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"取材城市树木输液，当代经验入诗，视角新颖，情意真挚。然意象经营偏于说明，'玉液''雨露''绿云'等语稍显凑泊；中二联对仗平稳而开合不足；结句以期待收束尚稳，但'冥'字生硬，说破较多，余味有限。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.75,"rationale":"取材当代街树输液，起句新鲜可感；然中二联皆言树体康复、层次重叠无开合，馨、宁、冥等字明显凑韵，红尘雨露套语稀释新意，结句直陈来日浓阴，说尽无余味。","_cost":0.05275},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"以街树输液入律，当代经验入诗可嘉；前半取象新切，后半红尘、雨露、绿云等套语稍密，语言偶生硬，章法平稳，结句直白少余味。","_cost":0.028697219},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.9,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.7,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.55,"rationale":"取当代树木输液入诗具生活气息。章法平稳直顺，起承转合规矩；中联铺陈略显平直，“叶茎馨”微有凑韵之感；尾联向未来宕开收束妥帖，但造境尚浅、余味平正。","_cost":0.0056505},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"行道树挂吊瓶取材 contemporary新颖，主脑集中；然中后联堕翠幕雨露浓阴套语，筋骨馨冥炼字牵强，转折平直，结句双言未来直白无余味。","_cost":0.0130645},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.25,"rationale":"树挂吊瓶有当代生活触点，但由扶弱写至成阴，立意较常见。“轻回”“叶茎馨”“雨露宁”语意欠妥；中联多泛饰，尾联两写将来，递进不足。结以绿云尚有景味。","_cost":0.03845}},"consensus":56.25,"final":56.25},{"key":"grok-4.6|机场送别|七律","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"送客楼头焰影凉，云衢直上势高翔。凭栏已见机轮转，举目还瞻铁翼忙。顿失音容天地隔，空余塔闪夜原茫。归途忽觉衫襟湿，后会难期梦里详。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.8,"意境":6.2,"语言":4.8,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.1,"警句":1.2,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.900000000000006,"rationale":"机场送别题旨集中，铁翼、塔闪颇具现代场景感，叙写脉络完整。“夜原茫”有氛围；但“势高翔”“铁翼忙”稍泛，“梦里详”语意生硬，结句直露而余韵不足。","_cost":0.005886},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.25,"rationale":"机场送别以今事入律稍有新意,但情感表达浮泛。颔联两句皆写望机,近乎合掌;'顿失音容天地隔'用语近悼亡,施于生离失当。'塔闪'生硬,'衫襟湿''后会难期'皆熟套。结句直陈梦语,说尽少余韵,全篇平顺而乏警策。","_cost":0.0397},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":3.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":32.0,"rationale":"尝试以当代经验入诗，但情感脱离生活逻辑。“音容天地隔”多指死别，用于航班送行属常识硬伤；词句直白生造，结句陈套兜底，毫无余味。","_cost":0.025202},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.0,"rationale":"熟题送别场面具体有主脑，角度常见。今古象杂糅未浑融，铁翼机轮稍硬。章法完整转平直，结句点破难期梦详余味薄。当代入诗有尝试，衫湿梦会等套语仍密。","_cost":0.017104},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"机场送别题材现代，情感真实但角度常见；意象择取具体，然'机轮转''铁翼忙'偏平直；语言通畅少锤炼；中二联有开合，结构完整；结句说破流泪，余味稍欠。","_cost":0.005578408},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.25,"rationale":"机场送别题旨明确但角度寻常。铁翼、塔闪等当代意象入诗可取，然炼字生硬（焰影、塔闪近生造）。颔联已见/还瞻语意重复近合掌。颈联天地隔对夜原茫尚有开合。结句衫襟湿承泪是旧套，梦里详直白收煞，余味有限。","_cost":0.00240336},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.4,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.3,"rationale":"机场送别题旨明确，现代物象有出新；但颔联意近，词语稍生硬，结句直说后会难期，余味不足。","_cost":0.015472},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.5,"rationale":"机场入七律有当代意识，脉络完整，颈联顿转有力；但机轮铁翼等象罗列未化为情语，颔联与首联意重复平直，「焰影凉」「塔闪」「梦里详」生硬凑韵，结句「难期」说破，天地隔、衫襟湿等熟语密度偏高。","_cost":0.019236},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.6,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.25,"rationale":"机场送别题旨明确而角度平常，中二联机轮铁翼同义反复无层次，焰影凉塔闪梦里详拗硬费解，结句直白兜底说尽无留白。","_cost":0.01132375},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.25,"rationale":"此诗写机场送别，题旨明确脉络平顺，但角度常规，当代民航意象入诗稍显生硬；误用悼亡语写生离为小疵，结句直白少余味，仅“空余塔闪夜原茫”稍有亮色。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"以机场入七律有当代经验之新，'塔闪夜原茫'取象尚切。然颔联'凭栏''举目'意复，机轮铁翼语近质实；结以泪湿、梦详说破兜底，余味不足。焰影、音容天地隔等语稍熟，情感真挚但收束平直。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.75,"rationale":"机场送别取当代物象（铁翼、塔闪）有可取处，但首联已“云衢直上”，颔联又回写“机轮转”，时序倒置；颔联两句意近合掌；“顿失音容”“衫襟湿”“后会难期”皆熟语，结句说破无余味。","_cost":0.05097},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"立6：旨明情常见；境5：夜航有象而机轮未融；言4.5：焰影凉、夜原茫佳，现代词与梦里详生硬；章5.5：承转完整，惟时序微舛；余4：结句直白。警2，出新1.5，硬伤2（高翔后见机轮），陈滥1，蹈袭0。","_cost":0.039554892},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.8,"章法":4.2,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.0,"rationale":"虽尝试现代机场入诗，但首颔联起飞时序颠倒；“音容”悼词生用欠妥；铁翼塔闪炼字粗疏，尾联衫湿梦详落入陈滥套路，说破无余味。","_cost":0.0059625},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.0,"rationale":"机场送别有主脑但仍旧式伤别；机轮铁翼塔闪生硬直白，情景未融；颔联同义反复；尾句后会难期说破无留白。","_cost":0.0129685},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"机场物象切题，塔闪夜茫能托离情，“归途忽觉”写出情绪的迟来；题旨仍属常见离愁。“势高翔”语意重复，“铁翼忙”“梦里详”欠自然。章法贯通，结句偏于直说，余味有限。","_cost":0.05613}},"consensus":49.45,"final":49.45},{"key":"grok-4.6|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"夜扫云仓月满廊，银辉遍地起尘忙。微风入户惊栖鸟，一帚闲抛对冷霜。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.4,"章法":6.3,"余味":5.8,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.95,"rationale":"夜扫劳作与月夜清寒相融，题材具体，末句由忙转闲稍有情绪余波。月、银辉、冷霜较熟，“起尘忙”“一帚闲抛”措辞略涩，转结未能充分生发。","_cost":0.006104},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.5,"rationale":"以当代'云仓'夜班劳作入诗有题材新意，惜情感未落到具体人事，仅止于清冷氛围。银辉、冷霜、惊鸟皆熟套，'起尘忙'凑韵乏力，无诗眼。转句与主线关联松散。结句'一帚闲抛'有画面留白，是全篇最可取处；月夜与霜并置微欠推敲。","_cost":0.04849},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.25,"rationale":"此诗章法合度，起承转合脉络清晰，结句“闲抛对冷霜”以动作连缀冷景收束，略有留白。然立意平平，意象如“月满廊”“惊栖鸟”流于陈套，“起尘忙”用语俗白，缺乏独到发现与炼字之功。","_cost":0.024854},"grok-4.6":{"立意":4.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"夜扫一景具体，情止劳后孤寂，未见翻新。月尘鸟霜对照成清寒。语平实闲抛稍炼。承转平列少变。结抛帚对霜留象。","_cost":0.023938},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.75,"rationale":"夜扫场景具体，结句抛帚对霜稍有余味；立意平常，意象多陈套，转结脉散，'起尘忙'略直硬。加分云仓现代物象，扣分陈滥。","_cost":0.00866734},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"以夜扫云仓这一当代劳作场景入旧体，主脑清晰，氛围统一。'一帚闲抛对冷霜'收得含蓄，倦意孤怀不着一字。但'月满廊'与'银辉遍地'意象重复，'起尘忙'稍显生硬，转句惊鸟偏熟套，整体中上而未能出彩。","_cost":0.00325896},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.6,"语言":5.9,"章法":6.4,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.1,"rationale":"夜扫题材小有画面，月下扬尘、惊鸟停帚皆清冷可感；但语多常见，转接稍平，题旨未深。","_cost":0.010586},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.25,"rationale":"夜扫情景具体，冷月、栖鸟、闲帚能成清寂氛围；但“云仓”只停在题名，银辉、冷霜熟象偏多，“起尘忙”生硬，转折与闲抛之理未足，结句稍有留白而力量有限。","_cost":0.0114918},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":4.2,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":3.8,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.2,"rationale":"题无主脑仅摹夜扫之景，月廊银辉等意象常见拼缀未融氛围，转句惊鸟突兀，忙与闲抛矛盾，结句抛帚对霜断脉无余味。","_cost":0.0066389},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"此诗写云仓夜扫即景，题旨明确，意象贴合清寒夜境，语言通顺，起承转合完备，结句稍有留白，但整体表达较平，无突出新警处，无硬伤、蹈袭，略有常见意象。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"以当代仓储劳作入旧体，题材有新意；月廊、尘忙、惊鸟、冷霜意象统一，寒夜孤清氛围可感。'一帚闲抛对冷霜'收束见态，留有余味。但'银辉遍地''微风惊鸟'取象常见，'起尘忙'稍生硬，情感内核偏淡，主脑不够鲜明，整体中上而未出熟境。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":3.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.25,"rationale":"题旨模糊，“云仓”所指不明，夜扫无具体情事支撑。月满廊、银辉遍地重复言月，“起尘忙”生硬；惊栖鸟、冷霜皆套语。转句平直，结句以景收尚可，但“闲抛”与前“忙”衔接生硬，余味有限。","_cost":0.04396},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.25,"rationale":"夜扫云仓场景实而情志不深，意象常见融情未紧；忙闲对照略亮，转句风鸟稍脱，结句以景收有余味。云仓未化入当代经验，用语偶滞，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.026121177},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.2,"章法":6.3,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.45,"rationale":"全诗写夜扫收束之景，章法由动入静，脉络通畅。结句“一帚闲抛”形神兼备，余味较好。唯“起尘忙”造句微平，“惊栖鸟”意象略陈熟，立意中规中矩。","_cost":0.00748875},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":3.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.0,"rationale":"夜扫有场景但主脑不明忙转闲突兀，月廊银辉风鸟冷霜皆熟语少交融，无诗眼，转结断脉，末句脱节无余味。","_cost":0.01356725},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.25,"rationale":"月色衬夜扫，场景尚可感；“起尘忙”搭配生硬，风惊栖鸟与扫仓关联偏弱，由忙入闲稍突兀。结句冷寂而略有留白，但情志未深，月、银辉、微风、冷霜较陈熟。","_cost":0.05447}},"consensus":53.42,"final":53.42},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"铁臂玻璃百宝楼，投钱欲取掌中柔。千钧钢爪偏无力，总在当空似钓钩。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.4,"rationale":"以铁臂、钢爪与“无力”反衬消费游戏的诱引和落空，取材新鲜，脉络清楚。百宝楼、掌中柔颇有意味；结句有画面，但“似钓钩”稍直，余韵有限。","_cost":0.005412},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"以当代事物入诗,借'千钧偏无力'点破机器欺弄之相,结句以钓钩喻商家诱人,人反为鱼,讽意有延宕。转结见巧思。惜'百宝楼''掌中柔'炼字稍泛,意象经营尚欠浑成,余味未臻悠远。","_cost":0.03163},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗，起承转合结构清晰。“千钧”与“无力”对比生动，刻画出抓取落空的无奈。然立意稍浅停于表象，结句比喻直白说尽，缺乏深层蕴藉与留白，整体偏向叙事白描。","_cost":0.013546},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写欲取不得，焦点集中情事具体。转句对比有力，结以空钩收束。意象贴切统一，氛围未更深拓；语言通畅有炼无惊人诗眼。出新在当代题材入古体。","_cost":0.014476},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"写抓娃娃机体验，钢爪无力如钓钩，暗讽投币徒劳。转结紧凑，意象反讽成立；立意稍浅，语言中平。当代题材与转结有加分，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.01432596},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"以旧体写抓娃娃机，当代经验入诗自然不隔。起承转合完整，转句'千钧钢爪偏无力'由欲而失，结句'似钓钩'以象收束，暗喻诱惑悬空、欲得反失，言尽意不尽。'掌中柔'炼字见巧，'百宝楼'稍显凑韵，整体妥帖而有讽味。","_cost":0.00249196},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.4,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.9,"rationale":"取抓娃娃机入诗，铁爪、玻璃、钓钩构成统一落空感，转结清楚。巧思有余，但意旨未深，个别语如百宝楼、掌中柔稍硬。","_cost":0.012282},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"以当代器物入七绝，'千钧钢爪偏无力'抓准娃娃机猫腻，翻转有锋；结句'似钓钩'双关，暗讽机台钓人钱财，宕出余意。通篇物象统一、转结得力；惜首句'百宝楼'略凑，整体以巧见长而情韵稍浅。","_cost":0.0128548},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.6,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.7,"rationale":"咏当代机巧以刚柔悖论见讽，起承转合分明，钓钩作结以形象收束留有余味；语言通顺而首句名词堆砌略损锤炼。","_cost":0.01073465},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机这一当代日常事物入诗，写出夹物落空的共通体验，暗合诱而不得的普遍况味，意象精准，结构平顺，结句有喻致，语言自然。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"以旧体写抓娃娃机这一当代经验,翻出'欲取还休'的新境;'千钧钢爪偏无力'与结句'似钓钩'形成张力,以景结情留白得当。意象切题交融,'掌中柔'与'百宝楼'略见锤炼。不足在整体语感稍熟,'铁臂''百宝楼'等词略平,深度有限。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.25,"rationale":"当代经验入诗，题材新鲜但仅停留在“钢爪无力”的常见调侃，未翻出新境。取象贴切而不深，“百宝楼”“掌中柔”尚可。“千钧”与“无力”对照略显夸张空泛。结句“似钓钩”有钓客钱财之暗喻，稍有余味，但“总在当空”近于说破，收束不够宕开。","_cost":0.0466},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入诗，钢爪无力、当空似钓钩取象精切，讽喻诱惑；章法完整，结句喻象留白。起笔稍平，立意深度有限。","_cost":0.023430101},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"当代日常经验有效入诗，摹写精微，“掌中柔”“偏无力”极切抓娃娃机情状，起承转合自然一贯。结句摹态收束偏实，诗意留白略显不足。","_cost":0.0048435},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"人反被钓一转有讽意但止于吐槽；玻璃楼钢爪取象切题而氛围浅，首句堆名掌中柔晦，结句以钩宕开留味。","_cost":0.0095343},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"以钢爪之强与抓取之弱写欲取不得，转句有讽意；“掌中柔”凝练，首句名物挤叠。起承转合清楚，末句钓钩之比留有诱取联想，但形貌比拟稍平。","_cost":0.05346},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"主脑在强爪失力，情事具体而见地未深，近常见消费牢骚。首句物名并列，百宝楼偏套，炼字不匀；三句一转、四句以钩悬空收住，余味最好。当代物象入诗成立，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0248688},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入诗，当代经验入律较有效。结句『似钓钩』暗转为机器钓人钱财，有一层讽意，但点到即止，开掘不深。『千钧』与『无力』对照成趣，『掌中柔』状毛绒贴切。起承平实，意象偏说明性，情境氛围较薄。","_cost":0.01746},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"以钢爪有力却抓取不得写出游戏的无奈，转折明快，当代物象入诗自然；“掌中柔”略显生硬，结句形象可见，但余味稍浅。","_cost":0.007972}},"consensus":72.48,"final":72.48},{"key":"grok-4.6|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"grok-4.6","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"云仓夜色隐流光，独自清辉映冷霜。默运长竿轻扫土，飞尘散入远西廊。襟怀忽觉凉生肘，满目昏沉雾气茫。渐止纤毫无剩滓，残更已尽转黎苍。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.6,"语言":4.4,"章法":6.3,"余味":5.2,"警句":0.8,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.1,"rationale":"夜扫至黎明，题材较少见，劳作过程具体，脉络清楚。冷霜、飞尘、残更能营造清寒氛围，但情志开掘偏浅；“襟怀凉生肘”“转黎苍”等表达生硬，结句稳而略直。","_cost":0.00606},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.25,"rationale":"写夜间仓库清扫劳作,题材有当代气息但仅止于过程铺叙,情志单薄无主脑。意象多冷霜、雾茫、残更旧套,交融度低。'凉生肘''转黎苍'措语生硬近生造,中二联开合乏力,平铺直叙。结句以晓色收束尚稳而无延宕。","_cost":0.04323},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":2.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":31.5,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫入诗略具当代气息，结构尚且完整。然通篇如流水账，“清辉冷霜”等陈辞堆砌，“剩滓”生造凑韵，结句直说到底全无留白，缺乏诗味与情感升华。","_cost":0.017834},"grok-4.6":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"夜扫事境具体，立意平实无新境。凉生肘、飞尘入廊较切，余多夜霜雾气套语。语言通顺有炼字，章法顺时铺陈转平。结句黎明收束言尽少宕开。","_cost":0.023368},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.75,"rationale":"写夜扫至天明，过程完整但立意平浅；意象氛围略散，套语较多；中二联开合不足，结句说尽兜底。云仓题材稍见新意，无警句与硬伤。","_cost":0.013083928},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫入诗，当代劳动经验有效入诗，题旨具体有主脑。夜色至黎苍一线贯注，结构完整但转折平直。'凉生肘'细节可感，然清辉、冷霜、残更等象偏陈套，中二联层次略平，结句以天色收束尚留余意。","_cost":0.00283876},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.4,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.2,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.8,"rationale":"夜扫题材较具体，冷霜飞尘略有清寂氛围；但语词偏常见，转折平直，结尾说尽扫净，余味不足。","_cost":0.013018},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"以当代云仓夜班洒扫入诗,题材有新意,劳动者彻夜至黎明的孤清可感。夜色、飞尘、雾气氛围尚统一,但清辉、冷霜、残更属熟语;'凉生肘'别扭,'转黎苍'生造凑韵,语言锤炼不足。章法起承转合完整而平直,结句以晓色宕开略有留白,惜措辞牵强,警句阙如。","_cost":0.0112428},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":4.3,"意境":4.6,"语言":3.8,"章法":4.7,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.25,"rationale":"夜扫流水实录，无主脑新境，仅作动作白描；清辉冷霜雾气残更皆陈套，景情未融；扫土凉生肘等近白话拗硬；章法按时平铺，转合无变；尾联直陈天亮，言尽无余味。","_cost":0.0089335},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"本诗叙云仓夜扫始末，脉络顺达，意象贴合场景，语言通顺，但立意平熟，意象偏熟常，炼字欠精警，结句直白少余韵，无硬伤、蹈袭与陈套，整体平妥缺新意。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"以夜扫云仓入诗，当代劳作经验可取，'凉生肘'体感真切。然清辉冷霜等意象偏熟，中二联由景入情转折平直，结句'转黎苍'为韵生造略硬，收束直白少留白，整体工稳而乏警策。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.5,"rationale":"夜扫云仓有当代劳作之题，惜未深掘，情事浮泛。取象清辉冷霜飞尘雾气皆常套；“隐流光”与“映冷霜”前后相悖，“襟怀凉生肘”词义错位，“黎苍”硬凑。中二联开合不足，结以晓色收束尚稳，余味有限。","_cost":0.07465},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"题旨云仓夜扫，角度常见、情志稍泛；意象统一而常见，‘飞尘’稍切；炼字少诗眼，‘襟怀凉生肘’冗弱；中二联转折平直；结以景收，略有余味。云仓入诗略新，无警句；‘凉生肘’小疵非硬伤，陈象少许，无蹈袭。","_cost":0.031514178},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.8,"语言":4.2,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.15,"rationale":"聚焦现代云仓保洁劳作，题材具现实感。然遣词多近直白，“轻扫土”“无剩滓”诗味较寡，律联对仗平弱。全篇顺时序平铺直叙，结句据实收束，余韵略欠。","_cost":0.00646125},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":3.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":36.25,"rationale":"全篇直叙夜扫尘土，无主脑统摄，夜色清辉冷霜雾气杂置未融，凉生肘黎苍生造，脉络线性平直，末句直报更尽天晓，说尽无留白。","_cost":0.01009955},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":2.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.75,"rationale":"夜扫至天明，主线清楚，冷寂氛围可见，但情志开掘较浅。“襟怀忽觉凉生肘”“渐止纤毫”“转黎苍”语意生硬；清辉冷霜等偏熟，结尾交代事毕，延宕不足。","_cost":0.0555}},"consensus":49.05,"final":49.05},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|机场送别|七律","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"航楼挥别值深秋，客子将飞向远洲。安检门分襟上雨，登机口咽一腔愁。云边跑道连天阔，眼底行囊逐影浮。寄语银鹰须稳去，归来莫待雪盈头。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.7,"章法":7.3,"余味":6.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.85000000000001,"rationale":"以航楼、安检等当代场景写送别，主线清楚；情景尚能交融。“行囊逐影浮”稍滞涩，末句情切但劝归较直，银鹰、雪盈头略熟。","_cost":0.007308},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"以机场入律有当代经验之新，安检门、登机口对仗见巧思。然'一腔愁''雪盈头'落套，'将飞向远洲'近白话凑句，颈联景语与情脉稍散。结句叮咛直说，情虽真而味不长。","_cost":0.03373},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"将安检门、跑道等现代元素入诗颇具时代感；但物象与古典伤别情感结合略显生硬，'银鹰'、'一腔愁'较陈旧。章法平直无波澜，结句直抒胸臆过于直白，缺乏含蓄留白之美。","_cost":0.020632},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"机场送别题旨清楚，安检登机等情事可感，然劝归角度平常。颔联稍能融景，银鹰雪盈头套语偏密，文白夹杂。中二联层次平，结句直说少留白。","_cost":0.021594},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.2,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.4,"rationale":"现代航站送别，立意具体，章法分合有序；安检门、登机口等意象有当代感，但部分造语略生，结句直白。分、咽见炼字，整体余味偏弱。","_cost":0.01255452},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.5,"rationale":"送别熟题但情事具体，中二联一近一远有开合；'安检门分襟上雨'以今物入旧格最见巧思。'一腔愁''雪盈头'稍落套，尾联寄语直白略欠宕开，余味中平。","_cost":0.00282436},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"机场题材入律较新，脉络清晰，跑道、行囊等有画面。然一腔愁等语偏直，安检门、登机口入句稍硬，结以雪盈头稍留余味，仍近平。","_cost":0.012444},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"以机场、安检等当代物象入七律，题旨集中、脉络贯通，'安检门分襟上雨'融今古较见巧思；然送别盼归属熟题，'一腔愁''雪盈头'略套，结句叮嘱直白，说尽而余韵不足。","_cost":0.0103398},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.2,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.8,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.45,"rationale":"机场送别题材具当代感但立意仍为常调离愁，意象列置融合不深，咽、分等字略显拗凑，章法完整而转折平直，尾联直嘱少余味。","_cost":0.00834025},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"此作写机场送别，主脑明确，融当代安检、登机口等场景入诗，脉络顺畅，炼字偶有亮点；唯立意未翻新境，结句偏直，部分语词稍熟，余味较淡。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"以古典七律写机场送别，当代经验入诗见巧思：'安检门分襟上雨''登机口咽一腔愁'取象精切，'咽'字有诗眼之效；颈联开合有度。然题旨仍是传统离愁套路，'深秋''雪盈头'等语陈熟，尾联直白叮咛说破，余味稍减。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"当代机场经验入诗，安检门、登机口取象新鲜，'分襟上雨'一字见巧；但'向远洲'凑韵、'咽一腔愁'直说、'银鹰'陈套，颈联景语泛，结句盼归说破，整体平稳而少警策。","_cost":0.05085},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"以机场安检、登机口入诗，当代经验有效，题旨明确但角度常见；中二联由内转外，结构完整而转折平直。“安检门分襟上雨”生硬，“银鹰”“雪盈头”陈套，结句直白少留白，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.040583636},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.05,"rationale":"将现代机场物象自然入律，流程交代清晰，章法起承开合适度。惟“一腔愁”略显直露陈俗，语言稍欠锤炼；尾联祝愿安稳、期盼早归，情致深挚，结得有味。","_cost":0.00603075},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.25,"rationale":"送别题旨明确而角度常见，机场物象具体而情景未融，遣词生涩无诗眼，结构完整转折平，尾联直白说尽余味薄。","_cost":0.0132888},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"以安检阻隔落实离情，有当代触感；中联由近及远，末联兼顾安危与归期，脉络清楚。“襟上雨”“逐影浮”略显牵合，深秋、银鹰、雪盈头偏熟。结句叮嘱直露，延宕有限。","_cost":0.05954},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.25,"rationale":"送别嘱归主脑清楚，机场物象使情事具体，但情志仍是常见别愁与恐迟暮。安检门分雨较切，咽愁、逐影浮生硬，银鹰、一腔愁近套。颈联少转折，尾联直嘱说破。当代场景入律有新意，未见整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.0244192},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.5,"rationale":"颔联以安检门、登机口写送别，双关分襟，当代经验入诗较切。首联平铺，挥别与将飞语意重复。颈联行囊逐影浮视角可疑，与颔联层次推进不足。银鹰、一腔愁、雪盈头偏陈套，结句直白说尽。","_cost":0.01626},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.25,"rationale":"安检门、登机口写出当代送别场景，脉络清晰；“分襟上雨”“行囊逐影浮”语意稍涩，“一腔愁”“银鹰”等偏熟，末句惜别之意较直白。","_cost":0.011158}},"consensus":59.55,"final":59.55},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|天台菜园|七律","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"半亩天台绿意长，栽瓜点豆趁晴光。晨浇嫩叶珠垂架，暮摘鲜蔬翠满筐。土浅偏能承雨露，根深自可耐风霜。城中亦有耕耘味，且把浮名换菜香。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.8,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.89999999999999,"rationale":"天台种菜切入城市生活，晨浇暮摘具体可感，层次清楚。颈联有自励意味，但“土浅根深”略显牴牾；尾句以菜香收束，形象却稍说尽，“浮名、风霜”等语偏熟。","_cost":0.006176},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"天台种菜取材当代生活，题旨明确而角度尚平。中二联对仗工稳但颔联流于流水账式白描；颈联寓意可取，然'土浅'与'根深'同一菜圃自相龃龉，微伤。结句化用'忍把浮名'意，直说破题，余味不足。语言通顺少炼字，整体中平之作。","_cost":0.03759},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.25,"rationale":"题材具时代感，但处理流于套路。颈联“土浅”与“根深”在天台语境下存在物理逻辑矛盾（硬伤）；结句“且把浮名换菜香”化用生硬且说理直白，毫无留白。整体通顺但缺乏诗意锤炼。","_cost":0.024042},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"天台种菜主脑清楚，颔联晨暮浇摘较可感；颈联土浅根深物理相忤且坠入格言；结句浮名换菜香说破无余。套语偏密，当代题材未翻新境。","_cost":0.025148},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.3,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.9,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.2,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.55,"rationale":"主题明确，写城市天台种菜之乐，情感真实但角度常见。意象妥帖却多套语，中二联对仗工整，转结尚可，收束直白略少余味。‘换菜香’稍有意趣，整体语言平实，陈套意象略密。","_cost":0.004571248},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"都市天台种菜是熟题中较具体的视角，'城中亦有耕耘味'主脑清晰。颈联'土浅偏能承雨露，根深自可耐风霜'由事入理，是全篇警策。结句化用柳永'忍把浮名换了浅斟低唱'翻出菜香，巧妙有余味。惟中二联意象偏常见，'雨露风霜'略显套话。","_cost":0.00278316},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.6,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.2,"警句":0.8,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.89999999999999,"rationale":"题旨明确，有城市天台种菜的生活细节；晨浇暮摘成画面，但意象词汇偏熟。颈联说理稍离景，土浅根深略有矛盾。结尾直说浮名换菜香，稳而少余味。","_cost":0.017068},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"天台种菜题材有当代气息，颈联'土浅/根深'由实入虚、开合有度，可称佳联；晨暮对仗工稳，意象统一。然淡泊名利之旨尚属常见，结句化柳永'忍把浮名'而成，虽切题而少自立，通篇妥帖有余、惊警不足。","_cost":0.0183288},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.3,"意境":5.9,"语言":5.7,"章法":6.6,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.800000000000004,"rationale":"城中天台躬耕题旨明确具体有主脑，颔联叙事颈联议理结构完整，唯意象语言多常见，结句直抒浮名换菜香说尽少留白。","_cost":0.0063845},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.8,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"此作叙都市天台种菜闲趣，题旨明确，意象清和，语言平顺，章法连贯；结句偏直白，化用旧句写当代日常，无硬伤蹈袭，仅少量熟语，颔颈两联尚有可观。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"天台种菜题材切近当代生活，颈联'土浅承雨露，根深耐风霜'由实入理，是全诗筋节；中二联对仗工稳，脉络贯通。但晨浇暮摘取象常见，'晴光''浮名换菜香'语意稍熟，尾联说破略直，整体清顺有余而深致不足。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"天台种菜为当代经验入诗，题旨明确但取象平实，晨浇暮摘、雨露风霜多为熟语。颈联“土浅”与“根深”略有矛盾。章法完整而转折平直，结句“浮名换菜香”直接说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.04001},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"题旨明确但轻名利角度常见；意象妥帖，珠垂架有亮点而雨露风霜稍陈；语言通顺，点豆炼字见巧；章法工稳，颈联转得平；结句说破兜底少余味。都市种菜入诗有新意，颔联有佳趣；然土浅根深矛盾，陈词多，无蹈袭。","_cost":0.033728396},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.3,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"都市生活经验入诗，脉络起承规整，晨浇暮摘具生活实感。然天台盆植土浅而称根深，逻辑稍嫌扦格；尾联化用柳永词意直说兜底，意趣虽好而余味稍欠。","_cost":0.00564525},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.35,"rationale":"天台种菜切近生活，晨暮写景具体但语泛；颈联转理稍硬，尾联浮名换菜香说破无留白，套语略多。","_cost":0.01475755},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"晨浇暮摘有劳作实感，天台种菜略具当代气息；章法完整，转折平直。雨露、风霜及浮名之语较熟，削弱了菜园经验的独特性；结句虽落在菜香，却将淡泊之旨点得过明。","_cost":0.04003},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.75,"rationale":"弃名归耕题旨清楚而常见。珠垂架略有画意，余多绿翠雨露套语。颈联土浅与根深相忤，转无力；尾联说破浮名，少余味。","_cost":0.0187472},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.75,"rationale":"都市天台种菜的题材有当代气息,但立意落在淡泊浮名,角度常见。颔联晨暮对仗妥帖,意象却平常。颈联土浅与根深自相抵牾,且议论空泛。结句化用柳永词意,直白说破,余味有限。","_cost":0.015684},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"天台种菜的晨暮景象具体，城中耕作亦有生活气息；但“雨露”“风霜”“浮名”较熟，末句点明取舍，余味稍弱。土浅与根深并写，略有抵牾。","_cost":0.008186}},"consensus":59.42,"final":59.42},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|机场送别|七绝","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"安检门分两处秋，行囊过尽几回眸。银鹰忽作穿云箭，没入苍茫不可留。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.2,"rationale":"机场送别取材鲜明，“安检门分两处秋”能以空间写离情；回眸至飞机远逝，章法顺畅。银鹰、穿云箭、苍茫稍陈熟，末句“不可留”略说尽。","_cost":0.005116},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"首句'安检门分两处秋'以当代场景翻新送别熟题,一门隔两秋,炼意精警;次句回眸具体可感。惜转句'银鹰''穿云箭'意象陈旧稍俗,与前二句新警不称;结句以景收束尚有余韵,'不可留'微露说破之痕。整体前工后弱。","_cost":0.03475},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"以现代经验安检门入诗，首句“分两处秋”巧融离愁与物理隔绝，出新有效。章法起承转合顺畅，然“银鹰”“穿云箭”等词汇略显陈俗，削弱诗意；结句“不可留”稍显直白说尽，余味稍逊，整体情感真挚。","_cost":0.015598},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"机场送别题旨明确具体，然角度常见。安检分秋、回眸、银鹰穿云意象妥帖交融。首句稍炼，通篇少废字。起承转合完整，忽转有势。结句点明不可留，略直白少留白。现代经验入诗自然，略存秋、苍茫套语。","_cost":0.019008},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.3,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.25,"rationale":"安检门分秋切入现代别情，意象具体，转结由低回至苍茫，章法稳健；首句为警句。唯银鹰、穿云箭稍熟，结句“不可留”略直露。","_cost":0.01802887},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.0,"rationale":"以安检门入诗，当代经验化古自然，'分两处秋'巧炼时空阻隔，为全篇诗眼。起承转合井然，回眸细节真切，结句以苍茫景语收束而'不可留'稍直说。'银鹰''穿云箭'略熟，然整体情事具体、氛围统一。","_cost":0.00254476},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.3,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.45,"rationale":"机场离别，当代物象入诗，起句有凝练，转写银鹰有力；然苍茫、不可留稍熟直，结句说破，余味减。","_cost":0.010082},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"以安检门作离别关口，现代经验入绝句而情事具体；首句最有张力。中转有势，结以苍茫收束，惜“不可留”稍说破，银鹰、穿云箭意象略熟。","_cost":0.0120018},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.4,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.1,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.2,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"安检门分两处秋切当代离别，回眸具体有真情；起承转合清晰，唯后联银鹰穿云较套，结句不可留说破直白，余味减弱。","_cost":0.01105725},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"此作撷取当代机场送别场景，细节真切，起承转合圆顺，以“安检门分两处秋”寄离思见巧，语言凝练；唯“银鹰”喻稍熟，结句略直，余韵稍欠。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"以安检门分秋化用'两处闲愁'而翻出新境，当代经验入诗自然；起句即佳，转结以箭入苍茫收束有力。惟'银鹰''苍茫'稍熟，结句'不可留'略直白说破，余味稍减。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"首句以安检门分隔两处秋意，切合当代经验，'分'字有力；次句几回眸具体可感。后二句转入'银鹰''穿云箭''苍茫'等陈套比喻，气象骤降。结以景收尚稳，'不可留'略说破。整体章法完整而转结乏新意。","_cost":0.05672},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"起句以“安检门”分秋，现代经验入古典送别，取象新警；承转由回眸至银鹰穿云而没，脉络清晰、结收得住。然“不可留”直白，余味稍减；银鹰、回眸等意象略熟。","_cost":0.026526681},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.0,"rationale":"首句“安检门分两处秋”将现代经验化入传统诗情，起调出彩；章法承转顺畅，情真意切。唯转结处“银鹰”“穿云箭”意象稍显俗熟，结句略微说破，余韵未臻深远。","_cost":0.00519975},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"安检门切入当代送别有新意，回眸具体；银鹰穿云稍熟，结句不可留说破，余味受损。","_cost":0.00665525},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"“安检门分两处秋”将空间阻隔化为双方离情，具体而有新意。由回眸到飞机远去，脉络清楚，转折稍平。“银鹰”“穿云箭”偏熟套；结句虽有苍茫远景，“不可留”仍嫌说破。","_cost":0.04013},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"首句以安检门分两处秋，离情具体，然情志仍属常套送别。银鹰、穿云箭、苍茫偏熟，结句“不可留”说破，余味不足。起承转合清楚，转在“忽”字。","_cost":0.018808},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"首句以安检门分出两处秋,把当代机场送别写得新颖可感,是全篇最亮处。次句回眸稍显常规。转句银鹰、穿云箭是熟套比喻。结句写飞机没入苍茫,有以景结情之意,但不可留三字说破,余味减弱。","_cost":0.014768},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"“安检门分两处秋”将送别之情落在当代场景，颇见巧思；由回眸到飞机远去，脉络清楚。“银鹰”“穿云箭”稍熟，末句“不可留”说得较尽。","_cost":0.007596}},"consensus":71.87,"final":71.87},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"铁翼巡天夜未央，万家灯海泻金芒。人间已是星河倒，谁在云峰最上方？","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.7,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.8,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写灯海与星河倒置，视角有现代感，第三句尤见神采。全篇由实景转天人之问，脉络清楚；末句虽有悬念，但“谁”所指略虚，“夜未央”等稍熟套。","_cost":0.005142},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰题材有当代经验,第三句'人间已是星河倒'翻转视角为一篇之眼,结句设问宕开尚存余味。然'铁翼''夜未央''万家灯'皆熟语,灯海如星河亦属常见比拟,语言未见奇警,章法顺畅而转折平实,整体中上而未臻高格。","_cost":0.03163},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"当代夜航经验有效入诗。转句“星河倒”为全诗警策，取象极佳，化现代景观为古典意境。结句设问宕开，由俯瞰转为仰望苍穹，拉升空间感与哲理意味。章法流转自然，唯“万家灯海”略见现代套语痕迹。","_cost":0.024634},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰，灯火作倒悬星河，意象尚融而题路熟套。语言通顺，“倒”“泻”略见炼。章法四句一气，结问能留隙，然“最上方”稍直白。铁翼、灯海略陈。","_cost":0.025308},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"以航空俯瞰视角写灯火如星河倒悬，景象壮丽，转结以问留白；但题旨尚属常见，部分措辞熟套。","_cost":0.0037015},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验入诗，题旨明确。'星河倒'以倒置天河喻万家灯海，转句有力；结句以问宕开，留白有余。章法起承转合完整。但'夜未央''灯海'略熟，'巡天'化用有痕，结句指向稍泛，整体工稳而新意中等。","_cost":0.00247296},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰取角较新，灯海作星河倒置，画面统一；泻字有动势。惜夜未央、金芒稍泛，结问略空，余味未深。","_cost":0.010966},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.0,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰切入当代经验,星河倒置之想有新意;灯海、星河、铁翼等象尚属常见,语言平顺少锤炼;转结以问宕开,不直说情怀,余味尚可;“人间已是星河倒”差堪警策。","_cost":0.0096558},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.3,"rationale":"夜航视角完成天地倒置营造新观，起承转合清晰，末句以问宕开留白有余味；惜灯海星河等意象常见，炼字未见突出诗眼。","_cost":0.00843625},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.7,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"此作写夜航俯瞰观感，起承转合圆顺，以\"星河倒\"喻灯海颇具巧思，结句设问留余，语言畅达；仅部分表述稍熟，无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰入诗，'星河倒'翻转天上人间视角，当代经验化古有效。'泻'字见炼。惟结句'谁在云峰最上方'问意游离，与前文灯海意象衔接稍弱，收束欠稳；'夜未央''万家灯'属常见套语，密度不高。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"航机夜瞰为当代经验，天地倒置之思有可取处；然灯海如星河、铁翼巡天皆熟套，夜未央近凑句。结以问句宕开，惟“云峰最上方”指向含混，问而无着，余味有限。","_cost":0.0421},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"以铁翼夜航俯瞰入诗，星河倒为核心佳象，结构首尾回环；然夜未央、万家灯海稍熟，结句设问答案稍显豁，情志深度有限。","_cost":0.032770502},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.15,"rationale":"当代夜航经验入诗自然贴切。转句“星河倒”切准俯瞰视角，结句以反诘宕开一笔，由壮丽灯海升华至宇宙哲思，留白充分，章法起承转合极佳。","_cost":0.00520725},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":4.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.25,"rationale":"灯海倒作星河小有视角翻新，然铁翼泻金等语陈旧口号化，无诗眼，结句设问宕开稍挽余味。","_cost":0.0135915},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"夜航视角明确，灯海与倒悬星河相映，“泻”字有动势。前三句层递清楚，末问虽宕开，却指向偏虚，缺少情意支撑。“夜未央”“金芒”等措辞稍熟。","_cost":0.04061},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"夜航俯视有主脑，情志却泛，位次之问未落到具体人事。灯海倒作星河，氛围统一，但是熟象偏多。泻、倒较醒，最上方偏白。起承转顺，结问略脱灯海，余味被问句说近。","_cost":0.025184},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.5,"rationale":"","_cost":0.02358},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰灯海，视角鲜明；由地上灯火写成倒悬星河，颇有画面。惟“夜未央”“星河”较熟，末句转问云峰，意脉稍跳，余味未充分展开。","_cost":0.008152}},"consensus":68.62,"final":68.62},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"万点星灯辨邑城，舷窗俯瞰夜航轻。长河一线穿平野，大月孤轮照去程。下界沉浮成海市，寒光闪烁乱心旌。人间望断云涛外，唯有天风翼底生。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.8,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.89999999999999,"rationale":"俯瞰夜航视角鲜明，星灯、长河、云涛构成高空夜境，情景较融。中二联由远景转心绪，末句“天风翼底生”有动势与余韵。惟“大月”“夜航轻”稍涩，“孤轮、心旌”等略陈。","_cost":0.00556},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰以当代经验入律,颔联'长河一线''大月孤轮'取象精切有画面。惟'乱心旌''望断'稍落套语,情感转折处交代空泛,颈联至尾联情脉稍松。结句'天风翼底生'以景收束,有余韵。整体稳健而未臻警拔。","_cost":0.03617},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"当代夜航经验有效入诗，意境宏阔。颔联极具画面张力与气势，章法脉络贯通，层次分明。尾联宕开一笔收束于天风，余味悠长。唯颈联'乱心旌'稍显平直，总体为化用新事物入诗的佳作。","_cost":0.016958},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰题旨清楚而新意有限；一线穿野、下界海市稍见经营，孤轮心旌望断云涛套语偏密。章法完整，颈联直说乱心，转势平。结句天风翼底以景宕开，尚有余韵。","_cost":0.027662},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.0,"rationale":"此作写夜航俯瞰，景象宏阔，颔联对仗精切，尾联以景收束有余味。但取象偏熟，情志略泛，“大月孤轮”费字，“乱心旌”稍直。整体中上。","_cost":0.00544786},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰这一当代经验入七律而气脉不隔，星灯、长河、孤月构成统一清寒夜境，景中含情。中二联开合有层次，结句以天风翼底宕开，景结留白。'海市''心旌'稍近熟套，'乱心旌'微露直陈，整体锤炼匀净。","_cost":0.00214216},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.7,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"夜航视角明确，颔颈由实景入幻境，现代经验入诗有效；但孤轮、云涛、心旌略熟，直说心绪稍减余味，尾联尚能宕开。","_cost":0.017666},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写人间渺小,当代经验入诗有效,高空夜景意象统一,'长河一线''大月孤轮'对仗工稳有画面;然情志仅止于'乱心旌'之泛感,转折平直,结句'唯有'稍说破,'心旌''云涛'等语略熟,整体稳妥而少独到发现。","_cost":0.0095448},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.2,"意境":7.7,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.3,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.2,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.05,"rationale":"航空俯瞰视角新颖，星灯长河孤月天风意象统一，章法转合有序，尾联宕开有余味；唯立意止于景感抒发，情志未深聚焦。","_cost":0.0068509},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.400000000000006,"rationale":"此作写夜航俯瞰观感，题旨明晰，意象切题，章法平顺贯通，语言稳畅；结句以景收尚有韵致，部分意象稍熟，略有航空视角新意，无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验入旧体，视角新颖，通篇统一于高空孤旅氛围。颔联'长河一线''大月孤轮'取象精切，颈联由景入情转折自然，尾联以天风收束、言尽意不尽。惟'大月''乱心旌'稍见生硬，'海市''心旌'略涉熟套，整体炼字尚有提升空间。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"俯瞰视角贯通，星灯、长河、孤月取象妥帖，尾句以天风翼底作结稍有宕开之致。但情感落点模糊，“乱心旌”空泛套语，颈联与首联意象重叠，中二联开合不足，属当代常见航旅题的稳妥之作。","_cost":0.05494},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"现代夜航经验入七律，俯瞰取象切当，章法完整；结句‘天风翼底生’有象而‘唯有’稍直，余味中等。情志稍泛，海市、寒光、心旌、云涛、天风等陈语密度中等；无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.026665572},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.6,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.1,"rationale":"夜航视角切入自然，当代生活经验入诗无斧凿痕。“长河一线”“翼底生”精准切题，尾联以景结情、格调高旷。颈联“乱心旌”情致稍嫌陈套空泛。","_cost":0.004755},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":4.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.55,"rationale":"高空视角统一，长河一线有压缩感，然情志仅乱心旌带过，主脑不明；语言通顺少诗眼，结句以天风宕开稍佳。","_cost":0.0191528},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"俯瞰视角贯穿，河月云涛呈现空间层次；夜航经验入诗略新，但情绪落在“乱心旌”，缺少具体触发。“大月孤轮”略显复沓，海市、心旌较熟；结以翼底天风，空阔有余味。","_cost":0.0419},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"夜航经验入诗尚真，长河一线与海市能成高寒氛围，但孤月、望断、云涛、心旌偏熟。夜航轻与大月孤轮欠炼。章法完整而转折平直，结句以唯有说破，余味不足。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.030196},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"","_cost":0.015216},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"舷窗视角贯穿全篇，灯城、河月与云涛渐次展开；结句落在翼底天风，留有余味。但“乱心旌”点情稍直，情感所系尚不够具体。","_cost":0.01105}},"consensus":68.33,"final":68.33},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"满架绒娃待币时，通明格内各憨姿。投钱暂假钢钩起，转柄轻教彩偶移。爪上悬丝千绕急，屏前落影半厘迟。几回空坠终无获，却笑童心不肯辞。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.8,"rationale":"以抓娃娃写屡败不止的童心，题材新鲜，过程描摹具体，层层推进清楚。“半厘迟”颇传神；“悬丝千绕”“暂假”稍显费解，结句点意略直。","_cost":0.005898},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.0,"rationale":"当代经验入诗可取,咏物纪事清楚。颈联'千绕急/半厘迟'对仗见巧,是全篇亮点。但中二联皆写操作过程,层次未开,近于说明;尾联'童心不肯辞'点破题旨,收得直白少余味,情志止于泛泛感慨。","_cost":0.03701},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"以现代生活入诗，章法严整。中二联生动刻画抓娃娃的动作与得失之机，“半厘迟”极准。结句直接点破童心，略显直白，整体生动有趣但意境稍欠深远。","_cost":0.018928},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"抓娃娃过程具体、主脑清楚，然「童心不弃」之旨常见。物象贴切，颈联近失有张力。暂假、半厘迟可观，千绕急稍填。由静而动而自嘲顺畅。结句点破，余味有限。","_cost":0.02122},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"抓娃娃过程具体，颈联“半厘迟”见细节张力，尾联点童心稍直；意象略复、结构平顺完整，当代题材有效入诗。","_cost":0.01904804},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"以七律写抓娃娃机，当代经验入诗妥帖自然。颈联'千绕急''半厘迟'对仗精工，抓取悬坠之态刻画入微，堪称诗眼。起承转合脉络清晰，一气贯注。结句'却笑童心'稍直白说破，余味略减。","_cost":0.00247516},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.4,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.6,"rationale":"当代题材，细节生动，起承转合清晰；颔颈有画面，尾联收束稍说破，现代语入诗偶有生硬，余味未深。","_cost":0.011916},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"以当代游艺入七律，题材新鲜，白描细腻。颈联『千绕急』『半厘迟』捕捉手感颇准，为全篇亮点。惜立意止于童心自嘲，未见更深开掘；结句直抒情怀，略说破。『悬丝千绕』与实物机理所距稍远，微瑕。","_cost":0.0086388},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"当代机巧入律，观察细密、颈联悬丝落影有张力；章法由静及动层次清晰；然情志止于童心不辞未辟新境，景情交融未深，结句直抒余韵浅。","_cost":0.009302},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"此作以当代抓娃娃机入律，细节真切，脉络顺畅，颈联传神写出游戏时的紧张与差失的怅惘，结句直点童心稍欠余韵，颇具日常趣味。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"以七律写抓娃娃机，当代经验入旧体自然妥帖，颈联'千绕急''半厘迟'对仗精切有张力。中二联层次分明，尾联转出童心不失主脑。惟结句'童心不肯辞'点破稍直，'憨姿''彩偶'等词略平，整体情意真挚而深掘不足。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.5,"rationale":"取材当代抓娃娃机，物象具体可感，颈联“悬丝千绕急／落影半厘迟”写钩落瞬间颇有张力。但中二联皆铺陈操作过程，开合不足；语言偏说明，“暂假”“千绕”稍嫌硬凑。结句“童心不肯辞”直陈说破，兜底收束，余味薄。","_cost":0.04833},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"写抓娃娃机如在目前，童心为主脑，当代经验入诗成功。颈联“千绕急”“半厘迟”警策生动，细节精切；尾联点旨稍直，起势平平，文白间杂。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.023291723},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.7,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.85000000000001,"rationale":"将现代日常体验有效入律，物象转化贴切自然。颈联状写机械操控与失手瞬间尤见微察。章法井然，逐层推进，唯结句直道童心，略嫌说破。","_cost":0.00753075},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"当代题材入律，过程摹写层进清晰，空坠而童心不辞小有寄托；然情意较浅，意象多白描少交融，暂假轻教生硬，结句直说无留白。","_cost":0.01271475},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.3,"语言":4.4,"章法":6.8,"余味":4.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.65,"rationale":"投币、操爪、空坠至自笑，脉络完整，失手而不改兴致颇见童趣。器物描写具体，但“千绕急”“半厘迟”辞意牵强；结句直点童心，收束平稳而余味有限。当代经验入诗尚自然。","_cost":0.04184},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"近失与空坠具体，主脑清楚，然童心不辞角度常见，结句说破。颈联半厘迟有张力，余多直叙；暂假、轻教略生，柄移彩偶稍舛。当代经验入律，出新可取。","_cost":0.0272976},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入律,当代经验有效入诗。前六句铺叙投币、操纵、落爪,次序清楚,但颔颈二联同写操作,层次偏平。'半厘迟'写失手之憾颇传神。'屏前'与玻璃柜不甚切。结句'却笑童心'稍显直白,意蕴不深。","_cost":0.018952},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"抓取时的急与迟写出临场心绪，题材有新意；“悬丝”“落影”所指稍虚，“童心不肯辞”直点题旨，结句余味偏浅。","_cost":0.008058}},"consensus":67.86,"final":67.86},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"夜半屏前语未成，殊方客路一灯明。凝眸犹是寻常影，却对无声更有情。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.9,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.3,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.2,"rationale":"以视频无言写异地深情，情境具体，当代经验入诗自然。前二句设境，后二句转合有力；“寻常影”反衬情深，但“更有情”稍直白，“客路一灯”略熟。","_cost":0.005334},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"以视频通话写羁旅相思，当代经验入诗有新意，'语未成''寻常影'情事具体。取象简净但'客路一灯明'近套语。转句尚有变化，惜结句以'更有情'直陈说破，未能以景宕开，余味打折。","_cost":0.03528},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"当代经验（视频）入诗自然，写出异乡客路孤灯下相对无言的深情，起承转合清晰。然全篇语言略显平直，尤以结句‘更有情’将意蕴说破说尽，缺乏留白；落脚于‘无声’亦显熟套，乏蕴藉之致。","_cost":0.016136},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.5,"rationale":"视频入诗见当代经验，情事尚具体；然意象平实，‘无声更有情’近说破，转结乏力，余韵有限。","_cost":0.016864},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"写视频通话中无言胜有言，情感具体真挚；意象统一但有常见痕迹；结句以无声宕开，留有余味。化用“无声胜有声”入现代经验，算有效出新。","_cost":0.004093408},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"视频通话入旧体，熟题翻新：语未成而无声更有情，情事具体。起承转合完整，转结有力。'殊方客路一灯明'稍落寒灯客路套语；结句以议论收，微有说破，然'寻常影'与'无声'留有回味。","_cost":0.00269596},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.2,"rationale":"写深夜视频相对无言，屏灯影映客居，情真而焦点明确；但意象偏常见，结句直言更有情，转合稍平。","_cost":0.010714},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":1.5,"score":62.25,"rationale":"视频通话入诗，题材当代且情感真切，聚焦明确。'无声更有情'有小警，然核心意象实承'此时无声胜有声'之意，翻古有限；'一灯明''凝眸'略熟，结句直抒点破情字，留白不足。整体平稳而少锐度。","_cost":0.0102792},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.6,"意境":6.9,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.4,"余味":5.4,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.05,"rationale":"以屏前视频写殊方羁旅，当代经验入诗自然；屏灯对照有氛围，起承转合完整，结句直抒更有情，留白不足。","_cost":0.008622},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"此作取深夜跨屏视频的当代日常场景，抒怀远挚情，细节真切，章法圆顺，语言清通无赘，当代经验入诗自然，唯结句稍直，余味略浅。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"以视频通话入旧体，当代经验化用自然，情事具体（夜半屏前、殊方客路），主脑清晰。'却对无声更有情'翻出静默胜言语一层，可称小警句；但'一灯''客路'意象偏熟，结句'更有情'稍近说破，留白不足，转合平顺而少奇变。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"以视频通话入绝句，题材有当代感，情亦可信。然物象仅屏、灯，殊方客路属旧套；三句转得平，结句“更有情”直陈说破，暗袭“无声胜有声”意而无新境。语言通顺无诗眼，整体平稳偏浅。","_cost":0.04675},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"以视频通话写远别相思，现代经验入诗，意旨集中；意象妥帖而常见，语多平实且稍有冗字，结句直白少留白，章法完整但转折平直。无硬伤蹈袭，略有陈语。","_cost":0.027880213},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.95,"rationale":"当代视频经验入诗自然得体，毫不生硬。起承转合流走无滞，借“一灯”“寻常影”构筑出静谧温煦的羁旅氛围。结句稍近直白说破，略欠留白，但情致深沉真挚。","_cost":0.00632025},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"视频入绝切近当代，无言之情具体可感；然意象单薄景情未融，语言平直乏诗眼，结句直抒更有情，说破无留白。","_cost":0.00975405},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.7,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"以深夜视频写异地相望，屏、灯、影贯通情境，当代经验入诗自然；但措辞多属熟语，第三句转意不强，末句“更有情”直陈主旨，收束虽稳，留白不足。","_cost":0.03652},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"视频夜话情事具体，主脑是无声胜言，然近熟套。一灯客路凝眸常套，屏影未写透。语未成尚稳，结句直说更有情，余味薄。起承完整，转结靠却字，偏平。","_cost":0.0172992},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"异地视频入诗,当代经验有效。但取象仅屏、灯、影,较单薄。“殊方客路”“一灯明”偏常套。首句“语未成”与结句“无声”意脉重复。结句明显化自“此时无声胜有声”,且直接说出“有情”,余味受限。","_cost":0.0151},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"屏前未语、客路孤灯，写出异地相望的情境；结句照应开篇，脉络完整。但“寻常影”稍泛，“更有情”直说情意，余味有所减弱。","_cost":0.007294}},"consensus":66.07,"final":66.07},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|深夜视频|七律","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"深宵独对掌中天，千里容光一线连。鬓影浮烟随画动，笑涡凝露隔空悬。屏前欲语声先咽，指下重敲字未传。待到灯昏人静后，半窗残月向谁圆。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.7,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.35000000000001,"rationale":"以视频寄千里相思，古典语汇融当代经验自然。中二联由见容转欲言，层次清楚；“半窗残月向谁圆”以景作结，余情悠长。月、露稍见熟套。","_cost":0.00483},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"以视频通话入律,'掌中天''一线连'化当代经验入诗见巧思,颈联'欲语声先咽''字未传'情事具体。惟颔联'凝露'稍雕饰失真,视频中'指下敲字'与语音场景微有龃龉;尾联残月问圆乃熟套,收束稳而余味平常。","_cost":0.03136},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"将“视频通话”等当代经验巧妙入诗，立意新颖且贴切自然。章法严密，由相见到情动，再至挂断后的落寞，脉络贯通。结句以景结情，留有余味。语言通顺贴切，但字词锤炼稍欠惊艳。","_cost":0.015082},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"远隔视频相思，主脑清楚而新意有限。掌中天、隔空悬、字未传能成境，颈联一转较稳。浮烟、声咽、灯昏残月等套语偏密。结句向谁圆过熟，意尽于言，余味不足。","_cost":0.026454},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.75,"rationale":"写视频通话之思，情感具体，意象交融，尾联以景结情余味悠长。颈联佳，当代经验入诗自然。略用常见月意象，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.00493944},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.5,"rationale":"深夜视频入律诗，旧题怀远翻出新境。'掌中天''一线连'巧切屏中相见；颔联以'浮烟''凝露'写影像之隔，景语情语交融。颈联'声先咽''字未传'得欲言又止之神，为诗眼。尾联以残月设问宕开，言尽意不尽。'灯昏人静'稍熟，整体炼字稳而不露斧凿。","_cost":0.00269516},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.3,"rationale":"以手机视频入诗，场景具体，情脉完整；颈联写欲言又止较真切。然浮烟凝露稍泛，残月向谁圆略熟，收意未脱常见离思。","_cost":0.0129},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"以视频通话写异地相思，当代经验入七律自然不隔；颈联'声先咽''字未传'细节真切可摘；结句残月问圆，以景结情且暗含悖论之伤。唯首联'掌中天''一线连'略熟，意象整体稳妥少奇境，故各维中上而不拔。","_cost":0.0073918},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.3,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.8,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.35,"rationale":"当代视频切入相思，颈联“声先咽/字未传”真切传神；颔联鬓影笑涡及残月等象偏陈，章法平直少开合，结句以景问圆宕开留白。","_cost":0.0114249},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"此作以深夜视频的当代场景写异地相思，细节真切，意象贴合，章法顺畅，炼字见功，情感真挚；唯结句稍落熟套，部分语词略嫌陈旧。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.25,"rationale":"视频通话入七律，当代经验与古典形式融合自然。颔联'鬓影浮烟''笑涡凝露'取象精切于屏幕光影，为全诗警策；颈联'声先咽''字未传'转出阻隔之痛，层层递进；结以残月问谁圆，以景收情留白有余。'千里容光一线连'稍熟，个别字面微见雕琢痕迹。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"当代视频通话入律，掌中天、一线连、指下重敲字未传切事有味，脉络顺畅。惟笑涡凝露稍涩，颈联欲语声咽属常见情态；结句以残月问圆袭用东坡套路，余味有而不新，中二联开合层次不足。","_cost":0.05698},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"以深夜视频写远别相思，‘掌中天’‘字未传’当代经验入诗，中二联由屏上人像转至欲语重敲，层次清。然鬓影、笑涡、残月向谁圆等象稍陈，结句直白，故余味中等。","_cost":0.031583371},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.60000000000001,"rationale":"将当代视频通话、打字未发等经验化入旧体，贴切自然。中二联虚实相映、细节传神，全篇脉络顺畅，由聚至散层次分明。尾联稍涉熟套，但结景延宕有效。","_cost":0.00477975},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"以掌中屏写千里相思，当代经验入律具新意；中二联分见所见所感，但浮烟凝露稍饰，诗眼不立；残月问圆宕开一笔，余味足。","_cost":0.01186775},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"视频、敲字使远隔之情具体可感，但题旨仍属常见相思。由传影到欲言难达，再归独夜，层次清楚。“浮烟”“凝露”稍显雕饰；残月问圆留有余情，也未脱传统愁境。","_cost":0.0559},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"视频入旧题，声咽、字未传具体可感，离愁未更深翻。掌中天、隔空悬成统一屏光之境，凝露稍饰。语言通顺，咽、悬有力而未极炼。起承转合完整，颈联由见转窒，为枢纽。结以残月发问，景在而意已点破。","_cost":0.0284032},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"以视频通话写两地相思,当代经验入诗有新意,但情感落在常见路数上。颔联「浮烟」「凝露」偏于藻饰,所指含混。颈联「声先咽」较熟。结句以月作结尚稳,但「残月」与「圆」略相牴牾,且落入旧套,余味有限。","_cost":0.017092},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"掌中屏与千里情相接，欲语未传一联尤为真切；由见人到难言，再以残月收束，脉络清楚。“浮烟”“凝露”稍虚，残月寄思亦偏熟。","_cost":0.0125}},"consensus":71.88,"final":71.88},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"天台数尺亦成园，瓜豆垂藤绿到门。莫道楼高无地气，一畦春雨带泥痕。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.6,"警句":3.6,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.45,"rationale":"以楼顶菜园写都市人亲土之情，题小而意足。瓜藤、春雨、泥痕相融，转结有力；“莫道”稍熟，末句含蓄鲜活。","_cost":0.004808},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"以天台菜园写当代都市生活，题材新而情事具体。三句'莫道楼高无地气'翻转有力，结句春雨泥痕以景收情、留有余味。取象妥帖统一，惟'绿到门'稍平，炼字尚欠奇警。章法起承转合完整，转句尤佳。","_cost":0.03019},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"本诗将当代都市“天台种菜”经验巧妙入诗，立意清新。起承转合极规范，“莫道”一转跌宕有致，“一畦春雨带泥痕”以景结情，巧妙回应“地气”之疑，语言自然生动，生活气息浓郁。","_cost":0.013166},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"屋顶菜园翻出地气之辨，情事具体、主脑清楚。起承转合利落，泥痕以景证理。意象妥帖而瓜豆春雨偏熟，语言通顺，「绿到门」略见炼字。当代经验入诗，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.020416},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"写城市天台种菜，角度新巧，反驳'楼高无地气'，以'春雨泥痕'作结，景中含情。'绿到门'炼字生动，章法转折自然。整体清新，余味可品，略欠警句与深度。","_cost":0.005519008},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"城市天台种菜是当代经验入诗，题小而意足。‘绿到门’‘带泥痕’炼字见眼，物象与‘地气’之辩交融。起承转合完整，‘莫道’一转以景结情，泥痕留白有味。通篇干净无套语，唯整体规模轻巧，未臻警策深厚。","_cost":0.00204436},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.3,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.7,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.05,"rationale":"天台小园着眼当代生活，瓜豆、春雨、泥痕意象统一，转结以景收，颇有泥土生机。第三句稍直，语象未臻深警，整体清新而略浅。","_cost":0.012762},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"天台种菜为城市新题，'莫道楼高无地气'翻案有致，接地气得趣；瓜豆垂藤、绿到门、春雨泥痕意象统一清新，转结以景收束有余韵。唯题旨尚浅，'地气'之巧近于点子，情感浓度与警策力未臻上乘，属稳妥清新之作。","_cost":0.0069438},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.9,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.3,"rationale":"天台觅地气有当代生活实感，转议有力，藤绿泥痕景情一体，末句以景结情余韵足，语平实章法完整。","_cost":0.01218175},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"此诗写都市天台菜园小景，翻“楼高无地气”的俗见，起承转合圆畅，结句以景留白有余味，语言清顺自然，融入当代日常经验，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.5,"rationale":"天台种菜为当代城市经验入诗，翻新有据；'绿到门''带泥痕'取象精切，景语即情语。第三句'莫道楼高无地气'转得有力，结句以春雨泥痕收束，言尽意不尽。语言自然少废字，唯意象略近田园常调，故陈滥微扣。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"当代城居经验入诗，题旨集中，'楼高无地气'转句有反驳之势，结以'春雨泥痕'景语作答，留白得当。取象具体但语言平实少锤炼，无夺目诗眼，整体稳妥小巧而未至惊警。","_cost":0.03811},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"写城市天台种菜，以泥痕翻出地气新意，当代经验入诗。立意8.5，意境7，语言7.5，章法8，余味9；结句佳加3，出新加3，无硬伤陈滥蹈袭。","_cost":0.025388385},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.95,"rationale":"当代都市生活经验有效入诗。转结极见功力，三句提笔翻转，末句以湿润的泥痕与春雨巧妙回应“地气”，以景结情，化解说理，生活野趣盎然，余味绵长。","_cost":0.0044475},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"天台种菜写都市农趣，主脑清晰；意象妥帖但常见，带泥痕有质感；转议结景合度，结句以景收束留白最佳。","_cost":0.01182475},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"楼居种菜切入具体，田园情志仍属常见。“绿到门”有延展感，末句以泥痕回应地气，收束可感；起承转合清楚，但“莫道”转语较熟，主旨略先说破，警策力度有限。","_cost":0.03764},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"楼顶成畦,以泥痕驳无地气,主脑清而情浅。垂藤、泥痕可感,春雨与莫道略熟。字净,地气稍虚。起承完,转偏申说,结景收束,意已先破故余味有限。当代经验入诗自然,无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0207696},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"以楼顶菜园写城市人的田园情，当代经验入诗较自然。“绿到门”“带泥痕”取象亲切。转句“莫道”句式稍显套路，结句以景作答，稳当可感，但点题意图较明，余味不深。","_cost":0.014984},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"天台种菜写出城市中的泥土生机，“绿到门”鲜活，结以雨后泥痕，留有可感之景。转句点题稍直，“莫道”句式略熟。","_cost":0.007998}},"consensus":77.25,"final":77.25},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"白发阿婆拄杖来，社区小灶午时开。三鲜两素随君点，一饭何妨笑语陪。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.3,"章法":5.8,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.95,"rationale":"社区助老题旨具体温暖，杖、小灶、饭菜构成生活场景；但铺叙平直，转折不足，“随君点”略显隔膜，结句语意稍拗且直露。","_cost":0.005196},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.25,"rationale":"当代民生题材入诗有可取处，白发阿婆一象具体可感。然通篇近于纪事，'三鲜两素随君点'如菜单说明，诗味寡淡；转句平直，结句'笑语陪'把温情说尽，无留白。语言浅白顺畅而乏炼字，整体是合格的新闻式白描，出新略可加分。","_cost":0.03051},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"本诗以当代社区食堂入题，生活气息浓厚，画面温馨。语言通俗流畅，脉络清晰。然通篇流于平铺直叙，字句缺乏锤炼，结句直白说尽，少诗意留白与延宕之味，胜在自然真挚。","_cost":0.013616},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"题材切近当代养老日常，阿婆拄杖、小灶午开画面具体，主脑清楚。然情志温而不深，意象偏叙事少交融，语言口语直白乏诗眼，章法平铺少转，结句说破笑语余味有限。","_cost":0.016006},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.0,"rationale":"题材有当代生活气息，人物细节可感；但语言偏口语直白，转结平淡，结句说尽少余味。","_cost":0.00847572},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"社区食堂这一当代民生题材入诗，立意温暖有主脑，白发拄杖之象具体可感。起承转合完整，然语言偏白话近乎记账，'三鲜两素随君点'似菜牌语，乏诗眼锤炼。结句'一饭何妨笑语陪'情意真挚但近说尽，余味稍欠宕开。","_cost":0.00198456},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.75,"rationale":"题材切近，有人物与暖意；但叙述偏直白，菜单语损诗味，转结少变化，余韵不足。","_cost":0.009004},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.0,"rationale":"聚焦社区养老助餐，题旨真切而角度常见；白描有序，暖意足而意象较薄，转结平直，末句温情略说破。当代题材入诗自然，少警策。","_cost":0.0100998},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.6,"意境":5.2,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.8,"余味":4.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.4,"rationale":"以社区食堂写老龄温情，题材贴近当代、情事具体；唯意象叙事化、语言锤炼与转结变化均显平实，结句直白收束。","_cost":0.00771425},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.75,"rationale":"本诗白描社区食堂老人就餐的温馨场景，题旨明确，脉络通顺，语言平实无硬伤；但立意平泛，意象寻常，表达直露，结句少余韵，唯当代民生入诗略有新意。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"取材当代社区食堂，民生小事入诗而情味温厚，'随君点''何妨'语淡意足，起承转合完整。惟意象平实常见，结句稍直白，'白发阿婆'近于熟套，整体妥帖有余、警策不足。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"取当代社区食堂入诗，情意温厚具体，然角度平直近于纪事。阿婆拄杖一象尚可，三四句流于菜单与直陈，无诗眼；转结平滑，结句把温情说破，余味有限。出新略可嘉，整体清顺而未见锤炼。","_cost":0.03698},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.75,"rationale":"主题明确而角度常见，写社区食堂温情；意象平实少交融，语言文白夹杂无诗眼；章法完整但转平直，结句直白少余味；当代题材略有出新。","_cost":0.026507998},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.2,"意境":4.6,"语言":4.3,"章法":4.8,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.400000000000006,"rationale":"切入当代社区生活，情感真挚质朴。叙事顺畅达意，但用语偏于口语流水账，炼字较平，转结平直且说透说尽，意境与诗味稍显欠缺。","_cost":0.00353775},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.25,"rationale":"取材民生小景有人情味，起承转合完整；然意象功能性直陈，语言近白少诗眼，结句直说暖意而少留白。","_cost":0.01128425},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.3,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.6,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.45,"rationale":"以拄杖阿婆、午餐点菜写社区温情，细节可感，角度较常见。由就餐转向陪伴，脉络清楚而转折平缓；“何妨”语意略显勉强，结句温暖但直白。当代生活入诗，尚无突出警句。","_cost":0.03088},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗，情事具体而主脑明确，然暖意止于常谈。象能指事，少交融，白发拄杖偏熟。语多白描，三鲜两素略亮。章法完整，第三句未转。结句说尽笑语，余味不长。","_cost":0.0254016},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.75,"rationale":"以社区食堂写养老民生,当代题材入诗,情事具体,但止于表面叙写,近颂扬体。阿婆拄杖、三鲜两素取象平实,缺少提炼。语言通顺而少诗眼,'随君点'偏口号化。第三句转得平直,结句'笑语陪'直陈说尽,余味浅。","_cost":0.013412},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗，有贴近当代生活的温意；阿婆拄杖、饭菜可见，但写法较平。第三句近菜单陈列，末句点明陪伴而少留白，“笑语陪”也稍显生硬。","_cost":0.007406}},"consensus":52.62,"final":52.62},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|社区食堂|七律","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"社区新灶近街坊，案净窗明饭菜香。白首扶筇寻座稳，青衫扫码取餐忙。三鲜小炒酬孤老，一碗浓羹暖夕阳。莫道市廛无此味，人间烟火意偏长。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.9,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.1,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"聚焦社区助老，场景具体；“扶筇”与“扫码”对照鲜明，颇具当代感。中二联推进自然，但“酬孤老”稍硬，尾联直抒且“人间烟火”略熟，余味有限。","_cost":0.005392},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.25,"rationale":"题材切近当下,颔联白首扶筇与青衫扫码对照有时代感,是全篇亮点。但通篇铺陈食堂场景,中二联层次平铺少开合,'暖夕阳''人间烟火'近套语,尾联议论说破、意尽言中,余味不足,整体近老干体而稍胜之。","_cost":0.03819},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"将“社区食堂”“扫码”等当代经验自然入诗，生活气息浓，章法完整。但语言略带新闻宣传腔，“案净窗明”“人间烟火”稍显陈套，结句议论说尽，缺乏留白与余味。整体通顺达意，属平实之作。","_cost":0.015326},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"题材具体含扫码等当代细节，角度常见近颂德；颔联今古对照尚可，余象多套；结句点破题旨少余味，炼字通顺无突出诗眼。","_cost":0.015258},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"写社区食堂有具体当代细节，立意清楚但未脱常情；中二联并列少变化，结句议论略直。“一碗浓羹暖夕阳”精切，扫码入诗见旧体新意。","_cost":0.01541232},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"取材社区食堂，当代民生入诗，主脑清晰。颔联'白首扶筇'对'青衫扫码'，老少与新旧对照是全篇亮点。中二联意象妥帖但'暖夕阳''烟火'略近套语。结句以议论收束，意有延宕而稍直白说尽。","_cost":0.00194156},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.8,"rationale":"题旨明确，当代场景入诗有温情；颔颈联细节生动，暖老之意可感。但尾联议论说破，余味不足；‘人间烟火’‘夕阳’等语稍熟，整体偏平实。","_cost":0.012722},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.5,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗题材新,白首青衫一联对照生动,孤老、夕阳情意具体。意象交融而稍熟,结句'人间烟火意偏长'点破题旨、余韵不足。'暖夕阳'可称亮笔,扫码等当代语化用自然。整体稳而少奇。","_cost":0.0104448},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.2,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.95,"rationale":"取材社区食堂关照孤老，白首青衫对比具体，立意真切有主脑；中二联层次清晰，唯案净窗明等语平实，尾联议论直收余味稍浅。","_cost":0.00946825},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"此作咏社区便民新事物，紧扣烟火暖民主旨，脉络顺畅，有当代生活细节，对仗工稳。但表达平直，“青衫”用词稍隔，结句直白，少量语词熟套，余韵不足。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"社区食堂题材切近当代民生，颔联'扶筇''扫码'新旧相映，事象具体有主脑。颈联'暖夕阳'语带双关颇佳，然'人间烟火''夕阳'等意象趋熟，尾联'意偏长'稍近说破，余味留白不足。整体脉络贯通，转结平实而稳。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.5,"rationale":"题材当代、扫码取餐有新意，白首青衫一联对照尚可，“暖夕阳”双关略见巧思。但立意止于歌颂民生，案净窗明、饭菜香、人间烟火皆套语，尾联直接议论说破，余味寡淡，整体平顺而少警策。","_cost":0.04741},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"写社区食堂，题旨明确而角度常见；意象妥帖但白首、夕阳、烟火等稍滥；语言通顺，‘暖夕阳’见炼字；章法完整，转结平稳；结句直白少余味。扫码入诗具当代感，稍有陈滥，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.023403433},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗自然，颔联老少对映、扫码入律工稳生动。全诗脉络贯通、充满民生温情，唯部分字句带顺口溜与宣传气，结句的人间烟火亦稍显直白陈套。","_cost":0.00426},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.8,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.35,"rationale":"取材社区食堂体恤孤老，时代感强而开掘未深；颔联老青对照生动，余多铺叙直陈；尾联人间烟火收束，直白少留白，略涉套语。","_cost":0.013544},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"扶筇寻座、扫码取餐，细节具体，当代生活入诗自然；关怀孤老的题旨集中而角度常见。“酬孤老”稍硬，“暖夕阳”“人间烟火”偏熟。章法顺畅，尾联议论点题，结句说意较尽。","_cost":0.04176},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"题材新而情志仍落常见温情：老幼对照可感，却未翻出更深发现。意象妥帖，窗明饭香夕阳烟火偏套；“寻座稳”较切，“酬孤老”稍凑。章法平铺，尾联说破，余味有限。","_cost":0.0205456},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"题材有当代感,'扫码取餐'入诗较自然,但立意停在颂扬层面,缺少独到发现。'浓羹暖夕阳'借夕阳指老人,算小有巧思。'酬孤老'的'酬'字稍欠妥。颔联与颈联都在铺叙,转折平直。结句'人间烟火'是套语,直接说破;'莫道市廛'一句逻辑也略别扭。","_cost":0.015964},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"扶筇、扫码写出社区食堂的具体场景，脉络清楚；“酬孤老”略显生硬，“暖夕阳”“人间烟火”偏熟。结句直说情意，余味较少。","_cost":0.012962}},"consensus":62.08,"final":62.08},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"长街新树挂银瓶，枝亦含愁未肯青。莫是东风偷药去，一腔清泪滴还停。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.1,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.7,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.6,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.45000000000002,"rationale":"吊瓶入诗，将新植树木拟作病者，观察新颖且情景相融。第三句转得灵动，惜“偷药”与末句指涉稍含混，“滴还停”略显凑涩；愁、泪稍熟。","_cost":0.005252},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.0,"rationale":"以街树输液这一当代城市细节入诗,题材新而不猎奇。银瓶、清泪与吊瓶点滴物象扣合精切,'偷药''滴还停'设问奇巧、炼字见功,转结有致。惟'含愁''清泪'稍近熟语,情感深掘略欠,结句留白尚可未臻悠远。","_cost":0.03967},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"本诗成功将当代生活细节“给树打吊瓶”入诗。转句奇想“东风偷药”灵动俏皮，结句“滴还停”既精准描摹点滴的物理特性，又化为树之清泪，以景结情，出新且不生硬，余味悠长。","_cost":0.015366},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"取材树挂吊瓶，当代经验入诗尚可。拟人清泪与东风偷药有巧思，然立意轻浅，意象未脱含愁清泪套语，结句稍直。","_cost":0.015482},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.75,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶入诗，拟人通贯，转句设问灵动，结以滴还停留延宕；立意新警，唯情志略浅，部分意象仍沿熟面。","_cost":0.01306316},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"以城市行道树输液这一当代景观入绝句,题新而情真。转句'莫是东风偷药去'痴问妙想,结句以滴泪之景收束,滴还停三字悬而不决,余味悠长。全篇物象紧扣吊瓶,'银瓶''清泪'皆从输液生发,情景交融。'含愁'稍落熟套,整体炼字自然。","_cost":0.00253276},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"以街树输液入诗，取象新颖，转结轻巧；但含愁、清泪稍落常套，情志偏轻浅，余味有限。","_cost":0.010366},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"以吊瓶写春树，城市化象较新，含愁、偷药有情致；然偷药逻辑稍硬，一腔清泪近熟，结句留白有限。","_cost":0.0130908},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.85,"rationale":"借街树吊瓶翻新咏春旧题，病容与垂泪意象统一，拟人自然；起承转合清晰，结句以滴势收束含愁不尽。","_cost":0.01094625},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.65,"rationale":"撷取街树挂营养液的当代日常入诗，拟人新巧，起承转合顺畅，以“东风偷药”的悬想勾连物象，语言自然，唯结句偏实余味稍浅，无明显硬伤。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"取材城市行道树挂吊瓶，当代经验入诗而情致真切，以'含愁未肯青'移情于树，转句'东风偷药'设问灵动，结以清泪滴停之景收束，言尽意不尽。全篇意象统一为病树之愁，章法起承转合完整。'一腔清泪滴还停'可称佳句。唯'含愁''清泪'稍近熟套，炼字尚可再精。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.5,"rationale":"取当代街树输营养液之景入诗，翻出移栽新树含愁之意，题材新而情事可感。以银瓶、滴泪贯通全篇，第三句“东风偷药”设问翻转有巧思，结句以滴停之象收情。惟含愁、清泪稍近熟语，情感偏于轻巧感伤，未臻深厚。","_cost":0.04444},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.8,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.2,"rationale":"当代树挂吊瓶经验入诗，起承转合完整；偷药化用偷灵药，泪滴与输液交融。然东风清泪稍熟，因果略松，故中评；出新加分，陈滥小减。","_cost":0.032004364},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.9,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.3,"rationale":"将当代“新树输液”敏锐入诗。转句“莫是东风偷药去”灵动狡黠，结句“清泪滴还停”逼真传达滴注之态又深融物情。当代经验化入古典意趣，转结自然，活泼可喜。","_cost":0.00551775},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.2,"意境":5.4,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.9,"余味":5.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.9,"rationale":"以行道树挂吊瓶为题别开生面，设问转合完整；然愁泪语直，一腔搭配欠稳，银瓶倚题始明，结收较实余味有限。","_cost":0.0197575},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶写街景，怜惜之意集中；“东风偷药”设问灵巧，转出奇趣。首尾瓶、滴照应，但“含愁”“一腔清泪”偏熟，“亦”略虚；结尾滴停之态尚有延宕，情绪点染稍露。","_cost":0.03976},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.8,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.1,"rationale":"病树之喻集中,银瓶与点滴可感,未肯青略见锤炼。愁泪东风偏熟,转句偷药与结句因果松,结句坐实清泪,余味不足。当代街景入诗有新意,无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0245936},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"以街树吊瓶这一当代景象入诗,题材新颖,暗含对移栽大树的轻讽,但讽意较浅。转句『东风偷药』想象俏皮,结句以滴液作清泪,『滴还停』有些延宕。『含愁』『清泪』略显常套。","_cost":0.017796},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"街树挂吊瓶，写出了春色迟来的具体情状；“东风偷药”转笔有巧思。“含愁”“清泪”稍显熟套，结句点情较直。","_cost":0.007962}},"consensus":73.39,"final":73.39},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"街树初移挂吊瓶，为输春液补空青。垂囊似月枝头坠，引线如针幹上停。不是疾深求药力，应缘根浅怯飘零。谁言造化无医手，一夜新芽绿到庭。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.1,"警句":2.6,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.69999999999999,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶写移栽护生，取材新鲜，医树譬喻贯穿，颈联转折有情。章法完整，结句有景；但“补空青”“针幹上停”稍显生硬，末句略近说满。","_cost":0.006184},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"当代街树输液入诗,题材新而寓意明:'补空青'药名双关见巧,颈联'根浅怯飘零'由物及情最动人。惟颔联比喻稍机械('似月'欠贴),尾联'医手'近乎说破,幸结句以新绿收景,尚存生机余味。章法完整而转折平直。","_cost":0.04235},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"当代经验“树挂吊瓶”入诗，立意新颖，颈联“根浅怯飘零”托物言志，章法脉络贯通。不足在颔联“垂囊似月”比喻略生硬，“空青”稍欠锤炼，结句偏于直白，余味稍欠。","_cost":0.021414},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"移栽挂吊瓶入七律，取材有当下感；颔联取譬具体，颈联根浅非疾，主脑清楚。然颈尾偏议论，‘谁言造化无医手’说破，余味不足，炼字亦有散文化。","_cost":0.019022},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.25,"rationale":"以城市树挂吊瓶入诗，题材与视角出新，尾联景结留余味；“垂囊”一联取喻贴切。但“春液”“补空青”生硬，中二联转折略平，通篇语言未达浑然。","_cost":0.0127578528},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.75,"rationale":"移栽街树输营养液这一当代城市景观入诗，观察精微，喻树为病人，构思完整。中二联一状物一议理，层次分明；'应缘根浅怯飘零'兼摄树与人，尾联以'一夜新芽绿到庭'收束，景语含情，余味悠长。语言自然，'补空青'用典贴切，唯'似月''如针'对仗稍平实。","_cost":0.00277116},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.3,"rationale":"取都市树挂吊瓶入诗，起题新切；颔联状物工巧，颈联由物及理，稍嫌说破；‘春液’‘空青’略生，尾联意尽而少余味。","_cost":0.00994},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"以街头输液树为诗眼，题新而焦点集中；医疗喻贯穿，根浅怯飘零有情。惜“空青”涩、“似月/如针”略不贴，结联先说理后取景，余韵稍损。","_cost":0.0175398},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":6.9,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.9,"rationale":"以街树吊瓶切入当代经验，颈联根浅怯飘零翻出新意，主脑清晰。颔联摹形亲切，章法起承转合有序，结句以新芽绿庭收束，唯比兴稍直、议论微露。","_cost":0.0100169},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"此作取当代街树挂营养液的新鲜题材，立意明确，章法连贯，颈联翻案见巧，结句以景收束见生机，语言妥帖，惟意象偏实、余韵稍浅，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"取材城市移树输液，当代经验入旧体而情真有主脑；'垂囊似月''引线如针'取象精切，颈联'根浅怯飘零'翻出深意，尾联以新芽之绿收束留白。惟'春液''药力'稍涉直白，颔联对仗略平。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"取城市新移街树输液为题，当代经验入诗有效；颔联囊月、线针取象精切，颈联“疾深/根浅”翻出飘零寄意，为一篇主脑。惟“补空青”稍生硬，颔联两比并列少变化；尾联“造化医手”与人力输液略有逻辑错位，“绿到庭”收得明白稍欠留白。","_cost":0.05497},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.1,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.8,"rationale":"取街树挂吊瓶当代经验，医疗意象新颖统一，颈联转、尾联收束稳；语言偶晦（空青），结句稍直白，无硬伤陈滥蹈袭，出新与佳联可赏。","_cost":0.034435346},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.2,"rationale":"将当代移树挂吊瓶之景有效入诗，构思新颖。颔联状物精工贴切，颈联体物入微、由形入理；尾联转出生机，起承转合章法井然。惟结处说得略满，留白稍逊。","_cost":0.00542025},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.6,"意境":4.8,"语言":5.6,"章法":6.7,"余味":5.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.8,"rationale":"以吊瓶写移木得新意，主脑在根浅怯飘零；中联月针二喻失切，补空青晦涩；转合由物及理层次分明，尾以景收而说理稍露。","_cost":0.01117955},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"以街树输液写移栽之怯，取材较新，主脑明确。章法完整但转折平直；“补空青”语意含混，“幹上停”稍显凑泊。末句以新绿收情，有画面，生机复苏的落点仍较常见。","_cost":0.05277},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.4,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.3,"rationale":"街树吊瓶是当代新材，题旨集中，颈联根浅有见。颔联同写一器，比喻坐实；空青、垂囊用词夹生，街与庭微脱。结句点明医手且一夜见绿，说满，余味不足。","_cost":0.037282},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"以街树输液这一当代物事入诗,取材新。颈联「根浅怯飘零」由树及人,有移栽漂泊之感,是全篇亮处。颔联两比较浅,「引线如针」本身就是针,比喻嫌实,「似月」也稍牵强。尾联归功「造化」,与人工吊瓶略有龃龉;「一夜绿到庭」夸张,有景可看,但余味一般。","_cost":0.018208},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"以街树吊瓶入诗，根浅一转写出移栽之脆弱，题材有新意；月囊、针线可见，但“补空青”“引线如针”欠贴切。结句直写新芽，余味稍薄。","_cost":0.012874}},"consensus":74.95,"final":74.95},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"夜扫云仓万码明，光流似水照人清。一枪点检千箱沸，涌作星河满库声。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.55,"rationale":"聚焦夜间智能盘库，题材新鲜，光、码、枪、箱交织成境，动静转换清楚。“千箱沸”“满库声”有张力；星河之喻稍熟，情志深度与结句留白略欠。","_cost":0.005986},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"以物流仓储夜班入诗,当代经验鲜活,题材出新。'一枪点检千箱沸'化扫码枪为诗语,颇见巧思;结句'星河满库'以景收束尚有气象,惟光声互涌略嫌铺张、余味稍促。'光流似水'近熟语,情志偏于场景速写,人的情感着墨浅,故立意未臻高格。","_cost":0.03854},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"当代物流经验入诗，立意具时代气息。扫码枪、云仓与古典意境交融无违和。转句‘沸’字极佳，结句化声为境，将夜班劳作写出磅礴诗意，出新而不生硬。","_cost":0.021182},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"仓储扫描入诗场面具体，光码化星河能成境；然情志止于铺陈缺深层发现，炼字通顺少眼，转结平直余味有限。","_cost":0.017416},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.8,"语言":6.7,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.30000000000001,"rationale":"现代仓储意象与星河通感结合，转结有势，结句以声景留白，余味较足；唯“光流似水”略套，情志偏于场景刻画而情感稍薄。","_cost":0.01025376},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"以扫码枪夜巡云仓入诗,当代劳动经验化古见新。'一枪点检千箱沸'取象精切有诗眼,结句'涌作星河满库声'以通感收束,言尽意不尽。起承转合完整,光流意象贯穿,唯'光流似水'稍熟,整体流畅工稳。","_cost":0.00257536},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"取现代仓储入诗，扫码点检化出星河声势，立意新而脉络顺；但光流照人清稍泛，词面略直，情味未深。","_cost":0.010212},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫入绝句，当代劳作出新且有主脑；光、码、枪、箱能成动势。然“似水”“星河”近熟，万千铺排稍夸，结句以景拓境而略溢，余韵被壮语冲淡。","_cost":0.0176112},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.3,"余味":6.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.95,"rationale":"云仓扫码当代题材以光流星河喻数据沸涌，意象统一、转结有势，沸字为眼；惟情志较浅，结句直抒少留白。","_cost":0.00731725},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.5,"rationale":"此作聚焦当代云仓夜盘场景，选材新颖，炼字切当，起承转合顺畅，将作业声光融于星河意象，当代经验入诗自然，无硬伤蹈袭，唯星河意象稍熟。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"以扫码枪、云仓入诗，当代经验化用自然，题材翻新可嘉；'一枪点检千箱沸'炼字见力，为全篇警句。结句'涌作星河满库声'以视听通感收束有气象，然'声'字为韵所迫稍显凑泊，且通篇颂扬之意略直白，留白不足。'光流似水'化用旧意尚妥。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"电商云仓夜扫入诗题材新颖，一枪点检有当代实感；但全篇止于光影声响的铺陈颂赞，缺少具体情事与人的温度。光流似水、星河属常见喻象，千箱沸稍硬，结句视听并置略显拼凑，气势有余而余味不足。","_cost":0.05801},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"聚焦云仓夜扫，现代物事入诗；起承转合清晰，转结有星河之想。然情志不深，语多平实，光流星河稍落套，末句满库声稍实。警句在千箱沸一联。","_cost":0.027541746},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.95,"rationale":"成功将智慧物流与扫码作业等现代经验入诗，无生硬违和感。章法由静入动、层层推开，“沸”“涌”二字炼得精警，转结声光交融、气势开阔，出新尤为可贵。","_cost":0.00466875},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.9,"语言":5.2,"章法":7.2,"余味":4.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.9,"rationale":"云仓扫码入绝题材新，一枪转合有势；然光流星河套语，满库声收尽无留白，沸外少锤炼。","_cost":0.0155298},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"扫码盘库入诗，有当代现场感；光流、星河贯串夜景，章法顺畅，但情志停于场面赞美。“照人清”语意含混，光、箱、声的转换稍硬；结句铺张多于含蓄，余味有限。","_cost":0.04948},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.5,"rationale":"写云仓夜扫，万码、一枪、千箱落实当代劳作，焦点集中，然情志止于光明奇观，照人清无具体情事。取象有光流、箱沸、星河，递换过频，未成统一氛围。一枪句见锤炼，承句似水、结句满库声偏直，说破而少延宕。","_cost":0.0313776},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"以扫码入仓写当代物流,题材新,有生活实感。但全篇重在铺陈场面,人的情志只剩“照人清”一点,主脑偏浅。“千箱沸”炼字有力。“光流似水”“星河”较常见;“星河满库声”视听通感略显勉强。转句只是递进,并无转折;结句热闹,但余味有限。","_cost":0.019824},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"扫码枪入诗，夜间云仓有当代气息；由灯光写到点检，脉络清楚。但“照人清”“千箱沸”稍显用力，“星河”较熟，结句声光交织却未留出更深余味。","_cost":0.008126}},"consensus":69.86,"final":69.86},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"云仓扫处月如霜，铁架灯河夜未央。万件千箱循轨迹，轻尘片屑避锋芒。全凭茧手除残秽，莫许微瑕误远航。待到明朝车发后，依稀露滴满衣裳。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.3,"余味":7.1,"警句":2.4,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.89999999999999,"rationale":"云仓夜扫切入当代劳作，主旨集中，灯河、茧手具实感。颔颈联稍直，“避锋芒”“误远航”略显拔高；结句以露写辛劳，有留白但情理稍涩。","_cost":0.006616},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫入律,当代劳动经验有新意,场景具体。惟颈联'莫许微瑕误远航'流于标语,'除残秽'直白少味;'月如霜''夜未央'系套语。结句露滴衣裳以景收情,稍存余韵。整体题材可取而炼意未深。","_cost":0.03693},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.5,"rationale":"以当代“云仓”入诗，题材出新，结构完整。首联“铁架灯河”具现代感，但颈联略带口号味，炼字稍欠，“依稀”与“满衣裳”语意微矛盾，“夜未央”较陈套。结句以景结情，留有余味。","_cost":0.016204},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"云仓夜扫有当代主脑，情实而角度常见。月霜灯河与铁架轨迹未浑融，避锋芒隔。语言通顺偶炼，套语不少。章法起承清楚转直。结以露滴稍留白。远航与车发微凿。","_cost":0.01747},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"现代仓储题材见新，尾联以景收束留余味；中二联虚实开合有序，但“夜未央”“茧手”等语略熟，立意仍属劳动礼赞常调。","_cost":0.009287168},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"当代云仓夜扫入诗，题材新颖，情感具体真挚。'茧手除残秽''微瑕误远航'紧扣劳动者身份，虚实相生。结句'依稀露滴满衣裳'以景结情，汗滴似露，言尽意不尽。中二联开合有层次，脉络贯通。'月如霜'稍熟，整体意象统一。","_cost":0.00218616},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.3,"意境":6.9,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.7,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.2,"rationale":"取云仓夜扫入诗，题材较新，铁架灯河与尘屑锋芒构成劳作场景，尾联以露湿收束有余味。不足在‘远航’等议论稍直，‘循轨迹’语感偏硬，月如霜、夜未央稍熟。","_cost":0.0117},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"以云仓夜班清扫入七律，当代物流经验有效，主脑在“微瑕误远航”的职业敬畏。但“万件千箱”“全凭莫许”近口号，尘避锋芒、露滴满衣略牵强；结有余意而未远。","_cost":0.0134688},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.6,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.4,"余味":4.7,"警句":0.5,"出新":0.8,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.4,"rationale":"夜扫小题立工匠之诚有主脑但未出新境；灯河茧手较切，月霜露滴陈套且内外景不一；轨迹锋芒句法拙少诗眼；章法线性平铺转弱；结句欲以景收而依稀露裳套语弱化余味。","_cost":0.009803},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.0,"rationale":"此作咏云仓夜扫劳作者，主脑明晰，章法连贯，当代物流题材入诗自然；惟部分意象偏熟，炼字稍平，转折较直，结句余韵欠丰，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"云仓夜扫入七律，当代劳动经验化古出新，题旨具体有主脑。颔联'循轨迹''避锋芒'对仗工稳见巧思，'茧手'细节真切。尾联以露滴衣裳之景收束，言尽意不尽，与首句月霜呼应。惟'月如霜''灯河'取象稍熟，颈联说理略直，整体中上之作。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.75,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫入诗,题材新,‘铁架灯河’一语可取。然‘月如霜’‘夜未央’落套,颔联‘避锋芒’硬凑,颈联全凭/莫许直陈说理近口号,转折乏味。结句以露滴衣裳收束尚有余味,惟‘依稀’虚字乏力。","_cost":0.0519},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"写云仓夜扫，当代物流入诗，立意集中出新。意象杂糅古今，陈套(月如霜、夜未央)与硬语(轨迹、残秽)并存，语言锤炼不足。章法起承转合清晰但转折平直，结句以景收而境稍熟。颔联对比稍有亮色。","_cost":0.03133744},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.2,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.85,"rationale":"现代电商物流题材入诗，首联“铁架灯河”造境贴切。章法推进有序，惜颔颈联微带口号气，“避锋芒”炼字欠精。尾联以拂晓车发、清露沾衣收束，以景结情，留有余味。","_cost":0.005667},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.2,"章法":6.3,"余味":3.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.3,"rationale":"当代仓储入诗有新意，主脑明确但近颂歌；灯河轨迹氛围尚合，月霜露滴室外象与室内脱节；尾联转露显断，口号句损炼字。","_cost":0.01535775},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"夜扫护运，主脑明确，劳动情志尚偏常见。“铁架灯河”“茧手”有实感，仓储题材略新；“避锋芒”“误远航”措辞牵强。章法完整，颈联说理偏直，露滴结尾稍留余情；霜月、未央等熟语削弱辨识度。","_cost":0.06823},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.5,"rationale":"夜扫云仓有场景与主脑，然情志近敬业常调，少个人发现。灯河、尘屑较切，颈联空说冲淡意境。万千轨迹偏散，锋芒略硬，炼字未净。脉络夜至晨完整，转折平。结句留露未说破，余味不强。","_cost":0.039624},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫写当代劳动者,题材有新意,但主旨仍是常见的礼赞。'铁架灯河'有新意,颈联直说近口号。'避锋芒'略显生硬;'远航'与车运不合,'依稀'与'满'相矛盾。结句以露湿衣裳收束,略有余韵。","_cost":0.01672},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"铁架、灯河与发车写出云仓夜作，有当代气息；中二联由货箱转清扫，脉络尚顺。“片屑避锋芒”语意不明，“远航”与车发不贴；结句以露收景，稍有余味，但月霜、夜未央较熟。","_cost":0.008416}},"consensus":63.52,"final":63.52},{"key":"glm-5.3|机场送别|七绝","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"话别廊桥夜未休，一声催客莫回头。长空银翼穿云去，独对航楼灯火稠。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":7.1,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.85,"rationale":"机场送别情境具体，廊桥、银翼、航楼构成现代空间。第三句转向远去，末句以灯火反衬孤身，收束有余味；“莫回头”“穿云去”稍显熟套。","_cost":0.004704},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.0,"rationale":"熟题而以机场当代场景入诗,廊桥、银翼、航楼取象贴切,起承转合脉络清楚,转句'穿云去'有势,结以'独对灯火稠'景结情、留白尚佳。惜情感处理仍属送别常套,'莫回头''灯火稠'略见陈熟,炼字平稳无突出诗眼。","_cost":0.03143},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"当代送别经验成功入诗，廊桥、银翼等现代意象运用自然。起承转合严密，结句以灯火繁华反衬独对之落寞，以景结情，余味悠长。立意稍显平直，但整体结构圆融，情境交融。","_cost":0.01622},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"机场夜别场景具体可感，廊桥银翼航灯构成统一氛围，结句以灯火收束略留白。题旨常见未翻新境，炼字平实少诗眼，起承转合完整但转结预期之内，莫回头银翼稍套。","_cost":0.014806},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"现代机场送别，情感真实，后二句以银翼穿云、独对灯火形成张力，结句以景留白；但立意仍属常见别情，前二句偏平，整体中上。","_cost":0.00745888},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"送别熟题借机场取新材，主脑清晰。'莫回头'以催客声写离别之痛，含蓄有力；结句独对灯火稠，以景结情，余味佳。起承转合完整，'稠'字见炼。惟'银翼穿云'稍落套，情感深度有限。","_cost":0.00176456},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"机场送别场景清晰，银翼、廊桥、灯火等现代意象统一，转结完整；但情感表达偏常规，“独对”稍说破，语词未臻精警。","_cost":0.006574},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"以廊桥、银翼、航楼灯火等现代意象入七绝,送别场景具体可感,转结层次清楚,结句以景结情、灯火衬孤,余味较好。然送别主旨与'莫回头'笔法常见,锤炼未至警策,整体稳妥有余、新境不足。","_cost":0.0087348},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.2,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.6,"章法":5.8,"余味":6.4,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.2,"rationale":"现代廊桥银翼航楼入诗具体，然送别情思仍属常格；稠字以密衬孤稍见巧，转结以景收束余味略胜，余则平直少锤炼。","_cost":0.00879325},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"此作写当代机场送别，主脑集中，情感真切，起承转合顺畅，以稠密灯火衬别后孤清，语言自然。惟立意未脱常调，新意不足，少警拔之句。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"以机场廊桥、银翼、航楼灯火等当代物象写传统离情，化古出新，取象精切统一。'莫回头'三字有力，结句'独对灯火稠'以景收情，留白得当。惟送别题旨角度仍属常见，中二句稍平，整体稳而不奇。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"机场送别题材当代,然全篇仍是古典送别套路移植:话别、催客、莫回头、穿云去皆熟语,情事不够具体。结句以灯火稠收束尚有留白,但'廊桥''银翼'意象平常,无诗眼,起承转合平直。","_cost":0.0426},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.0,"rationale":"送别题旨明确、情事具体而角度常见；意象现代统一，‘银翼穿云’稍熟；语畅，‘稠’字见炼；起承转合分明，结以景结情，余味8分。无硬伤蹈袭，当代机场经验入诗，警句2、出新2。","_cost":0.032167761},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"成功将当代机场送别经验入诗。起承转合脉络清晰，“莫回头”见情深，“银翼”写转折自然，结句以航楼灯火反衬孤寂，以景结情，情意真切无违和感。","_cost":0.0046065},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.2,"意境":6.4,"语言":4.3,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.1,"rationale":"题旨明确而角度常见；廊桥银翼灯火成境但交融未深；夜未休灯火稠欠炼无诗眼；去留对照完整平直；独对点破余味有限。","_cost":0.016932},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"机场别情具体，题旨仍属常见；话别、催客、机去、独留，层次清楚。末句以灯火之稠反衬人之孤，有余味。“夜未休”稍泛，“长空银翼穿云去”较熟；当代场景入诗自然，尚缺独到发现。","_cost":0.03622},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"题旨清楚,角度常见,无独到发现。夜机场意象能成境,银翼灯火对照可感,穿云仍熟。莫回头略见诗眼,航楼稍生。章法完整而依时序平推。结句独字说破,余味薄。当代场景入诗有效,无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0401136},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"以机场写送别，当代经验入诗，结句以'灯火稠'反衬'独'，有以景结情之意。但情事较泛，'银翼穿云'偏套，炼字平。常识上送行者难以到廊桥话别，'莫回头'主语亦欠明晰。","_cost":0.01458},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"机场送别有具体场景，末句以满楼灯火反衬独立，余味较好。起承转合清楚，但“银翼穿云”较熟，“催客莫回头”语意略显勉强。","_cost":0.008034}},"consensus":66.47,"final":66.47},{"key":"glm-5.3|机场送别|七律","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"离亭已换登机口，挥手从今隔海洋。行李岂如心绪重，鹏程不及别情长。天垂尾迹千寻白，人立风廊半晌凉。归去仰观星一点，犹疑闪烁是君航。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.3,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.7,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.65,"rationale":"“离亭换登机口”巧接古今，尾迹、风廊与星点构成送别现场。颔联略近套语且直露，末句疑航留白，脉络完整而余韵悠长。","_cost":0.007966},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"以'离亭换登机口'翻新送别熟题，当代经验入诗自然。颔联'行李/鹏程'虚实相较见巧，'鹏程'双关尤妙；颈联尾迹、风廊取象精切。尾联误星为航灯，以疑作结、余味悠长。惟颔联句式稍熟，中二联开合尚可更阔。","_cost":0.0372},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.75,"rationale":"将当代经验有效融于律诗中。颈联“尾迹”“风廊”极具现代画面感与冷清氛围，尾联以星拟夜航灯收束，余味悠长。唯颔联对比稍显直白。整体情真意切，时代气息浓，起承转合自然流畅。","_cost":0.017876},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"机场置换离亭有新意，情事具体主脑清楚但角度仍属常见送别。尾迹风廊星航交融成凉意远隔，颔联比喻偏套，君航稍硬。时序从挥手至归望贯通，结句疑星为航留白较好。","_cost":0.014138},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"机场送别切现代经验，情感具体，颈联景语精切，尾联星航余味尤佳；结构完整，中二联开合有致。唯离亭、鹏程等语稍熟。","_cost":0.00869},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.5,"rationale":"送别熟题以机场当代经验翻新，'离亭已换登机口'切入巧妙，情事具体有主脑。颔联'行李岂如心绪重，鹏程不及别情长'以今物作比，是警句。结句仰观星点疑是君航，以景结情、言尽意不尽。通篇意象统一，脉络一气贯注。","_cost":0.00262056},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.9,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.9,"rationale":"以机场新景写送别，起句巧，颈联景语清冷含情，结有延宕；然颔联情语稍熟，个别词略生。","_cost":0.012234},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"送别熟题以机场新境翻出，焦点集中，情感具体。颔联巧对，'鹏程'双关见炼字；'天垂尾迹'略生硬，'半晌凉'稍平。中二联由情入景开合有度，结联仰星疑为君航，以景结情、想象悠远，余味最佳。现代经验入诗自然，无生造之弊。","_cost":0.0103668},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"离亭换登机口翻熟题有新境，尾迹风廊具现场感，颔联说理稍直白，结句疑星是航以景结情留有余宕，当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.0099005},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"此作以当代机场场景写传统别情，意象切当，章法流转自然，颈联情景交融，结句以错认航灯留余味，语言凝练，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.75,"rationale":"以古典语汇写机场送别，'离亭已换登机口'化古出新自然。颔联对仗见巧思但'别情长'稍熟；颈联'尾迹千寻白''风廊半晌凉'景中含情，取象精切。结句仰观星点疑是君航，以景结情、留白得当，余味悠长。全篇脉络贯通，转合有致，唯颔联议论略直。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"以机场置换离亭,当代经验入诗自然。颈联尾迹千寻白、风廊半晌凉取象精切;结句疑星为航,以景收情余味悠长。颔联议论稍直,'心绪重''别情长'略近套语。","_cost":0.04797},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.5,"rationale":"以登机口、尾迹、风廊写现代别情，尾联疑星为航，含蓄有余味；中二联由情入景，章法完整，然颔联议论平直，鹏程、别情等语稍熟，君航略硬。","_cost":0.037723326},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.8,"rationale":"成功将当代机场送别经验化入律诗。尾迹、风廊与机灯取象精切，章法依时空自然推移，结句以景结情余味悠长。颔联对比略显平直套路，首句入诗略率，瑕不掩瑜。","_cost":0.00516525},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"首句以登机口换离亭有新意，然中联落鹏程别情窠臼；尾迹星象贯通，结句以星喻航留白较佳，君航略生造。","_cost":0.0107393},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.9,"rationale":"登机口翻新离亭，题旨集中而情意较常见。颔联轻重长短之比稍直露；颈联尾迹与风廊动静相映，以凉写情。归途疑星为航，延宕别绪，结有余味；“君航”略显生硬。","_cost":0.04123},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"熟题借登机口、尾迹、航班落笔，情事具体而命意常见。尾迹与疑星最见交融，中联说理稍巧。语言稳顺，风廊略生。由别到望再到归家，转结清楚。结句犹疑未说尽，余味最佳。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0185216},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"首句以登机口替代离亭，古题今写，起得有势。颔联两句都是比较句式，句法雷同近乎合掌，“鹏程”“别情”也偏熟。颈联以尾迹、风廊取象，清切入情。尾联把闪烁的星光疑作航灯，以景结情，余味较好。“君航”一词略显生硬。","_cost":0.016808},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"登机口换离亭，旧题有新景；尾迹与风廊一联尤佳。颔联直陈别情，略落熟套；结句以疑似航灯收束，留有余味。","_cost":0.008046}},"consensus":76.81,"final":76.81},{"key":"glm-5.3|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"玻璃城里锁温柔，袖底青蚨夜暗投。爪到中途偏脱手，绒熊稳卧不知愁。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.8,"余味":8.7,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.95,"rationale":"以抓取失败写欲望投射与徒劳，玻璃、钱币、机械爪、绒熊构成统一情境。第三句转折利落，末句以熊之无愁反衬人情，含讽刺余味；“青蚨夜暗投”稍显刻意。","_cost":0.005532},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"当代题材入绝句而不违和：玻璃柜作'城'、青蚨代币，用典贴切。三句'偏脱手'转折有力，结句以绒熊'不知愁'反衬人之怅惘，以物结情有余味。惟'锁温柔'略泛，炼字尚可再精，整体佳而未至警绝。","_cost":0.03404},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"当代生活入诗佳作。以“玻璃城”起笔，用“青蚨”代游戏币，古今词汇交融自然。起承转合极具巧思，转句点出机械之“坑”，结句以绒熊“不知愁”反衬抓客之懊恼，生动幽默，余味隽永。","_cost":0.016726},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"抓娃娃写求而不得，主脑清楚，结句绒熊不知愁有留白。然“温柔”偏空，袖底青蚨夜暗投与投币事实不合，文白夹杂明显，青蚨、不知愁稍熟。","_cost":0.027576},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃写求不得，题材出新。起句“锁温柔”凝练，转结由人及物，借绒熊不知愁反衬怅惘，余味足。青蚨暗投有巧思，唯“夜暗”微重。","_cost":0.00739288},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写求而不得之温柔，今题古调浑成。玻璃城、青蚨夜投取象精切，钱与情双关。三句转写爪偏脱手，结以绒熊稳卧不知愁，以物之无情反衬人之怅惘，言尽意不尽。全篇无一废字，章法起承转合俱全。","_cost":0.00211956},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.6,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.1,"rationale":"现代题材入绝，起承转合清晰，玻璃城、绒熊取象切题，结以物态留余味。惟“青蚨”“夜暗投”稍隔，语言微有凑痕。","_cost":0.012412},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写投入与落空的世相,玻璃城、青蚨、脱爪、卧熊意象贯通,转结见巧思,结句以物之不知愁反衬人之怅惘,留白得当。当代经验入旧体自然,唯'袖底暗投'略涩,'不知愁'稍熟。","_cost":0.0099708},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.6,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.9,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.9,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.14999999999999,"rationale":"娃娃机入绝新颖，起承转合分明，以熊之稳卧反衬人之暗投脱手，结句宕开留白；青蚨稍饰，立意止于得失感慨未入深境。","_cost":0.0130795},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.5,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.95,"rationale":"撷取当代抓娃娃机日常入诗，起承转合圆畅，炼字妥帖，以绒熊懵懂反衬玩家细碎怅惘，具新鲜趣味，无硬伤套语，唯余韵稍欠悠长。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.25,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入七绝，当代经验化古出新：玻璃城锁温柔、青蚨暗投皆切题而雅驯。转句'偏脱手'见失手之憾，结以绒熊不知愁反衬人心，以物结情留白有余。'不知愁'微袭闺怨旧语而翻用得宜，青蚨稍熟。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.25,"rationale":"当代题材入诗自然，'玻璃城锁温柔'以物寓求而不得，青蚨暗投用典贴切；转句'偏脱手'有变，结以绒熊稳卧对照人愁，稍嫌'不知愁'点破，然整体浑成有寄托。","_cost":0.04536},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机隐喻求而不得，现代经验有效入诗；转结以绒熊稳卧反衬愁情，余味悠长。青蚨句略显古典夹生，整体立意、章法俱佳。","_cost":0.026642218},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.6,"rationale":"切入当代生活经验，起承转合自然紧凑。“玻璃城”、“锁温柔”造语新巧，转结如实摹写落空情态，以绒熊“稳卧不知愁”反衬人之执念与自嘲，情趣盎然。","_cost":0.0049185},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.9,"章法":6.1,"余味":7.3,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.8,"rationale":"以娃娃机写求而不得，人愁熊不愁有主脑反衬；场景完整但温柔愁语偏虚，三句偏白，结句以物衬人宕开留味，当代题材化古尚贴。","_cost":0.014533},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.89999999999999,"rationale":"以抓取落空写求而不得，物象集中，转结灵动。末句借绒熊无愁反衬人心，含蓄有趣。“锁温柔”有巧思，“袖底青蚨夜暗投”稍显雕饰，情志尚未拓出更深层次。","_cost":0.04146},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"抓娃娃失败写欲得而不得,事具体、旨不深。玻璃城、脱手、绒熊成一境,偏字有力。起承转合顺,结句转向物但不知愁稍说破。青蚨略熟,新在题面,无误用袭句。","_cost":0.0228976},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"以古典笔法写抓娃娃机,当代经验入诗有趣。'锁温柔''青蚨暗投'用典贴切有味。转句写失手,平实稍白。结句以绒熊'不知愁'反衬人之怅然,有谐趣与微讽,但寄托不深,'不知愁'略熟。","_cost":0.014664},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"玻璃城、青蚨与机械爪串起投币落空的过程，转结以绒熊安卧映出人的失落，脉络紧凑。首句有巧思；“夜暗投”稍显雕饰，“不知愁”略说尽。","_cost":0.010332}},"consensus":77.19,"final":77.19},{"key":"glm-5.3|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"晶笼贮梦夜灯前,投罢银钱意惘然。铁爪垂空擒幻影,温香在握化轻烟。谁司离合纤丝上,我掷悲欢咫尺边。莫笑痴顽童子戏,人间万事一机悬。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.9,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.39999999999999,"rationale":"以抓娃娃映照得失离合，主脑鲜明，颔颈联由物及人，转承有力。晶笼、铁爪、纤丝成境；但“梦、幻影、轻烟、悲欢、人间万事”稍显泛熟，末句警策而略说尽。","_cost":0.004764},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写人生机缘,当代经验入诗有效。颔联虚实相生,颈联'司离合''掷悲欢'由物及理见巧思。惜尾联'莫笑''人间万事'议论说破,'一机悬'虽有双关仍嫌兜底;'温香''轻烟'微近熟语。整体脉络贯通,题材出新可嘉。","_cost":0.04293},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.5,"rationale":"咏物出新，将现代抓娃娃机自然入诗。前两联取象精准，“铁爪擒幻影”贴切且融情；颈联由物理升至哲理，结构严密。然结句“人间万事一机悬”虽点明主旨但哲理说尽，缺乏留白。整体是当代经验入诗的佳作。","_cost":0.027698},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机喻把握虚幻、命运悬丝，取象统一颔联可观；题旨常见略说教，尾联点破少留白，章法平直，语言通顺偶套。","_cost":0.019634},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.8,"rationale":"当代抓娃娃题材入七律，立意翻新；意象统一于迷幻失落氛围。中二联开合有致，结句由游戏宕入人生，言尽意延。颈联与末句可称警策。","_cost":0.0093192},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写人生得失,当代经验入诗有效,主脑清晰。中二联景议相生,'擒幻影''化轻烟'虚实相映,见锤炼。结句'一机悬'有双关余绪,然'人间万事'点题略直白。'咫尺边'稍嫌凑韵。","_cost":0.00255136},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.3,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.95,"rationale":"借抓娃娃机写得失机缘，意象新切，铁爪轻烟等句能化实为虚。颈联有警句，收以一机悬颇见巧思。惜尾联稍说破，幻影、悲欢等词微熟。","_cost":0.012898},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机喻人生得失,当代题材翻出新境,主脑集中。'贮梦''擒幻影''化轻烟'象意交融,'谁司离合'一联由物及人有开阖。结句'一机悬'警策但略近说破,稍损余味。","_cost":0.0084656},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.1,"余味":6.3,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.7,"rationale":"以晶笼铁爪等当代物象翻出命运悬线的哲理，中二联虚实刻画精切，章法由事入理开合有度，尾联直以议论作结，警策有余留白稍欠。","_cost":0.0101085},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"以当代抓娃娃机入律，小中见大，中二联摹物切情，炼字精准章法顺畅，惟结句说理稍直，无硬伤蹈袭，当代经验融入自然。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机翻出人生离合之思,当代经验入旧体而妥帖,颔联'擒幻影''化轻烟'取象精切,颈联'谁司离合''我掷悲欢'为佳联,对举有力。尾联点题稍直,'一机悬'尚留悬置之意。全篇脉络贯通,惟个别处议论略露,意象常见度微高。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"以娃娃机寓人生离合,当代经验入诗有效;“铁爪擒幻影”“谁司离合纤丝上”取象精切,颈联最见工力。结句点破“万事一机悬”,议论收束略直,余味折损;“夜灯前”“意惘然”稍落俗套。","_cost":0.0405},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"题材新颖，以抓娃娃机喻人生得失，起承转合清晰，中二联由外而内。‘铁爪垂空擒幻影’‘一机悬’锤炼见力；然结句直说，余味稍欠，‘化轻烟’等套语略陈，个别句如‘掷悲欢咫尺边’稍硬。","_cost":0.026452987},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.3,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.05,"rationale":"当代经验入诗的佳作。“晶笼”、“铁爪”等物象古典化精切，中二联由实入虚，写抓取落空与悲欢寄托极见功力。尾句以“一机悬”双关点旨，微显说破但警策有力。","_cost":0.00531},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"以娃娃机喻人生离合，题材新而哲理熟；中二联实转理但语意重复，温香不切，尾联议论兜底，一机悬双关可取。","_cost":0.0109218},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"以抓取得失喻人生悲欢，题材新而归旨常见。“晶笼贮梦”凝练，“幻影”“轻烟”稍显泛化。由实入虚，层次清楚；末句“一机”有双关，但包举万事、说理过满，余味受限。","_cost":0.04422},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"抓娃娃入律，离合、纤丝点出操控不在己，题有发现但情事概括，收于口号。晶笼、铁爪精切，温香、轻烟偏套。颈联为眼，章法完整而转直。结句说破，余味有限。","_cost":0.030368},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机喻命运得失,当代物象入诗,角度可取。颈联'谁司离合'有哲思。首联先写惘然,稍抢后文。'温香在握'用于玩偶略欠妥。尾联由'莫笑'转入议论,'一机'双关有趣,但仍属说破。","_cost":0.01684},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃写得失，有具体场景，中二联由铁爪转向人心，脉络清楚。但“梦”“幻影”“轻烟”“悲欢”稍密，结句直推“人间万事”，说尽而少余味。","_cost":0.007824}},"consensus":77.83,"final":77.83},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|云端相册|七绝","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"万片流云掌上存，翻时点点旧春痕。谁知像素成千亿，不抵人间一握温。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.7,"章法":8.3,"余味":7.6,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.69999999999999,"rationale":"以云端相册反衬真实触觉，主脑鲜明，当代经验入诗自然。首句双关巧，转结有力；“旧春痕”稍熟，“像素成千亿”略直，结句虽警醒但意旨稍显说尽。","_cost":0.005484},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"以云存储照片写数字时代情感稀薄，当代经验入诗自然，'万片流云'双关巧妙。起承转合完整，'谁知'转笔有力。惜结句以议论说破对比，虽'一握温'具体可感，仍近格言式收束，留白不足；'像素成千亿'语稍质直。","_cost":0.04236},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.75,"rationale":"将“云端”“像素”等当代经验完美融入绝句。前两句写手机相册，后两句以“千亿像素”与“一握温”作强烈对比，由虚转实，立意巧妙且情感真挚。结句虽偏直白，但警策动人，起承转合一气贯注。","_cost":0.026446},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"数字相册对照体温，主脑清楚但对比熟套。流云一喻尚可，春痕偏滥，结句说理点破少留白。像素入诗有时代感，语言通顺偶见锤炼。","_cost":0.013826},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.95,"rationale":"云端相册取当代物象，对比像素与体温，立意真切；转结有力，一握温为诗眼。惟流云、春痕略熟，转句稍直，故意境与余味未至极高。","_cost":0.00681406},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"以云端相册翻新旧题，数字时代记忆与体温对照，立意有独到发现。起承转合干净，'谁知'一转有力。'一握温'是诗眼，炼字见功。结句以对比收束，稍近说破但形象可感。'旧春痕'略熟，整体意象密度稍逊于议论力度。","_cost":0.00214456},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.4,"意境":7.3,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.2,"余味":6.8,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.94999999999999,"rationale":"以云端相册写记忆，立意新而主脑明。流云、春痕与像素相映，转结清楚；末句以一握温收情，有警策，但稍说破，余味未臻浑融。","_cost":0.01117},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字记忆不敌人间体温，题旨集中、角度新而不猎奇；首句'流云'双关云存储颇巧，'旧春痕'情景交融。转结对比有力，'像素成千亿'略近口语，结句'一握温'形象佳但主旨说破偏多，余韵稍损。中二句与转结层次清楚，一气呵成。","_cost":0.0082518},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"以千亿像素对一握温立意明确但属常见母题，起承转结完整有力，然中段偏议论损意境交融，结句直判说破余味稍浅。","_cost":0.0084945},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"此作取当代云端相册题材，围绕海量影像难抵真实触感的核心立意，章法圆熟，双关巧妙，语言自然，唯意象稍熟，结句偏直，略欠余蕴。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"以'云端'双关入诗，数字存储与人间温度对举，当代经验化用自然。起句'万片流云掌上存'取象精切，转句'千亿像素'翻出新境，结句'不抵人间一握温'以情收束、言尽意不尽，为全篇警策。唯'旧春痕'意象稍熟，中二句铺垫略平。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"以“流云”双关云存储与飘云，掌上翻检旧影，当代经验入诗有效。后半转入数量对比说理，“不抵人间一握温”有触感但把意思说破，虚实相衬的角度在当代诗中已属常见，余味稍欠。","_cost":0.04263},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字影像与真实体温之辨，“一握温”为诗眼；起承转合清晰，惜结句直白、意境稍倚巧思。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.024284608},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.7,"章法":8.4,"余味":7.1,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.8,"rationale":"当代数字经验入诗极贴切，“流云”双关妙合。后两句以千亿虚景反衬一握实温，转结有力、情思深切；结语虽略微说破，但感触真切，出新且动人。","_cost":0.00643725},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.25,"rationale":"云端对握温立意明确但科技冷暖对比常见；流云春痕较泛，像素直入伤意境诗味；起承转合完整；末句直陈道理说尽无余味。","_cost":0.01290755},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"以海量影像反衬现实接触的温度，题旨集中，当代经验入诗有效。流云、春痕稍泛，“成千亿”略显硬直；转结清楚，“一握温”有触感，但“不抵”直接点明主旨，留白有限。","_cost":0.03392},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"熟题：海量影像不抵真实体温，主脑明确而角度常见。流云掌上有双关，春痕陈熟，像素句堕为统计，意境未浑。语言通顺，「一握温」是诗眼，谁知不抵为套。章法完整，转折平直。结句说破，余味薄。云端经验入诗有效。","_cost":0.0302144},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"以流云双关云端,当代经验入诗较巧。起承自然,转以谁知略平。结句数字与温情对比,题旨虽明,角度常见,且直接说破,余味有限。","_cost":0.015672},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"“流云”兼映云端与旧景，掌上翻看颇有画面；像素与手心温度的对照切题，但“旧春痕”稍熟，“一握温”略涩。转结直陈胜负，余味偏薄。","_cost":0.008144}},"consensus":72.97,"final":72.97},{"key":"glm-5.3|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"抱瓮黄昏上女墙，瓜苗豆架两三行。低头忽见千窗火，我自浇畦带月光。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.6,"语言":8.1,"章法":8.7,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.45,"rationale":"以楼顶种菜写都市中的自适，情事具体。前二句铺陈，第三句由近景转万家灯火，结句月下浇畦，清静有余味；“抱瓮”稍古熟。","_cost":0.00595},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"都市天台种菜熟中翻新：抱瓮暗用汉阴丈人典无痕，转句俯见千窗灯火陡然开阔，结句化陶潜'带月荷锄'自成境界，以月光对万家灯火，闹中守静，言尽意远。惟起承二句取象稍平实，炼字微欠峭拔。","_cost":0.03394},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"将都市天台种菜之日常化入诗境，“千窗火”与“带月光”对比精妙，人工与自然相映。第三句“忽见”转折极具张力，结句脱胎陶诗而不落窠臼，余味悠长。","_cost":0.024194},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.0,"rationale":"天台灌园对照万家灯火，情事可感而安于垄亩之旨常见。千窗火与带月意象相生，语言通顺少炼。转合清楚，结句以行动收束略直。抱瓮妥帖，屋顶种植入诗自然。","_cost":0.023258},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"写天台种菜，具体亲切；转句以千窗火拓开都市背景，结句带月光有自适余韵。炼字自然，用典无痕。立意稍平，女墙略隔，警句强度有限。","_cost":0.01177044},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.0,"rationale":"都市天台种菜，以抱瓮灌园古意安顿当代生活，熟题翻出新境。低头忽见千窗火一转，城乡喧寂对照鲜明；结句带月光以景收束，自得之情不点破。用典无痕，带字见诗眼，起承转合完足。","_cost":0.00245076},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.3,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.7,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"天台种菜与千窗灯火相映，城市田园颇有新意；转结顺畅，末句以月光收束，画面清朗。然抱瓮、女墙稍显古硬，情志略浅。","_cost":0.010842},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"城市天台灌园，抱瓮暗合《庄子》，千窗火与带月光成冷暖对照，转结有势、末句留白。女墙略硬，田园语汇未尽脱熟，故未至极境。","_cost":0.0175098},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.7,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.6,"rationale":"天台种菜翻新田园旧题，抱瓮与千窗火成出世入世对照；俯瞰转收束于一瓢月光，景情交融，章法宕合有致，结句以景结情余韵远。","_cost":0.0074094},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"此作写都市天台浇菜日常，视角由菜畦转向千窗灯火再收归己身，语言清顺，章法妥帖，传统田园闲趣融入当代城市场景，唯立意稍平，余韵略欠。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.5,"rationale":"城市天台种菜入旧体，抱瓮典故化用无痕；'千窗火'与'浇畦带月光'俯仰对照，市声与田园张力自见。转结有力，以景结情留白得当。意象略近陶潜一路而情境全新，语言通体干净，唯'两三行'稍平熟。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.5,"rationale":"天台种菜的当代经验入诗，暗用抱瓮灌畦、带月荷锄而不露痕迹。转句“低头忽见千窗火”俯视都市灯火，与结句“我自浇畦带月光”形成高下、人我、俗隐之对照，意象统一，收束稍带表态但余味犁然。“两三行”略平。","_cost":0.04991},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"都市天台种菜题材新颖，起承转合分明；忽见千窗火转出都市繁华与月下浇畦对照，自字见淡泊。化用陶诗带月及抱瓮典无痕，结句以景叙事留白，余味悠长。唯上女墙稍费解，语言锤炼精当。","_cost":0.027326659},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.8,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.7,"余味":8.6,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.64999999999999,"rationale":"当代高楼天台种菜经验入诗，转结由近及远、俯仰自如。“千窗火”与“带月光”形成闹静反差，化陶句浑然无迹，神清骨爽，极富都市隐逸余味。","_cost":0.00622875},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"城上种菜对千窗灯火，以自守收束，主脑ชัด但角度常见；物象融成黄昏氛围，尾句以景结情余味较佳。","_cost":0.0133985},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"天台菜畦与千窗灯火相映，都市耕作写出具体自得；第三句俯视拓境，转折有效。“上女墙”措辞欠精确，结句月色留韵，但“我自”稍露表态。旧田园意趣移入都市，有新意。","_cost":0.0331},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"园事具体，守拙近常。两三行对千窗火，景情相生，最为出色。用字省净，带字见炼，女墙稍隔。起于登上，转入俯见，黄昏收至月光，脉络贯通。结句我自点明态度，余味稍短。都市菜畦入旧体自然，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.041288},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"以“抱瓮”典写城市天台种菜，古今相映，立意有新。第三句“低头”见千窗灯火，转得有力。结句化用陶诗“带月荷锄”却不露痕迹，以景收情，有余味。“上女墙”措辞稍欠妥帖。","_cost":0.016344},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"天台菜园与千窗灯火相映，写出闹市中的自得；由俯见灯火转入带月浇畦，脉络自然。结句有画面与余味，“我自”稍点明情意。","_cost":0.00809}},"consensus":80.92,"final":80.92},{"key":"glm-5.3|天台菜园|七律","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"百尺楼头寄傲耕，泥香半亩隔尘声。菘排翠浪随畦远，韭剪青丝带雨荣。汲罢一瓢浇月色，笑呼稚子数新萌。何须别觅南山下，已觉柴桑在此城。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.6,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.10000000000001,"rationale":"以楼顶菜园重构田园之乐，城市经验入古典诗境，主脑鲜明。颔颈联取象生动，“浇月色”尤佳；尾联化用陶潜略直白，说意稍尽。","_cost":0.004962},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"楼顶种菜将陶式田园移入当代都市，题材有新意，情事具体。'汲罢一瓢浇月色'炼字有味，颈联生活气足。惜尾联'何须''已觉'把意思说破，南山柴桑亦是熟套，余味打折，转结稍直。","_cost":0.03282},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"以天台种菜写都市田园，生活气息浓。“汲罢一瓢浇月色”兼具诗眼与巧思，意境生动。然尾联化用陶公典故过于直白，说破题旨而少留白，余味稍欠；“南山”“柴桑”等词亦略显套路。","_cost":0.020152},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"楼头半亩、浇月数萌，情事可感，然大隐于市、柴桑南山实为熟题。浇月色略见炼字，翠浪青丝等象常见。中二联开合平直，尾联点破题旨，余韵不足。","_cost":0.025722},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"都市天台种菜，细节真切，意境清新；颔联体物精工，颈联“浇月色”见诗眼。尾联说理稍直，余味略欠。用陶典自然无硬伤，偶见熟意象。","_cost":0.00745954},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"都市楼顶种菜，翻新陶潜归隐熟题，情事具体（稚子数萌）有主脑。中二联开合有序，'汲罢一瓢浇月色'虚实相生为诗眼。结句化用柴桑南山，宕开收束尚留余味，惟'寄傲耕''带雨荣'稍显凑韵直白。","_cost":0.00251016},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.8,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.1,"rationale":"天台菜园取材较新，浇月色、数新萌有生活清趣；然南山柴桑收束偏直，隐逸语稍熟。","_cost":0.011336},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"天台为圃翻转陶潜隐逸，题旨有主脑，城喧与泥香对照成境；“浇月色”最有诗眼。然翠浪、青丝、南山、柴桑熟象偏多，中二联略近列景，尾联点破题旨，余味受制。","_cost":0.0246108},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.2,"余味":4.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.2,"rationale":"天台寄耕点城隐主脑，畦景人事具体；菘韭对工而翠浪青丝稍熟，章法完整转折平，尾联柴桑兜底直白少留白，浇月色略具诗眼。","_cost":0.007879},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"此作写都市天台耕蔬闲趣，化用陶典翻出城市隐趣新境，景事交融，章法顺畅，炼字有巧思；唯结句偏直白，部分意象稍熟。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":80.25,"rationale":"以百尺楼头种菜翻新田园旧题，城市经验入诗真切可感。'汲罢一瓢浇月色'炼字见诗眼，中二联取象精切。惟'韭剪青丝'化用杜甫痕迹稍显，结句点出柴桑虽宕开仍近于说破，余味略减。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"都市天台种菜入诗有当代趣味，颔联菘韭铺陈工稳，“浇月色”“数新萌”颈联最活。但“半亩”“随畦远”与天台尺度不合，“寄傲耕”生硬；尾联南山、柴桑双典直陈，说破兜底，余味寡。","_cost":0.04509},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"都市天台慕陶，题旨明确而角度常见；意象妥帖，“浇月色”有诗眼，然翠浪青丝、南山柴桑稍陈；章法完整但转折平稳，尾联说理直白，余味略短。","_cost":0.029729298},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.6,"余味":6.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.9,"rationale":"当代天台农趣入诗，颈联“浇月色、数新萌”极见灵趣与温馨，起承转合自然一气。颔联词藻与尾联结典略带熟套，结句议论说得较尽，但整体清雅融洽。","_cost":0.0056745},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.4,"章法":6.8,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.4,"rationale":"楼头耕菜翻隐逸旧题为城中柴桑，具体可感；菘韭月色交融成趣；浇月色有诗眼；结构完整而转折平直；尾联以理兜底，直白说破。","_cost":0.01116155},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.3,"余味":4.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"楼顶种菜、稚子数萌使归隐题有生活实感；“一瓢浇月色”灵动。颔联略饰，“带雨荣”稍涩；由景入情脉络清楚，末联借陶意直陈，收束稳而留白少，归隐语汇稍密。","_cost":0.03511},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"归隐熟题移至楼头菜畦,泥香、稚子、新萌具体,主脑集中。菘韭取象精切,浇月色略露巧。中二联由畦色转入人事,脉络顺;结联何须已觉把柴桑说破,余味薄。习用南山柴桑,无误典与整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.0212032},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"以天台菜园写都市隐逸,当代经验入诗。'浇月色'有新意,颈联含情趣。但主旨不出陶诗'心远地自偏'的旧框,南山、柴桑属常用套典。结句直接点破题旨,余味偏浅。","_cost":0.016996},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.0,"rationale":"天台种菜与稚子数苗，使城市归耕之意具体可感；“浇月色”有巧思。“寄傲耕”“带雨荣”稍显生硬，结句点明柴桑，收束稳而余味略浅。","_cost":0.008122}},"consensus":72.57,"final":72.57},{"key":"glm-5.3|云端相册|七绝","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"万千影像驻云间，指下银屏岁月还。昔日同游人不见，更深独对旧时颜。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.3,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"以云端相册寄托怀人之情，当代经验入诗自然。前二句写触屏还忆，后二句由同游转独对，转结有力；“万千”“岁月”稍泛，“旧时颜”含蓄而有余味。","_cost":0.004692},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写睹照思人,当代经验入诗有巧思,'驻云间'语带双关。惜转结落入'人面不知何处'旧套,'人不见''旧时颜'皆熟语,情真而不深切。章法起承转合完整,结句画面尚存但近乎说尽,余味有限,语言平顺乏诗眼。","_cost":0.03005},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"将“云端”“银屏”等现代事物自然入诗，贴近当代生活。然语言偏于直白浅近，意象略显单薄；起承转合中规中矩，结句“独对旧时颜”直述其事，缺乏留白与余味。","_cost":0.02288},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"云相册怀旧题旨明确且有当代切入，然角度常见、情感类型化。意象贴切但未深融为不可删之境。语言通顺少锤炼与诗眼。章法起承转合完整、转折预期内。结句直陈孤独，说破少留白。","_cost":0.016158},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.3,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.3,"rationale":"以云端相册翻旧照写怀人，情感具体，是传统题材的当代转化。意象统一，唯“昔日同游”“旧时颜”略熟。转结顺畅，结句以深夜独对画面收束，留白有余味，但未至警句。","_cost":0.00638506},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"以云端相册这一当代经验入旧体，旧题翻新。'驻云间''指下银屏'扣题精切，景语即情语。转句'人不见'陡起波澜，结句以深夜独对照片之'旧时颜'收束，以象结情，言尽意不尽。语言自然微有亮点，全诗一气贯注，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":0.00196136},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.8,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.8,"rationale":"云端相册入诗，题旨明确，旧照怀人情事具体；意象统一但稍熟，结句直白少留白，当代题材有新意。","_cost":0.00614},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.0,"rationale":"云端、银屏入诗有当代感，怀旧主脑集中；三四句由同游到独对，转合清畅，结句留影不尽。然意象措辞多熟，“岁月还”略凑，警策不足。","_cost":0.0159408},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.3,"章法":5.9,"余味":4.3,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.400000000000006,"rationale":"云端、银屏点出当代经验具新意，但仍落入睹照思人的常见怀旧；意象妥帖欠精切，语言平实无诗眼，转结平直，末句直抒少留白。","_cost":0.00528665},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"此诗写深夜翻云端相册怀思旧友，主旨明确、情感真切，章法平顺、语言晓畅，融入当代数字生活经验，但意象平熟，结句直白少余韵，无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀人，当代经验入旧体而情事具体，'指下银屏岁月还'化科技语入诗自然。结句'更深独对旧时颜'以景收束、留白得当。惟'同游人不见''旧时颜'意象稍熟，中二句铺垫平直，整体稳而不奇。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写物是人非，'云间'双关略有巧思，当代经验入诗尚可；但情感落点仍是旧时人不见的常套，'银屏''旧时颜'语平，转结平直，结句虽以景收却近于说破，余味有限。","_cost":0.04032},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"以云端相册、指下银屏写入旧情，当代经验入诗较自然，主脑集中；章法完整而转稍平，意象偏概念，结句独对旧颜收束稳、余味不长。","_cost":0.025203308},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.8,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.2,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.15,"rationale":"将当代云端相册与划屏体验有效入诗，双关自然。起承转合流畅完整，情真意切；后半首落入物是人非的常见叹惋，结句直白点破，余味稍欠延宕。","_cost":0.00517275},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"云端入诗有新意但怀旧角度常见；数字意象偏实少情融；语言通顺乏诗眼；起承转合完整但转平；结句直收少留白。","_cost":0.0129375},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"云端存照、指下翻屏有效融入当代经验，转入人去影留，脉络清楚。结句以独对旧颜收情，未说尽离散缘由；但怀旧角度较熟，“岁月还”稍泛，缺少鲜明细节与警策之语。","_cost":0.03441},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"主脑清楚而旨趣常见,夜对旧颜尚可感。云屏能点题,意象未交融;语言通顺却多废字熟词,无诗眼。四句层进,转处平直。结句留人去之因,余味稍胜。当代入诗有效,套语偏密,无硬伤蹈袭,警句未立。","_cost":0.0450832},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀人，当代经验入诗，“云间”双关尚巧。后两句转结走“人面不知何处去”的常见路数。“人不见”“旧时颜”偏套，结句直陈独对，留白不足。","_cost":0.015148},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀人，触屏回忆与深夜独对相衔，转折清楚；但“岁月还”“旧时颜”较熟套，结句收束直白，余味稍弱。","_cost":0.007642}},"consensus":61.89,"final":61.89},{"key":"glm-5.3|云端相册|七律","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"浮生万象入云藏，指底轻翻岁月长。镜里朱颜能驻色，人间白发自添霜。屏中笑靥浑如昨，泉下孤坟久已荒。他日此身成旧照，凭谁掌上再端详。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.4,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.8,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.4,"rationale":"以云端相册贯串驻颜、悼亡与自我消逝，当代经验入诗自然；两联对照递进，末句设问有余响。朱颜、白发、添霜、孤坟稍熟，“能驻色”略涩。","_cost":0.009882},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"以云端相册写存殁之感,当代经验入诗有效,题旨集中。颈联'屏中笑靥/泉下孤坟'对照惊心,是全篇警策。惜颔颈两联皆作'像存人逝'对比,意近合掌,开合层次不足;'朱颜''白发霜'稍落陈套。结句以问宕开,人成旧照无人端详,余味悠长。","_cost":0.04018},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":9.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":95.5,"rationale":"本诗将当代经验‘云端相册’完美入诗。颔颈两联利用照片定格的影像与现实衰老、死亡作强烈对比，‘屏中笑靥’对‘泉下孤坟’极具情感冲击。尾联推及自身，余味深长，章法严密。","_cost":0.015734},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"云相册写记忆与死亡对照，题旨具体有主脑；朱颜白发孤坟等意象半陈，氛围统一但少精切；语言通顺缺诗眼；对比递进至问句收束，结有余味。","_cost":0.016808},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":94.25,"rationale":"由云端相册翻看引出生死对照与自省，情感集中；中二联今昔生死交织，颈联尤佳；尾联以问收束留白。当代题材化入自然，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.00460702},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.5,"rationale":"以云端相册写生死存殁，今物古悲交融，主脑聚焦。颈联'屏中笑靥浑如昨，泉下孤坟久已荒'今昔虚实对撞，最见功力。结句以问宕开，由人观照转为人被观照，余味深长。'浮生''朱颜''添霜'稍熟，但密度不高不伤全局。","_cost":0.00209096},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.6,"rationale":"云端相册入诗，立意新而脉络清，屏中笑靥与泉下孤坟对照有力。惜浮生、朱颜、白发等语稍熟，尾联设问留白，余味尚存。","_cost":0.012718},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"以云相册写生死记忆,当代经验入诗自然,朱颜/白发、笑靥/孤坟层层对映,尾联宕向自身一问而尽意不尽,聚焦有力。语言平稳少废字但诗眼不锐,颔联意象略熟。","_cost":0.0093948},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.6,"余味":8.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.3,"rationale":"以云端对照泉下，虚存实亡递进至自问，立意借当代经验翻新；中二联对举工稳，末句宕开以问留白，个别语象仍近熟套。","_cost":0.00637775},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.9,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.65,"rationale":"本诗借云端相册抒怀人逝岁之慨，章法层进圆融，结句宕开留余味，语言顺畅精准，意象妥帖唯稍熟，无硬伤、陈滥与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写悼亡，当代经验入旧体，熟题出新。颔颈两联皆今昔对照，结构略嫌同构；'朱颜''白发''孤坟'属悼亡常语但功能妥帖。尾联'此身成旧照，凭谁再端详'翻转视角、以问收束，言尽意不尽，为全篇警策。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.0,"rationale":"以云端相册切入，屏中不老与人间衰亡对照，尾联翻到自身成旧照、无人端详，立意有当代体验且收得住。惟中二联同构对比近合掌，层次未开；朱颜白发添霜等语陈熟，“镜里”亦欠精切。","_cost":0.05505},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.8,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.6,"余味":9.2,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.9,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字时代记忆与生死，立意新警、结句问留余味。‘屏中’‘泉下’联极佳。然首句稍空、‘镜’‘屏’意重，兼‘朱颜白发’略熟，故意境章法稍抑。当代语汇入诗自然，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.025663504},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.05,"rationale":"将现代云相册体验自然化入传统律体，毫无违和。中二联虚实相映、生死对照，层层推进；结句反观自身，设问宕开，引发普遍的数字存在共鸣，是当代经验入诗之佳构。","_cost":0.006915},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.8,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.5,"rationale":"以云端览照对照生老病死终问自身，主脑集中递进有层次；然朱颜霜发孤坟多套语，情景交融弱，情感泛论少实事。","_cost":0.0132803},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.6,"余味":7.8,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.65,"rationale":"由存照、衰老推进至悼亡与自问，层次递深；数字相册承载人去照存之悲，尾联尤切。朱颜、白发、添霜稍熟，“泉下孤坟”措辞欠精；结问有回响，但情意略显直露。","_cost":0.03636},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"借云相册写影像久于肉身，主脑清楚，然所悼之人与事不具体。屏笑对孤坟最切，朱颜白发等套象偏密。句法顺，中二联同构略平；结句及己设问，余味尚在而意已明。","_cost":0.030248},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.0,"rationale":"以云端相册写影像留存与肉身衰亡之对照，当代经验入诗有效。结联由观者转为被观者，翻出一层。中二联同为“影像/现实”对照，结构略显同构。“白发添霜”语意重复，“镜里”指镜头还是镜子略有歧义。朱颜、孤坟属常见意象。","_cost":0.01872},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"由云端相册写到身后谁人翻看，生死之思有当代切口。屏中笑靥与泉下孤坟相映有力，结句设问留有余味；「浮生万象」「白发添霜」稍嫌熟套。","_cost":0.008202}},"consensus":80.42,"final":80.42},{"key":"glm-5.3|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"铁翼裁云夜正长，凭窗俯瞰入苍茫。始知银汉非天上，散作人间万点光。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.3,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.7,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.8,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰翻转银河意象，当代经验入诗自然。铁翼裁云有力度，末二句转结鲜明；但“夜正长”“苍茫”“万点光”稍熟，结意略说尽。","_cost":0.005914},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.0,"rationale":"以当代夜航经验翻'银汉'旧典，转句陡起、结以景收，言尽意不尽，章法完足。'铁翼裁云'有炼字之功；惟'入苍茫'近凑韵套语，'凭窗俯瞰'与题重复稍费字，灯光如星之喻亦非全新，故未臻上乘。","_cost":0.0361},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"此诗以当代夜航经验入诗，起承平稳，转结出色。后两句化仰视银河为俯视万家灯火，想象瑰丽，画面壮阔。唯前两句字词略熟，情志未入深微，然整体结构完整，巧思可喜。","_cost":0.015262},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.5,"rationale":"夜航见灯如星汉的反转明确具体，然此构思已常见。铁翼裁云入苍茫到万点光成境统一，象多熟套。裁字稍炼余平实。绝句起承转换分明。结句说破题意少留白。末联可摘，夜航经验入诗有效。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.016944},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰将天上银河与人间灯火倒置，立意有发现；后两句精警，画面统一。唯“始知”略露说理，转结稍平，余味略减。","_cost":0.011058432},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰翻转银河意象，将天上银汉散作人间灯火，熟题翻出新境，主脑集中。'始知'一转自然有力，结句宕开而不说破，余味悠长。'铁翼裁云'炼字见功且切合现代经验。整体意象统一，起承转合完整，唯'苍茫''万点光'稍平熟，略减语言分。","_cost":0.00183776},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"夜航视角明确，铁翼裁云有现代感；转结以银河落人间，巧而能收。但苍茫等语稍泛，意旨说破，余味有限。","_cost":0.010222},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰之当代经验入七绝而不违和，转结处将银汉倒置于人间灯火，视角翻转有新意，结句以景收束余韵足。然「苍茫」「银汉」等语偏熟，「夜正长」略凑，首二句铺垫平直，炼字未见奇警，整体新而不峻。","_cost":0.0111882},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.6,"余味":6.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"夜航视角翻银汉为万家灯火，当代经验入诗自然，起承转合完整、结以景收有余韵；但属熟路翻新，铁翼等语稍直，未臻精锤。","_cost":0.00955175},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"此作写夜航俯瞰体验，以银汉喻人间灯火，立意新巧，起承转合圆合，“裁”字炼得生动，融当代飞行经验入诗有新意；唯结句稍直白，部分意象略熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰翻出'银汉在人间'之新境，当代飞行经验化入古典语汇自然妥帖。'裁'字见炼，后二句因果翻转成篇中警策，结句以景收束、言尽意远。唯'苍茫''万点光'稍近熟套，整体取象精切、脉络贯通。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰灯火如星河，当代经验入诗尚顺，然「银河落人间」之喻已属常见翻转。「裁云」稍见炼字，「夜正长」「入苍茫」偏凑韵填句，承句复述题目。转结清楚但「始知」说破，结句成图而少延宕。","_cost":0.04477},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.75,"rationale":"立意翻新银河，聚焦；意境意象稍空、理趣胜情；语言‘裁’‘散’精练；章法转结出色；结句以景结情，灯火璀璨而意未尽。警句佳，当代经验化古出新，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.030906424},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.35,"rationale":"现代夜航经验入诗熨帖自然，“铁翼裁云”起句劲健。后两句俯仰翻转，将万家灯火化作人间星汉，章法一气贯通。唯“银汉落人间”构思在同题中略熟，结语稍欠留白。","_cost":0.00521475},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"银汉落人间立意明晰然同类多；起承转合完整；裁散稍振而苍茫泛，景情交融浅，结句直点无留白。","_cost":0.013415},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"夜航灯火化作人间银汉，情景集中，翻转有效但并非罕见。“裁”字有力，“夜正长”略泛，次句偏于交代。转结紧密，末句以光景收束，尚有余韵，题意则已点明。","_cost":0.03362},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"夜航俯视、银汉落为人间灯火，题旨集中，转结清楚。然星灯之喻已近熟套：苍茫、万点光偏陈，俯瞰、始知近于说明，结句把意说满，余味不长。裁云较劲，尾联可摘；当代经验入诗有效，未见硬伤或整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.0136672},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰这一当代经验入诗,转结翻出“银汉在人间”一层,有巧思,但“灯火如星河”的构想较常见。“裁”字有力,“凭窗俯瞰入苍茫”偏平直。结句把喻意落实,稍有说破之嫌。","_cost":0.016368},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"由夜航视角将地上灯火看作银汉，转折明快，意象统一。“裁云”有力度，但“苍茫”“万点光”稍泛；结句点明比喻，余味略浅。","_cost":0.007014}},"consensus":76.21,"final":76.21},{"key":"glm-5.3|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"凌霄铁翼剪苍茫，俯瞰尘寰夜未央。灯火千城明似昼，星河一带冷于霜。云涛漫卷群峰没，月镜高悬万壑凉。却笑此身天外客，凭窗遥认旧家乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.4,"意境":7.1,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.3,"余味":6.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.44999999999999,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰寄托乡思，主脑明确，当代视角略有新意。云涛、月镜等营造高寒境界，但多属熟语；中二联铺景有层次，末联转情自然，“旧家乡”稍直且语意略赘。","_cost":0.00558},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"以夜航入诗有当代经验,颔联灯火与星河明暗冷暖对照见巧思。惟'苍茫''夜未央''云涛''月镜'等取象偏熟,颈联夜间见'群峰没'略泛。尾联由天外客转认旧乡,收束稳而思路常见,余味尚可未至悠远。","_cost":0.0343},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"夜航有效将现代经验入诗，章法严密，中二联视域宏阔，冷暖对比佳。然意象词汇多熟语，结句“认旧家乡”直白，稍欠余味。","_cost":0.015256},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.0,"rationale":"夜航使当代经验入诗，颔联灯火/星河冷暖对照最醒目。中二联皆铺俯瞰之景，开合不足。尘寰、云涛漫卷、月镜高悬等套语较密。结句点破家乡，收得住而少留白。","_cost":0.03052},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰题材现代，意象组合富有画面，但中二联平行写景缺层次，尾联点题直白，余味不足；偶有对比佳联但仍含套语。","_cost":0.006707008},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验入诗，视角统一，中二联灯火星河、云涛月壑对仗工稳有层次，'剪苍茫''冷于霜'炼字见力。尾联转出身世之叹收束自然，但'遥认旧家乡'意脉偏熟，'月镜高悬'稍落陈套，结句直白略欠宕开。","_cost":0.00252936},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.6,"rationale":"夜航视角鲜明，铁翼凌空有现代感；中二联明冷相映，篇脉完整。然灯火星河、云涛月镜等象偏熟，尾联天外客、旧家乡点意稍直，余韵未深。","_cost":0.012606},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写乡愁，现代经验入律而不生硬，视角较新。中二联天地对举、光影寒暖成境，『剪』字见炼。结联转入乡关，情真但落熟路，收束略直。尘寰、未央、星河、月镜、万壑等套象偏密，警句有而锤炼未至化境。","_cost":0.0120918},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.7,"rationale":"铁翼剪苍茫具现代机窗视角，灯火星河对举成境；然终归遥认旧乡意旨常见，云涛月镜等语偏熟，尾句直收少余韵。","_cost":0.00882625},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"此作写夜航俯瞰触生乡思，题旨明晰，意象谐和，炼字稳顺，章法连贯，唯抒情偏熟，部分意象较常，结句直白少余韵，民航视角略有新意，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.5,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写乡愁，视角新而情真。颔联冷暖对举、颈联云月开合皆佳，'剪'字见眼。尾联自嘲天外客遥认故乡，收束有情致，唯'旧家乡'稍直白。灯火明似昼意象略熟。当代经验入传统格律自然有效。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰以当代经验入诗，颔联灯火与星河冷暖对照尚可；但颈联云涛月镜万壑凉皆熟套，中二联同写俯景而无开合，结句直言认家乡稍说破，余味有限。","_cost":0.04597},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"起笔“剪苍茫”有势，铁翼俯瞰、灯火星河开现代夜航之境；中二联气象开阔而意象稍常见，尾联以天外客反认旧家乡，情真味永。结构平稳，转折略直。","_cost":0.031192382},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.8,"章法":5.8,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.95,"rationale":"切入现代夜航经验，颔联明暗冷暖对照颇工。中二联景物层次稍显重叠，月镜万壑略落陈套；结句点染乡思平稳切题，但径直说破，余味稍显不足。","_cost":0.0052245},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":4.8,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.6,"rationale":"铁翼夜航收束思乡有主脑，然中二联铺景重复，灯火星河月镜皆常见，语言直白，结句点破少留白。","_cost":0.0137775},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"夜航转入乡思，主脑明确而发现有限；城灯与星河的明冷对照较鲜明。中二联铺景稍复，“凌霄”“云涛”“月镜”偏熟。尾联由景及人自然，结句收稳但乡思点得较明。","_cost":0.04135},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"夜航有当代视点,情志仍是客中认乡常套。铁翼、云涛可观,明似昼、冷于霜、月镜等套语偏密。中二联皆铺景,开合不足;结句点明家乡,余味有限。","_cost":0.014952},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.75,"rationale":"以夜航入诗有当代经验，颔联城灯与星河冷暖对照尚佳。颈联仍是写景，与颔联同质，层次平。苍茫、尘寰、云涛、万壑等套语较密。尾联思乡收束直白，“旧家乡”语意稍复。","_cost":0.020008},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.8,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.65,"rationale":"夜航视角使城灯与星河的冷暖对照颇有画面感，但中二联多铺陈大景，乡思至尾方显。结句点明家乡，收束稳而留白不足；云涛、月镜等语稍显陈熟。","_cost":0.0101}},"consensus":62.75,"final":62.75},{"key":"glm-5.3|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"万里相连笑语迎，灯前白发两分明。更深话尽迟挥手，屏暗翻教顾影惊。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.10000000000001,"rationale":"以视频相聚写万里亲情与衰老惊觉，情事具体。由笑语、白发至挥手屏暗，层层转冷；结句借暗屏顾影蓦然收束，余味深。“两分明”略显拗涩。","_cost":0.005962},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"以视频通话写亲情别绪,当代经验入诗自然。'灯前白发两分明'情事具体,结句屏暗成镜、顾影自惊,翻出老境与孤影双重意味,言尽意不尽,为全篇警策。起承稍平,'笑语''灯前'略近熟语,然转结有力,一气贯注。","_cost":0.02816},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.5,"rationale":"巧妙将现代视频通话入诗，情感真挚。从'迟挥手'的不舍，到结句'屏暗'后突如其来的孤寂感，起承转合自然流畅，现代经验与古典诗词完美融合，极具时代共鸣与悠长余味。","_cost":0.016664},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"视频写远隔白发，情事具体有主脑。首句平弱略白，万里白发更深偏常见。迟挥手转屏暗顾影，章法干净、结句有余味。当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.022888},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.8,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.1,"rationale":"视频通话题材有当代感，以灯前白发细节切入，真切入微。转结由热转冷，屏暗顾影留白耐味，章法完整。炼字“惊”为诗眼，唯“翻教”稍露文语但无硬伤。","_cost":0.00617848},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"视频通话写亲情，熟题新境。'屏暗翻教顾影惊'以熄屏后顾影收束，由团聚骤转孤清，言尽意不尽，转结俱佳。'灯前白发两分明'融情于象。'万里'稍熟，'迟挥手'炼字见功。当代经验入旧体自然无痕。","_cost":0.00214476},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.6,"rationale":"以深夜视频写亲情思念，灯前白发与屏暗顾影形成明暗反差，当代经验入诗自然。起承转合完整，结句有留白。个别语词稍泛，语言未臻精警。","_cost":0.007886},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"以视频通话写亲情乡愁,当代经验入旧体而自然。'迟挥手'细节真切,结句屏暗见影、顾影自惊,由欢聚跌入孤寂,宕开有余味。'灯前白发'稍熟,前两联意象略常,然整体景情交融、转结有力。","_cost":0.0052188},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.9,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.4,"rationale":"以视频写衰老与牵挂，灯前白发与屏暗顾影光影呼应，迟挥手见深情，结句以惊字宕开，余味不尽，当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.00673965},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.0,"rationale":"此作撷取深夜与远方亲人视频的日常场景，情感真挚，章法圆顺，结句以屏暗顾影的细节留白余韵悠长，语言妥帖，仅开篇表述稍熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"以视频通话写游子与白发的隔屏相望，当代经验入旧体而不生硬，情事具体真挚。'两分明'见牵挂，'迟挥手'细节动人；结句屏暗顾影，由对面收回自身，以景结情，怅然有余味。'白发''更深'稍熟，语言通篇稳而诗眼略欠更警策处。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"视频通话入诗而不觉硌生,'白发两分明'写双方共老,结句屏暗成镜、顾影自惊,由对方之老翻见己身之老,转结一体、余味延宕。首句'笑语迎'稍泛,整体凝炼贴切,当代经验化入有效。","_cost":0.05133},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.75,"rationale":"视频通话入诗，起承转合绵密；“屏暗翻教顾影惊”化古出新，以象结情，余味深长。首句稍直白，“万里相连”略平，故语言、立意未至极高。","_cost":0.027405022},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"切入当代视频通话场景，真切动人。前两句写会聚之温与岁月之慨，转结极佳，以手机黑屏映照落寞孤独，现代体验化入古典诗境，毫无滞涩，余味悠长。","_cost":0.0042615},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.3,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.15,"rationale":"视频通话写衰老与离别，白发互见主脑清晰；接通对看惜别独惊层次分明，末句屏暗顾影宕开留白，语言通顺但前半偏白。","_cost":0.01356175},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.85,"rationale":"以两端白发、迟迟挥手写远隔之情，屏幕由相连媒介变为自照之镜，转结有力；末句点“惊”而未道尽缘由，余味可寻。“笑语迎”稍泛，“两分明”略显生硬。","_cost":0.03536},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"话尽屏暗、顾影一惊,情事具体,然孤寂仍是常情。意象成境,万里白发更深偏熟。语言顺畅,诗眼只在惊字,首句偏率。白发与顾影呼应,章法清楚。结句不说破,余味最好。无硬伤,未见整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.0404112},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"以视频通话写两地亲情。「两分明」兼写双方白发,含蓄见岁月。结句抓住屏幕熄灭后映出自身的瞬间,以影惊收束,当代经验入诗而不露痕迹,余味深长。首句「笑语迎」稍平套,第三句承多于转。","_cost":0.015112},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"视频相见与屏暗顾影前后相照，由笑语转入独处，结句留下衰老与离情的余味。“白发两分明”稍显拗口，起句亦较平常。","_cost":0.008052}},"consensus":81.84,"final":81.84},{"key":"glm-5.3|社区食堂|七律","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"里巷新开小食堂，晨炊一缕韭菘香。邻翁结伴扶筇至，笑靥先融两鬓霜。昔日空巢嫌昼永，今朝满座话家常。人言此地无珍味，几盏灯温岁月长。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.4,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.89999999999999,"rationale":"以社区食堂映照空巢老人境遇，情事具体，今昔转折清楚。炊香、扶筇、灯盏相互照应，结句温厚有余韵；“两鬓霜”“岁月长”稍熟。","_cost":0.005148},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"以社区食堂写空巢老人今昔之变，题材当代、情事具体。'笑靥先融两鬓霜'、结句'灯温'炼字见巧，宕开一笔有余温。惜中二联对仗欠工整、'话家常'等语稍平熟，颈联转折略直白，整体温厚而未臻警拔。","_cost":0.04753},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.75,"rationale":"题材切入当代空巢现象，立意真挚且不生硬。颔联‘融’字生动，颈联开合自然。尾联‘几盏灯温岁月长’化寻常为深情，以‘温’字作眼，余味悠长，是当代经验入诗的佳作。","_cost":0.022118},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"食堂暖空巢，题旨清而角度常见。韭菘香、灯温岁月有实感，扶筇霜鬓话家常偏套。起句过白，文白夹杂。中联昔今对比平直。尾联未说破，略有余味。当代事象入律可记。","_cost":0.02006},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"主题真实具体，聚焦空巢老人，生活意象有温度，结句以灯温岁月收束有余味。用词如“两鬓霜”“岁月长”略熟，出新有限。","_cost":0.00822184},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"以社区食堂写空巢养老之暖，当代经验入诗自然。'笑靥先融两鬓霜'景情交融，结句'几盏灯温岁月长'以景结情、言尽意远。中二联今昔开合有层次，唯'话家常'等稍平，整体锤炼尚有余地。","_cost":0.00226396},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.35,"rationale":"题旨切当代社区养老场景，烟火细节可感，今昔对照分明。但温情表达稍熟，结句略直，余味有限。","_cost":0.009134},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"社区食堂写空巢老人,题旨切实有当代体温,今昔对比使情意落地;'笑靥先融两鬓霜'炼字见巧,结句'灯温岁月长'以景结情有余韵。惜颈联对比略平直,'话家常'稍熟,中二联开合欠变化,整体稳而新境未深。","_cost":0.00598288},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.55,"rationale":"以社区食堂写空巢温暖，空巢/满座对比聚焦，真挚具体但角度常见；章法层次清晰转结自然，末句以灯温收具余味，语言平顺少锤炼。","_cost":0.01077925},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.2,"rationale":"此作写社区食堂的民生暖意，具象真切，章法顺畅，炼字见巧，结句有余韵；唯部分意象偏熟，整体平妥贴实，紧贴当代日常。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"社区食堂题材切中当代养老民生，昔空巢今满座对比具体，主脑清晰。'笑靥先融两鬓霜'炼字见巧，为全诗警句。尾联以灯温收束有留白但'岁月长'稍熟。颈联今昔开合得法，脉络贯通；意象妥帖而常见，'话家常''岁月长'略涉套语，整体情真意足。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗切中当代空巢老人经验，情事具体，脉络完整。“笑靧先融两鬓霜”较见炼字，中二联昔今对比稍平直。结句“灯温岁月长”有温度但“岁月长”偏泛，两鬓霜、话家常等语略陈熟。","_cost":0.05155},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"主题写食堂慰空巢老人，旨明而角度常见；韭菘香、灯温岁月等象稍新，霜鬓、空巢略熟；语言通顺有生硬处；起承转合完整、中二联有开合但转稍平；结句以景留白。当代经验入诗，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.038777081},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.6,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"切中当代老年空巢之痛，烟火气与人情味交融。颔联‘笑靥先融’与尾联‘灯温岁月’造语温润，章法开阖自然，当代生活入律贴合无隔阂。","_cost":0.00405375},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.6,"意境":4.4,"语言":5.2,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.2,"rationale":"空巢对满座主脑清晰具时代温情；然意象多常见套语，笑靥饰翁、灯温岁月欠锤炼；章法完整而转折直陈，结句直言温情少留白。","_cost":0.0182608},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"以食堂写老人由孤寂到相聚，情事具体，当代题材入诗自然。韭菘香与灯温相应，结句以景含情。今昔对照清楚但稍直，“笑靥融霜”略显雕饰，“两鬓霜”等语较熟。","_cost":0.04129},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"题旨清楚，空巢得伴可感，然近暖闻常调，少独到发现。韭菘香、融霜较精，全篇仍多平叙。颈联对举清楚，转折不险。结句灯温点明主旨，余味有限。当代食堂入诗自然，无典故硬伤。","_cost":0.017384},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"当代题材入诗，空巢与满座对照切中老龄社会，情事可感。'笑靥融霜'稍见炼意，其余语言平实。结以'无珍味'反跌、灯温收束，稳当而略显熟套。'话家常''岁月长'偏俗，全篇温情有余，深度不足。","_cost":0.01666},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"以韭菘香、扶筇老翁写食堂暖意，昔今对照贯通；结句以灯收情，留有余温。“两鬓霜”“岁月长”稍熟，题旨明朗而发现尚不深。","_cost":0.008258}},"consensus":69.76,"final":69.76},{"key":"glm-5.3|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"长街新柳试鹅黄，忽讶枝头挂药囊。应是东君知树病，一针输与满城香。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.7,"章法":8.7,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.6,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.15,"rationale":"由树木输液生发东君施针的春意，观察具体，构思新巧。四句见景、惊疑、转想、宕开，脉络明快；“鹅黄”“东君”稍熟，结句明丽而略说满。","_cost":0.00622},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"以城市树木输营养液的当代景观入诗,熟境翻新。起承写景纪实,转句以东君拟人巧设问,结句'一针输与满城香'双关'输液'与'输送',化俗为雅,警而有味。'试鹅黄''东君'略见套语,微扣陈滥;结句稍近说破,余味略减。","_cost":0.03824},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"本诗巧妙将城市给树打吊瓶的现代现象入诗，以“东君治病”的奇思化俗为雅。起承转合圆融，一“输”字双关输液与赐予，结句荡开至满城春色。当代生活经验入诗极自然，无生硬之感。","_cost":0.028626},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"吊瓶翻作东君疗树，主脑集中而情偏轻俏，属熟题小翻。鹅黄、东君、满城香套语较密，药囊、输与稍活。起承转合稳，结句把因果说破，余韵短。","_cost":0.029658},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.6,"rationale":"当代树挂吊瓶入诗，借东君翻出巧思，主脑集中；转结由实入虚见章法。语言“试”“输”有亮点，但“忽讶”“应是”稍白，意境偏巧欠深厚，“满城香”略陈。","_cost":0.01572032},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"都市护树吊瓶入诗，化俗为雅，熟题翻新。由鹅黄新柳忽见药囊，转以东君知病作想，结以一针输香满城，构想奇巧。起承转合完整，'输'字紧扣吊瓶而有诗眼之妙。结句稍直露，'东君'略熟，整体清新可喜。","_cost":0.00255916},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.35,"rationale":"以城市护树入诗，新柳起、药囊承、东君转、满城香结，构思灵巧，“输”字见趣。惜情志较浅，末句稍泛，语势偏直。","_cost":0.014106},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"以行道树输营养液之当代经验入诗，翻作东君医树之趣，题新而旨明。'输'字双关输液与输与，为诗眼；结句由一针宕开至满城香，言尽意不尽。起承转合紧凑，转结尤佳。惜'东君''鹅黄'稍落熟套，通篇巧思有余而深情稍薄，故立意未臻上乘。","_cost":0.0109548},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.65,"rationale":"以输液治树切入翻新咏柳旧题，物象奇而贴切；起承转合分明，试、输炼字见功，结句俏收略显直露。","_cost":0.00828065},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"此诗捕捉春日街树挂输液袋的日常小景，以春神疗树的巧思翻新春柳题材，起承转合顺畅，用语鲜活，唯结句稍直，部分意象偏熟。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"以城市行道树挂吊瓶入诗，当代经验化用自然，东君医树之想落想奇巧；'输'字双关输液与赠予，为全篇诗眼。起承转合完整，结句俏皮有余韵。惟意境止于巧思层面，情意稍浅，东君意象略熟。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"取当代街树输液入诗，翻出东君医树、一针输香之奇想，题意集中。起句鹅黄、东君稍熟套，第三句转合自然，结句巧用双关但意象直陈，余味略浅。","_cost":0.04006},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"取树木挂吊瓶之当代经验，借东君输液奇想，构思新巧；章法完整，‘输’字见炼。然情志偏巧浅，‘鹅黄’‘满城香’略熟，结句说尽，余味不长。","_cost":0.037756664},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.3,"rationale":"将当代园林树木输液的日常景观自然入诗。转结灵动，以“一针输与”扣题又宕开至春意，化俗为雅。起句略平，柳树结以“香”字稍显泛化，整体流转谐趣。","_cost":0.005589},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"春柳旧题缀入行道树吊瓶，当代经验翻新，主脑集中；起讶转释脉络清，然意象单薄情深不足，结句夸饰说破留白有限。","_cost":0.01121555},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"以树木输液接通东君施春，取材新鲜，转结灵巧；“输”字兼顾实景与想象。末句“满城香”稍泛，收意偏满，情志深度与余韵有限。","_cost":0.04025},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"当代街树挂瓶入诗,焦点清楚,但情只在巧思。药囊一象颇切,鹅黄东君满城香皆熟,意与象未紧合。输字是眼。脉络顺而转折平,结句把喻意说尽。","_cost":0.0317392},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.5,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶这一当代见闻入诗,借东君施针作谐趣翻转,角度新巧。起句'试鹅黄'较常见。转结构思灵动,但'满城香'稍嫌圆满说尽。柳本无香,逻辑略有松动,整体轻巧而不深。","_cost":0.015144},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"街树吊瓶与新柳春色相碰，取材新鲜；由惊讶转入东君施针，脉络清楚。“一针输与”有巧思，但“东君”“满城香”稍熟，结句把情意说得较满，余味有限。","_cost":0.0068}},"consensus":72.54,"final":72.54},{"key":"glm-5.3|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"夹道春杨半带伤，谁悬玉盏补琼浆。长街尽列扶衰客，点滴浑如续命方。本在云根眠岁月，翻教闹市困星霜。他时饮罢瓶中液，会报清阴一巷凉。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.6,"警句":2.2,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.3,"rationale":"吊瓶疗树入诗，题材新鲜，怜惜与期盼贯穿始终。颔联形象，章法顺畅；“玉盏琼浆”“云根星霜”稍显饰辞，结句稳妥但报恩之意略说尽。","_cost":0.006994},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"当代街景入诗,咏移栽输液之树而寄悯物之情,题材新而主脑分明。玉盏琼浆、扶衰客设喻贴切,颈联云根闹市今昔对照最见开合。尾联许诺报以清阴,收得温厚但稍说尽。个别语如'续命方'近直白,整体炼字有力少斧凿。","_cost":0.04267},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.5,"rationale":"巧妙将当代都市现象（树挂吊瓶）入诗，点滴双关，颈联对比自然与喧嚣，立意章法皆佳。唯结句“报清阴”过于直白，缺乏留白余味，“玉盏”比拟塑料瓶亦略显违和。","_cost":0.025712},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"吊瓶救树拟人报恩，主脑集中场景可感，角度常见。玉盏琼浆星霜清阴套语偏密。颈联出身与困市有层次，结句直说会报少留白。当代事象入律算出新。","_cost":0.018662},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶写城市移栽之痛，拟人贴切，情感具体。中二联虚实开合，转结有力。尾联以清阴报恩收束，留有余味。语言偶有熟套，但整体精炼，当代经验入诗见新意。","_cost":0.00521796},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.75,"rationale":"以城市行道树输营养液的当代实景入诗，将树拟作扶衰之客，立意翻新而情意恳挚。首联设问起势，颔联铺承，颈联'云根眠岁月'与'闹市困星霜'开合有力，为全篇警联。结句以'清阴一巷凉'许诺报答，以景结情，余味悠长。琼浆、星霜略熟，然密度低不伤整体。","_cost":0.00292816},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.7,"意境":6.4,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.3,"余味":6.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.95,"rationale":"选题入时，以医事喻街树，脉络清楚，颈联有慨。然玉盏琼浆等语稍熟，末句报荫意旨略直，余味有限。","_cost":0.015106},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"以行道树输液入律，题新而主脑集中；病树、续命、报阴一线贯通。惜玉盏琼浆略隔，云根生凑，结句报恩说意稍直，余韵未深。","_cost":0.0198192},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.4,"余味":6.9,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.8,"rationale":"以输液喻街杨扶衰客，新颖真切；章法起承转合分明，唯玉盏美化稍浮，结句许报直陈留白不足","_cost":0.01405225},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"取当代都市行道树挂吊瓶题材入诗，立意真切集中，拟人新巧，章法开合自然，中二联颇具巧思，唯结句偏直白，个别喻象稍隔，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.5,"rationale":"以输液吊瓶写城市护树，当代经验入诗，视角新颖，情真有主脑。颈联'云根'与'闹市'对开见转折之力，颔联'扶衰客''续命方'比喻精切为佳联。惟'琼浆''星霜'稍熟，尾联'会报清阴'收束略实，余味稍减。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"取街树输液之当代景入律，主脑清晰，颈联云根闹市对照有寄托，'点滴'双关见巧。惟颔联与首联意近，玉盏琼浆稍藻饰，'瓶中液'欠雅，尾联报答之意说得过明，余味略薄。","_cost":0.05919},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"以街树挂吊瓶如病患输液入诗，当代经验新颖，聚焦明确；中二联由现状转入本源，结构完整；然“瓶中液”等语略质直，结句“报清阴”稍落常套，余味不足。","_cost":0.032484566},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.25,"rationale":"敏锐摄取当代都市树木输液之景。颈联拓开时空，由物及人寄寓生存困顿，沉郁有致。当代经验入诗自然顺畅。唯首联修辞略显甜美堆砌，结句直接言志，余韵稍平。","_cost":0.00567225},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"以行道树输液为题材新切，扶衰客喻体贯穿，颈联翻出山林与闹市之叹；然玉盏琼浆过饰，瓶中液失炼，尾联许愿直白无留白。","_cost":0.01129825},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"吊瓶入诗有新意，怜树之情具体；“玉盏”“琼浆”略显浮饰，“云根眠岁月”虚泛。由见伤、怜困转向报阴，脉络完整；结句虽有凉意，报恩之旨已说透。","_cost":0.04972},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.8,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.1,"rationale":"街树挂瓶为当代新题,情志集中。前四句医象复沓,颈联方转。玉盏琼浆、星霜、清阴偏套,尾联直说报答,余味偏弱。点滴双关尚可。","_cost":0.019328},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶这一当代街景入诗,颈联由病树转到移栽之困,暗含对城市移植大树的反思,是全诗亮点。颔联「点滴」「续命」较直白,「玉盏」「琼浆」偏套语。结句以清阴相报收束,温厚稳当,但冲淡了颈联的批判,余味有限。","_cost":0.017016},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"以吊瓶写春树，病客之喻具体，终归一巷清阴，脉络完整；“琼浆”“星霜”偏熟，“扶衰客”稍拗，结句报凉说得较尽。","_cost":0.010144}},"consensus":72.28,"final":72.28},{"key":"glm-5.3|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"彻夜云仓灯火明，声声扫码过三更。千箱各有天涯梦，散作长车万里行。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.7,"rationale":"以夜间物流写人间奔赴，主脑清楚，扫码、云仓颇具时代感。后二句由箱及梦，转结顺畅；但“天涯梦”“万里行”稍熟，“散作长车”搭配略涩，结句偏直。","_cost":0.005772},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"以电商云仓夜班入诗,当代经验有效熟化,题旨集中。前二句实写灯火扫码,三句拟包裹为'天涯梦'翻出新意,转得巧;结句散作长车宕开有余韵。惟'灯火明''三更''万里行'措语稍熟,炼字未见奇警,整体清顺而力度中上。","_cost":0.02765},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.75,"rationale":"当代经验“云仓扫码”入诗极自然。起承写实，转句“千箱各有天涯梦”赋予寻常包裹诗意，结句“散作长车万里行”从逼仄仓库宕开至辽阔空间，境界大开。起承转合严密，立意新巧，余味不绝。","_cost":0.02707},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"物流夜扫有具体情事，千箱天涯梦略翻新，然发现不深。意象妥帖而灯火三更万里偏熟。语言通顺少锤炼。起承转合完整，转结较平。结句收束有象而余味有限。","_cost":0.012596},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"现代物流题材有发现，以“天涯梦”为诗眼，转结由实入虚。意象稍直白，结句“万里行”略点明但仍有延宕。","_cost":0.00337876},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"深夜物流仓储入诗，当代经验有效转化，题旨聚焦不散。'千箱各有天涯梦'将包裹拟人寄梦，转句翻出新境，为诗眼。结句以长车万里宕开，景结情留，余味悠长。起承转合一气贯注，唯'灯火明''万里行'稍熟，整体精炼自然。","_cost":0.00219876},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.3,"rationale":"以云仓扫码入诗，夜班灯火与三更声景具体；由千箱转天涯梦，再散长车，脉络清而有远势。惜天涯、万里略熟，新词稍直。","_cost":0.00798},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"以现代物流入诗，视角新鲜。「千箱各有天涯梦」拟人见情，警拔动人；结句散作长车，以景宕开有余味。唯「声声扫码」稍近口语，「天涯」「万里」略熟，整体意象统一、转结得力。","_cost":0.0091992},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.3,"意境":6.2,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.9,"余味":7.1,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.15,"rationale":"云仓扫码切入当代物流，千箱赋梦、散作长车，主脑清晰翻出新境；章法起承转合贯注。语言扫码入诗自然，唯灯火明略平，意象声光直陈，交融未深。","_cost":0.00659725},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"此诗聚焦当代云仓夜发场景，立意新颖贴实，起承转合顺畅，新意象入诗自然，“千箱寄梦”构思见巧，结句有延展余韵，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫入诗，当代物流经验化得自然，题材新而立意不猎奇。'千箱各有天涯梦'赋物以情，是全篇主脑；结句'散作长车万里行'以景收束、宕开有余味。起承平叙铺垫稍稳，'灯火明''天涯'略见熟语，整体气脉贯通，转结有力。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"以电商云仓夜班入诗，题材当代而不猎奇，“千箱各有天涯梦”赋物以情为全篇亮点。然情感止于旁观，无劳作者之切身；“彻夜”与“过三更”意重，“灯火明”“万里行”属熟语。结句以长车宕开尚有余地，惟收束偏平。","_cost":0.05117},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"以云仓、扫码写夜忙，题材新鲜；“千箱各有天涯梦”翻新出彩。然“散作长车”措辞稍滞，结以“万里行”稍落套语，余味平平。","_cost":0.034149386},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.6,"rationale":"当代物流题材入诗自然无隔。起承由视听深入夜仓细节；转结将千箱包裹赋以“天涯梦”，复随长车散向万里，由内及外、以虚带实，脉络畅达且气象开阔。","_cost":0.00516225},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"云仓扫码切入当代夜劳，千箱赋梦小有新意；转合分明，然首尾直述，灯火三更万里偏熟，结句收尽少余味。","_cost":0.01101725},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"灯火与扫码声切入仓储日常，第三句赋箱以梦，由仓内转向远途，转合清楚。“散作长车”搭配稍涩，“天涯梦”“万里行”较熟，结尾有行进感而余韵有限。","_cost":0.03886},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"夜班云仓、扫码入诗,主脑清楚,然「天涯梦」情泛。起承同写彻夜,转结由箱入车尚顺。「散作」见炼,三更万里为套。结句未说破,余味有限。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0261776},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"写物流夜仓,是当代经验入诗。转句赋予千箱「天涯梦」,把扫码劳作升华为远方想象,是全篇亮点。「散作」二字有力,结句宕开成万里之势。不足在于起承「灯火明」「过三更」较常见,劳动者也未入笔,情志略显浮泛。","_cost":0.013868},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"夜灯与扫码声写出云仓劳作，转由千箱写向远方，脉络清楚且取材新鲜；“天涯梦”“万里行”稍泛，“散作长车”语意略涩，结句收束偏直。","_cost":0.008102}},"consensus":72.88,"final":72.88},{"key":"glm-5.3|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"灯河一道贯云仓，人静犹闻扫码忙。铁带无声驰百箧，红光乍闪递遐方。柜间倦眼熬更漏，屏上归心逐雁行。晓笛催车穿雾去，遥怜万户拆封香。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"unknown"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.4,"余味":7.2,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.9,"rationale":"以夜间云仓劳作为主脑，物流科技与工人归心交织，题材鲜活。灯河、铁带、红光递进有序，晓车宕开至万户；“拆封香”稍显刻意，“更漏”“雁行”略熟。","_cost":0.005912},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"以物流云仓夜班入诗,当代经验具体可感,尾句宕开至万户拆封,以他人之乐收己之劳,余味颇佳。惟颈联'更漏''雁行'系旧套语,与扫码、屏幕等新象略有隔膜;'驰百箧'稍见凑字。章法完整,转结有变,整体中上。","_cost":0.03266},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.5,"rationale":"当代题材入诗的佳作。“扫码、铁带、红光”等现代意象自然融入律体。颈联由物及人写夜班辛劳，结句“遥怜万户拆封香”宕开一笔，以暖意收束，升华主题，极富人情味与余韵。","_cost":0.024416},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"写云仓夜班与晨送，主脑清楚，扫码铁带红光等当代经验入诗，然“劳动者托举万家”角度常见。颔联较有画面，颈联更漏雁行套语密。章法夜起晓收尚贯。结句遥怜说破，拆封香略留象。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.033318},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"现代物流题材较新，中二联意象鲜活，章法完整；语言偶有熟套，结句稍点破但拆封香有延宕。","_cost":0.0156572064},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"以云仓夜班入诗，当代经验有效入古典形式，题旨新颖聚焦。灯河、铁带、红光与更漏、雁行交融，氛围统一。颈联倦眼与归心对举见人情，尾联宕开遥想拆封者，言尽意不尽。个别措辞如'递遐方'稍硬，'雁行'略带熟套。","_cost":0.00243116},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.1,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.60000000000001,"rationale":"以云仓扫码入七律，题材新而情事具体；灯河、红光、晓笛等意象与劳倦、归心相融；语言稳健，唯‘扫码’稍直、‘拆封香’略生；起承转合清晰，结句有暖意而稍露。","_cost":0.01789},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫入律，题材新而主线清，由机声到人倦、由晓发到万户，层层外拓；现代语汇与更漏、雁行等多能相融，唯“递遐方”“拆封香”略硬，情事稍概括。","_cost":0.0184512},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.9,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.2,"rationale":"以云仓夜作为题材新，物人对照由夜及晓结构完整，然扫码语白、雁行更漏稍套，结以万户拆香具温情余韵。","_cost":0.0102144},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"此诗聚焦云仓夜班新题材，场景具象，脉络顺畅，落点温煦，当代物流经验入律自然；唯个别意象稍旧，语言偶有平实处，结句略直。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"以夜班分拣入律，当代经验化用自然，主脑在劳者倦眼与万家拆封之对照，情事具体。灯河、红光取象精切，雁行双关归心尤佳；更漏稍熟。起承转合完整，尾联宕开收束有味，言尽而意不尽。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"以云仓夜班入律，题材新而落笔具体；中二联一写机械一写人情，开合有层次，“屏上归心逐雁行”化旧象为新境。结句“遥怜”宕开尚可，但“拆封香”稍嫌硬凑，“更漏”“雁行”略带套语。","_cost":0.05023},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫入律,题材出新,起承转合清晰,中二联由物及人;然屏上归心等句炼字生硬,更漏雁行稍陈,结句遥怜直白,余味不长。","_cost":0.035265677},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.5,"rationale":"当代物流题材入律，现代物象炼铸古雅贴切。颔联工稳精警，颈联由境入人，尾联由自身宵劳宕开至万户拆封之乐，映衬有致，余味深长，出新极为成功。","_cost":0.00598725},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"夜扫贯通晓达万户主脑清晰；物人层次分明结构完整；扫码递遐拆封香直白夹杂，景情融合不足，颈联转人及宕开稍佳。","_cost":0.0118318},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.7,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.85000000000001,"rationale":"从流水作业写到工人归心，再转万户收件，层次清楚，劳动关怀具体。灯河、红光有现场感，物流经验入诗有效；“逐雁行”“拆封香”稍显牵合，结尾温厚而余味有限。","_cost":0.05091},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"前半灯河、铁带、红光切合夜仓，由扫码至晓发脉络清楚。后半倦眼、更漏、雁行、归心陈熟，遥怜说破，拆封香稍硬，未出劳逸对照的熟境。","_cost":0.0322288},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"以云仓夜班入诗，当代经验鲜活，首句灯河贯仓有气象。颔联物象切实；颈联更漏、归心逐雁偏旧套，情感略泛。结句推及万户拆封，有温度但遥怜稍直。人静与扫码忙略相抵牾。","_cost":0.017332},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"扫码红光与倦眼归心相映，写出夜仓劳作，晓车送货也使脉络完整。惟“更漏”“雁行”稍显套用，“闻扫码忙”“拆封香”欠贴切；结句转向万户，有温意而余味稍浅。","_cost":0.008292}},"consensus":72.24,"final":72.24},{"key":"qwen3.8-max|机场送别|七律","writer":"qwen3.8-max","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"夜静银楼送远航，风传广播入回廊。云程欲暮千山隔，客影虚窗一别长。闸口频催行色重，屏间屡映旅怀凉。明朝万里孤鸿外，唯见舷灯没大荒。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.3,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.6,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":1.2,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.15,"rationale":"广播、闸口、屏幕等机场物象入诗自然，送别主线清楚，末句以灯没荒空留余韵。惟“夜静”与“欲暮”“明朝”时序略乱，“旅怀凉”稍显硬凑，千山、孤鸿等意象较熟。","_cost":0.007742},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"以机场入律诗,广播、闸口、屏幕、舷灯等当代物象与旧体语汇融合尚称自然,结句以舷灯没入大荒收景,余味较足。惜送别对象与情事模糊,'行色重''旅怀凉'近套语,中二联开合平稳少变化,立意仍属熟题稳作。","_cost":0.04367},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"本诗将机场送别经验自然入诗，出新且情景交融。尾联“舷灯没大荒”以景结情，余味悠长。唯“欲暮”与首句“夜静”时序略有矛盾，中二联辞藻偶显直白。整体情感真挚，章法稳健。","_cost":0.018228},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"熟题送别入机场尚具体，古今意象可融而主脑未见翻新；结句舷灯没大荒以景宕开有余味，中联对仗平直炼字偶滞。","_cost":0.018072},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"机场送别以现代场景入诗，情感具体但角度平常。银楼、舷灯等意象交融冷寂，尾联以景结情最佳；中二联转接稍平，虚窗句略涩，结句可称警句。","_cost":0.01154911},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"以律诗写机场送别，广播、闸口、屏间等当代物象入诗自然，结联以舷灯没入大荒宕开，以景结情有余味。然中二联均铺陈离别场景，层次推进不足，频催屡映句意相近；孤鸿、大荒、千山等语稍熟，夜静与欲暮微有抵牾。","_cost":0.00336396},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.2,"rationale":"机场物象入律，氛围苍凉，颈联细节具体；然远航、孤鸿等熟语稍多，情感未深翻。结句以景收束，余味较好。","_cost":0.016956},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.0,"rationale":"机场新象入律有生气，结联舷灯没大荒以景结情最佳；然银楼、云程等语生凑，千山孤鸿大荒仍熟，中二联并列少开合。","_cost":0.0203808},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.1,"意境":5.4,"语言":4.7,"章法":5.8,"余味":6.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.05,"rationale":"机场题材切近当代，广播闸口屏显入诗；中二联写景铺排较实且近重复，锤炼少诗眼。尾联以舷灯没大荒以景结情，留白较佳，余味胜于前半。","_cost":0.01222175},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"紧扣机场送别场景，脉络顺畅，现代设施意象与传统离情融合自然，结句以景衬情有余味；惟立意未脱常调，部分意象偏熟，无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"以机场现代经验入七律，广播、闸口、屏显等物象与离情交融较妥，'屏间屡映旅怀凉'有巧思；尾联'舷灯没大荒'以景结情，余味最佳。惟中二联皆写别绪，方向相近，转折稍平；千山、孤鸿等意象略熟。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.25,"rationale":"机场送别嵌入广播、闸口、舷灯等当代物象有可取处，结句舷灯没大荒尚有画面；但“银楼”生硬，“行色重”“旅怀凉”落套，中二联皆写候机景状层次不开；“夜静”与“欲暮”时序相抵，“明朝”亦与即刻登机不合。","_cost":0.06489},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"以机场送别入七律，广播闸口等现代经验与云程孤鸿等套语并存；中二联虚实相生，结句没大荒以景结情有余味。然夜静与欲暮时令相悖，舷灯措辞及银楼、屡映稍欠精准。","_cost":0.032159435},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.6,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.2,"rationale":"机场广播、闸口、舷灯等当代物象入律自然，格调清冷孤阔。中二联脉络推进平实紧凑，结句以航灯隐没大荒宕开一笔，融现代表象入苍茫意境，余韵极佳。","_cost":0.00407175},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.25,"rationale":"机场取景有当代感但主脑散，银楼虚窗费解，文白夹杂，中二联同层徘徊，末句舷灯没大荒宕开稍挽余味。","_cost":0.01096105},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.2,"余味":7.7,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.80000000000001,"rationale":"送别主旨集中，广播、闸口、屏幕使旧题落到当下；“云程欲暮”“屏间屡映旅怀凉”略显牵强，中联情绪复沓。结以舷灯隐没，开阔而有余味；千山、孤鸿等意象仍偏熟套。","_cost":0.05156},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"送别焦点清楚，情志仍是常见离愁，人事不具体。闸口屏舷灯能造冷境，千山孤鸿行色旅怀套语密，与机场未全交融。隔绝写在催行之前，转折平；夜静与欲暮略矛盾。结句舷灯没大荒以景收住，余味最佳。","_cost":0.0227152},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.25,"rationale":"广播、闸口、屏幕、舷灯等当代意象入诗较自然，但送别角度常见。中二联同写离情，平行铺陈，缺少推进。'行色重''旅怀凉'偏套。时间有矛盾：首句'夜静'接'欲暮'，结句'明朝'又见'舷灯'。结句以景收束，尚有余味。","_cost":0.018576},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"广播、闸口、舷灯写出机场别境，末句灯影远没，有余味；情意仍较常见。“屏间屡映旅怀凉”稍显生硬，“夜静”与“欲暮”时序略抵牾。","_cost":0.013352}},"consensus":62.7,"final":62.7},{"key":"qwen3.8-max|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"qwen3.8-max","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"彩偶堆窗五色辉，投钱暗许愿相依。轻拈欲取浑难定，得失由来在一机。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.4,"意境":6.7,"语言":6.1,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.6,"警句":1.3,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.45,"rationale":"以抓取彩偶寄寓得失，主旨集中且题材新鲜；前三句由见、愿至取，推进清楚。“愿相依”稍硬，末句借“机”双关收束，却偏于说理说尽，余韵有限。","_cost":0.00546},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"当代物事入诗有巧思,结句借'机'字双关机器与机缘,略有理趣。但通篇叙述平铺,'愿相依'交代含糊,取象止于实录未成氛围;转句尚可,结句以议论说破,余味打折。整体属题材出新而笔力平平之作。","_cost":0.03029},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"以当代事物抓娃娃机入诗，起承转合严密。转句写机械爪无力颇传神，结语双关机器与机缘。然承句略显造作，结句直白议论缺乏余韵，语言尚待锤炼。","_cost":0.02258},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.0,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入七绝，以一机绾合物象与得失，立意有今感。起句有色，承写暗愿尚具体；转平，结句说理点破，余味不足。暗许、轻拈略见炼字，五色辉、由来稍熟。","_cost":0.02602},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机喻得失由机缘，角度有新趣但说理偏直。意象统一妥帖，“机”字双关为诗眼。起承转合清晰，结句点破而余味稍减。","_cost":0.003725128},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入诗，当代经验有效转化。结句“一机”双关机缘天机，翻出得失之思，立意有巧。起承转合完整：景—愿—试—悟，一气贯注。意象精切但“五色辉”稍泛，中二句偏白话直陈。结句以议论收，机趣可取而略近说破，余味中平。","_cost":0.00282056},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.3,"语言":6.4,"章法":6.8,"余味":5.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.6,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入诗有新意，‘一机’双关见巧；起承转合清楚。但彩偶、五色描写稍泛，末句说破得失，余味受损，情境亦未更深。","_cost":0.011768},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机寄寓人生得失之偶然，当代题材入绝有新鲜感，前两句意象具体。但后两句径直说理，结句'得失由来在一机'点破兜底，无余味；字句通顺而少锤炼，无诗眼。","_cost":0.0061398},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.6,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.2,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.3,"rationale":"当代机物入诗有新意，然归于得失泛论；取象贴切而偏泛，语言平实乏诗眼，章法完整转平，结句议论说破少余味。","_cost":0.0102234},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"此作咏抓娃娃机，起承转合顺畅，以'一机'双关见巧；唯感慨角度较常，意象平实，炼字偶有未切，结句偏直白，当代经验入诗尚自然，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"以七绝写抓娃娃机，当代经验入旧体而自然妥帖，'得失由来在一机'双关'机器/机缘'为全篇诗眼，结句由小物翻出人生之思。起承转合完整，转句'浑难定'状悬停瞬间颇传神。惟'五色辉'稍泛，结句说理微露，余味可再深一层。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.0,"rationale":"取材当代娃娃机，题材新而立意落在“得失在一机”的常见感悟，借“机”字双关略见巧思。意象仅彩偶、投钱，五色辉属泛语；“愿相依”稍生硬。章法顺叙平直，结句说破哲理，余味有限。","_cost":0.04266},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写当代经验，喻得失，立意清而角度常见；意象妥帖少交融，语言有“机”双关，章法完整；结句直说“得失在一机”，说破少留白。当代入诗略出新，末句略具警策；无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.024536376},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"现代生活经验入诗，起承转合结构完整。“轻拈”二字刻画抓取细节生动，结句“一机”巧妙双关机械与契机，寓理于物，虽略带说理倾向但收束结实自然。","_cost":0.00426525},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.25,"rationale":"以新题写小机悟得失，一机双关可取；然中后段流于议论说理，意象单薄，结句点破无留白。","_cost":0.01188755},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃写求取与得失，题材较新，叙写顺序清楚。设色偏泛，“愿相依”略显牵强；“一机”兼扣机器与机缘，有巧思，但结句泛化说理，留白不足。","_cost":0.05235},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.0,"rationale":"次句暗许相依稍具体,然旨归得失常谈。五色浮泛,末句抽离,物情未融。转无变,结句说破,通顺而无诗眼。娃娃机入诗有当代感,化用未深。","_cost":0.0205152},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入诗，当代题材有新意。“愿相依”点出情感寄托，但未展开。“轻拈”状写爪钩贴切。结句“一机”双关机器与机缘，有些巧思，但偏于说理，意思已经说尽。意象停留在表层彩饰，转句变化平直。","_cost":0.015304},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃寄寓得失，“机”字兼指机器与机缘，略有巧思。起承转合清楚，但“愿相依”所指稍含混，结句转为议论，说得较尽。","_cost":0.0076}},"consensus":56.98,"final":56.98},{"key":"glm-5.3|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"巷口新开小食堂，十元三菜热羹汤。空巢久惯孤灯冷，饭罢迟迟未散场。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.1,"语言":8.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.2,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.05,"rationale":"由平价饭菜转入空巢孤独，主脑集中且具现实温度。“十元三菜”入诗自然；“孤灯冷”稍熟，“热羹汤”略复。末句以迟迟不散写陪伴之需，含蓄有余味。","_cost":0.00501},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"当代民生题材真切入诗,'十元三菜'白描不俗。第三句'孤灯冷'与'热羹汤'冷暖相照,转折有力。结句'迟迟未散场'不说破孤独眷恋,留白动人。惜语言平实少炼字之工,取象亦稍简。","_cost":0.03179},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"本诗将“社区食堂”与“空巢老人”有效入诗。前两句白描食堂之暖，第三句宕开写孤灯之冷，结句“迟迟未散场”以细节收束，不言孤独而孤独自见。起承转合流畅，语言虽近口语，但胜在真挚感人，时代气息浓厚。","_cost":0.025868},"grok-4.6":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"食堂写空巢觅暖，十元三菜具体，转结自然见人情。孤灯稍陈，语言晓畅少锤炼，结句点明略直。当代题材入诗有效。","_cost":0.013834},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.6,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.9,"余味":9.3,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.1,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.85000000000001,"rationale":"以社区食堂写空巢老人，“热羹汤”与“孤灯冷”对映，转结由物及人，“迟迟未散场”以行写孤，留白耐味。语言生活化，后二句近佳联；题材具当代新意，惜起承略实。","_cost":0.00783728},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"以社区食堂写空巢老人孤独，熟题落点具体（十元三菜），第三句转入孤灯冷作反衬，结句'迟迟未散场'以行动留白，不说破而孤独尽出，当代经验入诗自然有效。语言平实，'孤灯'稍熟，整体意象密度妥帖、脉络贯通。","_cost":0.00218696},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.95,"rationale":"以社区食堂写空巢陪伴，细节具体，结句迟迟未散场留暖；但空巢、孤灯冷稍直且常见，意象锤炼未臻精警。","_cost":0.013756},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"以社区食堂写空巢冷暖，事象具体，三四句冷热相激，结以“未散场”留白见依恋；惜“空巢孤灯”略熟，语言平易而锤炼不足。","_cost":0.0147378},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.6,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.7,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.4,"rationale":"以社区食堂切入空巢议题角度新切，热汤与孤灯冷暖对照，结于未散场留白；语言白描少锤炼，意象平实。","_cost":0.0091099},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.5,"rationale":"此作以社区食堂切入空巢养老现实，细节真切，冷热对照自然，章法流畅，结句留白有余温，语言平实无硬伤，唯意象稍显常见。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"以社区食堂写空巢老人，当代经验入诗，'十元三菜'具体可感；'孤灯冷'与'热羹汤'冷暖对照见匠心，结句'迟迟未散场'以行为留白，恋恋不舍之态不言自明，余味悠长。语言平实稍欠锤炼亮点，'孤灯'意象略熟。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"取材当代社区食堂,以“热羹汤”对“孤灯冷”暗成冷暖对照,结句“迟迟未散场”不说破而见老人恋群之情,收得含蓄。惜前二句近白话记账,“空巢”“孤灯冷”稍套,炼字乏诗眼,意象偏薄。","_cost":0.04946},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"不评格律。诗以‘十元三菜热羹汤’实写食堂，衬‘空巢孤灯’之冷；结句‘未散场’以场景留白，言尽意不尽，余味佳。当代经验入诗，章法完整。然语言稍直白、意象略平，故意境、语言、章法居中上，立意见新。","_cost":0.028366241},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"当代现实题材入诗自然妥帖。以“热羹汤”对“孤灯冷”见温度反差，转折自然。结句以“迟迟未散场”的留白细节传神刻画空巢老人的社交心理，平实真挚，余味悠长。","_cost":0.004434},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"题材取社区食堂暖空巢，具体可感；孤灯冷略套，语言平白；转结以迟迟未散场留白，余味足。","_cost":0.01010525},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"“十元三菜”使情事具体，羹汤之热与孤灯之冷相映，结句以“迟迟”见出就餐之外的陪伴需求，留白有味。起承语言偏平，“孤灯冷”稍熟，胜在转结自然。","_cost":0.02925},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"以十元热餐写空巢者不忍归家，焦点集中，转结分明，有当代实感。取象止于热汤与孤灯，后者偏熟；语言白描顺达而少锤炼。结句已点明眷恋，余味停在可推知处。","_cost":0.0279936},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"以社区食堂写空巢老人，不说饭食而写孤独，当代经验入诗，角度好。前两句质实，“十元三菜”具体可感。第三句转入“孤灯冷”，略显套语。结句写饭后迟迟不散，不说破而情自见，余味较足。整体语言平实，少锤炼亮点。","_cost":0.014004},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"十元三菜写出当下生活，热羹汤与孤灯冷相映；末句以迟迟不散写出对陪伴的留恋，含蓄有味。“空巢”“孤灯”稍显熟套。","_cost":0.00781}},"consensus":76.59,"final":76.59},{"key":"qwen3.8-max|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"qwen3.8-max","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"琉璃柜锁锦娃辉，硬币轻投启暗机。铁爪探时偏复缩，童心掷处每相违。毫厘得失悬三指，顷刻悲欢付一挥。莫叹空回灯影瘦，余温犹在掌中飞。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.1,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.39999999999999,"rationale":"以抓娃娃写得失悲欢，题材新而主脑集中。中二联推进有层次，“悬三指”一联凝练。首联个别词语稍涩，末句想象灵动但“余温”“飞”衔接略虚。","_cost":0.006324},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"以当代娃娃机入律,题材新而寄意于得失悲欢,颈联'毫厘得失悬三指,顷刻悲欢付一挥'工稳有概括力。惟'锦娃辉'凑韵生硬,'余温掌中飞'意象略勉强,结句宕开但'飞'字失准;'灯影瘦'稍套。整体新题稳作,炼字尚欠精纯。","_cost":0.03569},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"当代经验有效入诗，颔联刻画机械爪极精准，颈联升华至毫厘得失，结构完整。唯尾联“灯影瘦”略陈套、“掌中飞”稍嫌凑韵，微损余味，整体瑕不掩瑜。","_cost":0.015208},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"当代抓娃娃入律，童心近失写得具体有主脑；颈联可摘，结句余温宕开。意象杂灯影套语，转由器入理较直，炼字稳少奇崛。","_cost":0.022586},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.4,"语言":8.4,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.3,"警句":4.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.5,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入七律，取当代经验写得失，焦点集中。颈联精警，尾联以余温留白。中二联开合有序，唯议论稍多，景语略少。","_cost":0.017040672},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入律，当代经验化古自然，是亮点。'毫厘得失悬三指，顷刻悲欢付一挥'工稳凝练，小中见大，堪为警联。全篇脉络清晰，起承转合完整，结句以'余温在掌'宕开，以象收情。稍憾'莫叹'微露说教，'空回'与'余温'逻辑略需读者补足，个别措辞如'启暗机'稍硬。","_cost":0.00388476},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.1,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.35,"rationale":"取抓娃娃机入诗，起承转合清晰，由操作转入得失，尾以余温留白。意象较统一，语言有炼字，但锦娃、暗机略生，悲欢童心稍泛。","_cost":0.00908},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"当代题材入律，柜、币、爪、灯诸象统一成境；颔联写屡试不中真切，颈联“毫厘得失/顷刻悲欢”以小见大最警，结以灯影余温留白。惜“启暗机”“锦娃辉”略凑，“掌中飞”与“空回”微扞格，情理翻法仍未尽脱熟径。","_cost":0.0157368},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.1,"意境":5.6,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.4,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.64999999999999,"rationale":"以娃娃机小戏喻得失悲欢，中联警策，章法起承转合完整；唯意象与议论参半，结句劝慰稍直，余味受限。","_cost":0.0104269},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.1,"rationale":"以当代抓娃娃机入七律，紧扣操作细节寄寓寻常得失与童心触感，中二联工切，结以余温留白，意新语顺，无硬伤、套话及袭用问题。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"以七律写抓娃娃机，当代经验入旧体而气脉贯通：颔联'偏复缩''每相违'切中机趣与人心，颈联'毫厘得失悬三指，顷刻悲欢付一挥'为全篇警策；尾联以'余温掌中飞'宕开收情，不说破而有延宕。首句'锦娃辉'凑韵微生硬，'悲欢得失'稍熟，整体取象精切、章法井然。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"当代物象入律，铁爪探缩、灯影瘦等取象具体，中二联颔联工切。但颈联即转入得失悲欢泛说，与颔联层次略叠；结句「余温」欲留余韵而「掌中飞」造语生硬，安慰之意稍露。","_cost":0.04811},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入律，当代经验有效；中二联‘毫厘得失’一联凝练成警句。‘掷处’‘掌中飞’稍硬，‘莫叹’略直，余味中等。无硬伤、蹈袭，陈滥轻。","_cost":0.027671807},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.7,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.85,"rationale":"当代题材入律浑然无迹，状物精切。“毫厘得失悬三指，顷刻悲欢付一挥”精准传神，小游戏翻出得失哲思。脉络清晰，转结从容，展现了良好的炼字与驾驭能力。","_cost":0.005037},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.5,"rationale":"以小机写得失悲欢主脑明确，然哲理常见；柜爪灯影有现场感而情景交融浅；悬付见功结语直白，颈联稍佳。","_cost":0.01018125},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.6,"rationale":"以抓取成败写童心悲欢，主脑集中，层次清楚；颈联“三指”“一挥”扣物传情。题材有新意，“锦娃辉”略涩，“掌中飞”稍显刻意；结意温厚，回旋未深。","_cost":0.05487},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"铁爪、三指取象精切，颈联最警，当代物象入律有效。情志却落在得失悲欢的常见感慨，尾联以「莫叹」说破兜底，余味弱。灯影瘦、掌中飞略生造。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0232448},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"以古体写抓娃娃机，当代题材入诗有新意。颈联'毫厘得失悬三指'由物及理，是全篇最佳处。颔联与颈联都写落空，层次略显重复。'童心掷处'用字欠稳。结句'余温飞'语意牵强，像是为押韵凑出，余味不足。","_cost":0.017984},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃写得失与童心，题材入诗自然；“毫厘得失悬三指”贴切有力。起承转合清楚，但“锦娃辉”稍显生硬，结句“余温”所指略虚，余味稍弱。","_cost":0.008074}},"consensus":73.75,"final":73.75},{"key":"qwen3.8-max|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"qwen3.8-max","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"天台小圃雨初晴，韭绿葱青照眼明。莫道白云无地种，晚风暗送豆花声。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.4,"语言":8.1,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.7,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.4,"rationale":"前二句写雨后菜圃，明净可感；后二句由实转虚，以白云可种、豆花有声拓开奇境。转结灵动，通感含蓄；题旨稍轻，韭绿葱青略熟。","_cost":0.00499},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"天台种菜的当代经验入诗自然，围绕小圃收束有主脑。三句宕开翻转，'莫道白云无地种'化闲云归己有，结以'暗送豆花声'以景收情、余味悠长。惟'韭绿葱青照眼明'稍熟，'豆花声'炼字微涉险而未害意。","_cost":0.03886},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.75,"rationale":"将“天台种菜”日常有效诗化，立意清奇。“莫道白云无地种”由实入虚极具巧思；结句“暗送豆花声”妙用通感，以景结情余味悠长。全诗烟火气与诗意交融，起承转合流畅有致。","_cost":0.015842},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"雨后小圃取象具体，转以白云无地翻出巧思，结用风送花声，章法转合较活。立意轻巧少深情，语言通顺而锤炼一般，余味已点明有限。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.020084},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.6,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.6,"rationale":"写城市天台菜园，切入点具体；后两句以白云作衬、豆花声收束，转结有致，留有余味。意象清新，'暗送'见炼字。惟'雨初晴''照眼明'等语略熟。无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":0.01305821},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"天台种菜是当代经验入诗，熟题翻新。三句“白云无地种”巧用天台高近云而不归己，转得俏皮有味；结以晚风豆花声收束，声色兼融。唯“豆花声”稍涉硬凑，花本无声，微伤逻辑。","_cost":0.00262236},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.7,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.10000000000001,"rationale":"天台小圃雨后清景，韭葱明丽，转以白云难种、豆花有声翻出巧趣，结句留白。惜前句略直，语料偏熟，情志稍轻浅。","_cost":0.010608},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"天台种菜为题颇新，'白云无地种'翻转有巧思，雨晴韭绿意象统一。起承转合完整，转结以景收。唯'豆花声'通感稍勉强，'照眼明'等语略熟，整体清新而锤炼未至化境。","_cost":0.0112488},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.7,"rationale":"雨后菜畦明净，转用白云无地种翻进，结以暗送豆花声听觉收束，章法转结有致余韵不尽，然韭葱并列意象常见，立意未超田园常境。","_cost":0.00776725},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"此作摹写天台菜园雨后清趣，转结以“种白云”巧思牵合晚风豆花，章法圆活，以景结情有余韵，唯部分意象用语稍平，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"天台种菜为当代经验入旧体，角度清新。'照眼明'写雨后菜色鲜亮，第三句'莫道白云无地种'翻转生趣，结句以豆花声收，通感细腻、言尽意不尽。惟'韭绿葱青'稍近常语，整体意象妥帖而未至惊警。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"都市天台种菜寄隐逸之思，第三句翻用“种白云”生新，转笔有力；结句以声收束留白，然“豆花声”所指含混（花不能有声，若为卖豆花之声则未点明），稍显生涩。“照眼明”较熟，前两句铺叙平实。","_cost":0.04983},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.4,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.5,"rationale":"以天台（屋顶）菜园入诗，当代经验；'种白云''豆花声'新警，转结以声留白，章法完足。语言自然，意象明丽；'照眼明'稍熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.029484189},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.3,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.4,"rationale":"将都市天台种菜点染出空灵野趣。转句‘莫道白云无地种’构思奇巧，结句‘晚风暗送豆花声’以微响写幽静，融生活气息与悠远意韵于一体，章法流转自然。","_cost":0.0050925},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"天台不写仙而写菜圃，以白云反衬烟火，小有翻新；韭葱照眼较平，结句风送豆花声以声收，薄有余韵。","_cost":0.0077375},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"天台种蔬具体亲切，以种白云翻出空间巧思。起承明晰，转句拓境；但“豆花声”通感铺垫不足，求巧痕迹较重，削弱结尾感染力。“照眼明”“莫道”等措辞偏熟。","_cost":0.05},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"立意以豆花暗应白云,主脑清楚而情浅。次句韭葱并列,照眼明套熟,意象可减。语言通畅,暗送、豆花声为眼。起承平,转结有变能收。结句以声留白,余味最好。无硬伤,无整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.0319328},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":60.0,"rationale":"都市天台种菜入诗，当代经验有效。第三句'白云无地种'转得有想象，但逻辑稍隐。'豆花声'以通感收结，有余味却略显生硬。'照眼明'袭韩愈成语，'雨初晴'常见，前两句平实少新。","_cost":0.017892},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"天台种菜引出种云之想，转句有趣；末句以声留白，但“豆花声”的声源稍虚。起承清楚，部分景语较常见。","_cost":0.00793}},"consensus":74.77,"final":74.77},{"key":"qwen3.8-max|天台菜园|七律","writer":"qwen3.8-max","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"百尺天台营小圃，四围烟雨润疏篱。青藤暗绕春棚密，紫芥初开晓露垂。短锸翻泥香满袖，长竿引蔓翠成丝。谁言城市无闲地，一握云苗入晚炊。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.55,"rationale":"以天台躬耕写城市闲趣，题材具当代感。藤、芥、锸、蔓层层交融，触觉嗅觉鲜明；转结由劳作翻出“云苗晚炊”，收束轻灵。个别春露烟雨意象稍熟。","_cost":0.005092},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"天台种菜以当代都市经验入诗,题材有新意,情事具体。中二联工稳写实但取象平常,'香满袖''翠成丝'稍熟。转句设问直白,幸结句'一握云苗入晚炊'以'云苗'呼应天台之高,收得清新有味。烟雨疏篱略陈套。","_cost":0.03389},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"将都市天台种菜经验入诗，立意真切，生活气息浓。中二联景事交融，脉络清晰。然“烟雨”略显套路，结句直白点题，缺乏留白余味。总体清新妥帖。","_cost":0.014108},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"屋顶种菜题旨清楚、劳作可感，然“城中亦有闲地”角度常见。意象统于圃事，烟雨疏篱、晓露稍熟。语言通顺，“香满袖”“云苗”略亮，诗眼不足。中二联静动开合稳，尾联“谁言”说破，余味受限。","_cost":0.02172},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"天台种菜题材具体，中二联对仗工稳但意象略熟；尾联以云苗入晚炊收束，有生活余味。","_cost":0.00799216},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"都市天台种菜入七律，当代经验有效入诗，题有主脑。中二联景事相生、对仗工稳有层次。结联'一握云苗入晚炊'以小景收束，化空中之圃于人间烟火，言尽意不尽。'云苗'稍近生造，'烟雨疏篱'略熟，整体精切不俗。","_cost":0.00313056},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.7,"rationale":"取材都市菜园，烟火与田趣相融，颔颈联细节生动；结以云苗晚炊有回味。惜‘谁言’句稍直，烟雨疏篱等意象略熟，未臻新警。","_cost":0.013888},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"以天台种菜写城市闲趣，题旨集中且翻'城市无闲地'一层，为熟题开新面。烟雨疏篱、青藤晓露意象统一成菜园氛围，'香满袖''云苗入晚炊'有炼字之功，尾句以事结情略有延宕。然中二联铺排稍平，转结'谁言'略嫌直露，烟雨晓露等象亦属常套。","_cost":0.0136818},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.8,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.2,"rationale":"都市天台自耕翻出新境，中二联静景动事分层体物细切，语言工稳而少奇警，尾联以炊烟收束生活化但议论稍直致余味略浅。","_cost":0.00710275},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.8,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.6,"rationale":"此作以城市天台种菜入诗，为传统田园题材注入当代日常经验，细节真切，章法稳顺，语言清通，结句有烟火气，唯转折略平，余韵稍欠。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.0,"rationale":"以天台菜园写都市闲趣，角度较新且情事具体；中二联对仗工稳，'香满袖''翠成丝'炼字见功。尾联设问翻转后以'一握云苗入晚炊'收束，言尽意不尽。惟烟雨疏篱等意象仍属常见田园套式，整体在稳妥与出新之间。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"天台种菜为当代经验入诗，题旨清晰、情事可感，立意有小新意。中二联写景写事皆平列铺陈，缺开合层次；“香满袖”“晓露垂”偶落熟套。结句“一握云苗入晚炊”以景收情较佳，惟第七句“谁言”说破稍直。","_cost":0.04786},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"咏都市屋顶种菜，题材集中，立意具体而角度常见；意象妥帖但交融未深；语言有‘香满袖’‘翠成丝’等亮点，评8；中二联景—人分明，起结平稳，结句反诘稍直，‘云苗入晚炊’略留余味；当代经验入诗，无硬伤蹈袭，略有常见意象。","_cost":0.032995604},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.6,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.6,"rationale":"将当代都市天台种菜经验妥帖入律，脉络严整，生活气息浓郁。劳作与景致写来生动自然，结句“云苗”扣天台意象。唯“香满袖”等句式略带传统田园陈套。","_cost":0.00540225},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":4.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"题旨明确但都市田园角度常见；中二联静观转劳作有层次，烟雨晓露稍熟；尾联谁言说破，留白不足。","_cost":0.0126405},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"都市种蔬有生活实感，取象集中，景物与劳作相承；章法完整而转折平直。“翠成丝”稍显求工，烟雨疏篱偏熟。结句以“云苗”接“晚炊”，贯通高台与烟火，鲜活有余味。","_cost":0.06301},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"城市天台种菜,情事可触、主脑清楚,识见止于闲适。烟雨疏篱晓露偏熟,与楼顶实境未尽贴。香满袖是眼,云苗、翠成丝略琢。中二联平列,谁言一转近套。结句一握入炊能收,余味不长。","_cost":0.0416848},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.0,"rationale":"以城市天台种菜入诗,有当代生活气息,但立意停在闲趣层面,角度常见。中二联都是铺写景物与农事,开合不足。'香满袖'等语偏熟,'紫芥初开'物候略可商。'一握云苗'切合天台之高,颇见巧思,但'谁言'一句近于说破。","_cost":0.018724},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.8,"rationale":"屋顶种菜写出城市生活中的田园趣味；烟雨、翻泥、晚炊贯通成篇。结句以采苗入炊收束，具体可感，余味尚可；“谁言”转句稍显直白，“翠成丝”略欠自然。","_cost":0.010332}},"consensus":71.49,"final":71.49},{"key":"qwen3.8-max|云端相册|七绝","writer":"qwen3.8-max","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"指上云端收旧影，屏中小景锁流光。悲欢聚散浑无迹，片羽犹能贮暗香。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.6,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.7,"余味":7.2,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.14999999999999,"rationale":"以云端相册寄托记忆留存，今景入诗较自然，四句由收影转向人生聚散，脉络清楚。末句含蓄，但“流光、悲欢聚散、暗香”略熟，“浑无迹”与前后留影贮香稍有抵牾。","_cost":0.00586},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"以云端相册这一当代经验入绝句，题材有新意，起承点题、三句转入聚散之慨，脉络清楚。惜情事泛写不具体，'流光''暗香''悲欢聚散'皆熟语，意象套化削弱新题之效。结句'片羽贮暗香'收得稳且留余味，但暗香一词落入陈套，余韵未足。","_cost":0.03436},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"以“云端”双关引入当代生活，出新且自然，章法规矩。但三句“悲欢聚散”过于直白，且“流光”“暗香”等词陈套，未与前两句现代感深度交融，结句收束略平，余味有限。","_cost":0.02688},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.5,"rationale":"以指上屏中写云端旧影，当代经验入诗为可取处；悲欢聚散乃熟套，转句直白伤境。片羽暗香稍见炼意，通篇意象未能完全交融，结句尚留一丝余韵。","_cost":0.019508},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"咏云端相册存影，动词收、锁、贮一线，结句以片羽贮暗香通感留白，有巧思。但悲欢聚散等情语较泛，立意略熟，意象张力稍欠。","_cost":0.00742324},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"以手机云端相册入诗，当代经验化古自然，'云端'双关见巧。起承写藏影锁光，第三句宕开言聚散无迹，结以'片羽贮暗香'以象收情，余味延宕。'浑无迹'稍平，'悲欢聚散'略近套语，整体意脉贯通、炼字稳妥。","_cost":0.00251836},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"题写云端相册，当代经验入诗，结以片羽暗香留余味；但一二句意近，中间偏抽象，语汇稍落常套。","_cost":0.008342},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写记忆可存而情事已远，题旨较新、焦点尚明；惜“悲欢聚散”落套，首二句意象近复，结句“片羽贮暗香”最有余韵。","_cost":0.0154542},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.3,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.2,"rationale":"云端入题切当代经验有新意，然悲欢聚散一语带过情事空泛；前二句有象三句转虚，意象未全交融；章法转结有致，末句以片羽贮香收束留白有余味。","_cost":0.01442575},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.5,"rationale":"此作以当代云端相册入诗，主脑明确，章法平顺，语言清通，意象妥帖但多熟语，结句稳当余味稍弱，融入当代经验但立意未深拓，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"以'云端相册'入旧体，当代经验化用自然，题旨聚焦。'锁流光''贮暗香'炼字见功，转句以聚散无迹反衬结句片羽藏香，章法完整，以景结情留有余味。惟'悲欢聚散''流光'属常见语，整体意象略平，未至惊艳。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗有当代经验，'指上云端''屏中小景'切题；但后二句落入'悲欢聚散''流光''暗香'等熟套，情事不够具体，转结平直，结句略嫌说破，余味有限。","_cost":0.04808},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"题旨明确而情事空泛，角度常见；取象有云端屏中之新，然流光暗香稍熟；语言通顺，收锁贮略有炼字；起承转合完整，转以议论稍平直；结句以片羽贮暗香留白，余味较好。当代经验入诗有效，无硬伤蹈袭，陈滥中度。","_cost":0.031547513},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"将当代数字相册体验妥帖入诗，无生硬隔阂。“收、锁、贮”炼字精到，起承稳健。三句以聚散无痕作转，末句以“片羽贮暗香”挽回虚无，虚实相生，余味温存延宕。","_cost":0.005328},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"以云端存照写有迹无痕，切入当代可取；然起承收锁同义复沓，流光暗香常见，议论直露余韵有限。","_cost":0.0089703},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写存影与留情，当代物事入诗自然。前二句意近，第三句转入人事，末句回扣旧影；但“悲欢聚散”偏泛，“流光”“暗香”较熟，余韵尚有，独到发现不足。","_cost":0.04085},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.25,"rationale":"主脑在云端留影,但悲欢聚散无具体情事,发现有限。屏影与暗香未融成一境,流光片羽偏熟。锁、贮有力,指上稍隔,第三句近套。起承重复,转结明白而平。结句点明能贮,余味不长。当代入诗算出新,无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0193328},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写记忆留存,当代题材入诗,有新意。立意取“浑无迹”与“犹能贮”相对,角度较常见。收、锁、贮三字有意锤炼,但“流光”“暗香”偏熟。“片羽贮暗香”喻象稍混,前两句同写屏中存影,略显平铺。结句收得稳,余味尚可。","_cost":0.018272},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"“指上云端”写存照动作，有当代感；但“小景”缺少具体内容，第三句转入泛说。“锁流光”“暗香”偏熟，结句有余意而情味稍虚。","_cost":0.00802}},"consensus":64.5,"final":64.5},{"key":"qwen3.8-max|云端相册|七律","writer":"qwen3.8-max","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"何处云端贮晚芳，一痕淡色入斜阳。闲翻片影惊前梦，暗锁年华护旧香。指上初开千里月，屏中忽见故人妆。音容尚带当时态，却隔青霄半世凉。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.2,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.60000000000001,"rationale":"以云端相册写故人旧影，古典情味与数字经验结合自然。由翻看至惊见、追忆，再以青霄之隔收束，脉络清楚；“指上初开千里月”有新意。旧香、前梦稍熟，“故人妆”略显牵强。","_cost":0.005594},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"以'云端'双关切入数字时代怀旧,题材出新且一篇有主脑。颈联'指上千里月/屏中故人妆'融今入古最见巧思。惟'晚芳''旧香''音容'等语稍落熟套,尾句'半世凉'点情微露,余味略减。整体章法贯通,属熟题新境之作。","_cost":0.03961},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"本诗巧妙将“云相册”与“滑屏”等当代科技体验无痕化入古典律体，首联双关起势，颈联动作入诗贴切。全篇脉络清晰，情致真切。结联略显直白，但整体出新成功，是现代经验入诗的佳作。","_cost":0.018002},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"云端相册写旧影怀人，情事较具体，角度常见。意象传统居多，屏指稍新但交融欠深。炼字有亮点欠浑成。结构完整转折平。结句说破隔世之凉，留白不足。","_cost":0.02385},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.5,"rationale":"云端相册化现代经验入怀旧，立意新而聚焦；意象统一偏熟；炼字如贮锁开隔有诗眼；中二联开合略平；结句以青霄双关宕开，余味较足。","_cost":0.0223674},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"以云端相册入七律，今题古调融合自然。'指上初开千里月，屏中忽见故人妆'以指翻屏幕对故人影像，虚实相生，堪称诗眼。通篇围绕翻检旧照一脉贯注，章法井然。结句'半世凉'稍直白说破，余味略逊。斜阳、旧香微有熟套，但密度低。","_cost":0.00280096},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.3,"rationale":"云端相册切入怀旧，题旨集中，屏月故人妆颇见新意；但晚芳旧香等象略泛，结句半世凉稍说破。脉络清楚，语言稳练，余味未足。","_cost":0.014222},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀旧悼人,当代经验入诗自然不生硬。\"指上初开千里月,屏中忽见故人妆\"一联新事旧调融合得体;结句\"青霄\"双关云端与黄泉,余味较足。中二联情景交融,章法起承转合完整。唯斜阳、旧香、半世凉略熟,语言锤炼尚欠诗眼级的精警。","_cost":0.012891},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":5.6,"语言":6.3,"章法":5.4,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.9,"rationale":"云端入怀旧有当代切口，颈联指上千里月为诗眼，然颔颈重沓层次未开，意象夹抽象说理，尾联直抒少宕开。","_cost":0.011261},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"此作以当代云端相册入诗，抒翻览旧照忆故之怅，脉络贯通，炼字精切，颈联见巧思，'云端''青霄'双关自然；唯部分意象稍熟，结句略直，余韵稍欠。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"以云端相册入七律,当代经验化入古典语境,取象颇新。'指上初开千里月,屏中忽见故人妆'为全篇诗眼,虚实转换精切。中二联由翻检到惊见,层次递进。惟'年华''旧香''前梦'等语稍熟,'半世凉'结句直点情字,说破略尽,余味稍减。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"以“云端”双关切入数字相册，颈联“指上”“屏中”将触屏经验妥帖入诗，结句“青霄”再扣云端、以“半世凉”宕出时空之隔，有余味。但晚芳、斜阳、旧香、年华、音容等语偏旧套，颔联稍空泛，取象新旧夹杂未尽融。","_cost":0.05678},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.5,"rationale":"写云端相册翻看旧照，当代经验入诗。起承转合严密，颈联“指上屏中”警策动人；立意聚焦情真，语言有诗眼。意象沿用晚芳斜阳等常见语，结句直说“半世凉”稍直白，故意境、余味稍逊。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.029080703},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.9,"rationale":"成功将云存储、触屏浏览等当代经验融于七律。颈联“指上初开千里月，屏中忽见故人妆”化新入古极自然。尾联由虚凝之貌折入岁月之悲，首尾照应，层次清晰。","_cost":0.00585},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.8,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"以云端贮照切入怀旧有当代感而掘进不足；斜阳旧香拼贴未融；中二联同义反复无转；尾联以凉收稍有延宕。","_cost":0.016514},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"云端存照与岁月难追回形成张力，怀旧主题有当代落点。颈联指、屏入诗较自然，结句由眼前可见转为时间远隔，余味较足；首联景意联系稍虚，“何处云端”稍涩，芳、香等取象偏熟。","_cost":0.06377},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"云端旧影只作入口，怀人仍常见，情事不具体。贮芳、指月、屏妆能成薄暮冷忆，斜阳旧香故妆偏熟。语言顺而少诗眼。起问转见脉络通，中二联层次不陡。结联说破隔冷，余味不足。","_cost":0.0240592},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"云端相册入诗有新意，云端与青霄双关，暗寓阴阳相隔，收得巧。但颔颈联同写翻看，层次重复。晚芳、旧香、前梦、音容等语偏熟，情事不够具体。结句以凉字点情，略显说破。","_cost":0.019052},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写故人旧影，屏中相见与岁月相隔的对照有情味；中二联推进清楚。“指上初开”切合题材，但“前梦”“旧香”等较熟，结句“半世凉”稍嫌说尽。","_cost":0.008224}},"consensus":74.28,"final":74.28},{"key":"qwen3.8-max|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"qwen3.8-max","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"夜航乍起俯苍茫，万井星桥落大荒。云浪翻空灯影小，人间一瞬失吾乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.39999999999999,"rationale":"以夜航升空写故乡骤隐，视角新而乡愁具体。云浪、灯影由壮阔转微小，末句收束有失落余韵；“万井星桥”略显意象拥挤。","_cost":0.004832},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"以夜航当代经验入绝句，视角有新意。'万井星桥落大荒'取象精切，俯瞰感真。三句云浪灯影承转自然，结句'一瞬失吾乡'以顿失感收束，留白有延宕。惟'苍茫''大荒'稍熟套，炼字见力但首句略泛。","_cost":0.03152},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.25,"rationale":"以夜航现代经验入诗，前三句写尽起飞瞬间的宏大苍茫与灯影变幻，结句“人间一瞬失吾乡”双关失重感与乡愁，转结自然，余味悠长。无生造凑句，是当代题材成功入诗的佳作。","_cost":0.014076},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"夜航失乡题旨清楚而角度不新。万井星桥落大荒较醒，结句直说失吾乡，余韵有限。章法起转尚顺，炼字稳而少诗眼。","_cost":0.021714},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"主题常见但意象宏阔统一，炼字有“落”“失”等眼；结构完整，结句直说乡愁致余味稍欠。","_cost":0.00689392},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰入旧体，取象现代而氛围统一：万井星桥落大荒，灯影、云浪皆切高空之景，转结由物及我，一瞬失吾乡翻出羁旅新感。语言精炼，唯乍起稍平。结句情语直露而余味尚存。","_cost":0.00229236},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.7,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.8,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.95,"rationale":"夜航视角较新，星桥云灯构成高旷苍茫之境；“落”“小”见锤炼，转合清晰。惟结句“失吾乡”稍说破，余味略减。","_cost":0.009386},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写乡愁，当代经验入诗而角度较新；万井星桥、云浪灯影取象精切、氛围统一，惜「落大荒」意稍含混，转结落入乡愁常调，结句直说「失吾乡」，说破有余、留白不足。","_cost":0.0098868},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.9,"余味":7.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.7,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰化登高为当代经验，大荒星桥对比阔大，云浪句转折自然，结句以失乡收束，微露存在况味，意境完整。","_cost":0.0043689},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"此作以当代夜航俯瞰视角写乡愁，主脑明晰，意象贴合高空观感，章法流转自然，炼字准妥；结句稍直白，航空经验入诗有新意，部分意象略熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰入诗，当代经验化古出新，'万井星桥落大荒'取象精切、气象宏阔，为全篇警句；第三句云浪与灯影大小相形，转出尺度之变，结句由景入情收束有力。惟'失吾乡'稍直白说破，情感略泛，若留一分含蓄则余味更佳。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代常见题材，起承转合脉络清楚，「万井星桥落大荒」取象较有气象；「云浪翻空灯影小」转折自然。结句「一瞬失吾乡」兼有实景与身世之叹，然以直说收束，余味略显说破。「苍茫」「大荒」等语稍带套味。","_cost":0.04929},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.5,"rationale":"起承转合分明，夜航俯瞰的现代经验写出瞬间失乡之感，立意新鲜。‘万井星桥落大荒’取象精警，‘灯影小’铺垫结句。结句直说‘失吾乡’，稳当而稍直白，余味略短；语言自然，偶有松处。","_cost":0.028846434},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.4,"rationale":"成功将当代夜航体验融入律绝。章法随航机升高层层拓深，视界由广及微；末句由宏景顿转乡思，苍茫孤绝，构思出新且一气贯通。","_cost":0.005418},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"以夜航高瞰统摄苍茫，万井落荒具势，惜苍茫大荒语义复叠，转句平直，末句以一瞬失乡宕开，略挽余味。","_cost":0.01158355},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"夜航升空与故乡骤失相扣，有现代悬离感；景由万井到灯影，层次清楚。“落大荒”稍显含混，苍茫、云浪等语偏熟；结句有力，但点情较明。","_cost":0.04991},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"失乡主脑明，情事不具体，角度常见。俯瞰能成境，苍茫与大荒略复。落、翻空有力，灯影小偏弱。递进清楚而转笔平。结句说破，余味少。夜航入诗有效，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0283024},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写离乡，当代经验入诗较自然。“万井星桥落大荒”状城市灯火颇有气象。第三句云掩灯小，承接顺畅，但转折偏平。结句“失吾乡”稍显说破，好在“一瞬”留有怅惘。“苍茫”“大荒”略熟。","_cost":0.016916},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"借夜航俯瞰写故乡忽然难辨，视角具体，灯影渐小与失乡之感相承。结句有余绪，但直点“失吾乡”；“苍茫”“大荒”等词稍显泛熟。","_cost":0.008012}},"consensus":75.31,"final":75.31},{"key":"glm-5.3|深夜视频|七律","writer":"glm-5.3","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"万里相思两地荧，寒宵一晤破幽冥。容颜咫尺分明见，语笑须臾仿佛听。话到深时光乍断，灯沉黑处泪先零。连呼再拨浑无应，坐守空屏候晓星。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.1,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"以视频断线写万里相思，古典语汇融入当代情境，情事具体。颈联突转有力，末句空屏待晓，留白深长；“破幽冥”稍显用力，“仿佛听”欠精准。","_cost":0.005426},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"以视频通话入律,当代经验有效诗化,信号中断一转有戏剧性,尾联守屏候星以景收情,留白尚可。颈联'光乍断''泪先零'对仗见炼字。惟'破幽冥'措辞欠妥,幽冥指阴间,易生歧义;'寒宵''相思'等语稍熟。","_cost":0.03905},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"当代经验‘视频断线’入诗，起承转合极佳，颈联突转有力，脉络贯通。然语言稍显直白，如‘分明见’‘仿佛听’缺乏锤炼，‘破幽冥’略生硬。结句‘空屏候晓星’画面感强，略有余味。","_cost":0.020492},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"视频断线写相思具体有焦点，空屏候星以景作结有余味；然熟题未翻深境，炼字平实少警策，意象新旧杂陈略陈。结构转合尚清。","_cost":0.015518},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"当代视频通话入诗，断线瞬间的失落写得具体可感，通篇聚焦一“断”字，立意新而主脑分明。意象切合荧屏情境，结句以“空屏候晓星”景结，余味悠长。语言有“光乍断”“泪先零”等佳处，无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":0.003523168},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.25,"rationale":"当代视频通话入七律，题材独到，情事具体。荧屏、幽冥、灯黑、晓星构成统一光影氛围，景语皆情语。中二联开合有序，由见听而断线而守候，一气贯注。'话到深时光乍断，灯沉黑处泪先零'景情交割，是警联。结句坐守空屏候晓星以景收，言尽意不尽。","_cost":0.00216156},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.1,"rationale":"以视频断线写相思，当代物象入诗较自然；起承转合清晰，颈联转折有力，结以空屏晓星有余味。但‘幽冥’稍大，‘泪先零’略直，个别语句偏平。","_cost":0.01159},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"以视频通话写两地相思，旧题得新境，情事具体。中二联'话到深时''灯沉黑处'光断泪零，虚实相生；末联连呼无应、独守空屏候晓星，以景结情，余味足。'破幽冥'稍显用力，'荧'字炼而略涩，相思泪零等语稍熟，整体章法贯通、转结得力。","_cost":0.0092148},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"视频写相思翻出新境，情事具体可感；荧屏与黑夜对比成境，转折断线一联尤突兀有力，末以空屏候晓星景结情留白。","_cost":0.00795765},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"此诗取当代深夜视频断线场景写相思，情感真切具体，章法流转顺畅，颈联捕捉瞬间情绪精准，融入当代经验见新意，唯部分表述稍平，结句留白略欠。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.75,"rationale":"以视频通话写异地相思，当代经验入旧体而情真事切，'荧''幽冥'取象精切。颈联断线之转为全篇枢纽，尾联'坐守空屏候晓星'以景结情，言尽意不尽。颔联稍平熟，然整体脉络贯通，炼字见功。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"当代视频通话经验入律,叙事完整:相见—见闻—断线—守候,脉络清晰。颔联见/听对举、颈联光断泪零有捕捉。'破幽冥'略重却暗添异感。结句以景收束尚可,但'候晓星'偏熟,余味中等。","_cost":0.05777},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"以视频通话写异地相思，当代经验入诗，章法清晰、结句以景留白；然陈套语与生造词夹杂，“仿佛听”“灯沉”稍悖体验。","_cost":0.021190882},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.3,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.85,"rationale":"将当代视频通话与骤然断联的生活经验有效入律，脉络顺畅，情感真挚。转结处切中情境，尤以“坐守空屏”具体可感；惟字句稍平直近叙事，炼度尚欠凝重。","_cost":0.006504},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"以视频骤断写异地相思，旧题得新事，转折分明；结以空屏候晓宕开留白。中联见听语直，破幽冥稍夸，略有套语。","_cost":0.009617},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.95,"rationale":"以视频骤断写远隔相思，情事具体，明暗转换贯通全篇，空屏候星收束有余味。“两地荧”稍涩，“破幽冥”用力偏重，颔联较平直，泪落之笔略显直露。","_cost":0.04688},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"断线守屏事境清楚，荧与空屏呼应，转结顺畅。情志仍是常见相思，幽冥泪零晓星偏熟。两地荧欠稳，再拨近白话，少诗眼。视频入律有新意，尚未化圆。","_cost":0.0291392},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"以视频断线写异地相思,当代经验入诗,情事具体。颈联'话到深时光乍断'最佳。首句'两地荧'生硬,'幽冥'多指阴间,用在此处失当。颔联平实,'仿佛听'与'分明见'对得有些勉强。全篇依次写见、断、候,脉络清楚但偏平直。结句以空屏候星收束,尚有余味。","_cost":0.019588},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"视频相见、断线、守候，情事具体，层次递进；空屏候晓有余味。“两地荧”见新意，“幽冥”稍显夸张，“相思”“泪零”略熟。","_cost":0.013316}},"consensus":73.61,"final":73.61},{"key":"qwen3.8-max|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"qwen3.8-max","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"铁翼排云夜气清，灯河泻地万星明。千街织网光成纬，一水连天影作城。斗柄横空沧海动，风涛倒卷碧虚生。凭舷欲辨归程路，坐觉人间化玉京。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.9,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.3,"警句":3.1,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.65,"rationale":"以铁翼、灯河、街网写高空夜视，天地倒置，景象统一且层次分明；归程情意稍浅，“影作城”略虚，末以玉京点明，收束稳而留白不足。","_cost":0.013398},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"以旧体写夜航俯瞰,当代经验入诗有效。颔联'织网成纬''影作城'取象精切,灯河星海气象浑成。颈联稍虚泛,'沧海动''碧虚生'略见凑泊。结句'化玉京'点题收束,意象尚佳但已说破,余味稍减。整体脉络贯通,语言洗练。","_cost":0.03825},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"作品将现代夜航体验自然融于律体。颔联“千街织网”取象精切，写出城市灯光壮美。结构由俯瞰到仰望、由景入情，层次分明。结句“人间化玉京”虽妙但稍显说破直白，余味略欠。当代经验入诗而不生硬。","_cost":0.034816},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"夜航俯城灯火，题熟而主脑清楚。颔联织网成纬、影水作城较精切；颈联沧海碧虚稍空转。结句点破玉京，留白不足。炼字通顺有亮点。","_cost":0.02757},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰意象宏阔，'泻''织'炼字有眼，中二联地天层次分明；然立意稍泛，颈联转折略陡，结句升华有致。陈套意象稍多。","_cost":0.01719696},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰取材新颖，俯仰视角统摄全篇，主脑清晰。中二联开合有致：颔联写城市灯网之密，颈联转向天海之动，动静相生。'灯河泻地万星明''千街织网光成纬'炼字见功，喻象精切。结句'人间化玉京'以幻境收束，微觉说破，然余韵尚存。'玉京'意象稍熟。","_cost":0.00213036},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.6,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.8,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰取象宏阔，灯河星城颇有现代感；中二联铺排略同，颈联转虚稍泛，结句说破，余味稍减。","_cost":0.01146},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验入律，视角新。灯河泻地、千街织网一联意象精切，俯瞰之势足。然通篇以壮观景象为主，归程一点情思未能深入，结句化玉京稍落熟套且说得较满。中二联皆景，层次有而情脉偏薄。","_cost":0.0108438},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.3,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.4,"章法":6.9,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.2,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"铁翼夜航为当代经验有效入诗，颔颈织网倒卷有想象；然立意止于奇观铺写，主脑不深，结句玉京略套，工稳有余峭拔不足。","_cost":0.0087894},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"本诗写夜航俯瞰景，语言较见炼字功夫，颔联状灯影水色贴切，融入当代飞行经验；但情志稍泛，归思铺垫不足，结句直白，部分意象未融，略有陈套。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰入旧体，当代经验与古典语汇融合自然，中二联'织网成纬''连天作城'取象精切、对仗工稳，为全篇警策。尾联由辨路转入坐觉玉京，转合有致；惟'沧海动''碧虚生'稍显空泛，结句'化玉京'点破略直，余味稍减。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰题材当代经验入诗，灯河泻地、坐觉等语尚见工力；但颔颈两联皆铺景，开合层次不明，风涛碧虚沧海玉京一路旧套，结句直言人间化玉京，说破少余味。","_cost":0.06137},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"以铁翼、灯河、街网写夜航俯瞰，当代经验入律尚可；颔联织网光成纬炼字见巧，颈联斗柄风涛稍落陈套，结句坐觉玉京略直白。意境宏阔而情志稍泛，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.026622222},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.1,"rationale":"成功将当代夜航经验化入律诗。颔联写俯瞰街衢光影极为精工贴切；颈联转写高空气象，开合有势；尾联翻转仙凡视角赞颂人间，章法严整，融古铸今。","_cost":0.00591075},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"铁翼灯海翻出人间天上，当代经验有效但意旧；取象宏阔交融尚匀，语言通顺而纬城稍涩；中联天地开合，结句点破玉京稍直。","_cost":0.01550525},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰有当代视角，“灯河泻地”鲜明有力；中二联由街衢推向天宇，但“影作城”“碧虚生”语意欠落实。归程之思未深展，结以“玉京”较熟，收束偏直。","_cost":0.04144},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"主脑为灯火似天，止于叹奇，归程未落成情事。灯河织纬影城较融，颈联碧虚套语冲散氛围。泻、纬有力，少诗眼。由街及海可通，转平，结句说破玉京，余味薄。","_cost":0.0361264},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰属当代经验入诗。颔联以织网喻街灯、以倒影作城,较精切。首联灯河与万星意思重叠;颈联斗柄、风涛转写高空,略显空阔,与前后衔接稍跳。尾联化人间为玉京,翻转了视角,但玉京、碧虚、铁翼偏于熟套,余味尚可。","_cost":0.021248},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰的视角较鲜明，灯网、水影颇有画面；颈联转入沧海风涛稍显虚张，归程情意着墨少。末句以“玉京”点明观感，收得直白。","_cost":0.013218}},"consensus":68.21,"final":68.21},{"key":"qwen3.8-max|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"qwen3.8-max","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"社灶初开饭菜香，街坊共坐话偏长。盘中素馔多清气，一碗温汤暖夕阳。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.2,"章法":5.8,"余味":7.1,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.05,"rationale":"社区养老互助入诗，情意温厚具体，饭香、闲话、素馔、温汤相互映照。前三句推进较平，转折不足；“暖夕阳”兼写暮景与晚年，结句有余韵，惟“清气”稍泛。","_cost":0.004876},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"取材当代社区食堂,题材可喜,结句'暖夕阳'兼指暮景与暮年,略有余味。惟三句'多清气'近乎凑句,转折平直,全篇顺叙铺陈缺变化;'饭菜香''话偏长'语浅意熟,炼字平平,整体温和有余而警拔不足。","_cost":0.03548},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"当代经验“社区食堂”自然入诗，充满烟火气。语言平实，“话偏长”尽显街坊温情，结句“暖夕阳”巧妙双关黄昏与暮年，托出敬老暖意。整体结构规矩，虽略欠深邃，胜在真挚自然。","_cost":0.01549},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"社区食堂写邻里温情，具体可感而角度常见。意象清浅成境，末句情景较融。语言通顺，『话偏长』『暖』有味，『清气』稍虚。起承平直转弱。结句以景收尚有余韵。当代题材略出新，微陈无硬伤。","_cost":0.018918},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"社区食堂题材有当代生活气息，情感具体；结句“暖夕阳”以景结情兼喻晚年，留白较好。但立意角度常见，前二句偏叙事，语言平实少诗眼。","_cost":0.01747812},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"社区食堂为当代民生新题,以小见大有温度,主脑清晰,得'出新'分。'话偏长'口吻自然。但整体直陈平铺,缺诗眼锤炼,'饭菜香''清气'近套语,转句无实质转折,结句'暖夕阳'以景收束尚稳而略熟,余味有限。","_cost":0.00161356},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"题材切近，社区温情可感；意象统一而偏熟，清气夕阳稍泛。语言顺畅少锤炼，转折平直，结有余温但不新奇。","_cost":0.00747},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"社区食堂入七绝，题新而情真，聚焦邻里温情有主脑。意象妥帖但偏常见，'话偏长'略显凑字，'社灶'有生造感。起承转合完整平顺，结句'一碗温汤暖夕阳'以景结情、'夕阳'双关老人，余味最佳，摘之可诵。整体清新但锤炼不足。","_cost":0.0077448},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.6,"意境":5.4,"语言":4.9,"章法":5.7,"余味":5.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.4,"rationale":"取当代民生入题，场景具体有温情但未翻新境；物象日常妥帖而未深融为境；语言通顺少锤炼，社灶、清气稍拗；章法平实转合无波；结句借温汤收束，稳当而直白。","_cost":0.01096375},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.8,"rationale":"作品描摹社区食堂的市井烟火暖意，立意贴实真切，语言自然顺达，章法平正，结句融情于景有余温，唯整体偏平实，未作深层掘进。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"以当代社区食堂入诗，题材新而情感具体，'暖夕阳'双关暮年与日暮，收束有味。起承平实，'素馔多清气'略近熟语，整体温润但锤炼稍欠，转结尚稳，留白适度。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"写社区食堂,当代题材入诗尚自然,街坊共坐、温汤夕阳暖意可感,但角度平常,取象多饭菜香、夕阳等熟语。第三句仅续写饭食,转折乏力。结句以景结情,“暖夕阳”兼寓老人,稍有余味,整体温和平顺而少警策。","_cost":0.04075},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"以社区食堂入诗，邻里共坐、汤暖夕阳，情事具体而角度常见；意象妥帖但语多平熟，转笔弱、章法平直；结句以景结情，‘暖夕阳’有余味；无硬伤蹈袭，题材有当代性。","_cost":0.026479653},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.1,"rationale":"切入当代社区助老日常，立意温厚具体。章法承转顺畅，烟火气充盈。结句“一碗温汤暖夕阳”语带双关，融晚景与暮年于一体，妥帖含情且有余味。","_cost":0.00434475},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.0,"rationale":"取材社区食堂写老境温情，贴近现实但开掘不深；意象家常，氛围和暖而常见；文白间杂，清气暖夕阳欠锤炼；平铺直进；结以夕阳双关稍有余味。","_cost":0.0082453},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"“共坐话偏长”写出邻里亲近，生活细节可感；“多清气”泛化且搭配欠精切。全篇顺承铺写，第三句转进不足。结句“暖夕阳”兼具景意与暮年联想，有余韵，但表达偏熟。","_cost":0.03543},"grok-4.7":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.75,"rationale":"有社区食堂的当代题面, 但情志仅止于邻里和暖, 不具体。香、夕阳偏熟, 清气空, 暖夕阳略做。四句平铺少转。结句以碗汤映晚照, 点明暖字, 余味不深。","_cost":0.0242896},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"当代题材入诗，邻里温情真切但角度常见。结句“温汤暖夕阳”以夕阳双关老人，物我倒置，是全篇亮点。第三句“多清气”平泛，转得无力，接近承句。“社灶”略生硬，整体通顺，余味尚可。","_cost":0.0152},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"社区共餐写得亲切，温汤映夕阳，结句有暖意和余味。前三句多为平铺，“话偏长”稍欠自然，“清气”较虚；当代题材可取，未见更深一层的转折。","_cost":0.006996}},"consensus":61.13,"final":61.13},{"key":"qwen3.8-max|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"qwen3.8-max","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"春街病树挂寒瓶，细管潜输一滴青。自有东风知脉理，暗携新绿上长亭。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.6,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.1,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.69999999999999,"rationale":"以树木输液沟通人病与春生，构思新巧。“一滴青”“知脉理”炼字传神，物我交融。转结流畅，但“上长亭”所指稍虚，结意略趋圆满。","_cost":0.00548},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"以城市树木输液这一当代经验入诗,题材新而聚焦。'一滴青''知脉理'炼字精巧,人工救治与东风天工相映成趣。转句宕开自然,结以新绿收束有余韵;惟'长亭'系离别旧典,与街树场景稍隔,微伤浑成。","_cost":0.0389},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.75,"rationale":"本诗巧妙将当代场景“树挂吊瓶”入诗。“一滴青”炼字精妙，“脉理”双关。转结将人工干预升华至东风浩荡的自然生机，“上长亭”拉开视野，以景结情，立意新颖且章法贯通。","_cost":0.013684},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"吊瓶入诗见新意，一滴青颇具诗眼，物象能交融。然春回主旨常见，东风长亭意象套用，章法转合平稳少变，结句以景收而稍直白。","_cost":0.016874},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.15,"rationale":"现代树挂吊瓶入诗，与传统东风意象共生，立意新警；“一滴青”炼字精妙，章法转合自然，结句以景收束有余味。警句、出新可赏，无硬伤与陈滥。","_cost":0.0075163},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.5,"rationale":"以街头病树输液之当代实景入诗，喻体精新：吊瓶为'寒瓶'，营养液为'一滴青'，东风解为知脉理之医者，构思一贯而巧。'细管潜输一滴青'是诗眼，转结由人力递到天工，结以新绿上长亭收景，留白得当。唯'长亭'稍落送别旧套，微伤余味。","_cost":0.00257396},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.6,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.35,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶入诗，现代细节翻出新意。细管、青液与东风脉理相联，转结有生机。语言巧而大致自然，唯长亭稍熟，余味清浅。","_cost":0.010608},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"以行道树输液这一当代街景入绝，翻'病木逢春'熟题为新境；'一滴青''知脉理'双关见炼，现代物象与东风长亭交融不隔；起承转合清楚，转结拟人宕开、以景收束有余韵。惜巧思胜于深情，长亭略熟。","_cost":0.0143052},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.9,"语言":8.4,"章法":7.3,"余味":8.1,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"吊瓶写春苏以小见新不猎奇，寒瓶潜输一滴青炼字精切，东风知脉一点巧转，暗携新绿以景结情留白足。","_cost":0.00944175},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"此作以当代行道树挂吊瓶入诗，立意新颖，主脑集中；“细管潜输一滴青”炼字精巧，起承转合顺畅，景结有余韵。唯结句意象稍熟，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.75,"rationale":"以输液吊瓶入诗，当代城市经验与古典语汇融合自然，'细管潜输一滴青'精切有诗眼；三句以东风知脉理作转，结句以景收束留有余味。惟'东风''新绿''长亭'意象偏熟，长亭与街树场景稍见游离，整体仍属翻新有据之作。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"以街树吊瓶这一当代景入诗，题材新；「潜输一滴青」「知脉理」将医事与物候贯通，转句宕开归于自然造化，脉络清楚。惜「长亭」为凑韵而设，与市街病树情境略脱，结句意象稍熟，余味中等。","_cost":0.04562},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":9.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.75,"rationale":"当代树输液经验入诗，寒瓶细管与东风新绿交融，“一滴青”炼字新奇；章法完整，结句以景宕开。然情志偏巧，转句稍显直白，“长亭”意略熟。","_cost":0.024417163},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"将当代“树挂吊瓶”经验化入绝句，生动妥帖。“潜输一滴青”状物传神，后半首由人力转写天工造化，“知脉理”扣题灵动，结句宕开至广阔春意，气脉贯通。","_cost":0.00456825},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.7,"rationale":"以病树输液写春翻出新境，脉理双关巧；然长亭突兀，景情未全融，结句偏散余味不足。","_cost":0.01250755},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"树挂吊瓶切入具体而新鲜，“一滴青”将输液与生机融为一体；东风知脉延续医树构思，但转折较平，“长亭”缺少铺垫，结句虽有景中余情，仍稍落熟套。","_cost":0.04085},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.4,"语言":8.2,"章法":6.8,"余味":6.3,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.3,"rationale":"借树挂吊瓶写春日救治,意新而情浅。前二句寒瓶细管一滴青,象切有眼;转句东风知脉理偏于说破,结句新绿上长亭收得住却去向已明,余味不长。长亭东风稍滥,无误典硬伤。","_cost":0.0237152},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"以街树输液这一当代景象入诗,转句借东风'知脉理'暗对人工救治,构思有巧思。'一滴青'化液为色,可称亮点。但'潜''暗'语义重复。结句'长亭'离别意象与春街语境不合,似为凑韵,削弱了余味。","_cost":0.018528},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"以街树输液写春意，取材新鲜；“一滴青”鲜活，“东风知脉理”转得巧。末句“新绿”略复前意，“长亭”与春街衔接稍虚，余味偏浅。","_cost":0.00813}},"consensus":80.77,"final":80.77},{"key":"qwen3.8-max|社区食堂|七律","writer":"qwen3.8-max","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"社灶新炊巷陌香，邻翁共坐话偏长。蔬盘淡泊存真味，粥碗温醇慰晚凉。半盏清茶消暮寂，一窗灯火映斜阳。此间寒暖如相问，只在寻常举箸旁。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.1,"语言":6.3,"章法":6.7,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.35,"rationale":"社区养老温情具体，食器、清茶、灯火构成统一暖境；中二联层次略复，淡泊、真味、寒暖等语稍熟。结句落于举箸细节，稳妥有余味，但“如相问”略显含混。","_cost":0.004894},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"以社区食堂入诗题材当代,情感温厚,尾联'只在寻常举箸旁'以细节收束尚有余味。然中二联皆平列食饮景语,开合层次不足,结构平直;清茶、灯火、斜阳等意象偏熟套,'消暮寂'与'斜阳'时序微龃龉,炼字通顺而乏诗眼。","_cost":0.03698},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"题材切入当代生活，立意温润接地气。中二联工稳但“清茶”“斜阳”等意象略陈套。结句将人情冷暖归于寻常举箸，虽点题明确但表述过于直白，缺乏余味留白。","_cost":0.022442},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"社区食堂切入邻里晚景，情事具体、主脑清楚，当代经验入诗。然清茶、灯火、斜阳、暮寂等象熟套偏密；颔颈二联皆写慰藉，转意不足。结句以寒暖双关点题，收得住而偏直白。","_cost":0.026564},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.0,"rationale":"立意温暖有具体生活发现；意象统一但偏熟，中二联并列少开合，语言平妥少诗眼。结句落在寻常动作，尚有余味。题材具当代性，未见硬伤，套语略多。","_cost":0.0117124128},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"社区食堂为当代新题材入诗,立意有时代感且聚焦寻常温情。中二联蔬盘粥碗与清茶灯火意境重叠、层次略平,近于合掌。尾联化用'如相问'句式而以'举箸旁'收,宕开有味,是全篇亮点。整体语言妥帖但诗眼不足,意象偏熟。","_cost":0.00280816},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.6,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.599999999999994,"rationale":"写社区食堂烟火与邻里温情，当代题材有新意而开掘尚浅；意象贴切偏熟，语言温顺少锤炼，中二联平列，结句点破寒暖，余味有限。","_cost":0.012528},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":57.5,"rationale":"社区食堂入七律，题新而情真，寒暖晚凉关怀可感；中二联蔬盘粥碗、清茶灯火铺排平行，开合不足，转折平直；结句点出'寻常'稍直白，欠留白；意象温醇斜阳皆常见，无突出诗眼。当代经验有效入诗予以出新分。","_cost":0.0105732},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.3,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.7,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"社区食堂切入老龄温情，主脑落在寻常举箸；茶粥灯火织暮境温和而意象偏熟，语言平实少诗眼，章法铺垫有序收束稳当，尾联点题稍直。","_cost":0.006249},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"此作聚焦社区食堂的日常烟火暖意，主脑集中，意象妥帖，语言平顺，章法连贯，当代新题材入诗自然，惟意象偏熟、余味稍浅，无明显硬伤。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"以当代社区食堂入旧体，题材有新意，情事具体，'蔬盘淡泊存真味'略见理趣。但中二联四句皆饮食灯茶一路平列，开合不足近于合掌；斜阳、晚凉、暮寂等意象偏熟。结句点题稍直白，余味有限。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.75,"rationale":"题材当代、主脑明确，尾联「寒暖如相问」稍有转折，但中二联同层铺陈食物茶灯，无开合；淡泊温醇等词抽象填充，晚凉、暮寂与斜阳、灯火时序略乱；结句点破主旨，余味有限。","_cost":0.05785},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"以社区食堂写邻里晚炊，题旨明确、当代经验入诗；中二联开合有层次，意象妥帖而稍常见。结句点破‘寒暖在举箸旁’，稳当但直白。无硬伤；‘如相问’化用王昌龄而非整句蹈袭，略有陈套。","_cost":0.028172007},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.8,"余味":7.3,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.9,"rationale":"当代助老餐题材入诗自然妥帖，无生硬隔阂。情致温润真切，蔬食与灯火烘托出生活气息。尾联以“寻常举箸”落笔化大为微，收束耐品。唯中二联铺陈略显平直，语汇稍见熟套。","_cost":0.00577875},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.1,"语言":4.6,"章法":5.8,"余味":3.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.050000000000004,"rationale":"社区食堂取材真切，以寻常举箸见寒暖为主脑；中二联铺食叙景完整而转折平直，尾联直陈事理少留白，语言通顺而乏诗眼。","_cost":0.013218},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.6,"语言":6.1,"章法":5.8,"余味":6.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.3,"rationale":"以共食写晚年陪伴，“话偏长”具体传情；蔬粥茶灯氛围统一，但意象偏熟，中二联多在温情上铺陈，推进有限。“举箸旁”落回日常，尚有余味，“如相问”稍显虚泛。","_cost":0.04022},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.8,"章法":5.2,"余味":4.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.3,"rationale":"社区食堂入律，情事具体，主脑在寻常饮食里的寒暖，立意尚稳。意象妥帖而偏熟，中二联同属暖物铺陈，转折偏平。结句点明题旨，收得住而少留白。社灶略生，无硬伤与整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.0181424},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.25,"rationale":"社区食堂是当代题材，温情可感，但角度平实。中二联罗列蔬盘、粥碗、清茶、灯火，是同一层面的平铺，原地打转。晚凉、暮寂、斜阳时间意象重复，灯火映斜阳略显别扭。结句收于举箸，稳而稍直，有些说破。","_cost":0.01798},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.25,"rationale":"社区共餐的温情具体可感，但蔬粥、清茶、灯火多沿常见写法；中二联层次稍弱，结句点明题旨而留白不足。","_cost":0.008014}},"consensus":64.53,"final":64.53},{"key":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813|云端相册|七律","writer":"deepseek-v4-pro-0813","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"云间相册贮青春，掌上流光不染尘。满卷悲欢随指转，几回聚散敛眉频。浮生片刻谁留影，故里经年梦未真。欲向屏前删旧我，却愁痕淡迹难循。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.1,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.9,"rationale":"以云端相册写青春留存与自我删改，今意鲜明。指转、删旧我贯穿有序，结句含惘然余味；“不染尘”“浮生”稍熟，“敛眉频”略显凑涩。","_cost":0.005094},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字时代记忆与自我删改，熟题得新角度，尾联'删旧我''迹难循'有哲思余味。中二联'随指转''敛眉频'贴切但情感稍浮泛，'浮生''故里'略落套语。章法完整，转合自然,当代经验入诗有效。","_cost":0.0306},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"本诗将数字生活“云相册”巧妙入诗，立意新颖。语言通顺，“随指转”、“删旧我”刻画生动。然中二联略平直，“敛眉频”等词见陈套，结句直抒胸臆未尽留白之妙，整体仍为切中现代情感之佳作。","_cost":0.019756},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"云端相册与删旧我有当代切入，情志尚具体。意象新旧并列欠浑融，语言通达少锤炼。章法平铺转弱，结句略留痕迹之思。","_cost":0.017038},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字记忆，尾联删旧我有巧思；中二联悲欢聚散浮生故里略泛，结句偏直说，余味稍减。","_cost":0.00674146},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字时代的记忆与自我更新，熟题翻新，当代经验入诗自然不隔。中二联悲欢聚散与留影归梦开合有层次。结句删旧我却愁痕迹难循，宕开一笔言尽意不尽。惟浮生、敛眉等语稍熟，个别句意微晦。","_cost":0.00192956},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.6,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.1,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字记忆，题旨集中，末联删旧我略有新意；然青春、浮生等语偏泛，意象抽象，锤炼未精，结构顺畅但转折平直。","_cost":0.013376},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀旧,旧题得新境,'删旧我而愁迹难循'心理真切、结句有反转余味。'不染尘'双关数字相册尤妙。唯悲欢聚散、浮生故里等语稍熟,中二联情感平行少开合,'敛眉频'句法略凑。","_cost":0.0154962},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":5.2,"语言":5.6,"章法":6.8,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.1,"rationale":"以云端存储写记忆留删的矛盾，立意贴合当代有主脑；章法递进完整，但意象偏抽象议论，语言平熟欠诗眼，结句直陈纠结余宕不足。","_cost":0.00812565},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"此作以当代云端相册入七律，围绕翻览旧照抒聚散之慨与旧我难寻的怅惘，主脑明晰；尾联有新意，章法顺畅，惟部分意象稍泛、结句略实，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字时代的记忆与自我删改，当代经验入旧体而情真有主脑；'删旧我却愁痕淡迹难循'翻出新意、结有余味。惟中二联'悲欢聚散''浮生故里'取象偏熟，'敛眉频'稍见凑韵，整体意象交融度尚可再深。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写流光聚散,当代经验入诗尚自然,'随指转'一句有巧思。然'敛眉频''痕淡迹难循'凑韵生硬,颈联'故里经年'与主脉略疏;结句欲删旧我又愁痕淡,意有新意但说得偏尽,余味中平。","_cost":0.05572},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字记忆，删旧我具当代经验与心理深度，结语耐品；然中二联浮生故里等意象稍熟，痕淡迹微费解，整体新境与陈语并存。","_cost":0.031848477},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.7,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.4,"rationale":"当代数字经验入律化合自然，“随指转”“删旧我”抓取细节生动。尾联叩问虚拟存储与个体存在的悖论，余味颇长。颈联对仗稍涉泛俗，但全篇构思新巧、脉络清晰。","_cost":0.0061845},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"数字记忆立意尚新，然中段泛入悲欢浮生故里而游离；多虚语少实象，尾联删留悖论稍挽余味。","_cost":0.011909},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"以云端存照写删我与惜痕的矛盾，主脑鲜明；“随指转”贴切，中二联情事偏泛，“敛眉频”略涩。尾联回折有力，结句仍偏直述；青春、浮生、乡梦等熟语稍密。","_cost":0.03662},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.25,"rationale":"云相册、随指转、删旧我切当代经验，主脑清楚。然悲欢聚散、浮生故里套语稀释意境，颈联旁逸，结句点明愁且“痕淡难循”与删而不去相忤，说破味薄。","_cost":0.0311616},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写当代记忆，立意有新意。'删旧我'而又愁'迹难循'，想删又怕失去，矛盾有味。中二联多用悲欢、聚散、浮生、故里等泛语。'敛眉频'凑韵，'故里'句游离题旨。意象偏虚，结句稍直露。","_cost":0.016408},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"以删照片写对旧我的不舍，当代经验入诗；但多写悲欢、浮生等抽象感慨，少有相册中的具体画面。故里一转稍显突兀，结句有牵念而未充分留白。","_cost":0.008194}},"consensus":68.66,"final":68.66},{"key":"qwen3.8-max|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"qwen3.8-max","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"春街老树挂晶瓶，弱影犹支雨后青。土脉寒凝芽未吐，泉声暗滴梦初醒。谁将苦液输枯骨，自借甘津养瘦形。莫道沉疴难再绿，东风已在叶梢听。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.1,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.7,"余味":7.3,"警句":2.2,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.7,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.85,"rationale":"以树木输液写春日复苏，取材新鲜，诸象围绕“疗病返青”收束。颔联较佳；“苦液”“甘津”略相牾，“芽未吐”而有“叶梢”稍显逻辑跳跃，结句有灵气但句法微涩。","_cost":0.007362},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"以城市街树输液这一当代景象入诗，题材新而情有所寄，全篇围绕'救树'一线收束。中二联'苦液输枯骨''甘津养瘦形'对仗切事，惟'弱影犹支'等处稍见凑泊。尾联'莫道'句先说破，赖'东风叶梢听'以景挽回，余味打了折扣。","_cost":0.04251},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"将当代“树挂吊瓶”之景入诗，立意新颖。以“泉声”喻滴液声颇具匠心，尾联“东风已在叶梢听”生动传神、余味不尽。唯颈联雕琢稍显斧凿，整体脉络贯通，现代经验转化自然。","_cost":0.017738},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"挂瓶护树场景具体，主脑清楚，当代感撑起立意；意象半新半旧，颈联稍整而通篇少诗眼；起承完整转势平直，结句以叶梢听略留余味。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.016698},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.25,"rationale":"以街树打吊瓶为新切点，医喻贯穿而情志具体；尾联东风听叶收束，留白有致。中二联略平，'雨后青'与'芽未吐'微有龃龉，'枯骨'稍重，但无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":0.0126258},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.75,"rationale":"以吊瓶输液治树入诗，当代都市经验化为咏物寄怀，立意新颖且聚焦。通篇以病树自况，'输枯骨''养瘦形'炼字见奇，'听'字作结以景收情，言尽意不尽。中二联开合有度，唯'苦液甘津'稍露人工痕迹。","_cost":0.00254236},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.95,"rationale":"取城市护树新题，以吊瓶写病枝复苏，脉络清楚；颔颈有象有意，但苦甘、沉疴等稍显直露，转折不深；结以东风叶梢留余味。","_cost":0.012312},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.5,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶写春城护理，喻体统一、结有生气；苦液枯骨稍硬，东风收束略露说教。","_cost":0.0145908},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.1,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.9,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"吊瓶救树翻新春木熟题，具当代现场感；泉声暗滴等炼字见功，结句听风留余，然枯骨瘦形略硬，转合稍平。","_cost":0.00949915},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"选取当代行道树打吊针的日常场景入诗，立意鲜活，章法连贯，炼字精巧，结句有余韵，唯部分语词稍熟，无硬伤蹈袭，颇具当代新意。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.25,"rationale":"以城市行道树输液这一当代经验入旧体，题材新颖且情志真挚。颔联'泉声暗滴梦初醒'以听觉写生机暗动，颈联设问流转有力；结句'东风已在叶梢听'以景收束、留白得法。中二联开合有层次，脉络贯通。语言通顺偶见锤炼，唯个别处稍平熟。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"取城市树木挂吊瓶入诗，当代经验有效化为病树待春之象，立意较新；“泉声暗滴梦初醒”以滴液为泉声颇见巧思。然颈联苦液/甘津、枯骨/瘦形意近合掌，“东风已在叶梢听”语稍生硬，结句“莫道”兜底略说破，余味中等。","_cost":0.05023},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.75,"rationale":"街树挂瓶写枯木逢春，当代经验入律，题意集中、角度新；中二联由景及人，脉络清而转折稍平。'泉声暗滴''叶梢听'鲜活，结句含蓄；'支''枯骨'略有斧凿。","_cost":0.047826534},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.7,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.60000000000001,"rationale":"将当代城市园林输液意象自然入律，情理交融。中二联推进略滞，枯骨对瘦形稍显词复刻意；尾联翻出希望，以听风收束，寄意深稳且余韵悠长。","_cost":0.00570825},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"古树输液取材新切有主脑，泉声暗滴双关巧；惟三联偏议，莫道说教失留白，支、听拈词生硬。","_cost":0.01290155},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.0,"rationale":"以街树输液写衰病求生，取材较新，主旨集中；晶瓶、暗滴切题，枯骨、瘦形稍显复沓。“自借”承接含混，“叶梢听”语意稍涩；章法完整，尾联先说破再拟人，余味受限。","_cost":0.04916},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"吊瓶化晶瓶、滴注作泉声,病树氛围能融,意境最好。主脑清楚,然情志止于可苏,不够独到。颈联苦甘枯瘦说破,承转平直。结句前半兜明,叶梢听只略留余味。当代经验入律有效,无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0356656},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"以吊瓶入诗,当代经验有效,但立意仍落在枯木逢春的常见路数。泉声暗滴喻输液尚巧,苦液、甘津对照略显刻意。首联写雨后青、尾联写叶梢,与芽未吐相抵,前后有矛盾。尾联以莫道起句,转向偏直,听字稍见新意。","_cost":0.020332},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"街树吊瓶入诗，输液暗滴与春意相融，关切具体；由寒凝写到灌养，脉络清楚。‘雨后青’与‘芽未吐’稍有牴牾，‘东风’略熟；结句以‘听’留有余意。","_cost":0.013512}},"consensus":75.46,"final":75.46},{"key":"qwen3.8-max|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"qwen3.8-max","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"万架灯凝一片霜，云仓夜扫电流光。千箱列宿无声动，指上星河入晓凉。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.8,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.7,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.39999999999999,"rationale":"以夜间云仓作诗境，将货架、箱列、扫描化为霜光列宿，冷静而有现场感。末句由指端宕入晓凉，余味佳；“夜扫电流光”“无声动”稍显压缩含混。","_cost":0.006176},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.3,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.4,"rationale":"以云仓夜间作业入诗，当代经验化用星河列宿意象颇见巧思，'千箱列宿无声动'尤佳。结句'指上星河入晓凉'以触觉收束有余味。惜情感稍薄，'电流光'凑意微硬，霜、星河属熟象，整体新而未深。","_cost":0.03457},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.0,"rationale":"本诗将现代“云仓”巧妙入诗。以“列宿”“星河”喻海量包裹与数据，宏大与微观交织。结句“入晓凉”点出彻夜劳作的清苦，科技感与古典诗意完美融合，意象翻新而不突兀。","_cost":0.014974},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"云仓夜役入诗，灯凝霜、箱列宿、指上星河成清冷统一境，题旨具体。电流光稍硬，转势平直近铺陈。结句以景收尚留晓凉余韵。当代仓景入古体可取。","_cost":0.015966},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"以霜、星、河为统一意象，写云仓夜扫颇见新意，结句最佳。立意稍停留在景象美感，未深挖；‘电流光’略生硬。","_cost":0.00816629},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"以星宿、霜、银河统摄自动化云仓夜扫之景，当代经验入诗自然而巧，一气贯注。结句'指上星河入晓凉'以景结情，余味悠长。唯情感偏于赞叹，主体情志稍浅，霜、星河等象仍属熟路。","_cost":0.00282196},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.6,"余味":8.1,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.7,"rationale":"写云仓夜扫，以霜灯、列宿、星河构光境，当代经验新颖。‘凝’‘入’有致，惟‘电流光’稍硬，情志偏场景，余味尚可。","_cost":0.008238},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"以云仓夜班入七绝,取象统一:万架灯霜、千箱列宿、指上星河,夜景氛围浑成,结句宕开有余味。然题旨偏朦胧,'夜扫'何指欠落实,情志较薄;'电流光'略生硬,'星河''霜'语熟。整体工整新巧而深度不足。","_cost":0.0070938},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.3,"语言":6.7,"章法":7.6,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.55,"rationale":"古意写今仓，以霜宿星河贯串冷光宇宙，章法由万架收至指尖，尾句以凉作结有余韵，个别用语稍直。","_cost":0.00949965},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"以古典星霜意象写当代云仓夜作，取象浑融，章法圆转，炼字稳当，结句有余味，将平凡劳作写出清旷浪漫诗意，无硬伤陈套，颇具新意。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"当代仓储夜班入七绝，取象精切：灯凝霜、箱作列宿、扫码光化星河，物我交融成统一清寒氛围。'指上星河入晓凉'以景结情，言尽意不尽。起承转合完整，第三句'无声动'暗转有力。惟'一片霜''电流光'稍近熟语，整体炼字见功而不露斧凿。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"以数据机房入七绝，灯霜、列宿、星河一脉光象营造冷寂氛围，当代经验入诗有效。然通篇写景无人情主脑，第二句复述题目、'电流光'稍硬，转句仍在铺陈光象缺变化；结句'入晓凉'以景收有余味。","_cost":0.03839},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"以星霜、列宿、星河喻云仓夜扫，当代经验入诗而出新；结句指上星河入晓凉，余味悠长。次句电流光略质实，情志稍隐，整体景语冷峻。","_cost":0.021729421},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.35,"rationale":"将当代智能仓储与夜间作业经验巧妙化入诗境。“列宿”“星河”取象精妙，切中自动化物流的秩序与光影。后二句尤工，以古典笔墨写现代科技，收于晓凉，余味清旷。","_cost":0.005361},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.2,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.6,"rationale":"云仓自动化题材新颖，以霜宿星河喻灯箱统一寒光氛围，但电流光直白，指上费解，一二句合掌，结句以晓凉宕开稍有余味。","_cost":0.0136485},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"云仓夜扫有当代质感，灯霜、列宿、星河贯成冷亮氛围；情志尚欠具体，“电流光”语意欠稳。由万架、千箱收至指上，层次可辨而转折稍平；结句以晓凉留韵。","_cost":0.04098},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.4,"意境":8.1,"语言":6.6,"章法":6.1,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.85,"rationale":"夜扫拟星河,焦点清,当代经验入诗,然情志偏冷,情事只落指尖。冷光氛围统一,霜宿星河略复。次句承题平,电流光欠炼,转折不烈。结不说破,晓凉可延。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0244144},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"以星宿、星河喻云仓夜间分拣,当代劳动经验入诗有新意。三句「列宿无声动」颇佳,结句落到指尖、以晓凉收束,有余味。但次句「电流光」生硬近散文,人物情感着墨偏少,主旨稍显单薄。","_cost":0.013896},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"以星空写云仓夜间作业，冷光与晓凉相贯，场景有新意；“指上星河”留有余味。但“电流光”稍涩，后两句意象相近，转折不够鲜明。","_cost":0.008106}},"consensus":78.3,"final":78.3},{"key":"qwen3.8-max|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"qwen3.8-max","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"夜扫云仓月满廊，灯青架冷照微霜。尘封秘阁千函静，漏断寒机一帚凉。指下银钩成脉络，屏中河汉焕天章。灵台已辟澄怀路，两袖秋光入大荒。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.7,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.7,"rationale":"以古典冷色写云仓夜扫，主脑清楚，物境由幽冷转向澄明。“屏中河汉”“两袖秋光”颇有亮色。惟后半抽象语偏密，“漏断寒机一帚凉”稍涩，结句壮阔而略泛。","_cost":0.008394},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"以夜理数据('云仓')入律,今事古咏有新意;'一帚凉''屏中河汉'虚实相生。惟颈联偏于干说,'灵台''澄怀''大荒'近乎套语,炼字未见真诗眼。结句宕开有余韵而气象稍空,整体清顺但力度未足。","_cost":0.04034},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"本诗巧妙将现代机房运维与云端数据清理的当代经验入诗。“灯青架冷”“屏中河汉”将科技物象与古典意境完美融合，颈联气象宏大。尾联“入大荒”宕开一笔，境界顿开，是科技题材诗词化用的佳作。","_cost":0.019518},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"夜扫云仓由尘函而屏汉而澄怀，主脑集中、角度半新。清冷可感，秘阁河汉灵台大荒略密。语言通顺，一帚凉、两袖秋光稍炼。转结由帚入屏较活。尾句入荒有余味。套语中等。","_cost":0.02601},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"夜扫云仓题旨集中，颔联实写清寒可感；颈联转出数据意象，有当代感。然古典陈套密集，屏中与秘阁等语汇略隔，尾联说破澄怀，余味偏虚。炼字有亮点，整体佳句可摘。","_cost":0.01013716},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.25,"rationale":"以夜扫云仓写机房值守，当代经验入古典语境，题旨聚焦有主脑。'秘阁千函''屏中河汉'化旧象写新境，颔联'漏断寒机一帚凉'见诗眼。结句以景宕开，余味悠长。'灵台澄怀'稍涉熟语，'入大荒'化用李白而不觉生硬。","_cost":0.00397096},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.0,"rationale":"取云仓夜扫新题，屏幕银钩稍有当代感；清冷意象成境，然尾联转虚，灵台大荒略泛，语词未全熔炼。章法完整，警句在颈联。","_cost":0.010432},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.2,"警句":2.2,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.8,"rationale":"以夜扫云仓写数字时代的澄心秩序，题旨较新；“指下”“屏中”一联最见融合。冷月秋光与灵台、大荒稍熟，物象间略跳脱，结句开阔有余韵。","_cost":0.0165378},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.9,"rationale":"以夜扫云仓翻旧为新，由廊月微霜至脉络河汉终入大荒，层次递进；尾联以景结情宕开有余味，中联稍见雕刻理语微直。","_cost":0.01004275},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"此诗写夜扫云仓的清寂景况与澄怀之思，细节真切，炼字有亮点，章法贯通；但主旨点破过直，余味稍薄，多取常见意象，无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.0,"rationale":"以夜扫云仓写数据中心守夜人，当代经验化入古典意象，题旨新颖聚焦。灯青架冷、屏中河汉物我交融，冷寂与浩瀚氛围统一。颈联'指下银钩成脉络，屏中河汉焕天章'为佳联。尾联以景结情有余味；唯'灵台已辟澄怀路'稍涉说理直白。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"以“云仓”“屏中河汉”将数据存储与秘阁夜扫古今叠合，构思有想法，前两联清冷氛围尚完整；但“一帚”与“屏”“机”意象体系互扰，焦点游移，颈联略夸饰。尾联“灵台”“澄怀”“两袖”“大荒”多为套语，说理式收束，余味平直。","_cost":0.06376},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"以古典语汇写云仓夜作，屏中河汉焕天章、两袖秋光入大荒二句新颖开阔；然寒机成脉络等处生硬，情志稍泛，结构完整而转折略平。","_cost":0.032104414},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.2,"rationale":"以古典诗语精妙化写现代数字云仓运维之境。前四句冷峻清肃，颈联银钩河汉虚实互生，新颖有力；结句宕开归于澄怀旷远。融当代经验于古典意象而不显凿痕。","_cost":0.00533025},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.1,"意境":6.6,"语言":5.1,"章法":5.9,"余味":4.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.55,"rationale":"夜扫云仓点出数字整理新意，然情事转虚发散；景氛清冷较统一，尾理说破收散，句法略生。","_cost":0.0159348},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"云仓、屏幕与古典物象交映，夜扫澄怀有主线；“一帚凉”较凝练。扫除转指下银钩稍突，“成脉络”偏泛，月霜天章等熟象偏密；结句宕远有余意，但“大荒”铺垫不足。","_cost":0.05147},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"前四句冷库夜色较完整，一帚凉有炼字。立意停在澄怀入荒的概括，情事不具体。颈联跳向银钩天章，第七句说破，结句虽宕开而秋光大荒近套。云仓、寒机入律有新意，未全化开。","_cost":0.0333232},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"以古秘阁夜扫写云存储维护，古今叠映有新意；颔联寒机一帚凉较精。颈联屏中河汉略浮泛，尾联灵台澄怀偏说理，两袖秋光入大荒气象虽开而语近套路，余味一般。","_cost":0.019384},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"夜扫云仓兼具实景与数字意味，灯、架、屏相映，有新意。中段由清扫转向创作略急；结句虽有开阔之势，却被“天章”“澄怀”“大荒”等泛语冲淡了余味。","_cost":0.008184}},"consensus":68.14,"final":68.14},{"key":"kimi-k3|机场送别|七绝","writer":"kimi-k3","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"执手殷勤问客程。残云漠漠意难平。遥看铁翼苍茫远。独对玻璃万盏明。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.8,"意境":6.4,"语言":5.7,"章法":6.6,"余味":7.1,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.900000000000006,"rationale":"送别主旨集中但角度常见；铁翼、玻璃切合机场，末句以明景反衬孤独，颇有留白。残云、苍茫、意难平稍陈熟，个别措辞略显生硬。","_cost":0.005892},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"熟题而以当代机场入境,前二句执手、残云皆旧套,后二句铁翼、玻璃万盏明化今物为诗象,结句以景收情、独立候机厅之孤寂有余味。章法起承转结完整,惟前半陈语稍拖后腿,语言平稳少诗眼。","_cost":0.04441},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"当代经验入诗，“铁翼”“玻璃”等意象融合尚可，章法完整。结句以景结情，灯火反衬孤影颇有余味。然“意难平”稍显直白熟滥，语言整体平正而略乏锤炼。","_cost":0.014974},"grok-4.6":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"送别题旨常见无新境，情欠具体。意象新旧并列未深融。语言通顺乏锤炼多套语。章法顺序完整转折平直。结以灯景略留白。当代物象稍新，执手残云等陈词较密。","_cost":0.016272},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"机场送别以铁翼、玻璃等现代意象入旧题，情感真切；结句以景结情，孤独与灯火反差有余味。但起承略熟，意难平直露，整体中上。","_cost":0.00450538},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"机场送别化古典情境入当代经验，'铁翼''玻璃万盏'取象精切。结句以繁灯反衬孤独，以景结情，余味佳。'执手殷勤'化用有痕，'残云漠漠'稍熟，整体脉络起承转合完整贯通。","_cost":0.00225136},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"机场入诗有当代感，起承转合清楚，结以灯下玻璃留余味；但情语直露，残云、苍茫等意象偏熟，铁翼、玻璃稍硬，未全融。","_cost":0.012308},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"送别熟题以机场新象撑起，焦点集中；残云、意难平稍熟且直说，铁翼、玻璃灯影成现代离境氛围。承转略平，结句独对万盏灯，以景收情，延宕较好。","_cost":0.0141708},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.4,"语言":4.8,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.7,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.3,"rationale":"机场题材以铁翼玻璃入诗有当代感，然执手意难平等语较泛，景情略分，转结空间对照尚稳，未见锤炼警策。","_cost":0.0065314},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"此作以当代机场场景写传统别愁，脉络贯通，结句以景衬情有余味，新旧意象融合自然；唯立意未拓新境，部分意象稍熟，语言平实少锤炼，转折略直。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":74.5,"rationale":"送别熟题而以机场场景翻新,结句'独对玻璃万盏明'以现代意象收束,以景结情,余味悠长,为全诗诗眼。'残云''意难平''执手'稍见陈套,'殷勤问客程'近柳词意脉。起承转合完整,三句宕开四句收回,脉络贯通。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"送别熟题移入机场,铁翼、玻璃万盏灯有当代实感,结句以景收情留白尚佳。但前二句执手殷勤、残云漠漠、意难平皆旧套,转句平直,语言少锤炼,整体稳而不奇。","_cost":0.04303},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"以铁翼、玻璃写机场送别，结句以景收束，有余味；然通篇多‘残云漠漠’‘意难平’等套语，立意常见、转折平直，语言欠炼，故中低档。","_cost":0.033790077},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"当代机场经验有效入诗。前两句稍嫌平直直白，转结极见功力，由铁翼远去转回收束于独对玻璃万盏，以景结情，空间开阔而孤寂感自出，余味绵长。","_cost":0.00503475},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.0,"rationale":"送别题旨明确而无新境，起承转结完整有人去留分，铁翼玻璃为当代经验但炼字欠精，残云意难平等套语多，结景反衬而晦涩。","_cost":0.01056125},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.2,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.1,"章法":7.2,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.3,"rationale":"送别题旨集中，角度仍常见。“残云漠漠”较熟，“意难平”直露，“铁翼苍茫远”略涩。由执手转遥看、独对，层次清楚；结句以玻璃与灯火衬孤独，现代场景融入情境，留有余味。","_cost":0.03426},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"送别题旨清楚,只是常见离情,未见独到发现。铁翼与玻璃灯火略能化今入诗,残云、意难平、苍茫则陈熟。承句虚说,转结以远去与独对收住。结句景语未说破,余味尚可,未成警句。","_cost":0.0160192},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.25,"rationale":"机场送别是熟题,借铁翼、玻璃入诗,有当代气息,角度仍属常见。次句“意难平”直说情意,属套语。“玻璃万盏”量词搭配欠妥。结句以灯火玻璃映照独立之人,以景结情,孤寂感尚有余味。转句平直,全篇稳而少警策。","_cost":0.016592},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"执手、目送、独对，送别脉络清楚；末句以玻璃与万盏灯光写孤独，留有余味。残云、铁翼稍显熟套，“意难平”说得较直。","_cost":0.007982}},"consensus":63.78,"final":63.78},{"key":"kimi-k3|机场送别|七律","writer":"kimi-k3","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"暮雨高空暗客尘，云关又渡远行人。灯前自语归期杳，别绪将成隔世身。检票声寒催旅急，天程已入九霄津。重门渐合山涯邈，独倚回廊数去轮。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"fail"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.8,"意境":6.4,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.8,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.300000000000004,"rationale":"送别主脑明确，暮雨、检票、重门递进有序，机场经验入诗尚自然。惟“隔世身”“九霄津”“数去轮”语意稍涩，部分旧套偏重；结句以独倚收情，有景有余味。","_cost":0.006828},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"机场入律有当代经验,'检票声寒''数去轮'贴切可感,结句倚廊望机以景收情有余味。但'隔世身'夸饰失度,'九霄津'凑意空泛,颔颈两联开合层次不清,由室内灯前跳至检票脉络稍乱,炼字见斧凿。","_cost":0.03523},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.75,"rationale":"尝试将机场送别入诗，但古典意象（云关、重门）与现代词汇（检票）融合生硬，文白夹杂。颈联刚检票即入九霄，时空逻辑脱节。结句以画面收束留有余味，但“去轮”略生造。","_cost":0.020126},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"机场送别题旨明确而角度常见，情事尚具体。古典送别套语与检票、去轮杂糅，境未浑融。用语偶硬。章法按时序可通，结句以景收略有余韵。","_cost":0.018514},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"送别主线清晰，结句以景收束有余味；意象新旧夹杂，'云关/九霄津/隔世身'等套语偏多，中二联开合与炼字不足。","_cost":0.00609928},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"机场送别以云关、九霄津、去轮化今入古，立意有新境；结句独倚回廊数去轮以景结情，余味最佳。但'暗客尘''隔世身'半属生造，别绪成身逻辑欠通；中二联开合不足，情感略显原地徘徊。","_cost":0.00457676},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.1,"rationale":"机场送别题旨明确，检票、回廊等现代细节使情事具体；别绪主线清楚，但‘隔世身’稍泛。意境有暮雨重门之统一氛围，语言个别词生硬；结句以独倚数轮留白，余味较好。","_cost":0.010674},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.25,"rationale":"机场题材入七律有新意,\"检票声寒\"\"重门渐合\"融现代物象尚可,暮雨客尘氛围统一。然\"隔世身\"夸张失度,\"九霄津\"生造,颔联少景语;结句独倚数轮以景结情,略有延宕。整体熟题套语偏多,亮点不足。","_cost":0.0156582},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.2,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.6,"章法":4.8,"余味":4.7,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.0,"rationale":"机场送别以隔世身夸饰失真，古今意象杂拼不融，句法拗涩缺诗眼，脉络跳接，结句数去轮生硬无余韵，仅取机场新材略有尝试。","_cost":0.00678725},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"此作写机场送别的怅惘，情感真切，章法平顺，能融入当代场域细节，但立意平熟，部分意象陈套，措辞偶有浮泛，结句偏直余韵不足，无显著硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"以机场入七律，检票声、回廊数去轮等当代经验化用较自然，结句以景收情有余味。但'云关''九霄津'等旧语与机场实景嫁接略生硬，'别绪将成隔世身'夸张失度，中二联意象常见，整体题旨明确而新境有限。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"机场送别以旧体写当代经验,云关、检票声寒、重门渐合有新意;结句独倚数轮以景结情尚有余味。但雨中言尘、已入九霄后又写门合,时序逻辑倒置;隔世身用力过重,九霄津凑韵生硬,客尘归期等套语略多。","_cost":0.06195},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"以律体写机场送别，当代经验入诗；情真而“归期杳”等略熟。意象有现代感，“九霄津”“去轮”稍硬；章法完整，结句以数去轮留白。警句在“检票声寒”与尾联，无蹈袭硬伤，陈滥轻。","_cost":0.040070099},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"尝试以古典诗境融合当代机场送别，章法按送客流程推进，脉络清晰。唯“隔世身”情感过火，“数去轮”指称微涩。尾联以景结情，独倚留白，颇有余味。","_cost":0.00506625},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.2,"语言":3.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.3,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.8,"rationale":"送别主脑不明隔世夸饰，暮雨云关山涯回廊与机场空间龃龉，暗客尘别绪成身搭配生硬，时序尚续，尾句数去轮晦涩留白不足。","_cost":0.01593055},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.05,"rationale":"送别主旨集中，检票声与重门较切机场情境；“隔世身”“九霄津”显得生硬，“去轮”指向欠明。中联情意推进有限，尾句以独倚计数寄托不舍，尚有余味，整体仍多传统羁旅语汇。","_cost":0.03844},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.0,"rationale":"主脑是航站送别，情事不具体，隔世偏夸。古今意象并置未融。检票声寒、数去轮较佳，旅急与九霄津嫌凑。检票可作转，升空后始合门，时序略滞。结句数轮留白，余味最好。前半套话偏多，无整句袭用。","_cost":0.0437568},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.0,"rationale":"题旨明确而角度常见。检票、回廊等当代物象可取。但暗客尘、别绪成隔世身生硬夸饰；颈联已入九霄，尾联才写重门渐合，次序颠倒，山涯与机场亦不切。结句倚廊数去轮尚有余味，但去轮于机场欠贴切。","_cost":0.01806},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"检票声、重门写出机场送别的实感，末句独倚尚有余情；但“隔世身”言情过重，“九霄津”“山涯邈”与眼前场景衔接生硬，转折也较平直。","_cost":0.011618}},"consensus":56.12,"final":56.12},{"key":"kimi-k3|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"kimi-k3","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"霓灯幻出夜光机，掷币柔情唤不归。铁爪悬空终又缩，绒熊隔水梦微微。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.1,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":0.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"借抓娃娃写柔情落空，主脑集中，铁爪与绒熊构成具体张力，转结含蓄有余味。“夜光机”稍显生硬，“隔水”虽有幻意但欠贴切。","_cost":0.005116},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写求而不得,当代经验入诗有新意;'铁爪悬空终又缩'一句具体传神,转折得势。惟'唤不归''梦微微'略显凑韵含混,'隔水'化用盈盈一水尚可但玻璃作水稍隔一层。结句留白有余味而意象稍虚。","_cost":0.03777},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"当代经验入诗自然，“隔水”喻玻璃绝佳，赋予抓娃娃“在水一方”的古典怅惘。起承转合流畅，结句以景收束，留白隽永。唯“夜光机”略显生涩。","_cost":0.015274},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入诗有当代感，铁爪一缩与绒熊隔水成境。然「柔情」落空，立意未出求而不得旧套；掷币柔情略硬，余味在结句尚可。","_cost":0.023084},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.75,"rationale":"借抓娃娃机写求而不得，立意集中。意象霓灯铁爪绒熊统一于迷离失落，转结尤佳。语言有“柔情唤不归”等亮点，结句以景收束，余味深。唯“隔水”稍晦。","_cost":0.0046915},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.5,"rationale":"以都市游戏机写求而不得之柔情，当代经验入诗自然。霓灯、铁爪、绒熊取象精切，情意与物象交融。起承转合完整，转句铁爪缩回有顿挫。结句以'隔水梦微微'以象收束，言尽意不尽，余韵佳。'唤不归'稍显用力，'隔水'于理略宽，然无碍大局。","_cost":0.00246556},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.7,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.64999999999999,"rationale":"取材现代游戏，场景集中，铁爪悬空一句描摹生动，结以隔水微梦留余韵。惜柔情、梦微微略泛，隔水于娃娃机未稳，整体清新而稍欠锤炼。","_cost":0.012168},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写可望难即的温柔消费幻境，焦点集中；铁爪一缩、绒熊隔梦，转结有势且留白。惟“掷币柔情”略硬，“隔水”指玻璃稍隔，意象未至极精。","_cost":0.0116778},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.6,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.85,"rationale":"以铁爪绒熊喻求不得之柔情，借当代物象翻出小境。霓灯与隔水氛围交融，转缩一笔传神，结句以景收情有余味，唯柔情微梦炼字稍虚。","_cost":0.0080354},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"此作撷取当代抓娃娃机日常场景，写期待落空的微怅，意象妥帖，章法顺畅，结句以景留白有余韵，当代经验入诗自然，无硬伤陈套。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写求而不得之情，当代经验入旧体而化用'盈盈一水间'意脉，题旨具体有主脑。霓灯、铁爪、绒熊取象精切，景语即情语。起承转合完整，结句'梦微微'以景收情、留白有余。'唤不归''终又缩'炼字见力。唯题材小巧、格局有限，故未至最高档。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"当代题材入诗，铁爪悬空复缩一句具象有致，隐喻求而不得尚可感。然“夜光机”“柔情”“梦微微”等属凑字填空，情意浮泛；“隔水”指玻璃隔断失准，结句软而未收，余味不足。","_cost":0.05034},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写柔情失落，起承转合清晰、转结佳；‘铁爪’句警炼，结句以景留白，当代经验入诗有新意。然‘隔水’违和（机非水），‘掷币’不切，情语稍泛。","_cost":0.039525212},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.8,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗极成功。后两句尤妙，铁爪动作精准传神，结句以水喻玻璃，写绒熊微梦，失落中见温柔与留白。唯起句夜光机炼字略显斧凿。","_cost":0.0047535},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.2,"语言":4.2,"章法":5.8,"余味":6.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.05,"rationale":"以娃娃机喻求而不得， contemporary题材出新；爪缩熊梦转结宕开留白；然柔情梦微微偏泛，隔水失切，语言未见诗眼。","_cost":0.0122283},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"借抓取失败写求而不得，铁爪与绒熊形成冷暖对照，脉络清楚。“夜光机”欠精准，“掷币柔情”衔接生硬；结句有虚化余韵，但“隔水”缺少情境支撑，“梦微微”稍显熟套。","_cost":0.04903},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃写求而不得,事具体而情只停在柔情二字,未翻出更深主脑。铁爪回缩、隔水梦微交融成境,删之则散。夜光机与微微较弱,第二句已判不归,转势略平。结句以景收,余味在而不浓。","_cost":0.040282},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"当代题材入诗有新意,借抓娃娃写可望不可即,但未翻出更深寄托。三句铁爪悬空又缩,写得精切。结句隔水梦微微以景结情,有余味。夜光机略显生造,唤不归所指含混。","_cost":0.014516},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"以抓取落空写欲得不得，铁爪与绒熊的对照具体，结句也留有距离感。由投币到爪缩、熊仍在彼处，脉络清楚；但“夜光机”“唤不归”语意欠稳，“隔水梦微微”稍显朦胧。","_cost":0.009436}},"consensus":74.2,"final":74.2},{"key":"kimi-k3|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"kimi-k3","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"霓虹隔柜春如梦，铁爪低垂欲下机。万币沉槽声渐杳，童眸近匣盼云归。绒熊列队闲相倚，彩钮妆成抱枕衣。骤缩钢钳风满袖，疏星淡荡一萤飞。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"unknown"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.8,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.4,"章法":6.7,"余味":6.9,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.8,"rationale":"以霓虹、铁爪、童眸写抓取瞬间，题材新且氛围统一；三四联推进，以“萤飞”留悬念。然“下机”“盼云归”“抱枕衣”语意牵强，末景与动作衔接稍虚。","_cost":0.011366},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"以娃娃机入律有当代经验之新，结句以疏星流萤宕开，稍具余味。然情志止于场景白描，主脑不显；'欲下机''抱枕衣''盼云归'等有凑韵硬造之嫌，文白夹杂；中二联开合浅平，'风满袖'施于钢钳意脉稍舛。","_cost":0.03944},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"将现代事物入诗具新意，前三联细致描摹抓娃娃场景与儿童心理。然“抱枕衣”“盼云归”略生造，且尾联“风满袖”“疏星淡荡”与室内场景割裂，强用古典景语导致结句游离失真。","_cost":0.01558},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"当代物事入律有新意，童盼与落空一线贯之，结以萤飞较留白。意象具体能交融。语言通顺偶见亮点，中联开合平直，彩钮句略涩。","_cost":0.026454},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"立意明确但新意不足；意象新旧夹杂，氛围略散；语言有现代感但多凑字；章法中二联平，尾联跌宕；结句以景结情有余味。警句2.5，出新2，陈滥1.5。","_cost":0.014351876},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入七律，取材新警，童眸与铁爪对照有时代感。首尾以景结情见余味。然'欲下机''盼云归''妆成抱枕衣'凑韵生硬、语义含混，颈联与颔联层次略平，炼字未稳，惜新意未得佳句尽发。","_cost":0.00289736},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.8,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.2,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.05,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入诗，题旨集中，童趣与落空可感；机台意象较新，结句宕开有余韵。惜个别词句稍生，颈联偏装饰，情感推进不够深。","_cost":0.012548},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃写欲望落空与童盼，霓虹、铁爪、沉币成境；唯“下机”“抱枕衣”略硬，中二联开合稍平，结句宕出星萤，清空有味。","_cost":0.0129318},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.5,"章法":4.8,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.6,"rationale":"取材当代机巧有新意，然止于铺陈器物，童眸一盼未提炼为情志主脑；中二联平列无开合，尾句由柜内骤宕星萤，欲留白而脉断。","_cost":0.0078279},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"以七律写当代抓娃娃机题材，细节真切，迷幻怅然的氛围统一，景结有余味；唯'盼云归''彩钮'句稍隔，中二联略平，个别语词稍熟。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"以七律写抓娃娃机，当代经验入旧体，取象贴切：铁爪、沉币、绒熊皆切题。颔联'万币沉槽''盼云归'虚实相生为佳联；尾联'骤缩钢钳'陡转落空，'一萤飞'以景结情，留白得体。惟'彩钮妆成抱枕衣'稍显凑泊，'风满袖'与抓空之痛关联略隔，炼字尚有提升空间。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"当代经验入律，铁爪空归之落空感有主脑，“骤缩钢钳风满袖”颇见力度；然“欲下机”“盼云归”“抱枕衣”为凑韵而语意含混，颈联铺陈平缓，结句宕开至疏星流萤稍显游离，余味有而衔接未紧。","_cost":0.06296},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"写抓娃娃机寄寓现代迷梦，童眸、星萤鲜活；然中二联未转，‘抱枕衣’生硬费解，结句宕开留白颇佳。","_cost":0.029666773},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.7,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.9,"rationale":"将当代抓娃娃机成功熔铸入律。“万币沉槽”极具现场感，“风满袖”妙喻落空两手空空，末句以景结情宕开意境。体物入微，兼有童趣与幻灭感。","_cost":0.006057},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.5,"rationale":"选题新而无主脑止于铺陈，中二联静态重复无推进，尾联硬转星萤脱节，语言生嵌费解。","_cost":0.01344725},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.5,"rationale":"童眸之盼与绒熊闲倚形成对照，日常题材略有新意；“欲下机”“彩钮妆成抱枕衣”语意欠稳。梦、云等意象稍泛，尾联由钢钳跳至星萤，缺少承接，结句留白近于游离。","_cost":0.04078},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"情志停在童盼与失落的常见感叹，闲盼对照未收成主脑。铁爪、沉槽、绒熊精切成境，彩钮费解，春梦云归疏星偏套。欲下与骤缩相呼应，颈联平直。结句以萤宕开未说破，与柜内略脱。","_cost":0.0450448},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.75,"rationale":"当代题材入诗有新意,「万币沉槽」「风满袖」写落空感尚可。但主旨停在描摹,未翻出深意。「下机」「盼云归」「彩钮妆成抱枕衣」词意含混生硬。颈联偏静,与前后衔接弱。结句以景收束有余韵,但柜内与星萤的场景跳接略显突兀。","_cost":0.019164},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.75,"rationale":"以娃娃机写童盼，题材有新意，童眸与铁爪相映；但“下机”“盼云归”“抱枕衣”语意牵强，末句星萤与机柜场景衔接不足。","_cost":0.013316}},"consensus":62.05,"final":62.05},{"key":"kimi-k3|天台菜园|七律","writer":"kimi-k3","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"架上云低接菜畦，风吹碧叶满梯西。晨移韭垄承朝露，雨过瓜棚翠欲迷。半亩泥香浮市井，一窗灯火宿鸡栖。收来小摘盈筐笑，夜剪柔葵佐老妻。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.3,"意境":7.5,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.7,"余味":6.3,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"屋顶菜园融市井与田园，归于夫妻日常，情味具体。“泥香浮市井”颇见新意。全篇脉络尚清，但“满梯西”“宿鸡栖”“佐老妻”搭配生涩，结句温厚而余韵稍浅。","_cost":0.00838},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"天台种菜入诗有当代生活气息，'半亩泥香浮市井'为一篇亮点，俯瞰视角切题。但'满梯西'凑韵痕迹重，'翠欲迷''朝露'意象平熟；天台宿鸡稍欠交代。结句化'夜雨剪春韭'收于家常温情，稳而稍尽，余味有限。整体温厚可读，锤炼未足。","_cost":0.04497},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"诗写都市天台种菜之趣，“半亩泥香浮市井”巧妙点题，当代经验入诗极具生活气息。然“宿鸡栖”有凑韵之嫌，“佐老妻”词语搭配生硬，结联直白且略显俗气，余味稍欠。","_cost":0.016266},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"菜园劳作与家常温情具体可感，颈联泥香浮市井稍活。主题属熟套田园乐，结句点破笑意佐妻，余味薄。意象妥帖多见套语，语言通顺少锤炼。","_cost":0.026246},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"写天台种菜有城市田园之趣，泥香浮市井等语较新；但韭垄、瓜棚、鸡栖等意象偏熟，移韭垄、宿鸡栖、佐老妻略硬。结句有生活细节，余味中等。","_cost":0.0084761952},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"都市天台种菜，题旨具体真切，当代生活有效入诗。'半亩泥香浮市井'一联以'浮'字沟通田园与市井，是全篇诗眼。中二联晨雨对写尚有层次，但颔联意象稍平行；结句温馨直白，余味中平。'翠欲迷''宿鸡栖'微有凑韵之感。","_cost":0.00295616},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.6,"章法":6.4,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.55,"rationale":"天台菜园以市井烟火与田园劳作相映，细节真切，颈联有新意；但线性铺陈，转折平直，梯西、宿鸡栖稍硬，结尾温馨而略直。","_cost":0.014228},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"天台种菜为当代田园新题，城市与泥土对照有发现，情感温馨具体。意象较密且晨—雨—夜时序贯通，结句'夜剪柔葵佐老妻'以事结情最佳。然'满梯西''宿鸡栖'生硬凑韵，'朝露''翠欲迷'近套语，语言锤炼不足，中二联开合略平。","_cost":0.0122658},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.8,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"天台菜园切入都市田园，晨昏劳作至夜剪佐妻，情真事具体有主脑而翻新有限；意象统一，语言通顺而翠欲迷等偏熟；章法时空贯注但转合平直，结句家常收束温实余韵不深。","_cost":0.0070214},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"此作写都市天台菜园闲居日常，立意真切，取象贴合场景，章法连贯自然，语言平实有炼字，颈联融市井烟火与田园意趣，唯结句偏实，余味稍欠。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"天台种菜入律，当代经验与田园传统嫁接，题旨具体有主脑。'半亩泥香浮市井'一句城市与菜园相映，是全诗警策。颈联由园及家开合得当，结句剪葵佐妻以事收情，温厚有余味。惟'翠欲迷''满梯西'稍见凑韵趁字，炼字尚可再精。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"天台种菜为当代经验入诗，题材有新意；“泥香浮市井”一句点出高楼田园与市井交融，颇有巧思。然中二联多铺陈景语，层次开合不足，“满梯西”“小摘”稍嫌硬凑，“半亩”于天台失实。结句以夜剪佐妻收束温厚，惟“盈筐笑”已先说破，余味稍减。","_cost":0.06274},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"天台种菜入律，'泥香浮市井'融都市田园，情事具体、脉络完整；然意象多熟语，'满梯西''宿鸡栖'稍凑，结句直白少留白，警句在'半亩泥香浮市井'。","_cost":0.03247873},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.7,"rationale":"聚焦当代都市天台种植经验，生活气息浓厚。颈联“泥香浮市井”虚实开合自然，尾联化典入日常、写夫妇共食之乐，情致朴茂温馨，脉络明晰流畅。","_cost":0.00560775},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.75,"rationale":"市井天台种菜陪老妻，真挚具体而新境不足；取象妥帖多常见语；满梯西、宿鸡栖等句法拙涩；晨昏脉络贯通转折平直；结句直白少留白。","_cost":0.0128633},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.2,"章法":6.3,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.7,"rationale":"市井菜园与夫妻日常相融，“泥香浮市井”有辨识度；“宿鸡栖”“收来小摘”语意生涩。章法完整而中联推进有限，结句温厚具体，但留白不多。","_cost":0.0459},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.5,"rationale":"田园自足，情事具体而乏新见。湿绿氛围统一，颈联泥香灯火较精，余象常见。浮、宿有炼意，翠欲迷与收来小摘偏熟偏赘。由昼入夜脉络通，转势平。结句点明笑与佐妻，收得住而说尽。","_cost":0.0254144},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.5,"rationale":"天台菜园是当代题材,「半亩泥香浮市井」点出城中田园的反差,较有意味。但「梯西」生硬,「晨…朝露」「宿…栖」「收来小摘」语义叠床。颈联已写入夜,尾联又言「夜剪」,时序重复。结句化用杜诗剪韭,情意温厚,但偏直白。","_cost":0.021596},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"“半亩泥香浮市井”写出天台种菜的城居趣味，末句亦见夫妻情意。但“满梯西”“宿鸡栖”“佐老妻”语意生涩，采摘之意重复，结句说得稍尽。","_cost":0.01298}},"consensus":66.37,"final":66.37},{"key":"kimi-k3|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"kimi-k3","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"天台果熟压新枝，汲水浇蔬破晓时。蝶过茄畦翻紫蕊，瓜棚月落影低垂。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.4,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"天台劳作题材清新，破晓、蝶影、紫蕊与落月相融，生活气息可感。末句以影收情，留白较好；“压新枝”“翻紫蕊”稍显着力，主旨开掘尚浅。","_cost":0.006278},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.0,"rationale":"天台种菜属当代生活经验入诗,题材有新意,惜止于写景,无情志主脑。'蝶过茄畦翻紫蕊'色彩生动为亮点。然四句近于并列铺陈,转结乏力;'月落影低垂'虽以景收但意象泛熟,余味平平,整体有句无篇。","_cost":0.03869},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.0,"rationale":"以天台种菜入诗，具当代生活气息。意象丰富画面统一，清晨劳作与微观生机交织。'翻'字生动，结句以景收束略带余味。唯章法平铺直叙，罗列景物偏多，立意停留在常见的闲适之情。","_cost":0.018422},"grok-4.6":{"立意":4.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.25,"rationale":"屋顶菜圃写实，压枝翻蕊较切，氛围统一；然题旨常见无深掘，四景并列转弱。结以月影尚留画面。语言通顺偶炼。当代园圃入诗略新，无误用抄袭。","_cost":0.017566},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.8,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.6,"rationale":"以晨间天台菜圃为轴，意象集中，结句以景收束余韵略存；‘压’‘翻’见炼字。立意与转承偏平，意象较熟。","_cost":0.0101802624},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"都市天台种菜取材真切，'汲水浇蔬破晓时'有事有我；'蝶翻紫蕊'景中含情，取象精切。结句瓜棚月影以景收，留有余地。惟立意止于闲适，未翻新境；'压''翻'见炼字但不惊人，转折略平。","_cost":0.00209276},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.6,"章法":6.3,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.9,"rationale":"写天台菜园生活，茄畦瓜棚细节鲜活，结句月下影垂有静味；但立意止于田园小景，情志未深，句间转折稍平，破晓与月落略跳。","_cost":0.010886},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"天台种菜属当代经验入诗,取景新鲜连贯,破晓汲水、蝶翻茄蕊、月落瓜棚一气而下,以景结情有留白。然情志止于闲适速写,无独到发现与主脑深化;语言通顺少诗眼;第三句转得平直;茄畦瓜棚稍密。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0123168},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":4.7,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.1,"章法":4.4,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.95,"rationale":"天台菜园稍涉当代经验但仍作一般田园白描，取象妥帖而常见未融为境，语言通顺少诗眼，四句并列转合平直，月落以景结余韵淡。","_cost":0.011531},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"此诗写天台菜园破晓浇蔬之景，题旨明豁，意象妥帖，语言平顺，唯章法平铺少跌宕，结句余韵稍弱，未凸显天台菜园的当代特质，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"天台菜园题材有当代生活气息，四句皆景、氛围统一，'蝶过茄畦翻紫蕊'色彩鲜活。但通篇止于闲适写生，无主脑情志，转结皆平铺景语，未宕出深意；'汲水浇蔬''月落影垂'取象略熟。以景收束尚有余韵，惜前文情意铺垫不足，延宕有限。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"天台种菜为当代生活入诗，茄畦紫蕊、瓜棚取象具体清新。然四句皆平列写景，无起承转合，缺一篇主脑；破晓与月落、新枝压熟果时序物理略悖。结句以景收尚有余味，惟'影低垂'稍弱。","_cost":0.05291},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"题旨清楚但属常见田园闲趣；取象具体，空间由果树菜畦至瓜棚推移，结句以景留白，余味较好。语言通顺，“压”“翻”见炼字。硬伤在“紫蕊”于茄花稍有常识不确；当代天台经验仅存标题，未有效入诗。蹈袭陈滥无。","_cost":0.031984356},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.3,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.8,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.85,"rationale":"天台农事实写当代生活经验，具真切情味。“翻紫蕊”生动，以景结情亦见宁静。惟破晓、蝶舞与月落交织，物候时序略显游移拼凑，炼字平顺未见警拔。","_cost":0.00642},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":4.0,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.1,"章法":3.6,"余味":4.4,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.8,"rationale":"纪事白描无主脑，茄畦瓜棚尚具体；翻字稍活余欠炼；并列铺陈无转，破晓见蝶时序舛；末句直收无余韵。","_cost":0.0135003},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"题旨集中于天台耕作，生活气息具体，情志开掘较浅。茄畦紫蕊清新，“翻”字见动态；四句多为景事并置，转折不足。末句以景收束，略有余韵，但“影低垂”稍显虚泛。","_cost":0.03799},"grok-4.7":{"立意":4.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.0,"rationale":"状菜园晓景,题旨明确而角度常见,情志未凝成主脑。茄畦紫蕊、汲水较切,氛围能统一,然情浅。炼字仅翻字见力,破晓时与影低垂偏熟。四句并列,转结平直。结句以景收,余味不长。","_cost":0.0246288},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.25,"rationale":"天台种菜是当代题材,有一点新意,但全篇只写田园景物,没有点出城居之感,也没有主脑,情志单薄。意象妥帖,'翻紫蕊'略见锤炼。四句平列,缺少转折;破晓之后再写月落,时序略显回环。以景作结尚有静意,但余味不深。","_cost":0.018104},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"菜园晨景具体，茄畦紫蕊颇有生气；但天台特色主要见于标题，四句偏于依次写景，转折较弱。月落作结留有静意，“影低垂”稍显含混。","_cost":0.008118}},"consensus":60.08,"final":60.08},{"key":"kimi-k3|云端相册|七绝","writer":"kimi-k3","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"云端万幅收千影，卷里春光触处明。检点风尘成故事，低徊夜色入屏情。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.3,"章法":6.4,"余味":4.9,"警句":0.8,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.9,"rationale":"以云端相册写夜间翻检旧影，题旨集中且具当代性。前两句略显数量重复，春光、风尘较常见；第三句转入追忆尚自然，末句“入屏情”生硬且收得偏实，余韵有限。","_cost":0.005516},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.5,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗有当代经验,题旨明确但仅泛写怀旧。首句'万幅''千影'语意重复,'入屏情'生硬凑韵,结句点破'情'字失之直露。转句'检点风尘成故事'尚稳,全篇脉络完整而意象笼统,缺乏具体可感的画面细节。","_cost":0.0321},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.0,"rationale":"“云端”“屏”等现代元素入诗具时代感。但全篇意象空泛，“风尘成故事”流于俗套套话，“入屏情”造词生硬且直白说破。整体章法平铺直叙，结语缺乏留白余味。","_cost":0.014628},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"云相册怀旧题旨明确然角度常见情较泛。新旧意象杂陈有夜览氛围，春光风尘仍套。触处明稍炼，章法完整转平。结句点情稍尽少宕开。","_cost":0.019224},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"云端相册题材有现代感，但情事泛化，缺乏具体细节与独到发现。意象妥帖但偏常见，'入屏情'生硬。结构完整而转折平直，结句直说情致，余味不足。'检点风尘成故事'稍见诗眼，整体陈套意象密度中等。","_cost":0.00486156},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗，当代经验有效化用，立意有新意但情感开掘不深。'触处明'暗合触屏，是诗眼；'夜色入屏'融景于器，意象统一。结句以'低徊'收但'情'字点破，余味稍直。'风尘''故事'略熟，整体脉络完整、起承平顺。","_cost":0.00239076},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.3,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.15,"rationale":"题取云端相册，有一定当代新意；但万幅千影偏泛，风尘故事夜色稍落常套，情在屏而景未深，结句有情而略直，整体顺稳少锤炼。","_cost":0.007542},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.5,"rationale":"云端相册入七绝，题材出新且情感落点具体（检点旧照、夜色翻屏），立意中上。'卷里春光触处明'意象尚可，但'入屏情''触处明'略生硬，炼字欠火候。起承转合完整而转结平直，结句以景结情有意图但'屏情'近于说破，余韵有限。'检点风尘成故事'稍有警意。","_cost":0.0089148},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.8,"意境":4.8,"语言":5.2,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.6,"rationale":"云端相册取材当代稍具新意但情事抽象未具体，春光风尘夜色意象常见氛围淡，语言通顺乏诗眼屏情略涩，章法起承转合完整而转结平直，尾句直点情字留白不足。","_cost":0.0081944},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.75,"rationale":"此作咏夜览云端相册忆旧，题旨明确但角度寻常，意象偏熟、情景融合一般，语言通顺稍欠锤炼，章法完整转折平直，结句直白少余韵；引入当代数码题材，无硬伤蹈袭，仅个别意象稍陈。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"以云存储入旧体，题材有新意，'检点风尘成故事'将数字影像与人生回望勾连，是全诗主脑。但'低徊夜色入屏情'结得直白说破，余味不足；'风尘''夜色'意象偏熟，'入屏情'稍显凑字，炼字平平。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗有当代经验，“触处明”暗合触屏点亮，一语双关为亮点；但“万幅”“千影”意重，“入屏情”硕凑生硬，结句直说“情”字而少留白，意象偏浮泛，整体流畅而未深。","_cost":0.04617},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字时代怀旧，题意明确；起承转合完整，转结平稳。意象多常语，“入屏情”稍滞，结句点“情”略直，整体有新题而未深。","_cost":0.021372611},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"现代生活经验入诗，章法起承转合清晰，深夜对屏忆旧情致可感。然“万幅千影”语意稍重，“入屏情”造语偏硬，“风尘”略带陈俗，结句稍平。","_cost":0.00442425},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"云端检阅旧影有主脑但情事抽象；春光夜色屏拼贴未融境；触处明入屏情生硬无诗眼；起承重复转结平直；结句直说情字无留白。","_cost":0.01298655},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.25,"rationale":"云端、屏幕为忆旧题材添入当代经验，由收影到检点往事，脉络清楚。但情事欠具体，春光、风尘较泛；“万幅”“千影”意近重复，“入屏情”生涩，结尾直点情字，余味有限。","_cost":0.04098},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.75,"rationale":"有题无境：云端相册意思清楚，情只泛写怀旧。春光与夜色不协，屏情生造，万千虚张，无诗眼。四句脉络在而转折平，结句点明入屏，余味薄。当代经验未化开，套语偏密。","_cost":0.0214912},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写翻检旧影，是当代经验入诗。“触处明”双关触屏，颇巧。首句“万幅”“千影”数字叠用，稍嫌冗。转句“检点风尘”较平。结句“入屏情”拼凑生硬，且直接点出“情”字，余味不足。","_cost":0.018208},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.0,"rationale":"借云端相册写回望旧事，题旨明确，数字媒介入诗略有新意；“春光”“风尘”较泛，末句“入屏情”语意牵强，转结缺少余味。","_cost":0.007996}},"consensus":53.65,"final":53.65},{"key":"kimi-k3|云端相册|七律","writer":"kimi-k3","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"旧照云边暗启时，流年似水去犹知。千山影里曾携手，一念存来万缕丝。夜半灯前翻未已，东风不识远人期。寒屏若个藏悲喜，月落星沉誓莫移。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"weak"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.1,"意境":5.8,"语言":4.7,"章法":6.2,"余味":3.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.7,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.74999999999999,"rationale":"以云端旧照寄怀远人为主脑，题材有当代性，灯前寒屏亦能融情。然“流年似水”“月落星沉”等偏熟，“去犹知”“若个藏”语意生涩；结句直陈誓言，说尽而少余韵。","_cost":0.005832},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀人,题材切入稍新,'寒屏藏悲喜'可取。然'流年似水''月落星沉'等套语密集,'一念存来万缕丝'凑句生硬。中二联开合不足,颈联'东风'与数码情境游离。结句'誓莫移'直陈说尽,余味寡淡。","_cost":0.03752},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.0,"rationale":"“云端、寒屏”将现代经验入诗具一定新意。但全诗陈套词语泛滥（流年似水、誓莫移），语言缺乏锤炼。结构平直，结句喊口号完全说尽，毫无留白，缺乏诗意张力与余味。","_cost":0.015774},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"云端旧照怀人题旨集中而角度熟套。寒屏千山影尚切，流年似水月落星沉等套语夹杂。语言通顺少锤炼。章法完整转结平直。结句誓言说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.016542},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.25,"rationale":"云端相册题材现代但未深挖数字特性，仍套用传统怀人意象如流年似水、东风、月落星沉，陈套密度高；章法完整但转折平直，结句直露失余味；语言通顺少诗眼。","_cost":0.00827772},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.0,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀旧忆远，今题入旧体有巧思，'寒屏若个藏悲喜'以冷屏藏情，今昔交融，是全篇诗眼。但'流年似水''万缕丝''月落星沉'等套语密度偏高；中二联对仗松散，'去犹知'意脉微涩；结句'誓莫移'直白说破，余味受限。","_cost":0.00320996},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.3,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.3,"章法":6.1,"余味":4.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.55,"rationale":"云端相册切入略有当代感，主旨明确；但流年似水、万缕丝等熟语偏多，意象未臻精切，转接稍平，结句誓言说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.010844},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"“云端/寒屏”有当代触点，怀旧氛围尚可；但情旨近常见离思誓约，流年似水、东风、月落星沉套象偏多，中二联开合弱，结句直誓少留白。","_cost":0.0232428},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.5,"rationale":"借云端相册写怀旧，情事抽象无主脑，流年万缕丝月落等套语连缀，结构平铺，尾联誓言直露无留白。","_cost":0.0078039},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.25,"rationale":"本诗写云端翻看旧照忆旧怀人，题旨明确情真但角度常规，意象多熟套，语言平顺偶有妥帖处，章法完整转折偏平，结句直白少留白，当代元素未深掘，无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"以云端相册入旧体，当代经验有效，'寒屏''夜半灯前翻未已'取象切题；然'流年似水''东风''月落星沉'皆熟套，中二联对仗欠工（存来/影里、翻未已/远人期失称），脉络平直。结句'誓莫移'直白说破，情尽于言，掩卷无延宕，余味最弱。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.0,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗，“云边”“存来”“寒屏”双关有巧思；但“流年似水”“东风不识”“月落星沉”等套语密集，情感泛泛无具体事。中二联层次尚可，结句“誓莫移”直接说破，余味寡淡。","_cost":0.06144},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀人，寒屏、翻未已等当代经验入诗稍见新意；然流年似水、万缕丝、月落星沉等多陈套，意象稍杂。结构完整而转笔稍弱，结句直言誓莫移，稳妥而少余味。","_cost":0.036130189},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.35,"rationale":"尝试以现代云相册入诗，新象尚能自洽。但内里情思未脱传统羁旅相思窠臼，千山携手、流年似水等熟语陈套较密，炼字平弱。结句直呼誓言，说破兜底，缺乏留白余韵。","_cost":0.00554025},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.5,"rationale":"借云端起兴却仍为泛泛相思，无具体情事主脑；意象陈套拼贴，语多涩滞，结构平直，尾联誓言说破无留白。","_cost":0.012535},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.8,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.2,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.65,"rationale":"云端相册与寒屏略有今意，怀人主线清楚，但情事欠具体，流年、情丝、东风等熟套密集。“去犹知”“存来”语涩；章法完整而推进有限，结句直陈誓志，说尽情意，延宕不足。","_cost":0.03916},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"云端入诗只停在云边、寒屏，怀远情志常见，未翻新境。流年似水、千山携手、东风、月落星沉套象密，去犹知、存来、若个欠炼。夜半翻照能接当下，结句誓莫移说破，余味薄。","_cost":0.0496432},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀人,当代经验入诗,角度可取,但情事空泛,缺少具体细节。流年似水、东风、月落星沉等套语较密,「去犹知」措辞生硬。中二联层次不明,「东风」一句接得突兀。结句以誓言兜底,说破无余味。「寒屏」一句稍有新意。","_cost":0.018156},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.5,"rationale":"云端旧照、夜半翻屏使怀远有当代落点；“流年似水”等陈语偏多，“一念存来”“若个”语意欠顺。篇章脉络尚清，末句直陈誓言，余味较弱。","_cost":0.007842}},"consensus":49.2,"final":49.2},{"key":"kimi-k3|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"kimi-k3","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"舷窗俯瞰沧溟小，九地灯浮一镜天。夜静云低星欲坠，人间寸火续长川。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.10000000000001,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰翻转天地尺度，灯火与星河相映，主脑清晰。末句“寸火续长川”以微光写人间生息，含蓄有余韵；“九地”“一镜天”稍显密涩，部分意象略熟。","_cost":0.005658},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"以夜航当代经验入七绝,视角新而不猎奇。九地灯浮、一镜天倒置有巧思,结句'寸火续长川'以象收情,余味颇佳。惟首句与题重复'俯瞰'稍费字,'星欲坠'略见熟套,转句平顺少变,整体清稳可诵。","_cost":0.04362},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"本诗成功将现代夜航经验入诗。起承转合严密，空间视角变化自然；由俯瞰宏景转至星空，终收束于'人间寸火'，意境开阔，温情与壮阔交融。炼字妥帖，结句余味深长。","_cost":0.01812},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰具体可感，灯浮镜天与寸火长川意象交融成境。立意未脱高空观照常轨。语言平稳。章法起承清楚转稍平。结句点明续意略直。飞行经验入诗算出新。","_cost":0.023258},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.3,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.4,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰取象高远，承句“灯浮一镜天”精切，转结由天象落到人间灯火，“寸火续长川”以景收束，有余韵。立意角度较常见，个别意象略熟。","_cost":0.00960432},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.5,"rationale":"夜航经验入旧体而浑成，以'寸火续长川'将人间灯火与星河接续，主脑鲜明。起承由窗到地，转句星欲坠蓄势，结句以小接大，言尽意不尽。'九地''一镜天'炼字见巧，稍欠自然。整体精切无陈滥。","_cost":0.00262516},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.2,"章法":5.8,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.6,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.15,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰视角明确，灯川与云天相映，境统一；结以人间寸火，略有远韵。但‘九地’‘一镜天’稍生，星坠云低偏熟，情志未深，转折亦平。","_cost":0.011044},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为现代经验入诗,视角较新;灯火、镜天、坠星、寸火诸象统一成高空夜景,情景交融,'人间寸火续长川'以景结情,余韵较足。然'九地'本义为至深之地,用以指俯瞰之地面,用法生硬可疑;'星欲坠'略熟;中二句张力稍平。整体稳健而欠警策。","_cost":0.0068628},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.6,"章法":6.8,"余味":7.8,"警句":1.8,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.89999999999999,"rationale":"舷窗俯瞰切当代经验，镜天与寸火长川对照见新意；意象统一但转句云低星坠略熟，结句以人间小火宕开收束，留有余味。","_cost":0.0079975},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.5,"rationale":"此作取当代夜航俯瞰视角，立意有温度，从宏阔天宇收束至人间烟火，炼字精切，章法顺畅，情景相融，唯部分意象稍熟，结句稳当有余味。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰入诗，当代经验化古出新，'人间寸火续长川'将灯火与星河接续，立意有独到处。意象统一于高空夜景，景语含情。'一镜天'稍欠精切，'沧溟小'略直。章法起承转合完整，结句以象收束留有余味，唯'续长川'稍近说破。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰为题，将地灯与星天互映，'寸火续长川'收束有象有余韵，当代经验入诗尚自然。但首句'俯瞰'与题重复，'九地'略凑，第三句转笔平缓仅铺景，'沧溟''星欲坠'稍显熟套。","_cost":0.05949},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰入诗，现代经验与“寸火”铸语颇新；然“云低星欲坠”意象稍熟，转句平弱，结句“续长川”稍直白，余味有限。整体章法完整而新境未深。","_cost":0.027415029},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.8,"rationale":"夜航经验入诗，结句“寸火续长川”见微茫烟火与生生不息，余味不俗。病在首句与标题重字犯题，承结两句皆写地上灯火略有重叠，转句炼象稍落俗套。","_cost":0.00648675},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"大小对照有主脑而情弱，意象尚统但星坠套语，九地一镜天生涩，转折跳脱，结句寸火续川以小收大稍留味。","_cost":0.0144235},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"夜航视角统摄全篇，“寸火续长川”以微续远，有人间温意与余韵；“九地”“一镜天”略显雕饰，“星欲坠”较熟，第三句转折偏弱。","_cost":0.04784},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"高空尺度倒置题旨明确而情事不具体，角度常见。镜天与寸火交融成境，星欲坠稍陈。小、浮、寸、续见炼，夜静偏平。起承顺，第三句未转。结句续川有余意，人间略点破。当代舷窗入诗有效。","_cost":0.0290576},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰是当代经验。'九地灯浮一镜天'以地灯映天，取象新警。结句'寸火续长川'呼应天河，略有余味。第三句'星欲坠'属常套，转句平直。'沧溟'夜间可见度存疑，'俯瞰'与题重复。","_cost":0.019656},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.25,"rationale":"舷窗视角将灯火与星云相映，末句以“寸火续长川”收出人间生息，留有余味。“九地灯”所指稍虚，“星欲坠”较熟，转折略平。","_cost":0.008088}},"consensus":73.14,"final":73.14},{"key":"kimi-k3|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"kimi-k3","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"云天海外夜分明，客眼灯河落旧城。万点星芒穿碧碎，沧波月色冷人情。长空俯瞰千家火，半卷风烟过处声。故国图开银汉迥，归心一线远山横。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.4,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.3,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.1,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.6,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.1,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰与归思相扣，灯河、故国图颇见视角；中二联层次略复，“穿碧碎”“过处声”语意生硬。结句以远山横收，尚有留白。","_cost":0.005452},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"以夜航入诗有当代经验,题旨明确。'灯河落旧城'尚可,结句'归心一线远山横'以景收情有余味。然'穿碧碎''冷人情'凑字生硬,'过处声'高空闻声近于失实;中二联皆写俯瞰灯火,开合不足,层次重复。取象半新半套,整体中平。","_cost":0.03696},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"将夜航俯瞰的当代经验有效入诗，以“灯河”状地平线夜景，意境开阔。结句由宏大图景收敛至“归心一线”，余味悠长。然中二联均写地面灯火，略嫌合掌，且“过处声”稍显凑泊凑音。","_cost":0.017318},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰写乡愁题旨明确而角度常见。灯河、千家火贴切，银汉归心稍套。语言通顺少诗眼，穿碧碎略硬。颈联少开合，转在尾联偏平。结句一线远山有画面，情稍直。","_cost":0.02262},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":7.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.7,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰串起灯河星月，景中寄归思，结句以景收束尚有余味。中二联意象略平行，灯河与千家火重复，半卷句生硬。通篇陈熟意象较多，胜在结句。","_cost":0.00568282},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰之当代经验入诗，归心一线远山横收束有味，以景结情最佳。中二联均写俯瞰之景，层次稍平；'穿碧碎'夜色用碧略生硬，'冷人情''风烟'稍落套。警句摘出仍佳，出新有效但不至满档。","_cost":0.00275536},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"夜航视角统一，灯河星芒等景尚有画面，归思明确；但沧波冷人情等偏直，故国归心略熟，转折稍平，结句稍说破而远山略有余韵。","_cost":0.014292},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰与归思有当代角度，灯河、千家火可取；但星月沧波风烟堆叠，视角与气息未统一，炼字多生硬。尾联“归心一线远山横”较稳，略有余味。","_cost":0.0146928},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.8,"语言":4.3,"章法":4.6,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.8,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.849999999999994,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰具当代切口但归心仍泛化；灯河星芒银汉等堆砌少交融；穿碧碎、过处声炼字生涩；颔颈重复俯瞰无层进；尾联直说归心，余味平直。","_cost":0.00900925},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"本诗写夜航俯瞰触动归思，题旨明确、脉络平顺；意象、语言稳妥但偏熟套，无亮眼炼字；结句直点归心少留白，余味不足，无硬伤蹈袭，乏新意警策。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写乡愁，当代经验入诗，视角新颖。'万点星芒穿碧碎'取象精切，尾联'归心一线远山横'以景结情，留白有余。惟'沧波月色冷人情''过处声'稍显凑泊含混，颈联与颔联意象略近，中二联开合变化不足。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰题材有当代经验，然情志仍归于泛泛归心。首联灯河落旧城稍见新意，中二联星月、灯火、风烟与首联意象重叠，层次未开；“穿碧碎”“冷人情”“过处声”凑字生硬，机上闻声亦欠理据。结句以远山横收，尚稳而意浅。","_cost":0.06388},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"以古典语汇写夜航俯瞰之当代经验，归心收束尚可；然中二联意象稍复，“碧碎”“过处声”生硬，结句略直白，气韵欠贯。","_cost":0.029234932},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.2,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.95,"rationale":"夜航经验入诗有出新之意，尾联以景结情、收束稳当。然颈联复见“长空俯瞰”，与前文打转，章法稍滞；“冷人情”“过处声”炼字凑合，高空闻风烟之声亦隔膜。","_cost":0.00626625},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.8,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":3.8,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.1,"rationale":"夜航视角带新意而归心仍旧调；海城山意象杂凑，景情割裂；穿碧碎生造，俯瞰白直；中二联灯火重复打转；结句说破归心，留白浅。","_cost":0.0134723},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":0.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.55,"rationale":"夜航乡思主脑明确，俯瞰灯火略有新意；星月风烟偏熟，“穿碧碎”“过处声”语意生涩，中段写景复沓。结句以远山横隔归心，较有余味。未见确切硬伤或整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.04171},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰有主脑，灯河、图开略见当代经验，然情志仍是习见羁愁，冷人情失之空判。中二联灯火反复，穿碧碎与风烟声生硬，海、城、山未成统一氛围。结句一线尚留余味。","_cost":0.0288352},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰归国,属当代经验入诗,题旨明确,但情志多泛写。灯河、千家火意象重复,中二联原地打转。“穿碧碎”生硬,“冷人情”突兀;高空闻“过处声”不合情理。结句以山横收归心,稳当而偏熟。星芒、银汉等常见意象较密。","_cost":0.019292},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"夜航望城而思归，灯河、千家火切题；但俯瞰视角未充分展开，“穿碧碎”“过处声”语意含混。结句以远山作收，尚有余味。","_cost":0.008102}},"consensus":56.41,"final":56.41},{"key":"kimi-k3|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"kimi-k3","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"重城久隔音频断，忽见屏开万里星。絮语灯前人影瘦，乡愁一点聚如萤。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.1,"警句":3.4,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.50000000000001,"rationale":"以视频通话承载久隔乡愁，屏、灯、星、萤构成光点意象链，转结凝练而有余韵。“音频断”稍显直硬，“一点聚如萤”语意略涩；题材当代，情致仍较传统。","_cost":0.005008},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.0,"rationale":"以视频通话入绝句,当代经验有效化入,结句'乡愁一点聚如萤'以象收情、有余味。'屏开万里星'亦见巧思。惜'音频断'生硬白话,与全篇雅语失谐;'人影瘦''乡愁'稍落熟套,转句平顺少变。","_cost":0.03346},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"当代经验入诗的佳作。“音频”、“屏开”融入自然，结句“乡愁一点聚如萤”以微光喻愁，巧妙贴合深夜屏幕的光感，具象且余味悠长。起承转合圆融，情事具体可感。","_cost":0.018688},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"视频通话写隔情，由断联至屏开星河再聚萤，章法有收束；然乡愁说破，音频稍硬，灯前瘦影较套，余味有限。","_cost":0.01702},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.8,"rationale":"由视频连通久隔写乡愁，情感具体集中；以星、萤微光意象贯穿，章法紧。结句点破乡愁稍直，但比喻尚留余味。'音频断'等现代语入诗稍白。","_cost":0.00564982},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.5,"rationale":"视频通话入七绝，当代经验与旧体交融自然，主脑聚焦。星、灯、萤之光象一线贯穿，景语即情语。'乡愁一点聚如萤'化抽象为微光，诗眼警拔，以象结情余味悠长。'音频断'稍直白，微减语言分。","_cost":0.00235276},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.8,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.3,"rationale":"写视频夜话，现代题材入诗较新。屏开如星、乡愁聚萤有巧思，脉络顺畅。惜人影瘦、乡愁稍熟，语词微有文白碰撞，结句略点破。","_cost":0.008496},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"以视频通话写乡愁，旧题接入当代经验，角度新鲜。'乡愁一点聚如萤'以微光收束，小对大、虚对实，余味悠长。'音频断'稍嫌质直，絮语人影略显常套，但整体意象统一，转结有致。","_cost":0.0088998},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.6,"章法":6.7,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.60000000000001,"rationale":"视频切入乡愁熨帖，星萤大小对照精巧，以景结情留余韵；唯‘音频断’直白夹杂，锤炼与转折稍平。","_cost":0.011288},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"此作取当代深夜视频场景写乡愁，主脑明晰，以微光意象贯串全篇，脉络顺畅，譬喻新巧，惟\"人影瘦\"稍熟，\"音频\"略生硬，结句点题稍直，余韵稍欠。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"以视频通话入旧体,当代经验翻新乡愁熟题,情事具体。'屏开万里星'取象新切,'聚如萤'以景结情有余味。'人影瘦'稍熟,'乡愁'二字直点略说破,'音频断'稍涉直白。起承转合完整,忽见一转有力,整体妥帖而有新意。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"以深夜视频写乡愁，屏光如星、终聚如萤，光意象前后呼应，当代经验入诗尚自然。但“音频断”偏技术语略生硬，“人影瘦”“乡愁”属常见套路，转句平缓，结句点破“乡愁”而以萤象收住，余味中等。","_cost":0.05583},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"视频通话入诗，'屏开万里星''乡愁聚如萤'新警，起承转合完满，化情为萤；'音频断'略质直，余味绵长。","_cost":0.029650087},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.8,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"当代视频经验入诗，章法完整。承转自然，结句以“聚如萤”将荧屏微光与抽象乡愁巧妙融摄，化虚为实，余味甚佳。“音频断”略嫌直白，“人影瘦”微带陈套。","_cost":0.0054675},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.3,"rationale":"久隔忽见脉络清晰，屏星灯萤具深夜氛围；然音频断文白夹杂，乡愁点破留白不足，当代经验入诗方向可取。","_cost":0.01193555},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"视频寄乡思，题旨集中，人影瘦有实感；星、萤映照屏光略见巧思，但“万里星”指向偏虚，“音频断”稍显直硬。由阻隔到相见脉络清楚，转折较平；结句直点乡愁，留白有限。","_cost":0.05634},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"视频入诗，离合情事具体，然思乡角度常见，主脑清楚而未翻新境。星与萤以微光相贯，音频未化为象，灯影偏熟。起断承开，转至人瘦，结收一点，章法最稳。结句点破乡愁，萤影略留余味而偏直白。","_cost":0.0253632},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"以视频通话写乡愁,当代经验入诗,但角度常见。'屏开万里星'有想象而指意稍虚。'人影瘦'属熟语。转句平直。结句萤火之喻尚有微光,可惜直书'乡愁',意蕴稍露。'音频断'与视频通话略有抵牾。","_cost":0.016112},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.15,"rationale":"视频重逢写出了隔城相思，“屏开万里星”将远近与光影相接。由音断到见人，脉络清楚；“音频断”稍显生硬，末句直点“乡愁”，削弱余味。","_cost":0.008148}},"consensus":72.14,"final":72.14},{"key":"kimi-k3|深夜视频|七律","writer":"kimi-k3","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"寒窗漏尽月初明，久坐空斋忆远情。掌上微光浮脸冷，千言欲寄却无声。孤灯照旧衫犹湿，半世飘蓬隔暮城。未问归期难忍说，何时剪烛话残更。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"weak"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.8,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.1,"章法":5.7,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.3,"硬伤":1.2,"陈滥":2.2,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"“掌上微光浮脸冷”能以现代物象写疏离，较为醒目；全篇围绕远情展开，但寒窗、孤灯、飘蓬、剪烛偏陈套。“漏尽月初明”时序含混，尾句化用痕迹重，收束较直。","_cost":0.006558},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":1.5,"score":53.5,"rationale":"以视频通话入律诗,题材有当代性,'掌上微光浮脸冷'是亮点。但中二联全不对仗,失律诗体制;寒窗、孤灯、飘蓬等陈套意象密集;结句直接化自李商隐剪烛话雨,余味依托前人,自家面目不足。","_cost":0.05188},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":37.25,"rationale":"虽以“视频”入题，仅“掌上微光浮脸冷”贴题且具画面感（予出新）。余皆“漏尽”“飘蓬”“剪烛”等陈词滥调，古今意象割裂严重（重扣陈滥）。整体章法平直，结句直白套用古人，缺乏余味。","_cost":0.023194},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"视频无声、未问归期较具体；掌上微光稍切。然寒窗孤灯飘蓬剪烛套语过密，境未融。中联转平，结句熟典余味有限。","_cost":0.020646},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.8,"章法":5.2,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":2.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"“掌上微光”点出现代视频情境，略有新意；然寒窗、孤灯、飘蓬、剪烛等套语密集，中二联铺陈未递进，结句化用西窗剪烛过熟，余味受损。","_cost":0.00816244},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"视频通话入律诗，今情古调结合得当，情感有具体依托。'掌上微光浮脸冷'化用当代经验精准，是全篇诗眼。中二联均写孤寂，层次略平；孤灯、飘蓬、剪烛等意象偏熟，结句'剪烛话残更'明显承李商隐，属化用而非自铸，余味尚存但新意打折。","_cost":0.00322036},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.6,"章法":6.2,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":62.849999999999994,"rationale":"题旨明确，深夜怀远；“掌上微光”有当代细节，颔联较真切。然旧象偏熟，颈联泛化，结句借剪烛意稍直，余味有限。","_cost":0.01333},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":2.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"视频入诗有新意，“掌上微光”一联较警；但寒窗、孤灯、剪烛熟境偏多，尾联近义山，个别句涩，余味受限。","_cost":0.0201258},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"掌上微光以今入古、冷暖对照见巧思，然整体仍归羁旅相思常调，中联意象偏旧，尾联借剪烛收束虽稳而直白。","_cost":0.008608},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.75,"rationale":"本诗写深夜羁旅忆远，题旨明确但角度常见，多用传统熟象，章法平顺少波澜，语言通顺无突出炼字，结句化用李商隐诗较直白，仅“掌上微光”略涉当代经验，陈套较密，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":2.0,"score":69.0,"rationale":"以视频通话入七律，当代经验与古典形式结合自然，'掌上微光浮脸冷，千言欲寄却无声'为佳联，见屏对屏而情难达之新境。然孤灯、飘蓬、寒窗等意象偏熟，尾联'何时剪烛话残更'化用义山'何当共剪西窗烛'痕迹过重，近于蹈袭，削弱结句独创性与余味。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":1.5,"score":45.75,"rationale":"题材当代，「掌上微光浮脸冷」一句有实感；余多寒窗、空斋、孤灯、飘蓬套语。「漏尽」「深夜」「暮城」时序矛盾，视频而「忆」不合。尾联化用义山「归期」「剪烛」过露，结束有余味但借力前人。","_cost":0.0653},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.25,"rationale":"题材常见，以手机微光入旧体稍具当代感，然多陈套意象（寒窗、孤灯、飘蓬、剪烛），情意直白，结句用典熟滥，结构完整而转折平。","_cost":0.026876489},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"“掌上微光浮脸冷”精切捕捉当代视频体验，化今入诗颇有亮点。然通篇多赖“漏尽、孤灯、飘蓬”等陈套支撑，中二联开合不足；尾联化用《夜雨寄北》过于直露说破，余味欠佳。","_cost":0.00642975},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"以掌上微光切入视频相思，有当代触感；然转入飘蓬剪烛套语，衫湿、未问等句费解，结作团圆愿，直白少余味。","_cost":0.01308325},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"掌上微光切合视频情境，冷光与无声相映传情；后半归于飘蓬、归期、剪烛旧套，层次略平。“难忍说”措辞生涩，结句盼聚较直，余味有限；剪烛属化用，非整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.04149},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"颔联以掌上冷脸、欲寄无声写视频相隔，主脑明确，稍有新境。前后寒窗孤灯飘蓬剪烛套语密，颈联只平行铺开，尾联说破归期并借熟典，余味偏直。","_cost":0.0516832},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":2.0,"score":40.75,"rationale":"“掌上微光浮脸冷”写视频有新意，其余多为寒窗、孤灯、飘蓬等旧套。漏尽、月初明、暮城时间相抵，“衫犹湿”无着落。中二联层次平。结句化李商隐剪烛、归期而近袭，且“难忍说”生涩。","_cost":0.0185},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.25,"rationale":"“掌上微光”写出隔屏相望的新意，但寒窗、飘蓬等熟象较密；中联情景略显重复，末句化用“剪烛”而直问相聚，余味偏薄。","_cost":0.013248}},"consensus":57.13,"final":57.13},{"key":"kimi-k3|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"kimi-k3","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"春街老树挂新瓶。碧叶如人亦有情。细管潜通根脉涩。东风入梦作莺声。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.1,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶写城市护绿，拟人贯穿，情景相融；由病涩转入春梦，结句有声有暖。次句稍直泛，“东风”“莺声”略熟。","_cost":0.005424},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"取当代街树输液入诗,题材新而聚焦。转句'细管潜通根脉涩'切物入微,结句以梦化莺声宕开,有余味。惜次句'如人亦有情'直说破题,削弱景语情语交融;'东风''有情'略近熟语。整体章法完足,一气贯注。","_cost":0.03806},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"以当代城市场景“树打吊瓶”入诗，题材出新。转句“细管潜通”刻画精切，结句化实为虚，余味绵长。惟承句“如人亦有情”略显直白，稍逊炼字之功。整体起承转合流畅。","_cost":0.020922},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"街树吊瓶有当代观察，题旨清楚而‘如人有情’偏泛。瓶管与东风莺声杂糅，氛围未浑。语言通顺，‘涩’略可。章法完整转折平。结句以景收，余味有限。","_cost":0.021398},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"以树木输液入诗有现代新意，“挂新瓶”“根脉涩”有质感；但“碧叶如人亦有情”直白，东风莺声偏套，转结略脱，余味有限。","_cost":0.00551122},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"取城市行道树输液这一当代景象入诗，视角新颖，树如病者输液之喻贯穿全篇，立意可取。'碧叶如人亦有情'稍直白，略欠锤炼。结句以东风莺声宕开，虚境收束，余味悠长。'根脉涩'炼字见功夫。","_cost":0.00233776},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.7,"rationale":"以城市树吊瓶入诗，题材新，拟人寄情，转结由实入虚，略有留白；但‘亦有情’等语稍直，东风莺声略熟，情感未深拓。","_cost":0.009854},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"以街边输液老树为题,当代经验入诗而有主脑,吊瓶—细管—根脉意象贯串,物我交融。'东风入梦作莺声'以景结情、留白有致。惜'碧叶如人亦有情'平直道破,炼字稍欠,东风莺声略套,结构转折平稳。","_cost":0.0067278},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.1,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.0,"rationale":"借吊瓶写春护树，化当代经验为诗眼，新而有情；由挂瓶、通脉到入梦莺声，转结自然有余韵，唯二句说破、个别词语偏直白。","_cost":0.0118119},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.8,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.3,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.349999999999994,"rationale":"以当代行道树挂吊针的日常新景入诗，题旨明晰，脉络连贯，新旧意象融合尚妥，用字有准处但偶有直白，结句留有余韵，略存熟套，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"以城市行道树输液入诗，当代经验化古出新，'碧叶如人亦有情'立意真挚有主脑。'细管潜通根脉涩'取象精切，结句'东风入梦作莺声'以幻境收束、不说破，余味悠长。惟第三句稍显说明性，语言尚可再炼。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"取城市树挂营养液吊瓶入诗,题材新而有关怀;结句以东风入梦、莺声宕开,余味尚可。惟承句'如人亦有情'干说直露,'根脉涩'字面生硬,承转乏力,中间未能把'病树'处境写深。","_cost":0.05033},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"以街头老树输液之当代经验入诗，医理与春景相融；转结有致，结语入梦留白。然次句直言‘有情’稍弱，‘涩’字锤炼略硬，整体新巧而未深。","_cost":0.028667196},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.8,"rationale":"当代园林物象入诗自然新颖。承句稍显直白说破，转句‘细管潜通’炼字贴切精警，结句化实入虚，借东风莺声寄寓生机，余味悠然。","_cost":0.00647025},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.0,"rationale":"以吊瓶输液救树立意新颖具温情，然细管直陈偏实，意象未融为境，转折平直，唯末句宕开病愈莺啼略有余味。","_cost":0.0125793},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"树挂吊瓶切入城市春景，老树与新瓶形成反差；“亦有情”直说，“潜通根脉涩”语意稍拗，承转欠圆融。结句由输液实景转入梦中莺声，有回春余想，但意象较熟。","_cost":0.04442},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.8,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.599999999999994,"rationale":"树输液入诗有当代焦点，情志停于同情未深化。唯“涩”精切；次句说破，结句落东风莺声套语，承转偏平，余味有限。","_cost":0.025352},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶这一当代街景入诗,取材新。次句“如人亦有情”是直白说理,为废笔。第三句“潜通根脉涩”细致可感。结句借东风入梦写病树盼春,略有余韵。惜转句仍在铺写,转折平直。立意止于怜惜,未能深掘。","_cost":0.015952},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"老树挂吊瓶的街景入诗有新意，结句借梦中莺声寄托生机，留有余味；但“亦有情”直白，“根脉涩”稍显生硬，承转也偏平。","_cost":0.008074}},"consensus":67.82,"final":67.82},{"key":"kimi-k3|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"kimi-k3","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"春街晓色入新阳，病树悬瓶滴露香。倦鹊窥城风更紧，灵津缓落护根忙。棉丝细引青荧动，碧液无声渗骨伤。软缕斜牵灯影乱，谁言草木少文章。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"unknown"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.9,"章法":6.3,"余味":5.4,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.4,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.3,"rationale":"吊瓶疗树入诗，视角新而主脑明确；中二联反复铺写滴液，层次稍窄。“青荧”“渗骨伤”略生硬，晓色与灯影衔接欠稳；结句点题偏直，仍见惜木之情。","_cost":0.01033},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"以街树输液入诗,当代经验立意可取。然中二联与首尾反复写吊瓶滴液,悬瓶、灵津、棉丝、碧液、软缕同质堆叠,开合层次不足,近于原地打转。'灵津''滴露香'措辞生硬失实。结句反问议论收束,直白少余味,惟'碧液无声渗骨伤'稍见锤炼。","_cost":0.03843},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"以当代“病树悬瓶”入诗，题材出新，颈联刻画输液微观状态细腻。但“滴露香”略乖事理，首尾“新阳”与“灯影”存时间逻辑微瑕。结句直白发议论，余味稍欠。整体立意新颖，表达平稳。","_cost":0.017876},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"病树吊瓶观察具体主脑清，情志平实角度常见。意象围绕输液尚统一，倦鹊灯影略添。炼字通顺‘渗骨伤’见力亦有不谐。结构完整转折平直。结句点破少余味。当代事物入诗有新意。","_cost":0.021362},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"题材新颖，写城市树挂吊瓶，但用词生造，时间意象前后相悖，结句直议论说破，整体中上。","_cost":0.020091808},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"城市行道树输液的当代经验入诗，题材新颖，情意有落点，意象群(悬瓶、棉丝、碧液、灯影)统一于都市早春氛围。中二联均围绕输液装置铺写，层次稍显重复；'灵津''护根'用词略欠精准(树液多输于干非根)，尾联设问收束尚稳但微直白。","_cost":0.00293996},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.7,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.8,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":1.2,"陈滥":1.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.19999999999999,"rationale":"题取街树输液，当代物象有发现，主线尚贯。中二联铺写稍平，‘灵津’‘青荧’等语略生，结以议论收破，余味不足；稍见佳句。","_cost":0.014038},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"以城市病树输液入七律,题新而情真,棉花细管、碧液渗骨等象精切,景情交融;然颔颈二联同写输液略复沓少开合,'晓色新阳'与'灯影乱'时序相悖,'滴露香'稍饰,结句议论近说破,余宕不足。","_cost":0.0126858},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.9,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.05,"rationale":"以输液护树切入当代经验，新颖具体有主脑。医养意象与春晓风鹊交融尚精切但颔联游离。中二联同写瓶滴层次未开，结句谁言说破无留白。","_cost":0.0110499},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"此作以当代春街行道树输营养液的新鲜题材入诗，脉络通顺，描写细腻；惟部分意象稍泛，炼字偶有生硬，结句偏直白余味不足，少量常套意象，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"城市行道树输液入诗，题材新颖，情事具体，'碧液无声渗骨伤'炼字见功。中二联皆写滴注，开合层次略平；'灵津'稍显生造。结句反问收束有余意但微露说理痕迹。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.25,"rationale":"题材取自当代街景，有新意；但中二联与首联皆反复铺写输液管滴落，原地打转无开合。“滴露香”“棉丝”“灵津”等造语失真且有斧凿，晓色与灯影时序稍乱。结句以泛问兜底，说尽而少余味。","_cost":0.05835},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"以现代树木输液入律，题材出新且聚焦；中二联铺陈稍平，转结偏直白。意象有‘软缕斜牵’等亮点，但‘滴露香’‘青荧’等欠精切，间有套语。无蹈袭硬伤。","_cost":0.034740468},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.8,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.35,"rationale":"以当代树木输液入诗具生活实感，颈联体物精微。然首联“晓色”与尾联“灯影”时间逻辑矛盾，营养液作“滴露香”欠真实；中二联微观重叠，结句“少文章”用词模糊、余味稍薄。","_cost":0.00565725},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.0,"rationale":"以行道树输液为眼，当代经验入诗；然中二联同义反复原地打转，尾联议论说破，意象欠融贯。","_cost":0.0092078},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.3,"章法":4.6,"余味":3.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.849999999999994,"rationale":"街树输液切入有新意，病树与照护构成主线；中二联反复写滴液，层次不足。“灵津”“渗骨伤”修饰生硬，部分物象含混。结句泛论“文章”，与病树处境衔接偏弱，余味有限。","_cost":0.0419},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"街树吊瓶入诗,题新而情偏观照,结句谁言说破。颈联青荧、渗骨较切,倦鹊、露香、灵津游离或溢美。章法有架而颔联断脉,转结直白。当代经验有效,无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0246848},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.25,"rationale":"街树吊瓶是当代题材,有新意,但止于状物,未翻出更深的体悟。中间二联与第七句反复描写输液管液,原地打转。'滴露香''灵津''护根忙'措辞生硬。'倦鹊窥城'一句游离主题。结句议论直白说破,余味浅。","_cost":0.01752},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.75,"rationale":"街树挂吊瓶入诗，有城市春景的新意；中二联反复写输液，“护根忙”“渗骨伤”语感稍涩。末句以“谁言”点题，说得较尽，余味不足。","_cost":0.01023}},"consensus":61.55,"final":61.55},{"key":"kimi-k3|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"kimi-k3","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"高楼月满一灯明，玉宇风回万籁清。铁马巡空千架冷，云仓夜扫落花声。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.6,"警句":3.6,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.7,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.8,"rationale":"前二句月夜清景稍熟，后二句骤转科技语境，“千架冷”与“落花声”虚实相生。主脑集中，转结有力；“铁马巡空”所指略涩，意象衔接尚欠圆融。","_cost":0.007846},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"以云仓、无人机巡检等当代经验入绝句,'铁马巡空''云仓夜扫'化古语指新物,转结机械之冷与落花之柔相映,结句以声留白有余味。惜前两句'玉宇''万籁清'落熟套,情志焦点稍虚,人未在场,情感附着不足。","_cost":0.04478},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"本作将现代“云仓”、自动化“千架”等科技场景入诗，题材出新。前两句景语略显陈套；第三句转折有力，“铁马”与“冷”字精切描摹机械运作感；结句以“落花声”隐喻科技运行的细微声响，刚柔并济，余味悠长。","_cost":0.024038},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.0,"rationale":"立意将云仓夜作纳入古典夜景，题旨明而情志浮泛少独到发现。意象玉宇万籁与铁马云仓拼贴未浑融，落花稍隔。语言通达乏锤炼。章法起承平顺转结尚可。结句以声留白有余味。当代物象略出新，套语密度偏高。","_cost":0.023872},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"以古典笔法写现代仓储夜景，立意稍见新意但情感空泛；意象清冷而拼贴，铁马、落花衔接突兀；语言通顺少诗眼；章法转合欠紧密；结句有余味但铺垫不足。","_cost":0.01914793},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"以七绝写无人云仓夜巡，熟题外开出新境，主脑聚焦'夜扫'。'铁马巡空'双关机械与古典战骑，结句'落花声'以声写尘、以景结情，言尽意不尽。惟'月满灯明''万籁清'稍落常套，承句偏平，转折力度略欠。","_cost":0.00257536},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.6,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.3,"余味":7.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.4,"rationale":"前二句清夜稍熟，三四以铁马、云仓化现代运维入诗，冷、声二字有韵，转结留白。但语多旧词，情志未深。","_cost":0.011212},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫写无人化劳动的冷寂，题旨较新且焦点集中；铁马、千架与落花声相接，有末句余韵。但高楼、玉宇、万籁、落花仍带熟套，前两联铺景略平，现代语汇入诗尚未完全化开。","_cost":0.0123948},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.4,"章法":5.8,"余味":7.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.949999999999996,"rationale":"云仓欲翻新题而情志虚泛，意象清冷统一但多熟语，语言通顺乏诗眼，章法平直少变，结句以落花声收束稍具余韵。","_cost":0.01338065},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":6.2,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.55,"rationale":"此作将现代云仓夜扫场景融入传统清夜诗境，炼字见巧，结句以声衬静余韵长；唯开篇意象稍熟，章法偏平，情志多停留在绘境，开掘不深。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.0,"rationale":"以数据中心夜景入旧体，'铁马''云仓''落花声'喻硬盘扫描声，当代经验化用较自然，结句以声收束有余响。但前二句月满、万籁清属熟套铺垫，情感主脑偏淡，止于巧思而少深挚之情；'玉宇风回'稍见陈言。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.25,"rationale":"欲以云仓、铁马巡空写当代数据机房/无人机夜景，但前二句纯是玉宇月满、万籁清等陈套铺垫，与题无涉；三句方切入新境却语意含混，结句“落花声”与云仓意象强行拼接，留白有余而所指不明，古今融合未成一体。","_cost":0.05185},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"写云仓夜景，起承清冷幽静，转结以声衬寂，结句‘落花声’以柔克刚，余味较好；但意旨偏纯写景、情志不显，‘铁马巡空’等意象稍杂，章法上题旨至末句方明且直嵌标题。当代经验入诗有新意，略有陈语，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.036575358},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.3,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.4,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.55,"rationale":"前两句起承略显陈套，转结将现代智慧物流“云仓”、立体库与穿梭机化入古典意境，题材新颖。“千架冷”见库区规模，“落花声”拟夜扫分拣之轻微，造意有巧思。","_cost":0.0063225},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.2,"意境":4.2,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.4,"余味":6.8,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.6,"rationale":"机房夜巡翻旧题，角度有新意；然前半套语堆砌，铁马巡空费解、扫声搭配失当，意境割裂，唯末句以落花喻机声稍留余响。","_cost":0.0143818},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.0,"rationale":"清冷氛围较统一，“千架冷”有力度；“云仓”带来新意，但夜扫情事未充分展开，与“铁马巡空”的关联欠明。前半意象偏熟，转折略生硬；结句以声收束，有留白，落花却稍显游离。","_cost":0.04813},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"立意停于冷观，云仓未落到具体情事。千架冷托落花声尚能成境，玉宇万籁嫌熟。语言顺而少锤炼。转句撑住章法，起承平铺。结以声留余，但点题偏实。","_cost":0.0214848},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"以云仓夜间作业入诗,当代题材有新意。“铁马巡空千架冷”借旧词写新物,颇有巧思。结句以“落花声”比扫码之声,轻灵而有余味。但前两句“月满”“玉宇”“万籁清”都是套语,与仓储主题关联弱。起承空泛,主脑到后两句才显出来。","_cost":0.01678},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"以云仓夜作对照落花声，有新意，结句也留得静意；但“玉宇”“万籁清”较熟，“铁马巡空”所指含混，机械场景与落花之间衔接稍突兀。","_cost":0.010396}},"consensus":63.39,"final":63.39},{"key":"kimi-k3|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"kimi-k3","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"夜扫云仓灯未灭，星河压架一棚光。寒屏射码青荧远，铁柜吞冰玉屑霜。万货奔流归网阔，人机织梦五更长。东风已动关山路，晓发千车载露凉。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"unknown"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.8,"警句":3.4,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.9,"rationale":"以夜间云仓作业入诗，冷光、货架、扫码与车流熔成鲜明现代图景。章法由仓内推至晓发，层次清楚；“星河压架”醒目。“织梦”“东风”稍套，“射码”“载露凉”略显用力。","_cost":0.007314},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"以电商云仓夜班入律,题材新而情事可感。'寒屏射码''铁柜吞冰'炼字见巧,颔联工切可摘。颈联'归网阔''织梦'稍虚泛,'东风''关山'略落套话。结以'千车载露凉'宕开收景,凉意延宕有余味。整体当代经验入诗有效,转联气脉稍平。","_cost":0.04114},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.5,"rationale":"本诗将当代物流云仓作业有效入诗，立意新颖。颔联“射码”“吞冰”精准刻画现代科技与冷链，出新极佳。然颈联“人机织梦”稍显直白。章法严谨，尾联以晨光发车之景收束，意境宏阔，颇有余味。","_cost":0.022156},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"云仓夜运入律，射码吞冰千车载露较具体，主脑在人机夜作至晓发。颔联稍工，通篇新意可取而中联开合平，结以景留凉意。东风关山略套。","_cost":0.016214},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.85,"rationale":"现代云仓题材出新，首联与尾联佳，尾联以景结情有余味；中二联意象略密，个别词组欠自然，立意偏劳动赞歌。","_cost":0.00819016},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.25,"rationale":"现代云仓夜班劳动入诗，题旨新颖而有主脑。中二联物象人事分层，'压''射''吞''织'等字锤炼见诗眼，寒光铁柜与星河交织成统一氛围。结句'载露凉'以景结情，宕开有余韵。'东风关山'稍近常调，中二联开合略平。","_cost":0.00281256},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.8,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.65,"rationale":"以云仓夜班入诗，星河压架、寒屏射码颇有新意；中二联稍涉概念，网阔、织梦略空，转结顺畅，晓车载露留白可味。","_cost":0.015768},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"以当代物流夜工入七律,题材翻出新境,主脑集中于夜扫至晓发,情意真切。「星河压架一棚光」「铁柜吞冰玉屑霜」取象精切,压、射、吞诸字有力,物象与劳作氛围交融。中二联开合有序,尾联以晓发载露宕开作景结,留有余韵。惟「东风已动关山路」稍熟,「人机织梦」略泛,故各维未至顶尖。当代经验化古无痕,予以出新与警句加分。","_cost":0.0094908},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.1,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.89999999999999,"rationale":"以云仓扫码冷链入诗取材新颖，颔联屏码柜霜具现场感，颈联铺叙稍虚，结构由室内至网络至晓发层次分明，结句载露以景收束有余凉。","_cost":0.00774225},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"此作以当代云仓夜作为题，紧扣扫码、冷链、物流配送等新场景入律，炼字见巧，章法开合顺畅，无硬伤蹈袭，仅个别传统意象稍熟，余味略平。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"以云仓夜班入律，当代经验与古典语汇融合自然，主脑清晰。'星河压架''青荧射码'取象精切，中二联由近景推向万货奔流，开合有致；结句'晓发千车载露凉'以景收情，留白得当。个别处如'吞冰玉屑霜'稍显雕琢，五更东风等词微见熟套。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"以云仓夜班入诗，当代物流经验有效入律，夜至晓脉络清楚，结以千车载露稍有余韵。惟情感仅止于场面铺陈，缺具体人事；“玉屑霜”“织梦”略嫌拼凑，中二联工整而开合不足。","_cost":0.05511},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"写现代云仓夜扫至晓发，脉络清晰；颔联‘寒屏射码’‘铁柜吞冰’取象新警，然‘网阔’‘织梦’稍抽象，情意交融不足。结句‘载露凉’以景收，有余韵；语言文白夹杂，尾联‘东风关山’略熟。","_cost":0.034339473},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.3,"rationale":"当代物流题材佳作。取象精切，化科技经验入诗而不隔；颔联炼字工警，章法由幽深仓房层层推向广阔网络，结以千车载露晓发，气象闳远，余味深长。","_cost":0.005217},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"题材取云仓夜作具时代感，然织梦口号化情弱；取象具体而屏射柜吞生硬，章法依夜深至晓铺叙贯通，尾句载露凉以景收略有余味。","_cost":0.0173685},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"云仓夜作有当代质感，灯、屏、霜、露贯通夜晓；“星河压架”有力，结句以露凉留味。“射码”“吞冰玉屑霜”稍显硬涩，“人机织梦”落套，情志仍偏常见的劳动赞歌。","_cost":0.03442},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"题在云仓夜作至晓发,主脑清楚,情事却偏全景未落到人。颔联寒屏射码、铁柜吞冰景情相切;颈联奔流织梦转虚,尾联东风关山近套,转折平直。载露凉略留凉意,未尽宕开。无硬伤与整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.0276656},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫写当代物流,题材有新意。「压」「射」「吞」三字见锤炼,冷光氛围统一。颈联「万货奔流」「人机织梦」近于口号,「东风关山」也属套语。「寒屏射码」主体不清。结句以晓车载露收束,尚有余味。","_cost":0.016984},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"扫码、冷柜到晓发千车，写出云仓夜班的忙碌，时序贯通，结句有凉意可回味；“归网阔”欠自然，“人机织梦”“东风已动”稍显套熟。","_cost":0.008074}},"consensus":72.72,"final":72.72},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|机场送别|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"广播催登别语稠，初经安检惜离愁。孤机滑出暮光外，我立窗前空伫留。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.2,"意境":6.3,"语言":4.8,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.4,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"机场送别场景明确，广播、安检、滑行层层推进；“孤机滑出暮光外”较有画面。情旨仍属常见，“初经安检”指向含混，“离愁”“空伫留”直露且略显冗滞。","_cost":0.005004},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"机场送别乃熟题,以安检、广播等当代经验入诗有可取处。第三句'孤机滑出暮光外'取象最佳,可摘为亮点。然'惜离愁''空伫留'凑韵直露,结句自陈伫立说得太尽,余味不足;'离愁''伫留'属套语,语言炼字尚欠火候。","_cost":0.03757},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.5,"rationale":"“孤机滑出暮光外”具画面感，现代生活场景入诗值得肯定。但全诗文白融合生硬，“惜离愁”搭配不洽有凑韵之嫌，且结句“空伫留”直白兜底，缺乏留白余味，整体流于直白记事。","_cost":0.019234},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.5,"rationale":"送别熟题，机场安检略具今感而情志仍落常套。孤机暮光稍成境，余多直说离愁。催登后再写安检，事序小碍。结句点破空伫，余味薄。","_cost":0.01527},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"机场送别具现代场景之真，转句“孤机滑出暮光外”以景运情，章法转结稳妥；惜离愁、空伫留稍直白，且“立”“伫留”语义重复，余味不足，套语略减分。","_cost":0.012498816},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"当代机场入旧体自然，广播、安检、孤机滑出暮光意象切境，第三句转得有力，结以人立窗前留有余姿。但'惜离愁''空伫留'炼字稍弱，伫留与立意重，离愁语近套话，通篇仍是常见送别框架，新意有限。","_cost":0.00257256},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.0,"rationale":"机场细节入诗，起承脉络清楚，孤机暮光有画面；但别语、离愁、空伫留直说，结句兜底，余味不足，语言稍显平直。","_cost":0.011318},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"现代机场送别题材入诗,安检、广播等意象新鲜有效,起承转合完整,三句转机有势,结句以人立窗前收束。惜'惜离愁''空伫留'直白说破,炼字欠诗眼,情感表达常见无独到发现,'孤机滑出暮光外'稍有画面但非警句。","_cost":0.0081708},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.5,"rationale":"送别熟题无新境，离愁直说；广播安检入诗生硬，暮光孤机意象散白；句法口语，空伫留重复，转结平直，末句兜底无余味。","_cost":0.009146},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.5,"rationale":"此作写机场送别实景，章法顺、语言通，但立意平泛，意象寻常，炼字无亮眼处，结句直白，虽引入当代机场元素却未翻新意，无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"机场安检、登机广播等当代经验入旧体，取象真切，'孤机滑出暮光外'有画面。惜'惜离愁'直陈点破，结句'空伫留'与'立'意重、说尽余情，转结稍平。整体题旨常见，情感真挚但缺乏独到发现，炼字偶有亮点而'伫留'稍生硬。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.0,"rationale":"题材当代具体，脉络清楚。“孤机滑出暮光外”一句有画面感。但“初经安检惜离愁”生硬凑句，“离愁”“伫留”系套语；结句直陈伫立，“空”字说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.04644},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"现代机场送别，场景具体而情致平常；起承叙事，转以孤机暮光稍振，结句直白少余味；语言杂现代词，惜离愁等稍拙；孤机句略有亮色，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.026992359},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"机场送别章法清晰，转入孤机暮光具开阔感，当代经验入诗自然。然炼字偏直，“惜离愁”略合掌，结句“我立窗前空伫留”说破兜底，余味不足。","_cost":0.004536},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"机场物象切合送别情境，第三句较有画面，题旨仍属常见。“惜离愁”搭配生硬，“立”“伫”“留”语义重复。由人及机、由动转静，脉络清楚；结句点情偏露，余味有限。","_cost":0.04077},"grok-4.7":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.0,"rationale":"送别主脑清楚,安检仅换场景,情仍是惜愁空伫,无独到发现。孤机暮光略能融情,余象平列。催登、伫留生硬,空字费而说破。起承同类,转结平直,结句把离绪说尽。无误典硬伤,套语轻度,无整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.0195424},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.75,"rationale":"以广播、安检、滑行写机场送别,当代经验入诗,但情感未见独到发现。\"孤机滑出暮光外\"有画面。\"惜离愁\"搭配别扭,\"立\"与\"伫留\"语义重复。章法按时间顺叙,转句平直。结句直陈伫立,余味有限。","_cost":0.017296},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"广播、安检写出送别现场，孤机没入暮光较有画面；由别语转向远望，脉络清楚。但“惜离愁”直露，“立”与“伫留”叠意，结句余味稍薄。","_cost":0.008044}},"consensus":54.2,"final":54.2},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|机场送别|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"霄航急告促登楼，别绪盈眶却欲愁，候室灯寒牵袖皱，舷窗映暮尚凝眸，朝飞万里烟云隔，泪逐长风渐远流，只剩孤身寻出口，归途寂寞对清秋。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":4.8,"意境":5.2,"语言":3.8,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.7,"警句":0.5,"出新":0.8,"硬伤":1.2,"陈滥":2.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.3,"rationale":"送别主脑明确，灯影、舷窗与出口构成进程，但情感较泛。措辞多有生硬，“映暮”后“朝飞”时序可疑；末句直说寂寞，余味浅。","_cost":0.010462},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.75,"rationale":"以机场入律诗题材尚新,候室灯寒、舷窗映暮有当代实感。惜语言生硬,'霄航急告''却欲愁'凑字明显;中二联开合不足,烟云、长风、泪、清秋皆熟套连缀。结句'孤身寻出口'具体可取,末句归于常语,余味平平。","_cost":0.03431},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":2.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":28.25,"rationale":"机场送别虽引入现代场景，但语言生造白话（牵袖皱、寻出口），且有“却欲愁”的逻辑矛盾。章法平铺直叙，中二联未见律诗开合，结句说破无余味，整体流于俗套。","_cost":0.017592},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.0,"rationale":"机场送别熟题，细节稍具体但无新境。暮朝时序矛盾、候室舷窗脉络欠清。却欲愁、牵袖皱生硬，结句直说寂寞少余味。意象常见。","_cost":0.016086},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.0,"rationale":"送别主题角度常见，情感虽真实但表达直露；意象基本妥帖，‘牵袖皱’‘舷窗映暮’有画面感，但后半‘泪逐长风’等流于套话；语言文白夹杂，凑韵明显；结构完整然转折平直，颈联与前重复泪意。结句景语有余味但‘孤身’‘寂寞’说破。","_cost":0.004499968},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"机场送别以旧体写当代经验，取材可取，但情感仍是常见离愁，未翻新境。意象有候室灯寒、舷窗映暮等实景，然与'泪''孤身''寂寞''清秋'等熟字连缀，密度偏高。'牵袖皱''促登楼'略见凑字斧凿；结句'寂寞'直白说破，余味有限。中二联对仗松紧不一，章法尚贯通。","_cost":0.00343736},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.2,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.4,"rationale":"机场送别题旨明确，细节尚可，但情语多直说；灯寒、舷窗等象有氛围，清秋长风稍陈；句法通顺而偶有生硬，结句说破寂寞，余味不足。","_cost":0.01279},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.5,"rationale":"送别题旨集中而立意常见；候室、舷窗、出口有现代感，然“别绪盈眶”搭配失当，“渐远流”生硬，清秋长风陈熟，登楼/候室/舷窗行踪略乱，结直。","_cost":0.0174738},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":4.6,"意境":5.4,"语言":4.3,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.699999999999996,"rationale":"机场送别题旨直白无新境；候室舷窗稍具现场感而烟云长风清秋偏陈；末联口语化少诗眼；时序平铺转合平直；尾句直言寂寞说尽无留白。","_cost":0.00872625},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.8,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.1,"rationale":"此作写机场送别，主旨明确但无新致，意象妥帖多熟套，语言通顺偶有小疵，章法完整却转折平直，结句直白少余味，当代元素入诗未出新意，无蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.25,"rationale":"机场送别入旧体，题材有当代感，候机灯寒、舷窗凝眸取象尚切。但'却欲愁''促登楼'等语生硬凑韵，泪逐长风、孤身寂寞皆熟套；中二联对仗工稳而转折平直，结句'对清秋'收束稳当然意尽于言，余味有限。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.5,"rationale":"当代机场经验入诗，候室灯寒、牵袖、寻出口等细节具体可感；但“却欲愁”“朝飞”等语意含混，舷窗凝眸视角与暮/朝略有抵牾。中二联层次尚可而少开合，结句“寂寞对清秋”直说破题，余味薄。","_cost":0.05908},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.5,"rationale":"写机场送别，现代物象入律，立意常见。意象妥帖而多陈语，语言文白夹杂，寻出口生硬；朝飞与映暮抵牾，却欲愁逻辑稍悖。章法完整而转结平直，结句直白。少警句，出新有限。","_cost":0.036530349},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.2,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.6,"rationale":"机场送别具现代生活气息，“牵袖皱”细节真切。然章法平铺直叙如流水账，后半段落入“泪逐长风”“对清秋”等陈套直白抒情，尾联说得过尽，余味不足。","_cost":0.005493},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.25,"rationale":"送别主线清楚，牵袖、寻出口有现场感；“霄航急告”“却欲愁”措辞生硬，舷窗凝眸视点略含混。烟云、长风、清秋偏熟，结句直点寂寞，余味有限。","_cost":0.04716},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.5,"rationale":"主旨是机场离愁,清楚但常见,情事未具体。候室灯寒、舷窗映暮尚切,后半烟云长风清秋套语密,视角游移。霄航、却欲愁等硬凑,少诗眼。顺序可循,暮与朝跳接,后幅反复言远与孤。结句说破寂寞,余味薄。","_cost":0.0354112},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.75,"rationale":"","_cost":0.022532},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.5,"rationale":"送别脉络清晰，“寻出口”有现场感；“霄航”“登楼”“却欲愁”用语生硬，“映暮”与“朝飞”时序相抵。结句直说寂寞，余味较弱。","_cost":0.010162}},"consensus":45.81,"final":45.81},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"币落机前觑爪光，钢钩欲下复彷徨，欢呼未定旋成叹，蓦忆儿时冀满囊。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.2,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.05,"rationale":"抓取瞬间牵出童年期待，题材入诗有新意；爪光、钢钩具现场感。三句转折利落，末句回忆稍突，“冀满囊”生硬且说意偏直。","_cost":0.004502},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.5,"rationale":"以当代娃娃机入诗有新意，前三句叙事紧凑，'欲下复彷徨'状物兼写人心尚佳。惜结句以'蓦忆'直接点破怀旧，说尽少留白，儿时之'冀'与眼前之'叹'的对照略显套路。语言通顺而炼字力度一般，无明显诗眼。","_cost":0.03629},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"当代生活入诗，起承转合流利，生动刻画得而复失的落差感。然意象偏写实，缺乏诗意升华，结句直抒胸臆、说破兜底，稍欠含蓄余味。","_cost":0.02322},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"抓娃娃机即时得失勾童年冀望，场景具体有焦点；钢钩彷徨、欢呼旋叹较活。转结直叙回忆，意象浅融，余味说破，属妥帖而未深的小制。","_cost":0.01491},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":4.8,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.3,"余味":6.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.55,"rationale":"抓娃娃机写当代微失落，立意具体但开掘不深；转合由眼前入儿时，章法完整。意象多事态少景语，结句略直，故各维中下。“欢呼未定旋成叹”可称佳句，现代题材稍出新。","_cost":0.004867104},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写当代小情境，由眼前得失宕开忆儿时冀满囊，立意有生活实感但归落怀旧较为常见。前两句白描生动，'旋成叹'见转折之妙；'冀满囊'炼字略硬。章法起承转合完整，结句虽宕开一笔而'忆'字稍说破，余味中平。当代经验入诗有效，给以出新分。","_cost":0.00231136},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"当代物象入诗，起承转合清楚，钢钩欲下句能传犹疑；但爪光、冀满囊稍生，结句说破，余味偏弱。","_cost":0.011556},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃写概率诱惑与儿时欲念，题材新而有小小发现；但欢呼成叹直说，末联忆旧稍突，‘冀满囊’生硬，佳象未足成警句。","_cost":0.0110238},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.8,"语言":5.3,"章法":6.4,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.9,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机切入当代得失，起承机杼动作具象，转叹蓦忆作结章法完整；然意象单薄、情与景粘合浅，语言通顺欠锤炼，结句直点冀满囊，余味有限。","_cost":0.00756275},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.3,"rationale":"此作抓取抓娃娃的当代日常场景，摹写临爪忐忑、瞬喜旋叹的情态真切，自然勾连童年冀获的共通体验，语言精准，章法平顺，结有余思，未臻浑融。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入旧体，当代经验与儿时'冀满囊'勾连，立意有新意且情事具体；'币落机前觑爪光'取象精切，第三句'欢呼未定旋成叹'转折有力。惟结句点破'蓦忆'稍直，余味略减；中二意象密度尚可再厚。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.5,"rationale":"当代经验入诗，由抓娃娃失手转入童年渴念，题意明确但层次单薄。“觑”“复彷徨”拟物尚可，“冀满囊”凑韵含混。前三句叙述平铺，结句点破怀旧，余味有限。","_cost":0.04956},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写今昔之感，取象现代而情事具体；转结由失手之叹宕开忆旧，有余味。语言稍杂、结句稍直，故未至高分。","_cost":0.024545548},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.2,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.15,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗，前三句状写抓机之态真实流畅，得其情境。结句引向儿时寄托虽拓开一层，但“冀满囊”造语稍生硬，且直白说破，收束略显仓促，余味不足。","_cost":0.00677925},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"欢呼转叹写出得失落差，叙事层次清楚；机器物象尚未充分化为情境。“觑爪光”“冀满囊”措辞生硬，结尾追忆童年衔接稍薄，直陈愿望而余味有限。当代题材有所开拓，未成警句。","_cost":0.05156},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"「钢钩欲下复彷徨」有张力，起承转合清楚，抓娃娃入诗不算生硬。然欢呼变叹直陈其事，结句点破儿时冀满囊，意象中断，余味发白。所见止于失败唤起旧愿，新题而未深。","_cost":0.0284176},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"当代题材入诗有新意,前三句写投币、犹豫、得失,过程可感,「欢呼未定旋成叹」颇传神。结句以「蓦忆」突转儿时,转得生硬;「冀满囊」措辞拙涩,且直说心事,留白不足。全诗意象单薄,由童心到人生的感慨没有展开。","_cost":0.017064},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.75,"rationale":"钢钩彷徨写出抓取时的悬念，欢呼转叹也贴合题材；但“觑爪光”“冀满囊”稍显生硬，末句直点儿时愿望，余味较浅。","_cost":0.008162}},"consensus":61.15,"final":61.15},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"灯明柜透试悬钩，粉色绒熊惑客眸。攥币操杆频失手，闲情爪影伴人愁。童心屡败仍回首，久倚橱窗忘晚楼。乃悟浮生皆若戏，悠然一掷付清秋。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"unknown"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"weak"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.3,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.1,"余味":5.7,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"抓娃娃入诗颇具当代感，诸象围绕机柜与失手展开，脉络清楚。尾联由童心转浮生，但“人生如戏”稍熟滥且说破；“晚楼”“付清秋”语意略虚，结句有姿态而余韵有限。","_cost":0.00525},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入诗题材新，场景具体可感，颔颈两联铺叙屡败心态尚有层次。惜语言多凑泊，'伴人愁''忘晚楼'为韵所累；尾联'乃悟浮生皆若戏'把感慨说破，落入'人生如戏'俗套，末句一掷付清秋稍作宕开亦难挽余味。当代经验入诗可嘉，锤炼不足。","_cost":0.03599},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.75,"rationale":"当代题材入律有可取，首颔联场景具体；但颔颈联皆写屡败，层次未开；「闲情」与「愁」自相牴牾，「忘晚楼」凑韵；尾联「乃悟浮生皆若戏」直接说破，落入俗套，余味寡淡。","_cost":0.05681},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.75,"rationale":"作品以现代游戏“抓娃娃机”入诗，题材较新。前两联物象具体，但“粉色绒熊”与“付清秋”文白夹杂且生凑。章法尚算完整，然结句“乃悟浮生”直接说破，落入俗套，缺乏诗意余味。","_cost":0.015604},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"抓娃娃过程具体有主脑，然落于浮生若戏熟套。今古意象拼贴欠融，文白夹杂缺锤炼。结构由事入理尚通，尾联说破点题，结句余味有限。","_cost":0.024608},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写浮生若戏，题材新而情事具体；爪影伴人愁意象佳。中二联失手/屡败稍显重复，结句点破略直。语言有亮色亦有套语。","_cost":0.01397748},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入七律，当代经验入诗有新意，取象具体。但中二联意脉重复（频失手/屡败原地打转），'惑客眸''忘晚楼'凑韵生硬，'闲情'与'愁'相犯。第七句'乃悟浮生皆若戏'说破题旨，结句直白兜底，余味受损。'浮生''清秋'等语略陈。","_cost":0.0043154},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"题材新鲜，抓机细节可感，脉络清晰；但“浮生若戏”说破，部分词语直白生凑，结句稍有余味。","_cost":0.011908},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":60.75,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入律，题材新、物象具体有情；频败—忘晚层次尚清。惜“浮生若戏”熟调直说破，余味打折，“惑眸”“闲情伴愁”略凑。","_cost":0.02964},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.6,"意境":6.7,"语言":5.6,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.050000000000004,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入诗题材新，由屡败回首悟浮生若戏，现场感具体但理路熟；中二联铺叙同层转折平，语言通顺而少诗眼，末句前已说破，余味受损。","_cost":0.0092385},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"抓娃娃机题材入律，当代经验有效；中二联由动作到心态有层次，末句以景收束有余味。然“浮生若戏”意涉常见，“乃悟”等句稍直白，清秋结法稍陈。","_cost":0.033740067},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机当代日常入诗，细节写实、脉络顺畅，但落于人生如戏的熟套，部分词句凑泊、意象泛常，理语说破致余味不足，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.2,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.6,"章法":5.4,"余味":3.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.8,"rationale":"现代题材入诗具生活感，抓娃娃细节真实可感。惜“粉色绒熊”微显文白驳杂，炼字尚浅；尾联以“乃悟”直白说破，强行拔高至“浮生若戏”，流于陈套且余味不足。","_cost":0.005232},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.75,"rationale":"投币失手有生活实感，绒熊、爪影切题，由试玩转感悟，脉络清楚；“忘晚楼”语义生硬，“浮生皆若戏”落入熟套，“清秋”缺少铺垫，结句虽作洒脱，余情偏泛。","_cost":0.04155},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.0,"rationale":"前半失手、绒熊、爪影具体，童心屡败略有情致，抓机入律是新处。中二联同层未开，尾联乃悟点破浮生若戏，与悠然相忤，余味尽。语言偶切，亦有硬凑与套语。","_cost":0.024368},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写当代生活,题材有新意。前四句情事具体可感。但闲情与伴人愁相抵,晚楼属生造硬凑。中二联都写屡败,层次不足。第七句浮生若戏属说破套语,结句悠然清秋较陈套,余味有限。","_cost":0.015764},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.0,"rationale":"抓娃娃的动作与屡败仍试的心态具体可感，取材有新意；“忘晚楼”语意含混。末联骤升浮生之叹，既显牵强，也把情意说尽。","_cost":0.00806}},"consensus":56.88,"final":56.88},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"天台寸土作蔬园，雨后青畦绿意喧，瓦缶成行藏野趣，朝来摘罢自开轩。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.3,"章法":6.1,"余味":5.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.2,"rationale":"屋顶辟园颇具生活气息，雨畦、瓦缶取象统一，“绿意喧”有声色。三句略说破野趣，结句“自开轩”空间衔接稍弱，余味平常。","_cost":0.006004},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.25,"rationale":"天台种菜取材有当代生活气息，情事真切但立意浅近。'绿意喧'稍见炼字，然'藏野趣'直说破意，转句乏力，四句平铺少起伏。结句'摘罢开轩'收得闲适安稳，惜直白少延宕。整体清顺小品，无大疵亦乏警策。","_cost":0.03391},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"以当代城市天台种菜入诗，生活气息浓郁。语言通顺，“绿意喧”炼字生动，“瓦缶”取象真实贴切。然章法转折稍显平直，结句收束稳当却嫌直白平淡，缺乏宕开一笔的余味。","_cost":0.018434},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.25,"rationale":"小园自足之乐题旨明确而角度常见，情事尚具体。意象统一成闲适氛围但多为常景，语言通顺「喧」略活而无真正诗眼。章法顺叙少转，结以摘蔬开轩收得住却直白。天台盆栽略带当代气息。","_cost":0.010804},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"天台种菜有生活情趣但立意平淡。雨后青畦、瓦缶成行统一清新，‘喧’字生动。语言通顺但青绿略复，章法完整而转结平直，结句叙事直白少余味。无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":0.02150016},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.5,"rationale":"都市天台种菜是当代经验有效入诗，题旨具体有主脑。'绿意喧'以听觉写视觉，是全篇诗眼；瓦缶成行取象精切。起承自然，第三句稍平，转得不够有力。结句'摘罢自开轩'以动作收束，尚留余味但不够宕开。'野趣'一词稍熟，整体真挚清新。","_cost":0.00223056},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.8,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.05,"rationale":"写天台小园，雨后瓦缶颇见生活趣，题旨明确；但取象用语稍熟，转结平直，“自开轩”余味未深。","_cost":0.011242},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"天台种菜经验较新，聚焦都市寸土农趣；“绿意喧”有通感亮点，青畦、瓦缶成色统一。惜三句仍属铺排而非陡转，结句“自开轩”与天台空间略隔，收束偏实，余延有限。","_cost":0.0163008},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.4,"章法":5.6,"余味":4.9,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.15,"rationale":"天台种菜切近当代生活但题旨未作深境，雨后青畦与瓦缶成行有象可感然转折平直，结句自开轩直收，趣在而余味不远。","_cost":0.00972475},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.0,"rationale":"此作写天台种菜闲趣，主脑明晰，意象妥帖，\"绿意喧\"稍见炼字，章法平顺，结句直白稳实；未发掘天台菜园独特意涵，整体平熟少新警，无硬伤蹈袭陈套。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"天台种蔬是当代经验入诗，题材有新意；'绿意喧'以听觉写视觉，是全诗诗眼。但第三句仍在铺景，未成真正之转，结句'自开轩'收束平直，情味说尽而留白不足。整体清顺可诵，惜深度与波澜俱欠。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"天台种菜取材当代，尚有生活气；“绿意喧”“瓦缶成行”稍见炼字。然“藏野趣”直说而无象，三句未成转折，结句“自开轩”闲适稳当而无延宕，整体平顺少奇。","_cost":0.04043},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.0,"rationale":"天台种蔬，闲趣具体、主脑分明而境浅；意象妥帖，“绿意喧”稍炼；语言通顺，炼字见巧未精；章法起承清而转弱；结以动作收，稳而稍直。楼顶种菜经验入诗，稍有出新。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.023230856},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.2,"章法":5.4,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.2,"rationale":"天台农趣切合当代生活，瓦缶成行具实景感。然“藏野趣”直说失之于露，“绿意喧”微显习套；转结平稳但波澜不足，收句怡适而余韵未宕，属平实顺畅之作。","_cost":0.00705375},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"天台种蔬有生活实感，题旨仍属闲适常境。青畦、瓦缶合成小园生趣，“喧”字稍见活力，“野趣”偏于点破。章法以铺陈为主，转折不足；结句“自开轩”与摘菜衔接稍松，余味有限。","_cost":0.04162},"grok-4.7":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.5,"rationale":"题旨止于田园自适,情事不具体,未出新境。“绿意喧”略见炼字,余多青畦、野趣等套语,景情未深交融。转结偏平,第三句仍罗列物象,结句直陈摘罢开轩,说尽而少延宕。无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":0.0219504},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.25,"rationale":"以城市天台种菜入诗，有当代生活气息，但只停在写闲趣，没有更深的发现。“绿意喧”近似前人“春意闹”，与“青畦”颜色重复。第三句未构成转折，结句“摘罢开轩”平淡直叙，余味有限。","_cost":0.016932},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"天台寸土与瓦缶成行，写出城市种菜的具体情趣；“绿意喧”稍见生动，但“青畦绿意”语意重复。末句转入采摘日常，收束平稳，余味略浅。","_cost":0.006164}},"consensus":56.7,"final":56.7},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|天台菜园|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"砌顶分畦入碧空，疏苗错落映霞红。晨昏抱瓮轻锄莠，雨足新蔬郁郁葱。晚摘青瓜堪饱腹，常邀野老共情通。闲观市井喧声远，此意悠然与境融。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.4,"章法":6.3,"余味":4.8,"警句":1.2,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"楼顶辟园切入日常，远市亲蔬之趣明确，取景清新而情旨较常见。中二联铺叙稍复，“共情通”“郁郁葱”略显硬凑；结句抽象说尽，不如以景留白。","_cost":0.004986},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.75,"rationale":"天台种菜属当代经验入诗，题材小有新意，然写法悉循田园旧套。'郁郁葱'截词生硬，'共情通''与境融'凑韵痕迹重，文白夹杂。中二联铺叙无开合层次，尾联说破悠然之意，无余味。抱瓮用典尚妥。","_cost":0.03413},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.0,"rationale":"天台种菜具时代气息，但语言偏白，“共情通”“与境融”流于直白干语。“野老”在城市天台略显突兀。结句完全说破，毫无留白，整体缺乏诗意锤炼。","_cost":0.02031},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.75,"rationale":"田园闲适题旨清楚而角度熟套，意象平实未交融成境。语言达意少锤炼，‘共情通’‘与境融’直白。章法顺叙少开合，结句说尽无余味。","_cost":0.01271},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"写天台种菜有生活气息，主题明确但角度常见；意象统一却多熟套，语言通顺少诗眼，'共情通''与境融'生硬；章法完整转折平直，结句说破余味不足。","_cost":0.00549912},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":36.5,"rationale":"天台菜园取材尚有当代生活气息，但立意仍落田园归隐套路。中二联对仗松散，'郁郁葱'截用成语凑韵，'共情通''与境融'生硬直说，缺乏诗眼。结句自道'悠然''境融'，说破无余。野老、霞红等套语密度偏高。","_cost":0.00310536},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.6,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"写天台种菜，生活细节可取，首联有空间色感；但词多熟套，“共情通”“与境融”直白生硬，结尾说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.010462},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.25,"rationale":"天台种菜题材稍具当代城市经验,归隐式主旨仍落熟套。意象敷贴而平常,情景交融不足。语言多处生硬:'砌顶'、'郁郁葱'截成语、'共情通'文白夹杂,'观喧声'视听失协。章法起承有序而转折平直,中二联少开合。结句'悠然与境融'直说心境,兜底无余味。","_cost":0.0154728},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.6,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.1,"章法":5.7,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.6,"rationale":"天台种菜具当代感但仍循田园常调，意象铺叙妥帖而陈，语言通顺乏诗眼，章法顺叙无转折，尾联直说与境融说尽无余味。","_cost":0.0098659},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.5,"rationale":"作品写天台种菜闲趣，题旨明确，语言平顺，脉络贯通；惟多传统田园熟套，未凸显天台特质，转折平直，结句说破意旨少余味，无警策新意，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"天台种菜以当代经验写田园旧题,起句'分畦入碧空'取象颇切,'抱瓮'用典自然;然中后幅渐趋平铺,'共情通''与境融'为凑韵而语意生硬,结句说破兜底,悠然之意尽出言表,余味索然。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.75,"rationale":"天台种菜取材有当代生活气息，首联“分畦入碧空”尚有画面；后文渐入平铺叙事，“郁郁葱”截词生硬，“共情通”“与境融”凑韵近于生造，“野老”与市井天台略不合。尾联直说悠然融境，全无留白。","_cost":0.0436},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"咏天台种菜，当代市井经验入诗，章法完整；然意象多承田园套语（抱瓮、野老、悠然），中二联开拓不足，结句直说心境，少留白。语言通顺而间有生硬。","_cost":0.024302128},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.75,"rationale":"脉络尚顺，但天台菜园套用“抱瓮”“野老”等古旧语汇，失却当代经验质感。“共情通”凑韵生硬，尾句“与境融”直白说破，炼字平乏且余味不足。","_cost":0.00434025},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"天台种蔬有城市田园意趣，题旨集中但开掘不深。苗蔬瓜实可感，碧空霞红稍套；“郁郁葱”“共情通”凑语感明显。劳作、会友、闲观层次尚清；结句直说意境交融，缺少留白。","_cost":0.03413},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.75,"rationale":"主脑是园居远喧，情事具体而角度常见，天台未出新境。首联取象较切，其后套语密，象可删而篇意不伤。堪饱腹、共情通弱，无诗眼。中二联并列，转结平。结句点明境融，说破无余味。","_cost":0.0344384},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.25,"rationale":"","_cost":0.01742},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.5,"rationale":"天台种菜有都市生活气息，起笔亦有空间感；劳作、收获、邀友依次铺开，转折较平。“郁郁葱”“共情通”生硬，结句直说悠然，余味偏薄。","_cost":0.010516}},"consensus":46.4,"final":46.4},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|云端相册|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"云端册展见星清，往昔欢颜似旧晴，岁月侵寻烟水过，留将记忆照深情。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.2,"意境":4.3,"语言":4.1,"章法":5.6,"余味":3.6,"警句":0.3,"出新":1.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.650000000000006,"rationale":"以云端相册寄怀往昔，题旨清楚且略具当代性，但情事泛化。星、晴、烟水意脉稍散；“册展”“照深情”欠自然。章法顺畅，结句直陈，余味较弱。","_cost":0.005394},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":33.0,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗题材当代,惜情感泛化无具体情事。'册展见星清'生硬费解,'岁月侵寻''烟水''深情'皆套语连缀。转句平直,结句将'记忆''深情'说破兜底,毫无留白,通篇干说少象,仅存题材之新。","_cost":0.02934},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":3.0,"意境":2.0,"语言":2.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":23.5,"rationale":"当代题材未有效入诗，通篇文白夹杂且空泛（记忆、深情）。用词生造凑韵（星清、旧晴），意象匮乏与情感脱节，结句口号化直白说破，毫无余味。","_cost":0.017134},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.5,"rationale":"云相册切入怀旧题旨清楚，情事空泛无具体人事。意象陈套（欢颜、烟水、深情）融合不紧，“见星清”费解。起承转合完整但转平。结句直说尽意无留白。当代物象仅点到为止。","_cost":0.01456},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":36.0,"rationale":"题材取云端相册略有当代新意，但情语泛泛；意象未与情意深融；语言平直少诗眼，“记忆照深情”显直白；章法完整而转结平；结句说破，余味弱；套语略多。","_cost":0.00476146},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.5,"rationale":"以云端相册入绝句是当代经验入诗的有益尝试,故给出新分。但立意仍落'岁月流迁、记忆留情'的常见窠臼,情志泛而不具体。意象偏少,'星清''烟水'与相册语境未融,通篇多陈述而少画面。'照深情'直说无余味,结句兜底。语言如'云端册展见星清'生硬欠炼。","_cost":0.00228236},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":5.2,"意境":4.3,"语言":4.6,"章法":5.4,"余味":3.6,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.050000000000004,"rationale":"云端入题稍有当代感，但岁月、烟水、记忆、深情等熟语偏多，意象虚泛，转结平直；结句说破，余味有限。","_cost":0.00807},"kimi-k3":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":34.0,"rationale":"题材取云端相册有当代意，但情事不具体；星清、旧晴、烟水、深情多为熟语串接，转结平直，结句说破，炼字生硬。","_cost":0.0136698},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":4.2,"意境":3.6,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.5,"rationale":"借“云端”立题而无新境发掘，意象以旧晴烟水等陈语拼凑，语言拗涩无诗眼，转结平直，末句直揭深情无留白。","_cost":0.00687225},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":34.5,"rationale":"此诗题旨明确但情志空泛无具体依托，“星清”意象突兀赘余，有熟套语，语言平顺略有凑泊，章法完整却平直泛化，结句直白说尽无余味，未凸显云端相册的当代特质。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.0,"rationale":"以'云端相册'入七绝，题材有当代新意，然处理泛化：欢颜、岁月、深情皆熟语，缺具体情事支撑。'星清''旧晴'取象含混，景与情未交融。结句'留将记忆照深情'直白说破，无留白。章法完整但转折平直，通篇稳而乏警策。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":3.5,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":31.75,"rationale":"题涉云端相册有当代经验，然仅为标签，未转化为具体情事。“星清”“旧晴”凑韵生硬，与相册意象不合；烟水、岁月侵寻皆套语。结句以“记忆”“深情”直陈，说破无余味，通篇泛叙。","_cost":0.04126},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.5,"rationale":"立意明确而角度常见，情志欠具体；意象杂凑，「星清」晦、「烟水」陈套；语言通顺，偶有「似旧晴」亮点；章法完整但转折平；结句直说深情，余味弱。无硬伤蹈袭，陈滥轻，警句稍欠。","_cost":0.027511732},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.2,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.65,"rationale":"虽尝试将现代云端相册入诗，起承转合结构清晰，但现代词与“烟水”等古典意象拼贴感强。起句造语略涩，结句直白说破，缺乏诗味与留白延宕。","_cost":0.0045585},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.0,"rationale":"云端相册入诗略新，怀旧主旨明确但缺少具体情事。“见星清”“似旧晴”语意牵强，烟水、深情等偏于熟套；章法完整而转折平直，结句直陈情意，留白不足。","_cost":0.03887},"grok-4.7":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":34.75,"rationale":"怀旧仅停留于通识，欢颜深情皆不落实。星清、旧晴、烟水不相生，册展生硬，结句说破。起承转合齐全，转处却是岁月常套。","_cost":0.0159024},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀旧，题材有当代感，但情感停在泛泛追忆，缺少具体人事。星清、旧晴、烟水三组意象彼此游离，没有形成统一氛围。第三句转得平直且落入套语，结句直说深情，说破无余味。","_cost":0.015944},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":32.5,"rationale":"“云端相册”引入当代物事，但“星清”与往昔欢颜关联不明；“烟水”“深情”等语较泛，转折平直，结句直言情意，余味偏少。","_cost":0.006244}},"consensus":39.12,"final":39.12},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"舷窗俯瞰万灯宵，地涌金波裂暗霄。细看衢街犹蚁聚，孤身此去意寥寥。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.6,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.7,"余味":4.1,"警句":1.3,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.599999999999994,"rationale":"俯瞰灯海转入羁旅孤情，主脉清楚，航空视角略有新意。次句较有光势；“万灯宵”“衢街犹蚁聚”稍欠精准，宵霄复沓，末句直说寥寥，余韵有限。","_cost":0.00642},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰引入当代经验,视角可取;\"地涌金波裂暗霄\"有气势,惟俯视之下言\"霄\"稍失位,且与首句\"宵\"同音近复。转句以蚁聚缩小人世尚妥,结句\"意寥寥\"直陈说尽,未能以景宕开,余味不足。整体题旨明确而收束平直。","_cost":0.04107},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰都市灯海生孤独感，角度常见。“地涌金波裂暗霄”气象可观，然俯瞰而言裂霄稍隔；“万灯宵”凑字，宵霄叠韵近复。三句蚁聚为熟喻，结句“意寥寥”直说情绪，说破无余味。","_cost":0.05139},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"引入夜航经验，前两句写景宏大，“裂暗霄”有张力，转句由宏入微。然结句“意寥寥”过于直白说破，毫无留白。整体章法完整，但情感落入“见繁华而叹孤身”的常见窠臼，语言稍平。","_cost":0.028334},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"夜航灯海对照孤寂，题旨清楚而旅愁角度常见。金波裂霄稍有气势，蚁聚、寥寥偏套。结句直说情志，余味薄。起承完整转承平直。机窗视角属当代经验入诗。","_cost":0.024886},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.2,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.2,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.9,"rationale":"前二句俯瞰灯海较有张力，“涌”“裂”见锻炼；转句由全景收至衢街，结句直说孤寂，略说破，余味不足。立意寻常，套语稍多，但无明显硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":0.0070619472},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰角度明确,起承转合完整:由俯瞰万灯到细察蚁聚,镜头由远及近,结句借蚁聚反衬孤身,章法较顺。'地涌金波裂暗霄'气象可观,然'万灯宵''意寥寥'近套语,结句直陈情绪、说尽无余,余味受限。属中平之作。","_cost":0.0034212},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.1,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.55,"rationale":"现代夜航视角有新鲜感，‘地涌金波’有势；但由景入情收束偏直，‘意寥寥’说破，余味不足；个别词稍生，结构尚完整。","_cost":0.009878},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰属当代经验入诗，角度可取，\"地涌金波\"有势；但\"裂暗霄\"夸张失理，\"蚁聚\"为陈喻，宵、霄同音韵脚相邻，转句仍写看而未真转，结句\"意寥寥\"直说兜底，客愁空泛无个人细节，余味遂薄。","_cost":0.026661},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.8,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"舷窗视角切入当代，宏阔金波与蚁聚微观对比衬孤身，章法起承转结贯通；惟立意归于寥寥近常见，万灯蚁聚略套，结句直抒少留白。","_cost":0.00759325},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"起承绘夜航灯海，‘涌’‘裂’见势；转以街衢蚁聚反衬，结句‘意寥寥’直白少余味。地涌金波稍有新警，然蚁聚、孤身之慨稍陈，情志未深。","_cost":0.022679802},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.8,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.35,"rationale":"此诗写夜航俯瞰灯海生羁旅孤愁，题旨明确，起承转合完整，“裂”字稍见炼字功力，但角度熟套，结句直露少余味，部分意象偏熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.8,"语言":4.8,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.6,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰切合现代生活体验，起承转合层次清晰。惜前两句句尾“宵”“霄”音义近重，且“裂暗霄”稍显板重；结句“意寥寥”直抒胸臆，说破无余味。","_cost":0.00507375},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.75,"rationale":"灯海繁盛反衬独行孤寂，主脑明确而情意泛化。“金波”有动势，“万灯宵”生硬，“衢街犹蚁聚”取譬欠切。由远及近再入情，层次完整；结句直陈寥落，套语收束，余味有限。舷窗俯瞰略具新意。","_cost":0.0345},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.0,"rationale":"夜航有焦点,然高处观蚁反衬孤寂,题旨常见,情只标「寥寥」。金波、蚁聚偏套,裂暗霄与下瞰不贴,无诗眼。章法完整,转结平直,结句说破,无警句。出新止于舷窗。","_cost":0.0321408},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰写入当代经验,次句“地涌金波裂暗霄”有气势。首句“万灯宵”生硬,宵、霄同音叠用。三句蚁聚喻常见,夜间“细看”略失真,转得平直。结句孤寂之情缺少铺垫,“意寥寥”空泛直露,余味不足。","_cost":0.017396},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"夜航灯海与孤身形成对照，脉络清楚；“地涌金波”有气势，但“万灯宵”稍显生硬，“衢街犹蚁聚”取象含混。末句直说寂寥，余味偏弱。","_cost":0.01028}},"consensus":55.12,"final":55.12},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"宵征万里俯星川，点点舷窗坠远天。大地棋盘铺碎烛，空浮云隙认江烟。机鸣微共孤光转，细数灯丛蚁阵连。忽觉此身成独客，回眸已度几重眠。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.1,"余味":5.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.300000000000004,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰与孤客之感相融，视角具当代性；棋盘、碎烛、蚁阵稍熟。前景后情脉络清楚，但转折略骤，“舷窗坠远天”“几重眠”语意含混，结句有留白而未能深远。","_cost":0.00614},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"当代夜航经验入诗有新意，'大地棋盘铺碎烛'取象可喜。然中二联皆写灯火，碎烛、孤光、灯丛意象重复，开合层次不足；'空浮云隙''机鸣微共'稍见凑泊。结句'几重眠'宕开有味但语意略晦。整体稳而未警。","_cost":0.04104},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"当代夜航经验有效入诗，中二联以“碎烛”“蚁阵”写俯瞰之景，取象精切有现代感，层次分明。惟尾联直白道破孤独，缺乏宕开的留白余味。","_cost":0.019178},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"夜航孤旅题旨明确而角度常见。碎烛、蚁阵、舷窗坠天能熔为俯瞰一境。机鸣孤光句滞涩。中二联同写灯火，开合不足。结句以几重眠收，略有余韵。","_cost":0.027484},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.3,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.15,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰取象真切，中二联有画面，尾联转入孤客感怀；但“舷窗坠远天”等词欠稳，转折稍平，结句略晦，意象略密。","_cost":0.008518048},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰属当代经验有效入诗，主脑在“孤客”之感，收束聚焦。中二联取象精切：碎烛棋盘喻城市灯火、云隙认江烟、灯丛蚁阵，皆贴切生动成统一氛围。颈联“机鸣微共孤光转”句法稍涩，“孤光”与“独客”意有重复。结句“几重眠”宕开有余味，但“忽觉此身成独客”稍直白说破。","_cost":0.00259096},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.8,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.4,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰角度新，棋盘碎烛、灯丛蚁阵有现代感，脉络清晰。惟“舷窗坠远天”稍涩，独客收意略直，余味未足。","_cost":0.009412},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰取当代经验入律,视角较新,俯瞰灯火的意象群尚统一,「大地棋盘铺碎烛」有画意。但「点点舷窗坠远天」事理不通(舱内人不见舷窗点点坠落),「机鸣微共孤光转」句法生硬,棋盘、碎烛、蚁阵喻象叠床架屋。结句「几重眠」欲留余味而语意含混,情感孤客之叹亦属常见。转结有气而炼字欠火候。","_cost":0.01621845},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"高空俯瞰以棋盘碎烛、蚁阵等象切景融情，中二联由远及近层次分明，当代机窗经验入律自然；然尾联直点独客，收束稍实余味略浅。","_cost":0.00665075},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"本诗写民航夜航俯瞰的羁旅感触，题旨明晰，脉络顺畅，语词稳当，融入当代乘机经验；但立意平熟，喻象偏旧，转合少跌宕，结句直白余韵弱，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"以旧体写夜航当代经验,取象颇新:'棋盘铺碎烛''灯丛蚁阵连'俯瞰视角精切,中二联开合有层次。惟首二句'俯星川'与'坠远天'意象略相犯,逻辑稍晦;'孤光'所指欠明。尾联直点'独客',情志稍露,'几重眠'收束尚稳而余味有限。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰入诗有当代经验，“棋盘铺碎烛”尚新切。但中二联皆写俯视灯火，碎烛与灯丛意象重叠，缺开合层次；“舷窗坠远天”“空浮”“微共”造语生硬。尾联“独客”直白，唯“几重眠”稍有余韵。","_cost":0.05596},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰入律，现代经验有效，中二联尚见层次；然意象有未融处，语言间硬凑，结句直说“独客”且“几重眠”晦涩，少余味。","_cost":0.03658954},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.6,"章法":6.8,"余味":6.2,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰之当代经验入诗，自然熨帖。“碎烛”、“蚁阵”摹高空夜景精准生动。脉络由宏入微、由外至内，条理清晰。结处由景转情略微说破，但以“几重眠”收束尚有余味。","_cost":0.005175},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.8,"意境":6.7,"语言":4.9,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.550000000000004,"rationale":"夜航视角较新，灯火缩微与孤客相映；棋盘、碎烛、蚁阵稍显杂叠，“机鸣微共”搭配牵强。由俯瞰转入孤独，脉络清楚但转意较熟；末句“几重眠”有延宕，亦略显虚缈。","_cost":0.05015},"grok-4.7":{"立意":4.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.2,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.65,"rationale":"夜航独客有场景而无新境，主脑偏晚。棋盘碎烛精切，余象常见且未融。空浮、微共、坠远天硬凑，视角微忤。中二联同写灯火，少开合。结句欲留白，眠意无铺垫。","_cost":0.0518592},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰属当代经验入诗，以星川、碎烛喻地面灯火有新意。但中二联反复写灯光，原地打转，层次不足。「舷窗坠远天」逻辑含混，「空浮」生硬。结句由景转情稍显突兀，「几重眠」留有余味，但「独客」偏常见。","_cost":0.016084},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰的视角有新意，灯火与孤独感有所呼应；“棋盘”“蚁阵”较熟，“舷窗坠远天”“几重眠”语意欠明，结句余味稍薄。","_cost":0.00816}},"consensus":61.62,"final":61.62},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"深宵对坐一屏寒，素脸微光话欲残，指按虚空温不寄，何时共剪烛花安。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.4,"余味":5.8,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":1.2,"score":72.35,"rationale":"以视频相对写咫尺天涯，“一屏寒”“温不寄”情景交融，转折有力。末句化用共剪西窗烛，照应团聚愿望，但“烛花安”稍涩，且直问说意，余味略减。","_cost":0.006816},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":1.5,"score":58.25,"rationale":"写视频通话之隔膜，当代经验入诗，'指按虚空温不寄'为全篇亮点，具体可感。然结句直接化用义山'共剪西窗烛'而添'安'字凑韵，气弱意露，以问说破，余味折损。前三句氛围统一，章法尚稳而转结不称。","_cost":0.03555},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":2.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"以视频通话入诗，一屏寒、指按虚空温不寄颇具当代实感，情事具体。惟'话欲残''温不寄'略生硬，'安'字为韵凑字；结句直接翻用李商隐'何当共剪西窗烛'，未能翻出新意，余味受损，蹈袭扣分。","_cost":0.04832},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.25,"rationale":"当代经验入诗极佳，用“一屏寒”“素脸微光”“指按虚空”精准捕捉视频通话的虚拟与冰冷，反衬相思之苦。前三句造语清新，转句尤痛切，唯结句化用李商隐稍显直白落套，略减余味。","_cost":0.016376},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.5,"rationale":"题写视频隔温，第三句意象较切，然立意常见，结句套义山直陈何时少余韵，炼字有亮点而章法平转。","_cost":0.039868},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":3.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"写视频相思，情感具体，“指按虚空温不寄”有当代体验，但结句明显化用李商隐“共剪西窗烛”，且“烛花安”凑韵，削弱余味；前三句氛围统一，转结平稳少警策。","_cost":0.007958346},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"视频通话入诗，当代经验落实为'一屏寒''指按虚空'，意象统一且情事具体。'指按虚空温不寄'炼字精警，触屏之温不可传，诗眼所在。结句化用义山'共剪西窗烛'，以问收束，以古愿衬今隔，余味未尽。转折稍平，'话欲残'到结句略急。","_cost":0.003156},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.4,"rationale":"写深夜视频，屏光与寒意统一，阻隔感具体；“指按虚空”细节新，结句化用共剪烛稍熟，略说破。","_cost":0.010008},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":1.5,"score":72.75,"rationale":"以视频通话写羁思,'指按虚空温不寄'为当代经验之真切发现,触而不达,最见新境;'一屏寒''素脸微光'意象精切统一。转结化用义山剪烛,用意可通然'烛花安'略生硬,结句依傍前人痕迹较重,余味稍减。整体情景交融,新题入旧体较为成功。","_cost":0.0101412},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.9,"余味":6.1,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.05,"rationale":"以屏寒烛暖翻新别情，寒暖光色对照成境，指按虚空句警策，转合分明；结句化用西窗烛直问，收束稳而留白稍浅。","_cost":0.01253625},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.25,"rationale":"写视频相思，‘温不寄’翻现代阻隔之新，象清冷次句弱；诗眼亮但结字凑；转句有力脉络清，结化李诗留问稍熟。转句警句，当代经验入诗，无硬伤蹈袭陈滥。","_cost":0.027318322},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"此作写深夜视频的异地相思，捕捉隔屏按触、温感难传的当代细节真切，脉络顺、语言准；唯结句用剪烛旧典稍直稍熟，余味欠悠长。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"当代经验入绝句，前三句以“一屏寒”、“指按虚空”极精准刻画视频的隔阂与温存，新巧可嘉。转句尤佳。惜结句骤返古人“剪烛”旧套，且末字涉凑韵，稍损余味。","_cost":0.004734},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"隔屏相对而温情难递，情境具体；“指按虚空”较有表现力。章法清楚，但“温不寄”稍涩，“烛花安”语意牵强；结句直诉团聚，余味有限。共剪烛意属化用，非整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.03643},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"第三句「指按虚空温不寄」精切有眼，冷屏、微光、残话成境，起承转完整。立意仍是常见相思，结句点明共剪烛花，用典显且说破，余味不足。视频经验入诗有效，无整句蹈袭与硬伤。","_cost":0.0267456},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"以视频通话写异地相思，当代经验入诗有效。“一屏寒”“指按虚空温不寄”真切见巧，为全篇亮点。结句化用义山“何当共剪西窗烛”，痕迹明显，“安”字凑韵，余味不足，转结略显平直。","_cost":0.015968},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.5,"rationale":"屏寒、微光与“温不寄”写出视频相见却不能相触的怅惘，转折自然。“指按虚空”尤见新意；结句借共剪烛花写团聚，意可会而“安”字稍显勉强，余味也较直白。","_cost":0.008166}},"consensus":70.61,"final":70.61},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|深夜视频|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"宵深半掩幕光幽，隔越山河见面愁，语滞时闻声断续，灯昏夜色满高楼，无端忽视频生涩，此际萤屏共泪流，倦把余温栖寂寞，空留一点照凝眸。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.3,"意境":6.1,"语言":4.6,"章法":5.8,"余味":6.4,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.5,"rationale":"深夜视频寄托远隔之愁，声断、屏涩等细节有当代实感，氛围统一。惟“隔越”“视频生涩”“余温栖寂寞”措辞生硬，中段复写愁泪，转折不足；末句以微光凝眸收束，尚有留白。","_cost":0.006392},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.75,"rationale":"当代视频通话经验入律有可取处，结句以萤屏微光照凝眸留白尚可。但语言粗糙，'无端忽视频生涩'硬凑拗口易生歧读，'愁''泪流''寂寞'直陈情语堆叠，中二联对仗松散、层次开合不足，整体炼字欠功。","_cost":0.03484},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":2.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":30.5,"rationale":"尝试当代生活场景入诗，题旨明确；但语言生造硬凑、文白夹杂严重（如'忽视频生涩'）。中二联缺乏开合层次且意象陈套，章法流于平直。结句'一点照凝眸'稍具画面感，勉强留有些许余味。","_cost":0.023516},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"视频通话入诗情事具体有主脑，然相思熟题新境有限；宵深山河高楼泪流等意象陈套密度偏高，萤屏稍可；语有硬凑，中联开合弱，结以一点光照眸尚留白。","_cost":0.023768},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"深夜视频细节如声断续、屏光共泪有实感，情感真切但角度常见。意象套语较多，中二联平行，颈联语句欠顺。结句一点微光略留余韵。","_cost":0.01610532},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.25,"rationale":"深夜视频通话写异地之情，当代经验入诗，题旨具体可感。但中二联均写屏前情态，层次未拉开；“无端忽”赘余，“视频生涩”文白夹杂，屏、夜意象重复堆叠；颔联对仗松散。结句“空留一点照凝眸”以象收束留白尚佳。","_cost":0.00333056},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.4,"语言":5.6,"章法":6.3,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.8,"rationale":"写深夜视频离思，情境真切，结句以屏光凝眸留白较好；但“见面愁”“泪流”偏直，“视频生涩”等词略硬，意象稍杂。","_cost":0.012926},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.0,"rationale":"深夜视频相思题新而情真，意象围绕屏光较统一；但'视频生涩''栖寂寞'等句生硬别扭，中二联松散无开合，脉络拖沓；结句'空留一点照凝眸'以光结情，稍有延宕，是全篇亮点。","_cost":0.0084828},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.8,"语言":3.8,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.05,"rationale":"题取深夜视频切近当代，但愁泪寂寞流于泛泛；意象多高楼泪眸陈套，少情景交融；视频生涩、栖寂寞等搭配生硬；章法平铺少转折，结句欲以景结而晦涩，余味不足。","_cost":0.00973125},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"此作写深夜异地视频的相思情境，脉络贯通、场景具体，但立意未拓新境，意象偏熟，语言偶有生硬直白，结句余味不足，融入当代视频经验但较生硬，无硬伤蹈袭，略有陈词。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"以隔屏相望写当代离愁，情事具体，'语滞时闻声断续'真切可感；但'灯昏''高楼''寂寞'等象偏熟，颈联'无端忽视频生涩'措辞生硬费解，中二联开合层次平直。结句'空留一点照凝眸'以景收束留有余味，整体达意而炼字欠精。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.0,"rationale":"深夜视频通话入诗题材尚新，惜情感直说：愁、泪流、寂寞层层点破，缺具体细节。语言硬凑，“无端忽视频生涩”“隔越山河见面愁”句法生硬，“灯昏夜色满高楼”近填充。中二联无开合层次，对仗松散。结句以屏幕余光收束稍有画面，但“空留”仍属说尽。","_cost":0.05066},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"以深夜视频写远别，声断屏涩、泪共余光等细节具当代经验，情真而聚焦。中二联稍平直，语言有硬处（“萤屏”当作“荧屏”、句法偶拗）。结句空留一点照凝眸，以景结情，余味悠长；间有灯昏凝眸等陈语。","_cost":0.033458286},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"将当代视频通话经验入诗，立意贴切，尾结微光余味较好。但中二联语意略显复沓，“忽视频生涩”句法文白夹杂，锤炼尚欠自然纯熟。","_cost":0.004224},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.25,"rationale":"隔屏相见而愁，题旨集中；断续传声有当代质感。“忽视频生涩”“把余温栖寂寞”句法牵强，中段推进偏弱。结以微光凝眸照应开篇，略有余味，泪流、寂寞等语较熟。","_cost":0.05371},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.25,"rationale":"写深夜视频相望，情事具体而发现平常。萤屏、断续声略能融情，但山河高楼寂寞皆套。视频生涩、栖寂寞生凑，中段与见面愁反复，结句有光而空留说破。无整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.015968},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":3.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.75,"rationale":"以视频通话写两地相思，当代经验入诗，有新意。但情感停在“愁”“泪流”的直陈，缺少具体细节。“隔越”“忽视频”拗涩生硬，“萤屏”应作“荧屏”。颔联与颈联都写信号卡顿，意思重复，原地打转。结句以屏光一点照凝眸收束，略有余味，但不够鲜明。","_cost":0.018724},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":3.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.25,"rationale":"隔屏相见写离愁，有当代生活感；声断续与视频生涩重复，转折不显。“无端忽”赘，“余温栖寂寞”搭配牵强。末句一点屏光稍有余味。","_cost":0.009082}},"consensus":54.41,"final":54.41},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"晨炊巷口启新堂，老弱相携饭菜香。小炒清蒸怜皓首，人间至味是分尝。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":5.9,"语言":5.4,"章法":6.7,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.45,"rationale":"社区养老入诗，题旨集中而有现实温度；炊烟、饭香可感，但取象较常。“小炒清蒸怜皓首”主谓牵强，结句有警策意，却直陈主旨，留白稍少。","_cost":0.00586},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"取当代社区食堂入诗有时代气息,题旨明确但情事泛写。'饭菜香'流于套语,取象常见未成氛围。转句'怜皓首'稍见用心,然结句直接议论说破,'人间至味是分尝'显系套改苏轼'人间至味是清欢',化用痕迹重且余味有限。","_cost":0.03543},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":37.25,"rationale":"题材取当代社区食堂,有现实感,但处理浮泛近于宣传口吻,情事不具体。取象常见,\"小炒清蒸\"与\"怜皓首\"拼合生硬。结句议论说破,套用\"人间至味是清欢\"句式,余味寡淡。","_cost":0.04},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.5,"rationale":"当代题材入诗，起承转合规整，描摹社区温情。然全篇偏于直白写实，意象缺乏深层熔铸，结句“人间至味”流于标语化说理且完全说破，缺乏余味。","_cost":0.014768},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"社区食堂写老人共餐，题旨明确有主脑，然角度常见正能量。意象妥帖如巷口饭香皓首，氛围普通。语言通顺结句点题过直近口号。章法起承完整转平。当代题材入诗略新。","_cost":0.02008},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":2.0,"score":59.0,"rationale":"题旨明确，以“分尝”收束有温情；意象偏常见，转结平直。结句化用苏轼痕迹明显，虽切题亦扣蹈袭分。","_cost":0.00831334},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"社区食堂为当代新题材，入诗有效，结句化'人间至味'翻出'分尝'，紧扣分餐共享，主脑清晰。意象具体但偏平实，'怜皓首'稍直露；'人间至味是分尝'脱胎'人间至味是清欢'，属化用而非生造，然近popular熟语，蹈袭酌减。章法完整，转句层次稍平。","_cost":0.0039304},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.6,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.6,"余味":4.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.599999999999994,"rationale":"题材有现实温度，食堂烟火与敬老之意清楚；但意象偏日常泛化，结句“人间至味”直白说破，余味不足，语言平稳少锤炼。","_cost":0.010132},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.0,"rationale":"取社区食堂新题，老弱相携、分尝至味，情真而意善；然角度近公益颂扬，结句化用“人间有味”而说破，留白不足。“皓首”“饭菜香”略熟，章法平稳少峭转。","_cost":0.0133952},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.6,"语言":5.8,"章法":5.7,"余味":4.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.85,"rationale":"社区食堂切入民生有温情，怜字见关切，但取象直白常见，转合平直，尾句以理收束说破少留白。","_cost":0.0079875},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"题材当代具体，然意象平实；'小炒清蒸'文白夹杂、句法稍硬。章法完整而转折平直，结句化用东坡，稳但直白。化古与当代经验入诗有新意，警句尚可，无硬伤蹈袭，微有陈语。","_cost":0.034151054},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"此诗咏社区食堂惠老场景，题旨明确，脉络平顺，语言质朴通顺，意象妥帖但偏平实，结句直白点旨少余韵，纳入当代民生题材但表达较常规，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.2,"意境":4.8,"语言":4.9,"章法":5.4,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.6,"rationale":"当代题材入诗，写市井温情，真挚通顺。唯诗笔平实偏于直叙，“怜”字略带俯视感。结句化东坡语直接说理收束，点题明快但兜底说破，余味欠缺。","_cost":0.00419025},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"关怀社区老人，主旨集中但角度常见；“相携”有温度，饭菜意象具体。“怜皓首”衔接稍硬，“分尝”略显凑措；第三句推进有限，结句套式议论，说尽情意，余味不足。","_cost":0.03825},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":3.0,"score":43.0,"rationale":"有主脑，社区食堂与老弱分食可感，然角度近公益口号。意象停于香、炒、蒸、皓首，未融成境。语言通而夹杂，三句硬接。起承平直，结句说尽，且套“人间至味是清欢”骨架，余味薄。","_cost":0.0187536},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":1.5,"score":44.75,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗有当代气息，情意温厚但角度常见。取象平实，“小炒清蒸”近乎罗列，“怜皓首”稍显生硬。第三句转折平直。结句套用“人间至味是清欢”句式，属说破式议论，余味有限。","_cost":0.0181},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"社区共餐的关怀具体，取材有当代性；但“饭菜香”等写法较泛，“小炒清蒸怜皓首”语意稍涩。结句点明分享之意，却说得太尽，余味不足。","_cost":0.00803}},"consensus":54.89,"final":54.89},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|社区食堂|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"老巷新开共食堂，蒸笼屉暖透幽香。银丝白发携孙坐，菜列如云任客尝。碗满微金宜晚岁，邻翁笑语话晨忙。闲来入座情偏洽，百味氤氲逐夜翔。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"weak"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.2,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.4,"余味":4.6,"警句":0.8,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.9,"rationale":"社区养老互助题材切近当下，蒸笼、祖孙、邻翁营造暖意；但主旨偏直，层次少变化。“银丝白发”重复，“微金”“逐夜翔”稍显硬凑，结句浮泛。","_cost":0.005162},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.0,"rationale":"取材当代社区食堂有时代感,惜写法近颂体,情事泛泛。'银丝白发'语义重复,'碗满微金''逐夜翔'生硬凑韵,'菜列如云'套熟。中二联平列场景无开合,尾句'百味翔'意象失据,收束脱节乏余味。","_cost":0.03271},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.25,"rationale":"题材贴近当代民生可取，但通篇铺陈场景，无主脑深意。“银丝白发”语义重叠，“菜列如云”“碗满微金”意象含混，“逐夜翔”为凑韵生造。中二联皆平面写景，无开合；尾联笼统作结，余味寡淡。","_cost":0.04428},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.75,"rationale":"题材具当代烟火气。但全诗偏于直白叙述，意象如“菜列如云”略夸饰，“银丝白发”语意重复。中二联平铺直叙乏变化。结句“情偏洽”直接说破。语言多处生造或干瘪（如“微金”“逐夜翔”），诗味不足。","_cost":0.026448},"grok-4.6":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.5,"rationale":"熟题社区温情，具体场景无新境。意象套叠如香云氤氲，交融一般。用语平，微金翔生硬。章法平铺无变。结句留味牵强。无警句，当代入诗略新，陈滥中，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.029966},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"题材有当代生活气息，老人用餐场景具体；但意象多常见，中二联平列少开合，'微金''逐夜翔'等语生硬，结句余味有限。","_cost":0.01050456},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.25,"rationale":"取社区食堂民生题材入律诗，角度可取但歌颂视角常见。中二联对仗松散，'菜列如云'与'银丝白发'失对，'碗满微金''逐夜翔'近于凑韵硬造。结联'情偏洽'说破直白，'百味氤氲逐夜翔'意象勉强，余味不足。整体完整但句句平推，缺乏层次与诗眼。","_cost":0.00327596},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.699999999999996,"rationale":"取材社区食堂，烟火气可感，主旨明确；但铺陈平直，意象偏常见，微金、逐夜翔稍生，结句余味较弱。","_cost":0.010202},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.0,"rationale":"取题较新、颂暖有焦点，老幼同桌具体可感；然“如云”“氤氲”等熟象偏多，“微金”“逐夜翔”生硬，晨夜时序略乱，结句欲以景结而词未达意。","_cost":0.023124},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.3,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.2,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.85,"rationale":"社区食堂切入当代养老烟火，情事具体不空泛；意象温馨但多常见语，语言通顺少诗眼，章法完整转合平直，尾句虚飘余韵淡。","_cost":0.00930325},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.0,"rationale":"题旨明确而角度常见，情止表层；意象妥帖但多陈套，炼字欠精（银丝白发、微金、逐夜翔）；中二联少开合，尾联直说情洽，结句景收而余味弱；当代食堂题材略出新，偶见蒸笼句。","_cost":0.035211489},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.75,"rationale":"此作咏社区新开食堂，题旨明确但视角平泛，意象偏熟偶有失准，语言平顺稍显凑泊，结构完整但转折平直，结句虚浮余韵不足，触及当代题材但发掘不深，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.95,"rationale":"现实题材入诗，烟火气足、老幼可亲。然炼字显生疏，“银丝白发”合掌，“微金”“逐夜翔”生造凑韵；尾联复述入座而章法稍滞，余味平淡。","_cost":0.00526425},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.5,"rationale":"社区共餐有现实感，携孙、饭廉切合助老温情，但开掘不深。“银丝白发”复沓，“微金”“逐夜翔”欠自然。章法完整而层次平直，结尾虽转景，却泛化飘浮，余味有限。","_cost":0.03851},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.0,"rationale":"题材当代而情志常见,主脑在食堂温情,携孙、微金尚具体,缺独到发现。蒸笼、白发可感,如云、氤氲为套。语言白直,情偏洽虚、翔字生硬,无诗眼。八句平铺,中二联无开合,结句说破后以香气宕开,余味不足。","_cost":0.024344},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.75,"rationale":"题材贴近当代民生，敬老温情可感，但停留在罗列场景，未有深入发现。中二联平铺，层次开合不足。“银丝白发”语义重复，“微金”费解，“逐夜翔”生造。晨与夜时间交错，脉络欠清。结句以氤氲香气收束，意在留韵，但用语浮泛，余味有限。","_cost":0.016832},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.25,"rationale":"社区共餐有生活气息，但情意多靠直说。银丝白发重复，碗满微金语意不明；末句以百味氤氲收束，未留下多少余味。","_cost":0.007642}},"consensus":49.31,"final":49.31},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"春街病柳挂瓶清，老树支针泣露晴，细管潜流苏朽骨，旁观自省独心惊。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.3,"意境":6.6,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.9,"余味":3.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"以树木输液触发自省，取材新鲜，细管、朽骨构成统一病愈意象。前两句语意重复，“挂瓶清”“支针泣露晴”稍显硬凑；结句直说心惊，自省所指空泛，余味不足。","_cost":0.006322},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"取材当代街树输液,题材出新可取,'细管潜流苏朽骨'稍有力度。然'挂瓶清''泣露晴'为凑韵而缀字,语意含混;结句'自省''心惊'直陈说破,省思内容空泛无着落,余味寡淡。前三句铺陈尚可,转结生硬。","_cost":0.03322},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":36.0,"rationale":"取城市给树打吊瓶入诗，具时代气息。然前三句铺陈“挂瓶”“支针”，缺乏诗化提炼，“苏朽骨”显夸饰；结句“旁观自省独心惊”强行拔高，空泛直白，将情意干瘪说尽，无留白余味。字词略带硬凑，意象未融。","_cost":0.01839},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"街树挂吊瓶入诗，由病柳输液落到自省，主脑清楚。意象贴切却未深融，‘泣露晴’稍拗。结句直说心惊，余味薄。题材有当代感。","_cost":0.013088},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"写城市给树输液，题材与角度较新，由物及己有省思。意象统一，但“泣露晴”“苏朽骨”等语稍硬。转结完整，结句点破心惊，余味略减。","_cost":0.01251536},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"以城市行道树输营养液入诗,取材当代、角度新颖,立意有主脑。'细管潜流苏朽骨'炼字见力。但'挂瓶清''泣露晴'有凑韵之嫌,结句'自省独心惊'直说破,情由景生而收束说尽,余味受限。","_cost":0.00299916},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.4,"章法":6.4,"余味":2.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.4,"rationale":"取材城市树木输液，颇有当代新意；“细管潜流苏朽骨”较见锤炼。然“挂瓶清”“支针”生硬，结句直说自省心惊，意尽少余味。","_cost":0.015576},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"取城市病树输液之当代新景,意象集中,'泣露''苏朽骨'见炼意;然前三句皆描景平行,转笔全托结句,结以'自省心惊'直抒抽象情,未明所省,余味受损。","_cost":0.0295431},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.2,"章法":5.6,"余味":3.8,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.15,"rationale":"以“树挂吊瓶”当代奇观入诗，视角新；前三句聚焦病树输液，意象集中但“泣露晴”拗造；由景转入“自省心惊”直露，缺乏宕开留白。","_cost":0.0116105},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"本诗取当代春街树挂吊瓶的日常场景入诗，立意有寄但落点稍虚，意象妥帖却交融不足，语言通顺偶有凑泊，章法完整但转合生硬，结句直白少余味，新物入诗尝试尚欠融炼。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"以街树输液入诗，当代经验翻新，由物及己有省思。但'挂瓶清''泣露晴'凑韵生硬，'朽骨'喻树欠切；三四句'潜流''自省'转折可而结句直说'心惊'说破无余，掩卷延宕不足。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"取材当代街树输液，角度新；病柳、支针、细管等象统一于医疗隐喻。但“挂瓶清”“泣露晴”凑韵生硬，前两句取象重复少推进，第三句仍属铺叙转折乏力，结句“自省心惊”直陈而所惊为何模糊，是含混而非留白。","_cost":0.05254},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.0,"rationale":"借街树输液之当代景象自省，立意有新鲜感而欠深；意象统一，“苏朽骨”炼字有力；转结平直，结句直白，语言偶生硬。","_cost":0.022725654},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.2,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.6,"rationale":"将当代树木滴灌入诗，体察入微具新意；转句状物尚工。病在炼字稍滞，“泣露晴”欠畅；结句直白道出“自省心惊”，说破无余，缺乏意境留白与回甘。","_cost":0.00608775},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.25,"rationale":"树木输液入诗有现实感，由病树转向自省，但所省未明。“挂瓶清”“泣露晴”搭配生硬；前两句内容复沓，第三句稍有推进，末句直陈心惊，缺少含蓄延宕。","_cost":0.03416},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.75,"rationale":"吊瓶入诗有当代新意，主脑在而自省未展开。前两句病柳老树、挂瓶支针近于重复，第三句略深却未成转，结句直说心惊，说尽无余。炼字多硬凑，细管一句尚可摘。","_cost":0.0134624},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.75,"rationale":"取街树输液这一当代景象入诗,角度有新意。前两句同写挂瓶,意思重叠。'泣露晴'搭配生硬,'支针'略显拗口,'苏朽骨'稍见锤炼。结句'自省''心惊'直接说出感受,却未点明所省为何,既显直白又失之空泛,余味不足。","_cost":0.017816},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.75,"rationale":"街树输液入诗，有当代生活气息；细管潜流一笔较生动。但“挂瓶清”“泣露晴”语意稍涩，结句直说自省与心惊，未将感触留给读者。","_cost":0.008032}},"consensus":56.52,"final":56.52},{"key":"qwen3.8-max|机场送别|七绝","writer":"qwen3.8-max","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"候馆灯寒送晚程，舷窗月白动风声。此身已在云千叠，孤翼横天入暮城。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.4,"意境":6.3,"语言":5.7,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.95,"rationale":"由候馆写至云天，空间推进清楚，寒灯、白月营造离情。题材与取象偏熟，送别对象及情事较虚；“舷窗动风声”稍涩，月夜与暮城时序略含混。结句以景收束，尚有余韵。","_cost":0.006706},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"以候馆、舷窗移植旧驿别意象于机场,当代经验入诗有可取;由地面别绪转入云中孤飞,脉络顺畅,结句以景收有画面感。惟情事泛写,'动风声'欠切,灯寒月白孤翼皆属熟套,情感未见具体独到之处。","_cost":0.04604},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"将现代航空送别经验有效入诗。前两句刻画候机凄冷，后两句转入想象中的凌空飞行，空间豁然开朗。结句以广阔暮城衬托客机远去，以景结情，余音袅袅，颇具现代人的孤寂感。","_cost":0.021768},"grok-4.6":{"立意":4.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"机场送别题下写登机远航，候馆借代略生硬，此身与送别视角冲突。意象清寒尚统一，孤翼横天稍炼。转结有而逻辑未密，结句略具画意。","_cost":0.023294},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"机场送别，视角由候馆跳至舷窗云层，转结以孤翼入暮城收束，有余味；立意较常见，“动风声”稍生硬，意象略熟，当代经验入诗可嘉。","_cost":0.013991472},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"机场送别以古调写当代经验，视角独特：不写送者写行人。第三句'此身已在云千叠'转出新境，结句以孤翼入暮城以景结情，收得空灵。候馆灯寒、舷窗月白意象精切交融，惟'送晚程'稍平，月白风声略见常语。","_cost":0.00282916},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.8,"rationale":"以候馆、舷窗、孤翼写现代别旅，清寒孤迥，起承转合顺畅，结以暮城留余。惜别情未深、语有小熟。","_cost":0.01268},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"以机场舷窗入七绝,题材新而取象统一,灯寒月白、云叠孤翼营造孤寂氛围较成功;转结由送别宕至飞行视角有变化,但'送'者与'此身'视角含混略伤逻辑;结句以景收,有余韵而未臻警拔。","_cost":0.0106692},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.8,"章法":5.2,"余味":6.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.3,"硬伤":1.2,"陈滥":0.7,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"空港题材以寒灯月白至孤翼暮城营造清寂旅愁，氛围尚贯；惜送者与行者主语游移，主脑不聚焦，动字亦欠妥。","_cost":0.0108749},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"这首机场送别以寒寂景衬泛化别愁，结构平顺少跌宕，语言稳当无疵，融入当代空港意象但未脱传统窠臼，结句以景收略有余韵，无硬伤蹈袭，缺警策新意。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.5,"rationale":"送别熟题，以机场入旧体有新意：候馆灯寒、舷窗月白营造清冷氛围，转句'此身在云千叠'宕开，结以'孤翼横天入暮城'以景结情，余味尚存。'候馆'用于机场稍隔，'动风声'略泛，整体意象妥帖而未至精警，情志偏于含蓄常见。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.0,"rationale":"题为送别，前句尚在候馆送人，三四句忽以“此身”入云、孤翼入城，视角由送者跳为行者，题意游离、逻辑龃龉。灯寒、月白、孤翼、暮城皆熟套，取象无独到处。结以景收尚有余味，惟全篇脉络不贯，立意平平。","_cost":0.05261},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"起承转合清晰，此身已在转得好，结句以景结情有孤寂余味；舷窗、孤翼等现代经验入古绝，稍有新意。然情志稍泛、角度常见，送晚程、动风声略平，意象稍显惯常。","_cost":0.03886544},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.9,"rationale":"现代航空送别入诗，当代经验转化自然。视界由候馆登机拔至云天暮城，层层递进。“孤翼横天”意象精拔，将飞行苍茫与离愁熔铸一体，结句留白悠远。","_cost":0.004218},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.5,"rationale":"送者行者视角错位主脑不明，灯月云暮拼贴少情融，动风声孤翼搭配生硬，转结断裂余味散。","_cost":0.01247105},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.2,"警句":0.8,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"送别情事未展开，孤旅意味较明。候馆、舷窗、云天递进自然；“动风声”语意稍牵强。航空物象略有新意，寒灯白月仍偏熟；结句以孤翼入城收束，留有空间余韵。","_cost":0.04143},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.6,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.4,"rationale":"题旨为夜航孤寂,场景清楚而人事不具体,立意常见。候馆灯寒与舷窗月白成境,后半云叠、孤翼、暮城偏熟。起承由地入空,第三句有转,结句入城且孤字点明,余味不足。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0256784},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"","_cost":0.020504},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"灯寒、月白烘出送别清寂，末句以孤翼远去留有余味；但意象多属常见，送别者忽称“此身已在云千叠”，视角转换稍显突兀。","_cost":0.007996}},"consensus":64.16,"final":64.16},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"霭色春街树映阳，烟垂碧柳露瓶光，枝间细管悬囊滴，点液无声养蕊香，忆昔儿时针痛苦，良医护木育新梁，生生共得东风意，莫道衰株不复长。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"weak"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.6,"语言":5.4,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.4,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.3,"rationale":"树木输液与儿时针痛相联，关怀生命，取材颇新。前景后忆脉络清楚；“育新梁”略显突兀，五六句偏直白，结句议论说尽，余韵不足。","_cost":0.006736},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"取材树挂吊瓶为当代经验入诗，题材有新意，颔联写输液细节尚具体。惜颈联忆儿时打针转折生硬、与树事勾连勉强；语言平实少炼，'蕊香''东风意'落套。结句以议论说破祝愿，余味不足。","_cost":0.03523},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":2.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.5,"rationale":"题材引入“树挂吊瓶”具时代感，但传统意象与现代事物拼接生硬。颈联“儿时针痛苦”极度散文化，语言直白缺乏锤炼。结句流于空泛说教，毫无留白与余味。整体结构平直，是一首缺乏诗意的图解之作。","_cost":0.022328},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.5,"rationale":"春街吊瓶场景具体，医喻有当代感，然颈联忆痛插入突兀，结句说破无余味；用语夹杂如“针痛苦”，意象未交融，东风衰株稍陈。","_cost":0.016866},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶起兴，联想儿时打针，立意尚可但表达直白；意象有拼凑，语言生造，章法平稳，结句议论稍尽。题材略有新意，传统意象略陈。","_cost":0.00757416},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"以城市行道树输营养液入诗,取材当代且找到儿时打针的共情点,立意有新境。颔联写景细致,颈联转忆有开合。但'儿时针痛苦'生硬拗口,'霭色''东风意'稍套,结句'莫道衰株不复长'直白说尽,余味收窄。","_cost":0.00319536},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"取象树挂吊瓶有当代新意，前联细描可见；但由物及医、忆儿时转得直白，尾句说破少余味，语言稍平。","_cost":0.009088},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.75,"rationale":"以街头树木输营养液入诗，题材新而当代表达有效，出新可取。前四旬取象具体，'细管悬囊''点液无声'颇见观察。然颈联'忆昔儿时针痛苦'句生硬凑泊，转忆突兀；'育新梁'喻意含混。尾联'莫道衰株不复长'直说兜底，余味尽失。","_cost":0.0147588},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.7,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.3,"章法":5.6,"余味":4.1,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.9,"rationale":"以树木吊瓶切入当代，视角新颖；然中后联由物及理较直白，语言夹白欠锤炼，意象纪实有余而交融不足，尾联说理收束无余味。","_cost":0.01205},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.0,"rationale":"作品写春街树输营养液的当代日常，题旨明确但角度平熟，意象写实欠浑融，语言平实少锤炼，颈联转笔生硬，结句直白兜底少余韵，平妥无硬伤，新意不足。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"以城市行道树挂吊瓶入诗，题材新颖有当代经验，主脑明确。'点液无声养蕊香'取象精切见巧思。但'忆昔儿时针痛苦''育新梁'等语直白近散文，且既言救活衰株又言育梁材微有抵牾；结句'莫道衰株不复长'直陈说破，议论收束乏留白。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"取城市树木输液为题，当代经验入诗有新意，颔联细管悬囊、点液养香写得具体。惟颈联忽转儿时针痛再跳至护木育梁，脉络生硬；尾联“东风意”“莫道衰株”直陈说尽，落入励志套语，余味寡淡。语言平顺少炼，“露瓶光”“育新梁”凑意。","_cost":0.0574},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"以街头树木挂吊瓶之当代经验入诗，由点滴联想到儿时针痛，构思新颖有焦点。然'针痛苦''护木'等语生硬，中二联转接稍突，结句直白说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.038156833},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.8,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.1,"rationale":"关注当代树木输液物象，具生活观察，立意尚暖。然炼字生硬粗疏，“针痛苦”等句文白夹杂；细节描写偏向说明，意象诗化不足；颈联由树及人转折突兀，尾联说理直白。","_cost":0.005661},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.75,"rationale":"树木输液入诗有新意，护生主旨明确；瓶光、细管具体可见，但情景融合不足。“针痛苦”“育新梁”措辞生硬，儿时回忆转入略突兀；结句劝说直露，余味不足。","_cost":0.04118},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"吊瓶新题可取,露瓶光与悬囊滴较切,前半由街及枝尚清。针痛跳至护木,新梁与蕊香、衰株不协;尾联把复苏说尽,余味薄。字句通顺而少锤炼。","_cost":0.032728},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.5,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶写当代街景,题材新。颔联写输液较具体,“点液无声养蕊香”稍见巧思。颈联由儿时打针跳到护木,衔接突兀,“针痛苦”生硬。首句霭色与映阳略有抵牾。尾联“莫道衰株不复长”说破题旨,落入常套,余味浅。","_cost":0.02006},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.75,"rationale":"春街树挂吊瓶，取景有新意；由树忆及儿时打针，转折稍突兀。“针痛苦”“育新梁”措辞欠自然，末句直陈树能复长，余味较少。","_cost":0.008076}},"consensus":52.16,"final":52.16},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"云仓夜扫万尘清，电海灯深彻暮明。败絮残篇皆拂去，惟留晓色照机声。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.4,"rationale":"以云端清理入诗，今意鲜明；夜灯、残篇、晓色、机声相互照应，去留对举推进有力。惟“彻暮明”“照机声”略显刻意，部分语汇稍熟。","_cost":0.006682},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"以清理云端数据入诗,题材新颖,当代经验有效转化。结句'惟留晓色照机声'以景收束,机声与晓色相映,有余味。惜'彻暮明'炼字生涩,'万尘''败絮'偏虚,第三句顺承少转折,气脉稍平。","_cost":0.0361},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"本诗将“云仓”等科技经验成功入诗，立意新颖。章法起承转合自然，“晓色照机声”化听觉入视觉，意境澄明，余味悠长。但“电海”“彻暮明”略显生硬，“败絮”句表达偏直白。整体是一首成功的现代题材佳作。","_cost":0.02201},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"云仓夜扫取材当代机房，题旨具体主脑尚清，翻新有限。电海晓色机声能成境。语言通达而照机声稍硬。转句仍承扫除，结构平直。结留机声有余味。题材出新，微有套语。","_cost":0.020494},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.0,"语言":2.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.75,"rationale":"现代云仓题材略有新意，但情感泛泛；电海、灯深、照机声等搭配生硬，意象不浑成；章法完整却转结平直，结句语病削弱余味。","_cost":0.01728012},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"以数据中心夜扫入诗，题材新颖，赋平凡劳作以澄明之境。'电海灯深'造语精切，结句以晓色照机声，视听通感，言尽意不尽。惟'彻暮明'稍显生硬，转折平直，炼字未至圆熟。","_cost":0.00240816},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫写当代机房清尘，题旨明确，晓色机声略有远韵。惟语多概括，电海、彻暮稍硬，第三句与首句意近，转折平直，新意可见而未完全融化。","_cost":0.013964},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"取当代云仓夜扫入诗,题旨集中且有新意;惜情志欠具体,仅是场景素描。第三句\"皆拂去\"与首句\"万尘清\"意复,转而未开,章法平直。\"电海\"\"彻暮明\"生硬,炼字未精;结句\"晓色照机声\"通感生姿,以景收束,稍有余味,为全篇亮点。","_cost":0.0242508},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.3,"章法":6.9,"余味":7.7,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.8,"rationale":"以夜扫云仓翻除旧题，当代数字经验切实入诗；电海灯深与晓色机声构成微光氛围，转结有序，末句以景结情有留白。","_cost":0.0090894},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.0,"rationale":"此诗写云仓夜扫场景，题旨明确，脉络平顺，'晓色照机声'以通感见巧，融入当代生产场景有新意，但意象适配略模糊，转折平直，结句偏实，余韵不足。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"以扫云仓喻数据清理，当代经验入诗自然，'惟留晓色照机声'通感收束有味。'电海灯深'造语新切。起承转合清晰，结句以景宕开不说破。惟中二句意象稍平，'败絮残篇'略见斧凿痕迹。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.25,"rationale":"以数据中心清理入诗有当代感，但“万尘清”“电海灯深”多属泛写，“彻暮明”与夜扫至晓时序含混，“败絮”喻数据牵强。结句“晓色照机声”以景收有余味，唯整体轻浮少凝练。","_cost":0.03857},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"现代云仓夜扫题材出新。结句‘晓色照机声’以景结、通感灵动，余味佳。然造语稍硬（电海、暮明），三四句清扫意略复，转弱；情志清浅，结构平平，故各维中平、结句独高。","_cost":0.035622477},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"将当代数字运维（数据清理）化入绝句，当代经验入诗较为自然。起承转合结构清晰，结句以晓色映机声收束，视听交融且余味延宕，炼字稍平但无生硬违和感。","_cost":0.00597},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.25,"rationale":"夜扫去芜，主旨明确而情事偏泛。云仓、机声略有新意，但“电海”“彻暮明”生涩，物象融合不足。首、三句意近，推进有限；结句声光相映，稍有余味。","_cost":0.04056},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.25,"rationale":"主脑在夜扫去芜、留晓与机声，情志明确而欠具体，角度近常套。电海、彻暮明含混，第三句复述首句，转弱结稍胜。结句有象外余响但惟留偏白。当代物象入诗未化透。","_cost":0.019848},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.75,"rationale":"以数据中心夜间清理入诗,题材新,但止于扫尘即清的表层比喻,未翻出深意。'电海''彻暮明'造语生硬。第三句复述首句'扫'意,转处无变。结句'晓色照机声'通感稍有余味,但略显牵强。","_cost":0.016188},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫入诗，有当代感；首、三句同写清除，转折偏弱。“彻暮明”“照机声”稍涩，晓色收尾尚有余韵。","_cost":0.008572}},"consensus":57.25,"final":57.25},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|云端相册|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"银河寸绪寄云天，百代光阴入镜年。往昔欢颜留醉色，今宵素魄带轻烟。开箱旧册都成梦，数据无声自永传。夜静披屏回故影，清辉满袖共长眠。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.3,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.7,"余味":6.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.6,"陈滥":1.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.14999999999999,"rationale":"以云端相册承载怀旧，古今媒介对照有新意。月夜、屏影氛围统一；“入镜年”“披屏”稍显硬涩，“永传”有失绝对。结构顺畅，结句含情但略近说尽。","_cost":0.006288},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"以'云端'双关切入当代经验,立意有新角度;旧册成梦对数据永传一联有开合。但'数据无声'文白夹杂,'欢颜''清辉''轻烟'落套,结句'共长眠'语义生歧、收束不稳,炼字整体欠精。","_cost":0.04091},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.0,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字时代记忆，题材有当代感，“云天”双关尚巧。但“寸绪”“入镜年”生硬，“数据无声自永传”直说无象；素魄轻烟、清辉成梦皆熟套。结句“共长眠”指向含混，略带不祥，余味未能宕开。","_cost":0.05423},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"本诗将“云端相册”等当代经验入诗，立意有新意。但古典意象与“数据”“披屏”等现代词汇融合生硬，文白夹杂。结句“长眠”常指死亡，用作入睡属严重词义误用，破坏了整体余味。","_cost":0.01798},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"云相册对照旧册成梦与数据永传，有当代感但发现寻常。月烟屏影与“数据”未融。炼字平，“寸绪”“镜年”生硬。中有对比转但平直。结“共长眠”稍尽。题材出新，月辉长眠略套。","_cost":0.02015},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"立意有当代感但略空泛；意象常见且虚实结合稍显割裂；语言通顺有“数据无声”亮点，但“寸绪”“披屏”生硬；章法平稳，中二联层次不足；结句以景收束但“共长眠”说破，余味中等。加分：题材出新、有佳句；减分：陈滥意象略多。","_cost":0.01496748},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"云端存照这一当代经验入诗，立意新而情事具体。'云'兼指云端与天云，妙化不隔。'数据无声自永传'与'清辉满袖共长眠'虚实相照，余味绵长。中二联开合有层次。惜'入镜年''披屏'稍显生造，'素魄轻烟'略熟，语言微逊于立意。","_cost":0.0046734},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.3,"意境":5.6,"语言":5.2,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.8,"陈滥":2.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.349999999999994,"rationale":"借云端相册写存忆，有当代感但情事偏泛；数据、旧册等意象有亮点，银河云天稍泛；“入镜年”“自永传”略硬；脉络完整，结以清辉长眠有余味。","_cost":0.01239},"kimi-k3":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.25,"rationale":"借云端相册写光阴记忆,数据永传与人事成梦的对照有立意苗头但未写透;新旧意象并置而未深融,素魄轻烟清辉偏熟;入镜年、醉色生硬,数据句近散;颔联往昔今宵对仗机械;结句共长眠意晦失重。当代题材入律之尝试可记,惜情泛炼粗。","_cost":0.027474},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.3,"章法":5.6,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.8,"rationale":"云端存照切今但情感泛化抽象，数据与烟辉意象拼贴少交融，语言文白夹杂乏诗眼，章法平直少转折，结句套语收尽无余味。","_cost":0.00940275},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":2.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.0,"rationale":"借云端相册写数据存忆，立意有当代性；然语言多生造（镜年、披屏），文白夹杂，意象陈套且氛围割裂，结句“共长眠”突兀说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.038837938},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":36.5,"rationale":"此作咏云端相册，题旨尚明但情感空泛，意象陈套且古今拼接生硬，有“长眠”误用、“镜年”生造等瑕疵，结构通顺却转折平直，结句直白少余味，仅略有当代题材尝试。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.2,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.4,"rationale":"尝试以数字经验入诗，但“数据”等词生硬未化，“披屏”造语欠妥。结句“共长眠”词义过重且涉误用；素魄、清辉等传统月象流于陈套，新旧意象未能浑融。","_cost":0.00714075},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"以云端存照写怀旧，旧册与数据对照略有新意；银河、素魄、轻烟偏熟，与题旨融合不足。“入镜年”“披屏”生硬，章法尚连贯，结句有清辉映衬，但“共长眠”落意突兀。","_cost":0.04079},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.5,"rationale":"主脑在夜览云存旧影，情事不具体。意象半融，素魄清辉套语密，数据破境。镜年寸绪生造，披屏略新。脉络完整，转直。结句有景而共长眠说满，词近死意。","_cost":0.0422},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字时代的怀旧,颈联纸册成梦与数据永传对照有新意。但所怀何人何事未落实。寸绪、镜年、披屏近于生造,数据句直白。颔联素魄轻烟与主题关联松散。结句以清辉收束尚可,但长眠多指死亡,语义歧出。","_cost":0.018712},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.25,"rationale":"借云端相册写怀旧，旧册与数据的对照切题，但情事较泛。“入镜年”“披屏”生硬，“自永传”失之绝对；末句有画面，却以“长眠”收得过实。","_cost":0.008148}},"consensus":49.6,"final":49.6},{"key":"muse-spark-1.2|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.2","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"云仓烛破夜灯清，尺地无尘待扫声。械臂巡行驱积垢，光眸洞察映流明。人携暮色推车往，雾敛星芒共月程。净域重归纤屑尽，晨来万货发晶晴。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.4,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":7.1,"余味":4.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.8,"陈滥":0.7,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.4,"rationale":"以智能云仓夜扫入诗，题材新且由夜至晨脉络清楚。械臂、光眸颇具现场感；但“待扫声”“共月程”“发晶晴”语意牵强，末句直露且炼字生硬。","_cost":0.004838},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.75,"rationale":"以智能云仓夜间清扫入诗题材新颖,然多干说少交融。'光眸洞察映流明''发晶晴'生造硬凑,'流明'夹带术语失谐。中二联对仗大意平铺,转折平直;结句'纤屑尽''发晶晴'说破兜底,余味寡淡。新题可嘉而炼字失度。","_cost":0.02596},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"本诗将现代云仓与机械作业入诗，立意具时代感且章法完整。但语言生造痕迹重，“流明”“发晶晴”等词显突兀，且“云仓点烛”不合常理。结句平直说破，缺乏诗意留白。","_cost":0.017622},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.0,"rationale":"仓储夜扫入律，角度略新而情志平实少主脑。工古意象杂糅未融，械臂流明稍硬。人携暮色一联稍活。转结说尽清洁发货，余味薄。无尘待扫略矛盾。","_cost":0.01494},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"现代仓储题材新颖，章法完整，人机对比有层次。意象统一但常语稍多，语言偶生造如“烛破”“晶晴”，结句说破少余味。颈联稍佳，可摘句。","_cost":0.00759},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.0,"rationale":"题材取自动化云仓夜扫，当代经验入诗有新意，但情感仅止于颂扬式描述，缺个人情志灌注。意象机械与月星并置尚成氛围，然语言多硬凑：'烛破夜灯'语义重复，'发晶晴'为凑韵生造，'洞察映流明'生硬。章法起承中二联分工尚可，结句直说其事、言尽意尽，余味不足。","_cost":0.00251316},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"题写云仓夜扫，立意较新而主旨明确；机械、光眸等当代意象有探索，但与星月旧语未全浑融；语言有炼意，局部生硬；章法完整，结句偏说尽。","_cost":0.01275},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.75,"rationale":"题材新而情味薄，夜扫—晨发脉络完整；械臂光眸有亮点，然烛破、流明、晶晴生造，人机与星月转接硬，结句说尽且涩。","_cost":0.0249942},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.8,"意境":4.2,"语言":3.2,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.6,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":1.2,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"云仓机扫具当代性但仅功能铺陈无主脑，室内外意象割裂，械臂光眸发晶晴等生造拗口，章法平铺直进，结句直陈说尽无余味。","_cost":0.00844775},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"此作写当代云仓夜扫备发场景，题旨明确、脉络贯通，有新事物入诗尝试，但新旧意象熔铸欠圆，部分字词生硬、有逻辑微瑕，结句直白，少余味警策。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.8,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"以智能仓储入律，题材新，夜扫待晨发的焦点明确。颈联人机与星月相接为佳。但'发晶晴''映流明'生造费解，'烛破'与灯明相碍；中二联铺排近于说明，结句意尽于言，余味平平。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.75,"rationale":"取材云仓夜扫，题材新而情志浅，多在铺陈流程。“无尘待扫”自相矛盾，“烛破”“流明”“晶晴”生造硬凑，颈联雾星月程与仓内场景脱节。结句直陈万货晨发，说尽无余味。","_cost":0.04373},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.6,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.85,"rationale":"题材当代，中二联械臂与星月对照有层次；然‘无尘’与‘积垢’矛盾，结句直白，语多生硬（如‘晶晴’），余味不足。","_cost":0.029565899},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.3,"章法":6.6,"余味":5.4,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.7,"rationale":"智能云仓题材切入当代生活，章法由夜扫至晨发清晰顺畅。然“烛破”“光眸”等语古今杂糅微带生硬，科技意象尚未彻底诗化，结句直叙略欠余韵。","_cost":0.00569025},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.0,"rationale":"夜扫至晨起脉络清楚，云仓题材有新意，但情志较薄。械臂、光眸切题，星月雾色偏于装饰；“无尘待扫”语意含混，“发晶晴”生硬。中段推进平直，结句刻意求明亮，余韵不足。","_cost":0.06114},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.0,"rationale":"写云仓夜扫以待晨发，题旨明而情止于颂洁颂发，无更深发现。械臂、推车尚切，星月雾与仓夜两截，流明、晶晴生造。时序完整，第六句断脉，转平。结句说尽，余味薄。仅无尘待扫略巧，题材新而未化开。","_cost":0.0215536},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":2.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":33.25,"rationale":"写智能仓储夜间清扫,题材新,但止于描述流程,缺少情志焦点。首联'无尘'与颔联'驱积垢'自相矛盾。'光眸洞察映流明''发晶晴'属生造硬凑。颈联室内外场景游离。尾联'纤屑尽'说尽,余味浅。","_cost":0.015772},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.0,"rationale":"夜扫云仓有当代题材，机器与人相继入画，脉络尚清；但“无尘待扫”前后抵牾，“发晶晴”生硬。结句直陈洁净，余味较浅。","_cost":0.008088}},"consensus":50.7,"final":50.7},{"key":"doubao-seed-2.1|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"doubao-seed-2.1","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"瓦畔分畦占一隅，牵藤接叶缀珍珠。闲来袖底沾云气，静撷青菘到晚厨。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.39999999999999,"rationale":"屋顶隙地、藤蔓菜蔬与晚厨相联，日常情趣具体，主线清晰。“袖底沾云气”点出高处环境，颇有灵气；珍珠之喻稍熟，结句落实生活而余韵略浅。","_cost":0.00473},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"以当代天台种菜入诗,题材有生活气,'袖底沾云气'切天台之高,是全篇亮点。但'缀珍珠'指涉含混近套语,结句'到晚厨'收得稳而稍直,言尽意随尽,余味不足。章法完整,转句有变化,整体属中上闲适小品,未出新境。","_cost":0.03753},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"立意取天台种菜之趣，具当代生活气息。三四句将‘袖底云气’之高远与‘撷菘晚厨’之烟火气巧妙融合，转合自然。唯‘缀珍珠’之喻稍落俗套。整体语言清朗，生动展现了隐于市的闲适情怀。","_cost":0.017196},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.0,"rationale":"田园闲适熟题，天台一隅稍具体仍无新境。畦藤云气与青菘可成小境，珍珠稍套。沾云气略见炼字，余平实。转势弱，结句入厨说尽少留白。","_cost":0.012224},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"天台种菜题材有当代生活气息，闲适情志具体可感，但立意未翻新。意象妥帖统一，沾云气句见诗眼。结构完整转平，结句直白少余味。","_cost":0.00761244},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"城市天台种菜是当代经验有效入诗，立意清新但情志仍属闲适常调。意象精切统一：分畦、牵藤、珍珠、云气、青菘皆扣题，袖底沾云气暗写天台之高，是全篇诗眼。章法起承转合完整，结句撷菘入厨平实有余、宕开不足，余味稍直。缀珍珠略熟。","_cost":0.00260896},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.9,"rationale":"写天台屋角菜园小景，起承清晰，转以云气增逸，结归晚厨，生活气与清雅兼具；意象统一而稍常见，语言自然有亮点，余味略直。","_cost":0.00931},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"天台种菜入诗,题材贴近当代生活而有新意;象统一,'袖底沾云气'情景交融为全篇亮点;转句得法。惜'缀珍珠'喻稍熟,'到晚厨'略生硬,结句以日常直收,说尽而余韵不足。","_cost":0.0132432},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.2,"章法":5.8,"余味":4.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.55,"rationale":"天台菜园切近当代都市生活，题旨明确但开掘不深；意象工稳而流于常见，云气一语稍虚；章法完整而转结平直，收束直白少余味。","_cost":0.00796265},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"此诗写天台种菜的闲居小趣，题旨明确，意象清和妥帖，语言顺畅有小亮点，起承转合完整但转折偏平，结句平实少余韵，无硬伤蹈袭，唯“缀珍珠”之喻稍熟。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"城市瓦畔种菜，以古典笔调写当代生活经验，题旨明确但属常见闲适题材。'袖底沾云气'取象轻灵有诗味，'缀珍珠'稍熟。章法顺承而下，第三句微转不奇，结句落到晚厨收束稳当，以事结情略有留白但延宕有限。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.5,"rationale":"以七绝写都市天台种菜，题材有当代气息；“袖底沾云气”借楼高接云，暗合隐逸意，是全篇亮点。然“缀珍珠”泛而不切，起承转合平顺无变化，结句“到晚厨”实叙收尾，说尽无留白，余味不足。","_cost":0.0517},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"写天台种菜，意旨明确、语言精炼，'沾'字灵动；惟珍珠、云气意象略熟，章法平稳，结句收束稳实而余味稍浅。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.027073226},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.2,"rationale":"将当代都市天台种菜之趣自然入诗。转结由天台高处的闲适拉回暮厨烟火，章法顺畅，情致恬淡。“缀珍珠”略呈陈套，结句重在纪实，余韵中规中矩。","_cost":0.004908},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":4.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.75,"rationale":"天台种菜稍具生活实感，然闲静之情常见无深化；藤叶缀珠可观，袖沾云气以大饰小；起承转结完整而结句直落晚厨无留白。","_cost":0.01230855},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.60000000000001,"rationale":"以天台种菜写闲适，题旨集中而发现不深。云气与晚厨相接，清逸中有烟火气；“缀珍珠”稍泛，“闲”“静”略直露。由园景转采撷，层次清楚；结句落在日常，温厚但延宕有限。","_cost":0.04175},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"全诗主脑是山中小畦闲摘入厨,情事可感而立意常见。云气、青菘、晚厨略能交融,珍珠与闲来偏熟套。字面通顺,沾、撷尚可,未见强诗眼。起承平直,第三句轻转,结句交代到厨,收住而少余味。","_cost":0.0209552},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"以天台菜园写都市闲趣，当代题材入诗，但立意止于闲适，角度常见。'袖底沾云气'切合天台之高，是全篇亮点。'缀珍珠'稍落俗套。转句有提升，结句平实温馨，余味有限。","_cost":0.0157},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"屋顶菜畦接云气与晚厨，日常情趣具体可感；由种植写到采撷，脉络清楚，但转折较平。‘袖底沾云气’有亮色，‘缀珍珠’稍显惯常；结句亲切，余味略短。","_cost":0.00612}},"consensus":65.4,"final":65.4},{"key":"doubao-seed-2.1|天台菜园|七律","writer":"doubao-seed-2.1","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"十丈层台接野隅，分来蔬甲绿成株。藤牵竹架风梳叶，瓮灌春畦露湿壶。摘翠阑边堪佐酒，供鲜厨下胜烹鲈。休言城郭无闲地，一片云天兴不孤。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.2,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.44999999999999,"rationale":"屋台种菜切入城市生活，情景具体，中二联由栽培转饮食，层次清楚。“风梳叶”颇生动；“露湿壶”关系含混，结句点旨稍直，“兴不孤”略泛。","_cost":0.0071},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"天台种菜取材当代都市生活,题旨明确有生活气。颔联'风梳叶''露湿壶'细节可感,颈联转入佐酒供鲜稍落俗套,'胜烹鲈'用典尚妥。尾联翻'城郭无闲地'收束点题,'兴不孤'略显直陈,余味中平。整体稳顺而少警拔之句。","_cost":0.0342},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"天台种菜之当代经验入诗，生活气息浓厚。中二联刻画细致对仗工稳，'风梳叶'颇具动感。然'露湿壶'略显凑泊，结句'休言…兴不孤'直白说尽，缺乏余韵。整体章法严密，流畅自然。","_cost":0.020908},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"城居种菜题旨清楚、情事具体，然熟题新境不足。意象妥帖而常见；风梳叶略见炼字。章法完整转折平直，尾联说破题旨，余味有限。天台入诗稍出新，套语密度中等。","_cost":0.016602},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.4,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.1,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.2,"警句":1.2,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"写城市楼顶种菜，情事具体，立意略有新意但不够深。中二联意象统一而偏传统，语言工稳，“风梳叶”稍见炼字。尾联以议论收束，略直，余味中等。题材略见当代生活气息，无硬伤与蹈袭，传统田园意象略多。","_cost":0.02026765},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"城市屋顶种菜是当代经验有效入诗，题旨具体有主脑。中二联'藤牵竹架风梳叶'等取象精切、动静相生，对仗见锤炼。尾联由景入议收束稳当，然结句'兴不孤'近于说破，余味稍直。整体意象统一，惟'佐酒''烹鲈'稍熟。","_cost":0.00272856},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.8,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.45,"rationale":"天台菜园题旨清晰，有城市田园之趣；颔颈写劳作与鲜食，画面连贯。意象较妥而偏熟，尾联说理稍直，余味不足；‘露湿壶’等语略生。整体平稳，少警句。","_cost":0.012768},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"以城郭天台种菜入律，题新而主脑集中，种、长、收、感层层推进，章法稳密。'风梳叶''摘翠佐酒'炼字见功，'胜烹鲈'暗用莼鲈而不露。尾联以云天宕开，惟'兴不孤'稍涉直说，余韵略欠。","_cost":0.0145218},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.7,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.4,"余味":4.6,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"天台种菜具当代城市田园意，题旨明确但翻新有限；意象切实而罗列感强；语言通顺少诗眼；章法完整而转折平直；尾联议论直露，余味不足。","_cost":0.0101545},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.2,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.4,"rationale":"此律写天台种菜的闲居之趣，章法平顺，语言清通，意象贴合日常，但多熟语熟象，结句直露，整体平稳无硬伤，唯新意、余味稍欠。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"以天台种菜入七律，将田园旧题落到城居新境，主脑明确，尾联'休言城郭无闲地'翻转有力，收得住。中二联对仗工稳、物象具体，然藤架灌畦仍属常见田园语汇；'堪佐酒''胜烹鲈'稍熟，炼字亮点有限。结句以景与议论相融，兴味有余而言意略尽。当代经验入诗有效，无明显硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"题材当代、尾联点出城中闲地之趣，立意尚可；中二联写景写用皆妥帖但流于常套，佐酒、烹鲈落入陈言，'接野隅''露湿壶'略欠稳实；结句直说兴致，余味有限。","_cost":0.04567},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"天台种菜写入七律，起承转合完整，颔联‘风梳叶’见炼字，都市闲地之意颇新；然尾联直白，‘兴不孤’稍滞，意象妥帖而常见，故章法最佳、余味偏弱。","_cost":0.02849964},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.7,"rationale":"切入天台种菜的当代生活经验，意趣真切。中二联对仗工稳，兼写劳作与收成，脉络层次井然。尾联翻出高楼闲趣，点题开阔。词句偶见佐酒烹鲈之熟套，结处微露直白，然通篇晓畅自然。","_cost":0.00537825},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"天台种菜切当代经验，有主脑但囿于口腹自足；意象罗列少交融；风梳稍亮而露湿壶涩；脉络贯通但转平；尾联直言兴不孤，说破少留白。","_cost":0.0172238},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"城中种蔬有实景实趣，从栽植、采食转入闲兴，层次清楚。“风梳叶”较灵动，“绿成株”欠自然，“露湿壶”与灌畦衔接稍弱。结句虽有云天拓境，仍以“兴不孤”直陈情意，余味有限。","_cost":0.0503},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"屋顶种菜题旨明白、事相具体，但情志仅止于不孤，角度常见。风梳叶有生气，露湿壶别扭，摘翠供鲜少锤炼。前半平铺，颈联两句一事，尾联休言说尽。园事略新，云天鲈酒仍套。","_cost":0.0281488},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.75,"rationale":"以都市天台种菜入诗,题材有当代气息,但立意仍落在闲适自足的常见路数。颔联风梳叶尚可,露湿壶略凑。颈联化用莼鲈典,较为妥帖。首句接野隅与城中天台略有龃龉。尾联点题直白,一片云天稍有开宕。","_cost":0.018388},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"天台种菜入诗，取材有生活气息；藤、架、春畦相映成趣。中二联由种而食，脉络清楚，但“绿成株”“露湿壶”稍欠自然，结句直言其兴，余味略短。","_cost":0.00826}},"consensus":64.39,"final":64.39},{"key":"doubao-seed-2.1|机场送别|七绝","writer":"doubao-seed-2.1","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"执手栏边风猎袂，银机待发响如雷。玻璃隔了声难达，独看行人屡顾回。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.6,"rationale":"机场玻璃阻声与频频回望写出送别的具体情境，四句推进清楚，结句有画面与余情。“银机”“响如雷”稍显硬熟，“行人”指称略泛。","_cost":0.005756},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"熟题而有当代细节,玻璃隔音、隔窗顾回颇具现场感,转句最见新意。惟'响如雷'笔力浮泛,'隔了'文白夹杂,炼字欠精。章法完整,结句以人物动作收束留有余味但稍直。'执手'化用无痕,不算蹈袭。","_cost":0.03398},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"当代机场送别有效入诗，“响如雷”与“声难达”的声学反差构思巧妙，起承转合自然。然“玻璃隔了”等流于白话，与首句文白夹杂，语言欠锤炼，结句直白。","_cost":0.023756},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.0,"rationale":"送别主脑清楚，玻璃隔声有现场感；意象可通但「如雷」「顾回」熟套。炼字仅「猎」可看，「隔了」偏口语。转合尚顺，结句点破回望，余韵不足。","_cost":0.024118},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"机场送别取玻璃隔声之当代细节，情事具体，意象统一；转结留白有余味。语言通顺偶有散句。","_cost":0.012658888},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"以绝句写机场送别，当代经验入诗自然，主脑清晰。执手、隔玻璃、屡顾回层层递进，转结有势，结句以人影回望收束，留白得当。'响如雷'喻陈熟，'屡顾回'为趁韵倒装略生硬，'银机'炼字欠精。","_cost":0.00293776},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.7,"rationale":"机场送别有现代细节，隔玻璃相望见情；但“响如雷”等语略陈，结句偏直，余味未足。","_cost":0.009002},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"以玻璃隔音写送别之隔阂，当代经验入诗自然，末句屡顾回首收得有韵。但'响如雷'直白，'隔了'口语入律句生硬，文白略杂，整体意象尚欠精警。","_cost":0.0078828},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.3,"余味":7.6,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.55,"rationale":"以玻璃隔音翻新送别常题，由执手风喧转入无声凝望，焦点收束；屡顾回以景结情有余味。惜响如雷套语，隔了等白直失炼。","_cost":0.0090444},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"此作写当代机场送别，细节真切，起承转合顺畅，情感真挚，融入当代经验；但表达偏平直，炼字无特出，结句偏实余味不足，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"当代经验入旧体：玻璃隔声难达一句以物理隔绝暗喻离人心境，取象精切，为全篇诗眼。起承铺垫有声势，结句'屡顾回'以动作收束、留白得当。惟'执手''风猎袂'稍涉熟套，语言通顺但炼字平平，整体情真而未至深婉。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"机场送别为熟题今写，玻璃相隔声难达一转有当代真实感，结句以屡顾回收束尚有余味。然“执手”“风猎袂”袭古套语，机场栏边猎袂亦欠贴切；“隔了”口语与“顾回”倒装凑韵，炼字见斧凿。章法平直完整。","_cost":0.05045},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"写机场送别，玻璃隔音、银机轰鸣的当代经验入诗；结句‘独看行人屡顾回’以细节收束，余味悠长。然‘隔了’文白夹杂，三句略直白，锤炼未精。","_cost":0.026924832},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"将当代机场送别经验入诗，情真质朴，章法脉络清晰。惟炼字平直散漫，“玻璃隔了”近乎口语，意象营造偏于实录，结句传神但稍欠诗味沉潜。","_cost":0.0038265},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"借玻璃隔音写今式送别，情事具体但开掘不深；银机隔顾有今意，响如雷则旧；隔了语白失炼；起承转合分明；末以屡顾回结，稳而显直。","_cost":0.01139975},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"由执手转至隔窗凝望，脉络清楚，玻璃阻声有现场感；尾句以回顾留情，但“屡顾回”语意复沓，“响如雷”较熟，整体仍是传统惜别情绪的场景移置。","_cost":0.03448},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"机场送别为熟题,玻璃隔声对机声略见新意,主脑清楚而无深境。意象能成喧寂对照,但执手、如雷、回望套语密。隔了夹白话,锤炼不足。起承转合全而转直。结句回望说得太明,余味短。","_cost":0.0406944},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.25,"rationale":"以玻璃隔声写当代送别，有真切体验。首句风猎袂与候机楼内场景略有龃龉，次句响如雷粗直。隔了稍嫌口语。结句屡顾回以动作收束，留有余情，但角度常见。","_cost":0.01654},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"执手、隔窗、回望层层推进，送别之情具体可感；“响如雷”较熟，“顾回”语义重复。结句收得稳，却未留下更多回味。","_cost":0.007946}},"consensus":65.78,"final":65.78},{"key":"doubao-seed-2.1|机场送别|七律","writer":"doubao-seed-2.1","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"执手廊前别思催，舷窗影逐旅云开。千程铁翼摩霄去，一袖霜痕拂面来。往事萦怀伤聚散，航牌过眼费徘徊。机声渐共烟光远，唯见寒风掠鬓回。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.6,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.4,"章法":6.3,"余味":6.7,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.4,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.4,"rationale":"机场送别主线清楚，铁翼、航牌具当代性，寒风收结尚有余韵；但聚散伤怀较熟，霜痕、烟光等偏套，“费徘徊”“掠鬓回”稍显含混生硬。","_cost":0.006266},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"送别熟题,情事泛写无具体对象,'伤聚散''费徘徊'近凑句。舷窗、航牌、铁翼将当代经验入诗略见新意,颔联对仗尚工。章法完整,结句以机声烟光、寒风掠鬓收束,以景结情有余味,但'别思催'等套语稀释感染力。","_cost":0.03843},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.0,"rationale":"本诗将现代机场场景（舷窗、铁翼、航牌）有效入律，立意明确，结句以景结情，颇具余味。然颈联“往事”句落入陈词俗套，语言偶显生硬，中二联叙事时空略显散漫，整体结构平顺而乏波澜。","_cost":0.019372},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"熟题机场送别，情真而境不新。意象杂糅尚融，霜痕费解。语言通达少炼，套语如伤聚散。中联层次平，航牌置于机去后略悖时序。结句以风掠鬓收，略有余韵。当代器物入诗可称出新。","_cost":0.024266},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"立意平常但情事具体；铁翼、航牌等现代意象融入较自然，章法开合有序，尾联以景结情有余味。惟颈联直露，'伤聚散'等语偏套，语言偶有熟滑。整体中上。","_cost":0.010538},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"机场送别为熟题，角度常见但情事具体。'铁翼''航牌'以古语纳今物颇见巧思，'千程铁翼摩霄去，一袖霜痕拂面来'一联开合有致堪摘。颈联'往事萦怀伤聚散'流于套话，'费徘徊'稍显凑韵。尾联以景结情，机声烟光渐远、寒风掠鬓，留白有余味。","_cost":0.00302356},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.1,"rationale":"机场送别题旨明确，现代意象融入较稳，颔联有画面。惜伤聚散等语直白，情感偏泛，转合平直，结以景收略有馀味。","_cost":0.011248},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"机场送别题旨明确但角度常见，伤感流于一般化。舷窗、铁翼、航牌等现代意象入旧体尚可，惜'一袖霜痕拂面'语意牵强。颈联'伤聚散'直白议论，转合乏力。结联以景收情，机声烟光、寒风掠鬓，留白有致，为全诗最佳处。略有当代经验之新，无蹈袭。","_cost":0.0121758},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.2,"意境":4.8,"语言":4.9,"章法":5.1,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"机场送别立意明确但角度常见；铁翼航牌等意象拼贴未融为境；语言通顺少诗眼；中二联转折平直；尾句以寒风景结略有余味而近套语。","_cost":0.00866775},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.0,"rationale":"此作写机场送别，题旨明确、脉络贯通，融入当代场域意象，情感平实，但立意无新见，转折平俗，炼字少亮眼处，余味较浅，无硬伤、蹈袭，陈词密度低。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"机场送别题材常见，但航牌、舷窗等当代物象入律较自然，情事具体。颔联'千程铁翼摩霄去，一袖霜痕拂面来'去来对举，是全篇警策；'费徘徊'稍显凑字。中二联由景入情层次分明，结句以寒风掠鬓收束，以景结情有余味，惟'别思催''伤聚散'稍落熟套。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"机场送别题材当代入诗，舷窗、铁翼、航牌等取象有新意，颔联尚可摘。但情感多“别思催、伤聚散、费徘徊”之类套语，一袖霜痕拂面语意勉强，机已远去而航牌过眼略乖时序。结句以寒风掠鬓收，稳而常见，余味有限。","_cost":0.0668},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"送别旨明，机场物象入诗稍见新意；中二联去来、内外相形，结句以景结情有余味。然伤聚散、寒风掠鬓等套语较多，航牌费徘徊稍硬，整体未深拓新境。","_cost":0.028774749},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.8,"余味":6.8,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"现代机场送别入律，起承转合脉络清晰。颔联对仗自然，尾联以机声风影以景结情，余味较足。唯颈联直抒胸臆略显浅直陈套，立意角度尚在常轨之中。","_cost":0.005097},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.5,"rationale":"熟题直抒聚散乏主脑，新象堆置而霜痕烟光含混，铁翼费徘徊生硬夹杂，颈联空议失脉，结以寒风稍有留白。","_cost":0.01608555},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":6.2,"余味":6.8,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.3,"rationale":"送别主旨集中，机场物象切题，但情事欠具体，伤别语多熟套。“霜痕拂面”含混，“费徘徊”生涩；中联直陈聚散，层次稍平。结以寒风掠鬓承接机声渐远，留有余味。","_cost":0.04208},"grok-4.7":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"送别主脑清楚，情只落在伤聚散，无新境。铁翼、航牌有当代感，舷窗旅云欠融，冷意未统一。颈联平直且时序回跳，结以寒风掠鬓，景收而余味不深。","_cost":0.027704},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"以铁翼、航牌写当代送别，有出新之意。颔联去来对照尚可。但首联用舷窗，视角混入机内，与送者身份相悖。颈联“伤聚散”直说无象。尾联“机声渐远”与颔联飞机离去重复，脉络原地打转。结句以景收情稳当，但句式近李白“唯见”，余味有限。","_cost":0.01794},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.25,"rationale":"机场送别有具体场景，结句以寒风收情，留有余味。中段“伤聚散”“费徘徊”说得较直，“霜痕”“舷窗影”所指稍涩，整体未脱送别常套。","_cost":0.009916}},"consensus":58.69,"final":58.69},{"key":"doubao-seed-2.1|云端相册|七绝","writer":"doubao-seed-2.1","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"残帧春痕寄太虚，他年笑影汇成图。指尖轻触封尘破，一瞬余温到座隅。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.1,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.7,"rationale":"以云端相册寄托旧日温情，题材入诗较新，触屏唤醒记忆，转结连贯。“残帧”“余温”可感；“寄太虚”“封尘破”“到座隅”稍显硬凑，情事仍略泛。","_cost":0.004978},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字时代怀旧,'太虚'双关云存储颇巧,当代经验有效入诗。转句'指尖轻触'点题自然,结句余温有情但'到座隅'略实。'汇成图'凑韵嫌平,'封尘'倒装稍生硬,通篇意象尚欠交融浑成。","_cost":0.04151},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"本诗将云相册与触屏体验等当代经验巧妙入诗，以“太虚”代指“云端”自然贴切。起承转合规整顺畅，情感真挚。唯结句稍显直白说尽，留白不足，余味略欠。","_cost":0.019874},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"云端旧照入诗有时代感，残帧、封尘破稍见炼字。然他年多指将来，与后文时序牴牾；起承复沓，转仅叙事。结句座隅余温较具实感，整体未脱旧影温情熟径。","_cost":0.022458},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"立意明确以云端相册怀旧，情感真切但角度不算深；意象稍空，后两句较佳；语言有“轻触封尘破”亮点，但“封尘”倒装略硬；章法起承转合清晰，结句以余温收束有余味。加分在现代经验与尾句处理，减分在意象略熟。","_cost":0.007707392},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"以旧体写云端相册这一当代经验，'太虚'妙译云存储，'封尘破'暗合触屏与拂尘双关，转结尤佳：指尖轻触，逝者余温抵达座隅，以体感收束，言尽意不尽。起承转合完整，一气贯注。个别措辞如'汇成图'稍平，通篇无硬伤陈滥。","_cost":0.00237456},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"取云端相册入诗，记忆复现题旨明确；指尖、余温有细节，而太虚、座隅稍空硬；转结顺而未尽宕开。","_cost":0.014432},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"以云端相册写记忆与温情,题新而情真,主脑集中。'太虚'双关云存储,'封尘破'兼物理与数字二义,炼字见巧;然'汇成图'稍平直,'春痕''笑影'略熟。起承转合清晰,结句以余温到座隅收,感而不尽,有延宕。","_cost":0.0136668},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.3,"章法":6.3,"余味":5.4,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.800000000000004,"rationale":"云端作太虚、指尖唤余温，当代经验入题有新意；然残帧春痕等象虚泛，缺锤炼诗眼，章法平直转结直白，余味未远。","_cost":0.00775115},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.2,"rationale":"此作取材当代云端相册，写点开旧照瞬间的怀旧暖意，章法顺适，语言精准真切；惟意象稍熟，结句余韵略平，当代经验融入自然，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"以'云端相册'入旧体,数字经验与古典语汇(太虚、座隅)嫁接自然,立意具体有主脑。'封尘破'炼字见力,结句以'余温到座隅'收束,体感真切略有留白。唯'残帧''笑影'稍近熟套,整体妥帖而未至警拔。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"以“太虚”借指云端，当代经验入诗颇有巧思，指尖触屏与封尘对接亦有转折。惟“春痕”“笑影”偏熟套，“汇成图”语平，数字相册言“封尘”略有逻辑龃龉。结句以余温到座隅收束，有余味但稍直。","_cost":0.04703},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字怀旧，起承转合完整，结句余温到座隅有余味；意象稍杂，语词文白夹杂，当代经验入诗部分成立，偶见陈语，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.02665389},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.95,"rationale":"将数字生活的云端相册自然化入古诗。“太虚”代云端，“残帧”状照片，妥帖不隔。章法起承转合井然，转结自指尖触发落于座隅余温，化虚为实，温润耐品。","_cost":0.00588375},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.75,"rationale":"借云端写数字怀旧具当代意识，然情事空泛无主脑，意象抽象松散，封尘余温陈套，指尖句生硬，座隅结句突兀无余味。","_cost":0.0118463},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"以触屏唤回旧照余温，题旨集中，有当代生活气息，第三句转折清楚。“封尘破”表达生硬，“到座隅”落点稍勉强；结句温婉，但情意较显，延宕有限。春痕、笑影偏熟套。","_cost":0.04114},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.6,"章法":6.3,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.3,"rationale":"题在云端旧照，焦点有而情事不深。座隅可感，残帧与春痕、太虚未融。前三句生造夹白话，结句较净。起承近复沓，转结能收。结未说破。触屏入旧体，出新成立。","_cost":0.0266464},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"以太虚喻云端，写触屏唤起旧影，当代经验入诗较自然。起承稍堆叠：残帧与春痕并置显挤，他年用作往昔有歧义。转句指尖破尘有动作感，结句余温到座隅收得稳，但余温一词略直，留白有限。","_cost":0.016412},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"云端存影、指尖唤回旧日温度，脉络清楚，当代经验入诗自然。结句以“座隅”落到眼前，留有余温；但“春痕”“封尘”等语稍熟，“汇成图”也略显笼统。","_cost":0.008178}},"consensus":66.53,"final":66.53},{"key":"doubao-seed-2.1|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"doubao-seed-2.1","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"万点繁灯下界铺，星河垂影近襟隅。谁将大地排棋局，粒粒人居是子无。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.2,"语言":5.4,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.35,"rationale":"俯瞰夜城视角鲜明，灯海、星河与棋局相贯，转结完整。棋局喻稍常见，“襟隅”“是子无”措辞生硬，末句虽以问收束，却未深拓人间意味。","_cost":0.004944},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰属当代经验入诗,以棋局喻万家灯火,设问收结不说破,有余味。惜'襟隅'凑韵生硬,'星河垂影'稍熟;三四句一喻贯注,转合自然。整体清畅有巧思,炼字尚欠精警,佳而未至警策。","_cost":0.03503},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"作品借夜航俯瞰，上承星河下俯灯火，空间感开阔，当代经验有效入诗。然将大地比作棋局略显熟套，结句“粒粒人居是子无”说破兜底，过于直白，缺乏留白与余味。整体结构完整但语言稍欠锤炼。","_cost":0.017064},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰收于棋局之问，主脑清楚，当代视点可取。起句繁灯、星河偏熟，炼字少诗眼，「是子无」略硬。转结尚活，问而不答略有余味。","_cost":0.0206},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.0,"rationale":"俯瞰城市灯光喻为棋局、人居为子，视角独到，有渺小与受制之思。转结有力，以问收束留白。语言稍生硬如“襟隅”，但整体精炼。","_cost":0.0051678},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰入诗，当代经验有效转化。起承远近得势，三四句以问作转，'排棋局''是子无'化用唐人问句口吻，结以问收，言尽意不尽。惟'万点繁灯''星河'略熟，'襟隅'稍见凑韵之痕。","_cost":0.00305656},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰灯如星河，转作棋局之想，视角清楚，有当代生活气息；但比喻较常见，‘襟隅’‘粒粒人居’‘是子无’稍生硬，结问直露，余味有限。","_cost":0.013044},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.0,"rationale":"高空夜景观照统一，繁灯星河有画面，“近襟隅”较警；惜棋局喻熟，末句“是子无”生硬致转结泄气，留白成含混。","_cost":0.0163158},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.4,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.85,"rationale":"夜航视角以灯火为棋子有新意但哲思未深，意象统一而星河略熟，铺字见功末句稍拗，起承转合分明，设问作结直露余味稍浅。","_cost":0.00842},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"此作以高空夜航俯瞰视角，将万家灯火拟为棋局棋子，起承转合顺畅，意象贴合，语词精准，以问句作结留有余韵，唯核心喻体稍熟，略有常见语，无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验入旧体，取景新颖。以棋局喻万家灯火，三句转得有力，结句以问收束留有余思。惟'是子无'稍嫌凑韵生硬，'星河垂影'意象常见；灯海与星河之对照未再深挖，意蕴止于泛言人如棋子，未能更进一层。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰入诗有当代经验，转以棋局设问、结以'粒粒人居是子无'略含人世微渺之思，有新意而不深刻。'襟隅'稍生硬，前二句灯河之象常见；后两句连用设问，收得稳而余味不足，喻意已近说破。","_cost":0.04885},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"起句有势，转句以棋局设问奇崛，当代夜航经验入诗而出新；然承句襟隅生硬，结句疑问直白少蕴藉，意象稍露比兴之迹。","_cost":0.028400422},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.9,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰之境高远开阔，上下视点转换自然，转结化大地为棋局观照人间，具现代体验与哲思。唯“粒粒人居”造词稍涩，“是子无”收束略显硬凑，炼字尚欠圆融。","_cost":0.00568425},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰转入大地棋局，结构完整具现代经验，但意象常见，襟隅粒粒炼字欠安，结句说破少余味。","_cost":0.00922055},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"夜航视角有新意，灯火与星河相映，转入人世棋局，脉络清楚。但棋局喻世较熟，“近襟隅”“是子无”措辞牵强；结句虽设问，却直点棋子之喻，余味有限。","_cost":0.05027},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"夜航灯火作棋局，主脑清楚，当代经验入诗有效。情偏理趣，襟隅、星河与下视灯火衔接不稳，结句把人居是子说破，余味有限。","_cost":0.0177056},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰入诗，当代经验真切。灯铺下界、星近襟边，上下对照有空间感。转句以棋局喻大地，结句设问，暗含众生如子之思，有余味。但棋喻较常见，'近襟隅'略凑韵，'是子无'措辞稍拙。","_cost":0.01602},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"夜航视角将地上灯火与天际星河并置，空间感鲜明；棋局之喻较常见，末句“是子无”略显生硬，又将比喻点明，余味稍弱。","_cost":0.011134}},"consensus":67.28,"final":67.28},{"key":"doubao-seed-2.1|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"doubao-seed-2.1","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"铁爪斜悬望眼迷，绒团软塑竞招携。心期一攫终难稳，乍得轻憨袖底提。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.4,"意境":6.7,"语言":5.1,"章法":7.2,"余味":4.8,"警句":0.8,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.05,"rationale":"以抓娃娃写期待、失手与偶得，题材新而情趣具体。铁爪、绒团营造现场感，转结有变化；但“轻憨袖底提”搭配生涩、所指含混，结句偏实，余韵不足。","_cost":0.008218},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入诗题材新颖，起承转合尚完整，转句写屡攫难稳、结句乍得而喜亦合情理。惜语言硬凑处多，'软塑竞招携''轻憨'生造别扭，意象仅作说明未成氛围，结句叙事说尽，余味有限。得分主要在题材出新与章法顺畅。","_cost":0.03402},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗，意象抓取精准，'一攫难稳'切中机器特点，情趣盎然。章法严密，起承转合自然。然'袖底提'略带古旧痕迹，结句直白道出结果，缺乏留白与余味。","_cost":0.016884},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入七绝，情事具体有主脑。铁爪绒团意象妥帖统一但欠深融。『竞招携』『轻憨』略见炼字。起承清楚，转结平直。结句说破成功，余味不足。题材出新明显。","_cost":0.016268},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"写抓娃娃机过程，题材较新但立意止于描述，未翻出深意。意象具体但“袖底提”费解，语言有亮点如“一攫终难稳”，然“轻憨”生造。结构完整，结句说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.00562056},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"当代生活入诗，取象精切：铁爪、绒团软塑皆抓娃娃实景，物象与情意相融。起望、承景、转'终难稳'、结'乍得轻憨袖底提'，转结有变化，以动作画面收束，留有余味。'心期一攫终难稳'暗含人生况味但未深挖，立意仍属游戏纪实层面，情感稍浅。","_cost":0.00203856},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.3,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.45,"rationale":"当代小景入诗，铁爪绒团切题，起承转合清楚；趣味具体而情志略浅，‘软塑’‘轻憨’稍生，结句得物即收，余味有限。","_cost":0.01059},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"以娃娃机入七绝,题材出新有效;『竞招携』『轻憨』炼字灵动,欲得不得至乍得的心理转折自然成章法。然立意止于小游戏趣味,未翻出更深一层,意象偏于状物、情味稍浅,结句虽以小得之乐作结有余趣,终欠宕开之笔。","_cost":0.0077628},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.3,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.8,"rationale":"当代抓娃娃机入绝，铁爪/绒团对比鲜明，望-期-得层次清晰；然立意止于游戏得失，意境未深化，语言通顺少诗眼，结句轻巧余味不深。","_cost":0.00737065},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"此作以旧体写抓娃娃的当代日常，情态真切，脉络顺畅，遣词妥帖，“轻憨”状玩偶鲜活；唯立意未深拓，结句偏实，余味稍欠。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"以旧体咏抓娃娃机，当代经验入诗自然，起承转合完整：爪悬、偶招、期攫、乍得，脉络贯通。'心期一攫终难稳'切中欲望与失手之张力，'轻憨袖底提'以景结情有余味。'竞招携''软塑'稍显生硬凑韵，炼字未至精纯，故语言略降。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.25,"rationale":"以当代抓娃娃机入诗，题材有新意，但仅作过程叙述，未由得失翻出寄托。“竞招携”“轻憨”属生造硬凑，“袖底提”与机器场景时代感错位。起承转合尚完整，转句“终难稳”平直，结以得娃收束，说破而少余味。","_cost":0.04869},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"以七绝写抓娃娃机，题意集中、情事具体；意象切当而稍显生硬，语言通顺有“轻憨”等亮点但“袖底提”硬凑；起承转合完整而转折平直，结句叙事收束、余味不长。当代经验入诗有新意，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.030500429},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.9,"rationale":"将当代抓娃娃经验入诗，物象化裁贴切自然。转折写落爪之失、收结摹偶得之喜，起承转合顺畅，“轻憨”炼字尤具神态，融俗入雅，颇具新趣。","_cost":0.00505425},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"小物写微欲得失具体有焦点，然止于过程复述未翻新境；取象集中而情融浅，招携轻憨搭配生硬，转合完整而平，结收实写无宕。","_cost":0.0115678},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.75,"rationale":"铁爪、绒团软塑切合题物，捕捉求取与偶得的小情趣，但开掘较浅。“竞招携”“轻憨”措辞生硬。由难稳转乍得，结构完整；结句落实携归动作，余味有限。","_cost":0.03954},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"情志偏浅,只写难得又乍得,未出深一层发现。铁爪、一攫、轻憨贴切,软塑、招携未融。起承转合清楚,三句一转有力;结句把结果说尽,余味不长。","_cost":0.036056},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.25,"rationale":"当代题材入诗有新意，但仅止于记述抓娃娃过程，未由“攫而难稳”生发更深体悟。以“轻憨”代指玩偶，灵动可喜；“招携”则略显生硬。三句转、四句收，脉络尚清。“终难稳”与“乍得”之间衔接稍跳。结句落在动作上，较直，余味有限。","_cost":0.018496},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"取材当代游艺，铁爪与绒团可见；由难攫到乍得，转折清楚。但“绒团软塑”“袖底提”稍显生涩，结句止于得物，余味较浅。","_cost":0.008038}},"consensus":64.81,"final":64.81},{"key":"doubao-seed-2.1|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"doubao-seed-2.1","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"暗里屏开隔远天，言轻窗罅堕寒烟。别来几换霜华影，笑指梅梢月又圆。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.7,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.35,"rationale":"以视频通话写久别，古典月梅与当代屏幕交融。三句推移时序，末句以笑与月圆含蓄收情；“窗罅堕寒烟”稍显刻意，月圆霜华亦略熟。","_cost":0.00519},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"以视频通话入绝句,当代经验与古典意象嫁接自然,一篇聚焦离思。转句以霜华写岁月,结句笑指梅月以景收情,留白有味。惟次句'窗罅堕寒烟'与通话情境衔接稍隔,霜华、梅月等意象偏熟,炼字稳而未见惊人诗眼。","_cost":0.04119},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"现代经验“深夜视频”入诗自然无违和感，立意新颖。起承写清冷与温馨，转句叹时光流逝，结句以动作和景物收束，留白得当。唯“堕寒烟”略显生涩，梅月意象微涉陈套。","_cost":0.020362},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"视频入古典离思，屏开寒烟略见新；梅月霜烟仍套。次句较炼。转写时序平直，结“又圆”稍说破，余味有限。","_cost":0.018804},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"以现代视频接通传统怀人，情境具体；结句以梅月收束，留白有味。惟“堕寒烟”稍拗，意象偏熟。整体章法稳而能转。","_cost":0.012087328},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"以七绝写深夜视频通话，当代经验化入古典语汇自然无痕。'屏开'双关巧思，'言轻''笑指'见人物情态，虚实两地融于一境。转句'几换霜华'收时间，结句笑指梅梢月圆，以景结情，一'笑'字翻悲为暖，余味悠长。'梅梢月圆'稍袭熟套，扣陈滥1分。","_cost":0.00308436},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.6,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.3,"rationale":"以屏、窗、寒烟写深夜视频，别情含蓄；转结由时间入月影，余味较稳。个别词语稍涩，传统意象略熟。","_cost":0.011952},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"以视频通话写异地相思，旧题得新媒介之眼，起结贯通，转结自然。然次句'言轻窗罅堕寒烟'生涩费解，霜华、梅梢月圆意象偏熟，结句以景收有情致而欠惊警。","_cost":0.0105528},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.9,"章法":7.4,"余味":8.1,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.65,"rationale":"以屏开视频翻新离思旧题，寒烟霜华梅月意象融夜色与相思，堕字精警，起承转合有序，末句指月以景结情，余韵悠长。","_cost":0.00979575},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"此作以深夜视频融入传统怀远主题，场景真切，脉络畅达，“堕”字炼字见巧，结句藏淡怅；当代经验入诗自然，仅梅梢月圆稍熟，无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.5,"rationale":"视频通话入旧体，当代经验化用自然：屏开隔远天点题精准。次句'窗罅堕寒烟'稍晦但氛围佳。三句霜华暗写岁月，结句笑指梅月，以景结情，苦隔中见暖意，言尽味长。起承转合完整，转句换影有变。仅个别字面略生，寒烟稍熟。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"视频通话入七绝，题材新而处理尚自然，'屏开隔远天'一语兼写景与隔。'窗罅堕寒烟'稍嫌硬凑；霜华、寒烟、月圆皆熟象。结句以笑指梅梢之动作收束，隔屏共月有余情，惟'月又圆'意近团圆套路，留白有限。","_cost":0.04861},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"以视频通话写相思，题旨明确但情志未脱窠臼；意象清冷而稍堆砌，次句句法稍硬；章法妥帖，结句笑指梅梢有余味。当代经验入诗较浅，陈意象偏多，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.026815622},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.4,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.8,"rationale":"当代视频经验有效入律，首承两句极具暗室低语之实感。转结虽取梅月熟象，但借“笑指”动作串联两端时空，以欢写怅，言尽而意不尽。","_cost":0.00550725},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.0,"rationale":"以深夜视频写隔屏相思，立意较新主脑尚明；寒烟霜华梅月偏熟，次句搭配费解；结构完整但转折平直；月圆结情稳当而意显。","_cost":0.01471725},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"视频寄相思略有新意，轻言、笑指使情感具体。由眼前转别后，再归当下，脉络清楚；月圆反衬人隔，结有余味。“窗罅堕寒烟”稍显生硬，霜华、梅月较熟，炼字尚欠精切。","_cost":0.0507},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"视频只借「屏」点题，情志仍是别离望月，有焦点而少新发现。次句取象较切，寒夜氛围能统一；霜华梅月偏套，炼字平弱。起承转合完整，转折平直；结以笑指留形，圆月近于说破。","_cost":0.0343024},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"以深夜视频写远别,当代经验入诗,起句“屏开隔远天”切题。次句“堕寒烟”稍显生涩。第三句“霜华影”较陈旧。结句隔屏同指月圆,团圆之象反衬分离,含而不露,有余味。但月圆、梅梢等意象较常见。","_cost":0.016424},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.0,"rationale":"以屏幕写远隔，有当代生活实感；由深夜通话转入久别，结句借月圆寄盼。寒烟、梅月氛围相合，但意象稍熟，“言轻窗罅堕寒烟”意脉略涩。","_cost":0.00812}},"consensus":71.28,"final":71.28},{"key":"doubao-seed-2.1|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"doubao-seed-2.1","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"瓦釜飘香出巷隅，家常肴膳味清腴。邻翁相约休烹煮，共对春盘笑语娱。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.1,"语言":5.4,"章法":6.3,"余味":4.2,"警句":0.8,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.1,"rationale":"由饭香落到邻翁相聚，切合社区食堂的人情温度，主旨清楚。取象亲切但较常见；“笑语娱”略显凑涩。结构顺畅，结句直陈欢乐，收束有余而留白不足。","_cost":0.005888},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.75,"rationale":"当代题材入诗可取，写社区食堂之温情题旨明确，但仅止于报喜式白描，无独到发现。'瓦釜'取象与现代食堂略隔，'味清腴''笑语娱'凑泛。转句'休烹煮'尚有生活细节，结句说尽无余味，通篇顺而浅。","_cost":0.03346},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"取材“社区食堂”展现邻里温情，立意接地气且章法完整平稳。然语言偏于通俗平淡，“笑语娱”略显凑字。结句和盘托出毫无留白，缺乏延宕与余味，属记事有余而韵味不足之作，当代经验入诗酌情加分。","_cost":0.023386},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗有当代气息，邻翁共餐场景具体温馨。然立意常见无翻新，意象妥帖缺奇，结句直说欢乐少留白，炼字通顺无突出诗眼。","_cost":0.014838},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"立意以社区食堂便民共餐为焦点，有当代生活情味但开掘不深；意象温暖但“瓦釜、春盘”偏套；语言通畅，“清腴”略见锤炼；章法完整而转结平直；结句直说笑语，余味不足。","_cost":0.00472054},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.5,"rationale":"以社区食堂入诗，当代民生经验有效入诗，立意有温度但开掘不深，止于表面和乐。意象妥帖而常见，'瓦釜''春盘'偏套。'笑语娱'之'娱'为凑韵，'肴膳'书卷气与题材微隔。章法起承转合完整，结句直说欢愉，说尽少留白，余味平平。","_cost":0.00223096},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.25,"rationale":"写社区食堂烟火与邻里和乐，题材有当代生活气息，但意旨较浅。首句飘香入巷稍具画面，后多直说，笑语娱收束说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.007426},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"社区食堂题材入七绝较新，邻里温情真挚、主旨聚焦。意象切题但偏常见，'清腴'有味而'休烹煮'稍生硬。起承转合完整而转结平直，结句'笑语娱'直白说尽，无警句可摘。题材出新可嘉，整体工稳少惊警。","_cost":0.0068778},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":5.4,"语言":5.9,"章法":6.3,"余味":4.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.2,"rationale":"取当代社区食堂入诗，温情可感但止于表层描摹；瓦釜春盘等象常见，交融较浅；语言通顺少诗眼；起承转合完整而转结平直；结句直陈笑语，言尽少余韵。","_cost":0.0056244},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"此诗摹写社区食堂邻叟聚餐的和乐场景，题旨明确，语言平顺，意象妥帖，章法完整但平直，结句直白少余味；涉当代新事物但开掘较浅，无硬伤。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"以七绝写社区食堂，当代经验入诗有可取处，邻里温情题旨明确但角度平熟。'瓦釜''春盘'取象尚妥而整体氛围浅淡，'味清腴''笑语娱'皆熟语。章法完整，转结无变化；结句直陈其乐，说破说尽，掩卷无延宕。通篇稳顺而少诗眼。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.75,"rationale":"题材取自当代社区生活有一定新意，然写法平铺直叙，只作说明性交代，缺具体细节与独到发现。“肴膳”“清腴”“笑语娱”语滞而套，无诗眼。转句尚有情事，结句却把“笑语”“娱”全说破，兜底无留白。","_cost":0.03888},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.0,"rationale":"写社区食堂，当代经验入诗（出新1.5）；立意止于表层赞美，意象妥帖而常见，语言通顺、首句稍有画面（警句1），章法完整但转结平直，结句‘娱’字点破，余味不足。陈滥轻微，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.024539711},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"题材关涉现代社区生活，写出邻里和睦与便民暖意。脉络承转规整，但“瓦釜”“春盘”等古典语汇略隔，结句直陈欢洽而缺乏留白，余味较平。","_cost":0.0049785},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"题取社区食堂具时代感，然情事泛化无焦点；瓦釜春盘与现代食堂龃龉，意象常见；肴膳叠床，清腴相牾；结构完整但转结平直；结句三喜字说尽无留白。","_cost":0.0111263},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"食堂聚邻，免炊相约有生活实感，题旨集中而开掘不深。香气、春盘取象妥帖但常见；“肴膳”“笑语娱”略赘。前半写食，后半写人，脉络清楚；结句直陈欢乐，留白不足。","_cost":0.04104},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.25,"rationale":"立意止于邻里共餐之暖,具体而常见。起句瓦釜出巷尚有气息,后半清腴、笑语皆平,春盘古饰与食堂实感未接。章法完整而转折不深。结句直陈欢娱,余味不足。语言通顺乏诗眼,肴膳与娱略赘。","_cost":0.0206656},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.75,"rationale":"写社区食堂,当代题材入诗,第三句'休烹煮'点出老人免于操劳,有现实温度,但角度平常,主脑不深。意象平实,'春盘'借用节令语,略欠贴切。'肴膳''笑语娱'有凑字之嫌,结句直白说尽,余味浅。","_cost":0.016252},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"邻翁相约就餐，点出社区食堂的便利与人情味；但取象较寻常，第三句转折不强。“肴膳”“笑语娱”略显叠赘，结句直说欢愉，余味不足。","_cost":0.006308}},"consensus":54.37,"final":54.37},{"key":"doubao-seed-2.1|云端相册|七律","writer":"doubao-seed-2.1","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"几叠云根贮旧图，轻翻影库万形殊。春堤试马衣凝翠，夜阁围炉酒泛珠。事往空惊鸿爪散，容存犹辨靥唇朱。凭谁问取经年别，独对冰屏认故吾。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.3,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.55,"rationale":"以云端旧照照见故我，主脑集中；春堤、夜阁由盛转衰，层次清楚。冰屏作结有时代感与留白。云根、影库、靥唇朱稍显拗涩，鸿爪意象偏熟。","_cost":0.006592},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"以'云根''冰屏'双关云存储与屏幕,当代经验化古入诗颇见巧思,一篇聚焦'照片犹在人事已非'。中二联忆昔与兴慨开合分明,惟'试马''围炉''鸿爪'取象稍熟。结句'独对冰屏认故吾'自照存照、认取旧我,言尽意长,是全篇警策。","_cost":0.03765},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.95,"rationale":"将云盘、屏幕化为“云根”“冰屏”，当代经验入诗无痕且雅致。章法严密，结句“独对冰屏认故吾”写透数字时代的孤独与岁月的怅惘，出新极佳，余味深长。","_cost":0.026706},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"云相册写怀旧有新意，颔联往事可感，颈联事容对照清楚。春堤围炉稍熟，结句认故吾说破，炼字通顺少诗眼。","_cost":0.017736},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.1,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.85,"rationale":"以云端相册写旧情，题材新，情事具体。颔联画面精工，颈联化典贴切；结构清楚，结句留自我观照之味。惟“云根”“影库”稍硬，传统意象略熟。","_cost":0.01691052},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"以云端相册入旧体，今昔开合清晰，尾联'独对冰屏认故吾'宕开一笔、言尽意不尽，为全篇主脑。'万形殊''酒泛珠'略见凑韵，中二联意象妥帖但未臻精绝；'云根'借指云存储稍歧义，然整体化古出新自然。","_cost":0.00243536},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.4,"意境":6.3,"语言":6.7,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.3,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.05,"rationale":"云端相册入诗，章法完整，颔联画面具体，尾句冰屏认故吾颇有余韵；但云根影库稍硬，鸿爪故吾偏熟，情事仍较泛。","_cost":0.013298},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"以云相册写物是人非，题新而情实，颔联两张照片具体可感，颈联借鸿爪转出今昔之叹，结句'独对冰屏认故吾'以象收情、延宕有余。'云根'双关妥帖，'冰屏'造语精警；唯'靥唇朱'略滞，鸿爪、围炉意象稍熟，整体中二联层次稍平直。","_cost":0.0126198},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.3,"语言":7.1,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"云根影库冰屏以当代经验翻新怀旧，有认故吾主脑；颔联铺陈图景颈联虚实对照章法完整，但新旧意象并置未浑融，结句直收余味略浅。","_cost":0.01186725},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"本诗咏云端相册忆旧抒怀，主脑明晰，章法圆融顺畅，语言稳切，意象妥帖，自然融入当代数码经验，唯结句稍直，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字时代的记忆与自我审视，题新而情真，'云根'双关巧妙。中二联回忆铺陈意象稍熟，'万形殊'略平。颈联'鸿爪'用典切题。尾联'独对冰屏认故吾'以冷屏照故我收束，宕开有味，是全诗警策处，余韵最佳。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗，当代经验有效，结于\"认故吾\"有焦点。然\"云根\"借义生硬，\"影库\"造词，中联\"试马\"\"围炉\"取象陈熟；颈联事往容存之对稳而不奇。结句\"冰屏\"点睛，尚留余响但略说破。","_cost":0.05702},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字怀旧，云根、冰屏化今入古，尾联冰屏认故吾警策，章法完密。然中二联试马、围炉、鸿爪等意象稍熟，意境止于妥帖，万形殊、容存略弱。","_cost":0.036151032},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.7,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"当代经验入律自然，“冰屏”“影库”融于古雅语境。颔联写旧照略显陈套，然转结浑融，“独对冰屏认故吾”收束精警，将技术物象转化为时光慨叹。","_cost":0.00695775},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":6.3,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.95,"rationale":"以云端翻图认故我主脑明确，颔例颈转章法完整；然新旧意象拼贴未融，影库冰屏嵌入生硬，结句点破略直。","_cost":0.01445125},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"以存影对照逝年，主线清楚，今昔层次分明。春堤、夜阁之景稍泛，“云根”“靥唇”略显牵凑。结句认旧我有余情，也稍点破；数字经验融入有效，警策尚少。","_cost":0.04131},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"主脑在独对冰屏认故吾，情志清楚而近熟题。春堤夜阁为可替换套景，云根与影库未成氛围。语言大体通顺，靥唇朱、万形殊偏弱。章法层序最稳，颈联能转。结句点明故吾，说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.0412768},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"以古雅笔法写云端相册,“云根”双关、“冰屏认故吾”能把当代经验收进旧体。颔联试马、围炉取景泛泛,只罗列照片内容,推进平直。“靥唇朱”有凑字之嫌,鸿爪之典也嫌熟。结句点出物是我非,收得稳,但略露题旨。","_cost":0.018008},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"由云端旧照转向辨认昔我，脉络清楚；“冰屏”收出冷意，余味较足。春堤、围炉稍熟，“万形殊”偏泛。","_cost":0.010042}},"consensus":73.27,"final":73.27},{"key":"doubao-seed-2.1|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"doubao-seed-2.1","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"锦柜晶橱列一隅，绒团憨态各相娱。投钱暗把机关控，探爪轻将软玉扶。屡欲捞时神竞悚，偶曾获处众齐呼。闲中拾取欢余味，岂在筠笼有与无。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"unknown"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.4,"语言":5.3,"章法":7.1,"余味":6.6,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"以抓取过程写游戏之乐，主脑明确，当代题材入律颇新。中二联动静有层次，结句能超越得失；但“各相娱”“神竞悚”“获处”稍显硬涩，“筠笼”与机器场景不甚贴切。","_cost":0.005148},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"以旧体写抓娃娃机,题材新而落点在'乐在过程不在得失',立意稳妥不算独到。章法起承转合完整,颈联对场景动静有捕捉。惜'软玉扶'易生歧义,'神竞悚'凑韵痕迹重,结句以议论反诘收束,说理稍露,余味有限。","_cost":0.03777},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.5,"rationale":"此诗以当代娱乐抓娃娃机入诗，题材新颖。章法稳健，起承转合层次分明，生动描绘了操作过程与围观心态。然“软玉”“筠笼”等旧词用于此处略显生硬，且结句说理直白，尽露无遗，稍欠余味。","_cost":0.017678},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写闲趣得失，场景具体、主脑清楚，然过程胜于结果之旨常见。中二联层次尚清，结句点破较实。古典语写现代偶隔，无警策。","_cost":0.018022},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"选材有当代生活气息，尾联点出得失之外之趣，中二联较有现场感；但“神竞悚”生涩，结句说理略尽，部分雅词偏熟。","_cost":0.02186096},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"当代游戏入旧体而气脉不隔，是本诗最大亮点。中二联‘投钱控爪’‘神悚众呼’写抓娃娃情态生动，开合有致。‘软玉’代绒偶稍隔，‘欢余味’措辞生硬。结句以议论收束，翻出‘不在得与失’一层意，然说理直白，余味打折。","_cost":0.00184296},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.15,"rationale":"取材新颖，过程描摹清楚，尾联点出乐趣不在得失；但以古语硬套现代器物稍显生硬，结句说理偏直，余味不足。","_cost":0.011934},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入七律,题材新而活,场景刻画具体,中二联写操作与围观心理颇有画面感,尾联翻出'岂在有与无'的闲淡意,略有理趣。然'软玉''筠笼'借古称今物牵强生硬,'神竞悚'凑字,语言锤炼不足;结句以议论收,余味稍直。","_cost":0.009966},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.95,"rationale":"以娃娃机咏物过程刻画具体，末联点出重过程轻得失略见主脑；然景情少融、语言平实少诗眼，结句直陈哲理少留白。","_cost":0.00935025},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"此作以七律写当代抓娃娃机日常，脉络顺畅，场景真切，颈联活现玩者情态，尾联点闲趣不在得失之旨，理路稍熟，结句偏直白。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"以七律写抓娃娃机,当代经验入旧体,取象精切(绒团、软玉、探爪),颈联'屡欲捞时神竞悚,偶曾获处众齐呼'捕捉现场心理,生动可感;尾联收于'岂在有与无'之理趣,章法完整。惟结句议论略直白说破,'筠笼'代指机器稍隔,整体意趣近于'重在过程'之熟理,翻新有限。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"当代题材入律，颔颈两联写操作与心情尚具体，主脑明确在过程之乐。惟对仗工而板，'神竞悚''软玉'略生硬不切；'筠笼'与首句'晶橱'物象自相抵牾。尾联直陈道理，说破兜底，余味寡薄。","_cost":0.04439},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入律，题材新颖；起承转合完整，中二联由操作转心理有层次。意象如“探爪轻将软玉扶”尚生动，然“暗把机关控”“神竞悚”等语生硬，尾联直白说破，余味稍短。无陈滥蹈袭及硬伤。","_cost":0.034100212},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.45,"rationale":"当代生活题材入律，物象化裁贴切。颔颈二联对操作与观者情态刻画入微，层次清晰。尾联议论直白收束，但能见旷达闲趣，具生活气息。","_cost":0.00479625},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"以新物入律有主脑,过程重于得失;写景叙事尚具体,但软玉筠笼失切,投钱捞时失雅,结句直说无留白。","_cost":0.014837},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"当代游艺场景入诗，重体验轻得失，题旨明确而见解常见；探爪、群呼有现场感，叙写层次清楚。“神竞悚”生硬，“软玉”“筠笼”指物欠切；结句反问申明主旨，留白不足。","_cost":0.04159},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"抓娃娃入律，情事具体、主脑清楚，然乐不在得失属常谈，故立意止于中上。颈联屡偶开合是章法亮点；探爪句略炼，神竞悚、欢余味、锦橱并举则冗弱。结句点破主旨，余味有限。当代经验有效，未至警句。","_cost":0.0298896},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.25,"rationale":"以古体写抓娃娃机,题材有新意,颈联能写出现场的紧张与欢呼。但立意归于重过程不重得失,较为常见。'软玉''神竞悚''筠笼'用字生硬或不贴切。全篇平铺直叙,结句说破,余味不足。","_cost":0.016256},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.25,"rationale":"写抓取时的紧张与得手后的欢呼，有生活气息；由陈设、操作到众人反应，脉络清楚。‘神竞悚’等语生硬，‘筠笼’与晶橱不合；末句直陈旨意，余味稍弱。","_cost":0.008458}},"consensus":61.01,"final":61.01},{"key":"doubao-seed-2.1|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"doubao-seed-2.1","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"列架银灯彻夜明，有人循码逐单清。指尖不觉凉生袖，屏外风牵万里程。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"聚焦云仓夜工，循码、逐单等细节具体，冷意与远程物流相融。第三句转入体感，末句由屏内宕向万里，余味开阔；“逐单清”稍显事务语。","_cost":0.005524},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"以云仓夜班拣货入诗,当代劳动经验具体可感,题材出新。'循码逐单'写实贴切,转句以指尖凉生落到体感,结句'屏外风牵万里程'宕开,将一人一屏与万里物流勾连,余味悠长。惟起句稍平,炼字尚欠奇警。","_cost":0.03447},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"本诗巧妙将“云仓”“扫码”等当代经验融于七绝，无生硬感。“列架银灯”点明夜班环境，转句由“凉生袖”微观感受过渡，结句“屏外风牵万里程”宕开一笔，将繁琐劳作升华为万水千山的联结，余味悠长。","_cost":0.013294},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"云仓夜拣入诗有当代实感，结句以风牵万里宕开略具余味。中联近说明书，取象半新半旧未浑融，炼字平实少眼，转合尚顺而无奇。","_cost":0.018602},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"写云仓夜扫，题材有当代感，转句触觉入细，结句宕开见余味；但前半偏平，“有人”略隔，语言亮点不多。","_cost":0.0091894},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"以云仓夜班拣货入诗，当代劳动经验真切可感，主脑聚焦。循码逐单与指尖凉袖由事及身，结句屏外风牵万里程以景宕开，人与货同夜不同程，言尽意不尽。语言精炼微有牵字稍露，整体格高不陈。","_cost":0.00238056},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.9,"rationale":"写云仓夜扫，现代物象入诗较自然。起承清晰，由灯下循码转至指尖微凉，再以屏外万里宕开，有余味。但“循码逐单清”稍硬，“彻夜明”“万里程”略熟。","_cost":0.011178},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"以当代仓储夜班入诗，选材新而情真：银灯、循码、凉生指尖层层铺出劳者体感，结句宕开一笔，由方寸之屏牵出万里物流，小题有远意。唯『循码逐单清』稍近口语、略见凑韵，诗眼未足，整体炼字未臻无痕。","_cost":0.0080508},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.6,"语言":5.9,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.2,"rationale":"云仓夜拣切入当代，微观指尖凉意宕至万里风程，转结开阔有余味；起承分明，唯次句循码逐单偏白直，锤炼未匀。","_cost":0.01119365},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"此作取当代云仓夜班劳作入诗，视角新颖，摹写场景具体真切，起承转合顺畅，结句宕开有留白，语言平实精准，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"当代仓储劳动入诗，题材新颖且情事具体，'循码逐单'见职业细节。三句转入体感（凉生袖）细腻真切，结句'风牵万里程'将屏幕订单与远方收件人暗连，以景结情有延宕。语言通顺偶见炼字，唯起承稍近说明性，'彻夜明'略熟。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"写云仓夜班拣货，当代经验入诗有效，聚焦清楚。第三句由外景转指尖凉意，身感真切为佳处；结句由屏内拓向万里包裹行程，宕开有余地，但“万里程”稍泛。语言通顺，“循码逐单”近术语而少韵致。","_cost":0.04594},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"云仓夜作当代题材，起承分明，转结由指尖凉生袖宕至屏外风牵万里程，景语含情；结句为警句，余味悠长。次句‘循码逐单’稍质直，炼字未至精纯。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.027320823},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.3,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.4,"rationale":"当代电商物流题材入诗极妥帖自然。起承写实入微，“循码逐单”精准生动；转联体察专注寒暖，结句自方寸屏幕宕至万里风途，时空豁然拉开，章法圆融且余韵悠长。","_cost":0.005166},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"云仓循码写当代夜劳具体，起承转结由近及远较贯通；然中段偏白直说，情景交融浅，结句拓远而意直，套语略多。","_cost":0.01384225},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.2,"rationale":"循码逐单写出夜间劳作实感，当代物象入诗较自然。由灯架到指尖，再推向万里，层次清楚；“指尖不觉凉生袖”语意稍涩，结句有空间延展，但“万里程”略泛。","_cost":0.03132},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"夜扫云仓，情事具体，焦点在清冷与远寄，立意稳而不深。凉袖为眼，由内转外，章法贯通；结未说破，而万里程稍泛。语言能纳码、单，彻夜明偏平。","_cost":0.0254048},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"","_cost":0.015336},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"循码清单与指尖微凉写出夜扫的具体劳作，结句由屏内宕向屏外，境界渐开。“凉生袖”稍欠自然，“万里程”略熟。","_cost":0.008024}},"consensus":74.97,"final":74.97},{"key":"doubao-seed-2.1|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"doubao-seed-2.1","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"铁翼摩空夜色铺，凭舷纵目瞰寰区。千灯错落摇星动，一水萦回似带纡。几缕云痕生袖底，万家城郭入枰图。我来已在尘嚣外，静对河山辗梦趋。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":7.1,"语言":5.4,"章法":6.3,"余味":4.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.95,"rationale":"空中俯城视角鲜明，灯、水、云、城构成统一夜景。“摇星动”有神采；“似带纡”复意，“枰图”稍硬，“辗梦趋”语义晦涩，结句未能宕开。","_cost":0.00696},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰题材有当代经验,惜写法仍是登高览胜旧套,主脑止于'尘嚣外'的泛慨。中二联铺排工稳,'云痕生袖底''城郭入枰图'稍见巧思,但'似带纡'陈熟。结句'辗梦趋'生造费解,收束乏力,余味转为晦涩,通篇一览而尽,层次少变化。","_cost":0.03765},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"夜航现代经验入诗，中二联俯视角度精切，'城郭入枰图'颇具画面感。但立意未脱'远离尘嚣'之俗套，'辗梦趋'生硬凑韵，结句直白说破，缺乏留白余味，整体语言平熟。","_cost":0.017302},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"夜航取境有现场感，中联“摇星”“袖底”能成境；然主脑仍落登高出尘旧套，中二联平行写景，转关平直。“辗梦趋”含糊，结句说破，余韵不足。","_cost":0.022934},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.5,"rationale":"咏夜航俯瞰，层次清楚，“万家城郭入枰图”稍警；然情意偏泛，“星动”“带纡”等套语较多，“辗梦趋”生硬且结句说破，余味受损。","_cost":0.00899976},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰题材有当代体验，中二联'千灯摇星''城郭入枰'取象精切，空中视角统一，层次开合得当。'铁翼''凭舷'直白少炼；结句'辗梦趋'生硬晦涩，收束力弱且近于凑韵，损及余味。","_cost":0.00209656},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.5,"rationale":"夜航视角清晰，中二联灯河云郭颇有画面；但情志止于高空超然，未更具体深入。尾联说破且‘辗梦趋’生涩，收束余味不足。","_cost":0.01445},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰题材较新,俯瞰视角统一,中二联灯、水、云、城层次分明,\"云痕生袖底、城郭入枰图\"一联较精。但\"尘嚣外\"超脱之语熟套,\"夜色铺\"略凑,\"辗梦趋\"生硬费解、结句拖垮余味,情志流于泛叹,主旨深度有限。","_cost":0.0100188},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.4,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.6,"章法":6.1,"余味":4.6,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.7,"rationale":"夜航视角尚新但情志泛于超尘，中二联灯水云城铺景有层次，尾联直说少余味，凭舷辗梦等字微硬，整体完整而少转折。","_cost":0.012369},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"此诗写夜航俯瞰观感，题旨明确，章法平顺，用语通畅；唯立意沿凌空出尘旧径，意象多熟喻，结句直白少余韵，略有陈词，无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰题材有当代经验入诗之新,中二联取象精切,'万家城郭入枰图'有俯视之趣。但颈联仍承颔联写景,转折平直;尾联'辗梦趋'生硬凑韵,意脉含混,说尽无余,结句拖累全篇。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰题材当代，却以灯如星、水似带、城如棋盘等旧喻套写，中二联皆景无开合；'云痕生袖底'稍有巧思。尾联'尘嚣外'直说破，'辗梦趋'硬凑不明，收束乏力，余味寡淡。","_cost":0.05647},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.5,"rationale":"写夜航俯瞰，脉络清晰，中二联有层次，“云生袖底”有致；然“带纡”“辗梦趋”凑韵生造，结句直白说破，陈套稍多，故语言与余味偏弱。","_cost":0.019012513},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰取景切题，中二联铺展工稳，“入枰图”具高空视感。然起结较平，套用“带纡”“袖底”等传统习语略显悬浮，尾句“辗梦趋”稍见凑韵，余味不足。","_cost":0.00513675},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.75,"rationale":"高空俯瞰层次尚清，然灯星水带枰图尘嚣皆熟语；凭舷失实、辗梦趋生硬，尾联直点超脱，了无余味。","_cost":0.01392605},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.0,"rationale":"俯瞰主线清楚，灯、水、云、城构成统一视野，“生袖底”有近身感。取譬多属熟套，夜航经验有所呈现，情志仍止于超尘。尾联转入抒怀较直，结句“辗梦趋”搭配生硬，含混未能化为余味。","_cost":0.0422},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰有主脑，袖底云痕与城郭入枰能化当代经验，中二联有开合。然超尘之旨常见，尘嚣句说破，辗梦趋生造，带水纵目为套语，结处无余味。","_cost":0.0300992},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰写当代经验，颈联“城郭入枰图”有新意。颔联“似带纡”语意重复，夜色中河流如带也略欠真切。中二联同写俯景，层次平直。尾联落入“尘嚣外”旧套，“辗梦趋”生硬费解，余味不足。","_cost":0.018488},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"灯影与星光相映，夜航所见有动感；由俯瞰转入远离尘嚣，脉络清楚但意旨偏熟。「似带纡」「入枰图」「辗梦趋」语意滞涩，结句未能留下余韵。","_cost":0.01068}},"consensus":57.82,"final":57.82},{"key":"doubao-seed-2.1|深夜视频|七律","writer":"doubao-seed-2.1","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"漏断疏窗夜气清，屏辉一线接遥程。眉边尚带当年笑，鬓畔新添数点明。话到深时声转细，风牵虚幌薄寒生。相看只隔玻璃面，万叠云山梦未成。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.4,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.35,"rationale":"以视频相望写近在屏前、远隔云山之情，鬓白、低语、薄寒具体可感。颔颈递深，尾联虚实反衬有余味；“数点明”稍涩，云山略熟。","_cost":0.006498},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"视频通话入七律,当代经验熟题出新,情事具体。中二联由面容而声息层次可观,'鬓畔新添数点明'炼字见巧但'数点明'稍晦。尾联玻璃咫尺与万叠云山对照,言尽意不尽。'漏断''云山'微涉旧套,'玻璃面'稍直白。","_cost":0.03904},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"该诗将当代经验“视频”巧妙入诗。中二联细腻入微，写尽岁月流逝与夜谈的温情。结联以“玻璃面”之近与“万叠云山”之远作强烈对比，道出科技难越空间阻隔的怅惘，古今意象融合无痕，余味悠长。","_cost":0.022388},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"视频相见写隔阂具体可感，当代经验入诗较稳。中二联有层次，结句宕开有余味。语言偶见套语，整体不空泛。","_cost":0.001612},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.45,"rationale":"写深夜视频通话，古今意象交融，情真境切；中二联见人见境，尾联以屏隔云山收束，余味绵长。微瑕在“数点明”稍晦，个别传统字面近熟。","_cost":0.00690118},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.0,"rationale":"视频通话入七律，古体承载当代经验而浑成不隔。屏辉接遥程、隔玻璃面相看而云山入梦，虚实相扣，题旨集中。颔联旧笑新霜对照见岁月，颈联声细寒生细腻传神。尾联以景宕开，言尽意不尽。'漏断'微有因袭痕迹，无伤大体。","_cost":0.00270836},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.1,"章法":7.3,"余味":6.8,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.35,"rationale":"视频入诗，细节真切，屏辉、玻璃面与清夜寒幌构成统一幽境；颔颈有佳处，然‘梦未成’等语稍熟，收束略直，整体工稳而未臻深警。","_cost":0.017908},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"以视频写怀远，屏辉、玻璃与漏断、云山交融，隔而未隔之悖论集中尾联。颔颈细描稍平、开合偏小，数点明略晦、薄寒语熟；结句宕开有馀哀，尾联可摘。当代经验入律自然，无明显硬袭。","_cost":0.0225198},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.6,"rationale":"屏辉一线接遥程切题精准，玻璃面与万叠云山悖论收束有力，当代经验入律自然，章法层次清晰，余味悠长。","_cost":0.0100445},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"本诗取深夜视频的当代题材写怀远情思，细节真切，章法圆融，语言清顺，意象贴合，尾联道破近屏远隔的怅惘，唯“漏断”稍涉旧套，结句略直。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"以视频通话写异地相思，当代经验入旧体而气脉贯通。颔联'眉边''鬓畔'于屏中见岁月，切题精巧；尾联玻璃一面与万叠云山对举，虚实相生，收得有味。'屏辉一线接遥程'稍平，'数点明'微嫌含混，语言整体稳而有亮点。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"以视频通话写隔屏相望与岁月侵鬓，题材当代而有真情。颔联“数点明”写白发精切；尾联玻璃之近与云山之远对举有味。惟“漏断”“云山”“梦未成”稍落陈套，中二联开合欠力，结句“梦未成”略说破。","_cost":0.04676},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"深夜视频入律，情真聚焦；屏辉、玻璃面等当代经验入诗，尾联对比成警句。中二联层次分明。然‘数点明’稍晦，薄寒、云山等意象稍常见，结句‘梦未成’略直白，意境余味居中。无硬伤蹈袭，陈滥微。","_cost":0.031275748},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.3,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.15,"rationale":"成功将当代视频通话经验化入七律，情真意切。颈联“话到深时声转细”体察入微，极富生活质感；尾联点破屏幕咫尺与关山万里的现实落差。唯部分字句略带旧诗陈套。","_cost":0.0051765},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.4,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.2,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.1,"rationale":"以视频写咫尺天涯主脑明确，颔联笑鬓对照动人；颈联转平，玻璃面直白，万叠云山略套。","_cost":0.01461325},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.0,"rationale":"以视频写近在眼前而远隔云山，旧笑新鬓使情事具体可感。颔联较佳，由细语转薄寒，层次清楚。“接遥程”略生硬，末句“梦未成”偏熟且直露，余味稍减。","_cost":0.04854},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"屏辉一线、玻璃相隔，主脑清楚，当年笑与鬓明对照真切。夜窗虚幌云山偏熟，意境未臻精切。语言有眼（一线、数点明、声转细），接遥程略虚。章法顺，转不陡。结句梦未成说破。出新尚可，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0444288},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.3,"语言":6.4,"章法":6.6,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.3,"score":66.6,"rationale":"以旧体写视频通话,当代经验入诗较自然。颔联今昔对照,颈联声细与风寒内外相生,较有情致。尾联用玻璃之近反衬云山之远,构思可取,但“玻璃面”稍显直白。“漏断”“虚幌”“云山”略显套语,首句也近似苏轼“漏断”之语。","_cost":0.020164},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.5,"rationale":"屏辉中见旧笑与新白，情感具体；由容貌、低语写到夜寒，层次顺畅。结联以玻璃之近反衬云山之远，颇有张力；“数点明”稍涩，“梦未成”略说破。","_cost":0.009638}},"consensus":78.56,"final":78.56},{"key":"doubao-seed-2.1|社区食堂|七律","writer":"doubao-seed-2.1","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"矮屋临街设食厨，窗明几净唤提壶。蔬堆脆嫩霜沾甲，味煮鲜浓暖透襦。童叟无欺凭论价，宾朋落座尽欢娱。相邻共话年光好，风递香丝过陌隅。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.8,"意境":6.1,"语言":4.9,"章法":6.2,"余味":6.3,"警句":1.2,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.35,"rationale":"社区食堂题材有当代性，烟火氛围较统一，末句以香气宕开尚有余韵。主旨偏颂扬，转折平直；“凭论价”“味煮鲜浓”等表意欠自然，套语稍多。","_cost":0.00793},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.75,"rationale":"取当代社区食堂入诗有时代气息,惜写法流于铺陈颂扬,'童叟无欺''尽欢娱'近套话,情事欠具体。中二联并列少开合,炼字平平,'唤提壶''陌隅'略生硬。结句以风送饭香收束稍有余味,全篇温而无警。","_cost":0.03024},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.25,"rationale":"题材切近生活，结构完整。然通篇流于平铺直叙，大量使用“窗明几净”“童叟无欺”等陈词，缺乏诗意提炼。颔联写蔬果尚可，结句宕开一笔略带余韵，挽救全篇。整体略显老干体之弊。","_cost":0.01908},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"当代食堂入律主题集中，然通篇颂美少独见；蔬霜暖襦香丝有象，窗明几净童叟无欺年光好则套而直。中联平行无开合，结句风香略宕开。襦陌与街厨时地微牾。","_cost":0.018122},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.0,"rationale":"题旨尚明但流于泛泛，中二联近口号少层次；语言有熟套与凑泊处，结句稍以景延宕，然前文已说尽。","_cost":0.012433168},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗有当代生活意趣，但立意停留在太平赞颂，'年光好''尽欢娱'近口号。中二联摹物尚工（霜沾甲、暖透襦有细节），惟层次平列少开合。结句以风递香宕开，是全篇最佳。'童叟无欺''共话年光'套语密度偏高。","_cost":0.00280796},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.3,"语言":5.2,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.15,"rationale":"题旨明确但偏颂扬，社区烟火有生活气；中二联平铺，套语稍多；风香作结略留余味，整体锤炼未深。","_cost":0.013},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"当代题材入七律有新意，颔联'霜沾甲''暖透襦'物象较真切，结句风递香丝以景结情尚有余韵。然'唤提壶''凭论价'生硬费解，'童叟无欺''窗明几净'等成语入诗显套，中二联平列少开合，整体立意止于颂美而欠独到。","_cost":0.0112998},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.6,"意境":5.2,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.8,"rationale":"社区食堂写实亲切，颔颈分咏物事人层次清晰，尾句香风宕开稍具余韵；唯立意与意象用语多套式，铺陈平实，锤炼与新境不足。","_cost":0.0087469},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.5,"rationale":"此诗咏社区食堂，主旨明确但视角常规，意象妥帖偏常见且略有违和，语言通顺偶有炼字亮点，结构有层次但铺叙平直，结句以景收然前句已点破题旨，留白不足，少量熟套，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"以社区食堂入旧体，当代经验有效，题旨明确但止于温情赞歌，'童叟无欺''尽欢娱'近标语套语。颔联'暖透襦'体感真切，尾联以景收束有余韵；然中二联平列铺叙无转折，通篇颂扬说破'年光好'，缺独到发现与深一层寄托。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.5,"rationale":"当代题材入诗可取，但仅作表面颂赞，无具体情事与主脑。窗明几净、童叟无欺、尽欢娱等成语套语连缀，年光好近口号；霜沾甲、唤提壶用字生涩。结句以景收稍有余味，惟前七句平铺无转。","_cost":0.05131},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"题旨清楚但角度平常，颈联空泛；颔联取象稍具体，‘霜沾甲’‘暖透襦’有触感，然‘窗明几净’‘童叟无欺’等套语频；章法完整而转平，结以风递香丝略留余韵；无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.026512178},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"切入当代社区民生题材，脉络清晰，颔联烟火气足，尾句宕开见余味。但颈联成语套语连缀，语近直白口号，立意停留于表面叙事，炼字尚欠精纯。","_cost":0.00565425},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.8,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"社区食堂题材贴民生而泛颂无主事；有烟火气但颈联说理；唤提壶霜沾甲生硬套语多；结构完整转折平；尾以香风宕开稍有余味。","_cost":0.01160375},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.25,"rationale":"题旨集中于食堂温情，但多泛赞，缺少具体人事情味。“唤提壶”“凭论价”语意生硬；中段铺陈平直，套语偏密。末句以香随风远收束，稍有余韵；题材贴近日常，表达出新有限。","_cost":0.0403},"grok-4.7":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.0,"rationale":"题为社区食堂，却只作温情颂赞，情事不具体，主脑浮于公平热闹。霜沾甲与结句香远稍能见象，窗明几净、童叟无欺等套话密，味煮、提壶有硬凑。脉络完整，颈联无转，结句以景收而余味不厚。","_cost":0.0252752},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.0,"rationale":"当代题材入诗有意义，但全篇平铺颂赞，缺少具体人事与独到发现。“霜沾甲”“唤提壶”“香丝”生硬费解；“童叟无欺”是商业套语，接“凭论价”语意相悖；“尽欢娱”“年光好”落入陈套。中二联排比平直，缺少开合。结句以风送香气收束，略有余韵。","_cost":0.017344},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.0,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗有生活气息，末句以香气飘远，留有余味；中二联由食物写到邻里，推进平直。“霜沾甲”指向不明，“童叟无欺”“尽欢娱”等语较熟。","_cost":0.00814}},"consensus":50.12,"final":50.12},{"key":"doubao-seed-2.1|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"doubao-seed-2.1","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"层仓列架夜灯明，掣电枪头扫码声。轨畔车回轻载转，廊边货逐浅红萦。千程路入烟村迥，一暖寒牵市井情。不觉宵深群动息，征轮待发即遄行。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.1,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.89999999999999,"rationale":"以扫码、轨车、红光写云仓夜作，当代题材鲜明；由仓内推至烟村市井，主脉完整。惟“掣电枪头”“一暖寒牵”稍涩，中联情意略泛，结句直收，余韵有限。","_cost":0.007418},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"以电商云仓夜班入诗,题材当代可取,'掣电枪头扫码声'有现场感。但'浅红萦''一暖寒牵'措辞含混硬凑,颈联抒情落套。章法完整而转折平直,尾联'待发即遄行'说尽无余,收束直白少延宕。","_cost":0.0329},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"本诗将现代物流场景有效入诗，首颔联“掣电枪头”“浅红萦”抓取精准，极具时代气息与画面感。章法起承转合规整。然颈联“一暖寒牵”略显生涩，尾联收束直白无余韵。","_cost":0.017058},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"云仓夜班入律，取材当代物流，题旨清楚而情偏概括。意象新旧拼贴未浑融，扫码等近白话。章法层次尚完，结句直陈循环，余味有限。","_cost":0.017784},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"现代物流入诗具体可感，章法完整；“掣电枪头”有亮点；但“一暖寒牵”生涩，转结略平，余味不足。","_cost":0.01668392},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.0,"rationale":"以云仓夜班入诗，当代物流经验有效入诗，立意有焦点：货连烟村与市井，见关怀。中二联一写仓内作业、一宕开至路途人情，层次分明。但'掣电枪头''一暖寒牵'炼字生硬欠自然，结句'即遄行'直陈说尽，余味不足。","_cost":0.00270816},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.8,"rationale":"以扫码、货架、车轨写云仓夜运转，题材新，脉络清晰；颈联由仓入市井有层次。然“浅红萦”“一暖寒牵”稍生硬，尾联说破少余味。","_cost":0.011436},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.75,"rationale":"物流夜班题材入七律有新当代意,夜班辛劳与市井牵挂之情可感;但'浅红萦''一暖寒牵'生硬费解,'掣电'夸饰,'遄行'古词硬嵌且与'待发'矛盾;中二联场景堆叠少交融,结句说破兜底无余味。","_cost":0.01137},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":5.2,"语言":4.9,"章法":5.6,"余味":4.6,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.6,"rationale":"云仓扫码切当代物流具新题眼，然情志止于行业礼赞欠具体；仓景与烟村意象拼合未融，语言掣电逐萦等拗涩乏诗眼，中二联铺陈重复转折生硬，结句直陈征轮待发无留白。","_cost":0.0079194},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"此作取材当代云仓夜作，主脑明晰，新业态场景入诗自然，章法平顺，语言通顺偶有亮点，唯结句偏直白少余味，无明显硬伤、陈套与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"ox-alpha":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.5,"rationale":"以七律写云仓夜班扫码发货，当代题材入旧体，立意有新意，颈联'千程路入烟村迥，一暖寒牵市井情'由物及情，是全篇主脑兼佳联。但'掣电枪头''浅红萦'稍显生硬含糊，尾联'即遄行'收束直白说尽，余味有限。章法起承转合完整，脉络贯通，唯结句乏力拖累整体。","_cost":0},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.5,"rationale":"以云仓夜班入律，题材新颖，首联颔联灯光、扫码声、浅红萦等取象具体可感。颈联转向烟村、市井情则趋抽象空泛，“一暖寒牵”凑字生硬，“掣电枪头”亦欠自然。结句以征轮待发收束尚稳，但“即遄行”说尽少留白，与“群动息”略有龃龉。","_cost":0.06817},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.0,"rationale":"写当代云仓夜扫，章法完整、脉络清晰；但语言多生造（如'一暖寒''浅红萦'），意象欠精切，结句直白。五维中偏低，当代经验入诗稍加分。","_cost":0.030166973},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.6,"rationale":"当代智慧物流入诗，贴切具体。颔联“浅红萦”摹写扫码激光极见巧思；颈联由仓内拓至市井烟火，开阖得当。唯结句“即遄行”稍显平直说尽，余味稍欠。","_cost":0.0051165},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.3,"意境":4.2,"语言":3.8,"章法":5.1,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.55,"rationale":"云仓夜扫取当代题材，主脑在远暖，然首颔同层复沓，扫码浅红直陈生硬，一暖寒牵费解，结句待发即行说尽无留白。","_cost":0.0195185},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"扫码、车货流转有现场感，物流连接民生，题旨明确且题材有新意。“货逐浅红萦”“一暖寒牵”语意欠畅；烟村、市井情稍泛。章法由近及远再归夜仓，收束完整，末句直陈行动，余味不足。","_cost":0.05034},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.0,"rationale":"主脑在夜仓连着远村，题旨明确而情事偏颂、不够具体。灯架枪轨取象尚切，颈联以降烟村市井征轮落套，景情未融。句法硬缩、文白夹杂。起承清楚，中二联开合弱、颈联陡跳。结句即遄行说尽，余味薄。","_cost":0.0315616},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.25,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫入诗,当代经验有效。'掣电枪头'生动。颔联'浅红萦'所指含混;颈联由仓内推向烟村市井,开合得当,但'一暖寒牵'生硬。尾联'群动息'化用陶句尚可,'即遄行'直白平收,余味不足。","_cost":0.016368},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"夜仓扫码与车货运转写出了当代场景，章法由仓内推向远途；但“一暖寒牵”语意生涩，“市井情”偏于概说。末句直言待发远行，余味较少。","_cost":0.008088}},"consensus":57.9,"final":57.9},{"key":"qwen3-30b-本机|机场送别|七绝","writer":"qwen3-30b-本机","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"长亭日暖送行舟，\n极目云边水自流。\n莫道离歌容易唱，\n归心先到故园秋。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"qwen3-30b-本机|机场送别|七律","writer":"qwen3-30b-本机","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"云横远浦接长天，送客孤舟向晚烟。鼓动离亭催画角，灯摇别馆照愁眠。风回塞雁声初断，日没关山路正悬。莫道天涯行路苦，归心先到水云边。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":true},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"qwen3-30b-本机|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"qwen3-30b-本机","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"玻璃窗里困娇颜，\n铁爪悬垂意若闲。\n几度提心终落空，\n一筐欢喜化云烟。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":["空"],"用韵":true,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":0.75,"duizhang":null,"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"qwen3-30b-本机|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"qwen3-30b-本机","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"彩翼垂悬幻亦真，悬丝轻曳困凡身。\n投钱只作贪心计，探爪难逃宿命尘。\n似笑还嗔空有影，将离未得总牵人。\n归来莫问囊中物，半是春风半是尘。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":true},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"qwen3-30b-本机|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"qwen3-30b-本机","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"天台雨过菜畦新，翠蔓牵风绕舍滨。\n手摘青蔬烹晚粥，满园香气醉闲人。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"qwen3-30b-本机|天台菜园|七律","writer":"qwen3-30b-本机","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"天台雨过绿秧齐，一径云深护菜畦。\n露滴青葱凝晓色，风摇紫茄动秋溪。\n锄穿石隙寻泉脉，杖点苔痕听鸟啼。\n莫道山家无俗事，满筐新翠夕阳西。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":["茄"],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":0.75,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"qwen3-30b-本机|云端相册|七绝","writer":"qwen3-30b-本机","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"云外千峰锁翠微，光风流转照窗扉。\n片时影像藏幽绪，化作星河入梦归。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"qwen3-30b-本机|云端相册|七律","writer":"qwen3-30b-本机","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"云端相册聚清辉，数点繁星落翠微。\n旧影依稀藏雾霭，新颜隐约隐尘扉。\n流光漫卷千山寂，往事重翻一梦归。\n莫道虚屏无实迹，心灯长照未忘机。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"qwen3-30b-本机|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"qwen3-30b-本机","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"万点寒灯落海隅，\n银涛卷雪夜如涂。\n机窗忽转星河近，\n一瞬尘寰入画图。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"qwen3-30b-本机|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"qwen3-30b-本机","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"夜航俯瞰：云外星河落万川，舷窗灯火对寒天。城如棋局分南北，江似长蛇绕碧阡。风定波平沉月影，灯流影动碎星烟。人间万事皆如寄，独倚危楼听夜弦。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":null,"coef":0.75,"duizhang":[],"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"qwen3-30b-本机|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"qwen3-30b-本机","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"荧屏夜半锁孤光，\n指尖轻触泪千行。\n人间聚散如流电，\n唯有相思入梦长。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":["半","孤","屏"],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":0.75,"duizhang":null,"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"qwen3-30b-本机|深夜视频|七律","writer":"qwen3-30b-本机","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"孤灯伴影夜沉沉，屏幕流光冷照心。\n笑语依稀传旧事，音容仿佛隔重襟。\n方知世路多虚妄，始觉人情半浮沉。\n欲问苍天何所似，唯余窗月照衣衾。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":["浮"],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":true},"coef":0.75,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"qwen3-30b-本机|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"qwen3-30b-本机","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"社区食堂烟火长，\n蔬羹暖粥慰匆忙。\n邻翁笑语分羹处，\n一盏清欢岁月香。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":["区"],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":true},"coef":0.75,"duizhang":null,"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"qwen3-30b-本机|社区食堂|七律","writer":"qwen3-30b-本机","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"市井喧阗近午钟，朱门小幌映春风。\n香浮灶火调羹美，味入杯盘笑语融。\n白发欢颜餐暖粥，童颜笑语伴疏蓬。\n此间自有天伦乐，不羡侯门万户宫。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":true},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"qwen3-30b-本机|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"qwen3-30b-本机","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"春街冻柳挂瓶悬，病骨难支泪泫然。药液无声催嫩蕊，东风借得作甘泉。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"qwen3-30b-本机|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"qwen3-30b-本机","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"春街柳眼挂银瓶，病骨枯枝待复生。药液如泉滋嫩蕊，针尖似剑护残英。风摇翠影惊寒梦，日透清辉照客情。莫道夭桃无气力，且看新绿满东城。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"ox-alpha|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"铁爪垂垂探锦囊，玻璃匣里卧鸳鸯。千金掷罢空回首，又见痴儿守夕阳。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.1,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.8,"rationale":"以古典语汇写抓娃娃机，物欲、痴迷与徒劳交织。前三句层递，末句宕入夕阳，循环感隽永；“锦囊”“千金”稍显装饰与夸张。","_cost":0.005762},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"以旧体写当代娃娃机，借'鸳鸯'双关欲求，题材出新且有讽喻主脑。转句'千金掷罢'翻出徒劳，结句宕开写'痴儿守夕阳'，以景收情有延宕。惟'锦囊''千金'措辞稍隔，'痴儿''夕阳'略近套语，炼字未见奇警。","_cost":0.03702},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"当代经验巧妙入诗，前两句具象刻画机器，唯“卧鸳鸯”略显凑古。转句写尽求之不得的怅惘，结句宕开一笔，将失落化为对世人执迷的叹惋，余味悠长，章法极佳。","_cost":0.018082},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写一掷空回之徒劳及痴儿夕阳之循环，立意具体。铁爪玻璃较切，锦囊鸳鸯稍隔。语言通顺无突出诗眼。章法转结分明。结句含蓄有余味。题材出新，略有套语。","_cost":0.033912},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.4,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写执迷与徒劳，题材今而不滑；铁爪、玻璃匣等物象与鸳鸯、夕阳相融。转结由机到人，结句景中留白，余味足。","_cost":0.01923636},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"以旧体写抓娃娃机，题新而意深：千金掷空、痴儿守阳，暗含沉迷与温软悲悯，主脑分明。垂垂探字见炼字功夫。四句起承转合完整，以景结情余味悠长。惟空回首、守夕阳稍熟，扣陈滥1分。","_cost":0.0026296},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.2,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.64999999999999,"rationale":"当代题材以旧语写之，铁爪、玻璃匣、鸳鸯场景具体，末句以夕阳收束有余味。但锦囊、千金等语稍泛，第三句直说空回首，略伤含蓄。","_cost":0.015014},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入七绝,当代经验与古调融合自然。'卧鸳鸯'喻玩偶精切有情,转结由掷金之空引出痴儿守夕阳,以景结情、余韵可感。'千金''夕阳'略熟,'玻璃匣'稍近白话,整体工稳而警策稍欠。","_cost":0.0109992},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.8,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写欲望落空，由物及人、由己及他，转结宕开以夕阳景语收束，意境统一余味长；当代题材入诗自然。","_cost":0.00744675},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"借当代抓娃娃机场景写世人求而不得的痴顽世相，意象精切，炼字妥帖，章法流转自然，结句宕开留余味，无硬伤陈套，警句动人，当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":null}},"consensus":81.49,"final":81.49},{"key":"ox-alpha|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"半亩青蔬上小楼，云边手植四时收。市声不到畦头雨，一箸清甜慰晚秋。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.9,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.1,"rationale":"都市天台种蔬颇具生活新意，声、雨、味交融，转结顺畅。“市声不到畦头雨”有隔尘之妙，略显句意压缩；末句温厚但稍直白。","_cost":0.007646},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"以天台种菜写都市闲趣,题材具当代生活质感,情事具体。转句'市声不到畦头雨'以雨隔市声,动静相生,是全篇亮点。结句'一箸清甜'落到味觉收束温厚,惟稍说尽,留白不足。语言自然少斧凿,章法起承转合完整。","_cost":0.03956},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.5,"rationale":"该诗将当代都市“天台种菜”之生活经验巧妙入诗。起承自然，转句“市声不到畦头雨”以天然之雨声屏蔽尘世喧嚣，为全篇诗眼。结句落于日常味觉体验，真挚动人，有效融合了现代生活与古典诗意。","_cost":0.018528},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"隐逸菜圃之乐具体可感，主脑清楚然角度不新。云边手植与畦头雨交融成清幽自足之境。语言通顺有亮点。章法起承转合稳妥。结句直说慰藉，余韵不足。","_cost":0.018806},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"以城市天台种菜为题材，有当代生活趣味，市声与畦雨对比营造清逸氛围。结句以清甜味觉收束，余味稍浅但稳当。语言自然少雕琢，章法完整，无硬伤套语。","_cost":0.00852852},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"都市天台种菜入七绝，当代经验化古自然，立意有独到处。'市声不到畦头雨'以城市喧嚣与畦雨对写，景语即情语，堪称诗眼。起承转合完整，结句'慰'字收得稳但稍直白，余味略逊。整体意象清新，陈套密度低。","_cost":0.0031014},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.8,"rationale":"天台种菜题材清新，畦雨、清甜颇有生活趣；转接自然，但结句说破，语言稍平。","_cost":0.00887},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"天台种菜以当代城市经验入诗,题旨新鲜具体;'市声不到畦头雨'以喧嚣反衬清静,为一篇之眼;'一箸清甜'量词活用见炼字。结句'慰晚秋'情语稍露,余味略损。","_cost":0.0188382},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.6,"章法":7.7,"余味":6.6,"警句":1.2,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.4,"rationale":"天台半亩切入都市田园，市声不到畦头雨对比鲜明，一箸清甜以味收束具体；章法转合自然，唯立意止于闲慰未拓深境。","_cost":0.00898575},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"此诗写都市天台种菜的日常清趣，立意真切具当代质感，意象妥帖，语言精准自然，章法顺畅，结句稳有暖意，无硬伤陈套，略有新意。","_cost":null}},"consensus":76.83,"final":76.83},{"key":"ox-alpha|机场送别|七绝","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"候机厅里别情生，广播频催万里行。目送银鸢穿雾没，空留天际暮云横。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":true},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.7,"rationale":"送别主旨集中，广播、银鸢切合机场情境，转结流畅，以暮云留情；但“别情生”“空留”等较泛熟，发现与个性不足。","_cost":0.004704},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"送别熟题以机场入诗,广播、银鸢有当代经验,唯情事泛化无具体人事。'银鸢穿雾'转句尚有画面,结以暮云横以景收情,留白稳当但'别情生''暮云横'皆属套语,炼字平实无诗眼,整体通顺而少警策。","_cost":0.02875},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.25,"rationale":"引入候机厅与广播等现代经验，章法完整。但首句直白如白话，语言欠锤炼，银鸢、万里行与暮云横属当代旧体常见套路。结句以景结情有一定余味，整体属具备时代感但笔法平泛之作。","_cost":0.021824},"grok-4.6":{"立意":4.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"机场送别题旨明确而角度常见，别情直陈。银鸢穿雾稍具画面，暮云横则套。文白夹杂少炼，转结平顺，结句留景而新意有限。","_cost":0.02098},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"立意常见但情事具体；意象统一，以银鸢、广播写机场送别。语言通顺，“频催”“空留”可点。章法稳妥，转结以景收束；结句留白有余味。整体中规中矩，新意稍欠，偶有套语。","_cost":0.00381172},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":63.75,"rationale":"机场送别取当代场景入诗，广播频催、银鸢穿雾有时代感；起承转合完整，结句以景收束，暮云横留有余味。但立意仍属常见离愁，别情、暮云等语偏熟，目送飞机消失的构思明显承自孤帆远影句式，新意有限。","_cost":0.0025472},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.35,"rationale":"以候机厅、广播、银鸢入诗，现代场景真切；起承转合完整，结以暮云留余。惜‘别情生’稍直，暮云意象偏熟，情事未更深。","_cost":0.011768},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.25,"rationale":"现代机场入七绝题材略新，但别情仍是熟调，无独到发现。候机厅、广播、银鸢、暮云诸象尚能交融成送别氛围，转结以景收、留白得法，章法一气。惜'别情生''空留'语熟，'银鸢'代称稍饰，全篇无警策之句，立意平直故整体居中。","_cost":0.0108228},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":4.3,"意境":5.6,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.4,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.55,"rationale":"机场送别为熟题，情志停留于“别情生”泛语无具体焦点；银鸢穿雾稍有新象，暮云则套语，情景交融不深；章法平铺直进，以景结情略有余韵但欠延宕。","_cost":0.00918425},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.5,"rationale":"此作写机场送别，结构平顺，意象契情，以景结尚有余味；但立意寻常无新境，语言平熟，仅融入当代场景，未脱传统送别旧套，偶用陈熟意象。","_cost":null}},"consensus":60.61,"final":60.61},{"key":"ox-alpha|云端相册|七绝","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"浮生留影寄云间，指底光阴似水潺。忽见屏中慈母面，容颜清减不堪删。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.7,"章法":8.1,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.9,"rationale":"云端相册承载母子深情，落点具体；第三句转折有力，“不堪删”兼具当代性与留白。前二句“浮生”“光阴似水”稍陈，“似水潺”略显生硬。","_cost":0.005498},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"以云端相册写念母,当代经验有效入诗。转句陡起,结句'不堪删'一字见诗眼,言尽意不尽,极有余味。惜首二句'浮生''光阴似水'落套,'潺'凑韵,前半铺垫平弱,后半力挽全篇。","_cost":0.03503},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"本诗将“云端相册”“划屏删图”等当代经验自然融入绝句，情感真挚，起承转合流畅。“不堪删”语意双关，颇具巧思。唯“光阴似水”略显陈套，结句情意直白，稍乏余味。","_cost":0.0174},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"云相册见母影清减不忍删，数字经验入诗有新，主题仍属常见亲情。意象新旧杂陈未成浑融。‘不堪删’略见锤炼，余句平实。章法完整而转结平直。结句点破情感，留白不足。略用浮生似水套语。","_cost":0.022824},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"前二句以云存储与流水喻时光，转结至屏中慈母面容，结句“不堪删”字字含情，当代经验入诗不隔；但“浮生”“似水”等语稍熟，前半意境略泛。","_cost":0.00705551},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.0,"rationale":"以云端相册写母爱老去，熟题翻新，主脑聚焦。起承转合井然，'指底'切合触屏滑动，新颖贴切。结句'不堪删'双关——既是不忍删照片，亦是岁月侵蚀容颜不堪看，以小动作收大情感，言尽意不尽。'浮生''光阴似水'稍涉熟套，扣陈滥1分。","_cost":0.00228816},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.05,"rationale":"云端相册切入悼亲，转至慈母照片，情事具体；‘不堪删’有当代诗眼。然浮生、似水稍落常套，起句略泛，结意稍直，故中高而不拔尖。","_cost":0.011936},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"云间相册、屏中慈母，旧孝思接入当代删除经验，转结有力；惜起承“浮生”“光阴似水”近套，“指底”“水潺”生硬。结句“不堪删”动人但略说破。","_cost":0.0130962},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.2,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.2,"rationale":"云端相册切入亲情具当代感，忽见慈母清减以不堪删收束有真意；惜次句光阴似水偏陈，意象虚多实少，景情交融未深。","_cost":0.00911325},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"作品借云端相册写睹照思亲，情感真切，起承转合顺畅，'不堪删'炼字精准，当代日常入诗自然；惟'光阴似水'语稍熟，结句余韵略欠，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":73.58,"final":73.58},{"key":"ox-alpha|天台菜园|七律","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"自向云端拓一方，水泥林里忽青秧。残盆犹蓄三分绿，破絮还遮彻夜霜。俯瞰长街车似蚁，低回小圃菜生香。黄昏掐取盈筐翠，嚼得霞光齿颊凉。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.7,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.74999999999999,"rationale":"楼顶拓园切入都市生活，残盆破絮见经营之艰，菜香与车流对照有情味。尾句通感鲜活，余韵清凉；“水泥林”“车似蚁”稍熟，“低回小圃”略显含混。","_cost":0.004748},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"当代都市天台种菜入诗,题材新而情事具体。残盆破絮见护苗细节,颈联俯瞰与低回一开一合有层次。结句'嚼得霞光齿颊凉'通感出彩,言尽意不尽,可摘为警句。惟'菜生香''三分绿'稍平易,炼字尚有余地。","_cost":0.03194},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":9.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.5,"rationale":"本诗将都市天台种菜经验入诗，立意新巧，情趣盎然。“残盆破絮”写尽真实，“车似蚁”与“菜生香”高低对比构筑极佳空间感。结句“嚼得霞光齿颊凉”通感奇绝，余味悠长，属难得佳作。","_cost":0.015528},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.5,"rationale":"天台种菜情事具体，残盆破絮落实，结句通感尚可。然城绿对照常见，车似蚁等象偏熟，章法平稳少波澜。","_cost":0.01662},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.4,"语言":8.3,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.8,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.5,"rationale":"城市天台种菜，细节真切，通感结句有余味；中二联开合稍平，车似蚁略熟。无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":0.01637196},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.25,"rationale":"都市楼顶种菜，熟题翻出新境，情事具体。水泥林与青秧对映，俯瞰低回开合有致。嚼得霞光以通感收束，余味悠长。语言凝练见诗眼，当代经验入诗自然无痕。","_cost":0.00258236},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.1,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.8,"rationale":"天台菜园以小见大，水泥林与青秧相映，残盆破絮细节真切。结句嚼霞生凉，清新生动；个别意象稍熟。","_cost":0.012914},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"天台种菜写都市人亲近自然,题新情真。残盆破絮、青秧傲霜意象精切,颈联俯瞰低回开合有致。结句\"嚼得霞光齿颊凉\"通感生新、余韵悠长。唯\"车似蚁\"略熟,整体锤炼见功而不露痕迹。","_cost":0.0083568},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.3,"余味":7.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.15,"rationale":"都市天台自辟菜圃，以残盆破絮见护绿之诚，水泥林与青秧、车蚁与菜香俯仰对照，结句嚼霞生凉以通感收束，有真切生活根柢。","_cost":0.0087145},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"此作写都市天台种菜的日常闲趣，立意贴实有当代感，意象鲜活熨帖，章法谨严流转，炼字精准，结句通感见巧余味悠长，仅“车似蚁”稍熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":84.41,"final":84.41},{"key":"ox-alpha|云端相册|七律","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"浮生碎影寄何方，点破屏光启旧藏。镜底眉梢春尚在，尘间鬓角雪初长。千张滑过如流水，一格停来是故乡。却羡闲云浑不记，去留无意自苍茫。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.6,"rationale":"以云端相册写流年、衰老与乡愁，古意中融入数字经验。颔颈联推进自然，“一格停来是故乡”凝练有力；结尾借闲云反衬人的记忆负重，余韵苍茫。春雪、流水及“去留无意”略熟。","_cost":0.006106},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":75.25,"rationale":"当代云端相册经验有效入诗，主脑清晰。颔联镜底尘间对照工稳，颈联'千张滑过''一格停来'化屏幕操作为乡愁，可摘为警句。尾联宕开羡云有余味，惟'去留无意'袭闲适成语、'苍茫'稍泛，收束略落熟套。","_cost":0.03776},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"巧妙将当代经验“云相册”入诗。颔联对比岁月痕迹，颈联聚焦故乡情结，尾联借“云”的双关宕开一笔。结构严谨，语言自然，立意新颖，成功实现了现代题材的古典转化。","_cost":0.016948},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"以云相册写浮生记忆，当代经验入诗较新。颔联春雪对仗工稳，颈联千张一格有警句感。结句宕开羡云，余味足。语言偶见套语，未尽锤炼。","_cost":0.002638},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.1,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字记忆，题材出新；中二联昔今、流动与停驻形成张力，语言“滑过”“停来”精准。尾联转闲云不记，反衬人深情，结得苍茫有余味。微瑕在用“浮生”“闲云”等套语，立意未全脱习惯。","_cost":0.0157768512},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"以云端相册入律诗，当代经验化古自然。颔联照片青春与鬓雪对照精切，颈联'千张滑过如流水，一格停来是故乡'写滑动翻屏之态尤妙，堪为警句。结句以云字回扣题面，宕开有余味，惟'去留无意'系熟语稍落套。章法起承转合完备，中二联开合有层次。","_cost":0.00289616},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.2,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.8,"rationale":"云端相册入诗有新意，屏光、滑页等细节贴切；颈联凝练有警句。尾联闲云苍茫稍落熟套，语言有亮点亦见泛语。","_cost":0.010732},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"以云端相册寄浮生流年之叹，熟题翻出新境，镜底春在、尘间雪长对照工切；“千张滑过如流水，一格停来是故乡”摘出动人。结句借闲云反扣“云端”存储，双关巧妙，以景宕开有余味。唯“去留无意”沿成语熟境，流水、苍茫等象稍常见，语言整体锤炼而“点破屏光”略生硬。","_cost":0.0148188},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.7,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.15,"rationale":"以云端屏光滑阅切入怀旧，镜底尘间、千张一格动静对照，羡云宕开收束；当代经验入诗贴切，个别意象语汇仍近熟套。","_cost":0.009693},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"此作以翻云端相册触发今昔乡思，主脑集中，章法流转自然，颈联鲜活有当代共感，语言妥帖见炼字；唯部分意象、结语稍熟，余味略直，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":77.13,"final":77.13},{"key":"ox-alpha|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"万里云涛沉足底，千灯似豆落苍茫。凭窗错认银河近，俯首人间是故乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.3,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25000000000001,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写乡思，视角新而情旨集中。云涛、灯豆、银河层层转换，转结自然；“人间是故乡”拓宽情境，但稍显直白，云涛银河亦略近熟套。","_cost":0.00473},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰乃当代经验有效入诗,转句错认银河与结句俯首人间形成天上人间之翻转,收束有情致而稍近说破。取象云涛、灯豆妥帖,惟银河、苍茫略见熟套,炼字平稳无显著诗眼。章法起承转合完整,一气可通。","_cost":0.03198},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"该作将夜航体验自然入诗，视角独特。“千灯似豆”与“错认银河”使天上人间交织，起承转合流畅有致。结句直接点明“是故乡”略显直白，少些留白之韵，但整体情感真挚，现代经验表达有效。","_cost":0.017638},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰取象贴切，转句错认有巧，题旨常见，结句点破故乡稍直，余韵有限。现代经验入诗尚可。","_cost":0.01451},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.60000000000001,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰由云涛灯火转出银河错觉，结归人间故乡，章法转结得力，意象浑成。立意稍常见，结句偏直露，意象略熟。无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":0.00840708},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"夜航视角入诗，取象统一，云涛、千灯、银河构成连贯夜航氛围。三句'错认银河'作转，结句翻转点出故乡，转结有力。乡愁主题常见但俯瞰角度有新意。结句直接点破'是故乡'，稍欠含蓄，余味中上。'灯似豆''银河'喻略熟但密度低。","_cost":0.00218256},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.3,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.6,"余味":6.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"夜航视角真切，云涛灯河与银河互映，转接自然；末句归于人间故乡稍显说破，意象词语偏熟。","_cost":0.009122},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.5,"rationale":"以夜航新经验入诗,灯火似豆误作银河,转结自然,'俯首人间是故乡'翻得有意味。取象统一、转合有度,惜结句抒情稍直,云涛银河之象略熟。","_cost":0.0073218},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.3,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.9,"余味":6.2,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.6,"rationale":"机窗俯瞰借错认银河翻出乡愁新意，云涛豆灯意象精切贯一，转合自然收于人间；结句直抒情意，余韵稍浅。","_cost":0.007162},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"此作取当代夜航俯瞰视角写乡思，起承转合圆畅，借错认银河的巧思落墨，意象切题，语言凝练；唯结句稍直，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭，有一定新意。","_cost":null}},"consensus":77.53,"final":77.53},{"key":"ox-alpha|机场送别|七律","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"千里关山从此长，叮咛未了立斜阳。回身已隔琉璃冷，挥手空闻广播忙。霹雳一声穿顶去，孤鸢万仞入云翔。古来折柳今何在？夹道航灯绿似杨。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"unknown"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.6,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.2,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.7,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.0,"rationale":"送别旧题融入玻璃、广播、航灯等机场经验，情景交织。中二联推进清晰，尾联以航灯化折柳，转结新颖有余味；“广播忙”“穿顶去”稍显生硬。","_cost":0.00773},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"送别熟题移入机场翻出新境:琉璃隔冷、广播喧忙以今物写离情,颔联最切。结联化折柳古意为航灯绿柳,言尽意远,是全篇警策。惜首联关山斜阳落套,'孤鸢''霹雳'状飞机稍粗,炼字未臻精纯。","_cost":0.03675},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"本诗将机场、广播等当代经验完美融入传统离别题材。尤以尾联将绿色航灯比作送别之杨柳，巧接古今离愁，意境交融无间，结构脉络贯通，结句余味悠长，出新而不觉突兀。","_cost":0.014},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"机场送别熟题，折柳对照角度常见。琉璃广播孤鸢航灯意象交融成境，绿似杨稍活。语言通顺有炼字，霹雳穿顶略硬。章法层次清楚转结平稳。结句有问有象，余味有限未宕开。","_cost":0.020596},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"机场送别取象现代，尾联航灯绿似杨暗合折柳，古今转换巧妙。中二联由地面到天空层次清楚，唯“广播忙”略直白。结句以景收束，余味足。","_cost":0.01376364},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"机场送别以现代经验重写折柳旧题，立意翻新。'琉璃冷''广播忙'取象精切，景语即情语；'霹雳''孤鸢'喻起飞生动。结句以航灯绿柳作答，以景结情，言尽意不尽。'千里关山'稍熟，通篇脉络贯通，转结尤佳。","_cost":0.00228316},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.9,"rationale":"机场送别以玻璃、广播、航灯入律，化折柳为航灯，立意新，结构完整；语稍口语，传统意象略熟。结有余味。","_cost":0.00834},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"送别熟题翻出新境：琉璃隔断、广播、航灯等当代物象与情意交融自然，尾联以折柳设问、航灯似杨作答，古今映照，以景结情余韵悠长。惜首联'千里关山'略熟，颈联'穿顶''入云'意近复沓，'广播忙'炼字稍松，章法整体稳而少奇变。","_cost":0.0134624},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.4,"意境":7.8,"语言":6.7,"章法":6.3,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.7,"rationale":"以航灯代折柳翻新别意，琉璃冷/广播忙具当代质感，颔联精切颈联稍突，尾句以景收束有余味但点破略显","_cost":0.0133615},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"此诗写机场送别，融当代场景与传统折柳意涵，熟题翻新，细节真切，“回身已隔琉璃冷”为佳句；唯部分词句稍粗，结句留白略欠，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":81.14,"final":81.14},{"key":"ox-alpha|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"云端忽见故园明，万里灯前笑语声。欲问归期言又止，隔屏犹自唤儿名。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.4,"意境":7.8,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.7,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.2,"rationale":"以视频通话写万里亲情，情事具体；“言又止”蓄势，末句以呼名动作见牵挂。云端、隔屏富时代感，惟故园、归期稍熟。","_cost":0.006076},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"当代视频通话经验入绝句而不违和,'云端'双关巧妙。转句化用义山问归期而翻出'言又止'之新,结句以母唤儿名收束,言尽情不尽,具体可感。'故园明''笑语声'稍近熟语,微扣陈滥。整体起承转合完足,一气贯注。","_cost":0.03104},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.5,"rationale":"本诗巧妙将现代视频通话融入传统思乡母题。语言平易真挚，转折自然，结句细节特写极具画面感与张力，当代经验入诗无违和，起承转合圆润顺畅。","_cost":0.015008},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"视频思乡情事具体，云端隔屏略具当代感；故园灯前归期等象偏熟，欲问近套。起承转合尚顺，结以唤名稍留画面，整体平稳少警策深境。","_cost":0.01741},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"以视频通话写乡思，转结聚焦言又止与唤儿名，细切真挚，结句留有余味。云端、隔屏带来当代感；故园、归期等意象稍熟。","_cost":0.00717508},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"视频通话入七绝，题新情真。'云端'双关巧妙，'言又止'与'唤儿名'写尽游子与父母双向牵挂，结句以声音场景收，言尽意不尽。'欲问归期'暗化义山句而不觉袭。个别措辞如'故园'稍熟，整体脉络贯通，转结尤佳。","_cost":0.00229116},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.6,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.9,"rationale":"以视频通话写乡愁，题旨明确而情事具体；欲问归期忽转唤儿名，结句含蓄有馀。云端、万里稍泛，语言略直。","_cost":0.006406},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"以视频通话写羁旅亲思，旧题得新境；转句“欲问言又止”见克制，结以唤名动作收，哀而不说破。唯“故园”“万里”“归期”稍熟，炼字尚少夺目诗眼，故中上而非高格。","_cost":0.01449},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.7,"rationale":"以云端隔屏切入归思，欲问又止见慈爱克制，情感具体真挚；起承转合分明，末句以唤名结情留白，化当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.00931515},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"此作以深夜视频通话切入思亲主题，情感真挚细节鲜活，章法流转自然，将当代日常经验融入旧体，语言平实妥帖，无硬伤套话，结句温厚有余情。","_cost":null}},"consensus":78.85,"final":78.85},{"key":"ox-alpha|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"琉璃匣里卧群羊，闹市喧嚣隔一方。数掷青蚨听脆响，孤悬铁爪泛寒光。初承皓腕凌霄汉，旋脱纤钩堕宝筐。携向小窗书案上，无人复问旧时香。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.1,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.15,"rationale":"借抓取玩偶写占有后的冷落，题材新而主线清楚；钱响、铁爪颇具冷意。皓腕指涉稍晦，凌霄汉略夸饰，旧时香含蓄却稍悬空。","_cost":0.015168},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"以旧体咏娃娃机，取材新颖，结句写获宠后遭冷落有寄托，惜'旧时香'与毛绒之物稍隔。中二联铺叙有序但'皓腕''凌霄汉'夸饰失当，'青蚨'等词书卷气与题材略不谐。章法完整而转折平顺，余味尚存未臻深永。","_cost":0.05457},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"当代经验入诗佳作。以古词构筑现代场景，描摹生动。全篇起承转合严密，尾联借玩具失宠隐喻世人得新忘旧之心理，余味悠长。唯“凌霄汉”“旧时香”略显大词小用与凑韵。","_cost":0.02314},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入七律题材较新，投币铁爪抓取过程具体，结以案头冷落略具讽喻。然皓腕凌霄汉夸饰未切，意象叙事多而交融弱，结句点破无人复问稍直，寒光青蚨尚有炼字。","_cost":0.027272},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.3,"语言":7.2,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.15,"rationale":"抓娃娃机题材新，中二联抓取过程有画面，尾联转入得后冷落见余味。'孤悬铁爪泛寒光'佳。惜铁爪纤钩意象略复，群羊稍凑，整体中上。","_cost":0.00831886},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写'得宠后被遗忘'之命运，熟题翻新，主脑聚焦。青蚨、铁爪、皓腕、纤钩取象精切，中二联'承—脱''升—堕'开合有力，暗喻人情冷暖不露痕迹。结句'无人复问旧时香'以物写寂，言尽意不尽。'凌霄汉'略夸而尚称题。","_cost":0.00344176},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.3,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.85,"rationale":"当代题材入律，抓取过程写得生动，起承转合清晰；惟旧时香略泛，皓腕凌霄汉稍失贴切，情志未深。","_cost":0.010586},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入七律而托物寓慨：琉璃隔喧、铁爪寒光，物象精切；颈联“初承/旋脱”开合见起落之幻，赢得即堕，反讽有力；尾联携归书案而“无人复问旧时香”，由得至弃，言尽意不尽。青蚨、皓腕化古入今不猎奇。惟“凌霄汉”稍张、“寒光”略熟，警句摘读未至绝伦。","_cost":0.0279408},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.8,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.8,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.1,"rationale":"取材娃娃机具当代感，中二联升堕对比生动、章法贯通；但立意止于得弃浅叹，皓腕喻铁爪牵强，结句旧香无根直露余味不足。","_cost":0.00985175},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.1,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机当代题材入七律，叙事脉络清晰，语词稳切，借玩偶遭际寄喜新厌旧的微怅，具新意；唯章法稍平，结句偏直，杂少量熟象，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":73.33,"final":73.33},{"key":"ox-alpha|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"炊烟起处饭蔬香，白发邻翁笑语长。莫叹空巢杯箸冷，此间灯火即家乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.9,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.1,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.8,"rationale":"以社区食堂回应空巢之冷，当代关怀明确；炊烟、饭香、笑语、灯火相互映照，转承完整。末句温暖但略近口号，“家乡”亦稍显泛化，余味有限。","_cost":0.00452},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"以社区食堂慰藉空巢老人，当代经验入诗有新意，一篇主脑清楚。转句'莫叹'有变，结句温情但把'即家乡'说破，余味打折。'炊烟'与社区食堂场景稍隔，意象偏熟（灯火、家乡），语言平顺少警策。","_cost":0.03536},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"当代题材入诗，现实关怀真切，章法起承转合严密。然取象与语言偏于平白常见，缺乏炼字之功；结句将题旨和盘托出，说理过白而无延宕留白，致使全篇少些诗意余味，属平顺达意的现实习作。","_cost":0.021178},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"以社区食堂化解空巢之叹，题旨明确具体。取象常见，氛围尚融。炼字平实，‘杯箸冷’略有亮点。起承转合稳妥。结句说破题旨，余韵不足。题材有时代新意。","_cost":0.02113},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"立意关怀空巢老人、情感具体；意象冷热对照妥帖但常见；语言通畅少警策；章法转结稳当；结句以灯火作归依，略有余味。","_cost":0.01366992},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"当代养老题材入旧体，以社区食堂之灯火化解空巢之冷，主脑清晰，情感具体。起承转合完整，结句翻出'即家乡'之悟，宕开有力。'杯箸冷'对'灯火暖'暗藏照应。唯'炊烟''白发'取象稍熟，结句议论直陈，余味稍减。","_cost":0.00208436},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.15,"rationale":"题旨明确，写社区食堂暖空巢；起承转合清楚。饭香、笑语等意象生活化但偏常见，“空巢”“家乡”稍直白，结句点破少余味。当代经验入诗有效，语言平顺。","_cost":0.011144},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.0,"rationale":"以社区食堂写空巢老人，题旨集中，杯箸冷与灯火暖对照有效，起承转合完整。然炊烟、白发、灯火皆熟象，语言平顺少诗眼；结句'即家乡'说破主旨，且暗承苏轼'此心安处是吾乡'，余味与出新均受限。","_cost":0.024246},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.3,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.3,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"空巢与社区食堂对照真切有主脑，炊烟灯火意象暖而妥帖但较常见，语言平实自然少诗眼，起承转合清晰，结句以灯火收束稳当稍显直白。","_cost":0.0069985},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"此作聚焦社区食堂对空巢老人的温情慰藉，立意真切有当代温度，起承转合圆顺，语言平实，意象妥帖但偏常见，结句稳当稍直，无硬伤蹈袭，当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":null}},"consensus":71.19,"final":71.19},{"key":"ox-alpha|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"扶摇直上夜初凉，俯瞰云涛接渺茫。河汉翻疑倾地底，冰轮不觉到舷旁。车川滚滚流金液，雾岛沉沉泊远航。遥指人间烟火处，其中一点是吾乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.1,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.9,"rationale":"夜航俯视车流而归于乡思，主脑清楚；天地倒置、车川流金颇见新意。雾岛句语意稍涩，扶摇、冰轮等略熟。结句具体含情，虽稍直白仍有余韵。","_cost":0.008328},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰翻转天地视角,颔联河汉倾地底、冰轮到舷旁想象奇警,颈联车川流金以今象入诗见新意,中二联天上地下开合有致。结句归乡收束温厚但'烟火''吾乡'稍熟,近于说破,余味略减。整体当代经验化古得体。","_cost":0.04334},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"该诗将夜航现代体验完美融入七律。章法严密，颔联写天际，颈联转写地面，“流金液”状城市夜景极妙。尾联由万家灯火收束于思乡之情，脉络贯通，意境开阔而不失温情。","_cost":0.017316},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰收束乡思，主脑清楚而角度不新。颔颈取象较活，车川金液能融今入古。结句点破“吾乡”，余味不足。套语密度中等，未见整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.023096},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"夜航由天及地、天地开合，中二联有层次，尾联结归吾乡。立意常见且结句点破，余味有限；意象壮阔统一，颔联为佳，但“扶摇”“人间烟火”等偏熟。无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":0.01169652},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰是当代经验入诗的成功之作：以飞行视角重造河汉、冰轮、车流、雾岛诸象，物象与高空情味交融，颔联'倾地底''到舷旁'尤为精切。章法起承转合完备，尾联由景入情自然，惟'其中一点是吾乡'稍近说破，余味略减。'人间烟火'微熟。","_cost":0.00276576},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.35,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰由云汉写入间，颔联错觉生动，颈联灯火有现代感；然烟火、吾乡等语略熟，尾联说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.016102},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"夜航高空视角较新，颔联星河倾地、冰轮近舷意象精切有气势；颈联'流金液'略生硬。尾联归乡题旨常见，结句'是吾乡'直说兜底，余味受损。整体章法贯通，当代经验入诗有效。","_cost":0.0071028},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.7,"余味":6.6,"警句":1.2,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"高空夜航视角带出新体验，中二联分写天光与灯川层次清晰，以一点乡灯收束；但扶摇云涛河汉冰轮等语较陈，雾岛泊航搭配微拗，结句直点余韵稍浅。","_cost":0.0083495},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"此作以夜航机俯瞰视角写乡思，主脑明晰，章法俯仰开合、脉络顺畅，意象贴合、语言平顺，唯结句稍直白，部分意象偏熟，无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":72.1,"final":72.1},{"key":"ox-alpha|社区食堂|七律","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"晨曦漫过旧街坊，一缕炊烟出灶房。素菜两元随客取，荤汤三块任翁尝。杯盘虽小人情厚，灯火可亲滋味长。莫道寻常茶饭淡，此中真意胜膏粱。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.3,"余味":4.4,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗有现实温度，价格细节具体。炊烟、灯火与人情相融，但措辞多熟套，“杯盘虽小”欠精准；章法完整，结句直陈真意，略显说尽。","_cost":0.006506},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.5,"rationale":"题材切当代民生,颔联以'两元''三块'具体入诗见真切,是全篇亮点。惟颈联'人情厚''滋味长'落套语,尾联'莫道…此中真意胜膏粱'议论说破,直白兜底无留白。章法完整而转结平直,意象多沿炊烟灯火旧径。","_cost":0.03475},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.5,"rationale":"题材切近现代生活，结构完整平稳。但通篇偏于白话直陈，缺乏炼字与意境营造。后半首“人情厚”及尾联“胜膏粱”全为直白议论，说破兜底，毫无留白与余味。","_cost":0.018794},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.25,"rationale":"社区食堂入题有当下感，颔联价格写实稍见人情；然炊烟灯火膏粱等套象密集，结句点破真意，劝世过显，余味薄、转笔平。","_cost":0.01729},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.65,"rationale":"立意具体但角度平常；意象温暖妥帖；语言平实少诗眼；章法完整平直；结句说理略露。‘杯盘’联稍佳，社区题材有当代感，惟‘真意’化用显熟。无硬伤，意象略陈。","_cost":0.01958484},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":62.75,"rationale":"当代社区食堂入诗，选材切时，颔联以\"两元\"\"三块\"写实见生活气，中二联层次清楚。但立意止于正面颂扬，无更深掘进；尾联\"莫道\"\"胜膏粱\"议论说破，直白兜底；\"人情厚\"\"滋味长\"\"此中真意\"皆熟语连缀，余味受限。","_cost":0.00273936},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"取材社区食堂，价格细节有生活温度，主脑明确；但意象偏常，议论直白，尾句说破，少余味。‘灯火可亲’稍暖，语多熟套。","_cost":0.009926},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":58.5,"rationale":"社区食堂入七律,菜价数字鲜活,题旨集中有人情味;但尾联直说'真意胜膏粱',说破无留白,'此中真意'近陶句,'荤汤任翁'逻辑稍偏,通体温稳而少警策。","_cost":0.0128088},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.7,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.3,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.050000000000004,"rationale":"题材切近民生、价格细节具体有真意，但立论直白少翻新；烟火意象统一而平实，语言通顺少锤炼，章法递进平直，结句以理兜底少余味。","_cost":0.0083045},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"此作咏当代社区食堂，主旨明确，意象贴合烟火氛围，语言平实通顺，章法平稳连贯；但角度寻常，结句直白少余味，略有熟套，以民生新事入诗尚有新意。","_cost":null}},"consensus":61.45,"final":61.45},{"key":"ox-alpha|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"又见春街移大树，柔条低亚小银瓶。生来不惯城中土，梦里家山几度青。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.85000000000001,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶写城市移植与乡土眷恋，物我相通，主脑鲜明。前二句摄景，后二句转入树之梦境，收束自然。“小银瓶”颇新鲜；“梦里家山”略熟，直抒稍减含蓄。","_cost":0.005488},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.25,"rationale":"以移栽大树挂吊瓶这一当代街景入诗,借树喻人写离土漂泊之痛,立意新切有寄托。'低亚小银瓶'取象精微,转句拟人自然,结句以梦中家山之青宕开,言尽意不尽。'家山梦'意象稍熟,微扣陈滥。","_cost":0.03631},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"以城市“大树打吊瓶”的当代经验入诗，借树之水土不服暗写游子迁徙之悲，立意出新。起承写实，转结入虚赋予人格，结句“梦里家山”宕开一笔，余韵悠长，现代意象与古典情怀交融无痕。","_cost":0.023514},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"吊瓶移树有当下感，银瓶意象精切，乡思拟人可感。题旨环保常见，转句稍露，结句点破梦境余味有限。无典故硬伤。","_cost":0.015372},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.4,"语言":8.1,"章法":7.6,"余味":8.7,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.35,"rationale":"移大树挂吊瓶拟人写乡愁，角度新且聚焦；后二句家山意象略熟；低亚、小银瓶炼字精准；结构稳妥；结句以梦景留白，余味佳。","_cost":0.01259412},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"移树吊瓶这一当代街景入诗，借病树寄乡愁，熟题翻出新意。'低亚'炼字见功，银瓶与柔条物象精切。三句转入树之不惯城中土，脉络贯注，结以梦里家山之青，以景结情，余味悠长。后二句稍直白但情事具体。","_cost":0.00260036},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.9,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.3,"rationale":"移树吊瓶入诗，取材新而情志明确；小银瓶有画面。转以城中土引出家山，脉络顺，但梦语稍熟，结意略直。","_cost":0.010494},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"以街头移栽大树挂输液瓶起兴,拟人化写树之乡思,当代经验入诗自然贴切,题旨集中有主脑。银瓶意象新奇,'低亚'炼字见功;转句由物及情,结句以'家山几度青'宕开,言尽意不尽。唯'家山'语稍熟,整体陈意不重。","_cost":0.0094188},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.4,"rationale":"以吊瓶大树喻水土不服，借当代城移之景作乡愁异化隐喻，主脑集中；物象精切情景交融，转结以梦青留白，经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.00826575},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"以当代街头移树挂吊瓶的日常场景托物寄意，暗合离乡入城者共情，起承转合顺畅，取象贴切，唯结句稍直，家山意象略熟。","_cost":null}},"consensus":81.22,"final":81.22},{"key":"ox-alpha|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"夜半灯浮货垒明，枪光掠处码齐鸣。人间千里凭双臂，送到天涯未识名。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.1,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":0.7,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.05,"rationale":"聚焦夜班仓工，以灯、货垒、扫码枪写当代劳动，转结由操作推向无名奉献。取象新鲜，首联可感；“码齐鸣”稍硬，“未识名”主语略含混。结句留有身份隐没之余味。","_cost":0.00512},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"以云仓夜班快递分拣入诗,当代经验入绝句而不生硬,立意聚焦无名劳动者,情事具体。'枪光掠处码齐鸣'化扫码枪入诗颇巧。转句'凭双臂'稍直,结句点破'未识名'感慨真切但留白略欠,余味稍减。","_cost":0.03934},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"本作成功将“云仓扫码”等当代经验入诗。“枪光掠处码齐鸣”声光交织，取象生动精切；转结由近及远，将流水线劳作升华为对底层劳动者“送到天涯未识名”的悲悯，起承转合自然流转，时代气息浓厚。","_cost":0.014276},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"云仓夜班入七绝，灯浮枪掠码鸣取象尚切。后联由景入议，点明无名劳作，题旨清而角度常见。结句说破，收得住少留白。当代经验入诗算出新。","_cost":0.018232},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.25,"rationale":"写云仓夜扫，聚焦无名劳动者，转结有力；现代意象真切但语言略生硬，'码齐鸣'稍凑；结句留白可味。","_cost":0.01037256},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"云仓夜班扫货入诗，当代经验真切可感，立意聚焦无名劳动者，主脑分明。起承景语精切，'码齐鸣'以声写扫码，转句宕开至'人间千里'，结句'未识名'收束有延宕。语言大体妥帖，'码齐鸣'稍显生硬，余多平稳。","_cost":0.00242896},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.1,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.2,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.35000000000001,"rationale":"夜仓扫码入诗，声光细节新颖，末转劳动者无名，有现实温度；但后二句议论偏直，稍损余味。","_cost":0.009208},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"快递夜扫题材入七绝，'枪光''码鸣'取象鲜活，当代经验转化有效；'人间千里凭双臂'有筋骨。然'无名奉献'主旨仍属常见，结句'未识名'稍直露，余韵欠宕开，整体立意高而炼字未臻精警。","_cost":0.0059478},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.1,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.2,"rationale":"夜半货垒与枪光扫码物象新切，后联由近及远以双臂托千里收于无名，结构完整转结有力，悲悯含蓄不作说教。","_cost":0.00755265},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.8,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"此作聚焦当代云仓分拣劳动者，炼字精准，场景写实，章法顺畅；主旨偏传统，结句稍直白，新材入诗自然，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭问题。","_cost":null}},"consensus":75.63,"final":75.63},{"key":"ox-alpha|深夜视频|七律","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"夜深独对寸屏明，远道容颜扑面清。白发新添浑未觉，童音渐改乍相惊。千山不隔眉间语，一线能牵梦里情。挂罢荧然成暗镜，依稀霜色鬓边生。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.7,"章法":8.8,"余味":9.1,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.2,"陈滥":0.7,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.14999999999999,"rationale":"视频通话写亲情与岁月，情事具体而主脑集中。明屏转暗镜、见他人白发而惊自身霜鬓，转结尤佳；“扑面清”“梦里情”稍泛，“荧然成暗镜”略涩。","_cost":0.00754},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"视频通话入律,当代经验有效化古。颔联白发童音对照具体可感,结联黑屏成暗镜、照见己鬓霜色,宕开有余味,为全篇警策。颈联千山一线、梦里情稍落熟套,炼字中平,整体脉络清晰完足。","_cost":0.03299},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"本诗将当代“视频通话”经验巧妙入诗。首联切题，中二联抒发岁月之叹与跨越千山的亲情，尾联挂断后“成暗镜”照见自身鬓霜，极具敏锐的生活体察，以景结情且首尾呼应。唯颈联语言稍落熟套。整体情真意切，余味悠长。","_cost":0.020004},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"视频见衰与暗镜自照情事具体，结句较有余味；颈联千山一线套语，转意平直，意象新旧杂陈，稳妥未翻新境。","_cost":0.020846},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.9,"rationale":"写视频通话而归于自见鬓霜，结句以暗镜收束，含蓄有味；中二联对仗工整，但“梦里情”“千山”等略熟，语言偶有生新未稳处。","_cost":0.01404741},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.75,"rationale":"视频通话入律诗，当代经验与旧体格律浑融。颔联白发未觉、童音乍惊，情事具体真切；结联挂断后屏幕成暗镜、照见己身霜鬓，以物象收情，宕开有味。中二联虚实开合，'千山''一线'对举精切。'扑面清'稍露，'梦里情'微熟，瑕不掩瑜。","_cost":0.00226116},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.8,"rationale":"以寸屏、暗镜写深夜视频，白发童音细节真切，颔联最动人；颈联稍熟，尾联转以黑屏映鬓收束，情在景中。","_cost":0.011362},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"以深夜视频写亲情与岁月流逝，'白发未觉''童音乍惊'具体可感；'一线'双关网络与牵系，结句屏熄成暗镜、照见己之霜鬓，以景结情余味最长。颈联'千山不隔'略熟，整体章法贯通，当代经验入诗自然不猎奇。","_cost":0.0115932},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.6,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.7,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.4,"rationale":"以寸屏视频切入亲情与流年，白发童音细节真切；明暗对照，章法贯注，尾联暗镜霜色以景结情，当代物象入律自然。","_cost":0.0111775},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.8,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.35,"rationale":"此作写深夜异地视频的亲情感触，细节真切，脉络通顺，结句以屏暗映鬓霜留白有余味，唯颈联表意稍熟，当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":null}},"consensus":81.7,"final":81.7},{"key":"ox-alpha|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"危楼列架接穹苍，万盏灯花竟夕光。智械无声穿巷陌，红绡一线扫盈箱。箧中各贮天涯念，屏上同销子夜长。晓别云仓人影瘦，满城犹在黑甜乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.05000000000001,"rationale":"云仓夜作与满城酣睡形成鲜明对照，主脑集中，场景推进清楚，结联尤有余韵。智械、红线入诗颇新；“穹苍”“天涯念”等稍泛，“竟夕光”略显凝涩。","_cost":0.008314},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.25,"rationale":"以电商云仓夜班入诗,当代经验有效落地,主脑清晰。颈联'箧中各贮天涯念'由物及情颇见巧思,红绡一线状扫码亦切。'智械'稍显生硬,'灯花''黑甜乡'略陈。结句以满城酣睡反衬人影瘦,含社会关怀而不说破,余味尚佳。","_cost":0.0422},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"本诗将现代物流云仓作业完美融入律诗。以“红绡一线”喻扫码激光极具匠心；颈联写快递寄托的人情，尾联以夜班工人清瘦与满城沉睡作结，对比强烈。当代经验入诗且无违和，立意与语言俱佳。","_cost":0.016364},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"云仓夜班入律，智械红绡有时代感，劳逸对照成篇。灯花巷陌用词未安，人影瘦稍直，平稳少警策。","_cost":0.018486},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"以云仓夜劳入七律,题旨独到,情事具体。中二联开合有层次:颔联写智械穿巷、红绡扫箱之景,颈联转入'箧贮天涯念'之思,将包裹拟作远人牵挂,是全篇诗眼。结以'人影瘦'对'黑甜乡'作对照,以社会反差收束,言尽意不尽。'红绡一线'稍晦,通篇炼字稳当。","_cost":0.00306316},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"现代云仓夜班题材有新意，中二联由作业转情思，结以满城沉睡反衬，余味足。语言偶有熟套如黑甜乡、灯花，但红绡一线、人影瘦有表现力。","_cost":0.013486814},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.1,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.4,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.85,"rationale":"云仓夜扫取材新，能借智械、屏影、包裹写出寄远之思，章法完整，结以城市沉睡反衬有余味。但灯花、天涯、黑甜等语偏熟，红绡一线稍隔，炼字未臻浑成。","_cost":0.018948},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫写现代物流与天涯相思，人机对照成境，结以满城沉睡留白；唯危楼、灯花、红绡略隔，中二联开合稍平。","_cost":0.0105348},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.9,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.65,"rationale":"现代云仓夜作切口，颔联红绡扫箱精准，颈联天涯念点睛，机器与人情对位，尾联以众眠衬独瘦，层次分明余韵长。","_cost":0.01366025},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"此作咏云仓夜班劳作，主脑明晰，脉络顺畅，能融当代物流经验入旧体，颈联较佳；唯部分意象稍晦，结句偏直，略有熟语。","_cost":null}},"consensus":76.54,"final":76.54},{"key":"ox-alpha|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"ox-alpha","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"春街万树尽悬壶，点滴朝朝注弱株。碧袋低垂银线细，琼浆暗度嫩皮濡。参天古木何曾灌，匝地新栽却倩扶。园叟巡行勤换液，笑言来岁满城苏。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.3,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.7,"警句":2.4,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.89999999999999,"rationale":"“吊瓶”入诗颇新，悬壶、点滴、换液一线贯通，中二联由细描转古今树势对照；“琼浆”“满城苏”略熟，末句直揭希望，收束完整而余味稍浅。","_cost":0.009484},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"以街树输液的当代景观入诗，'悬壶'双关巧妙，颈联古木不灌、新栽倩扶暗含讽喻，是全篇亮点。中二联铺陈具体但意象偏于说明性，'嫩皮濡'稍硬凑。尾联园叟笑言把话说满，收束直白少留白，损余味。题材出新可取。","_cost":0.03645},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"题材切入当代生活，以“悬壶”双关入诗，出新极佳。然全篇偏于客观纪实，颈联对比略平，结句直白兜底，缺乏留白与余味。","_cost":0.025714},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"吊瓶入律有现场，颈联新旧开合清楚；然“万树尽悬”与“古木何曾灌”抵牾，结句“满城苏”说破，琼浆参天略套，炼字平稳少眼。","_cost":0.02152},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"以城市树木打吊瓶入诗，题材新且情事具体，主脑清晰。中二联实写与对比开合有致，颈联尤见思理。结句借园叟之口收束，稍直白但有余韵。语言锤炼见诗眼而不露斧凿。","_cost":0.00390588},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"以城市行道树输营养液入诗，题新而情实。'悬壶'双关医树，妙手偶得；颔联摹写细切，颈联古木新栽对比生慨，脉路清晰。尾联借园叟笑言直陈愿景，收束稳当但说尽，余味稍薄。","_cost":0.00235156},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.9,"rationale":"写春街树挂吊瓶，取材新颖，细节真切；颔联描摹工细，颈联以古木新栽相衬；结句园叟笑语稍显直白，余味不深。","_cost":0.015332},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"以输液喻护树，都市新景入诗且主脑集中；意象成系统而“琼浆”“嫩皮”略造，结句直抒来岁，余蕴有限。","_cost":0.0204282},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.6,"余味":6.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.45,"rationale":"以街树吊瓶切入当代经验，颈联古木/新栽对照立主脑；颔联摹形精切，章法起承转合分明，唯全篇偏纪实写景、末句展望直白，换液等语稍白。","_cost":0.00924575},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.5,"rationale":"此诗写街树输营养液的当代城市场景，结构平顺、语言通顺，能以旧喻写新事，但立意平浅，表意偏直，余味不足，少量用词稍俗，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":72.93,"final":72.93},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"半旧衣衫叠未残,投箱一响铁声寒。余温尚带三冬暖,此去他乡认亦难。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.9,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.55,"rationale":"旧衣回收写物缘离散，题材新而情感具体；“一响铁声寒”以声传情，转结由余温写向他乡。章法清楚，末句有惘然余味；“叠未残”“三冬暖”稍显涩滞。","_cost":0.00512},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"当代题材入绝句而不生硬,以衣拟人寄惜别之情,主脑集中。'铁声寒'与'余温暖'冷暖相激,是全篇眼目。结句宕开,人衣两茫,余味悠长。惟'三冬暖'措语稍熟,第三句略近直陈,炼字尚可再进。","_cost":0.03035},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"当代物象入诗有效,铁声之寒与余温之暖对照见情,结句“认亦难”留有想象。惟“叠未残”稍生硬,“三冬暖”偏熟,整体尚欠一句真正动人之诗眼。","_cost":0.04002},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"当代经验入诗贴切。以'铁声寒'衬托旧衣'余温'之暖，冷暖对比精巧，情事具体可感。起承转合流畅。结句流露对旧物去向的淡淡怅惘，虽略显直白，但不失温情与余味。","_cost":0.018614},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"惜旧衣主题常见，铁寒与余温对照尚能融为清冷氛围。语言通顺有声响亮点但锤炼不足。起承尚顺、转结平直。结句点破去向，言尽少不尽。回收箱为今事入诗。","_cost":0.022648},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.3,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.05,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱题材见当代日常新意，情思具体；“铁声寒”与“余温暖”对比精切，物象统一。转结自然，但结句偏议论略露，“三冬暖”稍陈套。警句“投箱一响铁声寒”较佳。","_cost":0.00343596},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.5,"rationale":"以回收箱入诗，当代经验化古自然。铁声寒与三冬暖冷暖相激，叠衣、投箱、余温、他乡层层递进，脉络贯通。结句认亦难不点破谁认，物我双关留白。认亦难稍直白，语言整体妥帖而诗眼略欠惊警。","_cost":0.0035018},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.6,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.15,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，铁声寒与余温暖相映，当代题材有生活实感；结句略直白，语言小有生硬，余味未尽。","_cost":0.01171},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"旧衣回收入诗,题新而情真。铁声之寒与余温之暖对照成境,转结设想衣物远赴他乡、再难相认,以物写别,余味绵长。惜\"三冬暖\"近熟语,\"叠未残\"略生硬,字句尚欠精纯。","_cost":0.021819},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.1,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.6,"章法":6.9,"余味":6.2,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.45,"rationale":"以回收箱切入当代日常，铁寒与余温对照见人情，立意新切；意象妥帖章法平稳，语言平实少诗眼，结句直抒余味稍浅。","_cost":0.00920675},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"以回收箱入诗，当代经验入诗（出新）。'铁声寒'与'三冬暖'冷暖对照，炼字精警，立意翻新。起承完整，转句对比稍平，意象略常见抽象。结句宕开他乡，余味不尽。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.033409092},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"以当代旧衣回收箱入诗，抓取投箱瞬间冷暖细节寄寓淡怅，立意真切，章法顺承；唯“余温”与“暖”略有复义，结句稍直，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.95,"rationale":"现代生活经验入诗自然得体。“铁声寒”听觉通感精切，冷硬铁箱与衣物余温对比鲜明。承转自然，结句宕开至他乡流转，微含怅惘与善念，余味充足，唯“三冬暖”略有陈套。","_cost":0.0054075},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"回收箱切入旧衣捐赠，铁寒与余暖对照见惜物温情，主脑集中；意象略熟，结句认亦难稍拗而留匿名捐赠之怅惘。","_cost":0.0122115},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"以投箱铁响对照衣上余温，惜物之情具体可感，回收场景入诗自然。“叠未残”稍显凑合，“认亦难”所指含混；转结完整，但他乡难认之意未能充分深化。","_cost":0.03205},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.8,"余味":6.4,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.7,"rationale":"以未残旧衣投入回收箱，情事具体，主脑是不舍与失认。铁声寒与余温冷暖相形，意象能承情。语言顺达，‘一响’较切，‘三冬’‘他乡’偏熟。起承转合清楚，第三句转暖；结句直陈难认，留白不足。","_cost":0.0153312}},"consensus":76.78,"final":76.78},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|机场送别|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"安检门前话未休，茫茫背影没人流。荧屏忽换航班字，已起长天一点浮。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.7,"意境":7.2,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.6,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"送别旧题落在安检、荧屏与航班，情境具体；由背影、屏显推向长天，转结有层次，末句留白。惟“茫茫背影没人流”“航班字”“一点浮”略涩，情志仍较常见。","_cost":0.008284},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.5,"rationale":"安检、荧屏、航班等当代经验有效入诗，起承转合分明：话别未休、背影没入、屏显起飞、长天一点，层层推进。结句化李白孤帆远影之意而出新境，以景结情有余味。'没人流'炼字见功，'一点浮'稍欠稳，通篇脉络贯注，是熟题翻新之作。","_cost":0.0381},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"以安检门、人流、荧屏、长天一点串起送别时序，当代经验入诗自然，起承转合清晰，结句以景收束有余味。惟“荧屏忽换航班字”偏于叙述，“已起长天一点浮”句法稍滞，情感深度尚欠。","_cost":0.04407},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"本诗将机场送别经验完美融入绝句。起承转合自然，意象（安检、荧屏）切题且与离情交融。结句“已起长天一点浮”化用古意以景结情，余味悠长，是当代生活有效入诗的佳作。","_cost":0.011718},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"送别熟题，机场细节具体却乏独到发现。近远意象尚能交融成氛围。语言通顺偏叙述，‘一点浮’略有炼意。章法按时序推进，转结平稳。结句以景收束有余韵。当代场景入诗有效。","_cost":0.023398},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.5,"rationale":"以现代机场送别入诗，焦点集中；意象精切，景中藏情；‘没人流’‘一点浮’炼字有力，结句以景收束，余韵不散。","_cost":0.0052338},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.5,"rationale":"以机场安检入送别，当代经验有效入诗。四句依话别、影没、屏换、机远层层递进，脉络一气。结句以长天一点收束，以景结情，暗接孤帆远影而不袭其语，余味悠长。“没人流”炼字见巧。","_cost":0.0031944},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.1,"rationale":"机场细节真切，荧屏换字与长天一点形成有效转结，余味较好；但语词稍平，情志未深，略有常见离别套语。","_cost":0.009514},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"现代送别聚焦安检—人流—荧屏—长天，情事具体，收束于一点机影，有余韵；然熟题未大翻，“茫茫背影”“航班字”略硬，意象犹借旧送别。","_cost":0.0208932},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.05,"rationale":"送别常题借安检门、荧屏等当代物象翻出现场感，时空递进章法贯通，以一点浮景结情余韵不尽，唯立意未出新境个别语略泛。","_cost":0.006755},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"以安检、荧屏等当代意象写送别，结句'一点浮'化孤帆远影、以景结情，有余味；惟立意常见，转稍平直，语有白话杂糅。加警句、出新，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.026527171},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"以当代机场场景写送别熟题，起承转合圆顺，以景结情有余韵，意象贴合，语言平实有亮点，状快节奏时代送别之仓促怅惘，无硬伤套话。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.0,"rationale":"现代机场经验入诗自然无隔。章法如镜头推移，由门前执手、人流隐没，转至荧屏变动、长空远送。结句以极简景语收束，目送神驰，余味深长。","_cost":0.00333075},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.25,"rationale":"送别题旨明而角度常见，背影人海陈套；荧屏句白话直陈，一点浮炼字欠安；转接跳跃，唯末句远景收束略有余味。","_cost":0.01214555},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.25,"rationale":"送别题旨常见，安检、荧屏使情事具体；由话未休至长天一点，距离渐远，结尾以景留情。荧屏换字推进自然，但“茫茫背影”搭配欠准，“已起”与“浮”衔接略涩。","_cost":0.04087},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"题旨明确而角度常见,情事尚具体。意象递远成境,结句以一点浮留白。“航班字”生硬,末句紧拗,转接偏直。当代场景入诗有效,套语不多,无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0251952}},"consensus":76.56,"final":76.56},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|机场送别|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"明窗如水隔阴晴，铁翼冲霄万里行。半世牵萦随箧去，频回一顾没潮平。云端日出人犹夜，腕上钟针各自更。独抱余温归旧路，孤星渐远认长庚。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.6,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":0.7,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.7,"rationale":"以时差与钟针写离别，新意具体；颈联尤佳，情景递进自然。通篇主脉清晰，尾联有余韵，但“没潮平”稍涩，“认长庚”略显着意。","_cost":0.006538},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"熟题送别以时差经验翻新，'云端日出人犹夜，腕上钟针各自更'将现代空旅感受入诗且工稳可诵，为全篇警联。结句以孤星长庚宕开收束，余味悠长。惟'没潮平'意象稍隔，'铁翼冲霄'略近习语，气脉整体贯通。","_cost":0.04832},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"以时差入诗，颈联“云端日出人犹夜，腕上钟针各自更”将现代经验化为新警句，构思独到。结句以机灯渐远误认长庚收束，以景结情有余味。惟“铁翼冲霄”略套，“没潮平”稍晦，炼字未尽精。","_cost":0.05829},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"成功将机场送别、时差等现代经验化入律诗。颈联写跨洋飞行的时空错位极佳，出新且贴切；结句以远去机灯拟长庚星，景中见情，余味悠长。","_cost":0.027508},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"熟题机场送别，半世时差具体但未深翻新。意象现代入诗尚可，潮平稍隔。语言颈联、余温有炼。章法转时差层次平。结孤星认长庚景结留味。颈联佳。无硬伤袭用，铁翼稍套。","_cost":0.027558},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"时差一联警策，结句以景留白；送别情思具体。然“没潮平”生涩，部分意象近套，整体中上。","_cost":0.01579908},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"送别熟题以机场时差翻出新境，半世牵萦随箧去见巧思。颈联以日出钟针写时差，景语情语交融，为诗眼。结句余温长庚以景结情留白佳。长庚为昏星而诗境人犹夜，星象稍疑但可通，铁翼略硬，万里行稍熟。","_cost":0.00446964},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.4,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"送别题旨集中，能以铁翼、钟针、时差等新象写离情，颈联有巧思，结句以星收束留余味；但“没潮平”等语稍晦，部分词语偏常，意境略受影响。","_cost":0.013616},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"机场送别为当代经验入旧体之佳例：'随箧去''没潮平'情事具体，颈联'云端日出人犹夜，腕上钟针各自更'以时差写离别，摘出仍动人。结句以孤星认长庚宕开，余韵足。惜'没潮平'略滞涩，'万里行'稍熟，整体立意尚属常见亲情框架，未臻独造。","_cost":0.0171948},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.95,"rationale":"当代机场送别题材切实，时差意象翻新熟题；结构由送行-时空错位-独归层进，转结自然，尾句以星喻机含蓄有余味。","_cost":0.00805375},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"机场时差翻新旧题，‘云端/腕上’成警句；起承转合稳。‘潮平’景隔、‘长庚’拂晓名实微误，意象稍陈而情真。","_cost":0.041222225},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.2,"rationale":"此作写机场送别，融跨时差等当代经验，章法流转，颈联新巧，炼字妥帖，以景结有余味；唯少量语词略熟，抒情未脱传统离思常轨。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.4,"rationale":"当代经验入诗典范。颈联以时差写跨洋远别，构思精警极具现代感。通篇情意真挚，章法转折开合有度。微疵在“没潮平”略显牵强，晨昏星象（启明与长庚）常识略见龃龉。","_cost":0.0063045},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"当代时差经验入诗，颈联佳；半世牵萦空泛，潮平、认长庚费解小疵；结构由送到想到归尚贯，结以星景宕开留味。","_cost":0.0135925},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"以时差写离情，“云端日出人犹夜”有新意；“随箧去”“抱余温”使情意具体。章法顺畅，但“频回一顾没潮平”语意不畅、取象突兀，结句星影与机影的转换稍显勉强。","_cost":0.06264},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"送别借机场时差翻出新境，半世入箧、余温旧路，情志能收束。颈联「云端日出」「腕上钟针」是佳联。结句孤星认长庚，未说破。弱在第四句晦涩、「铁翼冲霄」近套，视点微跳。","_cost":0.0238912}},"consensus":78.38,"final":78.38},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"绿箧街隅夜色寒，匆匆投下敝衣单。余温犹贴肩头软，旧线曾承十指酸。此去关河千里隔，天涯身量与谁宽。殊途授受浑难问，一样人间冷暖看。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"weak"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.1,"余味":6.7,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.35,"rationale":"以旧衣流转写陌生人间的劳苦与温情，取材新且主脑集中。颔联细腻有力，冷暖相映；颈联宕开。惟“身量与谁宽”稍涩，末句偏于点题说破，关河、天涯略熟。","_cost":0.006972},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.75,"rationale":"以当代旧衣回收入律,题材新而情真。颔联'余温''旧线'具体可感,由物及人;结句借衣之冷暖双关人间冷暖,收得有味但稍近说破。'关河''天涯'略袭旧语,颈联想象宕开有致,全篇脉络贯通,属化古出新之佳作。","_cost":0.03892},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，当代经验有效化古：颔联余温、旧线由物及人细腻可感，颈联“身量与谁宽”一问宕开有想象。惟关河千里、天涯稍落套，结句“冷暖”双关而近说破，余味略减。","_cost":0.05804},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"当代事物入诗自然，起承转合严密。由投衣之举细腻描摹旧衣余温，转而想象远方受赠者，结于人间冷暖之思。情真意切，语言平易动人，虽结句略偏说理，仍属难得佳作。","_cost":0.015208},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"回收箱写衣物余温远授，情事具体有主脑。颔联较切，关河天涯意象熟套。语言偶炼余平。由近及远层次清。结句点破冷暖过直。当代物事微新，无硬伤。","_cost":0.024582},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"从旧衣回收箱切入，情感具体，颔联尤佳；后半议论偏多，颈联略涩，结句直白，减分主要在余味与陈套意象。","_cost":0.00632808},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"捐衣旧题翻出新意，旧衣连缀缝者与受者两端，主脑清晰。颔联'余温贴肩、旧线承酸'由物及人，最见功力。'冷暖'双关收结虽稍近说破，仍有余响。'身量与谁宽'炼字奇而不稳，'关河千里'略熟。","_cost":0.0037596},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.05,"rationale":"选题当代，绿箧旧衣切入有生活实感。颔联余温旧线体贴入微，颈联身量一问有情。惜尾联‘人间冷暖’说破，关河天涯稍熟，余味减。","_cost":0.013688},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入七律,角度新而情真:颔联'余温''旧线'由物及人,颈联'身量与谁宽'扣衣扣情,脉络由投而忆而想而叹,一气贯通。惜尾联'人间冷暖'径直点题,虽借双关稍留余韵,仍近乎说破;'关河''天涯'略熟。","_cost":0.015774},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.1,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.7,"章法":7.8,"余味":5.6,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.64999999999999,"rationale":"回收箱切入当代匿名授受，以余温针线串联投忆想悟，章法贯通；颔联贴切有味，末句议论兜底稍直，意象未臻景情浑融。","_cost":0.01314825},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入律，角度新颖，情事具体；颔联触觉细腻、佳联动人。中二联层次分明而颈联句法稍散，结句‘人间冷暖’稍直白，略见‘关河’‘天涯’陈语，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.029757641},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.6,"章法":7.3,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.8,"rationale":"选取当代旧衣回收箱入诗，从投衣细节寄寓普通人的冷暖共情，炼字细腻，章法顺畅，惟结句稍直，个别意象略熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.9,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.9,"rationale":"当代日常经验入诗极佳。由投衣忆往推及远方受者，“天涯身量与谁宽”体贴入微、情真意切，章法脉络井然，将琐事写出普遍冷暖。结句略偏直白说破，余味稍逊。","_cost":0.00520575},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"借回收箱写匿名授受，余温十指具体可感，主脑在冷暖；投衣追忆遥想层次贯通，惜尾联说理直露，关河天涯稍套。","_cost":0.01540655},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.1,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.85,"rationale":"旧衣牵连施受两端，当代题材融入具体温情；“旧线曾承十指酸”有质感。由余温转想远方，层次清楚；“身量与谁宽”语意欠顺，“殊途授受”偏硬，结句归于冷暖通论，留白不足。","_cost":0.04171},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"弃衣入箱，余温与针线之劳具体可感，立意有主脑。意象前密后疏，关河天涯冷暖落套。语言「承」「酸」「宽」有炼，而「肩头软」与尾联偏软偏直。章法由近及远清楚，结处重复问意并说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.0390544}},"consensus":75.33,"final":75.33},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"满匣绒娃灯下妍，铜圆几掷爪空悬。才提半路偏松力，一落人间不值钱。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.7,"警句":3.6,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"抓取失败的瞬间写得具体，并由娃娃身价翻出人世价值反讽，主脑鲜明。四句递进利落，转结有力；“铜圆”“松力”稍显硬凑，结句“不值钱”略说破。","_cost":0.005704},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.5,"rationale":"以娃娃机入诗,当代经验有效化用。前两句铺陈具象,第三句'才提半路偏松力'转得巧,结句'一落人间不值钱'双关身世之慨,言外有讽有悲,是全篇警策。惟结句意稍说破,'铜圆'指代游戏币微欠精准,故略扣。","_cost":0.03879},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入诗，物象具体，第三句“才提半路偏松力”转得有致，结句“一落人间不值钱”由物及人，带讽喻双关。惟“铜圆”略生硬，“偏松力”造语稍拗，结句意思几近说破，余味有限。当代经验入诗有效，可加出新分。","_cost":0.05671},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":9.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"该诗以“抓娃娃机”这一现代场景入诗，起承转合自然流畅。前三句写实入微，结句“一落人间不值钱”陡然升华，道出欲望与现实的价值落差，极富哲理，当代经验化用极为成功。","_cost":0.018502},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"以娃娃机写求而不得、得亦不贵，主脑清楚、情事具体。然文白夹杂，「不值钱」过白说破；半路松爪与落人间事理未洽。出新在题材，炼字余味不足。","_cost":0.029548},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写当代经验，末句双关成诗眼，意象统一、转结自然；立意稍偏机巧，结句议论略直，深度有限。","_cost":0.00639078},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入诗，俗题翻出哲思：末句'一落人间不值钱'由物及人，状理想半途坠落、入世即贬值的怅惘，双关宕开，言尽意不尽。起承转合完整，'偏松力'的'偏'字见诗眼。意象稍集中于一事，氛围略窄，故意境语言稍抑。","_cost":0.00209156},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.15,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入诗，细节具体，起承转合清晰；“半路松力”传神。惜结句“不值钱”说破，余味稍减，语言略直。当代题材有新意，无明显硬伤。","_cost":0.010244},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"以娃娃机写欲望的吊诡:未得时光艳,到手即贬值,题旨聚焦且有讽世意味。四句起承转合利落,'偏'字抓准机器猫腻,'一落人间'双关得巧,结句翻出新意而留有余思。稍嫌叙事多于氛围,意象偏实,'铜圆'略隔。","_cost":0.0153726},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.4,"余味":5.9,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.3,"rationale":"以娃娃机喻执念与价值幻觉，小题大做主脑突出；起承转合分明，过程即隐喻，结句直断“不值钱”稍显说破。","_cost":0.009052},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入诗，当代经验有出新。起承转合尚清，第三句“才提半路偏松力”生动传神。然结句“不值钱”说破直白，且“落人间”与娃娃落回匣中逻辑微舛。意象妥帖欠交融，语言文白夹杂。","_cost":0.032009365},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.0,"rationale":"此作以抓娃娃日常寄寓世态落差之慨，炼字精准，章法跌宕顺承，结句宕开双关有余味，当代经验入诗自然，无硬伤套袭，唯表达稍欠含蓄。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"当代日常经验有效入诗，取象精准生动。转结借机械爪抓放机制丝滑切入人情世态，后两句物态人情双关，刻画入微而寓意辛酸，章法圆融且警策有力。","_cost":0.00501975},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.5,"rationale":"以娃机喻得失幻灭，过程连贯转结有力；然结句不值钱说破兜底，口语损雅泄尽余味。","_cost":0.01590725},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"借抓取、松落翻出价值讽意，题旨集中，转结紧凑。“偏松力”切中情境；意象以实录为主。末句有警策，但“不值钱”断语较满，从落空到贬值的生发稍显跳脱。","_cost":0.05002},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃写欲望落空，灯色与空爪可感，主脑集中。第三句近说明，结句“不值钱”说破，余味有限；末句能摘，当代经验入诗有效，未见硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0266256}},"consensus":75.62,"final":75.62},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"百尺天台一寸田,蔬香暗与市声连。游蜂不辨楼高下,来去浑如旧圃前。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.2,"警句":3.6,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.35,"rationale":"以寸田嵌入高楼市声，写都市菜园而有田园情味。蜂“不辨楼高下”转得灵动，结句以旧圃宕出乡园联想；“暗与”稍虚，整体清新完整。","_cost":0.00519},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"熟题翻新:都市天台种菜入诗,'百尺'对'一寸'开篇有势;'蔬香暗与市声连'嗅听交融、城乡对接。三四句借游蜂视角作转,构思巧妙,惟'浑如旧圃前'把比拟说得稍尽,余味略减。全篇一气贯注,当代经验有效入诗。","_cost":0.03252},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"都市天台种菜,以“百尺”“一寸”开合,蔬香市声相接见巧思;转以游蜂不辨高下,借物写人之田园之思,结句宕开尚有余味,惟“浑如”稍近说明,整体清切自然而未至警拔。","_cost":0.03469},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.75,"rationale":"本诗将当代城市经验有效入诗。首句尺寸对比，次句“蔬香”交织“市声”，视听嗅觉交融。转结借游蜂不知楼高打破城乡界限，暗喻物我两忘之境。语言流畅，立意新巧，章法天然。","_cost":0.017594},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"楼顶寸田连市声，以蜂不辨高下翻出主脑，情事具体。意象妥帖而蜂圃稍熟。语言清通，百尺一寸、暗与有炼。转结完整，结句浑如略说破。","_cost":0.0208},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.9,"rationale":"以游蜂视角写天台菜园，城市与田园交融，角度巧；'暗'字精当，转结留白。无硬伤陈滥蹈袭。","_cost":0.01254924},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"城市天台种菜,熟题(田园)翻出新境(都市农耕),情事具体。'一寸田'对'百尺天台'炼字见巧,'蔬香暗与市声连'以嗅觉听觉勾连城乡,景语即情语。游蜂不辨楼高下,宕开一笔以物结,暗寓人亦可安顿闹市,言尽意不尽。起承转合一气贯注。","_cost":0.0017888},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"天台菜园以小见新，百尺寸田、蔬香市声相联，转以游蜂不辨高低，城市田园合一。语言清顺，结句稍说破，余味未至深长。","_cost":0.00954},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"以都市天台种菜入诗,题新而情真,百尺与一寸对举起势,游蜂一转消弭楼高与旧圃之距,乡愁暗出而不点破,结有余味。语言自然,'暗与'见炼,但整体锤炼未至浓至,警拔稍欠。","_cost":0.028065},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.3,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.1,"rationale":"百尺对一寸、香连市声有张力，借蜂不辨高下收束都会微田园，章法转结流畅，语言自然，唯结句直点旧圃余韵略浅。","_cost":0.01312225},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"天台菜园翻新田园题旨，当代经验入诗；意象城市与旧圃交融，语言有百尺/一寸与‘不辨’之炼；起承转合完整而承转略平，结句以蜂如旧圃收，稳当稍直、有余味。无硬伤陈滥蹈袭。","_cost":0.032110239},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.3,"rationale":"此作借游蜂错觉写天台菜园意趣，角度新巧，起承转合顺畅，用字凝练，城市场景与乡野记忆衔接自然，无硬伤套话，末两句颇有佳致。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.3,"rationale":"切中当代都市经验，首句尺寸对比见张力，承句声香交融；转结借游蜂不辨楼阁，寄托归真之趣，化现代场景入传统意境，章法自然，余味悠长。","_cost":0.00502125},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"以蜂不辨高下点出天台浑如旧圃，小翻新意；起承转合俱全，借蜂转折佳，然香声交融稍弱，结句点破少留白，语言欠诗眼。","_cost":0.013169},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"“百尺”与“一寸”对照鲜明，以游蜂不辨高下写城中田园，情景相融，转结自然。“蔬香”接“市声”稍虚，末句以旧圃映照天台，有余韵但略偏说明。","_cost":0.0382},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.25,"rationale":"百尺与一寸对举,楼顶菜畦具体可感,蜂不辨高下见出新意,情志却偏轻。意象能凝为一境,暗字较切;三四同义复说,结以浑如说破,余味不足。无硬伤蹈袭,旧圃蔬香略熟。","_cost":0.0265344}},"consensus":80.96,"final":80.96},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"琉璃匣里夜灯浮，百态娇憨叠作丘。铁爪悬空迟未落，一钱投下息先收。才言到手旋松指，便许倾囊不肯休。谁把吾身当彩偶，冥冥何处更垂钩。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.7,"意境":8.3,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.8,"余味":8.6,"警句":4.2,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.4,"rationale":"以抓娃娃的得失机制映照欲望与被操控感，主脑鲜明。颔颈联递进有力，末联反客为偶，宕入命运之问；“冥冥”稍熟。","_cost":0.005338},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.0,"rationale":"当代经验入律而不隔:前六句状抓娃娃情态细致,'息先收''旋松指'炼字传神。尾联由物及人、翻出天命垂钩之喻,宕开有力,唯'当彩偶'稍点破本体,留白略减。章法起承转合分明,一气贯注,无陈套硬伤。","_cost":0.03495},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"以娃娃机入律，由景入事再翻出人为彩偶、冥冥垂钩之感，脉络清晰。“息先收”“旋松指”炼字见功。惟结联以人生如偶为喻略近常套，尾句以问收犹有余韵而未至奇警。","_cost":0.04887},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.5,"rationale":"此作将现代事象巧融于古典诗境，前六句细致白描抓取过程，生动传神；尾联由物及人，升华出命运受控的哲学意味，宕开一笔，余韵深长，堪称当代题材入诗之佳作。","_cost":0.019168},"grok-4.6":{"立意":8.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机翻出被冥冥垂钩的自况，题旨具体有主脑。意象切题但写实铺陈、情景交融不足。语言通顺，‘旋松指’等有炼字，‘息先收’稍晦。中二联层次平、尾转常见。结句提问有延宕而略点破。当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.034132},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.35,"rationale":"抓娃娃之景勾连人生受控之思，转结警拔。意象精切，语言自然；中二联偏叙，略欠空灵。尾联问而不答，余味悠长。","_cost":0.0044968},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写人性被冥冥之力操控的宿命感，熟物翻出新境。中二联'迟未落''息先收''旋松指''不肯休'层层推进赌徒心理，物象精切。尾联由物及身宕开，以问作结，言尽意远。'才言到手旋松指，便许倾囊不肯休'为佳联，整体气脉贯通，几乎无废字。","_cost":0.00299864},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.7,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.6,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.25,"rationale":"当代物象入诗，抓娃娃机转喻命运操控，立意新警；过程描摹具体，尾联留白有余。语言大体凝练，稍有生涩直白。","_cost":0.012852},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机翻出'人亦彩偶'之喻，由物及己，主脑集中；结联设问宕开，余味悠长。中二联写机制与成瘾心理层层推进，章法整饬。惜'息先收'语意含混，'便许'稍弱，炼字未臻化境。","_cost":0.035889},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.9,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.4,"rationale":"以娃娃机喻人欲与被控，由物及人及己层层递进，末联设问宕开余味足；匣爪丘象具体有氛围，语言流畅偶欠精锤。","_cost":0.0071825},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机喻命运捉弄，立意新警；意象妥帖，尾联宕开有余味。惜'息先收'稍晦，中二联开合稍弱，语言个别处欠炼。","_cost":0.034687946},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.25,"rationale":"此作以当代抓娃娃机为切入点，翻出个体被无形操控的存在感喟，炼字精准，章法圆转，意象贴合，结句由物及人有思致，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.65,"rationale":"当代经验入诗之佳构。中二联体察入微，写尽博弈之态与心理波澜；尾联由物及人，将市井机戏升格为宿命哲思，寓意深警，毫无现代物象入诗的生涩。","_cost":0.0047445},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.0,"rationale":"以机喻人由玩到省主脑清晰，中二联机人分写转接有变；然意象偏纪实少融情，息先收晦涩，才言等偏口语，结问留白而稍直。","_cost":0.01053575},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.4,"余味":7.1,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.05,"rationale":"由取偶转为自疑受控，主脑鲜明；投钱屏息、得而复失，情事具体。尾联翻进一层，设问留有余地，但“冥冥”“垂钩”稍趋泛化，“便许倾囊”略显生硬。","_cost":0.04499},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"写爪机成瘾并反身被钓，情事具体而喻意单层。首尾有境，腹联偏过程，意象未贯全篇。息先收、旋松指见炼，余多平顺。起承至尾一问，脉络清楚。彩偶稍直，垂钩仍有延宕。当代入律有效，无硬伤袭套。","_cost":0.0438816}},"consensus":84.82,"final":84.82},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|天台菜园|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"负土穷梯到上方，半畦新绿破盆香。丝瓜引蔓攀虚架，苋叶舒红映女墙。俯视千灯浮夜海，回身小圃满星凉。归来自剪葱三寸，一碗清羹是故乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.7,"语言":8.1,"章法":8.6,"余味":7.8,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.30000000000001,"rationale":"负土、种蔬、剪葱煮羹贯成主线，灯海与小圃星凉相映，乡情具体而有新意；“破盆香”稍涩，末句点出故乡略直。","_cost":0.008654},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"都市天台种菜入诗,题材新而情事具体,乡愁有着落。颈联'千灯浮夜海''小圃满星凉'俯仰开合、大小映照,是全篇警策。丝瓜苋叶取象亲切,'破盆香'炼字见巧。惜尾句'是故乡'说破题旨,余味稍减;'一碗清羹寄乡思'路数亦近熟套。","_cost":0.03249},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"以都市天台种菜写乡思，情事具体可感。丝瓜苋叶取象精切，颈联俯仰千灯星凉，小圃与夜海开合有致，为一篇警策。结句“一碗清羹是故乡”落到实物却将主旨说破，余味稍减；“破盆香”略生。","_cost":0.05616},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.0,"rationale":"以都市天台种菜切入，现代经验入诗极自然。颈联城市夜海与田园星辰对比强烈，空间开合有度。结句点出故乡略显直白，但“剪葱三寸”极具生活气息，挽回了余味，整体情感真挚。","_cost":0.01967},"grok-4.6":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"负土穷梯具劳作实感，颈联城灯圃星对照见境。植物描写稍套，结句‘是故乡’说破少余味。葱三寸为诗眼。现代夜景入律有效。","_cost":0.032918},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.8,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.7,"rationale":"由天台种菜延至乡愁，立意具体；颈联千灯/星凉俯仰成趣，全篇脉络稳。语言“破盆香”稍涩，尾联“是故乡”略直，故语言与余味稍降。无硬伤蹈袭，城市对照有出新。","_cost":0.015743904},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.0,"rationale":"天台种菜为当代都市经验入诗，题小而意深。颈联俯视千灯与回身小圃，大小远近开合有致，为全诗警策。尾联剪葱煮羹以小事收束故乡之思，稍近说破然情味自足。物象精切，虚架女墙皆扣天台实景，脉络一气贯注。","_cost":0.00259664},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.8,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"天台种菜题材具体，负土、剪葱有生活实感；颔颈写园与夜景相映，颈联较警策。惜“破盆香”“满星凉”稍险，结句点破故乡，余味不足。","_cost":0.012226},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"以都市天台种菜写乡愁，题旨集中、角度较新。颔联丝瓜苋叶、颈联千灯浮海与满圃星凉，意象新颖交融成境；章法起作、承景、转览、结情，脉络贯注。结句点破故乡稍直，余味略损。","_cost":0.03274935},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.3,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.4,"余味":6.6,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.95,"rationale":"以都市天台种菜写微型故乡，俯仰开合有法，蔬象精切与星灯夜海交融成境，语言锤炼自然，结句以味收束略显直点。","_cost":0.011237},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"都市天台种菜入律，起承转合清晰。颈联千灯夜海对映小圃星凉，『满星凉』新警；尾联清羹点乡愁。然『破盆香』稍涩，结句直白，乡怀稍熟。","_cost":0.031060663},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.75,"rationale":"此作借都市天台菜园写乡思，熟题出新境，意象精切，炼字自然，章法开合有致，颈联警策，融入当代生活经验，唯结句稍直白，无硬伤套话蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.6,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.95,"rationale":"当代都市生活经验入诗极佳。颈联以夜海千灯对照小圃星凉，境界阔大空灵；尾联由高处回落至剪葱清羹，将乡愁具象化，情意真切，脉络贯通。","_cost":0.00588375},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":5.6,"章法":7.9,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"负土上天台切当代生活，中两联由近圃宕开夜海层次佳，然破盆香费解满星凉生硬，结句直点故乡说破。","_cost":0.01181925},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.4,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.95,"rationale":"负土、剪葱使乡情具体可感，都市灯海与天台小圃相映；俯视、回身开合有致。“穷梯”“破盆香”稍涩，结句温厚可摘，却直接点破乡思，留白有限。","_cost":0.04117},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.5,"rationale":"园蔬与夜色相映，情事具体，颈联俯仰有诗眼。但结句点明故乡，余味被说破；颔联平列，立意未离熟套。","_cost":0.0185264}},"consensus":81.36,"final":81.36},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|云端相册|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"存照千张寄作云，轻翻岁月未曾分。何期弹指当年事，笑语依然隔世闻。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.6,"意境":6.3,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.4,"警句":2.2,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.85,"rationale":"以云端相册寄托追忆，今昔转换自然，末句“隔世闻”含怅惘而有余韵。当代题材入诗较新，然情事稍泛，“未曾分”语意含混，岁月、弹指等语略熟。","_cost":0.005744},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.5,"rationale":"以云存储入绝句，'云'兼指云端与浮云，'弹指'兼佛家刹那与指尖点屏，双关巧妙，当代经验有效入诗。结句'笑语隔世闻'以听觉宕开，怅惘有余味。惟'未曾分'语意含混，承句稍弱，取象偏于叙述、氛围营造不足。","_cost":0.03433},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"以“云”双关云储存与云烟，题材新而情感尚属泛写。第二句“未曾分”语意含糊近凑韵，取象偏薄多干说。转结以“何期”翻出，“依然”与“隔世”相反相成，稍有余味，但“弹指”“岁月”属熟语。","_cost":0.04765},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"将“云端相册”当代经验入诗，“寄作云”语带双关立意较巧。然全篇意象偏虚，语言直白，后半首流于“弹指当年”“恍如隔世”的常见感慨，结句直白无留白，诗味稍欠。","_cost":0.015752},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"云相册写怀旧有当代经验，题旨明确情事可感但翻新有限。意象妥帖偏常见，语言通顺少诗眼。章法完整转合平直，结句隔世闻略留余味。","_cost":0.017682},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"云端存储入诗有新意，“寄作云”“隔世闻”巧妙；结句以听觉收束留余味。中段意象偏虚，“弹指”“当年事”略熟。","_cost":0.0068052336},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.25,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗，将当代生活经验化入旧体，'云''弹指'皆双关自然。结句'笑语依然隔世闻'以听觉作结，人存音在而人隔世，含蓄沉痛，余味最佳。转句'何期'引出今昔对照，脉络完整。'轻翻岁月'稍落熟套，整体情真意切，构思有巧思而未臻警绝。","_cost":0.00239976},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.7,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.2,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"云端入题有当代感，结句笑语隔世留余味；但岁月、弹指、隔世等语偏熟，第二句稍抽象，整体情真而角度常见。","_cost":0.009828},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"云端存照翻旧影、笑语隔世,题旨集中、怀旧之情真切,属当代经验入诗的合格尝试;然通篇以叙代象,'云'象仅点到即止,氛围未足,'未曾分'语意含混,'岁月''弹指'略熟;转结尚顺,'依然''隔世'之悖论留有余韵而未臻警策。","_cost":0.0192792},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.8,"语言":5.2,"章法":5.8,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.0,"rationale":"借云相册写怀旧，当代经验入诗；然取象抽象干说少境，语言平直少诗眼，转折平衍，唯末句以幻听宕开稍得余味。","_cost":0.00937425},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"借云端相册写重翻旧照，题旨明确而情事稍泛；‘寄作云’见巧却生硬，承句‘未曾分’晦，转结尚稳。结以‘隔世闻’留余响，现代经验入诗稍新，然陈语稍多。","_cost":0.026753095},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"此作以当代云端相册入诗，抒翻检旧照的隔世怅惘，情真意明，结构平顺，语言晓畅；唯意象偏熟，转折平直，结句稍直白，当代经验融入自然。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.8,"语言":6.3,"章法":6.8,"余味":6.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.85,"rationale":"立意切中当代数字记忆体验，“寄作云”与结句“隔世闻”将影像留声入诗，化用精妙自然。起承转合流畅完整，惜象境偏虚，句式略带散文化。","_cost":0.0065415},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"云存储切入当代但情事空泛无主脑，全篇虚写无精切物象，寄作云未曾分夹白费解，转结完整而平直，末句听觉稍留余韵。","_cost":0.0117245},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"云端存照切入当代怀旧，主旨集中；“弹指”兼有操作与流年意味。“寄作云”“未曾分”语意欠稳，转句稍涩。结句以笑语反衬今昔阻隔，略有余响，但具体情事不足，措辞偏熟。","_cost":0.04787},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.2,"语言":4.8,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.6,"rationale":"主脑在云存近而情隔世，焦点清楚，然情事笼统未到独境。云、弹指双关可取，余象多熟套。寄作云、弹指当年事欠自然。起承转合贯通，转笔平。结句点明依然可闻，隔世略有余响而未尽留白。","_cost":0.0263728}},"consensus":64.02,"final":64.02},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"灯尽人稀夜未央，慈颜万里隔重洋。声迟影滞留微笑，坐守残屏到晓光。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.4,"余味":7.8,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.35,"rationale":"以视频迟滞写万里亲情，情事具体，主线凝聚；三句细节鲜活，转结自然。“残屏”略显生硬，“夜未央”等稍熟，晓光收束有余韵。","_cost":0.005196},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"思亲熟题借视频通话翻出当代具体情境，'声迟影滞留微笑'以卡顿定格慈颜，最见巧思，堪为警句。起承稳，三句一转有变化。惜'夜未央''慈颜''隔重洋'等语偏熟套，结句坐守到晓收得稳而稍直白，余味中上。","_cost":0.03524},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"以视频卡顿写隔洋思亲，“声迟影滞留微笑”捕捉当代经验，凝定的笑容即凝定的牵念，是全篇亮点；“残屏”亦见炼字。惟起承二句“夜未央”“隔重洋”“慈颜”属熟语铺陈，结句守屏到晓稍近直叙，余味中等。","_cost":0.04686},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"将跨国视频通话的现代经验自然入绝句。“声迟影滞”精准刻画网络延迟，与“留微笑”形成动人反差；“残屏”造语新巧贴切。起承转合流畅，虽前两句略显常见，但整体化当代生活入诗极为成功。","_cost":0.013854},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"视频思亲细节真切有主脑，声迟影滞、残屏可感。前联夜景远隔较套，章法承接平直，结句叙至晓光偏直白。当代经验入诗算出新。","_cost":0.025826},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"写深夜与海外亲人视频，情感具体；“声迟影滞留微笑”捕捉延迟卡顿细节，有当代体验。结句含蓄但转结稍平，部分意象较熟。","_cost":0.0057394656},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"视频探亲入旧体，题旨真切有主脑。'声迟影滞'以四字写网络延迟，堪称诗眼；'留微笑'于滞涩中见慈母之爱，转句极佳。结以'坐守残屏到晓光'以景结情，宕开而余味绵长。'夜未央'稍熟，全篇情象交融，脉络一气贯注。","_cost":0.0029492},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.7,"意境":7.1,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.3,"rationale":"视频迟滞写入诗中，细节真切，能化当代经验。三四句有情，但起承语较熟，结句略直，余味未深。","_cost":0.010826},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"以越洋视频通话入诗，\"声迟影滞留微笑\"捕捉画面卡顿与凝住之笑容，象情交融；结以守屏至晓光作景结，余味尚足。惜转承平实，题属常见亲情，\"夜未央\"等语稍熟。","_cost":0.01784955},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.3,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.4,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.30000000000001,"rationale":"以网络延迟写隔洋慈亲，当代经验入亲情题见真切；声迟影滞一联具体可感，结守残屏至晓以景收情有余味，唯起句夜未央等语较熟锤炼未精。","_cost":0.0090695},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"以现代视频卡顿入诗，“声迟影滞留微笑”观察精切，翻新游子思亲熟题。起承转合妥贴，结句坐守至晓，余韵动人。唯首句“灯尽人稀夜未央”稍落窠臼，陈滥扣1分。","_cost":0.023888617},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"此作写深夜越洋视频思亲，细节真切，融当代通讯经验入传统题材，章法顺适，语言平实；唯结句稍直，余味略欠。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.8,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"前两句稍显平熟，但转句“声迟影滞留微笑”神来之笔，将跨洋网络卡顿的现代经验天衣无缝化入诗境，体物精微；结以“坐守残屏”，深情尽显，堪称当代题材入旧体的佳构。","_cost":0.00637575},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.5,"rationale":"以视频卡顿写隔洋思亲，真切具体主脑集中；然起结多套语，转折平直，残屏欠安，结句直陈守夜余味稍浅。","_cost":0.013787},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"“声迟影滞留微笑”将视频卡顿化作亲情凝驻，具体而有新意。起承措辞较熟，“万里”与“重洋”意复；章法顺畅但转折幅度有限。结以守屏至晓见眷恋，不直说愁，尚有余味。","_cost":0.04013},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"思亲熟题,以越洋视频的声迟影滞略翻新境,情真而浅。残屏、滞影较切,灯尽、慈颜、重洋、晓光偏套,次句稍冗。章法顺接,转结平直。末句坐到天明,收得住而说尽。","_cost":0.0264608}},"consensus":75.31,"final":75.31},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"巷口新开小食堂，白头三两倚门旁。经年冷灶无烟起，一勺清汤对面尝。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.1,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.8,"rationale":"以社区食堂落笔独居老人境况，题材当代而情事具体。前二句平实铺景，第三句转入冷灶旧日，末句以相对共食含蓄见暖；“对面尝”稍显含混生硬。","_cost":0.005048},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.25,"rationale":"以社区食堂写空巢老人,当代经验入诗有效。'经年冷灶'转出孤寂,'一勺清汤对面尝'以细节收结,冷暖对照见温情,言外有余。惟语言平实少警字,'倚门旁'稍凑,清汤意象略常见。章法起承转合清晰,转句尤见功力。","_cost":0.0378},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"当代题材真切入诗，以“冷灶无烟”对照“清汤对面”，独居老人之寂与社区食堂之暖不说破而自见，转句有力。语言平实少斧凿，惟“白头三两倚门旁”稍直、炼字未臻警拔，结句留白得体。","_cost":0.04367},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"本作以白描手法将当代社区食堂有效入诗。转句“冷灶无烟”揭示空巢凄凉底色，结句以对坐喝汤的动作收束，不落直白说教，情感真挚可感，余味悠长，属难得的现实题材佳作。","_cost":0.01635},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.0,"rationale":"社区食堂写老人孤寂转陪伴，冷灶清汤具体可感。语言过白少锤炼，白头等象较套，转承完整但平，结句叙事直白余味一般。","_cost":0.036404},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.75,"rationale":"以社区食堂切入空巢老人日常，冷灶与清汤对比，画面具体，结句留白，余味深长。语言平实有诗眼，章法转结有力。","_cost":0.00578688},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.75,"rationale":"以社区食堂写空巢老人,当代经验入诗自然。'经年冷灶无烟起'由今转昔,是全诗枢纽;结句'一勺清汤对面尝'以小景收束,不说破孤寂而孤寂自见。白头倚门与冷灶呼应,意象精省无废字,唯'对面尝'微有歧义。","_cost":0.00272064},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.1,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.45,"rationale":"现实题材具体可感，冷灶与清汤相映，转结自然；语言偏白，个别词略凑，余味温厚但未深宕。","_cost":0.009578},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"借社区食堂写老人孤暖，焦点集中，冷灶与清汤对照有意味；然“白头三两”“无烟起”生硬，今昔跳转略突，结句温而近直。","_cost":0.0127152},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":5.3,"语言":5.6,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.4,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.85,"rationale":"以社区食堂观照空巢老人冷灶境况，立意具当代关切；意象平实少融铸，语言通顺乏锤炼，章法起承转合完整但结句味淡留白不足。","_cost":0.0101155},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"以社区食堂写空巢老人，题材有当代性；“经年冷灶无烟起”稍见锤炼，惜结句清汤对面稍直白，意象间有常见处，章法完整。","_cost":0.024236256},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.7,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.05,"rationale":"此作以小见大写社区食堂的民生暖意，抓老人昔年冷灶、今尝清汤的细节，情感真切，语言干净无废字，章法顺承自然，结句含而不露，当代经验入诗妥帖。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.9,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.55,"rationale":"当代助老题材自然入诗。转结以“冷灶”对“清汤”，由独居之清索翻至对坐之温情，以微细生活场景收束，不着说教而人情饱满，耐人寻味。","_cost":0.005157},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.2,"语言":4.3,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.65,"rationale":"以小食堂写空巢冷暖，题材贴时有主脑；意象妥帖但常见，无烟对清汤略有对比，语言平直乏诗眼，结句以景收稍存余温。","_cost":0.010022},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"以冷灶与清汤映照老者孤寂及相聚之暖，社区题材落在具体情事上。第三句回溯略显突兀，结句“对面”含蓄点出陪伴。“冷灶无烟”稍复，“对面尝”略涩，尚乏独立警句。","_cost":0.04124},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"题旨具体：冷灶多年与一勺清汤相对，写出独居老人就食的微暖，非口号。意象能统，白头倚门偏熟；语言通顺而少锤炼。第三句转折清楚，结句未说破，余味有限。","_cost":0.0237296}},"consensus":73.36,"final":73.36},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|云端相册|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"信手拈来万象收，光阴千叠指尖流。云端忽报当年日，照里仍留少壮眸。半是同行成隔世，空余笑语向谁酬。影中不老人间老，夜夜荧屏话旧游。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.9,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.4,"警句":3.6,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.14999999999999,"rationale":"以云端旧照触发衰老与亡友之悲，情事集中且具当代感。章法递深，“影中不老人间老”醒目；“当年日”“少壮眸”略显硬涩，结句有景而稍直。","_cost":0.007632},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"以云端相册'当年今日'推送写生死聚散,当代经验入诗有效,情事具体。颔联转折自然,颈联伤逝真切,'影中不老人间老'近警句。惜首联泛写少象,'光阴''笑语''旧游'偏熟,结句夜夜荧屏点得太实,余味稍减。","_cost":0.03612},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"以云端相册“当年今日”推送切入，当代经验入诗有效，情事具体（同行半已隔世）。中二联由照中少壮转向现实凋零，脉络清晰。“影中不老人间老”警策而略说破，结句以夜夜对屏收束尚有余韵。首句“万象收”稍泛，“光阴流”“话旧游”略见套语。","_cost":0.07029},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"该作将云端相册、往年回顾等现代数字体验自然融入七律。立意在悼亡伤逝的旧题中翻出新境，情感真挚痛切。“云端忽报当年日”捕捉精准，“影中不老人间老”对比强烈。整体脉络贯通，唯部分意象略偏概念化、造语稍直白，但当代经验入诗极为成功。","_cost":0.024744},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.0,"rationale":"云相册切入有当代感，颈联同伴隔世较具体；意象与对比多熟套，炼字偶见指尖流而整体平直，结句夜夜荧屏近乎说尽，余韵不足。","_cost":0.015678},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.0,"rationale":"以云端相册翻新怀旧题，立意具体真挚；‘报’‘少壮眸’见诗眼，章法开合有序。然光阴、笑语、旧游等语略熟，结句稍露，故意境余味未满。‘影中不老人间老’为佳句。","_cost":0.01127915},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"云端相册这一当代经验入旧体，翻出睹照怀人之新境，情感具体有主脑；中二联开合有层，'半是同行成隔世'沉痛可感。'影中不老人间老'对映精警，堪称诗眼。惜'信手拈来''万象收'略带套语，结句'话旧游'稍直白说尽，余味略减。","_cost":0.00296364},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.9,"rationale":"题取云端相册，当代经验入诗，颔联功能与旧照相映，有情事依据。惜多直说，意象偏泛，颈联未落实具体人事，尾句说破少留白；若干词语偏熟。","_cost":0.014124},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"以云端相册触发现代怀旧，主脑集中在影像不老而人事已老；“影中”一联最警。起句稍夸，笑语、旧游等语偏熟，结句有情而略直，余韵未足。","_cost":0.012531},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.39999999999999,"rationale":"云端相册切怀旧有当代主脑，影中不老/人间老对照聚焦；颈联转隔世深化，章法贯通；意象偏抽象，尾句以事直收余味平淡。","_cost":0.008962},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写旧照怀人，当代经验入诗有效，脉络清晰；'影中不老人间老'见诗眼。意象稍抽象，起笔弱、结句略直，间有熟语，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.033474959},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"此作写翻云端相册忆旧，主脑明确情感真切，意象新旧相协，语言平顺有亮点，章法清晰但转折偏平，结句较实；“影中不老人间老”为佳句，当代经验入诗自然，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.9,"rationale":"当代数字生活经验有效入诗，写云端旧照推送触动物是人非之感，真切自然；章法贯通、对仗平顺，唯炼字偶见现成词，尾联说破较尽，留白略显不足。","_cost":0.00428925},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.8,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.3,"余味":4.6,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.8,"rationale":"以云端相册切入怀旧，当代经验贴切但掘进不深；结构完整转折平，影人不老可摘；意象偏散多议论，结句直陈少留白。","_cost":0.01158425},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.7,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.4,"rationale":"云端周年提醒引出故人之感，当代经验融入自然，今昔层次清楚。“影中不老人间老”醒豁有力；“少壮眸”稍显硬凑，笑语旧游偏熟，结句重申怀旧，留白不足。","_cost":0.04071},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"主脑在影不老人已老，云端与少壮眸使怀旧较具体，然终是熟题。指尖、荧屏能托氛围，隔世、旧游仍常套。起势偏弱，转结平直，结句说破，余味有限。","_cost":0.0184672}},"consensus":70.56,"final":70.56},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"天外舷窗月似霜，云低万户落苍茫。星河千点浮身下，一盏谁家守夜长。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.1,"语言":6.9,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.05,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写万家灯火，视角新而情意温厚。由月云转向身下星河，再聚焦孤灯，收束有味；“月似霜”稍熟，“云低万户落”语意略涩。","_cost":0.005484},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰将星河倒置身下,当代经验入诗有效,视角新。转句'浮身下'翻空成奇,结句聚焦一盏孤灯设问,收得住且留白悠长。惟'月似霜''苍茫'稍熟,'落苍茫'略欠精准,炼字尚可再进。","_cost":0.03977},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验入诗，万户→千点→一盏层层收束，第三句星河在身下的视角倒转是全篇亮点，结句以问收敛留有余地。惟“月似霜”“苍茫”落入熟套，“落苍茫”稍显空泛，炼字功夫一般。","_cost":0.05239},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.8,"语言":7.8,"章法":9.2,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.25,"rationale":"现代夜航体验入诗自然。前三句写高空视角的苍茫，将万家灯火化作“星河浮身下”；结句由宏大宇宙骤然收焦于人间“一盏”孤灯，透出羁旅之思。起承转合圆融，由大及小，留白极佳。","_cost":0.02729},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰熟题，收于一盏守夜，主脑清而发现有限。月似霜、苍茫、星河套语较密，炼字平。起承皆俯视，转合由千点到一盏尚顺。谁家略有余问，守夜长稍直。舷窗入诗为当代经验。","_cost":0.0322},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.0,"rationale":"高空俯瞰由冷寂苍茫收束至一盏守夜灯，转结有致；“浮”“守”见炼字。末句以问留白，余味足。唯“月似霜”等意象稍熟。","_cost":0.01206876},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验入诗，视角独到，主脑清晰。'星河千点浮身下'化用天上星河写地面灯火，虚实倒转见巧思。结句'一盏谁家守夜长'由宏阔收于一点人间灯火，以问作结，言尽意不尽。'月似霜'稍落俗套，'落苍茫'炼字略平。","_cost":0.00242576},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.95,"rationale":"夜航入诗有新意，舷窗、云、星河构成清冷高空之景，结以一盏守夜设问留白。语言通顺而“月似霜”等稍熟，情志略泛。章法由宏阔收至人间，转结自然。","_cost":0.009336},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"夜航入诗角度较新，「星河千点浮身下」以万家灯火倒装为星河，是真切的高空发现，镜头自天外层层收至一盏，章法有致；惜「月似霜」「苍茫」熟套，结句「守夜长」稍露意，情味偏淡。","_cost":0.0316572},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.9,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.7,"章法":7.3,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.85,"rationale":"舷窗视角由星河万点收至一盏守夜，由阔入微章法转结自然，结句以景结情留白；然月似霜等语偏陈，个别字面欠锤炼。","_cost":0.012908},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰视角新颖，结句由星河千点收于一盏孤灯，设问留白，余味足；然月似霜等语稍熟，三句尚铺景，炼字平稳。","_cost":0.032627946},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"此作写当代夜航俯瞰之景，由浩茫天宇、万家灯火收束到一盏守夜孤灯，脉络顺畅，语词清稳，“浮”字见巧，惟部分意象较熟，转折略平，结句稍直白。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.05,"rationale":"夜航经验入诗自然贴切。前三句写高空俯瞰之苍茫宏阔，“浮身下”点出航行情态；结句由大景骤收至“一盏守夜”，冷暖对映，寄托深微，章法开合有致，余韵绵长。","_cost":0.00549},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.2,"章法":5.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.65,"rationale":"由万象收至一盏，主脑清晰略显常见；高寒对孤暖有意境；二三句意叠，转折平直；结句设问留白余味最佳。","_cost":0.01610825},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.95,"rationale":"由舷窗远景转向万家灯火，再聚焦一盏，层次清楚；结句以问寄情，留有人间牵念。“浮”字切合俯瞰感受；“云低万户落苍茫”语意略混，“月似霜”较熟。","_cost":0.04137},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"夜航下望，千点对一盏，主脑清楚而情近常套。月似霜、苍茫熟，落、浮稍亮。前三句平铺，转结挤于末句；问句留隙，仍点破守夜。当代经验入诗有效，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0208272}},"consensus":74.33,"final":74.33},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"铁架森森午夜天，函封千叠白如烟。浮尘扫尽层箱静，细字犹题万里缘。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.7,"意境":7.1,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.1,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.1,"rationale":"由夜扫货架转向包裹细字所系的远方联系，主脑明确，现代经验入诗有效。冷寂物象较统一；“午夜天”稍凑，“层箱”略涩。结句由物及情，但“万里缘”偏熟，点意稍明。","_cost":0.03564},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.3,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.85,"rationale":"当代电商仓储题材有效入诗。起承描摹夜仓冷峻宏阔，转结由扫尘劳作聚焦至面单细字，落笔‘万里缘’温润宕开，章法清晰顺畅。","_cost":0.00454425},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"仓储夜扫,以冷架静箱对照犹存细字,主脑清楚,情偏直说。白烟铁架能成夜境,但森森、如烟偏熟,首句两象硬接。转笔平直,结句点明缘字,余味不长。当代经验入题,无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":0.0243616},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"题材现代仓储，立意新颖但情思略泛；意象冷寂统一，细字温情交融；语言有“森森”“白如烟”等亮点；转句平直，结句细节留白有余韵。","_cost":0.006264409536},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.25,"rationale":"现代云仓夜扫题材入诗有效，扫尘见箱上地址而念万里之缘，立意有独到处。铁架、函封意象统一，氛围清冷妥帖。结句由眼前细字宕开至万里，言尽意存。白如烟稍熟，整体炼字平实，转结略直白但脉络贯通。","_cost":0.0028992},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.6,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.05000000000001,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫写当代仓储，取象集中，铁架、函封、细字有现场感；转结由静入情，脉络顺畅。惜‘白如烟’‘万里缘’稍熟，结意略直，余味未深。","_cost":0.00971},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"以当代云仓夜扫入诗，题材新而不猎奇。前三句铺垫铁架、函封、浮尘，转结以'细字犹题万里缘'点出物与人的牵连，扫尘者扫不去人间缘分，立意由劳作翻向温情，有主脑。意象统一，'白如烟'稍熟。结句宕开有余味，但警策度未臻上乘。","_cost":0.008928},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.3,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.35,"rationale":"午夜仓扫小题见情，以细字万里缘收束有主脑；起承转合清晰，当代仓储入诗自然；白如烟略俗，结句直抒余味稍浅。","_cost":0.00842525},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":5.8,"语言":6.6,"章法":6.4,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"云仓夜扫入诗，立意新而聚焦；意象妥帖，“白如烟”稍熟；语言有“森森”“静”亮点；章法完整而转平；结句稍直有余味；末句可摘，警句2；当代经验有效，出新2.5；无硬伤蹈袭，陈滥扣1。","_cost":0.030795055},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"此诗取材当代云仓夜扫，立意新颖聚焦，意象贴合场景，语言精准自然，章法顺承有致，结句留有余温，当代经验入诗妥帖，无硬伤陈套，唯意象尚有锤炼空间。","_cost":null}},"consensus":72.23,"final":72.23},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"铁翼穿云入夜长，低眸下界万灯黄。人烟散作千星网，大道蜿蜒数缕光。灼灼几窗犹未寝，悠悠孤客寄穹苍。谁家一盏曾留我，咫尺相看隔渺茫。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"unknown"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.8,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.2,"警句":3.4,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.4,"rationale":"由舷下灯网转入孤客乡思，主脑集中，尾联以一盏灯勾连旧日与咫尺天涯，留白较足。“低眸”稍显生硬，星网、孤客、穹苍略近熟套。","_cost":0.004902},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写羁旅隔膜,当代经验有效入诗。'千星网''数缕光'取象精切,颔联工稳。颈联'悠悠孤客寄穹苍'稍泛套。尾联设问宕开,'咫尺相看隔渺茫'言尽意不尽,为全篇警策。章法起承转合分明,一气贯通。","_cost":0.04171},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验入诗，尾联“一盏曾留我”落到具体人事，咫尺渺茫有余意。然中二联皆写灯光，星网、缕光、几窗取象重叠，层次未开，近于原地铺陈；孤客、穹苍、渺茫稍见套语，炼字平顺无诗眼。","_cost":0.05223},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"本诗将现代夜航体验入诗，从“千星网”的宏观夜景自然推至“几窗”的微观人情，章法严密流转。结句写透了机窗外看似咫尺实则天涯的物理错觉与游子孤寂，情境交融。唯首句“铁翼”略显常语。","_cost":0.021856},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰属熟题，主脑在「曾留我」与咫尺渺茫，情具体而少新境。意象统于灯火，星网缕光妥帖常见。铁翼、孤客、穹苍套语偏密，灼灼状窗稍隔。前半铺景较平，颈联始转。尾联问而不答有延宕。","_cost":0.033882},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"写夜航俯瞰，由地上灯火反观孤客，角度尚好但非独造。中二联以星网、光缕、未寝之窗层层递进，物象与孤怀交融。结句以'曾留我'虚一灯's', '咫尺相看隔渺茫'有可追味。语言偶见'穹苍'陈熟，'万灯黄'转'千星网'开合较平。","_cost":0.005326288},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验有效入诗，取象精切：千星网、数缕光皆由高空视角生发，景语即情语。尾联宕开忆旧，'咫尺相看隔渺茫'以空间悖论收束，言尽意不尽。中二联开合有层次，唯'悠悠孤客'稍落常调，个别用词微熟。","_cost":0.0028912},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.3,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰视角明确，灯网窗光与孤客相映，尾联以问灯收束有余味；但中二联星灯意象偏熟，孤客穹苍略泛，语言稳妥少警策。","_cost":0.00944},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"夜航景与孤客思乡相贯,千星网、数缕光意象精切,尾联设问留我之灯有新意;惜灼灼悠悠语熟、入夜长略凑,转折尚平。无硬伤蹈袭,微有佳句。","_cost":0.0210786},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.6,"余味":8.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.4,"rationale":"俯瞰灯海起兴，中二联由广景到孤客分层转合清晰，尾联以“一盏曾留我”收束私人记忆，咫尺渺茫留白有味；立意仍是万家灯火对照羁旅常调。","_cost":0.00869825},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"俯瞰视角新颖，中二联由城景转入孤客，章法稳妥；立意明确但情致常见，语言通顺少锤炼，结句理语稍直。尾联有张力，飞行题材入诗可取，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.030196984},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.8,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.9,"rationale":"此作写夜航俯瞰灯火触发的羁旅思旧之情，脉络顺畅，视角具当代性，意象妥帖语言平顺；唯立意偏熟，转折平直，余味不足，偶见套语。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.7,"章法":7.3,"余味":7.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.9,"rationale":"有效将现代夜航经验入律，由空中万灯大景层层收束至一窗孤客。章法流转自然，尾联借咫尺与渺茫之反差宕开羁旅情怀，余味悠然；唯中二联词句略见平直。","_cost":0.00550575},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"夜航俯灯望乡愁视角具当代性，但孤客对万灯母题常见；前半铺景略泛，颈联转情，尾联设问收束较有余味。","_cost":0.00999605},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"由俯瞰灯网转入孤客归属之问，转结有层次；“谁家一盏曾留我”较动人。星网、缕光贴合夜航，“入夜长”稍涩，“寄穹苍”偏泛。结句有隔绝余情，但点明“渺茫”稍直。","_cost":0.04196},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"寻一盏旧灯，主脑清，然近咫尺天涯常情。星网、缕光切航视，是出新处，但偏景，与孤情未密合。套语（孤客、渺茫）不少。收束由万至一，顺而颔联同质。结句有问，次句说破。","_cost":0.0455632}},"consensus":72.33,"final":72.33},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"断根昨自故山来，命系悬瓶滴滴哀。错认长丝为雨脚，一街新绿病中开。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.3,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.1,"rationale":"以吊瓶移栽树写城市新绿背后的伤痛，主脑鲜明。三句错认转得灵动，末句以“病中开”形成反差，余意深。唯“滴滴哀”稍显直露。","_cost":0.00764},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"以移栽树挂营养液这一当代街景入诗,熟中出新。断根、悬瓶紧扣主脑,三句错认雨脚一转灵动,结句'新绿病中开'以景结情,生机与病态相刺,余味深长。惟'滴滴哀'稍露直说,微伤含蓄。","_cost":0.03091},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.25,"rationale":"以街树吊瓶写离根之痛，当代经验入诗有效；断根—悬瓶—雨脚—病中开脉络贯通，转句错认之笔含双重视角。结句「新绿病中开」悖反有味。「滴滴哀」稍露、点破情感，略损含蓄。","_cost":0.04288},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":9.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":94.0,"rationale":"将城市树挂吊瓶现象入诗，切入极佳。转句以输液管错认为春雨，想象奇警贴切；结句“新绿病中开”形成生机与惨痛的强烈反差，悲悯情怀深沉，完美化现代经验为古典诗意。","_cost":0.029658},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"城树断根吊瓶情事具体有主脑，然城市化伤春角度常见。悬瓶长丝雨脚与病绿交融成哀氛。语言通达，哀字稍露。错认一转有变，结句点破病稍直。当代经验入诗有效。","_cost":0.021026},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.8,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.8,"余味":9.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.7,"rationale":"以移栽树挂吊瓶切入，写断根之痛与新绿病中开，取象新警；转句错认输液管为雨脚，翻新自然意象，结句矛盾收束留余味。无陈套硬伤。","_cost":0.01133352},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.75,"rationale":"以移栽树吊瓶输液入诗，物我双关，暗写离乡进城者之漂泊病痛，立意独到而情感具体。悬瓶、长丝、雨脚取象精切，景语即情语。'错认'一转自然，结句以景收束，言尽意不尽。'滴滴哀'之'哀'字稍露，微伤含蓄。","_cost":0.0032466},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.8,"rationale":"取材城市树吊瓶，断根、悬瓶、雨脚、病中新绿相贯通，转结有含蕴；唯“滴滴哀”稍直，故山、新绿略熟。","_cost":0.013666},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"以街头移栽树挂营养液入诗，题新而意深：断根故山暗寓离乡移植之痛。错认输液管为雨丝，转得巧；'病中开'景结余味长。'滴滴哀'稍直露，整体锤炼到位。","_cost":0.0106206},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.1,"rationale":"以吊瓶输液写移栽街树，借病喻命悬一线，错认雨脚一转精警，一街新绿病中开以景结情，当代经验入诗自然有余味。","_cost":0.00996025},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.8,"意境":8.0,"语言":9.0,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.6,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.7,"rationale":"当代街树挂瓶经验入诗，断根悬瓶取象精切；转句错认长丝为雨脚为诗眼，结句病中开悖论留味。微瑕：故山新绿略熟，承句稍平，哀病字稍露。","_cost":0.032439538},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.5,"rationale":"此诗取行道树挂吊瓶的当代场景，以树的错觉写移植之痛，章法流转，转句尤巧，炼字有张力，唯部分表达稍直，留白略欠，无硬伤、套话与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.5,"rationale":"捕捉城市移栽树木挂吊瓶之景，当代经验化入格律。转句将输液管错认为雨脚，凄恻新巧；结句以“一街新绿”反衬“病中开”，虚实张力极强，余味深长。","_cost":0.0049815},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.8,"rationale":"以吊瓶续命移树翻新春题，怜讽交织有主脑；悬瓶雨脚新绿融成病春氛围；病中开为诗眼余句稍直；转接错认巧，结以景寓讽。","_cost":0.01181325},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.4,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.6,"rationale":"以移树输液写新绿背后的损伤，题旨集中，有当代感。“错认”生转折，结句由一树推至一街，新绿与病态相映，耐人寻味；“滴滴哀”稍直露，“长丝”指代略含混。","_cost":0.04415},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.0,"rationale":"街树挂瓶写成春病,焦点集中,情事可感。长丝误作雨脚、新绿病中开,意象收成病房般春街。次句命系、滴滴哀直说,起承偏叙述;结句病字点题,余味有而略说破。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.02588}},"consensus":87.09,"final":87.09},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|社区食堂|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"巷口氤氲小饭堂，邻翁拄杖候开张。荤蔬两样餐餐饱，满座忘年笑语长。冷灶多时惟自煮，热羹此日共人尝。将归更带余肴去，老伴楼头待夕阳。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.7,"rationale":"社区养老入诗，烟火温情具体；冷灶热羹对照有力，尾联以携肴、楼头候归深化相守之情。章法顺畅，结景含蓄。“忘年”稍泛，“夕阳”略熟。","_cost":0.006142},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"当代题材入律,情事具体可感,主脑聚焦老人孤居与共餐之暖。颈联'冷灶''热羹'今昔对照最见匠心,结句携肴归家、'待夕阳'语带双关,留白有味。惜颔联'餐餐饱''笑语长'近于白话记账,炼字稍弱,略沾套语。","_cost":0.04524},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"当代题材入诗真切,拄杖候开张、带余肴归楼等细节可感;颈联冷灶热羹对照见匠心。惟颔联“荤蔬两样餐餐饱”近说明书,语言总体平实少警;结句以景收束、老伴楼头有留白,余味尚佳。","_cost":0.04976},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"当代生活经验巧妙入诗。立意见真情，充满人间烟火气。颈联今昔对比点明主旨，尾联“老伴楼头待夕阳”以温馨画面结情，余味悠长。语言质朴自然，虽无奇崛诗眼，但整体浑然一体，切中时代脉搏。","_cost":0.017666},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"民生场景具体有主脑，冷热对比见情，然养老食堂角度常见。意象妥帖成暖意氛围，夕阳拄杖稍套。语言通达叙事偏多、炼字不足。起承完整转在颈联对比、结尚收得住。当代经验入律可取。","_cost":0.018748},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"社区食堂题材具体，冷灶到共餐的对比立意真切；尾联携肴待老伴，景中留情。但中二联偏直叙、炼字略平，'氤氲''夕阳'稍熟。","_cost":0.01586608},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.5,"rationale":"社区食堂这一当代民生题材有效入诗，立意聚焦独居老人，情事具体可感。颈联冷灶自煮与热羹共尝对举开合有力，属全篇警处。结句带余肴归家、老伴候于夕阳，以景结情，温润有余味。语言整体妥帖，惟'餐餐饱''笑语长'稍平熟，扣意境陈滥少许。","_cost":0.00296056},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.8,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.4,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗，烟火气与老年照拂具体可感。冷灶热羹对照见孤居到共食之暖，结携肴归伴夕阳有余温；语言自然偶有平直，意象稍熟。","_cost":0.00988},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"以社区食堂写老龄孤独与相扶，冷灶/热羹一联最有骨；结句楼头夕阳留有余温。通篇真切而语多平直，警拔与陌生化稍欠。","_cost":0.0139086},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.7,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.7,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.15,"rationale":"以社区食堂写老境冷暖对照，带肴待夕阳见真情，主脑集中；冷灶热羹转合有力，结句以景收情留味，白描通顺而意象锤炼平实。","_cost":0.0095775},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"当代社区食堂入律，首尾场景真切，颈联冷灶热羹对比为核心，结句景语有余味。然中二联较平，语近白话，夕阳等意象稍陈。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.030826403},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"此作借邻翁就餐的日常片段写社区食堂的民生暖意，细节真切，脉络顺畅，语言平实，结句以具象场景留白有余韵，融入当代经验，无硬伤。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.3,"rationale":"当代现实题材入诗的生动之作。叙写社区助餐，由候张、聚食到冷暖对比，层次井然；结句打包带饭、楼头相待，将公域关怀宕入暮年私情，烟火气与温情交融，余韵悠长。","_cost":0.00679875},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"以社区食堂写老境共温，冷灶热羹对照真切，尾句待夕阳以景结情余味足；唯颔联语直意象常见，口语损雅，故语言意境低。","_cost":0.01172005},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"温情落实于拄杖、带肴等细节，章法由入堂用餐推进至归家牵挂，结句留有余韵；中二联多直陈，“冷灶”与“自煮”搭配稍涩，“笑语长”等措辞偏熟。","_cost":0.05756},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"以社区食堂写老境温情，冷灶自煮与热羹共尝对照具体，主脑集中。起于候门、结于携肴归视，脉络顺、尾句留白。弱在中段近乎记事，意象与炼字偏平，夕阳略熟。","_cost":0.0156672}},"consensus":75.41,"final":75.41},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|深夜视频|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"夜深一指唤慈亲，彼岸朝阳照鬓银。笑到中途凝半面，皱纹放大倍觉真。俱言无恙藏心事，误劝安眠犹是晨。挂断残屏成黑镜，灯前忽见白头人。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":["觉"],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":0.75,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"fail"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.8,"意境":8.7,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.6,"余味":9.1,"警句":4.3,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.85,"rationale":"以跨时区视频写亲子互瞒衰老，细节具体；屏熄成镜的转结有力，余味深。“倍觉真”稍直，“误劝安眠犹是晨”句意略涩。","_cost":0.009578},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"熟题思亲以视频通话翻新：时差、卡顿、像素放大皆当代经验有效入诗，情事具体。'凝半面''误劝安眠'炼字精切。尾联黑屏成镜、忽见自己白头，双关翻转，以象结情余味悠长。'倍觉真'稍直，余皆佳。","_cost":0.0393},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"以跨时区视频通话写亲情，卡顿凝半面、皱纹放大、误劝安眠皆当代经验精切入诗；尾联黑屏成镜忽见白头，由亲及己翻出双重老去之悲，收束有力余味深长。惟颈联「俱言无恙」稍熟，「倍觉真」略平。","_cost":0.04452},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.0,"rationale":"本诗将跨时区视频通话这一当代经验完美入诗。'凝半面'写网络卡顿极妙，'黑镜'映白头结句极具画面与余味。起承转合严密，情感真挚，现代词语入诗妥帖自然，是不可多得的佳作。","_cost":0.025476},"grok-4.6":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"视频写慈亲时差凝面藏心事皆具体，黑镜自照白头有余味。炼字偶直白，鬓银白头稍套，章法平稳少变。","_cost":0.024448},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.75,"rationale":"写深夜与异国母亲视频，时差、皱纹、误劝安眠等细节真实。尾联黑屏照见自身，余味足。语言偏口语直白，中二联稍平。无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":0.0047416512},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.75,"rationale":"视频通话写亲情，时差、卡顿、藏病皆当代经验入诗而自然无痕。'笑到中途凝半面'状视频卡帧精妙，'皱纹放大'切镜头感。结句黑镜映白头，由亲及己，言尽意不尽。中二联开合稍平，语言个别处略直白。","_cost":0.00300086},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.8,"意境":8.6,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.7,"余味":9.2,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.3,"rationale":"以视频通话写亲情，时差、凝帧、黑镜等当代意象真切，结句黑屏见白头余味深；语言偶有直白，如“俱言无恙藏心事”稍熟。","_cost":0.012276},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"视频亲情题材具体，时差、冻屏、放大皱纹皆成情语；尾联黑镜照见白头，由亲及己，留白有力。惟慈亲、鬓银、白头略熟，个句稍直。","_cost":0.0278142},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.4,"意境":7.9,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.1,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"以视频卡顿、时差错位翻新思亲旧题，细节真切具体；黑镜自照以景结情，余韵深长，中二联开合有层次。","_cost":0.01149925},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"视频思亲，时态反差与黑镜映白头出新；中二联平直、语兼文白，鬓银白头略套；尾联成警句，以景结情余味足，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.028638859},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"以跨洋深夜视频的当代场景写思亲，细节真切鲜活，脉络贯通，结句以黑屏映白头宕出余韵，融入日常经验，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.9,"rationale":"当代越洋视频经验入律极为生动。捕捉卡顿、时差误会等细节极真切；尾联由母及己，以息屏黑镜映出自身白发收束，两代同老，笔力深沉，余味悠长。","_cost":0.0050655},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.9,"rationale":"以视频时差卡顿翻新思亲题，皱纹放大黑镜自照真切具体；尾联宕开余味长，中段语言稍直露套语。","_cost":0.01396155},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.7,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.15,"rationale":"以卡顿、时差写亲情，细节真切；末联由屏中慈亲转向自身白发，照应开篇而不说尽。“倍觉真”偏直露，“残屏”稍牵强，互道无恙的情意较熟。","_cost":0.05734},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"视频入诗具体：时差、冻帧、皱纹放大皆可感，主脑是亲情与自照。结句残屏为镜、忽见白头，余味最佳。中段略熟，个别句直白，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.023016}},"consensus":86.53,"final":64.9},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"昨日春街移巨树，梢头药袋挂晴天。缠身草索犹微湿，入木钢针夜未眠。昔在山中承雨露，今朝道左仰人怜。他年绿荫如云处，谁记浮生一线悬。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.6,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.60000000000001,"rationale":"以移栽树挂吊瓶写生命受制与遗忘，题材新而情志集中。草索、钢针诸象交融，“夜未眠”稍显用力；尾联由绿荫反照危悬，转结有余韵。","_cost":0.005882},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"当代街景入诗,以移栽吊瓶之树写浮生飘转,题材新而寄托切。'钢针夜未眠'状物含情,颈联昔今对照开合有致。结句'一线悬'双关吊瓶与命脉,以问宕开,余味悠长。惟'仰人怜'稍直露,炼字略逊。","_cost":0.03743},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"以城市移栽巨树挂营养液的当代景象入诗，物象新切具体，托树寄人有主脑。颔联钢针草索写得细，颈联今昔对比稍平直，用语偶落套（承雨露、仰人怜）。结句“一线悬”双关输液与命脉，反问留白，惟点意略显。","_cost":0.042},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.25,"rationale":"本诗将“树挂吊瓶”这一当代城市景观巧妙入诗，立意新巧，饱含悲悯。起承转合极有法度，颔联细节生动，颈联昔今对比，尾联宕开一笔结出对生命遭际的深沉慨叹。意象融入妥帖，余味悠长。","_cost":0.014778},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"吊瓶移树写悬命，主脑清楚，一线悬扣题。药袋挂天、钢针入木尚切，雨露绿荫稍套。语言通达偶炼，颈联对比 destinied。结句点破谁记，余味有限。当代场景入诗有效。","_cost":0.022902},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"立意以城市移树挂吊瓶入诗，聚焦“一线悬”，具体有新意。颔联细节精警，尾联设问留白有力。唯中二联意象略熟、对比较直，故意境语言稍抑。","_cost":0.0049983648},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.5,"rationale":"移树吊瓶入诗，当代经验翻出新境，全篇主脑聚焦。药袋、草索、钢针皆实象含情，'入木钢针夜未眠'以物拟人贴切。山中雨露与道左仰怜今昔对开，层次分明。结句'一线悬'双关吊瓶输液与浮生命悬，宕开一笔、言尽意不尽，余味极佳。'承雨露'稍熟，无碍。","_cost":0.00233404},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.7,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.6,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.39999999999999,"rationale":"以城市移树吊瓶入诗，药袋、钢针、草索等象真切，昔山中与今道左对照见寄寓。尾联悬线一问留白有余，惜雨露、浮生等语稍熟。","_cost":0.007742},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"以移栽大树挂营养液这一当代街景入诗，树如病人、生命线之喻聚焦而新鲜，中二联昔今对照有层次，结以反问宕开，'一线悬'双关尚可。然'仰人怜'等语平直，颈联转折的感发度有限，意象部分仍熟，整体中上。","_cost":0.0181602},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.7,"rationale":"以吊瓶古树入诗，物我同构，由晴天药袋到浮生一线悬，今昔对比收束于存在之问，意象精切，章法开合有度，结句宕开有味。","_cost":0.00655775},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"街树挂瓶入律，聚焦移植树生存与浮生若悬，立意集中。中二联实写转昔今对比，尾联以绿荫反问留余味。‘药袋挂晴天’‘一线悬’意象炼字见新，然‘承雨露’稍常，语言有平硬，陈滥轻。","_cost":0.034144396},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"借城市移栽大树挂吊针的当代日常寄寓命运感，意象真切，章法顺适，双关工巧，唯结句点“浮生”稍直，少量语词略熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.7,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.8,"余味":8.7,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.55,"rationale":"当代经验入诗的典范之作。取材城市移树吊水之景，取象精真，“草索”“钢针”体物入微。颈联昔今对比自然，结句拓开推想，由物及人寄托浮生之慨，沉痛深远，余味不绝。","_cost":0.00521025},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":8.4,"意境":6.7,"语言":7.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.85,"rationale":"以吊瓶喻浮生主脑鲜明，当代经验入诗自然；药袋钢针精切，昔今未来脉络清，结问宕开留味。","_cost":0.01383955},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"以移树输液写生存境遇，今昔与未来相照，主脑集中。药袋、钢针有现场感，“一线悬”兼有实指与寓意。“夜未眠”稍显用力，“仰人怜”直露；结尾设问有回响，但浮生、雨露等措辞较熟。","_cost":0.05021},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.6,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.7,"rationale":"以街树吊瓶写移植之危与他年遗忘，主脑清楚、事象具体。药袋、钢针、草索与“一线”互证，意境最胜。语言多平叙熟词，昔今转折偏直，结句问而近于点题。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.019912}},"consensus":81.81,"final":81.81},{"key":"claude-fable-5.1|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"钢架层层压夜城，云仓廓落昼犹明。残胶碎纸随人起，铁带如龙卧不惊。箱里万家将别去，尘中孤影未成行。扫余启户疏星坠，早发车轮破晓声。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.8,"意境":8.6,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.7,"余味":8.8,"警句":4.2,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.1,"rationale":"以万家货箱与尘中孤影相对照，写出物流夜工的处境，主脑鲜明。钢架、残胶、铁带等取象具体，末联由疏星转车声，余韵悠长；“如龙”“破晓声”稍熟硬。","_cost":0.008148},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"写电商云仓夜间清扫工,当代经验入诗有效。颈联'箱里万家将别去,尘中孤影未成行'以包裹之动衬人之滞,'成行'语带双关,是警句。铁带如龙、疏星车声皆切境。惟结句以晓声收束稍显平顺,余味略直,炼字大体妥帖而未臻惊警。","_cost":0.04229},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"以夜间清扫物流云仓为题，当代经验入诗有效；颈联“万家将别去”与“孤影未成行”对照见情，是全篇主脑。铁带卧龙取象新切，结句以晨发车声宕开，留有余地。惟“廓落昼犹明”“破晓声”稍见凑合，语言尚欠精炼。","_cost":0.04751},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.0,"rationale":"当代物流经验入诗极为成功。颈联将“箱里万家”流转与“尘中孤影”滞留对比，极具现代张力。意象精切，结构严谨，尾联以景结情，余味悠长，是难得的现代题材佳作。","_cost":0.015246},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"仓储夜扫以包裹万家与尘中孤影对照，焦点具体；铁带如龙、残胶碎纸等工业象能融情。语言通达有亮点但文白夹杂欠炼。章法有转尚平，结句车轮破晓偏实少宕开。物流场景入诗略出新。","_cost":0.024594},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.4,"rationale":"以夜扫云仓为线，意象统一于冷亮工业氛围；颈联由箱货系万家与孤影对照，篇末以车声破晓收束，留有余响。语言略有生新处，“未成行”稍晦。题材与对句可嘉，无明显硬伤。","_cost":0.012163418},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"咏云仓夜扫工，取象精切（残胶碎纸、铁带卧龙），颈联'箱里万家将别去，尘中孤影未成行'以'成行'双关成全篇警策，当代仓储经验入律自然。起承转合完整，结以景声收束留有余响；惟'廓落'稍书袋，'如龙''破晓'微熟，颔联对仗偏宽。","_cost":0.027917},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"当代云仓入诗，钢架、残胶、铁带等细节真切，由夜扫转至晓发，脉络清晰；‘箱里万家’有拓展。惜个别语词稍泛，孤影未成行略涩，余味尚可。","_cost":0.01672},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"以当代云仓夜扫为题,聚焦清扫者。铁带、残胶等象精切统一;颈联'万家别去'与'孤影未成行'对照见主脑。章法起承转合齐整,尾联破晓宕开但稍平,'疏星'类语略熟。","_cost":0.02403975},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.8,"rationale":"夜扫云仓切题有主脑，箱里万家与孤影对照见情；钢架、残胶、铁带构成工业夜境，末联启户坠星、车轮破晓以景声收束留白，语言通顺偶欠锤炼。","_cost":0.008489},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"以现代云仓夜扫入律，钢架、铁带、箱盒等取象新颖；颈联以万家将别对孤影未成行，寄寓劳动者的孤寂，意脉集中。语言偶有生硬（如破晓声、未成行），结句以车轮破晓收束，有余响。","_cost":0.027946084},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"此作聚焦当代云仓夜扫劳动者，题材新颖，主脑明确，意象贴实，章法顺贯，炼字精准，结句留有余韵；无硬伤蹈袭，当代经验入诗自然，唯部分表述稍平实。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.7,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.5,"rationale":"当代物流题材佳作。云仓、残胶碎纸等现代经验入诗自然不隔。颈联“箱里万家”与“尘中孤影”虚实对比极具时代体温与社会关怀。章法顺畅，尾联破晓收结，余味自生。","_cost":0.00565275},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.8,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.2,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.4,"rationale":"云仓夜扫切入当代劳作，铁带卧龙箱寄万家有新意，转合由物及人；炼字夹生，疏星坠牵强，结收车声尚稳而余味平。","_cost":0.01803605},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.7,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.1,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.85,"rationale":"夜扫劳动场景具体，“万家”与“孤影”对照见情志；残胶碎纸切境，结以车声，余情未尽。“昼犹明”时意欠清，“箱里万家”“未成行”稍显牵强；如龙之喻较熟。","_cost":0.03874},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"云仓夜扫情事具体，万家与孤影对照见主脑。残胶、昼明能融情，如龙、疏星落套。压、破晓有力，卧不惊虚，扫余偏直。由物及人、由夜入晓，顺而转平。结以车声，余味有限。","_cost":0.03916}},"consensus":78.16,"final":78.16},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"街头肃立一空箱，岁晚投衣置路旁。远道装车寒雪夜，温情满载入春阳。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.8,"语言":4.9,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.3,"警句":0.8,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.2,"rationale":"取材当代公益设施，主旨集中，寒夜运衣亦具情境。然“一空箱”“远道装车”略显生硬，末句以“温情”“春阳”直陈升华，稍落俗套且余味不足。","_cost":0.005186},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.0,"rationale":"取材当代旧衣回收,题材有时代气息,惜处理落入公益颂扬套路。'肃立'拟人稍见用心,余皆平铺直叙。'寒雪夜'对'入春阳'转折尚具章法,但'温情满载'直白说破,以概念代形象,结句兜底无余味,'温情''春阳'近于标语套话。","_cost":0.03173},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.75,"rationale":"题材当代可取，然情感流于公益口号式的泛泛善意。“肃立”拟人生硬，“置路旁”与“街头”重复凑字。三句雪夜装车稍具画面，结句“温情满载入春阳”将意说尽，抽象直白，余味寡淡。","_cost":0.038},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":33.5,"rationale":"题材取旧衣回收箱，具现实意义。但全篇语言直白如新闻报道，缺乏诗意锤炼。“温情满载入春阳”流于标语口号，结句说破兜底，毫无留白。章法完整但转折平直。","_cost":0.013094},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"旧衣箱入诗有当代感，慈善温情主线清楚。空箱、雪夜、春阳对照稍常套。肃立、满载略见炼字。叙事起承尚顺，结句直点温情，留白不足。","_cost":0.017564},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"题材有当代感，立意明确但转结落于常见温情颂扬；意象妥帖却显普通。语言“肃立”有亮点，通篇平实少炼字。结构顺畅，转合略平直。结句说破“温情”，余味不足。","_cost":0.00586344},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.25,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱为当代经验入诗，题材有效。全诗按物—事—运—愿线性叙事，寒雪夜与春阳对照见层次，但“温情满载”直白说破情意，结句兜底无留白；“肃立”拟人尚妥，整体语偏平实近顺口溜，立意止于善意颂扬，无更深发现。","_cost":0.0026544},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.25,"rationale":"选题有当代生活气息，脉络清楚，由投衣、装车到入春阳递进；但“温情满载”说破，寒雪、春阳偏熟套，叙事多于熔铸，语言略平直，余味不足。","_cost":0.00784},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"旧衣捐赠题旨集中，雪夜到春阳有推进；但角度近公益口号，“空箱/路旁/满载”逻辑小扞格，“温情满载”直白，警策有限。","_cost":0.01916055},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.4,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.3,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.50000000000001,"rationale":"以旧衣箱切入当代日常稍有新意，然温情满载直抒，寒雪春阳对照虽清而意象平实，语言转结偏直少余韵。","_cost":0.01020125},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，起承转合完整，转结清晰；惜意象平实、“装车”等语直白，结语“温情满载入春阳”说破少余味，套语稍滥。当代经验入诗有一定新意。","_cost":0.028887283},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.5,"rationale":"此诗咏旧衣回收箱，题旨明确，叙事顺承结构完整，但角度常规，意象平实，次句主语模糊有歧义，结句直点温情少留白，引入当代事物但发掘较浅，略有熟套语。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.8,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.85,"rationale":"取当代现实物象入诗，章法按事理顺承而进，脉络完整。唯诗化程度不足，“温情满载”等语略带标语口号色彩，意象较平直，结句说尽题旨而少留白余韵。","_cost":0.0043125},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.75,"rationale":"取材回收箱具当代感，但前二句同义重复，寒雪春阳对比陈套，温情直抒说破，无诗眼余味。","_cost":0.00947875},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.75,"rationale":"捐衣济寒的题旨明确，取材有当代性，但情感表达泛化。街头与路旁重复，“投衣置路旁”“远道装车”语意欠顺。由寒入暖的转结平直，“温情满载”直露点题，留白不足。","_cost":0.03468},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.5,"rationale":"空箱远送成春阳,题旨明而角度常见,情未落到具体人衣。箱、雪、车可观,温情抽象,未成统一氛围。肃立偏硬,装车近散文,无诗眼。脉络完整而转折平直,结句说破,余味薄。略有当代题,无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0215312},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.75,"rationale":"题材有当代气息,但只写回收流程,止于温情主旋律,没有独到发现。'肃立'拟人生硬;'街头''路旁'语义重复,'空箱'之后又说'置路旁',句意略显拖沓。转句寒雪夜装车稍有画面,结句'温情满载'是套话,直说而无余味。","_cost":0.01502},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.75,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱入诗，有当代生活气息；由投衣到装车，脉络清楚。但“投衣置路旁”指向含混，“温情满载入春阳”偏套语，结句说尽，余味较弱。","_cost":0.008076}},"consensus":47.21,"final":47.21},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"街隅电匣炫眸光，稚子争投笑欲狂。锐铗斜垂窥玩偶，银箱铁爪梦悠长。金钱一掷牵丝动，乍举俄惊底事忙。币尽人犹贪顾盼，归来倦眼念空荒。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.6,"章法":7.4,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.8,"rationale":"以抓取游戏写欲望落空，主脑明确，当代题材有新意。场景与动作层层推进；“电匣”“锐铗”等稍显刻意，“底事忙”语意含混，结句直点空荒，余味略减。","_cost":0.0054},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.5,"rationale":"以当代抓娃娃机入诗有取材之新，写沉迷与空虚亦有主脑。然中二联对仗松散、意象重复（铗爪两见），'梦悠长''念空荒'措辞生硬近凑韵，'底事忙'含混。结句直说'空荒'，说破无余味。整体题旨可取而炼字章法俱弱。","_cost":0.03699},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.75,"rationale":"题材当代，以贪恋与空虚收束尚有主脑，但角度常见。中二联皆写机器动作，重复少开合；“梦悠长”“底事忙”“念空荒”虚泛凑韵，语言欠精炼。结句直说空荒，留白不足。","_cost":0.04671},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.5,"rationale":"以当代生活入诗，起承转合清晰，脉络完整。然语言将现代事物生硬古化（如电匣、铁爪），略显拼凑；结句“念空荒”直接说破，缺乏留白与余味。立意停留在叙事表面，欠缺深层诗意。","_cost":0.014228},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"当代机趣入诗有新意,写争投至空荒主脑尚明。意象多铺叙过程,情意交融一般。语言通顺但‘底事忙’费解欠锤。章法完具转折平。结句直点空荒少宕。无典故硬伤,套语不多。","_cost":0.031638},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.5,"rationale":"题材有当代感，尾联略见落寞馀绪；但中二联句法生硬、意象散缓，套语密度较高，机械物象未与情志深度融合。","_cost":0.0067820016},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"以七律写抓娃娃机，讽喻消费与赌博式沉迷，题旨具体有主脑。'银箱铁爪梦悠长'冷物与幻梦对照见巧。然'锐铗''电匣'近生造，'底事忙''念空荒'稍凑且结句直点空荒，余味打折；中二联层次尚清而转折平直。","_cost":0.00353084},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"当代题材入诗颇具新意，借投币抓取写贪念成空，脉络清楚；然物象与旧语稍有龃龉，结尾直说空荒，余味不足。","_cost":0.01392},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写贪念与空落,当代题材入律有新意,'币尽人犹贪顾盼'颇见心理刻画;但题旨不过戒贪空幻之常意,中二联内容平行、转折平直,'底事忙'凑语含混,'梦悠长''笑欲狂'略浮,结句'念空荒'直说兜底,少留白延宕。","_cost":0.024066},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.2,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.3,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.05,"rationale":"以娃娃机喻投机欲望有主脑，然由炫光到空荒开掘尚浅；意象写实铺陈，情景交融不足；语言通顺少诗眼，尾联直说空荒说尽余味。","_cost":0.0086515},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入律，题材新颖；叙事完整而转折平直，意象具体欠融，造语间有生硬（如电匣、空荒），结句直白少余味。","_cost":0.027439215},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.5,"rationale":"此作以当代抓娃娃机入七律，依游玩顺序铺陈，摹写操作过程较切，暗寓求而不得的空幻感，但用词偶有生硬，结句点破\"空荒\"稍直，余味有限。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"成功将当代生活物象入律，叙事脉络清晰，由狂欢递进至虚无。唯炼字偶见凑韵（如“底事忙”），结句“念空荒”略有拔高说破之嫌，削弱了余味。","_cost":0.0046485},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.0,"rationale":"题材取娃娃机写投币幻灭，过程层次分明；然机件比拟生硬，虚词直陈，结句点破空荒，少景语余味。","_cost":0.0124},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"投币至币尽，欲望落空的主线清楚，章法完整。电匣、铁爪切题，但“底事忙”“念空荒”生硬，“梦悠长”偏泛；结句以抽象感叹收束，余味较薄。题材较新，未见独立动人的警句。","_cost":0.05435},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.75,"rationale":"写机前诱惑与币尽落空，情事具体而发现平常，稚子狂欢与归人空荒未拧成一主脑。锐铗窥偶较切，余多铺陈；底事忙费解，结句空荒说破。当代物象入律是其新处。","_cost":0.0258832},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.0,"rationale":"当代题材入诗,有一定新意,贪欲落空的主脑也在,但开掘偏浅。锐铗与铁爪同指一物,中二联意象重复,层次不足。梦悠长、底事忙、念空荒语意含混。币尽人犹贪顾盼尚可一读,结句空荒偏抽象,余味有限。","_cost":0.018204},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.0,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入诗有新意，电匣、铁爪写出现场；叙事脉络清楚，但“底事忙”含混，“梦悠长”“念空荒”偏虚，结尾直点失落，余味较弱。","_cost":0.00812}},"consensus":55.45,"final":55.45},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"铁爪垂纶映彩霞，玻璃城外竞豪奢。发力暗随银币落，一娃抱得众人夸。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":["人","力","娃","币","得","随"],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":true,"重字":false},"coef":0.75,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.3,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.1,"章法":6.4,"余味":3.4,"警句":0.8,"出新":2.1,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.65,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入诗，题材有当代感，铁爪、玻璃城、银币构成完整场景。主旨偏浅，“竞豪奢”稍显牵强，“一娃抱得众人夸”直白说尽，余味不足。","_cost":0.006002},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"以娃娃机入诗题材新,'铁爪垂纶'化俗为雅有巧思。但'竞豪奢'措辞夸张失当,与投币小娱不称。第三句写实平顺,结句'众人夸'把热闹说满说尽,无留白无宕开,余味寡淡。整体是有趣的即景小品,未翻出讽喻或人情深意。","_cost":0.03792},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"以当代娃娃机入诗，「铁爪垂纶」「玻璃城」取象尚可，第三句「发力暗随银币落」暗讽机关设置，为一篇之转。惟「彩霞」「竞豪奢」措辞欠精，结句「众人夸」说尽兜底，无余味，题旨止于浅层观照。","_cost":0.04369},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":3.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":2.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":27.0,"rationale":"题材涉足现代生活有新意，但“映彩霞”“竞豪奢”脱离抓娃娃机的真实语境，生拼硬凑。后两句滑向打油诗，结语大白话兜底，全无诗意留白。","_cost":0.023108},"grok-4.6":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.75,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入七绝有当代感，然仅场面铺叙，情志浅、无独到主脑。垂纶玻璃城稍活，彩霞豪奢未交融成境。字句通顺偶见力而无诗眼。转合平直。结句叙实说尽，无留白余韵。","_cost":0.020074},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.0,"rationale":"题材新而情事具体，但立意浅近；意象尚切，铁爪垂纶有巧思。语言直白，“发力”“竞豪奢”欠锤炼。结构完整然转结平直，结句说尽，余味不足。","_cost":0.00513766},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"咏当代新物有主脑：垂纶喻铁爪、玻璃城写机箱，取象巧而氛围统一；'暗'字为诗眼，银币与爪力暗合，讽消费之趣含而不露。起承转合完整，转句最佳；结句直白说尽，'众人夸'稍平，余味不足。出彩在出新与可摘之警句，彩霞、竞豪奢略带套语。","_cost":0.0224142},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.25,"rationale":"以当代游戏入绝，起承转合清楚，投币抓取有动态；但彩霞豪奢稍泛，末句众人夸说破，余味偏浅。","_cost":0.010328},"kimi-k3":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.25,"rationale":"取当代游乐入题稍有新意，'铁爪垂纶'以钓为喻尚可；然题旨游移于讽奢与夸技之间，'发力''一娃'用语生白失雅，结句直叙兜底，余味寡淡。","_cost":0.02716905},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.3,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.9,"章法":6.1,"余味":4.7,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.45,"rationale":"垂纶喻铁爪巧切，玻璃城点出现代场域，起承转合完整；然立意止于状物少深寄，结句直叙抱娃受夸，言尽意尽余味薄。","_cost":0.0097185},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"咏现代抓娃娃机，铁爪垂纶设喻新；三句转写暗随银币发力，揭机巧，结构完整。然‘玻璃城’‘竞豪奢’稍泛，结句直白少余味，语言偶有生硬。","_cost":0.034323623},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.75,"rationale":"该诗描摹抓娃娃机游乐场景，脉络通顺，选材有当代性，然立意平白无新思，部分措辞稍显违和，结句直白道尽，缺留白余韵，无突出警句。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"当代题材入诗，“铁爪垂纶”“玻璃城”取象新巧妥帖，叙事流畅生动。立意止于游乐嬉戏，结句直白道尽，缺乏留白余味。","_cost":0.00406275},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.75,"rationale":"取材娃娃机稍新，然仅直叙投币抓取，竞豪奢众人夸空泛无主脑，垂纶喻小巧，结句直白兜底无余味。","_cost":0.0087553},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃写消费竞逐，投币与爪力的暗联有现实观察。铁爪、玻璃切题，但“彩霞”“豪奢”稍显浮饰。转句揭出机关，结句以夸赞收束，略有反讽，延宕不足。","_cost":0.03426},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.25,"rationale":"题聚于银币暗驭铁爪、一娃邀夸，略有讽意而情事不切。彩霞、玻璃城、豪奢未融成境；发力、一娃与垂纶文白相杂。起转尚顺，承句松，结句直白少余味。题材新而未化透。","_cost":0.0274224},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.75,"rationale":"当代题材入诗有新意。“铁爪垂纶”喻抓钩颇巧,“玻璃城”取象亦贴切。但“竞豪奢”言过其实,“发力暗随银币落”语意含混。立意停在记事,未能生发对侥幸或消费的省思。结句“众人夸”直白兜底,余味浅。","_cost":0.014496},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.5,"rationale":"“铁爪垂纶”“玻璃城”写出抓娃娃机的趣味；“彩霞”“豪奢”稍显浮泛。由投币写到得娃，脉络清楚而转折平直，末句说尽，余味较少。","_cost":0.008152}},"consensus":53.15,"final":39.86},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|云端相册|七绝","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"数字留存影像新，天涯旧梦惹微尘。屏中笑语如相问，何日归来共此人。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.6,"章法":6.4,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.8,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"云端相册触发怀人与归期，主旨集中且具当代性。三四句由影入情，问句收束尚有余波；但“数字留存影像新”近说明语，“旧梦”“微尘”稍套，“共此人”指意含混。","_cost":0.005726},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.0,"rationale":"以云端相册写离思,当代题材有可取处,惜首句'数字留存影像新'纯属说明语,文白夹杂;'惹微尘'与数字影像意脉稍隔。三句'屏中笑语如相问'转得尚活,结句设问收束平直,'共此人'措辞生硬。整体题旨明确而炼字未精。","_cost":0.03606},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.25,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗有当代经验，然落脚于'何日归来'旧套。首句说明性过强近于文白夹杂，'天涯旧梦''惹微尘'套话，且数字影像惹尘意象略生涩。第三句'屏中笑语如相问'稍有画面，结句直接说破，问而无余。结构完整但平直。","_cost":0.04518},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.5,"rationale":"以当代经验（数字、屏幕）入诗值得肯定。但首句如白话，现代词汇与“天涯旧梦”等古典套语缝合生硬，缺乏化用之妙。起承转合虽完整，但结句“何日归来”直白兜底，毫无留白，整体意境干瘪。","_cost":0.02065},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"云端相册入诗有当代新意，怀人焦点明确。然首句直叙、文白夹杂无诗眼，新旧意象未融，转结平直，“共此人”生硬少留白。","_cost":0.01677},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.2,"意境":4.8,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.1,"rationale":"云端相册题材有当代感，情感可感但展开平常；意象偏虚，语言平实偶有拟人亮点；结构完整转折不深，结句以问收稍留余味。无硬伤与蹈袭，旧梦微尘略陈。","_cost":0.01038312},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"以云端相册入绝句，当代经验与怀旧之情结合，立意有新意但未臻深境。'惹微尘'虚实相映见巧思，'屏中笑语如相问'拟人贴切堪称诗眼。结句'共此人'稍显直白说破，问而不答本可留白，惜语意平常削弱余韵。转结脉络完整，惟结尾收束平直。","_cost":0.00200804},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.7,"rationale":"题旨明确，借云端相册写怀人，当代意象略有新意；但旧梦微尘、何日归来偏熟套，结句直问少留白，语言稍平直，情境未深。","_cost":0.007694},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"云端相册题材较新，思念有焦点，第三句拟人稍有生趣；但“数字留存”近散文，“惹微尘”“共此人”意脉含混，结句直问而少宕开，熟语亦见。","_cost":0.0112782},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.3,"语言":4.2,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.4,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.3,"rationale":"云端相册切入当代可取，然立意止于泛泛怀人，意象抽象直白少交融，语言偏口语欠锤炼，章法贯通而转折平直，结句直问少余味。","_cost":0.008254},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀人，题旨明确但情致稍泛；数字与旧梦意象未全交融，起句平、结句直白；转句拟人及化用“如相问”稍亮。无硬伤蹈袭，陈滥轻，当代经验入诗有新意。","_cost":0.029680098},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"此作借云端相册触发羁旅思旧，题旨明确，结构完整，语词通顺；唯意象偏熟，转折平顺，结句较直，数码入诗略有新意，无明显硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"当代数字相册经验有效入诗，脉络通顺。首句略近干说，转句写屏中笑语具现场感，结句落入寻常相思之叹且直白说破，余味稍欠。","_cost":0.005511},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.5,"rationale":"以影像常新反衬旧梦惹尘，触及当代经验但开掘浅；首句直陈少诗味，文白夹杂，结句直问少留白。","_cost":0.01139475},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.5,"rationale":"以云端影像寄怀远之情，题旨集中而情事泛化。“屏中笑语”有虚实相映之趣；首句偏说明，“惹微尘”“共此人”生涩。转结顺接，问归直露，余味有限；天涯、旧梦等语较熟。","_cost":0.03373},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.75,"rationale":"主脑在屏中远人，情可感而境常见，云端之题未入正文。首句说明化，微尘与数字未相融；第三句作转，章法完整。结句直问归期，余味有限。套语不多，无袭句硬伤。","_cost":0.024016},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.5,"rationale":"以云端相册写相思,当代经验入诗,但角度常见。首句“数字留存”直白近散文;“惹微尘”与数码影像略有抵牾。第三句拟人稍见巧思。结句“何日归来”落入套语,“共此人”生硬,余味有限。","_cost":0.016092},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.25,"rationale":"云端相册引出怀人之情，新影与旧梦有对照；但起句近于说明，‘天涯旧梦’稍陈。由屏中笑语转到归期，脉络清楚，结句却把思念说得较尽。","_cost":0.008096}},"consensus":53.71,"final":53.71},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"天台数尺倚云开，盆土分畦种菜栽。却喜嚣尘飞不到，一篮新绿带香来。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.4,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.4,"警句":1.8,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.2,"rationale":"取都市天台种菜，清新自足，物象集中，转结顺畅。“一篮新绿带香来”颇可感；但“种菜栽”语意重复，“嚣尘飞不到”稍显绝对，题旨与表达总体较常见。","_cost":0.00502},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.25,"rationale":"都市天台种菜为当代经验入诗,题材小巧亲切,结句以新绿带香收束尚有余味。惜'种菜栽'语意重复凑字,'嚣尘不到'为熟套,通篇平顺而乏警策,情感真而浅,炼字功夫不足。","_cost":0.03063},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"都市天台种菜为当代经验入诗，题旨明确但止于闲适自得。“种菜栽”词义重复，“倚云开”夸饰失实，“嚣尘飞不到”属陈套。结句以一篮新绿带香收束，形象具体、稍有余味，但全篇转折平直，无诗眼警句。","_cost":0.0341},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.5,"rationale":"当代生活入诗，天台种菜富有情趣，起承转合规整。然'种菜栽'同义重复略显凑字，语言偏平直。'一篮新绿'画面感佳，结句稳当但余味稍欠。","_cost":0.013668},"grok-4.6":{"立意":4.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"此诗写天台种菜之乐，立意浅近常见。意象如嚣尘、新绿较套，氛围尚统一。用语平实，‘种菜栽’略冗，无出色炼字。绝句结构完整，转合平直。结句具体有香，余味有限。无典故硬伤及蹈袭，当代生活入诗略见出新。","_cost":0.031524},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.25,"rationale":"写天台种菜，情怀真切，结句以景收束，余味清新。'倚云开''新绿带香'可见炼字与佳句，章法完整。惟立意稍浅，'种菜栽'微凑，'嚣尘飞不到'偏熟。","_cost":0.01010196},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"城市天台种菜题材有当代生活气息，主脑清晰。'倚云'与'盆土'高下相对，'嚣尘'与'新绿'雅俗映照，意境完整。章法起承转合分明，'却喜'一转自然，结句以景收束留有清味。惜'种菜栽'三字凑韵生硬，'栽'字属废字，语言硬伤拖累全篇。","_cost":0.00285696},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.6,"余味":7.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.7,"rationale":"题旨明确，写天台菜园闹中取静，情感具体但角度常见。‘新绿带香’收束清新，余味较好；起承转合顺畅而转折稍直。语言有亮点，唯‘种菜栽’略赘，‘嚣尘’等语稍熟。","_cost":0.015858},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.0,"rationale":"以都市天台种菜写避嚣之趣，题旨集中，转句'却喜'见开合，结句'一篮新绿带香来'以景结情，鲜活动人略有延宕。惜立意角度尚属常见，'嚣尘飞不到'意近熟语，语言通顺而锤炼未深，整体平稳少波澜。","_cost":0.0084392},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.4,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.3,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.7,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.7,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.39999999999999,"rationale":"都市楼顶辟圃题材常见，情直意浅；‘种菜栽’赘余、‘数尺倚云’夸饰失度；章法完整而平直，结句以篮菜带香收束，画面可感但余韵不深。","_cost":0.0104915},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"写天台盆栽种菜，题材当代而立意寻常；意象妥帖稍常见，语言通顺少诗眼，章法起承转合完整，结句以景收束有余味。“嚣尘飞不到”稍陈滥，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.030860573},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"此作写天台种菜闲趣，题旨明确，脉络顺畅，语言通顺，结句尚有清致；但立意、意象偏熟套，转折平直，余味不足，“种菜栽”略冗余，无硬伤蹈袭，稍有陈语。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.7,"语言":5.2,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.85,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗，起转顺畅，尾句“一篮新绿”收得生动鲜活，富于生活情趣。唯次句“种菜栽”同义叠凑、斧凿明显，转句稍落陈套，整体语浅意平。","_cost":0.004878},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.75,"rationale":"天台种菜取材都市生活较实，但喜避嚣尘意 common；盆土新绿小有生气，种菜栽重复、倚云夸饰；转结平直落于收获，无留白。","_cost":0.00826875},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"以天台种菜写尘中自适，情事具体但旨趣常见。“一篮新绿”鲜活可感；“种菜栽”语意复沓，“倚云”“嚣尘”略熟。起承清楚，转折较平，结句以色香收束，尚有余味。","_cost":0.03865},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"楼顶尺地种菜避嚣,主脑清楚,情志近田园常套。分畦、篮香较切,意境能统一;种菜栽凑字,却喜一转过直。结句以景收,余味浅。","_cost":0.0188944},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.0,"rationale":"都市天台种菜,当代经验入诗,但避尘喜绿的角度较常见。'种菜栽'语意重复,属凑字。'倚云开''嚣尘'略嫌套语。第三句用'却喜'转折,较平直。结句以'一篮新绿'收束,清新可感,但余韵有限。","_cost":0.01606},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"天台种菜写出闹中取静之趣，新绿带香，触感可喜。起承转合清楚，但“种菜栽”稍显重复，“倚云”“嚣尘”较熟，结句妥帖而余味有限。","_cost":0.00743}},"consensus":59.99,"final":59.99},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|机场送别|七绝","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"银鹰展翼入长风，此去云程托远空。目送航班升杳霭，从今别绪满胸中。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.8,"语言":3.8,"章法":4.2,"余味":2.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.45,"rationale":"送别主旨明确，但情事泛化；银鹰、长风、云程、别绪多属套语。前三句意象重复推进，转折不足；末句直陈胸臆，说尽无余味。“航班升杳霭”搭配稍硬。","_cost":0.005392},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":3.5,"意境":3.0,"语言":2.5,"章法":3.5,"余味":1.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":27.75,"rationale":"题材当代但处理平庸：无具体人事，送别对象与情事全无着落。'银鹰''云程''杳霭'皆套语，前三句同写飞机起飞原地打转，'银鹰'与'航班'语意重复且文白夹杂。结句'别绪满胸中'直陈说尽，毫无留白。","_cost":0.02351},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":2.5,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":1.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":26.25,"rationale":"题旨泛泛，无具体人事，仅是送别口号。“银鹰”“云程”“远空”“杳霭”皆陈套飞机意象，一二句重复写起飞，三句无真转，结句“别绪满胸中”说破兜底毫无留白。语言通顺而空洞，无诗眼。","_cost":0.03328},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":3.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":2.5,"章法":3.5,"余味":1.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":26.5,"rationale":"虽写现代送别，但立意平庸。充斥“银鹰”“航班”等陈套词汇，语言近白话，缺乏锤炼。结句“别绪满胸中”彻底说破，毫无留白与余味，整体起承转合平直如流水账，缺乏诗意张力。","_cost":0.02485},"grok-4.6":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":36.5,"rationale":"送别熟题未见翻新，情感空泛。银鹰云程等意象陈套，末句直抒无象。语言通顺但文白杂糅少诗眼。章法承转平直。结句说破无余味。","_cost":0.01983},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.25,"rationale":"送别题旨明确但角度常见，情事不具体。意象妥帖而陈套，银鹰、长风、云程等密度较高。语言通顺无诗眼。章法完整但转结平直，结句直说别绪，缺少留白。现代机场题材略有新意，但表达方式旧。","_cost":0.00811272},"glm-5.3":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.0,"rationale":"送别题旨明确但角度常见，无独到发现。银鹰、云程、杳霭意象妥帖却陈熟，未见诗眼。结构起承转合完整但转折平直。结句直陈胸中别绪，说破说尽，全无留白，余味大损。当代机场经验入诗可予微许，套话密度适中扣陈滥分。","_cost":0.0025632},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.75,"rationale":"机场送别题旨明确，现代物象稍有新鲜感，但银鹰、云程、别绪等语汇偏熟套；章法完整而转折平直，结句直说满胸，缺少余味。","_cost":0.006792},"kimi-k3":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.0,"rationale":"现代送别题旨明确但角度平常,情事不具体;前三句皆写飞机入空,意象(银鹰、云程、杳霭)套语连缀且义近重复,章法原地打转;结句'别绪满胸中'直说兜底,毫无留白。机场经验入诗稍予出新,然仅以古辞藻敷饰,未见化合。","_cost":0.0210396},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":4.8,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.2,"章法":5.3,"余味":2.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.8,"rationale":"题旨明确但角度常套直抒别绪，意象银鹰长风等陈熟；航班入诗夹白少锤炼，章法线性平直，结句说尽无留白。","_cost":0.0096165},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.5,"rationale":"题旨明确而角度常见；起承转合完整但转折平直；意象多长风、云程等陈语，情景未深融；结句直说别绪满胸，说破少余味。语言通顺，无警句，现代词入诗平平，无硬伤蹈袭，陈滥较重。","_cost":0.030070257},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.5,"rationale":"本诗咏机场送别，题旨明确但无新致，意象、语言平俗，章法顺直无波澜，结句直抒别绪太直白，无亮眼佳句，未出新意，无硬伤与蹈袭，部分表达陈套。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.2,"章法":3.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":33.15,"rationale":"前三句语义高度重合，皆写飞机入云；‘航班’入诗生涩，‘银鹰’流于俗套。章法原地打转，结句直白说尽离愁，缺乏留白与余韵。","_cost":0.006141},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":34.75,"rationale":"题旨常见无具体情事，银鹰长风皆套语，航班满胸中文白直露，结句说破兜底无留白。","_cost":0.0104128},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":1.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.75,"rationale":"送别题旨明确，情事欠具体；意象尚统一，但“银鹰”“云程”等陈熟，“托远空”语意勉强。首、三句复写升空，推进有限；结句直说别绪，缺少留白。航班入诗未带来独特发现。","_cost":0.03676},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":36.75,"rationale":"送别主脑清楚，然人事不具体，情志空泛。银鹰、云程、杳霭套语连缀，又与航班文白相犯，景情未融。前三句同写升空，转结无力；末句说破别绪，无余味。","_cost":0.02836},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":3.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":32.5,"rationale":"题旨明确但角度常见，未写出送别者与行人的具体情事。前三句都写飞机升空，入长风、托远空、升杳霭意思重复，原地打转，第三句无转。银鹰、云程属套语。结句直言别绪满胸，说破无余味。机场题材有当代感，但未有效入诗。","_cost":0.015572},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":31.5,"rationale":"送别之情明确，但缺少具体情事；前三句反复写飞机远去，转折不足。“银鹰”“云程”等语较熟，末句直说别绪，余味偏少。","_cost":0.005952}},"consensus":38.55,"final":38.55},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|天台菜园|七律","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"天台累土得清幽，巷陌尘嚣隔此楼。引水浇畦成绿圃，栽瓜种豆及时收。柔藤上架迎晖发，翠荚垂垂满眼稠。却喜人间生野趣，何须远慕武陵游。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.4,"语言":5.7,"章法":6.1,"余味":4.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.49999999999999,"rationale":"天台种菜切入都市生活，主旨集中，藤架翠荚颇可感；中二联铺陈稍平，“迎晖发”“满眼稠”略显凑意。结尾直陈野趣并借武陵作衬，收束完整但意尽，套意稍重。","_cost":0.005972},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.0,"rationale":"都市天台种菜有当代生活气息，题旨明确但角度仍是田园套路。中二联皆写种植收获，开合层次不足，取象平实少交融。结句以'何须远慕武陵游'说破题旨，兜底无余味。尘嚣、清幽、武陵等语陈熟，全篇稳顺而乏警策。","_cost":0.03596},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.75,"rationale":"天台种菜为当代题材，然写法全属旧套：中二联仅铺叙栽种长势，无开合；“及时收”“迎晖发”语涉平直。结句以“何须远慕武陵游”兜底说尽，桃源意象陈熟，余味寡淡。","_cost":0.04468},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"以都市天台种菜的当代经验入诗，生活气息浓厚且结构严整。但中二联铺陈平直，语言近乎白话缺乏锤炼，尾联直白说尽，毫无留白，整体流于浅露。","_cost":0.01745},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"都市天台种菜得野趣不慕桃源，主脑明而角度熟。藤荚等象具体氛围统一但清幽尘嚣武陵陈。语言达意少炼近散文。中联层次尚可结构完。结句说破无延宕。","_cost":0.029728},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"写城市楼顶种菜，立意具体但角度平常，尾联点题直露；意象妥帖而偏熟，语言浅白有文白夹杂；中二联铺叙少开合，结句说破武陵典，余味不足。无硬伤、蹈袭，稍有当代生活气息。","_cost":0.0148632},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"题旨明确：闹市楼顶自辟菜园得野趣，角度常见（小桃源套路）。意象妥帖但多常语，'翠荚垂垂'稍见工。章法完整，颔颈二联一叙一描有层次，尾联以'何须武陵'翻转尚稳，惟'却喜人间生野趣'说破题旨，结句直白余味有限。城市天台经验入诗略有新意。","_cost":0.00302216},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.5,"rationale":"天台菜园题旨明确，有生活实感，但归结避尘野趣、武陵旧意，略常见。畦圃藤荚意象统一而欠新警，语言平顺少诗眼，尾联说破，余味不深。","_cost":0.011994},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"以都市天台种菜翻桃源旧意，题旨集中、当代经验入诗可取；颈联柔藤翠荚意象鲜活着色，然全篇语言平稳少警策，中二联铺叙平直，结句“何须远慕”直说兜底，余味不足。","_cost":0.020133},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.3,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.1,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.6,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.849999999999994,"rationale":"天台自圃立意具体有主脑但翻新有限；意象写实妥帖少交融；语言平直乏诗眼；章法完整而铺叙平直；尾联直引武陵说尽无留白。","_cost":0.011942},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"以都市天台菜园入律，题意集中；当代经验与武陵典翻出人间野趣，立意稍新。中二联平列种收与藤荚，意象妥帖但转折平直，结句直白少余味。语言通顺，偶见‘柔藤迎晖’亮点，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.030562964},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.5,"rationale":"本诗咏天台菜园，题旨明确、脉络通顺、语言平实，但立意落熟套，意象平泛，结句直露说尽少余韵，无硬伤蹈袭，缺亮眼佳句与新意，略有陈套语。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.2,"意境":4.8,"语言":4.9,"章法":5.2,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.0,"rationale":"当代天台种菜入诗，情真质朴。中二联描摹具体流畅，但平铺叙写、缺乏深炼与开合。尾联搬用武陵故典直白议论，径自点破，余韵不足。通篇结构稳整但诗意略平。","_cost":0.00456375},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.3,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.85,"rationale":"楼顶自耕不慕武陵，题明而沿田园旧路；藤荚之象具体而少情融；语言平直散文化；中二联复写生长无层次；尾联议论说破无留白。","_cost":0.01400905},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.0,"rationale":"天台种菜有生活实感，都市躬耕略见新意，藤荚取象切题。中二联铺叙稍重复，“及时收”偏直，“满眼稠”欠炼。结句以武陵作比，直陈不慕远游，收束明确而余味有限。","_cost":0.03421},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.5,"rationale":"城中天台菜圃反拨武陵，主脑明而情仅道喜，欠具体。中二联浇畦种豆与藤荚垂稠同写繁茂，景齐情浅，字顺无诗眼。转至尾方出，结句说尽，余味薄。屋顶园入诗略新，套语未密。","_cost":0.0213216},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.5,"rationale":"以城市天台种菜入诗,写的是当代经验,但立意停在闹中取静的常见层面。中二联都是平铺种植过程,颔联近于叙述,开合不足。先写及时收、后写翠荚满眼,次序略有颠倒。结句借武陵桃源作比,把意思说破,余味浅。","_cost":0.016752},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"天台种菜为寻常田园意趣添了城市场景，藤荚之景可感；但先写收获、后写生长，层次稍逆。“满眼稠”欠自然，结句借武陵直白点题，余味偏薄。","_cost":0.009222}},"consensus":51.56,"final":51.56},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"九万风鹏凌碧落，遥空极目夜珠明。惊疑大地繁星满，散作神州锦绣城。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.1,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.7,"章法":7.2,"余味":4.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.35,"rationale":"以夜航灯火错认繁星，天地倒置颇有情趣，转折清楚。首句化鹏翼写航机有势；但“遥空极目”稍涩，碧落、神州锦绣偏熟滥，结句赞美直露，余韵不足。","_cost":0.005572},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰灯火如星的错位视角为一篇之眼,'惊疑'转句有致,起承转合完整。惜取象常见,'风鹏''碧落'系熟套;结句'神州锦绣'落入颂词,说破无余,削弱前三句蓄势,通篇稳而不奇。","_cost":0.03465},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.0,"rationale":"夜航见灯火如繁星，题材当代却角度常见。“九万风鹏”“碧落”“神州锦绣”皆熟套，第二句“遥空极目”有赘。转句“惊疑”尚有变，结句落入颂词，说尽兜底，余味全无。","_cost":0.04177},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":33.5,"rationale":"本诗起承转合完整，但以古套词生写现代夜航体验，意象陈滥且带口号感。结句将繁星错觉直白揭穿为“锦绣城”，说尽说破，毫无含蓄留白与余味可言。","_cost":0.015624},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"鹏鸟起兴、星城互喻有一转，夜航入典尚可；然题旨常见、结句点破神州锦绣过直，炼字平稳少眼，意象略套。","_cost":0.01646},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"化用大鹏起势，俯瞰灯火如繁星，转结有画面；但意象较熟，结句解释性收束，余味稍欠。","_cost":0.01036068},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰将天星倒转为地上灯火，构思清晰，转句'惊疑'有力，起承转合完整，脉络一气。但星灯互喻属常见翻案，'九万风鹏''碧落''锦绣'等语偏熟套，结句归于'神州锦绣'略带颂赞套语，收束偏实，余味有限。","_cost":0.00246996},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":4.8,"意境":5.2,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰灯火，题旨明确而视角偏熟；大鹏、繁星、锦绣等意象稳妥但套语较多，转合完整而结句说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.012268},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰见地灯如繁星、散为城郭，题旨集中，转结有法。意象夜珠繁星尚切而稍熟，结句直说'神州锦绣'，近颂语、失于说破，余味大减。鹏典借《逍遥游》用于航机尚可，未见硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.03884265},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":4.8,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.3,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.85,"rationale":"夜航观灯立意常见无新境；鹏、碧落、繁星、锦绣城意象完整而陈套；语言通顺乏诗眼；起承转合俱全但转结平直；结句直点神州说尽无留白。","_cost":0.00899675},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"结构完整，转句惊疑生姿；然风鹏、繁星、锦绣城等意象套语偏熟，结句直白少留白，当代夜航题材未深化，故得分中等。","_cost":0.03102147},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.0,"rationale":"此诗写夜航俯瞰城灯之景，题旨明确但角度寻常，意象妥帖多熟套，语言平顺少炼字，章法完整却转折平直，结句直露少余味，无硬伤蹈袭，略存陈语，乏新警之思。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.8,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.3,"章法":6.7,"余味":4.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.7,"rationale":"现代夜航视角入诗，章法起承转合完备，倒错星空之境顺畅。唯“夜珠明”“锦绣城”等用语偏于熟套，结句径直点破说尽，余味稍显不足。","_cost":0.00592425},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"天地繁星倒置有巧思，然起句堆砌大词，夜珠含混，末句点破颂语，结构贯通而余味尽失。","_cost":0.01298905},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"以地上灯火拟繁星，第三句有视角翻转，夜航经验略见新意。但鹏、碧落、锦绣等熟语偏密，“九万风鹏”组合略涩。结句落实城景，收束完整却说得太尽，颂赞套语削弱余味。","_cost":0.04101},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"高空误认城灯为星，转折清楚，然颂神州收束，立意常见。鹏、碧落、夜珠、锦绣多套语，惊疑略具诗眼，结句说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.018586},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.0,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写城市灯火,属当代经验入诗。'地上繁星'的比喻常见,次句'夜珠'与三句'繁星'意象重复。起句用鹏典,碧落、神州锦绣等语偏熟套。转句'惊疑'略有波折,结句以'锦绣城'直白收束,近于颂语,余味不足。","_cost":0.017848},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.0,"rationale":"夜航见地上灯火如繁星，视角有趣，起承转合清楚；但“碧落”“神州锦绣”等语偏熟，末句点明所见，余味稍浅。","_cost":0.008012}},"consensus":54.45,"final":54.45},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"巷口长身迎晓色，常收客赠旧衣香。曾随瘦骨经年雪，散作寒村遍野光。解下冬袍投此窖，终教敝絮入穷乡。无言独守晨昏影，乃是慈恩济世箱。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.2,"章法":6.2,"余味":3.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.8,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.050000000000004,"rationale":"以回收箱写旧衣流转与济贫，题材有当代性；“瘦骨经年雪”稍见情意。中二联意旨重复，“窖”“旧衣香”略显硬凑，末句直揭慈恩济世，留白不足。","_cost":0.005496},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.75,"rationale":"当代题材入诗可取,颔联瘦骨经雪、散作野光稍见意象经营。然颈联与颔联意思重复,原地打转;'旧衣香'欠切;尾联'乃是慈恩济世箱'直接点破题旨,近于颂语口号,余味尽失。整体咏物未能寄托深情,立意浅直。","_cost":0.0377},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.5,"rationale":"取当代物事入诗有新意，颔联“瘦骨经年雪／寒村遍野光”稍见笔力。然颈联与首联同说投衣入箱，层次重叠；“此窖”“客赠”“旧衣香”用词欠切；结句“乃是慈恩济世箱”直白点题，说破兜底，余味尽失。","_cost":0.04992},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"当代题材入诗值得肯定，颔联想象生动、富有温情。然颈颔两联意旨稍显重复，语言偏直白，如“投此窖”略显生硬。结句“乃是慈恩济世箱”直接说破下定义，缺乏留白与余味。","_cost":0.018762},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.5,"rationale":"以回收箱写济世角度稍新，颔联瘦骨经年雪较有力；然窖字失当，尾联点破无余味，慈恩套语说教，章法平直。","_cost":0.0188},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":31.5,"rationale":"题材有当代性但情感浮泛，主题直露如口号。意象间勾连松散，颔联“寒村遍野光”与旧衣关系模糊。尾联说破无余味，中二联平行堆叠，语言浅白少诗眼。仅题材略见出新，余多陈套。","_cost":0.006333448},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱拟人立意，写衣物由'经年雪'到'遍野光'的流转，视角有新意，颔联情景交融堪称诗眼。惜中二联意思重叠近合掌，'窖'字略生硬，尾句'慈恩济世箱'直呼题旨、说破无余，收束沦为口号，拖累全篇。","_cost":0.0041026},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.15,"rationale":"咏当代旧衣回收箱，题旨明确，颔联有温度；但慈恩济世箱说破，标语感重，意象稍泛，长身、此窖欠精。结构完整而结句乏余味。","_cost":0.015386},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.5,"rationale":"以回收箱写慈善有当代性，拟人亦有焦点；但“慈恩济世”直露兜底，“窖”“旧衣香”生硬，中二联开合有限，善意多而发现少。","_cost":0.0159486},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.8,"语言":4.3,"章法":5.7,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.45,"rationale":"借新物颂慈善，立意可取而流于概念；‘香’‘窖’‘遍野光’失切，中二联复沓，尾联‘乃是’直揭兜底，景未融情、余味说尽。","_cost":0.009962},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱为题作七律，题旨清楚而角度常见（立意中上）；用象如瘦骨、寒村、穷乡略熟，“投此窖”称箱不确（有硬伤），中二联意重、转折平直；结句直点慈恩济世，说破少余味；颔联“曾随瘦骨经年雪”稍有情味。","_cost":0.036816298},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.5,"rationale":"咏旧衣回收箱题旨明确，“曾随瘦骨经年雪”句有质感，但“窖”喻失准，中二联表意略复，结句直白兜底余味薄，落于俗常褒扬，新意有限。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.6,"语言":5.4,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.2,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"当代日常物象入诗，情怀真挚。颔联写旧衣去向颇具画面感。惜中二联语意复沓，颈联复述投衣助困致脉络停滞；尾联“乃是”直呼题旨，说破兜底，余味较寡。","_cost":0.00581775},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.8,"章法":5.2,"余味":2.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.5,"rationale":"以回收箱咏慈济取材新颖，颔联写旧衣流转略有情味，然中二联复沓，转而不转，窖、乃是箱失炼直白，尾联说破兜底。","_cost":0.0128153},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.75,"rationale":"以旧衣济困为主脑，题旨明确却止于泛泛颂扬；雪与光略有冷暖映照，中二联却重复衣物去向。“投此窖”措辞牵强，末句直陈功德、点题说尽。题材略新，尚未形成独特发现。","_cost":0.04733},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"题旨集中，回收箱入诗略有当代感，瘦骨经年雪尚见情事。颈联复述捐赠与去向，转接平，近于打转。结句以乃是慈恩济世说破，无余味。香、光、箱凑韵，回收径作济世欠妥，寒村穷乡敝絮偏套。","_cost":0.0288464},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，当代题材有新意。“曾随瘦骨经年雪”一句尚有温度。颈联与颔联意思重复，顺序也乱，衣物已散往寒村，又回头写投衣。“窖”字用来指箱，并不贴切。结句“慈恩济世箱”直接说破，近于口号，没有余味。","_cost":0.017828},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.0,"rationale":"借回收箱写济人之愿，题材有当代感；中二联重复写旧衣送往贫乡，“此窖”“遍野光”欠贴切。末句直陈主旨，余味较少。","_cost":0.008066}},"consensus":46.16,"final":46.16},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"异地逢君共视频，宵深暗里见伊人。屏中笑语温如昔，独对星河只影身。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.3,"意境":6.1,"语言":4.8,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.4,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.1,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"以视频之暖反衬异地孤寂，主旨集中，今事入诗自然。屏内屏外转合清楚；“共视频”稍生硬，“独、只影、身”语意重复，伊人、星河亦略陈套。","_cost":0.005232},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"当代视频通话经验入诗有可取处，结句以屏中之暖反衬独对星河之孤，稍有余味。惜前两句'逢君''见伊人'语意重复，'共视频'直白如白话，炼字乏力，'伊人''只影'皆熟套，转折平直，整体达意而欠锤炼。","_cost":0.03277},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"以视频通话入诗有当代经验，屏中笑语与独对星河的冷暖对照是全篇支点。但前两句语意重复（逢君、见伊人皆言视频相见），起承浪费；“共视频”“只影身”为凑韵略生硬；星河、伊人、只影皆熟象。结句以景收束尚可，惟“只影”已说破孤单，留白有限。","_cost":0.04594},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.25,"rationale":"以当代生活入诗，借虚拟相聚与现实孤单作对比，章法完整。但语言文白夹杂，首句如白话，“只影身”涉嫌凑字，后半段意象陈套，结句说尽无留白。","_cost":0.020648},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"异地视频相思题旨明确且情事具体，然角度常见未翻新境。星河、伊人、只影陈套，屏中与星河未融为统一氛围。文白夹杂，只影身生硬无诗眼。起承尚可，第三句未真正转。结句直说孤独，说破无留白。","_cost":0.021238},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.75,"rationale":"写异地视频通话，情感真实但角度平常；“宵深暗里”意重，“只影身”略凑。结句以星河只影反衬孤独，稍落套。现代视频题材略有新意，通篇无警句。","_cost":0.01177572},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"异地视频寄相思，题旨明确且当代经验入诗有效，屏中笑语与星河只影的冷暖对照构境尚可，结句以景收束留有余味。但'君''伊人'指代叠床架屋，'只影身'生凑凑韵，'宵深暗里'与题重复，星河孤影意象偏熟，语言锤炼不足拖累整体。","_cost":0.00379156},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.4,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.8,"rationale":"异地视频入诗，题旨明确，结构起承转合清楚；屏中温暖与独对星河形成对照，略有余情。但语多直白，伊人、星河、只影等意象偏熟，结句说破，锤炼与新境不足。","_cost":0.016226},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.75,"rationale":"以视频通话写异地相思，聚焦连接与孤寂之悖，题旨明确但角度常见；屏、宵、星河诸象尚能成氛围，然多陈熟；\"只影身\"\"共视频\"语生硬欠炼；结构完整而转折平直；结以星河孤影，留白尚可但属熟套。","_cost":0.02735145},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.2,"语言":4.6,"章法":5.7,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.50000000000001,"rationale":"以视频入题有时代感，屏中温语与星河孤影对比见情，立意完整。然语言平直口语化，意象星河只影较常见，少诗眼锤炼。","_cost":0.007823},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"写异地视频相会，屏上温笑与星河只影对照，情真而构思常见。语言文白夹杂，‘共视频’‘只影身’稍拙；转句平直，结以景收有余味。当代经验入诗，意象稍熟，有片段可取。","_cost":0.02594694},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.5,"rationale":"此作写异地深夜视频的孤怀，题旨明确但角度平熟，意象妥帖多套语，语言通顺略有冗余，章法完整转折偏直，结句稳实少留白，仅提视频场景未融新意，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.2,"意境":4.8,"语言":4.2,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.4,"rationale":"切入现代生活经验，转结合理，屏内温存与屏外冷清对比鲜明。然首句入诗略硬，古今语汇杂糅；“只影身”凑合显合掌，炼字造句尚欠精醇。","_cost":0.0044115},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":3.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.75,"rationale":"以视频写异地相思，屏暖身孤对比明确；然起承同义重复，语言夹白欠炼，星河孤影常见，结句以景收略有余味。","_cost":0.01193275},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.75,"rationale":"屏中温情与独处孤寂形成对照，题旨明确但角度常见。前两句意重，“只影身”生硬，“独”“只”复沓。结句以星河拓景，却又点明孤独，留白有限；视频入诗略有新意。","_cost":0.03256},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.25,"rationale":"题旨清楚：屏中温情对照身畔孤寂，然角度常见，情事未落到具体人事。前两句近于同义复述，语言偏白，只影身生硬。结句反差成立，但独、只影说破孤独，余味不足。星河、伊人、温如昔皆熟套。","_cost":0.012744},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.25,"rationale":"异地视频入诗,当代经验可取,屏中之暖与身外之孤对照成立。首二句语义重复,'逢君'与'见伊人'叠床,'共视频''暗里'近口语凑字。第三句尚温润。结句以星河孤影收,有对照但'只影'近套语,略说破。","_cost":0.014536},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.25,"rationale":"屏中笑语与独对星河形成冷暖反差，情意可感；前两句信息略重复，“共视频”“只影身”稍显硬凑，结句点明孤独，余味有限。","_cost":0.006782}},"consensus":50.59,"final":50.59},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|机场送别|七律","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"银鹰展翅向苍茫，客子辞亲怯晓凉。检票通关程已远，廊桥寂寂满清霜。班机忽破长空去，万里云山阻望乡。伫久幽厅人散尽，离情早付托飞航。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"fail"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"weak"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.4,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.3,"章法":6.1,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":0.8,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.39999999999999,"rationale":"送别主旨明确，机场流程使情境具体，叙事亦完整；但银鹰、长空、云山等陈套偏密，视角转换稍突。“满清霜”失实，“付托飞航”生硬，结句直说离情，余味较弱。","_cost":0.008352},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.25,"rationale":"送别熟题无新境,'银鹰展翅''万里云山'近老干套语;'检票通关程已远'文白夹杂如流程记述,中二联对仗松散、开合无层次。'廊桥寂寂满清霜'一句稍可,惜与室内场景略牴牾。结句'离情早付托飞航'说破兜底,余味殆尽。当代题材入诗有心而未化。","_cost":0.04588},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":3.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.75,"rationale":"题材当代却处理平庸：首联已“银鹰展翅”，颈联又“班机忽破长空”，时序重复混乱；“检票通关程已远”散文化，“离情早付托飞航”凑韵说破。惟“廊桥寂寂”“幽厅人散尽”略有氛围，然廊桥室内“满清霜”失实。","_cost":0.0464},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":33.5,"rationale":"将机场送别等现代经验入诗，脉络清晰。但文白夹杂，用语老套；结句直白兜底，毫无余味。且封闭的“廊桥”满“清霜”违背生活常识，意象生硬拼凑，整体流于平庸。","_cost":0.016238},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":2.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":3.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":31.5,"rationale":"题旨机场送别明确而角度熟套。银鹰清霜云山与检票廊桥杂糅，文白未融。起句已展翅，颔联仍通关，时序颠倒、视角游移。结句直点离情，余韵不足。","_cost":0.02696},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.25,"rationale":"机场送别题材现代，但意象情感多熟套，结句直白说破。中二联略有空间推进，语言平直少诗眼，'廊桥满清霜'稍涉不实，套语密度偏高。","_cost":0.01335708},"glm-5.3":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.0,"rationale":"送别题旨明确但角度平常，情语泛泛。机场物象入律诗略有新意，然'银鹰''辞亲''望乡''离情'等套语密度偏高；首联已写飞机升空，颈联复写'班机忽破长空去'，逻辑重复；结句直说离情、付托飞航，说破无余味。'廊桥寂寂满清霜'稍佳。","_cost":0.00424536},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"机场送别脉络清晰，现代场景略有新意；但银鹰、云山、离情等意象偏熟，结句直说，余味较弱。","_cost":0.011904},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"机场送别选材较新，线索完整，惜视角在客子与送者间游移；“银鹰”“万里云山”等熟象偏多，结句直说离情且“付托飞航”生硬，余味受损。","_cost":0.0179652},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.2,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.6,"余味":3.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.4,"rationale":"机场送别题旨明确而乏新境，取象切题但套语较多，语言夹白锤炼不足，章法循时序平直，尾联直抒说尽乏余味。","_cost":0.0124865},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"以机场送别入律，情事具体，现代经验有一定呈现；然意象多沿用清霜、云山、望乡等套语，结句直说离情，余味稍欠；章法完整、转折平稳，语言偶见怯、破之炼，整体中规中矩。","_cost":0.036367785},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.75,"rationale":"此作写机场送别，题旨明确但角度平俗，意象妥帖偏陈，语言平顺少锤炼，章法顺直无波澜，结句直白余味不足；融入当代场景未出新，无明显硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.2,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.65,"rationale":"现代送别入诗具生活感，但“银鹰”属泛滥套语。首句“展翅”与颈联“破空”时序重复，章法欠理；词句如“检票通关”近于直白记事，结句径说“离情”，余味稍薄。","_cost":0.0071025},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.0,"rationale":"题旨明确而情事笼统无主脑，廊桥通关当代语多直白散化，首联颈联两次起飞时序复沓，尾联直说离情无留白。","_cost":0.0132005},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.75,"rationale":"送别题旨明确，起飞至人散尚有层次；“银鹰”“云山”等熟象偏密，“清霜”略显硬置。“伫久”见留恋，但“早付托飞航”语意滞涩，末句直说离情，削弱余味；机场语汇未成新境。","_cost":0.04401},"grok-4.7":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.75,"rationale":"送别主脑清楚而情无新见，未见具体情事。凉霜云山与检票廊桥并置未融。文白夹杂，飞航幽厅生硬，无诗眼。时序完整而转平。结句直说离情，少余味。","_cost":0.0261728},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":3.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":32.25,"rationale":"机场送别有当代经验,但角度平常。首句已写飞机展翅,五句又写起飞,前后重复且时序混乱。'廊桥满清霜'不合实景。'望乡'视角偏向行者,与送别主体错位。'检票通关'直白近散文,'银鹰''万里云山'较陈套。结句'离情早付'说破,余味浅。","_cost":0.0175},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.0,"rationale":"检票、廊桥有送别现场感，但“银鹰展翅”“万里云山”较陈套；首句与第五句重复写起飞，结句直说离情，“付托飞航”亦显生硬。","_cost":0.010862}},"consensus":43.2,"final":43.2},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"〔默写嫌疑：与古典诗库整句重合，原文不予公开。九月尚未设收卷查重，本首按评委原分计入；自十月起此类作品记 0 分〕","dup_lines":2,"verdict":null,"coef":0.75,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":2.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":9.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.5,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":4.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":5.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"题名“社区食堂”与正文全无关联；正文完整照录崔护《题都城南庄》。原诗意象、转结俱佳，但本作无任何转化，属整篇蹈袭。","_cost":0.0078},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":0.5,"意境":1.0,"语言":1.0,"章法":1.0,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":3.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":5.0,"score":0.75,"rationale":"全篇照搬崔护《题都城南庄》原作，一字未改，属整首蹈袭，从重扣满。且题为《社区食堂》而文本与题旨毫无关联，题意完全游离。原诗虽佳，但非作者所创，各维不得计原作之功。","_cost":0.02312},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":1.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":3.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":5.0,"score":50.0,"rationale":"正文系整篮照录崔护《题都城南庄》，与题目《社区食堂》毫无关联，题意完全游离。文本本身为唐人名作，意象、章法、余味俱佳，但非作者创作，蹈袭满扣，立意归零，题文脱节计硬伤。","_cost":0.03599},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":0.0,"意境":9.0,"语言":9.5,"章法":10.0,"余味":10.0,"警句":5.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":5.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":5.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"全诗一字不差抄袭唐代崔护《题都城南庄》，属严重蹈袭。且标题《社区食堂》与正文内容毫无关联，严重文不对题，故立意0分，蹈袭与硬伤均满扣。其余维度依古人原诗水平给分。","_cost":0.017256},"grok-4.6":{"立意":2.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":9.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":5.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":5.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"全文即崔护《题都城南庄》，与标题《社区食堂》毫无干涉，题意完全游离，属整篇蹈袭。","_cost":0.01995},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":0.0,"意境":2.0,"语言":2.0,"章法":1.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":5.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":5.0,"score":3.0,"rationale":"正文系崔护《题都城南庄》全诗照搬，与标题《社区食堂》完全脱节，题意游离；蹈袭从重扣满，警句非己出不给分。","_cost":0.01968648},"glm-5.3":{"立意":1.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":3.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":5.0,"score":27.5,"rationale":"正文四句系崔护《题都城南庄》原文整首袭用，与标题《社区食堂》完全脱节，题意游离属逻辑硬伤。文本自身虽为名篇，但非作者创作，各维不给创作分，警句、出新均计零，蹈袭按整句袭用从重扣满。","_cost":0.0055012},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":2.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":9.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":5.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":5.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"正文为前人成作，且与标题《社区食堂》完全脱节；诗本身意境、语言、章法俱佳，但构成严重蹈袭与题意硬伤。","_cost":0.00807},"kimi-k3":{"立意":1.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":9.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":4.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":5.0,"score":58.5,"rationale":"正文系崔护《题都城南庄》原句整首照搬,属最严重蹈袭,警句、出新均不予计;标题《社区食堂》与内容全然脱节,题意游离构成硬伤。单论文本意境、章法、余味本为上乘,然非投稿者之作,立意维度按题文割裂从严给分。","_cost":0.0074898},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":1.5,"意境":8.8,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":5.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"全文照录崔护《题都城南庄》四句，与标题《社区食堂》题文完全游离，构成整首蹈袭；文本诗质虽高但归原作，不计加分。","_cost":0.01108575},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":1.0,"意境":9.5,"语言":10.0,"章法":9.5,"余味":10.0,"警句":5.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":5.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"题名《社区食堂》却全袭崔护《题都城南庄》，题意游离，立意极低。名篇意象交融，语言有“笑”字诗眼，章法精严，结句以景结情余味长，故余四维近满分。蹈袭扣5，警句加5，无他加减。","_cost":0.02993937},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":0.0,"意境":9.0,"语言":9.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":5.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":5.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"本作题为《社区食堂》，内容全袭崔护《题都城南庄》，题意严重游离，立意0分；所袭文本语工章合、境谐味永，有警策名句，无出新、硬伤、陈滥，整诗蹈袭从重扣分。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":0.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":9.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":5.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":5.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"正文全抄唐代崔护名作，蹈袭顶格扣5分，不计原创警句与出新。标题与正文彻底割裂，题意完全游离，立意定极低档且构严重硬伤。除文题脱节与剽窃外，文本自身语言、章法及结句余味达经典高度。","_cost":0.0377145},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":2.0,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.5,"警句":5.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":5.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"全文照抄崔护《题都城南庄》，与标题社区食堂完全游离，原作之美仍在，蹈袭从重。","_cost":0.01573255},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.5,"警句":4.5,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":5.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"人面、桃花交映，今昔转换紧凑，末句以花之依旧衬人之不见，余味深长。但与《社区食堂》题意无涉，正文全文照录崔护《题都城南庄》，蹈袭从重，不计出新。","_cost":0.0361},"grok-4.7":{"立意":2.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":3.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":5.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"正文全录崔护《题都城南庄》,与题《社区食堂》无涉,立意游离。四句本身取象精切、字有诗眼、起承转合完整、结句余味深,故维度不全盘压低。蹈袭从重扣满;题文抵牾另记硬伤;无出新。","_cost":0.0367552},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":1.0,"意境":2.0,"语言":2.0,"章法":2.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":3.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":5.0,"score":9.5,"rationale":"正文为崔护《题都城南庄》原诗整篇照录，连原题也一并抄入，属整篇袭用，蹈袭从重。原诗虽佳，却非作者所作，警句与出新不计。标题“社区食堂”与桃花人面之旨毫不相干，题文完全脱节，立意游离，各维按非原创、离题处理，从低评定。","_cost":0.015576},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":2.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":4.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":5.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"正文照录崔护《题都城南庄》，其意象、转结本有感染力，但与《社区食堂》题目毫无关联；全篇袭用，出新为零。","_cost":0.00788}},"consensus":49.0,"final":36.75},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"春街病树挂银瓶，玉液潜滋润瘦形。莫讶东风无药气，全凭一线引芳馨。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.6,"余味":6.3,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.15,"rationale":"以树木输液写春日疗愈，取材新鲜，物我映照尚含蓄。前二句设景，后二句转结清楚；“银瓶”“一线”醒目，但“玉液”“芳馨”稍熟，“潜滋润”略滞，结句收束偏直。","_cost":0.00519},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"以街树输液这一当代城市景观入诗，取材新颖，题旨集中。转句'莫讶'宕开有致，结句'一线引芳馨'化输液管为传春之媒，构思巧妙但收得稍直白。'玉液''芳馨'等词略落熟套，'润瘦形'炼字稍勉强。整体机趣有余，情味稍浅。","_cost":0.03728},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.5,"rationale":"取街树输营养液入诗,当代经验有效,构思巧;转结以“无药气”“一线引芳馨”双关收束,略带谐趣。惟“玉液”“芳馨”等词陈套,与吊瓶实景稍隔,“润瘦形”硌涩,结句偏于说破,情志浅而少感慨。","_cost":0.04315},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.0,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗，题材出新。然以“银瓶”“玉液”生套现代事物略感割裂，结句直白说理，缺乏留白余味，整体意境偏干，属结构完整但手法平直之作。","_cost":0.014752},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"吊瓶护树有当代观察，立意具体于病树瘦形但情偏说明。银瓶玉液一线与东风对照，氛围人工催芳尚统一。语言通达，潜滋一线稍炼。章法完整转平直。结句点破一线引芳，说尽少留白。出新有效，东风芳馨略套。","_cost":0.018684},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.6,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.4,"余味":5.7,"警句":2.2,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.9,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.6,"rationale":"现代树木输液入诗，立意新巧；银瓶、玉液转化医用物象，氛围统一但东风、芳馨稍熟。章法起承转合稳，转结有思致，惟结句略说破，余味稍弱。无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":0.0052382352},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.0,"rationale":"以城市绿化树输液的当代场景入诗,取材新颖,构思完整。起承写病树输液,转句宕开设问,结句以一线引芳馨收束,脉络贯通。玉液、东风等词稍熟,结句微露说意,但整体清新可喜。","_cost":0.00255636},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.3,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.8,"rationale":"当代街景入诗，病树输液取象新鲜，立意明确。银瓶玉液画面可感，但后两句议论稍直，收束略说破，余味有限。语言通顺有巧思，无硬伤。","_cost":0.008388},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"以街头病树输液之当代实景入绝，取象成系统、主脑集中，'东风无药气''一线引芳馨'翻出新意，转合清顺；惜机巧多于深情，'润瘦形'略滞，'全凭'稍露说明语，余韵欠厚。","_cost":0.0322692},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.3,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.8,"rationale":"以行道树挂吊瓶切入春题角度新颖具体，转结有变；意象集中但情融未深，结句以议论收束直露，余味略欠。","_cost":0.0089615},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"以街树输液之当代经验入诗，翻「东风」旧题，焦点集中，「一线」双关见巧；然立意情感稍浅，结句「全凭」直白少余味，间有「玉液」「芳馨」等常语。","_cost":0.026895654},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"此作取当代春街树挂吊瓶的新题材入诗，主脑集中，起承转合顺畅，意象妥帖，语言平顺；唯立意未深掘，结句偏直白，余味不足，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.6,"章法":6.8,"余味":6.2,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"将当代给树输液之景化入七绝，以银瓶、一线借代妥帖，章法承转自然。结处虽略显直白点题，然运思轻灵，成功将现代物象融入传统语境。","_cost":0.005997},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.2,"意境":4.8,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.8,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.300000000000004,"rationale":"以病树输液写春别开生面，主脑集中；然景情交融浅，结句直陈功效少留白，玉液芳馨略熟。","_cost":0.01117305},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"树木输液入诗，题材略新，病树与瘦形照应；“玉液”“芳馨”偏熟，“潜滋润”叠义。起承清楚，“莫讶”转折稍显牵强，结句以“全凭”说尽因果，留白不足。","_cost":0.05065},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"以街树输液翻春景,立意聚焦可感。银瓶、一线较切,玉液、东风、芳馨偏熟;次句平承,转结清楚,结句全凭说破,余味不足。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0203824},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.75,"rationale":"以街树输液这一当代景象入诗，题材新。但立意止于赞其疗效，缺少更深的发现。‘银瓶’‘玉液’偏于雕饰美化，‘潜滋润’语意重复。第三句转得巧，结句却落在解释，说得较尽。药气与芳馨的因果略显牵强。","_cost":0.0159},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"街树输液入诗，取材新鲜，“一线”兼有实物与生机之意。但“玉液”“芳馨”稍熟，“滋润瘦形”欠妥帖；末句以“全凭”点明用意，留白较少。","_cost":0.01086}},"consensus":68.92,"final":68.92},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|社区食堂|七律","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"巷口新开小食堂，邻翁聚处晚风香。盘中饭菜皆温饱，耄耋同餐共乐康。志愿相帮情倍切，街坊送暖一庭光。谁言老境无甘味，但得心安岁月长。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"weak"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.2,"意境":4.6,"语言":3.9,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.8,"警句":0.8,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.6,"陈滥":2.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.5,"rationale":"社区养老题材切近现实，主旨集中；晚风、饭菜、庭光略成氛围。中二联语意复沓且多“乐康、送暖”等套语，“饭菜皆温饱”搭配欠准。转结完整，但直陈心安长寿，余味较浅。","_cost":0.006842},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":36.25,"rationale":"取材当代社区生活可取，惜处理如新闻表扬稿：'温饱''乐康''送暖'皆干说标签，缺具体物象与细节。中二联对仗松散、开合无层次。尾联设问自答，'心安岁月长'说破兜底，余味寡淡。语言平顺而乏炼字。","_cost":0.03515},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":33.5,"rationale":"题材当代，然通篇干说，“皆温饱”“共乐康”“情倍切”“送暖”近于标语凑韵，取象稀薄，中二联无开合层次，结句直白说破，缺乏诗味与余韵。","_cost":0.03417},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":3.0,"意境":2.0,"语言":2.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":22.5,"rationale":"题材虽取当代生活，但全篇流于宣传口号，意象极度匮乏。多用套话如“志愿相帮”“情倍切”，缺乏诗家语。章法平铺直叙，结句说破说尽，毫无留白，未能将新题材有效化为诗意。","_cost":0.016724},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.5,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗有当代感，立意温情却常见说教；晚风香、一庭光稍可，余多叙述套语；结构完整而转平，结句直白说尽无余韵。","_cost":0.013336},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.25,"rationale":"社区食堂题材有现实关怀，但流于“温饱”“乐康”“送暖”等套语，情志泛化；意象常见未交融；中二联平列少开合；尾联议论说破，余味不足。略有当代题材出新，无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":0.00912516},"glm-5.3":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":32.75,"rationale":"取材社区养老有当代关怀，但通篇近颂体干说，中二联同写助老聚餐，合掌原地打转；温饱、送暖、心安、岁月长皆套话连缀，乐康、一庭光显凑韵，结句议论说尽无余味。","_cost":0.00270684},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.0,"rationale":"题材有现实温度，立意明确；但多直说颂语，缺少具体场景与新角。意象平常，语言偏宣传化，结句说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.010076},"kimi-k3":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.5,"rationale":"题旨明确但属常见颂扬角度，唯'晚风香'一象较精，余多直陈颂词；章法完整，尾联以议论兜底说破，缺留白；'乐康''送暖''岁月长'等套话密度偏高。","_cost":0.021945},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.8,"余味":4.3,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"社区食堂题材贴近民生具温情，但颂扬直露近口号，意象常见拼贴乏交融，语言平白少诗眼，中二联平铺少转折，结句议论说尽少余味。","_cost":0.00947675},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.75,"rationale":"当代社区食堂题材，题旨明确而角度常见；中二联多口号式陈述，意象陈套且情景未融；语言通顺但“饭菜皆温饱”用词硬凑；章法完整而转折平直；结句直白说理，少余味。稍有当代经验入诗，警句微弱，陈滥较重。","_cost":0.036377788},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.5,"rationale":"本诗咏社区食堂助老事，题旨明确但角度平熟，意象妥帖多常套，语言平顺少锤炼，结构平直无层折，结句直白欠余味，题材略新而表达落套，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.2,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.2,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.65,"rationale":"切入当代社区生活，题材具烟火气；但遣词偏于直白如报告，“志愿相帮”等句入诗生硬，中二联平直无波澜，结联直接说破，整体情味较浅。","_cost":0.00341025},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.2,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.4,"章法":4.6,"余味":2.6,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.6,"rationale":"取材社区食堂具现实善意，但情事笼统无细节主脑，意象常见虚写，中二联复沓无转，结句说理兜底，语言多套语乏诗眼。","_cost":0.01323375},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.75,"rationale":"题旨集中于邻里助老，但情事缺少细节。首联略有烟火气，中段多抽象颂语，“饭菜皆温饱”搭配欠妥。章法完整而推进平直，结句直陈心安，余味有限。","_cost":0.03046},"grok-4.7":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":33.0,"rationale":"题旨明而角度熟，情事不具体，近褒扬口号。意象少而套语密，中二联同义并列，尾联说破。语言顺却多凑字，饭菜皆温饱词未安。题材新而未成境。","_cost":0.0259152},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":31.5,"rationale":"题材属当代民生,但立意止于颂扬温暖,角度常见。中二联多叙述、少意象,只有“晚风香”“一庭光”略带画面。“皆温饱”“共乐康”“情倍切”“送暖”等词近乎口号,“饭菜皆温饱”搭配不妥。结句直白说理,余味浅。","_cost":0.014728},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":34.0,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗有现实感，但多以“送暖”“乐康”等套语代替具体情事；“饭菜皆温饱”搭配失当。中间数句意近，结句直陈祝愿，余味较浅。","_cost":0.008142}},"consensus":39.89,"final":39.89},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|云端相册|七律","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"收藏万象归云表，未许年华褪旧香。远岫烟霞留影像，晴窗翰墨认秋光。银屏咫尺描清景，网络须臾纳众芳。纵使沧桑惊客梦，人间胜概入瑶章。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.8,"意境":4.9,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.3,"余味":3.7,"警句":0.8,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":2.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.949999999999996,"rationale":"以云端保存年华，题旨明确且有当代元素；中二联多为同义铺陈，推进有限。古雅景语较密，“认秋光”等稍涩，结句以“胜概”“瑶章”直收，陈套而少留白。","_cost":0.006156},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.5,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗立意有当代性，然处理泛化：烟霞、翰墨、众芳、瑶章等套语连缀，物象与'云存储'本事贴合浅。中二联对仗平直、开合无层次，'银屏''网络'与旧词硬拼略生硬。结句'入瑶章'说尽兜底，余味寡淡。整体题材新而笔墨陈。","_cost":0.03115},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.25,"rationale":"以云端相册为题有当代切口，但全篇未落到具体一图一事，只以“万象、年华、烟霞、秋光、众芳、瑶章”等套语泛咏。中二联四句同义并列，无开合层次；“网络须臾纳众芳”生硬。尾联直陈兜底，说尽无余。","_cost":0.04222},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":31.5,"rationale":"该诗虽以现代科技“云相册”为题，但仅停留在对其存储功能的表层图解。传统意象与现代词汇生硬拼贴，文白夹杂，意境割裂。全篇平直少变，陈词滥调较多，结句强行拔高且说尽兜底，毫无余味。","_cost":0.018094},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"以云相册抗衡时光消逝，题旨集中有当代感但情欠具体。意象传统与数码并陈未浑成一境。用语大体清通，现代词略显嵌入。起承尚顺转结平实。末句点题说尽，余味不足。出新在题材，陈词略密无蹈袭硬伤。","_cost":0.022918},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.5,"rationale":"首联点题尚稳，中二联意象并列近合掌，尾联直说少余味；以云端相册入诗略有新意，但烟霞、秋光、沧桑等套语较多，整体空泛。","_cost":0.01282248},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗，题旨有新意，年华不褪旧香一联见巧思。但中二联皆铺陈收藏呈现，合掌之嫌致脉络平缓；银屏、网络等语入诗略显生硬直白；结句胜概入瑶章归于颂扬套语，说破而余味不足。","_cost":0.00338584},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.75,"rationale":"题旨扣云端存照，立意明确而偏概念，少具体情事；烟霞翰墨、银屏网络雅俗并置，意象妥帖但常见，语言稳顺略见炼意；章法完整而铺陈平直，结句说尽，余味较弱；套语稍多。","_cost":0.012852},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.25,"rationale":"以云存储入七律，题新而笔浅，止于称颂。意象多烟霞秋光熟套与银屏网络直词杂置，情景交融不足；中二联功能平行少开合；结句直说主旨少留白。『未许年华褪旧香』略有致。","_cost":0.0241794},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.6,"意境":4.7,"语言":4.3,"章法":4.9,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.85,"rationale":"云端入诗有当代意识，但止于功能礼赞，情事抽象无主脑深掘；中二联同义反复，银屏网络直露破坏意境与锤炼，套语密，结句直收无留白。","_cost":0.0081575},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.25,"rationale":"题旨明确，以古典诗语写云端相册，角度略新而情志空泛；意象常见，古今语融合生涩，中二联平铺，尾联直白少余味；有“归云表”巧思，陈语稍多。","_cost":0.026643062},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.0,"rationale":"本诗咏云端相册，题旨明确、章法通顺，但情志泛化无新见，意象多熟套，语言平顺少炼字，结句直白乏余韵；当代经验入诗略有新意，无硬伤蹈袭，陈套较多。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.2,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.8,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"首联以“云表”双关云端，切题巧思；惟中联“网络”直入微欠熔裁，翰墨烟霞等意象略显凑凑杂糅。章法平稳但转接稍直，尾联兜底说尽，余味稍弱。","_cost":0.00601725},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":4.2,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.95,"rationale":"借云存储言留影意明确，然全篇万象清景众芳泛咏无实事，中二联同义反复，银屏网络直白夹杂，尾联兜底无留白。","_cost":0.01472375},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.75,"rationale":"云端存影、留驻年华，题旨明确而情事不够具体；烟霞、众芳等多属泛饰，“翰墨认秋光”略显牵强。中二联意思重复，转折平直。网络入诗稍有新意，结句颂美说尽，余味较薄。","_cost":0.03588},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.0,"rationale":"题旨在云存抗遗忘，角度常见，情事不具体。烟霞秋光与银屏网络并置，景情未融。中二联同义反复，转结说尽，且由相册滑向瑶章。仅“褪旧香”略可摘，套语偏密。","_cost":0.0359808},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.25,"rationale":"题材属当代经验,“云表”双关云端尚巧。但全篇停在“存景留香”的泛泛称颂,缺具体情事。颔联、颈联同意复叠,原地打转。“网络须臾纳众芳”近乎说明文。烟霞、众芳、瑶章等皆属常套。结句直白兜底,余味浅。","_cost":0.015228},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.0,"rationale":"以云端存忆入诗，有当代切口；中二联多为景物与屏网的并列铺陈，递进不足。“烟霞”“众芳”“瑶章”等语偏熟，结句转为泛赞，未收住惜时存忆之情。","_cost":0.010746}},"consensus":47.19,"final":47.19},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"银鹰破夜驾云航，俯瞰千家火树光。错认星河浮岛屿，方知此地即吾乡。舷窗外望迷空阔，顿觉身如一粟茫。远际烟霞生袖底，明朝客鬓染新霜。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.4,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.8,"余味":4.7,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"夜航辨乡兼写羁旅身世，情景尚能交融。“错认”一联有光彩；后半转入渺小与霜鬓，衔接稍松。“银鹰、火树、一粟、客鬓新霜”较熟，结句偏直露。","_cost":0.00677},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":3.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":34.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰系当代经验入诗,题材可取,惜发挥常套。颔联'方知此地即吾乡'与尾联'客鬓新霜'情意矛盾;中二联对仗松散、'一粟茫'凑韵痕迹重。银鹰、火树、烟霞、鬓霜皆陈熟意象连缀,结句说破乡愁,余味寡淡。","_cost":0.04356},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":3.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰误灯火为星河再认吾乡，有一点当代经验入诗；但随后转入'一粟'渺小、'客鬓新霜'，主脑游离，既是吾乡何来客鬓。'银鹰''火树''一粟'皆套语，'迷空阔''一粟茫'凑韵生硬。夜航而见烟霞亦欠妥。结句直说无余味。","_cost":0.05948},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.5,"rationale":"夜航入诗具时代感，但中二联散文化如流水账，缺乏律诗开合层次；“生袖底”于密闭客舱违背常理；结句“客鬓新霜”落入羁旅俗套，直白无余味。整体语言平直，古今意象拼凑生硬。","_cost":0.018222},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰稍具当代视角，颔联错认星河尚可感；后半落入一粟、客鬓新霜陈套，结句直白说破，炼字偶见凑泊如“一粟茫”。","_cost":0.021666},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.3,"语言":3.8,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.6,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰见故乡灯火略有新意，但后四句转入泛泛旅愁，中二联缺乏开合；烟霞生袖底逻辑欠通，套语如身似粟、鬓染霜较多。结句直白，余味有限。","_cost":0.015426928},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰灯火、错认星河而识故乡，翻新羁旅乡愁，立意有独到处；'错认星河浮岛屿，方知此地即吾乡'为全篇诗眼，可摘。颈联与颔联同为顿悟句式，层次推进不足，对仗亦松（'迷空阔'对'一粟茫'勉强）；'驾云航''一粟茫'有凑韵之嫌。结句'客鬓染新霜'落套，余味收得平实。","_cost":0.004374},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.4,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.2,"rationale":"现代夜航入诗，俯瞰灯火如星河，画面鲜明；乡思与渺小之感清晰，但词语稍熟，转结偏直，尾句余味有限。","_cost":0.010026},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰有当代视角，“错认星河”一联见警；然“火树”“一粟”“新霜”多熟套，中空阔处重复，结以霜鬓收束平直，物象偶隔。","_cost":0.0158286},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.7,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.800000000000004,"rationale":"机窗错认星河有现场感，颔联可观；然一粟、火树、新霜等偏熟，颈联直抒，尾句说破感慨，章法平直余味未宕。","_cost":0.010437},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.25,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰的当代经验入诗，颔联错认星河、方知吾乡稍有新境，立意集中；然火树、一粟、烟霞、客鬓等多陈套，意象欠精切，“一粟茫”生造，转折平直，结句直白少余味。","_cost":0.034274447},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.75,"rationale":"本诗写夜航经乡的羁旅观感，“错认星河”联有巧思，但主旨稍散，意象多陈熟，转折欠自然，结句直白道破愁思，未脱旧套，有少量陈语。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.85,"rationale":"切入现代夜航经验，颔联以星河喻灯火见巧思。然银鹰、一粟、客鬓等套词偏密，中后段脉络稍有跳脱，尾联滑入客子衰飒窠臼，减弱了俯瞰新意。","_cost":0.00462525},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.75,"rationale":"熟题俯瞰乡愁无新境，一粟鬓霜皆陈语；颔联错认小有意趣，然银鹰舷窗白话生硬，结句直抒衰老无留白。","_cost":0.01271075},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.25,"rationale":"灯海与星河相映，航空视角略有新意；认乡转入身世之感，衔接稍松。“驾云航”冗复，“一粟茫”生涩。结句以客鬓霜白收束，身世感慨落入熟套，余味有限。未见明确硬伤或整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.05095},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.0,"rationale":"夜航识乡有具体情事,然渺小与客老为常套,主脑后半涣散。颔联误认星河尚可独立,余象多陈且袖底费解。语言有硬凑,颈联平直,结句说破衰老并脱节。","_cost":0.0197056},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰故乡,把灯火错认作星河,这一发现有些新意。但'顿觉身如一粟'写得直白,颈联只是重复迷茫之感,中二联缺少开合。'银鹰''火树''一粟''新霜'偏熟套。夜里生'烟霞'与'吾乡''客鬓'之间略有矛盾。结句突转写衰老,与前文衔接生硬。","_cost":0.022072},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"灯火错认星河、继而辨出吾乡，颇有画面；由认乡转向自伤略急。“银鹰”“一粟”“新霜”较熟，末句直点衰老，余味稍浅。","_cost":0.00815}},"consensus":53.7,"final":53.7},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"长街古干亦求生，病树悬壶挂药瓶。一线清泉苏困木，半空白露润枯茎。常忧蠹蚁伤根本，更借岐黄护此城。莫叹红尘多弱植，医林妙手唤春晴。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":true,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":0.75,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.4,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.8,"警句":0.8,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.7,"rationale":"吊瓶救树题材有现实新意，主脑明确，层层写病、疗、忧、护。清泉、白露等喻象尚协调，但“悬壶挂药瓶”略复，“岐黄”“妙手”“春晴”趋熟套；结句直露说尽，余韵不足。","_cost":0.0052},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"当代街头输液树入诗,题材新,'悬壶'双关有巧思,值出新分。但颔联'苏困木''润枯茎'意近合掌,颈联岐黄、尾联妙手回春等语滥熟,结句'唤春晴'说破题旨,颂扬式收束乏余味,情感浮泛未见深切寄托。","_cost":0.03516},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.25,"rationale":"题材取自当代街树输液，有新鲜处，“悬壶”双关尚有巧思；但“悬壶挂药瓶”语义重叠，中二联对偶平滑而少层次，颈联“护此城”转得空泛，尾联以“妙手唤春晴”直白颂扬收束，说尽无余，套语稍多。","_cost":0.05788},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.5,"rationale":"以树打吊针的当代现象入诗，题材具时代感。然词意直白，“清泉”“岐黄”作比稍显生硬违和。且结联完全标语化，直抒胸臆尽行说破，缺乏情景交融的诗意与余味，流于表层图解。","_cost":0.015136},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"街树挂瓶入律，悬壶岐黄之喻尚巧，护生情志具体。然环保题旨常见，意象半新半套，颈联扩至护城稍跳，结句直呼春晴说尽少留白。当代物象有效入诗。","_cost":0.021144},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"题材新，以树挂吊瓶入诗，首联切题且有双关。中二联合掌明显，清泉/白露、苏/润近义；颈联稍开合但未深。尾联说破劝慰，余味不足。整体通顺，警句偏少，熟套略存。","_cost":0.01188628},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"城市树木输液的当代经验入诗，立意具体真切，'病树悬壶'一语双关是诗眼。中二联对仗工稳但偏于说理，'岐黄护城'略显直陈。结句'莫叹''妙手唤春晴'以议论收束，说破兜底，余味不足。'红尘''妙手'等语略带套话，无硬伤，整体完整而收束平直。","_cost":0.0048625},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"街树输液入诗颇有新见，颔联清泉白露写得清润有象；后幅多议论，尾联说破，余味不足，语带熟套。","_cost":0.011862},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.5,"rationale":"以街头树木输液入诗，题材新，'病树悬壶'谐音双关见巧；颔联'一线清泉''半空白露'象意相交融。惜颈联转写平直，尾联'莫叹''妙手'直白说教，少留白，整体巧而不深。","_cost":0.0121572},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.3,"余味":5.6,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.4,"rationale":"以“输液护树”切入城市生态，悬壶/岐黄双关有巧思具主脑；颔联形神兼写，章法贯通，唯尾联直白说理、余味稍浅。","_cost":0.008642},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶当代经验入诗，立意明确；颔联取象尚可，后半说理直白；用语有斧凿（药瓶、半空白露），章法完整，结句直白少余味。有出新，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.034592909},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"此作咏春街行道树挂吊瓶，扣题紧密，脉络通顺，纳入当代日常场景，但立意偏平，部分意象凑泊，结句直白，有小硬伤与少量陈词。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.8,"余味":4.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.65,"rationale":"当代街景入诗具生活触角，颔联摹写输液形态尚切。然“挂药瓶”语质欠炼，后半篇借“岐黄”“医林”拔高立意，流于口号式赞颂，结语说破无余味。","_cost":0.00747825},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.8,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.9,"rationale":"以吊瓶救古树由木及城，立意新切有主脑；中二联写实夹议，意象未融为境，半空句费解；尾联劝慰直露，说尽无留白。","_cost":0.011838},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"吊瓶救树取材较新，关怀有具体依托；清泉、白露略趋泛美，悬壶与药瓶语意重复。中段由救树推及护城，拓展稍显空泛；结句以妙手唤春作赞语，说尽情意，余味较薄。","_cost":0.04175},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"街树吊瓶为当代新题，起句情事具体，然中后滑向护城颂医，焦点散、情志变口号。悬壶见巧，余象多套语；枯茎失切。转接平直，结句说破，余味薄。","_cost":0.0242752},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"以街树输液这一当代景象入诗,取材有新意。但立意止于颂扬护树,没有更深的发现。颔联以清泉、白露比喻药液,尚属妥帖;首联“悬壶”与“药瓶”语意重复。颈联由树骤转“护此城”,有脱节之感。结句“唤春晴”直白说尽,余味不足。","_cost":0.018352},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"街树吊瓶入诗，取材新鲜；颔联将药液写作清泉、白露，形象可感。后半转向“岐黄”“妙手”等熟语，结句直说春晴，余味较浅。","_cost":0.00814}},"consensus":58.68,"final":44.01},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"云仓夜半耀灯光，货架高低夹路长。竹帚轻挥人独扫，尘清地净满空凉。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.2,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.3,"章法":4.6,"余味":4.2,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.95,"rationale":"夜扫云仓题材具当代性，孤身清扫亦稍见清寂；但立意止于纪实。灯、架、竹帚取象具体，“夹路长”“满空凉”稍显硬涩，末句收束直白，转折与余韵不足。","_cost":0.004998},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.25,"rationale":"取当代物流夜工入诗,题材有新意,'人独扫'见孤影可感。然通篇平铺直叙,'耀灯光'有凑韵之嫌,'尘清地净'近套语,情志止于场景交代未见深掘。结句'满空凉'稍有清寂余绪,惜收束仍偏直白。","_cost":0.03789},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.0,"rationale":"取当代物流仓夜扫入诗，题材有新意，货架夹路一句略具画面。然通篇平铺直叙，'耀灯光''尘清地净'语滞而套，无转折起伏；结句'满空凉'稍有余韵，但前半已说尽，整体止于纪实。","_cost":0.04641},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.0,"rationale":"当代题材入诗值得肯定，“云仓”“货架”写实现场感强。但通篇语言偏于大白话（如“耀灯光”“尘清地净”），缺乏诗家语的锤炼。结句“满空凉”略见孤寂之意，然整体平铺直叙，意蕴较浅。","_cost":0.017594},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"夜扫仓储场景具体，孤寂清凉题旨常见无翻新。仓灯货架竹帚构成空凉氛围尚可。语言平实如叙，少锤炼。章法线性完整而转合平直。结句点净后凉，余味有限。当代仓景入诗略出新。","_cost":0.027792},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"夜扫仓库题材略有现代感，立意明确但止于表层清冷；意象统一，'满空凉'稍有余味。结构平稳，转结平直。整体中规中矩，缺乏警策。","_cost":0.00882288},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"取当代仓储劳动入诗，题旨具体、聚焦一人夜扫，然立意仅止于记述，未见开掘。意象妥帖但平凡，灯光货架竹帚皆平铺。'尘清地净'近乎口语说尽，'满空凉'稍有情味而力度不足。章法起承转合完整，结句以凉字收束略有延宕，通体平稳少奇。","_cost":0.00180696},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"云仓夜扫取材新，货架、竹帚、灯光成清寂画面；然立意浅、语偏熟，结尾稍直。","_cost":0.010766},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"云仓夜景与独扫者对照有当代感，货架、灯光、空凉合成冷寂氛围；然情志开掘不深，转折平直，“尘清地净”近套，结句以凉景收束尚有余韵。","_cost":0.0153306},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.3,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.4,"余味":4.3,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.95,"rationale":"纪实夜扫仓房较具体但止于表层勤劳无主脑；物象平实未融情为境；语言通顺无诗眼；章法线性铺陈转合平直；结句直陈尘净凉意说尽无留白，云仓入诗略有新意。","_cost":0.00716375},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"当代云仓夜扫入诗，题意集中而情致稍浅；意象妥帖、画面统一，“满空凉”略具余味。起承转合完整但转折平，语言通顺偶见诗眼。无硬伤蹈袭，现代经验有新意而警策不足。","_cost":0.025861073},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"本诗平实记录云仓夜扫场景，起承转合顺畅，意象贴合实景，语言通顺无错，但情志偏淡，炼字平实无亮眼处，结句余味稍弱，仅当代云仓入诗略有新意。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.3,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.6,"rationale":"当代物流入诗具现实感。起承铺展庞大空间，转入独扫劳作，脉络清晰。炼字较平实，“耀灯光”“尘清地净”略显滞白，结以“满空凉”寄托空阔清寂，微见余味。","_cost":0.00643875},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.0,"rationale":"夜扫云仓止于记事写实，无情志主脑；取象直白少交融，语言白直无诗眼，章法流水少转折，结句直陈功效无留白。","_cost":0.0063493},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"夜扫中的孤独有具体场景承托，货架、竹帚与灯光构成冷清氛围；“耀灯光”“满空凉”措辞欠自然。章法顺叙，转折较弱，结尾由洁净落到空凉，略有余味。云仓题材稍新，尚无警句。","_cost":0.03419},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫写独劳,题有当代感而情志仍是常见孤清。货架夹路尚切,竹帚与空凉能成氛围;尘清地净复沓且说破,转结平直,余味不多。","_cost":0.020632},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.25,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫写当代劳动，题材有新意，但通篇平铺记事，情志未深。'夹路长'稍见空间感，'耀灯光'等语平直。转句引出人物却转折平缓。结句'满空凉'略带孤寂余韵，然'尘清地净'近于说尽。","_cost":0.014904},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.5,"rationale":"灯光、货架与独扫之人构成具体夜景，“云仓”带出当代场景；但情意未深，转折平直。“耀灯光”“夹路长”稍涩，“尘清地净”直白，末字“凉”略有余韵。","_cost":0.007848}},"consensus":55.36,"final":55.36},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|深夜视频|七律","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"夜静屏开一鉴新，天涯咫尺见伊人。星河渐隐窗前树，岁月徒添驿路尘。两处关山迷远目，千般别绪湿罗巾。今宵且把归期数，唯盼相逢梦里频。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.8,"意境":5.4,"语言":5.1,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.3,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.9,"rationale":"视频寄情切题，首联以屏如鉴稍见新意；中二联脉络清楚，但星河、关山、罗巾等意象陈熟，未与当代经验深融。结句直陈梦中相逢，收束偏尽，余韵较弱。","_cost":0.005218},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.75,"rationale":"以视频通话入律有当代经验，首句'屏开一鉴'尚见巧思。惜中二联全落'关山''驿路尘''湿罗巾'等旧套，与视频语境割裂，情感泛化。结句'梦里频'说破兜底，陈滥密度高，通篇新题旧写，未能翻出新境。","_cost":0.03771},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.5,"rationale":"首联以屏为鉴、天涯咫尺切题尚新，然中二联即滑回驿路尘、关山、罗巾等旧套，与视频语境脱节，未借当代经验翻出新境；结句直说盼梦相逢，既说破又与既已视频相见略相扰，余味薄弱。","_cost":0.05323},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.5,"rationale":"题材虽引入现代事物（视频），但写法极度陈套。通篇堆砌“关山、罗巾、驿路”等陈词滥调，致使现代情境与古旧意象割裂违和。缺乏炼字，结句直白说破，毫无余味可言。","_cost":0.019008},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.0,"rationale":"视频开篇略新，旋即关山罗巾驿尘堆砌，见人与迷目矛盾；结句直陈说尽，意象未交融。","_cost":0.019934},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"写视频通话题材有当代感，但角度常见，情感真挚却无独到发现；意象传统且部分陈套，语言通顺少诗眼，章法平稳转折平直，结句说破无余味。","_cost":0.00255024},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"以视频通话写两地相思，当代经验入题是亮点，但仅首联点到即止；'一鉴新'喻屏尚巧。中二联意象堆叠罗巾、驿路、关山，多写离愁旧套，与视频场景脱节，层次未拉开。尾联'盼相逢'说破，余味收得直白。整体通顺而陈语密度偏高。","_cost":0.0037142},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.6,"章法":6.2,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.35,"rationale":"首联以屏如新鉴点题，略有当代感；中二联转回关山别绪、罗巾归梦等熟套，景情未深，结句说破少余味。脉络尚稳，语言通顺。","_cost":0.008542},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":42.0,"rationale":"视频题材略有新趣,惜首联之后即落入星河、关山、罗巾、归期、梦里等熟象;章法平推少开合;结句'梦里频'直白说破且凑字;唯'屏开一鉴'微见巧思。","_cost":0.0301758},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.6,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.3,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.45,"rationale":"屏开见伊人点出当代视频，稍有新意但未生发独到情思；中二联尽是关山罗巾驿尘套语，意象新旧割裂，锤炼平直，转结直说无余味。","_cost":0.00928715},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"以视频入律，首联“屏开一鉴新”略有新意；然中二联与结句渐落关山、驿尘、罗巾、梦逢等窠臼，意象套话较密，转折平直，结句直白少余味。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.027336673},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.0,"rationale":"此作以深夜视频为题写羁旅别思，未脱传统怀远窠臼，意象表达多陈套，情感泛化无具体细节，结构平顺，结句直白少余韵。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.2,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.85,"rationale":"首联借屏鉴写视频通话，具现代生活感；但中后段迅速倒退进关山、驿路、罗巾等陈套意象，与实景割裂。尾联直白落入梦中相逢之套路，高开低走，余味不足。","_cost":0.00681675},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.75,"rationale":"以视频写相思略有当代切入而情仍俗套，星河关山罗巾陈套拼贴，炼字无眼转折平直，结句说尽无留白。","_cost":0.0117418},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.5,"rationale":"视频寄情题旨明确，但当代场景未充分展开；关山、驿尘、罗巾等旧象密集，情事欠具体。“一鉴新”“梦里频”略显牵凑。章法完整而转折平直，结句直陈所盼，余味有限。","_cost":0.03314},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.5,"rationale":"首句以鉴喻屏略有当代感，情志仍是寻常相思。星河驿尘关山罗巾与视频脱节，套语密。中二联平铺无转，结句直说梦逢，说破且撇开已见之实。语言顺而少锤炼。","_cost":0.0202448},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":36.25,"rationale":"以视频入诗,首联'屏开一鉴''咫尺'扣题尚可。中二联驿路尘、关山、罗巾皆为古典套语,与视频情境脱节。既已屏中相见,结句却盼梦里相逢,逻辑略失照应。结句直白,当代经验未能真正展开。","_cost":0.016352},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.75,"rationale":"屏开见人切题，星河与窗树稍有画面；中二联多用驿路、关山、罗巾等旧套，视频带来的新感受未充分展开。结句直言梦中相逢，余味偏浅。","_cost":0.008118}},"consensus":46.74,"final":46.74},{"key":"hunyuan-hy4-preview|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"hunyuan-hy4-preview","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"夜静云仓泛冷光，流辉似水照空廊。千重铁架摇灯影，万轴机轮扫暗霜。玉帚轻挥清积垢，银梭疾走理新装。星河欲转车音绝，四野无声月色凉。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.4,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.3,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.2,"出新":2.1,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"以自动化云仓夜扫入诗，题材有新意，冷光、机轮与静夜交融。中二联铺写稍近复沓，“理新装”语意含混；末联由车音骤绝转入月凉，收束清寂有余韵。","_cost":0.005158},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"以旧体写智能仓储夜景,题材有当代气息,然通篇铺陈冷光机轮,未见情志主脑。玉帚银梭以古饰今略觉硬套,中二联皆平列写景少开合。结句以景收束有余味,惟流辉似水、月色凉等语近套,整体工稳而乏警策。","_cost":0.04062},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.25,"rationale":"以自动化云仓夜景入诗，题材当代而有新意，冷光、机轮、月色氛围尚统一。然中二联皆铺写机械动作，千重/万轴、玉帚/银梭对偶板滞、装饰古旧，缺开合层次与真切情志；暗霜、四野与仓内场景稍违。结句以景收束尚稳，但流辉似水、月色凉等语属熟套，余味一般。","_cost":0.05394},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"题材触及现代云仓作业，有一定出新。但通篇偏于图解式铺陈，情志单薄。中二联流于平行罗列，用“玉帚”“银梭”硬套现代机械略显生硬。尾联以景作结尚算稳当，然未脱常规套路。","_cost":0.019206},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"仓储夜扫题新而情志浅淡。工业意象与玉帚银梭未融。颔联稍具画面。章法内动外静尚可。结句月凉直白少延宕。当代物事入诗有意未化。","_cost":0.034706},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"题材有当代感，通篇聚焦夜扫，意象清冷统一，尾联以景收束较有余味。中二联对仗工稳，但情志平面、转折稍直，语言偶有夹生。未发现明显硬伤与整句蹈袭，个别意象略陈。","_cost":0.0052120992},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"以七律写无人仓储夜景，当代经验入诗自然不隔，冷光、铁架、机轮与月色凉构成统一清寂氛围，结句以景收束余味佳。玉帚银梭化机器人于古典语汇颇巧。不足在中二联皆铺陈器物，开合层次稍平，流辉似水略熟。","_cost":0.0035804},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.95,"rationale":"写现代云仓夜扫，取材较新；冷光、铁架、机轮与月色构成清寂氛围，章法由动入静，结句有留白。惜情志不深，玉帚银梭略旧，个别词语稍泛。","_cost":0.016482},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.0,"rationale":"以现代云仓夜班入七律,题材有新意,冷光空廊、铁架灯影营造冷寂氛围尚可,'千重铁架摇灯影'一联颇佳。然玉帚银梭与机械场景拟古夹杂,中二联平列少开合,结句'月色凉'熟滑,收束平稳而无延宕。整体工整有余,情志深度与炼字精度不足。","_cost":0.013407},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.3,"语言":5.6,"章法":6.2,"余味":5.7,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.8,"rationale":"夜扫云仓记景有条理而情志未深，铁架机轮等象工稳却偏熟套、景情未融，语言通顺少诗眼，章法平铺少转折，尾联以静景收束略有余韵。","_cost":0.01132625},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"以古典语汇写现代云仓夜扫，中二联对仗工稳、结以景语；然情志浮泛、少独到发现，意象与收束间有套语，整体平稳而欠深味。","_cost":0.034705454},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.2,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.4,"rationale":"本诗摹写云仓夜扫场景，题旨明确、脉络顺通，尝试纳入当代物流题材有新意，但新旧意象稍隔，炼字略有凑泊，转折平直，结句余韵偏平，偶见熟语，无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.7,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.4,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"以古典律体写现代智能云仓，当代经验入诗颇见新意。章法层次分明，中二联摹写机械运转贴切工稳。唯“玉帚银梭”略带古典代称之斧凿感，结句以景收束虽稳，用语稍显平套。","_cost":0.00616275},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.5,"rationale":"云仓夜扫题材新而无主脑情志，玉帚银梭饰语浮泛，中二联铺排平直，唯尾联宕开由仓内至星野稍留余味。","_cost":0.01322175},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":4.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.0,"rationale":"云仓夜扫略有新意，冷光、灯影贯成清寂氛围；但情志未深，玉帚银梭偏于装饰，“理新装”语意含混。中二联推进有限，末句以景收束，有余韵而境语较熟。","_cost":0.04149},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"题在夜扫云仓，主脑清楚而情事不具体，近冷色观赏。铁架机轮可感，然玉帚银梭、千重万轴饰套，中二联同面铺写，转势弱。结句以沉默月色收，法是而语熟，余味有限。当代仓储入诗算出新，未成警句。","_cost":0.0175712},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.25,"rationale":"以云仓夜作入诗，题材较新，但通篇铺写，缺少人的情志，没有主脑。中二联都写机器劳作，“扫暗霜”与“清积垢”语意相近，有合掌之病。“千重”“万轴”“玉帚”“银梭”偏于藻饰。结句以景作收，稳当却落入熟套。","_cost":0.020696},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"云仓夜作入诗，冷光、铁架与机轮构成夜境；但“扫暗霜”“理新装”所指欠明，中二联意脉近复，结以月凉收束，余味稍弱。","_cost":0.013038}},"consensus":59.79,"final":59.79},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"晶匣堆绒眠百兽，轻移铁指下虚钩。分明揽得离深槛，翻被机心一纵休。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.7,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.65,"rationale":"以古典语汇写抓娃娃机，物象集中，得而复失的转折鲜明；“机心”双关有讽意。三四句承转利落，但“下虚钩”“一纵休”略显硬涩，结尾余味尚足。","_cost":0.006406},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"咏当代物象而有寄托,「机心」双关机器与算计,翻转有力。起承交代具体可感,转句「分明揽得」蓄势,结句一跌收束,微嫌点破而余味稍减。「虚钩」「一纵休」炼字见功,取象贴切不落陈套,当代经验入诗有效。","_cost":0.03166},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"当代题材入律,取象晶匣、绒兽、铁指皆精切;“机心”双关庄子语与机器机关,为诗眼,讽意含蓄。起承转合紧凑,结句翻转有力但略说尽,“离深槛”稍硬。","_cost":0.04823},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.0,"rationale":"本诗将当代事物抓娃娃机巧妙入诗，‘晶匣’‘虚钩’取象精准，动作刻画传神。结句以‘机心’双关，既指机器设定又暗含哲理，起承转合严密，生活气息与古典雅致交融，颇具意趣。","_cost":0.014916},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃近得远失为题，机心双关出新。意象精切情景融。语言达意偶炼。结构完整转折直，结句说尽乏余味。","_cost":0.028206},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.8,"余味":7.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.3,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入诗，古今结合，讽“机心”有主脑；转结跌宕得力。但后二句偏说理，点破稍露，意蕴不深，语言偶见锻炼痕迹。","_cost":0.0058440096},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.0,"rationale":"以七绝写抓娃娃机，当代经验入古体而浑成。'机心'语带双关，暗用《庄子》机事机心典，翻出被操控之戏谑与喟叹，立意独到。'眠百兽''虚钩''一纵休'炼字精切，起承转合分明，结句宕开一层，不落说破。惟'揽得离深槛'句法微涩，意脉稍滞。","_cost":0.00337},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.8,"rationale":"以现代抓娃娃机入绝，场景集中，起承转合清楚。‘眠百兽’生动，‘机心’双关见新。惜‘虚钩’‘一纵休’稍生，结句略点破，余味未全宕开。","_cost":0.01414},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"抓娃娃机这一当代经验入诗，题新意足。晶匣、绒兽、铁指、虚钩取象精切，氛围统一。两次翻转（以为得之—翻被纵之）章法有效。借《庄子》机心双关机器机关，警句有味；惜结句点破机关，情志深度止于巧思。","_cost":0.0264252},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.2,"意境":8.1,"语言":8.5,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.75,"rationale":"以娃娃机喻机心弄人，起承转合利落，晶匣铁指虚钩意象精切双关，结句一纵休宕开有味，当代器物入诗自然。","_cost":0.007924},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入诗，借“机心”双关写似得复失，讽操控；意象集中，转结有翻转，但结句稍直白、字法偶生硬。","_cost":0.025897263},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"此作以当代抓娃娃机入诗，借游戏场景双关‘机心’，寄寓将得复失的人生况味，意象精切，炼字工稳，章法顺畅，化古自然，无硬伤陈套。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.0,"rationale":"晶匣铁指对照精切，机心双关由物及人，主脑明确。后半转叙事氛围稍散，结句点破稍直。当代经验入绝自然有效。","_cost":0.01253525},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.7,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.7,"rationale":"以抓取复失贯穿全篇，“机心”双关有讽意，“眠百兽”鲜活，当代物事入诗自然。由得转失利落；“下虚钩”“一纵休”稍显生硬，结句点意较明，留白有限。","_cost":0.03768},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"得而复失焦点集中，机心双关是巧思而非深情。晶匣、铁指、虚钩精切，软硬成境；炼字有眼，起承转合清楚。结以“休”收死，事尽意浅，余味不足。","_cost":0.0255088},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"以古典语汇写抓娃娃机，当代经验有效入诗。‘眠百兽’‘深槛’将玩偶拟为囚兽，自成一体。‘机心’双关机械与庄子机巧，是全诗诗眼，寓得而复失之理。‘虚钩’略泄结局。‘分明…翻被’转折清晰但偏直，结句寓意止于小巧，余味中等。","_cost":0.018632},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.6,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.3,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"晶匣、铁指写出抓取现场，“机心”兼有机关与算计之意。由将得到骤失，转折鲜明；但“虚钩”稍含混，结句点明落空，余味略短。","_cost":0.008076}},"consensus":79.66,"final":79.66},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"悄立街隅绿铁箱，旋翻暗斗纳余裳。潜留寸缕千家暖，远寄穷檐御雪霜。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.4,"语言":5.7,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.8,"rationale":"以回收箱入诗，题材新切，四句由形貌至功用，主旨集中。拟人颇温厚，但“暗斗”“潜留”稍涩，穷檐、雪霜略套；末句直陈御寒，收束稳而留白不足。","_cost":0.00689},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗,题材有当代新意,'旋翻暗斗'状物精切。惜后二句直陈善举功用,'千家暖''御雪霜'近公益标语,情虽正而意浅。结句说尽无余,以颂语兜底,少留白延宕。整体咏物达意而未臻物我交融之境。","_cost":0.02928},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.0,"rationale":"取当代物象入诗，'旋翻暗斗'摹箱口机关尚见观察；然后二句转入公益说教，'寸缕千家暖'牵合勉强，'穷檐御雪霜'落套语，结句说尽无余，通篇平铺直叙。","_cost":0.0431},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.0,"rationale":"咏当代事物，起承写实精当，“旋翻暗斗”颇具匠心。然转结落入俗套，“千家暖”“御雪霜”属陈词，且结句将题旨完全说破，缺乏诗意留白与宕开之致，流于浅白的图解。","_cost":0.013442},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.75,"rationale":"回收箱入诗有当代视角，立意明确却近劝善宣传。前联取象尚具体，后联概念化说破，情景未交融。语言通达少锤炼，章法承转平直，结句功用尽吐无余韵。","_cost":0.017182},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":1.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":36.0,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱题材有当代关怀，但立意偏公益口号，不够深入。意象妥帖多套语；“暗斗”稍硬。结构完整而转结平直，结句说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.0059334528},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗,当代经验有效转化,立意有新意。'旋翻暗斗'写投衣口准确生动见诗眼。起承转合完整:立箱—纳衣—留暖—远寄,脉络一气。结句'御雪霜'点破善举,收束稳当但偏直白,余味有限。'穷檐''雪霜'略近套语。","_cost":0.0029636},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.1,"rationale":"取旧衣回收箱入诗，题旨明确且有现实温度；脉络清楚，但转结偏直。“千家暖”“穷檐雪霜”稍熟，“旋翻暗斗”略硬，余味不足。","_cost":0.006822},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"以回收箱为眼,体察入微,'旋翻暗斗'状物精准;立意角度颇新,但题旨落于捐赠御寒之常套,结句直说宗旨、余味欠厚。章法通顺,无袭夺之嫌。","_cost":0.02263755},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.3,"意境":5.4,"语言":6.1,"章法":6.9,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.05,"rationale":"新物入诗有发现、主脑集中；章法起承转合完整。但意象功能化直赋、情景分离少氛围，结句说尽少留白，语汇多熟语。","_cost":0.01110725},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"以绿铁箱写捐衣送暖，当代物入诗，焦点集中；‘寸缕千家暖’炼意颇佳，转句有力。然‘绿铁箱’‘暗斗’文白夹杂，结句直白稍欠余味，整体稳妥而出新有限。","_cost":0.030564963},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"此诗咏当代旧衣回收箱，主旨明确，脉络通顺，新事物入诗有一定新意；但立意角度常规，意象偏熟，转折平直，结句直白少余味，个别用词略生歧义。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.2,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.1,"章法":6.4,"余味":4.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.3,"rationale":"取材街头回收箱颇新颖，由近及远脉络清；惜后半流于公益宣示，暖雪霜语较套，结句直收少余味。","_cost":0.00978705},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"回收箱入诗有当代气息，济困主旨明确，街隅铁箱具实感。“旋翻暗斗”“潜留”稍涩；由形制、功用推至寄愿，脉络完整而转折平直。“千家暖”“御雪霜”偏熟套，结句直陈目的，留白不足。","_cost":0.05275},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.0,"rationale":"立意有焦点，绿箱暗斗略见当代物象，然情志近公益口号，三四句陈套并说尽，转结平直，余味薄。语言偶有锤炼，未成诗眼。","_cost":0.0248784},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.75,"rationale":"当代物象入诗，题材有新意。“旋翻暗斗”写投衣口的机关，具体可感。但立意止于颂善，角度常见。“悄立”“潜留”意思重复，“寸缕”与“千家暖”对应失衡，逻辑不严。第三句转得平直，结句“御雪霜”直陈说尽，缺少余味。","_cost":0.01696},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"街隅铁箱入诗，有当代生活气息；由投衣转向济寒，脉络清楚。但“千家暖”“穷檐御雪霜”较熟套，结句把善意说尽，余味稍弱。","_cost":0.00802}},"consensus":56.52,"final":56.52},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|机场送别|七律","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"百尺银楼罗广漠，层舷列阵动雷声。迟回只拟重携手，隔界翻成独自行。掣电凌虚穿宿雾，凭窗俯视见孤城。平原望断云无际，落日长风满袖清。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.1,"硬伤":1.2,"陈滥":0.7,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.2,"rationale":"由航站惜别推进至凌空远眺，主线清楚，隔界独行具体动人。颈联开阔，结句清远；但“层舷”“满袖”稍显刻意，密闭舱中长风满袖亦欠合理。","_cost":0.006644},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"以机场安检隔界写送别,当代经验入律有新意,颔联'隔界翻成独自行'情事具体动人。但颈联突转机上俯瞰,视角由送者滑向行者,脉络含混;'落日长风''望断云无际'稍落熟套。结句以景收情尚有余味,惟未能全篇一气。","_cost":0.05367},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.25,"rationale":"机场安检隔界之感入诗有当代意味，颔联尚切。但颈联忽转机上俯视，尾联又似地面长风满袖，送者行者视角混乱，脉络断裂；“罗广漠”“层舷”凑硬，结句落日长风套路化。","_cost":0.05079},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.5,"rationale":"将现代机场体验无缝融入古典律诗，‘隔界’精准写出现代送别特有情境。起承转合层次分明，视点由地及空，尾联以景结情，落日长风尽显寥廓，余味悠长。出新自然，无生造之弊。","_cost":0.024998},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"送别熟题掺机场飞机，情具体但未出新境。意象驳杂欠交融，银楼广漠未精切。语言通顺颔联稍炼。章法有地空之转但视角略跳。结以风日留白尚可。轻微时空逻辑。套语密度中。","_cost":0.03149},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.5,"rationale":"机场送别以现代隔离边界翻古别情，颔联具体可感；尾联以景结情，余味悠长。中二联视角略跳，孤城落日等意象稍熟。","_cost":0.0055280544},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"以古典语汇写机场送别，题材入新且情事具体：'隔界翻成独自行'以登机隔离写别离，最见巧思。视角在送者与行者间微有游移，'银楼''层舷'炼字稍见生硬。章法由地而天、由聚而散，脉络清晰；结联以景收情，余味佳。'落日长风满袖清'可为警句。","_cost":0.00477},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.1,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.7,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.14999999999999,"rationale":"机场声势与隔界独行相映，现代别情较具体；由送而飞而望，脉络清晰，结以落日长风略有清旷余味。惟俯窗视角稍跳，望断、长风等语略熟。","_cost":0.011938},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"现代机场经验入诗得法，掣电、动雷声见炼字；章法由送别至飞行递进、结以景语，余味可取。惜“银楼罗广漠”略硬凑，“望断”“云无际”“落日”熟套偏多。","_cost":0.05620485},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.45,"rationale":"安检隔界写当代送别，情事具体不空；地面雷动转凌虚俯视，层次贯通；落日长风以景结情有余韵。个别措辞略生，意象仍近常见。","_cost":0.0086275},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"机场送别具当代性，“隔界翻成独自行”情真；后半“孤城”“落日长风”等意象常见，意境稍杂，视角转换略跳。语言有“翻”“掣电凌虚”亮点，结句以景结情而稍熟。无硬伤蹈袭，稍有陈滥。","_cost":0.035644504},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"此作写机场送别怅惘，题旨明确，融入当代机场场景，结构完整通顺；但立意未脱传统窠臼，部分意象陈熟，转折平直，结句余味平平，警策不足。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"机场隔界携手稍具当代感然情泛，起承转合完整但转平，语言直白少诗眼，尾以景收留白有限。","_cost":0.01734425},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"隔界独行将离情落实于机场阻隔，由送别到凌空远望，层次清楚。“罗广漠”“层舷”措辞生硬；结句以景收情，但“长风满袖”与舱内视点稍疏，云、落日等组合偏熟。","_cost":0.05197},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"「隔界翻成独自行」情事具体，是全篇主脑；此后转入飞行望城，送别未收束。银楼雷声有场，孤城落日长风为套象，满袖与机舱相忤。颔联有诗眼，颈联动词堆垛。起转清楚，结句套景少延宕。","_cost":0.0289616},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"颔联“隔界翻成独自行”把安检隔离写入别情,是全篇亮点。首联场面尚壮。颈联忽作机上俯视,尾联又回到地面望远,视角跳脱,脉络欠贯通。“掣电凌虚”稍嫌套语。结句以景结情,有余韵,但“清”字与离情略隔。","_cost":0.019616},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"“隔界”写未能再携手，别情具体；由候机转入俯瞰，脉络可循。“层舷”“罗广漠”稍涩，孤城、落日偏熟；既凭机窗俯视，结句“长风满袖”便有失真之感。","_cost":0.013464}},"consensus":65.83,"final":65.83},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"默立街隅翠色幽，千门脱卸絮袍收。虚囊巧贮经霜褐，转斗轻翻御雪裘。拂拭微埃行远道，移将厚意动遐陬。宁甘寂寞当衢守，总把温存静处留。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.3,"语言":5.7,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.4,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.05000000000001,"rationale":"旧物回收寄托温情，题材入诗颇新，物我贯通，铺展亦有层次。惟“厚意动遐陬”等稍显硬涩，末联拟人直陈，收束稳而留白不足。","_cost":0.006698},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.5,"rationale":"以回收箱入七律,当代物事有取材新意,咏物拟人立意尚明。然中二联铺陈平列,'经霜褐''御雪裘'对仗工而意近,层次开合不足;'转斗''遐陬'炼字见凑。尾联'宁甘寂寞''总把温存'直陈其德,说破无余,近颂扬套路。","_cost":0.03128},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，当代题材有新意，中二联铺叙贮衣、转斗、远送层次尚清。但取象偏泛，「御雪裘」略夸饰，「厚意」「温存」「寂寞」等语近套话；尾联拟人自白，把奉献之意说尽，缺少留白，余味不足。","_cost":0.05855},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"咏当代事物且描摹贴切，颔联写内部构造巧妙切题。但全诗托物言志略显套路，尾联议论直白说破，缺乏留白与余味。","_cost":0.015954},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"旧衣箱入七律题材较新，然默守传温的情志仍属常见咏物路数。衣物意象贴切而未深融，语言通达少诗眼，章法平叙少转，结句点破温存较直。","_cost":0.015534},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗有当代感，立意明确但偏于直说奉献；意象统一，经霜御雪等略熟；中二联对工有层次，尾联点破温存，余味偏弱。","_cost":0.00729498},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入律诗，当代经验化为古典语汇，构思新颖，主脑聚焦于“默默收纳、传递温暖”。中二联一收一送，开合有层次。尾联“宁甘寂寞”稍近说破，结句直白略欠宕开。“脱卸”稍生硬，个别字微露凑韵痕迹，整体工稳自然。","_cost":0.00310416},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.85,"rationale":"拟人写旧衣回收箱，取材新颖，主脑清晰，颔颈有层次。惜抽象词较多，厚意温存说破，结句少余味；个别语汇稍生。","_cost":0.011862},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.75,"rationale":"题新旨熟:拟人歌颂'默默奉献、温暖远人'为常调。颔联'转斗'写翻盖尚具体,然'虚囊''脱卸''移将'语多造作。脉络通畅而推衍平直,结联直陈甘守寂寞、静留温存,说破失余味。","_cost":0.0409089},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.5,"意境":4.8,"语言":5.4,"章法":6.8,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.15,"rationale":"立意以衢边小箱寄城市温情，主脑集中且翻熟为新；章法由形及用及情层次贯通；然中二联说明味重，意象实写少情景交融，语言平实少诗眼，结句直赋点题说尽少余味。","_cost":0.01017775},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"咏当代旧衣回收箱，题材有效入诗（出新2）；立意明确而托物言志稍常见，意象语言有‘转斗’生硬与套话（陈滥1），章法完整但转折平直，结句直白少余味。无警句、硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":0.021338785},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.25,"rationale":"咏当代旧衣回收箱，题旨明确，以传统托物手法写奉献意，角度常规。意象妥帖偏常套，章法平顺少波澜，语言通顺偶有字欠准，结句直白余味薄，引新事物入诗略有尝试。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.75,"rationale":"以市政小物入咏视角尚新，然情事空泛缺具体可感；物象罗列未融为境；中二联同义反复无开合；结句直陈温存说破无留白。","_cost":0.01308475},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"以回收箱写衣物传暖，取材有新意，情旨较常见。袍、褐、裘叠用稍滞，“千门脱卸”“动遐陬”略显牵凑。由收贮至远送，脉络清楚；结句直陈温情，稳而少余韵。","_cost":0.04824},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"回收箱拟为静默施予者，主脑清楚，然厚意温存近于颂德，未落一人一衣。翠色、经霜褐较切，转斗与动遐陬隔膜。由收到送再归守，脉顺而转平。结句宁甘总把，意已说尽。","_cost":0.0288928},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.25,"rationale":"以当代旧衣箱入诗,取材有新意,但立意落在拟人颂奉献,角度常见。颔联“转斗轻翻”写投衣机关,颇精切。颈联“厚意”“遐陬”偏抽象。章法平铺,缺少转折。尾联“寂寞”“温存”直陈说破,余味不足。","_cost":0.01784},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱入诗有新意，街隅、旧裘等物象切题；中二联由收纳写到转送，层次尚清。“转斗”语意不明，“厚意”“温存”偏泛，结句将情意说尽，余味较弱。","_cost":0.008208}},"consensus":58.05,"final":58.05},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"架竹栽蔬临碧落，瓜花引蔓俯尘流。携筐笑向青畦畔，采得新香佐晚瓯。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.1,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.3,"余味":6.9,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.1,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.14999999999999,"rationale":"天台种采入诗，生活情趣具体，碧落与尘流构成立体空间。三四句由观景转劳作，脉络清楚；“尘流”“晚瓯”稍显刻意，结句清雅但意味略尽。","_cost":0.005274},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.5,"rationale":"天台种菜属当代经验入诗，'临碧落''俯尘流'高低对照颇有意趣，为一篇亮点。惟三句'携筐笑向'转折平直近套语，结句'采得新香佐晚瓯'把闲趣说尽，收束稳当而少留白，全篇顺畅有致但锤炼未深。","_cost":0.03964},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"天台种菜是当代经验,首联碧落/尘流高下对照有巧思,瓜花引蔓亦妥。然三四句转入采摘直叙,笑向、新香皆熟语,佐晚瓯稍显凑韵,结句说尽而少延宕,整体平稳而不深。","_cost":0.04971},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"立意切中都市田园情结，前两句借“临碧落”与“俯尘流”的空间对比写出天台之高与出尘之意。后两句转入采摘，语言流畅自然。唯结句“佐晚瓯”直白收束，略乏余韵，整体结构平顺。","_cost":0.016778},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"田园采蔬熟题，情事具体而角度常见。首联碧落尘流有高下层次，后半转入家常。语言通顺，「尘流」略硬凑，「新香」小亮。章法完备转笔平直，结句直叙佐餐，收得住而少余味。","_cost":0.028096},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"写天台种菜，以“临碧落”“俯尘流”营造超然意境，语言凝练，转结自然，结句生活气息浓。佳联可赏，略欠新意。","_cost":0.00501996},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.5,"rationale":"首二句以临碧落、俯尘流写出天台菜园悬于城市上下的独特空间感，取象精切，是为全诗亮点。转句携筐稍平，结句采香佐瓯收束稳当、略带清味但未宕开。整体情事具体、脉络贯通，唯立意止于闲适，挖掘不深。","_cost":0.0042248},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.3,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.35,"rationale":"天台菜园小景清新，起承转合完整，瓜花青畦有生活气。但题旨常见，碧落、尘流稍泛，结句收稳而意尽，少警策。","_cost":0.009006},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"天台菜园属当代城市经验，入诗有效。俯尘流一联居高临下、取象有致，新香语亦鲜活。章法起承转合分明，转以人入、结落晚瓯；结句具体但稍落实，余味中平。碧落等语略陈熟。","_cost":0.0285627},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.3,"意境":7.1,"语言":6.9,"章法":6.4,"余味":5.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.2,"rationale":"天台种菜切入当代都市田园，碧落俯尘对举有意，景—人—事脉络清晰；立意温小，转结平实，余味安稳而少宕开。","_cost":0.01189475},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"写天台种蔬，当代经验入诗，首联临碧落/俯尘流空间对照稍亮；然意象常见，‘瓜花引蔓’微悖物理，转结平直，结句佐晚瓯稳而少余味。","_cost":0.023323735},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"此作写高处菜园采蔬闲趣，紧扣高旷位置取景，章法平顺，语言清通，结句稳实但余味稍平，取景略有巧思，无硬伤蹈袭，“瓜花引蔓俯尘流”稍有亮点。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.6,"rationale":"天台种蔬俯仰碧落尘流，以高衬俗具当代意；取象妥帖而夸饰，转结平直，末句直收少留白。","_cost":0.01418705},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"天台蔬圃与尘流形成高下对照，采蔬之乐具体可感。前景后事，脉络清楚而转折平直。“瓜花引蔓”稍显牵强，“碧落”“尘流”偏熟；结句落实日常滋味，但延宕有限。","_cost":0.05387},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.0,"rationale":"立意止于田园自适，欢意泛而不切事。前联以碧落、尘流拉开高低，取象尚能成境，为全篇胜处。三句转入携筐笑畦，承转平直。结句点明采以佐饮，收得住而说尽。语言通顺，引蔓、晚瓯略佳，尘流、新香偏虚。","_cost":0.0310704},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"以天台菜园写都市中的田园之乐，题材有当代感。首联“临碧落”“俯尘流”点出楼顶之高、俯临市声，对照有味。第三句“携筐笑向”平常，转得不力。结句采菜佐餐，收得稳当，但直白说尽，余味有限。","_cost":0.014644},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"天台种菜兼得高处俯望与日常采收，情趣可感；由景入人，脉络顺畅。“瓜花引蔓”“尘流”稍欠精切，结句温润但收得较实，余味有限。","_cost":0.008134}},"consensus":64.88,"final":64.88},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|云端相册|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"莫向缣缃觅旧真，云端不惹百年尘。轻屏漫拂当时笑，脉脉犹迎白发人。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.7,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.4,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"以云端相册映照容颜老去，古雅语汇与当代经验交融。由缣缃、云端转入拂屏相逢，脉络清楚；结句昔笑迎白发，含蓄动人。“旧真”略显生硬。","_cost":0.004942},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"以云端相册翻'睹旧照思年华'熟题,'缣缃—云端'古今对举立意新颖。转句'轻屏漫拂当时笑'具体可感,结句照片旧笑迎白发人,时光落差有余味。语言自然少斧凿,惟'脉脉''白发'稍近熟语,气象尚可更开。","_cost":0.0346},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"以云端相册对照缣缃旧照，当代经验入诗自然。前二句偏说理稍板，后二句“轻屏漫拂”“脉脉犹迎白发人”以旧照笑颊对白发今人，情景交融，结句有余味。整体妥帖而未臻惊警。","_cost":0.04902},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.25,"rationale":"当代科技完美融入旧体。以“云端不惹尘”双关极妙，“轻屏漫拂”生动切当。结句以数字影像之青春反衬观者之白发，物是人非之感悠然而生，化新事入旧律，毫无违和斧凿之感，余味深长。","_cost":0.027626},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.0,"rationale":"云端对照缣缃写旧照迎白发，立意有当代切入但情志仍属常见怀旧。意象妥帖新旧杂糅，氛围统一一般。语言通顺，‘不惹尘’稍见炼。章法完整转平直。结句稳有象未尽说破。","_cost":0.023986},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":9.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"以云端相册对照旧缣缃，写数字时代怀旧有真体验，立意新。转结以动作拟人收束，余味不竭。意象偏说理，景语稍弱。","_cost":0.01301124},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.0,"rationale":"以云端相册翻新怀旧旧题：数字影像不惹尘、笑靥长驻而观者已白头，新旧反差真挚可感。“漫拂”暗合拂尘旧忆，是为诗眼。起承转合顺遂，结句以笑迎白发人收束，言尽意不尽。当代经验入诗自然，化古无痕，无硬伤无陈套。","_cost":0.0032556},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.1,"rationale":"以云端相册翻新旧照怀旧，题旨集中，今语入诗较自然。轻屏拂笑与白发相迎有画面余味；但云端、百年尘稍概念，脉脉白发略熟，结意微露。","_cost":0.009558},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"以云端相册对缣缃旧册，熟题翻新有主脑；'不惹百年尘'见巧思，结句白发迎笑得情。惟'缣缃'稍隔、'轻屏'稍硬，情味偏熟，余韵中等。","_cost":0.0217569},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.3,"余味":7.9,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.9,"rationale":"缣缃对云端翻新怀旧题，当时笑迎白发人情真有主脑；取象精切交融但次句偏议论；漫拂/脉脉炼字自然；起承同面转结收束有余味，当代经验入诗得当。","_cost":0.01107925},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"借题旧写真而入云端相册，古今交融，情事具体。轻屏拂笑、笑迎白发，转结动人。语言凝练有诗眼，当代经验出新；章法完整而转稍平，结句留白。无硬伤蹈袭，陈象不滥。","_cost":0.028269044},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"此诗将云相册、触屏等当代经验融入览旧主题，立意新颖，章法圆畅，炼字有亮点，结句见今昔之慨；唯“缣缃”稍隔、“旧真”稍硬，意境、余味未入高境。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"缣缃对云端切当代记忆，有新意；前半说理偏干，意象单薄，抚屏对视结尾以象收束，余味较佳。","_cost":0.00968525},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"以云端留笑与人渐白头相照，将数字存影转为岁月之感；后联由屏入情，末句让旧影迎人，颇有余味。起联略偏议论，“旧真”“轻屏”措辞稍涩。","_cost":0.04651},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.5,"rationale":"题旨清楚而发现常见，旧笑迎白发有焦点。前半近议论，后半笑影始出，取象未精。字句省净而脉脉偏熟。起承平直，尘线未贯结。结句情已点明，犹字稍留。云端入诗有效，缣缃略隔。","_cost":0.0517632},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"以云端相册写容颜长驻而人已老，当代经验入诗有效。“缣缃”“旧真”古语对接数码，“拂”字呼应“尘”，炼字见心。结句以旧笑迎白发，反差含蓄有余味。意象稍单薄，“脉脉”“白发人”略熟。","_cost":0.017528},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"云端与缣缃对照有新意，旧笑迎白发人的时光反差动人；起承转合清楚。但“旧真”稍涩，“百年尘”略熟，结句情意较明。","_cost":0.010932}},"consensus":77.17,"final":77.17},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|天台菜园|七律","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"凌虚筑圃对斜阳，聚土成畦引菜香。翠蔓随风舒嫩绿，红椒结实带余光。凭高远避车尘闹，倚槛偏迎绝顶凉。漫道渊明归去早，云端数陇即柴桑。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.7,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.60000000000001,"rationale":"屋顶菜园融入隐逸情怀，题材有当代新意，诸色物象相映。前六句铺写有序，尾联借渊明宕开。“带余光”稍含混，“绝顶凉”略显刻意，柴桑之喻亦稍说满。","_cost":0.004718},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"以天台种菜写都市隐逸,当代经验入诗有新意,结句'云端数陇即柴桑'化陶渊明典较巧,惜一'即'字点破稍尽。中二联写景对仗工稳但'带余光''绝顶凉'炼字平弱,取象(斜阳、嫩绿)偏熟。章法完整,转合自然,整体中上而未臻警拔。","_cost":0.04138},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"天台种菜属当代经验入诗，题旨明确，尾联以云端数陇比柴桑略有新趣。然中二联翠蔓红椒、避尘迎凉皆常见语，写景平顺少警策；结句用渊明典直说归隐之意，虽稍翻案却说破无余。","_cost":0.0396},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"将都市天台与古典田园相连，立意新巧，章法起承转合严谨流贯。然颔联“翠”“绿”意重且用语平白，意象锤炼稍欠。结句以云端拟柴桑，颇有余味。","_cost":0.025374},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"隐逸主题常见无新境，菜园细节具体。红椒余光意象较佳，余多套语。语言通顺少炼。结构完整转结平直。结句点破少余味。","_cost":0.021074},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"天台种菜与陶潜隐逸对接有当代感，意象具体但炼字平实，颈联转得自然，结句以典收束稍涉议论，余味中等。","_cost":0.0058872},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"都市天台种菜入律，取材新颖，主脑聚焦。颈联避闹迎凉开合有致，尾联翻用渊明典故，'云端数陇即柴桑'化古出新、以典结情而不说破，余味悠长。中二联层次分明，唯'斜阳''翠蔓'等取象稍熟，炼字偶平。","_cost":0.00359874},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.7,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.3,"警句":2.6,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.7,"rationale":"写天台菜园之趣，以“云端数陇即柴桑”收出即地归隐之旨，主脑明确；意象清丽而稍熟，语言顺畅但锤炼不足，章法自然，结句有余味而略靠典故。","_cost":0.009806},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"以天台菜园翻陶渊明归田旧题，'云端数陇即柴桑'反用典故，立意有新意；翠蔓红椒、车尘绝顶，意象妥帖但略常见；语言通顺少诗眼，'舒嫩绿'稍熟；中二联一近景一远怀，开合清楚，结句宕开有余味。无明显硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.008088},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.7,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.4,"章法":5.9,"余味":4.9,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"天台筑圃翻隐逸旧题，云端即柴桑稍见新意；中二联写景铺叙平实，层次变化不足，尾联直点陶典收束说破，遣词如带余光稍欠锤炼。","_cost":0.01050675},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.4,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.4,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.4,"rationale":"以天台菜园比渊明柴桑，融都市车尘云端经验，立意有新而情志稍平；意象妥帖多常见，语言通顺带散句，中二联稳；章法起承转合完足，结句直点柴桑稍说破。尾联云陇即柴桑为警句，当代经验入诗，略陈，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.030934779},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"本诗咏天台菜园，寄寓避尘闲逸之思，立意明确，章法规整，意象妥帖，语言清顺，用典自然，但整体平熟少警策，结句偏直，无明显硬伤。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"云端菜陇比附柴桑略有新意而情事空泛，前景后议割裂氛围，舒嫩绿带余光等炼字疲弱，颈联复意转平，结句即柴桑说破无留白。","_cost":0.01785655},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.1,"语言":6.4,"章法":6.8,"余味":5.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.7,"rationale":"屋顶种菜将都市生活与归隐之趣相接，“聚土成畦”具体，“云端数陇”见巧思。写物转入抒怀，脉络清楚；斜阳、余光略复，尾联借陶意点题较熟，结句判断过实，留白有限。","_cost":0.03684},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.75,"rationale":"高圃避车尘，红椒余光与云端数陇合成晚景，为全篇所长。隐逸主脑借渊明柴桑说尽，情志未深；中二联并列，开合不足。结句“即”字坐实，余味不长。语言通畅，锤炼有限。","_cost":0.0260912},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"以城市天台种菜写当代归隐，结联把云端菜垄比作柴桑，有巧思。颔联翠蔓、红椒具体可感，但'翠'与'嫩绿'意思重复。颈联'远避车尘闹'说得太直，'绝顶'言过其实。'漫道渊明归去早'语意稍拗。中二联都在铺景，开合变化不足。","_cost":0.0199},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"天台种菜与陶渊明的田园意趣相接，有当代生活气息；由圃景转向避喧，脉络清楚。“翠蔓”“嫩绿”意重，“绝顶”稍夸；末句直指柴桑，余味略浅。","_cost":0.011118}},"consensus":68.13,"final":68.13},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|云端相册|七律","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"莫道虚空无纸墨，能将瞬息作长留。凝眸寸景生春色，触手荧屏唤旧游。渐觉飞霜侵客鬓，常存笑靥不知秋。遥分万脉归霄汉，漫遣光阴任倒流。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.10000000000001,"rationale":"以云端相册凝住瞬息，对照客鬓渐霜与笑靥长存，主脑鲜明且有当代性。中二联情景相生，转折自然；“万脉归霄汉”语意稍涩，结句直说光阴倒流，余味略减。","_cost":0.004634},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"以云端相册入律,当代经验有效化入,颈联'飞霜侵鬓'与'笑靥不知秋'对照人老照驻,最见匠心。惟'触手荧屏'稍露直白,尾句'任倒流'把题意说尽,余味略减;'飞霜客鬓'语涉熟套。整体章法完足,起结呼应。","_cost":0.03776},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗有当代经验，颈联“飞霜侵鬓”与“笑靧不知秋”对照见意，是全篇支点。惟取象多虚说（虚空纸墨、寸景春色），意境交融不足；“飞霜客鬓”偏熟套；尾联“光阴倒流”说破题意，余味稍欠。","_cost":0.05063},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"本诗以旧体写现代“云端”，以“虚空无纸墨”喻云存储，借数字相片的不老反衬“飞霜客鬓”的衰朽，立意新颖、结构完整。然“荧屏”稍显直白，结句“光阴任倒流”说得过尽，欠缺留白余味。","_cost":0.025108},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.0,"rationale":"云端相册入诗有新意，主题对比瞬间永存与鬓霜易侵，情志集中。意象新旧杂陈，飞霜客鬓较套。炼字平实有对照，章法完整转结稍平。结句说破倒流，余味有限。","_cost":0.021994},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"首联点题，中二联由触屏旧游转入客鬓与笑靥对比，层次清晰；语言有“唤旧游”等眼，但结句稍直露。现代题材出新，飞霜、霄汉等意象略熟。","_cost":0.0142824},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"咏云端相册，熟题翻新：颈联'飞霜侵鬓'与'笑靥不知秋'对照，人老而影像常驻，主脑鲜明。'万脉归霄汉'以天河喻数据流，古今语汇融合自然。起承转合完整，颈联陡转见力，结句'光阴倒流'宕开有余韵。'飞霜侵鬓'稍落套，个别措辞如'漫遣''任'微觉意近。","_cost":0.00380364},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.4,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.4,"余味":5.2,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.24999999999999,"rationale":"题旨聚焦云端存照，能化当代经验；中二联由屏景入岁华，脉络清晰。惜荧屏、飞霜、光阴倒流等语稍涉熟直，结句说破，余味未深。","_cost":0.014308},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":65.0,"rationale":"熟题(留影)接入云端经验，颈联“飞霜侵鬓/笑靥不知秋”以人老衬像不老，情志具体且为全篇主脑，颇见警策；首联破题有势。惜“万脉归霄汉”含混，尾联“任倒流”说破且夸大，反泄颈联张力，余味受损。用语大体锤炼而少生造。","_cost":0.022569},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.3,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"云端入诗以笑靥不老对飞霜客鬓立意较新，结构起承转合完整；唯意象多通用语，语言平实少诗眼，结句直陈倒流少留白。","_cost":0.009092},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.5,"rationale":"以云端相册写瞬息长留，题旨聚焦而情稍泛；意象新老杂糅，“飞霜侵鬓”稍陈；语言有“笑靥不知秋”亮点，“万脉”生硬；章法完整，尾联直白少余味；颈联可摘，当代经验入诗有效但略生造。","_cost":0.030678351},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"此作咏云端相册，紧扣虚拟存贮特性抒忆旧叹逝之情，主脑明晰，脉络通顺，用语平实；唯转折偏平，结句直白，意象多熟见，新事物入诗尚自然，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":4.2,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.849999999999994,"rationale":"以云端留影抗衰老尚有新意，颈联霜鬓对笑靥具主脑；然荧屏等象偏实直，尾联放空说尽，语言欠诗眼。","_cost":0.01011625},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.5,"rationale":"以云端存影对照人身衰老，题旨集中，颈联较有情味。中二联由忆旧推进至感时；“遥分万脉”语意含混，结句直说光阴倒流，留白不足。春色、飞霜等熟象稍多。","_cost":0.05057},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"以云端存照写人老照不老，主脑清楚，但是熟题，未见深一层发现。颈联霜鬓对笑靥最切，可成句。首尾多判断，万脉取象不清，结句直说倒流，余味薄。荧屏等当代经验入诗尚可，寸景、漫遣稍硬。","_cost":0.0289536},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写留住时光,当代经验入诗有效。颈联以真实鬓霜对照照片中笑靥不知秋,张力最佳。起句议论直露。结句'光阴任倒流'直白说破,消解了颈联的深意。意象跨度大而欠统一,'遥分万脉'稍嫌生硬。","_cost":0.020852},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"以云端存照对照客鬓渐老与旧照常新，情感有着落；“笑靥不知秋”可赏。末联由具体转向空泛，“光阴倒流”说得较尽，余味稍弱。","_cost":0.009564}},"consensus":66.95,"final":66.95},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"万仞舷窗接夜凉，神州九陌织流光。凭虚莫问仙源处，一粟红尘是故乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.1,"警句":3.6,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.95,"rationale":"借夜航俯瞰翻写乡情，灯路、凭虚与一粟红尘相映，转结有力。“万仞舷窗”稍显压缩，神州、流光、红尘略熟。","_cost":0.006724},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰当代经验入诗,反用求仙旧题,归结于'一粟红尘是故乡',翻出人间温情,立意有新境。'织流光'炼字见巧,转句宕开、结句收得住且留余温。'红尘''仙源'略近熟语,微扣陈滥。","_cost":0.03396},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰以古典语汇写当代经验，'织流光'炼字见巧，三句'莫问仙源'转向人间尚有变化。但'神州''红尘''故乡'意象偏熟，结句直接说破'是故乡'，余味有限，'万仞'亦嫌夸饰。","_cost":0.05243},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"夜航经验有效入诗，古典意词与现代景象融合无痕，“织”字炼得精妙。起承转合圆融，转句由天界拉回人间，结句将高旷空间收束于温情眷恋，对比强烈，虽略直白但极具情感张力。","_cost":0.02165},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰翻出红尘即乡，场景较新、主脑清楚。起承写实转结说理，脉络完整。织流光有炼，流光红尘略陈。结句点破，余味平直。","_cost":0.017984},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰由高空流光转出红尘故乡，转结有力；“织”字精炼，“一粟红尘”张力足；立意略常见而收束完整。","_cost":0.014609936},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰这一当代经验入诗自然。起承转合分明，第三句以'莫问仙源'宕开，结句化沧海一粟之意翻转出'一粟红尘是故乡'，大与小、仙境与人间对照见巧。'接''织'炼字精当。结句'是故乡'稍作点破，余味略减。","_cost":0.0042664},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.6,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.35,"rationale":"夜航视角新，舷窗灯网有画面；转入仙源与故乡，收束见思，但语汇稍熟，结句略说破。","_cost":0.010602},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":62.5,"rationale":"以夜航入题,翻桃源熟典故为'红尘即故乡',转结有思;'织'字见炼。然意象尚常,结句理语说破,余味稍弱,现代经验入旧体稍具新致。","_cost":0.021204},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.1,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.2,"rationale":"万仞织光起势阔，转以仙源宕开收于一粟故乡，章法完整；织字为眼，当代舷窗经验入诗自然，唯九陌仙源红尘略熟，结句以理收余韵稍浅。","_cost":0.008536},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"起承转合完整，舷窗、织流光将现代夜航融入古典意境；结句以一粟红尘收束，情志真切但略直白；用语妥帖有锤炼，仙源与红尘对照稍常见。","_cost":0.028576326},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"此作写夜航俯瞰观感，章法流转自然，“织流光”炼字精准；立意不慕虚渺仙源，归重红尘故乡，主旨明畅，唯意象稍熟，结句略直，余韵稍欠。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"凭虚俯瞰转归红尘故乡，主脑集中；织字稍亮，万仞接凉搭配生硬；起承转合贯通；结句直点故乡，说尽留白不足。","_cost":0.01146425},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"“织”字写灯火成网，夜航俯瞰与微小故乡形成尺度反差。由仙源折回人间，转结清楚；但“莫问仙源”稍泛，末句点明乡情，留白有限，仙源、红尘等熟语略多。","_cost":0.03457},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"起承转合清楚，先张九陌流光再收为一粟，章法最稳。舷窗夜色可感，但仙源、红尘、凭虚、一粟皆熟套，第三句离即目之景。立意止于故园即仙境的常见翻转，结句揭明题旨，余味有限。","_cost":0.0288752},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰写入当代经验，前两句写灯火如织，“织流光”颇见炼字。转句由高空仙想折回人间，结句归于“故乡”，情意温厚。但“凭虚”“一粟”化自《赤壁赋》，痕迹较显。结句点破主旨，余味稍浅。","_cost":0.014632},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"由夜航俯瞰转入故乡之思，脉络自然；“织流光”有画面，末句以渺小见眷恋，但“是故乡”稍直白，“仙源”“红尘”亦较熟。","_cost":0.008114}},"consensus":72.81,"final":72.81},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"青荧方寸照深更，万里关山咫尺明。絮语依依催早歇，空留满枕月华清。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.1,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.9,"rationale":"以视频通话写万里亲情，方寸青荧与满枕月华虚实相映。前三句递进自然，结句由絮语转清寂，含蓄有余味；“关山咫尺”稍熟。","_cost":0.004392},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"以视频通话入七绝,当代经验融旧体,情事具体:屏光照更、絮语催眠、挂断后空枕对月,脉络清晰,结句以景收情有余味。惟'万里关山咫尺''月华清'取象偏熟,炼字平稳少警策,略扣陈滥。","_cost":0.03282},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"以“方寸青荧”对“万里关山”，当代视频经验入诗妥帖，起承有对比之趣；转句“催早歇”自然，结以枕月收情，稍见余味。惜“絮语依依”“月华清”属常见语料，“空留”已点破，整体稳而不奇。","_cost":0.04394},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"“青荧方寸”巧妙代指手机屏幕，将当代生活完美融入古体。起承具时空张力，转句充满生活气息，结句“满枕月华清”以景结情，写出屏幕熄灭后的怅惘。起承转合自然流转，余味悠长，是出新的佳作。","_cost":0.013664},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"视频相思情事具体有主脑，角度仍属常见。青荧与月华对照可感，关山絮语偏陈，氛围统一中等。语言通顺，方寸见炼。章法起承清楚，转结层次预期内。结句空留略说破，余味有限。当代经验入诗有效。","_cost":0.022},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.6,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"写深夜视频通话，现代经验入旧体不硬；结句以月华满枕收束，留白有延宕。语言中“絮语”略熟，警句不显。","_cost":0.00745272},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.5,"rationale":"熟题翻新：以'方寸青荧'写深夜视频，万里咫尺之悖因科技而实，挂断后'空留月华'归于孤清，屏光与月光首尾映照，情事具体、主脑鲜明。结句以景结情，余味绵长。'万里关山咫尺'稍熟，'照深更'微硬，整体妥帖自然。","_cost":0.00273664},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.1,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.1,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.9,"rationale":"以“方寸”写屏幕，化现代经验入旧体，关山咫尺与月华空留相映，情事具体。转结自然，余味在景；惜语汇稍熟。","_cost":0.007636},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"深夜视频入旧体而不隔，方寸双关、万里与咫尺翻转见警，絮语催歇细节真切；结以满枕月华宕开，有余韵。然关山、月华语稍熟，情旨未脱相思旧窠。","_cost":0.015105},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.2,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.1,"余味":7.9,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.1,"rationale":"青荧方寸与月华清寒虚实对照，转结由絮语温存跌入空枕独对，以景结情余味较足；当代题材入诗自然，但情思仍在常调离思内。","_cost":0.009834},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"以视频通话写相思，当代经验入诗自然。起承转合工稳，转句写絮语声，结句以月华清景结情，余味悠长。唯思致未深，意象稍杂常见语，故立意意境中上，章法语言结句佳。","_cost":0.020382558},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"此作取材当代深夜跨地视频场景，取象贴切，起承转合顺畅，结以月景点出挂断后的空寂，语言自然，唯核心情思与部分意象稍熟，无硬伤、蹈袭问题。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"以视频写相思，荧屏转月光，转结分明余味较佳；万里关山偏概念，意象薄，语言平稳少诗眼。","_cost":0.01164875},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"屏光与月光相映，隔屏亲昵转为独卧清寂，转结有层次。“咫尺明”稍显牵合，关山、月华较熟；视频经验入诗自然，结句留情于景，但独到警策不足。","_cost":0.04066},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"屏前暂聚、挂后空枕，情事具体而发现不深。青荧方寸较新，关山絮语月华偏熟。起结清楚，转偏平；空留略说破，余味有限。","_cost":0.0210192},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"以视频通话写异地相思，当代经验入诗较自然。“青荧方寸”指屏幕精当，与结句月华形成人造光与天然光的对照，挂断后的空寂以景收束，有余味。但“空留”稍嫌说破，“絮语依依”“月华清”偏熟，角度也较常见。","_cost":0.015996},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"以屏光起、月光收，隔屏虽近而人仍远，转结含蓄有余韵。“咫尺明”稍涩，“万里关山”“絮语依依”略熟；视频入诗较自然。","_cost":0.008042}},"consensus":76.05,"final":76.05},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"四壁晶莹围软兽，投钱试引冷银钩。凝眸漫把机枢转，屏气徐教铁掌游。乍抱茸躯腾半尺，翻离弱指坠香丘。青蚨掷尽憨如旧，独对冰函一笑休。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.8,"余味":7.9,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.85000000000001,"rationale":"以古雅语写抓娃娃的投入、将得复失与自嘲，叙事一线贯通；颈联动态鲜明。青蚨、冰函稍显刻意，结句含蓄而未臻深远。","_cost":0.007108},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"当代题材入律而不隔，冷银钩、铁掌游状物精切，中二联一静一动开合有致。青蚨用典贴合，香丘化用稍显借力。'憨如旧'见自嘲之趣，结句一笑收束稳当，惟'休'字稍说尽，留白略欠。整体炼字见功而不猎奇。","_cost":0.03686},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"当代经验入律得体，冷钩铁掌与茸躯软兽冷暖对照贯穿全篇，颈联抱腾翻坠最见工巧。中二联皆顺叙过程，开合层次略平；结句自嘲一笑稳而稍熟，余韵有限。","_cost":0.05443},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.2,"意境":8.3,"语言":8.6,"章法":8.8,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.05,"rationale":"本诗将现代游戏“抓娃娃”完美化入七律。意象如“软兽”“银钩”古雅贴切；中二联将摇杆、下爪、抓起、滑落的动态刻画得精细生动，波澜起伏；尾联“一笑休”尽显无果后的释然。当代经验入诗极为成功。","_cost":0.031386},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"新题入律，过程层次清楚，颈联腾坠具体。意象映射机台尚可但香丘冰函稍隔，语言通顺少诗眼。结句一笑休收束偏尽，余味有限。出新有效。","_cost":0.022422},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.25,"rationale":"以冷暖物象写抓娃娃之专注与落空，画面集中。颈联抓放瞬间生动。尾联收束稍直，余味有限。现代题材化入七律较新，但凝眸屏气等略熟。","_cost":0.02621784},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"以七律写抓娃娃机，当代经验入诗而全用古典语汇，取象精切：冷银钩、铁掌、香丘状物传神，颈联腾/坠一扬一抑见转折之妙，结句一笑而休留有余温。香丘借葬花词典而略带戏拟之趣。","_cost":0.0046266},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.3,"余味":7.9,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.3,"rationale":"写抓娃娃机全程，颔颈摹态生动，现代物象入诗较稳，尾联自嘲有余。惟“香丘”“冰函”稍生，略见雕琢。","_cost":0.013892},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"当代题材入七律自然不隔,抓取—悬起—坠落的经验刻画精准;颔联'凝眸''屏气'工切,颈联'乍抱''翻离'转折有力,'香丘'化葬花语而谐趣自见;通体冰函/茸躯冷暖相映。结句'一笑休'自嘲通达然稍平直,余味欠宕;立意独到而未深挖一层。","_cost":0.017013},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.1,"rationale":"以当代抓娃娃机入律，冷钩软兽对照精切，过程摹写层层递进至乍得遽失，章法完整；然情止于掷钱一笑的小自嘲，未开新境，结句直收少宕远。","_cost":0.00854575},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.0,"rationale":"题材新颖，意象冷软对照、颈联生动，意境高；中二联叙事稍平、情志止于自嘲，故章法与立意中等。结句有余味，语言有诗眼。加分为佳联及当代经验，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.032441215},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"此作叙写抓娃娃的当代日常，过程具象真切，章法顺畅，动词精准，颈联捕捉得失瞬间画面感强；唯“香丘”稍隔，结句余韵略平，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.4,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.4,"rationale":"以旧语写今器，操纵起落摹写细致，颈联腾坠动感足；然止于叙游戏成败，未能翻出深意，结句一笑收束稳而意浅。","_cost":0.01330305},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"以抓取、脱落写小欲落空，软兽与冷硬机爪形成情境张力，颈联动势鲜明，章法贯通。“香丘”“冰函”略显雕饰；结句自嘲明确，余波有限。当代器物入诗较自然。","_cost":0.05014},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃入律,情事具体而理趣未深。冷械与茸兽对举成境,弱指、半尺为眼。由凝眸至腾坠,转折清楚;一笑休收得住而稍直。当代经验入诗有效,香丘略饰,无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0259264},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"以古雅语写抓娃娃机，颈联腾坠有动势，“香丘”借葬花语作戏谑。但全篇顺叙过程，少深层发现。“凝眸”与“漫把”略相抵。结句“一笑休”收得稳当，略显直白收尽。","_cost":0.019872},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"以冷硬机爪对照柔软玩偶，得失一瞬写得鲜活；起承转合清楚，末句自嘲有味。题旨仍偏常见，“香丘”稍嫌饰辞，结句余韵有限。","_cost":0.013368}},"consensus":76.52,"final":76.52},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"邻坊日午起炊烟，软饱家常齿颊鲜。莫向空厨愁举火，齐围暖案胜华筵。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.3,"语言":5.4,"章法":7.1,"余味":4.8,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.65,"rationale":"社区互助入诗，主旨集中而具现实温度；炊烟、空厨、暖案相互照应。转结完整，但“软饱”“齿颊鲜”稍显生硬，末句直判胜负，余味不足。","_cost":0.007634},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.5,"rationale":"以社区食堂入诗有当代生活气息,题旨明确、脉络完整,转句关切空厨独居者见人情。惟取象平常(炊烟、华筵近套语),结句'胜华筵'一语说破,议论兜底乏余味。'软饱'本指饮酒,借指饭食微有失当。整体温厚平稳,警策不足。","_cost":0.04056},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.5,"rationale":"题材当代，起承转合齐备，第三句转向独居空厨有关怀意。但取象泛而无实景，社区食堂写“炊烟”略失真，“软饱”本指饮酒，借用稍偏；结句“胜华筵”直陈评断，说破无余味，近于宣传口吻。","_cost":0.05223},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.0,"rationale":"本诗写当代“社区食堂”，立意切题。语言通顺，“软饱”暗切长者较为妥帖，但通篇偏直白，套语较多（如胜华筵）。章法平直无波澜，结句流于口号，说破说尽缺乏余味，整体属平庸之作。","_cost":0.016594},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗有当代感，主脑清楚然颂温情角度俗。炊烟空厨华筵意象常见，氛围浅融。软饱齿颊稍炼。起承转合完整但平直。结句直陈胜华筵，说破少余味。","_cost":0.024204},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"社区食堂题材有生活气息，意脉完整；起承转合清楚，尾句点题但直露，余味稍欠。“软饱”用词略偏，整体意象妥帖常见。","_cost":0.01177968},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"社区食堂当代民生题材入诗，以“空厨愁举火”对照“齐围暖案”，主脑清晰，翻出老有所养新境。起承转合完整，“软饱”体贴老人齿颊，炼字见心。结以“胜华筵”比较收束，意完而稍直白，余味略减。","_cost":0.00302844},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.05,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗，题材有当代生活温度；炊烟、暖案颇能成境，但齿颊鲜、胜华筵等语偏熟偏直，结句说破，余味稍欠。","_cost":0.007948},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.4,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.9,"rationale":"题旨聚焦空厨举火之难，暖案胜华筵有对照；象尚统一而炊烟、华筵偏熟，结句明判少留。第三句转得有力，新题入诗有效。","_cost":0.039672},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.6,"章法":6.2,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.1,"rationale":"当代民生题材切实有主脑，邻里共食暖意具体；意象家常妥帖但欠精切，语言通顺乏诗眼，章法转结平实直收。","_cost":0.0073835},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.0,"rationale":"社区食堂题材具当代性，空厨愁举火等语尚贴切；然立意止于家常胜华筵常调，意象偏熟，结句直白少余味，章法完整但转折平。无警句蹈袭，略有陈滥。","_cost":0.028863449},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"此诗聚焦社区食堂的便民暖意，立意平实贴近民生，意象妥帖偏熟，章法顺承完整，语言通顺有小炼字，结句直白点旨少余味，当代经验入诗略有新意，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.75,"rationale":"选材社区食堂具时代感，主脑收于共暖，然炊烟暖案意象常见，软饱生硬，结句直判胜华筵而无留白。","_cost":0.01019275},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"共食解炊愁，题旨集中，社区生活略有新意；“空厨”与“暖案”照应，章法清楚。意象较熟，“软饱家常”搭配稍涩；末句以“胜华筵”说破，留白不足。","_cost":0.05337},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"空厨对暖案有主脑，共食之暖可感，但结以胜华筵落入常见劝勉，情事欠具体。炊烟、华筵陈熟，氛围未凝。语言通顺，软饱不碍。起承转合全而转折平直。结句说破，余味薄。","_cost":0.028096},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"","_cost":0.018752},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.5,"rationale":"以空厨之愁衬食堂之暖，题旨明确，也写出了邻里共餐之意。炊烟、华筵稍显惯常，“软饱家常”语意不够清晰；结句直言胜过华筵，收得稳却少余味。","_cost":0.008174}},"consensus":58.98,"final":58.98},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"铁翼分云向斗牛，悬窗极目俯寰洲。平铺宿火连幽甸，倒泻银河作巨流。下界微茫如聚粟，千城泛彩若浮沤。凭高不尽红尘路，自载孤怀逐远游。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.7,"余味":6.2,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.4,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写尘世微茫，视角新而孤怀稍泛。宿火、巨流、浮沤层次鲜明；“悬窗”“寰洲”略涩。转结贯通，末句稳却落入孤怀远游套语。","_cost":0.007184},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.25,"rationale":"以夜航入律有当代经验，颔联'倒泻银河作巨流'气象可观。然中二联皆写俯瞰灯火，聚粟浮沤与前联意复，开合层次不足；'斗牛''红尘''孤怀'等语近套话；结句直陈情怀说破无余，收束平弱。","_cost":0.03898},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"当代夜航经验入律,取象尚切,‘倒泻银河作巨流’有气势。但中二联皆写俯瞰灯火,如/若并用,层次重复无开合;尾联‘红尘’‘孤怀’‘远游’套语连缀,转结平直,余味有限。","_cost":0.06705},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"本诗将当代夜航经验有效入诗，起首切题自然。中二联气象宏阔，'聚粟''浮沤'两喻深带哲理，俯瞰感极强。唯尾联'红尘''孤怀'略流于概念，说得较满，稍欠余味与留白。整体结构严谨，意象开阔。","_cost":0.018054},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰写城灯微茫转入孤怀，题旨明确而情志稍泛。颔联宿火银河较融，颈联聚粟浮沤妥帖。结句直点孤怀少留白。飞机夜景入诗可取，斗牛红尘略陈，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.021448},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰题材较新，画面统一，中二联有开合但意象多熟。尾联直说孤怀，余味不足。偶有佳联，陈套词如红尘、远游较多。","_cost":0.00573276},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰属当代经验入诗，取象精切：聚粟、浮沤写千城灯火生动传神，通篇氛围统一。中二联皆铺陈俯瞰之景，层次欠开合；结句直抒孤怀，收束偏直白，余味有限。语言锤炼尚可，铁翼、宿火见巧，红尘、银河稍熟。","_cost":0.00358364},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.3,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.2,"章法":6.8,"余味":5.6,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.49999999999999,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰视角新，灯火星河之喻统一；中二联略同层推进，结句说破孤怀，余味稍浅。","_cost":0.011148},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":56.25,"rationale":"夜航入律，取景统一，'倒泻银河''浮沤'二喻有生机；然情志止于'孤怀'口号，中二联皆俯瞰而意重，结句直说'孤怀远游'无留白，'如''若'重出，'红尘''远游'等成套语。","_cost":0.02710635},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.3,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.8,"rationale":"铁翼俯瞰机窗意象统一，颔联动词精切有光色感；中二联同质铺景少层次递进，尾联直抒孤怀，收束平实余味不足。","_cost":0.0082275},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.6,"rationale":"以铁翼夜航俯瞰入律，中二联巨细相形，'千城泛彩若浮沤'等取象鲜明；尾联直抒孤怀远游，余味稍欠，间有极目、红尘等套语，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.028922308},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"此作写夜航俯瞰之景，脉络畅达，炼字稳顺，灯海喻银河一联颇具画面感；但情思、喻象多沿传统登临旧径，结句直白少余韵，无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"灯火银河取象有气魄，然颔颈同义反复转接平直，尾联孤怀远游直抒兜底，落入凭高感小常套。","_cost":0.01377105},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰以灯火、银河铺展宏阔，再以聚粟、浮沤引向人生感怀，脉络清楚。中二联略有复意，“悬窗”“寰洲”欠自然；结句直陈孤怀，情感未落具体，余味偏薄。","_cost":0.03942},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"夜航俯视有统一氛围，铁翼、宿火、浮沤见当代经验。情志仍是孤怀远游熟题，不够具体。中二联同写灯火微茫，转结平直。结句点明孤怀，说破而少余味。银河倒泻、红尘等偏套。","_cost":0.0351072},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰属当代经验入诗。'倒泻银河'以星河喻城市灯火,颇见巧思。颈联'聚粟''浮沤'暗寓渺小与无常,可惜点到即止。中二联都写下界灯火,句法均为比喻,层次推进不足。'寰洲'略显生凑。结句'红尘''孤怀''远游'较套,余味浅。","_cost":0.0204},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰的灯火城彩有画面，“千城泛彩若浮沤”亦见俯视之感；中二联视角略重复，“寰洲”“宿火”稍滞，末句直陈孤怀，余味偏浅。","_cost":0.011414}},"consensus":65.02,"final":65.02},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|机场送别|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"长廊引睇明窗阔，铁翼排风卷白尘。万里关河归一瞬，微温未散已无人。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.6,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.2,"rationale":"以机场瞬别写距离骤然拉开，主脑集中；末二句时空与余温相映，转结有力。首句略涩，“白尘”稍含混，部分语汇偏熟。","_cost":0.005478},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"送别熟题以航空时代经验翻新，'万里归一瞬'之速与'微温未散'之情形成张力，焦点集中。结句以细节留白，言尽意不尽，可摘为警句。'铁翼排风'取象切当，惟'引睇'稍见生硬，起句略平。章法起承转合完整，转结有力。","_cost":0.04214},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"以现代机场入诗，前二句实写长廊铁翼，第三句宕开写空间瞬缩，结句以「微温未散」对「已无人」，速度与体温对照，转结得力。惟「引睇」略拗、「卷白尘」于机场稍失实，「万里关河」为熟语。","_cost":0.05691},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"当代经验入诗的佳作。前两句刻画机场空间与飞机起飞的现代场景，转结以空间之阔与速度之快，反衬“微温未散已无人”的失落感。起承转合流畅，意象精准，留白深远，极具感染力。","_cost":0.016904},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"机场送别翻熟题，一瞬对照关河、微温落情具体。取象场景妥帖却与传统语并存未浑融。语言通顺，「微温未散」见锤炼。起承转合分明，结句空寂有余味。「万里关河」稍陈，无硬伤袭用。","_cost":0.023066},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"现代机场送别，以“微温未散已无人”收束，情感具体有张力。转结得力，章法完整。“铁翼卷白尘”画面稍隔，“引睇”略古奥，但整体意象统一，当代经验入诗有效。","_cost":0.00385374},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"送别熟题以机场现境翻新，铁翼、长廊皆现代经验入诗自然妥帖。结句以体温写离思，微温未散而人已远，物感真切，言尽意不尽，是全篇诗眼。起承转合一气贯注，唯引睇稍见雕琢，卷白尘略欠精切。","_cost":0.00256204},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.6,"警句":3.4,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.35000000000001,"rationale":"机场送别有现代经验，铁翼、明窗与万里关河相映；转结以速度对照余温，颇见情致。惟首句稍平，‘引睇’略涩，白尘、关河稍熟，未臻浑成。","_cost":0.012656},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"送别熟题翻出新境:以飞行之速('万里关河归一瞬')反衬余温尚存人已杳,情感焦点集中、事象具体。意象围绕机场场景统一,'铁翼''白尘'尚切而略平;'引睇'稍生硬。起承转合干净,结句'微温未散已无人'以触觉收视觉,留白有力,是警句所在。当代经验入诗自然不隔,唯'关河''万里'语稍熟。","_cost":0.0133116},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.3,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.35,"rationale":"以航空一瞬压缩万里与掌心微温对举，化旧别为现代经验，转结由阔景收至触觉，留白深长；首句引睇略拙。","_cost":0.00897175},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.0,"rationale":"起承写机场场景，转以万里关河归一瞬压缩时空，结句微温未散已无人以触觉写骤别，余味深长；当代经验入诗，语淡情浓。立意新、意象稍平，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.025608814},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.5,"rationale":"此作写当代机场送别，抓住速度与情感滞留的反差出新，章法流畅，炼字精准，结句有余味；唯“万里关河”稍泛，意象未臻极致，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"以微温对已无人聚焦离散瞬间，立意具体；前三句取象偏泛散，转折稍跳，结句触觉收束留白最佳。","_cost":0.01079655},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.6,"rationale":"以航程之速反衬别情未冷，末句“微温”使离情具体可感，留有余韵。前两句略显铺陈，“卷白尘”取象欠精，“万里关河”稍熟；转结由宏阔入细微，收束有力。","_cost":0.03404},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"「微温未散已无人」体感具体，余味最佳，可独立成句。转结清楚而起势不足，「引睇」「白尘」欠稳，意象未浑。机场入诗有新意，离情结构仍常见，「万里关河」略套。","_cost":0.0370112},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"以航空之速翻转古典送别的迁延,'万里归一瞬'与'微温未散'形成时空与体感的对照,立意有新意。结句借触觉余温写人去,留白有味。'铁翼'略熟,机场'白尘'稍欠贴切。前两句铺景偏平,转结见力。","_cost":0.019984},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"由明窗远望收至微温犹存，远近转换有力，末句不说破所留之物，余味较足。“引睇”“白尘”稍显生硬，“万里关河”略熟。","_cost":0.008028}},"consensus":80.33,"final":80.33},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"截断云根别故川，青囊倒挂滴甘泉。微针缓透千丝脉，强绽新芽媚市天。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.1,"意境":7.8,"语言":6.6,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.9,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.35,"rationale":"以树木输液写城市移植之痛，取材新颖，四句脉络完整。“强绽”含反讽，主脑鲜明；但“云根”“千丝脉”“媚市天”稍显硬饰，结句寓意较露。","_cost":0.006446},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"咏城市移栽树挂吊瓶,当代经验入诗,角度新而有讽意。'截断云根'起势沉痛,'青囊''微针'切物精当,一气贯注。结句'强绽''媚'字为诗眼,点出被迫粉饰之悲,惜议论稍露、意思说破,余味略减。","_cost":0.03602},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"取当代街树输液入诗，青囊、微针双关医事贴切，末句“强”“媚”二字含讥刺，立意有指向。惟四句顺叙一线，转折欠力，结句意旨稍直，余味中平。","_cost":0.05024},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"题材极佳，将城市“树挂吊瓶”巧妙入诗。“青囊”借代双关，“强绽”“媚”二字尽显草木被迫点缀市井的无奈。当代经验无缝融入传统诗境，立意深刻，炼字精准。","_cost":0.020706},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"城树吊瓶写移植强制萌发以媚城，当代入诗有新意且题旨具体。医树意象可通，语言偶炼。章法线性少变，结句点破用意，余味弱。","_cost":0.02111},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"移栽树挂吊瓶的当代城市经验入诗，拟人同情与反讽统一。意象切题，转结有力，但结句‘媚市天’略露，余味稍减。","_cost":0.003536368},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.75,"rationale":"以移栽行道树挂营养吊瓶入诗,取材独到,讽喻城市化截断自然之意贯穿全篇。'截断云根''微针缓透千丝脉'物象与情意交融,'强绽''媚'二字见诗眼,结句讽而不露,余味存焉。脉络起承转合完整,以树拟人手法新颖,当代经验入诗有效。","_cost":0.0034944},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.1,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.7,"余味":6.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.55,"rationale":"城市树挂吊瓶题材新，青囊、微针与树脉相融，见当代经验；起承转合清晰，强绽媚市天有讽而稍直，余味略减。","_cost":0.009258},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"街树输液题材翻出新境,青囊喻吊瓶、微针透丝脉,象意交融;结句'媚市天'含讽,言外有余。惟'云根'本指山石,用于树根可疑;二三句同写输液稍叠意,章法语言略抑。","_cost":0.0298509},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":6.3,"余味":5.4,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"以输液写行道树切入当代城市生态，视角新颖带讽意；青囊、千丝脉取象精切，前三句有层次，末句媚市天说破批判，余味稍直。","_cost":0.00903325},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"街树挂吊瓶题材新颖，以古典语汇写现代经验；意象精警统一，强绽与媚见诗眼。章法完整而转稍平，结句点破略直，余味稍欠。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.029876013},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"此诗选取行道树挂吊瓶的当代题材，讽喻人工造景的刻意，意象切题，炼字精当，章法顺贯；唯结句偏直白，余味稍弱，新事物入诗妥帖。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"以行道树吊瓶为题材新颖，强媚暗含讽意；然首句空大，市天生造，意象图解多于交融，转折平直，末句议论说破无留白。","_cost":0.01139355},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"以街树输液写移栽之痛，题材具体，物象围绕主脑；“强”“媚”揭出被迫逢迎之意，但“市天”稍显生硬，中段推进有限，结句讽意说得偏透。","_cost":0.04073},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"以街树挂吊瓶写移栽催活,焦点明确,吊瓶与树脉相生,青囊、微针较精。承转同写施注,转折平直;结句强、媚说破讽意,余味不足。无误典与蹈袭。","_cost":0.0277328},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"以大树移栽挂吊瓶入诗，借当代城市景观讽刺揠苗式绿化，角度新。青囊借医家语颇巧，强、媚二字点睛。第三句仍是铺叙，转折不足。结句褒贬说破，余味有限。云根本指山石，借指树根稍隔。","_cost":0.015296},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"以街树吊瓶写移植之痛与城市装点之需，角度新鲜；从离土到输液、发芽，脉络清楚。“微针缓透千丝脉”细切，但“媚市天”稍显生硬，结句点意略直。","_cost":0.008206}},"consensus":76.0,"final":76.0},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|深夜视频|七律","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"冷镜腾辉破夜幽，天涯倩影掌中浮。频传软语如当面，漫触晶屏始觉愁。各报平安宽别绪，相看倦色慰双眸。重逢许罢微光敛，满室清寒月上楼。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.8,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.60000000000001,"rationale":"以视频通话写远别，触屏顿生隔膜，情事具体。明暗冷暖贯穿，转结自然；尾联由微光敛至月上楼，余韵较佳。惟“倩影、别绪、双眸”等稍熟，“重逢许罢”略显硬涩。","_cost":0.006498},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"当代视频通话入律，题材有新意且脉络完整：由屏启至光敛，收以'满室清寒月上楼'以景结情，余味较佳。'漫触晶屏始觉愁'触屏生愁一转可取。惜'倩影''别绪''双眸'等语落套，'相看倦色慰双眸'意复字冗，中二联开合平直。","_cost":0.03841},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"以视频通话写离情，当代经验入诗颇具体，「漫触晶屏始觉愁」由亲切转生隔膜是转折佳处。中二联意近略平，皆言互慰，层次未开；「倩影」「双眸」「别绪」稍陈。结句微光敛而月上楼，以景收情，余味尚存。","_cost":0.04623},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"本诗将当代经验“视频通话”有效入诗，立意真挚，焦点集中。“冷镜”“晶屏”等词融入古典语境自然。章法严密，结句挂断视频转入“满室清寒月上楼”，以景结情，余味悠长。","_cost":0.015732},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"视频入诗情事具体（触屏倦色），离愁熟题未翻新。屏辉月寒对照成境，语言通顺偶炼（始觉愁），中联平铺少层次，结以月色留白。陈词如天涯倩影别绪稍密。","_cost":0.02416},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"写视频通话亲近与触不可及并存，情事具体；尾联以景结情余味最佳。中二联开合稍平，'慰双眸'等语略熟，镜、屏取象稍复。无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":0.01943436},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.0,"rationale":"视频通话入旧体而情事真切，掌中浮影、触屏觉愁皆当代经验与古典语汇相融。中二联稍平列微重复，结句屏幕光敛、清寒月上以景结情，宕开有余韵。个别措辞如'腾辉'略饰，'天涯倩影'稍熟。","_cost":0.0036076},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.7,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.6,"余味":8.1,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.60000000000001,"rationale":"写深夜视频，当代情境入诗，掌中浮、月上楼有画面。情感具体而脉络清，但语多熟套，晶屏等词略硬，中二联稍平。结以清寒月色，余味较好。","_cost":0.011484},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":67.0,"rationale":"以深夜视频入律，情事具体，报平安、许重逢主线清楚，结以月上楼之景收，余味尚可；惟颈联平直，“冷镜”“晶屏”杂沓，“倩影”“天涯”稍熟，炼字未精。","_cost":0.02170845},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.2,"章法":6.3,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.050000000000004,"rationale":"当代视频入诗以虚暖衬实寒，尾联以景结情余味佳，然中二联意复语平少诗眼，立意未超常见离愁。","_cost":0.00875975},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"以深夜视频写别情，现代经验入律而情事具体；颔联触屏始觉愁、尾联微光敛后月上楼，以景结情有余味。中二联稍平，语言间有软语倩影等陈语。","_cost":0.026390461},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.5,"rationale":"此作取当代深夜视频通话场景写异地相思，情事真切，章法连贯，结句以景结情余味悠长，语言妥帖有亮点，自然融入当代经验，仅少量传统意象稍熟。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.2,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.05,"rationale":"触屏始觉愁点破虚拟近而实远，敛微光转清寒月以景结情；中两联语白同层，倩影别绪等意象较熟。","_cost":0.01292475},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.3,"rationale":"触屏生愁写出可见不可及，报安、倦色使离情具体；由如当面转入屏息人远，层次清楚，结以清寒留有余味。“重逢许罢”稍涩，“天涯倩影”“月上楼”等偏熟。","_cost":0.03889},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"情事具体而旧题未翻新境。冷镜、掌中与月色对举成境,中段直陈愁慰,套语与白话夹杂。按时序贯通,颈联两句同义稍平。结句清寒月上未说破,余味最好。视频经验入诗有效,佳句可摘而未成警句。","_cost":0.0362112},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"以视频通话写异地相思,当代经验入诗较自然。'漫触晶屏始觉愁'以触屏之实写咫尺天涯之虚,颇见新意。颈联稍平,'慰双眸'略凑。结句写屏暗、室寒、月升,以景结情,余味尚可,惟'月上楼'较熟。","_cost":0.016212},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"触屏而觉愁，写出视频相见却不能相近的落差；由通话写至屏暗，脉络清楚，结句留有清寒余意。中二联稍显直白，天涯、倩影、月上楼等语较熟。","_cost":0.008208}},"consensus":72.77,"final":72.77},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|社区食堂|七律","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"闹市深居欣有托，晨炊分饷惠邻翁。香浮菜甲蒸偏软，味入汤羹煮更融。白发相呼移短策，青衿互让集堂中。休夸五鼎钟鸣贵，一饱何妨化大同。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.3,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.7,"余味":4.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.55,"rationale":"社区养老入诗，题材新切，白发短策颇具体。中二联层次清楚；“分饷”“青衿”稍隔，蒸软煮融近直陈。结句拔高至“大同”，说理过满，余味受损。","_cost":0.006234},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"以当代社区食堂入律,题材新鲜可嘉。中二联'白发相呼''青衿互让'具画面感,层次尚清。惟颔联炼字平平,'蒸偏软''煮更融'近凑对。尾联'化大同'说破题旨,落入颂扬套路,余味索然,'五鼎钟鸣'亦属陈语。","_cost":0.0355},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.75,"rationale":"当代题材入律有心，中二联菜羹、白发青衿写实妥帖但平铺，“偏软”“更融”凑字，“青衿”与社区食堂语境略隔。尾联以钟鼎对比翻出“大同”，说破兜底，口号感强，余味不足。","_cost":0.04587},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"立意关注民生，颔联“蒸偏软”“煮更融”具生活气息且契合老人受众，描写细腻。中二联由物及人，章法稳当。但尾联“化大同”直白拔高，说尽无留白。当代经验有效入诗，整体平实温馨。","_cost":0.01601},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.5,"rationale":"当代食堂惠老有主脑、场景尚具体；意象常见、颔联平叙乏炼，结句“化大同”说破无余味，语言通顺无诗眼。","_cost":0.020906},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.5,"rationale":"以日常食堂见社会大同，情真象洽；炼字精当，章法井然；尾联议论稍露，但余味仍存。","_cost":0.00464508},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"社区食堂入七律，以日常烟火翻'五鼎钟鸣'之典，收束'大同'有主脑，当代经验有效入诗。中二联一写食一写人，层次稍平，颔联两句意近。结句议论说尽、直白点题，余味有限。'青衿''大同'略熟，整体炼字稳妥自然。","_cost":0.00262884},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.3,"意境":6.6,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.2,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗有当代烟火气，饭菜、老少场景具体，脉络清楚；但意象稍泛，尾联直说大同，收束少余味。","_cost":0.011096},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"养老助餐新题入七律，由食及人及义，层次清楚，尾联翻至平等大同稍有气象；然颂体情志偏公共、少个人深挚，香浮味入有生活气息而后半转议论稍干，结句说尽少留白。“休夸五鼎”一联可摘，题材出新可奖，无整句蹈袭，熟典密度不高。","_cost":0.0155661},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.3,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25000000000001,"rationale":"社区食堂题材切近当下，颔颈分咏饮食与老幼相让，结构完整而转折平直；语言平实少诗眼，尾联直议大同，余味不足。","_cost":0.0102425},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"社区食堂写养老，题旨明、场景实；中二联由物及人，章法完整而转折平。意象常见，语文白夹杂，少佳句；尾联直说大同，言尽意尽。当代题材略有新意，用典无误，间有陈语。","_cost":0.035695358},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"此作咏当代社区食堂，题旨明确、脉络顺畅，饭菜场景描写较贴切，但转折平直，结句直白说尽，部分语象偏熟套，新意有限，无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.8,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.6,"rationale":"取材社区食堂、蒸软煮融体贴老人较真切，中二联分写食与人层次清，然尾联直揭大同说破少留白。","_cost":0.0104013},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"软食、短策切合助老情境，由饭菜到人物，层次清楚；“煮更融”语意偏虚。社区题材有现实感，尾联以富贵作反衬尚稳，结句径升“大同”，拔高说尽，余味不足。","_cost":0.03867},"grok-4.7":{"立意":4.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.25,"rationale":"社区食堂入律有当代感，惠老场景具体，但收束拔向大同，近口号而情未深。菜甲、短策差可成象，汤羹联虚。字面软平，不见诗眼。章法完整而中二联平列，转折无力。结句说尽，无余味。","_cost":0.03572},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"以社区食堂写当代养老，题材切近。颔联“蒸偏软”“煮更融”暗合老人齿牙，颇见体贴，但语近白描，锤炼不足。颈联老少相让，温情可感。尾联用钟鸣鼎食作反衬，归于“大同”，议论拔高而说破，余味较弱。结构完整，转折平直。","_cost":0.017228},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.75,"rationale":"由饭菜写到邻里互让，层次清楚，蒸软菜蔬也照应长者；但“蒸偏软”“煮更融”近于复沓，结句以“大同”拔高说尽，余味不足。","_cost":0.008154}},"consensus":61.83,"final":61.83},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"华陌春深见病姿，悬囊倒注藉人医。泉通细脉穿皴骨，露滴残躯续老枝。远别烟峦消野性，空怜市井汲灵滋。凭君莫贺新阴合，终觉天机向此迟。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.8,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.6,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶写城市移植对自然生命的损耗，主脑鲜明。颔联物我交融，转结有力；“汲灵滋”稍显生硬，末句略偏议论。","_cost":0.006292},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"以城市行道树输液这一当代物事入诗，题材新而聚焦于'消野性'之慨，立意有独到发现。颔联体物精细，'穿皴骨''续老枝'炼字见功；颈联宕开写远别山野，开合有层次。惟尾联以议论说破'天机迟'，余味稍减，'汲灵滋'微觉凑韵。","_cost":0.04072},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"以街树吊瓶入诗，当代物象有效转化，以病体喻移植古树、野性消磨，主脑集中。中二联以医象承、以远别转，层次清晰。“穿皴骨”炼字见力，“灵滋”稍生造；结句寄慨于“天机迟”，有省思但略偏议论，余味中上。","_cost":0.05139},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"本诗将“树挂吊瓶”这一当代现象无痕融入律诗，反思人工与自然天机的关系，立意独到。中间两联刻画精切、章法脉络贯通。唯结句直白说理，略有说破之嫌，余味稍减。","_cost":0.017666},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"街树吊瓶写都市伤自然，情志具体有主脑而角度不新。医树意象尚切，语言通达少诗眼。章法完整转平，结句点破余味弱。颔联稍可摘。当代事象入诗有效，略套语无硬伤袭用。","_cost":0.016692},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.0,"rationale":"写城市树挂吊瓶，立意独到，反思人工养护与野性消磨。意象精切，中二联开合分明。结句以理收束，留慨不尽。语言精炼，唯个别词语稍沿古意。","_cost":0.0076532016},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"以城市行道树挂吊瓶为题，立意新颖真切，暗喻野性驯化与人工续命，翻熟题出新境。颔联'泉通细脉穿皴骨，露滴残躯续老枝'以医道写树，意象精切。'藉人医''汲灵滋'稍显生硬凑韵。颈联转出别离烟峦一层，尾联'莫贺新阴'宕开劝诫，收束有余意但'天机向此迟'略近说破。","_cost":0.003765},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"以街树输液入诗，体物细而寄慨深。颔联精切，颈联由山林入市井，脉络清晰。惜结句稍直，抽象词略多。","_cost":0.01582},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"题旨聚焦市树输液之当代经验，借“别烟峦入市井”反思人工续命与自然天机，主脑清晰、角度较新。意象统一，颔联“泉通细脉穿皴骨”锤炼见警。颈联开合得法；结句“天机向此迟”略嫌说破，余味受损。","_cost":0.0269154},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.9,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.4,"余味":5.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.95,"rationale":"吊瓶入诗具当代发现，病姿—天机一线收束；医象与枯树交融有氛围，转合由形入理层次清，末联直断天机少留白。","_cost":0.0109075},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"街树挂吊瓶之当代经验入律，立意翻新，聚焦人工续命与天机迟滞；意象统一，颔联警策，然“皴骨”“灵滋”稍硬、语言未纯；章法完整而结句直白，余味短。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.029734301},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.0,"rationale":"此诗取当代行道树挂吊瓶题材，反思违逆天性的人为干预，立意有新见，意象切题，炼字稳当，章法连贯，结句有余思，略有熟语，无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"吊瓶写病树视角新颖主脑集中；颔联细脉穿皴骨精切，颈后偏议论，结句直断天机少留白。","_cost":0.01211605},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶反思都市生境，题旨集中，切口较新；“细脉”“皴骨”形象可感。由病树推向野性消磨，层次清楚；但部分措辞雕琢，结句“天机向此迟”抽象滞涩，议论收束削弱余味。","_cost":0.04976},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"前四句以悬囊、细脉、皴骨把街树吊瓶写实且交融,是全篇骨力。立意焦点清楚,但人工非自然之慨偏常。后半烟峦、灵滋、凭君莫贺入议论,颈联意复,结句说破,天机向此迟余味有限。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0377968},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"以街树挂吊瓶这一当代景象入诗，颈联点出移栽失野性，批判有所指，立意较新。颔联以泉露喻输液，贴切但略显板实。“汲灵滋”稍嫌硬凑。尾联议论收束，有反讽意味，但近于说破，余味一般。","_cost":0.016596},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"以街树挂吊瓶写都市与自然的失衡，细脉、皴骨取象贴切；“藉人医”“汲灵滋”稍显硬涩，结句落入议论，余味有限。","_cost":0.011502}},"consensus":75.8,"final":75.8},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"叠架排霄积万箱，飞芒迅扫动星光。输轮默运分流去，散作春风遍远疆。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.1,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.45,"rationale":"以夜间智能仓储入诗，题材新鲜，光、架、输送线构成动景，脉络清楚。“输轮”略显生硬，结句以春风喻物流惠远，稳妥但稍泛且说意较尽。","_cost":0.00525},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.75,"rationale":"以电商云仓夜间扫码分拣入诗，题材新颖，当代经验入诗有效。'飞芒迅扫动星光'将扫码光与星光交融，颇见巧思。惜结句'春风遍远疆'落入颂体套语，说破而少余味；全篇线性铺陈，转折平直，未见更深情志。","_cost":0.04027},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫入诗，题材新，前两句取象尚切，'飞芒迅扫动星光'稍有光彩。但全篇止于场景铺叙与颂扬，无人事情志作主脑；转句平直，结句'春风遍远疆'落入套语式升华，说尽无余。","_cost":0.04969},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"本诗将云仓物流经验有效入诗，'叠架排霄''飞芒迅扫'精准描绘高架与扫码作业，极具画面感。结构依流程推进，脉络清晰。然结句'散作春风遍远疆'略显陈套直白，余味不足。整体题材新颖，语言自然。","_cost":0.02081},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"题写云数据夜运，过程具体有主脑，然情近颂少深挚。意象拼合仓库星光轮运春风，氛围未浑。语言通顺，‘飞芒迅扫’稍亮。章法流程平铺转折弱。结句直陈远播，余味不足。题材算出新，春风远疆略套。","_cost":0.030758},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"咏现代物流题材，取象精切，起承转合清晰。‘飞芒迅扫动星光’见新意；然结句‘春风远疆’略近套语，余味稍平。","_cost":0.00381876},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"以智能云仓夜班分拣入诗，当代经验有效转化为诗境，主脑清晰。起承转合完整：由静态叠架到光扫、分流，再宕开为春风远疆，脉络贯注。结句以景结情，言尽意延。'飞芒''输轮'炼字见巧，稍带机巧痕迹；'星光''春风'取象略熟。","_cost":0.00278064},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.1,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.3,"警句":2.2,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.05,"rationale":"写云仓夜扫，题材新颖，飞芒星光有画面；转结顺畅，但春风远疆稍显颂套，情志未深。","_cost":0.009896},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.3,"意境":6.6,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.05,"rationale":"仓运意象较新，扫描、输送层层推进且耦合尚紧；但结句“春风遍远疆”略落颂体熟套，情感厚度与余味有限。","_cost":0.0274911},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.4,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.4,"rationale":"当代云仓入诗由静及动及散，章法递进贯通，飞芒默运有光感对比；然春风遍疆近套语，颂扬有余而情味与余韵稍薄。","_cost":0.01148175},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.25,"rationale":"取象融现代仓储于星光春风，立意集中而情志稍浅；‘动星光’‘散作春风’有亮点，然‘输轮’‘分流’稍硬；章法完整而转折平直，结语直白少留白。当代经验入诗加2分，陈滥扣0.5。","_cost":0.026373778},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"此诗咏当代云仓夜间分拣劳作，章法顺畅，新事物入诗自然，“飞芒迅扫动星光”颇具巧思；唯结句稍直，春风意象略熟，无硬伤及蹈袭问题。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.0,"rationale":"取自动化云仓夜作业有时代感，但情志止于颂扬空泛；飞芒星光春风拼贴未融，结句说破口号化无留白。","_cost":0.0122993},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"以夜间仓储分拣入诗，当代经验转化初见成效；扫描光与星光相映，由仓内推向远方，脉络清楚。“输轮”略显生硬，结句以“春风”“远疆”泛化赞颂，余味偏薄。","_cost":0.0408},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"夜写云仓分拣,星芒输轮取象较新,当代经验入诗成立。情志止于颂流通之利,欠具体情事。前两句并写场景,第三句沿工序顺下,转势不足。结以春风遍疆,喻意说尽,余味偏薄。语言清整,锤炼未深。","_cost":0.0183008},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":53.25,"rationale":"以诗写物流云仓夜间分拣，当代经验入诗，是出新之处。“飞芒迅扫动星光”一句较有光感。第三句仍在铺叙运转，转得平直。结句“散作春风”化用李白“散入春风满洛城”，情意偏颂扬，收束稳当但较直白，余味有限。","_cost":0.017016},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.25,"rationale":"以夜间云仓入诗，扫描光影颇有现场感；由货架写到分流，脉络清楚。但“输轮”稍涩，结句以“春风遍远疆”概括物流惠及远方，落入套语，余味偏弱。","_cost":0.00812}},"consensus":67.95,"final":67.95},{"key":"gemini-3.8-flash|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"gemini-3.8-flash","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"巨厦排云通列宿，缃函叠递若川流。朱芒疾扫连环检，铁臂齐分万里邮。网脉潜回循法则，遐途指顾不劳筹。封缄尽带平安意，晓发征车遍九州。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.6,"余味":5.8,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.55,"rationale":"以朱芒、铁臂、网脉写智能仓储，古语摄取当代经验，主线清楚。中二联有动势，但“缃函叠递”“网脉潜回”稍涩；结句稳而直，九州等语略熟。","_cost":0.006642},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"以自动化云仓入律，题材出新，'朱芒疾扫''铁臂齐分'将当代物流化入旧体，颇见巧思。然中二联偏于铺陈罗列，'循法则'近于干说，情志停留在礼赞层面。尾联'平安意''遍九州'套语收束，意尽言中，余味不足。","_cost":0.04461},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"以旧体写智能仓储物流，选题新颖，颔联“朱芒疾扫”“铁臂齐分”写物精切。但全篇纯作场景铺陈，中二联并列无开合，缺情志主脑；尾联“平安意”“遍九州”落入颂体套语，结句宏大而说尽，余味有限。","_cost":0.05878},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"本诗巧妙将现代物流云仓与自动分拣技术入诗，立意新颖。“朱芒”“铁臂”等意象转化贴切，颔联描摹生动，章法层次分明。然“循法则”略带术语感，尾联收束虽有人情味但偏直白，余味稍欠。","_cost":0.020062},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"物流夜仓入律有当代感，中二联扫描分拣稍具体；然排云川流万里九州等套语密度高，结句点破平安意而直白，余味弱。","_cost":0.024844},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.75,"rationale":"题旨明确但近颂体，情感泛化；意象现代与套语夹杂，偏说明。中二联偶有力度，然“潜回”等炼字生硬。结构完整而转折平直，结句说破平安意，余味不足。","_cost":0.01468236},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"以古典语汇写自动化云仓夜扫，题材新而主脑清晰，脉络由巨厦—机杼—法则—封缄层层推进，章法完整。缃函若川流、朱芒铁臂对仗见炼字功夫，属警句。然中二联偏铺陈说明，物象与情意交融不足，结句遍九州稍平直，微有套语。","_cost":0.00314752},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.4,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.4,"rationale":"题写云仓夜扫，现代物流入诗，立意明确且有新意；扫描、铁臂等象较切，然颈联偏抽象说理，语带标语气；章法由景入事再收以晓发，脉络清；结句说尽平安九州，余味稍浅。","_cost":0.01459},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"以现代物流入律，缃函、朱芒、铁臂取象新洁，首联气象阔大；中二联按分拣—调度流程平列，开合不足；循法则文白夹杂，平安意落点稍浅；结以晓发九州宕开有余味；当代经验入诗自然，可嘉出新。","_cost":0.030495},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.3,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.8,"rationale":"云仓入律题材出新，朱芒铁臂炼象可观，章法由厦及检及网及发层递有序；唯颈联偏理语伤意境，尾联直赋遍九州，情志宏阔而欠具体，余味平直。","_cost":0.0094299},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"咏现代云仓物流，脉络清且中二联有层（章法7）；意象罗列未融（意境4），语多文白夹杂（语言4），结句说破直白（余味3），情志稍空（立意5）。当代经验入诗（出新2），朱芒联稍精（警句1）。尾联套话（陈滥1），无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.027555928},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"以七律写当代云仓物流新题材，作业流程清晰，颔联捕捉分拣场景贴切；但情志偏泛未及个体，新旧意象稍隔，转折平直，结句直白少余韵。","_cost":null},"muse-spark-1.3":{"立意":4.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"以智慧仓夜扫流程入律，朱芒铁臂具现场感，脉络贯通；然止于颂扬，套语宏大，结句遍九州直露无留白。","_cost":0.01149725},"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.0,"rationale":"夜扫至晓发脉络清楚，朱芒、铁臂切合云仓场景；“叠递”稍涩，“循法则”偏说明。寄寓平安较泛，末句“遍九州”熟套，余味有限。当代物流经验入诗有新意，尚少警策。","_cost":0.03606},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"云仓夜拣入律，题材有当代感，情志却近颂赞，缺具体人事。朱芒、铁臂取象较精，列宿、川流、九州、征车偏熟。颈联滑入抽象法则，转折不陡。结句「尽带平安意」说破，晓发虽有景而意已尽。可摘惟颔联。","_cost":0.0297408},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.75,"rationale":"以古体写智能物流分拣，当代经验入诗有新意。颔联朱芒、铁臂对仗具象可感。但通篇铺叙流程，情志单薄，夜景氛围缺席。颈联理语板滞，缃函借指包裹略欠妥。结句平安意说破，余味有限。","_cost":0.018272},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"朱芒、铁臂写出夜间分拣的鲜明场景；由夜扫至晓发，脉络清楚。中段稍显抽象，“排云”“万里”“九州”较熟，末句收束直白，余味不足。","_cost":0.008182}},"consensus":58.65,"final":58.65},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|机场送别|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"送君直到候机楼，望断长廊起别愁，巨翼轰鸣离地去，空留远响湿双眸。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.2,"意境":5.6,"语言":4.8,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.2,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"送别主旨明确，机场场景具当代性，叙事脉络完整；但“别愁”“湿双眸”等较直白陈熟，转折偏弱，结句说尽，余韵有限。","_cost":0.004688},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.25,"rationale":"以机场入诗有当代经验,转句'巨翼轰鸣离地去'有声势画面。惜承句'起别愁'干说情语,结句'湿双眸'说破无余,'望断''别愁'均属送别套话。章法完整、脉络顺畅但转结皆平直,整体通顺而少锤炼。","_cost":0.03499},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"机场送别属当代经验入诗，起承转合完整，「巨翼轰鸣」「空留远响」略有现场感。然「别愁」「湿双眸」皆直说套语，结句以泪兜底，情感说破无留白，角度常见，出新有限。","_cost":0.04251},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.0,"rationale":"将机场送别引入诗中具有时代感，结构亦算完整。但通篇语言直白浅露，近乎白话分行，缺乏诗意锤炼；“起别愁”“湿双眸”落入俗套，结句将情绪直白说破，毫无留白余味。","_cost":0.017878},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.2,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.25000000000001,"rationale":"机场送别具时代气息，起承转合脉络顺畅，“巨翼”转得生动；但“起别愁”“湿双眸”用语陈套且情意直接说破，结句余味略显不足。","_cost":0.005085},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.5,"rationale":"机场送别题旨明确却无新见，候机楼巨翼等象实而少情意交融。语言直白夹杂，章法平铺。结句点破泪眼，余味不足。当代场景入诗但未化境。","_cost":0.011748},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"机场送别题材现代，情感具体但角度平常；意象统一，结句以声传情有余味。语言平实，'湿双眸'略有亮点但锤炼不足。章法起承转合清楚。无硬伤与蹈袭，陈套语略多。","_cost":0.00428802},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"机场送别以当代经验入绝句，选题有新意。起承转合完整：送、望、飞去、余响，脉络一气。'望断长廊'、'空留远响'取象贴切，但'起别愁'直说，'湿双眸'近套语，结句收得住而略直白，余味中平。","_cost":0.00288126},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"机场送别场景清楚，起承转合完整，远响收情略有馀味。但别愁、湿双眸较直，语多熟套，现代意象有效而未深掘。","_cost":0.009416},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.0,"rationale":"机场送别题材新而情事具体，轰鸣、远响能成氛围；但“望断”“别愁”“空留”“湿双眸”多熟语，转结平稳，末句余音可取而泪意说破，警策不足。","_cost":0.0092144},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.75,"rationale":"以机场送别写传统离愁，题材稍新而情志常见；意象妥帖但多套语，语言平实缺诗眼，章法完整而转结平直，结句泪湿双眸略直白。“远响湿双眸”微巧，无硬伤蹈袭，陈滥轻。","_cost":0.030840906},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"此作叙机场送别的常规离愁，题旨明确、脉络平顺，引入空港当代场景却未拓新境，意象语言平正少警策，结句直露点破情绪，余味不足，整体偏平熟。","_cost":null}},"consensus":58.82,"final":58.82},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"青衫旧絮满堆箱，绿柜无言守巷芳。老妪携包晨悄放，邻翁整束夜添香。寒衣尽洗重登市，断缕零丝织作裳。莫道微尘皆厚意，仁心远播九州光。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.2,"语言":4.1,"章法":6.2,"余味":2.6,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.8,"陈滥":2.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.95,"rationale":"题材具当代性，捐衣场景具体，层次尚清。然“巷芳”“添香”语意牵强，洗衣登市与拆丝织裳路径混杂；尾联口号化，说理过尽，余味不足。","_cost":0.005998},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":1.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":33.5,"rationale":"取材当代旧衣回收有新意，然全篇流于表扬体。'守巷芳''夜添香'施于旧衣逻辑牵强，'满堆箱'语序生硬。中二联仅平铺流程无开合。尾联'仁心''九州光'口号说破，全无余味，陈滥语连缀。","_cost":0.03446},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":2.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":1.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":30.0,"rationale":"题材取当代旧衣回收箱，颔联老妪邻翁尚有画面。但“巷芳”“添香”为凑韵而生，与回收箱情境相悖；尾联“九州光”直落口号，说尽无余。语言多硬凑，结句最弱。","_cost":0.04498},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":3.5,"意境":3.0,"语言":2.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":27.25,"rationale":"当代题材入诗值得肯定，章法叙事顺畅。但全诗流于白描报道，语言凑韵生硬（“巷芳”“夜添香”悖乎常理）。尾联堕入老干体标语口号，全无诗意留白，意境空泛。","_cost":0.018832},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.2,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.3,"章法":6.2,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.75,"rationale":"取材当代生活，章法顺畅有序。然炼字多处勉强，如“添香”强套旧词；尾联滑入高调口号，说尽无余味，冲淡了生活实感。","_cost":0.00702825},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.5,"rationale":"回收箱写仁心场景尚具体但题旨常见说教；巷芳添香牵强不切，结句口号说尽无余味，语言硬凑欠炼。","_cost":0.017748},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.25,"rationale":"题旨有现实关怀，但落于公益宣传语。中二联叙事完整，炼字直白少诗眼；尾联两语说破，余味不足。套话稍多，无明显警句与硬伤。","_cost":0.00541134},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.0,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱题材当代有效入诗，惜主脑归于歌颂善举，中二联俱写捐衣、功能重复少开合；守巷芳、添香、九州光凑韵生硬；结句说破说尽，直白口号，余味尽失。","_cost":0.0031712},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"题材有生活新点，人物细节可见，但尾联口号化，绿柜、添香等语稍凑，整体意胜于境，结句说破少余味。","_cost":0.01081},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.25,"rationale":"旧衣回收当代题材入七律,题旨明确、颔联老妪邻翁有生活实感,惜立意止于颂善,无更深翻掘。'巷芳''添香'生造凑韵,'莫道微尘皆厚意'语义反成硬伤,尾联'仁心''九州光'口号兜底,说尽无余。","_cost":0.0084994},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.75,"rationale":"写旧衣回收，中二联人物分层尚清，断缕零丝一联稍佳；然起结平弱，尾联直以仁心九州作口号，说尽无余味。用语有守巷芳、夜添香等生硬处，现代题材未脱套路，故各维中等偏下，佳联稍加分，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.029703796},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.75,"rationale":"本诗咏旧衣回收箱，题旨明确但角度平俗，尾联空泛；意象有凑泊违和处，语言通顺偶有硬凑，结构平顺少波澜，结句直白无余味，存逻辑小疵，多陈套，无警句新意。","_cost":null}},"consensus":43.89,"final":43.89},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"街头静立蓄寒箱，袖底余温托旧香。破絮重缝连夜寄，明朝雪化作春光。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.1,"章法":7.3,"余味":6.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.30000000000001,"rationale":"以回收箱寄托旧衣传暖，题材入诗颇新；寒、温、雪、春照应紧密。拟人自然，三句推进稍显跳跃，结句明快但“春光”略熟且说得偏满。","_cost":0.005112},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，当代经验可取，'蓄寒''袖底余温'颇见巧思。惜第三句'重缝连夜寄'与回收流程稍隔，结句'雪化春光'升华直露、落入暖心套话，说破无余，全篇由具体滑向空泛，余味不足。","_cost":0.0399},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.75,"rationale":"取当代旧衣回收入诗，题材新而立意仍是常见暖心公益视角。'蓄寒箱'生硬，'重缝连夜寄'与箱体逻辑稍隔；'雪化春光'套语结尾，说尽无余味。'袖底余温托旧香'一句尚可。","_cost":0.04687},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.5,"rationale":"当代题材入诗值得肯定，但现代事物与古典意境未能融合。“破絮重缝”脱离旧衣回收常识，“蓄寒”造词逻辑生硬。结句“雪化春光”流于口号，缺乏留白，整体存在生造拼凑之弊。","_cost":0.021866},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.2,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.9,"rationale":"当代旧物箱入诗立意温厚。‘蓄寒箱’炼字稍涩，‘破絮连夜寄’与回收机制微隔。转结流畅但结句‘化春光’略落俗套，胜在情思朴实。","_cost":0.00563025},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"回收箱入诗有当代切口，袖底余温可感，起承清楚。转结由重缝直跳雪化春光过露，结句说破；炼字偶亮，春光收束仍熟。","_cost":0.018942},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"主题明确但角度常见；'袖底余温托旧香'有佳句感，结句稍直白；'蓄寒箱'略生硬。","_cost":0.00841104},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱这一当代事物有效入诗，立意翻新，焦点集中。起承转合完整：箱—旧香—重缝寄—雪化春光，脉络一气贯注。结句以景结情，暖意不言自明，余味佳。'蓄寒箱'微有硬凑之嫌，'春光'稍熟，扣语言与陈滥少许。","_cost":0.00393204},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.6,"语言":6.8,"章法":6.8,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.7,"rationale":"题取旧衣回收箱，由寒箱余温转出寄暖之愿，立意较新。‘袖底余温托旧香’有细感；然‘连夜寄’稍跳，结以雪化春光偏直白，余味不足。","_cost":0.007558},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"当代物事入诗，寒温相照，“袖底余温托旧香”较切；结以雪化春光有象。惜善意升华略熟，转句叙事偏硬，炼字与余味未臻警策。","_cost":0.02607},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，视角新，‘袖底余温托旧香’情事具体、诗眼动人；‘蓄寒箱’稍涩，‘连夜寄’略直，结句雪化春光稍熟，余味中等。","_cost":0.021683911},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"此作紧扣旧衣回收箱写凡人善意，主脑明晰，细节含温，章法顺妥；唯意象、结句偏平直，新意稍弱，无硬伤蹈袭，略有熟语。","_cost":null}},"consensus":69.37,"final":69.37},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"钢箱通透铁悬钩，小手攀窗锁定眸。掷下铜钱迎爪落，空拳看偶堕添愁。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.3,"章法":7.2,"余味":4.2,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.15,"rationale":"取材当代且情事具体，攀窗、投币、爪落至失手，脉络清楚。然“锁定眸”“空拳看偶堕”句意稍涩，结句“添愁”直说，留白不足。","_cost":0.005698},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.75,"rationale":"题材取当代游艺入诗有新意，叙事线索清楚。然'锁定眸'生硬，'铜钱'与投币机不合时宜；结句'添愁'直说情绪，说破无余味。全篇止于白描记事，未翻出更深一层意，语言文白夹杂欠锤炼。","_cost":0.04185},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.75,"rationale":"当代题材入绝句有尝试，但仅作流程白描：透视、投币、爪落、偶堕，未见深一层寄托。“锁定眸”生硬夹杂现代词，“铜钱”与游戏币失实，“堕添愁”把情绪说破，结句无留白，全篇少诗眼。","_cost":0.04797},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.0,"rationale":"本作以绝句写“抓娃娃机”，结构完整，将现代体验入诗有出新之趣。但语言稍欠锤炼，“锁定眸”生硬，“掷铜钱”略违和。全诗偏于动作白描，结句“添愁”直白说破，缺乏余味与留白。","_cost":0.014482},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.2,"语言":4.8,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.45,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗，取象真实切题，起承转合脉络顺畅。惟造语偏于平实，“锁定眸”略显生硬，尾句径言“添愁”稍嫌说破，余味欠醇。","_cost":0.00367725},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"抓娃娃入诗情事具体有主脑，然未翻出新境。意象器物直描少交融，语言通达无诗眼。章法线性完整而转合平，结句添愁说破余味薄。出新在当代题材。","_cost":0.021768},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"取现代抓娃娃机入诗，情事具体；后二句平直，结句直说“添愁”少余味。意象真切但炼字平平。","_cost":0.00700194},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"以七绝写抓娃娃机，当代生活入诗有新意，情事具体可感。'小手攀窗锁定眸'传神，但'钢箱通透铁悬钩'稍硬，结句'添愁'直说破，少留白；'铜钱'以古语状今物略隔。整体完整而亮点有限。","_cost":0.00231864},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.3,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.6,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入诗，题材新而场景具体；动作链条清楚，起承转合完整。但“铁悬钩”“锁定眸”稍生硬，结句“添愁”直白，余味不足。","_cost":0.011448},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写可望难即，画面集中且题材新；但“锁定眸”“迎爪落”生硬，“偶堕”含混，结句“添愁”说破，转折平直，余味不足。","_cost":0.009906},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入诗，当代经验有新意；起承转合清晰，叙事完整。然“铜钱”不合现代情境成硬伤，“锁定眸”“迎爪落”文白夹杂稍凑，结句直点“添愁”少含蓄。意象明畅而欠精切，整体中平。","_cost":0.030047255},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"此作写抓娃娃机当代日常，叙事连贯，意象贴题，情志具体；但立意较平，笔法平实少波澜，结句直白点愁余味不足，“铜钱”代今币稍隔，无硬伤陈套。","_cost":null}},"consensus":58.04,"final":58.04},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|机场送别|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"晨輝別友指遙天，候館喧聲促餞筵，過檢提箱含淚眼，憑欄忍痛望雲邊。驚雷掣電離塵去，細雨挑燈伴夜眠，莫問征途何處遇，期君早返話當年。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":4.8,"意境":5.2,"语言":3.8,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.6,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":2.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.300000000000004,"rationale":"机场送别题旨明确，过检、提箱等稍具现场感，但情感表达偏泛。晨景忽转夜眠，视角与时序欠稳；“挑灯伴夜眠”“何处遇”语意牵强。结尾直陈盼归，余味较浅。","_cost":0.006076},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.25,"rationale":"机场入诗有当代经验,颈联以惊雷掣电写飞机升空稍见巧思,得微量出新。然情感表达直白,含泪眼、望云边、话当年皆熟套连缀;语言平实少炼字,无诗眼。章法完整但转折平直,颈联时空跳接稍生硬。结句说尽期盼,兜底无余味。整体属应酬式送别,中下之作。","_cost":0.03914},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.5,"rationale":"熟题常调,情感以含泪、忍痛直陈,缺具体事象。过检提箱等当代细节可取,但惊雷掣电喻起飞夸饰,机场设饯筵、晨辉骤转挑灯夜眠衔接生硬。结句期君早返话当年说尽无余,挑灯、话当年等套语连缀。","_cost":0.05721},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":2.5,"章法":3.5,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":31.0,"rationale":"尝试以现代机场送别入诗，但“过检”与“候馆”杂糅，文白夹杂严重。情感词“含泪眼”“忍痛”直白干瘪，流于套话。结句完全说破，缺乏诗意锤炼与余味。","_cost":0.01493},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":4.8,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.8,"章法":4.3,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.7,"rationale":"虽尝试将过检提箱等当代经验入诗，但词句浅直如顺口溜。晨辉骤转夜眠稍显断脉，飞机起飞状如雷电略显突兀。结联完全说破，套语连缀，余味不足。","_cost":0.00554775},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.5,"rationale":"机场送别熟题无翻新，情具体可感但角度常见。意象现代与古典杂陈欠交融。语言通达偶有亮点却文白夹、无诗眼。章法层次尚清转折平直。结句直说期望说破无留白。餞筵情境稍不合，套语密度偏高。","_cost":0.022134},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.25,"rationale":"主题集中但角度常见；机场现代细节与古典意象混杂，氛围不统一；字词直露少诗眼；结构完整但尾联直白说尽，陈套意象密集。","_cost":0.0065208},"glm-5.3":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.25,"rationale":"机场送别题材有当代性，但情感落点仍是俗套的盼归话旧。通篇泪眼、云边、挑灯、话当年等套语密集；候馆、饯筵为古语硬贴机场，新场景被旧衣裳遮蔽。惊雷掣电喻飞机起飞稍见奇气，惟与细雨挑灯衔接突兀。结句说破盼归，无余味。章法起承转合尚完整。","_cost":0.00523844},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.25,"rationale":"机场送别题旨明确，现代场景略新，但泪眼忍痛等直说过多，意象偏常，结尾期盼说破，余味不足；章法尚整。","_cost":0.01236},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.0,"rationale":"机场送别属熟题新场景,过检提箱情事尚具体,但题旨角度常见。意象堆叠而交融不足,惊雷掣电喻飞机生硬,与细雨夜眠气候逻辑相牴牾。过检、挑灯等语文白夹杂,炼字平平无诗眼。章法起承转合完整,颈联有开合。结句期君早返直说兜底,余味寡淡。无警句,当代经验入诗略有出意,套语少量,未见整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.0144642},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":2.5,"章法":2.5,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":3.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":30.5,"rationale":"晨起送别至颈联突转夜眠，时序断脉；以'离尘'状飞机起飞乃词义误用，机场设餞筵悖常识；'过检提箱'等现代词与'凭栏挑灯'古典象文白夹杂；结句'期君早返'直白兜底，意象多陈滥。","_cost":0.030640839},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.5,"rationale":"此作写机场送别，主旨明确但无新见，多传统送别陈熟意象，语言平顺乏锤炼，结构完整但转折平直，结句稳当却直白少余味，仅“过检”稍涉当代，套语较密，略有场景违和。","_cost":null}},"consensus":43.64,"final":43.64},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"抱土登樓沐曉光，瓜苗菜甲共芬香，朝來雨露滋青蔓，小圃能餐滿院陽。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.1,"意境":6.8,"语言":5.9,"章法":5.8,"余味":6.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.7,"硬伤":0.2,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"屋顶种菜切入日常劳作，抱土登楼具体有生气，诸象明朗统一。二三句意近，转折不足；“瓜苗芬香”稍泛，“餐满院阳”有新意但语意略涩。","_cost":0.00716},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.25,"rationale":"写楼顶种菜的当代生活,'抱土登楼'具体可感,题材有新意。但三句'雨露滋青蔓'与次句意复,无转折;结句'能餐满院阳'措辞生硬,且'满院'与天台自相龃龉,说尽无余味。全篇平铺直叙,炼字乏诗眼。","_cost":0.04204},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":3.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.25,"rationale":"题材当代,“抱土登楼”一细节可感;然后三句皆泛写晓光、雨露、菜香,原地铺陈无转折。“能餐”生硬,“满院”与天台自相矛盾。结句直白说尽,余味寡淡。","_cost":0.04336},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.0,"rationale":"“抱土登楼”将城市天台种菜的当代经验入诗，生活气息浓厚；语言平实，“餐”字略见用心。但第三句转折平直，结句收束稳当却留白不足，整体属生活小品，胜在真挚自然。","_cost":0.01601},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.4,"章法":5.8,"余味":6.3,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.150000000000006,"rationale":"“抱土登楼”切中当代都市田园经验，真切生动。中两句写景平顺妥帖，转折略平直；结句“能餐满院阳”炼意鲜活，收束明亮温暖，富有烟火生趣。","_cost":0.005364},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"写天台菜园晨景，情具体而旨常见无翻新。抱土登楼较切，余象如雨露芬香青蔓套。炼字平，餐阳稍活但整体无诗眼突出。起承尚可转弱，铺叙为主。结句直陈园沐满阳，余味不多。屋顶种菜略出新，陈词有，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.035824},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.05,"rationale":"写城市天台种植有生活趣味，但立意平实。意象清新统一，结句“餐阳”有巧思，炼字局部出彩。转句稍平、时间与起句略有重复；结句以景收束，尚有余韵。无硬伤与蹈袭，雨露青蔓等略陈套。","_cost":0.0062488272},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"写都市天台种菜，题旨明确、情事具体可感，'抱土登楼'见细节真趣。意象围绕小圃统一，四句起承转合完整。'餐滿院陽'欲以食阳收结，意象略生硬欠自然，余味中等。整体清新但属常见田园闲适路数，新意有限。","_cost":0.001558584},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"写天台晨圃，题旨明确，生活气息可感；“小圃能餐满院阳”略有新意。但瓜苗雨露等意象偏熟，三四句推进平直，语言稍欠锤炼，余味未深。","_cost":0.010526},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.75,"rationale":"题材取当代天台耕作，“抱土登樓”有生活质感；然意象多熟，三句犹铺叙，结句“餐陽”求奇反硬，情致止於清新可喜。","_cost":0.0152386},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.5,"rationale":"写天台种菜，题旨明确而开掘浅近；意象常见，情景交融平平；前三句尚通顺，结句“餐”字生硬凑泊；第三句未转，结句直白兜底无余味。无警句，少新意，略显陈熟。","_cost":0.023491302},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.75,"rationale":"此作咏天台菜园晨景，题旨明晰但角度寻常，意象妥帖偏熟未显天台特质，语言平顺偶有巧思，章法顺承无跌宕，结句稍直白少余韵，无硬伤蹈袭，新意不足。","_cost":null}},"consensus":55.81,"final":55.81},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|云端相册|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"云端百态贮留香，拂指频翻见旧妆，笑语当年存片影，天涯不散梦中乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.6,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.4,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.2,"rationale":"以云端相册寄托怀旧乡情，题旨集中且有当代入口。四句多在复述存照追忆，层次稍平；“贮留香”“见旧妆”语意欠贴切，结句以梦乡收束较熟滥直露。","_cost":0.00571},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.5,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗有当代题材之新，惜写法仍循怀旧套路。'留香''天涯''梦中乡'皆熟语连缀，'贮留香'与数码影像意脉不切。转句平直，结句以'梦中乡'兜情稍空泛，余味有限。语言通顺但乏诗眼，出新意识可嘉而炼字未逮。","_cost":0.03178},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.75,"rationale":"以云端相册寄乡愁，取材当代略有新意，但情感处理泛化。「贮留香」「旧妆」「片影」「梦中乡」皆旧套语，「百态」空泛无象。第三句承而不转，结句直说乡梦，说破兜底无余味。整体通顺而乏诗眼。","_cost":0.0402},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.0,"rationale":"本诗以现代科技“云端相册”入诗有出新意识，但通篇缺乏物象营造，意境空泛。章法平铺直叙无波澜，结句直接说破兜底无留白，语言缺乏诗意锤炼，词汇多陈套。","_cost":0.013116},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.2,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.35,"rationale":"切入当代数字生活体验，“拂指频翻”刻画动作生动。惟起承转结偏于平顺，后半首“片影”“梦中乡”等语汇稍显陈熟，结句直抒胸臆，余味稍显不足。","_cost":0.00601575},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.5,"rationale":"云端相册入诗见当代经验，情志仍属常见乡愁未翻新境。留香与数字媒介未融，旧妆梦乡较套。拂指频翻稍活。章法平铺，结句直白点题无宕开。","_cost":0.018912},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.5,"rationale":"以云端相册怀旧，题材有新意但情事泛泛；意象妥帖常见，‘贮留香’略凑；结构完整转结平直，结句直白少余味。无硬伤与蹈袭，套语密度中等。","_cost":0.00744876},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"以云端相册入诗，当代经验有效入诗，立意有新意。'拂指频翻'精准摹写翻屏动作，是诗眼。'贮留香'喻照片略嫌生硬，香与影像无涉。结句'天涯不散梦中乡'收得稳但稍偏直白，'梦中乡''天涯'属常见套语。脉络起承转合完整，情感真挚但角度仍属寻常怀旧。","_cost":0.00267964},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.2,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.2,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.85,"rationale":"云端相册入诗有当代感，怀旧题旨明确；但意象偏虚泛，语多套语，转合平直，结句说破且语义略涩。","_cost":0.008358},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.5,"rationale":"题以云端相册寄怀旧，当代意可取而情景空泛；意象铺排少交融，语言多熟套，转结平直，末句“不散”说破，余韵有限。","_cost":0.01180428},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀旧，题意集中而情致空泛；意象多沿旧调，语言略生硬，章法完整而转弱，结句说破而少余味；略有当代题材之新，然陈语不少。","_cost":0.042797352},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.5,"rationale":"本诗借云端相册抒怀旧思远之情，题旨明确，章法平顺，语言通顺；但意象平熟，抒情空泛，转折平直，结句直白余味弱，仅当代事物入题略有新意，无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":52.64,"final":52.64},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"银梭破雾逐星游，俯瞰寰尘点似舟，望断云涛翻碎影，冰窗客梦接天楼。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.6,"意境":6.1,"语言":5.3,"章法":5.2,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.2,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.550000000000004,"rationale":"夜航视角切题，云海、冰窗与客梦相融，结句略有虚境。全篇推进较平，转折不显；“寰尘点似舟”指涉含混，银梭、星游、云涛等语偏熟。","_cost":0.00551},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.0,"rationale":"以夜航入诗有当代经验，然多用银梭、云涛、客梦等熟套喻象，'寰尘点似舟'比拟稍隔。三句承而不转，脉络平推少变化。结句'客梦接天楼'虚实相接稍存余韵，但全篇观感浮泛，情事不够具体可感。","_cost":0.03579},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.25,"rationale":"夜航题材尚有当代感，但仅止于俯瞰景象描摹，无独到发现。银梭、云涛属飞行诗惯用套象；“寰尘点似舟”凑字生硬，“接天楼”指涉含混。第三句未真转，仍写视象，结句以客梦收束略有留白，却因语意不清而余味打折。","_cost":0.04836},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"本诗将现代夜航经验入诗，起承转合完整。结句“冰窗客梦”虚实结合，具画面感。然“寰尘”“点似舟”造语生硬，炼字欠火候，情感略显单薄空泛，部分词汇略显陈套。","_cost":0.019658},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"有效将现代夜航体验入诗，“冰窗”取象精切。起承转合由宏阔转入幽微，脉络清晰。次句“俯瞰”犯题，炼字尚有琢磨空间。","_cost":0.004839},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰现场感明确，银梭冰窗稍切当代，然客梦虚浮、云涛望断陈熟密度高，转合平直，结句接天楼说破且涩，余味不足。","_cost":0.029074},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"夜航羁旅题旨常见；“寰尘点似舟”生硬，取象未稳；结构完整但转结平直；结句略留白而“天楼”虚泛。语言有“银梭破雾”亮点，然套语较多。","_cost":0.00654786},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"以夜航入绝句，取材当代经验，立意有新意；'寰尘点似舟'化俯瞰灯火为舟，意象尚佳。但'寰尘'生造欠稳，'接天楼'意脉含混，结句梦景稍晦，留白打折；'云涛''客梦'略带陈套，密度不高。","_cost":0.00280684},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.6,"章法":6.2,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.15,"rationale":"夜航视角明确，银梭、冰窗稍见当代感；星云涛客梦偏熟，‘寰尘点似舟’语意生涩，情志较泛。结句略有余味。","_cost":0.00994},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"以银梭喻机、冰窗客梦写夜航，当代经验入诗有出新，结句宕开有余味。惟\"点似舟\"物象含混，云涛、碎影意象偏熟，转句平直，气脉略散。","_cost":0.0089922},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"以银梭喻机写夜航，现代经验入诗；意象统一，结句冰窗客梦接天楼留白有余味。惜情志稍泛、转折略平，语言偶用熟语。","_cost":0.024018179},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"此作写夜航俯瞰触发羁思，结构顺承，用语稳妥，能引入当代飞行场景，但意象多熟常，情志偏泛，转合平直，结句少余韵，无硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":60.52,"final":60.52},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|天台菜园|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"高楼顶上设畦空，抱瓮浇蔬趁晚风，旧桶新箱堆土厚，残砖废瓦叠墙同，晨淋碧蔓分珠露，夕采青茄满眼红，久住喧城无野地，心田菜味乐融融。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.4,"语言":5.1,"章法":6.3,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.1,"硬伤":0.8,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.9,"rationale":"楼顶种菜切入城市生活，旧桶残砖等物象具体，晨夕铺陈有序。惟“设畦空”生硬，“青茄满眼红”语意含混；末联直陈乐意，“心田”“乐融融”稍熟滥，余味不足。","_cost":0.006352},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.25,"rationale":"都市天台种菜题材有当代生活气息,旧桶残砖取象具体。惜炼字粗率:'叠墙同''满眼红'有凑韵之嫌,青茄言红近于失实;中二联铺陈平列少开合。结句'乐融融'说破兜底,套语收场,余味尽失。","_cost":0.03349},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.25,"rationale":"都市天台种菜取材真切，旧桶残砖颈联颇具生活质感，抱瓮用典亦贴。然「设畦空」「叠墙同」凑韵填字，「青茄」而「满眼红」自相矛盾，晚风与晨夕重复，结句「心田」「乐融融」说破兜底，余味殆尽。","_cost":0.06696},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":2.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":36.25,"rationale":"题材具都市烟火气；然语言白话，拼凑感重（设畦空、叠墙同）。物象罗列如流水账，青茄与满眼红色彩矛盾。结句“乐融融”过度直白，全无余味，属粗浅习作。","_cost":0.023538},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.2,"意境":4.8,"语言":4.2,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.6,"rationale":"取材具当代都市生活气息，脉络顺畅。惟颔联凑韵稍显，颈联“青茄”与“满眼红”物色稍抵牾，尾联径直说破且语近老干，余味不足。","_cost":0.0050355},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"屋顶种菜细节具体真挚，题旨明确然城市田园角度常见。意象妥帖日常少深融。语言通顺珠露稍亮而叙多炼少。章法顺承平铺少转。结句点破乐融融说尽无留白。当代经验入诗尚可。","_cost":0.02786},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"主题明确但角度平常；意象实写略杂，“青茄”与“满眼红”色感冲突；语言有“分珠露”佳处，亦有“设畦空”凑词；结构平直少转；结句说破直露。题材略见新意。","_cost":0.00952512},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"都市楼顶种菜属当代经验入诗，立意可取；器物晨夕之象具体有生活气。但\"设畦空\"\"叠墙同\"显系凑韵，\"青茄满眼红\"物色矛盾，结句\"乐融融\"说破兜底、直白无余，通篇语多顺而少锤炼。","_cost":0.00291464},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.099999999999994,"rationale":"题材有当代气息，天台种菜具体可感；中联罗列稍平，语多凑韵，青茄满眼红不稳；结尾直说乐融，余味较弱。","_cost":0.014968},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.25,"rationale":"城市天台种菜题材新鲜切实,生活细节(旧桶新箱、抱瓮浇灌)具体可感,惜语言平白欠锤炼,'叠墙同''满眼红'生硬凑韵,结句'乐融融'直说兜底、无余味;晨夕一联稍有画面但整体意脉平直。","_cost":0.0056784},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"天台种菜，题材具体而立意平常；意象有生活气却常见，情景交融弱。语言通顺，‘分珠露’略亮，然有凑韵硬处。章法完整而转折平；结句直说‘乐融融’，余味薄。无警句；当代经验入诗加1，套语‘珠露’‘乐融融’减1，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.036169373},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.75,"rationale":"本诗写都市天台种菜闲趣，题旨明确、结构平顺、意象贴实，但炼字稍粗，结句直白少余味，无醒目警句，\"青茄满眼红\"略有违和，整体平熟。","_cost":null}},"consensus":52.06,"final":52.06},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"云端俯仰一孤舟，斗转星移瀚海流，远瞰人间灯火密，银河散作万家楼，空濛雾敛城乡静，大野苍茫尽入眸，此夜魂飘天际外，归程梦不醒寒幽。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"fail"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"weak"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.6,"章法":6.3,"余味":4.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.8,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写天地错位，灯火化银河颇见新意，整体氛围统一。前六句铺景稍平，斗转星移、大野苍茫偏熟；“俯仰”“不醒寒幽”语意欠稳，结句幽冷而略涩。","_cost":0.005604},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰属当代经验入诗，'银河散作万家楼'倒转天地颇有巧思为全篇亮点。然中二联皆写俯瞰之景，开合层次不足近于原地铺陈；'斗转星移''苍茫入眸'落套。尾联'寒幽'生造硬凑，结句说而未化，余味寡淡。","_cost":0.03465},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰题材有当代经验，“银河散作万家楼”稍见巧思；然中二联皆写俯视所见，俯仰、远瞰、入眸反复，无开合层次，对仗松散。“斗转星移”“空濛”“苍茫”套语连缀，“梦不醒寒幽”硬凑生涩，结句虚飘无着，余味寡淡。","_cost":0.05467},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.5,"rationale":"夜航题材切入有效，“银河散作万家楼”联想巧妙，画面壮阔。但总体意象略显陈套，章法平直铺叙，缺乏顿挫。结句“梦不醒寒幽”生涩硬凑，削弱余味。","_cost":0.018338},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"夜航经验入诗，“银河散作万家楼”设喻精切有亮色。中二联俯瞰视象略显同义反复，层次欠开合；尾联造句稍滞涩，结势偏弱。","_cost":0.00383775},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"夜航孤寂主题常见无新境。银河散楼稍切，余象多套。语言平实偶拗。中联铺景少层次。结句点破寒幽少宕开。飞行经验入诗略可。","_cost":0.022422},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.8,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰取象偶见亮点，“银河散作万家楼”较有画面，但中二联视角平行，章法缺推进；结句直说归梦寒幽，余味不足；套语如“斗转星移”“大野苍茫”稍密。","_cost":0.0068406624},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验，'银河散作万家楼'化用翻新，是全篇诗眼。惜中二联开合不足，多为罗列景语；'斗转星移''大野苍茫'近套语，'寒幽'生造凑韵，结句晦涩未成宕开，余味受阻。","_cost":0.0061078},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰题旨明确，“银河散作万家楼”化灯火为星河，有新意；但星移、苍茫、魂梦等意象泛熟，情志未落实，章法平铺，结句偏直且“寒幽”稍硬。","_cost":0.009788},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验,'银河散作万家楼'意象精巧,景情交融。然'斗转星移''大野苍茫'皆熟套,中二联铺景无开合,原地打转;'梦不醒寒幽'生硬凑韵,结句含混非留白,情志亦停留于观感层面。","_cost":0.0109212},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.5,"rationale":"题意明确而角度稍常，情志略泛；取象有氛围但多套语，中二联铺陈平、转折弱；'银河散作万家楼'稍见新意；结句直白，余味不足；无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.036125529},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.5,"rationale":"写夜航俯瞰观感，题旨尚明但角度平俗，意象多熟套，唯“银河散作万家楼”略有巧思；语言通顺稍凑泊，结构平直少层次，结句直露脱节少余味，有少量陈语，无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":51.86,"final":51.86},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|云端相册|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"屡换新机旧影空，雏儿巧笑寄虚风，慈亲鹤发藏深箧，晚辈婴孩驻小宫，指上流年删不尽，云端往事阅仍融，宵阑静对灯前泪，破晓长天现彩虹。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.3,"意境":5.4,"语言":4.6,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.2,"警句":2.3,"出新":2.1,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.15,"rationale":"以云端相册寄托亲情流年，题材有当代感，主线清楚。“指上流年删不尽”颇佳；但“寄虚风”“驻小宫”“阅仍融”语意生硬，末句彩虹转暖过熟，余味稍浅。","_cost":0.005516},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写数码时代亲情记忆，题材新而可取，'指上流年删不尽'稍见巧思。然'寄虚风''驻小宫'生造硬凑，颔联雏儿与颈联婴孩取象重复；首句言旧影空又云往事阅仍融，前后龃龉。结句彩虹俗套说破，强行光明兜底，与灯前泪脱节，余味尽失。","_cost":0.0414},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":3.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":37.5,"rationale":"换机丢照、云端存忆为当代经验，立意有新角度但主脑散。“小宫”“阅仍融”生造硬凑，雏儿与婴孩、深箧与云端意象重叠，中二联开合无层次。结句灯前泪转彩虹陈套且突兀，兜底说破，余味尽失。","_cost":0.05557},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.0,"rationale":"题材切入当代经验（云端相册），有尝试之功。但语言生造硬凑严重，如“寄虚风”“驻小宫”“阅仍融”词不达意。结句“现彩虹”转折生硬、强行昂扬，破坏全篇感怀氛围，毫无余味可言。","_cost":0.018178},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.85,"rationale":"数码经验入诗具新鲜感，颈联切题畅达；但颔联“雏儿”与“婴孩”合掌叠见，“小宫”造词勉强；尾联以垂泪见彩虹作结，拔高突兀且流于俗套。","_cost":0.00520575},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.5,"rationale":"以换机云端写亲情影像流年，情事较具体有当代感。然虚风小宫生硬，意象未浑融；灯前泪、彩虹陈套说尽，余味不足。颈联稍见炼意。","_cost":0.019846},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"亲情主题真切但角度平常；意象可感然“虚风”“小宫”生硬未融；“指上流年”见灵光；末联以彩虹收束偏俗套，削弱沉痛余韵。","_cost":0.009571782},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字时代的记忆流散，当代经验入诗有新意。颈联'指上流年删不尽'见诗眼，但'驻小宫''阅仍融'生硬凑韵，雏儿与婴孩意象重复。结句彩虹以景收情却偏俗套直白，全诗情真而炼字未精。","_cost":0.002903544},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":5.6,"语言":6.1,"章法":6.3,"余味":3.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.6,"rationale":"题材入诗有当代生活气息，亲情影像具体；颈联较有警意，但若干词语稍显生造，结尾彩虹过直，削余味。","_cost":0.011606},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.5,"rationale":"云端相册题材当代可喜，'指上流年删不尽'有句。然'驻小宫''寄虚风'物象含混，旧影空与藏箧逻辑微牴牾；中二联平列少开合；结句夜泪骤转彩虹，熟套说尽无余味，鹤发、流年、灯泪、长天彩虹陈象密度偏高。","_cost":0.0224622},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":2.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.0,"rationale":"题旨明而常见，以云端换机写亲情，落夜泪彩虹套。意象杂陈，虚风小宫不精；语言生造硬凑，惟删不尽稍炼。章法完整、层次有开合而转平。结句晓虹陈套，余味浅。当代经验未浑成，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.03859284},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.5,"rationale":"本诗以云端相册寄忆亲之情，题旨明确但情事空泛、角度平常；部分意象凑泊、字词欠稳，结构完整但尾联彩虹突兀，余味不足；“指上流年”稍见巧思，当代元素入诗融合欠佳，无蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":51.74,"final":51.74},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":null,"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"斜阳巷口晚风凉，老幼扶携进食堂。小碗时蔬鲜软烂，人间至味是家常。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.3,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.45,"rationale":"社区养老入诗，情意温厚且细节可感；由巷口、扶携写至餐食，脉络顺畅。“鲜软烂”质实稍板，末句化熟语点题过尽，余味有限。","_cost":0.00611},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":2.0,"score":48.0,"rationale":"取材社区食堂有当代气息,老幼扶携情事可感,故立意尚可。惟三句仅罗列菜品未见转折,结句以议论说破,'人间至味是家常'显系苏轼'人间有味是清欢'句式翻版,新意打折且余味尽失。'鲜软烂'质朴近俚,炼字乏力。","_cost":0.03239},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":2.0,"score":43.25,"rationale":"题材当代、老幼软烂之食细节可感,但情志止于温情表态,角度常见。首句斜阳晚风套语起兴,末句直陈说破,且明显套用苏轼「人间有味是清欢」句式,余味与原创性俱损;「鲜软烂」堆叠稍拗。","_cost":0.04761},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.75,"rationale":"本诗以当代经验“社区食堂”入诗，起承转合规整，画面温馨具体。然语言偏于白话，如“鲜软烂”略欠锤炼；结句“人间至味是家常”直抒胸臆，说理透尽而乏留白余味。整体通顺达意，生活气息浓厚。","_cost":0.017982},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.5,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗具当代感，温情主题明确然角度熟套。意象平实未深融。鲜软烂稍见炼字。起承尚可转结说理。结句点破无余味。","_cost":0.02639},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":59.5,"rationale":"以斜阳晚风衬老幼扶携，意象温馨但常见；末句点出家常至味，有立意而少新境。语言平实，‘鲜软烂’稍散。结句近于说破，余味偏浅。化用苏轼句式，未整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.0178398},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"社区食堂这一当代题材入绝句，立意温暖具体，老幼扶携画面可感。但'人间至味是家常'化自东坡'人间有味是清欢'且近乎流行套语，结句直接说破、议论兜底，余味打折；'鲜软烂'三字并列略显直白，全诗意象妥帖而锤炼不足，转结平直无波澜。","_cost":0.002081844},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.4,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.2,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.8,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.4,"rationale":"以社区食堂写民生温情，取材有当代性；斜阳巷口、老幼扶携颇具画面，但意象偏熟，语言直白，结句说破家常而少余味。","_cost":0.013216},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":2.0,"score":57.5,"rationale":"社区食堂题材入诗有当代性,老幼扶携、小碗时蔬情事具体。但立意止于温情颂扬,角度常见;'斜阳巷口'意象偏熟;结句'人间至味是家常'直说道理、说破兜底,且'人间至味'承袭汪曾祺熟语、暗合东坡'清欢'句意,自得之语不足。","_cost":0.0069198},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.75,"rationale":"以社区食堂写老幼就餐，题意明确、当代细节稍具；然起结多用熟语，意象语言平熟，结句直白说破，余味与炼字一般，陈滥轻。","_cost":0.02177027},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"本诗描摹社区食堂日常烟火，主旨明确真切，意象平实贴题，语言通顺精准，章法起承转合平稳，结句直白稍欠余味，融入当代民生场景，部分表达偏熟。","_cost":null}},"consensus":57.98,"final":57.98},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"深宵两地共霜天，夜视频窥慰未眠，泪眼相逢声渐暖，还将笑语约来年。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.8,"语言":4.6,"章法":6.8,"余味":4.8,"警句":0.8,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"以视频写两地相慰，情事具体且推进清楚；声暖由泪转笑有层次。深宵与夜重复，“视频窥慰”搭配生硬；霜天、泪眼稍熟，结句直说来年，余味偏浅。","_cost":0.004566},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.0,"rationale":"以视频通话写两地相思，当代题材可取但角度平常。次句'视频窥'凑字生硬，文白夹杂。情绪由泪至笑有递进，脉络尚通。结句直白说破，约来年兜底无余味。'霜天''泪眼'略陈套。","_cost":0.03077},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.0,"rationale":"题材取当代视频通话有生活感，但情事泛泛。次句“夜视频窥慰未眠”硬凑，“窥”字失当；三句“泪眼相逢声渐暖”稍有可感处。结句直陈“约来年”说尽无留白，“共霜天”“约来年”俱属熟套。","_cost":0.04084},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":2.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":33.5,"rationale":"题材贴近生活且章法尚算完整。但语言生造痕迹重，“夜视频窥”生硬凑字，破坏语感节奏。全篇多直白叙述而少意象交融，结句和盘托出，缺乏诗意留白与余味，流于老干体。","_cost":0.02397},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.75,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗，情感真切，章法承转顺畅。然次句“夜视频窥”语法生硬杂糅，且与首句叠“夜”字；后半纯以白描直述，结语说破无留白，余韵稍欠。","_cost":0.00419325},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"两地视频慰未眠，情事具体有主脑，然相思熟题角度常见。共霜天尚可，泪眼未眠等象陈套未深交融。窥慰生硬、视频突兀少锤炼。起承转合完整平顺。结句约来年说破无留白。","_cost":0.024566},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"写异地视频相思，情感具体，结构完整；声渐暖有亮点。但立意常见，后半偏直白，第二句表达略硬。","_cost":0.0111804},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.5,"rationale":"以视频通话入七绝，当代经验有效入诗，情事具体真挚，结以“约来年”收得稳。但通篇偏于直陈，“泪眼”“共霜天”意象熟套，物象与情意未交融；首句“深宵”与次句“夜”犯复，“视频窥”之“窥”字生硬凑韵，语言锤炼不足。","_cost":0.00222944},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"题材明确，异地深夜视频之情可感；但取象偏少，直叙多于融景，“夜视频窥”略生，结句温暖却说尽，余味有限。","_cost":0.009574},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.25,"rationale":"视频慰相思属当代经验入诗,情真意切,角度尚可;然'夜视频窥'生硬、深宵/夜/未眠意重字复,霜天泪眼皆熟象;结构完整而转结平直,'约来年'宕开一线稍有余韵但偏直白。","_cost":0.0124812},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":2.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":42.0,"rationale":"写深夜视频通话，题旨清而情致常见；意象唯霜天泪眼，氛围未洽；'夜视频窥'生造硬凑，文白夹杂；章法起承转合完整但转折平；结句直白少余味。警句微弱，陈词稍密，出新不足，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.027568763},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.5,"rationale":"写异地深夜视频慰相思，情感真挚，结构平顺，融入当代经验，但意象常见，“深宵”“夜”重复，“窥”字欠妥，结句偏直白，整体未脱常套，无硬伤。","_cost":null}},"consensus":53.32,"final":53.32},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"春烟淡染衢街柳，槁树悬壶续脉流，细吊瓶输甘露液，明朝翠满密高楼。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.1,"语言":5.2,"章法":5.8,"余味":4.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.8,"陈滥":0.7,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"街树吊瓶入诗，都市春景与疗治想象颇新，“悬壶续脉”有巧思。三句复述题面，部分措辞稍涩；结句直说复苏，且“翠满密高楼”关系含混，余味不足。","_cost":0.007278},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.25,"rationale":"以当代城市树木输液入诗，题材新颖，'悬壶续脉'借医典喻树有巧思。惜语言粗糙：'衢街'叠床架屋，'细吊瓶输甘露液'近于说明文，'密高楼'凑字费解。结句直白说尽愿景，无留白。章法平铺，转结乏力，出新有余而炼字不足。","_cost":0.03565},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.25,"rationale":"题材取当代街树输液，有新意；“悬壶续脉”双关尚可。但二三句同义复叠、无转折，“衢街”“密高楼”生硬凑字，“甘露液”陈套；结句直陈愿景、说尽无余，整体流于说明。","_cost":0.05192},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":3.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":2.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":27.0,"rationale":"引入“大树打吊瓶”之景有一定新意。但语言文白夹杂，生硬拼凑（如“细吊瓶输”“密高楼”）。全诗直白铺叙，缺乏诗意转折与意象交融，结句和盘托出，毫无余味。","_cost":0.016662},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.5,"rationale":"街树吊瓶属当代所见，悬壶续脉略见双关。春烟甘露等象偏熟，三四句近复述，结句直陈明朝翠绿，说尽无余。情志浅显，整体平实。","_cost":0.019788},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"立意取城市给树挂吊瓶，视角新但情感略泛；意象古今杂糅未臻圆融，转句过实；语言起承有炼字，后二句偏白；章法平直少转宕；结句直说期待，余味不足。悬壶可通，无硬伤。","_cost":0.01395372},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"取材当代街树输吊瓶，熟题翻新，悬壶续脉之喻颇巧。但'细吊瓶输甘露液'近乎白话直陈，甘露亦落套；转句未转，原地铺陈；结句展望虽稳而'密高楼'凑韵失炼。意胜于辞。","_cost":0.00277304},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.4,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.3,"余味":5.4,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"取城市护树吊瓶入诗，有新意；“悬壶”拟医较切。但“细吊瓶输甘露液”语感生硬，末句直说翠满，余味不足。","_cost":0.009356},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"以行道树打吊瓶这一当代经验入诗,题材新,'悬壶续脉'双关有巧思;然'细吊瓶输甘露液'与上句意复,'衢街''密高楼'生造硬凑,结句直说愿景、无余味,春烟、甘露等象亦偏熟。","_cost":0.0123432},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"题材新颖，‘槁树悬壶续脉流’巧用悬壶双关；然情志浮浅，三句‘细吊瓶输甘露液’文白夹杂、与次句意复，转折平直，结句直白少余味，语言除次句外生硬。","_cost":0.033534484},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.0,"rationale":"此作写春街行道树输营养液的当代场景，立意明确但挖掘不深，意象略有抵牾偏俗，语言偶有巧思但含直白硬语，章法平直少宕开，结句直露，轻度陈套，略有新材入诗尝试。","_cost":null}},"consensus":56.71,"final":56.71},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"灯火云仓夜未收，寒光铁臂扫尘流，开箱验货标签遍，净地迎朝送远舟。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.8,"语言":4.9,"章法":6.4,"余味":5.3,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.1,"硬伤":0.8,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.3,"rationale":"智能仓储入诗，题材新且夜作场景具体。灯火、铁臂能成氛围，但“标签遍”直滞，“扫尘流”稍涩；末句由仓库突接远舟，虽有晨运收束，关联略显牵强。","_cost":0.005376},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":3.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":36.0,"rationale":"以云仓夜班入诗题材尚新，但通篇流水记事，无情感焦点。'铁臂扫尘''标签遍'近乎说明文，取象未化为诗境。第三句转折乏力，仅罗列工序。结句'送远舟'与物流仓储实景脱节，为凑雅而生硬。当代经验入诗略可嘉，然锤炼不足。","_cost":0.03005},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":3.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":36.75,"rationale":"以自动化仓储入诗有当代题材之新，惟通篇平铺流程如工作日志，无情志主脑。铁臂扫尘稍具画面，开箱验货标签遍纯是硬凑罗列，第三句无转。结句送远舟与云仓物流意象不甚相合，直白少余味。","_cost":0.04362},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.25,"rationale":"尝试将现代物流入诗，具时代感。但语言如'开箱验货标签遍'形同汇报，文白夹杂；结句'送远舟'套用古典意象与现代云仓割裂且生硬。通篇平铺直叙，意境干瘪，缺乏余味与波澜。","_cost":0.014964},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.5,"rationale":"取材当代智慧物流，具时代感。但转句“开箱验货标签遍”直白如公文说明，诗意骤减；尾句借远舟拓境，古典与工业物象尚未完全融洽。","_cost":0.0049695},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"云仓夜作取材有当代感、题旨集中，然情偏记叙少翻新；铁臂等象杂入未融境；验货标签近白话欠炼；顺叙完整少转；结句实说迎朝送舟少留白。","_cost":0.019286},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.2,"意境":3.4,"语言":2.8,"章法":3.6,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.0,"rationale":"题材有当代感但立意平常；“铁臂扫尘流”等语言生硬，“远舟”与云仓意象不谐；转句偏散，结句说破，余味较弱。","_cost":0.01431144},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.25,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫入绝句，当代经验入诗有新意，惜立意止于铺陈劳作，未见深掘。'寒光铁臂'稍见意象，但'验货''标签遍'近于记账式罗列，景语情语未能交融。四句皆平铺直叙，缺转折；结句'送远舟'为凑韵而与云仓物流语境略违，收束直白，余味有限。","_cost":0.0027234},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.2,"章法":5.6,"余味":5.4,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.25,"rationale":"写云仓夜作，题材有当代感；但流程化叙述多于情志，标签、验货偏直白，结句略见远意而余味不深。","_cost":0.008624},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"以云仓夜班扫码入诗，题材当代、题旨明确，但止于白描工序，情志发掘不深；灯火、铁臂、远舟意象妥帖而未交融深味；语言通顺无诗眼；起承平稳，转结以'迎朝送舟'宕开稍有远意，略存余韵。","_cost":0.0064392},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.5,"rationale":"题旨明确而情志浅，首二句工业意象尚生动，第三句近说明、转折弱，结句直白少余味；现代经验入诗未化尽。","_cost":0.02286355},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.5,"rationale":"此作写云仓夜间整备待运，题旨明确但立意平实无新致，意象偏写实、融合不足，语词通顺欠锤炼，转处稍杂，结句直白少余味，题材略有当代性，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":48.29,"final":48.29},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|社区食堂|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"晨暾暖透万窗光，老幼扶携进食堂。灶旺锅开鲜饭饱，盘丰价定美羹香。欢颜共话团圆乐，白发相依孝悌常。莫道杯盂皆小事，人间满处是吾乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"unknown"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":5.6,"意境":4.8,"语言":4.2,"章法":5.7,"余味":4.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.8,"陈滥":2.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.0,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗有现实关怀，主旨集中但偏颂赞。“鲜饭饱”“价定”稍硬，团圆、孝悌等语较泛；尾联能提升题旨，却说理较满。","_cost":0.005588},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":35.0,"rationale":"题材当代可取,但处理成颂扬套路,情事不具体。中二联'欢颜''孝悌'干说凑对,'鲜饭饱''美羹香'措辞生硬近老干体。章法完整而转折平直,结句化用'此心安处是吾乡'尚有余温,惜前文铺垫空泛,说理气重,余味有限。","_cost":0.0317},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":38.5,"rationale":"题材取自当代社区食堂,有现实感,但通篇颂扬语气,缺乏具体可感的细节与个人视角。中二联并列铺陈,\"鲜饭饱\"\"价定\"\"孝悌常\"凑韵直说,套话密度高。结句化用\"此心安处是吾乡\"略显借力,收束尚稳而余味有限。","_cost":0.03922},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":2.0,"意境":1.0,"语言":1.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":13.5,"rationale":"典型“老干体”。题材虽切近当下，但“价定”“鲜饭饱”等词直白粗糙，流于新闻报道；充斥“孝悌常”等标语式口号，全无诗意氛围；结句强行升华，说教味极浓而毫无留白，缺乏含蓄蕴藉之美。","_cost":0.027646},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.2,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.25,"rationale":"关照当代民生具烟火气，章法合度。病在炼字平俗，“盘丰价定”“孝悌常”近于标语宣教，诗味寡淡；结句说破无留白。","_cost":0.006345},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.5,"rationale":"社区食堂场景具体，然立意落入团圆孝悌套式；厨食事象罗列未成交融氛围；语言通顺有对仗无诗眼；章法平铺完整；结句点题说破，余味薄。","_cost":0.017056},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":40.75,"rationale":"主题明确但近宣传语，情意空泛；意象多套话，删换无伤；炼字平淡，中二联平列少开合；尾联化用东坡句，有余味但直白。","_cost":0.01224564},"glm-5.3":{"立意":4.0,"意境":2.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":34.25,"rationale":"题材当代（社区食堂）但写法近应制颂体：欢颜、团圆、孝悌等套语密集，中二联铺排干说少实景，情不具体。结构完整、结句化用东坡宕开一笔略有余响，然杯盂小事到吾乡转折直白，警拔不足。","_cost":0.00340784},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.8,"章法":5.8,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.8,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.7,"rationale":"题材切实，社区食堂有生活暖意；但直说较多，团圆、孝悌等词偏概念化，意象平常，中二联铺排平直，尾联说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.00728},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":1.5,"score":48.75,"rationale":"社区食堂题材入七律有当代意识,尾联'莫道—是吾乡'试图以小见大、宕开升华,是全篇主脑。但中二联'灶旺锅开''盘丰价定'仅铺陈罗列,层次平直;'鲜饭饱''孝悌常'凑韵生硬,欢颜团圆等语近套话;结句'是吾乡'明显承袭东坡'此心安处是吾乡',警拔不足。整体平稳有余,锤炼与新境欠火候。","_cost":0.0129432},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.5,"rationale":"题意集中而角度常见，情感近口号；取象常见，情景未深融。语多硬凑，杂白话“价定”“满处”。章法完整，由物及人，尾联议论；结句说破，余味短。无警句，题材略具当代性。无硬伤蹈袭，陈滥中等。","_cost":0.028994002},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":3.8,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":41.25,"rationale":"此作咏社区食堂，主旨明晰但视角平泛，意象熟套稍显违和，语言平畅偶有生硬，结构完整但转合平直，结句直白说破余味不足，套语较多，无硬伤袭用。","_cost":null}},"consensus":43.78,"final":43.78},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"街头柳病挂瓶光，袋裹输津润蕊香。管细针斜悬苦液，风轻叶嫩泛新芳。朝来护树怜羸弱，夜半扶人惜瘦长。并作春恩同灌溉，无声染翠映晴阳。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.3,"语言":5.2,"章法":6.2,"余味":5.4,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.8,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.95000000000001,"rationale":"树木输液入诗，题材新鲜，怜树及人亦有主脑。针管、嫩叶取象可感，但“扶人惜瘦长”语意含混，“同灌溉”生硬。章法尚完整，结句明净却偏熟套，余味有限。","_cost":0.007328},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"取材城市树木输液，当代经验入诗可取。但颈联'夜半扶人'突转人事，与护树并置牵强，脉络生涩；'挂瓶光''润蕊香'凑韵痕迹重。尾联'春恩''映晴阳'落入颂体套话，说尽无余，全篇有新题而无新境。","_cost":0.03693},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":49.25,"rationale":"取城市树木输液入诗，题材当代有新意，护树与扶人并举稍见寄托。然柳言蕊香、营养液称苦液、以灌溉喻人皆欠贴；'扶人'突起无铅垫，尾联先说破春恩再以染翠晴阳泛收，套语偏多，未能深化。","_cost":0.0633},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":32.5,"rationale":"当代题材入诗值得鼓励，但语言生造凑韵（如挂瓶光），意象过于直白干瘪。颈联强转到写人逻辑突兀，尾联总结说尽，缺乏含蓄留白与余味。","_cost":0.016498},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.5,"rationale":"街树吊瓶具今象，树人并写有焦点。春恩近口号，意象医器与春芳罗列欠浑。输津、瘦长见凑。章法全而转直，结已点破景收薄。","_cost":0.022526},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.5,"rationale":"题材有当代新意，但表达未熟。意象杂糅，如“润蕊香”与“病”“苦液”不协；颈联“扶人惜瘦长”逻辑费解。结句直白落套，余味不足。","_cost":0.01053624},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"以街头柳树挂吊瓶入诗，当代经验入旧体，立意新、情事具体。颔联'管细针斜悬苦液'写物精切可取；但颈联'夜半扶人惜瘦长'意脉含混，'挂瓶光''泛新芳'等为韵所迫，略见凑字。结句以景收束尚留余味，然'春恩''晴阳'微近套语。","_cost":0.00306284},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.3,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.65,"rationale":"题材入诗较新，细描树输液有生活感；但语词略显生硬，尾联说破，结句景语偏熟。","_cost":0.013562},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.0,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶这一当代街景入诗，拟树为病人、移医患之情于草木，角度较新；针管、苦液、输津等意象具体成组。惜颈联'夜半扶人惜瘦长'语义含混，柳言'蕊香'欠切；'春恩'直说破题，结句染翠晴阳略显熟滑，炼字未至精警。","_cost":0.0151392},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"以街树挂吊瓶的当代经验入诗，联类护树扶人，立意新颖聚焦；管针苦液取象精切，然风轻叶嫩、染翠晴阳稍陈，语言文白夹杂，转折平稳；结句先揭春恩后以景收，余味稍短。无硬伤蹈袭，略有陈滥。","_cost":0.033893805},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.8,"语言":4.2,"章法":4.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.949999999999996,"rationale":"选取城市行道树挂吊针的当代题材入诗，题旨明确但表达平浅，意象多熟套，颈联表述有歧义，结句直白少余韵，打磨不足，无明显蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":56.85,"final":56.85},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|深夜视频|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"银屏乍亮夜灯光，万里容颜入小房，笑语温柔驱睡意，寒窗月影满清霜。离愁两处难言尽，咫尺天涯共故乡，线断声销仍不寐，无眠枕畔嗅余香。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.7,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.8,"余味":5.9,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.8,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.85,"rationale":"视频传情切入当代离愁，主脑清楚，断线后失眠亦有层次。“万里容颜入小房”可取；月霜、天涯、余香稍陈，“嗅余香”于视频情境略显悬空。","_cost":0.00636},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.0,"rationale":"以视频通话写两地相思,当代经验入诗可取,惜处理常见。'咫尺天涯''离愁两处''清霜月影'皆套语,中二联对仗松散、开合无层次。尾联'仍不寐'与'无眠'语意重复,属废字硬伤;结句嗅余香稍有余味但衔接牵强。整体平顺而乏警策。","_cost":0.04367},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.0,"rationale":"视频通话入诗有当代感，起句尚可。但中二联对仗松散，颈联「离愁两处」「咫尺天涯」干说套语，「寒窗月影清霜」陈滥。尾联「仍不寐」「无眠」重复，「嗅余香」与视频情境略脱节，余味稍存而未真留白。","_cost":0.05834},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.25,"rationale":"现代经验“视频”入诗具时代感。但语言直白且文白拼凑，中二联缺乏律诗开合层次，多用“清霜”“天涯”等陈套。结句“嗅余香”与隔屏语境逻辑略显脱节，有凑韵之嫌，余味平平。","_cost":0.020866},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.2,"章法":5.8,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.8,"rationale":"将现代视频场景融入传统离别意脉，情真意切。然炼字偏俗直，传统套语拼接痕迹较重。尾联“不寐”与“无眠”词义合掌犯复，结句略显艳俗，余韵受阻。","_cost":0.00481875},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.5,"rationale":"视频离思具体但角度常见无新境。银屏与霜月离愁未交融。文白夹杂少炼。脉络贯通然颈联直抒。结嗅余香稍留白。当代事入诗,套语密度中。","_cost":0.03626},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"题材有当代生活感，结句以嗅觉细节留余味；中二联层次平直，寒窗、清霜、离愁、无眠等套语偏多，语言略有凑字重复。万里容颜入小房稍佳。","_cost":0.0113290848},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"以视频通话入旧体，角度可取，'万里容颜入小房'有巧思。但整体被套语侵蚀：咫尺天涯、离愁、无眠、月影清霜连缀成篇，情意直陈少象外之致。结句'嗅余香'与视频情境逻辑稍隔且近说破。脉络尚贯通，结得住。","_cost":0.0038302},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.2,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.4,"余味":6.2,"警句":1.2,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.6,"rationale":"视频入诗有当代感，题旨明确，起承转合完整，结以余香稍留白。但离愁、天涯、月霜、余香等语较熟，颈联直说，且“不寐”“无眠”重复，余味受限。","_cost":0.010994},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.5,"rationale":"视频通话入诗有当代意识，惜立意停留于常见离愁；'寒窗月影''咫尺天涯'皆熟语，少精切之象；尾联'不寐''无眠'重沓，'枕畔嗅余香'于万里视频情境逻辑牵强，结句欲留味而失真；全篇平直少警策。","_cost":0.0088962},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":48.75,"rationale":"写深夜视频别情，起承转合完整，现代意象（银屏、线断声销）稍新；然寒窗清霜、咫尺天涯、枕畔余香等陈套，结句不寐无眠重复且余香与视频情境矛盾，意境融合不足，余味直白。","_cost":0.030883924},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":45.25,"rationale":"写深夜与远方亲人视频的羁旅离思，题旨明确、结构平顺，然意象多熟套，语言略有冗笔，引入当代题材但未脱旧路，结句平实余韵不足。","_cost":null}},"consensus":50.63,"final":50.63},{"key":"muse-spark-1.3|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"muse-spark-1.3","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"云仓夜火彻晴空，旷宇千门透晚风，货架高排连峭立，光分码验路全通，寒衢寂静机旋扫，电眼晶明烁绮红，户外朝车来候命，晨炊万巷兆欢同。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-5.6-sol":{"立意":6.2,"意境":5.8,"语言":4.3,"章法":6.7,"余味":3.2,"警句":1.2,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.1,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.7,"rationale":"夜间云仓运转至清晨配送，主脑清楚，当代题材有新意。机、码、电眼诸象具体，章法顺畅；但“连峭立”“朝车”“兆欢同”等生硬，结句拔高说尽，余味较弱。","_cost":0.007874},"claude-fable-5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.5,"rationale":"以智能物流仓入诗题材新颖，然全篇平铺陈述如流水账，中二联仅罗列设备场景无开合。'连峭立''烁绮红'凑字生硬，'光分码验'费解。结句'兆欢同'颂语说尽，落入口号，余味索然。出新略可嘉，语言意境俱弱。","_cost":0.03256},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.25,"rationale":"以智能云仓入诗，题材当代有新意，然多为铺陈罗列，中二联层次平直；“连峭立”“光分码验”“兆欢同”等硬凑生涩，尾联以“欢同”说破兜底，流于口号，余味殆无。","_cost":0.04863},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"立意":5.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.5,"rationale":"题材取现代云仓入诗具时代感；但通篇流于说明文式白描，意象组合缺乏诗意，语言多处生造硬凑（如“光分码验”“兆欢同”），结句形同标语口号，全无留白与余味。","_cost":0.016024},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":43.0,"rationale":"仓储夜运入律场景具体，立意止于颂劳欠深；意象新旧驳杂未融为境，术语硬嵌入诗炼字生凑；铺叙少层次，结句点破欢同无余。","_cost":0.02313},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.0,"rationale":"题旨写现代物流夜勤，明确但浅露。意象多新词堆叠，情与景未交融。中二联并列，少开合转承。结句直说欢同，缺乏留白。现代题材略见新意，但语言生硬、套语夹杂，整体平淡。","_cost":0.01082136},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.0,"rationale":"取材现代云仓物流夜景，视角有当代性，是可取之处。但立意止于表面颂扬，无独到发现；中二联意象罗列（货架、光验、机扫、电眼）近于说明书式铺陈，物象与情意未交融。'路全通''兆欢同'等凑韵生硬，结句直白说破、兜底收场，余味短。出新浪得当代经验，然炼字章法皆平。","_cost":0.00277506},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.8,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.05,"rationale":"取现代云仓入诗，题旨明确，夜景至晨车脉络清楚；但术语与旧语夹杂，句多说明，意象未浑融，结句直白说破，余味不足。","_cost":0.015616},"kimi-k3":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":3.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":38.75,"rationale":"云仓、码验、电眼等当代物事入诗有出新之志，但通篇近设备清单与颂扬，情思不属个人，炼字多硬凑如“路全通”“兆欢同”；结句直说欢同，余味尽泄。","_cost":0.0169572},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.0,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫入律，题材具当代性；然物象罗列，情景未融，“光分码验”等生硬。章法完整而转折平直，结句“兆欢同”直白，少余味。","_cost":0.028564173},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":44.5,"rationale":"本诗写当代云仓夜间作业，题材有新意但立意平泛，意象写实却融合欠妥，语言偏直白少锤炼，章法顺直少起伏，结句直露余味不足，无硬伤蹈袭，有少量熟套语。","_cost":null}},"consensus":44.72,"final":44.72},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"铁柜临街漆色新，童衫叠罢又逡巡。名签剪落箱门闭，只有针痕认得人。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"取当代旧衣回收之细事，以“逡巡”写母心不舍，“剪落名签”而“针痕认人”，物象精切，景语即情语。起承转结紧凑，结句留白有延宕，唯“只有”稍显点破。","_cost":0.04667},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.8,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.7,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.95,"rationale":"当代日常经验入诗的佳构。剪名签、关箱门等细节极具生活质感，结句“针痕认得人”化古无痕、情思深挚，起承转合浑然天成，兼具现实温度与古典余韵。","_cost":0.00499425},"grok-4.6":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"回收箱写童衫告别具体真挚，针痕结有余味见出新。意象妥帖语言通顺，章法顺叙转折平直，未臻景情浑融。","_cost":0.023634},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":9.0,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.4,"章法":8.6,"余味":9.5,"警句":4.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":95.8,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱为题材，剪名签去身份与针痕留记忆对照精妙；结句尤耐寻味，意象统一，现代经验入诗而不浅白。","_cost":0.00464376},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱写慈母手泽与离别，当代日常入诗而情事具体。'逡巡'见不舍，'剪名签'细节真切，结句'针痕认得人'以物证情，言尽意不尽，是全篇诗眼。四句起承转合完整，一气贯注。","_cost":0.0030384},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.7,"意境":8.4,"语言":8.1,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.6,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.85,"rationale":"取材旧衣回收箱，童衫、名签、针痕细节真切，由弃衣转入记忆，转结含蓄。起句稍平，语言微有文白相杂。","_cost":0.011454},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.25,"rationale":"旧衣回收之当代题材翻出别情新境,剪名签、认针痕事细情真,母缝针脚暗通古意而不袭句。转结有力,结句以物认人、言尽意不尽。稍欠处在意象体系尚简,次句逡巡略直叙。","_cost":0.0079898},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.7,"意境":7.8,"语言":8.4,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.05,"rationale":"借回收箱写母爱与不舍，铁柜新漆与针痕温情冷暖对照，逡巡剪落动作传神，末句以痕认人余味悠长","_cost":0.0076415},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.5,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.75,"rationale":"现代回收箱入诗，剪名签留针痕细节真切；结句“只有针痕认得人”化用慈母线而翻新，含蓄动人。起句稍平、语言略白，瑕不掩瑜。","_cost":0.026259075},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.1,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.6,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.4,"rationale":"此作选取投旧衣入回收箱的当代日常场景，以细切意象寄寓轻浅怅惘，起承转合圆融，结句含蓄有余味，语言平实精准，末句警策，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"以街边旧衣箱写割舍：叠衣逡巡、剪签闭门，针痕一句把匿名捐物翻成私人辨认。情事具体，结句有余味；起句平，转接顺而少变，炼字集中末句。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0188224},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱写亲情与割舍，当代题材有效入诗。叠衫逡巡、剪签闭箱，动作细节具体可感。新漆铁柜衬旧童衫，暗含对照。结句以针痕认人收束，含蓄有延宕。惟“逡巡”稍文，次句略显平。","_cost":0.016428}},"consensus":89.18,"final":89.18},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|机场送别|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"安检门前话未终，长廊背影没灯中。班机隐入层云后，只剩玻璃映老翁。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"以安检门、长廊、层云、玻璃层层推进，当代送别经验入诗自然；结句以玻璃倒影收束，送人者反照自身之老，含蓄有余味。惟“没灯中”稍生硬，三句略平直，语言尚欠锤炼。","_cost":0.04598},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.1,"rationale":"当代机场物象入诗自然妥帖。章法由近推远，转结处从云端骤收至窗前倒影，开合得体；以景结情，不言孤独而孤寂尽出，余味绵长。","_cost":0.005331},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"机场送别熟题，场面由近及远具体可感，主脑在离去后的孤影，角度仍常见。消逝意象层递统一。语言简净偶有亮点无诗眼。章法递进完整转折平直。结句以映象收束留白尚可。当代器物入绝句为出新。","_cost":0.016456},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"送别场景具体真切，机场现代意象与古典离情结合，结句以玻璃映老翁收束，留白有余味。语言偏散淡，少数意象略常见，但整体脉络贯通。","_cost":0.00940236},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.0,"rationale":"送别熟题翻出新境：安检门、长廊、玻璃皆当代物象自然入诗，焦点收束于送行者自身。话未终—背影没—班机隐三重消逝层层递进，结句宕开一笔以镜中老翁收束，以景结情、留白充分。'没''剩'见炼字，惟'班机隐入层云'稍平实。","_cost":0.0201988},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.95,"rationale":"机场送别场景具体，现代物象融入离情，由话未终到背影、飞云，再收至玻璃孤影，脉络清晰。结句有留白，但“只剩”稍说破，语言个别处欠锤炼。","_cost":0.014826},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"现代送别题材处理克制:前三句层层推进——话未终、影没灯、机入云,结句突转定格'玻璃映老翁',以景结情,画面感强、留白充分,全篇一气贯注。字句自然少废字,唯'背影''层云'意象稍常见,语言锤炼未到诗眼自鸣之境,故语言维未入高段。","_cost":0.007863},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.3,"意境":8.1,"语言":6.7,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.2,"rationale":"机场安检翻送别旧题，话未终见匆促，玻璃映老翁收束孤寂有焦点；背影-层云-倒影递进，末句以景结情余味悠长，前三句白描炼字稍平。","_cost":0.0071745},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"机场送别以现代安检、长廊、班机构成新式别情，结句玻璃映老翁以景结情，孤寂自照，余味悠长。语言稍白，炼字未精警，章法平稳完整，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.024856012},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.5,"rationale":"此作写当代机场送别，依流程逐层铺排，取象切境，结句以玻璃映影的实境收束，留白含怅，语言平实精准，无陈套硬伤，唯炼字警拔度稍弱。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"送别情志具体,焦点在迟暮独留,发现未深。意象冷清统一,映翁最精,层云稍熟。语言顺达,没、映有力,余多平直。由门及云及玻璃,脉络清而转折偏直。结句只剩略说破,映影仍可回味。","_cost":0.0279936},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"以安检、长廊、班机、玻璃写当代送别,取象新而贯通。前三句渐行渐远,结句由外景折回自身,老翁倒影暗含孤独与衰老,以景结情有余味。‘没灯中’稍涩,‘只剩’略直白,炼字尚欠。","_cost":0.016612}},"consensus":79.78,"final":79.78},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"投钱按键机声起，布偶方悬爪忽开。稚子临窗张两臂，玻璃借影许相偎。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"当代题材入诗自然，抓空落爪后借玻璃倒影令稚子与布偶“相偎”，构思巧、结句含蓄有情。首句“投钱按键”偏流水账，用语平实少炼，“借”“许”二字为诗眼。","_cost":0.0421},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.3,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗之佳构。前两句刻画精准，转句显童真渴望；结句“借影相偎”以虚补实，化失落为温情，炼字入微，构思奇绝且余味绵长。","_cost":0.00468975},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入诗，童子张臂借影相偎，情事具体有焦点。前联叙事质直少炼字，转结尚顺。结句以象留白有余味。当代经验入诗算出新，无硬伤套语。","_cost":0.02115},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.75,"rationale":"转结以稚子张臂、玻璃借影相偎收束，化抓取落空为温存，结句留白有余味；起句偏实，余皆精切。","_cost":0.0066919776},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.0,"rationale":"旧体写抓娃娃机，当代经验入诗自然。承句爪开偶落，转句稚子张臂，结句隔玻璃仅能借影相偎——由物及人，以景结情，'借''许'二字见诗眼，留白有余韵。首句稍平直，取象皆扣一境，脉络贯注。","_cost":0.01464842},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.19999999999999,"rationale":"当代题材，抓爪忽开与稚子张臂相映，失落不直说，借玻璃影收束，有童趣与余味。前句稍白，语意新而略涩。","_cost":0.012044},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"以当代场景入诗,抓取投币—落空—临窗—借影的完整情事,落差不怨而转生温情,主脑集中。'玻璃借影许相偎'化虚为实,以景结情,留白有暖意,是全篇诗眼。首句稍平实,意象提炼仍可更精。","_cost":0.010104},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.2,"rationale":"以机冷衬童稚，张臂落空后借玻璃虚影自偎，转结温柔微酸。当代物象入绝自然，章法贯一，末句以景结情余韵足。","_cost":0.00998025},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"取娃娃机一角，稚子隔玻璃借影相偎，情事鲜活；结句以景结情，余味悠长。起句稍质直，现代词入诗略白，故语言、章法未至满分；无硬伤陈滥蹈袭。","_cost":0.027655466},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.0,"rationale":"此作捕捉抓娃娃机前稚子隔玻璃借影偎偶的细腻瞬间，用字精准，结句留白有韵，当代日常入诗自然，无硬伤陈套，唯意象、章法稍平直。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.0,"rationale":"当代物象入诗,以落爪失手与玻璃叠影写稚子求而不得,情事具体,焦点收得住。首句平铺记事,字欠锤炼;中幅依序直叙,转势不大。结句「借」「许」不说破,余味最胜。","_cost":0.0194272},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写可望难即之憾，当代经验入诗有效。次句“方悬爪忽开”一扬一抑，写出得失一瞬。结句借玻璃之影求相偎，以虚象慰实失，稚气中含怅惘，余味可品。首句平铺近散文，“许”字稍露解说痕迹。","_cost":0.01638}},"consensus":81.44,"final":81.44},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"屋顶匀开三寸土，瓜花点点照黄昏。邻翁教我分春韭，始信高楼也有根。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"都市天台种菜写出栖居扎根之意,'三寸土''分春韭'具体可感,'匀开'见炼字。起承转合清晰,由景入事再入理。结句以'根'双关点题虽巧,但'始信'说破稍直,余味略减。当代经验有效入诗。","_cost":0.04114},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.7,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.5,"rationale":"当代经验入诗的佳作。起承摹景清丽，转入人事极富烟火气；结句以“高楼有根”点睛，既落实土木又双关归属感，将都市疏离化为温情，情真意笃。","_cost":0.004548},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"天台薄土种菜写都市寻根，三寸土、分春韭具体可感，末句双关点题。起承转合完整，根字回扣土与韭。结句理语说破，留白不足。黄昏邻翁略熟，当代人事入诗尚自然。","_cost":0.025848},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.8,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.8,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.45,"rationale":"立意将都市天台种菜与“根”相融，角度新颖；意象精切统一，“照”字见炼字之工；章法起承转合紧凑，转结有力。结句议论略直，但“根”字双关，尚有余味。无硬伤陈滥。","_cost":0.00451356972},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.75,"rationale":"起承转合完足：'匀开''分春韭'炼字见园艺实感；转句引入邻翁生波澜，结以'高楼也有根'翻出都市扎根新境，化杜甫剪春韭于无痕。惟结句议论近说破，余味稍敛。","_cost":0.0272314},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.7,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.2,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.1,"rationale":"以屋顶菜园写都市乡土之思，细节真切，结句‘高楼也有根’颇能翻新；但‘始信’稍显说破，余味略减。","_cost":0.008548},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"天台种菜翻出'高楼有根'之思，熟题得新意；瓜花照黄昏、邻翁分韭皆具体可感。转结由事入理，结句宕开有余味。语言平易少锤炼，前二句意象略熟，整体清新而深度稍欠。","_cost":0.006054},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.4,"意境":7.8,"语言":8.1,"章法":8.2,"余味":6.9,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"三寸土见经营，由瓜花黄昏到分韭悟根，翻出高楼亦有根新境；匀、照等字精切，起承转合一气贯注，末句双关留味但说理稍直。","_cost":0.00919275},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"章法起承转合清晰；以屋顶种菜、邻翁分韭的当代经验翻出“高楼有根”新意，立意集中且化春韭古意。意象语言妥帖但稍平熟，结句巧而直白，余味略欠。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.032912567},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.0,"rationale":"此作写天台菜园日常，熟题翻出都市烟火根脉的新境，章法圆转，炼字自然，意象妥帖但多常见，结句稳有双关却稍直，融入当代经验，无硬伤套话。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"屋顶薄土与分韭情事具体，主脑是高楼寻根，根字双关为眼，当代经验入诗有效。意象妥帖而未深融，章法完整但转折平缓。结句以始信说破题旨，收得住而余味不足。","_cost":0.0223648},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"写当代天台种菜，由邻翁分韭引出高楼有根。根字兼指植物与人情归属，立意有新意。匀开、照字炼得较稳。前两句写景，第三句转到人事，自然而有层次。结句用始信点破题旨，稍嫌直露，但双关仍留余味。分春韭暗化杜诗，用得无痕。","_cost":0.019436}},"consensus":81.0,"final":81.0},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|机场送别|七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"母嘱添衣声断续，催程广播报航班。玻璃隔语唇犹动，行李离身指尚弯。屏上机移千里路，心头影驻一重关。舱中忽觉寒侵领，默把围巾绕两环。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"以“添衣”起、“绕围巾”收，主脑清晰首尾呼应。颔联“唇犹动”“指尚弯”细节精切可摘，机场玻璃、广播、屏幕航迹等当代经验入诗自然。颈联“一重关”稍泛，“屏上机移”略硬。结以动作代言，余味佳。","_cost":0.05981},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.4,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.95,"rationale":"现代机场经验入诗自然无痕。颔联“唇犹动”“指尚弯”特写细节精绝，传神入微；尾联以“绕两环”暗扣首联添衣之嘱，首尾呼应，行止间深情涌动，余韵绵长。","_cost":0.0046995},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"母子机场送别题旨具体可感，然添衣母爱角度常见。颔联唇动指弯较切，颈联千里关寒稍泛。语言通达但广播航班近口语。章法由场入舱叙事完整转平。结句绕巾回扣未说破。","_cost":0.02244},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.7,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.7,"rationale":"现代机场细节真切，颈联以屏上机移写心驻一关，工新；结句以绕围巾回应添衣，含蓄有余。首联对句稍散，尾联视角切换略跳。","_cost":0.02312126},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.25,"rationale":"以机场经验重写游子之别：广播、玻璃、屏幕诸象与情交融，添衣—围巾首尾呼应。颔联'唇犹动/指尚弯'以余姿写深情最警，颈联移驻开合有度，结以绕巾两环用动作留白。惟'报航班'微平，'千里路/一重关'稍熟。","_cost":0.02883222},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"机场送别取象新切，隔窗指弯、围巾绕领等细节有情；转结含蓄。题旨较熟，个别词稍平。","_cost":0.00996},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"送别慈母旧题翻入机场新境，细节具体：玻璃隔语、指尚弯、绕围巾，情事交融，主脑集中。颔联取象精切近乎白描而动人。'报航班'稍平直，'添衣'略熟。章法起承转合一气贯注，结句以绕围巾暗应母嘱，以景结情、言尽意不尽，余韵悠长。","_cost":0.011259},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.5,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.7,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"以围巾为线索贯穿机场送别，情事具体真挚；玻璃唇动指尚弯等当代物象精切融情；锤炼有诗眼而自然，颈联虚实对照，尾联以动作结情留白悠长。","_cost":0.00999275},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.5,"rationale":"以机场送别写母爱，当代经验入诗而情事具体。“玻璃隔语”“指尚弯”“绕两环”细节真切；结句以动作收束，呼应“添衣”，余味深长。主题承游子吟传统，颈联稍抽象。","_cost":0.03348413},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.3,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"此作写机场母子送别，细节鲜活真切，当代场景融入自然，章法圆合，炼字精准，结句呼应开篇添衣嘱托，含蓄有余味，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"主脑在母嘱未散：隔玻璃、指尚弯、绕巾两环皆具体可感。意境与结句最佳，收处不说破。次句偏白，千里与一重关略熟，中二联同写残留，转势偏平。","_cost":0.0191152},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"当代送别经验入诗，玻璃隔语、指尚弯细节真切，是全篇亮点。尾联以围巾应首句添衣，首尾呼应，以事结情，余味足。颈联稍显概念化，“报航班”较平。屏上与舱中两句时序略有重叠，视角稍欠清晰。","_cost":0.020924}},"consensus":84.31,"final":84.31},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"琉璃匣底小熊眠，扯袖频催父换钱。铁爪凌空绒耳颤，娇儿仰首脚跟悬。铃声未尽毛团落，笑靥初收嫩指蜷。大掌摊开无一物，归途两手自相牵。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"unknown"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"当代生活题材入律而不隔,叙事聚焦父女一局抓娃娃,情事具体。中二联“绒耳颤/脚跟悬”“毛团落/嫩指蜷”对得工切传神,大掌与嫩指相映。结以空手却牵手,不说破而情自见。首联稍散文化,“毛团”略俚,语言精度可再提。","_cost":0.06912},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.4,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.65,"rationale":"当代日常经验入诗的典范。中二联动态捕捉极其传神，“脚跟悬”“嫩指蜷”形神兼备。结句化两手空空为父子相牵，从物之得失跃入亲情温厚，余味悠长自然。","_cost":0.00541575},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"抓娃娃亲子日常具体有主脑，空手与牵手对照尚可但角度常见。绒耳颤、脚跟悬、嫩指蜷等象精切交融。语言通顺偶有炼字。起承转合完整。结句牵手留白未说破。末联可摘。当代题材入诗。无硬伤陈滥蹈袭。","_cost":0.023152},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.4,"语言":8.2,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.8,"rationale":"抓娃娃机细节鲜活，中二联对仗工稳，尾联以空手相牵收束，情味深长。立意偏日常，语言偶有浅白，整体不涉硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":0.0063626904},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"抓娃娃机当代经验入律,不着生造;'眠''颤''悬''蜷'炼字传神见诗眼。中二联同摄一瞬、开合稍平。尾联空掌与两手相牵对照,以景结情,言尽意远,情真无套语。","_cost":0.02309442},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.9,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.1,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入诗，题材新而细节真切；由企盼到无获，归于牵手，情在言外。章法清晰，炼字生动，唯个别语稍直白。","_cost":0.014806},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃落空翻为父子相牵，题旨集中而具体；匣、爪、绒耳、脚跟诸象联动成境，结以空手对大掌，失望化温情，余韵足。唯中联接续略顺，未臻奇警。","_cost":0.012961},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.7,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.7,"rationale":"当代抓娃娃机入律新颖，镜头递进刻画精切；以空掌反衬牵手温情，主脑集中，起承转合贯通，结句以景结情余味隽永。","_cost":0.009423},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.8,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.05,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入律，当代经验自然。'绒耳颤''脚跟悬'取象精切；尾联空掌与牵手反差，温暖含蓄，余味足。唯'换钱''毛团'等语稍白，然章法完整，无硬伤。","_cost":0.032780025},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"此作取材当代亲子抓娃娃日常，细节鲜活，炼字精准，章法连贯，结句以空手相牵的细节寓平实温情，无陈套硬伤，当代经验入诗自然妥帖。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃失败写亲情，情事具体，落点近常见温情。铁爪、悬踵、蜷指精切，中二联一悬一坠，尾联空掌对牵手，余味最佳。毛团、换钱偏平，娇儿笑靥略甜。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0259344},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"当代亲子小事入诗，情事具体。“脚跟悬”“嫩指蜷”状童态传神。颔、颈两联由期待到落空，层次分明。尾联以“大掌摊开”与“两手相牵”作对照，得失之外见亲情，以动作收结，留有余温。“毛团”略俗，中二联偏于白描，稍欠开合。","_cost":0.018528}},"consensus":84.5,"final":84.5},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"收衣绿匣立街边，袋口徐开袄半悬。短袖犹存攀树迹，深兜尚卧买糖钱。斜阳一寸随包落，往事千重伴絮眠。稚子催归声渐急，身高已及母亲肩。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.5,"rationale":"当代经验入诗有效：回收旧衣见儿女成长，情事具体。颔联“攀树迹”“买糖钱”细节精切，颈联一寸/千重由实转虚。结句以身高及肩收束，不说破而有延宕。“稚子”与“及肩”略有龃龉，“母亲肩”稍白。","_cost":0.06107},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.35,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗极佳。颔联细节生动，颈联时空转折自然，尾联以现实催归与身高之变收束，言近旨远，将光阴流逝与抚育之情融于生活日常，章法圆满。","_cost":0.00514875},"grok-4.6":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"回收箱切入童衣旧迹与长成，攀树买糖具体真挚、焦点收束。颔联可摘。结句直陈身高较尽。斜阳往事略套。当代物象入诗有效。","_cost":0.025532},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.15,"rationale":"旧衣细节切入童年与代际成长，立意集中；颔联以“攀树迹”“买糖钱”见炼字，结句转出稚子身高及肩，不说破有余味。首联偏实白，颈联“斜阳”“往事”稍熟。无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":0.0093671424},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱这一当代物件入律诗,化古而不隔,情事具体真挚。颔联'攀树迹''买糖钱'细节精切如见,颈联由实入虚层次分明;结句以身高及肩写成长,不言惜别而余味自深。'往事千重'稍落熟套,'身高'一语略近直白。","_cost":0.02021082},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.4,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.19999999999999,"rationale":"当代物象入诗，童年旧衣细节真切，颔联尤佳。颈联稍涉熟泛，结尾以生长作收，有余味。","_cost":0.012308},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.5,"rationale":"借旧衣回收箱写童年流逝，熟情翻出新题。颔联攀树迹、买糖钱细节真切，颈联情景互注。结句'身高及肩'点题稍说破，余味受损；'往事千重'略泛。","_cost":0.0304323},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.7,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.8,"rationale":"借绿匣旧衣触发成长记忆，物象琐细精切情真，当代经验入诗自然，章法由物及忆收束当下，结以身高点题余韵悠长。","_cost":0.01048175},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"当代回收箱入诗，颔联攀树迹、买糖钱细节动人；结句以‘身高已及母亲肩’收束，余味深长。中二联转靠斜阳往事，稍平熟。","_cost":0.031800467},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"以当代街边旧衣回收箱切入忆旧，细节鲜活，脉络顺畅，结句以眼前稚子场景收束留白，仅个别表述稍熟，无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"旧衣回收写孩子长成，攀树迹与买糖钱使怀旧落到实物，情志真而不空。意境统一，斜阳千重略泛。语言有卧字诗眼，首尾近白。脉络通而转缓，结以身高留白，未说尽。","_cost":0.039032},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱写孩子成长，是当代新题材。颔联“攀树迹”“买糖钱”细节真切，堪称佳联。颈联“往事千重”偏套，由实入虚较泛。尾联以身高作结，含而不露，但“稚子”与“及肩”略有龃龉。","_cost":0.017768}},"consensus":80.38,"final":80.38},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|天台菜园|七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"负土登梯趁晚晴，残砖作界菜畦成。藤梢暗绕通风管，架影斜侵蓄水罂。虫口争回三两叶，灯前煮得半瓯羹。人犹是客瓜先熟，试叩邻扉唤一声。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"以城市天台种菜写客居生涯，通风管、蓄水罂等当代物象入诗自然，'虫口争回'见炼字。'人犹是客瓜先熟'翻出客愁新境，结以叩门唤邻，动作悬而未落，余味悠长。中二联层次略平，藤影一联稍属静写。","_cost":0.05074},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.4,"语言":8.1,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.65,"rationale":"当代都市经验入诗的典范之作。通风管等物象化入工稳，生活感极强；由劳作细节自然拓至客居心境与邻里人情，结以唤邻分享，温润深长，一气贯注。","_cost":0.00519},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"屋顶菜园写客居，瓜熟人客对照有主脑。残砖、通风管、架影取象贴切，氛围统一。斜侵、争回见炼字，中二联由植至食尚清。结以试叩邻扉，事结意未尽。当代物事入诗自然。","_cost":0.035566},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":9.0,"语言":9.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.5,"rationale":"都市天台种菜细节真切，虫口争回、瓜先熟等语情味俱足；结句以叩扉唤邻收束，余韵不散。","_cost":0.01264032},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"以天台种菜写都市客居，残砖作界、藤绕通风管，当代经验入旧体自然无痕。'人犹是客瓜先熟'翻久客旧题，主脑鲜明；结句叩邻留白，言尽意不尽。炼字如负、趁、暗、侵、试皆见功。惟颔联两句同为侵绕取景，视角略重，开合微平。","_cost":0.02184302},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.7,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.6,"rationale":"天台菜园以当代日常入诗，负土、残砖、管道、水罂细节真切，虫口夺叶、灯前煮羹转出生趣。客居瓜熟而叩邻作结，留余味。语言偶有生涩，中段稍平。","_cost":0.014428},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"城市天台种菜题材新鲜，残砖、通风管、蓄水罂取象精切，景情交融。颈联由物及人转得自然，'人犹是客瓜先熟'为全篇主脑兼警句，结以叩扉呼邻，留白温暖、言尽意不尽。语言大体自然，'蓄水罂'略生硬，个别句近平白，故语言分稍抑。","_cost":0.0120852},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.9,"语言":8.4,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.6,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.55,"rationale":"天台种菜写城市寄居心境，以瓜先熟反衬人犹客，最后叩邻一唤收束具体；藤绕通风管等工业田园意象交融锤炼见功，章法层进结句留白。","_cost":0.00669055},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"天台种菜题材新，取象精切，中二联由景及事，章法完整；‘人客瓜熟’见暂居温情。惜结句直白、余味稍弱，语有文白夹杂。","_cost":0.028096145},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.8,"rationale":"写客居都市打理天台菜园的日常烟火，物象真切，脉络圆畅，炼字鲜活，当代都市生活经验入诗自然，结句含而不露，饶有烟火暖意，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.65,"rationale":"客居生根、以瓜待邻，情事具体而不空。管、罂与藤影交融合一，三四句动词最切。由负土到叩扉脉络顺，结句不说破。首句稍平，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0132288},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"以天台种菜写城市客居，“人犹是客瓜先熟”翻出归属之思，是佳句。通风管、蓄水罂等当代物象入诗自然，“虫口争回”一句谐趣精警。结句叩门唤邻，暖意可感，但稍显直白，中二联开合也可再深些。","_cost":0.018856}},"consensus":84.6,"final":84.6},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"更深客舍一屏光，母说明朝要赶场。不问归期轻转镜，新衾已覆旧时床。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.25,"rationale":"视频通话入诗而不猎奇，母亲言赶场之琐屑、不问归期之隐忍，借转镜所见新衾旧床收结，无一字言念而念自深。次句稍平白，然衬托有功。转结俱佳，结句以物代情，余味悠长。","_cost":0.04296},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.8,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.1,"rationale":"当代经验入诗的绝佳范本。“轻转镜”转折极具画面感与心理层次；结句以景代言，不着思念二字，而母爱与期盼尽显，情真意切，余味悠长。","_cost":0.004494},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"夜视频写游子见母，不问归期而转镜示床，情事具体、结句以景留白。次句过白、文白夹杂；客舍旧时略陈。转处可取，视讯入七绝有一定新意。","_cost":0.027156},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.75,"rationale":"以深夜视频家常细节写母爱，转镜展示新衾覆旧床，含蓄而有张力。意象清冷中透暖，结句以景结情。语言自然略平，'新''旧'对照佳。章法转结见匠心。无明显硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":0.00462656832},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.75,"rationale":"以深夜视频写亲情,母不问归期,转镜示新衾旧床,深爱尽在不言,熟题翻出新境。一屏光、赶场取象精切,家常口吻自然,诗眼在轻、已。转句宕开、结句以象收束,言尽意不尽。视频通话之当代经验入诗无痕,不觉生造。","_cost":0.0194902},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.8,"rationale":"深夜视频切当代亲情，屏光、转镜与新衾旧床相映，结句以物留白。语自然，惟“赶场”稍白。","_cost":0.01092},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"以视频通话写母爱盼归，题材新而情事具体：母不问归期，只轻转镜头示以铺好的新衾旧床，不言情而情自深。转结尤佳，以景结情、言尽意不尽。语言平淡自然，『轻转镜』见炼字，唯前两联略平直，整体意象尚简，警拔稍欠。","_cost":0.009308},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.7,"意境":8.4,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.6,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.95,"rationale":"以不问归期、轻转镜见新衾写母爱克制深挚，屏光衾床意象精融，转结宕开有余味，当代视频入诗自然。","_cost":0.00747325},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.5,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":95.75,"rationale":"以视频通话细节写母爱，切入精巧。‘不问归期’反用归期典，转镜引出‘新衾覆旧床’画面，以景结情，余味悠长。起承自然，转结见功力。语言凝练，当代经验化入无痕，是为上乘。","_cost":0.027368342},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"此作以当代深夜视频场景写羁旅母子情，细节真切独到，起承转合圆融，以新衾覆旧床的镜头结笔，含蓄留白，语言平实耐读，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.4,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"游子夜视频，母只言赶场、不问归期，转镜见新衾覆旧床，情事具体，主脑清楚。一屏光与“已”“轻”见炼，次句过白，转镜稍生且主语含混，意境未全浑。结以景收，余味最佳。","_cost":0.0335536},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"以视频通话写母爱与乡思，母亲不问归期，只转镜给孩子看床上新被，情事具体。“赶场”乡土气足。转句“不问”暗翻义山“君问归期”，结句以物写情，新被旧床对照，留白深远。当代经验入诗自然，前两句稍平。","_cost":0.015044}},"consensus":87.19,"final":87.19},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|云端相册|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"一触云端开旧照，屏中缺齿笑如初。重裁小像频停手，半截围裙不忍除。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.6,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.3,"rationale":"云端相册裁图这一当代经验有效入诗。缺齿笑与半截围裙皆精切物象，不着一字言母而母在，转句频停手蓄势，结句不忍除以物代情，留白深长。语言略直白，尚欠锤炼。","_cost":0.03899},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.5,"rationale":"当代修图生活经验完美入诗，毫无生涩违和。后两句抓取“半截围裙”极具神采，动作与留白尽现深沉亲情与岁月感伤，转结精妙，余味悠长。","_cost":0.0044625},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"云端相册写童真怀旧，缺齿笑与半截围裙细节具体真挚，裁图停手有当代生活实感。意象妥帖温情但交融不深。语言畅达偶见动作亮点。起承转合完整。结句点破不忍较直白。微有套语，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.019824},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.75,"rationale":"以云端旧照与裁相片细节写怀人，情感具体，“半截围裙”有生活质感。转结尤佳，结句不直说思念而余味深长。字句自然，无明显硬伤陈滥。","_cost":0.00506418},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.75,"rationale":"以云端修照这一当代小事写深挚亲情：旧照中缺齿童笑依旧，裁像时频停手，结于'半截围裙不忍除'——裁去的是已不在之人的一角衣衫，以物留人，不说破而悲惜俱在。起承转合完整，转在'停手'，结以细节宕住，言尽意不尽。语言白描精切，'不忍除'三字为诗眼。当代经验入诗自然无痕，出新满分。","_cost":0.0025678},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.9,"余味":7.3,"警句":2.6,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.7,"rationale":"云端旧照切入当代记忆，缺齿、围裙细节真切。转结由裁像落到不忍除，情事集中；唯“频停手”“不忍”稍直，余味未尽说破。","_cost":0.011242},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"以云端旧照、裁像留影写怀亲，新经验入熟题而不隔；缺齿、围裙取象具体，中二句转出有波澜，结得稳。惜“不忍”稍露，靠“半截围裙”撑住余韵；语言清省而少惊人字。","_cost":0.0235596},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.4,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.3,"rationale":"云端开旧照切入新颖，缺齿笑与半截围裙细节传神，裁照频停见深情，以景结情余韵悠长。","_cost":0.01055825},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"以云端裁照的当代细节写怀旧，情事具体；缺齿笑、半截围裙等意象精切交融；语虽浅白而“裁/除”见巧；起承转合稳顺，结句直说“不忍”稍减余味。无硬伤蹈袭，当代经验入诗有效。","_cost":0.029999736},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.4,"rationale":"此作以云端相册这一当代场景切入怀人，取象真切（缺齿笑、半截围裙），情感沉挚不浮，起承转合顺畅，语言平实精准，以细节收束留有余韵，无陈套硬伤，当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"以裁照屡停托住旧人残痕，缺齿与半截围裙具体，焦点收得住。语言有“裁”“除”之眼而自然。脉络顺直，转折不陡；结句“不忍”说破，余味遂减。","_cost":0.0297232},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"以云端裁照写亲情，半截围裙暗示画外之人，不言其人而思念自见，细节精切。前二句稍平，“缺齿”为亮点。转句“频停手”蓄势，结以物收，“不忍”略露情语，仍有余味。当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.015456}},"consensus":85.86,"final":85.86},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|云端相册|七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"旧照离箱寄远天，开屏又立故堂前。低檐尚挂新收蒜，土灶长凝欲散烟。两指徐张颜渐近，双唇未语笑依然。白头点到初生页，犹在慈亲膝上眠。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"云端相册、两指放大、翻至首页等当代经验自然入律，无生造之感。「土灶长凝欲散烟」写照片定格，一凝一散见诗眼；中二联由景及人层次分明。尾联白头翻至初生页、犹在母膝，时间对折，以景结情，余味深长。「寄远天」稍泛。","_cost":0.05491},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"当代经验有效入诗的佳构。“两指徐张”写触屏放大自然妥帖，旧照物象生动。尾联白头倒溯初生，定格于慈亲膝畔，脉络贯通，深情具象且余味悠长。","_cost":0.00468075},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":55.5,"rationale":"云端相册写怀旧，蒜灶、捏放、膝上细节可感，题旨常见未翻新境。颈联较活，结构平叙相册层次，结句白头对幼时稍说尽。乡居套语密度中等。","_cost":0.03271},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.8,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.5,"rationale":"以云端相册翻看旧照勾连今昔，颔联生活细节真切，尾联以幼时依母画面收束，含不尽之思。立意载体出新但情感仍属常见，语言自然偶有平直，整体佳。","_cost":0.0061611264},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":9.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.5,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":94.75,"rationale":"云端入诗不隔：'两指徐张''点到'今语炼入古法，'长凝欲散烟'凝驻瞬间成诗眼。由檐蒜、灶烟到膝上初眠，镜头层层收拢；尾联时光倒卷，以景结情，'犹'字不说破而余哀自远。中二联同在屏中所见，开合稍平。","_cost":0.04423342},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.1,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.9,"rationale":"以云端翻照写亲情，蒜檐灶烟细节真切，缩放动作入诗新颖。起承转合清晰，结于慈亲膝眠有余味；惟‘远天’‘初生页’稍显生造，语意未臻浑成。","_cost":0.015518},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"云端相册载乡愁,题新而情真。'两指徐张颜渐近'以缩放手势入诗,自然无痕,当代经验与古典形式交融。低檐蒜、土灶烟意象精切,结句翻到初生页如眠母膝,余韵悠长,惟稍近直白。章法起承转合贯通,中二联一景一情开合有度。","_cost":0.0087204},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.6,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.4,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.45,"rationale":"以云端寄照切入当代经验，由离箱到展卷到指触递进有序，收束于白头对初生回照；颔联农家意象较熟，语言白描少锤炼，尾联以景结情余味较足。","_cost":0.010515},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.75,"rationale":"当代云端相册经验自然入律；低檐蒜、土灶烟、两指徐张等取象精切，中二联由景及人，尾联点至初生页、结以膝上眠，情真味长。唯'初生页'略硬，整体出色。","_cost":0.029913045},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.2,"章法":6.8,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"以云端翻旧照写思亲，烟火细节鲜活，自然融入触屏缩放等当代经验，脉络顺承，语挚情真，唯转结稍平直，个别语稍熟，无硬伤套袭。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"借云端相册重返故堂,旧题有新境,情事具体而收得住。蒜檐土灶精切,指缩放亦成象,与田园景尚未浑融。语言通顺,笑依然等偏平。章法顺叙,转折不陡。结句以膝上眠叠时,余味在而稍直白。","_cost":0.0423408},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"以云端相册写怀亲，当代经验入诗自然。'长凝欲散烟'写照片定格极精，'两指徐张'化手势为情致。尾联以白头对襁褓，逆时收束，亲已不在之意留白而出。'笑依然'稍熟，'初生页'略生。","_cost":0.020064}},"consensus":84.26,"final":84.26},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"舷窗俯见长街细，灯火沿河断续黄。欲认当年深巷口，玻璃一触指尖凉。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰故地，思乡熟题得当代新境。前二句取象精细，「细」「断续黄」写高空俯视贴切；三句转入寻旧巷，结句以触玻璃指尖凉收，隔膜与怅惘尽在触感中，不着一字言情而余味悠长。","_cost":0.04467},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.3,"rationale":"现代夜航经验入诗自然妥帖。前两句取景真切，转句勾连旧忆，结句以指尖触碰冰冷舷窗的微小动作收束，将时空阻隔与怅惘化作生理之凉，不落言筌，余韵极佳。","_cost":0.0047235},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"借夜航写乡愁，欲认深巷情事具体，结以指尖凉有留白。意象清冷交融，语言通顺少锤炼。转合完整起承较平。飞行经验算出新，灯火深巷略陈，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.022218},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"俯察灯火、欲认旧巷，结句以触觉“凉”收束，不直言怀旧而隔膜感自出，余味佳。意象精切，章法紧凑；立意略欠独到，语言自然。无硬伤、陈滥、蹈袭。","_cost":0.00929544},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰翻乡愁熟题,情事具体(欲认当年巷口),焦点收束。全篇俯瞰视角统一,细街、断续灯火与玻璃之凉交融为隔世氛围。转句由视觉坠入触觉,结以体感收情、不说破,余味最佳。炼字稳,'细''断续''凉'见功,唯首句稍平,'当年'略熟。","_cost":0.02019982},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.1,"rationale":"现代夜航视角与旧地记忆相合，由远及近、由视转触，“断续黄”“指尖凉”见炼。结以触感留白，有余韵。略少惊警，词语稍平。","_cost":0.006764},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"以夜航舷窗写故园之思,由俯瞰灯火转入'欲认当年',怀旧焦点集中;'玻璃一触指尖凉'虚实相生,触觉结情,留有余味,当代经验入诗自然。唯长街、灯火意象稍熟,'断续黄'炼字可再斟酌。","_cost":0.0067722},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.6,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.7,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.05,"rationale":"航窗视角翻新寻旧乡愁，景情交融，视触递进；欲认一转，指尖凉以物理之寒收心理之隔，含蓄有余味。","_cost":0.007709},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰视角新，结句‘指尖凉’以触觉写旧巷难寻，余味悠长；结构完整，炼字见‘细’‘凉’。唯‘深巷口’稍熟，三句略直，立意深度一般。","_cost":0.029129388},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"此作写夜航俯瞰牵起旧忆，主脑明晰，景情交融，炼字精准，结构完整但转折偏平直，结句以触觉收束余味悠长，融入当代经验，无硬伤陈套。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.4,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.3,"rationale":"夜航寻旧巷，情事具体，主脑集中。长街之细、指尖之凉精切交融；次句灯火稍熟。起承皆俯视，略平；三句转认，结以冷触，未说破，余味足。","_cost":0.023324},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰故地,把当代经验有效写入诗中,情事具体。前两句的街细、灯黄取象精切。第三句“欲认”一转自然。结句写玻璃冰凉,以触感收束,阻隔与乡愁不言自明,余味较足。首句“俯见”稍显平直,与题目重复。","_cost":0.013168}},"consensus":83.17,"final":83.17},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"一荤两素寻常味，晚照穿窗碗底红。洗净杯盘门半掩，留双竹箸待邻翁。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"当代生活入诗，一荤两素起得平实，晚照映碗底红一句得景，转句收拾门掩，结以留箸待翁见人情，未言翁之迟来缘由，留白尚可。惟语言略平，寻常味、邻翁稍熟，未成警策。","_cost":0.05021},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.4,"rationale":"当代题材有效入诗。起笔接地气，承句光影交融极富诗意；转结自然，以“留双竹箸”之细节写活邻里温情与人文关怀，不发议论而情意自足，余味悠长。","_cost":0.004266},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.5,"rationale":"食堂邻里守候具体有主脑,角度半新。碗底红稍融,余象常见。语言通顺有眼。章法平直少变。结句点破待翁较尽,余味弱。当代入诗有效,无硬伤袭用。","_cost":0.032696},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"「晚照穿窗碗底红」以光影细节写日常，情景交融；结句留箸待邻翁含蓄见温情。立意角度略熟、语言平实中有亮点，整体不陈滥。","_cost":0.00760335708},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.25,"rationale":"当代社区食堂入绝句而语汇全然古雅，以'留箸待翁'小事写基层温情，主脑集中。'晚照穿窗碗底红'以夕光点化寻常饭食，是全篇诗眼；结句以动作留白，余韵悠长。第三句转折稍缓、起句平实，章法略让；语言精严无废字。","_cost":0.02599022},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.3,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.7,"rationale":"写社区食堂烟火与邻里温情，细节具体，晚照碗底红有光色；语言清畅而稍直，结句点意略明，余味尚可。","_cost":0.009972},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"以社区食堂日常起笔，落到“留箸待翁”，情事具体、焦点集中；晚照、碗红、门半掩合成温煦暮色。语言大体干净，“碗底红”亮眼，白描处略近散；结句留白有期待，未说破。题材入诗较新而少猎奇。","_cost":0.0126932},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.2,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.3,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.9,"rationale":"寻常食堂见邻里温情，具体可感；暮光碗红、门半掩、竹箸等象融为暖境；起承自然转结轻巧，末句以物寓情留白足，唯首句语直欠锤炼。","_cost":0.012407},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"起承转合清晰，借晚照碗底红与留箸待邻翁细节写社区温情；意象新鲜，结句含蓄有余味。语言稍显平白，当代经验入诗自然，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.023024939},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.25,"rationale":"此作撷取社区食堂日常片段，小中见暖，情志真切。意象贴合烟火氛围，语言净洁有细节，章法顺畅，结句留箸见温厚余韵，无硬伤套袭。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"邻里温情题近熟，借一荤两素与社区食堂落成具体情事，焦点收在待翁。碗底红为诗眼，光色与餐食相融。章法完整，三句转至净洗掩门，四句留箸收住。结句点出待人，余味在空位而未宕远。首句略白。","_cost":0.021872},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"以社区食堂写当代邻里温情，一荤两素、竹箸等细节具体可感。晚照映碗底一句色调温暖，情景相融。转句洗盘掩门转得自然，结句留箸待邻翁，不说破而人情与孤老之思俱在，余味悠长。个别字面稍平。","_cost":0.015064}},"consensus":80.97,"final":80.97},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"老树悬瓶垂细管，砖封寸土雨难侵。春风未许残年歇，又向枯枝索绿阴。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"取当代街树输液之实景入诗，物象精切统一；前二句写困境，第三句以春风反转为逼迫者，'索'字为诗眼，结句以事收情不直说。稍憾寄托之意略显，余味尚可再蕴。","_cost":0.04695},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.75,"rationale":"起承写实，将城市行道树地表硬化与吊瓶精切入诗；转结拟人尤见力度，“索”字如铁，既状老树遭催折之苦，又深具社会隐喻，构思新颖，讽慨深沉。","_cost":0.006024},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.5,"rationale":"输液老树入春题焦点集中。吊瓶砖封意象切，春风枯枝稍套。语言通顺「索」有力。章法完整转弱。结直陈少留白。","_cost":0.026894},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.75,"rationale":"从树挂吊瓶切入城市绿化困境，拟人转结含讽而不说破；意象精切，炼字见力，结句言尽意不尽。章法起承写实、转结翻进，次句稍平。","_cost":0.0080784},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"取城市老树输液的当代实景，翻出'残年不得歇'的新境，讽喻含而不露，主脑聚焦。'索'字为诗眼，结句逆用春风恩泽之常意，宕开一层，言尽意长。'春风未许残年歇，又向枯枝索绿阴'摘出仍警策。惟前二句铺叙稍平直，章法转折稳而少奇。","_cost":0.02290262},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.1,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.85,"rationale":"写街树输液，取象新而具体；三四拟人转出被迫返绿之意，颇有讽怜与余味。惜“雨难侵”稍硬，情志未深。","_cost":0.00931},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"以街头输液老树切入,当代物象与悯树讽世之情交融,'索'字见诗眼,转结翻出'强留残年仍责其荫'的冷峻意蕴,以小见大。唯'春风''绿阴'略熟,语言尚有可锤炼处。","_cost":0.00696195},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.7,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.7,"rationale":"以吊瓶入诗切当代街景，树人双关，砖封寸土与索绿阴构成张力；起承写实、转结生讽，炼字精准，结句以事结情余味不尽。","_cost":0.0095055},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.75,"rationale":"街树挂吊瓶之当代经验入诗，讽刺砖封阻雨仍强索绿阴，立意新锐专注。意象精准统一，「封」「索」炼字见力；起承转合分明，结句悖理留白，余味深长。无硬伤陈滥蹈袭。","_cost":0.02774266},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"此诗撷取春街行道树挂吊瓶的当代日常，暗讽对羸弱生命的过度索取，炼字精准，章法顺畅，观察有新意；唯结句稍直，余韵略薄。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.6,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.55,"rationale":"吊瓶、砖封与索绿阴对举,主脑集中,观察真切。索字为眼,起结有势,承句近说明。结句诉求已明,余味有限。当代物象入诗有效,春风枯枝稍熟。","_cost":0.018152},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"以街树挂吊瓶这一当代景象入诗，砖封寸土点出病因。转结借春风不许老树歇息，暗讽城市对树木的索取，角度新颖。'索'字有力。前两句偏重纪实，氛围稍薄；结句讽意较为显豁，但仍留有思索余地。","_cost":0.01604}},"consensus":84.01,"final":84.01},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|深夜视频|七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"夜半慈颜到异乡，厨灯隔海照寒床。移盘细指新蔬碧，转镜欣夸晚菊黄。影滞唇边言欲尽，声迟耳畔意偏长。荧屏暗后犹相对，掌底余温尚未凉。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"当代视频通话经验入诗自然，厨灯隔海照寒床构思巧；颈联以画面卡顿、声音延迟写离情，切事切情，为一篇诗眼。结以掌底余温收，不说破而意长。‘细指’‘欣夸’稍弱，‘慈颜’‘异乡’略熟。","_cost":0.05541},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.4,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"将当代跨国视频经验入诗，极为自然贴切。颈联借画面网络延迟写尽母子情深，尾联以手机机身余温衬挂断后的落寞留恋，构思精巧，细节真挚，余味悠长。","_cost":0.005496},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"视频思母为熟题，情事具体有主脑但角度常见。厨灯隔海、影滞声迟意象交融成统一氛围，颈联炼字见巧。结构完整转合尚可，结句余温留白。颔联叙述偏平，慈颜寒床稍套。当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.025902},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.25,"rationale":"以视频通话细节写亲情，颈联影滞声迟捕捉现代经验，尾联荧屏暗、掌底余温留白有力。意象统一，炼字自然，无硬伤陈套。","_cost":0.00832758},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.75,"rationale":"视频通话写思亲，旧题翻出新境：厨灯隔海、信号迟滞、掌底余温等当代细节真切入诗而不生造。中二联一实写母亲展示、一虚写声影迟滞，开合有层次。结句以物之温度代情之温度，言尽意不尽。慈颜、寒床等熟语略有存量，密度低，扣0.5。","_cost":0.02115402},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"写深夜视频亲情，细节真切，结构顺畅，结句余温留白较好；但语词稍杂新旧，炼字未臻精警。","_cost":0.015142},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.3,"rationale":"以视频卡顿写隔海亲情，题熟而能入新，细节真切；慈颜寒床晚菊稍熟，尾联余温传情有余韵，然“尚未凉”收束略满。","_cost":0.0114608},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.55,"rationale":"以视频通话写隔海亲情，细节具体真切；厨灯照寒床、影滞声迟等象情交融，结句以掌温余热宕开，余韵悠长。","_cost":0.008849},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.25,"rationale":"以深夜视频写跨国母子情，焦点集中、情事具体。‘厨灯隔海’‘影滞声迟’融现代经验，意象交融；章法起承转合分明，颈联转佳。结以屏暗余温收，含蓄不尽。个别词如‘转镜’稍硬，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.033925141},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.0,"rationale":"此作写跨洋深夜与母视频的日常，细节真切，炼字精准暗合视频卡顿等现代经验，情感沉挚，章法圆融，结句以掌温留余味，无硬伤蹈袭，鲜见陈套。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"深夜视频写隔海思亲,情事具体,主脑集中在通话未尽与挂后余温。意境最胜,颈联以延迟作诗眼;结句未把思念说尽。起句平弱,慈颜、寒床稍熟,犹相对略说破。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0306784},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"以视频通话写隔海亲情，当代经验入诗自然。颔联移盘转镜细节具体、情态可感。颈联化网络延迟为言尽意长，是全篇警策。结句以手机余温收束，含蓄有温度。慈颜、寒床稍嫌熟套，尾联犹相对略直露。","_cost":0.016864}},"consensus":84.69,"final":84.69},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"铁翼轻欹移皓月，舷窗一角纳山形。江流割断长街火，野路牵来几队萤。万籁沉埋千仞下，繁华压入水晶屏。谁家稚子凭栏望，错认飞灯是远星。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"当代夜航经验有效入诗，颔联“割断”“牵来”以萤喻车灯精切生动；尾联视角倒转，地上稚子错认飞灯为星，与首联皓月呼应。惜“水晶屏”稍隔，颈联与颔联同层俯视，转折略平；结句已点破“错认”，余味稍减。","_cost":0.05079},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.75,"rationale":"夜航经验入诗自然妥帖。颔联炼字警辟，写高空俯瞰具体生动。尾联由俯视反转为地面稚子仰观，双向对望成趣，结构腾挪灵动，留白悠远。","_cost":0.0054795},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰取象较切，颔联割断牵来见炼字，结句稚子错认飞灯反转俯仰有余味。立意常见偏观察，颈联稍抽象，章法承转平直，皓月萤星略套。","_cost":0.022212},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"立意写夜航俯瞰并有地面仰看之回环，但情味略淡；颔联意象精切、动词炼字突出；尾联以稚子错认作结，留白有味。无硬伤与蹈袭，偶见传统熟象。","_cost":0.00547228},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.25,"rationale":"以夜航经验入七律,取象精切,‘割断’‘牵来’‘压入’‘纳’皆见诗眼;中二联城乡对照、声色收放,层次分明;结句翻转到地面稚子错认飞灯为星,宕开留白,言尽意不尽。惟情志偏于巧悟,深情稍逊,故立意略收。","_cost":0.02506382},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.6,"语言":8.1,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.8,"警句":4.2,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.39999999999999,"rationale":"夜航新题，舷窗取景，灯河萤路，颇具画意。颔联工警，尾以稚子错认飞灯作结，清空有回味。繁华、皓月稍熟，视角小跳，不伤大雅。","_cost":0.014448},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"夜航当代经验入诗自然无隔,首联取景精切,颔联'割断''牵来'炼字见力;尾联忽转地面稚子仰观,以'错认飞灯是远星'翻转视角、留白有余,为一篇主脑。稍欠处:'水晶屏'比喻略生硬,高空俯瞰见'几队萤'有违常识尺度,'万籁''繁华'用语稍熟。","_cost":0.0147368},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.6,"语言":8.7,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.2,"rationale":"机舱俯瞰主脑一贯，割断/牵来、沉埋/压入炼字精切，微缩意境完整；宕开稚子错认收束，余味悠远，当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.008408},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.05,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写现代飞行经验，舷窗压缩繁华、稚子误认飞灯为星，视角反转有余味；中二联层次尚可，起承平稳，情志偏于观景、未更深挚，语言炼字有力而间有生硬。","_cost":0.03217611},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"此诗写当代夜航俯瞰体验，机上与地面稚子的视角错位精巧，炼字灵动，意象浑融，章法顺畅，结句有余味，唯立意稍浅、个别意象稍熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"立意在星灯对倒，有发现而情事虚。江火割街、野路牵萤是全篇骨象，颈联万籁千仞偏熟。章法完整，颈联未转，真转落在结句。错认稍点破，互喻仍有余味。","_cost":0.0335536},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.0,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写当代经验，颔联\"割断长街火\"\"牵来几队萤\"取象精切。颈联偏议论，\"水晶屏\"所指稍含混。尾联宕开，转为地面稚子视角，把飞灯错认作远星，视角互换，余味颇佳。情志偏于观感，深度有限。","_cost":0.017676}},"consensus":83.31,"final":83.31},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|社区食堂|七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"门前小榜标餐价，巷里新炊隔院香。饭为牙疏多煮软，羹因雨冷略添姜。蓝衣取盒车铃急，白发临窗笑语长。欲去重询明日菜，厨娘细说笋尖汤。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"当代题材真切入诗，牙疏煮软、雨冷添姜细节具体见温情；蓝衣白发一急一缓成对照。尾联以“笋尖汤”收，不说破而暖意自出。首句稍近白话流水，全篇为白描小景，深度有限。","_cost":0.0454},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.89999999999999,"rationale":"现实题材佳作。当代经验入诗妥帖无痕，颔联体贴入微，颈联蓝衣与白发对比鲜活生动。尾联以家常问答作结，不落空泛说理窠臼，市井烟火与人情关怀交融，余味温厚。","_cost":0.004833},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"当代社区食堂养老日常，细节真挚具体有主脑。颔联炼意较好。意象妥帖统一但平实常见。语言通顺少废字。章法层次分明有对比。结句场景收束较直白，余味有限。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.02162},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.6,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.2,"rationale":"写社区食堂日常，细节真实，颔联煮软加姜见体贴，尾联对话留白有余味；唯立意偏日常小景，无更深翻新。","_cost":0.01171104},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.25,"rationale":"当代民生经验入七律而不隔，全篇有主脑：颔联软饭添姜见恤老之细，颈联蓝衣白发、急铃长语开合生动，'急''长'为诗眼；结句宕开明日，以笋尖汤收而不说破，余温可感。惜首联偏直白，通篇记叙平顺，意象深度稍欠，警句仅颈联可摘。","_cost":0.02558642},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.30000000000001,"rationale":"写社区食堂以小见大，细节体贴，烟火气足；颔颈两联有人情与画面，尾联以明日菜收出余味。语言自然偏白，说明性字稍多，意象虽新而未至浑成。","_cost":0.013362},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"颔联因果寓体贴，蓝衣、白发对举有神采，外卖、食堂等当代经验入律自然；然立意止于温情颂赞，开掘稍平；结以问菜、答汤宕开一笔，暖胃亦留余味。","_cost":0.03852915},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.4,"语言":5.6,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.3,"rationale":"聚焦社区食堂老龄温情，细节真切有主脑；中二联对比有序，结留明日之期；唯意象语言偏白描纪实，诗化与锤炼不足。","_cost":0.010359},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"以社区食堂入律，取适老软饭、添姜羹汤等细节，焦点集中，温情具体；章法完整，中二联有对比。然意象稍实，语言文白夹杂且欠诗眼，结句直答‘笋尖汤’，收束稳而少余味。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.029508374},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"作品抓取社区食堂日常细节，温煦真切，语言精准自然，章法顺承连贯，以具象场景承载烟火暖意，无陈套硬伤，唯立意开掘稍浅，余韵略平。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"社区食堂入律，牙疏煮软、雨冷添姜情事具体，蓝衣急与白发闲对举，焦点收得住。结于明日笋汤，意未说破而余味有限。起势平，标价、细说稍直。","_cost":0.019232},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"以社区食堂写民生温情，情事具体。颔联“牙疏煮软”“雨冷添姜”细处见体贴，是全篇佳联。颈联借外卖骑手与老人写出当代市井。中二联层次偏于平列，转折不够强。结句以问菜收束，余温尚在，但宕开不足。","_cost":0.0162}},"consensus":79.55,"final":79.55},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"长街病树各悬瓶，一缕春从针底醒。石隙蟠根泥欲裂，风前展叶色初青。车流逐秒奔如电，液滴移时缀似星。悄把柔条伸路侧，犹分薄荫待人停。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.25,"rationale":"以街树吊瓶入诗，当代经验真切，一篓收束于病树犹分荫。'一缕春从针底醒'为诗眼；中二联由树身转城市快慢对照有层次，然'奔如电''缀似星'稍熟。结句待人停略直而尚存余意。","_cost":0.05532},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.05,"rationale":"敏锐切入当代城市日常，“针底醒”炼字新颖警策。颈联以车流之骤衬液滴之缓，章法匀整；结笔“犹分薄荫待人停”深情温厚而留有余韵。唯“奔如电”稍嫌熟套。","_cost":0.007233},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"吊瓶病树观察具体，针底醒、车液对照有氛围，然立意止于奉献常见，承转平直，结句待停稍说破。颈联可摘。当代场景入诗有效，无硬伤蹈袭，略套。","_cost":0.025356},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.3,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.8,"rationale":"以城市病树输液为题材，现代经验与古典意象结合新警；“针底醒”为诗眼，取象精切；中二联层次清晰，尾联拟人收束有余味；唯车流句略熟。","_cost":0.016666188},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.0,"rationale":"以都市行道树输液的日常小事入律，题新而情真。'一缕春从针底醒'炼字精警，是全篇诗眼。中二联树之困顿生机与车流液滴快慢对照，开合有层次。结句病树犹分薄荫，以情收而留白。惟'逐秒奔如电'稍露直白，整体仍是熟手经营，未臻浑成。","_cost":0.0029576},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.7,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"以城市病树输液入诗，立意新而聚焦。‘春从针底醒’等处体物有情，根裂叶绿、车流滴液相映。转结自然，尾联以薄荫待人留余。惜个别现代语略直，稍欠锤炼。","_cost":0.010836},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"城市行道树输液入诗,题新而情真。'一缕春从针底醒'见诗眼;颈联以车流之疾对液滴之缓,开合有张力;结以病树分荫待人,以景结情稍露意。整体精切少废字,结句略直,未臻上乘。","_cost":0.0081186},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.3,"余味":6.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.10000000000001,"rationale":"吊瓶切入城市生态，以针底醒为诗眼，动静对比为转，薄荫收束有温情；然电星等喻稍陈，个别句口语化削弱锤炼。","_cost":0.01167425},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"以街树挂吊瓶写当代城市生态，'春从针底醒'警策新奇；中二联根叶与车流液滴开合有致，结句柔条分荫，情韵温厚。颈联'移时'等措辞稍涩，稍见斧凿，整体出新有效。","_cost":0.030876424},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.65,"rationale":"聚焦当代春街挂吊瓶的行道树，体察细腻，新意象入诗自然，“一缕春从针底醒”颇具巧思，章法顺畅，唯结句稍直，个别表述略熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"输液街树题旨明确，针底春醒得句。情志近人树对照常格，未成新境。颔联树态熟，颈联电星喻陈且移时凑对。结句点明待停，余味偏直。当代物象入诗有效，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0286048},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶这一当代街景入诗，写病树犹分荫待人，立意有温度。“针底醒”一语新警。颈联以车流之疾对液滴之缓，城市节奏与草木疗愈的张力有发现，但“奔如电”“缀似星”比喻较熟。颔联稍平。结句以景含情，暗含行人匆匆不停，余味尚可但偏温婉直露。","_cost":0.017828}},"consensus":79.14,"final":79.14},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"夜半云仓收铁臂，空廊只剩竹枝声。胶黏履底行犹涩，纸落灯前字尚明。一片残签藏故里，千重货架隔归程。东方欲白车先动，拂到村名分外轻。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"电商云仓夜扫工题材新颖，残签藏故里、货架隔归程一联以物写情精切；结句拂到村名分外轻以细节收情，含蓄有余韵。首联竹枝声代扫帚略隐晦，铁臂微觉刻意，然通篇当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.0441},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.8,"意境":8.9,"语言":8.6,"章法":8.7,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":94.35,"rationale":"当代仓储物流经验入律的绝佳范例。物象精严契合，颔联细节极真；由残签扯出千重货架与乡愁，转接自然。结句以轻拂村名之动作收束，深情克制，留白延宕。","_cost":0.0056175},"grok-4.6":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"物流夜仓翻熟题乡愁，残签货架联对照精切有警策。胶涩灯明细节可感。结句村名轻略留白。铁臂竹枝新旧并置未融，章法承转平直，东方欲白稍套。","_cost":0.04549},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.5,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫中残签引出乡愁，当代经验入诗自然。颈联佳，结句“轻”字含不尽之意，章法严谨。","_cost":0.00825924},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.75,"rationale":"云仓夜班劳动入诗，题新而情实。颔联写履涩、灯明，工切实感；颈联'残签藏故里，货架隔归程'以物写乡愁，为全篇诗眼。结句车动拂村名而'分外轻'，以景结情，言尽意远。中二联开合有层次，脉络贯通，当代经验与旧体格律融合自然。","_cost":0.00283016},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.8,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.10000000000001,"rationale":"以现代云仓夜扫入诗，细节真切，由残签引出乡愁，转结自然；个别语如“东方欲白”“归程”稍熟，但“拂到村名分外轻”收束有韵味。","_cost":0.014076},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.5,"rationale":"云仓铁臂对接竹帚残签,乡愁落于物流细节,情事具体。颈联'残签藏故里、货架隔归程'景情交融;结句'拂到村名分外轻'以动作收情,不点破而余韵悠长。语言质实少废字,'东方欲白'稍熟,整体当代经验入诗自然,新而不猎。","_cost":0.0110193},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.3,"意境":6.9,"语言":7.6,"章法":7.2,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫切入当代劳作，胶黏涩行、残签藏故里等细节真切，主脑在拂村名之轻；颔联并列写实、颈联直抒稍损景情浑融，转结则以轻驭重余味佳。","_cost":0.0103305},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.3,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.25,"rationale":"当代云仓夜扫写乡愁，残签村名聚焦；中二联小大相形，结句轻拂含蓄。语言略杂白话，炼字稍弱，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.026672583},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.7,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.8,"rationale":"此作以云仓夜扫劳作者视角切入，当代劳作细节入诗自然，牵发真切乡愁，取象精切，炼字有神，章法顺畅，结句以动作藏情，余味悠长，无硬伤陈套。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.6,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"仓夜残签见乡，情事具体而乡思角度常见。铁臂残签鲜切，胶纸二句可删，未尽交融。收、藏、拂见炼，字尚明偏白。起承转结合法，二联稍平。结句以轻反隔，有延宕而稍点明。","_cost":0.0374496},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.7,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫写异乡劳动者思归，切入新颖，情事具体。竹枝声双关，胶黏、残签等细节可感。颈联点破故里，稍显直露，也与尾联村名重复。结句以轻拂村名的动作寄情，含蓄有余味。","_cost":0.02118}},"consensus":85.67,"final":85.67},{"key":"gpt-6-astra|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"夜半长廊红线闪，乡名逐码上云端。箱签忽见儿时巷，贴罢封条又细看。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"云仓夜班、扫码上云与乡愁交织，当代经验入诗自然。前三句铺陈递进，结句以“贴罢封条又细看”一个动作收束，不说破而情自现。红线、乡名逐码等语精切，唯首句稍平，整体佳作。","_cost":0.04795},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.25,"rationale":"当代物流经验有效入诗之佳作。扫码上云入象自然无痕，后二句因“儿时巷”忽起波澜，结以“又细看”之白描动作，不着一字空泛抒情而乡愁深沉，余味无穷。","_cost":0.0055125},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"仓夜扫码见乡名起乡愁，情事具体有焦点。物象叙事性强、交融浅。语言通达少炼。起承转合完整。结以细看稍直。云仓码端入诗算出新。","_cost":0.026158},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.5,"rationale":"现代云仓夜班中见儿时巷名，聚焦箱签细节，主题集中。转结以“忽见”“细看”生波留白。前二句稍技术化，意境略冷。加分在当代经验与佳句，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.004367616},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"乡愁旧题借云仓分拣翻出新境，情事具体可感。'乡名逐码上云端'虚实相生，化物流术语为诗语而不隔。转句'忽见儿时巷'自然有力，结句以'贴罢又细看'的动作细节收束，不说破而眷恋尽出，余味深长。","_cost":0.00218792},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.6,"rationale":"以扫码封箱写乡愁，云仓红线、箱签儿巷等当代意象新而能融。转结由劳作入记忆，不说破而有余味；唯词语稍直，云端略泛。","_cost":0.009288},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.5,"rationale":"云仓夜扫与乡愁猝遇，当代经验入诗自然；“红线”“逐码”冷景反衬“儿时巷”，转结以“又细看”留白，情真焦点集中。唯“上云端”略概念，炼字尚可更紧。","_cost":0.0084756},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.9,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.5,"rationale":"以云仓扫码夜作切入，于箱签瞥见儿时巷触发乡愁，冷峻分拣与温热故地对照真切；结构转合利落，末句以“又细看”动作结情，含蓄有余味。","_cost":0.00854375},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.2,"rationale":"以云仓扫码入诗，乡名随码入云，箱签忽现儿时巷，结句“又细看”含蓄见乡思，当代经验有效入诗。立意新、章法完、余味长；意象偏叙事，语言稍平实，有“逐码”等硬语。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.031311586},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.14999999999999,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫的当代场景写乡愁，切入新颖，情感真切，起承转合自然，以动作藏情余味绵长，语言平实，无陈套硬伤，当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":null},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.8,"rationale":"仓夜偶见旧巷,乡愁有具体情事,转结清楚,贴罢又看不说破。语言通畅而少诗眼,次句偏过程说明,意象未充分交融。出新在当代经验入诗,非猎奇。","_cost":0.026736},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.25,"rationale":"以云仓夜班扫码写乡愁,角度新颖,情事具体。第三句'忽见儿时巷'转得自然。结句只写贴签后又细看的动作,不点破乡思,余味足。'逐码上云端'一句把当代物流经验有效写入诗中。前两句取象稍显平实,诗眼不够突出。","_cost":0.01492}},"consensus":83.5,"final":83.5},{"key":"gpt-6-astra-pro|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra-pro","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"巷口青箱字半残，童衫欲舍又重看。归来密补襟边绽，不是吾儿也怕寒。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"gpt-6-astra-pro|机场送别|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra-pro","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"临行又把围巾整，隔着玻璃唤小名。直待机身融暮霭，归来屏上两城晴。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"gpt-6-astra-pro|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra-pro","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"铁爪提熊才半尺，翻身跌落笑依然。孩童忍泪揉衣角，却把娘亲小指牵。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"gpt-6-astra-pro|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra-pro","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"巷口梧阴覆铁箱，冬衣洗罢带微香。针痕细密藏灯影，领字依稀记学堂。剪却名签辞故主，留将厚絮御风霜。轻投窄隙浑无响，又待新肩试短长。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{},"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"union-alpha|机场送别|七绝","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"箱轮辘辘催君去，隔着玻璃认口形。铁翼穿云灯渐杳，人声满耳剩叮咛。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.3,"rationale":"送别题旨常见，但箱轮、玻璃、口形使情事具体；由近及远，声光转换贯通。“满耳”与“剩”写出心理反差。“铁翼穿云”稍熟，结句点明叮咛，留白略少。","_cost":0.0458},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.5,"rationale":"机场送别的当代经验有效入诗，'隔玻璃认口形'为独到发现，情事具体可感；铁翼、灯杳、满耳人声皆景语即情语。结句以喧嚷反衬心中叮咛，稍显说破。'隔着'略白话，整体自然有诗眼。","_cost":0.04958},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.1,"rationale":"现代机场送别题材，意象转化妥帖自然。“认口形”细节生动抓人；结句以喧哗人声反衬回响之叮咛，以闹写寂，脉络清晰，余味悠长，是当代经验有效入诗的佳作。","_cost":0.0049335},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"机场送别熟题，箱轮声与隔玻璃认口形具体可感。铁翼穿云稍套。结句直陈叮咛说尽，余味弱。起承尚顺转合平直。当代场景入诗有效。","_cost":0.018936},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"机场送别翻熟题为新境:玻璃隔音、隔窗认口形之细节独到,'认''剩'炼字见眼;起以辘辘声、结以满耳人声中独剩叮咛,声起声结、视听互转,脉络贯注而余响不尽,当代经验入诗自然无痕。","_cost":0.0260644},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.25,"rationale":"当代机场细节入诗，情感集中；意象统一，尾句以声绾合，留有余味。语言平实但\"剩\"字见力，章法完整而转合略直。警句、出新俱佳，无硬伤陈滥蹈袭。","_cost":0.01512266},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"机场送别细节真切，“隔玻璃认口形”新颖动人；由近及远再归余声，脉络清楚。语词大体精当，稍有常见意象与轻微说破。","_cost":0.009172},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"机场送别取境真切，玻璃认口形、灯杳剩叮咛尤警；现代物象入七绝而不隔。结以声衬情，余响足。惟铁翼略熟，开阖尚稳。","_cost":0.014022},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.85,"rationale":"以玻璃认口形、喧中剩叮咛翻新送别俗题，情事具体有焦点；声色意象交融氛围足，转结由远景收束内心，余味悠长；语言平实自然略显白口。","_cost":0.0105395},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"当代机场送别写得具体，'隔着玻璃认口形'精切；起承转合完整。然角度常见，'铁翼穿云'略陈，结句直点叮咛少余味，语感稍杂糅。","_cost":0.02903852},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.65,"rationale":"此作抓取当代机场送别专属细节，隔玻璃认口形、闹境剩叮咛等描写真切具象，章法顺适，语言精准自然，无陈套硬伤，旧题写出现代人的共情新态。","_cost":null}},"consensus":80.88,"final":80.88},{"key":"union-alpha|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"巷口方箱迎暮雪，棉衣叠妥尚余温。临投绽处重缝密，怕有寒风过远村。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.6,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.3,"余味":7.2,"警句":3.3,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.25,"rationale":"以投衣前补缝的细节写对陌生人的体恤，情意具体。由巷口推向远村，转结有开拓；化用“密密缝”母题贴切。“临投”句稍显挤迫，末句点明关怀，含蓄略逊。","_cost":0.04234},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"当代题材真切入诗，投衣前补缝一事具体可感，“余温”双关，末句由针线推想远村寒风，宕开有致。语言平实少斧凿但诗眼不甚突出，转结略带说明。","_cost":0.04749},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.8,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.5,"rationale":"化用母爱典故入当代慈善之题，情真意切。三句动作细腻，结句宕开至远村，由己及人，余味温厚绵长。","_cost":0.004755},"grok-4.6":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"捐赠前缝补写推己及人，情事具体有主脑。暮雪余温与远村寒风交融尚可。转句见用心，结句点破“怕有”偏直。语言通顺少诗眼。回收箱入诗自然。","_cost":0.016258},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.85,"rationale":"以方箱暮雪与棉衣余温形成冷暖对照，细节真切；后两句化用游子吟而另辟捐衣语境，转结有情。结句以怕寒风过远村收束，留有余虑。唯暮雪、寒风等意象稍熟。","_cost":0.01408308},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.75,"rationale":"捐衣小事翻出新境，情事具体可感；'密'字为诗眼，缝补细节见真。暮雪对余温、近巷对远村，冷暖远近相映，起承转合严整，结句宕开留白。回收箱当代经验入诗自然无痕，未见硬伤与袭用。","_cost":0.01810236},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.3,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.55,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱入诗，细节具体，缝衣寄远有温厚之意。暮雪余温与寒风远村相映，转结自然；唯‘临投’稍硬，末句心理略直，意象未全新。","_cost":0.011124},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"以回收箱俗物起，余温与暮雪成冷暖对照；临投重缝为真转，结句“怕有寒风过远村”宕开生情、言外有仁。第三句稍密，临雪缝补略乖事理，然诗性可容。","_cost":0.0210672},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.7,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.7,"rationale":"暮雪方箱与余温对照，临投重缝一细节见仁心，宕至远村寒风，今物入诗，冷暖交融，一气收束，余味悠长。","_cost":0.00741025},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.9,"rationale":"化用“临行密密缝”写捐衣前重缝，当代经验入诗、情事具体；意象妥帖稍常见，结句以寒风远村宕开，余味未尽。无硬伤陈滥蹈袭。","_cost":0.027159435},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.5,"rationale":"抓取投旧衣前重缝绽口的细处落笔，将恤寒暖意藏于平实动作，起承转合圆融，意象冷暖相映，语淡情真，当代事物入诗自然，余韵悠长。","_cost":null}},"consensus":86.25,"final":86.25},{"key":"union-alpha|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"巷口青箱开窄隙，谁将旧暖寄他乡。襟边密线留灯影，领内疏绒带皂香。昨日犹嫌双袖短，明朝或抵五更凉。轻推铁板浑无语，一寸余温路尚长。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.1,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"以旧衣联通施受双方，针线、皂香使情意具体；颈联由己及人，今昔冷暖转换有力。“旧暖”凝练，“浑无语”稍熟，结句虽向远处拓开，“路尚长”仍略泛。","_cost":0.04087},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.5,"rationale":"当代旧衣回收箱入诗,以\"旧暖寄他乡\"立主脑,颔联针线灯影、疏绒皂香细节精切,颈联昨日袖短与明朝五更凉时空对照有力,结句以余温、路长收束略近说破而尚留余地。\"浑无语\"稍显填凑。","_cost":0.03938},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.4,"语言":8.4,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"当代日常经验入诗极贴切自然。颔联物象具体生动，颈联由“袖短”之惜转入“更凉”之祈，翻转极巧且深具温情。尾联轻推铁板以动作收束，余温绵长。","_cost":0.0059445},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"旧衣回收入律，主脑清楚，颔联灯影皂香融情于物，颈联今昔对照见思。语言通顺有小炼而未臻诗眼。结句点明余温路长，收束稳而偏直。器物出新有效，稍杂熟语。","_cost":0.0367},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.3,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.1,"rationale":"以旧物寄温情，立意当代且情感具体；“旧暖”“余温”炼字得力；中二联开合有致；尾联以景收束留有余味。唯意象略熟，结句稍直，瑕不掩瑜。","_cost":0.0107118},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.5,"rationale":"以回收箱入律，'旧暖'为诗眼，暗化游子吟而归于当代善举，立意独到。中二联一察物、一及人，昔今开合分明。结以一寸余温对长路，宕开留白，言尽意不尽。颈联'嫌短''抵凉'反差可摘。微瑕：青箱、铁板语近实录，意境稍坐实。","_cost":0.02635336},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.4,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.6,"rationale":"取材旧衣回收箱，密线、皂香等细节真切，颈联由己及人，情志温厚；语言自然略有熟语，结句稍直而仍有余味。","_cost":0.011306},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱写人情冷暖，题新而情实。中二联密线灯影、疏绒皂香，触觉嗅觉交融；颈联'犹嫌袖短'翻作'或抵五更凉'，转念见仁心。结句以物无语、余温路长收，留白有度。稍憾'他乡''旧暖'语近熟，气象未大开。","_cost":0.0069108},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.80000000000001,"rationale":"以旧暖余温为核切入青箱，密线皂香具体可感，昨日明朝我他一转，轻推无语以景结情；当代物象自然入律，无陈滥硬伤。","_cost":0.011073},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.5,"rationale":"以七律写现代旧衣回收箱，取象精切（密线留灯影、疏绒带皂香），中二联由物痕转至今昔之用，尾联余温路长留白。惟送暖角度稍常见，故立意略平。","_cost":0.030579979},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.65,"rationale":"以当代旧衣回收箱入诗，立意温厚真切，围绕旧衣传温铺展，意象细腻，颔颈联精工，转合自然，结句有余韵，语言妥帖，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null}},"consensus":85.91,"final":85.91},{"key":"union-alpha|机场送别|七律","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"夜雨初收客未眠，长廊送汝到关前。箱轮碾碎叮咛语，闸影平分咫尺天。两掌临窗空欲合，千言隔障竟难传。航灯渐没苍茫里，指印纵横淡似烟。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":true,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":0.75,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"unknown"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.6,"章法":7.2,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.6,"rationale":"机场细节使送别具体，箱轮、闸影与指印贯串情境；“碾碎叮咛”有力，末句以残痕留情。颈联复写阻隔，层次稍滞；“咫尺天”略显雕琢，“苍茫”“似烟”稍熟。","_cost":0.03886},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.0,"rationale":"以箱轮、闸影、玻璃隔窗、指印等当代机场物象写送别，取象精切，“碾碎叮咛”“指印淡似烟”可摘。中二联颈联两句意近稍叠，颔颈层次略平；结句以景收情有余味，惟“苍茫”“千言难传”等语略熟。","_cost":0.06033},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.4,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.25,"rationale":"当代机场送别题材处理极佳。颔联以箱轮、闸影写阻隔，极具张力；尾联由航灯苍茫宕开，复收归于舷窗指印，以微物结深情，虚实相生，当代经验入律自然典雅。","_cost":0.00421575},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"机场送别以箱轮、闸影、指印等现代细节入律，情事具体、意象与离情尚能交融。颔联稍见炼意，结以淡烟有余韵。然题旨仍属常见送别，章法承转平直，语言通顺而整体锤炼有限。","_cost":0.025324},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.5,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.75,"rationale":"机场送别翻新出奇，紧扣“隔”字：箱轮、闸影、玻璃掌印等现代意象精切交融。中二联由声光到触觉递进，结句以航灯、指印景结，余味不尽。警句“箱轮碾碎叮咛语”等出彩，无硬伤陈套。","_cost":0.01365012},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.5,"rationale":"机场送别熟题翻新境，情事具体、焦点（闸窗之隔）贯通；箱轮、闸影、指印皆景语即情语，碾碎、平分、纵横见诗眼。中二联同写'隔'与'难传'，开合层次稍平。结以指印淡烟收，以景结情，言尽意不尽。","_cost":0.01913716},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.8,"警句":4.2,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.2,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.35,"rationale":"机场送别取象新颖，箱轮、闸影、航灯与隔窗掌印贴合离情，颔颈联工巧有诗眼；但夜雨、千言、苍茫稍熟，情绪略直，故小幅扣分。","_cost":0.009848},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"以安检闸机、箱轮、玻璃指印等当代物象翻新旧送别题,情事具体、焦点集中。颔颈两联景语即情语,'碾碎''平分'炼字见力;结句指印淡似烟,以景结情余韵悠长。唯首联稍平,'叮咛语''千言'意有重复,语言密度可再榨。","_cost":0.012510644886416},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.9,"意境":7.9,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.7,"rationale":"当代机场送别以隔障为焦点，情感具体真挚；闸影箱轮等现代意象与离情交融统一；中二联递进有层次，末以指印淡烟景结情，留白隽永。","_cost":0.0092565},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.5,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.5,"rationale":"以机场安检、隔窗等当代经验写传统别情，熟题翻新。箱轮、闸影、指印等意象精切交融，炼字有‘碾碎’‘淡似烟’诗眼。脉络清晰，结句以航灯没、指印淡收束，余韵绵长。唯‘箱轮’略白、‘客’字稍歧，故未满分。","_cost":0.022600956},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.25,"rationale":"此作写当代机场送别，取象精切，炼字见功，章法顺贯，结句以指印淡痕留白，“箱轮碾碎叮咛语，闸影平分咫尺天”联亮眼，融当代经验自然，无硬伤陈套。","_cost":null}},"consensus":87.24,"final":65.43},{"key":"union-alpha|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"铁爪悬空隔水晶，毛熊欲起又斜倾。囊中硬币都投尽，小手牵衣唤一声。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.85,"rationale":"抓取失手、硬币投尽，末转小手牵衣，由物及人，脉络清楚。结句不写所唤内容，留有情绪回响。当代场景入诗自然，但立意尚属常见；“水晶”略泛饰，第三句稍直白。","_cost":0.04092},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"当代经验入诗，一物一事写得具体可感，起承转合清楚。次句“欲起又斜倾”状物真切，结句止于牵衣一唤而不说破所唤何语，有留白。惟“水晶”代玻璃稍隔，“都投尽”偏白，情思仍止于寻常父子小景，未见更深翻转。","_cost":0.0478},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.3,"rationale":"成功将当代经验化入绝句，物象融洽无生造感。“欲起又斜倾”摹态逼真，转结起承自然。结句以纯白描收束，动作传神且留白丰厚，生活温情与童趣跃然纸上。","_cost":0.00560025},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入七绝，孩童未得而牵衣一唤，场景具体。斜倾传神，结句留白。语言文白夹杂后两句偏直，结构由机及人尚顺。","_cost":0.01646},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.7,"语言":8.6,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.4,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.55,"rationale":"当代日常入诗，转结由物及人，结句以动作留白，余味足；前二句景情稍隔，语言自然少废字。","_cost":0.0077560758},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入七绝，当代经验化得自然；'隔'字立屏障，铁爪、毛熊欲起又斜倾取象精切；三句转入人事，结以牵衣一唤收束，留白有味。语言稍平，立意止于白描，警句略欠。","_cost":0.01805716},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.7,"rationale":"以铁爪、毛熊、硬币等细节写抓娃娃，场景生动，结句牵衣唤声留白有余情。语言自然但“水晶”略泛，转合清楚。","_cost":0.010462},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"当代题材化俗为雅：「隔」「欲起又斜倾」摹形传神，可望难即之意自出；「投尽」逼出困境，转结有力；结句小手牵衣不点破，温情与酸楚俱在。唯「水晶」稍取巧，主旨止于小温情，未更深掘。","_cost":0.0250479},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.3,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.45,"rationale":"截取当代日常切片，情事具体可感；起承写机承转写尽兴，转结以小手牵衣宕开，由冷机械转暖人情，留白有味。","_cost":0.011461},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"现代题材入七绝，场景真切；取象妥帖而情韵稍浅，三句转稍平直，结句以未明之唤留白，余味尚可。语言通顺，偶有生动。无硬伤蹈袭，稍有出新。","_cost":0.032449882},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"此作撷取孩童抓娃娃的当代日常片段，状物精准，脉络顺畅，结句以牵衣动作留白，富生活气息，新题材入诗自然，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null}},"consensus":78.84,"final":78.84},{"key":"union-alpha|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"瓦缶新栽三寸韭，层楼只借一方晴。邻家隔网分莴苣，未记门牌已识名。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.4,"余味":7.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.15,"rationale":"以天台种菜写都市邻情，细节具体，题旨集中。“一方晴”炼字见巧，“隔网分莴苣”由景入事，转承自然。末句以门牌与姓名相对照，收束有情趣，但点题较明，留白稍少。","_cost":0.04117},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"以天台种菜写都市邻里，题材新、情事具体。'层楼只借一方晴'借字精切，隔网分菜转出人情，结句以'门牌'与'名'对照点出都市疏离中的暖意，唯稍说破，留白略欠。语言自然少斧凿。","_cost":0.0446},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.65,"rationale":"切入当代都市天台种菜生活，充满烟火温情。“网”与“门牌”等现代物象化用妥帖，章法一气呵成。转结由物及人，以“未记门牌已识名”破除都市人际隔阂，余韵悠长。","_cost":0.0052455},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"都市天台种菜邻里情具体可感主脑明，角度常见。意象生活化罗列氛围浅。语言通顺「只借一方晴」稍炼。章法起承转合完整转平。结句点破识名过直少留白。当代经验入诗有效。","_cost":0.023756},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"都市天台种菜，由种韭借晴到隔网分莴苣、未记门牌已识名，现代邻里情味具体；“只借”见炼字，语言平实；转结留白有余味。无硬伤陈袭。","_cost":0.01235121},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.25,"rationale":"都市天台种菜入诗,翻田园旧题为新境;'借'字为眼,'层楼只借一方晴'摘出仍警;结句以门牌与识名之反差宕开,言尽意不尽;起承转合完足,由物及人层次分明;取象精切少废字;无硬伤陈滥。","_cost":0.02155476},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.1,"rationale":"天台种菜、隔网分蔬，细节新鲜，城市人情小而真切。起承转合自然，末句以门牌与姓名对照收束，有余味；语言清顺，略少锤炼力度。","_cost":0.00723},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"城市天台种菜、隔网分菜识邻，当代经验入诗，熟题翻新、人情焦点明确；瓦缶层楼意象真切但氛围未臻浑然；语言平白自然，'三寸''一方'对仗见巧思；结句'未记门牌已识名'有温度有转折，然略近道破，余延宕不深。","_cost":0.00723438},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.9,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"天台瓦缶种韭、隔网分莴，当代都市生活入诗，真切具体；物象精切氛围温煦，转合由物及人，结句以事寓情，含蓄有余味。","_cost":0.00797975},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"都市天台种菜题材新颖，瓦缶、借晴、隔网分莴苣等意象鲜活；‘借’字见锤炼。起承转合稳妥，结句直陈识名忘门牌，稍直白，余味中等。无硬伤蹈袭，当代经验入诗有效。","_cost":0.026393296},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"此诗写都市天台菜园的日常邻谊，立意有当代新意，意象贴实，语言通顺有炼字，章法顺畅，结句见人际微温，无陈套硬伤，于细碎日常见真切人情。","_cost":null}},"consensus":82.21,"final":82.21},{"key":"union-alpha|天台菜园|七律","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"《天台菜园》\n负土登楼开寸圃，瓜藤越槛趁斜阳。盆留宿雨葱根润，架透朝晖豆荚长。脚底车声催客急，畦头露气浸衣凉。携篮叩户分青韭，换得层城一缕香。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.4,"余味":7.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.55,"rationale":"由负土开圃写至分韭睦邻，都市耕作有具体情味。车声与露气对照见佳，章法层层推进。语言稳健而警拔稍欠；结句以香寄情，有余韵，但“层城”略显泛大。","_cost":0.03667},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"都市天台种菜入诗，题材有当代经验，中二联“脚底车声”与“畦头露气”高下对照见巧思，尾联分韭换香有人情温度。惟斜阳、朝晖、露气时序杂陈略失照应，“换得”稍说破，结句余味中上。","_cost":0.05728},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.65,"rationale":"当代都市天台经验入诗，真切鲜活。颈联以车声与露气对比，高下反差极佳。结句以分韭睦邻收束，化冷漠为温情，脉络清晰。颔联意象略近熟套，结句稍白，但整体清新自然。","_cost":0.00762675},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.0,"rationale":"天台种菜入城居，负土分韭细节可感，颈联车声露气对照见意。意象仍多园圃常语，炼字通顺少诗眼，结句点破“一缕香”收束偏直。","_cost":0.0178},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"城市天台种菜，情事具体，对比车声与露气，结句分韭换香有余味。中二联开合有致，炼字精当，唯立意角度稍常见。","_cost":0.00665808},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.75,"rationale":"都市天台寸圃入七律，当代经验与旧体浑融，立意聚焦'分青韭换香'。颈联脚底车声对畦头露气，俯仰间城园两界，最见匠心；结句'层城一缕香'虚实留白。微瑕：首联斜阳与颔联朝晖时间略杂揉，颔联句法稍平。","_cost":0.01942556},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":7.7,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.89999999999999,"rationale":"天台种菜取材新颖，盆雨架晖细切有生活气，车声露气相生，结以分韭换香留余味；语言清顺，少斧凿，但尾联略平，警句未足。","_cost":0.012856},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.1,"语言":6.7,"章法":7.9,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.45,"rationale":"以层城寸圃切入都市微田园，主脑集中；上下对照成境，颔联略平板；中二联由物及境对比分明，转合有致；结句分韭换香收束完整而稍实。","_cost":0.0102915},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"以天台菜园写城市田园，题旨集中、角度较新；颔联盆雨架晖意象精切，颈联脚底车声与畦头露气开合有致；结句分韭换香以事作结，略有余味。然情致偏浅，语言稳而少警策，香字收束稍熟。","_cost":0.021606873029278},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.25,"rationale":"都市屋顶种菜题材入律，当代经验有效，章法完整；中二联写景略平、意象稍常，语言偶有活字。结句分韭换香，余味尚可。","_cost":0.02553429},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"写都市天台菜园闲趣，融当代城居经验于传统田园书写，章法转合有致，颈联忙闲对照见巧，结句留韵，唯部分意象稍熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":78.39,"final":78.39},{"key":"union-alpha|云端相册|七绝","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"云端旧照贮斜晖，指底庭花拂母衣。欲唤屏中人转面，炊烟不动燕初飞。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.7,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.6,"rationale":"云端、指底将数字相册融入怀亲之情；“欲唤”转出痴意，结以静止炊烟与初飞燕影，凝住欲动未动的瞬间。“贮斜晖”稍显雕琢，佳处多赖全篇映发，独摘警策略弱。","_cost":0.03648},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"以云端相册写思母，当代经验入诗自然。指底拂衣双关触屏与恋慕；转句欲唤人转面，结以炊烟不动、燕止初飞，以定格之景写不可回之憾，不说破而恸。斜晖炊烟稍熟，转面微硬。","_cost":0.04715},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.2,"rationale":"将当代触屏看云端旧照的体验化入诗中，自然无隔阂。转结尤佳，“炊烟不动”点出相片定格之实，以静衬悲，唤而不得的怅惘尽在景中，余味绵长。","_cost":0.0047955},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.5,"rationale":"云端怀母、欲唤转面有焦点，情事具体而题旨仍常见。贮晖拂衣与炊烟凝滞成境，燕飞稍熟。结句以景对照不说破。屏中入诗算出新，指底一句意脉略挤。","_cost":0.029502},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.2,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.4,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.5,"rationale":"云端相册写怀母，情事具体，虚实相生；转结以景收束，欲唤不得，情隐于炊烟燕飞之间，余味悠长。意象精切，唯炊烟燕飞略熟。","_cost":0.01495362},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":96.5,"rationale":"云端、指底、屏中人把数字经验无痕织入思亲旧题，立意翻新而情事具体。三句欲唤是转，四句烟凝燕滞以景结情，一瞬悬停，余味最佳；炼字净洁少废字。警句在结联。","_cost":0.02959396},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.3,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.15,"rationale":"云端怀母，触屏与斜晖、庭花、炊烟相融，转结以景留白。‘贮’‘拂’见炼意，末句有余韵；现代语入诗自然，稍凭常见旧照意象。","_cost":0.010312},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"以云端旧照看怀亲,熟题翻出新境,情事具体有主脑。'欲唤屏中人转面'警策动人,结句'炊烟不动'暗写照片凝固、以景结情,余韵悠长。'指底'略生,斜晖燕飞稍熟,但整体交融、当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.010502851827758},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.6,"rationale":"云端指底屏中人将数字经验有效入诗，虚实交生；欲唤转面情挚具体，末句以炊烟不动对燕初飞静动留白，景语即情语。","_cost":0.00865405},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.5,"rationale":"数字经验入诗，立意聚焦旧照凝滞时光与唤母不应之怅；起承转合清畅，结句以不动炊烟、燕初飞锁住画面，余韵深长。炼字精警，屏中人稍白，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.032502403},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":8.1,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.1,"rationale":"以云端相册这一当代日常写思亲旧题，触屏如拂母衣的细节真切，章法顺畅，以景结情余味悠长，唯部分意象稍常见。","_cost":null}},"consensus":89.35,"final":89.35},{"key":"union-alpha|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"舷窗俯见一城明，岸曲桥横认旧程。忽有流云遮故巷，归心却向暗中行。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.9,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.4,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.15,"rationale":"以云遮故巷反衬归心不受遮阻，夜航经验与乡情结合自然，明暗转换推动情景深入。“向暗中行”兼写行程与心路，结有余意；“认旧程”稍泛，前联炼字尚欠鲜活。","_cost":0.03122},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰归乡为当代经验有效入诗，明城与暗巷对照统一，第三句流云遮巷转得自然，结句归心逆向暗处有反差之味。惟“认旧程”稍生涩，“归心”直点略显说破，整体稳健而未臻惊警。","_cost":0.04246},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.9,"rationale":"现代夜航经验有效入诗，视角独特。转结尤见章法，前三句明暗交叠，结句‘归心却向暗中行’以虚带实、反跌有力，拓出别样情境，真挚耐读。","_cost":0.00416625},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"熟题归思，夜航俯瞰角度具体但未见独到翻新。夜灯、曲岸、流云、故巷取象妥帖成氛，交融中上。语言通顺有炼，文白微杂。章法起承转合完整转折较直。结句暗行未说尽，略具余味。","_cost":0.042676},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.0,"rationale":"夜航归思题旨清晰，转结以云遮故巷引出归心向暗，稍见新意。意象统一，语言凝练，“暗中行”双关耐味。唯前二句稍熟，整体未脱常见归乡框架。","_cost":0.00808534},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.75,"rationale":"夜航经验入诗出新，全篇以明暗两字撑起：起见城明，承认旧程，转忽云遮，结归心暗行，转结得法、一气贯注。“认”“遮”见炼字之功。惟“归心”微露直白，空中辨故巷稍涉牵强；三四句摘出仍动人。","_cost":0.01536996},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰角度较新，由城明、桥岸认旧程到云遮故巷，转接自然。归心入暗有余意，但稍直，语象稳妥未至精警。","_cost":0.007306},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写归心，当代视角有效；明暗对照与云遮故巷构成转折，结句向暗中行留白有余。意象尚属常见，归心略熟，警策未至化境。","_cost":0.009724131101654},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.9,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.89999999999999,"rationale":"舷窗夜航切入当代，明暗对比收束归心，转合自然有焦点；句法平实欠锤炼，一城明略泛，但暗中行余味足。","_cost":0.00920325},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰之现代经验写归思，起承转合清晰，‘云遮故巷’一转见巧；然意象稍常规，结句点‘归心’略直，语言平稳，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.032804192},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"此作写夜航临归的乡思，起承转合顺畅，语词自然，以当代机上俯瞰视角入诗，'流云遮巷''归心暗行'对照见巧，但立意未脱羁旅归思常轨，余味稍浅。","_cost":null}},"consensus":76.99,"final":76.99},{"key":"union-alpha|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"《夜航俯瞰》：夜半云开千嶂黑，舷窗忽涌一川明。桥收细火分双线，水截繁灯作两城。地上悲欢俱隐去，图中聚落各标名。微光欲没犹回首，不识何人梦未成。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":null,"coef":0.75,"duizhang":[],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.4,"余味":6.8,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.6,"rationale":"夜航灯火与地图标名相对，转出对无名者的关怀，层次清楚。“水截繁灯作两城”凝练有力；颈联略直露，结句以不知留白，但“梦未成”稍熟，余味有所减弱。","_cost":0.04819},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验有效入诗，'涌''收''截'炼字有力，颔联视觉精切；颈联以地上悲欢与图中标名对照，见抽象俯视与人间温度的张力，为警联。结句以疑问收束，留白尚可，'梦未成'略近熟语。","_cost":0.05476},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.4,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.4,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰之当代经验入诗极贴切自然。颔联摹写俯瞰夜景炼字精警；颈联转为高空视角的疏离哲思，尾联复归对人间个体的温情回眸，起承转合浑然一体，余韵深长。","_cost":0.00524025},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰视角具体，颔联灯火取象精切交融；颈联转地图化人生有层次。结句点破梦境稍尽，情志未翻新境。无硬伤。","_cost":0.017958},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰切入现代经验，颔联炼字警策，以灯水分城状高空视角；颈联转入人间悲欢，结句设问留白。通篇焦点集中，惟颈联稍直白略损语言韵味。","_cost":0.01602216},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":9.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":96.25,"rationale":"俯瞰取象精切，'涌''收''截'皆见诗眼；颔联状桥灯水城如画，颈联由景入思，一实一虚，脉络贯通；尾以一点微光问而不答，言尽意不尽；飞行经验入旧体自然而能出新，无硬伤陈滥。","_cost":0.02148936},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.4,"语言":8.1,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.4,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰视角较新，桥火水城一联精切有锤炼；由景入思转折自然，结句留白有余。唯悲欢、梦未成稍熟，颈联略直。","_cost":0.01332},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.6,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.1,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.39999999999999,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰化灯火为山河地图，视角新而主脑集中；颔联最警，颈联略抽象，结句由冷观返悲悯，余意较好，唯悲欢、梦未成稍熟。","_cost":0.021449876272731},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.7,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.55,"rationale":"夜航新境切实，中联桥水对仗精切有画面，颈联由景转理以地图对照悲欢，尾联回首问梦留白，意象与情思交融一气。","_cost":0.00859075},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.6,"语言":7.1,"章法":7.4,"余味":8.2,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.7,"rationale":"航空夜瞰取象精新，“桥收”“水截”一联警策；颈联转抽象略平，尾以微光牵出未知梦者，余味绵长。现代语入诗自然，无硬伤蹈袭，惟“标名”“梦未成”稍直白。","_cost":0.027923086},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"此作紧扣夜航俯瞰视角，状景精切，动词锤炼到位，起承转合顺畅，由实景转及人间遥思，现代飞行经验入诗妥帖，唯结句稍直白，无硬伤套袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":87.23,"final":65.42},{"key":"union-alpha|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"夜半荧屏慈母笑，灯前白发几茎新。镜头忽转儿时榻，晒暖棉衾待远人。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.4,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.1,"rationale":"视频场景融入自然，白发、儿时榻与暖衾使亲情具体可感。“镜头忽转”兼作章法转折，结句以物寄情；但“慈母笑”措辞略熟，“待远人”稍点破，留白有限。","_cost":0.04086},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"以视频通话写思亲，镜头转切即诗之转，结以晒暖棉衾之实景收情，含蓄有味，当代经验入诗有效。惟“慈母”“白发几茎”属熟套，前二句稍平，字面欠锤炼。","_cost":0.04662},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.7,"rationale":"当代经验入诗极为自然，“荧屏”“镜头”不显生硬。三句“忽转”章法灵动，引出末句“晒暖棉衾”，细节极具温度与生活感，真切动人；唯前两句语词略见常套。","_cost":0.00635025},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"视频入诗写母慈待归，情真、象切，镜头一转为章法亮点。思亲熟题，结句点破待远人略直，白发棉衾稍陈，今古语夹杂尚可。","_cost":0.01798},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"以视频通话与镜头切换写母爱，构思具体、角度较新；转结以晒被收束，有余味。惟首句偏直白，部分意象常见，语言略平。","_cost":0.01401708},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.5,"rationale":"深夜视频通话入七绝，旧题翻出当代新境。白发几茎、晒暖棉衾取象精切，灯屏冷暖对照成境；镜头忽转兼作章法之转，双关巧妙，结以衾待人、言尽意不尽。唯荧屏、镜头稍带实用语感，立意仍属游子思亲常域。","_cost":0.01502256},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.5,"rationale":"视频入诗自然，母子之情具体真挚；由荧屏白发转到儿时榻、暖衾待远，脉络清晰，结句以物留白。白发远人略熟。","_cost":0.007362},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.64999999999999,"rationale":"以深夜视频切入慈母、白发与旧榻，熟题有当代落点；镜头忽转见章法，结以棉衾待人，余温足。唯慈母、远人语近熟，炼字尚可更紧。","_cost":0.008177929524033},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.1,"意境":7.9,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.7,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.4,"rationale":"借视频镜头翻新慈母题，荧屏白发与晒暖棉衾虚实交融，转接如电影蒙太奇，末句以景结情留余温。","_cost":0.00918675},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"起承转合清晰，结句棉衾待远人温情动人；意象稍熟，语言平实，现代经验入诗有新意。","_cost":0.025941105},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.0,"rationale":"借深夜视频的当代场景写母子亲情，细节真切，起承转合流畅，暖衾待归的细节动人，语言平实，个别语词稍熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":80.59,"final":80.59},{"key":"union-alpha|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"玻璃匣里卧绒羊，一币铿然入暗箱。铁爪徐升牵稚眼，绵躯骤坠冷灯光。轻敲薄壁疑伊痛，细数零钱觉夜长。欲去回头犹软语，明朝接汝晒春阳。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.5,"rationale":"以怜惜绒羊写童心，投币、失手、怜痛、惜别层层推进，冷灯与春阳相映。“疑伊痛”尤见情真；“冷灯光”句法略涩，结句许诺温厚，兼有希望与不忍，留白稍少。","_cost":0.05694},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"当代经验入律有效，绒羊、铁爪、冷灯光取象精切，情事具体。颔联动作、颈联心理层次清楚，'疑伊痛'一句最动人。结句以明朝之约收束，温暖但略近说破，余味稍逊。","_cost":0.03942},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.55,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗之佳作。物象提炼精准，中二联动态与心理刻画入微，将失落化作极度纯真的怜惜。尾联软语抚慰，情味温煦延宕，出新且格调雅正。","_cost":0.005538},"grok-4.6":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"立意寄情抓机绒羊拟人，具体但常见欠深。意境匣爪光阳对照融。语言炼「铿然」「骤坠」「疑伊痛」自然。章法完整转平。结宕开明日约有余味。新事物入诗算出新，无硬伤蹈袭陈滥。","_cost":0.037814},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.1,"rationale":"现代题材入诗，情感真挚具体，意象精切交融，中二联生动传神，结句留白有余味。语言流畅自然，个别处稍直白。无硬伤陈套。","_cost":0.0072204},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":9.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.25,"rationale":"当代经验入七律而浑成：铁爪暗箱之冷与稚眼春阳之暖相映成境，'牵稚眼''疑伊痛'炼字传神，结以春阳宕开，言尽意存。惟依时序平铺，转折稍直，立意温厚而掘之不深。","_cost":0.03059356},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.1,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.9,"rationale":"当代题材入律，抓绒羊一事写得细腻温软。动作与怜意相生，颔联有戏剧感；但“绵躯”“软语”稍显生熟夹杂，结意温暖而略直。","_cost":0.012872},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃写守护与失落，冷光、铁爪、绒羊成统一情境；中联有声色张力，结以明日春阳宕开暖意。伊/汝稍隔，未害大体。","_cost":0.0146352},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.1,"意境":8.8,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.5,"警句":1.6,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"铁爪冷光对绒羊春阳，移情见怜为主脑；取象精切氛围一贯，起落—共情—温诺层次分明；句法自然，结以春阳留白，当代物象入律贴切。","_cost":0.0125005},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入律，题材新而情事真；意象精切，冷暖对照。中二联由事入情，转结自然，颈联尤动人。尾联许诺明朝，宕开留白。语言稍平，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.029142737},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"以当代抓娃娃机日常入律，摹画投币、夹取、坠空、留约全程，共情真挚，意象贴境，脉络圆顺，语浅情柔，惟结句稍欠蕴藉。","_cost":null}},"consensus":86.31,"final":86.31},{"key":"union-alpha|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"《社区食堂》\n巷口厨窗向晚明，餐盘饭软菜汤清。邻翁独住西楼久，食罢犹听隔座声。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"以独居老人食罢留听人声写孤寂与慰藉，情事具体，有当代生活质感。由饭食转入人情，末句“犹听”含蓄有力；次句稍显平直，整体取象妥帖而不奇。","_cost":0.03549},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"当代题材入诗自然，以独居老人食罢犹坐听邻声写孤寂，不点破而情自见，结句留白得法。前二句写实平稳略近白描，转承脉络清楚但无奇变，语言平易少警字，'犹'字见力。","_cost":0.03955},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.15,"rationale":"当代日常经验入诗的佳构。起承白描食堂风味，转引入独居邻翁；结句“食罢犹听隔座声”以极传神的细节动作写尽老人对烟火喧阗的留恋，不着一字孤苦而温情自现，余味深长。","_cost":0.0050535},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.0,"rationale":"社区食堂写孤老日常，情事具体有当代切入；取象平实少交融，语言近口语乏锤炼诗眼，章法完整而转折平直，结句听声略留余意。","_cost":0.0115},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.75,"rationale":"立意从独居翁食后犹听邻座声切入孤独，具体真切。意象统一，转结得力，结句留白佳。语言自然，惜“厨窗”欠稳。警句可摘，“西楼”略陈。","_cost":0.0110022},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"社区食堂写空巢之寂，当代经验入旧体妥帖，'独住'与'隔座声'对照见孤寂中温情，立意具体有发现。'犹'字为诗眼，结句以声宕住，言尽意不尽。起承偏平铺，次句近白描乏锤炼，意境稍家常。","_cost":0.01811536},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.4,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.4,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"写社区食堂日常，饭软汤清与隔座声衬独居老人之寂，有当代人情温度。结以声留白，余味较好；但意象语言偏平直，转折虽顺而少奇。","_cost":0.006704},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"以当代社区食堂写独居老人孤寂，题材出新，情感具体可感。结句'食罢犹听隔座声'以细节见孤独、言外有味，为全篇诗眼。前二句写景叙事平实，'饭软菜汤清'近乎口语、略伤凝练；章法起承转结完整但二句稍弱。无蹈袭硬伤。","_cost":0.00959148},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.3,"意境":5.6,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.2,"余味":7.6,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.85,"rationale":"以社区食堂观照独居之孤，切口小而真切；结句“犹听”以行为写孤寂，留白有味。前两句白描平实，意象锤炼与交融不足，章法平铺直进。","_cost":0.00748955},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"写独居老人于社区食堂，题材新、焦点集中；结句‘食罢犹听隔座声’以事留白，余味长。意象平实，‘餐盘’等语略白，语言中上；起承转合稳。无硬伤蹈袭，有新意。","_cost":0.026396289},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"撷取社区食堂日常细节，聚焦独居老人的淡寂心境，语言平实精准，意象妥帖，脉络顺畅，结句以细节留余味，融入当代生活经验，无硬伤陈套。","_cost":null}},"consensus":78.67,"final":78.67},{"key":"union-alpha|云端相册|七律","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":null,"consensus":null,"final":null},{"key":"union-alpha|深夜视频|七律","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"《深夜视频》\n夜静荧屏通故里，灯前白发问归期。\n声迟半拍犹含笑，手隔玻璃欲抚儿。\n悄转机身遮药碗，轻拈趣事解愁眉。\n余音忽断人无语，掌上微温尚护持。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.5,"rationale":"声迟、隔屏与遮药碗使亲情具体可感，中二联由欲亲近转入藏忧解愁，结以掌温留住牵挂。白发问归较熟，“轻拈趣事”“尚护持”略显雕琢。","_cost":0.0616},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"以视频通话翻新思亲熟题，声迟半拍、隔屏欲抚、转机遮药碗等细节真切可感，当代经验入诗有效。颈联主语略含混，结句掌上微温留白有味而“护持”稍直，白发问归期等偶带套语。","_cost":0.05884},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.95,"rationale":"当代经验入诗之典范。抓取网速延迟、转机遮药等生活细节，精准传神。颔颈两联情致入微，尾联借手机余温结穴，余味悠长。物象化用妥帖自然，全无滞涩生造之弊。","_cost":0.006519},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.5,"rationale":"熟题视频思亲，半拍遮药等细节具体，颈联转出隐瞒有力。结句余温留白。语言平实有亮点，白发归期略陈。章法贯通无硬伤袭用。","_cost":0.030472},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.75,"rationale":"以视频通话入律诗，当代经验与旧体形式浑融无碍。'手隔玻璃欲抚儿''悄转机身遮药碗'细节精切，白发藏病、趣事解愁，情感具体真挚。结句'掌上微温尚护持'以物结情，言尽意不尽，余味深长。中二联开合有致，通篇一气贯注。","_cost":0.0029952},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.6,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.4,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.85000000000001,"rationale":"视频通话细节真切，镜头感强；颔联声迟、隔屏抚儿尤佳，中二联写双向隐瞒与安慰；尾联以掌温收束，留有余味。语言偶见生新而未至圆熟。","_cost":0.01332482},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.9,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.9,"rationale":"深夜视频切入亲情，延迟、遮药碗、断线余温等细节真切，当代经验入诗较自然。脉络清晰，结以微温留白；唯白发归期、愁眉稍熟，个别词略直。","_cost":0.014776},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"以视频通话写亲恩,遮药碗、隔屏抚儿皆具体可感,细节即深情;“声迟半拍”精准捕捉延迟,“掌上微温”以物结情、言尽意不尽。中二联层次递进,结句宕开有余韵。唯“问归期”“解愁眉”稍熟,整体当代经验入律自然而不猎奇。","_cost":0.0117198},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.9,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.2,"rationale":"以视频通话翻新思亲旧题，声迟半拍、悄遮药碗、掌上微温等细节真切，隐忧温情并蓄；取象精切，章法贯通，末句以温留白，余味不尽。","_cost":0.0069185},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"以深夜视频写亲情，问归期等稍熟，但遮药碗、隔玻璃抚儿等细节具体，当代经验入诗；结句掌上微温含蓄有余味；语言偶有套语，章法完整。","_cost":0.033033953},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.4,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.2,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.95,"rationale":"以当代深夜视频通话场景写亲子双向体恤的深挚亲情，卡顿、遮药碗等细节鲜活，章法浑成，结有余韵，无陈套硬伤，当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":null}},"consensus":86.01,"final":86.01},{"key":"union-alpha|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"病树悬瓶倚粉墙，尘风卷絮过斜阳。银针入骨春难醒，细管垂空液淡黄。厚甃封根遮宿雨，高楼蔽日减晴光。行人只道花期晚，又问何时好纳凉。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"借病树输液写城市生境与人的功利目光，取材具体。由病状转病因，再以行人问语反讽，层次清楚。“春难醒”有力；“蔽日减晴光”语意稍复，结句讽意较露，延宕有限。","_cost":0.05092},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"取当代街树输液入诗，视角新，主脑清晰。颔联银针细管写实贴切，颈联揭因，尾联借行人问纳凉反讽而不说破，有余味。惟“液淡黄”“减晴光”稍平，“尘风卷絮过斜阳”略近套语，炼字未至精警。","_cost":0.06566},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.5,"rationale":"当代经验入律极自然切合。颈联深挖病由，揭示城市对自然的压抑；尾联以行人功利之态反衬树之悲凉，冷峻讽喻，余味深长。脉络井然，炼字精切。","_cost":0.004554},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.5,"rationale":"吊瓶病树写都市生态与人树隔膜，角度较新、主脑清楚。医景意象尚切，颈联点因、尾联讽行人，章法完整。然情感偏冷静观察，尾联说破少留白，斜阳絮影等稍常见。","_cost":0.017112},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.4,"语言":8.6,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.7,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.35,"rationale":"以城市病树挂吊瓶寄生态焦虑，切入点新而具体。中二联意象精警，银针、粉墙、楼影等交融出冷峻凉意。结句借行人之问留白，不说破旨意而余味自生。微嫌斜阳、粉墙略熟。","_cost":0.0079584},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"以吊瓶医树写都市生态之殇，熟题新境，主脑鲜明。中二联由树及因（甃封根、楼蔽日）层次井然，'银针入骨春难醒'造语奇警。结句借行人只问纳凉，讽其不省己过，言尽意不尽。'液淡黄'观察精切，通篇物我交融，罕见废字。","_cost":0.0033487875},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.4,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.7,"rationale":"取材城市病树输液，细节真切，颔联有痛感；颈联补写封根蔽日之因，结以行人问花纳凉，余味可寻。个别词略实，转折稍平。","_cost":0.01528},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"借街树挂瓶讽城市伤树、人心漠然，立意新而主脑集中；银针、细管、封根、蔽日统一于'病'境；'春难醒'见诗眼，'液淡黄'略质直；章法由景及因及人层层推进；结以行人问凉，讽刺含蓄，余味足。","_cost":0.0233037},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.7,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.7,"rationale":"以吊瓶喻病树切入城市生态病症，近状远因分层递进，末联借行人误语反讽收束，题旨集中，当代经验入律自然有味。","_cost":0.008409},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"以街树挂吊瓶写城市生态，当代经验入诗，意象新颖；中二联层次分明，结句反讽留白。然语言夹入现代词、结句稍直白，整体未臻高境。","_cost":0.032774682},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"此诗取当代城市行道树挂吊瓶题材，立意新警有现实关照，意象贴合，章法顺畅，炼字见功，结句以行人漠然反衬树境有余味，仅少量传统意象稍熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":83.58,"final":83.58},{"key":"union-alpha|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"长街病树悬瓶立，细管无声续一春。脚下重砖封旧土，还将寸碧赠行人。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.3,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.95,"rationale":"以树木输液切入城市生态困境，细管续生与重砖封土形成张力。“续”“封”有力，第三句转出困境，末句以微绿回应；但“赠行人”拟人寄意较熟，收束略显明白。","_cost":0.03475},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"写城市树木挂吊瓶，当代经验入诗有效，病树输液与重砖封土形成反讽，第三句由上转下有变。'细管无声续一春'凝练可摘。结句'赠行人'情意稍显直白，'悬瓶立'之'立'略凑，整体精切自然，无陈套。","_cost":0.04581},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.75,"rationale":"成功将当代都市树木输液意象入诗。转句揭出生存困境，结句‘寸碧赠行人’翻出微光与温厚情怀，物我互照，脉络清晰，浑融无隔。","_cost":0.00381},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"吊瓶病树是可感的城市场景，奉献主题明确但角度常见。悬瓶、细管、重砖能成境。“续一春”稍见炼字。结句点破赠绿，留白不足。当代实景入诗。","_cost":0.020642},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":94.25,"rationale":"以城市病树挂吊瓶切入，意象新而统一；续字精当，转结由困境到赠绿，余味含蓄。无明显硬伤与蹈袭。","_cost":0.01037256},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"城市吊瓶输液救树是当代新经验入诗，物象精切：瓶、细管、重砖、寸碧层层扣题。结句'还将寸碧赠行人'宕开一笔，以受难者之馈赠收束，言尽意不尽。三句'重砖封旧土'暗含批判而含蓄不露，全篇围绕病树一意贯注。语言稍平，个别句可再炼。","_cost":0.00137522},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.6,"rationale":"以街树输液写城市生态，病树、重砖与寸碧相映，立意具体而温厚。“续”“封”有炼字，转结顺畅；但结句“赠行人”稍说破，余味略减。","_cost":0.007774},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"以城市病树输液入诗,题材新而观察实,'病树—封土—赠碧'层层递进,困境中见奉献,主脑集中。'细管无声续一春'炼字见警,'寸碧'精切。结句稍露题旨,余韵略欠,整体当代经验化入旧体自然无痕。","_cost":0.0123498},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.6,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.7,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.25,"rationale":"病树悬瓶切入当代城市境遇，重砖封土与寸碧相赠对照强烈，物象精切景中含情，转合有力，结句以景收束悲悯犹存。","_cost":0.00773055},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"当代街树输液入诗，角度新鲜；病树悬瓶、细管续春等意象交融，炼字见诗眼。章法转结稳当，结句“赠行人”略直白，余味中等。无硬伤陈滥蹈袭。","_cost":0.029815988},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"此诗捕捉城市行道树挂吊瓶的当代日常，立意具象有新意，意象切当，章法转合自然，语言凝练，无陈套硬伤，唯结句稍直，余韵略欠。","_cost":null}},"consensus":84.95,"final":84.95},{"key":"union-alpha|社区食堂|七律","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"巷口新开小食堂，邻翁拄杖趁斜阳。时蔬一碟分春色，热饭双盘带稻香。壁上餐牌标薄价，窗前老伴话家常。归来未觉空巢冷，几缕人声入夜长。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.1,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.19999999999999,"rationale":"以薄价饭食与邻里人声写空巢慰藉，情事具体，角度稍熟。中联由饭菜推进至人情，尾联转入归后感受；结句以声延情，颇有余韵。春色、稻香等措辞较熟，佳句尚欠警拔。","_cost":0.04223},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"取材当代社区食堂，聚焦空巢老人，题旨具体有焦点。中二联皆平铺白描，餐牌薄价近于说明，开合层次不足。语言朴实通顺，“分春色”稍见炼字。结以人声入夜，以景收情有余韵，惟第七句已先点破“空巢冷”，留白稍减。","_cost":0.05634},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.6,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.3,"rationale":"切中当代老龄民生痛点，笔触温润细腻。中二联叙事平直略欠锤炼，但起承转合自然紧凑；尾联由食入心，以入夜人声消解空巢孤寂，化俗为雅，余味悠长。","_cost":0.00533925},"grok-4.6":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"食堂写空巢暖意，场景具体有主脑，题旨常见。意象妥帖能交融，分春色稍炼。中二联平铺少层次，结句人声宕开有余味，然未觉空巢冷略说破。","_cost":0.022104},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.25,"rationale":"立意具体真切，写社区食堂慰藉空巢老人，有当代生活发现。意象妥帖，语言通顺偶有亮点，章法完整，结句以声收束有余味。中二联稍平直，斜阳、空巢等意象略常见。","_cost":0.005712102},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.5,"rationale":"当代社区养老题材入七律，熟题翻新、情事具体。颔联'分春色''带稻香'炼字见巧，景语情语交融。尾联以人声入夜宕开，言尽意不尽。中二联开合稍平，'话家常'略熟，整体温情贯通、收束有余韵。","_cost":0.00211556},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.3,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.85000000000001,"rationale":"社区食堂与空巢温情写得具体可感，起承转合清楚；细节有当代气息，结以人声留余味。但语词偶见熟套，颈联偏直白。","_cost":0.010276},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.0,"rationale":"以社区食堂写空巢晚晴，题旨真切而角度不新；意象成暖境，语言平顺少锤炼，中二联略实，结句以人声宕开有回味，唯“空巢冷”点题稍直。","_cost":0.014079},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.1,"语言":5.3,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.3,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.85000000000001,"rationale":"拈社区食堂写空巢温暖，题材贴近当下、情志具体有主脑；尾联以声入夜余韵较佳，然中二联流水铺叙，意象语言平实欠锤炼。","_cost":0.008084},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.0,"rationale":"题材聚焦社区食堂与空巢温情，当代经验入诗；意象妥帖，中二联稍平，语多白话；结句以声结情，余味佳。","_cost":0.024698118},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"以社区食堂当代民生小切口，借日常细节传递空巢老人的烟火暖意，脉络顺畅，结句景结留余，语言平实，部分意象稍平，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":74.44,"final":74.44},{"key":"union-alpha|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"云仓夜静带犹鸣，纸上乡关一线明。忽见村名停片刻，推箱不觉手偏轻。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.6,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.7,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.9,"rationale":"以夜班分拣时瞥见村名触发乡思，情事具体，现代场景入诗自然。“手偏轻”以细微动作传情，结而不尽；“一线明”稍虚，二三句信息略有重叠，转折尚可更凝练。","_cost":0.03268},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"云仓夜班扫件见故乡村名，当代经验入诗贴切，情事具体。起承交代场景，转句「忽见」有变，结以「手偏轻」一个动作收情，不说破而味长。「带犹鸣」略生硬，「乡关」稍套，整体流畅有真味。","_cost":0.04317},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.0,"rationale":"当代物流经验入诗的佳构。流水线与扫码细节精切，“一线明”生动传神。后两句一顿一收，以“手偏轻”的微细体验写深厚乡情，克制而余味绵长。","_cost":0.0045105},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"夜仓见村名而手轻，情事具体有主脑；物流入诗翻出乡思新境。意象简明统一，结句含蓄未说破。语言通达有炼字，章法起承转合较顺。乡关稍套但密度低。","_cost":0.019572},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.2,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫写乡愁，取象现代且具体，意与境融。转结由见村名到推箱手轻，用细节含蓄收束，余味足。立意角度较新，语言自然但稍平。","_cost":0.010725198},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":9.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.25,"rationale":"夜班扫描见寄往故乡之村名，推箱手轻：乡愁熟题翻出物流新境，情事具体；'一线明''手偏轻'皆诗眼，结以动作藏情，言尽意不尽；惟二、三句均写见村名，承转微复。加分予警句与当代经验入诗。","_cost":0.01607716},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.6,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.2,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫触发乡愁，取角新；村名、手轻细节真切，收束含蓄。‘一线明’稍泛，转接略直。","_cost":0.011664},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.25,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫寄乡思，题新而情真；“纸上乡关一线明”造境警切，结句“手偏轻”以动作留情，不说破。意象略单，氛围厚度未至极境。","_cost":0.0059406},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.1,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.4,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.9,"rationale":"拣选夜仓见乡名而手轻，以当代分拣经验翻新乡愁旧题，声色触觉层进，转结以轻写重，末句动作代言不说破，余味长。","_cost":0.0093103},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫、见村名写乡愁，当代经验入诗自然，情事具体。起承转合清晰，结句“手偏轻”含蓄有余味。意象新切而稍直白，情志略轻，故各维多在7.5-8.5间；无硬伤陈滥蹈袭，出新满分。","_cost":0.025768044},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.8,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.85,"rationale":"此作写云仓分拣员夜值时瞥见快递单上故乡村名的瞬时触动，以新场景入乡愁旧题，细节真切，章法顺畅，结句以动作藏情留白，语言平实精准，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null}},"consensus":86.37,"final":86.37},{"key":"union-alpha|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"union-alpha","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"云仓彻夜白灯明，四壁频传扫码声。架上冬衣封絮暖，屏中细字列邮程。胶痕满指茶犹冷，铁辊催人月渐横。忽见街名通旧巷，低头又送一箱行。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.10000000000001,"rationale":"胶痕、冷茶与衣暖构成有意味的对照，夜班细节具体；街名触动乡思，转结自然，低头续工含而不露。“封絮暖”“列邮程”稍显雕凑，首联较平。","_cost":0.04128},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"仓储夜班当代经验入诗有效，白灯扫码、絮暖茶冷、铁辊月横取象精切且冷暖相衬；颈联可摘。尾联由包裹街名忽触旧巷乡思，旋即低头送箱，转结有变而不说破，余味绵长。\"列邮程\"稍生硬。","_cost":0.04139},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.7,"rationale":"当代仓储劳动题材，将扫码、铁辊、胶痕等现代物象熔铸无痕。颈联细节写实，尾联瞥见故里街名却低头复工，情绪内敛克制，余味深长。","_cost":0.0050865},"grok-4.6":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"云仓夜班入律，扫码胶痕茶冷等细节具体，尾联旧巷一闪后仍低头续劳，略具人情。意象偏纪实少交融，炼字平实无突出诗眼，结句直叙循环，余味有限。","_cost":0.02049},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"写云仓夜班，取象具体，颈联以胶痕、冷茶、铁辊、月渐横传劳顿与时间感；尾联借旧巷触动乡愁，以动作收束留白。语言偶平实，整体切时而不生造。","_cost":0.00908314},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.5,"rationale":"以当代仓储夜工入诗，取象精切：扫码声、封絮、胶痕冷茶皆实感，景语即情语。中二联人与境开合有层。结句忽见旧巷街名而低头续工，情感收于无言，言尽意不尽，为全诗诗眼。无陈套蹈袭。","_cost":0.00267716},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.7,"余味":8.8,"警句":4.2,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.45,"rationale":"取材电商夜仓，细节真切，白灯扫码、胶痕茶冷写出辛劳；中二联物象与人情相融，尾联旧巷一闪转接，复归低头劳作，留白有余。现代语入诗自然，个别词稍硬。","_cost":0.013226},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"现代物流夜役入诗，白灯扫码与冬衣旧巷冷暖相映；结句俯首续行，劳而不怨，余韵在箱外。字句大体稳，警策未至极。","_cost":0.0132726},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.8,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.1,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫切入物流劳动，细节真切有主脑；胶痕冷茶、铁辊催月等象精切交融，旧巷一瞥低头即行，收束含蓄，当代经验入律自然。","_cost":0.00772525},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.25,"rationale":"以七律写现代仓储夜作，细节真切；颈联凝练，尾联克制有余味。章法完足，语言稍平，无典故常识硬伤。","_cost":0.028003607},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"此诗写当代云仓分拣工夜作场景，细节真切，将瞬逝乡情融入日常劳作，章法顺承清晰，语言质朴准确，无陈套硬伤，结句留白有余味。","_cost":null}},"consensus":86.32,"final":86.32},{"key":"grok-4.7|机场送别|七绝","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"携君直到候机楼，袖底余温未肯休。栏外声声催客切，回身暗认翼光流。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.6,"rationale":"送别题旨常见，胜在“袖底余温”使依恋可感；催客声推进离情，结以翼光留有余韵。机场物象融入自然，但“未肯休”稍熟，“暗认翼光流”凝缩略涩。","_cost":0.03315},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.0,"rationale":"送别熟题移入机场，袖底余温、栏外催声、翼光流三象贯通成当代离情，结句以景收束不说破，有余味。惟起句平铺、'未肯休'稍着力，整体妥帖而未臻警拔。","_cost":0.04472},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.05,"rationale":"当代机场送别写得情真意切，章法脉络清晰。承句细节生动，结句“暗认翼光流”成功将现代航空意象古典化，以景结情，含蓄悠远。","_cost":0.004761},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"送别情真，袖底余温细节动人；结句翼光流以景收束不点破，余味足。立意仍属传统别情，转句稍平。","_cost":0.009243168},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"送别熟题借机场场景翻出新境，'袖底余温未肯休'以体温写离情，具体可感。第三句广播催客作转，结句'暗认翼光流'以景收束，人机俱远而情未尽，言尽意不尽。取象精切，物象与情意交融，当代经验入诗自然无痕。","_cost":0.00149928},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.6,"rationale":"机场入诗，袖底余温与翼光流相映，别情具体；起承转合清晰，结以景收有回味。惜首句稍直，催客语略熟，未臻深警。","_cost":0.010082},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"送别熟题而机场场景出意较新，'袖底余温'细节真切，'暗认翼光流'以景结情，留白有致。起承转合清晰，转结得力。唯'未肯休'略生、'催客切'稍硬，语言锤炼未臻上乘，整体真挚而欠警策。","_cost":0.0112134},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.55,"rationale":"以袖温、翼光写机场离别，情事具体可感，起承转合完整，结句以景结情有余味；唯立意角度常见，语言锤炼未精。","_cost":0.00928425},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"以机场现代场景写传统送别，袖底余温、翼光流取象精切，景语即情；起承转合清晰，结句以翼光流收束，言尽意远。首句稍直白，暗认略涩，无硬伤蹈袭，当代经验入诗有效。","_cost":0.03042574},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.6,"rationale":"此作以当代机场场景写送别怅惘，细节真切，起承转合圆顺，结句以暗认翼光藏情留白，语言精准；唯立意未脱离情常轨，无硬伤陈套，略有新意。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.0,"rationale":"以机场写送别，旧题换新场景，情事具体。袖底余温、催客声、翼光层层递进。结句“暗认翼光流”在众多航灯中辨认，含不舍与茫然，留白可感。起句平直，“未肯休”略显凑韵，炼字尚欠。","_cost":0.017208},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.25,"rationale":"以袖底余温写送别，情意具体；机场翼光使结句留有远望之意。由相携到回身，脉络清楚，但题意较常见，“催客切”“翼光流”稍显费解。","_cost":0.00716}},"consensus":76.91,"final":76.91},{"key":"grok-4.7|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"天台菜园绿阴阴，春雨滋生万绿林。细雨轻烟笼竹径，晨曦映照菜畦深。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":["园"],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":true},"coef":0.75,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.0,"rationale":"菜园春色题旨明确，但缺少独到发现。雨、绿反复，画面尚统一而意象陈熟。“滋生万绿林”搭配生硬，“深”字落点含混。章法平铺，晨曦略作变化；结句以景收束，却少延宕。","_cost":0.03515},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":2.5,"意境":2.5,"语言":2.0,"章法":2.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":20.5,"rationale":"天台小园却言“万绿林”“竹径”，与春雨、晨曦并置，物象失真互矛。“绿”“雨”重复，“滋生”“映照”直白无炼。四句平铺景语，无转无结，无情志主脑，结句凑韵，余味寡淡。","_cost":0.04528},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":4.0,"意境":3.5,"语言":3.2,"章法":3.8,"余味":3.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":34.05,"rationale":"全诗意象拼凑，缺乏真切情志。“绿”“雨”重出，炼字粗疏；天台菜园与“万绿林”“竹径”尺度脱节，烟雨与晨曦逻辑微瑕。转折平直，结句无余味。","_cost":0.00501},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":3.0,"意境":2.5,"语言":2.0,"章法":1.5,"余味":1.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":20.25,"rationale":"四句平列写景，立意空疏，取象常见且时序不一；‘绿’‘雨’重复，炼字欠精；无起承转合，结句直露无余味。无警句与出新，套语较密。","_cost":0.005443232256},"glm-5.3":{"立意":3.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":2.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":2.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":22.0,"rationale":"题为天台菜园，却写'万绿林''竹径'，题意游离且逻辑失真。'绿''雨'各重出两次，废字多、无诗眼。四句平铺写景，起承转合俱无，原地打转。结句直白说景，无余味。通篇套语连缀，密度高，'细雨轻烟'一类皆陈词。","_cost":0.0016525818},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":4.2,"意境":4.4,"语言":3.8,"章法":4.0,"余味":3.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":39.1,"rationale":"题旨明确而平常，多写菜园雨霁之绿；意象统一但绿、雨叠出，略泛。语少锤炼，结句直白，余味有限。","_cost":0.006836},"kimi-k3":{"立意":3.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":2.5,"章法":2.5,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":25.5,"rationale":"天台种菜本有现代生活意趣,惜只作泛泛景物罗列:四句平铺无转合,'绿'字两见、'雨'意重复,'万绿林'状一小园失实,'笼''映照'皆熟套。无人物无情感焦点,结句'菜畦深'平收无余味,通篇形同说明文字。","_cost":0.010818},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":2.8,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.2,"章法":2.2,"余味":2.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":25.6,"rationale":"题无新境仅泛咏菜园之绿；意象以绿阴春雨轻烟竹径陈套堆砌未融为境；语言重复浅白无诗眼；章法四句平铺无转合变化；尾句直白收束言尽无余味。","_cost":0.0075055},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.0,"意境":2.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":32.0,"rationale":"题意明确而角度常见，全篇堆砌绿阴、细雨、晨曦等套语，意象陈滥少真景；语言通顺但多硬凑，转结平直，结句直白无余味。无警句、出新与蹈袭，未见明显硬伤。","_cost":0.028928475},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":3.0,"意境":3.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":31.0,"rationale":"此作泛写菜园春景，情志空泛无主脑，意象多常见套话、取象欠精，语言平俗有重复，章法无转折，平列景语，结句直白无余味，无警句新意，陈词较多。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":2.5,"意境":3.0,"语言":2.5,"章法":2.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":1.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":21.75,"rationale":"通篇写景而无情志主脑。“春雨”与“细雨”、“绿阴阴”与“万绿林”重复。天台上写出“万绿林”“竹径”“菜畦深”，夸张失实；细雨笼罩又写晨曦映照，景象互相矛盾。四句平铺没有转折，结句只是直白写景，没有余味。天台菜园这一当代题材未能写出新意。","_cost":0.015092},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":3.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":33.0,"rationale":"写春日菜园，题旨明确，但绿荫、细雨、轻烟、晨曦多为熟景；两次写雨，层次变化不多。“滋生万绿林”用词生硬，结句止于景物描写，余味较浅。","_cost":0.00806}},"consensus":29.02,"final":21.77},{"key":"grok-4.7|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"蓝箱薄暮纳衣裳，袖口犹沾旧日香。补处仍存灯下迹，襟前不复去年长。随身暖意成远别，隔巷寒宵入异乡。休问后来肩上客，微温续向未知方。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":["远"],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":0.75,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"以旧衣流转写惜物与关怀，袖香、补痕具体含情。“去年长”语意含混，“隔巷”接“异乡”稍显牵强。末联转向陌生受衣者，但结句偏抽象，延宕有限。","_cost":0.04053},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"以回收箱写旧衣离别，题材当代而情事具体；颔联灯下补迹、襟前不长写成长与母爱最切。颈联稍空泛，'未知方'有凑韵感。结句宕开不说尽，尚有余温。","_cost":0.05219},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.3,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.4,"rationale":"成功将当代物象化入七律。颔联从亲情与成长细微处落笔，颈尾联荡开至远方受助者，由私己眷恋升华至对陌生人的善意，结句温润留白，脉络贯通且极具人情味。","_cost":0.005133},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱寄时光流转之物情，细节真切不空谈。意象融合尚佳，中二联有层次。尾联稍直露余味略减。题材与‘微温续向未知方’有当代感。","_cost":0.004982},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.8,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.95,"rationale":"旧衣回收入诗，题旨新而主脑明；袖香补痕等细节真切，脉络由物及人，收束有留白。惜寒宵异乡等语稍熟，尾意微直。","_cost":0.008816},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.25,"rationale":"旧衣捐赠入律诗，题新而情挚，围绕'微温'收束全篇。意象精切（袖香、灯下迹）皆景语即情语。结句'未知方'宕开有延宕。'襟前不复去年长'句法略拗，暗指人长而衣短，稍隔。","_cost":0.00382725},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"旧衣回收的当代题材翻出新境,以袖口余香、灯下补痕等具体物象寄托人与旧物之情,主脑聚焦。中二联开合有序,转联由身及远。结句'微温续向未知方'宕开留白,余味悠长。'襟前不复去年长'语意稍涩,颈联'隔巷寒宵'略虚泛。","_cost":0.00847725},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.05,"rationale":"以回收箱写温情流转，由灯下补迹到未知肩客，立意新而有主脑；薄暮寒宵与微温对照成境，结句宕开留白，余韵不尽。","_cost":0.010215},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"以回收箱写旧衣流转，蓝箱、旧香、灯下补痕意象具体；尾联微温续向未知方，含蓄有余味。中二联由静转动，惟‘襟前’句及‘续向’稍拗，语言因之扣分，无蹈袭硬伤。","_cost":0.035288527},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.1,"rationale":"这首以当代旧衣回收箱入诗，紧扣旧衣的私人记忆与微温传递，意象贴实，章法顺畅，语淡情真，结句有余韵，唯部分意象稍熟，个别词句略涩。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱写物与人的离别,当代题材切入有新意。颔联以补痕、襟短暗写亲情与成长,含蓄可感,是全篇亮点。颈联'成远别'略显生硬,与尾联同写温暖远去,稍有重复。结句宕向未知,有余意,但'微温续向'稍嫌说明。","_cost":0.020496},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.15,"rationale":"蓝箱、袖口与补痕使旧衣承载具体记忆，再由近身旧事推向未知去处，脉络清楚。“肩上客”“未知方”略显刻意；结句有留白，也稍直白。","_cost":0.011746}},"consensus":79.22,"final":59.42},{"key":"grok-4.7|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"黄昏小巷旧棉裘，暗扣犹含去岁秋。箱口斜斜垂敝袖，来年雪里覆肩头。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.1,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.1,"rationale":"暗扣、敝袖使旧物有情，末句由眼前弃置转向来年赠暖，时空转换自然。回收题材落实于细物，有新意；“含去岁秋”稍显泛化，结尾虽留受赠者不写，愿景仍较明白。","_cost":0.03677},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"题材当代而不猎奇，暗扣含秋一句以细物系时间，敝袖垂箱口有拟人之感；转结由眼前跳向来年雪里他人肩头，以想象景收，温厚有余韵。惟意思偏于说全，语言妥帖而少奇警，黄昏小巷起句略常。","_cost":0.0524},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.9,"rationale":"当代生活经验有效入诗的佳作。以暗扣、敝袖等微观细节见真情，转结由弃置物象宕开至雪夜送暖，充满悲悯温情，起承转合浑然天成，结句余味悠长。","_cost":0.00479625},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.8,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":7.8,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.6,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱入诗，角度当代而有情味；“暗扣含秋”精警，结句由实入虚，以雪中覆肩留白，余味绵长。章法转处稍平，但整体凝练无套语。","_cost":0.00663795},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.75,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱这一当代事物入诗自然无痕，捐衣之情不直说而处处可感。'暗扣犹含去岁秋'以一含字串物我，是诗眼亦是警句。起承转合清晰，结句'来年雪里覆肩头'宕开一笔悬想受衣者，以温念收束，言尽意不尽。意象精切统一，惟'黄昏小巷'稍熟，通篇无硬伤无袭。","_cost":0.0036574},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.8,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.7,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.19999999999999,"rationale":"以回收箱写旧物循环，暗扣含秋、敝袖垂箱皆细切；结想来年雪中覆肩，有温度而稍直，转折略平。","_cost":0.012574},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"以回收箱旧衣贯通去岁与来年，弃物转为他人雪中暖，主脑集中；暗扣含秋、敝袖垂箱意象精切，结句宕开不说破。惜中幅略平，雪巷黄昏根基仍近常见，未臻化境。","_cost":0.0148308},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.8,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.95,"rationale":"旧箱小题寄温情不说教，暗扣含秋、敝袖斜垂、雪覆肩头三时一线，景即是情，结句宕向未来，余温不尽。","_cost":0.00952725},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.5,"rationale":"取象新切，回收经验入诗自然；“去岁秋”“来年雪”勾连时间，结句以未来景留白。起承转稍平，语较质朴，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.033673364},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"该作咏旧衣回收箱，抓取暗扣、垂袖等细节，融旧岁余温与来朝送暖的期许，脉络平顺，用字工巧，无陈套硬伤，结句淡有余韵。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.5,"rationale":"以回收箱写旧衣流转、暖意传递，当代题材有效入诗。“暗扣犹含去岁秋”藏记忆于细物，颇见巧思；“斜斜垂敝袖”形象可感。第三句仍是写景，转意不足。结句跳到来年雪中，不点明肩头属谁，留有余温与余味。“棉裘”用字稍欠精确。","_cost":0.01708},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"旧衣箱入诗有新意；“暗扣”“垂袖”使旧物含情，结句转向他人肩头，脉络清楚。惟“黄昏小巷”稍熟，末句点明善意，留白略少。","_cost":0.008184}},"consensus":84.22,"final":84.22},{"key":"grok-4.7|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"玻璃匣内坠银钩，半抱红绒未肯收。偶落原堆难入袖，儿童绕膝再三求。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.55,"rationale":"现代游戏入诗自然，失手与复求构成生活情趣，立意尚属常见。银钩红绒鲜明，“半抱”传神，“偶落”“入袖”稍欠贴切。第三句承前多于转进，结句由物及人，以反复央求留下未了之意。","_cost":0.04992},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.5,"rationale":"当代生活小景入诗，取象具体（银钩、红绒、原堆），“未肯收”拟物有趣。但“难入袖”略生硬，转结止于儿童求索、情境写实而意旨浅，结句直叙场面，余味有限，属稳妥而不惊人的咏物小品。","_cost":0.04073},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.6,"余味":6.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.9,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗极精巧。以“银钩”“红绒”摹写机械抓娃娃过程，绘声绘色、起承转合自然。结句由机内转至机外童趣，真实可感。意趣小巧，余味稍显平白。","_cost":0.00494025},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写儿童求而不得，题材当代，情事具体；“半抱红绒未肯收”有拟人趣味。但意境偏实，转结平直，结句叙事少余味，“入袖”稍凑。","_cost":0.0168155},"glm-5.3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.5,"rationale":"当代题材入七绝自然贴切，'银钩''红绒'取象精切，'偶落原堆'写抓娃娃屡试不中之挫，物态逼真。'难入袖'暗用古语写今事，有巧思。结句转写儿童绕膝，情事具体，但全诗偏平铺实录，结意直白，余味有限。","_cost":0.00255656},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入诗，银钩、红绒等取象生动，儿童绕膝见生活趣味。转承清晰，结以事而留余地。惜“原堆”“入袖”稍显生硬，余味偏直。","_cost":0.012672},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"当代题材入旧体而浑然不隔。『半抱红绒未肯收』拟人生动,可望不可即之态兼得人生况味;转结写偶落与儿童再求,叙事完整、转承自然。意象精切统一,惟立意深度尚浅,结句偏叙事收束,余韵稍欠宕开。","_cost":0.00739704},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.2,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.4,"rationale":"抓娃娃机入绝句取象切实，半抱未肯收写尽机制与欲念拉扯；唯全篇白描叙事，意境未融为氛围，结句直收少宕开余味。","_cost":0.0096195},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":4.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"古典语汇写抓娃娃机，现代经验入诗，取象清晰、造语有亮点；然意旨止于场景白描，情景未深融，转折平直，结句稍直白少余味。","_cost":0.02393231},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"此作描摹抓娃娃机日常场景，取材鲜活，炼字准切，“半抱红绒”尤见巧思，章法顺直，结句偏实余味稍欠，当代经验入诗自然，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":4.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":52.0,"rationale":"当代题材入诗，写得细致。“半抱红绒未肯收”拟人传神，是全篇亮点。“偶落”与娃娃多半跌回的常态略有抵牾，“原堆”偏白。转句只是承接，没有转出新意。结句写儿童央求，生动但直白，未深化出得失或欲望之思，余味有限。","_cost":0.016632},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"银钩、红绒与绕膝儿童构成具体生活场景；由抓取失手写到再三央求，脉络清楚，但转折较平。“难入袖”稍显牵强，结句留有循环再玩的意味。","_cost":0.008094}},"consensus":65.96,"final":65.96},{"key":"grok-4.7|机场送别|七律","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"向晓登机语未央，屏间绿字促云航。玻璃影里人渐远，闸口灯前手尚凉。乍见银身离地起，遥看尾焰破空翔。层楼独对窗已白，望极微明一缕光。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":["已"],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":0.75,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"屏字、玻璃、闸灯切合现场，“手尚凉”以触感传情。题旨常见，起飞两句推进偏平；“促云航”生硬，“尾焰”不合通常民航景象。结以微光，略有余情但偏泛。","_cost":0.05257},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"机场送别以屏间绿字、玻璃影、闸口灯等当代物象入诗，颔联“手尚凉”具体可感。颈联“破空翔”较空套，客机“尾焰”稍失实。结句以曙光收情留白尚可，惟“窗已白”与“微明”意近略冗。整体稳妥而不惊人。","_cost":0.0659},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.2,"rationale":"当代机场经验入律自然贴切。“屏间绿字”“手尚凉”捕捉精准，情致具体可感。由话别、过闸到目送银身破空，章法极具层次。尾联天白光微，以景结情，留白悠远。","_cost":0.0046725},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.8,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.8,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.44999999999999,"rationale":"现代机场送别具真实感，颔联‘手尚凉’等细节佳，尾联以景收束有余味；但‘促云航’等用语生硬，颈联较直白，中二联转折稍平。","_cost":0.017580698},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"以机场晨别入律，屏间绿字、闸口手凉等当代细节真切不隔；镜头由闸内至玻璃、至离地、至天际一缕光，层层推移，章法最有匠心。'促''凉'见炼字，结句以景宕开留白。惟立意仍属送别旧题之翻新，'层楼独对'句稍平直。","_cost":0.00637152},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.3,"余味":7.4,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"以现代机场入诗，绿字、闸口、尾焰等细节真切，别后独望收束有留白；章法清楚，语言稳。惜离情角度较常见，个别词语稍平，余味未尽深。","_cost":0.012218},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"现代送别题材入主脑分明,颔联'玻璃影里/闸口灯前'情景交融最见功夫;惜中二联叙事实平直,'云航''银身'略生,尾焰写民航稍欠稳。结以晓光宕开,尚有余韵。","_cost":0.021489},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.8,"余味":7.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"航站送别现场具体，手尚凉颇有触感；取象贴合现代但尾焰失实，时序平进转折稍弱，结以微明之光收束尚有余味。","_cost":0.008002},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"以现代机场经验入律，情境具体，脉络清晰；颔联‘手尚凉’及尾联‘望极微明一缕光’以景结情，有余味。然情感角度未脱送别窠臼，颈联稍实，‘尾焰’于客机起飞略欠准确，现代词入诗偶有生硬。","_cost":0.026321268},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.25,"rationale":"此作写机场送别，细节真切情感诚挚，取象贴合当代场景，语言通顺有亮点，脉络平直，结句稳而余韵稍浅；颔联较佳，融入当代经验，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.25,"rationale":"当代送别入诗,屏字、闸口、手尚凉等细节具体可感,颔联较佳。颈联乍见、遥看平铺,翔字凑韵,民航客机不见尾焰,属小失实。尾联层楼对窗句法拙滞,以微光收结稍有留白,但意蕴偏浅。","_cost":0.01752},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"屏字、闸口写出机场送别的具体情境，“手尚凉”尤见情意；起承清楚，后半写起飞略有重复。“促云航”生硬，客机“尾焰”失真；结句以晨光收束，却与“窗已白”意象相叠，余味有限。","_cost":0.008364}},"consensus":68.64,"final":51.48},{"key":"grok-4.7|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"玻璃匣里铁钩垂，客把铜钱试一持。利爪徐伸钳彩带，棕熊乍举近窗楣。红绳忽脱回旧垛，数币先沉入暗池。稚颊仍凭温气结，繁灯未歇待新痴。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":["旧"],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":0.75,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"unknown"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.8,"语言":5.8,"章法":7.6,"余味":6.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.9,"rationale":"抓取、脱落与钱币沉没写出欲望落空，稚颊与凝气添出留恋；“试一持”“温气结”稍显生硬。章法由物及人，层次清楚；结句灯景能延宕，但“新痴”点破讽意。","_cost":0.04063},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"当代题材入律,叙事清晰:投币、钳举、脱落、币沉,层层推进;'稚颊温气结'摹儿童贴玻璃之状真切,'待新痴'收得有讽意。惟'铜钱'与今机不合,'试一持'凑字,结句'痴'字稍说破,余味中平。","_cost":0.05773},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.3,"rationale":"将当代生活经验化入律诗，典雅妥帖。中二联动态摹写如在目前；尾联以玻璃呵气特写宕开至“待新痴”的世态讽思，章法紧凑，余味悠长。","_cost":0.00485625},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.89999999999999,"rationale":"写抓娃娃机，当代经验入旧体，题材出新；中二联抓取、脱回对仗生动，结句以灯与“新痴”收束，留犹大。立意稍止于过程描写，未更深入；个别新词略生涩。","_cost":0.005237336},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"以七律写抓娃娃机，当代经验入诗自然无猎奇感，围绕'欲望与机制'收束。意象精切成统一氛围，颈联'红绳忽脱回旧垛，数币先沉入暗池'写失败与吞币，机心与人心互映，最为动人。结句以景结情，'待新痴'宕开留白，讽而不露。'试一持'稍显凑韵。","_cost":0.00256736},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.1,"语言":6.7,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.1,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.3,"rationale":"当代题材入律，起承转合完整，抓取与失落脉络清楚，结句有留白；但铁钩、窗楣、温气等语稍欠精切，个别处略硬。","_cost":0.012542},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写欲望循环与机心陷阱，当代题材入律而贴合。意象精切统一：铁钩、彩带、沉币、稚颊呵气结雾皆景中含情。颈联一脱一沉转折有力，结句'繁灯未歇待新痴'冷峻留白，讽意不尽。唯中二联略偏实录，个别字句如'试一持'稍硬，锤炼未至化境。","_cost":0.0140475},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.65,"rationale":"以娃娃机咏当代微欲，时序起承转合完整，尾联由稚颊温气宕至繁灯待新痴，微讽留白；中二联写实工切但意象铺陈、情融未深，语言通顺少诗眼。","_cost":0.009766},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"以律诗写抓娃娃机，当代经验入诗，叙事井然，中二联由举转脱有层次；尾联稚颊温气与繁灯待痴相映，结句稍直白。意象妥帖而情韵未深，语言通顺偶有硬处。","_cost":0.032439548},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"此作以七律写当代抓娃娃机日常，描摹具象，章法顺稳，颈联写功亏一篑之态真切，唯‘铜钱’稍隔，立意未及深警，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"当代题材入律，写诱惑与落空的循环，有讽意。颔颈两联按时序铺叙，开合不足。“数币先沉”“稚颊温气”写得细，可感。“试一持”“窗楣”用字较生硬。结句“待新痴”点出轮回，余味尚可。","_cost":0.020692},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"抓取、脱钩到孩童守候，场景连贯；“数币先沉入暗池”有讽意。“试一持”“温气结”稍涩，末句“待新痴”点破，削弱余味。","_cost":0.013346}},"consensus":75.53,"final":56.65},{"key":"grok-4.7|云端相册|七绝","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"云端展卷见荷田，母笑犹扶石槛边。坐对寒屏生白发，此身已隔几重天。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"以云端旧照写亲情阻隔，母笑与寒屏白发相映，今昔转折有力；“犹扶石槛边”稍涩，“几重天”呼应云端，但表达偏熟，结意较直。","_cost":0.05298},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"以云端相册寄哀思，当代经验有效入诗；\"云端\"与\"几重天\"双关呼应，结构完整。\"寒屏\"炼字见冷暖对照，惟\"展卷\"于数字相册略隔，\"生白发\"稍熟，结句道破而余韵尚存。","_cost":0.04801},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.2,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.9,"rationale":"以当代数字经验入诗，化古融今毫无滞碍。“寒屏”炼字极精，与前幅母笑荷田形成冷暖虚实之烈照。转结自然，由电子影像跌入苍茫时空之叹，情真意笃。","_cost":0.00401625},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"以云端相册为今事写怀亲，旧照音容与寒屏白发对照，结句余哀不散；'犹'字传神，唯'生白发'稍直，个别意象略熟。","_cost":0.01182535},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.5,"rationale":"以云端相册忆亡母，'云端'双关存储与天界，'几重天'宕开生死之隔而不说破。起承见荷田母笑之暖，转句'寒屏'与暖景对照，白发承岁月，结句言尽意不尽。当代经验入诗自然无痕，转结尤佳。","_cost":0.0034082},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.1,"rationale":"云端相册入诗有新意，荷田、石槛、母笑与寒屏白发相映，情真而焦点明确。转合完整，但结以“几重天”稍说破，白发、隔天等语略熟。","_cost":0.01251},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"以云端相册唤出亡亲旧影，寒屏与荷田冷暖对照，情事具体且有当代经验；惜“白发”“几重天”稍熟，结句直陈隔绝，余韵未充分宕开。","_cost":0.00967464},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.2,"余味":5.2,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.6,"rationale":"以云端双关串联荷田记忆与寒屏当下，当代感真切；冷暖对照成境但取象常见；语言平实缺诗眼；起承转合清晰；末句直抒隔绝，余味稍薄。","_cost":0.0072395},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"以云端相册、寒屏写悼母，当代经验入诗而出新；起承转合清晰，转结由屏前生白发宕至几重天，情境真切。意象妥帖，寒屏/犹字见炼；惟生白发、几重天略熟，余味稍直。","_cost":0.027996093},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"此作借观云端相册中母亲旧照抒睽隔之思，情真事切，章法圆转，当代经验入诗妥帖；唯意象偏熟，结句稍直，余韵略浅。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"借云端相册写思亲，把当代经验有效写进诗中。“云端”与“几重天”双关，照应巧妙，天人之隔含而不露。“母笑犹扶”写得具体可感，“寒屏”一词精当。第三句“生白发”略显习见，转折稍平。结句收得住，有余味。","_cost":0.017544},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"荷田、石槛的旧影与寒屏相对，转出时光与离思；“云端”照应“几重天”，有新意和余味。“生白发”稍熟，末句的情意也略显直白。","_cost":0.008716}},"consensus":78.48,"final":78.48},{"key":"grok-4.7|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"深夜视频 夜深人静看视频\n灯火通明映屏幕\n思绪万千浮眼前\n心事如潮涌不止","dup_lines":0,"verdict":null,"coef":0.75,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":3.0,"意境":2.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":25.0,"rationale":"夜观视频题旨可辨，却无具体情事支撑；灯屏仅作背景，情景未融。“思绪万千”“心事如潮”套语密集。章法由景及情但推进平直，结句直陈情绪，缺少余味；视频题材未形成有效出新。","_cost":0.02844},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":1.5,"意境":1.0,"语言":1.5,"章法":1.0,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":9.75,"rationale":"四句皆成语套话连缀(夜深人静、灯火通明、思绪万千、心事如潮),无一具体物象与实事,思绪心事究竟为何全未着落;起承转合缺失,四句原地打转,结句说尽无余。当代题材'视频'仅作标签,未有效入诗。","_cost":0.03941},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":2.5,"意境":2.0,"语言":1.8,"章法":2.5,"余味":1.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":18.85,"rationale":"通篇拼凑熟套成语，语言直白近乎打油。虽涉当代生活题材，但全为抽象干说，无意象锤炼，转结平直且将心绪彻底说破，空泛无味。","_cost":0.00488625},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":2.0,"意境":1.5,"语言":1.5,"章法":1.0,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":11.75,"rationale":"通篇以“夜深人静”“思绪万千”“心事如潮”等套语直说，情志空泛，无具体事象；四句平列，无转结，末句说尽无余味。","_cost":0.00525888},"glm-5.3":{"立意":2.0,"意境":1.0,"语言":2.0,"章法":1.5,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":13.0,"rationale":"通篇干说无象：'夜深人静''思绪万千''心事如潮'皆为成语套话连缀，无一具体物象与情事。四句并列原地打转，无起承转合，结句直白说尽，毫无留白。取材当代但未做有效提炼转化，仅以'视频''屏幕'入题而无观察发现。","_cost":0.00204056},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":2.5,"意境":2.5,"语言":2.8,"章法":2.5,"余味":1.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":22.9,"rationale":"题旨仅深夜看屏生感，未落到具体情事；夜深、灯火、屏幕有当代生活痕迹，但思绪万千、心事如潮等套语直说，景情未融；结构平铺，结句说破，少余味。","_cost":0.011106},"kimi-k3":{"立意":3.5,"意境":2.5,"语言":2.5,"章法":2.5,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":26.0,"rationale":"题旨可辨但情感笼统,'思绪万千''心事如潮'皆套语直说,无独到发现;唯'灯火映屏幕'略有当代画面,余皆干叙;四句平铺无转合,结句说尽无余味。当代题材入诗稍予出新,然处理无效近乎顺口溜。","_cost":0.00553245},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":1.5,"意境":1.5,"语言":1.0,"章法":1.5,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":11.0,"rationale":"题同白描无主脑，意象套语堆砌无氛围，语言口语流水无诗眼，章法平铺无转结，结句直抒兜底无留白。","_cost":0.00716175},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":1.5,"意境":2.5,"语言":3.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":23.0,"rationale":"通篇以成语加“视频”“屏幕”拼凑，夜深观视频仅泛言思绪心事，立意空泛、意象陈套；语言无诗眼而稍硬凑，结构有起承转合但转折平直，结句直说如潮，言尽意尽。无警句出新，陈滥满格，硬伤蹈袭俱无。","_cost":0.025943113},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":2.0,"意境":1.0,"语言":2.0,"章法":2.0,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":14.5,"rationale":"作品空泛无具体情志焦点，多直陈干说，意象浅俗未融情，语言直白凑泊，结构平直无转合，结句说尽无余，多用陈套语，无警句新意。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":1.5,"意境":1.5,"语言":1.0,"章法":1.5,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":9.5,"rationale":"全诗由“夜深人静”“灯火通明”“思绪万千”“心事如潮”等成语套话连缀而成,心事所指始终未交代,缺少主脑。无具体意象,三四句同义反复,原地打转。结句直白说尽,毫无余味。“夜深人静”与“灯火通明”略有矛盾,首行又误混入标题。","_cost":0.015844},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":2.0,"意境":2.0,"语言":1.5,"章法":1.5,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":14.0,"rationale":"视频内容未见，心事也无具体所指；“夜深人静”“思绪万千”“心事如潮”接连套用。四句缺少转折，结句直说情绪，余味弱。","_cost":0.006838}},"consensus":17.55,"final":13.16},{"key":"grok-4.7|云端相册|七律","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"银屏夜半映流年，一指轻移到眼前。母倚炉边烟湿鬓，父停渡口雪盈肩。云端尚贮当时色，掌上难回去日缘。暗却微光空欲语，双亲仿佛未成眠。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.3,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.3,"rationale":"炉边、渡口使亲情具体，云端留影与旧日难回形成张力，明屏至暗屏脉络贯通。“去日缘”稍显凑语，“流年”偏熟；结句转入双亲未眠的想象，有延宕而略点明。","_cost":0.05757},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"以云端相册寄亲情，当代经验入律自然，颔联双象具体可感，云端/掌上双关见巧。颈联转为议论稍直，“去日缘”略凑。结句屏暗而“仿佛未成眠”留白有余味。整体稳而不惊，流年、眼前等语稍熟。","_cost":0.05636},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.7,"rationale":"将当代“翻看云端相册”的经验妥帖入诗，毫无生硬割裂感。颈联“云端/掌上”深具今昔张力，起承转合自然流转，熄屏收尾余味绵长，情意深挚真切。","_cost":0.0068685},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.25,"rationale":"以当代云端相册怀亲，情感具体；中二联意象精切，尾联含蓄留白。颈联稍平，个别词套语。","_cost":0.004112031264},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"以手机云端相册思亲,熟题翻出新境。中二联'烟湿鬓''雪盈肩'白描精切,情事具体;'云端尚贮当时色,掌上难回去日缘'虚实对仗见巧思,为全篇诗眼。结句熄屏欲语、双亲仿佛未眠,生死不明之恍惚,以景结情余味悠长。","_cost":0.0030762},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.7,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.2,"警句":3.3,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.35,"rationale":"云端旧照牵出亲恩，中二联画面真切，今昔对照有深情。语言大体自然，但个别词稍平，结尾略见说破。","_cost":0.012102},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"以云端相册写思亲,旧题接入当代经验而不隔。颔联'烟湿鬓''雪盈肩'双象精切,颈联'云端/掌上'一语双关见巧思,自然无痕。结句'双亲仿佛未成眠'宕开一笔,不说破生死而哀意自深,余韵足。惜首联稍平,'流年''去日缘'略熟,炼字未到通体生警。","_cost":0.0162549},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.2,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.15,"rationale":"以云端相册切入当代思亲，数字与旧影对照出新；颔联烟鬓雪肩具体可感，颈联云贮难回凝练，尾联暗屏幻觉留白蕴藉。","_cost":0.007912},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"以云端、掌上化古出新写相册旧照；颔联烟湿鬓、雪盈肩意象精切，颈联去日缘稍滞涩，尾联空欲语、未成眠余味悠长。","_cost":0.03305896},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.1,"rationale":"此作写夜半翻云端相册忆双亲，情真具象，颔联画面鲜活，章法顺畅，结有余韵，当代经验入诗自然，无硬伤蹈袭，仅部分表述稍见平熟。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"以手机云相册写怀亲，当代经验自然入诗，情真事切。颔联炉边、渡口两景具体可感，“雪盈肩”有分量。颈联“去日缘”偏虚泛，与首联同写屏幕，略显重复。结句“双亲仿佛未成眠”以虚写实，留有余温。","_cost":0.020084},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"指尖翻相册引出双亲旧影，炉烟、渡雪具体可感；云端存色与掌上难追回形成对照。惟“流年”“去日缘”稍泛，结句有留白而余味未深。","_cost":0.008164}},"consensus":80.19,"final":80.19},{"key":"grok-4.7|天台菜园|七律","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"天台九月豆棚黄,雨足青菘一径长。芥甲抽茎沾宿露,芜菁垂叶压低墙。山僧负锸行还倦,田妇提筐去复忙。岭暗人稀声渐远,宵来垄上已微霜。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.75,"rationale":"秋圃物象具体，僧妇劳作使田园不落空景；由菜畦到人物，再归暮岭微霜，层次清楚，结有清寒余意。“压低墙”稍显用力，“行还倦”“去复忙”较平直，题旨出新有限。","_cost":0.04994},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":4.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.75,"rationale":"秋园写景规整,芥甲、芜菁等物象具体而不落俗,尾联以岭暗微霜收束颇有余韵。然题旨仅止于摹景,情志无独到发现;中二联“行还倦/去复忙”对法程式化,“芜菁压低墙”略失实;转折平直,缺乏诗眼与警句。","_cost":0.05712},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.4,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"写天台秋日菜圃，物象具体生动。起承细描蔬甲，转写僧妇农事，尾联以日暮声远、寒霜初至收束，脉络贯通，余韵悠然。立意偏于传统田园白描，工稳而新意稍平。","_cost":0.00612675},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"写天台菜园秋日劳作，意象真实饱满，中二联对仗工整，尾联以微霜景语收束有余味；立意角度平常，情感略欠独到，语言通顺偶有佳句但整体平淡。","_cost":0.00573072},"glm-5.3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.75,"rationale":"写秋日菜园物象充盈、氛围统一，中二联一物一人有开合，结以微霜收得住。但属常见田圃题材，菜名罗列近铺排，山僧、田妇、岭意象与天台（屋顶）菜园语境略有游移，警句不显，味稳而新意不足。","_cost":0.00402675},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.1,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.15,"rationale":"写天台秋园，蔬菜人事相映，景清脉稳，尾联以暮色微霜收出余味。惜题旨较熟，中二联稍嫌罗列，情志未深。","_cost":0.014388},"kimi-k3":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"田园熟题而取象具体,芥甲、芜菁、青菘等菜园风物入律颇见观察,颔联'抽茎沾露''垂叶压墙'细腻成联;惜情志偏淡,止于摹景,颈联'行还倦/去复忙'对仗平板、近合掌,'一径长'略凑。起承顺畅,结以微霜以景结情,尚有余韵而力度一般。'天台'与'山僧'并置略生龃龉,未成大碍。","_cost":0.0199905},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":5.3,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.8,"警句":0.5,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.65,"rationale":"菜蔬取象精切少见，氛围统一有农味；章法景—物—人—夜层进贯通，以微霜景结留韵；语言平稳锤炼而无惊艳诗眼，立意止于白描记景未翻新境。","_cost":0.0075965},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":4.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"菜园秋晚即景，意象真切少陈套，‘压’‘声渐远’等炼字及蔬圃联略成佳句；章法由物及人再以景收，转折稍平；结句微霜留白有余味。田园常见，出新有限；无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.035940115},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.5,"rationale":"此诗写天台九月菜园秋暮景致，脉络平顺，意象贴实，语言稳当无硬伤；唯立意平熟无新致，表达偏平，无警策句，结句景收略有清味而余韵稍浅。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":4.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":47.25,"rationale":"山园秋景写得平实可感,但主旨只是罗列景物,缺少情志焦点。前两联菘、芥、芜菁接连铺排,层次重复,中二联开合不足。“压低墙”稍见锤炼,“芥甲抽茎”搭配略显生硬,“行还倦/去复忙”句式套路化。结句以微霜收束,有一点余味。","_cost":0.020548},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.75,"rationale":"菜蔬、劳作与夜霜相接，秋园气息可感；由近景转人事再归田垄，脉络清楚。题旨较常见，“压低墙”略显费解；末句以霜收束，留有余味。","_cost":0.008248}},"consensus":64.06,"final":64.06},{"key":"grok-4.7|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"夜半低窗纳市光，江流一线冷于霜。遥看几处灯犹暖，过尽千家未是乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.8,"警句":3.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.3,"rationale":"乡思题旨常见，夜航俯瞰赋予新视角；江冷灯暖相映，由景入情顺畅。“低窗”略涩，“冷于霜”稍熟。末句凝练有力，但直接点明非乡，留白有限。","_cost":0.04481},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验入诗，视角新；'江流一线冷于霜'与'灯犹暖'冷暖相形，景语即情语。结句点出思乡略近说破，且'过尽千家未是乡'明显化用温庭筠'过尽千帆皆不是'，虽有新意仍属借势。","_cost":0.04871},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.4,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰视角精切，江流如线、冷暖互衬尤显高空感。由物及情脉络贯通，转结化用古人意脉自然。唯结句“未是乡”略显说破，留白稍逊。","_cost":0.004563},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"俯瞰夜景取象精当，江流冷、灯暖对照见情。尾句化用古句而切合夜航，点出无乡之慨，但直说未是乡稍欠留白。","_cost":0.01200144},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰是当代经验入诗的成功尝试，冷市光与暖灯对照，收于\"过尽千家未是乡\"，化用温庭筠\"过尽千帆皆不是\"而自出新意。\"纳\"字见诗眼，结句以陈述收而余味悠长，唯\"冷于霜\"稍落熟套。","_cost":0.0035342},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.9,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰视角较新，低窗纳光、江流一线切题，冷暖灯色烘托羁思，脉络清楚。惜‘未是乡’说破，灯、乡意象稍熟，余味因此减弱。","_cost":0.013358},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"夜航视角较新，冷江与暖灯对照成境，结句点出无乡之孤，警拔而稍直；个别意象近旧套，整体完成度较高。","_cost":0.01098246},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.6,"余味":5.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.85,"rationale":"夜航视角切旧题羁旅，江冷灯暖对照成境，起承转合有序；结句直点未是乡，少宕开余味，意象真切而略熟。","_cost":0.009013},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰现代视角写羁旅乡愁，起承转合稳洽；‘江流一线’‘过尽千家’具镜头感且化用自然，结句有力而稍直白，意象略常见，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.034770469},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"此作写夜航俯瞰触发羁旅乡愁，情真境切，冷暖意象对照妥帖，起承转合顺畅，炼字精准；唯结句稍直白，融入当代高空视角，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":68.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰的当代经验入诗有效,以江冷与灯暖对照,落到乡愁,主脑清楚。三句转得自然,冷暖相映成境。结句化用“过尽千帆皆不是”,切合情境但稍嫌说破,余味中上。“冷于霜”较常见。","_cost":0.015744},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"俯瞰中以江流之冷衬灯火之暖，末句落到思乡，脉络清晰且有余意。“过尽千家未是乡”动人；“低窗”稍显含混，乡愁题旨亦非新境。","_cost":0.008162}},"consensus":76.57,"final":76.57},{"key":"grok-4.7|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"机舷俯瞰万家光，眼底平铺一片霜。曲水弯环如匹练，华灯错落似星芒。高空凛凛临小牖，下界煌煌认旧乡。侧翼微倾城渐远，何人未寝夜初长。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":["小"],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":0.75,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.25,"rationale":"由俯瞰灯火转入认乡、离城，脉络清楚；侧翼微倾有现场感，结问将乡情引向未眠之人。霜、匹练、星芒较熟，“高空凛凛临小牖”语意稍滞，佳句尚欠警拔。","_cost":0.04004},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰题材有当代经验，颈联凛凛煌煌对举稼稼落到旧乡稼见情志。然颔联匹练星芒陈套且近合掌，中二联皆景少层次，语言平顺无诗眼。结句宕开问下界未寝之人，略有余味。","_cost":0.05561},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.2,"语言":5.3,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.550000000000004,"rationale":"夜航视角融入当代经验，脉络开合清晰，“侧翼微倾”具现场感。然颔联“如匹练、似星芒”比喻陈滥，首联以霜喻光微滞，结语发问稍平，炼字通畅而少警策。","_cost":0.0060195},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":4.0,"意境":4.0,"语言":3.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":40.0,"rationale":"夜航认旧乡题材常见，情思浅泛。意象多套语如霜、练、星芒，语风文白夹杂少诗眼。起承转合尚完整，结句设问略有留白，惜铺垫未深。","_cost":0.005979756},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰当代经验入诗自然，光、霜、练、星芒统一于高空视象，景中含归乡之情。颈联由景转人，结句以问收，宕开留白，余味最佳。惟匹练、星芒属常见套语，炼字未见鲜明诗眼。","_cost":0.003057},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.7,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.7,"rationale":"夜航视角统一，起承转合清楚，颈联有高下对照；但霜、星芒、匹练等喻偏熟，情志止于泛写旧乡与未寝，余味尚存而未深。","_cost":0.01144},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.0,"rationale":"夜航题材入诗自然，“认旧乡”略有情事；但万家光、匹练、星芒多熟喻，中二联铺排偏平，结句设问有余味而未深。","_cost":0.0143562},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.6,"章法":7.1,"余味":7.7,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.64999999999999,"rationale":"机舱俯瞰切入当代经验，颈联高下对照显身临感，尾联侧翼倾远宕开一问余味佳；颔联匹练星芒等比兴工稳而陈，语言通顺少诗眼。","_cost":0.007602},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":56.75,"rationale":"夜航题材具当代经验，章法完整，中二联由景及情，'侧翼微倾'一联生动；然意象多沿套语（霜、匹练、星芒），情景未深融，结句平稳稍直，硬伤轻微。","_cost":0.034974728},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.5,"rationale":"此诗写夜航俯瞰触发的乡思，脉络平顺，情感真切，但意象喻体多熟套，曲水喻匹练稍欠贴切，虽取当代航空视角却未拓新境，整体平正少警策。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":4.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":46.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰属当代经验入诗，颈联“认旧乡”略带情思，但主脑不聚。万家光、华灯、煌煌三写灯火，原地打转。颔联如练、似星芒两喻平直陈熟。以霜比灯光，冷暖相左。结句转向未寝之人，稍有余味而未深。","_cost":0.018604},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.5,"rationale":"由俯城、认旧乡到城远问人，脉络清晰；侧翼微倾有现场感，结句留有牵念。匹练、星芒较熟，“曲水弯环”稍冗，“高空凛凛临小牖”句意不够自然。","_cost":0.009718}},"consensus":58.77,"final":44.07},{"key":"grok-4.7|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"春街柳树吊瓶光，软管低牵贴腕旁。细滴频侵肤上冷，残英半惹鬓边香。千家药力扶瘦骨，几处林阴代病床。薄暮悬壶摇叶隙，银波未尽映斜阳。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":["瘦"],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":0.75,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"街树输液与病者形象相叠，取材有新意，冷香相映；“吊瓶光”“千家药力”措辞牵强，中段拟人反复而推进有限。结句以暮光收束，留有余韵。","_cost":0.05864},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.5,"rationale":"取当代城市树木输液入诗，以树拟病人贯穿全篇，构思有新意；'悬壶'双关、'残英惹鬓'较见巧思。惟'吊瓶光''贴腕旁'稍硬，'千家药力'语意含混；中二联皆铺陈拟人，层次开合不足，转折平直。结以银波斜阳收景，余味尚可。","_cost":0.07528},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.8,"rationale":"将当代给树木输液的经验妥帖入诗，咏物寄怀。通篇全拟人形，体物细腻，“贴腕”“肤冷”极具通感。章法由细至阔，尾联以夕照景结，画意延宕。","_cost":0.005868},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"以城市树木挂吊瓶入诗，拟人贯串，意象统一，颈联有讽喻；语言见“悬壶”双关巧思，但立意偏描写，情志略浅，结句景结有余味但不深。无硬伤，陈套轻微。","_cost":0.0131957},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.0,"rationale":"以城市行道树输营养液入诗，题旨独到，通篇以'树如病患'为统一脉络，意象精切交融。颔联近景细写，颈联拓展千家几处，由昼入暮收束有势。'悬壶'化典双关巧妙。结句银波斜阳以景结情，言尽意不尽。语言略有个别处直白，但不掩整体之新。","_cost":0.00335776},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.9,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.69999999999999,"rationale":"以吊瓶入春街，题材新而细节具体；冷滴、残英、斜阳与病弱相映。然软管、药力稍直白，树与人语义微含混；结景留白较佳。","_cost":0.016434},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"以春街树挂营养液翻出病树如病人之境，焦点集中，结尾银波斜阳留白较好；中联合度而“千家”“悬壶”稍撑、现代语入口略硬，故语言未至化境。","_cost":0.01215351},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.4,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.9,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.25,"rationale":"当代街头树挂吊瓶视角新切，冷香对感具体有主脑，颔颈由一人而千家层次分明，尾联以银波映阳景结情留余，个别句偏白。","_cost":0.0082055},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"写街树悬吊瓶、借树阴代病床，当代经验入诗，立意新且聚焦；中二联稍涉概念，结句景中见情。语言夹现代词，略有陈套，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.042840373},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"此诗选取当代街树挂吊瓶的新鲜题材，拟人贴切，结构平顺，语有巧思；但立意未深掘，部分表述稍滞，结句余味偏淡，有少量常见意象，无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"街树挂吊瓶是当代题材,拟人为病者颇有新意。但只写情状,未触及大树移植等深层意涵,立意偏浅。'悬壶'双关巧妙,颔联'肤''鬓'拟人贴切。颈联'千家药力''林阴代病床'逻辑稍混,转折平直。结句以银波映斜阳作结,稳当而余味有限。","_cost":0.020292},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"树木输液入诗有新意，冷滴与残英写出病树之感；但“千家药力”语意虚，“林阴代病床”稍显牵强，斜阳作结稳妥而余味有限。","_cost":0.013298}},"consensus":72.08,"final":54.06},{"key":"grok-4.7|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"低枝暗挂吊瓶光，点滴声中坐树旁。落蕊飞来依病腕，行人只道杏花香。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.25,"rationale":"街头输液与春日花景相映，题材组合有新意。“落蕊飞来依病腕”情景相融，末句以行人赏香反衬病者处境，留有余味；但“暗挂吊瓶光”搭配稍拗，“点滴声中”略显刻意。","_cost":0.0406},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"街树挂吊瓶输液，当代经验入诗有效，病痛与春光对照成一篇主脑。“落蕊依病腕”物我交融，为全篇亮点。“暗挂”与“光”稍碍，“坐树旁”平钝；结句以行人旁观宕开，有余味，但“只道”句式习见。","_cost":0.05166},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.4,"rationale":"当代经验自然入诗。前两句微凉入题，后两句以“落蕊依腕”转入“行人道香”，反衬病痛与世情之隔阂，以乐景衬哀，反差精妙，结句余韵深远。","_cost":0.00702825},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.0,"rationale":"聚焦城市树木输液，意象与反差俱佳，转结尤有言外意；‘病腕’稍见拟人用力，但无硬伤。","_cost":0.00374836704},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.25,"rationale":"以城市行道树输液的当代细节入诗，树病人病浑然莫辨，'病腕'移情于枝，杏花暗扣杏林之喻，结句宕开于路人浑然不觉，含蓄有余。'吊瓶光''坐树旁'稍平，转折略缓，故语言章法微扣。","_cost":0.002431392},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.8,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.1,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.45,"rationale":"以吊瓶写病树，春景与病象交融，结以行人误认花香留余味。现代物象入诗较新，唯‘吊瓶光’‘点滴声’稍直，‘坐树旁’主语略晦。","_cost":0.008744},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"以街头输液入诗，病腕与落蕊相接，景情交融；结句借行人只闻花香反衬病者孤苦的隔阂，宕开有力、余味足。惟'吊瓶光''坐树旁'表述稍平直，落蕊杏花意象略熟，整体新而不险、稳而少惊人语。","_cost":0.0110514},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.7,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.6,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.2,"rationale":"以街头吊瓶翻出春日新境，病腕落蕊与行人误作杏香对照成主脑；景即情语，转结宕开反衬，现代经验入诗自然，余味不尽。","_cost":0.00687775},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.75,"rationale":"街树挂瓶入诗，立意新婉（8）；医疗与春景交融，“吊瓶光”稍晦（7.5）；“病腕”成诗眼，然“挂光”略凑（6.5）；起承转合稳，转结对比强（8.5）；结句借行人语留讽喻空白（8）。警句4，出新3，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.033066796},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.6,"rationale":"此作撷取春街树挂输液吊瓶的当代日常小景，拟人写病树情态，以路人只赏杏香的反差收束，观察细腻，新巧自然，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.5,"rationale":"以街头树下输液入诗,当代经验真切。病腕落蕊与行人赏花对照,冷暖自见。杏花暗合杏林,含蓄有味。结句以旁观者口吻收束,不说破而余悲延宕。瑕疵是“吊瓶光”略硬,“点滴声”稍失实,次句平直。","_cost":0.016904},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.5,"rationale":"街树吊瓶与杏花香相映，病腕落蕊写出病中孤寂；末句借行人所见留有余味。“吊瓶光”搭配稍涩。","_cost":0.00791}},"consensus":83.11,"final":83.11},{"key":"grok-4.7|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"社区食堂暖心房，邻里欢聚共餐忙。菜香四溢情谊长，岁月静好共时光。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":["堂","月","溢","聚","餐","香"],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":true},"coef":0.75,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":3.0,"意境":2.0,"语言":2.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":20.5,"rationale":"题旨明确，却止于温情口号；“菜香”略具感官性，其余多抽象套语。四句同义铺排，缺少转折；“共时光”搭配生硬，结句直白说尽。无可确认的蹈袭或事实硬伤。","_cost":0.02622},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":2.0,"意境":1.5,"语言":1.5,"章法":2.0,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":14.25,"rationale":"题材虽当代，却全是口号式套语连缀：暖心房、欢聚、菜香四溢、岁月静好，无一具体物象与情事。四句平铺无转，结句直白说尽毫无余味，语言近乎标语，仅取材上略有当代生活痕迹。","_cost":0.02323},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":2.5,"意境":2.0,"语言":2.5,"章法":3.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":21.75,"rationale":"虽取现实题材，但通篇充斥标语套话，如“暖心房”“岁月静好”等。毫无具体诗家物象与炼字，四句平铺直叙、原地打转，全如顺口溜，了无诗味与余韵。","_cost":0.0042555},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":3.0,"意境":2.5,"语言":2.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":22.75,"rationale":"通篇为套话口号，缺少具体场景细节与真切体验；意象空泛堆砌，章法平直，结句说尽且“岁月”“时光”重复，无余味。","_cost":0.00265625712},"glm-5.3":{"立意":2.5,"意境":2.0,"语言":2.0,"章法":1.5,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":16.75,"rationale":"题材取当代社区生活略有新意，但通篇口号式直说，无具体情事与形象，'暖心房''岁月静好''情谊长'皆套话连缀。四句原地平列，起承转合俱无，'共'字两见显凑。结句说破说尽，毫无余味。陈滥密度极高，从重扣分。","_cost":0.00204354},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":2.5,"意境":2.0,"语言":2.0,"章法":3.0,"余味":1.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":19.75,"rationale":"题旨明确但流于宣传口号，少具体情事；暖心、菜香、岁月静好等皆现成套语，情景未融；语言平顺而多熟词凑韵，章法并列少转结，末句说尽无余味。","_cost":0.008434},"kimi-k3":{"立意":2.0,"意境":1.0,"语言":2.0,"章法":2.0,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":14.0,"rationale":"题材虽新却写成宣传口号:四句平铺直叙、同义反复('共'字三见),'暖心房''情谊长''岁月静好'皆熟滥套语,无象可寻、无转无结,结句兜底说尽,毫无余味。","_cost":0.0074553},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":3.5,"意境":3.0,"语言":3.2,"章法":3.0,"余味":2.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":28.65,"rationale":"题材当代但全用暖心房、菜香四溢、岁月静好等套语，无具体情事与精切物象，四句平行铺排无转折，结句口号说尽无余味。","_cost":0.00745125},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":3.0,"意境":2.0,"语言":4.0,"章法":4.0,"余味":2.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":27.5,"rationale":"题意直白，社区食堂温情仅为空泛口号；意象仅“菜香四溢”套语，通篇直说；语言通顺无诗眼；结构完整而转结平直；结句“岁月静好”陈词说尽，无余味。陈滥密集。","_cost":0.024122876},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":2.0,"意境":1.5,"语言":2.5,"章法":2.0,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":16.25,"rationale":"全诗为空泛颂赞套话，无具体事象细节，四句平推无转合层次，满篇陈熟公共语，表意直白说尽，乏余味与新意。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":2.5,"意境":2.0,"语言":2.0,"章法":2.0,"余味":1.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":2.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":18.25,"rationale":"题材有当代性,但通篇是颂赞口号,缺少具体人事与发现。意象只有泛泛的'菜香',其余多是干说。'暖心房''岁月静好'为流行套话,'共'字重复,句式近白话。四句平铺,没有转折。结句说破兜底,毫无余味。","_cost":0.014012},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":4.0,"意境":2.0,"语言":2.0,"章法":2.0,"余味":1.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":3.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":21.0,"rationale":"题旨明确，但只写邻里共餐之乐，缺少具体情事。除菜香外少有可感之象；「暖心房」「共餐忙」欠自然。四句意思重复，结句以「岁月静好」说尽，余味较弱。","_cost":0.005414}},"consensus":20.61,"final":15.46},{"key":"grok-4.7|深夜视频|七律","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"夜半屏光冷似秋，传来笑语莫教休。锅边热气灯将散，巷口微芒水独流。暗里人声沉又起，荧中客影换难收。殷勤一捺辉全灭，枕上残温梦外浮。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"屏冷与残温相映，写视频散后的依恋，结句有余韵。中二联声影略复，巷景衔接偏弱；“灯将散”“荧中”“换难收”欠自然。当代经验入诗有效，但尚未充分化为独到发现。","_cost":0.04909},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"以深夜视频通话写牵念，当代经验入诗有效，屏光冷、一捺辉灭切题。中二联景象指向模糊，颈联与首联意稍重复，层次欠开合；“莫教休”“换难收”“殷勤”等词略生硬。结句残温梦外浮留白有余韵。","_cost":0.05514},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.8,"rationale":"成功将当代深夜视频连线经验入律。“殷勤一捺”、“锅边热气”等细节真切生动，屏内外冷暖明暗对比鲜明。颔颈联铺陈稍显杂碎，然尾联熄屏归寂，留有余味。","_cost":0.00580425},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"写深夜视频通话，情感具体，结句以枕上残温收束，留白有余味。中二联意象稍散，'灯将散''换难收'略生硬，但现代经验入诗有亮点。","_cost":0.00797544},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"视频通话入七律，当代经验化古有效。屏光冷与锅边热气对照，隔屏见景融情。中二联声影开合有层次，尾联一捺灭辉、残温梦外浮，结得含蓄有余味。语言偶有生硬处如换难收。","_cost":0.00356196},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.55,"rationale":"深夜视频入诗，角度新，屏光、笑语、灭屏余温一线贯串。中二联内外互映，颇有清寂氛围。惟‘莫教休’‘换难收’稍显旧凑，个别意象略泛。","_cost":0.014798},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"以视频通话写离别牵念，当代经验入律自然，屏光之冷与笑语之温对照见情。中二联意象妥帖而稍熟，\"灯将散\"\"换难收\"炼字略生硬。结句残温浮于梦外，宕开有韵，余味最佳。","_cost":0.016434},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.2,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.9,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.10000000000001,"rationale":"屏光冷秋对笑语温存，按灭后残温收束，当代题材立意具体；颔联锅边巷口游离主线致意境不一；“殷勤一捺”牵率，句法欠锤炼；中二联断续；尾联以景结情略有余味。","_cost":0.0089935},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.25,"rationale":"以深夜视频通话入律，起承转合清晰，尾联熄屏残温以意象收束，余味悠长；中二联写屏中景与声影，层次分明。惟‘灯将散’等语略拙，立意常见而情真。","_cost":0.02967094},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.4,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.7,"rationale":"本诗撷取当代深夜视频通话的日常经验入律，屏内屏外虚实对举，章法流转自然，炼字有巧思，结句留淡怅余味，唯‘换难收’稍隔，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":4.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.75,"rationale":"以深夜视频入诗有当代感，屏光之冷与锅边热气形成冷暖对照。但全篇在视频通话与刷短视频之间摇摆，主脑不清。颈联与颔联多为同类铺写，层次不足。“荧中”“殷勤一捺”生涩，结句“残温”稍有余韵，“梦外浮”偏虚。","_cost":0.019056},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"屏光明灭写隔屏相念，有当代生活气息；锅边与巷口的场景转换欠交代，“灯将散”“客影换难收”语意欠稳。末句以残温收束，留有余味。","_cost":0.012408}},"consensus":73.09,"final":73.09},{"key":"grok-4.7|社区食堂|七律","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"午市初开满室香，邻翁策杖入厅堂。钢盘正盛家常菜，铁勺轻分豆腐汤。莫谓廉餐唯饱腹，须知暖意已回肠。归时袖底犹余热，转首窗光尚未凉。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.0,"rationale":"策杖、钢盘、豆腐汤使社区温情具体可感，题旨仍较常见。颈联议论说破，“暖意回肠”稍显牵强；尾联以余热承接窗光，将人情融入景物，留有余韵。当代日常入诗略见新意。","_cost":0.04878},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":58.75,"rationale":"当代民生入诗,场景具体,钢盘铁勺豆腐汤写实可感;但颈联‘莫谓…须知…’直陈议论,情意说破,转折平直。尾联袖底余热、窗光未凉以景结情,余味较佳,为全篇亮点。","_cost":0.04047},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.8,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.15,"rationale":"切中当代民生题材，钢盘铁勺切合生活真实。中二联由实入虚，颈联说理稍显直白，尾联融情于微温光景，收束含蓄有余味，脉络清晰自然。","_cost":0.003999},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.75,"rationale":"当代题材，情意真实但议论略直；意象具体，尾联以余热窗光收束，含蓄有延宕。中二联对仗稳而炼字偏平。优劣互见，故各维拉开。","_cost":0.010331376},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.25,"rationale":"当代社区养老食堂入诗,取材真切,情事具体。中二联一实一虚,'钢盘''铁勺'取象精切,'袖底犹余热'以细节传暖。结联以景结情、言尽意不尽。颈联议论稍直白,'暖意回肠'微近套语,整体气息贯通,格守而意暖。","_cost":0.00222204},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.3,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.4,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.95,"rationale":"立足社区食堂，场景具体，温暖有主脑。钢盘铁勺等当代物象入诗自然，尾联余热窗光留味。惜颈联议论稍直，暖意回肠略熟，语言锤炼未深。","_cost":0.012072},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"当代题材入律且落到实处，邻翁、钢盘、铁勺取象具体，情事真切。颈联'莫谓/须知'转议论稍平直带说教味。结联'袖底余热''窗光未凉'以景结情、暖意双关，是全诗最见功力处。通篇工稳妥帖而缺惊人句，故各维居中等偏上。","_cost":0.00557976},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.4,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.9,"rationale":"社区食堂切近民生以小见暖有主脑，颔联白描颈联说理稍直，尾联袖热窗光以景结情具余味，炼字平实少诗眼。","_cost":0.01136575},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"写社区食堂，取材当代，首尾以景融情；中二联由物及议，结句‘窗光尚未凉’留白有余味。然取象稍实，语多平白，颈联议论直露。","_cost":0.023849776},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"以邻翁就餐小切口展现社区食堂的民生暖意，意象贴实，章法顺畅，结句以窗光留温有余韵，语言平实，当代经验入诗有新意，唯思致稍平。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":50.5,"rationale":"题材属当代社区生活。颔联写钢盘、铁勺，细节具体。颈联以'莫谓/须知'直接说理，'回肠'常用于愁肠之意，此处用来写暖意略显生硬，转折也平。尾联以余热、窗光作结，稍有余味，但'热'与'未凉'意思相近，意境不够开阔。","_cost":0.014968},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.0,"rationale":"策杖入堂、钢盘分汤，写出了社区食堂的生活质地；颈联直说暖意，“回肠”稍显生硬。尾联回到余热与窗光，收束有温存，也留有余味。","_cost":0.008076}},"consensus":68.35,"final":68.35},{"key":"grok-4.7|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"夜扫云仓万架长，屏光屡切未开箱。行间腕冷人初散，月色低临入远廊。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫写劳作中的清冷，屏光与腕冷相映，当代物象入诗有效。“屡切”稍涩，“未开箱”的情意关联未足；由人散转月廊脉络清楚，结句留有空间，但尚无特别凝练的警策之语。","_cost":0.03769},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.5,"rationale":"以电商云仓夜班扫码入诗，屏光与月色冷暖相映，腕冷人散见劳者孤寂，当代经验入诗有效。惟“屏光屡切未开箱”稍生硬含混，转折略平；结以月入远廊以景收情，留白可取。","_cost":0.05368},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.6,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.35,"rationale":"切入现代仓储夜作，将“屏光”“腕冷”等当代劳动经验自然入诗，体察真切而不隔。章法承转顺畅，结句以月色入廊宕开，以景结情，清冷自生余味。","_cost":0.00363375},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"写云仓夜间扫码劳作，转句以“腕冷人散”带入身体感受，结句以月色入廊收束，含蓄清冷，章法完整。个别用语如“屡切”“未开箱”偏实涩，立意略浅。题材意象有当代感。","_cost":0.01063095},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.75,"rationale":"云仓储运夜班是当代经验入诗，题材新且情事具体。屏光、冷腕与月色远廊相融，工业场景缀以古典月色，结句以景收束，言尽意留。惟'屡切'炼字稍晦，转句层次略平，月色结法本身偏熟。","_cost":0.0030384},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.2,"章法":6.8,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"写当代云仓夜扫，场景具体，清寂氛围自现；‘腕冷’有体感，结以月色远廊留白。然‘屏光屡切未开箱’语稍硬，现代词与古雅语未全融合，转折亦平。","_cost":0.013442},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"当代仓储夜班入诗而不猎奇，屏光、腕冷、人散、月廊层层收束，劳务的孤寒具体可感；结句以景宕开有余味。个别词语稍紧、月色意象略熟，未成大伤。","_cost":0.00838056},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.6,"章法":6.9,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.3,"rationale":"云仓夜扫题材新颖，屏光/月光冷暖对照，腕冷一细节真切有焦点；以景结收留白有余味，唯万架、远廊等语较平。","_cost":0.0112485},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"云仓夜班题材新，屏光腕冷真切；转结由人散到月色远廊，景收有余。语言稍硬，承句滞，结句略熟。","_cost":0.029572558},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.5,"rationale":"此作取材当代云仓夜作，细节真切，脉络顺畅，以景结留清寂余韵，当代意象融入自然；唯立意稍平，“屡切”略涩，整体偏平实，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.0,"rationale":"以云仓夜间扫码入诗，当代劳动经验有效入诗。“屏光屡切”“腕冷”取象具体，寒夜氛围统一。第三句转得偏平，“低临入”略有叠床。结句以月入远廊作景结，稳当但较常见，余味有限。","_cost":0.016692},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"屏光、腕冷与月色相映，写出云仓夜间劳作的清寂；由作业转向人散、廊远，结句留有余味。“万架长”“低临入”措辞稍涩。","_cost":0.008078}},"consensus":72.14,"final":72.14},{"key":"grok-4.7|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"grok-4.7","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"云低廪脊夜灯凉，自扫空廊净石场。尘起梁阴粮积厚，霜封壁隙鼠行忙。仓盈更觉怜田父，年稳犹愁怕后荒。月转西楹眠未得，东方欲白垛如冈。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"仓满忧荒，主脑清楚，夜扫诸象较为连贯；“年稳”稍涩，“犹愁怕”语意叠复，颈联议论偏直。结以破晓粮垛映衬彻夜忧思，尚有余味，但整体翻新有限。","_cost":0.04423},"claude-fable-5.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.5,"rationale":"以守仓人夜扫为视角，物象具体（霜封壁隙、鼠行、垛如冈），结句以景收情尚有余味。惟颈联直陈议论，'愁怕'语义重叠，'年稳'嫌弱，居安思危之意常见，章法平稳而少变。","_cost":0.05932},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":6.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":0.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"夜扫仓廪取象精实，颔联见现场动感。颈联忧农念荒情志真挚，唯“愁怕”稍显直露。尾联由宵入曙，以“垛如冈”雄阔景致收结，言尽意不尽，通篇脉络贯通。","_cost":0.00528825},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"守仓人夜扫视角翻出怜农忧荒之思，立意有主脑；仓廪夜景物象精切统一，'霜封壁隙鼠行忙'见功力，结句以垛如冈宕开收景。颈联'更觉怜''犹愁怕'动词叠用，语近凑滞；'净石场'稍生硬，扣语言分。","_cost":0.00470844},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.3,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.2,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.9,"rationale":"夜扫粮仓题材具体，悯农忧荒情志真切；意象统一，尾联以景收束有余味。语言通顺但颈联偏直白，个别词语如“净石场”略生，整体中上。","_cost":0.009535004},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.8,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"夜扫粮仓，细节清冷，仓盈翻出悯农之忧，脉络贯通；颈联警切而稍直，结以黎明垛影留余味。语言妥帖，然略涉说明。","_cost":0.009752},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.75,"rationale":"守夜扫仓、怜农忧荒,题旨具体有主脑,悯农居安思危角度尚稳但不新。尘梁霜隙鼠行取象精切,夜寒氛围统一。颈联'年稳犹愁怕后荒'文白夹杂、炼字欠工,稍伤通体。起承转合完整,结以'垛如冈'以景结情,留白有余味,惟'东方欲白'近套。","_cost":0.020568},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.6,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.7,"余味":5.9,"警句":1.5,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.05,"rationale":"夜扫仓廪由实景转怜农忧荒，主脑明确但丰年思歉属熟境；仓廪意象具体统一，章法起承转合有序，语言平实少锤炼，结句以景收而余味平淡。","_cost":0.009584},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"主题怜农忧荒，角度稍新而语直；夜仓霜鼠等意象冷寂妥帖；起承转合完整，结句以景留白、言尽意不尽；颔颈联见佳联，语言稍平，‘田父’‘东方欲白’稍陈，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.034859683},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"此诗写守仓人夜扫所见所感，惜粮悯农之情真挚，意象贴合实境，章法环环相扣顺妥连贯，以景结尚有余韵；唯整体偏平实，炼字新警不足，无硬伤、套话及蹈袭。","_cost":null},"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":0.5,"出新":0.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":53.5,"rationale":"守仓夜扫、丰年忧荒,题旨明确,角度较常见。颔联「鼠行忙」细节可感,但「尘起」与「粮积厚」因果勉强。颈联直说,「犹愁怕」语意叠床。结句以粮垛如冈的晨景收束,呼应仓盈,略有余味。","_cost":0.018168},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":0.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.75,"rationale":"夜扫粮仓写丰年仍忧荒年，主旨清楚；灯、尘、霜、鼠使场景可感。中联直陈情志，“犹愁怕”语意重复。结句以晓光映粮垛，收束稳妥，余味稍浅。","_cost":0.008276}},"consensus":69.34,"final":69.34},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"绒偶堆箱笑靥斜,纤钩乍落力偏赊。人间我亦橱中物,犹待谁人一爪拿。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":true},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.4,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.2,"rationale":"由抓取无力转入自况，写被动待选之感，主脑集中。“笑靥斜”传神，“力偏赊”稍显牵强。转句有力，结句回扣爪钩，但直陈期待，留白有限。","_cost":0.03898},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.6,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.55,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机喻当代人生存境遇，物象精切，“笑靥斜”“力偏赊”体察入微。章法由物及人，转折自然。唯结句“一爪拿”语涉直白且径直说破，余味稍欠。当代生活入诗颇见巧思。","_cost":0.006381},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"以弱爪抓偶喻人成橱中待选之物,主脑集中,当代经验入诗有效。起承转合清楚,笑靥斜、乍落较切;力偏赊稍晦。结句明言等待,余味靠前句力弱反衬,未以景宕开。无硬伤袭套。","_cost":0.0253264},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.6,"rationale":"前二句咏物真切，“笑靥斜”有巧思；第三句转入自喻，章法紧凑。结句问而不尽，但“一爪拿”稍直露，语言略有文白相杂。整体以抓娃娃机寄身世之感，当代性强。","_cost":0.0039676032},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.0,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入绝句，取象精切，'赊'字见炼，物我转换一气贯注，结以问句宕开留白。然'我亦橱中物'直陈喻义，稍涉说破；立意机巧有余而情志深度一般，喻体新而所喻之意仍属常见。","_cost":0.017417},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.4,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.3,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机起兴，由爪落力赊转入人生待选，构思新巧，主脑明确。绒偶、纤钩等意象统一，但第三句说破稍直，余味略减。语言自然，个别词稍生。","_cost":0.01204},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机起兴,由物及人翻出'我亦橱中物'的自喻,当代经验入诗且主脑集中,转笔有力;'力偏赊''笑靥斜'炼字见功。唯结句'犹待谁人一爪拿'自白说破,余味稍损;前两句意象妥帖但未臻奇警。","_cost":0.0054128},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.1,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.9,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.85,"rationale":"借娃娃机自况物我合一，立意新巧；钩爪箱偶意象聚焦交融，起承转合自然，结句设问有余味。","_cost":0.0095565},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.5,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机喻人被物化、待挑选，立意新奇；转结人机互喻，章法紧凑。语言文白夹杂，'赊'稍硬；结句设问留余味。无硬伤蹈袭，当代经验入诗有效。","_cost":0.0358254},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"借抓娃娃机日常场景托意，由物及人翻出身处世网、被动待选的共通感，章法顺畅，取象切题，炼字精准，唯结句稍直，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":4.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.0,"rationale":"由抓娃娃转写盼人垂顾，取材新而情意可感；前两句有画面，第三句转入自身也自然。惟“力偏赊”语意稍涩，末句将所待说尽，余味偏弱。","_cost":0.008086}},"consensus":80.17,"final":80.17},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"慈针密线尚留痕,叠入街头铁口吞。莫问明朝谁著得,但教霜夜有余温。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"由旧衣针线写亲情向陌生人传递，题材转化有效。“铁口吞”与“余温”冷暖相映；“慈针”略涩。转结顺畅，但末句愿语较熟，情意偏于明说。化用慈母缝衣意象，不属整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.04931},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.1,"章法":8.3,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.55,"rationale":"当代题材切入精妙。“铁口吞”状物传神，由私人亲情自然升华为众生大爱，脉络顺畅无滞。结句发愿略显直白说尽、余味偏薄，但全篇情怀真挚，当代经验入诗典雅得体。","_cost":0.0054225},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"针线余温延续于匿名他人,情事具体而意偏熟。铁口一吞冷暖相形,为全篇不可删之象。慈字直说,莫问但教为熟套,结句点出余温,收得住而偏直白。回收箱入诗有效,无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0300016},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"立意真挚但较常见；‘铁口吞’见力度，‘霜夜余温’留暖意，唯‘慈针’稍涩。章法转结稳当，结句以景收束有余味。旧衣回收题材具当代经验，化用尚自然，无硬伤。","_cost":0.018987},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱这一当代物件入诗，暗化《游子吟》慈母线痕，小中见大，情事具体。“铁口吞”取象精狠，转句“莫问”宕开，结句“霜夜余温”收束温厚、言尽意不尽。通篇无一废字，物与情浑融，是旧题翻新、当代经验入诗的佳作。","_cost":0.0019269432},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.2,"rationale":"题取旧衣回收，针线余温贯穿，立意温厚；铁口吞有势稍露，慈针密线略熟。起承转合清楚，末句留暖。","_cost":0.012092},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":1.0,"score":74.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱当代物象入诗,化用'慈母手中线'而翻出新意,'铁口吞'取象生辣,霜夜余温由衣及人、由私及公,情事具体有主脑。结句以愿代答,留白延宕,余味最佳。唯'慈针密线'承袭痕迹明显,'谁著得'略生硬,炼字未到化境。","_cost":0.009912},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.1,"语言":7.8,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.3,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.95,"rationale":"借回收箱将私慈转为共暖，主脑集中不说教；慈针与铁口、霜夜对比精切，转合由施及愿，结句以温景结情，余韵不尽。","_cost":0.013524},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，慈针密线化用《游子吟》，铁口吞与霜夜余温构成冷暖对照，情真而焦点集中；结句以‘余温’宕开留白。章法起承转合完整而转折稍平，意象妥帖少陈滥，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.027201951},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.25,"rationale":"此作取当代旧衣回收题材，化用传统针线意象，翻出善意传递新旨；“吞”字炼得精当，章法顺畅，结句温厚稍直，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.75,"rationale":"针线旧痕与街头铁箱相接，写出旧衣所承的亲情及赠人的心意；当代物象入诗自然。转结顺畅，但“谁著得”稍拗，末句点明温情，余味略浅。","_cost":0.008102}},"consensus":78.89,"final":78.89},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|机场送别|七绝","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"咫尺黄痕不许随,回眸犹隔薄玻璃。一灯红上青冥去,独向繁星认是谁。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.6,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.7,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.4,"rationale":"黄痕、玻璃将离情落实为可见的阻隔，红灯入星空，由近而远，层次清楚。末句以寻认寄不舍，留有余味；“红上”搭配稍涩，“认是谁”略显刻意，但机场物象有效翻新送别旧题。","_cost":0.04139},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.7,"意境":8.9,"语言":8.4,"章法":8.8,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.7,"rationale":"将机场黄线、玻璃幕墙与航行红灯等现代经验完美化入绝句。转结从咫尺拉至青冥繁星，视境开阔，张力十足；结句痴绝苍茫，极具留白与感染力。","_cost":0.0053265},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"送别之情真切而角度未出古意，新在机场阻隔，故立意只取中上，出新另计。意象由黄线、玻璃推至红灯、繁星，交融紧凑。结句以认留问，余味足。黄痕稍晦，青冥回眸略熟，语言次之。","_cost":0.0316512},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.8,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.6,"余味":9.3,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.5,"rationale":"机场送别以黄线、玻璃、红灯、繁星等现代意象翻新离情，主脑集中，转结巧妙留白；后二句可成佳句。唯“黄痕”稍显晦涩，略损语言自然。","_cost":0.0075392},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.75,"rationale":"以机场黄线、玻璃隔断入诗,旧题翻出新境,情感真切。'咫尺不许随'与'隔薄玻璃'由近而不得近,层层递逼;'一灯红上青冥去'以景转,结句'独向繁星认是谁'以痴问收,言尽意不尽,余味悠长。'黄痕'指警界线略需揣度,微瑕不掩。","_cost":0.0016765128},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.4,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.3,"rationale":"机场送别取象新切，黄线、玻璃、红灯、繁星构成离境氛围；转结由实入远，‘认是谁’留白。唯‘黄痕’‘薄玻璃’稍生略平。","_cost":0.011082},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.5,"rationale":"黄线、玻璃、航灯皆机场实景,层层推进至'独向繁星认是谁',以景结情,余韵悠长;当代经验入旧体而不隔,主脑集中。唯'青冥''繁星'略熟,'黄痕'稍生,未减其佳。","_cost":0.0097392},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.6,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.7,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.95,"rationale":"以黄痕薄玻璃红航灯写当代送别，咫尺天涯真切可感，四象由地面递至青冥繁星，末句发问宕开，余韵悠长。","_cost":0.00899225},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.5,"rationale":"以机场黄线、薄玻璃写现代送别，情境真切；转句“一灯红”振起，结句星中认人，言尽意远，章法完密。语言稍白，然化古出新，当代经验入诗，佳联动人。","_cost":0.027756831},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.8,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.9,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.45,"rationale":"此作写当代机场送别，抓取黄线、隔离玻璃、夜航灯等专属细节，层层递写阻隔怅惘，章法圆转，结句以痴望留白，语浅情深，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.5,"rationale":"由黄线、玻璃写送别之隔，再以机灯没入繁星作结，情景递进，余味悠长。“黄痕”“一灯红”稍显费解，“青冥”略熟。","_cost":0.008018}},"consensus":88.33,"final":88.33},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"琉璃方匣锁绒囚,一币投时兴未休。屏气徐推钢爪落,悬心忽见粉团浮。临门偏是松钳处,倾袋犹余最后筹。空手归来城似柜,千窗灯火待谁钩。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"unknown"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.7,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.95,"rationale":"投币、悬爪、失手、倾袋，递进清楚；末联以城为柜，将游戏中的受诱与受困推向日常生活，设问留有余波。“绒囚”略显刻意，“兴未休”较泛，语言精度稍逊于构思。","_cost":0.04977},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.5,"rationale":"题材现代而融铸无痕。前三联状写抓物之悬心波折，极具现场感；尾联骤然宕开，以城为柜，反照都市生存困境，结句意蕴深远，余味绵长。","_cost":0.0045915},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"近事可感,城似柜是真发现,焦点收得住。绒囚、松钳、千窗与钩交融,中段偏叙事。次句兴未休稍熟,余多锤炼。起转结贯通,承联平。结句不说破,问意宕开。","_cost":0.0276064},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.7,"余味":9.3,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.55,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机隐喻城市欲望，尾联城似柜、灯火待谁钩宕开一笔，余味不尽。中二联动作心理层递，炼字见锁绒囚、松钳处。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0172661},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写都市孤独,熟题翻新,主脑鲜明。'城似柜'、'待谁钩'将人、城、机三层勾连,结句以景结情、言尽意不尽。'锁绒囚''粉团浮'炼字见诗眼,中二联叙事有开合,颈联转出挫败,章法一气贯注。物象与情意交融,当代经验入诗自然无痕。","_cost":0.0035369},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.1,"rationale":"取材抓娃娃机，过程写得真切，末联由游戏宕入城市如柜、灯火待钩，颇有寄托与余味。语言新巧而偶见险涩，章法完整。","_cost":0.01518},"kimi-k3":{"立意":9.2,"意境":8.8,"语言":8.7,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.5,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":97.4,"rationale":"以抓娃娃写欲望、侥幸与都市困境，细节连贯且尾联升维有力；个别措辞稍熟，但整体精切新颖。","_cost":0.0087667564},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.7,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.9,"rationale":"小机见大城，绒囚钢爪取象精切，情景交融；由得失宕至城柜灯火，锤炼有诗眼，尾联以景结情余味悠长。","_cost":0.01138025},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.75,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机喻都市人生，立意新、章法熟；尾联“千窗灯火”以景结情，余味深长。中二联生动有层次，然“绒囚”“城似柜”稍直白，意象语言未臻高境。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.027907243},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.3,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.55,"rationale":"此作取材抓娃娃的当代日常，炼字妥帖，章法圆融，尾联以城喻机，翻出都市人悬望落空的共感，余味悠长，仅个别意象稍熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.95,"rationale":"由抓取落空推至满城灯窗，机匣与城市相映，尾问留下人与物的双重悬念。中二联动作传神；“兴未休”稍显凑语。","_cost":0.008054}},"consensus":89.27,"final":89.27},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"天台箱盎列纵横,瓜蔓偏缘晾架生。阿母辞田经十载,犹凭老眼卜阴晴。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":["纵"],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":0.75,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"瓜蔓攀晾架，将农耕经验嵌入天台日常，情事具体。第三句由景转人，末句以看天动作寄寓未改的乡土习性，“卜”字有味。起句偏于交代，整体语言稳妥，独立警策性稍弱。","_cost":0.05462},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"当代城市经验入诗,真切动人。起承描摹天台微型菜圃,转结精炼自然。结句以“老眼卜阴晴”的细节白描收束,传神写出离土老人深植骨髓的农人惯性,言尽而意蕴悠长。","_cost":0.0054375},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"辞田十载仍卜阴晴,主脑集中,情事可感,箱盎晾架使当代经验入诗不隔。起句铺陈平弱,炼字仅偏、卜见光,境不够厚;结句以动作收,未说破,余味尚存。","_cost":0.0236864},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.7,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.1,"rationale":"写城市天台种菜与母亲旧习，转结以老眼卜阴晴收束，细节真切，留白有余味；偏字精当。全篇无硬伤陈套，唯列纵横稍平。","_cost":0.0097979},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"都市天台种菜而忆母辞田十载,熟题翻新,主脑聚焦于农耕本能与亲情的延续。箱盎、晾架取象精切,转句由物及人自然有力。结句'犹凭老眼卜阴晴'以细节收束,言尽意不尽,人物跃然。'箱盎'稍显生硬,余皆妥帖。","_cost":0.0016324488},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.6,"rationale":"天台箱盎、晾架瓜蔓写入诗，见当代日常；转至阿母辞田，以老眼卜阴晴收束，含蓄有余。语言朴素，首句稍平直。","_cost":0.013056},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"以天台箱盎种瓜写进城老农,题旨新而情事具体;转结'阿母辞田经十载,犹凭老眼卜阴晴'将农耕记忆嵌入都市空间,含蓄有余味。'列纵横'稍生硬,意象密度略疏,但整体情真语切、当代经验入诗有效。","_cost":0.0067401},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.8,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.55,"rationale":"天台箱盎切当代，转入辞田老母犹卜阴晴，题小情真；起承转合分明，结以动作收，景情交融余味长。","_cost":0.01064625},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"取象新鲜（箱盎、晾架）而情事具体，转结以‘老眼卜阴晴’收束，乡土记忆融入都市天台，余味足。微瑕在‘箱盎’稍古奥、起句平实，故未至满分。","_cost":0.031597876},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.3,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.7,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.55,"rationale":"作品取天台种菜日常片段，抓取阿母离田十载仍凭老眼卜阴晴的细节，情感真挚，章法顺畅，语言平实干净，意象贴实，结句有余韵，无硬伤陈套。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"菜箱、晾架写出天台种植的生活实感，后两句由眼前瓜蔓转入阿母身世，见离田未离农的情意。结句有余韵；首句“列纵横”稍显板滞。","_cost":0.008114}},"consensus":81.68,"final":61.26},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"街隅铁柜漆犹新,窄口吞衣不问因。袖短方惊儿骨长,襟宽尚认母腰身。寒村或借他肩暖,陌路难知旧日亲。空手归时风乍冷,皮囊也待付谁人。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.2,"余味":6.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"由旧衣牵出成长与亲情，再推向陌路温暖、生死归属，层次清楚。颔联以衣写人，具体动人；“借他肩暖”语意稍曲。结句设问有延宕，但“皮囊”直揭哲思，略显用力。","_cost":0.04187},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.8,"意境":8.7,"语言":8.8,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.2,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":95.05,"rationale":"当代日常物象入诗极自然。颔联以衣度人，母子深情真切动人；颈联推想去向见世情；尾联归于自身，以风冷空手引出皮囊之叹，升华至生死宿命，章法井然，寄托深远。","_cost":0.00665775},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.3,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.35,"rationale":"以回收箱串起亲情与身后之思，袖短襟宽一联情事具体，是全篇骨力。后半寒村陌路偏虚，结句以皮囊点破喻意，余味受损。语言大体锤炼，皮囊、陌路稍熟。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0188112},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.8,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.2,"rationale":"旧衣箱生发出亲情记忆与人生去处，立意独到；中二联由衣及人、由近及远，章法开合。颈联稍平但意象切题。尾联以景反问收束，余味悠长。‘袖短’联精警，当代物象入诗自然。","_cost":0.01378377},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":95.25,"rationale":"回收箱入七律，当代经验与'皮囊'之思绾合，主脑坚、情事切。颔联'袖短方惊儿骨长，襟宽尚认母腰身'以衣写岁月双向流逝，最警动；'吞''惊''认'炼字见眼。颈联稍涉议论，意象略让。结句以问宕开，言尽意远。","_cost":0.02094556},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.7,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.3,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.9,"rationale":"以街隅铁柜起题，袖襟两联由旧衣牵出亲长，情真象切；颈联推开至寒村陌路，尾联以风冷皮囊设问，有余味而略涉熟语。当代物象入诗较新。","_cost":0.01477},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收勾连成长、母身与施受隔膜，题旨集中且有现实感。中联对仗精切，最见功力；结句宕向生死，余味足而略显用力。","_cost":0.015969},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.25,"rationale":"以铁柜收衣切入，颔联袖短襟宽见亲情，颈联宕至寒村陌路，尾联由衣及皮囊设问，物小思深，结构一气贯注结句留白。","_cost":0.00893225},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.25,"rationale":"以回收箱写旧衣，颔联由衣见儿长母身，情事真切；转结由暖人至皮囊之问，意脉贯而余味长。语言凝练有诗眼，中二联稍欠景深，故意境略减。当代经验入诗出新，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.028470803},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"以当代旧衣回收箱入律，取象精切，颔联亲情细节动人，章法圆融流转，由衣及人叩问归宿，唯结句稍直，无硬伤、套语与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.75,"rationale":"由旧衣牵出儿女成长、母亲身影，再由捐衣转问自身归处，脉络贯通。颔联具体动人，结句留有思索；“寒村”稍显悬空，“皮囊”略熟。","_cost":0.009934}},"consensus":87.6,"final":87.6},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|云端相册|七绝","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"指底流年一触还,高堂犹是鬓无斑。如今亦作云中客,咫尺屏光隔万山。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.4,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.89999999999999,"rationale":"触屏唤回旧照，“云”叠合相册存储与亲人远逝，数字悼亲有新意，今昔转折清楚。结句以空间阻隔暗写生死距离，尚有余响；“亦”字承接稍虚，“咫尺—万山”对举略熟。","_cost":0.0595},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.4,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.95,"rationale":"当代数字经验入诗的典范。触屏翻照化用无痕，“云中客”双关科技与生死悬隔，转折有力。结句“咫尺屏光隔万山”以冷光托出无尽时空阻绝，意境凄绝，余味深长。","_cost":0.0053955},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"思亲题旨明确,云相册无斑之鬓尚具体,但情事偏类型化,新境有限。指底、屏光能融情,流年高堂万山较熟。炼字通顺,一触、犹是见用心。起承转合完整,亦字转折略巧。结句点明隔绝,收得住而少延宕。","_cost":0.036986},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.5,"rationale":"以触屏翻相册切入，写数字时代亲情距离；转结用咫尺屏光与万山对照，留有余味。语言简炼，章法完整。立意稍常见。","_cost":0.007839744},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.75,"rationale":"以'云端'双关扣题：指尖翻看旧照，见高堂昔日青鬓，转句'云中客'兼指云端存储与漂泊之身，结句'咫尺屏光隔万山'以近写远，物象与情意交融。当代经验入诗自然无痕，起承转合完足，转结尤佳。'隔万山'稍承熟语，然非袭用。","_cost":0.00162752832},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.39999999999999,"rationale":"以云端相册写亲情与时距，触屏、屏光等当代意象入诗，起承转合完整，结句有咫尺天涯之慨。语词基本凝练，唯流年、万山稍熟，云中客略泛。","_cost":0.009026},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"以云端相册写流年亲情，'云中客'双关生死，'咫尺屏光隔万山'化咫尺天涯而不着痕迹，当代经验入诗妥帖，结句宕开有余味。惟'一触还'稍涩，中二句意脉略平。","_cost":0.0066705},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.7,"意境":6.4,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.2,"警句":1.8,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.55,"rationale":"以一触还流年切入云端相册，以咫尺屏光收束万山之隔，当代经验真切；章法转合自然结句以景结情，惜前半意象偏虚叙，锤炼未臻精切。","_cost":0.01112525},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"以云端相册写数字亲近与山河远隔，立意集中出新；屏光隔万山为警句，转句稍平、具象略薄，无硬伤，结句尚有余味。","_cost":0.027085238},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"以当代云端相册入诗，写触屏见父母旧照触发的羁旅思亲，双关自然，章法顺畅，结句以屏山反差寄慨，唯个别意象稍熟。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"指尖翻相册，旧日父母与眼前屏光形成今昔之隔；“云中客”兼有云端与远逝之意。结句有余味，但“隔万山”稍熟，“亦”字所指略虚。","_cost":0.00811}},"consensus":80.38,"final":80.38},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|机场送别|七律","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"黄线横分咫尺间,回身犹露少年颜。行箱半是家乡味,嘱语多于两鬓斑。窗外银鹰频拔地,心随每架上云山。从今我夜君方昼,枕畔屏灯不敢关。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"weak"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"黄线、乡味、时差与屏灯贯串送别，情事具体；由眼前送行转入日后牵挂，尾句“不敢关”含蓄有力。“嘱语多于两鬓斑”比量稍显牵强，银鹰、云山较熟。","_cost":0.04208},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.2,"rationale":"当代离别经验入诗之佳作。黄线、行箱、时差等物象精炼真切；尾联以“枕畔屏灯不敢关”作结，将越洋牵念化为典型生活细节，余味深长。颈联“银鹰”稍俗，整体一气贯注。","_cost":0.00507825},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"送别情事具体，时差与屏灯翻出新境，焦点清楚。黄线、嘱语较精，银鹰云山偏熟，颈联顺承少变；结句未说破，余味可感。","_cost":0.0269552},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.8,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.8,"rationale":"送别题常见，但以机场黄线、银鹰、时差、屏灯等现代细节入诗，情感具体真切。颔联“行箱半是家乡味”与尾联“枕畔屏灯不敢关”摘出仍动人，结句以守灯细节留白，余味绵长。个别意象如“云山”“两鬓斑”稍熟。","_cost":0.005619216},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"送别熟题而以机场安检线、时差昼夜、枕畔屏灯等当代经验翻出新境，情事具体真挚。'嘱语多于两鬓斑'以数量语写深情，堪称诗眼。'银鹰''每架上云山'稍显直白，颈联略平，但结句以物象留白，掩卷有余温。","_cost":0.00202266},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.8,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.10000000000001,"rationale":"机场送别以黄线、行箱、时差、屏灯入诗，细节新而情真；尾联含而不露，余味佳。惟“嘱语”句稍拗，银鹰、云山略熟。","_cost":0.010566},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"送别熟题翻出新境:跨国时差、屏灯守候使慈母送子之情具体可感。颔联'行箱半是家乡味,嘱语多于两鬓斑'对仗工而情真,足称佳联。结句以枕边不敢关屏灯的细节收束,言尽意不尽。惜'银鹰拔地''上云山'略近熟套,'心随每架'造语稍涩,通体仍属上乘。","_cost":0.0117432},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.6,"章法":7.1,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.05,"rationale":"以黄线、屏灯、昼夜颠倒写当代机场送别，细节具体赋旧题新感，尾联以灯不关代牵念尤佳；中二联银鹰云山略熟，转折平实。","_cost":0.00985375},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.25,"rationale":"以机场黄线、时差、屏灯等当代经验写送别，情事真切；尾联‘我夜君昼’‘不敢关’含蓄有致。中二联稍平，‘银鹰’‘云山’略熟。","_cost":0.035219333},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.75,"rationale":"此作写当代机场送别，以具象细节托真挚离思，融入时差待讯等当代经验，章法顺畅，炼字见巧，仅“银鹰”“云山”稍熟，真切自然。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"黄线、行箱与枕畔屏灯串起送别后的牵挂，末联以昼夜时差写等待，具体而有余味。中二联推进自然；“银鹰”“云山”稍陈，“嘱语多于两鬓斑”比拟略涩。","_cost":0.008236}},"consensus":80.89,"final":80.89},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"翼底千城火树舒,长衢如缕缀人居。檐前稚子应相指,一点流星过太虚。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"由俯瞰转入想象稚子仰望，“应”字使视角转换自然。结以流星反写飞机，童趣与远意兼具。情志不以深厚见长，“火树”“太虚”稍熟，“缀人居”略平。","_cost":0.06123},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.65,"rationale":"起承写夜航俯瞰灯火；转结运对写法，翻出地面稚子仰指视角，反照己身为太虚流星。主客互映，章法精妙，将现代经验化入古典意境，空灵隽永。","_cost":0.005367},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"主脑在俯瞰与仰视对转，千城对一点，章法最稳。火树、流星、太虚偏熟，稚子情泛，应相指近说明。缀字较警。结句以景收而喻意已明，余味不厚。","_cost":0.0298304},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"由俯瞰灯海转入地面稚子仰望，俯仰对照成篇；舒、缀炼字工稳，结句以流星收束留有余味。火树、太虚稍熟，立意小巧而情味偏淡。","_cost":0.0109886},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"当代夜航经验入绝句，构思巧妙：前二句俯瞰灯城，后二句翻转到地面稚子仰望，飞机化作流星，视角逆转是全篇主脑。起承转合完备，结句以景收束、言尽意远。'火树''太虚'稍熟，'缀人居'略平，整体锤炼自然、意象交融。","_cost":0.002159325},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.6,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰转写地面稚子指机如流星，视角翻转新巧，结句以景留白。惜情志较浅，火树、太虚略熟，‘缀人居’稍生。","_cost":0.011352},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"夜航现代经验入旧体而不违和,第三句视角陡转至地面稚子,结句反认飞机为流星,双向互看构思新巧、主脑集中。意象统一,'火树''太虚'稍熟,'缀人居'略平。转结有力,以景结情,余韵可寻,惟语言锤炼未到字字精警。","_cost":0.012684},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.3,"rationale":"机舱俯瞰翻转为檐下童观，视角对换巧而有情；火树、如缕取象精切，转结以景结情，空灵有余味，当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.006367},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.5,"rationale":"章法井然，俯瞰转为稚子仰指，飞机如流星，视角互易见新意。意象妥帖，‘缀’字生动，然‘火树’‘太虚’稍熟，情味偏淡。","_cost":0.034869675},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"本诗写夜航俯瞰，以高空与地面双向视角错位翻出巧思，起承转合顺畅，炼字妥帖，结句以稚子误认航机为流星留有余韵，无硬伤蹈袭，唯“火树”意象稍泛。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"由俯瞰灯城转入想象稚子仰望，视角互换自然；末句将夜航之机写作流星，留有余味。「火树」「太虚」稍显熟套。","_cost":0.008026}},"consensus":79.83,"final":79.83},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|天台菜园|七律","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"水泥顶上一畦晴,破桶残盆韭叶生。瓜蔓暗攀天线去,鸽翎斜拂菜花明。锄轻未碍霓虹闹,土浅偏知节序更。旧垄尽埋楼百尺,阿娘犹向最高耕。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.6,"rationale":"“瓜蔓暗攀天线去”新鲜有神，城乡意象相生；尾联由旧垄转阿娘，显出田园消失后的坚守与酸楚。“锄轻未碍”语意牵强，“最高耕”稍涩，结句仍有延宕。","_cost":0.05207},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.8,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.95,"rationale":"当代城市化题材佳作。天线、霓虹与农事意象熔铸自然。立意聚焦母辈对土地的眷恋，尾联“旧垄尽埋楼百尺，阿娘犹向最高耕”力透纸背，情真而具时代痛感。","_cost":0.00482925},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"失地后阿娘仍向楼顶耕,主脑具体。破桶韭叶、瓜蔓暗攀天线等象精切;颈联未碍、偏知偏说理,转折平。结有象而犹字点破。语言通畅,当代经验入诗有效。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0297184},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.55,"rationale":"以天台种菜写失土与城市生存，意象具体，城乡张力在瓜蔓、天线、霓虹间自然展开。尾联收束有力，不直说而余味长。语言偶有亮点，但个别处偏直白。","_cost":0.004181562},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.0,"rationale":"都市楼顶种菜的当代经验入诗,旧垄埋于百尺楼下而阿娘'最高耕',熟题翻出新境,主脑聚焦。天线、霓虹与瓜蔓、菜花交融,取象精切,'暗攀''犹'等字见诗眼。尾联由物转人,收束有力而余味悠长。","_cost":0.0035922},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.1,"警句":3.6,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.30000000000001,"rationale":"天台菜园题材新，瓜蔓天线等细节鲜活，尾联以阿娘耕作收出乡愁，余味较好；‘霓虹’‘节序’稍常，‘最高耕’略硬。","_cost":0.01402},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.0,"rationale":"城市天台农耕切入城市化记忆，旧垄埋没与阿娘高耕形成主脑，题熟而境新。天线、霓虹与瓜蔓、菜花交融，象精而氛围统一；‘一畦晴’‘暗攀’见炼字。颈联由景入理稍平直，结以人影收束，犹字最高留白，余响足。","_cost":0.0206676},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.7,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.4,"rationale":"天台种菜切中当代城市经验，破桶天线鸽翎等象新切融洽，章法层递，末句最高耕一语双关余味悠长","_cost":0.011611},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"天台菜园折射城市化吞没农田，天线霓虹等现代经验入诗，意象新鲜统一；结句含蓄有力，余味足。中二联转稍平、起笔弱，用语偶生硬，故章法语言略低。","_cost":0.040197158},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.0,"rationale":"此诗取都市天台菜园的独特场景，融城市符号与乡土意趣，意象鲜活，炼字贴切，章法圆熟，以当代经验翻新田园题旨，结句有张力，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.3,"余味":7.7,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.95,"rationale":"破桶、天线与旧垄相照，写城中续耕，情意具体；尾联有力。惟“锄轻未碍霓虹闹”语意稍涩，结句略有点明之嫌。","_cost":0.008184}},"consensus":86.5,"final":86.5},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"万里乡音掌上听,娘窗初日客窗星。殷勤只劝眠须早,挂罢空屏映我形。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.6,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.8,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.7,"rationale":"两窗日星以时差写离隔，劝眠家常而情真；由乡音到空屏倒影，将相聚翻为独处，转结有力而不说破。视频经验融入自然，次句、末句可摘赏；起句稍平，语言尚非句句精警。","_cost":0.05404},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.55,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗典范。二句时差对举工切，转句叙事传情，结句借手机熄屏反光特写，不着一字写尽挂断后的落寞孤寂，情境交融，余味绵长。","_cost":0.00444525},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.0,"rationale":"思亲熟题而以时差、挂屏落在具体情事,主脑收得住。初日与客星对举,空屏映形,景情相生。炼字见「只」,然万里、殷勤稍熟。起承清楚,转势偏平,结句以象留白。无误典硬伤,无整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.02581},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.75,"rationale":"以视频通话写异地亲情，时差句精警，结句空屏映形含蓄延宕。意象统一，转结有致；语言自然，劝语稍直但真切。无硬伤、陈滥、蹈袭。","_cost":0.004749525},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":94.0,"rationale":"视频通话这一当代经验入诗自然无痕，'娘窗初日客窗星'一句以两窗景象并置浓缩时差与两地亲情，精切传神。结句'挂罢空屏映我形'以象收束，挂断后的孤独与影像余存言尽意不尽。语言凝练，章法一气贯注，转结尤佳。","_cost":0.00125873712},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.3,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.0,"rationale":"写深夜视频思亲，娘窗初日与客窗星对照时空，真切有新意；结以空屏映影，含蓄有余。唯部分语词稍直。","_cost":0.0093},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"深夜视频、母劝早睡皆熟题，但以“娘窗初日/客窗星”拉开时空，结于空屏自照，情景相生且留白；语言稍平易，“挂罢”略硬，整体成篇而少警策。","_cost":0.0177201},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.15,"rationale":"掌上乡音切当代，初日/星对照见万里昼夜，以空屏映形景结情，情真事切收束有余味。","_cost":0.00781625},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"视频通话入七绝，“娘窗初日客窗星”时空反差新警，结句空屏映形，以物结情，余味悠长；章法稳而转略平，现代经验自然，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.030868075},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.9,"rationale":"以跨时区深夜与母视频写乡思，细节真切，章法流转顺畅，结句以空屏映影留余味，语言平实精准，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.8,"余味":8.9,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.1,"rationale":"“娘窗初日客窗星”以两地晨昏写牵念；由叮嘱早眠转至空屏照影，含蓄见孤独。视频经验入诗自然，“眠须早”稍显生硬。","_cost":0.008098}},"consensus":86.73,"final":86.73},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"灶冷空斋久不烟,今随邻里坐同筵。厨娘识我牙根软,一碗温存似昔年。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.2,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.6,"rationale":"由冷灶独处转向邻里共食，以厨娘体察咀嚼之难落实人情温暖，转句有力。“一碗温存”虚实相融；“牙根软”稍欠精准，“似昔年”较泛，结尾点情多于留景。","_cost":0.0351},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.75,"rationale":"写当代社区助餐，接地气且见性情。“牙根软”之细节特写尤为真切动人，以体贴之暖消解空巢之冷；转结自然宕开至昔年温存，酸楚与暖意交织，当代生活入诗极为成功。","_cost":0.00474225},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.75,"rationale":"以社区食堂写老境受照拂，牙根软收束主脑，情事具体。灶冷对温碗有氛围，次句平叙，结句点明温存，余味偏直。牙根软是诗眼，同筵略隔。无硬伤蹈袭，昔年稍熟。","_cost":0.0222448},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.25,"rationale":"写独居冷清与食堂人情温暖，'牙根软'细节真切，今昔对比自然。结句以'温存'点破，略欠含蓄，但仍有昔年余想。意象统一，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.005069609352},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.75,"rationale":"社区食堂这一当代题材有效入诗，写独居老人之孤与暖，情事具体可感。'牙根软'细节精准，'温存'移情于碗，结句'似昔年'宕开留白——似谁的昔年？妻炊还是旧邻？言尽意不尽。起承转合完整，唯'灶冷'意象稍常见。","_cost":0.0016690622},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.1,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.6,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.85000000000001,"rationale":"社区食堂新题，冷灶起笔，转入邻里共食与厨娘体恤，细节真切，有人间暖意。惜“温存”“昔年”稍直，余味略减。","_cost":0.01058},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.0,"rationale":"以灶冷空斋与同筵对照立骨，“牙根软”细节真切，见独居老境与社区温情；惜意象不厚，“温存似昔年”略熟且点破，转结平直，余延有限。","_cost":0.0118866},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.4,"意境":7.3,"语言":8.2,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.64999999999999,"rationale":"以灶冷到同筵写老境孤温，社区食堂切中当代而情真具体；牙根软为诗眼，温存似昔年以味牵情有余韵；唯前半叙笔略直，物象密度稍薄。","_cost":0.00693325},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.5,"rationale":"以社区食堂写空巢之冷与共餐之暖，'一碗温存'诗眼凝情；转结由厨娘细节宕入昔年回忆，余味略白。'牙根软'等措辞稍拙，起承转合完整，当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.02782936},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.5,"rationale":"此作以个人亲历写社区食堂的日常温情，细节真切，炼字鲜活，起承转合顺畅，结句借“昔年”留余韵，当代经验入诗自然，无硬伤陈套。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.5,"rationale":"由冷灶独居写到食堂相聚，以“牙根软”落到被人记挂的细处，情意真切。起承转合清楚；末句“一碗温存”直抒其情，“似昔年”稍泛，余味略减。","_cost":0.00816}},"consensus":81.46,"final":81.46},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|云端相册|七律","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"一键轻传上九天,浮生片片寄苍烟。银盐褪尽人间色,像素长留昔日妍。旧岁花簪慈母鬓,今春草没故山阡。年年续费存颦笑,窗外闲云自在眠。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.1,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.7,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.45,"rationale":"由存照转入悼母，中二联层次清楚；“年年续费存颦笑”将技术经验落到亲情，独立成警句。结尾以闲云反衬付费留影，扣题有余韵；“浮生”“苍烟”“昔日妍”稍显泛熟。","_cost":0.04884},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.8,"rationale":"将像素、续费等当代数码经验天衣无缝化入律诗。颈联切入生死至痛，尾联以“续费留颦笑”的人间执念与“窗外闲云”的自然冷眼强烈对冲，立意深刻，余味悠长。","_cost":0.0062505},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"题旨落在付费存忆与慈母故阡的对照,情事具体而角度未脱数字怀旧。颈联景情相切,首尾“一键”“像素”“续费”未化入意境,炼字生熟不齐。起势弱而转结清楚。结句闲云略有宕开,仍偏显豁。颈联摘出可感。","_cost":0.0205504},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.8,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.1,"rationale":"以云端相册寄悼念，立意真挚而有新境；颈联今昔对照动人，尾句以闲云对比收束，留有余味。现代语汇稍直白，个别传统意象略熟，故语言与意境未至极致。","_cost":0.005562360072},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"以云存储写丧母之痛,当代经验入旧体而浑成。颔联银盐/像素对举精切,颈联旧岁今春陡转沉痛,主脑分明。'年年续费存颦笑'以俗语反衬至情,是警句。结句闲云自在眠以景结情,人事执着与云物无心相照,余味宕开。语言整体锤炼,稍逊在个别措辞仍近熟套。","_cost":0.0029088},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.05,"rationale":"云相册新题入诗，银盐像素对照见巧；由存照转入慈母故山，情事具体，结以闲云留白。惟苍烟、浮生等语稍泛。","_cost":0.009166},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"以云端相册写生死记忆,数字长存与人事已非之对照有真感;'银盐/像素'一联工切见警,'续费存颦笑'细节新而痛;结句闲云双关宕开有余味。惟'九天''苍烟'略熟,意象密度尚可更炼。","_cost":0.0103752},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.2,"意境":6.9,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.95,"rationale":"以云端储存翻新悼亲怀乡旧题，银盐/像素对照具时代感；由器物转人事再宕开真假云对比，结构清晰，末句以景收束余味较长，唯颔联偏议论，口语词稍损诗质。","_cost":0.00955375},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"云端存照忆母，银盐/像素、续费与闲云对举，当代经验入律；中二联由媒介及慈母转进，结句以景宕开。惜科技词稍白、意象有常见处，陈滥减1，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.031662569},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"此作借云端相册抒思亲之怀，融入当代数码经验，意象妥帖，章法顺畅，结句以景宕开有余味，用词新切，仅个别意象稍熟，无硬伤、蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"由云端存照写至慈母故阡，情事具体；“续费”与窗外闲云相映，结句有余味。银盐、像素之对照见巧，“上九天”“昔日妍”略显套熟。","_cost":0.012078}},"consensus":80.81,"final":80.81},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"舱帘半卷月孤悬,俯视云开万炬然。大邑纵横铺锦网,奔车首尾缀珠弦。悲欢高处皆成点,冷暖人间各有天。渐落始分千户牖,谁家灯下未曾眠。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.05,"rationale":"由俯瞰城灯转向个体悲欢，再随下降落到窗牖，层次清楚。“悲欢高处皆成点”有警策；锦网、珠弦比喻较熟，冷暖句略泛。结以未眠之问，留有想象余地。","_cost":0.03454},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.9,"rationale":"夜航经验入诗自然，视线随飞机降落由宏转微，章法极紧凑。颈联宕出哲思，结以问句留白、关怀人间，情味延宕。唯颔联比喻略熟，炼字未臻极纯。","_cost":0.0058725},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"有主脑而角度常见。境可成,锦珠孤月偏套。皆成点有力,各有天空滑,炼字未精。航迹由高到落,转结清楚,中二联少开合。结问有余味,未眠稍说破。当代夜航入诗有效,无硬伤。","_cost":0.0487472},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.7,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.3,"rationale":"夜航视角由景入情，中二联对仗精工，结句以问收束留白；语言偶有微瑕。整体意象统一、脉络贯通。","_cost":0.00707484},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.5,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰入旧体，当代经验有效转化。中二联开合有层次：颔联绘景精切，颈联'悲欢成点'由景入理，是全篇警策。尾联由宏阔俯瞰收束到一户灯下，以问作结，言尽意不尽。'锦网''珠弦'取象新颖贴切。唯'月孤悬''未曾眠'稍沿熟路。","_cost":0.00171798192},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.6,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.8,"rationale":"夜航视角清晰，灯火与人间冷暖相生，章法由远及近；颈联有概括力，但冷暖、未眠等语稍熟，结语设问有余味而未臻含蓄。","_cost":0.010638},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.0,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰由宏阔灯网车流降至千窗一灯，焦点集中；锦网珠弦略熟，颈联议论稍直，然“悲欢成点”有警策，结以问句留白，当代经验入律较自然。","_cost":0.0099186},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.9,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰以高度变化统摄全篇，由万炬锦网珠弦之景转入悲欢皆点之理，终以一灯设问收束，景理交融，章法贯通，当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.00822075},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":5.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.5,"rationale":"夜航视角入诗，灯火意象由锦网珠弦渐分千户牖，转出人情冷暖，结句设问留白；惟情志稍泛，语有凑处，结构完整。","_cost":0.032165612},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.0,"rationale":"本诗以夜航俯瞰为线，从高空城景递落到人间温凉，脉络顺畅，炼字精准，结句以问留白，自然融入当代飞行经验，唯部分意象稍熟，未脱传统感怀路径。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.75,"rationale":"由云开俯城到渐落辨牖，视角递进清楚；“悲欢高处皆成点”凝练。锦网、珠弦稍熟，冷暖一联偏直陈，末问有余情却略泛。","_cost":0.011508}},"consensus":78.52,"final":78.52},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|深夜视频|七律","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"我在三更母已晨,一框明暗两边人。声迟屡使言相撞,画冻方惊鬓尽银。絮絮添衣兼早睡,频频颔首诺难真。屏昏忽照灯前影,眉目依稀似老亲。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.8,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.05,"rationale":"时差、声迟与画面冻结使牵念具体可感，中二联由惊老转入应诺，层次清楚。结以暗屏自影似老亲，将亲情推进到自身衰老，余味深长。“母已晨”“诺难真”凝缩稍涩。","_cost":0.05495},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.0,"rationale":"当代经验入律的极佳范式。颔联以“声迟”“画冻”切中时空延迟与苍老之惊；尾联借息屏反光写眉目渐似老母，化情入骨，余味绵长。","_cost":0.005388},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"时差、延迟、冻帧、空诺聚于一通话,远隔难践诺,情事具体。一框明暗与画冻见银景情相生,颈联偏叙述。结句点明似亲,收住而稍直。画冻可摘,媒介入律有效,无硬伤。","_cost":0.0400928},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.8,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.2,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.65,"rationale":"以视频通话的声画细节写异地亲情，真实可感；中二联对仗精切，转结由屏影映己，留白有延宕。立意虽属常见题材，但以当代经验出之，语言炼字见诗眼，唯叮嘱语稍熟。","_cost":0.01796784},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.75,"rationale":"视频通话尽孝入七律，时差起笔即见巧思。'一框明暗两边人''声迟言相撞''画冻鬓尽银'以今事炼古语，句句切题无陈套。尾联屏昏照影以象收情，余味深挚。中二联开合稍平，颔颈皆叙通话，层次可再拓展。","_cost":0.00169276752},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.1,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.7,"余味":7.3,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.55,"rationale":"借深夜视频写母子时差，细节新而情事具体。画冻、灯影皆能贴题生情，结有延宕。惜部分语词稍硬，颈联略平直。","_cost":0.016154},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.3,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.89999999999999,"rationale":"时差视频入题新而切，明暗、声迟、画冻皆成情象；由母之絮叨转到屏暗自照，结句似见老亲，留白有悲意。个别句近口语、添衣早睡稍熟，故未满格。","_cost":0.0167466},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.4,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.7,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.1,"rationale":"时差一框切题精准，声迟画冻细节入诗，絮叮颔诺人情真切，末句以影照己宕开余味。","_cost":0.008949},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.8,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.1,"rationale":"当代视频通话入七律，框明暗、声迟言撞、画冻惊见银鬓，取象精切；颈联稍直白；尾联屏昏自照，眉目似老亲，以景结情，余味绵长。无硬伤蹈袭，当代经验入诗，出新明显。","_cost":0.040069264},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.3,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.45,"rationale":"此诗选取跨时区与母深夜视频的当代场景，细节真切，炼字精准贴合网聊体验，脉络贯通，结句有余味，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.7,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.1,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.35,"rationale":"以时差、声迟画冻写隔屏思亲，细节具体；由惊见母亲白发转至屏中自影，层次自然，结句有余味。“一框明暗两边人”可摘；“母已晨”“诺难真”稍显生硬。","_cost":0.01172}},"consensus":86.63,"final":86.63},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"锯断根须入市尘,高悬点滴续残身。枝头强绽三分绿,犹梦青山十里春。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"以吊瓶树写移栽之伤，切入具体，有当代感。“强绽”见挣扎，三分绿与十里春形成反差；由伤根、续命到勉强萌绿、梦归山野，层次清楚。但“残身”点情偏露，尾句春梦稍熟，余味有限。","_cost":0.05769},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.0,"rationale":"成功将当代都市移树吊液之景化入诗中，托物言志，寓有人性与异化之思。后两联‘三分绿’与‘十里春’对比极具张力，炼字精切，结句宕开故山魂梦，余味深长。","_cost":0.00427875},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"以街树挂吊瓶写移植伤根,情事具体、主脑清楚。点滴、残身、强绽较新,市尘与青山稍熟。起势明而转不陡,结句犹梦点明眷恋,余味未尽留。","_cost":0.023314},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.25,"rationale":"以移栽树挂滴液切入城市与自然冲突，立意具体可感；意象由伤根、点滴到强绿、梦山，层次相关。结句以虚收束，余味颇长。语言精炼，转句稍平，但整体不陈套。","_cost":0.00613404},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.75,"rationale":"移栽行树悬吊瓶,当代都市经验入诗而托物有寄托。'锯断根须'起笔见痛感,'点滴续残身'扣题精切,'强绽'字有诗眼之工。结句宕开梦回青山,以虚景结情,言尽意不尽。全篇围绕'残身犹梦'一主脑收束,物我交融,脉络一气贯注。","_cost":0.0013659},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.9,"语言":7.7,"章法":8.3,"余味":7.6,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.69999999999999,"rationale":"以街树输液入诗，题材新而寄托明。锯根、点滴、强绽层层推进，末以青山之梦收束，有转有留。惜‘犹梦’稍说破，青山十里春语略熟。","_cost":0.014568},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"以行道树挂营养液这一当代经验入诗,断根入市、吊瓶续命、强绽新绿、犹梦青山,层层转进,暗寓离乡入城者之痛,主脑集中,托物言志而不说破。结句宕开一笔,余韵悠长。'三分绿'略熟,语言尚可更锤炼。","_cost":0.0140916},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.1,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.6,"rationale":"以吊瓶输液树切入都市生态困境，立意具体新切；点滴残身与梦归青山对照成境；“强绽”有诗眼，章法转合分明，结句宕开留余味。","_cost":0.0096275},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.8,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.95,"rationale":"城市树挂点滴的当代经验入诗，锯根、吊瓶、强绿、梦春意象统一，悲悯与讽喻交融；转结由枝绿宕入梦青山，余味宛转；语言有‘续残身’等微瑕。","_cost":0.020989959},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.15,"rationale":"咏城市移栽挂液的街树，立意新颖有寄托，意象精切，炼字到位，起承转合顺畅，唯结句稍直，当代经验入诗自然，仅\"十里春\"稍熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"借街树悬点滴写移栽之痛，市尘与青山映照鲜明，四句递进自然；“残身”说意稍露，“青山十里春”略熟，结句余味稍减。","_cost":0.008258}},"consensus":86.02,"final":86.02},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"红光一线过千箱,铁带回环夜正长。偶见面单题故里,低头轻放似还乡。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.75,"rationale":"以流水线上的故乡面单触发乡思，情事具体，主脑集中；机械回环与轻放动作形成情味反差，转折自然。“题故里”略涩，“似还乡”点明情意，收束妥帖而留白稍少。","_cost":0.03332},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.8,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.75,"rationale":"当代物流经验成功入诗。前两句写工业流水线的机械冰冷与长夜劳顿，转结由面单触动乡愁，以“低头轻放”一动摄全篇之魂，情境反差极具张力，真挚动人且毫无隔阂。","_cost":0.00575475},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.6,"余味":6.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"思乡熟题置于云仓夜扫，面单故里与轻放之姿具体，红光铁带冷景托情。起转清楚，然结句“似还乡”点明喻意，余味稍减；“夜正长”略熟。当代劳作入诗有效，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0150848},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.3,"章法":9.0,"余味":8.6,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.95,"rationale":"以云仓夜班新场景写乡愁，情志真切具体。转结从面单故里到轻放动作，不直说破，余味可嚼。结构起承转合分明，意象妥帖统一。无明显硬伤、陈滥或蹈袭。","_cost":0.003336102},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.75,"rationale":"快递夜班劳动入诗，旧题翻出新境。红光扫码、铁带回环取象精切，物象与思乡之情浑融。「偶见面单题故里」陡转自然，「低头轻放」以动作收情，含蓄不尽。全篇无一字说破乡愁，结句言尽意远。","_cost":0.001929},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.3,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.1,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.8,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.8,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.95,"rationale":"以扫码、传送带、面单等当代仓储物象写夜工乡愁，转结自然，情事具体；但结句‘似还乡’稍说破，现代词入诗略有生硬。","_cost":0.007424},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"以扫码、传送带写当代打工经验,题材新而情真。'偶见'一转自然,'低头轻放似还乡'以动作结情,乡思不言而自深,余味悠长。意象精切统一,唯首二句锤炼稍平,未到字字生辉。","_cost":0.0070605},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.7,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"当代云仓分拣入诗，偶见故里以“轻放”收束，冷峻工业景与微暖乡心对照，主脑清晰，转结自然，动作结情余韵隽永。","_cost":0.0077495},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.25,"rationale":"云仓夜扫取象新切，面单故里触发轻放似还乡，情事具体、转结有力；惟语词稍质直，结句明喻略白而有余味。警句出新尚可，陈滥轻，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.037246458},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.8,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.55,"rationale":"以当代云仓夜班分拣场景写乡愁，熟题出新，细节真切。意象贴合，章法顺畅，炼字自然，唯结句“似还乡”稍点透情绪，余韵略减，无硬伤陈套。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.25,"rationale":"扫码红光、回环铁带写出夜仓劳作；面单上的故里使动作由快转轻，乡思具体。末句“似还乡”点明情意，稍减留白。","_cost":0.006944}},"consensus":85.72,"final":85.72},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"货架如山夜未昏,轮声似雨彻宵喧。千签过眼红光扫,万里分途短响奔。汗渍工衣盐作雪,屏开家讯字留温。天涯百址皆经手,不见溪头老柳村。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"百址经手而故乡不见，立意有切口；扫描、汗盐、家讯由外入内，层次清楚。颈联工衣与家讯相映可赏；“夜未昏”“短响奔”欠自然，老柳村收尾稍落熟境。","_cost":0.05808},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.7,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.39999999999999,"rationale":"当代物流经验入诗的佳构。“红光扫”“短响奔”取象精切，化入律体自然无隔。尾联以经手天涯万址与不见故里老柳对照，脉络贯通，情致深婉，余味悠长。","_cost":0.0063075},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.8,"意境":6.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.6,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.2,"rationale":"经手百址而家园缺席,情事具体,非口号。红光短响盐雪新切,如山似雨与柳村偏熟,意境未浑。盐作雪是诗眼,字留温稍软。章法由劳作转家讯再收缺席,一气顺。结句对照略直,仍有未归之憾。","_cost":0.0273792},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.3,"余味":7.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.6,"rationale":"现代仓储劳作与乡愁结合，中二联对仗见细节；'汗渍盐作雪'与'屏开字留温'一苦一暖，结句以故乡景反衬。语言偶有简省如'百址'，余味稍直。","_cost":0.00717244},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"当代云仓夜工入诗,题材新而情真:颈联'盐作雪''字留温'一苦一暖,诗眼夺目;结句由'百址经手'陡转'不见老柳村',以景结情,余味绵长。首联取象精切,唯'短响奔'稍显硬凑,语言微有斧凿。","_cost":0.00174307392},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.8,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.7,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.6,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.1,"rationale":"取材云仓夜班，扫码、轮声、家讯等细节真切，颈联苦中见温，尾联以故乡不见收出余味。现代语入诗较自然，但‘似雨’‘天涯’等稍熟，个别新词略硬。","_cost":0.01512},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.5,"rationale":"以云仓拣货之夜写劳工乡愁,'百址经手不见柳村'翻出新意,主脑集中。扫描红光、盐渍如雪等当代物象与情意交融,氛围统一。'盐作雪''字留温'见炼字,颈联由景及人开合得法,结句以景结情余韵足。'夜未昏'与'彻宵'略有扞格,'柳村'稍涉熟象,然整体当代经验入律成功,无袭痕。","_cost":0.0205206},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.6,"意境":7.3,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.05,"rationale":"以云仓夜扫切入当代劳作现场，以盐雪、红光等工况细节出新，末以经手天涯却难归老柳作结，今昔对照收束有力余味悠长。","_cost":0.00762375},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"题材新颖，以云仓夜作写劳工乡愁，立意聚焦；意象明快而中段稍叙述化；'盐作雪''字留温'见锤炼；章法起承转合有序；结句以故乡景反衬缺席，稍直白。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.030990634},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"本诗写当代云仓分拣工的夜作辛劳与羁旅乡愁，题材新颖，细节具象，炼字精准，结有余味，章法平顺，唯核心情志未脱传统羁旅窠臼，个别喻象稍熟。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"扫码声、汗渍与家讯写出夜班乡思，层次清晰，结句以故村遥隔留味。颈联可摘赏；“短响奔”稍牵强，“如山似雨”较熟。","_cost":0.008126}},"consensus":82.86,"final":82.86},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"暖雨新晴柳色稠,谁将药袋挂枝头。孤根尚裹来时土,截顶初窥万户楼。近市争夸春速到,远山宁问穴空留。邻窗亦有随儿叟,对树无言数滴流。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.7,"意境":8.2,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.6,"警句":3.2,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.45,"rationale":"以移树映照随迁老人，情事具体，主脑鲜明；“孤根”一联形神兼具，结句借数滴之举寄托难言之情。颈联议论稍露，“近市”“穴空留”措辞欠自然。","_cost":0.03925},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.8,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.7,"余味":8.6,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.85,"rationale":"将移栽截顶之树与随迁异乡的老人同构，兼具生态反思与人文关怀。颔颈二联对仗精警有力，脉络清晰。尾联以老人对树数吊滴定格，不着悲声而余味无穷，当代现实经验入律之上乘之作。","_cost":0.005913},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.2,"余味":8.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.6,"rationale":"吊瓶与迁叟扣题,情事具体,然城春虚假、山穴被夺的角度已常见,对举略工。孤根裹土、截顶窥楼、数滴流精切;颈联说理,起句近套,春速到、随儿叟略生。结句不说破。","_cost":0.0288976},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.25,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶与随迁老人互喻，立意新深；颈联对比、尾联双关含蓄，余味足。中二联开合有致。语言偶直白，但炼字见亮点。无硬伤、陈滥与蹈袭。","_cost":0.0070369728},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.0,"rationale":"咏移栽行道树挂营养液,当代都市经验入诗自然。中二联开合有层次:树之孤根截顶对城乡两界,远山穴空暗指生态代价,批判不着痕迹。结句叟与树无言数滴,以景结情,余味悠长。个别句如宁问穴空留稍见生硬。","_cost":0.0024444},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.4,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.6,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.1,"rationale":"以树之吊瓶映随儿老人，当代经验入诗而情在无言。孤根、截顶取象切，结句数滴留白。惜‘穴空留’稍生，颈联略隔。","_cost":0.017186},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶写移栽进城之树,颈联'穴空留'转出讽意,尾联以随迁老人与树互喻,'数滴流'双关含蓄,主脑集中、当代经验入诗有效。'宁问''争夸'略用力,首联柳色稍熟,整体起转收皆稳。","_cost":0.005211},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.3,"语言":7.6,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.15,"rationale":"以吊瓶树喻随迁老人，物人同构立意新切具体；取象精切而后半稍虚，章法由物及人层递，结句双关滴流以景结情余味长。","_cost":0.012104},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.7,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.4,"章法":7.6,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.75,"rationale":"街树吊瓶与随迁老叟并置，当代经验入律而意象新切；结句数滴流以景结情，余味深长。中二联稍涉理语，起句略熟，字句偶生硬。","_cost":0.029417015},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.7,"rationale":"此作取城市移栽树挂吊瓶的当代题材，暗合随迁老人失根共情，立意新颖，意象切当，章法顺畅，结句留白余味足，炼字见工，无硬伤套话，唯个别字稍显刻意，警策度待提升。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.0,"rationale":"以移植树照见城市求速与老人处境，截顶窥楼一联尤见新意；由树及人，结句滴液似泪，留有余味。“宁问穴空留”“随儿叟”语意稍涩。","_cost":0.01175}},"consensus":86.31,"final":86.31},{"key":"claude-opus-5.5|社区食堂|七律","writer":"claude-opus-5.5","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"蒸笼掀处午生烟,白发扶筇排最先。米烂深知牙齿怯,盐轻暗合药方笺。儿孙隔海屏中笑,邻座分甘箸上传。桌角忽虚王叟位,早携温饭到床前。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"gpt-6-astra":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.8,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"米烂盐轻写出养老细处，屏中亲情与邻座温情相映；空位转送饭，转结有情事。“排最先”“药方笺”稍显凑泊，尾句施事略含混；结尾温厚具体，但悬念随即解尽，余味稍受限。","_cost":0.04852},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.8,"意境":8.7,"语言":8.6,"章法":8.9,"余味":8.8,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.55,"rationale":"当代现实题材佳作。紧扣老龄社会图景，颔联关怀入微堪称佳联，颈联对比道尽空巢酸楚，尾联由堂食转至送饭上门，章法层层递进，充满烟火温情。","_cost":0.0047235},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.4,"余味":6.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.3,"rationale":"以社区食堂写老年照护,烂米、淡盐、隔海屏笑、虚座送饭皆具体,主脑集中,非口号。章法由众到独,忽虚一转有力。语言有诗眼而颈联稍平,结句把事说满,余味不足。白发扶筇略熟,无硬伤。","_cost":0.033114},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":9.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.75,"rationale":"社区养老熟题写出温情新境，主脑鲜明。'米烂深知牙齿怯，盐轻暗合药方笺'体物入微，拟人见诗眼，堪为佳联。隔海屏中笑以当代经验入诗自然无痕。结句以虚位反衬善举，以事结情不落言诠，通篇脉络贯注，惟结意稍近交代。","_cost":0.0023097},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.6,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.7,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.3,"rationale":"聚焦社区食堂老人群像，意象具体而氛围统一；颔联写适老饮食，颈联写远亲近邻，尾联以空位宕开，见人情余温。语言稳炼，警句突出，当代题材入诗自然。","_cost":0.01270678},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.0,"rationale":"当代题旨具体，适老细节与送餐收束有新境；意象生活化而统一，语言多锤炼，惟“药方笺”等稍硬；章法由堂中到床前，转折自然；结尾温厚但略说破。","_cost":0.014536},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"社区食堂入七律,题新而情真。米烂牙怯、盐轻合药,体察入微;隔海屏中笑与邻座箸上传对出孤老之境。结联忽虚王叟位、携饭床前,转得有力,余意含而不尽。唯首联扶筇意象略熟。","_cost":0.013677},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.1,"意境":6.9,"语言":7.3,"章法":7.9,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"聚焦社区食堂空巢日常,颔联米烂盐轻体贴精切,颈联以屏中笑对照箸上传,尾联忽虚一转以温饭收束,白描贯注,情真事切,温煦中见孤寂底色,结句以事代情留有余温。","_cost":0.01365275},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.75,"rationale":"取材社区食堂写当代养老，角度新颖；中二联分写饮食关护与邻里送暖，章法井然。'怯''箸上传'炼字见巧，然杂入'排最先''屏中'等现代语，结句直白交代，余味稍欠。","_cost":0.03501842},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.15,"rationale":"此作聚焦当代社区食堂养老日常，细节鲜活，语言平实精准，章法顺畅，融入现代生活元素尽显市井温情，无硬伤蹈袭，唯结句偏实余韵稍弱。","_cost":null},"gpt-6-sol":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.7,"章法":8.3,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.6,"rationale":"软饭淡盐、屏中儿孙写出养老日常；王叟空位一转，落到送饭床前，情意具体。“箸上传”“药方笺”稍显刻意，结句留有牵挂。","_cost":0.008194}},"consensus":84.93,"final":84.93},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|抓娃娃机|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","poem":"投钱落处铁钳游，彩兽齐肩待客收。乍近槽边熊又坠，窗前小手屈成钩。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.0,"rationale":"当代题材入诗自然。前三句写机中得失，第三句“熊又坠”写出功亏一篑。结句把镜头移到窗外孩童，“小手屈成钩”与铁钳互相映照，渴望与失落不说自明，余味较足。首句“投钱落处”稍显拗滞，立意偏小巧，未进一步开拓。","_cost":0.014512},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.1,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.4,"rationale":"当代题材入诗之佳作。起承转合自然流畅，转结尤工。“熊又坠”扣人心弦，结句“小手屈成钩”动作刻画极传神，与首句“铁钳”妙成呼应，以形传情，余味无穷。","_cost":0.004773},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"小儿失玩具，手拟铁钳，发现具体而开掘不深。机内彩兽与窗外小手成映，象切而前二句偏叙述。‘游’‘又坠’‘屈成钩’是眼，‘落处’‘待客收’滞。转结清楚，结句留象，余味最好。","_cost":0.0199136},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.75,"rationale":"抓娃娃机题材新颖，铁钳游、熊坠、小手屈成钩构建统一场景，末句以动作留白。立意稍浅，前二句略平，但炼字精准，章法完整。","_cost":0.005565714},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"当代游戏机入诗，题旨聚焦不散。起承铺陈妥帖，转句'熊又坠'写落空之憾。结句尤佳：孩童隔窗小手不觉屈成钩，人被机器同构，渴望与无奈尽在不言中，以象结情，言尽意远。'铁钳游''屈成钩'炼字见眼。惟'彩兽齐肩'稍平。","_cost":0.0034066},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.3,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.85,"rationale":"以现代游戏入诗，场景集中，铁钳、彩兽、坠熊、小手等细节鲜活，末句动作传神。起承转合完整，惜立意止于机趣，未更深拓。","_cost":0.008906},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"童戏入绝，焦点在欲得复失；结以小手化钩，暗应铁钳，留白见怜。意象统一而“待客收”稍直，警拔有余，浑厚未足。","_cost":0.00865395},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.4,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.6,"余味":8.2,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.45,"rationale":"以娃娃机写当代微挫，情事具体有焦点；起承转合清晰，末句人手屈钩镜照铁钳，以景结情留白足，出新自然。","_cost":0.008279},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.4,"意境":6.1,"语言":6.7,"章法":6.9,"余味":7.3,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机入诗，机内失手翻出机外小手成钩，暗喻人亦被‘钓’；取象较新，结句留白有余味。然情志稍浅，炼字偶粗。三四句可摘，当代经验入诗有效，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.030601644},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"撷取抓娃娃这一当代日常场景，聚焦临得复失的微末瞬间，起承转合顺畅，细节鲜活，结句以动作藏纳孩童情绪，入诗自然，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null}},"consensus":77.94,"final":77.94},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|旧衣回收箱|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","poem":"街灯照见旧衣箱，袖口针痕带皂香。铁腹无声藏小袄，墙根稚子正披霜。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱入诗，当代经验落地，是朱门路骨式对照的新载体。针痕、皂香细节温厚，铁腹炼字有力。结句以景对照，不言而悲，但对比略显直露。袖口从箱外可见、皂香可闻，写实上稍牵强。","_cost":0.016776},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.8,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.7,"余味":8.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.95,"rationale":"当代现实题材佳作。前两句微观写温情，转结以“铁腹无声”对“稚子披霜”，剧烈反差直逼杜陵遗意。取象精切，批判不落口号，画面定格极具悲悯震撼力。","_cost":0.00424125},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"箱中藏袄、墙根披霜, 情事具体而对照常见。针痕皂香与铁腹交融, 意境最胜; 字有锤炼, 首尾偏平。前三句皆写箱, 转势不锐; 结句景收而怜悯说满。回收箱入诗见出新, 无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0259488},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.8,"语言":7.8,"章法":9.0,"余味":9.2,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.05,"rationale":"以箱内小袄与墙根披霜稚子形成冷暖对撞，取象精切、结句留白，现代物象入诗不隔；“铁腹”“披霜”见炼字。立意角度仍属常见关怀，但具体可感。","_cost":0.00581154},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.5,"rationale":"当代题材入绝句,旧衣箱与披霜稚子对照,针痕皂香细节见慈母之爱与人间冷暖,主脑鲜明。'铁腹无声'以物拟腹,冷热对撞不着一字议论,结句以景收束,言尽意不尽。转结由物及人,章法妥帖。","_cost":0.00227984},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.3,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.4,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.6,"rationale":"取材当代旧衣回收箱，针痕皂香细节有温度；转写铁腹藏袄、稚子披霜，现实关怀自现。起句稍平，结象略苦。","_cost":0.012276},"kimi-k3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.5,"rationale":"以旧衣回收箱写冷暖对照：皂香针痕之温与铁腹披霜之寒相冲，转结锐利，主脑集中且不落说教。意象精切交融，结句以景收留白足。唯起句稍平，个别字面（街灯照见）略近散文，故语言未至极。","_cost":0.0129675},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.9,"章法":8.4,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.8,"rationale":"以旧衣箱切入当代现实，针痕皂香具体可感，铁腹无声与稚子披霜冷暖对照尖锐，起承转结分明，末句以景结情不落说教，余味悠长。","_cost":0.01345675},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.75,"rationale":"以现代回收箱入诗，袖口皂香与稚子披霜构成尖锐对照，具象而含蓄；结句留白深长。起笔稍平，第三句转势不足，炼字略有硬处。","_cost":0.033106813},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.0,"rationale":"此作咏当代旧衣回收箱，以带皂香的旧衣、冷硬铁箱、披霜稚子构成冷暖对照，章法圆转，结句留白有余味，炼字精准，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null}},"consensus":85.06,"final":85.06},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|抓娃娃机|七律","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","poem":"抓娃娃机\n夜市霓灯照彩箱，孩童掷币看绒羊。横移铁臂牵丝线，直下银钩捉绣裳。乍举棉身离旧伴，旋从爪隙跌回床。零钱耗尽还扶槛，父影微弯入镜光。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.25,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机写当代夜市,取材新而具体。颈联拟人写落空,颇见巧思。颔联偏机械铺叙,'捉绣裳'略凑,中二联层次不够开阔。结句宕开写父影微弯,含亲情与无奈,余味较足。","_cost":0.01836},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.6,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.85,"rationale":"当代世俗题材入律之佳作。中二联精准刻画抓取过程之得失跌宕，尾联由物及人，借镜中弯腰之父影收束，镜头感极强，亲情与微酸交融，余味绵长。","_cost":0.00570375},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"欲得复失与父影相映，情事具体而发现未深。全篇一境，颈联转折、结句以影留白最佳。颔联横直铺写偏平，丝线绣裳略饰。当代物象入律有效，无硬伤袭套。","_cost":0.0271216},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"取象生动，中二联动作开合有致；结句以父影入镜收束，含而不露。唯立意略浅，情感依附于尾联一折，余味佳而情志尚欠深广。","_cost":0.01139},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"以当代夜市抓娃娃机入诗，题材新颖；爪起爪落写尽孩童期待与失落，父影微弯收束见慈爱与苍凉，情事具体。中二联皆写机械动作，稍显叠合；'绣裳'与'绒羊'物象略杂。结句以人影入镜光，宕开有味，言尽意不尽。","_cost":0.0032414},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.8,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.6,"余味":8.6,"警句":3.2,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"当代题材入诗，抓取过程细密生动，动词链有画面；结以父影微弯入镜，留出生情余地。稍嫌雅词与机台场景微有龃龉，中二联偏于铺陈。","_cost":0.015738},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"当代经验入七律而有效：抓娃娃机写孩童执念，尾联转出父影微弯，情感具体含蓄。中二联摹写机械过程有序生动，然“绣裳”稍凑、颈联意象略平。结句以景结情，余味最长，是全篇亮点。","_cost":0.0047063},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.4,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.3,"余味":7.9,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.1,"rationale":"当代抓娃娃机入诗具体可感，乍举旋跌转合分明，终以父影镜光景结情有余温；中二联工写机械，情景交融未深。","_cost":0.010383},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.4,"语言":6.8,"章法":5.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.1,"rationale":"以七律写现代抓娃娃机，叙述抓取失败，结以父影入镜，题材新颖、叙事具体；中二联偏重过程描摹，转折稍迟，措辞工稳而略有刻意；结句以景收情，含蓄有回味。","_cost":0.034248114},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.55,"rationale":"以抓娃娃机当代日常入律，细节真切，动词摹写精准，章法起落有致，结句借玻璃映父影留白存味，无陈套硬伤，新题材融入自然。","_cost":null}},"consensus":77.33,"final":77.33},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|机场送别|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","poem":"航班误点到更阑，忽报登机话未完。闸口灯光收背影，空廊座位未全寒。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":true},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"以当代机场入诗,误点久候与忽报登机形成张力。“收”字炼得好,灯光收走背影。结句“座位未全寒”以物写情,余温暗寓离思,有余味。“未”字在第二、四句重复,稍损精炼;第三句转折略平。","_cost":0.015448},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.9,"rationale":"当代经验入诗的佳构。起承转合脉络贯通，情事具体可感。炼字精炼，“收”字生动，结句“座位未全寒”以触觉反衬离情，留白深远，余味悠长。","_cost":0.00452025},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"延误夜候忽被催行,情事具体而角度未深。后二句闸口灯、空廊、余温成境,收与未全寒较精,前两句偏白。由事及影再落空座,转折清楚。结句不说破,余温将散,味较长。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0234208},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.8,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.2,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.3,"rationale":"写机场误点送别，细节具体，“座位未全寒”以余温状别情，含蓄新警。立意仍属传统离愁，起句稍平，但转结精当，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":0.00955284},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.25,"rationale":"熟题翻新：以误点、闸口等当代经验入诗，情事具体可感。'收'字为诗眼，结句'未全寒'以余温写离情，以物结情、留白甚佳，时间线一气贯注。前二句叙事偏白、稍平直，是全篇之弱；后联摘出仍动人。","_cost":0.014773},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.6,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.4,"余味":8.3,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.14999999999999,"rationale":"机场细节具体，闸口灯光与空廊余温能把离情落到物象；结句有留白。惟首句叙述稍直，现代词与旧语并置略见痕迹，转合平稳，警句未至拔尖。","_cost":0.013354},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.6,"语言":8.1,"章法":8.4,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.5,"rationale":"以误点、忽报压缩送别时刻，背影与余寒映出聚散；结句以物传情，余味悠长。唯首联叙述稍平。","_cost":0.00707745},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"误点至更阑、忽报话未完有现场真感，闸口收影与座位未寒情景交融，起承转合顺畅，结句以余温触觉留白，语言稍白口。","_cost":0.00809675},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"以机场误点、登机切断未完话别写现代送别，情事具体；‘闸口灯光收背影’‘空廊座位未全寒’造境写余温离痕，结句以景结情而含蓄延宕。语言稍杂现代词，章法完整但转折平和。","_cost":0.029222758},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"该作撷取当代机场送别细节，以闸灯、余座等具象托仓促别绪，章法顺承自然，结句留白有韵，语言精切，无陈套硬伤，惜立意未出新境。","_cost":null}},"consensus":81.64,"final":81.64},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|天台菜园|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","poem":"楼顶青畦带露光，清晨剪下嫩葱香。邻翁笑指盆沿处，半架黄瓜过短墙。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.75,"rationale":"写都市天台种菜,题材切近当代生活,情事具体,但主旨较轻浅。前两句平实,略显常见。第三句引入邻翁,转得自然。结句化用'红杏出墙'为黄瓜过墙,暗含邻里谐趣,以景结情,有余味。'带露光'稍涉熟套。","_cost":0.018956},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.85,"rationale":"当代都市天台种菜经验入诗，极具生活气息。起承转合流利自然，转结处邻翁笑指引出黄瓜过墙，深得宋人绝句活泼生趣，画面明快，结句余味充沛。","_cost":0.00442125},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"楼顶畦圃情事具体,而情志不出田园小喜,立意未深。露光、葱香与过墙黄瓜能成一境,末句最切;第三句散文化,少诗眼。起承平直,转结以指点揭示,章法可观。结句留象未说破,味薄。盆栽经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.033088},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"写楼顶菜园小景，情感真切；末句“黄瓜过短墙”将生长溢出与邻里互动暗合，留白有余。转结自然，结构完整。立意稍浅，用词略熟，如露光、嫩葱。","_cost":0.0055537536},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.5,"rationale":"城市天台种菜入诗，题材新鲜、情事具体可感；起承转合完足，转笔借邻翁笑指宕开视角，结以黄瓜过短墙之景收情，暗化'红杏出墙'而不露痕迹；'剪''过'见炼字。惟立意仍属田园闲趣一路，深度有限，语言整体偏平易。","_cost":0.01612536},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.2,"意境":6.4,"语言":5.8,"章法":6.8,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.2,"rationale":"写楼顶菜园晨趣，起承转合清楚，结以黄瓜过墙，颇有生活气息；但题旨较浅，语多平直，盆沿等词稍弱，未臻深远。","_cost":0.009952},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.5,"score":70.5,"rationale":"都市天台种菜入诗,题材新而情真,露光、葱香、邻翁笑指皆具体可感。'剪下嫩葱香'以味通感见巧,'半架黄瓜过短墙'化'红杏出墙'而不露,以景结情有延宕。唯次句稍平直,整体锤炼尚可再进。","_cost":0.008316},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.6,"余味":8.1,"警句":1.2,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.3,"rationale":"天台种菜以小见趣，露光葱香与邻翁笑指具现场感；半架黄瓜过墙以景结情尤佳，章法转合自然，唯立意止于闲趣未拓深境","_cost":0.01189325},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":57.5,"rationale":"写楼顶种菜，起承转合完整，转结自然；立意因都市田园稍新，意象语言偏平熟，“盆沿处”稍俚、“嫩葱香”略凑。结句以景收束有余味。“半架黄瓜过短墙”略新可摘。无硬伤蹈袭，陈滥轻微。","_cost":0.036804958},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.5,"rationale":"此作写都市天台菜园清晨小景，情志真切，意象鲜活，语言平实精准，起承转合圆顺，结句以景寓趣有余韵，融入当代日常经验，唯立意稍平，无硬伤陈套。","_cost":null}},"consensus":71.26,"final":71.26},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|机场送别|七律","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","poem":"别语将穷到闸门，玻璃那畔隔晨昏。屏前细认航班字，掌上微留一握温。背影匆匆随队去，人潮乍合便无痕。方知未问归期事，独对残茶不忍吞。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"weak"}],"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.0,"rationale":"以机场闸门、航班屏、人潮写当代送别，情事具体。'人潮乍合便无痕'为佳句。'方知未问归期'反用李商隐诗意，有新意。'隔晨昏'稍显勉强，'吞'字为押韵而生硬。中二联偏平铺，结句以残茶收束尚有余味。","_cost":0.02072},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.9,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.1,"rationale":"成功将当代机场送别经验入诗且毫无隔膜。情事具体细腻，'掌上微温'与'人潮乍合'对比传神；尾联以失神忽悟'未问归期'转入残茶独对，章法井然，余韵悠长。","_cost":0.005043},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.5,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.0,"rationale":"熟题常情，情事尚具体。航班、一握温、残茶可感，晨昏、匆匆、无痕偏套。有凑字，玻璃与晨昏不谐。顺叙完整而转折平直。残茶略有余味，不忍已说破。当代场景入诗尚可，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0382976},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.5,"rationale":"机场送别细节真实，掌温、人潮、残茶等现代意象融情；方知未问归期有悔，结句以景收束留余味。题旨较常见，个别字直白。","_cost":0.0141306},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.5,"rationale":"机场送别熟题翻新，闸门、玻璃、航班屏、残茶皆当代实景，物象与离情交融贴切。'人潮乍合便无痕''掌上微留一握温'炼字见诗眼。尾联未问归期、独对残茶以象收情，留白有延宕。'归期'稍涉常语，微瑕不掩。","_cost":0.0035764},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.2,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"现代机场细节真切，颔联有温度，脉络顺畅；但部分语句稍直，结意略说破，晨昏、残茶稍泛。","_cost":0.012682},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"送别熟题置于机场新境,未问归期之悔与残茶难咽收束,情事具体有主脑。航班字、一握温、人潮无痕等象与情交融,中二联别前别后层次分明。语言自然偶见锤炼,'隔晨昏'略硬。结句以物寄情,余韵足。","_cost":0.018258},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.4,"意境":7.7,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.4,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.55,"rationale":"机场物象连缀成境，掌温残茶具体真切；章法随行止由近及远一气贯注，结句以景留白；语言平实少诗眼，立意真挚而翻新有限。","_cost":0.01076625},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"机场经验入诗较有效，取象新切；中二联由近及远、开合有致，章法井然。“掌上温”“人潮乍合”为警句。惜尾联稍直，“航班字”等语略硬，故加减分。","_cost":0.046186875},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"此作写当代机场送别，细节真切，情感沉挚，脉络顺畅，炼字自然，无陈套硬伤；中二联开合得宜，唯结句稍实，余味略欠，有好句动人。","_cost":null}},"consensus":75.29,"final":75.29},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|旧衣回收箱|七律","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","poem":"旧衣回收箱\n院外新添旧服箱，寒灯照见小儿裳。\n衣兜尚夹公交票，袖口犹沾皂角香。\n试罢童衫才觉短，娘亲洗净叠成方。\n风吹绿盖轻轻响，不识谁肩正受凉。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"以回收箱写母爱与推己及人，题材当代。颔联公交票、皂角香细节真切可感。颈联叙事平直，'娘亲''轻轻响'偏口语，炼字不足。结句转向陌生人受寒，有余味但稍显隐晦。'寒灯照见'箱内衣物略欠合理。","_cost":0.019628},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.45,"rationale":"当代生活经验入诗极妥帖自然。颔联“公交票”“皂角香”细节极真切生动；尾联借绿盖风声宕开至恤寒之意，推己及人，余韵深长。颈联语稍显直白，整体情真意切、体贴入微。","_cost":0.00525225},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.8,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.35,"rationale":"回收箱纳旧衣与母爱，情事具体而忧寒之旨常见。票、皂香、绿盖精切；中段回叙，转折偏晚。结句以盖响留白，余味最佳。语顺少炼。","_cost":0.0317232},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.6,"意境":8.3,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.7,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.85,"rationale":"从旧衣箱切入，以公交票、皂角香等细节写成长与母爱，情志具体；尾联以风吹绿盖、不知谁受凉留白，延宕关切。中二联层次清楚，语言自然，佳联动人。","_cost":0.00697324},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.75,"rationale":"旧衣捐赠入七律，小中见大，当代经验化用自然；公交票、皂角香取象精切，残痕兼写母爱与成长之痛；结以风响绿盖宕开，悬念谁肩受凉，言尽意远。惟'旧服箱''娘亲'语体微滞，颈联叙事稍平直。","_cost":0.03359116},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.9,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.8,"rationale":"题取旧衣回收箱，细节真切；公交票、皂角香见生活余温，结处由己及人，略生远意。语言自然但稍平，收束略直。","_cost":0.01838},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"旧衣回收箱之当代题材入诗而情真事切，公交票、皂角香等细节具体可感，结句'不识谁肩正受凉'宕开留白、余味悠长；唯颈联叙事稍平直，'叠成方'略见凑韵，整体锤炼未至化境。","_cost":0.0143383},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.1,"语言":7.7,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.3,"rationale":"借回收箱写童稚成长与母爱洗叠，细节真切收于对他者受寒的悲悯；物象日常而情浓，脉络递进，末句以风声宕开留白。","_cost":0.008056},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.1,"rationale":"以回收箱写母爱与匿名济贫，题旨新切；颔联票、香细节动人，脉络由见衣、忆洗叠到怜人；尾句稍直白，措辞有平淡处，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.036014653},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"以当代旧衣回收箱为切入，借车票、皂角香等细切意象融亲子温情与推己及人仁怀，章法顺承，结句留余韵，语言平实精准，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":null}},"consensus":80.41,"final":80.41},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|云端相册|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","poem":"云端旧照忽回还，夜半屏中见母颜。院角浇花人未老，庭前铁桶已生斑。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.3,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.45,"rationale":"借云端相册写思母,当代经验入诗自然。转句写照中人未老,结句写庭前铁桶生锈,用今昔对照暗示时光流逝,以物结情,不说破母亲今况,余味较深。首句「回还」稍泛,「院角」「庭前」空间略重复,语言平实少诗眼。","_cost":0.016284},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.6,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.05,"rationale":"成功将手机相册智能推送的当代经验入诗，起承自然。转结切入旧照细节，以“铁桶生斑”暗喻光阴侵蚀，不直言衰老而物是人非之感自出，收束含蓄有味。","_cost":0.00688875},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.0,"rationale":"思亲见照属熟题，云端夜屏使之落实，未翻出深境。起承近叙述，“忽回还”稍赘。转结以浇花未老对照铁桶生斑，物象精切、不说破，余味最佳。无典误与套话堆砌。","_cost":0.0274768},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.5,"rationale":"以云端旧照与庭前铁桶对举，物变与人颜如旧相衬，思念含蓄。三四句细节具体，结句景结有留白。题旨不算全新，意象稍平，但当代经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.0075623},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.25,"rationale":"旧照思亲是熟题，但以'云端相册''夜半屏中'的当代经验入诗，翻出新境。前两句叙事简洁铺垫，后两句以'人未老'与'铁桶已生斑'的时间反差作结，物象承载物是人非之痛，景语即情语，言尽意不尽。通篇无一字直说悲思，取象精切，脉络一气贯注。'院角''庭前'对仗稍显平列，略陈熟，然瑕不掩瑜。","_cost":0.00298616},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.6,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.39999999999999,"rationale":"云端、屏中写旧照怀母，角度新而情真；院角浇花与铁桶生斑对照，以物收束有余味。但‘回还’稍凑，母题常见。","_cost":0.00983},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"云端旧照、夜半屏中为当代经验入诗而不生硬,主脑集中。转结最工:照片中浇花人未老,现实中铁桶已生锈,以物之斑朽衬时之流逝,以景结情、言尽意不尽。语言平实少锤炼,'忽回还'稍松,首二句略平直,未至警策。","_cost":0.00555375},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.1,"rationale":"借云端旧照写当代乡愁，人未老与铁桶生斑对比见时光，以物证情，景结有余味，转合自然。","_cost":0.00731175},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.5,"rationale":"云端旧照触发夜半思母，‘人未老’与‘铁桶生斑’对照光阴，焦点集中；取象稍平常，语言通顺偶有亮点；结句以锈蚀物象含蓄不尽。","_cost":0.029592907},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"此作以云端睹母旧照为引写思亲之慨，取浇花人、锈铁桶等具象寄寓岁月怅惘，语言精准自然，章法流转，结句以物托情留白有余韵，当代经验入诗妥帖。","_cost":null}},"consensus":79.72,"final":79.72},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|天台菜园|七律","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","poem":"百尺楼头豆角长，晨昏侍弄趁微凉。空调滴水浇青蒜，旧桶藏泥护嫩姜。烈日蒸城伤菜叶，邻翁举勺润瓜秧。归人倦立街灯下，忽有鲜蔬带露香。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"unknown"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":62.75,"rationale":"以天台种菜写都市人的小小田园,情事具体,温厚可亲,但立意较常见。“空调滴水浇青蒜”把当代经验有效入诗,鲜活可喜。中二联都铺写劳作,层次略平。尾联转到归人的视角稍显突兀,楼顶菜香飘到街边也有些牵强。结句以香作收,还算留有余味。","_cost":0.021808},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.65,"rationale":"将当代都市经验巧妙入诗，空调水、旧桶等现代日常物象取裁精切、生活气息浓郁。颔联对仗工整生动，尾联从楼顶劳作转至街灯归人，以温情收束，意境亲切可感。","_cost":0.0054345},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"楼顶种菜情事具体，冷凝水、旧桶、举勺等象新切，当代经验入诗有效。中二联近于铺排，开合不足；结句直陈露香，收稳而少延宕。语言顺畅，蒸城、举勺略见锤炼，未成警句。","_cost":0.0309504},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"该作以都市楼顶种菜入诗，取材当代视角，情感具体，主脑清晰；意象多取自真实生活，结句留白有味。中二联略平铺，个别词汇仍带熟套，但佳的如空调、旧桶对举，炼字自然。","_cost":0.0055108736},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"都市天台种菜，当代经验入诗自然妥帖；空调滴水、旧桶藏泥取象精切，颔联堪称佳联。结以带露鲜香宕开，景语含情，言尽意远。惟菜蔬名目略密近列锦，颈联转折平直，锤炼稍欠，故意境语言章法微降。无硬伤袭用，套语极少。","_cost":0.01571556},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.4,"章法":7.1,"余味":8.3,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.8,"rationale":"天台种菜取当代生活细节，空调滴水、旧桶护姜颇有实感；结以街灯下蔬香，稍留余味。但中二联铺陈略平，语言偏实，诗眼未显。","_cost":0.01458},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"以空调滴水、旧桶藏泥等当代物象入七律，田园意趣移植楼顶，立意真切有焦点；结句\"忽有鲜蔬带露香\"以嗅觉收束、留白生韵。惜中二联层次稍平，邻翁一转略散，语言有炼字而通体未匀。","_cost":0.01473465},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.2,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.3,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.45,"rationale":"天台种菜切入当代都市经验，空调滴水旧桶等象新切具体，烈日蒸城与举勺润秧对照见温情，末以归人闻香宕开收束留有余味，语言平实少锤炼。","_cost":0.00955875},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.3,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.5,"rationale":"都市天台种菜题材新颖，焦点集中；“空调滴水浇青蒜，旧桶藏泥护嫩姜”摘出仍动人；意象稍欠熔炼，结句留香有余味。无硬伤、陈滥、蹈袭。","_cost":0.037657809},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.5,"rationale":"本诗聚焦都市天台菜园日常，意象鲜活有当代质感，语言精准自然，结句以感官细节留余味；唯立意开掘较浅，章法转折偏平，无硬伤陈套。","_cost":null}},"consensus":75.64,"final":75.64},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|云端相册|七律","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","poem":"掌上云窗越海天，闲翻旧影见童年。溪边赤脚拈螺壳，灶畔花衫染暮烟。片里慈颜浑未改，灯前稚子已华颠。重逢只隔玻璃面，欲唤阿娘指半悬。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.25,"rationale":"诗人借云端相册写忆母，是当代经验有效入诗，情事具体。颔联两个童年画面鲜活，颈联用照片中未改的慈颜与灯前已白发的自己作今昔对照。尾联以“指半悬”这一动作收束，不说破而哀思自现。“浑未改”“华颠”稍显熟套。","_cost":0.016192},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.6,"rationale":"当代科技经验自然入律。颔联写童年鲜活如画，颈联今昔对照沉郁沧桑。尾联“指半悬”细节精微，将屏幕阻隔的岁月与死生之痛写得深沉克制，余味绵长。","_cost":0.004812},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.7,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.7,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.85,"rationale":"云窗与半悬之指使怀母熟题落到具体经验，主脑集中。意象有螺壳花衫，亦有海天暮烟之熟。语言见诗眼，只隔偏说明。章法完整而颔联平列。结句停于欲唤，余味最胜。无硬伤蹈袭，套语轻度。","_cost":0.0368},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.5,"rationale":"以云端相册翻旧照为线，今昔对比具体真切，结句“指半悬”留白见深情；意象稍熟但“染暮烟”等融入氛围，章法收束有力。","_cost":0.002977128},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":93.0,"rationale":"云端翻旧照怀母，今昔对照主脑鲜明。颈联'片里慈颜浑未改，灯前稚子已华颠'以照片定格反衬岁月，熟题翻新境；结句'欲唤阿娘指半悬'以悬停指尖收束，言尽意不尽，当代经验入诗自然无痕。惟'慈颜''暮烟'稍常见，扣意境微降。","_cost":0.01754016},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.8,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.4,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.55,"rationale":"以云端相册写思亲，旧景与今身对照，细节真切，结句悬指留白有余味。局部词稍直，旧语略熟。","_cost":0.012072},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.5,"rationale":"以云相册翻旧照寄思母之情，题材新而情事具体。颔联溪边灶畔意象鲜活，颈联今昔对照有力。结句「欲唤阿娘指半悬」以细节留白，玻璃之隔写尽生死之隔，言尽意不尽。语言锤炼见诗眼，唯首联稍平。","_cost":0.0065955},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.4,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.2,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.6,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.10000000000001,"rationale":"云端相册切入当代经验真切，片里未改与灯前华颠对比凝练，末联指半悬以景结情留白足，唯溪灶意象略常见。","_cost":0.00941125},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.75,"rationale":"以云端翻旧照写思亲，数码屏幕隔出重逢新境；中二联细节真切，尾联以指半悬留白，余韵深长。起句稍平，整体凝练。","_cost":0.023039464},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.6,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.8,"rationale":"以当代云端相册切入写思亲，细节真切，章法顺畅，尾句以动作留白余韵悠长，仅个别语词稍熟，无硬伤蹈袭，当代经验融入自然。","_cost":null}},"consensus":85.19,"final":85.19},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|夜航俯瞰|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","poem":"夜航俯瞰\n舷窗忽见一城明，数座长桥截水横。欲认家门无处觅，空余两岸旧街名。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":5.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":61.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰故城,当代经验入诗,主题是城变与失乡,角度较常见。前两句取象清朗,'截水横'有力度。转句寻家不得,结句以旧街名收束,有余味。不足是'空余''无处觅'略显熟套。高空能否辨认街名稍有逻辑疑点,理解为记忆中的街名则可通。","_cost":0.016768},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.8,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.8,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.2,"rationale":"现代夜航经验自然入诗，起承转合规整流转。由万家灯火之宏阔转入寻认家门之渺然，以虚名结实景，余味悠长。炼字略显平易，胜在情真脉畅。","_cost":0.005535},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":4.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":59.75,"rationale":"夜航认家，情事具体而角度常见。前二句俯瞰有景，截字较挺；后半转干说，街名与舷窗视点未密合。章法完整，承句平直。结以空余点破，余味偏薄。当代经验入诗有限，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0212064},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.25,"rationale":"从夜航俯瞰寻旧居切入，情感具体，但立意不算独到。意象妥帖融合尚可，'截'字略见炼字。构思清晰，转结自然，结句以'旧街名'收束留余味。整体中上，无硬伤。","_cost":0.0019907072},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰为当代经验有效入诗，乡愁熟题翻出新境，主脑聚焦。'截水横'取象精切，'截'字见炼。三句转得力，结以旧街名宕开留白，言尽意不尽。微瑕：第三句稍平，'数座''无处觅'略近熟语。","_cost":0.01669416},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.2,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.2,"章法":7.4,"余味":6.4,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.85,"rationale":"夜航视角较新，城桥灯火有画面，转合完整，乡愁明确。惜“欲认”“空余”稍直，旧街名难由俯瞰落实，余味未宕开。","_cost":0.010772},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"夜航寻家不得，落脚旧街名，乡愁具体且留白；起承转合完整。桥水取象略粗，“截”字稍硬，新境有成而未至奇警。","_cost":0.0139356},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.3,"意境":5.6,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.8,"警句":1.2,"出新":1.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.95,"rationale":"舷窗夜俯切入当代离散体验，以万家明灭反衬家门难觅，起承转合清晰，结以旧街名留白有味，然意象与炼字未臻精切。","_cost":0.00814575},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":5.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.0,"rationale":"起承转合清晰；夜航俯瞰的当代视角为乡思翻出新境，情感具体。取象妥帖但稍常见，结句以空余直陈，余味中等；语言通顺，截字有力而略带白话。无硬伤、蹈袭，亦无明显陈滥。","_cost":0.027962257},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.2,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.0,"rationale":"此作写夜航俯瞰的真切感怀，情志具体，脉络顺畅，用字精准，结句稳当有余韵；唯整体角度、意象偏平实，转折较直，未脱羁旅望乡常见路数。","_cost":null}},"consensus":70.08,"final":70.08},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|深夜视频|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","poem":"深夜视频\n夜半屏光照客床，阿娘举镜过回廊。檐前小犬闻声起，却向柴门摆尾狂。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.25,"rationale":"以深夜视频写乡思，借小犬闻主人声而奔向柴门的误会，侧写游子未归，情事具体、角度新颖。起承平实，转结有变，结句以动作收束，留有余味。不足在于“举镜”指代手机镜头，语义不够明晰；“摆尾狂”稍显粗直，有凑韵之感。","_cost":0.017784},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.8,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.2,"章法":8.7,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":92.35,"rationale":"当代经验入诗的绝妙佳构。化用视频毫无滞涩，结穴尤见神采：写小犬听声误认游子归家而向柴门狂摇其尾，以灵动细节直戳泪点，真挚深沉，余韵悠长。","_cost":0.00480075},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.5,"rationale":"屏光举镜把视频写成隔门之归，犬向柴门摆尾是焦点，情事具体而发现未深。意象能交融，语言多白描，狂字写满，结句少延宕。起承转合完整，转在闻声，收得住但平顺。","_cost":0.035496},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.75,"rationale":"以深夜视频为背景，借犬闻声摆尾写思归，角度具体；结句宕开留白，余味较好。语言自然，唯“举镜”稍歧义。传统意象稍熟，瑕不掩瑜。","_cost":0.00356433},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.75,"rationale":"以视频通话入诗，阿娘举镜过廊，情事具体可感；转结最妙——小犬闻声误认游子归来，柴门摆尾而人实未归，以景结情，酸楚尽在不言中。语言自然，'举镜'切题有巧思，'摆尾狂'稍口语化。当代经验化古无痕，章法一气贯注。","_cost":0.0028844},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.9,"rationale":"写深夜视频见亲情，母举镜、犬吠柴门细节鲜活，当代经验入诗有效；结以动作留白。语言稍直，古今语象微有缝隙。","_cost":0.007034},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"视频通话入旧体，情事具体：屏光、举镜、回廊层层推进，转结以小犬闻声向门摆尾收束，人未归而情已至，以景结情留白得当。'举镜'略嫌含糊，个别意象属传统套式，故酌扣。","_cost":0.0105906},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.1,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.9,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.4,"警句":1.8,"出新":2.4,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.45,"rationale":"以视频举镜翻新游子思亲，客床冷光与回廊犬迎对照真切，举镜、摆尾狂锤炼见功，转合以犬误认空门收束，景结情留白悠长。","_cost":0.006852},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.0,"rationale":"当代视频通话入七绝，焦点集中；以犬闻声奔柴门摆尾收束，错位期盼有余味。然语言稍白，'举镜'与'摆尾狂'锤炼不足。","_cost":0.024408335},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"此诗写客居深夜与母视频的日常场景，细节鲜活真挚，章法圆转，以小犬摆尾的景语结情留余，自然融入当代通讯经验，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":81.17,"final":81.17},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|社区食堂|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","poem":"巷口灯明小饭堂，葱花蛋饼出锅香。门前白发扶筇至，柜上留羹尚未凉。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":66.0,"rationale":"以社区食堂写养老温情，当代题材有效入诗，葱花蛋饼细节可感。转句老人扶杖而至，结句留羹未凉暗示有人等候，温情不说破。惜扶筇略套，前两句平直，立意停于小暖，未有更深开掘。","_cost":0.015108},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"当代民生入诗，烟火气与人情味兼备。起承转合脉络清晰，语言朴实流畅如白话诗。结句“留羹尚未凉”以细致入微的关照收束，前后照应，温暖动人，尽显温情。","_cost":0.004968},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.75,"rationale":"以留羹未凉写社区照护，情事具体、收束不说破，结句有余味。关怀老人属常题，新在食堂与蛋饼入诗。白发扶筇稍熟，起句平而脉络贯通。无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0236592},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.5,"rationale":"从社区食堂落笔，抓住留羹与白发细节，情感温暖具体；转结自然，以“尚未凉”收束，留有余味。语言平实略有诗眼，前两句意象稍常见但不落熟套。","_cost":0.0025286528},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.0,"rationale":"社区食堂为当代民生题材，熟题写出暖意。蛋饼出锅香、白发扶筇、留羹未凉，皆具体可感，末句以'尚未凉'暗写照拂之情，言尽意不尽。通篇象与情融，脉络自然。'白发扶筇'稍近陈套，扣陈滥微降。","_cost":0.00149064},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.4,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.3,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.8,"rationale":"以巷灯、蛋饼香写社区食堂烟火，白发扶筇引出留羹未凉，细节有温情。语意自然，略近口语，筇字稍旧；起承转合清楚，结句留白尚可。","_cost":0.012806},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"取社区食堂白发留羹，题旨温暖具体，当代经验入诗自然；意象统一而稍熟，语言平实少锤炼，起承平稳，转结以“尚未凉”宕出余温，最见佳处。","_cost":0.0055832},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.6,"意境":7.2,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.2,"余味":7.0,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.9,"rationale":"以社区食堂切入老龄温情，题材具体有烟火气；意象可感交融，章法顺承而转折平直，语言白描少锤炼，结句以留羹收束尚有余温。","_cost":0.006945},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":69.0,"rationale":"以社区食堂、葱花蛋饼入诗，聚焦‘留羹未凉’，情真意切；意象语言稍平，转折略直。结句以温羹传情，含蓄有味的；‘白发扶筇’稍旧，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.03233567},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"以小见大摹写社区食堂的烟火暖意，意象贴实、语言干净、章法平顺，结句以细节藏温，当代市井经验入诗自然，仅个别表述稍熟。","_cost":null}},"consensus":73.94,"final":73.94},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|春街树挂吊瓶|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","poem":"夹道垂杨药袋悬，银针入木接流泉。行人不识根中渴，却有新阴落客肩。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.75,"rationale":"取街树输液这一当代景象入诗，树忍渴仍布阴，隐含默默付出之意，托意不说破。转结对照有力，以阴落客肩作结，余味可品。流泉稍美化，却有略显虚弱，垂杨略熟。","_cost":0.015644},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.2,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.55,"rationale":"敏锐摄取当代街景入诗，化俗为雅。转结尤见功力，以行人不识树苦、树反赠人清凉作结，关合人情物理，体物入微，仁厚蕴藉，余味绵长。","_cost":0.004602},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"街树吊瓶入诗,情事具体,焦点在根渴而人不知。银针新切,流泉稍套。起承完整,转句已说破,结句有象而余味不厚。","_cost":0.0251344},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.8,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.94999999999999,"rationale":"从城市给树输液切入，拟写根中渴与新阴答客，转结有情味。“银针入木”精当，“新阴落客肩”以景收束而不说破，无陈套硬伤。","_cost":0.007902246},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.0,"rationale":"取城市行道树吊瓶输液这一当代实景入诗，见人所未见。“银针入木接流泉”化医疗为树语，精切自然。转结尤佳：人不识根渴，树仍以新阴惠人，以景结情，怨而不怒，余味悠长。垂杨、流泉稍熟，整体意象统一，脉络一气贯注。","_cost":0.00268096},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.4,"章法":8.1,"余味":8.4,"警句":3.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.4,"rationale":"以城市护树入诗，药袋银针与垂杨新阴相融。转句点出受荫而不知根渴，结以落肩之景留白。立意新颖，脉络清楚，语言稍现代而自然。","_cost":0.010074},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.25,"rationale":"以街边输液树木这一当代实景入诗,翻出新意:起承写药袋银针,'接流泉'喻点滴精切;转结'行人不识根中渴,却有新阴落客肩'由树之隐忍付出翻出人情,以景结情、余味自足。唯'根中渴'与树干输液之实略有抵牾,前二联用语稍平,未见更多锤炼。","_cost":0.01002995},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.7,"意境":7.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.6,"余味":8.4,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":87.39999999999999,"rationale":"以输液喻根渴化俗为雅，熟题翻新有主脑；起承写实、转合生情，结句以景结情留余味，章法贯注。","_cost":0.008829},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.5,"rationale":"以树木挂吊瓶这一当代经验入诗，结句“新阴落肩”以景收束，暗寓不识之恩；惟医疗与古典意象略杂，意境稍欠浑融，章法平稳，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.024883525},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.0,"rationale":"以当代街树打吊针的日常场景入诗，立意精巧有新意，起承转合顺畅，语言自然妥帖，结句含蓄有余味，无陈套硬伤，意境浑融度尚有提升空间。","_cost":null}},"consensus":82.75,"final":82.75},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|夜航俯瞰|七律","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","poem":"夜航俯瞰\n翼畔红光隔雨悬，云开万点入长川。\n江湾黑水分街市，渡口车灯接夜船。\n座背航图标故里，邻人倚枕已成眠。\n低头欲认归来路，一盏孤明过眼前。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰写归乡，当代经验入诗，取象具体。颔联黑水分街市、车灯接夜船，写实精切。颈联由窗外转入舱内，航图标故里与邻人已眠相衬，但对仗偏松，情思稍浅。结句以一盏孤灯掠过收束，欲认而不得，余味可感。","_cost":0.017684},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.2,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.9,"rationale":"当代夜航经验成功入律。起承绘机外俯瞰夜景，视域开阔；颈联以内外观照转入归乡情怯，结句以景结情，一盏孤明过眼，余韵悠远。现代物象无生硬感，脉络顺畅。","_cost":0.00681525},"grok-4.7":{"立意":6.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.75,"rationale":"归望具体而角度常见。翼灯、江水分街、航图交融，并有效纳入当代经验；渡口联稍赘。悬、分、标见炼，成眠、欲认偏平。由万点收至一盏，舱内有转，颔联少开合。结句以灯掠过，未说破，孤明已略点情。","_cost":0.041504},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.6,"语言":6.4,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.6,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.4,"rationale":"全诗以夜航归乡为线，外景舱内切换自然，结句孤灯留白有味；但颈联‘座背航图标故里’偏散文化，语言炼字稍平，立意未脱归途常见。现代细节有效入诗。","_cost":0.01275428},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.25,"rationale":"夜航俯瞰这一当代经验入诗自然无痕,化李太白低头之典而不露。中二联开合有致,颔联状景精切,'黑水分街市'取象独到;颈联转入人事,邻人成眠反衬己之未眠。结句'一盏孤明过眼前'以景结情,言尽意不尽,余韵悠长。通篇氛围统一,少见之佳构。","_cost":0.00390356},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.7,"意境":7.6,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.1,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.3,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.4,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.55,"rationale":"题取现代夜航，俯瞰与归思相生，章法清晰。颔联灯水相映有画面，尾句孤明留味。语言稳妥而稍平直，个别词略生。","_cost":0.009364},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.0,"rationale":"以夜航俯瞰写归乡辨认,当代经验入律而不生硬,意象群(翼灯、云川、车灯、孤明)统一于夜色氛围。颈联由景入舱内,转出归心,脉络贯通。结句'一盏孤明过眼前'以景结情、留有余韵,是全篇诗眼。惜中二联对仗语稍平直,'座背航图'句略近散文,锤炼可再紧。","_cost":0.00662775},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.3,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.8,"余味":7.4,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":68.25,"rationale":"夜航现代经验切实，以欲认归路为眼串联舷外灯川与舱内对照，以孤明景语收束留白；意象妥帖但翻新与锤炼未至上乘。","_cost":0.009032},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":84.75,"rationale":"取象精切，当代航空经验自然入律；中二联开合有致，尾联以孤灯过眼留白深远；颈联叙述略平直，语言偶有平白。无硬伤、蹈袭与陈滥。","_cost":0.023612193},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":7.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.0,"rationale":"以当代夜航俯瞰视角写羁旅归思，取象切境，章法承转圆熟，语稳意顺，景中含情；结句有留白，唯情志未翻新境，个别意象稍熟。","_cost":null}},"consensus":77.76,"final":77.76},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|深夜视频|七律","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","poem":"夜半屏中学步图，娇儿踉跄向娘趋。咿呀稚语频呼父，断续机声隔远途。欲把双肩移画里，空将两手握虚无。荧光灭后仍低首，只剩玻璃映电弧。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":["跄"],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":0.75,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"unknown"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":1.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":67.25,"rationale":"","_cost":0.012664},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.2,"章法":7.6,"余味":6.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.4,"rationale":"写现代视频通话之骨肉离情，当代经验入诗极为真切自然。颈联情态毕现，虚实相生，深沉动人。尾联以熄屏落笔，余韵悠长，唯“电弧”一词施于手机熄屏略欠常理，稍显生硬。","_cost":0.00564225},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":6.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"隔屏见学步、呼父不可触，情事具体而主脑集中。颈联欲与空对举，转关有力，摘出仍动人。机声含混、电弧失据，意象未尽交融，结句景语费解，余味有限。套语疏，无整句蹈袭。","_cost":0.023976},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":91.0,"rationale":"视频看儿题材当代经验入诗有效,情感具体真挚。'欲把双肩移画里,空将两手握虚无'虚实相生,是全篇警策。结句荧光灭后玻璃映弧,以景结情,低首不语,余味悠长。中二联开合有致,'机声隔远途'稍平,'电弧'用词略生硬但不害全局。","_cost":0.00269236},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.85,"rationale":"以深夜视频写现代亲子异地，情感真切；颈联虚实对比为佳联。尾句以景结情，延宕有力。唯“机声”“电弧”稍险硬，语言略欠自然。无硬伤陈套。","_cost":0.0131064},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.4,"语言":7.1,"章法":7.8,"余味":7.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.0,"rationale":"以深夜视频写亲子远隔，聚焦学步与触屏不得，情感具体；颈联有巧思，现代意象入诗较自然，唯电弧略生，余味稍涩。","_cost":0.01091},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"打工者深夜视频看儿学步,题材切实、情感具体不空泛。'空将两手握虚无'为诗眼,颈联开合有力;结句'玻璃映电弧'暗点焊工身份,宕出余味。唯中二联对仗意近、'机声''远途'略熟,语言锤炼尚可更紧。","_cost":0.007251},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.2,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.7,"余味":8.0,"警句":1.6,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":76.85,"rationale":"视频学步取材真切，虚握一联以当代经验入诗有新意；起承转合顺畅，荧灭低首以景结情留有余味，唯起句机声等处稍显直拙。","_cost":0.01207475},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.2,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.4,"rationale":"深夜隔屏看幼子学步，题材新而情真；中二联由景入情，转合清晰。颈联'握虚无'句佳。惜'移画里''映电弧'造语稍硬，收束有余味而未尽深长。","_cost":0.039632764},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.75,"rationale":"此作写羁旅深夜视频见稚子学步的思亲之情，细节真切，融当代日常经验入旧体，章法顺畅，结句留白有余味，无硬伤陈套。","_cost":null}},"consensus":79.7,"final":59.78},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|春街树挂吊瓶|七律","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","poem":"春街树挂吊瓶\n小树临街挂药瓶，春风过处响车铃。\n园丁俯首寻虫迹，细管穿皮润叶青。\n汽笛频催人影急，童儿驻足问安宁。\n斜阳照透玻璃腹，一滴犹悬未肯零。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"weak"}],"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.5,"rationale":"以树挂吊瓶这一当代街景入诗，取材新鲜，童问一节有温情，但立意停在观察，未深掘。中二联动静相映，颔联稍平，“问安宁”略凑。结句“一滴犹悬未肯零”以物结情，留有余味。","_cost":0.020832},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.7,"语言":7.6,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":82.25,"rationale":"写都市绿化树木输液之景，当代经验入诗熨帖自然。颈联借行人匆遽反衬童心体惜，转笔灵动。尾联定格夕照药滴，以物传情，微观精妙且余味绵长。","_cost":0.00530475},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":72.0,"rationale":"吊瓶养护是当代实景，题有发现，情事具体而多旁观。玻璃腹与悬滴精切，车铃汽笛人影偏套。语言偶见诗眼，通篇偏白，问安宁近于点题。起承转合完整，转折平直。结句以景收住，意未说尽。","_cost":0.0207216},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.25,"rationale":"以街树输液写城市生态关怀，角度新、情感具体。尾联以景收束，一滴悬而未落，余味佳。中二联层次清晰，语言自然但略平，春风斜阳等熟象稍多。","_cost":0.00898392},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":88.0,"rationale":"以街头树挂吊瓶这一当代城市小景入诗，拟人贴切而有悲悯焦点。中二联一写救治、一写喧嚣与驻足之对照，开合有层次。结句聚焦玻璃腹中一滴悬而未落，以景结情、物我合一，'未肯零'三字见诗眼，余味悠长。'问安宁'稍平，整体炼字精到无陈套。","_cost":0.00318596},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.2,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.1,"章法":7.8,"余味":8.2,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":83.85,"rationale":"以城市护树入诗，题旨具体，细节生动；‘玻璃腹’‘一滴悬’有余味。现代语词稍硬，颈联略直，故稍抑。","_cost":0.01169},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.5,"rationale":"以城市树木输液这一当代经验入七律,角度新鲜且情事具体,园丁寻虫、童儿驻足使主旨有焦点。取象精切,'玻璃腹''一滴犹悬未肯零'景情交融,结句以景结情、留白耐读,为全篇最佳处。中二联开合尚可,颈联稍平,'人影急'等语略熟,语言整体通顺而锤炼未至化境。","_cost":0.0063202},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.6,"意境":6.9,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.1,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":75.95,"rationale":"借树吊瓶切入城市春景，小题见温情；以童稚一问对照行人匆急，主脑清晰，末句一滴悬光以景结情，留白隽永。","_cost":0.01160025},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"当代树木输液题材出新，立意稍浅；中二联偏实写，转折平直、情景欠融。结句斜阳悬滴，以景结情，余味悠长。","_cost":0.035067433},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":73.25,"rationale":"此作捕捉春街行道树挂吊瓶的当代日常，观察细腻，脉络顺畅，结句定格将落药液留白有余味，语言平实有亮点，无硬伤蹈袭，唯立意欠深掘，个别意象稍泛。","_cost":null}},"consensus":76.78,"final":76.78},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|社区食堂|七律","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","poem":"清晨巷口饭初香，老友相携入食堂。一碟青蔬添肉末，双瓯白粥映秋阳。楼头独叟难移步，灶下厨师送热汤。薄暮窗前灯未灭，归人背影过长廊。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.0,"余味":5.5,"警句":0.5,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.5,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":51.75,"rationale":"当代社区养老题材入诗，情事具体。颈联送汤独叟为情眼，但未深掘。语言平实近白，'厨师''肉末'略显俗直。按晨至暮铺排，转折平缓。结句以灯影背影作结，有余温，但'归人'指向含混。","_cost":0.017508},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":7.8,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.8,"章法":7.6,"余味":7.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.35,"rationale":"聚焦当代社区助老题材，情事真切。从晨食写至暮归，由堂食推及送餐，章法通达，烟火气与关怀并具。语言清浅自然，结句以光影留白，平实中有余温。","_cost":0.005763},"grok-4.7":{"立意":5.5,"意境":5.0,"语言":4.5,"章法":5.5,"余味":6.5,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":54.25,"rationale":"社区食堂与送汤事具体，有生活温度，但立意止于常见温情，无独到发现。意象妥帖，颈联近于直叙；语言通顺而少诗眼。晨暮有脉络，人事物略散，结句以灯与背影收，余味尚在而未厚。","_cost":0.0266096},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":7.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.25,"rationale":"写社区食堂日常温情，情事具体，意象妥帖，结句以景收束有余味；但立意角度常见，语言偶有亮点，整体中上。","_cost":0.00573672},"glm-5.3":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"社区食堂入诗，题材当下、情事具体，颈联独叟得汤是佳转，全篇围绕民生温度收束。结句背影长廊以景收，留有余味。语言平实通顺而锤炼稍欠，颔联略近流水账，无警拔诗眼。","_cost":0.00252076},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":6.8,"意境":6.4,"语言":6.1,"章法":7.2,"余味":7.8,"警句":2.2,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.2,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.4,"rationale":"以社区食堂写烟火与人情，题材较新，细节具体；由晨至暮，脉络清楚，尾联灯影背影有留白。但叙述偏平直，语词多常见，锤炼与意象密度不足。","_cost":0.0106},"kimi-k3":{"立意":6.5,"意境":6.5,"语言":5.5,"章法":6.0,"余味":6.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":63.0,"rationale":"以社区食堂写暮年互助，题旨真切而角度不险；晨昏推进、由众及独脉路清楚，但叙述偏散文化，炼字少警策。结句借背影收束略有留白，未至悠远。","_cost":0.00642725},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":6.5,"意境":5.8,"语言":5.2,"章法":6.6,"余味":5.9,"警句":0.0,"出新":1.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":60.75,"rationale":"取材社区食堂具时代感，温情纪实有主脑但开掘不深；白描写实意象平实，语言通顺少锤炼，章法时序贯通转合平直，结景收束尚稳余味淡。","_cost":0.008915},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":5.0,"章法":5.0,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":65.5,"rationale":"以社区食堂写养老助老，当代日常经验有效入诗，情事具体。中二联多叙事、转合稍平，语言直白少锤炼。结句以景宕开留白，有余味。","_cost":0.037833033},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":6.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":5.5,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":64.25,"rationale":"此作平实记录社区食堂从早到晚的烟火温情，细节具体，语言自然，以景结有余韵；但章法平直，意象偏平实，立意无深拓，当代题材入诗自然，无硬伤、陈套与蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":65.67,"final":65.67},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|云仓夜扫|七绝","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","poem":"夜半云仓扫积尘，孤灯点检旧音频。千条杂讯纷纷灭，欲弃娘音手未伸。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":true},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":null,"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.5,"意境":6.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.0,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":71.25,"rationale":"以清理云端旧音频写亲情,当代经验入诗,主脑集中于娘音。“扫积尘”移用于云仓颇巧。三句以千条俱灭反衬一音难舍,转得有力。结句以动作收束,未说破哀思,有余味。“孤灯”稍套,“娘音”略生硬。","_cost":0.01666},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.3,"余味":8.2,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.15,"rationale":"当代数字生活经验入诗极熨帖自然。前三句大刀阔斧清理存储，转结至“欲弃娘音手未伸”，以指尖停滞的微小动作定格至深亲情，对比鲜明，章法严谨且余味深长。","_cost":0.005511},"grok-4.7":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.75,"rationale":"立意胜在云端清档与弃娘音之迟疑，情事具体。孤灯夜半略熟，点检纷纷偏白，唯手未伸为眼。章法完整，转靠对比。结句留手势未说破。当代经验入诗有效，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":0.0193456},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":7.3,"语言":7.8,"章法":8.4,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.4,"rationale":"聚焦删除旧音频时对母亲声音的不舍，情感具体真切。转结以动作留白，余味足。云仓、音频等现代经验入诗自然，但夜半、孤灯等意象略熟，中段稍平。","_cost":0.01505592},"glm-5.3":{"立意":8.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":9.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":86.25,"rationale":"以夜扫云端入诗，当代数字经验有效化入古典格辙，立意新警。'欲弃娘音手未伸'以定格动作写不舍，诗眼醒豁，结句留白极佳。'点检''灭'炼字见功；惟'纷纷''旧音频'稍直白，第三句转折平缓。","_cost":0.02129396},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.4,"意境":6.6,"语言":6.8,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.6,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":80.1,"rationale":"夜扫云端旧音频，千条杂讯可删，唯娘音不忍，情感具体；新题入诗有转结，末句动作留白。惜科技词稍直，娘音略生，意境未臻浑成。","_cost":0.009988},"kimi-k3":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.75,"rationale":"以清理云存储为题材翻出新境，'千条杂讯'与'娘音'对照，数字化断舍离中见孝思深情，立意真切入骨。章法起承转合干净，转结得力，结句以迟疑手势定格，不言悲而悲自现。意象稍简，'纷纷灭'句略平；新词入诗自然，无蹈袭痕迹。","_cost":0.0070064},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":8.6,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.2,"章法":8.0,"余味":8.4,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.8,"rationale":"以云端扫尘切入娘音难弃，当代经验真切，主脑集中；起承转合清晰，结句以动作留白，意境因音频杂讯等白话词稍损雅切。","_cost":0.00828675},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.0,"语言":7.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":77.0,"rationale":"以夜扫云仓、删旧音频的当代经验写思母，焦点集中，结句“手未伸”含蓄有力，出新而警策；意象稍实用、转合略平，无硬伤、陈滥、蹈袭。","_cost":0.024259108},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":78.75,"rationale":"取深夜清理云存储的当代日常，以欲删母亲语音却停手的细节见真挚亲情，章法顺畅，细节传神，仅“孤灯”稍熟，无硬伤蹈袭。","_cost":null}},"consensus":80.02,"final":80.02},{"key":"gpt-6-sol|云仓夜扫|七律","writer":"gpt-6-sol","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","poem":"云仓夜静隔街霜，人影沿墙过侧廊。纸屑随风黏辊轴，封条卷角挂空箱。尘埃扫尽装车路，货件分流赴四方。忽见乡名浮眼底，回身帚响碎灯光。","dup_lines":0,"verdict":{"平仄有误":[],"用韵":false,"孤平":false,"三平尾":false,"三仄尾":false,"失粘":false,"重字":false},"coef":1.0,"duizhang":[{"name":"颔联","verdict":"ok"},{"name":"颈联","verdict":"ok"}],"scores":{"claude-opus-5.5":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.5,"余味":7.5,"警句":1.5,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.25,"rationale":"写云仓夜班清扫，当代劳动经验有效入诗。颔联辊轴、封条取象精切。颈联「货件分流赴四方」偏平直。尾联由面单乡名触发乡思，以「帚响碎灯光」动作结情，含蓄有余味。「浮眼底」稍弱。","_cost":0.015312},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"立意":8.8,"意境":8.5,"语言":8.3,"章法":8.2,"余味":8.8,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.35,"rationale":"当代物流经验入诗极精到。颔联工细逼真，颈联拓开空间，尾联忽见乡名而隐忍回身，“碎灯光”以动写静，将劳碌与乡愁化于帚声灯影之中，含蓄深婉，余韵悠长。","_cost":0.006174},"grok-4.7":{"立意":7.5,"意境":8.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":2.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.25,"rationale":"夜扫云仓忽见乡名，情事具体、收束集中，但乡愁触发角度常见，立意未入高境。辊轴封条空箱冷切成境，结句帚响碎光，不说破。颈联近陈述，忽见略直，炼字有眼亦有平句。仓储经验入诗自然。","_cost":0.0346592},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"立意":8.5,"意境":9.0,"语言":8.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":89.75,"rationale":"前六句以云仓夜扫细节铺垫，意象冷寂而具体；尾联乡名触发乡愁，转结有力。结句“帚响碎灯光”视听交融，留白佳。中二联稍平，颈联偏泛。","_cost":0.0083948},"glm-5.3":{"立意":9.0,"意境":8.5,"语言":7.5,"章法":8.0,"余味":9.0,"警句":4.0,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":90.75,"rationale":"夜扫云仓取象精切:辊轴、封条、空箱皆当代物流实景,景语即情语。颈联'分流赴四方'暗伏乡愁,尾联忽见乡名、回身帚响,以声碎光收束,不言愁而愁自深。当代经验入诗有效,结句余味隽永。","_cost":0.01070856},"qwen3.8-max":{"立意":8.1,"意境":8.3,"语言":7.5,"章法":7.9,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.5,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":85.8,"rationale":"当代仓储经验入诗，细节真切，颔联体物工细，尾联由乡名转出情思，以帚声灯影作结，颇有留白。惜现代词与熟语相杂，颈联稍平。","_cost":0.013292},"kimi-k3":{"立意":7.0,"意境":6.5,"语言":6.0,"章法":6.5,"余味":8.0,"警句":2.5,"出新":2.5,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":1.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":70.75,"rationale":"云仓夜班题材较新，辊轴、封条、空箱取象具体；尾联由乡名触情，帚响碎灯留白有力。惜颈联近物流口号，起联“隔街霜”稍隔，通体锤炼未匀。","_cost":0.00843235},"muse-spark-1.2":{"立意":7.3,"意境":7.5,"语言":6.5,"章法":6.8,"余味":7.8,"警句":1.0,"出新":1.8,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":74.2,"rationale":"以夜扫库房琐事起兴，工业细节取象精切，忽见乡名陡转生情立主脑，末句帚响碎光以声景结情余味足。","_cost":0.00748225},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"立意":7.5,"意境":7.0,"语言":6.5,"章法":7.5,"余味":8.5,"警句":3.5,"出新":3.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":79.25,"rationale":"当代物流经验入律，纸屑黏辊、封条挂箱取象精切；尾联忽见乡名，帚响碎灯光，以景结情，余味悠长。中二联稍平，个别现代词略硬。","_cost":0.02950955},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"立意":8.0,"意境":7.5,"语言":7.0,"章法":8.0,"余味":7.5,"警句":3.0,"出新":2.0,"硬伤":0.0,"陈滥":0.0,"蹈袭":0.0,"score":81.25,"rationale":"以当代云仓夜扫劳作为场景，于平实劳作细节中嵌入偶见乡名的乡愁触动，意象贴实，脉络顺畅，结句藏情于景有余味，语言精准无陈套。","_cost":null}},"consensus":81.16,"final":81.16}],"note":"consensus=九月终榜在席评委（去本人、去同门）的均分；final=consensus×声律系数（出律作品×0.75），即诗才分逐首口径。对仗标注只记事实，不计分（九月标准与题面均未要求对仗，见本页勘误）。scores 含季内全部评委的原始打分与理由。"}