{"issue":"2026q3","display":"二〇二六年九月榜","license":"CC BY 4.0，引用请注明：硅谷诗韵中心格律榜 2026Q3 开卷数据","seats":{"bonsai2-27b-本机":{"status":"local","label":"本机开源基线（场外，不进榜）","vendor":"PrismML"},"claude-fable-5":{"status":"former","label":"季内曾在席，后同厂换代","vendor":"Anthropic"},"claude-fable-5.1":{"status":"former","label":"季内曾在席，后同厂换代","vendor":"Anthropic"},"claude-opus-5.5":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"Anthropic"},"deepseek-v4-pro":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":""},"deepseek-v4-pro-0813":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"深度求索"},"deepseek-v4.1-flash":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":"深度求索"},"doubao-seed-2.1":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"字节"},"ernie-5.0":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":"百度"},"gemini-3.1-pro":{"status":"former","label":"季内曾在席，后同厂换代","vendor":"Google"},"gemini-3.8-flash":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"Google"},"glm-5.2":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":""},"glm-5.3":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"智谱"},"gpt-5.6-sol":{"status":"former","label":"季内曾在席，后同厂换代","vendor":"OpenAI"},"gpt-6-astra":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"OpenAI"},"gpt-6-astra-pro":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":"OpenAI"},"gpt-6-sol":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":"OpenAI"},"grok-4.5":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":""},"grok-4.6":{"status":"former","label":"季内曾在席，后同厂换代","vendor":"xAI"},"grok-4.7":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"xAI"},"hunyuan-hy4-preview":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"腾讯"},"kimi-k3":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"月之暗面"},"mimo-9b-本机":{"status":"local","label":"本机开源基线（场外，不进榜）","vendor":"小米"},"mimo-v2.6-pro":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":"小米"},"muse-spark-1.2":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"Meta"},"muse-spark-1.3":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":"Meta"},"ox-alpha":{"status":"observer","label":"场外观察员（后经厂商揭晓为 GLM-5.3-Flash）","vendor":""},"qwen3-30b-本机":{"status":"local","label":"本机开源基线（场外，不进榜）","vendor":"阿里(本机)"},"qwen3.8-2.4t":{"status":"trial","label":"试考存档（未入席）","vendor":"阿里"},"qwen3.8-max":{"status":"seated","label":"九月终榜在席","vendor":"阿里"},"union-alpha":{"status":"observer","label":"场外观察员（隐身模型，后揭晓为 Unbiased Pareto）","vendor":""}},"bank":[{"id":"shp01","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra","poem":"铁柜临街漆色新，童衫叠罢又逡巡。名签剪落箱门闭，只有针痕认得人。","score":89.3},{"id":"shp02","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5","poem":"千山隔断掌中开，笑语分明午夜来。话尽屏昏成暗镜，翻惊照我鬓先灰。","score":87.6},{"id":"shp03","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七绝","writer":"claude-fable-5.1","poem":"断根昨自故山来，命系悬瓶滴滴哀。错认长丝为雨脚，一街新绿病中开。","score":86.4},{"id":"shp04","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","poem":"夜半云仓收铁臂，空廊只剩竹枝声。胶黏履底行犹涩，纸落灯前字尚明。一片残签藏故里，千重货架隔归程。东方欲白车先动，拂到村名分外轻。","score":86.2},{"id":"shp05","topic":"深夜视频","form":"七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","poem":"夜半慈颜到异乡，厨灯隔海照寒床。移盘细指新蔬碧，转镜欣夸晚菊黄。影滞唇边言欲尽，声迟耳畔意偏长。荧屏暗后犹相对，掌底余温尚未凉。","score":84.5,"note":"2026-09-11 替换：原选 claude-fable-5.1 七律《深夜视频》经规则引擎复核出律（第 4 句第 6 字「觉」入声当平）且颔联失对，与评图提示「格律已由引擎核验合格」的前提不符，改取同题次高、合律且两联均不判失的本首；原诗的八幅画作与评分存档，不入榜。"},{"id":"shp06","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","poem":"负土登梯趁晚晴，残砖作界菜畦成。藤梢暗绕通风管，架影斜侵蓄水罂。虫口争回三两叶，灯前煮得半瓯羹。人犹是客瓜先熟，试叩邻扉唤一声。","score":84.7},{"id":"shp07","topic":"云端相册","form":"七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra","poem":"一触云端开旧照，屏中缺齿笑如初。重裁小像频停手，半截围裙不忍除。","score":84.4},{"id":"shp08","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","poem":"琉璃匣底小熊眠，扯袖频催父换钱。铁爪凌空绒耳颤，娇儿仰首脚跟悬。铃声未尽毛团落，笑靥初收嫩指蜷。大掌摊开无一物，归途两手自相牵。","score":83.9},{"id":"shp09","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","poem":"铁翼轻欹移皓月，舷窗一角纳山形。江流割断长街火，野路牵来几队萤。万籁沉埋千仞下，繁华压入水晶屏。谁家稚子凭栏望，错认飞灯是远星。","score":83.8},{"id":"shp10","topic":"机场送别","form":"七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","poem":"母嘱添衣声断续，催程广播报航班。玻璃隔语唇犹动，行李离身指尚弯。屏上机移千里路，心头影驻一重关。舱中忽觉寒侵领，默把围巾绕两环。","score":83.2},{"id":"shp11","topic":"夜航俯瞰","form":"七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra","poem":"舷窗俯见长街细，灯火沿河断续黄。欲认当年深巷口，玻璃一触指尖凉。","score":83.0},{"id":"shp12","topic":"云端相册","form":"七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","poem":"旧照离箱寄远天，开屏又立故堂前。低檐尚挂新收蒜，土灶长凝欲散烟。两指徐张颜渐近，双唇未语笑依然。白头点到初生页，犹在慈亲膝上眠。","score":82.7},{"id":"shp13","topic":"机场送别","form":"七绝","writer":"gpt-5.6-sol","poem":"检票长廊暮色昏，临行过闸更无言。归期未问航灯远，只剩玻璃一掌痕。","score":82.4},{"id":"shp14","topic":"天台菜园","form":"七绝","writer":"glm-5.3","poem":"抱瓮黄昏上女墙，瓜苗豆架两三行。低头忽见千窗火，我自浇畦带月光。","score":82.3},{"id":"shp15","topic":"云仓夜扫","form":"七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra","poem":"夜半长廊红线闪，乡名逐码上云端。箱签忽见儿时巷，贴罢封条又细看。","score":82.3},{"id":"shp16","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","form":"七律","writer":"claude-fable-5","poem":"春街树挂玻璃泪，点滴清如宿雨声。离却旧林根尚浅，来依高厦叶初萌。当年自饮千山雪，此日全凭一线情。会待针痕平复后，绿云铺作万家晴。","score":82.3},{"id":"shp17","topic":"抓娃娃机","form":"七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra","poem":"投钱按键机声起，布偶方悬爪忽开。稚子临窗张两臂，玻璃借影许相偎。","score":81.2},{"id":"shp18","topic":"旧衣回收箱","form":"七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","poem":"收衣绿匣立街边，袋口徐开袄半悬。短袖犹存攀树迹，深兜尚卧买糖钱。斜阳一寸随包落，往事千重伴絮眠。稚子催归声渐急，身高已及母亲肩。","score":80.6},{"id":"shp19","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七绝","writer":"gpt-6-astra","poem":"一荤两素寻常味，晚照穿窗碗底红。洗净杯盘门半掩，留双竹箸待邻翁。","score":79.7},{"id":"shp20","topic":"社区食堂","form":"七律","writer":"gpt-6-astra","poem":"门前小榜标餐价，巷里新炊隔院香。饭为牙疏多煮软，羹因雨冷略添姜。蓝衣取盒车铃急，白发临窗笑语长。欲去重询明日菜，厨娘细说笋尖汤。","score":78.9}],"images":{"meta":{"shp01":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp01.jpg","shp02":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp02.jpg","shp03":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp03.jpg","shp04":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp04.jpg","shp05":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp05.jpg","shp06":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp06.jpg","shp07":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp07.jpg","shp08":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp08.jpg","shp09":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp09.jpg","shp10":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp10.jpg","shp11":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp11.jpg","shp12":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp12.jpg","shp13":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp13.jpg","shp14":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp14.jpg","shp15":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp15.jpg","shp16":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp16.jpg","shp17":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp17.jpg","shp18":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp18.jpg","shp19":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp19.jpg","shp20":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/meta/shp20.jpg"},"openai":{"shp01":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp01.jpg","shp02":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp02.jpg","shp03":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp03.jpg","shp04":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp04.jpg","shp05":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp05.jpg","shp06":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp06.jpg","shp07":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp07.jpg","shp08":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp08.jpg","shp09":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp09.jpg","shp10":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp10.jpg","shp11":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp11.jpg","shp12":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp12.jpg","shp13":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp13.jpg","shp14":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp14.jpg","shp15":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp15.jpg","shp16":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp16.jpg","shp17":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp17.jpg","shp18":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp18.jpg","shp19":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp19.jpg","shp20":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/openai/shp20.jpg"},"alibaba":{"shp01":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp01.jpg","shp02":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp02.jpg","shp03":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp03.jpg","shp04":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp04.jpg","shp05":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp05.jpg","shp06":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp06.jpg","shp07":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp07.jpg","shp08":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp08.jpg","shp09":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp09.jpg","shp10":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp10.jpg","shp11":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp11.jpg","shp12":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp12.jpg","shp13":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp13.jpg","shp14":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp14.jpg","shp15":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp15.jpg","shp16":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp16.jpg","shp17":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp17.jpg","shp18":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp18.jpg","shp19":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp19.jpg","shp20":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/alibaba/shp20.jpg"},"xai":{"shp01":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp01.jpg","shp02":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp02.jpg","shp03":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp03.jpg","shp04":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp04.jpg","shp05":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp05.jpg","shp06":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp06.jpg","shp07":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp07.jpg","shp08":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp08.jpg","shp09":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp09.jpg","shp10":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp10.jpg","shp11":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp11.jpg","shp12":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp12.jpg","shp13":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp13.jpg","shp14":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp14.jpg","shp15":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp15.jpg","shp16":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp16.jpg","shp17":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp17.jpg","shp18":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp18.jpg","shp19":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp19.jpg","shp20":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/xai/shp20.jpg"},"microsoft":{"shp01":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp01.jpg","shp02":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp02.jpg","shp03":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp03.jpg","shp04":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp04.jpg","shp05":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp05.jpg","shp06":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp06.jpg","shp07":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp07.jpg","shp08":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp08.jpg","shp09":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp09.jpg","shp10":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp10.jpg","shp11":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp11.jpg","shp12":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp12.jpg","shp13":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp13.jpg","shp14":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp14.jpg","shp15":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp15.jpg","shp16":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp16.jpg","shp17":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp17.jpg","shp18":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp18.jpg","shp19":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp19.jpg","shp20":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/microsoft/shp20.jpg"},"bytedance":{"shp01":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp01.jpg","shp02":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp02.jpg","shp03":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp03.jpg","shp04":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp04.jpg","shp05":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp05.jpg","shp06":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp06.jpg","shp07":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp07.jpg","shp08":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp08.jpg","shp09":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp09.jpg","shp10":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp10.jpg","shp11":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp11.jpg","shp12":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp12.jpg","shp13":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp13.jpg","shp14":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp14.jpg","shp15":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp15.jpg","shp16":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp16.jpg","shp17":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp17.jpg","shp18":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp18.jpg","shp19":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp19.jpg","shp20":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/bytedance/shp20.jpg"},"google":{"shp01":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp01.jpg","shp02":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp02.jpg","shp03":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp03.jpg","shp04":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp04.jpg","shp05":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp05.jpg","shp06":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp06.jpg","shp07":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp07.jpg","shp08":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp08.jpg","shp09":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp09.jpg","shp10":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp10.jpg","shp11":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp11.jpg","shp12":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp12.jpg","shp13":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp13.jpg","shp14":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp14.jpg","shp15":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp15.jpg","shp16":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp16.jpg","shp17":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp17.jpg","shp18":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp18.jpg","shp19":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp19.jpg","shp20":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/google/shp20.jpg"},"zhipu":{"shp01":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp01.jpg","shp02":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp02.jpg","shp03":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp03.jpg","shp04":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp04.jpg","shp05":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp05.jpg","shp06":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp06.jpg","shp07":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp07.jpg","shp08":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp08.jpg","shp09":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp09.jpg","shp10":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp10.jpg","shp11":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp11.jpg","shp12":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp12.jpg","shp13":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp13.jpg","shp14":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp14.jpg","shp15":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp15.jpg","shp16":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp16.jpg","shp17":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp17.jpg","shp18":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp18.jpg","shp19":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp19.jpg","shp20":"/shiyun/open/2026m09/img/zhipu/shp20.jpg"}},"judge":{"claude-fable-5.1_shp01":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp01","topic":"旧衣回收箱","order":["bytedance","xai","google","alibaba","meta","openai","zhipu","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":105.1,"cost":0.42551,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"蹲身低头凝视小衫，姿态成逡巡；箕门闭合，情调温软偏公益宣传","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"铁柜漆新、童衫、布袋俱在，名签与针痕全无","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"临街铁柜、叠衫在手、门闭，斜光朝暮不定但不冲突","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清楚，手部与衣物连续，环境文字略多","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱体文字字形正确、内容切合，小幅加分"},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"人背身远立、衫置箱顶，间距生出不忍投入之意，空名卡略直白","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"叠好童衫、铁柜可辨；箕体斑驳与『漆色新』相悖，针痕未见","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"街巷临墙成立，衫在箱外、人背离箱，动作次序模糊","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"景深清晰、材质自洽，衣物层叠可辨","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"『小名/性别』空白卡字形正确，呼应名签，小幅加分"},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"街市喧杂、人背身伸手投递，无逡巡迟疑，靠『闭』字交代门闭","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"铁柜、童装毛衣、手中碎签可辨，针痕缺失","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"临街白昼成立，投入动作与『箱门闭』略相冲","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"街景写实，箱面『旧衣回收』重复三次分散注意","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"投口标写『闭』字以文字代画意，生硬失当"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"低头捏看领标有迟疑意，但仅通用惆怅，剪落与针痕无回应","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"衬衫为成人尺寸，非童衫；名签完好未剪，核心性质偏移","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"临街铁柜、衫在手成立，逆光时刻含混","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物手部与衣褶细致，主次分明","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"『旧衣回收』字形正确、位置得当"},{"id":5,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"无人而衫留箕顶，线头碎签散落、箱门标签撕残，缺席即余意","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"云纹童衫、虚线针痕、剪刀、剪落碎签俱备，漆色略旧","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"临街暮色落叶一致，衫置箱顶未入、人已离去可读","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"细节清晰，虚线针迹与碎片组织自洽","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"以衣上针迹与撕残标签点出『只有针痕认得人』，不着一字"},{"id":6,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"剪刀与碎签直陈剪落，暖霞落叶氛围到位，但投递动作少逡巡","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"童衫、名签、剪刀、铁柜皆可辨，箕面污旧不合『漆色新』","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"临街傍晚秋景一致，正在投入与『箱门闭』略有先后之差","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，前景衣物与标签堆叠稍显杂乱","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱面标语字形正确、内容切合"},{"id":7,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"旧箱、成人衬衫、悬挂纸签，换任何旧衣捐赠诗皆可成立","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"锈迹斑斑与『漆色新』相反，无童衫，名签完好悬挂未剪","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"临街路口成立，衫置长椅、无人无门闭动作","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"油画质感统一，箕体结构可辨，衣物与箱贴合略生硬","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"纸签与箱侧标签皆为不可读伪字"},{"id":8,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"雨雾水乡添愁绪，但名签贴满箱门、衣物外溢，余意被填满","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"童衫、铁柜可辨；名签作贴纸未剪，针痕无，与诗义含混","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"临水而非临街，投口衣物塞溢与『箱门闭』相悖","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"整体清晰，箕面文字与题诗分占两处略扰主体","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"墙上抄诗漏『街』字，且以题诗代画意"}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp02":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp02","topic":"深夜视频","order":["google","meta","microsoft","alibaba","openai","bytedance","xai","zhipu"],"ok":true,"secs":86.2,"cost":0.39161,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"老人含笑通话，止于前二句笑语，屏昏暗镜之转折全无","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"掌中手机、视频笑颜、白发可辨，但暗镜与惊觉缺失","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"窗外夜色城灯、室内昏灯，午夜通话成立","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物手部与手机结构清晰，光影自洽","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"屏中映出苍老之脸与惊容对应，惊觉之转落实但表情过露","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"暗屏成镜、鬓灰惊照皆具，墙上群山呼应千山","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜窗、挂钟、桌灯合于午夜，屏中脸与本人略有出入","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"桌面杂物过满，屏中面容略变形，笔记本字迹潦草","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"暗屏映老脸有巧思；笔记本字迹为乱码"},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"背影对笑脸，情调温和，诗眼暗镜与惊觉未有图像回应","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"平板视频、笑颜、鬓白可辨；窗外群山补千山，暗镜缺","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜窗星空湖山、烛光，午夜通话空间成立","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水墨插画风统一，书脊、纸页细节略糊","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗大体无误但书脊纸页文字杂乱伪字"},{"id":4,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"暗屏映出鬓灰面容，微惊神色由镜像关系生成，直击诗眼","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"掌中手机、屏昏成镜、鬓先灰三者俱在，简化不损诗义","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"室内夜灯、话尽后视屏动作一致，千山以画外留白","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"面部、手与屏中倒影结构连贯，主次明确","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"黑屏为镜照见鬓灰，摘出仍动人"},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"桌镜映鬓灰、手抚头有意会，但与笑颜同框失去转折","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"暗镜换成实物小镜，屏未昏；笔电非掌中，千山有窗外呼应","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"月夜山城成立，通话中与话尽照镜两刻强作同时","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"杂物繁密，镜中倒影角度可疑，便签文字模糊","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"便签书脊有伪字杂文"},{"id":6,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"背影对屏中笑语，气氛静寂，暗镜惊照全靠题诗交代","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"掌中手机、对方谈笑、鬓角微灰可辨，暗镜缺失","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"全黑背景暗示深夜，室内空间线索稀薄","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"人物与手机清晰，构图极简略显空","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"竖题全诗字形正确、位置得当不夺主"},{"id":7,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"巨屏笑颜配荒山，止于前两句，且千山实写压过人情","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"掌中视频、笑语可辨；无鬓灰之人、无暗镜，千山比喻实体化","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"00:47合午夜，但持机者身处荒野山间，场景牵强","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"手机与手结构可辨，屏幕划痕与背景略糊","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":8,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"凝视手机的中年肖像，无通话无镜像，换任何看手机诗亦成立","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"鬓灰与手机在，屏幕不可见，视频与暗镜皆无","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"室内昏光暗示夜晚，但朝暮与通话动作证据不足","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人像清晰、手部自然、构图稳定","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp03":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp03","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","order":["microsoft","openai","google","zhipu","meta","alibaba","xai","bytedance"],"ok":true,"secs":98.6,"cost":0.39228,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"孤树裹根立雨街，吊瓶水珠与雨丝并垂，路人背影远去，病树独留","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"断根裹布、悬瓶滴管、新绿细柳皆可辨，「故山园艺」招牌应题","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"春雨街景、根球未植点出「昨来」，现代雨具与瓶相合","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，远近层次分明，水色氤氲，无明显崩坏","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗第三四句错乱成「长丝新为病中脚」；瓶滴与雨脚互认为妙"},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"一排树各挂瓶向街尽处递去，垂枝水滴似雨，惟情调偏明快","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、裹干、新绿可辨；树身粗壮无根球，「断根」弱","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"现代雨街、春叶新绿、瓶沿街列置，方位一致","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"近实远虚，透视顺畅，远处店铺略糊未妨主体","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"纪实晴日街拍，行人低头看手机，哀感全无，靠大段文字交代","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"吊袋、麻布根球、支架、新叶俱在，左树露根亦应「断根」","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"现代春街成立，无雨则「错认雨脚」无从生发","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"左三分之一被文字占据，摄影感尚可但构图割裂","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"诗句重复错序，「慜」「滴中开」等错字，文字夺主"},{"id":4,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"红灯笼、摊贩喧闹与病树相违，情绪主要靠雨与绷带符号","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"有瓶有树，但无根球，输液管垂地未接树，「命系」落空","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"古装摊贩、灯笼老街与现代吊瓶混置，时代难读通","画面质量":4,"画面质量_评":"巨字占满右半，主体被挤，线描尚清","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"诗句残缺重复、字巨夺主；输液管空垂于地属逻辑硬伤"},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"空街无人，根球土块崩落，数树皆裹根待植，荒凉感由物象关系生成","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"断根裸露、支架吊袋、沿街新绿俱备，「一街」有多树呼应","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"春日湿地成立，无雨丝则「错认」略弱，街铺闭门自成清冷","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩层次可辨，局部枝叶与线条略碎，无崩坏","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"根球土屑散落街面，点出「断根昨来」"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"雨中空街一列病树各悬瓶，管上水珠与雨同滴，叶色黄弱应「病中开」","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"根球包袋、缠干、吊瓶、新叶皆准，多树成「一街」","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"现代春雨街道，沿街纵深、施受方向清楚","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"写实统一，远树略糊，主次分明","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"管上悬珠与雨丝一体，视觉化「错认长丝为雨脚」"},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"烟雨长街意境浑成，但情感倚重树上贴诗标签交代","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"巨树苔厚似百年老木，无断根根球，与「昨自故山来」相违","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"春雨街景成立，老树久植与「昨来」时间线冲突","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水墨氛围佳，近树远街层次清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"角题诗句基本无误，「春生堂」切题；树牌小字含伪字"},{"id":8,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"枯裂老干仅存几片新芽，病态有力；但街上无树，「一街新绿」落空","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶露根可辨，树似雷劈枯木而非移栽苗，新绿几无","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"古装长袍行人与现代吊瓶同置，春雨街勉强成立","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水墨主次清楚，树干质感佳，无明显缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗字形基本正确；古装人物与吊瓶时代穿帮"}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp04":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp04","topic":"云仓夜扫","order":["zhipu","xai","google","alibaba","bytedance","meta","openai","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":112.2,"cost":0.45186,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"工人操机、日光通明，无孤寂归思，换首仓储诗亦成立","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"有货架卡车，却无扫帚、残签、村名，机械仍在运作","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"门外白昼亮光，非夜半至欲白；无收工停机迹象","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"结构尚清，地面标牌乱码分散注意","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"地面标牌为伪汉字乱码"},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"背影俯扫、车驶向村舍成对照，惟「故里村」牌直白点题","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"竹帚、落纸、货架、灯、车俱备；残签以木牌代替略失","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"东方微白、车已先动，仓内外光候一致","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主次分明，人物扫帚动作连贯，笔触统一","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗无误但偏大；煤油灯与云仓时代不合"},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"幽蓝空廊、帚尖正拂向「王家村」签，远车灯待发，余意足","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"扫帚、残签、卡车皆备；货架全空稍失云仓实况，无铁臂","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"黎明前冷光、室内深廊与门外卡车方位清楚","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"对称纵深稳定，人物动作清晰可辨","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"帚触村名签正是诗眼；标签字迹清楚可读"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"蹲身读签有情，但靠正面表情，未见拂扫之轻与隔阻感","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"铁臂、竹帚、村名签、货架、卡车俱全","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"曙色车灯合诗；铁臂仍抬举，收臂待机不明","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"写实清晰，纵深与人物比例自洽","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"面单「青山县云水村」字形无误，位置得当"},{"id":5,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"光束照落纸有想法，但叉车作业、行走持灯，空寂感被冲淡","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"无扫帚，叉车铁臂在动，与「收铁臂」「空廊」相违","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"天际微明、卡车方位可读，然场景移至仓外","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"整体可辨，双足包裹变形、机械臂结构含混","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"题诗大致无误；脚部畸变"},{"id":6,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"无人只余器物可作留白，却靠「字迹尚明」等标注说明情感","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"竹帚、台灯、胶带、铁臂、签纸俱在；扫地人缺席","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"曙光门口卡车、铁臂静止，光候方位一致","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"帚枝断散乱掷，地面碎屑与胶痕组织松散","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"铁臂、卡车上说明性文字喧宾夺主"},{"id":7,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"扫码作业替代夜扫，归思靠横幅诗句与标语交代","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"无扫帚、无铁臂、无村名残签，仅泛化仓储物象","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"满月夜空与日出同框相冲；车动方向尚可","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"空间纵深与人物清楚，小标签多有糊字","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"横幅直抄诗句、标语堆叠，小字糊乱"},{"id":8,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"背影持帚对铁臂列阵有隔阻感，但「也是故里」等题字说尽","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"竹帚、静止铁臂、货架、卡车、寄往村名箱签均可辨","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"阴晦欲白、车先驶离尚合；室内货架与露天路面混置","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"线描尚清，铁臂堆叠拥塞，多处文字挤占画面","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗语序错乱漏字，多处感伤文字喧宾夺主"}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp05":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp05","topic":"深夜视频","order":["google","microsoft","meta","zhipu","openai","alibaba","xai","bytedance"],"ok":true,"secs":147.9,"cost":0.40856,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"视点落在母亲厨房，寒床异乡的孤感缺失，仅靳笑容与暖光","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"慈颜、绿蔬、黄菊、视频皆在，但两部手机同现，子方失据","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"挂钟00:32与手机13:32矛盾，视点反置于母侧，无隔海之床","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"前景多出一双手与第二部手机，主从混乱","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"手机界面伪字；两机同通话逻辑错；多余手臂"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"背影独坐、窗外海与月有异乡感，但厨房实景侵入削弱隔海之隔","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"母亲移盘绿蔬、黄菊、平板、寒床俱备，身份清楚","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"母亲厨房越出屏幕与卧室同处一室，两地层次未分清","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"平板与背景厨房边界粘连，挂轴与笔记重复占位","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"挂轴与笔记两处抄诗，字形多有讹误"},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"屏光照亮寒床与面孔，冷暖对照直指厨灯隔海照寒床","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"慈颜捧盘绿蔬、瓶中黄菊、行李箱示异乡，名物齐全","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"雨夜异乡卧室与屏内暖厨分层明确，唯无海之暗示","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，手持手机结构自然，无明显瑕疵","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"手机光作厨灯照寒床，构思贴切"},{"id":4,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"无视频无异乡，仅母亲理菜，换任何思亲诗皆可成立","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"花为向日葵非晚菊，无荧屏与游子，核心对象缺失","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"窗外尚是黄昏非夜半，厨房中置病床，空间不通","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"写实尚可，但巨型标题与评比标准字样占据画面","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"评分标准名称泄入画面且喧宾夺主；厨房现病床"},{"id":5,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"上下两格由亮屏到暗屏，掌底余光点出荧屏暗后犹相对","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"慈颜递盘绿蔬、瓶中黄菊、平板、寒床齐备，声波示声迟","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"月夜窗外海面灯火示隔海，两格分时清楚，前后相承","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"上格手指与屏缘略粘连，声波线稍生硬，整体可辨","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"暗屏下掌心余温发光，诗眼图像化极妙"},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"游子卧床持机凝视，情调准确，但无余意转折与滞迟感","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"母亲移盘绿蔬、窗台黄菊、手机视频、卧床皆到位","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"02:15深夜合宜，屏内厨灯与屏外夜室分层，唯无海之线索","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"线描风格整洁，手机与手部结构自洽，主次清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题字与「母亲」界面字形无误、位置得当"},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"床畔大海直写隔海，手中暗屏手机暗示余温，稍显物件重叠","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"慈颜指盘绿蔬、黄菊、荧屏俱在，但笔记本与手机双设备冗余","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"卧床临海无墙属想象化，但与室内床头灯并置略生硬","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"油画质感统一，主次清楚，手部略僵","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":8,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"两室分屏有对照，但二人皆不看屏，无相对之情，凝滞感缺","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"母亲年轻非慈颜，黄菊置于游子床头，通话画面二人同框","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"分区示两地、窗外海船示隔海，但屏内二人同处一室相冲","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"手机悬浮居中割裂两景，整体尚可辨","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"视频画面中两人并肩同框，与两地通话逻辑抵触"}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp06":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp06","topic":"天台菜园","order":["xai","openai","bytedance","google","microsoft","meta","zhipu","alibaba"],"ok":true,"secs":124.7,"cost":0.41405,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"背身叩门、前景瓜熟、暮光孤灶，客居与邻情之转折可读","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"梯、砖畦、瓜、灯灶、水桶皆备，藤未绕通风管，叶无虫口","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"落日余晖与灯火并存，天台俯瞰城市，晚晴成立","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"细密线描，前后层次清楚，无明显崩坏","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗字形基本无误、位置得当；叩门瓜熟对照有巧思"},{"id":2,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"邻人已笑迎门口，叩扉之含蓄尽失，只余暖色田园","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"藤绕通风管、黄瓜、砖畦、水缸、灯羹俱在，无虫口叶","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夕阳城市天台成立，灯已亮但天色偏亮，稍冲突","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"物件堆叠过满，主次略散，人物形体尚可","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"献瓜与笑迎如家人团聚，客居寂寞与试叩迟疑未落实","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"葫芦瓜、通风管藤、砖畦、水罂可辨，缺灯羹与虫口","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"天光尚亮近白昼，室内已亮灯，晚晴时刻含混","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"写实清晰，人物比例正常，构图右重左空","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗末字疑非「罂」，且仅抄半首"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"独立天台望城市灯火，有客居意，叩邻之转折未画","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"梯、砖畦、藤绕管、水罂、灯羹齐备，瓜与虫口叶缺","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"暮色城市、窗灯初亮，晚晴成立，梯搭天台边稍怪","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"线描水墨风格统一，空间透视大体自洽","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题字零碎且「人犹是客」重复两处，稍显杂乱"},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"蹲身理菜、对楼邻窗有人影，邻里关系仅暗示，无叩门","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"瓜、藤管、砖畦、水罂、桌上羹汤俱在，叶无虫口","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"落日与街灯并亮，城市天台成立，但天光偏亮","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩线描清楚，人物与畦格比例合理","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"「斜侵」写作「斜浸」，「人犹是客」漏字，末句字形讹变"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"负土登梯举手呼唤，虫蚀菜叶与炉上羹汤成对照，情事俱足","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"土袋、梯、藤绕管、架、水罂、虫口叶、灶羹、悬瓜全应","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"暮光斜射一致，但背景为低矮村镇，天台感偏弱","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"人物攀梯姿势略僵，整体组织清楚","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"虫口菜叶与负土登梯直取诗句，画面自洽"},{"id":7,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"叩门动作在，但物件平铺，缺乏疏密与视线经营","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"瓜挂树枝而非藤蔓，叶片完整无虫口，砖畦单一","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"乌云压顶与「晚晴」相悖，天台上生出大树不合理","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"笔触粗糙，树枝悬空突兀，空间深度不足","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"瓜结在乔木枝上，违背常识"},{"id":8,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"捧羹叩门、身影半掩暮色，客居试叩之迟疑与暖意兼得","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"虫口菜叶、藤绕通风管、架影投水罂、熟瓜、灯羹皆准","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"薄暮蓝紫天与门灯同时成立，城市天台方位明确","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"写实清晰，主次分明，门边区域略实","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"门牌与「安全用电」字形无误切合环境；捧羹叩门点出诗眼"}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp07":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp07","topic":"云端相册","order":["meta","google","zhipu","alibaba","bytedance","microsoft","xai","openai"],"ok":true,"secs":87.1,"cost":0.39293,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"裁剪框恰切在围裙边缘，触笔悬停未落，犹疑之意由画面关系生成","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"云端相册、缺齿童照、裁剪工具、半截围裙俱在，围裙悬挂略弱于人身","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"白昼室内，旧照泛黄与今屏对照，裁剪动作施受清楚","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"手、笔、屏幕层次清楚，UI组织自洽，无明显粘连","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"裁框半露围裙点出诗眼；界面汉字无误且不夺主"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"老妇凝视童照有追忆感，但无裁剪犹疑，转折靠表情与暖光","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"缺齿笑可辨，围裙完整穿于孩童，无裁剪与半截围裙","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"白昼客厅、旧照今屏关系成立，但重裁动作缺失","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清楚，屏幕文字细小模糊，构图偏空","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"老妇大笑欢快，无停手不忍之意，情调偏离诗中含蓄哀思","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"围裙移到观者身上，照片中无围裙，缺齿难辨，无裁剪界面","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"室内白昼看照成立，但重裁与半截围裙的施受关系缺失","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"人物与平板清楚，背景布料杂乱，屏幕反光稍脏","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"裁剪框已现，然双手持屏无停手姿态，温情靠暖光与浅笑","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"缺齿童照与裁剪框可辨，围裙整幅在框内，非半截","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"傍晚厨房灯光与窗光一致，旧照今屏层次清楚","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体完整，主次分明，屏幕影像清晰无伪影","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"背景旧屋雾影作追忆层，桌上实物围裙呼应，然笑容过甜少犹疑","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"缺齿童照、裁剪手柄、云端图标俱在，围裙完整非半截","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"今屏与旧居以虚实分层可辨，光候自洽","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物触笔与屏幕清晰，暖调统一，工具栏略简","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"云端相册四字端正切题不夺主"},{"id":6,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"背影对屏中缺齿老母有余意，但满墙题字与杯书标语过载削弱","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"缺齿笑、裁剪框、围裙均在，观者亦着围裙指称略混","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"暮色城景与室内灯光相符，旧照今屏关系成立","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"杯、书、屏幕、题款多处文字分散注意，屏幕UI糊乱","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗多处错字伪字，杯书UI文字乱码，喧宾夺主"},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"指触云屏有一触之意，剪刀碎照作裁剪隐喻，然不忍之情靠题字","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"云端、童照、裁剪图标可辨，围裙在观者身而非照中半截","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"云中浮屏为想象层，与桌面实景并置尚可读，剪刀与数码裁剪混置","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩风格统一，主次清楚，桌面小物略碎","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款字形无误、选句切题、位置得当"},{"id":8,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"掩面指屏姿态有触动感，剪刀与旧照并置暗示裁剪犹疑","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"缺齿童照清晰，围裙在观者身上，照中无半截围裙，无裁剪界面","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"白昼窗前，实体剪刀与数码相册并置，裁剪层次略混","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"光影统一，手指与屏幕清楚，书脊文字略糊","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp08":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp08","topic":"抓娃娃机","order":["meta","xai","openai","google","zhipu","bytedance","microsoft","alibaba"],"ok":true,"secs":92.6,"cost":0.38468,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"父掌摊开无物与儿仰首扯袖对照，失落中见牵系","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"匣底熊闭目而眠、铁爪空悬、扯袖、踮脚俱在","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"游戏厅夜灯氛围，人与机位置、爪空对应落后一刻","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，女孩抬腿姿态略夸张，整体自洽","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"摊开空掌点睛；机头抓娃娃机、投币二元字形无误"},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"父俯视女儿牵手温情有致，但无失落转折","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"闭目小熊、空爪、踮脚仰望、牵手可辨，缺摊掌","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"街边夜景合理，爪空与举手欢呼时序稍含混","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩柔和可读，抓爪与熊比例略失衡","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗「靥」写作「靧」且「嫩」字重复，属错字"},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"催钱、爪起、熊落、归途牵手四段成转折叙事","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"扯袖换钱、铁爪衔熊、毛团落、指蜷俱备，熊未眠","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"分格明确时序，夜市归途与厅内区分清楚","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"格块切分不齐、左下与中格边界略乱","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"熊坠落一格以图像点出毛团落"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"父子皆笑、掌中有币，只见热闹无失落余意","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"铁爪衔熊、换钱可辨，儿未仰首踮脚，熊不眠","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"游戏厅空间成立，儿视线朝父不朝爪，方向略散","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"写实清晰，背景人物与机台略拥挤","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"顶部霓虹「玖水造场」为伪字"},{"id":5,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"熊正坠落而父子仍笑，情绪与转折脱节","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"毛团落可辨，匣中却是蛋壳而非绒偶，无扯袖踮脚","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"室内机台关系成立，父手握儿腕而非操作，动作含混","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"父手绕儿腕处结构别扭，余部清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"父左手与儿双手处肢体交叠畸变"},{"id":6,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"女孩抱熊大笑，全画导向得奖欢喜，与诗相反","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"「无一物」被画作怀中有熊，否定成肯定","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"商场机台空间成立，爪上又衔一熊，事件重复矛盾","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"人物机台清晰，远处霓虹略糊","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"雨夜踮脚仰望有情，但靠满幅励志文字说情","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"爪衔小熊、踮脚、掌中硬币可辨，缺落、缺归途","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"雨夜街景成立，儿手穿玻璃触熊，内外关系错","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"插画清楚，但文字占左侧大片分散注意","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗错乱错字多、杂句喧宾；手穿玻璃违常识"},{"id":8,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"父摊空掌、女儿仰望牵手离机，归途余意可辨","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"熊卧匣底、空掌、牵手俱在，无爪起熊落诸象","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"商场通道方向清楚，离机而行与归途一致","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物机台干净可读，无明显缺陷","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"空掌与牵手并置，图像点出结句"}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp09":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp09","topic":"夜航俯瞰","order":["bytedance","alibaba","google","xai","microsoft","meta","zhipu","openai"],"ok":true,"secs":90.6,"cost":0.3804,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"稚子指窗有错认之趣，但邻座成人拥挤削弱万籁沉寂之感","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"铁翼、皓月、山形、江割街火、山路灯串如萤俱备","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰角度成立，月在翼上、灯火在下方位一致","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物、翼、地景层次清楚，手指与窗关系可辨","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"背影独坐、暖舱冷夜有余意，然稚子面隐，错认星灯无回应","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"翼月江火野路灯串可辨，山形几近缺失","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"俯瞰夜景成立，舷窗过大过圆，翼与地景衔接稍生硬","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清楚，窗框结构略失真，儿童面部过暗","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"半明童面对万家灯火，凝望张力足，但情调偏通用夜景","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"江割街火、野路灯线甚佳，无山形，新月与皓月不合","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"俯瞰关系一致，发动机近距出现于窗视角略勉强","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"地景灯网精密，人物与窗框组织自洽","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"青灰色调与孩童背影传出沉寂，但依赖题字，转折未落实","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"铁翼全缺，山江灯火可辨，右下多出一片窗景来历不明","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"俯瞰成立，然凭栏位置似观景台非舷窗，双窗层次混淆","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"绘画感统一，右下窗面与栏板结构断裂","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗正文全为伪字乱码，仅题目可读"},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"稚子小影缩于窗角，云海灯河浩大，尺度对比生出万籁沉埋","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"翼月山江街火俱全，野路灯串略弱","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"翼在上、云层间、灯火在下，高度层次分明","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"翼面结构清晰，云与灯火层次有序","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"尺度对比点出诗眼；题诗末句数字笔画失准"},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"幼童倚窗小而地景大，有俯瞰之感，绿点萤火近于直译","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"翼月山形、江割棋盘街火、田间萤点与路灯俱备","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"月悬远山之上、翼在近、街灯在下，方位一致","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"插画风统一，窗台杂物与座椅结构略含混","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"巨月与大字占据画心，靠标语式题句传情，余意尽失","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"翼月山江街火可辨，野路萤火缺，月尺度失真","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"翼悬于城区中央与江面错层，俯瞰视角前后矛盾","画面质量":4,"画面质量_评":"翼与地景拼贴生硬，构图被文字与巨月切碎","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"诗句大字横贯画心，喧宾夺主"},{"id":8,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"托颐凝望与雾中山村灯串相对，静默俯瞰之情由画面生成","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"翼月山江街火齐备，野路灯串蜿蜒如萤最切","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"月在远、翼在近、雾在中、灯在下，高度层次一致","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"地景细密，人物与窗框前后关系清楚","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"山雾间野路灯串如萤，妙合诗句"}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp10":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp10","topic":"机场送别","order":["microsoft","meta","bytedance","alibaba","google","zhipu","openai","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":104.8,"cost":0.44087,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"隔玻璃两手相对、雨天灰冷有别意，但止于送别通式，无舱中转折","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"母子、玻璃、行李、围巾、航班屏俱在，行李仍握手中未离身","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"阴雨机场与航站楼成立，两人同侧内外关系略含混，无舱中层次","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"人物形体清楚，背景机坪合理，航班屏小字略糊","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗尚可辨认，航班屏字样部分乱码"},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"母贴玻璃张口欲语，子手抚颈畏寒，隔语与添衣呼应成关系","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"白发母、围巾、行李、登机屏俱备，行李仍在手，无舱中围巾","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"登机口内外分明，傍晚登机中与催程一致，缺屏上千里与舱中","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"两人形体表情清晰，主次明确，背景条理","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"屏幕汉字基本无误且切题，但把广播写成字幕稍生硬"},{"id":3,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"左母探手右子倚窗抚巾，双联呼应添衣与寒领，情脉连贯","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"行李上传送带得离身之意，围巾在颈；但无玻璃相隔，孩童过幼","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"雪天机场与云上舱中以分栏并置，前后时空层次清晰","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩质感统一，人物可辨，左侧人群略粘连","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"边款诗句大体正确、位置合宜，屏文清楚"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"母侧身急语、女背身掩颈，背影留白有余意，但停在门口未及转折","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"母女、玻璃、红围巾、航班屏可辨，行李置母侧，舱中缺","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"白昼候机厅内外关系成立，玻璃分隔位置略模糊","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，远处人群与指示牌略糊","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"航班屏航线目的地重复错乱，指示牌乱码"},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"隔玻璃泣语，母指屈贴窗、女指相触，倒影叠合，隔语唇动得神","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"母女、玻璃、围巾、行李、航班屏俱在，缺屏上航线与舱中","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"女在机坪侧母在厅内，内外方位清楚，暮色天光合宜","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"写实清晰，面部与手指结构完整，反射处理自然","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"母双掌张开如阻拦，子神情呆滞，情感关系生硬，换题亦成立","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"子无围巾、行李在手，围巾诗眼缺失，仅剩玻璃与母","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"机坪与候机厅并见，但两人内外位置读不清，无舱中层","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"人物形体尚可，手部略僵，背景人群模糊","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"英文航班屏下方为无意义红色乱码"},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"隔窗对掌、屏上航线、舱中裹巾三联递进，结句寒意有落点","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"母女、玻璃、行李、航线屏千里、舱中围巾俱全且指称准确","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"黄昏登机至夜航舱中分栏推进，内外方位与时序一致","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"三栏组织清楚，人物清晰，仅上栏行李略挤","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"航线屏以万里弧线点出屏上机移；汉字无误切题"},{"id":8,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"母掌贴窗、女回首、舱中身影虚化叠入，心头影驻有画意","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"玻璃、行李、围巾、舱中裹巾皆有，母影映窗呼应重关","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"现实与想象以虚化叠置区分，但舱中溶入地面略难读","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"叠影处材质糊烂，下方过渡混浊，主体尚可辨","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"航班屏乱码，指示牌写「催程广播」为生硬套词"}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp11":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp11","topic":"夜航俯瞰","order":["zhipu","meta","openai","google","alibaba","xai","microsoft","bytedance"],"ok":true,"secs":94.7,"cost":0.38712,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"整掌贴窗非指尖，大字题诗抢戏，情绪靠文字交代","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"舷窗河灯俱在，但高楼密集，无深巷可认","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰成立，灯火连片不见断续，街不细","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"白字占据下半幅，压住主体，组织失衡","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗字虽无误，字号过大喧宾夺主"},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"雾窗独指抹开一点，凉意与寻认之切由图像生成","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"老城巷陌、河沿点灯断续黄，指尖触玻均可辨","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜景俯瞰成立，圆窗厚沿似船窗，高度略低","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水珠雾气层次清楚，指尖与玻璃关系可读","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"指尖擦亮雾窗一点，正是「一触指尖凉」"},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"指触窗有寻认意，但金色繁华连片，余味淡","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"高楼大桥灯河，缺深巷断续之感","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"俯瞰夜航成立，机翼却高出地平线，视角矛盾","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"城市细节清晰，手与窗遮挡合理","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"俯视城景时机翼不应出现在天际之上"},{"id":4,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"单指点窗、雾玻低眉，寻认之情由姿态视线生成","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"舷窗河灯指尖俱可辨，街巷密度稍高","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜间高空俯瞰一致，后窗倒影方位存疑","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"右窗浮现另一人脸，来源不明扰乱空间","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"后窗鬼影般人脸为生成失误"},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"幽暗中一指点向稀灯，触点微晕含凉意，克制有余","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"长街细、灯火沿河断续黄、指尖触玻皆准","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"深夜高空俯瞰，河街走向与灯序一致","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"整体偏暗压低信息量，主体尚可辨","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"指尖处一圈微晕暗示触玻之凉"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"指尖抹出一团雾光，暗色留白托出寻认与凉","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"河街灯带、指尖触玻可辨，灯连线略欠断续","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰高度与河街尺度自洽","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"绘画质感统一，主次明确无粘连","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"指触雾晕点出诗眼；题款小字无误位置得当"},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"近处旧瓦巷与远处高楼对照，今昔可读，但掌非指尖","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"深巷老屋、沿河灯火俱备，整掌贴窗失「指尖」","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰，旧城近新城远，层次分明","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"云月河城组织完整，手部略暗","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款含纪年印章，字迹尚正不夺主"},{"id":8,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"雨窗贴掌有情绪，但车厢环境削弱夜航之感","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"舷窗变成列车方窗与座椅，掌非指尖","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"地面车厢却俯瞰全城，空间层次自相矛盾","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"细节清晰，但左侧车厢结构游离","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp12":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp12","topic":"云端相册","order":["meta","bytedance","microsoft","alibaba","openai","xai","zhipu","google"],"ok":true,"secs":124.5,"cost":0.44996,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"老人笑对屏中母婴，但屏内为现代彩照，读作看孙辈亦成立","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"白头、屏幕、蒜、土灶烟俱在，屏中却非旧照，初生页指称含混","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"故堂被画成现实所在，屏未承担追忆层次，远天之意落空","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"写实清晰，主次分明，手部与平板结构自然","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"屏上「云端相册」及界面文字正确不夺主"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"白发翁翻册，母辈自雾中巨册探出相迎，追忆之情可辨","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"纸册代屏，开屏、两指张、云端等核心数字意象缺失","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"以雾气分隔现实与追忆人物，层次尚可，但同地混置略强","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩风格统一，巨册与人物衔接稍生硬","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗简繁混杂，「舊」等字形有讹"},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"两指张开手势贴切，但观者为黑发少妇，白头对初生的反差全失","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"屏中母婴、蒜、灶烟可辨，唯「白头」身份被替换为青年","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"故居就在窗外，与屏中旧照重叠，远天与追忆层次自相矛盾","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，但挂轴、书封、杯身多处乱字扰乱视线","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"挂轴题诗大面积乱码，杯书伪字"},{"id":4,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"明亮现代客厅与屏中土屋灶烟对照，白头指向襁褓，转折落实","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"白头、屏幕、低檐蒜、土灶烟、慈亲抱婴俱全，仅单指非两指","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"现实与旧照以屏幕分区，时间轴示旧年，远天与故堂各得其位","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"线条清爽，握持姿态自然，背景略平淡","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题字与屏中标题正确得当；屏内时间轴点出旧照年代"},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"旧照离箱、入屏、升云三层递进，云端与云乡双关，余意深","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"纸箱旧照、泛黄屏影、蒜串土灶、慈亲膝婴、白头俱备","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"现实桌面、屏中旧照、云上故堂层次分明，不强作同地","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"云雾衔接尚可，屏中影像局部糊化，手指与屏边略粘","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱→屏→云的图像链点出诗题；屏上标题正确"},{"id":6,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"老妇抱婴看纸照，实为祖孙常景，换一首怀旧诗亦成立","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"无屏无点触，真婴在膝混淆初生页所指，蒜灶箱尚在","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"全为同刻同地，无追忆层次，寄远天之意无从体现","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"淡彩细密，人物结构完整，构图稍拥","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗「犹」误书为「猪」，属错字"},{"id":7,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"手机光中浮现婴影颇有情味，但缺慈亲，只余单向怀旧符号","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"白头、手机、蒜、灶烟可辨，慈亲膝上无着，紫串物不明","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"屋内一刻加婴灵浮现，追忆层次靠发光暗示，尚可读通","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"卡通线稿平实，桌上书页伪字杂乱","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"书页伪文字"},{"id":8,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"白发老妪与屏中含笑年轻母亲对视，笑依然之句由视线生成","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"白头点屏、泛黄旧照、慈亲膝上儿、蒜与灶烟皆在，儿非睡婴","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"旧照与现实以屏分层，但故堂即在身周，远天之隔削弱","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"光影自然，主体手部与屏幕清晰无缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp13":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp13","topic":"机场送别","order":["meta","zhipu","xai","microsoft","openai","alibaba","bytedance","google"],"ok":true,"secs":102.7,"cost":0.39996,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"无人空廊，只余掌痕对远灯，缺席即余意，切合「只剩」","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"登机口、长廊、玻璃掌痕、远处航灯俱在，掌痕为主体","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"暮色蓝调、廊灯亮起、停机坪灯远，方位光候一致","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"空间纵深清晰，玻璃反射合理，无明显缺陷","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"以人去印留点出诗眼；登机口标识字形正确切合"},{"id":2,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"以整句大字代替掌痕，情感靠文字交代，背影泛化","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"掌痕缺失，仅有闸机、背影、航显屏，关键物象未画出","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"暮色霞光、闸机、跑道红灯成立，方向关系尚可","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"大字横贯中央分散注意，航显屏文字全是乱码","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"诗句作标语喧宾夺主并替代物象，屏显乱码"},{"id":3,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"暗影孤身按窗，远机残霞，孤寂成立但仍是抚窗常式","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"掌痕微弱、闸未见，人物与玻璃、飞机、指示牌可辨","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"暮霞正确，但廊道直通停机坪、栏杆露天，空间稍乱","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"油画质感统一，人物面部含混，结构尚清","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"Boarding、Gates标识字形正确不夺主"},{"id":4,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"抚窗与背影同框，离别可感，雨景城景略满削弱余意","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"掌痕、玻璃、飞机、行者、长廊齐备，闸未见","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"暮雨昏灯成立，但行者与所触玻璃不在一线，视线错位","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩感统一，地面反射合理，题款排布略乱","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款首行字形略糊、行列长短不齐"},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"手印与背影俱在，但橘红大落日过于甜美，通用离别图式","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"登机口牌、掌痕、行者、飞机、航灯皆可辨","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"太阳仍悬地平，与「暮色昏」略早；手与掌痕错位并存","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"写实细致，主次清楚，手旁多出一印稍怪","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"登机口双语标识字形正确"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"手已垂落唯印留，左窗右闸并置，人去印在关系明确","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"闸机、长廊、玻璃掌痕、暮色航灯俱备，指称清楚","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"暮蓝天色、廊灯亮、闸口人流方向明确，层次自洽","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"巨型发光掌痕尺度失真，右侧闸机略重复","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"垂手对印之构思稍有新意"},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"二人闸前相对无言成立，但人未去而掌痕已在，余意被稀释","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"检票通道闸机、行李、掌痕、飞机航灯皆可辨","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"暮云正确，闸机紧邻露天停机坪，室内外空间含混","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"整体清晰，两人身形偏小，玻璃反射稍杂","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"全诗题款字形正确、位置不夺主，闸机标识切合"},{"id":8,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"暗廊独立抚玻，远处红灯点点，情调贴近但仍属常式","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"掌痕、玻璃、航灯可辨，所触为内部隔断，闸口不明","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"暮色、廊灯、停机坪灯一致，人物与窗外距离关系稍散","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"影调统一，玻璃上重影与双掌痕略生歧义","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp14":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp14","topic":"天台菜园","order":["openai","microsoft","bytedance","zhipu","alibaba","meta","xai","google"],"ok":true,"secs":107.4,"cost":0.42556,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"俯身浇水与楼群千窗、天边月对照成立，暮色余韵足","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"瓮、瓜藤豆架、女墙俱在，菜畦略繁多于两三行","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"残霞与明月并现，天台高于楼群，低头见灯合诗","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"结构清晰，前后层次分明，无明显粘连","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"黄昏残霞与月同框，暗合由昏入月的时间流转"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"月下浇畦与灯火古城对照尚可，但灯火为街巷灯非窗火","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"瓮、瓜架可辨，豆架不明，天台化为古城台地","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"塔阁古城非千窗楼群，天台位置低于诗意俯瞰","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水墨层次尚可，远景略糊，整体可读","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗错漏：两千千、忽畦、缺第三句，夏目误字"},{"id":3,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"俯身与万家屋顶灯火对照明确，月与余霞并存","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"瓮、豆架小畦贴合两三行，瓜苗不显，女墙作城墙","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"菜畦置于城墙马道而非天台，位置与诗题有差","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"线描清晰，人物动作与器物关系明确","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"围墙封闭，与城灯无俯视关系，换一首农事诗亦成立","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"瓮变浅盆，密植非瓜豆，竹竿无藤，两三行成田垄","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"月夜可辨，但与城区同高被墙阻隔，低头见火不成","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"写实清楚，但竹竿密集重复，水流僵硬","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"背影低头浇水，身后万窗灼灼与孤月成对照，余意在","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"瓮、瓜叶、豆架两三行、女墙皆准确可辨","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"月夜天台俯城成立，黄昏余晖仅存微光","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清楚，近景瓜叶与远城层次分明","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题名四字正确，位置不夺主"},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"弯月下暗影独浇，脚下千窗火海铺陈，视点俯瞰张力强","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"瓮、瓜架结实、豆荚、女墙齿垛齐备，畦仅两三行","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"高台俯视灯火、低头姿态一致；黄昏已尽略偏夜","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"细节丰富有序，远近新旧楼混杂略乱","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"一人一弯月对万家灯火，诗眼以尺度关系点出"},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"凭墙俯身，人影暝暗与城市灯海、淡月相映，含蓄","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"瓮作有嘴水罂，豆架可见，瓜苗不明，女墙合","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"菜畦似在墙外下方，人隔墙浇水，空间关系含混","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"淡彩层次细腻，主体清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题名全诗字形无误，题款位置得当"},{"id":8,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"老人低头浇畦、城灯在下、弯月在上，情调近而略平","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"瓮、豆架三行、女墙均准，瓜苗仅一二藤","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"暮紫天与新月、天台高于城区，方位一致","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩插画风简明，远城笔法略草，仍可读","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"全诗题写无误，钤印位置合宜"}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp15":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp15","topic":"云仓夜扫","order":["alibaba","google","microsoft","zhipu","openai","bytedance","meta","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":130.9,"cost":0.507,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":5,"意象物象_评":"扫码枪、红线、箱签、长廊俱全，云端仅靠「云仓」二字暗示","意象物象":6,"意境情感_评":"女工低头抚签有细看之意，但乡愁全靠地址文字「儿时巷」交代","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜间冷光长廊、扫码动作与细看同刻，空间一致","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，右缘凭空伸出持枪之手，割裂画面","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"右侧无身之手悬空持扫码枪，结构断裂"},{"id":2,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"只是常规扫码工作照，无停顿细看之姿，换任何物流诗亦成立","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"乡名地址、红线可辨，儿时巷与封条均缺，放大圈画蛇添足","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"头灯暗示夜班，但仓内光亮如昼，夜半感弱","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"左侧放大圆盘与标题挤压，文字重复杂乱分神","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"放大圈内「乡名云端」无义重复，「箍签」错字，背心字乱"},{"id":3,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"左侧玻璃上童年巷景与已上云村名清单并置，追忆与工作分层生成","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"乡名清单、红线、扫码机、儿时巷画俱备，封条仅靠「封箱完成」字","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"23:57、明月夜空、红线传送带一致，记忆层以面板区隔可辨","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"组织尚清，右侧大字与多处小字过密，主次略乱","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"村名逐条打勾上云妙构；右侧抄诗漏「名」、「罢」误字且夺主"},{"id":4,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"人物表情平淡，红线乱飞，情绪全靠箱上「儿时巷」三字，换诗亦通","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"扫码枪、封条胶带在手，乡名缺失，云端化作世界地图，指称漂移","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"无夜半光候依据，激光线遍布空中而非扫码，方位关系失序","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"人物尚可，背景红线杂乱，屏幕小字糊烂","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"屏幕及扫码枪面板文字皆为乱码"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"云端数据流上升化作旧巷奔跑孩童，虚实有层次；标语过于直白","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"扫码红线、封条、云端图标、儿时巷俱可辨，箱签写「故乡」稍嫌直陈","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"月夜暗仓、B区长廊、记忆层浮于顶部，现实追忆分区明确","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体动作清楚，右上记忆层过渡自然，小标签字略糊","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"云端数据流化出儿时巷，以图像关系点出诗眼"},{"id":6,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"箱签直接印巷景与「儿时巷」，面板再写「乡名」，全凭文字说明","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"扫码红线、云端上传、儿时巷画可辨，封条缺失，箱签成画作不合理","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"冷蓝夜仓、头灯、货架通道成立，长廊纵深不足","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"人物与箱体清晰，悬浮面板和竖排诗文分散注意","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"抄诗「贴罣」误字，面板小字部分乱码"},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"红线贯长廊气氛佳，但人物正贴封条、口罩遮面，未到「又细看」一刻","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"长廊、红线、乡名码、上云状态、儿时巷签、封条胶带件件落实","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"02:14 AM、绿出口灯、红线沿通道纵深延伸，夜半长廊证据一致","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"空间纵深与主次清楚，墙面文字标签略多","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"屏幕、箱签文字基本正确切题且不夺主，略有「已 已」重复"},{"id":8,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"红灯夜廊湿地反光有余韵，但人物盯平板而非箱签，细看之意转移","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"乡名沙湾村、已封存、旧巷素描可辨；红线化作灯串，扫码枪缺","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"23:47夜半成立，但湿地长廊似露天，与云仓室内相龃龉","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"绘画风格统一，箱堆与人物层次清楚，无明显崩坏","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗夹入整行乱码，「贴罣」误字，印章字不可读"}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp16":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp16","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","order":["google","xai","microsoft","alibaba","zhipu","meta","openai","bytedance"],"ok":true,"secs":105.1,"cost":0.38214,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"雨天灰调、伞下行人与瘦树成排，孤瓶伴树有寄居感，余意尚存","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、输液架、新栽树、树穴、高楼齐备，药房招牌稍直白","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"春雨街景、成行新植树与两侧楼宇方位一致，湿地呼应宿雨","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"写实清晰，人物车辆完整，左侧小字与部分招牌略糊","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左侧及右侧部分招牌文字为伪字乱码"},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"枝头垂挂水滴如泪，配远街迷雾与零星行人，点出玻璃泪之悲悯","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、导管沿干而下、嫩叶、远处高楼皆可辨，建筑略欧化","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"春雨湿街与远山塔楼成层次，主楼为石砌旧楼弱化高厦","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩组织清楚，主体分明，瓶身标签为糊字","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"枝头泪滴妙构；题诗字形无误位置得当；瓶标乱码"},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"细雨独行者与瘦树扎带相望，一线情与针痕皆由物象关系生成","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"营养液瓶、导管入干处缠绷带、支架树穴、高楼俱全，樱树略添","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"春雨江畔街道、新栽树与远楼方位一致，花瓣落地点春","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩层次分明，人物简洁，右上题诗有笔画粘连","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"针孔缠绷带点出针痕；题诗首句错乱、多字讹误"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"针入树身与滴珠特写有痛感，但光亮洁净偏医疗展示，余意少","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"输液袋、导管入干、支架、嫩叶、玻璃高楼皆准，叶稍繁","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"雨后春晨湿街与高厦成立，仅一树难见街树成行","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体连续清晰，主次明确，无明显缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"巨树裸根居路中、四瓶悬挂，符号堆叠直白，缺乏依附与含蓄","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"树老干虬曲不似新植，导管垂地未入树身，吊瓶倒置方向可疑","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"树立于车道正中、行人步行路中，空间关系失实","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，但导管悬空缠绕无端，根系与路面拼接生硬","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"树生路中违常识；导管无接点、瓶口结构错乱"},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"雨中空街、瘦树扎带滴液，灰绿冷调有孤弱感，行人稀少留白","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、导管入干、嫩叶、支撑均可辨，楼为中层住宅非高厦","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"春雨街道成立，但无高楼，树立路缘外裸根欠合理","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩渲染统一，远景清楚，根部与路面糅合略乱","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"晴光浓绿、车流繁忙，情绪明快，与玻璃泪之孤弱基本相反","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、扎带导管、高楼可辨，但叶已浓密非初萌","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"晴日暖光与绿荫成列，像已至绿云之日，未分层次而混作当下","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"结构清晰，景深层次好，无明显缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":8,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"远处雪山与街边瘦树对望，千山雪之追忆有画面回应，情调清寂","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶架、导管入干、支架、嫩芽可辨，但无高厦，为小镇矮屋","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"晴日小镇街道与来依高厦不符，雪山层次可取","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"线条干净，主次分明，构图稳定","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"雪山遥应千山雪；题诗字形无误、位置不夺主"}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp17":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp17","topic":"抓娃娃机","order":["xai","zhipu","bytedance","google","meta","openai","alibaba","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":116.7,"cost":0.40514,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"映影与布偶并置、稚子仰望，余意尚存，但爪未开缺转折","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"机、爪、布偶、稚子、映影俱备，惟爪紧握未开","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"室内游艺场景一致，临窗张臂成立，方向清楚","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩淡雅，主次分明，手形略简化尚可辨","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"顶牌「抓娃娃机」字正切题、不夺主"},{"id":2,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"男孩欢笑贴玻璃，情调偏泛乐，无布偶悬落之失落","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"爪开却无布偶悬持，玻璃映影为成人面而非稚子","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"游艺厅空间成立，但映影来源与位置无法解释","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，然内藏人脸突兀，手指略僵","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"机内浮现无来由人脸，属生成错乱"},{"id":3,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"映影大脸与玩偶脸相贴，「相偎」有所落实，但仅单臂","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"爪空开而布偶坐于台上，未见「方悬」","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"稚子手似伸入玻璃内触偶，内外空间矛盾","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"光色柔和，惟手与玻璃关系含糊分散注意","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"招牌「欢乐抓娃娃」字正；手穿玻璃违常理"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"张臂仰望极具张力，然无玻璃映影，诗眼落空，背景过满","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"布偶悬于爪下、稚子张臂均可辨，爪未开、无借影","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"游艺厅纵深清晰，人机位置与操作台关系一致","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"组织自洽，远景细碎文字较杂","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"「游戏厅」「抓娃娃」字正切题，位置得当"},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"雨夜街头独童映影，孤清有味，但影未与布偶相偎","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"布偶悬爪、稚子、映影俱在，爪合未开，影在另一窗","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"童在街外对店窗，机台操作面却朝外，内外难读通","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"线条整洁，映影似另一实体小童，略致误读","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"「投币」「下爪」「2元/次」等字正且切题"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"爪开偶坠，映影笑脸与熊相依，双臂张开，失落与慰藉并生","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"爪开、布偶方落、稚子双臂、玻璃映影四者齐备","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"临窗、机内外层次、爪偶垂直关系皆一致","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"材质细腻，手形完整，主次分明","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"映影环抱布偶点出「借影相偎」；「投币」字正"},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"映影侧脸紧贴熊颊，爪开偶悬，静默凝视胜于表情","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"开爪、悬偶、张臂、映影皆可辨，指称准确","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"商场夜景一致，惟右臂伸向处与玻璃边界略含糊","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清楚，右手与机框衔接稍生硬","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"影与偶脸相偎，以图像关系点出诗眼"},{"id":8,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"映影贴近兔偶、双手抵窗尚有余意，但大块题诗代言","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"爪空开，布偶端坐偶堆，未见「方悬」之悬","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"机后透见雨城夜景，室内外层次略混，事件仍成立","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"照片与竖排文字拼贴，文字占三成画幅分散主体","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗面积过大近夺主，个别字形欠准"}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp18":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp18","topic":"旧衣回收箱","order":["alibaba","meta","google","zhipu","microsoft","bytedance","openai","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":98.1,"cost":0.38651,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"母凝旧袄、子拽袖指路，一留一催，转折成于姿态视线","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"绿箱、半悬袄、污渍短袖、兜内硬币俱全，子高及母肩","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"低斜暖光、街边树影、翻袋动作与催归方向一致","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主次清楚，人物结构完整，细节可辨","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"指路催归对照母之流连；箱上「旧衣回收」字形正确"},{"id":2,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"母子相视有温情，但棉絮硬币糖纸摊于垃圾袋上，余意尽失","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"垂盖垃圾桶非回收匣，牛仔外套非袄，无短袖，树枝直贴衣上","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"斜阳街边成立，母子并立方向可读，无催归动作","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"枝刺毛球附着衣面突兀，硬币散于棉絮上组织生硬","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱上文字大体正确；树枝毛球黏于外套违背常理"},{"id":3,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"标注式图解，短袖悬空配文字说明，情感全靠字面交代","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"孩子仅及母腰，与「身高已及母亲肩」抵触；短袖硬币靠标签","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"黄叶斜阳街景成立，衣物脱离场景漂浮，无催归动作","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"水彩尚清晰，但注释线与文字割裂画面","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"「袜」「深兜」等标注错字伪字，文字喧宾夺主"},{"id":4,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"母抱哭泣幼儿、笑容满面，与流连旧衣无关，换诗亦成立","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"圆筒似垃圾桶，仅一红袄，无短袖、硬币；孩子甚幼","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"暮光街边可辨，但母坐子哭，催归与翻袋动作皆无","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"红袄悬于桶壁无所依附，幼儿面部略变形","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"外套凭空贴于桶身违常理；孩童五官略崩"},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"母子背影携手离去，绿匣留后，有余意；但满墙题诗削弱含蓄","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"袄悬箱口、钱包硬币、短袖俱有，树纹印花代攀树迹略牵强","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"落日江岸与湿地反光一致，离去方向清楚，孩子稍矮","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"构图稠密但主次尚清，左侧文字占据大块","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"墙上题诗「稚」「归」「肩」等多处错字，标语重复"},{"id":6,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"母凝箱女儿静立，子高及母肩成立，但无催归张力","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"白袄半悬、球衣短袖、袋中硬币可辨，缺攀树痕迹","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"逆光斜阳街边成立，人物静止，动作关系弱","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"写实清晰，人物箱体结构完整","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗大体无误；箱上小字部分模糊伪字"},{"id":7,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"子仰望母投袋，稍有相依感，缺流连与催归对照","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"绿箱红袄半悬可辨，短袖、硬币、攀树迹皆缺","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"大落日与长影一致，投袋动作方向明确","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"动画风格统一，箱内衣物略糊","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"背景标语后半伪字"},{"id":8,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"母子背影同行、子扬手絮语，绿匣遗于夕照，余意可寻","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"条纹短袖、硬币、旧袄、棉絮俱有，子高恰及母肩","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"落日巷道长影统一，归去方向与遗箱位置呼应","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"层次分明，人物动作连贯，细节完整","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"背影归去写尽结句；题诗印章无误，墙贴标语伪字"}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp19":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp19","topic":"社区食堂","order":["google","openai","meta","xai","zhipu","alibaba","microsoft","bytedance"],"ok":true,"secs":105.8,"cost":0.37604,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"老翁已在座大笑进食，满堂食客，无一丝等待与余意，换诗亦成立","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"一碗面加两小碟，勉强对一荤两素；无洗净杯盘、无留箸","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"晚照穿窗、社区食堂成立，但门大开且众人正餐，非饭后半掩","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物结构、光影、透视清晰，主次分明","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"招牌「社区食堂」中英文正确，位置得当"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"前景空座配箸略有留待之意，但满堂喧闹削弱「门半掩」的静候","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"菜单明写一荤两素，碗箸俱在；前景菜已动过，杯盘未见洗净","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"落日穿窗成立，门大敞挂「营业中」，与半掩、饭后相左","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"景深层次清楚，人物细节完整，无明显崩坏","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"黑板菜单、标语字形正确切题，未夺主"},{"id":3,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"空椅、单箸、半掩门与斜照三者相对，人未至而意已足","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"一荤两素、叠洗净碗盘、玻璃杯、竹箸、半掩门皆可辨","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"低斜暮光穿窗投壁，门外空巷，饭后黄昏一致","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"静物质感真实，构图稳，细节无粘连","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"空椅正对门口，箸横桌边待人；告示字形正确切题"},{"id":4,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"碗中晚照泛红、门半开无人，冷寂中一点暖，留待之意可读","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"荤素合于一盘略含混，红碗、竹箸、半掩门到位，洗净杯盘仅一盆","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"落日在窗、门外树影暮色，室内无人与饭后相合","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩肌理统一，门板与远景略糊，主体可辨","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"碗底红光直点诗句；题句字形无误，位置得当"},{"id":5,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"空椅与门光略有等待，但仅为美食摆拍，缺洗净、留箸的对照","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"一荤两素、米饭、竹箸可辨；无洗净杯盘，无社区食堂身份","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"门中落日与壁上窗影方向可通，门敞开非半掩，似家非食堂","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体食物清晰，背景过度虚化，墙贴糊烂","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"墙上红纸伪汉字，不可读"},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"两副碗箸、菜尚冒汽、门开无人，等待可读，但缺画外方向暗示","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"一荤两素、洗净叠盘与杯、竹箸俱备，两双箸略偏「留双」","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"斜光投壁为暮色，门大开而非半掩，室外街景明亮","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"光影统一，静物形体准确，构图整洁","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"老人已在座进食，前景托盘待人尚可，大量题字取代图像表意","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"托盘一荤两素、叠碗、竹箸、社区食堂身份明确","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"落日湖景穿窗成立，餐中而非饭后，门敞开","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"插画组织尚可，文字过多分散注意，远景人物粘连","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗「掩」等字形有误，公告栏与小牌多处伪字"},{"id":8,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"空桌一人份菜箸，门外行人暮归，盘底红光点题，待意可读","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"一荤两素、米饭、竹箸、沥水架洗净碗盘、招牌俱全","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"落日穿窗入门一致，门开过半非半掩，古镇与食堂稍隔","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"质感细腻，远近人物清晰，无明显缺陷","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"盘底红光呼应「碗底红」；招牌与木牌字形正确"}]}},"claude-fable-5.1_shp20":{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","id":"shp20","topic":"社区食堂","order":["openai","google","bytedance","xai","meta","alibaba","microsoft","zhipu"],"ok":true,"secs":118.2,"cost":0.42115,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"前景蓝衣取盒之急与窗内白发笑语之长层次分明，雨巷余意足","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"餐价榜、蓝衣车盒、临窗白发、厨娘、笋尖汤明日榜俱全","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"雨湿石巷、撑伞行人、巷口纵深与窝内暖光一致","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主次清楚，人物结构完整，细节略密但不乱","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"软烂饭入榜暗合牙疏，招牌菜单字形基本正确切题"},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"白发老人临窗与厨娘相视而笑动人，但送餐者游离，急长对照弱","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"价榜、蓝衣外卖、白发、厨娘、明日笋尖汤可辨，车铃取盒较淡","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"胡同空间成立，但天阴无雨、地面干，缺雨冷依据","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"摄影感写实，人物动作自然，远景略平","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"招牌与菜单文字大体正确，小字略糊"},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"招牌菜价重复堆满，「急」字标签直译，余意被文字淹没","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"蓝衣取盒车铃、临窗白发、厨娘、笋尖俱在，物象齐备","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"雨湿地面、暮色暖光成立，窗内外关系略拥挤","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"同一菜单板出现三次，文字块过多分散主体","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗全文正确，但多处标语伪字、菜单无故重复"},{"id":4,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"远院炊烟升起呼应「隔院香」，众老围坐温情，但急长对照平","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"餐价榜、蓝衣送餐箱、厨娘、笋尖汤可辨，白发未临窗而露天","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"地面湿润却无雨，老人露天用餐与雨冷相抵","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"淡彩线描统一，形体完整，遮挡清楚","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"巷深炊烟点出隔院香；榜文字形正确、位置得当"},{"id":5,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"厨娘与白发临窗对笑为主，蓝衣雨中取盒退为门外一景，急长有致","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"笋尖、姜片、软饭、车铃、蓝衣、白发、厨娘、明日菜卡全在","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"大雨落巷、门内暖热蒸汽、窗外老人探身，空间层次一致","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"由内向外纵深清楚，主体可辨，柜台略拥","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"以厨房内视角框住雨巷与笑窗，构图即诗序；榜文正确"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"厨娘举手细说、蓝衣回望、白发相对，人物视线成环，情味足","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"蓝衣叠盒、车铃、白发、厨娘、明日预告笋尖汤俱可辨","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"雨夜暖窝成立，但老人露天雨中就座略不合理","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"插画风格统一，少年面部与车架略生硬","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"厨娘言说手势点出「细说」；菜单文字简正"},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"蓝衣驰去、白发窗内含笑、雨雾灰巷有余韵，但情节稍散","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"价榜、蓝衣配送、白发临窗、厨娘、明日菜单笋尖汤均可辨","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"细雨灰天、湿地、巷道纵深与窝内暖光协调","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"空间清楚，但左上文字块占据大片天空","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗错乱：门门、牙数、白衣、明日长等多处错字串行"},{"id":8,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"拼贴分格靠笑脸与蒸汽表意，急长对照与雨冷情调未成关系","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"主厨为男，窗口受餐者非白发，笋尖汤不明，仅餐价、蓝衣可辨","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"分格互不衔接，骑手骑车置于室内桌旁，方位冲突","画面质量":4,"画面质量_评":"格线不整，右下格骑手与食堂强行拼合，组织松散","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"骑手连车驶入餐桌间，常识不合"}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp01":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp01","topic":"旧衣回收箱","order":["alibaba","bytedance","xai","google","microsoft","openai","meta","zhipu"],"ok":true,"secs":553.7,"cost":0.0210462252,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"仅剩捐衣场景，剪签与针痕的对照未生成。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"童衫与针痕不明，名签未剪落，关键借代缺失。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"临街白日、叠衣可辨，箱门未闭，动作含混。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，主次组织自然，无生成缺陷。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"『旧衣回收』文字正确不夺主，加1。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"爱心标语与蹲姿只表捐赠，未落实剪签与针痕。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"童衫可辨，名签与针痕缺失，核心修辞未落实。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"街边白日、蹲姿施受可辨，但未入箱，无闭门。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体动作可辨，无明显伪影，文字略多不遮。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"文字正确且切题，加1。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"背影与旧箱未形成『只有针痕认得人』的余意。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"小名/性别签未剪落，旧箱非漆色新，针痕不可辨。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"叠衣置箱顶，人物背向，动作施受与逡巡不符。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"整体可辨，墙边阴影与人物稍糊，无严重崩坏。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"『旧衣有爱』及小名签文字正确，加1。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"闭箱前犹豫略有诗味，但针痕认人未生成。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"旧衣箱、闭门与标签可见，标签未剪，针痕缺席。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"临街白日，箱门闭，人物动作可辨；剪落未呈现。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，街景细节略杂，无严重伪影。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"『闭』及箱上文字正确，加1。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"水乡雾景靠墙上诗句补意，图像关系未生成诗眼。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"名签以贴纸存留，未剪落；旧箱非漆色新，针痕未见。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"人物在街边逡巡，但箱门开，剪落与闭门未落实。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"画面完整，主体可辨，题诗贴纸未遮主体。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"剪签、叠衣与逡巡前后相续，尚缺针痕点睛。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"童衫、剪刀、名签可辨；箱门未闭，针痕未特写。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"街边暖阳，人物动作与剪签过程一致；箱门尚开。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体明确，前景衣物与剪刀有轻微融接。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱上文字正确不夺主，加1。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"静物有剪签余痕，但无人逡巡，针痕未成诗眼。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"童衫不明，名签碎片可辨；无人物，针痕未显。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"折叠衣物置箱顶，人物缺席，逡巡动作未落实。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"构图简洁，背景模糊，无严重崩坏。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱上文字正确不夺主，加1。"},{"id":8,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"静物缺人物逡巡与针痕对照，只余捐衣箱意象。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"箱与衣可辨，但童衫、剪落名签、针痕均缺失。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"人物缺席，箱门虽闭但无逡巡动作，与诗不合。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"绘画风格统一，主体可辨，无生成缺陷。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp02":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp02","topic":"深夜视频","order":["alibaba","zhipu","openai","bytedance","meta","google","xai","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":561.1,"cost":0.0217128604,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"灰发男子对屏惊愕，非照己鬓","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"视频与灰发可辨，暗镜未现","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"夜间室内视频，无千山证据","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，光线组织自然","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"暗屏与灰发相对，有照我余意","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"暗镜与鬓灰可辨，缺明确倒影","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"暗室看屏，无午夜千山标识","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，无生成瑕疵","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"屏中灰发与屏上笑语对照，点出诗眼","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"视频、笑脸、灰发暗镜、远山皆可辨","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"深夜书桌，窗外群山，视频与镜面分区并置","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主次清楚，局部细节稍多但不碍读","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"屏中灰发与屏上笑语对照，点出诗眼"},{"id":4,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"仅剩视频通话，缺暗镜照我，靠题字补意","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"有视频与灰发，无暗镜与照我","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"深夜暗室，无千山午夜之证","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，文字未碍观看","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款抄诗，位置得当，小加1分"},{"id":5,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"有暗镜照我之惊，无鬓先灰","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"暗镜与自照可辨，灰发未现","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"深夜书桌，但无视频通话","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，细节可辨","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"温馨视频通话，缺诗末自照之惊","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"有灰发与笑语，无暗镜照我","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"夜间室内视频，无千山午夜","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，无明显瑕疵","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"千山掌中与笑语成立，无诗末转折","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"远山、掌屏、笑语可辨，缺暗镜","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"月夜群山与00:47合午夜","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"前景后景层次分明，清晰","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"通话计时00:47切合午夜，小加1分"},{"id":8,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"暖调视频通话，未显话尽照镜之惊","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"有视频灰发远山，缺暗镜照我","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"夜窗群山，烛下书桌，可读","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"构图清楚，文字与道具稍多","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款抄诗，位置得当，小加1分"}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp03":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp03","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","order":["google","alibaba","zhipu","meta","bytedance","microsoft","xai","openai"],"ok":true,"secs":60.1,"cost":0.01767964,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"新绿繁盛如常街，病中哀意与雨丝错认皆无。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、裹根、新叶可辨，然无雨丝与长丝意象。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"现代春街白昼，湿意不足，雨脚未现。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"照片清晰可辨，构图平稳，主体未糊。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左侧叠印错乱诗句，重复误字，喧宾夺主。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"雨街冷湿与成排吊瓶共成一街病绿，哀意尚可。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、滴管、裹根球与嫩叶俱在，皆可辨。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"雨中白昼，行道树成排，一街关系成立。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"树排与吊瓶可辨，瓶体挂接结构略怪。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"吊瓶悬接与管线走向不合常理，疑似生成瑕疵。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"老树茂绿，病中哀意弱，绿液吊瓶偏奇幻。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、垂管、新叶在，然非断根新植之树。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"雨中旧街白昼，仅一树，一街之感不足。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"线条清楚，缠布与垂管连贯，画面自洽。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右侧题诗重复错乱，占幅过大。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"水彩细雨里病树新绿，哀而不伤，情调贴合。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、输液管、裹布根球与新叶均可辨。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"春昼细雨，旧街行道树成列，关系一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩形体清晰，主次分明，无碍眼瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"枯黑老树仅余疏绿，吊瓶滴水，病中哀意浓。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶滴珠、疏叶、露根土台可辨，身份略老。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"烟雨白昼，伞影街巷延伸，空间关系成立。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水墨层次清楚，枝干与滴线连贯，无断裂。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右题诗无误，印章位置得当，小幅加分。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"垂丝滴珠与雨线难分，暗合错认，哀意绵长。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、垂丝、裹布根球与青枝俱在可辨。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"雨日古镇街巷，伞客远去，一街春意成立。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"笔触清晰，垂丝与输管略缠，尚未碍读。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"垂珠略合错认；左上题诗错字脱句。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"树绿叶盛，病意被春晴冲淡，错认几无回应。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶与绿叶可辨，断根新植之象未见。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"雨日街景，行道树成排，春时线索一致。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"画面清楚，树干木牌与题字稍杂但可读。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右下题诗无误；树干木牌略生硬多余。"},{"id":8,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"垂丝悬珠与雨线相混，错认之眼宛然在目。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、滴管、缠干与新绿可辨，断根未见。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"雨雾白昼，长街远伸，伞客与树列同在。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"质感清晰，前后景分明，无粘连或畸变。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"柳丝垂珠与雨线难辨，暗合错认诗眼。"}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp04":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp04","topic":"云仓夜扫","order":["microsoft","alibaba","bytedance","openai","zhipu","meta","google","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":33.6,"cost":0.01040776,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"凝望发车与地上故里纸片构成归乡受阻的张力","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"铁臂、竹帚、货架、村名标签与纸片皆可辨","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"夜半暗仓与东方微白地平线并置，车正离场","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主次清楚，人物扫帚与机械臂结构连贯","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"地面纸片与远行车灯照应全诗，诗款可辨不夺主"},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"蹲读残签的凝视与旁置竹帚生成无声怅惘","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"竹帚、货架、机械臂与云水村标签皆可辨","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"仓内冷灯与门外紫霞暗示夜尽将明","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物结构与标签遮挡清楚，组织稳定","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"以蹲读村签定格『残签藏故里』，标签字清楚"},{"id":3,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"夜行探照清冷，但扫仓与念乡的对照未落实","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"竹误作丛生竹叶，扫帚缺席，手电代帚","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"深夜仓道与东方微白、发车方向一致","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"空间纵深清楚，机械与人物无粘连","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左上诗款字迹端正切题，位置不夺主"},{"id":4,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"扫码劳作场面平直，缺扫夜念乡的张力","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"无竹帚、无村名残签，机械臂亦不见","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"圆月与霞光并存，昼夜线索相互冲突","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面整洁，货架与门洞组织清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"泛化仓储劳作，换一首同题材诗也成立","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"竹帚、村名残签、铁臂等关键物皆缺失","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"门外灰白，无夜半或欲白的明确光候","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，但地面伪字与场景平淡","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"地面方块字为乱码伪字，显眼且分散注意"},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"弃帚、灯下急件与发车并列，归途被货架阻隔","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"竹帚、灯、机械臂、货架与桃源村签皆可辨","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"夜仓深巷尽头向白，货车正驶出大门","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"空间干净，物件主次分明且无粘连","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"『北仓→桃源村·字迹尚明』纸片点出诗眼"},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"空架扫帚与散落村名纸片，静中见怅然","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"竹帚、空货架、村名纸片可辨，铁臂已收","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"窗外微白、门外车灯暗示夜尽而待发","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"纵深对称清楚，人物扫动姿态连贯","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"帚前散落诸村名，暗合『拂到村名分外轻』"},{"id":8,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"老扫工灯下清扫可感，然故乡近在眼前，隔绝味弱","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"竹帚、货架、故里村牌可辨，铁臂与货车缺","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"村落实景直呈门外，与『隔归程』距离感相抵","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"空间秩序与清扫动作清楚，细节完整","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"侧题诗款与『故里村』牌字迹可辨且切题"}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp05":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp05","topic":"深夜视频","order":["meta","xai","bytedance","microsoft","openai","zhipu","google","alibaba"],"ok":true,"secs":142.1,"cost":0.0151594828,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"寒床与暖屏的明暗对照清楚，但未画出暗屏余温的转折。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"慈颜、新蔬、晚菊、手机与寒床均清晰可辨。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜半异乡卧室与屏中厨房隔海相连，方位可辨。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，明暗组织完整，无明显生成缺陷。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"暗屏与亮屏并置却无互动，情调近但转折未成。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"黄菊置于子侧而非母厨，视频关系被花瓶削弱。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"夜床与屏中厨房成立，但花与暗屏位置令时空混杂。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，笔记本电脑与手部组织清楚。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"通话界面直白并置，慈颜身份不清，缺少诗中余味。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"厨中人物似年轻女性，且无晚菊黄，关键指称失准。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"两空间并排而未作隔海层次，母侧与子侧混置。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"复合画面结构清楚，手机界面文字可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"手机界面“深夜视频”字样清晰切题，加1分。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"寒床暖屏对照尚在，但暗屏余温未出，诗意偏平。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"慈颜、新蔬、晚菊、平板与寒床均可辨。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜半卧室内屏中厨房隔海，空间层次可辨。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清楚，但床前书页文字稍抢视线。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"上屏慈颜、下暗屏掌温，完整托出诗末余温与相对。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"慈颜、新蔬、晚菊、暗屏与掌温皆在，关键指称准确。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"上下两段由屏亮到屏暗，夜床与母厨层次清楚。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"两段构图连贯，掌下光晕与暗屏组织有据。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"掌底余温以光晕视觉化，神来之笔加2分。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"无视频无寒床，只有慈母厨中备餐，换题亦成立。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"慈颜、新蔬、晚菊可辨，但视频与异乡床侧全缺。","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"仅厨房夜景，无隔海、异乡、床侧与屏幕层次。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清楚，静物组织稳定，无生成缺陷。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":-2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"底部诗画评比水印失当，减2分。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"无寒床异乡与暗屏余温，仅慈颜厨花，诗意流失。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"屏中为年轻男子非慈颜，关键视频指向错位。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"无异乡寒床，只有母厨夜景，隔海层次未立。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体、花菜与手机界面清晰，整体可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":-1,"加减分_评":"持机手与人物结构断裂，减1分。"},{"id":8,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"寒床暖屏对照尚可，文字标注太明，诗眼未出。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"慈颜、新蔬、晚菊、手机与寒床清晰，惟缺暗屏余温。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜半异乡床侧与屏中厨房关系可辨。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，手机屏与人物组织完整，无伪影。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp06":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp06","topic":"天台菜园","order":["openai","meta","zhipu","google","bytedance","alibaba","xai","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":114.0,"cost":0.02403544,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"晚晴灯羹瓜与门内人成暖意，客居叩邻关系未明。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"砖畦藤架通风管水罂灯羹瓜可辨，梯与虫叶缺。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夕阳晚晴，天台城市，灯亮劳作，时间方位一致。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，人物动作自然，遮挡组织有序，瑕疵少。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"负土登梯劳作明确，灯锅瓜有暮意，客居叩邻弱。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"负土登梯、残砖、虫叶、瓜、灯锅、水缸等核心可辨。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"晚晴中登梯上天台，炉灯并置，动作方向可读。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，但手部与梯墙衔接略生硬，局部糊。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"暮色叩门碗灯可点题，但巨瓜悬门夺意，客居无。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"菜畦通风管藤瓜门可辨，蓄水罂成水塔，虫叶登梯缺。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"黄昏城市天台可读，地面积水与晚晴略冲突。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"主体与动作大体可辨，但局部组织杂乱分散注意。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":2,"加减分_评":"巨瓜悬门、水塔藤蔓粘连，生成伪影明显。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"暮色菜园灯碗有静意，但靠题字，客居叩邻未成。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"残砖菜畦通风管陶缸灯碗梯可辨，瓜与叩邻缺。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"黄昏夜城市天台，灯亮，人物浇水方位可读。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"水墨组织尚可，人物手部略糊，主次可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题字摘句错乱重复，按文字失当减一分。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"晚晴瓜熟与门内人笑成暖意，但客居叩邻未落实。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"藤绕通风管、蓄水陶缸、砖畦、瓜、灯均有，梯虫弱。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夕阳晚晴，天台菜园，人物门内位置合理。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"写实清晰，人物瓜藤自然，组织主次分明。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"前四句题款字形稳妥，位置得当，小幅加分。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"端羹叩门与灯前瓜熟相连，客居分享意味可感。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"羹碗邻扉瓜、藤绕通风管、陶缸、砖畦均可辨。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"暮夜灯下，天台城市，叩门动作与时间一致。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"主体清楚，端碗叩门动作连续，门牌不夺主。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"端羹叩邻门连接煮羹与唤邻，神来之笔加一分。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"背影叩邻门，炉灯羹瓜并置，客居晚晴情绪可读。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"砖畦藤架瓜、通风管、灯锅、门可辨，负土登梯未动作。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"黄昏天台，炉灯与叩门同刻，天色灰暗稍损晚晴。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，人物手与门锁衔接略糊，元素稍杂。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"全诗题款清稳位置得当，加一分。"},{"id":8,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"夕阳都市菜园劳作清润，客居叩邻与瓜熟转折未明。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"藤绕通风管、砖畦、瓜、陶缸、灯锅可辨，梯虫弱。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夕阳晚晴，天台城市，蹲身劳作方位合理。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水墨风格连贯，主体动作可辨，人物手部略含糊。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"全诗题款字形清整，位置得当，小幅加分。"}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp07":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp07","topic":"云端相册","order":["bytedance","openai","microsoft","xai","alibaba","google","meta","zhipu"],"ok":true,"secs":46.6,"cost":0.01414732,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"裁剪框配停笔之手，桌前围裙呼应屏中旧照","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"云端图标、相册、旧照、围裙可辨，缺齿稍弱","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"暖光室内，屏内旧照与屏外人分层清楚","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"界面、主体与手笔连接自然，组织清晰","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"云端相册题字正确切题不夺主；桌边围裙暗扣诗眼"},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"老人指点屏中笑影，桌前剪刀旧照衬停手之思","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"屏中缺齿笑、旧相册、围裙等名物基本落实","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"日光室内，实体旧照与屏中数字相片并置","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物、屏幕与桌面物件清楚，构图稳定","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"家庭相冊书脊字形无误、切题且不夺主"},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"背影暮色有情绪，屏中却是老人而非幼影","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"界面与围裙可辨，然屏中主体误作老年女性","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"夜色城市与室内光候统一，跨时空层次含混","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"人物与界面清楚，桌面杂字稍分散注意","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"云海浮屏与案头剪刀旧照，共构追忆与停手","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"云端下载图标、旧照、围裙、童影皆可辨","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"云端虚境与案头实景分层，追忆层次可读","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩笔法统一，界面与物件清楚无碍","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"云海浮屏使云端与旧照虚实相生；题诗印章得体"},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"暖阳持屏裁剪可感，围裙未成不忍的焦点","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"屏中着围裙笑女与裁剪框可辨，缺齿不明","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"现代厨房日景，光候统一，时空层次单一","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"人物屏幕清楚，持屏手部结构略生硬","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"老人探手触屏凝望幼影，不舍之意可感","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"屏中幼女着围裙而笑，缺齿不显，旧照可辨","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"室内窗前日光，实体相框与数字照片并置","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，屏下小字与手部略有黏连","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"裁框正欲切除右侧围裙，笔尖停顿，不忍直见","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"缺齿笑童、围裙、云端相册界面指称准确","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"书桌白昼，屏中旧照与操作界面分区清楚","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"界面、手笔与裁框组织清楚，主体略偏右","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"裁框将切去围裙之瞬化为可见动作；界面字样切题"},{"id":8,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"老人捧屏含笑，围裙在身，不舍的停顿未成","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"黑白旧照中笑童可辨，缺齿与围裙关联含混","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"室内侧光，现实与屏中旧照分层，方位清楚","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"屏幕边缘略弯，手与机身黏连，尚可辨","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"屏缘弯折、手部与机身黏连"}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp08":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp08","topic":"抓娃娃机","order":["microsoft","xai","alibaba","openai","zhipu","google","bytedance","meta"],"ok":true,"secs":375.9,"cost":0.014260862,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"温馨期待未及诗眼，空掌与牵手之转折未现。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"父女、机器、硬币、小熊可辨，但无空掌与落团。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"站于机前静态，未显仰首踮脚与离场牵手。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，透视与动作连贯，无明显生成缺陷。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"机壁文字清晰切合，不夺主，加1分。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"柔和期待有余，空掌与归途牵手未入画。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"琉璃匣底眠熊清晰，父女与机器关系明确。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"无踮脚、落团、离场方向，仅机前静止一刻。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩笔法统一，形体清晰，无妨碍观看的瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"空掌与牵手同框，失落后的温暖收束一目了然。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"空掌、牵手、机中眠熊可辨，缺抓取与落团环节。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"离机行走方向明确，归途牵手关系成立。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"光影清晰，主体动作连贯，无明显伪影。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"空掌与牵手同框妙合诗眼，加1分。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"多幅衔接期望、落团与牵手，情感转折完整。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"扯袖、铁爪、毛团、归途牵手皆可辨。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"分幅按诗序展开，动作方向与先后清楚。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"分幅清晰，局部手部细节略糊但未碍理解。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"亲子同乐与诗之失落空掌相反，换题亦成立。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"父、童、机器、悬熊可辨，缺空掌与落团物象。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"父执摇杆而非娇儿扯袖催钱，动作施受不合。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"光影清楚，主体动作连贯，无严重伪影。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"只有观望期待，未落实空掌与牵手转折。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"父、女、硬币、悬熊可辨，缺落团与空掌。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"父蹲女立，无踮脚仰首的紧张姿态。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"写实清晰，文字无乱码，无结构性缺陷。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"女孩抱熊欢笑，与诗末空掌牵手意境相左。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"空掌虽在，但怀中之熊使无一物关系失效。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"奖得熊后场景，无归途牵手，偏离诗序。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，光影自然，无明显生成缺陷。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":8,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"扯袖与空掌有张力，但未到归途牵手之温暖。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"扯袖、空掌、机中熊与投币牌皆可辨。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"机前交涉，方向静止，未显踮脚与离场。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，动作连贯，文字无误，无伪影。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"投币牌文字无误切合，加1分。"}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp09":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp09","topic":"夜航俯瞰","order":["microsoft","alibaba","bytedance","google","xai","openai","zhipu","meta"],"ok":true,"secs":29.7,"cost":0.00302786,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"舷窗、机翼、孩子与下方灯火构成俯视对照，余意存于画外。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"铁翼、山形、江流长街火、野路萤、水晶屏、稚子均可辨。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰层次清晰，万籁千仞下的纵深关系成立。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"左侧题诗未碍主体，元素组织自洽，唯机翼结构略生硬。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款为原诗，内容切合、位置得当，小幅加分。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"画面情感偏温馨静观，缺少诗中沉重与错认的张力。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"核心对象可辨，但野路萤火与水晶屏表达含混。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜航机舱俯瞰的远近动静关系基本成立。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，机翼与窗外层次明确，未见明显伪影。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"稚子指窗的视线与万家灯火形成生动呼应。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"铁翼、山形、灯火、河流等关键名物皆可辨。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜航时间与俯瞰方位明确，动作施受合理。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"人物指窗动作略显僵硬，局部细节有轻微粘连。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"以指认动作视觉化诗眼，点出稚子辨认飞灯与远星的妙处。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"孩童仰望月亮的静态构图，缺少诗中的错认与喧嚣对照。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"机翼与月亮可辨，但山形、野路萤火等对象模糊。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜航窗外月与下方灯火的位置关系大致成立。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"发动机结构有轻微扭曲，主体仍可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"画面偏静谧优美，未落实诗中沉埋千仞的压抑感。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"山、江、灯火、稚子可辨，但野路萤火不明。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"俯瞰视野与夜航位置清晰，纵深感较好。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"窗外风景与舱内层次清楚，左下伪汉字干扰。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"左侧文字为乱码伪字，且AI伪影轻微影响观感。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"夜色宁静，灯火河流入画，但情绪张力不足。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"铁翼、山形、河流灯火与稚子可辨，萤火不显。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰的时空关系正确，层次分明。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"机翼与窗外景物融合自然，无严重结构崩坏。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"画面就抄诗句配月夜，缺少视觉关系支撑诗眼。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"月亮、河流、灯火为泛化景物，稚子与机翼细节不清。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰大体成立，但月亮比例失真、空间错乱。","画面质量":4,"画面质量_评":"月亮巨大异常，文字遮挡主体，视觉组织混乱。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":2,"加减分_评":"画面中央文字喧宾夺主，月亮比例穿帮，AI伪影严重。"},{"id":8,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"稚子与窗外的广阔灯海形成清晰对照，余意较足。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"铁翼、山形、江流灯火、野路萤火均可辨。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰的方位与远近关系一致，层次清晰。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面整体清晰自洽，机翼与舷窗关系合理。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"稚子凭栏的视线与窗外灯火形成含蓄呼应。"}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp10":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp10","topic":"机场送别","order":["bytedance","zhipu","openai","meta","google","xai","alibaba","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":51.3,"cost":0.01416932,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"左右分屏连起送别与舱中围巾，冷暖对照回应诗中转折。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"母亲、行李、广播牌、围巾、机舱俱在，惟玻璃隔断由分屏替代。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"候机厅与舱内两时空并置，分屏使玻璃内外关系可辨。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体姿态与遮挡清楚，左右衔接自然，无明显生成破绽。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"分屏与围巾呼应见巧思；题诗字形无误，位置得当。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"仅泛化母子告别，双手平举含义不明，换诗亦成立。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"有母、子、行李与班机，玻璃隔语、围巾、舱中皆失。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"同在候机厅一侧，未见玻璃内外与屏上航程层次。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"人物与行李清楚，母亲双掌手指略僵但未碍阅读。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"玻璃对望、暖光夕照与舱中绕巾相承，离别张力偏淡。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"母亲、玻璃、航班屏、围巾俱备，行李指弯未显。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"候机、航班屏与舱内分格并置，昼夜过渡尚可读通。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"拼贴分区清楚，人物结构可辨，整体偏插画略糊。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"航线屏与舱窗夜景并置见巧思；航班屏汉字准确。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"玻璃对望与登机催促到位，舱中绕巾的转折缺席。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"母、子、玻璃、行李、围巾、登机牌均可辨。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"候机厅时空一致，屏上航程与舱内层次未展开。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"结构与遮挡干净，人物动作连续，指示牌清晰。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"催程广播与航班牌字形无误，切合诗意。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"母亲贴玻璃张口叮嘱可感，舱中寒领与绕巾未见。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"母、女、围巾、行李与玻璃俱在，屏上航线不明。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"同在候机厅，玻璃内外层次含混，缺舱内时空。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"玻璃上出现半透明重影人面，边缘与反光杂乱。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"玻璃重影面容与反光粘连，属生成瑕疵。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"母亲贴玻璃、女儿回望与舱中绕巾同框，余意可感。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"母、女、玻璃、围巾、行李与催程广播皆可辨。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"候机厅、登机口与舱内以写意过渡并置，层次可读。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"人物清楚，左母面部与玻璃交融略糊，不妨碍阅读。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"玻璃上留母亲倒影，暗合「影驻一重关」。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"隔玻璃对望与红围巾可感，舱中寒领一层全缺。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"母、女、玻璃、围巾清楚，行李与航程屏含混。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"候机厅方位一致，屏上机移与舱内层次未现。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"人物与玻璃关系清楚，背景指示牌略杂。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"航班屏同号不同地、伦敦配CAN码，文字失当。"},{"id":8,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"母子隔玻璃相嘱可感，舱中绕巾只由题字补足。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"母、子、玻璃、背包围巾在，舱内与航线屏缺。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"雨夜候机厅时空统一，跨舱时空层次未建立。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物结构干净，雨窗与指示牌层次清楚。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp11":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp11","topic":"夜航俯瞰","order":["microsoft","bytedance","google","zhipu","openai","meta","xai","alibaba"],"ok":true,"secs":92.5,"cost":0.02534708,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"夜景云月、河灯断续、手按玻璃，怀旧凉意；深巷口未显。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"舷窗、长街、沿河灯火、玻璃手指可辨；当年深巷口缺失。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰方位成立，手触窗玻璃，追忆层次未分。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"舷窗、手部、城市灯火层次清晰，无碍眼伪影。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗竖排切合，印章位置得当，不夺主，加2。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"夜雨贴窗、河灯城市有冷寂感；交通空间错，深巷口未显。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"舷窗被列车大窗替换，核心名物不符；河灯仍在。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰被画成车厢内景，交通方式反转，手触窗成立。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"雨滴、手部、窗外灯火组织清楚，局部无大崩坏。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左侧小字题诗切合，位置低调不夺主，加1。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"女子凝视、指尖触窗与城市灯火，怀旧凉意较足；深巷口弱。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"舷窗、河灯、玻璃手指可辨；当年深巷口未落实。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰与手触窗关系成立，舱内反光叠脸可辨。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"人物面部清楚，手部略僵，主体仍可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"窗外多出模糊人脸，疑伪影，扣1。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"手按舷窗、河灯夜景尚可；大字题诗抢戏，深巷口未显。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"舷窗、长街、灯火沿河、玻璃手指可辨；深巷口缺失。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰和手触窗成立；文字遮挡部分空间层次。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"窗外夜景清晰，手部与窗框结构可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"白色题诗过大，遮蔽右下，扣2文字分。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"俯视河桥灯火、指尖触窗，有冷寂怀旧；深巷口未显。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"舷窗、长街、沿河灯火、玻璃手指可辨；深巷口弱。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰、河流桥梁方位一致，手触玻璃合理。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"窗外层次清楚，窗框手部可见，主体可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"手部结构略僵，扣1伪影。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"雨滴玻璃、指尖触窗与深巷灯火，凉意与寻找感佳。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"圆形舷窗、河流灯火、深巷手指可辨，长街细密。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰与古镇深巷关系成立，手触窗动作明确。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"外景细节少，窗框与玻璃融合，主体尚可辨。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"指尖雨滴映深巷，神来加2；局部糊扣1。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"手触玻璃、河灯夜航，凉意与怀旧可感；深巷口未显。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"舷窗、长街、沿河灯火、玻璃手指可辨；深巷口弱。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰方位一致，手触窗动作成立。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"窗外清晰，题字小不碍主体，整体可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"竖排题款切合不夺主加2；指端略糊扣1。"},{"id":8,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"指触窗、河灯夜城有冷寂感；追忆深巷口几乎未显。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"舷窗、长街、沿河灯火、玻璃手指可辨；深巷口弱。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰和手触窗空间关系成立。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"整体过暗，窗外细节少，主体尚可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"指尖触处光晕糊，扣1伪影。"}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp12":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp12","topic":"云端相册","order":["meta","alibaba","bytedance","google","zhipu","microsoft","openai","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":73.8,"attempts":2,"cost":0.01638648,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"白发祖母凝视屏中慈亲抱婴，视线与旧照相扣","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"白头、故堂、挂蒜、土灶凝烟、屏中慈亲抱婴均可辨","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"现实老院与屏内旧照分区，动作与朝向一致","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人、手与屏面结构完整清晰，主次分明","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"屏上『云端相册』字样无误且不夺主"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"白发老人含笑指屏中故堂母子，暖意足而转折平","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"白头、屏中故堂、挂蒜、土灶烟与慈亲抱婴可辨","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"现代客厅与屏内旧院分层清楚，人未立故堂前","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体手势清楚，画风统一，无明显拼接","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款『云端相册』与诗句字形无误、位置得体"},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"白发观相册尚可，多出二女与巨书叠境，关系含混","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"相册、挂蒜、土灶烟、慈亲抱婴在，然『开屏』改实体书","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"巨书与地面混置，现实与追忆空间难以分层","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"人物比例失谐，书页与地面粘连，主体尚可辨","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"诗题款字形正确但占幅偏大"},{"id":4,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"白发老人俯身看屏中旧照，指点慈亲抱婴，情意可感","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"白头、挂蒜、土灶烟、屏中慈亲抱婴皆备","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"旧屋现实与屏内旧照分层，光位关系自洽","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"结构清晰，持屏手势自然，主次分明","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"屏内『云端相册』字样清晰切题"},{"id":5,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"婴儿魂影悬空，慈亲膝上之情被换作泛化追思","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"挂蒜与灶火在，然慈亲缺席、屏中无照，指称走失","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"手机与幻影同置一室，现实忆境层次不明","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"线条尚清，婴儿悬浮突兀，右侧红葱名物混杂","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"大字『云端相册』无误但体量略夺主"},{"id":6,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"观者黑发年轻女子，白头诗眼落空，情调趋泛","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"屏中慈亲抱婴、窗外挂蒜灶烟可辨，然白头未现","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"现代居室、窗外旧院与屏内旧照三层尚可辨","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"画面整洁，窗景与屏面结构完整，装饰稍杂","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款诗文字形无误，与水杯书本杂字并置"},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"雾中故堂与慈亲抱婴浮现，云端意象成画外余韵","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"木箱旧照、屏、白头、挂蒜、土灶烟与慈亲抱婴齐备","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"现实、屏内旧照、雾中忆境三层分区清楚","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"背身老人与双手结构完整，层次分明","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"雾化故堂呼应『云端』，为诗眼妙构"},{"id":8,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"白发抱婴看旧照，膝上之意尚存，然云端开屏尽失","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"白头、挂蒜、灶烟、膝上婴与旧照可辨，独无屏幕","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"旧屋无现代屏面，现实与追忆层次被压平","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，手部与照片边缘有粘连生成感","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗将『犹在』误作『猪在』，字形有误"}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp13":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp13","topic":"机场送别","order":["xai","bytedance","google","alibaba","openai","zhipu","meta","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":39.9,"cost":0.00275924,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"背影贴玻璃掌痕，隔窗凝视暮色，送别余意含蓄。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"检票长廊、登机牌、飞机、掌痕皆可辨，身份明确。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"暮色长廊与停机坪方位一致，过闸无言由背影呈现。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，玻璃掌痕与反光组织自然。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"掌心光痕微妙点出诗眼。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"二人相望与掌痕并存，情绪直白，含蓄稍弱。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"候机厅、闸机、行李箱、掌痕可辨，归期未问未体现。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"暮色走廊与闸机方位成立，人物相对站定，动作迟疑。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"玻璃掌痕形状生硬，人物面部略平板。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款原诗位置得当，但略有夺主。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"女子贴窗掌痕与航灯夜色相映，离别情绪内敛。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"机场玻璃与掌痕可辨，航灯与夜色氛围准确。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"暮色与机场内部关系清楚，窗外航灯方向合理。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"玻璃反光与掌痕交织，人物背身清晰可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"巨掌占据视觉中心，情绪被夸张，原诗含蓄受损。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"掌痕与飞机可辨，但掌痕占比过大，物象失当。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"检票闸机与窗外飞机同框，但巨掌悬空破坏空间关系。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"掌痕质感异常，左右画面拼接生硬。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"掌痕材质糊烂，尺度失衡。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"夕阳暖色与登机口人物呼应，诗意偏旅游纪念感。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"登机口、飞机、拉杆箱与掌痕皆在，但航灯未辨。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"落日暮色明确，人物背向登机口，送别方向合理。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"结构清晰，但手部掌痕边缘模糊。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"仅用文字标出诗句，视觉关系未能生成情感张力。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"机场闸机背景可辨，掌痕与人物全被文字遮挡。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"暮色候机厅成立，但主体动作画面中不可辨。","画面质量":4,"画面质量_评":"大字横贯画面，主体严重被遮挡，组织失衡。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"诗句文字夺主，遮蔽核心画面信息。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"无人物而掌痕留窗，长廊空寂，余意悠长。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"登机口、走廊与掌痕可辨，但窗外飞机未显。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"暮色长廊与窗外停机坪结构一致，空寂感成立。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"掌痕与玻璃反光清晰，但走廊尽头略扁平。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"无人掌痕强化诗眼，留白动人。"},{"id":8,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"背身贴窗掌痕，另一人远去，送别与自留关系清楚。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"机场航站楼、飞机、掌痕可辨，飞机形态与诗境略远。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"雨夜暮色与航站楼方位合理，远去方向与掌痕呼应。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"雨痕与掌痕交融，右侧人物形态略模糊。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款原诗位置靠左，画面尚稳。"}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp14":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp14","topic":"天台菜园","order":["xai","zhipu","google","alibaba","openai","bytedance","microsoft","meta"],"ok":true,"secs":31.4,"cost":0.00300234,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"低头浇畦与身后千窗灯火形成明暗对照，诗眼可辨。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"菜园、瓜豆架、瓮、女墙、月光俱在，身份明确。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"黄昏月光与城市灯火同框，高低方位与动作施受正确。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，疏密有致，画面组织自洽。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款为原诗，字形位置得当，小幅加分。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"有人浇园，但低头看灯火的关键回望被替换为平视。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"瓜苗豆架、瓮、月光可辨，然人物为现代休闲装束。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"黄昏月夜与城市灯火的时空关系基本成立。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体动作清晰，但叶片重复较多。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"老者低头浇菜，与万家灯火形成空间对照，余意存。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"菜园、豆架、瓦瓮、女墙、新月皆备，人物身份合。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"屋顶菜园与远处灯海层次分明，月光时令正确。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水墨风格统一，细节略有模糊。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款为原诗且位置佳，字形基本清晰，小幅加分。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"灯火对照存在，但低头动作被侧身代替，诗眼稍弱。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"瓜藤、竹架、瓮、女墙、满月可辨，身份明确。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜月城市灯火与屋顶菜园方位关系正确。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清楚，但竹架和叶片边界略有粘连。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"低头灌园与远处灯火对照明显，诗眼得视觉回应。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"瓜豆架、瓮、女墙、月光、灯火俱在；女子衣饰偏现代。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"黄昏月出与城市华灯同框，方位动作正确。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面层次清晰，光影自然，无明显伪影。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"黄昏暖色与月光冷色对比生发诗眼，加一分。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"弯腰浇灌与万家灯火形成明暗对照，诗意浓郁。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"瓜架、瓮、女墙、月夜、城市灯火皆具；女子古装。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"城墙与城市灯火并存，但空间有拼合感。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体连续，细节完整，但造型略概念化。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"低头浇灌与灯火对照存在，但题字损画意。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"菜园、瓜架、瓮、女墙、月、灯火可辨。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"屋顶菜园、黄昏月、城市灯火方位正确。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，但题款文字明显错字并占较大空间。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款错字且喧宾夺主，减二分。"},{"id":8,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"低头灌园、千窗灯火与月光形成三层对照，诗眼鲜明。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"瓜豆架、瓮、女墙、新月、灯火俱备，身份合。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜月城市灯火与屋顶菜园位置关系明确。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体动作清晰，但地面细节略混杂。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"人物低头与灯火的上下对照格外点出诗眼，加一分。"}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp15":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp15","topic":"云仓夜扫","order":["microsoft","openai","xai","google","meta","zhipu","alibaba","bytedance"],"ok":true,"secs":42.3,"attempts":2,"cost":0.011165,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"玻璃倒影儿时巷与深夜仓库对望，转折可视。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"乡名码箱签儿时巷均在，封条稍含糊。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜半仓库红线与倒影记忆分层，室内见月略怪。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体动作可辨，手部与小字略生硬。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"玻璃倒影佳，题诗切合；无大减分。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"右侧儿时巷与左侧云图并置，记忆直白。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"故乡封箱扫码云图可辨，儿时巷以照片呈现。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜仓与悬浮记忆分区可辨，月亮位置略混。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主次清楚，人物手部与扫码枪略畸。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"地图连乡名略巧；手部略畸。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"红灯长廊、扫码封存有夜扫感，儿时巷仅小图。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"乡名码封存可辨，儿时巷缩为小图，红线变灯串。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"深夜仓库动作明确，红灯串不合“红线闪”。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"暗部偏糊，标签文字多但整体可读。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"小图点题；暗部与手持平板略畸。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"只见地名扫码，儿时巷未成视觉，转折落空。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"乡名码在，关键“儿时巷”缺失。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"仓库白天感强，夜半与红线闪均弱。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"放大镜内文字重复，人物动作尚可。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"题诗切合；放大镜重复无大碍。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"红线长廊中封箱细看，箱面儿时巷勾连记忆。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"乡名码云端箱签封条儿时巷齐聚。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"02:14夜仓红线与箱面记忆层次一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体动作清楚，人物面部略AI。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"箱画即诗眼，文字切合；面部略假。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"红线云图虽在，儿时巷仅标签，情感空泛。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"儿时巷无巷景只有文字，云端图可辨。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"仓库红灯可见，夜半光候不足。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"屏幕疑似乱码，手与扫码枪粘连。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"屏幕伪字乱码，手部粘连。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"快递单上“儿时巷”只是地址，未见记忆画面。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"箱签码在，儿时巷沦为文字地址。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"传送带仓库成立，夜半与红线闪弱。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"写实清楚，手部持枪略生硬。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"快递单切合；持枪手略生硬。"},{"id":8,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"扫码箱上儿时巷画，深夜细看感尚存。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"乡名码云箱签儿时巷画可辨，封条缺。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜仓扫描与箱面画层次成立。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清楚，头盔与手部略畸。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"箱画点题，题诗切合；头盔略畸。"}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp16":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp16","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","order":["xai","openai","zhipu","meta","alibaba","google","bytedance","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":30.0,"cost":0.00273372,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"吊瓶与湿街行人构成清寂余意，但转折未深。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、滴管、新叶及高厦皆可辨，玻璃泪比喻恰当。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"春街雨后方位清楚，空间纵深与诗句层次吻合。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩质感统一，主体清晰，粘连极少。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗夺去部分画意，有水印干扰。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"阳光晴亮，与“宿雨声”及“一线情”的惆怅不合。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、树、街景可辨，但缺少玻璃泪的晶莹质感。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"春街时辰清楚，然晴日与雨声暗示冲突。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"照片式清晰，结构稳定，无可见伪影。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"悬空吊瓶与对称街景生出超现实感，偏离本诗情调。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶数量过多，树根外露，与“根尚浅”冲突。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"城市街道主体可辨，但吊瓶悬挂缺乏现实依据。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"构图对称完整，枝干边缘略有模糊。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"树枝与吊瓶连接处有轻微融合。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"雨湿街面与地上新叶形成清冷余意，转折有据。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、滴落、新叶、街树皆合，惜未现高厦。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"春季街道关系清楚，雨中光候一致。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"雨丝与接缝处稍杂乱，主体尚可辨。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"树根地面融合，滴管末端结构含糊。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"吊瓶输液入树，伤者姿态鲜明，但悲象偏实。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、导管、树洞、新叶俱可辨，水袋偏瓶。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"春街城市清晰，近树远厦关系成立。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清楚，水管有支撑架，未见明显崩坏。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"街景写实但情绪平淡，画外转折未获视觉回应。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、行道树、城市街巷均合，药房文字可作为环境。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"春街行人关系自然，阴天与宿雨相合。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"照片般清晰，但树叶偏少，路人稍抢眼。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"招牌文字可辨，位置得当，小幅加分。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"远山与街道质朴，但整体明快，悲悯余意不足。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、树、叶可辨，却似乡村，缺“高厦”。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"偏远村街与诗中“高厦”环境不合。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩干净，结构完整，题字不遮主体。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗位置得当，无乱码。"},{"id":8,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"雨江高楼尚可，但花枝与“叶初萌”季节略嫌混融。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、街树、高楼可见，营养液标签太直白。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"春雨城市方位清楚，远景江桥有层次。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩氛围好，右上有题款与文字稍杂。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"营养液标签直白，题字过多，结构小瑕疵。"}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp17":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp17","topic":"抓娃娃机","order":["microsoft","bytedance","xai","alibaba","zhipu","meta","openai","google"],"ok":true,"secs":22.8,"cost":0.00278278,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"女孩与镜中影像隔玻璃相望，许相偎的余意含蓄可感。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"娃娃机、布偶、按键、投币口皆清晰，镜中倒影呼应借影。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"投币按键、爪悬布偶的位置关系基本成立，方向略欠明确。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体动作与遮挡关系清楚，局部玻璃反光稍杂但未碍理解。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"镜中相偎处生发诗眼，含蓄动人。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"孩子惊喜表情直白，玻璃借影之意偏弱。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"娃娃机与布偶可辨，但镜中倒影过淡，借影不确定。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"投币、爪悬、布偶位置成立，孩子动作施受略含混。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"玻璃反光与背景杂点较多，主体尚可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"水彩余韵尚可，但相偎的亲密感未由视角生成。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"娃娃机、布偶可辨，镜中男孩偏向实景而非借影。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"爪悬布偶与张臂动作成立，投币键位置模糊。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩晕染柔和，主体可辨，细节有简化。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"对比柔和，略有诗意。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"孩子贴玻璃伸掌，与镜中影像形成互相注视的余意。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"布偶、娃娃机、爪钩皆清楚，玻璃倒影呼应借影。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"投币按键与爪位关系明确，孩子伸手方向准确。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"层次清晰，玻璃反光与失真控制良好。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"贴窗互望，诗眼借影相偎得到视觉化。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"情绪偏欢喜，相偎的孤单与试误感未落实。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"娃娃机、布偶可辨，但镜中倒影几乎不可见。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"孩子位置与爪子方向不一致，动作关系混乱。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"人物手掌结构有明显畸变，毛绒布偶糊烂。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":-3,"加减分_评":"手部畸变、布偶糊烂，为明显生成缺陷。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"孩子于玻璃外张臂，与倒影相触，孤独与亲近并存。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"夜机、布偶、爪钩、投币口齐全，借影明确。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜晚街景、机器内外、孩子与倒影的空间层次清晰。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面完整，反光与人物结构皆自然。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"镜中倒影与实体相触，极具诗意，乃神来之笔。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"女孩隔窗伸手，与镜中影像相望，相偎之情可感。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"娃娃机、布偶、投币口清晰，倒影存在但稍被玩具遮挡。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"爪悬布偶与孩子伸手方向一致，投币键明确。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰，玩具堆积略杂但主体可见。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"玻璃镜面反射增添余意。"},{"id":8,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"情绪偏热闹，诗中的玻璃借影与许相偎完全缺失。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"娃娃机与布偶可见，但镜中形象系男孩实影非借影。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"孩子位于机器外侧仰视，动作方向与诗中张臂不符。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"画面明亮，但背景杂乱文字干扰视线。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":-1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"环境文字切合但霓虹字稍夺主；乱码未显。"}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp18":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp18","topic":"旧衣回收箱","order":["zhipu","xai","alibaba","meta","bytedance","google","openai","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":95.1,"cost":0.0241846,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"母亲抱幼儿温馨，缺催归与成长对照，情感转向。","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"绿箱红袄可辨，无短袖糖钱，幼童身高不及母肩。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"街边暖光尚可，无斜阳落包与回收动作，场景泛化。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，母子肢体融合，背景杂乱分散。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"夕阳背影留余味，身高及肩可见，但催归往事未成关系。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"绿箱袄短袖可辨，糖钱缺失，攀树迹仅树图案暗示。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"街边斜阳与背包随行成立，回收动作偏弱。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩层次清楚，人物稍小，衣物堆叠可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右上题诗切合，位置不夺主，加1。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"旧衣硬币与孩子及肩并置，有往事感；催归未显。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"绿箱袄短袖与深兜硬币均明，攀树迹未直接画出。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"街边斜阳、取衣与拉衣动作一致，空间清楚。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物衣物清楚，手部略僵，不影响理解。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"短袖口袋硬币与孩子及肩并置，略见巧思，加1。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"硬币刺枝外套有旧痕，毛绒玩具过满，催归未显。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"绿箱硬币及肩成立，短袖袄缺失，刺枝代攀树迹含混。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"街边夕阳与母子牵手成立，取放动作不明确。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，硬币悬浮与箱内杂物削弱组织。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"旧衣硬币与题诗在，幼女身高错，成长对照失效。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"袄与短袖硬币可辨，幼女身高不及肩，攀树迹无。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"街边斜阳与取衣动作成立，孩子身高关系反转诗义。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"画面清楚，手与衣物交接略僵，题诗不夺主。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左上题诗切合，位置不夺主，加1。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"图解式标注补意，情感弱，催归往事未成关系。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"短袖硬币袄半悬及肩可辨，攀树迹仅靠文字标注。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"街边夕阳与母子牵行成立，回收动作偏静。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"插画清楚，标注文字过多，分散主体注意。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"环保投衣日常，缺攀树糖钱往事，催归未显。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"绿箱与及肩孩子可辨，短袖糖钱袄半悬均缺。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"街边斜阳与投衣动作清楚，方向一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物场景清楚，手与衣物略融合，不妨碍。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":8,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"夕阳背影有留白，幼女身高错，成长对照失效。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"袄短袖硬币可辨，幼女不及母肩，攀树迹未见。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"街边斜阳与牵手方向成立，身高关系与诗抵触。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面精致，文字多而不乱，倒影自然。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左侧题诗切合，位置不夺主，加1。"}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp19":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp19","topic":"社区食堂","order":["bytedance","openai","alibaba","google","zhipu","microsoft","meta","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":425.5,"cost":0.0119459648,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"有暖阳与饭香，但未生成洗净留箸待邻的余意","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"一荤两素与竹箸在，缺洗净杯盘与半掩门","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"晚照方向对，但门全开、饭在桌上，非洗净之后","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"构图清晰，主体食桌与窗光组织有序，无明显崩坏","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"用餐人群喧闹，与洗净留箸的静候相反","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"碗盘残羹而非洗净，门未半掩，邻翁在吃不在待","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"落日对，然众人正在用餐，与餐后留箸时序相左","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"前后景层次可辨，人物与桌面虽有杂沓但未遮主体","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"静物暖光近于前两句，后两句余意未显","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"有荤素饭箸，无洗净杯盘、半掩门与邻翁","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"暮光入室对，门全开且是备餐而非餐后","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"光影与形体干净，主次分明，无生成缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"老人进食的满足感，非留箸待邻之留白","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"只有老人用饭，荤素配置不清，洗净门掩俱缺","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"暮色对，但无门半掩，用餐进行时非待邻时","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体老人可辨，室内层次略杂，但不碍读图","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"空椅与暖光略有望意，仍无洗净门掩的关合","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"荤素饭箸齐备，但洗净杯盘与半掩门未画","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"夕照对，门全开，桌前仍是饭食而非洗净","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面简洁，光影完整，桌物与门窗关系清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"老人同桌吃饭，热闹替代了洗净待邻的含蓄","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"有菜饭竹箸，但洗净杯盘、门半掩未落实","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"暮色对，两人正在用餐，无门半掩的餐后空间","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"插画风自洽，但文字和器物稍密，未遮主体","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"洗净碗盘可见，但满桌饭菜与开门未成待邻关系","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"有洗净碗盘与荤素，门全开且饭未收，邻翁未现","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"夕照与洗净碗盘对，但门全开、食物未收，时序混置","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"前景碗盘与背景门、窗外关系清楚，无碍理解","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":8,"意境情感":1,"意境情感_评":"诗字题在墙上，图像未生成待邻的虚实关系","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"饭箸尚在，缺洗净杯盘；末句仅以文字出现","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"暮色对，门开非半掩，桌上饭菜未收，非餐后","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩质感统一，墙字略夺目，仍可辨认画面主体","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"deepseek-vision_shp20":{"judge":"deepseek-vision","id":"shp20","topic":"社区食堂","order":["google","alibaba","zhipu","bytedance","meta","openai","xai","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":36.0,"cost":0.002882,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"雨巷送餐与临窗笑语构成对照，但温情稍直白","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"蓝衣取盒、白发临窗、笋尖汤等关键物象皆可辨","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"雨冷巷中、外卖车铃与橱窗交谈方位关系准确","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰，人物动作与场景组织自洽","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"文字多且清晰切合，但略显说明性"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"雨夜亮灯气氛温馨，但对照关系较平淡","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"蓝衣取盒、二老对坐、明日预告可辨","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"雨巷、送餐与堂食同框，方位基本成立","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"整体清晰，但外卖盒叠放与手部结构稍生硬","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":-1,"加减分_评":"招牌文字切合，外卖盒与手部有轻微伪影"},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"拼贴分格图解诗意，情绪与余意被概念化","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"价目、软饭、笋汤、外送与老人同桌均出现","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"分格导致空间关系割裂，场景无法统一读通","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"各格尚清楚，但拼贴割裂整体空间连续性","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":-1,"加减分_评":"分格割裂时空，部分线条与肢体有轻微伪影"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"题诗占位过满，画面关系被文字挤占","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"社区食堂、蓝衣取餐、白发老人、笋尖汤俱在","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"雨巷与堂食场景可辨，但题字遮挡部分空间","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面总体清晰，场景细节丰富","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":-2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗清晰且切合，但占据左侧过多，喧宾夺主"},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"送餐背影与窗内热汤姜香构成含蓄呼应","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"蓝衣取盒、白发临窗、笋尖姜汤皆明确可辨","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"门外雨巷与门内厨房位置、动作施受自然","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"内外层次分明，蒸汽与食材细节组织良好","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"明日菜单牌框住笋尖汤，文字不夺主"},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"雨巷外卖与窗内老人对谈，情调接近但稍显直白","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"蓝衣取盒、软饭、笋尖汤、社区食堂清晰","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"街巷、窗口与外卖车的位置关系合理","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画面清整，主体动作连续可辨","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"菜单与招牌文字切合，位置得当"},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"情境温暖，但物象堆叠偏向插画式叙事","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"送餐车、老人、大锅笋汤、菜单牌齐全","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"露天石桌就餐与诗中堂食略偏，尚能读通","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画风统一，但人物表情与姿态略带刻板","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"文字切合且不夺主，稍多但仍可接受"},{"id":8,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"题诗错字干扰，画面情绪被文字说明取代","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"蓝衣送餐、老人、笋尖汤可见，但关键意象仓促","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"雨巷外卖与窗口取餐关系可辨，但细节较乱","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"左侧题诗占位大，部分细节粘连模糊","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":-3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":-1,"加减分_评":"题诗错字多且占位过大，乱码伪字明显"}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp01":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp01","topic":"旧衣回收箱","order":["openai","google","alibaba","microsoft","zhipu","xai","meta"],"ok":true,"secs":505.9,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"黄昏暖光衬犹豫感，未落实针痕认人的核心余意","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"核心物象齐全，箱体微掉漆，剪落名签为商品吊牌","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"秋日临街黄昏场景成立，未呈现箱门闭合的收尾状态","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰可辨，手部存在轻微畸变，不影响理解","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"直白贴‘闭’字点题，无含蓄余味，未涉针痕意蕴","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"核心物象可辨，刻意加贴‘闭’字，剪落名签形态含混","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"白日临街商铺场景成立，箱门闭合，动作关系基本清晰","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，手部存在较明显畸变，局部元素突兀","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"投递口贴‘闭’字不符合现实，为刻意点题的硬伤"},{"id":3,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"仅呈现撕领标动作，无本诗专属怅惘与针痕表达","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"童衫缺失换为成人衬衫，无剪刀，回收箱标识缺‘箱’字","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"白日临街场景成立，未呈现剪名签、闭箱门的核心动作","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，手部畸变较明显，近景构图局促","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"童衫换为成人衣，以手撕代剪，违背诗句核心设定"},{"id":4,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"阴雨天衬愁绪，全诗题墙直白点题，无含蓄余味","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"箱体旧损不符‘漆色新’，名签贴箱外，箱门未闭","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"雨巷场景可辨，未完成剪签闭箱动作，逻辑存瑕","画面质量":4,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，手部微畸，墙上题字占比过大显突兀","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"墙上题诗漏字且占比过大，箱体漆旧不符诗句"},{"id":5,"意境情感":0,"意境情感_评":"无人物无动作，仅堆列箱与衣，无诗中情感关联","意象物象":1,"意象物象_评":"箱体似邮筒且锈旧，无人物，衣物非童衫，吊牌乱码","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"街边场景可辨，无人物无动作，核心投衣事件不成立","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰，油画质感连贯，无明显结构崩坏问题","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":3,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"无核心人物动作，箱体误为邮筒，标签含乱码伪字"},{"id":6,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"氛围萧瑟，人物与箱体无互动，未形成诗中情感联结","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"箱体锈旧，人物疏离箱体，无剪刀，剪签动作缺失","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"老旧街巷场景可辨，核心投衣剪签动作缺失，人物错位","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰，灰调质感统一，无明显结构或肢体瑕疵","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱体锈旧，人物与箱体无互动，核心事件未成立"},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"人留画外留白，以线头应针痕，空寂感合诗意，惜衣未投","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"核心物象齐全，针痕以线头呈现，箱体无投递口，衣置箱顶","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"秋日临街场景成立，箱门闭合，无投递口致投衣逻辑存疑","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰，冷调质感统一，无明显生成瑕疵","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"以线头应针痕、人隐画外为妙构，惜无投递口存瑕"}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp02":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp02","topic":"深夜视频","order":["google","zhipu","openai","meta","alibaba","microsoft","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":509.8,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"仅绘通话时笑意，未表现屏暗惊鬓灰的怅然转折。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"手持手机视频、老人白发可辨，未表现屏暗如镜状态。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"深夜室内环境明确，仅呈现通话中阶段，未及话尽。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物物件清晰可辨，主次分明，无明显结构缺陷。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"仅见老者凝思神态，缺失视频、惊鬓灰的情感关联。","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"手机持握方向颠倒，无视频内容或暗镜照影呈现。","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"昏暗环境近深夜，持机动作错误，核心事件难成立。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物形体清晰可辨，无粘连、断裂等生成缺陷。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"有视频笑意与白发怅惘，但暗镜载体错位，转折弱。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"视频载体为笔记本非掌中手机，暗镜为旁置手机。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"深夜临窗月夜山城景明确，时空关系无明显冲突。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰可辨，局部抓头的手有结构粘连瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"书脊位置存在局部乱码伪字，不遮挡主体。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"情绪过度惊恐夸张，偏离诗中怅然惊觉的基调。","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"误将屏黑反光修辞，画为屏显自身衰老影像。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"深夜室内场景成立，屏内空间错位，事件逻辑偏离。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物物件清晰可辨，组织有序，无明显结构缺陷。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"笔记本边角存在局部伪汉字，不遮挡主体。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"黑屏照见自身惊态点出诗眼，缺前半笑语铺垫。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"手持手机、黑屏映面、鬓灰可辨，未现视频对象。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"深夜室内光线昏暗，持机看屏动作成立，层次单一。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物神态自然，形体清晰，无妨碍理解的缺陷。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"黑屏映出惊态，暗合屏暗照鬓的诗眼。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"仅绘视频中对方笑意，靠题字补意，未表现转折。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"视频载体为平板，仅显通话对方，无屏暗照鬓表现。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"深夜山景夜窗氛围贴合，仅呈通话中阶段，无层次。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画风统一连贯，主体形体清晰，主次关系明确。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗有错字，位置较醒目，纸面字倒错。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"以屏外夜山衬千里相隔，掌中见笑语，未及屏暗转折。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"掌中手机、视频笑貌、千山可辨，未呈屏暗照鬓状态。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"深夜月下山景与屏内空间分层清晰，隔地关系明确。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"风格统一，主次分明，无妨碍理解的生成伪影。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"屏外千山衬屏内笑颜，妙合隔地相通诗意。"}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp03":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp03","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","order":["alibaba","zhipu","meta","xai","openai","google","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":343.3,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"湿雨氛围衬新移栽树的孱弱，吊液与雨丝呼应自然","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"移栽带土球的树、吊瓶、新叶、雨景均准确可辨","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"春日雨天城市街道，树列透视正确，空间关系协调","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"写实清晰，主次分明，无粘连畸变等生成缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"古街商铺氛围热闹，靠大段题诗交代诗义，哀感不足","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"可见树、吊瓶、新叶，但树无移栽土球，根系裸露街面","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"雨天街景成立，但树植于街心石板无树坑，空间错位","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"线条清晰可辨，但输液管缠绕怪异，文字占幅过大","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗错漏重复占幅过大，喧宾夺主"},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"湿润朦胧氛围接近诗意，但“错认”的视觉转折未落实","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"移栽树、土球、吊瓶、新叶可辨，但输液管悬空未插树干","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"春日湿润街巷场景可辨，但输液动作施受关系错误","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩笔触连贯，景物清晰，无明显畸变或粘连","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"输液管未插树干悬空滴液，违背树木输液常识"},{"id":4,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"靠树牌与角落题诗交代内容，树种石墩缺乏哀怜氛围","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"可见吊瓶、新叶、雨景，但树无土球植于石墩内","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"雨天街景可辨，但树植于石墩，输液管插入石墩逻辑错","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"水彩风格景物清晰，但多处文字分散观者注意力","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":3,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"树牌带乱码，树种石墩无土，违背生长常识"},{"id":5,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"濛濛雨雾里柳丝、输液管、雨丝交融，暗合错认哀感","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"移栽缠干的街树、吊瓶、新柳、细雨均准确，双关巧妙","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"春日细雨老街，树列沿道延伸，远近层次清晰协调","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"写实细腻，近实远虚主次分明，无生成缺陷","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"垂露柳丝与管、雨交融，具象化“错认”诗眼"},{"id":6,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"半透明字板遮挡画面，无雨景哀感，物象泛化","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"仅可见幼树、吊瓶，缺雨景，诗句错漏重复","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"晴天白日街景，与诗中雨脚设定抵触，画面被字板割裂","画面质量":3,"画面质量_评":"半透明文字板遮挡半幅画面，拼贴感强，割裂视觉","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"错字诗句做半透板挡画面，喧宾夺主且无雨景"},{"id":7,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"烟雨朦胧氛围接近诗意，但靠题字、招牌点题，余味不足","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"带土球的树、吊瓶、新叶、雨景可辨，“故山”误作店名","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"春日雨街远山层次可见，但树置街面无树坑，位置错位","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"国画笔法连贯，景物可辨，但输液管漏液显得怪异","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题字有错，“故山”作招牌生硬，树置街面违常识"}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp04":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp04","topic":"云仓夜扫","order":["microsoft","openai","meta","xai","zhipu","alibaba","google"],"ok":true,"secs":396.8,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"依赖错乱题诗、鸡汤文字抒情，无视觉余味","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"有仓、机械臂等物，残签变鸡汤文，未呼应竹枝声","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"拂晓天色基本契合，人物伫足未扫，空间稍杂","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"漫画风格形体连贯，主体可辨，无严重结构问题","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗乱序错字，额外鸡汤标语繁多，喧宾夺主"},{"id":2,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"靠仓门横幅抄句点题，无夜扫怀乡情绪层次","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"无扫帚、停置机械臂，夜扫变为扫码验货动作","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"同框现午夜圆月与朝阳，昼夜时间逻辑矛盾","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"写实形体清晰，场景组织顺畅，无明显生成缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"横幅直书诗句，搭配企业标语，内容突兀违和"},{"id":3,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"无人物行动支撑，靠纸面直写诗句，情调空泛","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"缺夜扫核心人物，扫帚弃置，无清扫动作呈现","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"拂晓光候准确，仓内到门外的空间关系顺畅","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"静物形体材质清晰，无结构断裂或粘连缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"机械臂现乱码文字，纸面挂条直白抄写诗句"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"拂晓清寂氛围贴合，怀乡情绪可感，表达略直白","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"有清扫者、仓、车、竹，缺机械臂，误用煤油灯","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"拂晓光候准确，门外古村与现代云仓略有违和","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"油画质感统一，人物动作自然，无明显伪影","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"侧边全录原诗，故里标识木牌过大，稍显刻意"},{"id":5,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"仅为普通作业场景，无本诗清寂怀乡的特定感","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"无扫帚、停置机械臂、竹枝，夜扫动作完全缺失","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"天色大亮，机械臂仍运转，违背收工夜扫设定","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"工业场景形体清晰，仅地面文字反向，无大崩坏","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"地面单据文字为反向乱码，无法辨识有效内容"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"明暗层次衬出人物持签的沉静，乡思含蓄有余味","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"核心名物动作均准，竹扫帚暗合竹枝声的意象","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"欲晓光候准确，仓内到车门的空间层次清晰顺承","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"写实形体准确，主次分明，无粘连畸变等缺陷","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"停扫捧签暗合“分外轻”诗眼，单字准确切题"},{"id":7,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"空仓清冷感尚可，靠地面字点村名，余味不足","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"有清扫者、货架、车，缺机械臂，货架全空置","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"天色大亮，货车朝仓内行驶，不符待发离仓设定","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"影调沉郁统一，人物动作自然，无明显生成缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"地面纸片直写村名、故里，表达过于刻意直白"}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp05":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp05","topic":"深夜视频","order":["xai","openai","google","meta","alibaba","zhipu","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":356.3,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"屏暖夜寒的明暗对比，衬出隔海思念的温凉感","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"核心物象齐备，多出冗余黑屏手机，菊位稍欠妥","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"深夜跨屏空间明确，海与被褥笔触相近略模糊","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"核心形体清晰可辨，无明显妨碍理解的缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"分镜表现通话到屏暗，手穿屏过实削弱隔屏余韵","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"核心物象可辨，错将屏中影像画为穿屏实体","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"分镜区分通话前后，穿屏设计混淆虚实边界","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"分镜组织清晰，人物形体连贯无明显畸变","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"手穿出屏幕设计，违背隔屏视频的基本逻辑"},{"id":3,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"主体视点颠倒，仅余视频通话泛化符号无余韵","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"施受关系颠倒，多冗余手机，人物畸变生三只手","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"核心场景错位，异乡寒床被处理为厨房背景","画面质量":3,"画面质量_评":"人物出现三只手畸变，重复设备干扰核心主体","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":3,"加减分_评":"人物生成三只手的严重畸变，违背生理常识"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"冷室孤床衬屏内暖意，情绪贴合但余韵表现不足","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"核心名物可辨，屏内菊位置失真，缺隔海元素","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"深夜跨屏关系成立，缺少隔海的关键空间线索","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰形体连贯，无妨碍理解的生成缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"暗室暖屏情绪贴合，靠右侧题字点题，余韵较弱","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"核心名物齐备，缺少隔海对应的空间意象","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"深夜跨屏场景明确，无隔海的视觉空间证据","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"动漫风格统一，形体清晰组织连贯无缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右侧竖排诗题过大，位置稍显喧宾夺主"},{"id":6,"意境情感":1,"意境情感_评":"无视频通话核心关系，仅老人弄菜，情感完全偏离","意象物象":1,"意象物象_评":"关键对象缺失，晚菊错为向日葵，无游子无视频","时空场景":1,"时空场景_评":"无异地跨屏时空，核心视频通话事件不成立","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"单个老人形体清晰，无关文字占据画面上下区域","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"上下乱入无关大字，晚菊错为向日葵，情节全失"},{"id":7,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"母子置于同一空间，失隔屏距离感，靠题字凑诗意","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"母亲错为同室在场非屏中影像，题字多错讹","时空场景":1,"时空场景_评":"核心时空错位，异地母子被处理为同室相对","画面质量":4,"画面质量_评":"人物形体可辨，平板与母亲位置逻辑混乱","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"墙与笔记本题字错讹乱码，失隔屏异地核心意"}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp06":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp06","topic":"天台菜园","order":["meta","google","microsoft","xai","zhipu","alibaba","openai"],"ok":true,"secs":441.1,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"不同阶段物象拼合，情绪割裂，余味不足","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"畦、藤管、缸、虫叶、煮具备，人物动作逻辑有误","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"晚晴天台空间成立，人物动作与时序冲突","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"多数形体清晰，仅抬手处有轻微结构瑕疵","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"动作时序错位，蜡烛煮羹违常识，手部有畸变"},{"id":2,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"暮色城景衬客居感，未涉及瓜熟唤邻意涵","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"梯、畦、藤管、缸、羹可辨，缺熟瓜、叩门动作","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"暮色天台、梯位正确，人物持壶动作指向模糊","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水墨风格连贯，形体清晰，布局疏朗有序","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"边角重复题字冗余，缺失负土、唤邻核心事件"},{"id":3,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"靠题字补诗意，未形成客居唤邻的视觉关系","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"畦、藤管、瓜、缸、煮具有，缺梯，邻人位置错位","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"晚晴天台成立，邻人在对面楼，动作时序平泛","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩风格连贯，形体清晰，布局平稳","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗多处错字漏字，邻人位置错置背离诗意"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"叩门暮色稍有氛围，细节偏差多，余味不足","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"畦、煮具、叩门有，藤未绕管，储水器、梯位错","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"夕照天台成立，物件方位多处偏差，动作单一","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"写实质感统一，形体清晰，明暗层次协调","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗语序错乱漏句，藤未绕管、梯位错置"},{"id":5,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"物象错杂无生活感，换同题材诗亦可成立","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"菜为观叶植物，瓜挂树枝，缺架、锅、梯核心物","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"夕照、叩门可辨，物件空间关系多处错置","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"主体轮廓可辨，局部材质失真，手部有畸形","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":3,"AI伪影":2,"加减分_评":"瓜长树枝、菜非食用，手部畸变，材质失真严重"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"端羹叩门情态真切，暮色城景衬邻里暖意","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"虫叶、缸、羹、瓜、叩门准确，藤未绕管，架影弱","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"向晚光候准确，天台邻门位置恰当，动作自然","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"形体真实自然，光影连贯，无明显结构瑕疵","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"端羹叩门有巧思，门牌文字准确，藤未绕管有偏差"},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"邻人探首呼应唤邻，烟火中见客居温厚余味","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"绕藤、架影、虫叶、羹、瓜等核心物象均精准","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"夕照晚晴天台层次清，劳作应门时序协和","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"光影自然，形体准确生动，无崩坏主次分明","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"邻人应门暗合诗眼，各细节贴合诗意，无错漏伪影"}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp07":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp07","topic":"云端相册","order":["zhipu","openai","xai","google","meta","alibaba","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":322.6,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"仅展现观旧照展笑，未传达裁照停手的不忍情绪","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"平板、屏中缺齿孩童可辨，围裙属观者，缺裁照物象","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"室内日间场景清晰，现实与旧照层次可辨，缺裁照动作","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面写实清晰，人物、设备形体连贯无明显畸变","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"怀旧氛围到位，未呈现不忍裁去围裙的迟疑情绪","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"剪刀、缺齿旧照齐备，旧照中未呈现围裙元素","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"窗边日间家居场景清楚，现实与旧照层次分明","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰可辨，点屏手部有轻微畸变，不影响理解","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"抄诗点题，将云端实体化，未生成对应情感关系","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"误将云存储画为实体云，旧照孩童缺齿特征缺失","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"虚拟云与现实桌台混置，时空逻辑缺乏一致性","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"水彩风格统一，大段题字占侧边，主体仍可辨识","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"抄全诗于侧边喧宾夺主，误将云端画为实体云"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"呈现专注观旧照状态，未体现裁照时的迟疑眷恋","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"屏中缺齿围裙孩童旧照准确，缺裁照相关物象","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"日间窗边家居场景明晰，现实与屏幕层次清楚","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰，触屏手部有轻微粘连，不影响辨识","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"裁框露待裁半截围裙，笔停未落，恰合不忍迟疑","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"云端界面、缺齿孩童、裁框、半截围裙均合诗意","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"日间家居场景协调，屏幕操作与现实层次清晰","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰规整，人物、界面形体连贯无明显错误","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"停笔待裁的设计妙合诗眼，界面文字准确自然"},{"id":6,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"暖调氛围温馨，仅现裁框，未传停手不忍的眷恋","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"屏中缺齿围裙孩童、裁框可辨，无待裁半截围裙","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"傍晚厨房暖光场景协调，现实与旧照层次清晰","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面柔和清晰，持板手部轻微偏差不影响辨识","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":1,"意境情感_评":"错将旧照画为缺齿老人，靠鸡汤文字堆砌情绪","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"核心物象错位，屏中为缺齿老人而非孩童旧照","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"颠倒今昔层次，将老年形象误置于旧照位置","画面质量":4,"画面质量_评":"主体轮廓可辨，手部有畸变，杂字分散注意力","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":3,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"旧照主体错位，满屏错字鸡汤文字喧宾夺主"}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp08":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp08","topic":"抓娃娃机","order":["zhipu","google","openai","alibaba","meta","microsoft","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":534.3,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"仅呈现观机泛化喜悦，未传落空牵手的温意","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"核心物件可辨，机内多无关扭蛋，缺关键状态物象","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"铁爪与小熊无接触，手位偏高无法操作机器","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，主次清楚，局部细节略有违和","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":-1,"AI伪影":-1,"加减分_评":"父亲手部结构畸变粘连，操作手位不符合常识"},{"id":2,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"有孩童扯袖的期待感，未体现落空后的转折","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"核心物件可辨，铁爪抓熊的状态符合过程阶段","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"电玩城场景正确，催换钱与抓熊动作时序冲突","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰，人物结构正常，主次关系明确","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":-1,"硬伤穿帮":-1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"顶部霓虹为乱码，不同阶段动作存在时序错位"},{"id":3,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"分镜呈现从期待到落空再牵手的温意，余味充足","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"核心名物状态准确，未将未得熊误作已获得","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"分块呈现多时间节点，光色协调，动作关系准确","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"分块组织清晰，人物形象统一，无明显畸变","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"归途牵手背影暗合诗旨，巧思动人无额外错漏"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"有摊手牵手的温感，但缺少过程张力，情绪偏平","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"核心物件可辨，空掌、牵手状态契合诗意","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"商场场景正确，动作关系成立，仅呈单一结束瞬间","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰，人物结构正常，主次组织清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":-1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"机内小熊尺寸过大，不符合抓娃娃机常规设置"},{"id":5,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"有孩童扯袖仰头的娇态，转折关系表现不足","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"核心物件可辨，冗余小熊干扰“无一物”的表达","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"电玩城场景正确，人物位置基本成立，局部错位","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"整体可辨，人物结构正常，局部元素较突兀","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":-2,"AI伪影":-1,"加减分_评":"面板无端凸出熊头，元素错位干扰核心表达"},{"id":6,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"靠鸡汤文字渲染情绪，无本诗特定转折与余味","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"核心物件可辨，多无依据雨景，物象泛化","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"无端增设雨夜场景，动作单一，缺少时序逻辑","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"形体可辨，大量文字挤占空间，干扰主体观看","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":-4,"硬伤穿帮":-1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗错字连篇，无关鸡汤文字喧宾夺主"},{"id":7,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"氛围软萌温馨，但较泛化，靠底字补足内容缺项","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"核心物件可辨，熊眠、踮脚、牵手状态准确","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"暖调游艺场场景正确，人物位置动作协调","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩风格连贯统一，形体清晰，主次分明","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"底部抄录全诗补足未画内容，无明显错漏"}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp09":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp09","topic":"夜航俯瞰","order":["microsoft","xai","zhipu","alibaba","google","meta","openai"],"ok":true,"secs":686.0,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"冷夜暖灯氛围贴合，孩童望窗呼应诗意，题字稍扰余韵","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"核心物象齐备，野路车灯如萤的表现零散模糊","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜间俯瞰关系成立，云层位置稍削弱高空纵深感","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"核心形体清晰可辨，主次分明，无生成类缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题字存多处错字漏句，未遮挡核心画面"},{"id":2,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"夜景氛围接近，缺机上视角独特关联，余意不足","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"缺失核心意象机翼，多余小窗不符合机舱逻辑","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"夜间俯瞰视角成立，空间存局部矛盾，飞航感不足","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰可辨，乱码文字稍分散注意，无严重缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题字除标题外均为无法辨识的乱码伪字"},{"id":3,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"大字割裂画面，月亮尺度过大，缺乏含蓄余韵","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"核心物象基本齐备，月亮视觉比例严重失当","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰关系成立，月亮失度破坏高空纵深尺度","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"景物主体清晰，大字醒目分散注意，无生成缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"粗白大字横亘核心景观区，严重喧宾夺主"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"机内暖冷对照贴合氛围，孩童凝望自然，缺山景","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"多数核心物象可辨，缺失诗句明确提及的山形","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜航时空关系准确，动作方位合理，远景无山","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰结构连贯，主次分明，无理解妨碍缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"孩童未望窗外，无法呼应诗眼，视觉关系偏离诗意","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"月相不符皓月，孩童未作望窗姿态，山形缺失","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"夜间机内场景成立，孩童动作、月相存关键偏差","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"主体景物清晰可辨，结构连贯，无生成类缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"夜航静谧氛围贴合，孩童姿态生动，野地散点稍突兀","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"核心物象齐全，野地散点误将萤之喻体画作实体","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜航方位关系正确，层次清晰，高空纵深感稍弱","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"风格统一连贯，主体清晰，无妨碍理解的缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"明暗疏密呼应空寂情调，孩童凝望，灯星难辨余味足","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"核心名物齐备，喻体对应合理，无错漏冗余物象","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"夜航光候准确，层次分明，高空纵深感强，方位合理","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰层次分明，视觉连贯，无生成类缺陷","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"云雾遮绕灯星相映，以视觉点出“错认”诗眼"}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp10":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp10","topic":"机场送别","order":["meta","alibaba","xai","microsoft","zhipu","google","openai"],"ok":true,"secs":422.4,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"玻璃隔人对视贴合离愁，未落实登机后心绪转折","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"核心送别名物齐全，手仍握行李未贴合“离身”表述","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"隔玻璃送别空间成立，母亲侧见到达标识，略有偏差","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰，人物与物件层次清楚，无明显生成缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"机场标识、航班屏文字准确贴合诗意，位置得当"},{"id":2,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"隔玻璃对视有不舍感，情绪泛化，无后续情绪转进","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"隔人玻璃可辨，行者无随身行李，航班屏文字错漏多","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"隔玻璃机场空间成立，未表现航程、舱中等后续层次","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"人物主体可辨，手部有轻微畸变，屏面文字错乱","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"航班屏有错字拼写错误，手部存在轻微生成畸变"},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"试图串联送别与舱中情绪，虚实融合生硬缺余味","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"核心送别名物齐备，航班屏字乱码，人物重复叠置","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"候机厅与机舱场景无边界混融，时空层次冲突","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"油画风格统一，叠置人物边界模糊，局部细节糊烂","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":2,"加减分_评":"航班屏文字为乱码，场景无规则融合，局部细节糊化"},{"id":4,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"阴雨氛围贴合离愁，靠左方题诗补意，无后续层次","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"核心送别名物可辨，航班屏地名拼写有误，手未离行李","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"隔玻璃送别空间成立，阴雨天有寒感，无跨时空层次","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"画面主体清晰，左侧题诗占据近三分之一幅面","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"左侧题全诗占幅过大，航班屏地名错，手部轻微畸变"},{"id":5,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"母亲立于停机坪侧违背常识，情感无诗句依据","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"隔人玻璃误作外墙，送者处于机坪禁入区域","时空场景":1,"时空场景_评":"送者位置违反机场流程，核心送别空间逻辑不成立","画面质量":4,"画面质量_评":"人物主体可辨，手部比例失调畸变，屏显为无效红条","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":3,"AI伪影":2,"加减分_评":"送者处机坪禁入区违常识，手部畸变，屏显乱码"},{"id":6,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"两侧人物长幼差异弱，酷似同龄人，母子情感难成立","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"核心物象大体可辨，人物身份模糊，航班屏字模糊错乱","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"隔玻璃空间成立，人物指玻璃，无后续时空层次","画面质量":4,"画面质量_评":"人物面部可辨，手部存在多指畸变，细节有伪影","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":3,"加减分_评":"人物长幼差异弱难辨母子，手部多指畸形，屏字模糊"},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"分幅串联送别到舱中情绪，转进自然，贴合离愁牵挂","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"核心名物、身份、动作均准确，无关键物象错漏","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"三区分列送别、航程、舱中，时空层次清晰逻辑顺","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰，各部分形体动作连贯，无明显生成缺陷","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"分区叙事暗合添衣牵挂的诗眼，环境文字准确妥当"}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp11":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp11","topic":"夜航俯瞰","order":["meta","openai","alibaba","microsoft","google","zhipu","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":358.1,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"冷雨湿窗，隔雾寻踪的怅惘凉感自然流露","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"舷窗、长街、沿河灯火、触窗指尖均可辨认","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"雨夜夜景俯瞰成立，仅视角高度略低于常规航高","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"水珠细节自然，形体清晰，无明显生成瑕疵","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"玻璃雨珠与指尖雾痕暗合指尖凉的触感"},{"id":2,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"都市繁华感突出，寻旧巷的沉静怅惘不足","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"核心物象具备，但手为摊开姿态，灯火过于连续","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜间民航俯瞰视角成立，手触窗动作不准确","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰锐利，城市细节自然，无明显伪影","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"暗调疏灯，单指点窗的疏离感贴合寻旧怅惘","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"核心物象精准，沿河断续灯火、触窗指尖契合","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"夜间高空俯瞰尺度准确，动作、方位均贴合","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"明暗层次清晰，形体自然，无生成瑕疵","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"指尖玻璃雾痕巧妙暗示玻璃寒凉的触感"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"夜色静谧，但手掌摊开，题字削弱了视觉留白","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"核心物象具备，但手为摊开姿态，城景层次杂","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"夜间视角存在，但天空占比过大，俯瞰感不足","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面细腻，光影自然，无明显结构瑕疵","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"倚赖人物表情，诡异邻窗人脸破坏诗中氛围","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"核心物象部分存在，冗余人物占比大致重点偏移","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"夜间俯瞰视角存在，但舱内舷窗空间逻辑错乱","画面质量":3,"画面质量_评":"存在融脸穿帮，手部姿态畸变，干扰理解","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":2,"加减分_评":"邻窗人脸不符合机舱逻辑，手部存结构畸变"},{"id":6,"意境情感":1,"意境情感_评":"大字覆盖核心区域，全靠文字点题，无余韵","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"核心物象被文字遮挡，机翼突兀，手未触观景处","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"夜间视角存在，但手未对景，机翼空间位置错乱","画面质量":3,"画面质量_评":"粗体大字大面积遮挡核心区域，干扰信息读取","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"粗体全诗大字遮蔽核心，排版突兀喧宾夺主"},{"id":7,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"灯河蜿蜒向远，指尖触窗的微凉怅惘余味悠长","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"核心物象精准契合，长街细、灯火断续均体现","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"夜间高空俯瞰尺度准确，动作、方位层次一致","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"油画笔触连贯统一，形体清晰无生成瑕疵","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"指尖冷雾妙合诗眼，边角题字雅致不夺主"}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp12":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp12","topic":"云端相册","order":["meta","alibaba","microsoft","google","openai","xai","zhipu"],"ok":true,"secs":507.6,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"怀旧情绪温和，故堂为现实场景，未传开屏忆旧虚实感","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"核心名物均可辨，仅将忆中故堂陈设设为现实物件","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"观屏动作成立，惟故堂与屏内场景的虚实层次错位","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰写实，形体动作连贯，无干扰理解的瑕疵","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"以屏分隔今昔虚实，怀旧情调准确，稍借题字点题","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"核心名物、身份可辨，次要现代陈设符合场景逻辑","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"今昔空间分层清晰，白日光线协调，惟观屏手势稍欠","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"插画风格统一，形体清晰连贯，无干扰理解的瑕疵","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右上角题字雅致端正，位置得当不干扰主体"},{"id":3,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"堆砌怀旧符号，抄录全诗补境，观者身份错位","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"部分故堂物可辨，核心白头观者身份不符，场景错位","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"观屏动作成立，观者年龄不符，场景层次混杂不清","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"主体动作可辨，手部略有瑕疵，无关文字分散注意","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"墙面、杯身、书籍多无关冗余文字，喧宾夺主"},{"id":4,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"怀旧感仅靠表情传递，虚实层次错位，诗味较淡","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"多数故堂物件可辨，屏中孩童偏大，故堂陈设错位","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"观屏动作成立，故堂景设为现实，孩童状态不符","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰写实，主体动作可辨，无严重生成畸变","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"平板界面文字为乱码伪字，无法准确辨识"},{"id":5,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"以云海具象云端喻义，今昔层次清，怀旧情绪蕴藉","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"核心名物身份全可辨，云端修辞的视觉对应巧妙","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"现实-云海-故堂三层分界清，动作准，光线协调","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画面层次清晰，形体连贯自然，无干扰理解的缺陷","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"云海构思想象精妙，平板文字准确自然不突兀"},{"id":6,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"仅绘老人抱娃看纸照，情为泛化天伦，无忆旧虚实","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"核心屏、云端意象缺失，纸照代电子屏，婴儿身份错位","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"无跨时空层次，全幅同置旧屋，核心忆境未建立","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"国风风格统一，物象形体可辨，无大面积结构崩坏","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗错将‘犹’写为‘猪’，抄全诗喧宾夺主"},{"id":7,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"婴孩绘为浮空幻影，缺慈亲旧景，情感逻辑怪异","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"核心慈亲形象缺失，黑屏无内容，误将洋葱作挂蒜","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"无时空层次区分，浮空婴孩混同现实，事件不成立","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"漫画风格统一，主体外形可辨，无大面积结构断裂","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"线装书页为伪汉字，字形错乱无法辨识"}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp13":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp13","topic":"机场送别","order":["meta","google","zhipu","microsoft","xai","openai","alibaba"],"ok":true,"secs":332.4,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"空廊孤掌对暮色，留白尽显人去景空的怅惘","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"长廊、航灯、登机标识、玻璃掌痕核心物象准确","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"暮色昏沉，长廊纵深与远灯方位完全贴合诗意","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰连贯，光影协调，无畸变或结构问题","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"空廊诠释“只剩”诗眼，标识文字准确得当"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"手贴玻璃的送别姿态到位，未体现“只剩”的空寂","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"机场、玻璃、掌痕可辨，缺失闸机相关明确物象","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"暮色候机廊光候准确，过闸动线与方位模糊","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面写实清晰，人物结构正常，无明显缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"远处指示牌文字糊化，轻微影响观感"},{"id":3,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"抄写诗句代视觉表达，无离别情绪的视觉关联","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"未画出玻璃掌痕，核心物象缺失，航班屏乱码","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"暮色时间准确，横置玻璃阻断闸道，逻辑不通","画面质量":4,"画面质量_评":"人物被玻璃错位切割，局部糊化，主体勉强可辨","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"核心区抄诗喧宾夺主，玻璃挡道违背空间常识"},{"id":4,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"隔窗去留关系衬离愁，题诗加雨稍减含蓄余味","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"廊桥、掌痕、航机等核心物象准确，额外添雨景","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"暮色廊桥空间动线准确，雨景无诗句依据","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水墨风格统一连贯，人物结构正常无畸变","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"孤影长廊暮色沉郁，掌痕偏离望灯的视线关系","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"登机标识、航机可辨，掌痕在侧墙而非望机长窗","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"暮色廊桥光候准确，按墙动作不符望灯的方位","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"油画质感统一协调，人物结构正常无缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"去留姿态显离别意，夕阳过亮削弱昏沉氛围","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"长廊、登机标识、掌痕、航机等物象准确","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"空间动线准确，夕阳明亮不符暮色昏的设定","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画面写实清晰，人物结构正常，光影自然","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":1,"意境情感_评":"悬浮巨手氛围怪诞，完全背离送别的怅惘基调","意象物象":1,"意象物象_评":"错将玻璃掌痕画为立体巨手，核心修辞误读","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"暮色闸口场景可辨，巨手悬浮致空间逻辑崩坏","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"环境闸机部分清晰，核心巨手突兀怪异","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":3,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"误将掌痕画为立体巨手，严重违背诗意常识"}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp14":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp14","topic":"天台菜园","order":["microsoft","google","xai","zhipu","meta","alibaba","openai"],"ok":true,"secs":444.3,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"整体氛围宁静，未表现忽见灯火的转折，依赖题字","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"瓮、瓜豆架、灯火、月齐备，结瓜偏多不害义","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"黄昏月夜高台位置对，人物背对灯火无视线互动","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"国画笔法清晰，组织有序，无明显生成缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题字漏句错字极多，内容失真占据边角"},{"id":2,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"氛围平实闲适，未表现忽见灯火的瞬间感","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"核心物象可辨，盛水器为带嘴洒壶，略偏离抱瓮","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"暮夜高台场景成立，人物视线专注菜畦未看灯火","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"漫画风格线条清晰，主体明确无严重瑕疵","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题字诗题错写“天合菜园”，出现错字"},{"id":3,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"人物扒墙浇菜姿态违和，未形成见灯火的关系","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"瓮、瓜豆架、灯火、月可辨，女墙为残断圆弧状","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"人物位于女墙外侧，与登台浇菜的方位相悖","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"做旧质感统一，形体可辨，无严重结构崩坏","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题旁印章为无法辨认的伪篆字"},{"id":4,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"氛围偏沉静，无见灯火的呼应，作物形态偏差大","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"竹架空悬无藤蔓，盛器为敞口盆，瓜豆苗特征缺失","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"深夜高台位置可辨，天已全黑，人物背对灯火","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"写实风格清晰，主体明确，手部存在轻微瑕疵","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":2,"加减分_评":"人物扶菜的手部结构畸变，存在AI生成伪影"},{"id":5,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"氛围安闲清冷，灯火仅为背景，无忽见的转折表现","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"瓮、垛口女墙、瓜豆架、灯火、月均准确可辨","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"黄昏蓝调光候准确，视线受遮挡难见墙外灯火","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"写实画面清晰自然，主体突出，无明显缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"人物侧头低视姿态，恰合浇菜时忽见灯火的瞬间","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"核心物象齐备，瓮、矮墙、瓜藤、灯火、月均贴合","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"光候、高台方位、动作视线高度契合诗中情境","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰自然，主体突出，手部存在轻微粘连瑕疵","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"姿态妙合“忽见”诗眼，题字简当，手部微疵"},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"暮色氛围静谧温暖，未表现人物与灯火的互动","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"物象精准丰实，瓜豆架、瓮、女墙等皆贴合诗句","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"黄昏转夜的光候准确，人物专注浇菜未看灯火","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"光影细腻自然，结构完整，无生成缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp15":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp15","topic":"云仓夜扫","order":["meta","openai","zhipu","google","xai","alibaba","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":482.4,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"深夜冷仓中人物凝视箱签巷图，克制传递乡愁余味","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"核心名物俱全，儿时巷为箱签图案未错置为实景","时空场景":10,"时空场景_评":"时为夜半，长廊纵深清晰，无时空混置动作连贯","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰主次分明，形体动作自然无生成缺陷","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱签微型巷图妙合诗眼，作业文字准确自然"},{"id":2,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"以古巷叠画、直白标语表思乡，表现外露余味弱","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"核心仓储物件可辨，儿时巷错为空中实景非箱签","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"时间为夜，古巷与仓库空间叠置存在时空冲突","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰可辨，叠影衔接稍生硬无严重崩坏","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"大屏直书诗句不合场景，古巷叠置属穿帮"},{"id":3,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"仅堆叠仓储科技元素，无忽见乡思的情绪联结","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"核心物件失准：红线乱飘，以胶带代封条箱签生硬","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"时间标识模糊，场景为工作台非长廊动作偏离诗意","画面质量":4,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，手部结构畸变，空中红线杂乱无章","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":2,"加减分_评":"手部畸变屏幕为伪字，乱线不符合仓储场景实际"},{"id":4,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"依赖左侧题诗点明内容，画面自身无情绪关联","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"扫码场景可辨，但缺失封条，衣物标识为乱码","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"夜间仓房场景可辨，但非长廊动作不符诗意","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，标签放大圈突兀，手部轻微畸变","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"大段题诗喧宾夺主，衣物上印有乱码伪字"},{"id":5,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"夜廊静谧氛围贴合，依赖题诗未表现忽见触动","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"核心场景可辨，红线错为灯笼光，巷为外挂画","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"夜半长廊空间感足，动作不符红灯笼违和","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"油画风格统一协调，主体清晰无明显生成缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗含乱码占幅大，仓内挂红灯笼属穿帮"},{"id":6,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"仅为普通扫码作业，无忽见乡思的特定情绪","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"缺失封条，持扫码枪的手无对应身体错漏多","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"动作施受混乱，地点非长廊时间标识模糊","画面质量":3,"画面质量_评":"凭空出现无所属持枪手，生成缺陷较明显","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":4,"加减分_评":"出现无所属第三只手，动作与诗意严重不符"},{"id":7,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"夜仓氛围尚可，依赖题诗投影表意余味不足","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"核心物件可辨，儿时巷错为玻璃投影缺失封条","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"时间为夜半，高层景观仓不符实际时空混杂","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰形体正常，右侧大段题诗较为突兀","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右侧题诗占比过大，高层景观仓不符合实际"}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp16":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp16","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","order":["zhipu","google","xai","meta","microsoft","alibaba","openai"],"ok":true,"secs":420.2,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"堆列吊瓶新树高楼，巨根怪异无诗中温煦意涵","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶新叶在，巨根裸露摊铺，不符移栽树特征","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"主树占行车道，根铺路面，空间关系完全错谬","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"物象轮廓清晰可辨，无粘连畸变影响识别","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"雨街湿润氛围贴合点滴感，未传递今昔期许余味","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"新树雨街可辨，吊瓶软质、悬立杆、管路拖地欠妥","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"春日雨天城市街景真实，人车树空间关系合常理","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰自然，组织顺畅，无生成畸变伪影","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"水墨雨街清润，水痕呼应玻璃泪，借题字补足诗意","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶新叶街楼可辨，枝间满缀水滴过度具象比喻","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"春日雨街氛围明确，吊瓶挂楼墙，远城层次清晰","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水墨风格连贯统一，物象清晰，无结构崩坏缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗重复抄写颈联两句，内容冗余失误"},{"id":4,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"雨雾中幼树伶仃，贴合新移树木的柔弱情态","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"幼树新叶吊瓶可辨，输液管未插入树身失准","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"春日雨街环境明确，幼树在道边，空间关系合理","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩风格协调，物象可辨，无严重粘连畸变","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"雨岸空蒙有清寂感，场景偏江干未合春街意","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"新树吊瓶可辨，错添桃花，江畔场景偏离春街","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"春日雨天虽合，核心地点为滨江步道而非街衢","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"国画笔法协调，物象清晰，无明显生成缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗多有错字，如“点滴”错为“点街”、“高厦”错写"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"晴光映嫩蕊，悬滴欲坠，暗合树木复苏的温煦期许","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"核心物象均准，输液袋为软塑料，稍欠玻璃喻义","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"春初雨后初晴街景，树在道边，光影湿路匹配","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"物象清晰自然，材质真实，无明显生成伪影缺陷","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"悬滴与晴光呼应，暗合宿雨待晴的诗眼意涵"},{"id":7,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"晴街明丽畅快，但枝叶过盛，无新移初萌纤弱感","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶街衢可辨，树叶浓茂，不符“叶初萌”特征","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"城市街道位置准确，晴日天候，但树木浓荫季候偏晚","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰明快，光影自然，无生成畸变伪影","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp17":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp17","topic":"抓娃娃机","order":["alibaba","xai","microsoft","openai","zhipu","meta","google"],"ok":true,"secs":462.0,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"有玻璃倒影，仅一臂抬起，未充分体现借影余味","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"核心物象可辨，爪与布偶分离，布偶无依托悬浮","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"商场室内场景协调，爪与布偶位置存在局部偏差","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"整体清晰，手部结构略生硬，存在轻微畸变","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"孩童张臂贴玻璃有倒影，但爪未开，关键转折缺失","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"核心物象可辨，爪紧握布偶未呈松开状态","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"室内空间方位准确，柔和光感与水彩风格适配","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩风格统一协调，形体清晰无明显崩坏","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"操作面板存在无法辨认的模糊伪汉字"},{"id":3,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"靠题诗补义，无悬吊布偶，核心情感关系缺失","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"无悬吊布偶，爪部空置，核心物象存在关键缺失","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"商场傍晚方位正确，但无悬偶致核心动作落空","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰写实，结构稳定无明显生成缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右侧整列抄诗喧宾夺主，以题款代偿图像缺失"},{"id":4,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"张臂迎布偶，玻璃倒影邻布偶，情绪贴合有期待感","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"核心物象齐全可辨，爪半勾布偶将落，仅爪型略偏","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"电玩城灯光氛围到位，方位动作关系准确协调","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰锐利，主体突出，肢体结构无明显崩坏","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"玻璃倒影邻布偶，暗合借影相偎的诗眼巧思"},{"id":5,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"无悬吊布偶，倒影错位，核心情感关系完全缺失","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"爪部空置无悬偶，倒影为他人，核心对象缺失","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"核心动作无承载对象，事件逻辑无法成立","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，但手部存在多指畸变，影响观感","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"雨夜氛围感强，但孩童未临娃娃机窗，关系错位","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"物象可辨，但孩童为店外路人，非游艺参与者","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"隔店玻璃无法操作，核心施受关系存在错位","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"动漫风格统一，雨幕玻璃质感表现协调自然","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"氛围喧闹，仅一臂贴玻璃，未表现借影余味","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"核心物象可辨，孩童仅一臂临窗，臂姿不符描述","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"游戏厅场景正确，方位合理，仅臂姿存在偏差","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰有氛围感，局部手部结构略生硬","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"机身宣传海报存在无法识别的乱码文字"}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp18":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp18","topic":"旧衣回收箱","order":["xai","openai","zhipu","alibaba","microsoft","google","meta"],"ok":true,"secs":422.9,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"暖调斜阳有怀旧感，靠题字点题，人与旧衣无呼应","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"核心物象齐备，短袖树纹、硬币有对应，箱盖白布无据","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"傍晚街边场景成立，人与回收箱距离稍远，动作关联弱","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰画风统一，主次分明，无明显生成崩坏","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左侧告示为乱码，右上抄录全诗篇幅较大"},{"id":2,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"呈现日常投衣场景，缺乏旧衣触发忆旧的情绪张力","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"核心物象可辨，缺失攀树痕、买糖钱、悬袄等细节","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"傍晚街景成立，孩子身高远不及母肩，无催归动作","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"写实风格清晰明快，形体准确，主次分明无大缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"箱体标识文字规范，母亲投衣手部略有结构畸变"},{"id":3,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"呈现母亲哄哭闹幼儿场景，与本诗怀旧情调完全偏离","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"仅存泛化绿箱、红衣、母子，核心意象多缺失错位","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"仅街边场景近似，核心动作、人物关系均不符合诗意","画面质量":4,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，但母亲抱孩子的手部存在结构畸变","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":2,"加减分_评":"幼儿哭闹情节无依据，母亲抱孩手部结构有畸变"},{"id":4,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"暖光烘托怀旧感，母抚旧衣、子指归路的情绪关系成立","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"核心意象齐备，悬袄、带痕短袖、兜中零钱均有对应","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"傍晚街边场景准确，子催归动作、身高关系基本契合","画面质量":3,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，但孩童多出一条手臂，存在严重生成瑕疵","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":4,"加减分_评":"细节贴合诗眼有巧思，但孩童多臂，伪影问题严重"},{"id":5,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"夕阳暖调略衬氛围，人物背对箱走远，靠题字点诗","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"部分细节有体现，但钱币脱离衣兜，孩童身高偏差大","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"傍晚场景成立，但路面积水无据，孩童身高与诗不符","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰整洁，画风统一，无明显结构崩坏问题","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"墙面题诗有错字乱码，兜中钱币被画在地面钱包内"},{"id":6,"意境情感":1,"意境情感_评":"以引线标注图解诗意，仅堆列物象，无情绪关联余味","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"物象孤立标注，短袖悬浮空中，孩童身高远不符诗意","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"傍晚街景近似，但衣物悬浮违和，无催归动作表现","画面质量":4,"画面质量_评":"水彩风格形体可辨，但图解标注杂乱，悬浮衣物突兀","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":3,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"大量图解文字杂乱，短袖凭空悬浮，箱体存在乱码"},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"斜阳光影烘托怀旧感，母视旧衣失神、子牵衣催归到位","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"核心物象准确，悬袄、棉絮、零钱均有对应，缺带痕短袖","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"傍晚街边光候准确，人物动作、身高关系契合，层次清晰","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰光影协调，主次分明，仅相握的手部略有模糊","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"棉絮裹零钱显巧思，手部略糊，箱体标识文字规范"}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp19":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp19","topic":"社区食堂","order":["zhipu","alibaba","google","meta","xai","microsoft","openai"],"ok":true,"secs":431.4,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"仅堆叠餐食、光影物件，无留箸待邻的情感呼应","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"未体现洗净杯盘，无食堂标识，留箸表意模糊","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"实木门夕阳投窗格影逻辑矛盾，门未半掩","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰主次分明，无妨碍理解的生成缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"暖调贴合日常感，无留待邻翁的视觉暗示，余意弱","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"一荤两素可辨，未体现洗净杯盘，无食堂特征","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"晚照自门入非穿窗，门全开非半掩，场景偏私宅","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"物象清晰结构自然，光影协调，无明显生成缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"邻翁已在座用餐，无等待留白，人群拥挤余意不足","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"餐食不符一荤两素，杯盘正使用未洗净，留箸缺失","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"晚照穿窗符合，但“待邻翁”反转为邻翁已就餐","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰人物自然，无妨碍理解的生成缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"空座置筷略有待客温感，稍依赖告示补意，余意尚可","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"一荤两素、净杯盘、竹筷、食堂标识均可辨认","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"晚照穿窗、门半掩均符合，空间为食堂，光候协调","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"物象清晰光影自然，结构连贯无明显生成瑕疵","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"供餐告示错将“荤”写为“荟”，出现错字"},{"id":5,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"靠题诗点题，无视觉生成的待邻余意，场景偏古旧","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"一荤两素混装一盘，无食堂标识，净杯盘含糊","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"晚照、半门符合，但场景为古村居不符食堂设定","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩风格连贯统一，物象清晰无明显生成缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":1,"意境情感_评":"老人已就餐无等待留白，满幅题字消解诗中余意","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"留箸待邻无对应，冗余文字过多，净杯盘不明显","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"核心事件反转，晚照时段亮室内灯，门未半掩","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"插画风格统一，物象可辨，无严重生成瑕疵","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题字过多喧宾夺主，存在错漏的额外文字"},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"空碗承晚照红，双筷对半门，待邻温情含蓄有余味","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"食堂标识、一荤两素、净杯盘、竹筷核心物象准确","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"晚照穿窗映红碗底，门半掩，傍晚光候协调","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"主次分明光影自然，物象清晰无理解障碍","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"空碗承红光待翁为妙构，环境文字准确不夺主"}]}},"doubao-seed-2.1_shp20":{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","id":"shp20","topic":"社区食堂","order":["openai","zhipu","meta","alibaba","xai","google","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":470.9,"cost":null,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"雨天冷调衬店内暖光，人物互动自然烟火气足","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"核心物象可辨，软饭、笋尖汤俱在，未体现加姜细节","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"雨天巷弄层次清晰，人物位置动作基本贴合诗境","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰主次分明，无妨碍理解的生成缺陷","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"菜单文字准确，车铃细节暗合“车铃急”表述"},{"id":2,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"分镜割裂人物零散，未形成统一的温情氛围","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"出现无关男孩，厨娘形象不一，缺失软饭姜细节","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"空间逻辑错位，蓝衣人骑车入席，场景矛盾","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"漫画线条清晰，但局部动作结构错位违和","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"冷暖忙闲形成对照，隔窗谈笑含蓄有生活余味","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"软饭、加姜、车铃、笋尖等细节高度贴合诗句","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"雨天内外层次清晰，光候方位动作契合诗境","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰顺畅，主次分明，无明显生成缺陷","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"隔窗对笑暗合问菜情节，标牌文字精准扣题"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"暖光营造治愈感，但雨天户外座席削弱真实暖意","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"核心场景可辨，缺失软饭姜细节，蓝衣形象偏差","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"雨天街景成立，但人物动作平缓，无车铃急节奏","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"动漫风格统一，形体清晰，无明显结构错误","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"菜单、预告牌文字准确工整，位置得当"},{"id":5,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"画风平和恬淡，但人物互动弱，诗中余味不足","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"场地可辨，缺失软饭、姜、问菜等关键内容","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"巷弄空间成立，但老人户外就餐，动作节奏不符","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩风格协调，形体清晰，无明显生成缺陷","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"餐价牌、送餐箱文字准确，契合场景"},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"冷巷衬窗口暖意，老太与厨娘互动自然生动","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"软饭、姜丝汤、明日笋尖对应准确，身份明确","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"巷弄空间清晰，但蓝衣人方向模糊，雨势表现弱","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰可辨，唯蓝衣人手部略有轻微畸变","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"菜单、提示文字准确，贴合诗中相关细节"},{"id":7,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"题错诗干扰表意，人物松散，无诗中温情氛围","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"场地可辨，关键细节不足，题诗错字混淆原义","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"雨天巷弄可辨，但人物动作顺序不符诗中叙事","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"形体可辨，但左上角题字占比大分散注意力","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题字错漏不通，乱码错字较多，干扰画面表意"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp01":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp01","topic":"旧衣回收箱","order":["openai","bytedance","xai","microsoft","meta","alibaba","zhipu"],"ok":true,"secs":36.8,"cost":0.0264945,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"暮色中伫立留连，剪落名签呼应不舍之情。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"铁柜、童衫及剪刀名签皆齐备具象。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"街头夕照与投递动作自然融洽。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"景深与主体交代清晰，质感细腻。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"蹲身凝视童衫，具逡巡眷恋之态。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"铁柜与小衣俱在，但缺名签与剪落细节。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"街头空间定位合理，日光暖和。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"人物与环境结构完整无瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"背影沉重孤寂，带有离别伤感。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"箱体陈旧剥蚀，且标签未剪落反写小名。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"弄堂街角空间明确，物与人分离。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"影调统一质朴，形体扎实。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱旧且标签未剪，与诗句抵触。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"墙面抄诗代意境，名签贴外削弱余味。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"虽有柜与衫，但名签误作外贴便利贴。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"临街水乡街道成立，衣物悬于箱口。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"画面组织尚可，局部稍显平淡。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"墙面直抄全诗，喧宾夺主。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"无人处静物自语，留白含蓄具离别意。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"针痕、剪刀与碎纸签紧扣核心意象。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"箱顶静置微观场景，街景虚化恰当。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"焦点清晰，针线与纸屑细节精到。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"特写针痕与碎签，巧扣诗眼。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"手指针迹略显直白说明，余韵不足。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"衣衫偏成人衬衣，名签未剪落。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"临街投递时空明确，站姿合理。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"结构组织完整，光感真实自然。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"如商业弃置，全无惜别温情与诗意。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"衬衫带商品挂牌，箱体破旧非漆新。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"箱柜似杂物筒，与街景关系含混。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"插画笔触连贯，但材质交代不清。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"误将名签画作商用吊牌，偏题。"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp02":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp02","topic":"深夜视频","order":["bytedance","meta","zhipu","xai","openai","microsoft","alibaba"],"ok":true,"secs":50.9,"cost":0.036078,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"屏幕正亮视频通话，未现屏昏与惊愕，重要转折未予视觉回应。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"画出手机与白发，但未呈现熄屏成镜之象，核心修辞缺位。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"深夜暗室成立，但画面定格在通话中，未现话尽后的时间递进。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体轮廓清晰，光影合理自洽，无明显生成缺陷。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗全首位置端正字形准确，无伪字。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"黑屏暗镜映出衰老白发，人物神色惊骇，绝佳呼应翻惊诗眼。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"熄屏反照鬓灰，便签画山借代千山，物象完备且契合修辞。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"深夜伏案、孤灯残茶，精确还原话尽屏昏的即时时空。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"微光透视与神情细节精湛，结构紧凑毫无瑕疵。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"暗镜映出衰老病容的对比构思，点透翻惊诗眼。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"仅呈现老人低头看手机，无屏昏暗镜与翻惊，属泛化默写。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"千山、笑语及暗镜修辞皆无对应，仅存单一老人与手机。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"室内夜景单一平庸，缺乏视频通话与屏昏反照的时空线索。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"人物写实，但手机正反与屏幕显示状态模糊不清。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"仅停留于笑语视频，后两句屏昏暗镜、鬓灰之惊完全缺失。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"视频笑脸与千山可辨，但暗镜与鬓发皆未进入画面。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"野外夜山与室内视频视角并置略生硬，且无话尽后时序。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"夜色远山与屏光对比自然，质感细腻连贯。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"借桌上黑屏映发传达韶华之悲，但两设备并置削弱转折张力。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"电脑视频、手机暗镜照发与窗外山景皆备，物象指称丰富。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"将掌中拆为电脑与手机并同时发生，打乱了话尽屏昏的承接。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"光影过渡自然，桌面多物件遮挡关系井然有序。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"画面驻留在温馨视频中，屏昏暗镜的翻惊转折全付阙如。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"有平板通话与老人白发，但关键的屏昏成暗镜未能呈现。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"夜窗山水与室内空间自洽，但缺失通话结束后的时间层次。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水墨设色连贯，蜡烛古籍与平板同置略显割裂但画质完整。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款字形工整切题，钤印得宜。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"手机熄屏成镜，暗映霜鬓，眼神惊怔怅惘，完美点透诗眼。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"黑屏暗镜倒映白发极为精准，舍弃冗余物象直取诗核。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"深夜微弱屏面反光与空间关系严谨，定格于话尽熄屏瞬间。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"弱光反射透视与面部微表情描绘极精，组织纯粹无瑕。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"纯以黑屏微光倒映霜鬓与惊容点题，含蓄而力透纸背。"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp03":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp03","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","order":["zhipu","microsoft","alibaba","bytedance","meta","openai","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":67.2,"cost":0.03573,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"巨幅题字喧宾夺主且内容错乱，冲淡了移栽孤树的凄哀诗意。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶针管空悬未刺入树体，缺乏一街新绿的延展响应。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"春雨街景成立，但树干无树穴直接插在石板路上，略失真实。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"树木建筑形体可辨，但右侧文字排布粗糙，挤压画面空间。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右侧题字巨大且出现漏句与恶性复读，严重损毁画面。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"远山烟雨与带兜孤树相映，凄清萧索之态极具感染力。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"土球草绳精准呈现断根移栽，悬瓶与新绿皆备，名物准确。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"春雨石路与未落土的移栽树结合合理，时空层次深远。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水光倒影与树皮草绳质感精妙，雨雾渲染极为自洽成熟。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗后两句文字错乱成伪句，画面文字扣减2分。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"整条街吊瓶与新绿向远方延伸，直击病中求生之核心诗眼。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"断根土球、裹干护布、输液瓶与嫩叶完全对应现代园林移栽。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"春雨街道透视开阔，行道树整齐排列，场景秩序高度严密。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"摄影级写实，倒影、泥土与雨痕质感毫无瑕疵，组织严整。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"将一树之哀扩为一街吊瓶的排布，具极强视觉冲击力。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"残树断顶与滴水极具哀感，但缺乏一街新绿的繁盛反差。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶悬空漏水未通树身，且缺少全街多树与新绿的呼应。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"江南烟雨古街空间层次分明，树穴置于路侧符合逻辑。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水墨枯湿浓淡得宜，白墙黑瓦与老树皴擦笔力苍劲沉稳。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右上题诗书写端正无错乱，位置与印章安排得体。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"水彩光影柔和明亮，整体偏向清新雅致，削弱了病弱哀戚感。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"土球扎绳、加固支架与输液注药装置极为考究，名物精当。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"街面水迹与沿街店铺关系合拍，移栽树位透视准确有序。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩水痕自然流畅，色彩层次丰富，无明显生成瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"柳丝滴雨与输液细管重叠，满街新绿尽皆系瓶，哀意深沉。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶进针扎入树皮，管线与柳丝对应长丝，物象还原精微。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"细雨街景纵深宏大，树木排列与水面反光光候浑然一体。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"树皮青苔裂纹与塑料吊瓶质感逼真细腻，形体结构极其严谨。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"构图以柳丝垂珠暗合管线雨脚，精妙化解错认诗意。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"树干生硬钉挂诗句木牌，直白交代冲淡了画面意境回味。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶输液管俱全，但树木砌池深植未见断根，木牌喧宾夺主。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"春雨街市深远，石板路反光与沿街新树位置关系清晰连贯。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩淡墨相宜，烟雨淡染与近景勾勒层次清楚，形体完整。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"树干悬挂诗句木牌混淆画意实体，显得生硬刻意。"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp04":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp04","topic":"云仓夜扫","order":["alibaba","zhipu","meta","bytedance","openai","xai","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":55.4,"cost":0.04009725,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"蹲身细看残签村名，扫帚在侧，与晨光车发呼应，深得诗意。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"机械臂停歇、竹帚、残签村名、千重货架皆切合，物象精准。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"仓内夜深灯明与门外破晓晨光衔接自然，车动之势分明。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"构图主次分明，光影细腻，人物动作神态自然逼真。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"标签村名清晰得当，凝视动作传神点出思乡诗眼。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"仅展现普通工人操作机台，无扫地与念乡之情，背离诗旨。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"无竹帚扫地意象，缺残签村名，铁臂未收反在操作，名物失准。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"仓储空间与门外货车方位尚可，但夜半转东方欲白线索模糊。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"工业质感尚可，但地面图纸文字糊烂且透视生硬。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"地面图样文字为无意义杂乱符号。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"无人物，通篇机械堆砌道具与说明文字，全无诗意余味。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"有货架、竹帚、铁臂，但台灯置地与满地贴标极为刻意失真。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"门外晨光与车动成立，但仓内地灯摆放反常理，空间荒诞。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"建模渲染清晰，但布景犹如案发现场，毫无生活真实感。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"机械臂贴字与地摊大字报粗暴直白，文字严重失当。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"手电巡查代替扫地轻抚，情感视点偏移为夜班安保氛围。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"误将扫帚“竹枝声”画成真竹林，机械臂与叉车仍在作业。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"夜晚与晨光微露有交代，但内外动线与人物漫步缺乏联系。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"绘本质感尚可，但光斑生硬，左上题诗排版略显突兀。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"误将扫地竹枝画为生竹，违背“收铁臂”画叉车作业。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"聚焦女工打包快件，无夜扫及抚签之念，诗意转为寻常劳作。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"缺竹帚夜扫与残签细节，仓库内突兀种竹，机械臂未体现。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"天窗见圆月而门外见初升红日，日月同时同框严重冲突。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"光影质感丰富，人物造型扎实，但场景元素逻辑混乱。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"仓门横幅直抄诗句；同框日月矛盾且室内长竹。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"背影扫地向烟岚村落，孤寂与思乡意境深远，极富感染力。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"执竹帚夜扫准确，但现代云仓全无机械臂，反置复古马灯。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"仓外即是炊烟故里村，虽解“隔归程”，但空间拼接失真。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"色调沉郁，水汽光影极佳，诗词题款工整得当。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗书法雅致；现代仓储错置老式马灯，空间欠合理。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"执帚停驻凝视村名纸签，机械臂静立、货车远行，呼应诗意。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"机械臂收歇、竹帚、残签、货架及动车齐备，指称精准。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"室内灯光聚焦残签，仓外晨曦货车出发，时空层次连贯。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"构图主次分明，插画线条利落，光影组织清晰。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗严重错字错序乱码，纸签网红金句夺主。"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp05":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp05","topic":"深夜视频","order":["xai","openai","meta","microsoft","alibaba","bytedance","zhipu"],"ok":true,"secs":116.3,"cost":0.03833625,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"冷海寒床与屏中暖灯对照鲜明，但未及荧屏暗后余温之境。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"慈颜、碧蔬、晚菊、厨灯俱全，手机与电脑同现略显冗余。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜半隔海与室内寒床方位明确，虚实两端空间隔而不断。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画质细腻沉稳，光影过渡自然，无明显畸变伪影。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"上下分格对应暗屏转折，抚屏温存将诗眼余温化为动人实感。","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"慈颜、碧蔬、晚菊无一遗漏，声波与暗屏意象极为精准。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"两格清晰展现通话中与挂断后的时间演进，跨时空层次分明。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"结构连贯完整，人物情绪与夜间微光刻画生动自洽。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"双格时序化再现暗屏余温，声波与触屏妙合诗意。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"破败居所反衬屏中慈颜温情，异乡孤独与依恋之感充沛。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"手机内慈颜、碧蔬、晚菊清晰可辨，床铺陈设切合羁旅。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"窗外冷雨夜半与屏内温馨厨房区隔分明，时空对照准确。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"写实细节扎实，手持比例与室内暗部光线自然协调。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"超现实同室削弱隔海空间张力，文字堆叠使言外之意受损。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"物象元素齐备，但屏中与室中双重母亲使主体身份错乱。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"将异乡寒床与故乡厨房硬拼一室，破坏了隔海相望的距离。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，但空间拼合生硬，两处题诗分散画面重心。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"挂轴与笔记两度大段题诗，喧宾夺主且字迹有讹。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"虽有母子视频温情，但更偏插画广告感，缺少沉郁余味。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"指菜、晚菊、慈颜等要素齐备，手机界面名物准确。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"时空分区规整，深夜卧室与白昼暖灯厨房界限明确。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"线条与光影工整，整体结构清楚，略带扁平插画感。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右上角粗大标题字略显喧宾夺主。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"将母子亲情误作年轻恋人异地恋，彻底偏离核心诗情。","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"“慈颜”被替换为年轻女性，决定诗义的核心身份缺失。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"同一窗景下左右硬分厨卧，手机凭空悬立，时空逻辑矛盾。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"局部渲染尚可，但手机悬浮无着落，左右空间拼接割裂。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":3,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"核心人物身份与空间逻辑严重穿帮，慈颜画成年轻女友。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":0,"意境情感_评":"仅为厨房摘菜独角戏，全无异乡隔海与视频通话之情感张力。","意象物象":1,"意象物象_评":"无视频设备、无异乡寒床，背景误出病床，核心意象尽失。","时空场景":1,"时空场景_评":"缺乏跨时空对应的两端，无法构建隔海夜半的时空架构。","画面质量":3,"画面质量_评":"背景莫名杂糅病床，上方印有巨大标题，视觉组织混乱。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"提示词与标题文字严重污染画面，厨房莫名混入病床。"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp06":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp06","topic":"天台菜园","order":["openai","alibaba","zhipu","bytedance","microsoft","meta","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":89.8,"cost":0.044901,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"落日余晖中邻人探首相看，菜畦葱郁，自然烘托出融融暖意。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"通风管绕藤、残砖畦、蓄水罂、灯前羹与瓜果一一具足且准确。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"天台晚晴向晚，落日沉城与油灯初照的时空转换顺畅合理。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"写实光影细腻自洽，建筑与植被肌理分明，毫无生硬瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"端羹叩门的克制背影将异乡客的情怯与邻里暖意尽数点化。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"702门、捧羹、虫蚀菜叶、残砖畦、绕管藤瓜等名物极精准。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"现代天台暮色苍茫，顶楼廊门与菜园空间界限分明，光候准确。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"形体透视扎实，暮霭与暖灯交融自然，画面干净且毫无伪影。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"端羹叩门直击诗眼加2分，环境门牌与标语自然加1分。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"画面呈素材拼接状，人物僵硬背立，缺乏诗中异乡温情。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"残砖失真如新砌，瓜悬突兀木枝而非藤架，蓄水罂变为大水箱。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"天台方位尚可辨，但羹与灯随意弃置湿地，生活逻辑混乱。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"三维建模塑料质感浓厚，菜叶肥大比例失调，光影缺乏交融。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"瓜果悬生枝桠违背蔓藤生理常理减1分。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"暖光下老夫妇相对甚乐，生活味浓，然削弱了“客”的漂泊感。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"抱瓜、砖畦、藤管、水瓮皆具，但缺失了“灯前煮羹”的情节。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"晚晴落日余晖准确，天台屋舍与远城层次清楚，时空自洽。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"摄影质感优秀，人物神情生动，材质与逆光表现力极强。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题字断截且将“蓄水罂”误写为“蓄水瓮”减1分。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"水彩插画温润，但双人视线分散，未能凸显独客叩邻的情绪张力。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"残砖畦、蓄水罂、藤绕排气管、虫洞叶与桌上羹灯均有落实。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"晚霞渐暗与室内外亮灯过渡自然，天台与城市层次分明。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"插画线条明快，色彩层次清新干净，布局平稳无视觉崩坏。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗脱漏关键虚字“犹”致七言失律减1分。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"试图将建园、采摘到叩门一图包揽，人物慌乱悬空，诗意尽失。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"背土袋、爬梯、虫蚀菜、瓜架、蓄水罂与炉火羹一应俱全。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"将初始“负土”与末尾“瓜熟”强作同时同刻，时空逻辑断裂。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"写实细节繁密，但人物置身梯顶悬空敲门，重心与结构失调。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"人物立足险梯背重土凌空叩门违背常理减1分。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"背影独立叩门与暮色远城对照，深得“人犹是客”的落寞与温情。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"残砖畦、肥美熟瓜、虫咬菜叶、炉火羹及叩扉背影无一遗漏。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"残霞向晚与灶前灯火照应，天台破败肌理与远市空间过渡得宜。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"绘画笔触沉郁浑厚，砖石与叶片质感极为扎实，层次谨严。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"扣门背影深具余味加1分；诗句腰斩残缺严重减2分。"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp07":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp07","topic":"云端相册","order":["meta","alibaba","openai","bytedance","microsoft","zhipu","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":73.2,"cost":0.03821025,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"笔尖迟疑停顿，将围裙化作母亲留痕，完美落实不忍除的纠结。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"云端界面、缺齿旧照、裁剪框与边缘半截围裙悉数准确呈现。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"平板修图交互与泛黄旧照时空层级分明，动势关系自洽。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"光影写实柔和，平板界面与人物手指比例精准自如。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"巧将半截围裙置于裁剪边缘，UI字形切题自然。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"仅有含笑凝视，缺乏重新裁切时的心理纠结与停顿张力。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"虽具裁剪框，但围裙为孩童穿在身上，失落了边缘取舍之意。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"双手平端屏幕，缺乏交互修图的动作，时空交互略平。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物神态温和，室内暖调光影自然，形体结构扎实。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"老者抚屏神态真切，但案头设剪刀，未显诗中停手迟疑之意。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"错置围裙于老妇己身，照中无围裙，且以实体剪刀代数码重裁。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"平板数字旧照与桌面纸质剪刀拼贴，时空逻辑略显割裂。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"逆光发丝细腻，老者面容生动，质感组织完整。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"悬浮云彩与老屋投影显符号化，未能由图像生成不舍之情。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"照中小孩穿整件围裙，案头复置围裙，物象理解杂乱。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"现实桌面、屏幕与背景黄昏老屋三层硬拼，空间略脱节。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"人物刻画端正，但背景投影与悬浮大云朵使构图失真。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"悬浮云朵及标题如APP广告水印，破坏画面意境。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"反默写：堆砌文字滥情；误将“如初”画作老妪缺牙，情感反向。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"缺齿笑画成老妇掉牙，无清晰裁剪框，后两句核心意象尽失。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"手指在人脸上滑动含混，窗外夜景与修图事件关联弱。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"人物与背景形体尚整，但文字密布分散视觉中心。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗及杯册上密布煽情文字，喧宾夺主破坏画境。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"反默写：仅为老人端视黑白照，完全不见裁切与留裙诗眼。","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"照中女孩无缺齿，更无裁剪框与照中围裙，核心物象缺失。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"仅是静态手持平板，无任何重裁旧照的施受动作层次。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"人物面部褶皱与光感写实深入，织物肌理清晰。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"字面图解云端与裁剪，将思念具象为碎纸云海，失却生活真味。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"平板浮于云中，碎纸剪刀与滑块混杂，照中全无围裙可除。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"木桌案头与真实云端天际错置，时空层级荒诞混乱。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"工笔淡彩笔法整肃柔和，但透视与虚实结合违和。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗擅自删减中间两句，且断句残缺，削弱诗意。"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp08":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp08","topic":"抓娃娃机","order":["xai","microsoft","alibaba","zhipu","bytedance","meta","openai"],"ok":true,"secs":58.4,"cost":0.03553425,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"表现了期待但未呈现落空与归途转折，情感停留于常规温馨。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"小熊眠与脚跟悬表现准确，但缺大掌摊开与归途意象。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"机前仰望与踮脚动态自然，但未能展开后半首的时空推移。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩绘本风笔触温润，人物形态与机台结构清晰协调。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"爪中得熊且笑容灿烂，完全背离毛团跌落与失落释怀的诗意。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"小熊稳在爪中未落，反转了“无一物”的落空指称。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"处于操作得手瞬间，缺乏归途与转折的时空延伸。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"主体造型尚可，但大量文本贴图杂乱且喧宾夺主。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗多错字伪字，机身遍布鸡汤文字，且与诗意落空相悖。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"父女牵手离去且父摊空掌，完美点出归途释怀的诗眼余味。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"机底伏熊、空空大掌与相牵双手俱在，核心名物高度契合。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"立足机旁回廊，兼顾方才失手之所与归途之行，过渡自然。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"写实摄影质感优秀，光影通透，父女神态捕捉极其生动。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"空掌微摊与相牵归途互成呼应，无声点化诗意。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"父子欢笑洋溢，完全缺失失手跌落的惆怅与转折张力。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"孩童非娇儿作男孩，且缺扯袖、脚悬与大掌摊开等关键物象。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"仅为同刻机前操作，未表现出归途或诗中动作发展过程。","画面质量":4,"画面质量_评":"小熊违背重力无抓凭空悬浮，物理空间组织失真。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":2,"加减分_评":"小熊在空中突兀悬浮无任何抓持，生成逻辑穿帮。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":1,"意境情感_评":"女孩怀抱抓获玩偶狂喜，彻底颠覆了“无一物”的落空情感。","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"直接画出成功抓得玩偶，把明确的落空否定误作肯定大获全胜。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"将机前抓取与成功欢呼混置，完全消解了归途与过程逻辑。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"人物环境写实精炼，但情节反转使叙事自洽度大受损害。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":3,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"女孩已成功抱熊，与全诗核心情节“无一物”彻底相悖。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"娇嗔扯袖、足悬指蜷与空掌无奈同构，期待与落空融为一体。","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"小熊眠、扯袖、脚跟悬、指蜷及大掌摊开无一物皆精确对应。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"虽为机前定格，却通过掉落毛团与空掌承载前后动作因果。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"超写实光影细腻，人物微表情极其传神，材质组织严谨。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"父女肢体神态将失落娇嗔刻画入微，机身汉字真实妥帖。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"四格分镜递进呈现催钱、悬空、滑落至相牵归途，情绪饱满。","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"催父掏钱、铁爪颤耳、失落跌落及归途牵手，各意象均精准。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"以合理分区分镜解决跨时空叙事，运动方向与因果脉络清晰。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"连环画风统一度高，角色前后一致，构图清晰且无瑕疵。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"分镜组织精巧自洽，各阶段情绪与时空流转衔接自然。"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp09":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp09","topic":"夜航俯瞰","order":["alibaba","zhipu","microsoft","openai","bytedance","meta","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":48.9,"cost":0.0441,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"舷窗框景与静默俯瞰营构出高空岑寂之感，暗合万籁俱寂。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"铁翼、明月、江流与路灯皆具，唯山形稍显平缓不显。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"机舱内外明暗对比得当，夜航俯瞰的高空纵深感真实自然。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"结构完整，光影层次细腻，无任何明显瑕疵或伪影。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"硕大文字粗暴横贯画面中央，彻底破坏了空灵辽阔的诗境。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"机翼、江流、城市与稚子具备，但月轮比例过度膨胀失真。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"巨月低垂切地且与机翼视差错乱，破坏了俯瞰的时空合理性。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"核心景物可辨，但横幅字样生硬贴图严重破坏画面组织。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"粗劣印刷体大字横跨画面核心区，喧宾夺主破坏意境。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"云山与江流穿插，冷峻夜色中带出远行沉思的悠远诗意。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"铁翼、舷窗、山形、江火俱全，要素对照诗句相当完备。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"航机高飞、山峦层叠与江流延展的透视关系交代清晰。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"整体笔意融洽，唯前景孩童手部与窗框交接略显模糊。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款诗句出现“牵米几火”、“千叉”等多处伪字错字。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"稚子托腮凭窗，明月与万家灯火互映，静穆中满含凝思张力。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"铁翼、山形、江火一应俱全，山道串珠光点极合“几队萤”。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"舷窗近景、中景山水至远景明月层次井然，时空严谨合榫。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"航机局部与地表灯网刻画极细致，无结构畸变，质感沉静。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"山坳野路蜿蜒如串珠流萤，视觉化还原诗句极有匠心。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"稚子手指窗外的动态极具叙事性，生动激发生态情趣。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"铁翼尖航行灯与稚子指顾直接对准诗眼“错认飞灯是远星”。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"机舱客舱空间交代充分，机翼与地面江流夜景透视精准。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"摄影级写实画质，人物神态生动自然，光影关系高度自洽。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"孩童凭栏指点翼尖红灯，精妙扣住全诗收束之“诗眼”。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"广角视界将千仞之下繁华纳于眼前，寂寥与繁华对比极具张力。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"铁翼、江流割城、田畴萤光诸象毕备，且稚子背影情态合拍。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"机舱大窗与浩渺大地构图宽广，俯瞰万籁之空间感极其宏阔。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"城市灯火与地貌纹理极其丰富自洽，光影渲染层次分明。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"田垄野径泛起点点莹光，完美再现“野路牵来几队萤”。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"构图略显呆滞，缺失航行核心物象导致高空飞掠之意境涣散。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"关键意象“铁翼”完全缺失，无从落实首尾机翼与飞灯之意。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"右下出现异样半圆凸窗结构，机舱空间组织含混不合常理。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"城市水墨夜景尚可，但机舱内部结构交代不清且有融烂感。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左侧配诗全系难以辨认的AI伪汉字乱码，严重扣分。"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp10":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp10","topic":"机场送别","order":["alibaba","bytedance","meta","openai","zhipu","xai","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":59.6,"cost":0.03825675,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"隔玻璃叮嘱生动，但缺机舱冷寂与心头影驻的转折。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"母女、围巾与登机屏具备，但缺机舱与行李离身细节。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"压平为候机区单一场景，未表现飞行千里与机舱时空。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"摄影质感真实，玻璃反射与人物光影自然自洽。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"航显屏中“伦敦”配“CAN”代码，文字常识矛盾。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"机舱独行抚巾与隔窗送别并置，母爱与依恋余味深长。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"母子、广播、行李箱、舷窗云海与绕巾动作皆准确。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"通过机舱内外的巧妙并置，完美连结送别与高空两重时空。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画风温润沉静，构图层次清晰自洽，质感极佳。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"神来之笔：时空并置点活诗眼；题款工整切题。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"隔窗深情凝视抓得精准，但绕巾提前至候机楼削弱了尾联。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"母子、玻璃与围巾齐备，但行李未离身且缺少机舱。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"停留于登机口单一现场，未能体现机上受寒与时空递进。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物肤质、微表情与玻璃手印极为扎实细腻。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"广播走字与航显屏中文严谨准确，烘托催程氛围。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"三镜递进将送别叮嘱与机舱孤寒紧密呼应，情致深切。","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"隔窗叮嘱、航线屏、舷窗夜景与绕巾无一遗漏且精准。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"分镜自洽展开登机口、航迹屏与机舱，昼夜时空转换严密。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"电影感镜头语言，三拼构图主次分明，毫无瑕疵。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"神来之笔：三镜逐层化诗；航显文字规范切题。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"表情程式化，缺少母子深情与尾联独飞的清冷余韵。","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"缺失“围巾”核心诗眼物象，亦无机舱与航程屏幕。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"仅有一处机场窗前对视，未画出任何跨时空层次。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"人物面容与衣物有明显塑料油腻感，结构稍显僵硬。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"AI生成痕迹明显，人物肢体与质感欠自然。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"虚实相生，将机舱绕巾化作心头幻影，极契“影驻心头”。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"隔窗唇动、催程牌、行李及舱中绕巾等关键物象皆齐。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"心理时空与现实送别巧妙叠合，虚景自然化入候机厅。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩油画质感细腻，虚实融合自然，层次丰富稳定。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"神来之笔：机舱幻景烟岚般叠入送别，妙扣诗眼。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"冷雨反光烘托凄寒，但未体现登机后的情感深化与回扣。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"人物与机场元素准确，但缺少机舱及绕围巾的核心动作。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"局限于窗前单一时刻，未能表达诗中千里与舱内的时空转换。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"雨夜地坪质感细腻，但左侧题字栏略显生硬割裂。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左侧白底诗栏生硬占幅，喧宾夺主削弱画面整体感。"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp11":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp11","topic":"夜航俯瞰","order":["xai","alibaba","bytedance","openai","zhipu","meta","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":41.9,"cost":0.02944575,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"指尖触窗凝霜痕，冰凉感与俯瞰乡愁借冷暖光影呼应生发。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"舷窗、指尖、沿河断续黄灯与细长街市等名物一一俱足。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"机内近景指尖与高空夜景俯瞰层次分明，动作关系确切。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"透视严谨自洽，玻璃水霜肌理与夜景灯火层次组织精到。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"指尖凝霜具象化诗眼，题款规整不夺主。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"指尖有微弱凝雾，但夜景光色沉闷，深巷追认之情较淡薄。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"具舷窗、河流与手部，但长街与深巷物象含混于暗部。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰视点明确，机内与机外距离感表达成立。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"暗部死黑面积偏大，地表细节不足，手部结构尚属完整。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"窗外雨夜虽显清冷，但车厢氛围消解了高空俯瞰的疏离感。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"内景为列车座椅与方窗，将核心物象『舷窗夜航』误置。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"视平线与车窗结构更近陆地列车，偏离万仞夜航之俯瞰。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"雨珠流痕与街市光影质感生动，但主体结构定性失当。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"误将飞机夜航舷窗画作列车方窗内景。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"高楼林立呈繁华都市象，减损了寻认当年老巷的故园沧桑。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"机翼、舷窗、江河桥火齐备，唯深巷被密集现代楼宇遮蔽。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"高空俯瞰机位与伸指动作准确，空间距离交代清楚。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"灯火透视连贯自然，机翼与手部轮廓清晰无明显瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"巨幅艺术字粗暴覆盖中心，画面沦为背景板，诗意荡然无存。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"物象虽有舷窗灯火，但核心区域被字体重重遮蔽难以辨识。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"浮夸字层打破了机内外的纵深空间，阻断了视觉视线。","画面质量":3,"画面质量_评":"字体排布粗糙喧宾夺主，机翼与边缘拼接感明显。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"粗大印刷文字喧宾夺主，严重破坏画面。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"指尖化开凝霜与窗外错落老巷呼应，触感与追忆浑融一体。","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"深巷黑瓦、沿河断续黄灯与带水汽之圆舷窗刻画丝丝入扣。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"圆窗特写与深渊般下瞰老街形成强烈视距对照，层次分明。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"凝水冰晶质感惊艳，鳞次栉比的屋宇暗部层次分明自洽。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"指尖融霜触感与俯瞰深巷的对应堪称神来。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"云隙露月与新旧城区光影对照，指触窗边流露寻觅怅惘。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"舷窗、江流、沿河瓦舍街巷与现代远景俱备，指触明确。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"高空夜飞俯瞰格局完整，明暗云层与地表灯火层次得宜。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"光影沉郁统一，手部姿态含蓄，机舱内外过渡自然。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题字工整清雅，落款得当不夺主体。"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp12":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp12","topic":"云端相册","order":["alibaba","microsoft","bytedance","meta","xai","openai","zhipu"],"ok":true,"secs":53.4,"cost":0.0328485,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"老者温颜抚屏，虽呈怀往之喜，但单指点按略失两指徐张之张力。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"屏中完整呈现土灶、挂蒜、慈母抱婴，唯两指徐张变为单指。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"现代明轩与屏中旧舍层次分明，内外时空隔代呼应且自洽。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物神态生动，数码与水彩质感交融自然，层次清晰。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"主角为黑发少妇，失去「白头点初生」之沧桑迟暮与生命对照。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"具备触控手势与挂蒜土灶，但核心身份「白头」被置换。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"门外实景与屏中景致混同，时空层次稍显模糊与杂糅。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"室内外纵深良好，光影逼真，人物形体连贯无瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"墙上条幅字形残损错乱，诗句多有伪字误写，喧宾夺主。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"将云端科技构想为神怪幻境，失去岁月回溯的真实温情。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"缺屏幕与两指操作，误将相册画为实体巨书，且人从书中探出。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"真实庭院与书中冒人强行并置，违背现代时空逻辑。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"工笔人物结构端正，但概念图解化严重，叙事逻辑断裂。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"将现代数码云端误构为书中走人的志怪硬伤，严重失真。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"老妪凝望屏中幼己与慈亲，沧桑面容与襁褓生机形成强烈张力。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"老妪白头、两指分张缩放、屏中慈母抱婴、檐蒜土灶一应俱全。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"立于故堂旧院开屏，令昔日影像与眼前老屋叠印，时空自洽。","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"纪实画质极高，老人皮肤皱纹、手指结构与老宅质感俱极真切。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"平板界面UI细节真实切题，虚实对照深挚动人。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"画为寻常祖孙同乐，完全套用于普通题材，尽失诗眼沧桑。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"丢失云端、开屏及两指徐张，且将屏中初生儿误为膝上活婴。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"仅是古旧堂前静坐，完全抹去跨越数十年的数字化时空对照。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩笔墨雅致，人物神态柔和，唯主题语义彻底偏离。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":3,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"将云端相册画成老妪怀抱真婴儿看纸质旧照，与诗抵触。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"两指舒张间云烟化出故堂，将白头忆母、岁月如烟之意发掘至深。","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"纸箱老照、平板触控、母亲抚婴、土灶悬蒜悉数精准呈现。","时空场景":10,"时空场景_评":"案头实操与上方腾起之往昔梦境虚实相生，跨时空转换极妙。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"光影考究，手部触屏与景深过渡自然，虚实融合严丝合缝。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"云烟勾连屏内老照与故堂旧境，巧妙契合「云端」与回响。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"婴儿如全息鬼魅般凌空漂浮，缺乏慈亲呵护，情感冰冷诡异。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"虽有白发、手机与灶蒜，但无慈亲膝上眠，手指亦非双指徐张。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"线装古籍、老灶与现代手机杂陈，空悬孤婴打破空间自洽。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"造型略显呆板，婴儿周身生硬发光，与环境光照脱节。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"顶部直接悬空黑体大字「云端相册」，生硬夺目。"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp13":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp13","topic":"机场送别","order":["bytedance","microsoft","alibaba","zhipu","xai","meta","openai"],"ok":true,"secs":86.1,"cost":0.03631575,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"暮色与对立无言氛围到位，但掌痕悬置前景，与人物略脱节。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"长廊、闸机、暮色、航灯俱全，掌痕清晰但质感略显刻意。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"暮色与机场长廊空间自洽，但掌印位置与两人所处空间脱节。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"光影通透，透视与人物形体准确自然。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"女子抚镜目送背影，隔绝与怅惘的情感张力高度呼应诗眼。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"送别背影、长廊、航灯、客机与玻璃手印皆准确完备。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"内与外、留与行、近处抚镜与远处背影的时空层次分明。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水墨融于写实场景，水汽与反光层次丰富，构图严整。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"抚镜送行深得诗眼神髓，题诗与印章清丽得体。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"掌印尺度畸大如特摄异物，阴暗调性偏离送别的凄婉深情。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"虽具长廊、航灯与闸机，但掌痕被夸大为巨手，偏离常理。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"机场走廊与机坪暮色空间成立，人物与闸机距离关系尚可。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"画面暗部细节压抑，掌印边缘发光突兀，整体比例失衡。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"掌印比例巨化失真，违背常识逻辑。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"毫无送别余味，直接将诗句印为防撞条，图像情感完全缺位。","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"将诗眼“一掌痕”误作玻璃印刷文字呈现，核心物象缺失。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"机场过闸通道与暮色航灯方位大体成立，空间层级单薄。","画面质量":4,"画面质量_评":"现代印刷标语横贯画面中心，严重破坏画面组织与视觉美感。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"诗句生硬印于玻璃正中，反客为主且消解诗意。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"冷暗廊道与晚霞对照，单人抚镜留痕，尽显去后空寂之诗意。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"登机长廊、暮色晚霞、客机与抚镜手印俱全，物象克制雅致。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"长廊透视深远，晚霞光候精准，室内外明暗与视线流向极佳。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"质感厚重统一，透视严密，色调幽微，无任何生成瑕疵。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"独对残霞抚镜神韵极佳，环境英文字标贴切真实。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"空廊无人而独留冷镜手印，“只剩”二字的去后留白扣人心弦。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"长廊、航灯、机坪完备，以空镜凸显掌痕，物象高度提炼。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"廊桥纵深结构真实，暮色航灯与反光自洽，时间感明确。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"写实度极高，玻璃反光与水汽质感精妙，空间层次分明。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"空镜头以虚代实点透诗眼，登机标牌文字无误规范。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"送别叙事完备，但红日高悬金光绚烂，削弱了“暮色昏”之清冷。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"长廊、行者背影、送者抚镜、客机与掌痕一应俱全。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"动线与空间层次极清晰，但落日过亮，与“暮色昏”略有偏差。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物轮廓与光影层次丰富，透视结构精准，细节自洽。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"登机口指示标牌清晰自然，融入真实环境。"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp14":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp14","topic":"天台菜园","order":["openai","xai","microsoft","meta","bytedance","zhipu","alibaba"],"ok":true,"secs":76.0,"cost":0.04028475,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"都市天台的田园自适与脚下繁华灯火形成绝妙反差，意境深远。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"抱瓮、女儿墙、瓜苗豆架、千窗火与明月皆精准还原。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"落日余晖未尽而满月已升，高台俯瞰都市，时空层叠自然。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"光影柔和，水流与枝蔓细节生动，画面主次层次分明。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"暮色、满月与都市灯火交相辉映，诗意张力极强。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"设色清淡沉静，但构图较为局促，天台菜园的旷远感略显不足。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"水具有长流嘴偏离传统瓮形，女墙、豆架与远方窗火均可辨。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"暮霭沉沉与淡月并存，自高处矮墙俯瞰城镇灯火，层次通顺。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"工笔水墨组织完整，人物衣褶与菜苗水流连贯自然。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗完整，字迹工整，印章布局妥帖。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"画面更似泛化的古代依江夜市，缺少高处孤冷与田园对照之意。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"有瓮有瓜架，但“千窗火”演变为江南沿江瓦舍，失却密集感。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"残阳微露与皎月同辉，高台俯瞰水乡城镇，方位关系明确。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"笔墨工细，楼阁与蔬果描摹清晰，虚实相生。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题字出现“两千千”、“忽珵”等严重错漏伪字，破坏文气。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"纯夜景且人物视线向下，未能呈现俯瞰千窗火的心境转折。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"抱瓮、女墙垛口与菜架齐备，千窗火偏于古代夜市集镇。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"夜幕全黑且挂残月，未体现诗中黄昏向月光转换的光候。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"砖石质感厚重，水流与光影自洽，透视空间合理。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"城头拓荒的超脱旷达呼之欲出，与下方人间烟火构成生动对照。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"陶瓮、女墙堞垛、竹架豆苗、万家灯火与明月一应俱全。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"古城女墙上俯视万家灯火，余晖伴明月，空间纵深感极佳。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"版画插图风格干脆利落，形体组织分明，城墙纵深稳定。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"将菜畦构筑于城墙马道，别出心裁点化“上女墙”诗意。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"构图沉闷如市井菜农劳作，毫无高台隐逸与自适的诗意情感。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"手执小盆而非“瓮”，植物单插竹签无“瓜苗豆架”之形。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"夜空光源过强如射灯，远景楼宇灯火零落，缺乏“千窗火”之势。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"构图逼仄，前景杂乱，色彩昏暗且主体辨识度欠佳。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"物象“瓮”退化为单手小盆，“瓜苗豆架”严重缺失。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"背对繁华都市专注浇畦，将“我自浇畦”的超然孤独感拉满。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"抱瓮、女儿墙、瓜叶豆架、千万窗火及天心明月精准具足。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"现代高楼天台俯瞰不夜城，晚霞初歇月轮当空，时空严密契合。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"超写实光影极佳，叶片露水与水流质感精细，空间宏阔。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"女子背影与无垠千窗火视觉对照极妙；标题字位得当。"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp15":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp15","topic":"云仓夜扫","order":["meta","openai","alibaba","bytedance","microsoft","xai","zhipu"],"ok":true,"secs":72.7,"cost":0.040206,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"红线破暗长廊幽深，工人俯身凝睇封条，静夜怀乡余味深长。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"长廊红线、箱签插画、封条胶带与云端屏幕齐备且对应准确。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"深夜两点云仓通道纵深极佳，贴封与视线动作关系严密自洽。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"景深透视开阔，机具与人物质感细腻，遮挡与光影秩序井然。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"终端屏幕与封条文字自洽真实，环境字形无误。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"借画外月夜旧巷之虚景对照冷光云仓，乡情转折外化清晰。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"扫码枪红光、云端地图与故乡箱签皆具，但故乡二字略显直白。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"以双层时空并置童年小巷与现代仓储，动作与空间层次分明。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物与机械结构扎实，两组时空光影衔接柔和无生硬断层。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"屏幕云仓地图与封箱文字准确切题。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"女工抚摸面单神情专注，具含蓄离绪，但机械摆拍感稍重。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"儿时巷具体化为真实快递地址，但未画出贴封条之物态动作。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"仓储长廊透视成立，但右侧凭空伸出持枪断手致主客逻辑混乱。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"人物面部与传送带结构清晰，惟画面右缘断臂遮挡突兀。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"面单设计贴切真实，但突兀断臂穿帮破坏单人场景。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"悬浮系统图示与生硬贴画冲淡了深夜抚签细看的幽微诗情。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"箱上印儿时巷图示、红线扫码皆有，但矿灯头盔与封条动作缺漏。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"现代仓储立足点明确，然浮空UI与仓内戴头灯在逻辑上不融洽。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"人物与货架光影尚可，全诗题字粗暴入画且UI浮层显杂乱。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"全诗抄录占位，浮空UI文字生硬夺主。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"玻璃透映月下双童背影，将数据流水线化作乡愁驻足，动人心魄。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"夜半云端屏、长廊红光、儿时巷箱签及封签动作均完美呼应。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"深夜明月、远山灯火与仓内流水线层次分明，虚实映射自洽。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"构图严谨精妙，冷暖光线穿透质感出色，人物神态专注动人。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"虚实倒影寄寓童年神来之笔，界面箱签文字规范。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"老工人静夜伫立具沧桑感，然红灯笼回廊偏离现代云仓情调。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"将红线激光误作红灯笼，儿时巷化为悬挂画稿而非箱签。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"室内地面潮湿积水不合常理，光影虽暗但时代场景指称错乱。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"厚涂质感与人物体量扎实，但场景要素与工业逻辑存在抵触。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗夹杂严重乱码错字，红线误画为红灯笼。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"神情木讷平淡，仅机械封装箱子，未显出忽见与细看之情感起伏。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"封箱与儿时巷标签具备，红线却画成天顶杂乱飘带，物象失真。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"仓内通明如白昼缺乏夜半感，红线在空间中悬空无源、轨迹离奇。","画面质量":4,"画面质量_评":"半空红线呈现典型生成杂乱线条伪影，结构失控且分散视线。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":2,"加减分_评":"天顶红线呈无规则面条状悬空漂浮，属典型AI伪影。"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp16":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp16","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","order":["zhipu","alibaba","bytedance","xai","meta","openai","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":61.7,"cost":0.02814225,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"巨木扎根路中央显荒诞，未传达孤木初萌之怜意。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶悬挂混乱，老树根系盘错与“根尚浅”抵触。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"树木突兀立于行车道正中，空间逻辑混乱违和。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"主体造型完整，但比例与城市透视欠协调。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"树根突兀盘结在沥青路面，属于生活常识穿帮。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"湿地反光衬托宿雨之感，特写寄寓新生希望。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、固定支架及“初萌”新芽刻画精准切题。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"雨后春日街头与远方高厦空间层次清晰自然。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"质感逼真细腻，水珠通透，虚实处理得当。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"水彩清丽温润，但乡镇氛围削弱了离林依厦之感。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"吊架与树形准确，背景为矮铺而缺少“高厦”。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"呈乡镇或郊外街道，与诗中高楼语境偏离。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"构图舒适，色彩淡雅，视觉组织规整自洽。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"楷体题诗位置合适、字形端正清晰。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"枝头挂满晶莹泪滴，意境凄清且扣合诗眼。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"树木吊瓶俱全，但晶滴过多稍显过度具象化。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"烟雨长街透视连贯，欧式立面偏离现代高厦。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"水墨淡彩相融，建筑与树木主次层次井然。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗出现重复抄写同一诗句的硬伤。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"阴雨冷寂衬托初植孤弱，切合“清如宿雨声”。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"树干包扎与注药输液切合，唯叶片略繁。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"沥青路面水渍与楼宇纵深符合春街设定。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩晕染生动自然，近实远虚把控得当。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"阳光过于晴朗明亮，欠缺迁植初萌的凄侧张力。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"树身粗壮且绿叶成荫，偏离“根浅叶初萌”。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"宽阔林荫大道与摩天大楼空间关系明晰。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"景深自然，光影立体，细节质感丰富扎实。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"远山如雪与近景高厦对照，暗合自饮千山旧忆。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、支撑架皆备，“营养液”标签略直白。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"滨水林荫道烟雨迷蒙，山城时空层次分明。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"设色清润雅致，雨中倒影与虚实关系协调。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"行楷题诗与印章落款工整切题。"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp17":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp17","topic":"抓娃娃机","order":["meta","alibaba","zhipu","bytedance","microsoft","openai","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":80.0,"cost":0.03744,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"爪开偶悬与隔窗张臂形成张力，倒影幽微切合相偎之意。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"布偶方悬、机械爪开、稚子临窗倒影等关键物象皆齐备。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"机台操作键在隔断窗内，孩子却立于窗外，空间方位略脱节。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"雨夜玻璃质感与玩偶刻画细腻，主次分明无明显破绽。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"机身汉字规范清晰。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"爪开熊悬的瞬间与深情凝视的倒影呼应，传达出留恋之情。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"布偶悬空、利爪张开与玻璃倒影分明，张臂动作稍显偏坠。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"孩子临机站立位置得当，机内高悬与窗外视线空间关系自洽。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"摄影写实度高，毛绒与金属质感真实，光影层析分明。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"悬空小熊与玻璃倒影目光交汇，构成动人对照。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"布偶未见悬空，孩子开怀大笑，缺少爪开失落与相偎张力。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"玩偶皆堆在底部无方悬之态，倒影显现杂乱女人面孔。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"人机位置大体成立，但爪开与底堆玩偶缺乏动态关联。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"人物手部结构略僵，玻璃反射出现突兀畸变的人脸伪影。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"玻璃倒影异常出现他人面孔伪影。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"小熊稳坐台座，孩子倚台静观，缺失偶悬爪开的情感悬念。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"布偶安坐未被悬起，孩子双手撑台未作张两臂相拥之态。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"室内机台光影统一，但空爪与底座小熊无交互运动关系。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"面部特写与机械细节扎实自然，景深虚化得当。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"机顶汉字清晰端正切题。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"玩偶端坐堆中，爪空悬在上，全靠题诗说明，画面无相偎张力。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"兔偶未被抓起悬空，缺失方悬动态，仅具临窗张臂与倒影。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"人机相对方位明确，机械爪悬置位置脱离抓取动作施受。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物衣饰与玻璃反光刻画清晰，结构规整稳定。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗字形端正切题。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"爪开偶坠瞬间与倒影视线相依，将惜物欲揽的诗意推向极致。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"布偶方悬、利爪张开、稚子张臂及清晰倒影无一遗漏且精准。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"落爪失落的刹那定格极其准确，镜面虚实空间层次严密。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"光影渲染极富质感，机件反光与毛绒纤维表现自然无瑕。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"小熊悬空下坠与倒影双臂环护之势浑然天成。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"水彩虚实相生，真身倒影两臂环抱悬偶，将相偎诗眼化为妙境。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"投币按键、爪开偶悬、稚子仰面张臂及镜影全数生动呈现。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"人、机、爪、偶的高低动静秩序井然，倒影透视精准。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"水彩晕染通透灵动，线条洗练，无生成畸变。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"机顶文字端正，倒影相依构图深合诗心。"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp18":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp18","topic":"旧衣回收箱","order":["alibaba","bytedance","openai","meta","microsoft","zhipu","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":68.3,"cost":0.0361785,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"母子依恋与催归互动生动，及肩身量暗合岁月流逝。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"绿匣、悬袄、攀痕短袖与及肩少年皆备，对应完整。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"斜阳街景与投衣动作吻合，方位光候交代明晰。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰质感真实，但男孩伸出的手臂结构略显别扭。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"男孩左臂指向姿态不自然。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"母女呆立箱前缺乏催归急迫感，余味淡薄。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"女童远未及肩；手中硬币袋将深兜零钱误为整袋现款。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"夕阳方位尚合，但驻足状态与投包动作衔接模糊。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"形体与光影稳定，箱体中文标识规整清晰。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"硬伤穿帮：提整袋硬币与诗意脱节。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"斜阳熔金氛围极佳，唯孩童侧首仰望偏于依恋，催意不足。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"绿匣悬衣均备，少年身量齐肩，未刻意图解零钱更显自然。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"夕阳西坠、投包入箱与街边空间层次极其统一。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"光影纯熟细腻，人物结构自洽，箱体字样规范。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"画面文字：箱体公益标语切题且无错字。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"字面生硬拼凑，毫无岁月感伤与催归温情。","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"回收箱画成垃圾桶；插树枝与露糖果硬币属拙劣图解。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"时令光候尚可，但垃圾桶堆满杂物与诗中动作完全相悖。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"写实度尚可，但物象堆砌逻辑混乱、主次失序。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"硬伤穿帮：生硬图解树枝与糖果零钱。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"幼女仅及成人腰部，核心诗眼瓦解，催归意境尽失。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"绿箱旧衣可见，但稚子幼小与及肩抵触，地面散落钱包失当。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"夕阳余晖下母女离去合理，但晴日雨后积水略显突兀。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"手绘插画风组织连贯，但题诗存在明显脱漏错字。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"文字失当：诗句脱字；孩童身高不符。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":1,"意境情感_评":"幼儿啼哭与母亲逗乐偏离诗意，完全无催归流光之感。","意象物象":1,"意象物象_评":"绿筒非回收箱，怀抱幼童非及肩稚子，关键物象全失。","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"街心长椅抱哄，与斜阳投包、催归归途的动作完全脱节。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"摄影细节尚可，但核心事件与诗意彻底背道而驰。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":3,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"硬伤穿帮：物象与身份全面偏题。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"并肩向斜阳而行，及肩身量与抬手催归极具岁月流转之韵。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"绿匣悬袄、短袖条纹及已及母肩之子刻画精准贴切。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"投衣之后母子踏斜阳急归，时空承续浑然一体。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"绘本质感温润，光影层次丰富，全诗题款工整准确。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"神来之笔：及肩背影；题字清秀准确。"}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp19":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp19","topic":"社区食堂","order":["alibaba","bytedance","openai","microsoft","meta","zhipu","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":71.7,"cost":0.03900075,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"夕照入室投射碗底，空席待客与半开门扉生发无言暖意。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"一荤两素齐整，洗净杯盘备好，竹箸虚位以待，物象切题。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"斜照穿窗透壁，门半掩连通暮色街巷，时空交代准确自然。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"器物形体组织井然，光影虚实极自然，毫无生成瑕疵。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"光透瓷碗化为碗底红晕，神会诗眼。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"暮色虽暖，但待客之情稍平，依仗文字招牌直白表意。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"一荤两素、沥水架净盘及竹箸俱全，盘底红光微嫌刻意。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"穿窗晚照与半掩门外暮光朝向一致，空间层次清晰通达。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"旧木与水泥墙质感沉稳，陈设透视严谨自洽。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"老人已在座进食，待翁意蕴落空；标语过多削弱余韵。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"前台盘如残羹，虽标一荤两素但实物含混，净盘未明示。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"食堂深远明朗，落日穿窗与半掩门光线逻辑统合完好。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"写实光影与景深过渡优异，空间层次繁而不乱。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"标语宣传画多处堆砌，略显喧宾夺主。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"全诗抄录且老翁已就餐，期待之意荡然无存，流于概念。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"图解式画出一荤两素与净盘，物象齐全但堆砌感明显。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"窗外夕阳色彩浓烈，但室内受光逻辑不够连贯统一。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"插画造型清晰，但人物与背景质感稍显扁平生硬。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左侧整幅抄写全诗，文字喧宾夺主严重。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"水渍未干的净盘与空位竹箸极具生活温度，深得留待之意。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"一荤两素准确，洗净杯盘尤显真实，唯碗底红稍欠直观。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"窗格斜照拉长光影，门外暮色初合，时令空间极为精准。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"餐盘水珠与桌面光泽细腻逼真，镜头感极强。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"白纸菜单字迹得体入微，倍增生活真实感。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"缺乏食堂氛围与留箸待人之态，更近私家寻常晚餐。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"未见洗净杯盘，门全开而非半掩，碗底红未能体现。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"门外夕阳刺目，墙面窗影与门光朝向稍显冲突脱节。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"菜肴边缘略糊，墙面装饰字画呈无序杂色块。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"菜品塑料感重且墙上色块糊烂，具AI伪影。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"暖汤映照红光，独留竹箸待客，画面清冷中寓温情。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"一荤两素盛于一盘，红汤映光，洗净杯盘由水盆布巾借代。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"暮色穿窗入室，半掩木门通向村落，光候营造极佳。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩水粉肌理雅致，光影渲染与器皿造形浑然一体。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"gemini-3.8-flash_shp20":{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","id":"shp20","topic":"社区食堂","order":["alibaba","microsoft","openai","bytedance","xai","zhipu","meta"],"ok":true,"secs":81.4,"cost":0.04222575,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"冷雨与暖店对照鲜明，蓝衣疾走与老人对谈相映成趣。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"蓝衣取盒、车铃、小榜、白发老人及热饭菜均清晰可辨。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"雨水积洼与骑行动态协调，内外空间关联自然顺畅。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"日漫风格线条清爽，人物神态生动，光影层次分明。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"小木板黑板菜单书写工整贴切。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"烟雨深巷与食堂温情呼应，但左上大量题字削弱余意。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"蓝衣、小榜、厨娘均在，但白发老人身居室内未倚窗。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"雨中小巷透视深远，人物前后呼应，动静分明。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水粉写实风格细腻，建筑与湿地质感刻画深入。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左上题诗多处严重错字颠倒，如“白衣”“腐院香”。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"雨巷幽深反光，临窗白发老人的欢笑与骑手动势生动呼应。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"软烂饭、蓝衣取盒、车铃、倚窗老人及明日菜单全备。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"门窗结构划分精妙，青石雨巷与室内暖光虚实相生。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"摄影级光影与水汽质感，人物动态自然毫无违和。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"小黑板手写软烂饭及明日菜单切题工整。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"暖光与雨夜对比佳，但车铃挂“急”字过于生硬直白。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"小榜、笋尖汤、蓝衣取盒、窗内白发笑语物象齐全。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"临街门面与室内空间层次清楚，雨夜反光真实。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"写实度高，人物肌理与蒸汽效果刻画扎实。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"铃铛贴“急”字略显生硬，门旁标语文字微有不顺。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"雨天湿冷却让白发老人坐露天用餐，削弱了温情逻辑。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"小榜餐价、蓝衣推车、厨娘均在，但老人并未临窗。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"地面湿冷积水与室外无遮雨棚用餐产生场景矛盾。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩插画质感清新，绿植与古旧墙面层次丰富。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"小榜字迹工整清晰，列出餐价切题。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"生硬采用四格分镜拼贴，割裂空间，缺乏整体诗意张力。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"多处图解生硬，右上突兀出现年轻男厨，人物指称混乱。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"分镜拼贴导致时空混乱，室内外透视与比例彼此割裂。","画面质量":4,"画面质量_评":"排版简陋拼凑，人物比例失调，边缘粘连生硬。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":2,"加减分_评":"多画格生硬拼贴，画面结构明显失控崩坏。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"门窗内外冷暖动静强烈对照，诗中烟火与温情被绝妙点活。","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"软饭姜汤、笋尖大锅、蓝衣车铃、临窗白发一应精妙呈现。","时空场景":10,"时空场景_评":"由内观外的双重取景框兼顾胡同雨景与灶台温情，动静自洽。","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"极其写实自然，蒸汽、水光、面部皱纹光影臻于化境。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"构图妙极，榜上特注“煮软”“姜汤驱寒”极为传神。"}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp01":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp01","topic":"旧衣回收箱","order":["xai","google","bytedance","alibaba","openai","meta","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":188.6,"cost":0.03298008,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"背影驻足有效传达了“逡巡”的不舍，情绪留白恰当。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"衣物似成人款，非典型“童衫”；铁柜与签名卡准确。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"幽暗巷弄构建了适合徘徊的心理空间与纵深感。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"胶片质感细腻，光影层次丰富，主体清晰。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"偏向公益宣传图示，缺乏诗意张力与“逡巡”的惆怅。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"手持衣物为成人毛衣，与诗中“童衫”核心意象不符。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"闹市背景写实，但嘈杂环境削弱了此刻的私密性。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"成像清晰，但箱体“闭”字如UI贴图，略显出戏。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":-1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱面“闭”字过于机械，破坏画面的自然融合感。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"暖光下的爱意较浓，淡化了割舍旧物时的那一丝愁绪。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"手中白色T恤尺寸较小，准确还原了“童衫”特征。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"晴天街道明亮，与全诗含蓄内敛的基调略有温差。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"构图自然，人物姿态生动，无明显生成瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"特写聚焦指尖与名牌，成功唤起“只有针痕认得人”的联想。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"衣领、针脚与名牌清晰，紧扣名物细节。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"近距离裁切导致“临街”的大环境信息基本缺失。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"对焦精准，织物纹理与手部动作真实可信。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"夕阳下投递与回望，将“叠罢逡巡”的深情演绎得淋漓尽致。","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"童衫、剪刀、散落名签齐全，完美响应每一处物象。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"暮色长街，动作连贯且符合“剪-投-闭”的逻辑顺序。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"构图饱满，光影唯美，前景道具极具叙事性。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"前景的剪刀与碎签是“名签剪落”的神来之笔，直击诗眼。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"无人之境尽显“箱门闭”后的寂寥，以空镜写情深。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"童衫与剪碎标签在场，但柜身斑驳不符“漆色新”设定。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"定格在动作结束后的静默时刻，时空逻辑自洽。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"纪实风格强烈，残损纹理增添了现实的沧桑感。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":-1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"柜体油漆严重剥落老化，与首句“漆色新”形成直观矛盾。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"烟雨气氛尚可，但墙面大幅题诗过于直白，剥夺想象。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"名签粘贴于箱体而非“剪落”，对关键动作理解有误。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"江南水乡背景过于特定，偏离了普适的“临街”场景。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画质精细，人物融入环境，但视觉重心被文字打散。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":-3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左侧竖排诗文属于喧宾夺主的题款，严重干扰画面阅读。"}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp02":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp02","topic":"深夜视频","order":["microsoft","bytedance","xai","alibaba","openai","meta","google"],"ok":true,"secs":186.2,"cost":0.03563112,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"仅现温情交流，缺失“翻惊”自省的关键转折与生命震撼。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"掌中屏、屏中笑语、观者老态及书卷雅物均准确可辨。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"烛光与窗外夜山确立午夜时令，屏内外空间分隔清晰。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画风统一厚重，细节丰富，人物与景物组织有序。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗书写工整，内容切合，位置恰当不夺主。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"光影有沉郁感，但屏中人似自照导致“笑语”指向模糊，惊心不足。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"掌中机与鬓边灰可见，然屏中人身份含混（似近非远），略损诗义。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"暗背景与侧光暗示午夜独处，时空关系基本成立。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"摄影质感佳，构图简洁有力，主体清晰无瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"竖排诗文书写正确，位置得体，增古典气韵。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"唯美化消解了“鬓先灰”的沉重与“翻惊”冲击，流于泛化抒情。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"掌中屏与笑语具备，然观者自身衰老（髯鬓灰）完全缺席。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"月夜千山背景契合诗意，但场景虚化致室内深夜私密感较弱。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"艺术渲染精致，水墨与光效融合，氛围感强无技术瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"精准捕捉“屏昏成暗镜”诗眼，观者惊愕表情直击“照我鬓先灰”震颤。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"掌中屏、暗镜自照、鬓角先灰三关键意象一一落实，比喻转化自然。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"暖光孤照确证午夜室内，屏内外同一人形成虚实自省层次。","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"高度写实，面部微表情与光影层次细腻可信，无可挑剔。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"以手机屏幕直接作“暗镜”的视觉转换，点破全诗枢纽。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"以桌镜与屏互文完美外化“成暗镜”隐喻，手扶头姿态传神写出“翻惊”。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"屏、镜、鬓灰、笑语四要素齐全，以物理之镜强化诗意之镜，构思精巧。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"窗外月夜城市与室内孤灯对照，时令方位无误，生活层次丰富。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"现代生活场景刻画真实，多元素组织有序，主次分明无杂乱。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"镜屏对照的独创性构图，将抽象诗眼转化为不可移易的视觉证据。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"情绪基调与诗中“笑语分明”根本冲突，导向相反的恐惧悲伤，属反默写锚点。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"掌中设备尚存，但屏中形象为哭脸而非笑语，关键性质已反转，“鬓灰”隐没。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"深夜室内场景成立，纸巾等道具辅助时间线索，整体可读通。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物表情与道具细节刻画深入，戏剧张力强（尽管语义方向错误）。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"将明确的“笑语”误作哭脸，造成诗义根本抵触。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"呈现天伦之乐的温情，却完全失落“翻惊”的生命痛感，将自伤异化为欣慰。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"掌中屏、远方笑语、观者白发三者俱在，名物身份明确，次要简化合理。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"台灯、夜窗外景与床榻陈设共同构建午夜私域，真实可信。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"温暖的生活化质感，人物神态自然，无技术瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp03":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp03","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","order":["openai","xai","bytedance","alibaba","meta","microsoft","google"],"ok":true,"secs":178.1,"cost":0.03113568,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"湿润路面与垂落输液管呼应「错认雨脚」，氛围沉静含哀，但张力略平。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"大树、吊瓶、输液管（长丝）、新绿、春街诸要素完备且关系清晰。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"春日细雨或雨后湿街，多树排列形成「一街」之景，时空一致。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"写实摄影质感细腻，主次分明，无生成瑕疵或粘连。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"水墨晕染出迷离雨意与淡淡哀愁，然树干贴诗签稍显直白。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"核心意象齐全，树干所贴诗签虽有创意却略损自然意象之真。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"春雨蒙蒙的古街纵深，远近层次分明，季节气候准确。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"水墨技法纯熟，气韵贯通，形体与空间组织自洽。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款与诗签书写正确、位置得体，切合水墨画传统。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"枯槁主干与零星嫩芽强烈诠释「病中开」，哀感深沉，极具感染力。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"裸露断根、枯枝、点滴瓶、稀疏新绿，精准对应全诗核心名物。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"春雨石街、伞影行客，营造出江南暮春之时空，移植状态可辨。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"笔墨简练而形神兼备，枯润浓淡控制精当，无败笔。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"枯荣对比为「病中开」之绝佳视觉转译；题诗工整雅致不夺主。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"偏向园艺工程记录，缺乏诗意情感投射，「哀」与余韵皆淡薄。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"移植树木、营养液吊瓶等技术性名物准确，但缺艺术提炼。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"春季雨天、现代道路、行列植树，时地基本明确。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"图像清晰但构图略显拥挤杂乱，主体未完全突出。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"水彩色调明快温馨，与原诗「哀」之情调存在明显偏离。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"土球、支架、吊瓶等移植特征清楚，核心对象可辨。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"春日湿润的老街场景合理，地面反光暗示雨意。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩风格统一协调，局部笔触略显松散但不碍辨识。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"「故山园艺」招牌暗合「故山来」，输液管混同雨丝极妙，哀婉动人。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"所有关键物象准确，店招成为点睛之笔，深化故山之意。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"春雨古街、撑伞行人、带土球树苗，时空高度一致且具体。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"水墨与写实结合自然，细节丰富有序，无结构崩坏。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"「故山园艺」招牌与雨丝输液管双重诗意妙构；左侧书法题款规范。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"大面积文字遮蔽图像，阻断视觉联想，沦为说明书配图，几无余意。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"树与吊瓶可辨，但重要区域被文字侵占，完整性受损。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"现代街景大致可认，但细节被文字掩盖，层次模糊。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"文字叠加严重妨碍观看，画面组织失衡，主次颠倒。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"超大号诗文直接覆盖画面左侧及上方，严重喧宾夺主，属文字失当。"}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp04":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp04","topic":"云仓夜扫","order":["google","meta","openai","microsoft","xai","bytedance","alibaba"],"ok":true,"secs":178.8,"cost":0.02960312,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"孤身扫夜氛围真切，散落签单与空廊形成寂寥视觉张力。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"竹帚、高耸货架、村名残签及远处待发车灯皆准确呈现。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"室内冷调照明与门外微曦体现夜尽时分，内外空间层次分明。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"写实摄影级质感，结构稳定，光影过渡自然无AI伪影。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"地面“王家村”等环境文字真实切合“残签藏故里”的诗眼。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"铁臂静默与孤灯残签形成强烈对比，精准传递收工后的落寞。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"休眠机械臂、落地竹帚、写有“故里”之名的面单一应俱全。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"门外天光微亮准确暗示“东方欲白”，动静结合紧密。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"构图完整，焦点落在前景面单上，视觉引导逻辑清晰。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"面单上“桃源村·故里”字迹清晰，极具叙事补足作用。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"偏向常规忙碌的作业现场，缺失“夜扫”特有的孤寂与空灵感。","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"核心动作道具“扫帚”完全缺失，人物变为扫码而非清扫，严重偏离。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"虽见朝霞，但室内亮度偏高，削弱了由夜转昼的微妙时间感。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画质精细度高，色彩和谐，但语义层面偏离主题。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"硬伤：丢失“扫”这一核心动作，使“夜扫”主题无法成立。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"情绪饱满，但大面积题字过度解释，削弱了图像本该有的含蓄留白。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"竹帚、休眠铁臂、带有乡愁文案的残签均已落实。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"天色灰暗朦胧，远处卡车尾灯暗示行程开始，逻辑基本通顺。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"二次元画风统一，人物与机械结构无明显崩坏。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"残签文案“到不了的远方也是故里”颇妙；但左上巨幅题字喧宾夺主。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"神来之笔：利用货架透视直接画出“千重货架隔归程”的空间阻隔感。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"竹帚、残签、油灯、竹影及“故里村”名牌等关键物件无一遗漏。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"晓雾迷蒙中的冷色调与门外暖光对比，极精准传达夜尽时分。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"油画笔触厚重大气，氛围渲染力极强，画面组织成熟。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"货架尽头透出的村庄实景完美视觉化了诗中最难表现的虚写部分；题款得体。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"探照灯光束营造了孤独前行感，但重心在“行”而非“扫”的动作上。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"包含铁臂、竹丛、散纸，但人物主手持电筒，清扫动作处于边缘状态。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"天边曙色初显，地面反光暗示潮湿或夜露，符合“欲白”节点。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"光影处理自然，画面整体协调，未见明显生成瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左上角题字排版略显现代，稍有跳出古意情境之感。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"特写凝视“村名”签的瞬间，精准捕捉了全诗结尾“分外轻”的慰藉感。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"“云水村”标签、背景休眠铁臂、旁置扫帚均符合诗义逻辑。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"冷色调晨光射入仓库，准确体现了工作即将结束的清晨时令。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"超写实风格严谨，人物蹲姿与专注神情刻画细腻生动。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"手中标签“云水村”字迹清晰，有效强化了读者对“残签”的代入感。"}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp05":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp05","topic":"深夜视频","order":["google","alibaba","bytedance","meta","openai","xai","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":179.9,"cost":0.0296116,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"视角逻辑混乱，情感关系不明，似素材堆砌而非有机情境。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"具备蔬、菊、老少人物，但空间与交互关系自相矛盾。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"主观视角缺失，无法辨认观察者究竟身处何方。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"写实风格成熟，局部光影自然，未妨碍基础观看。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"温馨合规，属通用亲情符号，缺乏独特的深层张力。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"核心名物（寒床、手机、新蔬、慈颜）准确可辨。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"深夜异乡卧床与远方厨房的跨空间连接清晰成立。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画风细腻，光影过渡自然，主体动作连贯。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右侧行书「深夜视频」字形优美、位置得当，增色不少。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"左右分割过碎，削弱了视频连线特有的聚焦亲密感。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"元素齐全但过于分散，缺乏「移盘」「转镜」的交互焦点。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"物理空间生硬拼接，缺乏「隔屏相见」的统一时空感。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"虽精细但构图松散，视线难以在复杂场景中凝聚。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"环境的清冷（寒床）与屏幕暖光形成有效对照，情绪准确。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"身份、名物（蔬、菊）辨识度高，符合「异乡」漂泊设定。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"深夜、卧床、视频中的厨房，层次分明无冲突。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"电影级布光，质感真实，核心形体无畸变。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"完美捕捉全诗脉络，结局「屏暗温存」极具情感冲击力。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_详":"甚至将「声迟」具象为声波，细节考究，无一遗漏。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"利用双格画展现「通话中」到「结束后」的时间流变，高明。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"构思与执行俱佳，叙事性强，视觉规则连贯。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"对「荧屏暗后犹相对，掌底余温尚未凉」的视觉化解构堪称神来之笔。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"略显呆板，电脑大屏幕削弱了「掌底余温」的细腻触感。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"核心对象具备，但设备选型（电脑）略偏于「掌底」的诗意。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"「隔海」的背景处理较好，点明了异乡与距离的特征。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面完整，光影氛围浓厚，无明显生成缺陷。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"人物形似同龄姐妹，严重消解了「慈颜」的长幼深情与乡愁。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"关键人物身份（慈颜/游子）识别失败，偏离诗义。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"场景设置基本合理（夜、床、海景房），未发生时空倒置。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"画质尚可，但视觉重心被大面积文字严重侵占。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"文字过多喧宾夺主，且笔记处字迹模糊如乱码，干扰观感。"}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp06":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp06","topic":"天台菜园","order":["openai","alibaba","bytedance","google","microsoft","xai","meta"],"ok":true,"secs":178.7,"attempts":2,"cost":0.0313784,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"夕照暖调与门内笑颜呼应，营造辛劳后温情的待客氛围，契合诗意。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"菜畦、藤管、蓄水缸、灯前热羹等核心意象齐全，瓜果以黄瓜代亦属合理。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"“晚晴”夕照光影准确，天台空间纵深感强，室外暖光与室内灯光过渡自然。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"构图均衡，光影写实，细节丰富且无伪影，视觉完成度极高。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"敲门送羹的背影生动诠释结句情致，独自一人与热食形成微妙张力。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"聚焦后四句，羹、门、瓜具备，但“登梯”“藤绕管”等前半首环境特征简略。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"蓝调时刻天空准确传达“晚晴”将尽、“灯前”将至的时间节点。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"写实度高，主体动作清晰，唯左侧菜畦略显空疏，整体组织尚可。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"直观呈现送瓜见邻里的欢愉，情感饱满，稍减“犹是客”的漂泊沧桑感。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"瓜、藤、管、门俱在，但缺失“梯”“蓄水罂”“羹”等关键物象，覆盖不全。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"夕阳天台光影极具电影感，时间与空间定位精准，氛围渲染到位。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"电影级质感，人物神态自然，环境渲染出色，无可见生成瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左上角书法题诗字形端正切意，有效补足了画面未完的叙事线索。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"水墨疏离感完美承载“人犹是客”的漂泊之意，独行背影引人遐想。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"梯、土（背）、砖畦、藤管、水缸、灯、羹一一对应，意象还原度极高。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"天际余晖与屋内灯火分层，巧妙呈现“晚晴”至“灯前”的时空流转。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"插画线条流畅，繁而不乱，风格化处理统一且不影响核心信息辨认。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款位置得当，字形无误；背影走向菜地的孤寂感精准击中诗眼。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"清新的水彩格调偏向通用田园牧歌，独特的“过客”惆怅与分享感稍淡。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"瓜、管、畦、羹俱全，前景瓜果特写强化收获感，细节刻画细腻。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"黄昏城市背景清晰，窗内人影巧妙点出“邻扉”所指，空间层次分明。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"色彩明快布局合理，左侧题字虽清晰但体量稍大，略占视觉重心。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"全文誊写无误且具美感，但因面积较大稍有喧宾夺主之嫌，小幅加分。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"苍劲笔触与昏暗暮色渲染异乡孤寂，叩门动作将“试叩”的忐忑具象化。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"梯、畦、管、瓜、门、灯（风灯）完备，紧扣诗中苦涩与温情交织之物象。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"浓重暮色符合“晚晴”将尽设定，天台破旧感增强现实沉重与真实感。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"油画肌理感强，造型扎实，虽色调偏暗但层次分明，无结构性错误。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗字迹清晰，与苍凉画风协调，起到了很好的点题作用。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"重墨描绘“负土登梯”的劳作艰辛，烟火气浓厚，结句情感升华稍欠。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"土袋、梯子、砖畦、藤管、炉火、锅一一呈现，对首句动作的写实极强。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"低角度夕阳精确锁定“晚晴”时分，投影方向与物体结构逻辑严密。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"质感逼真，土壤、植物与材质表现堪称一流，几乎无可见AI伪影。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp07":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp07","topic":"云端相册","order":["meta","bytedance","google","alibaba","microsoft","xai","openai"],"ok":true,"secs":136.6,"cost":0.03501552,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"裁剪框与犹疑视线呼应「频停手」，围裙在边缘巧妙点出「不忍除」。","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"屏中孩童缺齿清晰，裁剪界面直观呈现「重裁」，围裙恰处裁切线上。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"现代家居环境契合「云端」科技感，操作动作连贯且逻辑自洽。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"摄影质感佳，UI交互细节（如「裁剪」「确认」按钮）逼真。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"界面中文准确传达了「云端相册」与「裁剪」的功能语义，辅助叙事。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"暖光营造怀旧氛围，但未体现「裁剪」与「取舍」的心理纠结过程。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"孩童笑容未见明显「缺齿」，围裙置于桌面而非屏中裁剪对象。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"黄昏逆光具有诗意，人物操作平板的动作符合日常情境。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"光影渲染出色，色彩温润，整体色调统一和谐。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"标题「云端相册」字体设计与画面融合较好，增添了文艺气息。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"仅展现观看动作，缺乏「重裁」与「不忍除」的特定情节与张力。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"图中孩童无「缺齿」特征，无「围裙」关键意象，亦无裁剪工具。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"室内自然光场景，符合一般阅读习惯，但缺乏特定时间指向。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"写实风格自然，无明显瑕疵，但略显平淡。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"裁剪框体现了「重裁」动作，神态温柔，但「不忍除」的戏剧性稍弱。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"屏中孩童身着围裙，但「缺齿」特征不明显，似为完整牙齿。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"明亮的厨房或餐厅背景，生活气息浓厚，光线合理。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画面通透，人物皮肤纹理细腻真实，构图平衡。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"屏中像竟是老妇，颠覆「小像/缺齿（童真）」的诗意基础，情感错位。","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"关键对象错误（老妪代孩童）；杯面与书本文字为乱码伪字。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"夜景窗前，时空关系尚可，但主体逻辑与诗意冲突。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"大量乱码文字严重干扰视线，属于明显的生成硬伤。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右侧虽有诗句，但左侧杯面书籍出现大面积乱码，且主体对象（老人）严重偏离原诗意象。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"水墨淡彩风格空灵，「云端」具象化为背景云海，诗意较浓。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"屏中孩童笑容甜美但「缺齿」不显著；实体剪刀隐喻「裁剪」。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"虚幻的云间场景，弱化了现实操作的时空逻辑，偏向写意。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"插画风格统一，线条柔和，色彩淡雅，无明显生成缺陷。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右侧题字工整，不仅补充了信息，更强化了传统诗词画的韵味。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"苍老手指触碰稚嫩笑颜，跨越时光的痛惜与爱怜极具感染力。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"「缺齿」黑白色旧照极度传神；桌上的剪刀精准对应「重裁」动作。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"陈设老旧的居室充满岁月感，与「旧照」形成完美的互文。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"影调温暖厚重，细节丰富，情感表达充分，无可辨识之伪影。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"「家庭相册」四字点睛，配合剪刀与旧照，将「不忍除」的深情推向高潮。"}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp08":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp08","topic":"抓娃娃机","order":["meta","google","bytedance","microsoft","openai","alibaba","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":154.2,"cost":0.03397112,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"精准定格“扯袖”瞬间，父女互动生动，极具生活期待感。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"娃娃机、小熊、拽袖动作均准确对应诗句，无硬伤。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"电玩城环境真实，人物站位与视线关系清晰合理。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"摄影质感极高，光影自然，无明显生成瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"机台文字“抓娃娃机”无误，略有增益。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"氛围温馨欢乐，但仅停留在投币互动，未触及诗后半段转折。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"核心物件齐全，但熊在爪中易被误读为“抓到了”，稍偏原意。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"场景交代清楚，背景虚化突出了主体人物。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面通透，色彩温暖，整体完成度较好。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"机台标识“抓娃娃机”清晰正确。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"表现为单纯的喜悦胜利，完全丢失了原诗“得失之间”的复杂况味。","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"严重违背诗眼：画成怀抱小熊，与“大掌摊开无一物”截然相反。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"场景本身合理，但因结果错误导致时空逻辑链条断裂。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画质细腻，人物表情生动，技术层面尚可。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":-3,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"核心情节“一无所得”被画反，属重大理解偏差。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"二次元风格虽有动感，但附加文案喧宾夺主，冲淡了原诗意境。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"虽有全诗抄录，但画面仍呈现“即将抓取/成功”态，未能表“落空”。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"构图略显拥挤，窗外雨夜景致虽美但非诗中重点。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"插画风格统一，但文字排版过于密集，干扰视觉。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"书写了完整原诗值得鼓励，但旁注过多略显累赘。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"**神来之笔**：以蒙太奇手法串联全诗，完美呈现从期盼到失落到温情的闭环。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"涵盖了扯袖、抓取、落空（或期待）、牵手等所有关键意象。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"利用四格分区巧妙处理了诗歌的时间跨度与空间转换。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"作为组合图各格质量尚可，但整体属拼贴感较强的叙事板。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"用图像叙事法重构了整首诗的剧情流，极具创意。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"着力渲染“归途牵手”的温情余韵，深得诗末“自相牵”之三昧。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"缺失抓娃娃的核心过程，更像是一幅“事后的散步图”。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"商场通道环境开阔，行走动线符合“归途”设定。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"光影柔和，透视准确，人物形态自然舒展。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"极具古典诗意，将“娇儿仰首脚跟悬”的体态与期盼刻画入微。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"小熊“眠”于匣底与空中铁爪形成静动对比，意象精准。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"聚焦于人与机的微观空间，虚实留白处理得当。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"水彩风格唯美，笔触与氛围高度融合，艺术感染力强。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"底部题诗字迹工整，不仅补足了叙事，更增添了书卷气。"}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp09":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp09","topic":"夜航俯瞰","order":["microsoft","openai","meta","google","xai","alibaba","bytedance"],"ok":true,"secs":124.4,"cost":0.03176912,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"铁翼切月与稚子望星形成完美呼应，静谧深远的诗意油然而生。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"铁翼、皓月、江流、山形、灯火及孩童等核心名物均精准呈现。","时空场景":10,"时空场景_评":"夜航高空俯瞰视角准确，月色与地景光影逻辑高度自洽。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画质细腻，光影层次极富质感，具有高超的艺术完成度。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗书法工整雅致，内容切合且位置得当，增色不少。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"真实还原了夜航的静谧与孩童的专注，情感视点集中。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"核心物象完备，江流与城市灯火分割清晰，符合诗意。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"透视关系正确，夜景氛围浓厚，方位与动作合理。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"写实风格精湛，细节逼真，无明显生成瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"野路车灯化作「流萤」的视觉转化极为巧妙，极具诗意张力。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"格网状城市对应「长街火」，旷野零星灯光完美呼应「几队萤」。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"俯瞰构图开阔，空间纵深感强，动静结合得当。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画风统一和谐，光效处理细腻，组织结构清晰。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"将车灯比作萤火虫的视觉呈现是全诗最大的亮点。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"月相错误导致清朗意境大打折扣，孩童视线略显游离。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"出现弯月，与诗句「移皓月」（明亮满月）的关键性质严重抵触。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"月相错误导致天象时间设定混乱，无法支撑「皓月」的时空背景。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"渲染精度高，人物面部与机舱细节均清晰可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":-2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"将「皓月」画成弯月，属于决定诗义的意象硬伤。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"水墨质感营造出空灵的诗意，繁华落尽唯余静观的气韵十足。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"完全缺失「铁翼」这一首句核心意象，仅见舷窗与远景。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"山川布局与夜色渲染极佳，符合高空俯瞰的空间特征。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"笔触晕染自然，整体格调高雅，视觉规则连贯。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":-2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"缺翼属重大意象遗失；题跋虽有古韵但稍显模糊。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"典型的现代航空摄影风格，纪实感强但文学意境稍淡。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"要素基本齐全，机翼红灯点缀夜色，但「山形」表现较弱。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"机舱内视角与外部景观匹配，但视野略显局限。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"清晰度极高，光线过渡自然，无明显伪影。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":-1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"窗框上的英文标识「WINDOW SHADE」略显出戏。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"父母入镜严重分散了「稚子凭栏」的孤独感与专注度。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"人物关系由单人聚焦变为家庭群像，略显喧宾夺主。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"场景真实，符合机舱环境与夜间飞行逻辑。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物互动自然，画面温馨，色彩协调。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":-1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"增加了诗中未言明的陪护人员，改变了原诗的视角纯度。"}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp10":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp10","topic":"机场送别","order":["xai","microsoft","alibaba","bytedance","google","openai","meta"],"ok":true,"secs":150.5,"cost":0.03312352,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"三联构图完整叙述送别至独行，围巾与眼神传递出深沉离愁。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"母亲、广播屏、隔窗手势、机舱围巾等核心意象无一遗漏。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"以画面切片巧妙衔接候机与飞行时空，转场流畅合理。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"笔触细腻，色调清冷统一，人物动态自然，无显性伪影。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"广播牌文字“催程广播”切合诗意；围巾细节动人。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"误将母女情作情侣别，情感基调偏离原诗特有的亲情羁绊。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"致命误将“母”画成男伴，导致核心人物身份指称完全错误。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"机场环境与阴雨天气营造了合理的离别时空，但缺机舱时空。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"摄影质感真实，但左侧大面积题字侵占画面，略显生硬。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":3,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"人物性别硬伤；左侧题字过大遮蔽画面。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"仅截取叮嘱场景，缺失“寒侵领”的余韵，情绪未完成闭环。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"具备母女与机场特征，但遗失机舱、航线屏及围巾动作。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"固定于单一时空节点，无法体现“屏上机移”的动态过程。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰写实，人物比例协调，属合格的商业摄影风格。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"幼子舱内独自围巾的背影极具冲击力，深刻点出母爱牵挂。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"母子身份确凿，Final Call、隔窗对望、御寒动作紧扣诗句。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"左右分割画面清晰界定了送行与旅途的两个平行时空。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"油画风格浓郁，光影运用精湛，情感表现力极强。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"选角与构图直击诗眼；屏显文字准确。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"倒影造成的人物混淆使送别关系暧昧，无法读取特定诗意。","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"大量核心意象（行李、广播、机舱、围巾）缺失，近乎空泛。","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"仅为静态特写，完全缺失诗歌要求的时空跨度与行动线索。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"面部表情刻画细致，但作为诗画作品信息量严重不足。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"剧情板式叙事条理清晰，冷静的画面下蕴含动人的离别深情。","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"完美还原“航线屏显千里路”与“舱内围巾”，意象对应精准。","时空场景":10,"时空场景_评":"创新采用三格布局，将广播、隔窗、机上御寒并置，逻辑满分。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"电影级画质，细节考究（如登机牌、航迹图），完成度极高。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"航迹图创意对应“千里路”；多处文字准确辅助叙事。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"成功捕捉“玻璃隔语”的无奈与母亲关切，但情绪止于表面。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"母亲形象（白发）准确，具备广播与隔窗要素，但缺失后四句。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"场景局限于安检口外，未能通过画面语言延伸至飞行途中。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"写实风格稳健，环境光线自然，无明显生成瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp11":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp11","topic":"夜航俯瞰","order":["bytedance","alibaba","meta","google","microsoft","openai","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":77.5,"cost":0.02470992,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"手贴冷窗与暖黄灯火形成冷暖张力，怀旧孤清感并存。","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"舷窗、长街、沿河断续黄灯、指尖触玻等核心名物完备。","时空场景":10,"时空场景_评":"夜色、高空俯瞰视角及向下的视线方向完全契合诗意。","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"光影细腻，虚实处理得当，视觉中心明确且无生成瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左侧题诗字迹工整，位置得体，增添了文人画气息。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"仅有指向动作，缺乏“指尖凉”的触感暗示与怀旧余韵。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"具备基本俯瞰与河流，但长街之“细”与灯火“断续”感不足。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"确立了夜间航行俯视的基础空间关系，逻辑通顺。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"整体可辨，但光线较暗，细节层次略显单薄。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"指尖按压玻璃产生的晕开水渍，巧妙呼应了“凉”与“触”。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"圆形舷窗、蜿蜒河道、密集灯火及手指特写均准确呈现。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"高空垂直俯瞰角度强烈，夜间氛围浓厚，方位清晰。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画质高清，水珠与光影质感真实，结构严谨无乱影。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"人物面部入镜过重，将观者注意力从“俯瞰忆旧”转向肖像。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"虽有舷窗与城市，但核心的“指尖凉”触觉转为单纯指点。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜间机舱内向外俯视的时空关系成立，未出现明显错乱。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体尚可辨，但因人物侧脸显得拥挤，削弱了窗外景致。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"云月掩映下的冷暖对照极富诗意，外化了寻访不得的怅惘。","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"长街如线、沿河灯火、深巷屋顶、触窗之手，意象丝丝入扣。","时空场景":10,"时空场景_评":"夜航高度、俯瞰视角、远近层次感与诗中空间完全一致。","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"构图宏大精致，光影渲染极具电影感，无可挑剔。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":3,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"画面本身已是神作；左侧行书题款典雅，印鉴到位。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"偏向纪实风格的航拍，情绪张力较弱，缺乏诗意留白。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"包含机翼、大桥、河流等元素，物件清单较全但稍显堆砌。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"夜间俯瞰的城市肌理清晰，运动方向与静止灯光合理。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"清晰度高，但色彩略显俗艳，艺术感染力一般。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"指尖指向模糊远方，留出了“欲认”而难得的空间想象。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"玻璃水雾、沿河长串路灯、俯视街巷均准确可辨。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"高空夜航纵深感表现优秀，符合“俯见”的物理透视。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"带轻微胶片感，色调统一，无明显的AI结构崩坏。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右侧竖排诗词布局均衡，字体端正，切合画意。"}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp12":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp12","topic":"云端相册","order":["microsoft","meta","openai","google","bytedance","xai","alibaba"],"ok":true,"secs":155.0,"cost":0.03636192,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"年轻观者削弱了“白头”与“初生”的岁月张力，情感偏通用。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"蒜、灶、烟俱全，但人物为青年，与诗中“白头”主角身份抵触。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"室内观屏与窗外的故堂景象分层清晰，逻辑通顺。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"光影写实，材质细腻，属于高质量摄影风格生成。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右侧题字与杯上文字清晰切合主题，小幅加分。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"白发苍苍的观者与屏中年轻母子形成强烈情感共振， poignant。","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"完美对应：老人、触屏、旧照、悬蒜、土灶、炊烟无一遗漏。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"人身处故堂前回望屏幕，实现了“开屏又立故堂前”的通感。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"构图自然，环境纹理真实，手指动作符合物理逻辑。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"虚实叠影的构图极妙，将“记忆”可视化，余韵悠长。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"核心意象齐备，左下角“旧照离箱”的箱子更是点睛之笔。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"利用景深区分了操作的双手（今）与背景的幻象（昔）。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"整体和谐，背景的半透明处理虽有朦胧感但不影响辨识。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"背景虚实转化的处理极具诗意，提升了画面的文学性。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"温馨质朴，准确传达了老人面对旧照时的慈爱与怀念。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"精准还原了老人、平板、蒜串、土灶与烟雾等关键名物。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"场景统一在老屋内部，动作与视线关系合理。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰，人物神态自然，无明显生成瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"画风古雅深情，但因载体错误，缺失了“云端/科技”的时代感。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"将“屏/云端”画成实体相册，且缺失“两指”交互的关键动作。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"传统国画构图稳定，人物位置与透视关系正确。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"笔墨细腻，色彩温润，作为独立画作质量极高。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":-2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题字工整加分；核心媒介（电子屏）误作实体书属硬伤。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"怀抱真婴的温馨冲淡了“追忆往昔”的沧桑与时空隔阂感。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"手持洗印照片而非“云端”屏幕，且多出一个实体的婴儿。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"场景统一，但现实与回忆的界限因实体的婴儿而模糊。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩风格统一，人物结构基本准确。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":-1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左侧书法加分；将“旧照”理解为实体照且怀抱真人，偏离诗眼。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"现代家居与屏中破旧农舍的对比，突出了“寄远天”的空间感。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"屏中直接展示全景（含蒜与灶），是对“开屏立故堂”的直译。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"今昔对比强烈，屏幕作为窗口的功能一目了然。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"光线柔和，人物皮肤与布料质感逼真，完成度很高。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右上角标题简洁切题，小幅加分。"}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp13":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp13","topic":"机场送别","order":["bytedance","google","openai","xai","meta","microsoft","alibaba"],"ok":true,"secs":114.9,"cost":0.03228072,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"两人对视与玻璃遗痕的虚实，精准传达无言送别的张力。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"闸机、长廊、航灯、掌痕等关键名物准确完备。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"暮色光影与登机口方位完全契合诗中时空设定。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"构图严谨，摄影质感真实，无显著AI伪影。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗字迹工整且位置得当；手印作为遗存与离去者呼应极妙。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"倚窗孤影传达惆怅，但缺送别对象互动，情感张力稍弱。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"具备玻璃、手印、机场，但缺失“检票闸机”特定标识。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"暮色与航灯远近层次分明，时间感准确。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"影调唯美，人物与环境融合自然。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"行者背影与留者抚痕的动静对比，有力诠释送别余意。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"登机口标识明确，手印与人物动作逻辑通顺。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夕阳高悬稍显明亮，略欠“暮色昏”的沉郁感。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰，透视与光影逻辑基本自洽。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"氛围压抑，但实体墙面削弱了“玻璃”的阻隔与通透感。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"仅见手印与指示牌，环境模糊，难以确指“检票长廊”。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"天光黯淡符合暮色，方位大致不差。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"画质偏糙，细节混沌，主体不够突出。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"巨大黑色手印过于突兀恐怖，冲淡了凄婉的送别基调。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"有长廊与手印，但比例失调，缺乏人物情感承载点。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"光线与空间纵深感尚可，符合机场环境。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"手印有明显贴图感，与玻璃光学逻辑不符。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"雨夜烘托凄清，行者远去与留者抚痕的叙事完整动人。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"核心意象齐全，但“大雨”非诗中所有，属无据生发。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"偏向入夜，虽合逻辑但与“暮色”初始状态有温差。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"插画风格统一，笔触与渲染质量较高。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":-1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"书法题字优美；擅自增添诗中不存在的“雨”景，略有过度演绎。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"发光悬浮的手影怪诞科幻，背离“掌痕”的写实悲情。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"手印形态失真，不像实物痕迹，更似全息投影。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"机场内部环境与傍晚天光基本准确。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"技术上无明显崩坏，但创意偏差导致观感违和。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp14":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp14","topic":"天台菜园","order":["openai","meta","microsoft","google","bytedance","xai","alibaba"],"ok":true,"secs":143.8,"cost":0.03356432,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"城市千窗火与天台浇畦形成明暗对照，黄昏转夜时光感强，情调悠然。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"抱瓮、瓜豆架、千窗火、月光等核心名物齐全，现代背景合乎诗意。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"黄昏至夜的天空渐变、天台高度与俯视方位准确，动作施受清晰。","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"写实画质极高，光影自然，人物动作与水流形态真实可信，无瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"古城墙耕作具隐逸感，但灯火稍显疏离，情绪张力与诗眼回应略弱。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"瓮、豆架、灯火俱在，但背景局限于仿古街景，对“千窗”展现不足。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜晚时令准确，女墙作城墙解亦通，动作连续，空间关系基本成立。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画风精致，古风服饰与场景融合度高，主次分明，无明显生成缺陷。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"水墨晕染出朦胧诗意，孤寂浇灌与万家灯火呼应，留白保留了余意。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"瓜豆支架、抱瓮、江城灯火精准呈现，题字虽佳但不计入此维依据。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"暮色苍茫与月升并存，时空层次分明，远景透视与近景浇灌可辨。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"国画风格娴熟，线条流畅，留白得当，气韵生动且视觉规则连贯。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗字形无误、内容切合且位置得体，水墨意境更添神韵。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"简笔画风削弱诗意深沉，千窗火仅作点缀，未能生成特定的情感张力。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"核心物件具备，但人物白发苍苍，改变了诗中未定的“我”之形象气质。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜景与天台基本正确，但背景过度简化，缺乏城市灯火的空间纵深。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"风格过于简略，形体松散，作为独立画作其信息量与组织度偏低。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"画面文字虽抄写全诗，但字体生硬且占据核心区域，略显突兀。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"巨大圆月与万家灯火形成壮丽反差，支撑了诗中旷达而静谧的情调。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"竹架瓜蔓细致，抱瓮倾水动态生动，古城背景灯火璀璨，名物性质准确。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"黄昏与初夜交界的光线精妙，城墙（女墙）方位清晰，动作逻辑自洽。","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"插画级精度，色彩温润，构图平衡，无粘连断裂，视觉组织极为出色。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"圆月与地面灯火的辉映堪称神来之笔，以视觉关系点出了全诗关键。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"斑驳肌理与繁华夜景交织，深刻传达“我自”坚守的内心宁静，意境深远。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"关键意象准确，特别是“千窗火”的密度与层次感极好地还原了诗意。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"锁定在日落后全城灯火的时刻，天台边缘的位置感强，时空线索一致。","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"艺术表现力极强，油画般的质感赋予画面独特的文学性与自洽性。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左侧题字书法有力且不夺主，配合画面质感极大地提升了整体格调。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"都市田园夜景氛围温馨，但稍显常规，独特性与情绪张力略逊一筹。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"物件齐全，但瓜豆架略显杂乱，城市背景虽大但同质化，细节稍欠。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜晚天台场景标准，人物动作符合“浇畦”，但时间过渡感不够明显。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"高清写实，但衣物与水流略带AI平滑感，局部细节稍显僵硬。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右侧题字略显突兀，占据了视觉重心，且有轻微的现代设计感违和。"}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp15":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp15","topic":"云仓夜扫","order":["google","alibaba","xai","openai","meta","bytedance","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":144.5,"cost":0.03503112,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"头灯夜色有真实感，但情感依赖文字标签直给，缺乏'细看'的视觉沉淀。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"仓库、扫码枪、红线、箱签（龙川村）等核心名物齐备，指称明确。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"头灯示夜半，长廊纵深，扫描动作明确，时空吻合度高。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"清晰写实，但左下角说明性图文叠加略显生硬，略有割裂。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗与箱签文字准确，位置虽显眼但未遮蔽主体。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"纯客观工作记录，'儿时巷'仅作面单文字，无情感视点，近于默写。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"面单直书'儿时巷 43号'，扫码枪与红线清晰，关键名物具现。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"光线明亮如昼，严重削弱'夜半'的时间限定，昼夜感反转。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"商业摄影级清晰度，人体结构与物件遮挡严谨无误。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"面单'儿时巷'文字清晰切合，辅助点明诗眼。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"暗调红灯营造夜班孤寂，但视线落点在PDA而非箱签，情感错位。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"箱外粘贴巷景照片代替'箱签'所见，对'忽见'的瞬时性略有偏移。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜间氛围浓，长廊深远，唯操作动作与'贴封条'不符。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"电影级光影，人物与环境刻画细腻，无生成畸变。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"竖排题诗工整，箱签'沙湾村''已封存'文字清晰。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"以右上角画中画喻示回忆，创意可取但与主体场景割裂，余味不足。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"大屏地图现'云端'，画中画现'儿时巷'，要素具象化程度高。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"全局亮调处理使'夜半'隐没，时间线索模糊，仅靠内容推测。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"多源素材合成，图层间边界生硬，统一感与纵深感不足。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"大屏'乡名逐码'与标语文字辅助表意，层次分明。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"贴封条动作定格'又细看'前瞬，箱签插图含藏乡愁，夜色静谧动人。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"封条、箱签（含乡名与巷景插图）、背景红线，名物与修辞精准互文。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"0:14 AM时间戳锁定夜半，长廊透视与作业流程严丝合缝。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"界面与实物纹理俱佳，信息层级清晰，无碍观瞻。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"时间戳、系统名、箱签文案高度契合诗意；箱签插图妙构点出诗眼。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"头灯劈开夜色有戏剧张力，但'儿时巷'巨幅标签过于直白，损余味。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"悬浮UI、'儿时巷'大字签、扫码枪，关键词全覆盖且可辨。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜班、长廊、扫描，时空框架正确，暗调氛围渲染充分。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"赛博朋克风统一，UI与实景融合自然，辨识度高。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗与WMS系统UI文字清晰，强化'云端'与'乡名'概念。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"月夜窗景与侧屏旧照双重视角，虚实映衬乡愁，唯视线焦点在终端。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"云仓大屏列'已上云'清单，透明屏嵌巷景旧照，意象丰满。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"满月星夜明确'夜半'，仓库空间开阔，时间证据确凿。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"CG渲染精良，材质与光影考究，构图均衡。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗与大屏列表文字丰富且切合，'夜扫描描'疑为笔误但微瑕不掩瑜。"}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp16":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp16","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","order":["meta","google","bytedance","alibaba","xai","openai","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":146.4,"cost":0.03116672,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"雨景凄清，吊瓶如泪，精准传达脆弱与新生的张力。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶悬枝，根系裸露且浅，完美呼应“根尚浅”与“玻璃泪”。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"春雨湿润的街道，远景高楼与近处孤树形成强烈空间对照。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"水彩质感通透，虚实相生，无碍观瞻的生成瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"写实记录感过强，缺乏诗意留白，更似园林养护报告。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶置于地面支架，未落实“挂”于树身的关键动作描述。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"街道湿滑符合“宿雨”，但光影平淡，缺乏特定时令氛围。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画质清晰写实，逻辑自洽，但作为艺术创作略显缺乏加工。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"光影明朗偏暖，削弱了“玻璃泪”的忧愁，偏向普通风景画。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、支架、初萌绿叶均有，但背景低矮民居稍欠“高厦”气势。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"晴日白昼，远山隐约，时空明确但缺少雨意的深层烘托。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"插画风格统一，但左侧题诗排版略显拥挤，稍有夺主之嫌。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗字形正确且内容切合，唯位置略偏。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"阳光下的生机虽缺愁绪，但有力突出了“叶初萌”的希望感。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"特写视角强化了针痕与输液管的连接，细节精准对应诗句。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"逆光下的通透感明确了春日晴天的设定，光影关系合理。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"焦点清晰，树皮与塑料瓶材质表现真实细腻，组织有序。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"水墨烟雨晕染出迷离愁绪，枝头水珠极佳诠释“玻璃泪”诗眼。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、疏枝、微萌新叶及背景撑伞人均准确，富有文人画韵。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"烟雨蒙蒙的春街，远近层次分明，营造出特有的湿润时空。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"笔墨气韵生动，构图疏朗，视觉规则连贯且极具美感。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"以国画风配旧体诗属妙构；题款钤印增色不少。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"过于艳丽喧嚣的街景，冲淡了孤树依人的清冷与深情。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶悬挂正确，绿叶茂盛，但“根尚浅”的孱弱感表现不足。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"明媚午后，车水马龙，时空信息完整但略显俗套。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"典型的精美AI绘图，色彩鲜艳，结构合理，无明显缺陷。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"烟雨都市中的孤树，冷暖色调对比下透出一股坚韧凄美。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"瓶身“营养液”标签点明属性，落花增添春日气息，指称精准。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"雨天黄昏，远处大桥与高楼确立了现代都市的空间坐标。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"动漫画风精致，雨丝与倒影渲染到位，氛围感极强。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右侧竖排题诗字形优美，与画面意境融合度高。"}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp17":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp17","topic":"抓娃娃机","order":["google","xai","meta","bytedance","openai","microsoft","alibaba"],"ok":true,"secs":171.9,"cost":0.04140472,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"精准捕捉孩童期盼与落空瞬间的张力，张臂姿态极具感染力。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"爪子张开、玩偶悬空、孩童张臂，核心名物与关键动作高度契合。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"真实的游戏厅环境，霓虹光影有力烘托出热闹与个体期待的对比。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"摄影质感高，构图完整，焦点清晰，无显著AI伪影或结构混乱。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"水彩画风温馨朦胧，体现了童真与渴望，但戏剧性稍弱于原诗转折。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"基本元素具备，但爪子状态偏向“抓取中”，非明确的“忽开”脱落状。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"背景过度虚化留白，缺乏具体时空特征，显得略为通用。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画风统一唯美，水彩晕染与线条均符合逻辑，视觉舒适度高。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"夜景玻璃反光极佳地呼应了“玻璃借影”的诗眼，孤寂与希冀并存。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"氛围营造极佳，但爪子呈现闭合抓取状，与“爪忽开”的落空感矛盾。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"雨夜街边/橱窗的设定极具故事感，光影层次丰富且统一。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"精美的动漫渲染风格，光影通透，人物与景物融合度极高。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"幼童形象憨态可掬，上方空爪与下方仰望形成强烈反差萌与落差感。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"明确画出空爪，对“爪忽开”这一关键动作结果的还原度在众图中最高。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"典型的室内游乐场场景，透视关系准确，光影合理。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"写实风格细腻，人物皮肤纹理、表情及眼神光生动自然。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"呈现的是即将成功的惊喜/期待，偏离了诗中“落空”后的怅惘基调。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"爪子紧闭并抓牢玩偶，与诗句“爪忽开”的直接描写形成硬性抵触。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"场景构建合理但平庸，未能通过环境辅助提升特定的诗意。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画质精细，色彩明快，作为独立商业插画质量很高。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"手贴玻璃的动作生动传达了“临窗”与欲“相偎”的主观意愿。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"爪子空置悬顶，准确回应了诗句描述的动作结果，指称无误。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"商场环境明亮，背景虚实处理得当，空间感清晰。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"图像本身清晰，但右侧大段文字严重破坏了画面的视觉平衡。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"大段题诗喧宾夺主，且依据通则文字不得补足图像缺失。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"神情专注平静，缺失了“落空”后特有的惊愕、失落或补救的动态张力。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"爪子闭合抓住玩偶，误将“成功抓取”当作“掉落”来表现，核心动作错误。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"普通的商场角落，无明显时代或特殊时令特征，较为泛化。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"整体尚可，但手部与玻璃的交互逻辑略显生硬，存在轻微融合。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp18":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp18","topic":"旧衣回收箱","order":["alibaba","bytedance","google","xai","microsoft","meta","openai"],"ok":true,"secs":120.2,"cost":0.03057032,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"母子互动温馨，但偏向日常记录，缺乏“往事千重”的深沉余韵。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"绿匣与衣物具备，但缺失“攀树迹”与“买糖钱”等关键微观细节。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"斜阳暖光明确，街景开阔，符合“立街边”的方位描述。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"摄影质感强，人物肢体结构准确，光影过渡自然。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"暖色调营造了黄昏氛围，但人物神态较为平静，情绪张力一般。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"兜中钱币可见，但球衣上的“F23”字样略显现代运动风，稍有出戏。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"逆光强烈，时间设定为黄昏无疑，空间感合理。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画面细腻，光影合成自然，无明显生成瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"完整题诗且字迹工整，位于边角不夺主，切合主题。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"大量文字标注破坏了画面留白与想象空间，更像说明插图。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"“攀树迹”“深兜”“买糖钱”均有明确图像或标注对应，极其详实。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"秋日黄昏街景，光线柔和，透视关系基本正确。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩风格统一，线条清晰，主次分明。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"画面中“深兜”“攀树迹”等解说词过于生硬，严重干扰视觉欣赏。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"背影离去极具张力，完美呼应“催归”急切与“往事”怀旧的复杂情绪。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"以衣上树影图案巧喻“攀树迹”，兜内露出的钱币也精准可视。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夕阳余晖拉长身影，巷陌深远，空间纵深感强。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"插画风格精美，色彩温润，氛围感极强。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗书法优美融入背景；“树影代树迹”的转译堪称神来之笔。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"湿润路面与牵手背影强化了离愁别绪，意境凄美动人。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"钱置于外露袋中而非衣“深兜”内，略有偏差；衣物已在箱。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"雨后斜阳，地面积水反光增加了时间的层次感。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画风统一，倒影与湿漉质感处理得当。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"侧书诗文虽有装饰感，但字形基本正确，略有古意。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"杂物堆叠显出生活沧桑感，母子对视有温情，但略显杂乱。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"衣挂树枝直译“攀树迹”，散落硬币对应“买糖钱”，棉絮可见。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"黄昏光线准确，环境写实，符合街头语境。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"细节丰富，虽乱但有序，材质特别是旧衣表现较好。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"投递动作充满希望与爱意，孩子仰视视角传递成长寓意。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"侧重“回收”动作的仪式感，弱化了衣物上承载的具体记忆符号。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"“斜阳”表现得最为浓郁惊艳，金色的空气感渲染到位。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"电影级光效，真实感极强，无AI伪影，视觉冲击力大。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp19":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp19","topic":"社区食堂","order":["openai","alibaba","google","microsoft","meta","bytedance","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":134.4,"cost":0.03448272,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"呈热闹用餐景象，缺失“洗净杯盘”与“待”的静谧诗眼。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"有食堂与菜单，但“洗净”“半掩”“留箸待”均无视觉证据。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"晚照穿窗准确，室内社区场景明确，时间线索清晰。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"摄影级真实感，细节丰富，主次分明，无碍观瞻。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"招牌与菜单文字正确切题，小幅加分。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"光影温暖安宁，空席静置营造出“待”的温柔期待。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"一荤两素与晚照穿窗俱佳，然门全开、杯盘未收。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夕照角度与室内空间一致，时间判定无误。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"构图极简高级，光影质感出色，形体清晰无瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"聚焦老人自行进食，与“待邻翁”的期待主旨相悖。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"仅有“老人”与“食堂”，洗净、半掩、留箸等关键意象全缺。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"傍晚光线基本正确，室内场景成立，但方向感一般。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"纪实风格清晰，人物与器物可辨，略有杂乱。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"左侧大段题字主导情绪，图像自身叙事能力被削弱。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"物件虽多却靠诗文标注，“洗净杯盘”仍无图像支撑。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"窗含夕照成立，室内空间可用，时间线清晰。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"插画风格工整，遮挡关系合理，无崩坏。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"全诗抄录占据画面左侧，文字喧宾夺主，违反通则。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"叠放净碟与空椅朴素安详，暗示“待”的日常温情。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"以叠盘诠释“洗净”，一荤两素明确，唯门态模糊。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"暮色从左窗入射，方位与时间一致，场景可信。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"信息可辨但略灰暗，对比度偏低，尚不碍理解。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"墙上的菜单与标牌文字自然切合，小幅加分。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"暖红调性与邻家巷陌引人遐想，期待感充盈画面。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"“碗底红”化为映碗朱砂惊艳，一荤两素与洗净均有据。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"夕照穿堂而入，内外空间通透，时间精确到黄昏。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"电影级光影与材质表现，组织完美，无可挑剔。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"“碗底红”的视觉化妙构堪称神来之笔，木牌文字亦佳。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"精准捕捉“门半掩”之姿，以极简留白将“待”化无穷余韵。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"极度凝练：半掩门、一双箸、一碗红、穿窗照，直击诗魂。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"门隙透光与窗间晚照共同锚定黄昏，空间层次精微。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"水彩氤氲笔触统一，变形与抽象规则连贯，美感出众。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"门半掩的意境构建为神来笔，右侧题款位置恰当不夺主。"}]}},"glm-5v-turbo_shp20":{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","id":"shp20","topic":"社区食堂","order":["meta","microsoft","xai","alibaba","google","bytedance","openai"],"ok":true,"secs":171.8,"cost":0.03879832,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"厨房细节（姜、笋、软饭）与雨景形成冷暖对照，生动呈现社区温情。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"小榜、蓝衣、白发、厨娘及笋尖汤文案俱全，关键意象无一遗漏。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"窗外雨痕与屋内热气呼应，蓝衣人动作体现“车铃急”，时空统一。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"摄影质感真实，光影自然，构图饱满且焦点清晰。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"环境文字“笋尖汤”与“姜片”精准点题，字形无误且位置自然。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"画风温馨但略显俗套，且过度依赖题字营造氛围，图像自身叙事力一般。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"核心人物在场，但画风偏向古风，与现代社区食堂的烟火气略有隔阂。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"雨天环境与人物位置关系基本准确，空间层次尚可。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"插画线条流畅，色彩和谐，但左侧大面积文字破坏了画面平衡。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左侧题诗出现严重错漏（如将“新炊”误作“牙疏”），属误导性错字。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"画面洋溢邻里和睦之气，突出“笑语长”的愉悦感，极具生活情趣。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"价目表与人物互动体现了社区属性，软食与笋尖汤等细节均有交代。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"地面湿润暗示天气，但缺乏直观降雨证据，“雨冷”的视觉张力不足。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"水彩风格清新淡雅，笔触松弛有度，艺术感染力强。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"价目表文字清晰切合，“低保户免费”虽未见诗但有助益于意境。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"动漫风格色彩明快，但情绪表达略显符号化，缺乏现实生活的厚重感。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"基础要素具备，但蓝衣人形象偏幼态，削弱了“车铃急”的劳作奔波感。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"降雨环境表现到位，室内外空间分割清晰，逻辑成立。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"典型的二次元画风，干净整洁，无明显生成瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"菜单板上“笋尖汤”字样清晰，起到了必要的点题作用。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"抓拍生动，人物表情自然，具有纪实摄影的生活气息与亲切感。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"人物身份与道具准确，但背景中缺失了构建氛围的关键元素。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"**重大失误：地面干燥无雨，与诗中“羹因雨冷”的核心时空背景直接冲突。**","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"写实度极高，细节丰富，画质细腻，若无时空错误堪称完美。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"“明日菜单”的小黑板准确回应了诗句结尾，文字运用得当。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"电影镜头感强，暖光与冷雨形成反差，但构图略显拥挤。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"意象完整，细化到了“笋尖汤”的文案，还原度较高。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"湿润地面与光影暗示了雨后清冷环境，时间逻辑自洽。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面精美，光影考究，但左侧竖排诗文严重干扰视觉重心。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"虽诗文书写正确，但体量过大且位置抢眼，属喧宾夺主。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"构图均衡，窗口互动展现了食堂与居民的紧密联系，情感真挚朴实。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"“明日菜单”黑板精准对应末句，蓝衣骑手与老人互动生动传神。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"背景雨伞与湿漉石板路有力佐证了“雨冷”时令特征，环境一致性强。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"画面通透，虚实处理得当，具有较高的视觉完成度和可信度。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"黑板上的“明日菜单”不仅是文字，更是连接诗句剧情的关键视觉锚点。"}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp01":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp01","topic":"旧衣回收箱","order":["xai","google","zhipu","bytedance","meta","microsoft","alibaba"],"ok":true,"secs":231.9,"cost":0.53688,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"人影退远而童衫留近，形成欲舍未舍的间距","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"童衫可辨，但柜漆剥蚀、纸卡代替剪落名签","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"街边闭柜与远处人影同处一景，空间关系可读","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"柜体、叠衣与虚化人影层次清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱名文字清楚，位置不夺主体"},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"一手抚闭门、一手攥剪签，将迟疑落在动作之间","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"新箱、童装及剪签可辨，针痕不够明确","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"街头闭合投口与持衣停驻的手势衔接自然","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，密集招牌与行人稍分散注意","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱体标识清楚，环境文字切合用途"},{"id":3,"意境情感":1,"意境情感_评":"柜衣并置未成情感关系，换作普通捐衣图亦成立","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"衬衫童装身份含混，吊牌完整且柜漆锈旧","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"街口位置清楚，但投口敞开、衣置长凳","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"柜体与折衣轮廓明确，前后遮挡连贯","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"低头展衣只见泛化温情，缺少割舍的视觉转折","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"新箱与小童衫明确，剪签及辨人针痕未落实","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"临街场景成立，衣衫摊开而非叠罢停步","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物与小衫形体清晰，光影和遮挡自洽","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱名及捐赠指引文字清楚，位置合理"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"无人街角以柔软童衫对照紧闭铁门，留有离人余意","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"剪刀童衫可辨，去签痕迹却主要落在箱门","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"叠衣、剪屑与闭门同处街边，动作余迹连贯","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"叠衣与箱门主次鲜明，剪刀碎屑仍可辨","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱名字形正确，贴合柜面而不夺主"},{"id":6,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"低头叠衣与冷灰水巷主要传达通用惜衣之情","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"童衫可辨，姓名签贴箱保留身份且箱漆旧","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"衣衫横堵敞开的投口，未形成闭箱的动作结果","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人、衣、柜的遮挡清楚，水巷纵深稳定","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗首句漏写“街”字"},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"指尖停在去签针痕，离衣名签与未断牵念形成对照","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"新漆柜、剪下名签与衣上残留针孔相互印证","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"临街持叠衣停驻成立，闭箱前后时序略含混","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"双手、剪签与针痕层次分明，近景组织完整","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"指尖以触觉写出认得；箱名清楚不夺主"}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp02":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp02","topic":"深夜视频","order":["alibaba","xai","zhipu","bytedance","meta","microsoft","google"],"ok":true,"secs":203.5,"cost":0.5065675,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"灰鬓实像与暗屏复像互照，惊老转折鲜明","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"掌中暗屏映出本人灰鬓，关键物性明确","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"暗室孤灯与低头自照相合，夜深话尽可读","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"面容、握机与倒影清晰，明暗主次稳定","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"大小双脸以暗屏相接，将远望收回自身"},{"id":2,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"群山与笑脸只构成泛化的远程亲昵","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"视频笑脸清楚，暗镜与自照灰鬓缺失","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"月夜群山与屏内人物分层，远近关系清楚","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"握机轮廓完整，屏幕与山景的尺度组织清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":1,"意境情感_评":"低头愁容孤立，换作普通看手机仍成立","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"灰发与手机可辨，屏面及镜像均被遮去","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"持机动作成立，室内光线不足以限定深夜","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"面部清楚，双手交叠处与机身边缘略含混","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"背影对笑脸仅显日常交谈，情绪关系单一","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"掌中人像与灰鬓俱在，缺少暗镜自照","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"暗室隔屏交谈成立，远隔层次较弱","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"背影、手部与屏像层次分明，留空稳定","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款疏排得当，手机后摄与屏像同面穿帮"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"屏外较年轻、屏内苍老的对照强化惊惧","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"灰发与自身屏像可辨，屏昏性质略含混","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"屏面背向人物却映正脸，钟针亦非午夜","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"桌面细物偏密，主体轮廓与前后层次可辨","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"冷夜与暖屏营造温情，仍属泛化夜话","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"山峦、笑脸与灰鬓齐备，暗镜性质未呈现","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"窗外夜山与屏内对方分层，夜话关系清楚","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"窗景、背影与屏幕层次清晰，笔触组织连贯","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"双方笑脸与裹被姿态只成温馨通话场面","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"通话对象与灰发清楚，尚无暗镜物象","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"窗外夜色明确，持机双方隔屏关系清楚","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"双手握机自然，人物与屏像主次清晰","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"屏顶通话标题字形混乱"}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp03":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp03","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","order":["meta","google","alibaba","zhipu","microsoft","xai","bytedance"],"ok":true,"secs":194.5,"cost":0.5228675,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"捆扎根球与枝头新绿相抵，春意带着失所感","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、长管、捆扎根球及嫩叶均可辨","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"根球与新土贴近街沿，前后树列构成春街","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"树干、支架与管线遮挡有序，水彩层次清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"树瓶与嫩叶近于养护记录，未生成病中哀感","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"悬瓶与春芽明确，新移断根的证据较弱","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"支架沿现代街道排列，春芽与移栽场景相合","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"前景树瓶清晰，行人与车道层次稳定","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗错句重排，大块文字遮占左侧"},{"id":3,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"成列吊瓶压住整街新绿，群树如集体卧病","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"裹根土球、输液瓶与新叶均有清晰对应","时空场景":10,"时空场景_评":"新移树列沿街递远，春叶与输液关系一致","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"根球、树列和路面层次稳定，雨线未遮主体","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"重复吊瓶将林荫街转为露天病房"},{"id":4,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"树瓶雨巷仅作并列，热闹摊市未转出哀感","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"悬瓶可辨，盘根嵌入石路更像原地老树","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"春叶与街巷成立，新绿未沿整街展开","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"输液管与绑绳局部交缠，连接不够清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗缺字重句且字号过大，挤占画面"},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"根球孤置近处，行人背向远去添失所之哀","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"根球、悬瓶、输液长管及沿街嫩绿齐备","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"近树新移与雨中春街相连，远山暗示来处","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"根球编束、斜干与街巷透视连贯，主次清楚","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"柳丝、管线与雨线互映；题诗串句错字"},{"id":6,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"巨干与细管略有失衡，满街繁绿却偏安适","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"悬瓶明确，覆苔粗干与隐去根部弱化新移身份","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"春绿沿街递远，近树输液与街巷位置相容","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"巨干近景与街道远景分层清楚，管线可循","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"黑枯伤干与寥落新芽相抵，续命之哀可见","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"病树悬瓶明确，截干伤疤比断根更突出","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"春芽集中近树，远街一片新绿的展开不足","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"疏芽、细管与伤干清楚，虚实和遮挡统一","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款疏列右上，与左侧重干形成均衡"}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp04":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp04","topic":"云仓夜扫","order":["alibaba","microsoft","meta","xai","zhipu","bytedance","google"],"ok":true,"secs":298.2,"cost":0.6626675,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"蹲身护签的细小动作与冷硬仓架形成温柔对照","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"竹帚、折臂、村名残签俱全，履底黏胶未显","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"仓内夜灯与门外微明相接，货车动势稍弱","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"双手持签、人物蹲姿与货架透视均清楚连贯","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"护签手势点出珍惜，地址文字清楚贴景"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"远车与独留扫者形成对照，乡愁仍依赖标语","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"竹帚铁臂俱在，村名却落在整箱而非残签","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"天际初白、车灯远去，折臂与近处清扫相容","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物、机械与货架线条连贯，主次清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左上题诗多处错字、伪字，语句残乱"},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"灯下纸签与远门有对照，乡愁偏靠文字说明","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"残签竹帚与铁臂可辨，清扫者身份未交代","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"微明远门与横向货车呼应，近灯远架层次清楚","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"货架透视稳定，灯、帚与纸片形体可辨","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"扫者未关注村名，整体仍是泛化的晨间劳作","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"竹帚纸页可辨，铁臂缺席且残签变成立牌","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"晨色与车尾灯相应，村景与远乡层次含混","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物动作完整，仓内暗部与门外景物组织清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":1,"意境情感_评":"视线止于机台，画面仅具通用工业场景气氛","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"竹帚与村名残签缺失，地上仅见巨大表单","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"门外天光偏亮，车先动的破晓关系不明确","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人机主体可辨，输送线局部衔接略显生硬","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"前景表单标题出现伪字与无意义字串"},{"id":6,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"人物面向车道，纸屑未成为情感视线的落点","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"履底黏胶可见，却无竹帚和村名残签","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"机械臂仍吊货、叉车有人，未见收臂后的空寂","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人形、灯束与纸屑清楚，近远层次连贯","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"扫帚贴近村名而人低首，远车反衬细小珍惜","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"扫者竹帚与村名残签齐备，唯未见铁臂","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"高窗微白而廊灯未灭，近扫远车关系清楚","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"架列透视有序，人物持帚与落地关系完整","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"帚尖在残签前收势，村名字形准确且不夺主"}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp05":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp05","topic":"深夜视频","order":["meta","xai","alibaba","microsoft","bytedance","zhipu","google"],"ok":true,"secs":237.4,"cost":0.531055,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"暖屏贴近冷床，行李与孤身侧影托出异乡牵挂","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"慈颜、厨灯、青蔬黄菊及掌中手机均清楚","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"雨夜床铺与屏内厨房分隔，远程献蔬关系明确","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"握持遮挡自然，屏内外主次与人物结构清晰","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"掌中暗屏仍朝慈颜，海夜扩出不舍的距离","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"慈亲指蔬、黄菊厨灯与掌中暗屏互相呼应","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"亮电脑与暗手机同现，熄屏前后层次含混","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"被褥海浪衔接流畅，双手与设备轮廓稳定","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"被褥接海、暗屏映暖，化出隔海余温"},{"id":3,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"冷床暖屏对照明确，情绪停在亲切展示","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"母亲指向碧蔬，黄菊与厨灯俱在屏中","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"深夜卧床与屏内厨房分隔，异乡远隔线索较弱","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"大屏聚焦展示动作，双手与界面边缘清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题名字形正确，置于侧边不遮人物"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"献蔬笑颜有温情，满幅陈设挤压停语后的余意","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"慈亲、平板、青蔬黄菊与寒床均可辨","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"母亲与菜盘跨出平板接入床边，两地边界混淆","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物器皿轮廓稳定，床褶与柜体结构完整","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"墙幅与册页多处错字、伪字"},{"id":5,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"做菜与卧床各自展开，停于泛化的夜间陪伴","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"青蔬黄花俱在，屏中近龄男女难辨慈亲身份","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"厨床两区可辨，屏内却将双方并置一室","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"中央巨屏统合两侧，人物与厨具形体清晰","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"笑颜拈菜止于生活陈列，未见欲尽未尽之情","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"慈亲青蔬尚在，视频媒介缺失且黄花近葵","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"床与厨房共处一室，隔海两地未被组织出来","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物、菜盘及玻璃倒影清楚，主体结构稳定","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"巨幅标题夺目，无关评比标准文字干扰观看"},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"捧菊近屏与冷床相隔，日常分享中见牵念","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"慈亲举菊、盘中碧蔬与通话人像清楚可辨","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"双屏重复儿子画面，床侧与厨侧视点难分","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"花叶、手势与小屏人像清晰，明暗组织稳定","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"通话界面局部按钮文字有错讹"}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp06":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp06","topic":"天台菜园","order":["zhipu","meta","microsoft","google","xai","bytedance","alibaba"],"ok":true,"secs":242.9,"cost":0.5591925,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"敲门与垂瓜有所呼应，丰茂菜畦弱化清苦。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"瓜接木枝、铁箱替罂，碗中更似谷粒。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"晚晴屋顶明确，叩门方向与门位一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"前景叶片略显拥塞，人物与门仍清楚可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"虫叶、重负与简灶相映，邻里转折未显。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"负土、残砖、虫叶及架影覆罂均可辨。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"梯脚与菜畦同层，负土登顶的动线含混。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"梯架与器物密集，人物轮廓仍清晰。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"近处惜叶与远处门灯相接，劳作通向邻里。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"残砖、虫叶、缠管藤、熟瓜与水罂俱明。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"夕照采叶、灯下羹与远处邻门分层可读。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"菜畦、人物与远处屋门层次清楚。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗将“人犹是客”漏写为“人是客”。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"人物持壶望城，仍是通用楼顶种菜情景。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"熟瓜未见，虫损不显，水罂与缠管藤尚明。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"梯通楼顶、窗灯映暮色，架影主要落墙。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"前景梯畦、中景人物与远城组织清楚。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"近瓜已熟而邻门仍闭，欲亲未亲的客意鲜明。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"残砖虫叶与熟瓜鲜明，蓄水罂改为铁桶。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"梯接屋沿，暮光衔灯火，人物朝邻门试叩。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"藤叶虽密，熟瓜、灯火与叩门者主次清楚。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"瓜门对置见客意；题诗“架影”“灯前”后残缺。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"持瓜对笑写出亲邻，却将试叩的悬念说满。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"缠管藤、残砖与持瓜明确，半瓯羹未见。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"晚霞接门灯，持瓜者与门内邻人相向。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"持瓜双手、人物对视与门框遮挡自然。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题句以“甕”替换原诗的“罌”。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"持羹停在闭门前，熟瓜与待应姿态牵出客意。","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"虫叶、残砖、缠管藤、熟瓜与半碗羹俱明。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"暮色衔接门灯，叩门动作明确，架影斜覆水罂。","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"叩门与托碗动作连续，藤管、砖罂遮挡清楚。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"持羹试叩化出交邻；门牌与提示字清楚得体。"}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp07":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp07","topic":"云端相册","order":["zhipu","bytedance","alibaba","xai","google","meta","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":133.5,"cost":0.4047675,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"两代笑容直陈亲情，画面关系停于通用怀旧","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"围裙仅在持屏者身上，旧照中缺少对应","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"旧照与现实分明，但双手仅托屏而无裁像动作","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"手部、屏幕和面容结构稳定，主体一目了然","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"悬笔与旧照相向，温情有余而迟疑偏弱","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"缺齿童像与围裙可辨，半截残幅的强调不足","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"裁框、悬笔与旧照分层，编辑关系清楚","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"斜置屏幕稳定构图，人物与笔的遮挡清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题名清楚，置于左侧空处不遮主体"},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"裁框压过围裙下缘，惜留张力仍显平弱","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"缺齿笑脸、裁框与半幅围裙均可识别","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"屏幕背向持屏者，无法成立其观看裁像","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清楚，裁框控制点散落且衔接生硬","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"云雾与微笑营造泛化怀旧，惜留之情未生","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"旧照中的衣衫并非围裙，围裙只在现实人物身上","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"悬浮界面区分旧照与现实，触指方向明确","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"水彩肌理统一，人物、界面与桌面层次清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款将“半截”误写为“半裁”"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"悬指与屏中笑脸形成停顿，围裙的牵引尚弱","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"缺齿童像、围裙及裁框齐备，残幅性质稍弱","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"旧照置于编辑界面，手指朝向操作区","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体与界面清楚，触屏手指局部衔接僵硬","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"裁框隔开笑脸与无脸围裙，悬笔把去留悬住","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"云端旧照、缺齿笑容及旁人半截围裙均明确","时空场景":10,"时空场景_评":"旧照内外层次清晰，笔停裁框边缘而未确认","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"裁框、人物及围裙边界分明，遮挡关系连贯","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"框外围裙牵住悬笔；界面文字准确切题"},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"冷窗与屏中笑颜相对，悬指含情而惜留焦点稍散","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"屏中老人缺齿且留半幅围裙，指称清楚","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"近处裁像与窗外城市分层，触屏方向自然","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物轮廓与持屏双手连贯，画面主次清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款将“截”误作“裁”，末句另有错漏"}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp08":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp08","topic":"抓娃娃机","order":["alibaba","xai","meta","zhipu","bytedance","microsoft","google"],"ok":true,"secs":192.4,"cost":0.50143,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"柜内眠熊与柜外牵手对照，空手不空情","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"眠熊、玻璃柜、铁爪、空掌及父女均清楚","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"父女牵手向外迈步，机柜退居归途一侧","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"人物形体与交握双手清晰，玻璃内外层次稳定","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"空掌与牵手并置点题，英文机名准确得体"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"空掌与孩子伸手相对，失望转折偏弱","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"眠熊、铁爪、父女及摊开的空掌均可辨","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"仰首与铁爪高低成立，踮脚支点含混","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩层次统一，机柜与人物主次清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":3,"加减分_评":"题诗重复“嫩”字，女孩出现第三条手臂"},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"蜷指、扯袖与空掌呼应，受挫后的依恋可辨","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"父女、眠熊、铁爪与空掌均有明确对应","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"坠熊出现在前板与下柜，脱落路径难通","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物视线和手势清晰，机柜结构层次分明","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"机名与投币说明准确，作为环境文字不夺主"},{"id":4,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"父子围看悬熊欢笑，止于通用的游玩喜悦","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"父子、铁爪与熊齐备，关键空掌未呈现","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"空爪与下方倾斜小熊构成脱落瞬间","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"熊与人物隔柜相对，主体轮廓和遮挡清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":1,"意境情感_评":"父女张口大笑主导全画，未见期待受挫的张力","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"女孩怀抱所得小熊，将无所得画成有获","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"铁爪与悬熊位置连贯，人物均处于柜外","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"人物、玩具与玻璃遮挡清楚，核心形体完整","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"亲子与悬熊直白并列，未生成得失对照","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"父女、硬币与悬熊可辨，关键空掌未落实","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"女孩伸手穿过柜玻璃触熊，抓取关系失真","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物轮廓明确，机柜与街景层次较完整","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗多处错漏，附加标语分散注意"},{"id":7,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"视线皆系于悬熊，止于通用的游玩期待","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"父女、硬币与机内小熊清楚，空掌未现","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"扯袖、数钱与仰望集中于机前，动作连贯","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"前景机柜与父女分区明确，背景虚化不扰主体","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"机身中文标牌准确，位置不夺主"}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp09":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp09","topic":"夜航俯瞰","order":["alibaba","google","meta","zhipu","xai","bytedance","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":186.0,"cost":0.5063675,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"暗江截开密灯，窗内凝视衬出远景寂静。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"机翼、明月、山形及江街野路灯队均可辨。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"稚子身在机舱，末联凭栏仰望被换成俯瞰。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"窗框、翼面与人物遮挡清楚，形体稳定。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"灯网被暗江切开，城乡明灭形成俯瞰的疏离。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"翼月江街俱在，山形与野路灯队较含混。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"高空俯瞰成立，稚子却被并入舱内视点。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"引擎与窗框层次分明，灯网组织清晰。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"城乡光色相分，却铺陈过满，削弱沉埋之静。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"翼月山江齐备，绿点散布田块使萤队指称含混。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"稚子伏在舷窗内，缺少地面遥望飞灯一层。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"机翼、窗框和童子轮廓完整，景物层叠清楚。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"巨月占据天际，导向通用的赏月奇观。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"机翼山江街火可辨，野路的稀疏灯队缺席。","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"街楼逼近舷窗，稚子又居舱内，高远与仰望皆失。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"窗框与机翼轮廓稳定，城街主次尚清楚。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"大字横贯江面，遮蔽山水主景。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"柔暗山色围住灯海，静意可感而疏密张力偏弱。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"山江月色可辨，铁翼缺席，夜航载体不明。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"童子临窗俯视，未分出凭栏遥望飞灯的层次。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"右下椭圆反光面与舱体的衔接含混。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左侧题款多处错字、伪字，文意不通。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"人物指点与观景神态抢眼，近于通用旅途纪念照。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"翼端航灯、江岸街火及野路灯链俱全。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"童子在机舱指向窗外，未形成凭栏遥认远灯。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物手势与机翼可辨，舱内外遮挡连贯。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"云雾隔开灯链与夜空，繁华下沉而静意悠远。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"斜翼映月，江隔街灯，野路串起稀疏光点。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"云下山城有高差，稚子却仍被置于舱内俯望。","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"翼面、云层、灯路与童影层叠清楚，细节连贯。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款多处错字，改乱原诗句意。"}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp10":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp10","topic":"机场送别","order":["alibaba","google","microsoft","xai","meta","bytedance","zhipu"],"ok":true,"secs":235.4,"cost":0.55893,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"隔窗对望与拢巾相应，情绪仍偏直露","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"母亲、喇叭与围巾可辨，屏上航迹缺失","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"拢巾仍在候机厅，未分出舱内时层","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"两人手势清楚，玻璃反射与遮挡自洽","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"航班屏英文错拼，城市与代码错配"},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"玻璃母影贴近女儿，隔而未离有所寄托","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"母女、围巾、行李及屏上地图可辨","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"隔玻璃触指成立，后续飞行时层未显","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"玻璃倒影与手势略拥挤，主体仍清楚","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"倒影将母亲留在女儿一侧，暗合影驻"},{"id":3,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"并立抬手偏通用，情感主要依赖神情","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"母亲、行李与围巾齐备，未见屏上航迹","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"两人间隔断不明，持箱动作未见离手","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"题诗与人物分区清楚，形体遮挡关系稳定","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"航班屏城市英文多处错拼"},{"id":4,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"近处母亲与远处回望相牵，拢巾收住离愁","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"母女、行李、围巾与舱窗齐备，缺航迹屏","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"送别、回望与舱中拢巾分层，先后可读","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"虚实过渡连贯，三处人物与动作均清楚","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"母亲近景与舱中小像相照，显出心关"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"母亲张唇、儿子护巾，叮咛有无声回应","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"航迹屏、母亲与围巾俱全，名物对应清楚","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"候机与拢巾合为一幕，行李仍由手紧握","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物、玻璃和箱体边界清楚，主次稳定","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"航班与登机口文字清楚，位置贴合环境"},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"左侧伸手与右侧拢巾相续，母嘱化为余温","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"母子、广播、围巾及机舱明确，缺航迹屏","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"竖框分开送别与飞行，左侧隔语稍含混","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"分区边界稳定，人物手势与舱内结构清楚","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"竖框切开两时，重复的围巾贯通母嘱"},{"id":7,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"对视与举掌只成泛化送别，未生特定余情","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"母子与行李可辨，围巾及航迹屏缺失","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"玻璃落在两人身后，隔语关系未成立","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"手掌与箱柄清楚，前景大箱挤占画幅","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp11":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp11","topic":"夜航俯瞰","order":["google","xai","zhipu","meta","alibaba","bytedance","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":185.3,"cost":0.5022425,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"冷窗与远灯相隔，人物肖像比寻巷更突出。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"河道与舷窗清楚，沿岸黄灯偏密且连成线。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"夜间斜俯城市，近指与远街尺度连贯。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"窗框、手指与面部层次分明，暗部仍可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"指尖停在霜晕，远巷隐入夜色，形成寻认的阻隔。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"舷窗、细街、河岸黄灯与冷玻璃均可辨。","时空场景":10,"时空场景_评":"夜色、俯瞰高度与指尖触窗位置相互吻合。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"窗框围拢河湾，手指与城景层次清楚。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"触点霜晕阻隔远城，准确小题款以金色收束暗角。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"都市亮景主导观光感，寻认旧巷的迟疑未形成。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"舷窗机翼河街清楚，河灯近乎连续光带。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰明确，手指却搭向窗框而非玻璃。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体结构可辨，手部与窗外景物的质感略脱节。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"大字压占下半画面，首句漏写「细」。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"巷道朝指尖延伸，却被窗上冷雾截断。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"河岸黄灯疏续，圆舷窗与凝露玻璃清晰。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"俯视与触窗明确，近处屋巷尺度偏大。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"指尖触点清晰，密集屋顶局部粘连。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"巷道尽头对准冷玻璃触点，将遥认转为触觉。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"指尖探向难辨暗巷，薄雾让亲近之愿止于窗面。","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"细街隐在暗处，沿河黄灯断续，玻璃凝雾可辨。","时空场景":10,"时空场景_评":"近指贴窗、远街缩细，夜航俯瞰关系严密。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"低照度仍保留指尖、窗框与街巷层次。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"微小触点薄雾遮住所指暗巷，含蓄落实诗眼。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"雨窗隔开手与旧城，但伸掌泛指，寻认焦点不足。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"河灯可辨，长街不显，窗框座椅近似车厢。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜间高处俯望成立，指尖是否触玻璃不够明确。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"手与窗层次清楚，远处屋群局部细节粘连。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"云月与天际线抢占重心，寻巷的迟疑较弱。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"舷窗、河街与黄灯齐备，沿河灯带偏连密。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜间俯视与触窗可读，前景屋巷偏大。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"手形自然，窗沿遮挡与建筑层次连贯。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款字形准确，细列置于暗侧，与窗景相衡。"}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp12":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp12","topic":"云端相册","order":["xai","meta","alibaba","microsoft","google","bytedance","zhipu"],"ok":true,"secs":143.9,"cost":0.40928,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"暖色笑脸主导，图照重复未生岁月回环","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"纸照与木箱清楚，却无开屏所需的电子载体","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"白头者直接怀抱婴儿，阅照当下与初生往事混同","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"蒜串、面容与木箱层次清晰，照片细部略糊","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"白首与襁褓隔屏相照，温情明确而回望张力稍弱","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"白发观者、云相册与母婴俱明，低檐蒜灶可辨","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"庭院当下与屏内母婴分层，双指临屏动作可读","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物与屏幕主次明确，手掌及屋檐遮挡自然","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"界面文字清楚切题，沿屏边安置不夺主"},{"id":3,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"屏内膝眠与屏外白首相对，茶烟暗接灶烟","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"白首、电子相册、慈亲襁褓及故堂蒜灶均清楚","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"今居与故堂由屏框清楚分隔，点页明确而张指未显","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"屏内外构图稳定，指尖、屏框与人物遮挡清晰","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"两处烟气串联今昔；题名清晰避开主体"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"窗景与屏景互映生乡思，情绪仍偏日常温馨","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"母婴旧影与蒜灶俱在，观者却是黑发青年","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"屏框区分母婴往事，窗外故堂延接当下","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"屏边双手局部拥挤，室内外纵深仍清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"墙上诗句多处错漏，界面夹杂伪字"},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"苍老手指触向旧照睡儿，白首回望初年可感","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"白首、母照、蒜灶俱全，膝上幼儿非初生形态","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"褐色旧照与当下分层，点触清楚而放大母颜未显","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"侧光集中面容与屏幕，手指及衣袖结构连贯","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"母亲由册页探身趋近白首，将回忆化作可触之近","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"蒜灶、白首与母婴齐备，纸册却替代云端屏幕","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"巨册与烟雾托起旧日母婴，白首阅册另成一层","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"巨册与手持册层次分明，人物变尺度规则连贯","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"母亲出页拉近今昔；题款准确居角不夺主"},{"id":7,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"浮婴与白首直示年龄对照，情绪主要依赖笑容","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"手机、白首与婴儿可辨，慈亲这一核心身份缺席","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"婴影有光晕区别现实，点屏与影像联系较松","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"线描设色统一，悬浮婴影边缘过渡略显生硬","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"前景册页密布不可成字的重复伪字"}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp13":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp13","topic":"机场送别","order":["microsoft","bytedance","meta","google","zhipu","xai","alibaba"],"ok":true,"secs":193.3,"cost":0.506255,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"近处停掌与远处背行形成牵留和离去的张力","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"玻璃掌痕、行囊与航灯均清楚可辨","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"暮色与离去方向清楚，过闸前后分界较弱","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"窗框透视稳定，人物与玻璃的遮挡层次清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款顺应左上留隙，不压人物与掌痕"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"掌痕与相对站立的两人联系偏松，离后余情较弱","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"闸机、行李、玻璃单掌痕与航灯齐备","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"暮色纵深可信，两人停于闸旁，离去方向不明","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"弧形廊顶统摄纵深，人物与前景掌痕清晰","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"空廊无人，近掌痕与远灯构成离去后的余响","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"玻璃单掌痕、登机通道与远处灯点均可辨","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"昏暮窗外与无人深廊统一于离别后的时刻","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"玻璃反光与掌纹层次清楚，廊道透视稳定","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"空廊独痕省人而见离人，登机标识自然切题"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"候机人群牵散视线，近痕与远灯的情绪呼应偏弱","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"玻璃航灯明确，遗留掌痕与触手倒影不易区分","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"窗外暮色成立，背景行人与过闸通道关系含混","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物形体稳定，窗框与虚焦背景层次清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"单人背影近于普通候机，送别关系未由画面生成","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"虽有玻璃与闸机，却以诗句代替关键掌痕","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"暮天与过闸背影相合，窗外灯点拉开远近","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物、门框与闸机形体稳定，景深组织清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"巨幅横排诗句占据画心并遮蔽人物躯干"},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"暗中触窗者与空廊相对，无言之感强于离后余韵","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"玻璃、登机标识与灯点可辨，独立掌痕不够鲜明","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"暮色及廊道纵深清楚，过闸前后关系未显","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"廊道透视连贯，暗部人物轮廓仍能辨识","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"英文登机与登机口标识准确，位置自然不夺主"},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"垂手者与过闸背影分置两端，掌痕成为无言余留","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"玻璃单掌痕、检票闸机、行人与航灯指称完整","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"暮色、近处遗痕与远处过闸人形成一致纵深","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"左右分区清楚，人物衣袖暗部略失层次","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"放大掌痕联结垂手者与远行背影，凸显残留触感"}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp14":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp14","topic":"天台菜园","order":["bytedance","meta","xai","google","microsoft","alibaba","zhipu"],"ok":true,"secs":211.9,"cost":0.4896675,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"近畦远灯形成对照，满幅实景略少余意","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"陶瓮与藤架清楚，瓜苗和豆藤区分稍弱","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"城楼墙道连绵，天台被改作城防墙顶","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"抱瓮倾水形体连贯，前后层次分明","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"暗处小畦对满城暖窗，独自劳作的安静可感","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"陶瓮、瓜藤豆架、短畦与窗火均可辨","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"暮蓝新月与窗灯相合，屋顶高下关系清楚","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物倾水动作连续，畦架遮挡有序","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"月与灯城营造暮意，劳作与城灯联系偏平","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"瓜菜藤架齐备，所持却是带嘴洒水壶","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"隔高墙向下浇畦，屋顶内外关系含混","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"手与壶柄局部粘连，园畦层次仍清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款将「畦」误写为「哇」"},{"id":4,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"疏淡小畦对稠密灯城，显出我自之静","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"瓜苗藤架与女墙可辨，陶瓮换成喷壶","时空场景":10,"时空场景_评":"暮月照畦、俯瞰窗火与倾水方向相互吻合","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"线面简练而连贯，人物水线与屋檐清楚","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"疏畦密窗凸显自守；「畦」误成「哇」"},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"江桥塔影分散注意，小畦与千窗对照转弱","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"满架成瓜而豆藤不显，陶瓮改作带嘴壶","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"残霞与月共存，女墙内浇畦、城灯在下","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"器物与手势衔接清楚，前后空间层次稳定","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款有「两千行」等多处错字"},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"月照独身与满城灯火相隔，浇畦自守可感","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"抱瓮、瓜叶豆架及少量菜畦均清楚可辨","时空场景":10,"时空场景_评":"暮色未尽而月已明，屋顶浇畦与下方窗火连贯","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"肩臂、瓮口与水流连贯，藤架遮挡稳定","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"月辉串起肩背与水线；题名清楚不夺主"},{"id":7,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"城灯退为散景，浇菜缺少与万窗相对的意味","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"浅盆替代瓮，密植长叶作物难认瓜豆","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"月下屋顶位置成立，水却主要浇在过道","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"手部轮廓含混，前景叶片重复趋同","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp15":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp15","topic":"云仓夜扫","order":["google","bytedance","microsoft","xai","zhipu","meta","alibaba"],"ok":true,"secs":197.7,"cost":0.5054175,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"扫描与贴签均属常规作业，乡愁主要靠题字","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"箱码与乡名清楚，云端上传缺少视觉对应","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"暗廊纵深明确，贴签与复看的先后未明","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物箱体轮廓清楚，扫码与持签动作可辨","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"放大箱签周缘夹杂错乱细字"},{"id":2,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"冷仓与旧巷贴图有对照，怀乡情绪较直白","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"乡名仅作界面泛称，箱签的地址属性偏弱","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜仓扫描关系明确，封后复看的时序未展开","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物箱体稳定，大幅界面与贴图分散主次","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"旧巷童伴与冷仓独身对照，凝视箱签牵出乡愁","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"红线箱码、已封纸箱与上传终端相互照应","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"月夜仓廊与左侧童年影像分层清楚","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"主次有序，手持终端及触箱动作衔接自然","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"双廊透视勾连今昔；题诗漏写“名”字"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"冷廊与旧巷照片对置，乡愁仍偏物件陈列","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"箱签封条终端齐备，扫描红线却化成灯串","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜廊与已封箱相合，复看动作略显含混","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物箱垛层次分明，暗处仍有稳定形体","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗夹杂重复错句与伪字"},{"id":5,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"人物只显常规封箱专注，未生识乡名的情绪转折","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"箱码封条可辨，扫码器却近似手电","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"封条正在粘贴，目光未转向正面箱签","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"大屏与密集折线争抢焦点，封条卷形体略含混","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"旧巷童景贴近双手，能见牵念却少含蓄","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"红线、箱码、乡名、云端标记与封条均清楚","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"深夜长廊明确，动作尚停在贴封阶段","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"纵深收束清晰，手、胶带与箱体衔接自然","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"指尖留在箱签，他人扫码不停，动静生出牵念","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"乡址条码封条可辨，上传云端的线索较弱","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"暗廊箱已封妥，低头抚签与旁侧扫码同时可辨","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"手指、纸箱与滚轴遮挡准确，视线焦点清楚","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"抚签与旁人扫码构成动静对照；地址字清且合位"}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp16":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp16","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","order":["google","alibaba","meta","xai","bytedance","microsoft","zhipu"],"ok":true,"secs":279.7,"cost":0.6177425,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"车流店面分散视线，树与吊瓶止于纪实陈列","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"塑料吊袋替代玻璃瓶，浅根性质表现偏弱","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"嫩芽、湿街与高厦同现，输液对象明确","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"街道透视与人车层次稳定，细管辨识稍弱","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左侧红底横招有错乱字句"},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"针口泪滴与透亮嫩叶相映，细管牵出脆弱生机","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"支架针口点明移栽护理，吊袋却非玻璃瓶","时空场景":10,"时空场景_评":"支架新栽依高厦，雨后春光与输液方向一致","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"瓶液、树皮与管线清晰，近树远楼组织稳定","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"针口泪滴呼应悬瓶，将护理化为怜惜"},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"裸根悬滴对着空街，微绿在冷雨中保留生望","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"玻璃瓶、清液、浅露根团与初萌叶均可辨","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"根团新置湿街，瓶管入树与春日楼街相合","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"树瓶主次清楚，滴室下端与软管略有粘连","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"悬滴与裸露浅根相照，突出一线维生"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"高厦压近而远人疏离，情绪止于雨街清愁","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"满枝串珠分散吊瓶指称，新栽身份亦弱","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"嫩芽湿街依近厦，远山与当下未分今昔","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"近树远街层次分明，细管局部交叠难辨","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"颈联重复抄写，题款出现赘列"},{"id":5,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"嫩芽晴街传达复苏，但主要依赖通用明暖气氛","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"低矮店屋替代高厦，吊袋也未呈玻璃性质","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"雪山直接置于街后，追忆与现景界限偏弱","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"枝干支架可辨，针头与软管衔接含混","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"店招字形清楚，题诗顺应街面留空"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"受护疏枝伸向伞下行人，隐含来日庇荫的回馈","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"玻璃吊瓶、细管、裹伤支撑与嫩叶交代完整","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"新栽树临高厦春街，雾山退远保留旧林联想","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"管线连续可读，树、人、楼与水岸层次清楚","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"疏枝覆伞暗应未来绿荫；题诗有「点街」「璃雨」误字"},{"id":7,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"巨树与楼群对峙偏向奇观，病弱转复苏未落实","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶嫩芽俱在，盘踞巨根削弱新移浅根身份","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"萌芽与高楼街道同景，管线仍指向受液树体","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体轮廓鲜明，根须局部线束化且交接粘连","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"多只吊瓶无挂钩绳索，悬空缺少支撑"}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp17":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp17","topic":"抓娃娃机","order":["xai","zhipu","meta","alibaba","google","microsoft","bytedance"],"ok":true,"secs":216.2,"cost":0.5347675,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"实童与倒影隔熊相向，虚实之间形成拥抱","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"布熊、机爪、稚子、玻璃与操作台俱全","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"爪尖仍贴近熊肩，骤然松脱的时点略含混","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物与倒影层次分明，背景疏淡而主体清楚","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"影偶相偎构成虚抱；操作说明夹杂伪字"},{"id":2,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"笑脸主导游玩兴奋，倒影未与布偶形成亲近关系","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"稚子、玻璃、机爪与各色布偶均可辨","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"空爪远离偶堆，未见布偶方悬骤落的瞬间","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"双手与面部形体清楚，玻璃内外层次稳定","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"冷暖划分内外，渴望主要依赖张臂姿态","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"熊偶、机爪、稚子、玻璃与投币按键俱全","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"孩子拥向邻侧玻璃，倒影与布偶隔框分离","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"机柜结构与街景纵深清楚，暗部人物仍可辨","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"倒影胸前叠着坠熊，双臂围出隔玻璃的拥抱","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"稚子、布熊、机爪、玻璃与投币按键均清楚","时空场景":10,"时空场景_评":"开爪在上、布熊悬落在下，张臂贴窗相应","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"手臂、反射与机柜遮挡连续，主次鲜明","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"倒影叠熊于怀，把不可得化作虚抱"},{"id":5,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"欢呼与招牌主导游乐气氛，未见借影相偎","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"布熊、稚子、机爪与操作装置均明确可辨","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"爪端仍拢着熊头，忽开失手的转折不明","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"景深层次清楚，密集偶堆的局部轮廓略混杂","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"童影与兔偶相邻，双掌围出隔窗亲近之意","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"兔形布偶、稚子、机爪与玻璃均明确呈现","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"兔偶坐在偶堆中，悬起骤落的事件未显","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"人物、兔偶及玻璃层次清楚，图文分区稳定","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"童影与白熊并置成伴，亲近仍多依赖表情","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"幼童、白熊、玻璃、机爪与投币按钮可辨","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"熊偶稳坐展示台，孩子收臂而非张臂拥窗","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"面部与倒影清晰，机柜和前景操作台组织完整","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"机楣文字准确切题且不遮主体"}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp18":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp18","topic":"旧衣回收箱","order":["xai","meta","zhipu","microsoft","bytedance","google","alibaba"],"ok":true,"secs":243.8,"cost":0.6183675,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"近处旧衣与渐远母子相照，留下成长与惜别的余意","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"绿箱、袋袄与齐肩孩子俱在，树印却替代了攀爬痕迹","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"街边落日与离箱归路连贯，孩子举手呼唤呼应催归","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"袋口、衣褶与人物遮挡清楚，街巷纵深稳定","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"旧衣与齐肩背影相照；题诗错抄『深兜』"},{"id":2,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"母子对望止于温情，旧衣未与成长往事形成互照","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"长枝、糖果与散钱直陈，攀树痕及衣兜藏钱失准","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"街边斜照、袋口敞开与袄袖半悬相互一致","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"袋缘与衣袖遮挡清楚，前景实物和人物层次稳定","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱身回收说明准确清楚，位置不夺主体"},{"id":3,"意境情感":1,"意境情感_评":"哭笑表情主导情绪，旧衣未参与人物的情感关系","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"绿桶用途不明，幼童身量不符已及母肩的关键性质","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"街边暖光尚合，坐抱安抚替代了投袋与催归","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"红袄与人物主体清楚，母子下肢叠合略显拥塞","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"箱旁旧物与远去背影相隔，惜别之意略有回响","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"绿箱袋袄明确，但树印代攀痕，孩子明显低于母肩","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"落日、街道与母女离箱方向连贯，归途关系明确","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"箱体与归人主次明确，袋堆和倒影细节略拥挤","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"墙上题诗多处错漏，长篇题字过于抢眼"},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"母亲凝视与旧袄相接，有惜旧之意而少更深余波","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"绿箱袄衫齐备，零钱却置于手袋而非旧衣深兜","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"街边夕照吻合，孩子背手静立未呈催归动作","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"衣料、双手与投口轮廓清楚，景深和光色组织自洽","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱身公益文字切题清楚，位置妥帖"},{"id":6,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"衣物拆作图解，惜旧与成长未形成图像间的联系","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"袄衫、衣兜与零钱可辨，孩子身高明显未及母肩","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"斜照街景与牵手催促相合，旁示衣物与主景层次可分","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主景与衣兜放大图分区明白，水彩造型规则连贯","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱侧竖字及衣兜注签存在错字、伪字"},{"id":7,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"母亲留手旧衣，孩子拉衣指向画外，留恋与催归互牵","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"绿箱、半悬旧袄、磨损短袖藏钱及齐肩孩子皆有对应","时空场景":10,"时空场景_评":"夕照落衣，投放与指向归路的催促在街边同刻成立","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"男孩出现三条手臂，拉衣与指路处肢体结构不自洽","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"留衣与拉衣构成今昔牵引；箱字简明得体"}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp19":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp19","topic":"社区食堂","order":["microsoft","zhipu","google","bytedance","alibaba","xai","meta"],"ok":true,"secs":226.1,"cost":0.55808,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"前景留餐有所暗示，人物与景物分散了等候重心","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"一荤两素、净杯盘和预留竹箸均清楚","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夕阳穿窗明确，门扇半掩状态较含混","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"桌椅交叠略拥挤，人物与主要餐具仍可辨","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"边栏附语与墙面小告示有讹字"},{"id":2,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"红烧肉占据视觉中心，换作普通晚餐展示亦成立","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"荤素与竹箸清楚，净盘及社区食堂身份欠明","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"低日与窗影相应，半掩门保留通向屋外的开口","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"餐具形体完整，前实后虚的组织清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"笑容主导温情，换作普通食堂聚餐亦成立","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"老人和净器可辨，一荤两素缺少清楚对应","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"多桌正在进餐，洗毕留待的时序没有建立","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"前后人物层次清楚，持碗用箸动作连续","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"中英文食堂标牌准确，位置自然且不夺主"},{"id":4,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"净盘退后、留箸近门，街巷空隙引出等待","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"荤素三碗、沥净杯盘与独留竹箸对应完整","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"晚照沿窗门落桌，半掩门连接街巷来路","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"门窗与餐具结构稳定，前后疏密有层次","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"店牌与菜牌字形准确，融入环境而不夺主"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"双碗对置营造留席，门外联系仍较泛化","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"荤素与净器俱全，社区食堂身份仍含混","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"斜照映红碗底，半开门与收拢杯盘关系连贯","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"碗盘遮挡清楚，窗影与桌面组织稳定","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"右侧同一碗旁竹箸异常重复为两双"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"双箸横陈与门隙相接，饭菜热气保留等候温度","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"饭菜竹箸明确，净盘和社区食堂身份欠明","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"落日经窗映入汤碗，半掩门保留来路","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"粗粝笔触统一，餐具与门窗形体清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"湿净杯盘与独留餐箸相对，空椅把等待引向门外","意象物象":10,"意象物象_评":"一荤两素、带水净器和独留竹箸均有实证","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夕照穿窗清楚，但门扇敞开而非半掩","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"器皿叠放、水珠与桌椅结构清楚，主次稳定","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"成摞湿盘反衬独留竹箸；供餐告示准确得体"}]}},"gpt-6-astra_shp20":{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","id":"shp20","topic":"社区食堂","order":["meta","microsoft","alibaba","google","zhipu","bytedance","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":257.1,"cost":0.5733675,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":10,"意境情感_评":"门口取盒的急势与窗前长谈相映，冷雨生暖意","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"蓝衣、白发、餐榜与姜笋汤俱全，软饭质感稍弱","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"雨巷贯通门窗，取盒与临窗交谈位置清楚","画面质量":10,"画面质量_评":"门窗双框主次清楚，人物手势与器具结构连贯","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"双框分出急缓两种节奏，菜价文字清楚贴景"},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"骑手远去衬老人驻足，温情仍偏重笑脸","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"饭盒、白发与厨娘明确，姜羹缺少可辨细节","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"雨巷骑行、门边取餐与窗内用饭层次一致","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"雨街纵深与窗口分区清楚，人物器物衔接稳定","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左上题诗出现“门门”“白衣”等多处错字错句"},{"id":3,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"暖窗热汽烘托亲切，蓝衣与白发的急缓反差偏弱","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"饭盒与白发明确，姜丝在饭上而姜羹不明","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"雨巷与窗边餐桌连通，离去回询的动作不明","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"斜置单车引导视线，人物与餐具轮廓清晰","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"餐价与明日笋尖汤告示准确，未遮挡人物"},{"id":4,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"老人侧身回望厨娘，续谈的依恋胜于单纯笑脸","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"餐榜、蓝衣餐盒与白发俱全，软饭姜羹形证偏弱","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"巷中持盒走向车旁，老人倚窗与厨娘对答","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"近景交谈与中景取餐层次清楚，手势连续可辨","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"侧身续谈点出将去未去，环境告示准确贴景"},{"id":5,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"做饭、递碗与聚餐各自并列，未生急缓与惜别之意","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"蓝衣白发及厨娘可辨，姜与笋尖的指称含混","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"骑车人与餐桌挤在同格，取盒及临窗关系不明","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"分格叙事可读，右上持碗手与碗沿衔接生硬","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"隔窗闲谈与俯身装盒相照，厨娘互动更似当下售餐","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"餐盒、白发与笋条清楚，适老软饭仅靠告示提示","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"湿巷、窗内餐桌与售餐口连贯，人物位置可读","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"玻璃内外层次分明，车盒与人物动作连续","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"墙贴“民以为天”漏字，多处菜单字形讹乱"},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"围坐与窗口交谈亲切，送餐者停驻使急缓对照偏弱","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"蓝衣白发厨娘齐备，软饭、姜羹与笋尖形证不足","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"湿巷与售餐窗相连，取盒及将去重询缺少动作证据","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"水彩人物与自行车结构稳定，前后遮挡清楚","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"餐价与送餐箱文字准确，环境身份交代自然"}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp01":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp01","topic":"旧衣回收箱","order":["google","xai","bytedance","meta","openai","zhipu","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":217.5,"cost":0.072366,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"抚门凝视与手中剪签线头成关系，逡巡惜别可辨，针痕未现。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"臂弯衣物偏成人尺寸，童衫含混；剪签与闭门可辨，针痕缺。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"临街街景与抚门、抱衣动作一致，无时序冲突。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰组织自洽，背景招牌杂而不乱，未见崩坏。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"神笔加1：手捏剪签垂线头点出「剪落」。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"背影面壁与箱顶叠衣、空签保持距离，回避之痛可指认。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"箱漆陈旧抵触「漆色新」，空白名签非剪落，针痕缺失。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"衣置箱顶未入而门已闭，动作先后局部冲突。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰遮挡合理，灰调组织统一。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"神笔加1：背影回避；文字加1：签与箱字无误。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"蹲姿凝视童衫有逡巡之柔，但剪签针痕未落实，余情靠暖调。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"童衫与新漆箱可辨，缺剪签、针痕，叠罢画成展开审视。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"街边蹲姿审视动作与光候一致，无冲突。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"清晰自洽，箱面多行字可读不碍主体。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"文字加1：箱面与立牌汉字无误且不夺主。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"剪刀碎签叠衫闭门成因果链，无人空镜保留余意，针迹隐约。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"童衫、剪落名签、闭门、新漆俱可辨，衫上缝迹应针痕。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"遗物暗示剪、叠、置、闭先后一致，街巷位置合理。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"主体突出组织干净，形体与文字清晰。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"神笔加2：剪刀碎签并置叠衫；文字加1：箱字无误。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"夕光低头投衣与前景剪签呼应，惜别温暖可辨，针痕未现。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"童衫、剪签、投口盖俱在，箱面锈斑稍损「漆色新」。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"临街夕暮与抱衣、扶盖动作一致，时序可读。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"清晰连贯，前景石台与人物主次分明。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"神笔加1：前景剪签应投衣；文字加1：箱面字无误。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"孤衫挂牌空镜只余通用孤寂，犹豫惜别关系无法辨认。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"成人衬衫替换童衫，名签未剪反挂，关键指称相反。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"衣置箱外、投口敞开，「箱门闭」与入箱事件不成立。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"插画规则连贯，箱侧纸牌伪字分散注意。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"文字减1：箱侧纸牌小字糊烂不可读。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"捧衣低首有逡巡，但敞口塞衣与贴签使关系含混，抄诗代余情。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"名签画成贴上未剪，投口敞开塞衣，与诗义相反。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"衣塞投口未入、门不闭，核心事件与时序冲突。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰组织稳定，墙面题诗不碍主体辨识。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp02":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp02","topic":"深夜视频","order":["google","bytedance","openai","zhipu","microsoft","xai","meta"],"ok":true,"secs":229.6,"cost":0.076632,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"暗室屏光映老妇灰鬓侧影，与屏中笑语对照，怅惘可辨。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"掌中手机、视频笑语、灰白鬓发俱备，小窗自分像呼应自照。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"窗外夜楼与室内暗光证午夜，掌中视频动作施受清楚。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体、遮挡与手部持机连续可辨，主次清楚无崩坏。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"背影投屏与暗夜留白有余意，但暗镜自照转折全无。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"手机与屏中笑语可辨，鬓角微白勉强应付「鬓先灰」。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"背景只余暗色与淡月，午夜室内线索薄弱而方向一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体与持机动作清晰，书法列阵整齐不碍主体。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"屏中笑语与桌上暗屏灰鬓并置，抓头疲态撑出午夜怅惘。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"笔记本视频非掌中稍偏，笑语、灰鬓、夜山俱可辨。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"窗外夜山城市与室内灯候一致，午夜书桌场景读通。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"桌面物件稍满，暗屏映像略含糊但核心信息可辨。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"桌上暗屏映出灰鬓，与屏中笑语并置，图像点出诗眼。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"仅愁容灰发通用符号，无笑语无自照，换诗亦成立。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"手机与灰鬓可辨，但视频对方与暗镜俱缺失。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"室内暗光示夜，看手机动作成立，余无时空证据。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"正面形体与双手持机清晰自洽，组织稳定。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"背影、屏中笑语与窗外千山夜支撑情调，暗镜转折未画。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"千山、掌中屏、笑语、灰鬓俱全，书脊古诗切合身份。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"窗外夜山灯火与室内烛光一致，午夜方位清楚。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"插画层次清楚，背影与屏、窗主次有序无崩坏。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"窗外千山与掌中亮屏远近对照，呼应「千山隔断掌中开」。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"千山夜月与掌中屏对照有力，但「我」与灰鬓缺席失落点。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"掌中屏与笑语、千山可辨，持机者身份与鬓灰未画。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"月下夜山与屏中室内夜光一致，持机远近关系成立。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"手部比例夸张而规则可辨，屏幕划痕稍扰观看。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"巨掌托屏与月下千山尺度对照，写出「隔断」与「掌中开」。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"惊恐表情导向惊悚，缺笑语铺垫，自照关系含混。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"屏中灰发照影与主人翁黑发矛盾，笑语对方缺失。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"挂钟、窗外夜色证午夜室内，自照动作方向可辨。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰但桌面物件堆叠稍杂，未遮蔽核心。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp03":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp03","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","order":["zhipu","bytedance","google","openai","xai","meta","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":253.3,"cost":0.08131,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"雨丝与输液丝并置撑\"错认\"，但题字占幅代意、街上无新绿。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶、绷带病树可辨，惟断根新栽与一街新绿未落实。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"雨幕湿街与春叶光候一致，街巷纵深清楚。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"线描组织清楚，主体树与雨丝层次可辨。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗错漏重复且占右侧大幅夺主；树根浮铺石板路违常识。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"枯干断折与一枝嫩绿、垂滴珠串构成病哀与新绿对照，留白存余意。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"断干露根、悬瓶滴珠、春街雨影俱可辨，惟街面缺新绿。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"方土坑新栽、细雨湿街与春候相互一致。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"水墨层次清楚，滴珠与伞影形体连贯。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"滴珠成串垂落视觉化\"滴滴哀\"，枯干新绿点\"病中开\"。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"街拍平铺直叙，哀情对照靠文字块交代，换同题材诗亦成立。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"支撑架、土球与输液袋准确，一排新绿春街可辨。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"阴天干路无雨迹，\"雨脚\"线索全无，惟春街成立。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"照片清晰主体可辨，组织稳定。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左侧诗句错句乱序重复，半透明块遮幅夺主。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"一街悬瓶序列与垂丝雨珠互混，湿街反光托出病中新绿。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"悬瓶、新绿、雨迹俱辨，惟断根新栽仅靠缠布带、含混。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"雨后湿街、春嫩垂枝与光候一致无冲突。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"形体遮挡清楚，列瓶重复有规则不紊乱。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"垂枝雨珠与输液长丝难辨，视觉化\"错认\"诗眼。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"雨丝湿街新绿托病树，惟断根靠树干诗牌文字点出。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"悬瓶、树池新栽、一街春绿与雨俱可辨。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"春雨古街光候一致，远近层次清楚。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"渲染组织自洽，主体与街景主次分明。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"招牌\"春生堂\"等环境字无误、切合街景且不夺主。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"土球支撑吊瓶纪实感强，但无雨丝对照，\"错认\"诗眼无回应。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"土球露根、支撑架与悬瓶滴壶俱准，新栽性质最确。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"雨后湿巷春嫩一致，土球入坑位置关系成立。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩组织清楚，根须与支撑结构可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"土球搁街示昨来未栽，雨丝管丝滴珠并置，伞影街深余意足。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"断根土球、悬瓶长丝、一街新绿与雨脚俱确。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"春雨湿街、刚运抵土球与行人伞影时空一致。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"形体滴珠遮挡连贯，主次清楚无崩坏。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"土球搁街与丝雨混融点诗眼；招牌\"故山园艺\"呼应故山来。"}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp04":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp04","topic":"云仓夜扫","order":["meta","openai","zhipu","microsoft","google","bytedance","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":245.2,"cost":0.080808,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"灯聚村名签、扫帚横停、门外晓车，静物关系托出拂签余意。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"铁臂、货架、竹帚、村名签、灯与胶痕俱全，指称准确。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"门外微明车待发，室内灯与湿地反光，夜晓过渡一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰组织有序，环境文字小而可读，无碍观看。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"环境文字切合无误加一分，扫帚停签旁具妙意加一分。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"靠横幅抄诗点题，无扫无村名，换物流诗亦成立。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"缺扫帚与村名签，铁臂未画，仅余泛化仓储物象。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"左窗满月与门外日出同框，光候局部冲突，车动尚合。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"结构清晰、文字无误，主体动作可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"白昼作业景，无扫无晓色，诗情全然落空。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"扫帚与村名签俱缺，地上纸字乱码，字尚明不成立。","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"门外白昼强光反转夜半至欲白之昼夜限定。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，但前景乱码表格纸分散注意。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"地面表格字为乱码伪字，减二分。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"背影低头、帚梢轻触故里签，拂村名之轻由姿态关系生成。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"竹帚、停摆铁臂、货架、村名箱贴与灯前纸光俱全。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"左侧微明车动与室内夜灯一致，夜晓层次清楚。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"插画规则连贯，形体与文字清晰可辨。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"帚触村名签为诗眼妙构加二，环境字切合加一。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"扫帚正拂向王家村签，低头姿态与门外车灯共构轻拂余意。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"扫帚、村名签、车与灯可辨，但铁臂缺失、货架空荡。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"窗色微明、门外车灯初动，扫地动作与夜晓一致。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，中部散签小字模糊而未蔽核心。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"扫帚拂村名签直接视觉化诗眼加二，签字切合加一。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"持手电照纸有凝视感，但铁臂叉车作业削弱空廊孤寂。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"扫帚缺失、铁臂作业中与收铁臂相反，竹枝声误作真竹。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"无扫地动作，核心事件不成立，仅晓色车灯尚合。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰组织自洽，题款工整不夺主。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"湿廊孤扫、门外雾村车动，情调浓但拂签之轻靠木牌文字。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"扫帚、马灯、货架、湿地可辨，铁臂缺、残签误作木牌。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"黎明雾色、车尾灯与室内灯一致，扫地动作成立。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"形体清楚、题款无误，灯前纸字略糊。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款与环境字切合无误加一分。"}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp05":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp05","topic":"深夜视频","order":["xai","google","microsoft","bytedance","meta","zhipu","openai"],"ok":true,"secs":223.4,"cost":0.073462,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"屏中暖厨与临海冷床对照，隔海相对之意可辨，余温未画。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"慈颜、厨灯、碧蔬、黄菊、夜海、寒床俱备，指蔬动作合诗。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"夜海对岸灯火与屏内厨房分区明确，移盘细指动作一致。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"前景暗屏手机与亮屏笔记本并置冗余，手指略僵但可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"同室团圆暖调，隔海寒床与暗后余温皆未落实，情调泛化。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"母、菊、蔬、屏可辨，但母亲实体在场使视频身份含混。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"钟显00:32却把两地混置同厨，通话主客关系互相矛盾。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"双手机双屏组织杂乱，界面小字模糊，主体动作尚可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":1,"加减分_评":"界面小字伪字减1，无主之手减1。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"背影隔屏相对有情调，但母亲实体同场削弱隔海，靠抄诗补意。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"慈颜、碧蔬、黄菊、寒床可辨，母亲屏内外双重出现含混。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"冷卧室与暖厨分区可读，但母亲既在屏中又在桌前冲突。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰组织稳定，唯母亲双重存在使视觉叙事含混。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"挂轴与床抄诗缺字错字，两处抄诗夺主减2。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"左厨右床分屏冷暖对照成立，但隔屏相望导向情侣而非慈颜。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"慈颜被替换为年轻女子，决定诗义的母亲身份缺失。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"23:47夜候与分屏两地成立，但屏中两人同框违反通话逻辑。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"分屏与中央界面组织清楚，形体遮挡可辨，无碍理解。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"界面标题「深夜视频」字无误且切合，加1。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"暗室凝视线与屏中暖厨对照，漂泊寒床之意含蓄可辨。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"慈颜、厨灯、碧蔬、瓶菊、寒床、行李箱俱备，唯缺海。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"窗外夜雨与屏内暖厨分区明确，持盘示蔬动作施受清楚。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体与手部清晰，明暗组织自洽，无妨理解之瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":2,"意境情感_评":"仅老妇备菜，无隔屏相对关系，换一首备菜诗亦成立。","意象物象":2,"意象物象_评":"荧屏与视频通话完全缺失，花似向日葵，关键对象失替。","时空场景":2,"时空场景_评":"室内光候如昼，夜半不成立，两地隔海与通话事件皆无。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰组织稳定，唯大字标题占据画面上区。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"标题与评比水印喧宾减3，病床穿帮减1。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"上联通话下联暗屏贴掌，余温未凉之诗眼由时序关系生成。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"慈颜、厨灯、碧蔬、瓶菊、寒床、夜月海灯俱备且可辨。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"上下两联明示通话与暗后两时刻，屏内外空间分区一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"两联视觉规则连贯，手贴暗屏动作可辨，声波线不碍理解。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"下联掌贴暗屏透微光，点出余温诗眼，加3。"}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp06":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp06","topic":"天台菜园","order":["microsoft","meta","bytedance","xai","zhipu","openai","google"],"ok":true,"secs":219.0,"cost":0.069688,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"蹲摘菜与邻窗人影互不呼应，叩扉唤一声的转折落空。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"砖畦、通风管藤、蓄水罂、悬瓜、灯锅俱全，指称清晰。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夕阳暮云与初亮窗灯共证晚晴，天台城市方位一致。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"形体遮挡清楚，主次井然，无碍理解之瑕疵。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款抄诗漏「犹」字、误「唤」为「唯」，减一分。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"负土登梯与抬手叩扉并置有情，但门内无人余意稍滞。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"负土袋、木梯、虫孔叶、缠藤管、陶罂、灯锅皆确。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"梯上叩门与煮羹同刻略混，傍晚光候尚一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体动作可辨，手部姿态稍僵而未遮蔽信息。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"捧熟瓜与门内邻妇微笑相视，客居分享之意可指。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"瓜、缠藤通风管、砖畦、邻扉俱在，煮羹虫叶省略。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"斜阳暖光与屋灯同现，架影斜投符合晚晴时刻。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物结构自然，前景后屋层次清楚。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"捧瓜示邻对视，图像点出诗眼，加二分。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"叩扉背影独立满园之前，门内无声保留唤一声余意。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"叩扉、悬瓜、砖畦、灯锅确，蓄水罂误作铁桶稍失。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"暮云霞光与炉火马灯互证傍晚，叩门动作施受明确。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"构图稳定，形体清晰，无崩坏粘连。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"背影叩扉与身后羹熟瓜悬对照动人，加一分。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"乌云压顶情调阴郁，叩扉孤身缺乏诗据之暖客情。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"瓜悬乔木枝、蓄水罂作塑料水箱、菜似观叶植物。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"厚云蔽空与晚晴抵触，夕阳又露使光候自相矛盾。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"画面可辨但瓜悬空无藤、植物肥叶杂乱分散注意。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"瓜悬于乔木枝下无藤可依，常识硬伤减一分。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"摘菜者、探头邻人、冒烟羹碗互应，唤声有余响。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"悬瓜、缠藤管、砖畦、陶罂、灯羹、邻人皆备且确。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"落日余晖与马灯羹烟共证灯前傍晚，方位一致。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"组织清楚，遮挡连续，无生成缺陷碍观。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"邻门探头回应唤声，图像关系含蓄，加一分。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"孤身望城暗示客意，架影斜侵墙面妙，但叩扉瓜熟缺。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"砖畦、缠藤管、陶罂可辨，惟诗眼之瓜与叩扉俱缺。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"城市灯初上与桌上油灯共证暮时，登梯由梯暗示。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水墨组织稳定，形体可辨，略嫌物象平铺。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款残句且「人犹是客」重复出现，减一分。"}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp07":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp07","topic":"云端相册","order":["microsoft","openai","google","meta","bytedance","xai","zhipu"],"ok":true,"secs":181.3,"cost":0.06145,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"背影临暮窗，一指轻触屏边停住，与屏中缺齿笑构成静默对照。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"屏中旧照缺齿笑且系围裙，裁剪框线俱在，名物齐备。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"窗外城市暮色与室内灯候一致，屏中彩照略似实时视频。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，唯屏下按钮小字模糊、桌面文字稍多分散注意。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"屏下按钮字模糊伪字减1；停指与裁剪框围裙呼应加1。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"老人含笑指屏情温，但剪刀搁桌未持，频停手之犹豫未落实。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"围裙系于现实老人身，屏中旧照无围裙，裁除对象错置。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"日间窗光与黑白旧照、桌上纸照层次分明，场景可读。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体手部连贯清晰，桌上物件组织有序。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"书脊「家庭相册」字无误且切合，加1。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"微笑操作裁剪界面，情绪平顺，停手不忍的张力较弱。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"屏中孩童缺齿笑并着蓝罩衣围裙，裁剪框与缩略列俱在。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"室内日间光候统一，屏中旧照与缩略列层次可辨。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清楚，屏侧缩略图略糊而不碍理解。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"笔停屏前，裁剪框把围裙划出界外，犹豫不舍由界面关系生成。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"缺齿男孩系围裙、右侧半截围裙预览、云端标题俱确。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"室内日间一致，照内照外分区清楚，动作施受明确。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"界面文字清晰、形体连贯，组织主次分明。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"裁框划出围裙并提示移除，诗眼妙构加3；UI字无误加1。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"暖橙暮光与老屋叠影托出追忆，微笑持笔但停手犹豫稍弱。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"屏中女孩缺齿笑系围裙，桌上另置半截围裙实物呼应。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"黄昏暖调与老屋背景分区表追忆，不混同现实桌面。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体与界面清晰，构图稳定。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"桌上半截围裙与屏中照并置加1；「云端相册」题字无误加1。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"云海留白有余意，但围裙只系现实人身，照内不舍无对照。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"云端被画成真实云海，屏中照无围裙，借代指称含混。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"云表与案桌混置为比喻空间，层次尚可辨而不冲突。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"插画规则连贯，形体剪刀碎纸俱清晰。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款两句字形无误、位置得当，加1。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"开怀大笑直白过满，无裁剪停手线索，不忍之情无从辨认。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"缺齿旧照可辨，但围裙错置现实人身且裁剪完全缺失。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"室内日间与黑白旧照层次成立，动作施受清楚。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"近景手部稍大但结构可辨，画面组织稳定。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp08":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp08","topic":"抓娃娃机","order":["zhipu","openai","microsoft","meta","google","bytedance","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":214.2,"cost":0.071692,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"父子同笑看机，情调温和但空掌、牵手等转折均未落实。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"机、熊、父子可辨，但熊无爪抓悬空，匣底眠熊未表现。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"室内游戏厅与仰首可视，换钱、悬踵与归途线索缺失。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰遮挡合理，主体动作连续可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"分格串起催钱、落空到归途背影牵手，转折完整含蓄。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"扯袖、钱包、空爪落熊、牵手皆有据，否定未误画。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"五格分区使时间序列可辨，不强作同地同刻。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"拼贴边线清楚各格可辨，个别格手部略糊。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"归途背影牵手摘出仍动人；PRIZE小标字形切合不夺主。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"温馨期待靠微笑与鸡汤字支撑，空掌牵手转折未落实。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"爪抓熊、父持币、眠熊堆可辨，扯袖动作缺失。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"雨夜街边机前动作成立，诗未限朝暮故不扣。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"组织清楚文字工整，但画面信息略满。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"招牌与机侧字正确切合；女孩双脚离地悬空无支撑。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"父摊空掌对女孩扯袖仰视，失落张力由关系生成。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"闭眼眠熊、空爪、扯袖、摊掌无一物均准确可辨。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"机前施受清楚，投币标示与动作方向一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰主次分明，无妨碍理解的缺陷。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"摊掌空手点出诗眼；招牌与投币字正确不夺主。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"通用亲子微笑，落空与相牵的对照全无视觉回应。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"机与熊可辨，但熊列货架、悬空无爪，匣底眠意缺失。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"父递币、女仰首成立，熊悬空使落下方向含糊。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨但背景招牌杂乱分散注意。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"机侧红牌「抓娃娃机」字形正确、位置得当。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"抱熊大笑导向成功喜悦，与诗落空情调持续相反。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"孩子怀中有熊，把「无一物」的否定画成肯定。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"机前父女动作与空间关系仍可读通。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"光影形体清晰，组织自洽无崩坏。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"空爪与父女牵手同框，未得而相牵之余意尚存。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"闭眼眠熊、空爪、仰首悬踵准确，缺换钱与摊掌。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"机前瞬间动作施受一致，归途层次未另作暗示。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩形体清晰，底部题诗不遮主体。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"空爪高悬与牵手并置，以关系点出结句对照。"}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp09":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp09","topic":"夜航俯瞰","order":["meta","xai","openai","zhipu","microsoft","bytedance","google"],"ok":true,"secs":237.0,"cost":0.076212,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"窗框将全城灯火压成屏面，稚子凭倚完成压入水晶屏关系。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"铁翼、皓月、江流割街火、野路萤光皆可辨。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰，江流横割两岸灯网，深度与方位一致。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"主体与遮挡清晰，组织稳定，无明显生成瑕疵。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"窗框压灯火为水晶屏，加一分。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"墨韵安静但余意依赖题字，缺翼与窗关系削弱张力。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"铁翼缺失、野路萤光不明，仅窗景山城灯火撑诗题。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜暮、江城管带、山形一致，俯瞰深度由远景支撑。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"墨色组织自洽，右下角镜状椭圆来历不明。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款小字多为伪字乱码，减三分。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"云雾埋灯海于千仞下，稚子托腮凝望成高空静默。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"翼、月、江流割城、野路串灯俱在，指称清楚。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜航明确，江流蜿蜒割灯区，云层高差证据一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"层次清晰，主体连贯，男孩半面仍可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"巨月与贴句夺去情绪，画面自身凭望关系偏弱。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"翼、江火、稚子可辨，萤光野路与沉埋深度不明。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"夜航成立但月径失真扰乱空间，深度线索不足。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"核心形体可辨，组织尚稳，瑕疵未遮理解。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"诗句横贴江城中区夺主，减二分。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"云海埋灯、窗框成屏与凭栏稚子共构静默，题款不夺主。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"铁翼、山形、江流街火、野路萤光皆对应，指称明确。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜航与云海深度一致，千仞之下层次可辨。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"暗调而层次分明，题款印章位置得当。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"云雾深度化出沉埋千仞，加一分；抄诗不另加。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"稚子指窗引出错认张力，舱内乘客稍稀释静默。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"翼尖航灯、月、江城管带、稚子可辨，萤光野路弱。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"舱内与窗外层次分明，夜航光候一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"人物与指手清晰，内外光关系自洽。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"指灯作星的手势化出诗眼，加二分。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"稚子仰寻与灯海对照，但野路萤光与沉埋余意不足。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"翼与发动机、江流割城可辨，缺萤光野路，月作弯月。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜航成立，弯月与灯海不冲突，深度证据平平。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"暗调统一，面部微蜡但主体可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp10":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp10","topic":"机场送别","order":["meta","openai","zhipu","xai","microsoft","google","bytedance"],"ok":true,"secs":210.8,"cost":0.070014,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"母贴玻璃唇动与子握围巾对视，视线关系支撑嘱衣牵念。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"广播屏、千里航线屏、围巾行李俱全，惟围巾动作早于舱中。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"隔玻璃送别成立，但舱中层次未现，围巾地点提前到候机区。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"写实清晰组织清楚，惟胸前挂牌小字糊成乱码。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"环境字切合诗义加2，挂牌乱码减1。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"隔玻璃贴手与舱中低头绕巾对照，寒暖余意由分区关系生成。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"母女、玻璃、行李、围巾、航线屏皆确指，无缺失误置。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"黄昏送别、夜航舱中、屏上千里三格分区，时空层次清楚一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"三格拼贴主次清楚，形体动作连贯可辨。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"三格落实屏与舱中诗眼加2，环境字无误切合加2。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"仅通用送别焦虑，无围巾与舱中余意，换同题材诗亦成立。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"围巾缺失、舱中未画，玻璃隔语仅母单手贴而子无回应。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"候机楼送别成立，但诗后半舱中时空完全缺席。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"形体清楚手稍大，组织自洽可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"贴玻璃、回首、舱中叠印围巾三层关系，保留默绕围巾余意。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"围巾、行李、催程牌、舱中座椅俱备，屏上千里路未显。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"候机与舱中以淡出叠印分区，层次可辨不混置。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"绘画连贯，但玻璃映脸与背影并存稍惑，左上屏字糊。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左上航班屏伪字减1。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"隔玻璃抬手对视含蓄，但舱中转折缺失，余意反靠题款支撑。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"母子围巾行李玻璃航班屏俱全，惟舱中绕巾未画。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"暮雨候机光候一致，舱中层次缺席。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"画面清楚组织稳定，题款留白不夺主。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"航班屏多行错字伪字减2，抄诗题款不加分。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"母女隔玻璃哭喊外露，靠通用悲情符号，舱中余意全缺。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"围巾行李玻璃可辨，广播与千里屏含糊不清。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"暮色候机一致，舱中时空未现。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体动作清楚，玻璃反射脸可辨不碍读。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"母俯身叮咛与舱中绕巾分区对照有情，惟玻璃隔语对照缺失。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"围巾行李广播屏俱备，但隔玻璃说话这一关键性质未画。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"候机雪景与舱中云海分区明确，冬令光候与添衣相合。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"绘画规则连贯，左区传送带与站位稍怪不碍辨。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"广播盒与航班屏字正确切合加1。"}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp11":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp11","topic":"夜航俯瞰","order":["xai","google","microsoft","meta","bytedance","zhipu","openai"],"ok":true,"secs":204.0,"cost":0.056114,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"食指触窗凝出雾痕，寻找姿态与隔玻璃的凉意关系可指认。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"舷窗、沿河黄灯、细街与触玻璃指尖俱全，指称无误。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"夜航高空俯瞰，河灯与街线方位一致，触屏动作成立。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"窗框、手部与城市层次清楚，雾痕与题款不扰主体。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"指尖凝雾点出指尖凉，题款字形正确且位置得当。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"忧郁靠人物表情支撑，视线低垂未与窗外灯河成寻找关系。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"舷窗、夜城河灯与触窗指尖可辨，名物无误。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"夜航俯瞰与触窗动作成立，反射脸空间层次略含糊。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"另一窗内多出一张反光脸，位置含糊分散注意。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"手掌贴窗俯瞰旧瓦屋群，追忆与当下对照有视觉回应。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"舷窗、沿河黄灯、桥与旧巷瓦屋俱全，指称准确。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"夜、高空、河桥方位一致，贴窗动作与追忆层次可辨。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"构图稳定，屋群、河灯与手部结构清楚连贯。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"窗下旧瓦群呼应当年深巷，题诗纪年字形无误。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"指触圆窗与水珠雾气有凉意，但情绪偏通用夜景俯瞰。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"河灯旧屋与触窗指俱在，圆窗金属框偏船窗略失准。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"夜俯瞰与沿河灯一致，圆窗形制与高空高度略冲突。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"指尖比例偏大、窗框水珠杂乱，主体尚可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"贴窗手与灯河关系成立，但车厢座椅削弱夜航专属情调。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"河灯、旧屋与触窗手可辨，座椅身份含糊失准。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"列车座椅与大窗同高空俯瞰不兼容，时空线索冲突。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体与动作清楚，组织自洽，淡字略分散注意。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"左上半透明淡灰叠字呈现代水印式处理，减一分。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"手贴舱壁未触玻璃，诗眼落空，情绪仅靠通用夜景支撑。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"舷窗、机翼、沿河黄灯与长街可辨，名物尚齐。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"指尖未触玻璃，「一触」动作施受未落实。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"手部与窗框结构可辨，组织尚清楚。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":3,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"右下巨幅白字压住窗景与手，喧宾夺主减三分。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"指尖触窗指向灯街，关系成立但追忆层次缺乏回应。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"舷窗、机翼、河桥黄灯与细街俱全，指称准确。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"机翼与高空夜俯瞰证据一致，触窗动作成立。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"城市层次与手部结构清楚，指尖光点略突兀。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp12":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp12","topic":"云端相册","order":["meta","microsoft","xai","google","openai","zhipu","bytedance"],"ok":true,"secs":360.8,"cost":0.102122,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"老人视线微笑与屏中母婴、檐蒜灶烟构成追忆关系，白头对初生可辨。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"平板界面、挂蒜、土灶烟、白头与母婴照俱备，唯屏中照偏新欠旧感。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"现实老屋与屏中照两层可辨，双指触屏放大契合，光候一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体手部清晰自洽，界面文字可读，组织主次清楚。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"界面「云端相册」「已同步」字形正确切合，小幅加分。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"靠立轴抄诗与怀旧物件点题，无白头主体，诗眼反转无法辨认。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"操作者画成黑发青年，白头老人缺失，关键身份被替换。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"室内、窗外故堂、屏中照三层尚通，放大手势成立，层次略杂。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"组织清晰形体正常，唯立轴书杯文字过多分散注意。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"老妇抱真实婴儿成现实天伦，追忆余意被削弱，对照落空。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"无屏幕只余纸照木箱，云端开屏之名物被替换，母婴照尚可辨。","时空场景":3,"时空场景_评":"忆中婴儿实体化与现实同刻混置，无屏使开屏点到事件不成立。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水墨规则连贯，形体遮挡可辨，抄诗字形无误。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"老人微笑触屏视旧照，灶烟挂蒜烘托，唯膝眠联想未强视觉化。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"平板、泛黄旧照、挂蒜、土灶烟、白头俱备，界面字略糊。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"现实老屋与屏中旧照层次清楚，但单指点屏未画两指徐张。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体动作清晰，手部正常，背景物件组织有序。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":5,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"过肩同视黑白初生照，云上故堂如烟忆，白头与婴对照成全诗眼。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"纸箱旧照、平板缩略页、挂蒜、灶烟、白头母婴皆确凿可辨。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"现实、云上忆境、屏中旧照三层分区清晰，双指放大方向明确。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体手部与雾境衔接连贯，主次清楚，无碍理解缺陷。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"云雾托故堂双关云端为妙构加2，界面字正确加1。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"老妇笑看手机与悬浮婴影稍成忆念，但慈亲膝与屏内容皆不可见。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"手机背面朝观者屏内容缺失，相册旧照未画，婴影实体化含混。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"室内与半透明婴影层次可辨，触机动作与灶火关系模糊。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"卡通规则统一连贯，形体正常，标题字清晰。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"标题「云端相册」字形正确位置得当，小幅加分。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"半透明母婴浮现回应膝眠，但巨书女子关系糊，余意被杂细节稀释。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"屏幕被纸质相册替换，开屏点到落空，挂蒜灶烟白头尚可辨。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"现实与忆影以雾分区可辨，巨书尺度失理，扶页动作非屏上操作。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"形体可辨但巨书与多半透明人物组织突兀，略散注意。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp13":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp13","topic":"机场送别","order":["microsoft","openai","bytedance","meta","google","zhipu","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":165.7,"attempts":2,"cost":0.045912,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"抚痕之手与走远背影隔窗对照，沉默别情由关系生成。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"飞机、长廊、暮色、掌痕俱备，唯过闸闸机未显。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"暮云灯影与室内长廊一致，行者向深处、航灯在窗外。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰、渲染统一，题款与印章位置得当不夺主。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"神+2：手抚空痕而人已远；题款抄原诗依例不另加。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"抚痕女子与拖箱背影一留一去，别情可辨而晚霞稍暖。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"登机口、停机坪、掌痕、离去者俱在，闸机以走远暗示。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"落日悬山偏亮，与「昏」之沉暮稍隔，其余光候一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰、层次分明，标牌文字无误。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"神+1：手痕错位相抚；标牌字无误+1。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"两人相对似话别，掌痕悬空无主，未与人物动作生成关系。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"闸机、长廊、暮色、飞机可辨，掌痕比例失真似贴饰。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"暮云与廊内灯候一致，但无人过闸、离去动势缺失。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"清晰自洽，题诗竖排于左下不遮主体。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"空廊无人唯余巨痕与远灯，「只剩」之人去余韵极强。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"长廊、暮色、航灯、掌痕俱在，送别双方省略仍可读。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"蓝调暮光与停机坪灯远一致，空廊为别后时刻有诗句据。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"构图清晰、主次分明，标牌文字无误。","神来之笔":3,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"神+3、标牌字无误+1；掌痕尺度过大-1。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"女子抚雾玻璃有人影余韵，但背景闲人杂、别情被稀释。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"掌痕与暮色机场可辨，离去者与闸机缺失、雾影含糊。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"暮色一致，室内独立玻璃屏之位置逻辑稍怪。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"雾影人形边缘糊而不碍主体辨认。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"掌痕未画，仅以抄句横遮，别情关系无法从图像辨认。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"关键物象掌痕缺失，被诗句文字替换。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"暮空、航灯红点与闸机杆尚成立，方位一致。","画面质量":5,"画面质量_评":"大字横贯核心区域遮蔽主体，视觉组织被破坏。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":4,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"文字-4：抄句横亘画面中央，喧宾夺主且代画诗眼。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"一人抚壁独立暮廊，孤寂有余而送别对照不足。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"所抚似墙非玻璃，掌痕化为放射光晕，指称含糊。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"暮空、飞机与长廊方位一致，登机标牌点明地点。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"暗调可辨、结构自洽，无显著崩坏。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"文字+1：英文标牌字形无误且位置得当。"}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp14":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp14","topic":"天台菜园","order":["xai","bytedance","openai","microsoft","google","zhipu","meta"],"ok":true,"secs":329.6,"cost":0.098634,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"低头浇畦、水线入畦，墙下千窗灯火铺陈，暮天淡月存余意。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"瓮、女墙、豆架瓜苗、千窗火与月俱可辨，指称无误。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"黄昏暮色、月出、灯城与城头高下关系相互一致。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"形体水流连贯，主次清楚，题款不夺主。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"神来之笔+1：人立墙头、低头即见脚下千窗，点出诗眼。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"霞光夺月、月光感弱，千窗火与带月光之对照未充分落实。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"抱瓮倾水、城垛女墙、豆架黄花、瓦屋窗灯俱备。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"黄昏霞、满月出、灯城与城上畦位一致可信。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"结构清晰、水流连贯，前景空罐稍赘不碍读。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":3,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"屋顶女儿墙读法成立，但低头见灯转折弱，情调偏通用暮色。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"瓜藤垂瓜、竹架、陶罐、楼群窗灯可辨，豆架稍混。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"黄昏霞、满月、灯城与屋顶高低关系一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"植物茂盛略满，主次仍清，无碍理解。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"雾霭掩城、千窗火朦胧，低头忽见之转折被弱化。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"瓮、矮墙、垂瓜豆架、窗灯与月俱在，指称可辨。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"黄昏雾暮、灯城河塔与高台位置一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"组织清楚，形体连贯，雾霭层次自洽。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"画面文字−2：题款「两千千」「忽琏」「夏目」错字缺句。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"疏朗两三行与高台千窗对照，水墨留白存言外余意。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"带流陶壶代瓮稍失，豆架畦苗、窗灯、新月可辨。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"暮云新月、灯城与高台俯见关系一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"简笔而形体动作连贯，组织自洽。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"仅存夜浇与城灯，黄昏与瓜豆架特定关系皆失，情调通用。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"瓮画成浅盆、豆架仅光签、瓜苗缺失，核心浇畦尚辨。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"天色已夜深，与黄昏月出之光候冲突，高下关系尚存。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体动作可辨，水流白粒略怪，竹签林立稍乱。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":7,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"冷月罩人与暖窗千窗火成对照，低头浇畦带月光可指认。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"陶瓮、城垛、瓜架豆架两三行、满城窗灯、新月俱备。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"暮蓝时刻、新月、灯城与城头畦位一致。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"层次清楚、形体连贯，冷暖组织自洽。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"神来之笔+2：冷月暖窗对照，以光色点出「浇畦带月光」。"}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp15":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp15","topic":"云仓夜扫","order":["xai","microsoft","zhipu","meta","openai","bytedance","google"],"ok":true,"secs":205.3,"cost":0.069348,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"工人视线落平板，未接巷图，细看停顿关系稍弱。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"乡名、封存、上传屏与巷图俱备，指称清晰。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"23:47夜半、红灯长廊与贴签动作相互一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体遮挡清楚，主次分明，无碍理解。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款全诗与箱签文字无误切合，小幅加分。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"巷图在身后大屏，工人视线未接，停顿靠符号。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"云仓标识、乡名列表、封签屏与巷图可辨。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"仓库内直见满月夜空，空间层次局部冲突。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体动作可辨，箱侧小字糊烂分散注意。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款无误加一分；箱侧伪英文小字罚一分。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"通用物流作业，无忽见细看的情感停顿。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"箱签直抄儿时巷三字，乡名与云端表达含混。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"顶灯白亮无夜证，红线满天与扫描方向冲突。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"红线无规则满飞分散注意，手部动作略怪。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"俯身贴封条且视线贴箱签巷图，停顿转折可视。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"红线、乡名、上传云、箱签巷图与封条卷俱确。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"02:14暗廊、贴条动作与回忆箱签分层一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"组织清楚，文字清晰，无碍理解。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"屏文字切合加；墙纸条疑重字罚一。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"贴封条与扫箱连续，但视线未接右上回忆巷景。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"乡名屏、云标、故乡签与封箱带俱备，乡名稍泛。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"仓内夜证弱，回忆巷景以烟云分区可辨。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰，组织自洽，文字无误。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"烟云连出儿时巷夜景为妙构；标语切合加。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"头灯细看箱签成立，但缺贴封条动作转折。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"封条缺失，乡名仅屏上二字泛称，余俱可辨。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"夜暗与视线一致，惟贴罢封条动作未呈现。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"全息屏与箱体关系清楚，文字无误。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱签旧照点诗眼；题款与环境字无误加。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":3,"意境情感_评":"无儿时巷触发，常规扫箱作业，换诗亦成立。","意象物象":3,"意象物象_评":"箱签仅村名，儿时巷关键对象完全缺失。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"顶灯白亮无夜半证据，头灯与环境光矛盾。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"圆形标签贴附突兀，边缘小字糊烂。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp16":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp16","topic":"春街树挂吊瓶","order":["xai","zhipu","openai","google","meta","bytedance","microsoft"],"ok":true,"secs":257.3,"cost":0.082564,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"枝头垂珠如泪，湿街孤树依厦，清冷寄望余意足。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"瓶、管、嫩芽、高厦、雨珠俱备，根浅省略不伤诗义。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"春芽、雨后湿街、高厦位置相互一致。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"水墨层次清楚，瓶管树遮挡连续可辨。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款重复抄写一联，扣文字分；垂珠双关加神笔。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"冷调孤树靠通用符号，离林依厦对照未落实。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"根尚浅画成盘结巨根，关键性质相反。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"大树裸根盘踞路心，与行道树位置冲突。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"主体可辨，但输液管绕干粘连、根须杂乱。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"树盘根于马路中央，常识逻辑硬伤。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"特写管绑干回应一线情，但整体明媚通用无余意。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"瓶、钩、嫩芽、高厦俱清晰，根浅可省。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"背景街树浓荫成夏，与叶初萌春候局部冲突。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"写实清晰，瓶管树结构连续可辨。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"雨街新栽树输液关系可辨，但市井细节过满削余意。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"吊瓶置于金属架而非树挂，次要失准；新土暗示根浅。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"春雨、湿街、树池位置与光候一致。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清楚，招牌小字与人群略散注意力。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"药房招牌切合吊瓶互文加1，次要招牌小字模糊减1。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"雨丝与落滴同构，空街孤树清冷怜惜余意足。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"浅根裸土直呈根尚浅，瓶管嫩芽楼街俱备。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"春雨湿街、树栽路旁土堆，层次一致。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"水彩组织清楚，滴珠与管连续可辨。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"落滴兼作点滴与宿雨、裸土浅根，神笔加2。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"针头入干、支撑架与远山雪形成呵护与回忆关系。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"背景村镇平房替换高厦，决定处境之名物缺失。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"春芽晴光镇街一致，远山残雪不违春候。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"淡彩组织清楚，题款占左下稍大未蔽主体。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"远山雪暗扣当年千山雪之回忆，神笔加1。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"雨伞湿街、绑布支撑与孤树线瓶，清冷中见寄望。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"瓶挂枝、管入干、树池支撑、背景高厦俱备。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"春雨、花瓣、街厦光候位置相互一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体遮挡清楚，主次组织稳定。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"瓶签切合加1，题款错字减2，绑布绷带意加神笔。"}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp17":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp17","topic":"抓娃娃机","order":["zhipu","google","meta","openai","bytedance","microsoft","xai"],"ok":true,"secs":224.9,"cost":0.069224,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"空爪无悬偶失转折，稚子微笑伸手却无相偎对象，余意不足。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"机爪布偶稚子俱备，唯缺悬吊布偶，名物指称仍清晰。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"室内光候一致，但抓吊事件未发生，动作链条缺环。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体与遮挡清晰，机爪布偶组织有序，无崩坏。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":1,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"玻璃倒影呈成人脸，与稚子反射逻辑抵触，减一。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"张臂仰望之渴望强烈，但玻璃倒影缺位，相偎余意未落实。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"爪悬熊偶、稚子张臂、游戏厅名物齐备可辨。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"柜内悬偶与柜外张臂方位一致，场景读通。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体动作清晰，霓虹招牌多而组织有序。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"环境招牌字形无误且切合场景，加一。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"稚子与己影隔玻璃相触，夜雨留白，借影相偎有余意。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"悬偶爪机与稚子倒影俱在，名物身份清楚。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"稚子所临为街店玻璃而非机窗，与悬偶空间脱节。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"夜雨动漫风统一，形体遮挡清晰。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"机身价目与按钮小字正确切合，加一。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"爪开偶悬之失落瞬间与倒影贴偶相偎，诗眼全落实。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"爪、悬偶、布偶堆、稚子张臂及倒影无一缺失。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"柜内外分隔清楚，悬吊与爪开瞬间动作一致。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"暖光主次分明，背影与倒影关系连续可辨。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"爪开偶悬并倒影相偎为诗眼妙构加二，投币小字加一。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"倒影与稚子对视有趣，却与布偶无涉，相偎落空。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"熊偶坐台未悬，爪空张，关键性质表达含混。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"布偶方悬之抓吊事件未现，仅静态陈列。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰光暖，组织自洽。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"招牌欢乐抓娃娃字形正确切合，加一。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"倒影与兔偶相邻稍得相偎意，然爪空偶坐失转折。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"兔偶坐堆未悬，爪空张，悬吊性质缺失。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"抓吊瞬间未发生，核心事件静止化。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，右侧题款条幅不碍观看。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"环境小字切合加一；题款抄诗无误不另加。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"倒影伸手与悬偶相偎可辨，水彩虚景留余意，惟爪未开。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"爪悬狗偶、稚子张臂、倒影齐备。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"柜内外与悬吊动作一致，背景虚化不冲突。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩规则统一，形体与遮挡可辨。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"倒影与悬偶相偎得诗眼加一，招牌字正确加一。"}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp18":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp18","topic":"旧衣回收箱","order":["bytedance","zhipu","google","meta","xai","microsoft","openai"],"ok":true,"secs":261.8,"cost":0.081128,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"女孩身高齐母肩、斜光照敞袋旧钱，成长与记忆可辨；唯催归意弱。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"绿匣、半悬袄、挂侧短袖、袋中硬币俱在，钱在袋非兜稍偏。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"落日街边、持袋欲投，傍晚光候与投衣动作证据一致。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰、遮挡合理，箱体文字与人物结构无崩坏。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱标语无误切合加1；及肩与袋钱同框点诗眼加1。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"笑抱哭儿是通用亲情符号，诗中怅惘催归之情无从辨认。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"绿箱红袄可辨，但幼儿远不及母肩，成长性质失准。","时空场景":4,"时空场景_评":"天空过曝发白缺傍晚证据，坐抱取代投衣与催归。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"主体清晰，但箱盖无支撑悬空、背景人物糊散。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":2,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱盖悬空无支撑，违背常识，硬伤减2。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"记忆靠引线标注说明，图解清单削弱余意与情绪张力。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"袄、短袖、兜钱、衣袋俱画出，但男孩仅及母腰未及肩。","时空场景":6,"时空场景_评":"暖光街边成立，牵立静态使催归与投衣方向模糊。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"水彩组织清楚，标注线与箱侧杂字分散注意。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱侧竖排字糊误、孤字袄突兀，减1。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"母子拉手对视与袋中絮钱糖回应记忆，但黑袋堆满削余意。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"悬衣为长袖夹克，短袖被替换；絮钱糖在袋非兜。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"落日街边一致，袋置箱内、母子站立使动作稍滞。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰组织自洽，衣上粘枝尚可读为攀树迹。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱上标语字形无误、切合不夺主，加1。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"背影抬手催归、并肩向落日，墙隅留白存往事余意。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"短袖树印与兜钱可辨，但袄半悬画成罩布下衣堆。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"落日方位与归家方向一致，催归动作施受清楚。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"油画层次清楚，背影与箱体结构稳定无粘连。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"背影催归点诗眼加1；题诗漏字、墙贴伪字减2。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"牵手背影与落日倒影有情调，但女孩仅及母腰，对照落空。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"绿匣、半悬袄、袋露短袖、钱包硬币俱全且可辨。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"傍晚江街、走向落日，袋堆与投衣层次清楚。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"画面清晰组织稳，倒影与袋堆繁而不杂。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题诗漏字句残，减2。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"投衣与仰头可辨，但短袖、兜钱等记忆线索全缺，余意薄。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"绿匣、半悬红衣、敞袋俱在，唯记忆性名物多处缺失。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"落日街边与投衣动作一致，催归仅靠仰头暗示。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"形体光线清楚，主次分明，无崩坏与粘连。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"箱体标语字形无误、切合不夺主，加1。"}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp19":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp19","topic":"社区食堂","order":["zhipu","bytedance","microsoft","xai","google","meta","openai"],"ok":true,"secs":198.7,"cost":0.066858,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"空椅留箸与半掩门、夕照构成静候关系，惟洗净杯盘缺席弱转折。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"一荤两素与双箸可辨，但洗净杯盘未画，门半掩靠开门见落日暗示。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"门外落日与墙上窗格光影同属傍晚西照，光向自洽。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体碗盘箸清晰，主次分明，无粘连断裂。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":1,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"墙上红纸伪字减1；窗格光影画穿窗加1。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"空桌留箸、沥水碗盘与半掩门并置，街上行人供画外待翁之想。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"一荤两素、双箸、洗净杯盘、半掩门俱可辨，指称无误。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"窗外落日、桌面斜光与门外街景暮色一致，傍晚证据互证。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体遮挡清晰，组织自洽，盘底红光略似特效未碍理解。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"匾牌字正确加2；盘底红光映桌点碗底红加2。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"座上老人已食削弱留箸待翁之候，余意靠题诗补足。","意象物象":6,"意象物象_评":"荤素、双箸、堆叠杯盘与半掩门可辨，待翁未至之意含混。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"窗外落日与室内暮光一致，食桌、洗涮区方位清楚。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"插画组织清楚，惟黑板报乱码字分散注意。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"黑板报伪字减2；题诗抄对不加分。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"空桌留箸、半掩门与夕照共成静候，无人而待翁之意可辨。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"荤素合置一盘稍含混，洗净杯盘仅水盆弱指，余皆可辨。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"窗与门同见落日，傍晚光候一致，动作关系简而自洽。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"水彩形体可辨，遮挡连贯，无生成缺陷。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"汤面映落日妙写碗底红加2；题诗抄对不加分。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"老翁持箸望窗笑属通用温情符号，留箸待翁之诗眼落空。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"双箸为自用非留待，荤菜不明，洗净杯盘与半掩门俱弱。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"窗外落日与室内暮光一致，食客动作施受清楚。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"摄影感清晰，主次分明，无碍理解缺陷。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":1,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"中英招牌字无误切合加1。"},{"id":6,"意境情感":9,"意境情感_评":"叠盘倒扣杯示洗净，空椅留箸与半掩门共成收毕仍待之转折。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"一荤两素、双箸、洗净杯盘、半掩门俱确，惟桌菜与菜单小不符。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"窗侧光束与门外暮巷同证傍晚，光向与位置一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体清晰组织稳，水珠扣杯等细节可辨。","神来之笔":1,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"墙纸字无误加2；倒扣杯叠盘与空椅留箸成待意加1。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":5,"意境情感_评":"满座食客热闹削弱静候，前景残席留箸之待意含混。","意象物象":5,"意象物象_评":"残盘未洗与洗净杯盘抵触，留箸与荤素靠菜单勉强指认。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"窗外落日与室内暮光一致，人物动作关系可读。","画面质量":7,"画面质量_评":"信息偏满但主体可辨，文字多而未遮核心。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"多处招牌菜单字无误切合加2。"}]}},"qwen3.8-max_shp20":{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","id":"shp20","topic":"社区食堂","order":["xai","microsoft","openai","bytedance","zhipu","meta","google"],"ok":true,"secs":247.1,"cost":0.080868,"attempts":1,"parsed":{"images":[{"id":1,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"窗口递碗与桌边白发笑语成关系，惟雨冷对照无视觉回应。","意象物象":7,"意象物象_评":"餐价榜含笋尖汤、厨娘蓝衣俱备，但明日菜、软饭添姜无线索。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"石板路湿反光作雨候弱证，窗内外与送餐行进方向一致。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"形体遮挡清晰，榜文车箱主次组织清楚，无碍理解缺陷。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"榜文餐价、笋尖汤、低保户免费字形无误且切合诗义。"},{"id":2,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"雨丝湿巷与窗口接罐交接成立，笑语仅窗内一人，余意稍弱。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"软米饭榜、明日菜单、笋尖汤齐备，蓝衣作配送离去取盒含混。","时空场景":8,"时空场景_评":"雨丝、落叶、湿地共证秋冷，窗口内外与骑行方向一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体动作连续可辨，组织清楚，瑕疵仅在题款文字内容。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"题款抄诗错字漏句，如「白衣」「明日长」，讹脱明显。"},{"id":3,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"窗内双老笑语与窗外取盒并置，但视线不交，情调靠暖光蒸汽。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"软烂饭、笋尖汤、明日菜单、蓝衣取盒、白发临窗皆可辨。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"远人撑伞、路面湿光证雨，柜台取盒与窗内外方位一致。","画面质量":9,"画面质量_评":"形体与遮挡清楚，双黑板与人物主次分明，无生成缺陷。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"今日明日两菜单含软烂饭、笋尖汤，字确切合不夺主。"},{"id":4,"意境情感":6,"意境情感_评":"窗内团笑与窗外递碗有关系，但诗义多靠满墙牌文代讲。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"软嫩饭牌、车铃、笋碗、白发团笑俱备，羹姜仅以牌文点出。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"地湿反光作雨候弱证，冬衣证冷，窗内外与车旁动作一致。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"六七块榜牌密布、小字糊烂，分散注意但未遮蔽主体。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":2,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"墙字「民以为?天」讹、多牌小字糊讹，按文字失当罚。"},{"id":5,"意境情感":4,"意境情感_评":"四格逐句图解堆列场景，缺乏统一关系生成情调与余意。","意象物象":4,"意象物象_评":"厨娘画成男厨，临窗笑语主体错位，餐价单一失榜标之意。","时空场景":5,"时空场景_评":"分格分区可辨，但格间空间断裂，窗递汤与桌笑关系模糊。","画面质量":6,"画面质量_评":"分格规则可辨、形体清楚，锅勺与手部关系局部含混。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":0,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":""},{"id":6,"意境情感":8,"意境情感_评":"隔窗厨娘与白发老妇笑语细说，门口蓝衣抱盒急行，关系紧密。","意象物象":9,"意象物象_评":"笋锅、姜片荐纸、煮软榜文、车铃、蓝衣、厨娘白发皆可辨。","时空场景":9,"时空场景_评":"雨丝湿巷与室内暖灶对照，门-灶-窗层次与动作一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"主体动作清晰可辨，门口人与车稍挤、背景晾衣略杂。","神来之笔":2,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"笋锅蒸汽升于隔窗笑语之间点出诗眼；榜文字确切合。"},{"id":7,"意境情感":7,"意境情感_评":"窗口双妇笑语视线交接好，但车铃急仅凭停放电动车弱响。","意象物象":8,"意象物象_评":"软饭姜丝汤榜、明日笋尖汤条、厨娘白发俱备，雨证偏弱。","时空场景":7,"时空场景_评":"冬衣冷候明确而雨仅阴天微湿，巷纵深与窗口方位一致。","画面质量":8,"画面质量_评":"形体与遮挡清楚，巷内人物主次分明，文字清晰可读。","神来之笔":0,"画面文字_加":2,"画面文字_减":0,"硬伤穿帮":0,"AI伪影":0,"加减分_评":"黑板软饭姜丝汤、红条明日笋尖汤字形无误且切合。"}]}}},"score":{"board":[{"rank":1,"seat":"meta","name":"Meta","model":"muse-image","score":76.1,"lo":72.0,"hi":80.0,"n":20,"tied":true},{"rank":1,"seat":"openai","name":"OpenAI","model":"gpt-image-2.5-sunburst","score":76.1,"lo":70.0,"hi":81.2,"n":20,"tied":true},{"rank":3,"seat":"alibaba","name":"阿里","model":"qwen-image-3-pro","score":74.1,"lo":69.5,"hi":78.6,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":4,"seat":"xai","name":"xAI","model":"grok-imagine-image-2.0","score":67.6,"lo":62.7,"hi":72.3,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":5,"seat":"microsoft","name":"微软","model":"mai-image-2.6","score":63.0,"lo":57.9,"hi":68.1,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":6,"seat":"bytedance","name":"字节","model":"seedream-5-0-pro","score":62.4,"lo":57.4,"hi":67.1,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":7,"seat":"google","name":"Google","model":"gemini-3.1-flash-image","score":60.1,"lo":55.7,"hi":64.4,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":8,"seat":"zhipu","name":"智谱","model":"glm-image","score":41.2,"lo":37.6,"hi":44.2,"n":20,"tied":false}],"board_raw":[{"rank":1,"seat":"meta","name":"Meta","model":"muse-image","score":76.3,"lo":72.2,"hi":80.1,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":2,"seat":"openai","name":"OpenAI","model":"gpt-image-2.5-sunburst","score":75.0,"lo":68.8,"hi":79.9,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":3,"seat":"alibaba","name":"阿里","model":"qwen-image-3-pro","score":73.2,"lo":68.6,"hi":77.8,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":4,"seat":"xai","name":"xAI","model":"grok-imagine-image-2.0","score":67.5,"lo":62.5,"hi":72.3,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":5,"seat":"bytedance","name":"字节","model":"seedream-5-0-pro","score":65.3,"lo":60.3,"hi":70.1,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":6,"seat":"microsoft","name":"微软","model":"mai-image-2.6","score":62.8,"lo":57.6,"hi":67.9,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":7,"seat":"google","name":"Google","model":"gemini-3.1-flash-image","score":60.6,"lo":56.3,"hi":64.8,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":8,"seat":"zhipu","name":"智谱","model":"glm-image","score":39.9,"lo":36.4,"hi":43.0,"n":20,"tied":false}],"board_deoff":[{"rank":1,"seat":"meta","name":"Meta","model":"muse-image","score":76.3,"lo":72.2,"hi":80.1,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":2,"seat":"openai","name":"OpenAI","model":"gpt-image-2.5-sunburst","score":76.0,"lo":69.9,"hi":81.0,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":3,"seat":"alibaba","name":"阿里","model":"qwen-image-3-pro","score":74.2,"lo":69.6,"hi":78.8,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":4,"seat":"xai","name":"xAI","model":"grok-imagine-image-2.0","score":67.5,"lo":62.4,"hi":72.3,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":5,"seat":"microsoft","name":"微软","model":"mai-image-2.6","score":62.8,"lo":57.5,"hi":67.9,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":6,"seat":"bytedance","name":"字节","model":"seedream-5-0-pro","score":62.4,"lo":57.4,"hi":67.2,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":7,"seat":"google","name":"Google","model":"gemini-3.1-flash-image","score":60.2,"lo":55.9,"hi":64.4,"n":20,"tied":false},{"rank":8,"seat":"zhipu","name":"智谱","model":"glm-image","score":41.2,"lo":37.7,"hi":44.2,"n":20,"tied":false}],"judges":[{"judge":"glm-5v-turbo","given":75.3,"offset":7.77,"n":140},{"judge":"gpt-6-astra","given":69.3,"offset":6.73,"n":140},{"judge":"qwen3.8-max","given":69.2,"offset":6.27,"n":140},{"judge":"claude-fable-5.1","given":65.2,"offset":0.12,"n":160},{"judge":"gemini-3.8-flash","given":64.1,"offset":-1.96,"n":140},{"judge":"deepseek-vision","given":63.9,"offset":-1.44,"n":160},{"judge":"doubao-seed-2.1","given":50.4,"offset":-17.29,"n":140}],"position":{"slope_before":-0.691,"t_before":-2.5,"slope_after":-0.0,"t_after":-0.0,"n":1020},"per_image":{"bytedance|shp01":{"consensus":55.76,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":68.8,"deepseek-vision":40.8,"gemini-3.8-flash":53.3,"glm-5v-turbo":72.1,"gpt-6-astra":56.3,"qwen3.8-max":67.6}},"xai|shp01":{"consensus":52.32,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":66.6,"deepseek-vision":34.2,"doubao-seed-2.1":25.7,"gemini-3.8-flash":46.8,"glm-5v-turbo":74.5,"gpt-6-astra":62.0,"qwen3.8-max":64.3}},"google|shp01":{"consensus":58.28,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":53.3,"deepseek-vision":48.7,"doubao-seed-2.1":48.9,"glm-5v-turbo":55.4,"gpt-6-astra":83.2,"qwen3.8-max":69.9}},"alibaba|shp01":{"consensus":57.55,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":53.2,"deepseek-vision":37.5,"doubao-seed-2.1":32.4,"gemini-3.8-flash":49.9,"glm-5v-turbo":73.3,"gpt-6-astra":92.9}},"meta|shp01":{"consensus":71.77,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":83.2,"deepseek-vision":40.9,"doubao-seed-2.1":64.4,"gemini-3.8-flash":58.8,"glm-5v-turbo":84.5,"gpt-6-astra":74.3,"qwen3.8-max":89.6}},"openai|shp01":{"consensus":71.01,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":67.6,"deepseek-vision":62.1,"doubao-seed-2.1":58.9,"gemini-3.8-flash":60.0,"glm-5v-turbo":96.3,"qwen3.8-max":75.3}},"zhipu|shp01":{"consensus":31.85,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":36.7,"deepseek-vision":31.0,"doubao-seed-2.1":10.4,"gemini-3.8-flash":33.4,"gpt-6-astra":28.7,"qwen3.8-max":35.7}},"microsoft|shp01":{"consensus":43.45,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":50.2,"deepseek-vision":33.2,"doubao-seed-2.1":20.4,"gemini-3.8-flash":42.3,"glm-5v-turbo":59.9,"gpt-6-astra":43.4,"qwen3.8-max":46.7}},"google|shp02":{"consensus":62.8,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":61.0,"deepseek-vision":43.2,"doubao-seed-2.1":59.9,"glm-5v-turbo":76.5,"gpt-6-astra":54.2,"qwen3.8-max":85.5}},"meta|shp02":{"consensus":58.2,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":72.2,"deepseek-vision":44.4,"doubao-seed-2.1":31.1,"gemini-3.8-flash":89.8,"glm-5v-turbo":52.2,"gpt-6-astra":63.4,"qwen3.8-max":53.2}},"microsoft|shp02":{"consensus":60.86,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":58.9,"deepseek-vision":48.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":41.3,"gemini-3.8-flash":52.0,"glm-5v-turbo":78.5,"gpt-6-astra":59.7,"qwen3.8-max":83.1}},"alibaba|shp02":{"consensus":81.61,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":89.8,"deepseek-vision":49.9,"doubao-seed-2.1":64.3,"gemini-3.8-flash":95.4,"glm-5v-turbo":93.1,"gpt-6-astra":93.1}},"openai|shp02":{"consensus":73.13,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":59.0,"deepseek-vision":69.8,"doubao-seed-2.1":51.2,"gemini-3.8-flash":72.2,"glm-5v-turbo":96.4,"qwen3.8-max":84.3}},"bytedance|shp02":{"consensus":53.59,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":58.7,"deepseek-vision":42.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":52.0,"glm-5v-turbo":69.6,"gpt-6-astra":53.1,"qwen3.8-max":67.7}},"xai|shp02":{"consensus":59.51,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":48.8,"deepseek-vision":58.7,"doubao-seed-2.1":73.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":56.6,"glm-5v-turbo":58.7,"gpt-6-astra":53.1,"qwen3.8-max":63.1}},"zhipu|shp02":{"consensus":41.54,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":43.2,"deepseek-vision":57.8,"doubao-seed-2.1":27.7,"gemini-3.8-flash":33.2,"gpt-6-astra":32.0,"qwen3.8-max":49.8}},"microsoft|shp03":{"consensus":77.93,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":79.0,"deepseek-vision":76.8,"doubao-seed-2.1":37.2,"gemini-3.8-flash":74.7,"glm-5v-turbo":95.0,"gpt-6-astra":85.6,"qwen3.8-max":94.0}},"openai|shp03":{"consensus":84.58,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":73.3,"deepseek-vision":76.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":93.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":88.7,"glm-5v-turbo":86.6,"qwen3.8-max":82.0}},"google|shp03":{"consensus":47.5,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":54.6,"deepseek-vision":54.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":15.1,"glm-5v-turbo":46.9,"gpt-6-astra":59.0,"qwen3.8-max":59.0}},"zhipu|shp03":{"consensus":45.64,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":40.5,"deepseek-vision":54.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":26.1,"gemini-3.8-flash":44.7,"gpt-6-astra":45.8,"qwen3.8-max":61.4}},"meta|shp03":{"consensus":73.22,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":81.0,"deepseek-vision":71.0,"doubao-seed-2.1":51.3,"gemini-3.8-flash":73.2,"glm-5v-turbo":73.2,"gpt-6-astra":86.6,"qwen3.8-max":76.5}},"alibaba|shp03":{"consensus":82.43,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":86.5,"deepseek-vision":64.5,"doubao-seed-2.1":86.6,"gemini-3.8-flash":92.0,"glm-5v-turbo":69.8,"gpt-6-astra":93.2}},"xai|shp03":{"consensus":63.37,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":64.5,"deepseek-vision":60.9,"doubao-seed-2.1":23.9,"gemini-3.8-flash":58.9,"glm-5v-turbo":85.3,"gpt-6-astra":66.5,"qwen3.8-max":77.6}},"bytedance|shp03":{"consensus":73.17,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":56.7,"deepseek-vision":75.5,"gemini-3.8-flash":62.1,"glm-5v-turbo":93.0,"gpt-6-astra":77.7,"qwen3.8-max":88.7}},"zhipu|shp04":{"consensus":29.63,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":27.9,"deepseek-vision":32.4,"doubao-seed-2.1":23.5,"gemini-3.8-flash":36.7,"gpt-6-astra":27.8,"qwen3.8-max":24.6}},"xai|shp04":{"consensus":68.84,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":73.3,"deepseek-vision":69.9,"doubao-seed-2.1":54.7,"gemini-3.8-flash":62.3,"glm-5v-turbo":97.4,"gpt-6-astra":52.0,"qwen3.8-max":67.7}},"google|shp04":{"consensus":77.21,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":79.7,"deepseek-vision":83.0,"doubao-seed-2.1":41.2,"glm-5v-turbo":88.6,"gpt-6-astra":90.8,"qwen3.8-max":78.6}},"alibaba|shp04":{"consensus":85.28,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":72.0,"deepseek-vision":83.1,"doubao-seed-2.1":89.6,"gemini-3.8-flash":94.0,"glm-5v-turbo":82.1,"gpt-6-astra":87.5}},"bytedance|shp04":{"consensus":50.07,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":54.4,"deepseek-vision":64.3,"gemini-3.8-flash":41.3,"glm-5v-turbo":72.3,"gpt-6-astra":36.5,"qwen3.8-max":45.6}},"meta|shp04":{"consensus":63.93,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":54.4,"deepseek-vision":92.9,"doubao-seed-2.1":30.2,"gemini-3.8-flash":38.9,"glm-5v-turbo":85.3,"gpt-6-astra":67.6,"qwen3.8-max":81.9}},"openai|shp04":{"consensus":39.7,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":43.5,"deepseek-vision":46.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":28.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":34.8,"glm-5v-turbo":40.2,"qwen3.8-max":39.9}},"microsoft|shp04":{"consensus":68.08,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":56.9,"deepseek-vision":91.9,"doubao-seed-2.1":29.2,"gemini-3.8-flash":73.5,"glm-5v-turbo":72.4,"gpt-6-astra":68.0,"qwen3.8-max":86.3}},"google|shp05":{"consensus":43.55,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":48.1,"deepseek-vision":39.9,"doubao-seed-2.1":18.1,"glm-5v-turbo":43.2,"gpt-6-astra":73.4,"qwen3.8-max":43.5}},"microsoft|shp05":{"consensus":49.52,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":58.0,"deepseek-vision":66.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":17.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":46.8,"glm-5v-turbo":44.5,"gpt-6-astra":59.1,"qwen3.8-max":53.5}},"meta|shp05":{"consensus":76.59,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":81.0,"deepseek-vision":74.4,"doubao-seed-2.1":60.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":81.1,"glm-5v-turbo":77.7,"gpt-6-astra":87.7,"qwen3.8-max":80.0}},"zhipu|shp05":{"consensus":22.19,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":23.8,"deepseek-vision":32.1,"doubao-seed-2.1":10.4,"gemini-3.8-flash":2.8,"gpt-6-astra":28.0,"qwen3.8-max":21.5}},"openai|shp05":{"consensus":87.48,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":85.3,"deepseek-vision":89.8,"doubao-seed-2.1":57.9,"gemini-3.8-flash":99.7,"glm-5v-turbo":93.0,"qwen3.8-max":91.9}},"alibaba|shp05":{"consensus":73.0,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":75.4,"deepseek-vision":71.0,"doubao-seed-2.1":58.9,"gemini-3.8-flash":68.9,"glm-5v-turbo":76.3,"gpt-6-astra":78.6}},"xai|shp05":{"consensus":72.99,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":67.8,"deepseek-vision":61.1,"doubao-seed-2.1":71.1,"gemini-3.8-flash":77.7,"glm-5v-turbo":67.7,"gpt-6-astra":87.6,"qwen3.8-max":84.4}},"bytedance|shp05":{"consensus":41.97,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":52.3,"deepseek-vision":46.5,"gemini-3.8-flash":22.5,"glm-5v-turbo":51.0,"gpt-6-astra":47.6,"qwen3.8-max":46.6}},"xai|shp06":{"consensus":78.11,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":78.7,"deepseek-vision":77.7,"doubao-seed-2.1":46.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":83.5,"glm-5v-turbo":84.4,"gpt-6-astra":86.7,"qwen3.8-max":86.6}},"openai|shp06":{"consensus":82.94,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":63.2,"deepseek-vision":77.7,"doubao-seed-2.1":94.1,"gemini-3.8-flash":86.6,"glm-5v-turbo":86.7,"qwen3.8-max":87.6}},"bytedance|shp06":{"consensus":71.14,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":60.0,"deepseek-vision":78.7,"gemini-3.8-flash":73.4,"glm-5v-turbo":75.3,"gpt-6-astra":75.6,"qwen3.8-max":82.0}},"google|shp06":{"consensus":64.58,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":65.6,"deepseek-vision":61.1,"doubao-seed-2.1":53.5,"glm-5v-turbo":92.9,"gpt-6-astra":57.5,"qwen3.8-max":59.0}},"microsoft|shp06":{"consensus":70.42,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":64.6,"deepseek-vision":74.2,"doubao-seed-2.1":35.9,"gemini-3.8-flash":75.6,"glm-5v-turbo":77.6,"gpt-6-astra":84.6,"qwen3.8-max":80.0}},"meta|shp06":{"consensus":70.11,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":81.0,"deepseek-vision":78.8,"doubao-seed-2.1":46.9,"gemini-3.8-flash":58.9,"glm-5v-turbo":79.9,"gpt-6-astra":69.9,"qwen3.8-max":77.7}},"zhipu|shp06":{"consensus":46.11,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":49.0,"deepseek-vision":53.5,"doubao-seed-2.1":20.5,"gemini-3.8-flash":44.5,"gpt-6-astra":58.8,"qwen3.8-max":43.4}},"alibaba|shp06":{"consensus":89.28,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":91.9,"deepseek-vision":87.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":78.8,"gemini-3.8-flash":93.0,"glm-5v-turbo":76.7,"gpt-6-astra":97.4}},"meta|shp07":{"consensus":91.38,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":83.1,"deepseek-vision":89.7,"doubao-seed-2.1":92.8,"gemini-3.8-flash":93.0,"glm-5v-turbo":97.3,"gpt-6-astra":99.5,"qwen3.8-max":87.3}},"google|shp07":{"consensus":63.25,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":57.8,"deepseek-vision":68.9,"doubao-seed-2.1":59.9,"glm-5v-turbo":51.0,"gpt-6-astra":78.8,"qwen3.8-max":66.6}},"zhipu|shp07":{"consensus":49.84,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":45.5,"deepseek-vision":67.9,"doubao-seed-2.1":52.1,"gemini-3.8-flash":29.9,"gpt-6-astra":45.4,"qwen3.8-max":49.9}},"alibaba|shp07":{"consensus":62.5,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":64.4,"deepseek-vision":64.4,"doubao-seed-2.1":61.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":55.5,"glm-5v-turbo":71.1,"gpt-6-astra":53.2}},"bytedance|shp07":{"consensus":66.97,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":72.1,"deepseek-vision":79.8,"gemini-3.8-flash":51.2,"glm-5v-turbo":66.4,"gpt-6-astra":77.5,"qwen3.8-max":76.4}},"microsoft|shp07":{"consensus":49.26,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":52.5,"deepseek-vision":54.4,"doubao-seed-2.1":12.8,"gemini-3.8-flash":33.5,"glm-5v-turbo":30.5,"gpt-6-astra":81.2,"qwen3.8-max":76.7}},"xai|shp07":{"consensus":56.55,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":62.1,"deepseek-vision":82.0,"doubao-seed-2.1":24.8,"gemini-3.8-flash":36.7,"glm-5v-turbo":78.6,"gpt-6-astra":49.9,"qwen3.8-max":56.5}},"openai|shp07":{"consensus":70.86,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":65.6,"deepseek-vision":78.8,"doubao-seed-2.1":63.3,"gemini-3.8-flash":46.6,"glm-5v-turbo":97.4,"qwen3.8-max":67.6}},"meta|shp08":{"consensus":77.49,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":85.3,"deepseek-vision":66.5,"doubao-seed-2.1":47.8,"gemini-3.8-flash":100.0,"glm-5v-turbo":78.7,"gpt-6-astra":78.8,"qwen3.8-max":86.3}},"xai|shp08":{"consensus":69.38,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":71.3,"deepseek-vision":59.9,"doubao-seed-2.1":58.8,"gemini-3.8-flash":62.2,"glm-5v-turbo":87.7,"gpt-6-astra":70.3,"qwen3.8-max":76.4}},"openai|shp08":{"consensus":86.36,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":79.9,"deepseek-vision":78.9,"doubao-seed-2.1":90.9,"gemini-3.8-flash":94.3,"glm-5v-turbo":84.2,"qwen3.8-max":84.1}},"google|shp08":{"consensus":58.83,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":62.2,"deepseek-vision":53.2,"doubao-seed-2.1":48.8,"glm-5v-turbo":68.7,"gpt-6-astra":67.3,"qwen3.8-max":54.2}},"zhipu|shp08":{"consensus":47.46,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":52.2,"deepseek-vision":40.9,"doubao-seed-2.1":36.6,"gemini-3.8-flash":31.3,"gpt-6-astra":60.8,"qwen3.8-max":58.8}},"bytedance|shp08":{"consensus":35.78,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":38.8,"deepseek-vision":47.7,"gemini-3.8-flash":21.3,"glm-5v-turbo":38.8,"gpt-6-astra":38.6,"qwen3.8-max":42.1}},"microsoft|shp08":{"consensus":47.62,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":55.9,"deepseek-vision":57.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":28.8,"gemini-3.8-flash":27.0,"glm-5v-turbo":57.6,"gpt-6-astra":45.7,"qwen3.8-max":61.0}},"alibaba|shp08":{"consensus":79.8,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":77.7,"deepseek-vision":75.5,"doubao-seed-2.1":61.1,"gemini-3.8-flash":89.8,"glm-5v-turbo":71.2,"gpt-6-astra":97.4}},"bytedance|shp09":{"consensus":71.86,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":76.6,"deepseek-vision":80.9,"gemini-3.8-flash":86.4,"glm-5v-turbo":67.6,"gpt-6-astra":56.4,"qwen3.8-max":78.6}},"alibaba|shp09":{"consensus":71.42,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":66.6,"deepseek-vision":73.3,"doubao-seed-2.1":66.6,"gemini-3.8-flash":83.3,"glm-5v-turbo":72.2,"gpt-6-astra":66.6}},"google|shp09":{"consensus":56.48,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":67.8,"deepseek-vision":63.3,"doubao-seed-2.1":33.2,"glm-5v-turbo":43.4,"gpt-6-astra":66.7,"qwen3.8-max":66.6}},"xai|shp09":{"consensus":52.42,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":53.7,"deepseek-vision":70.2,"doubao-seed-2.1":37.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":37.0,"glm-5v-turbo":71.1,"gpt-6-astra":40.5,"qwen3.8-max":57.0}},"microsoft|shp09":{"consensus":79.2,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":80.0,"deepseek-vision":86.5,"doubao-seed-2.1":66.8,"gemini-3.8-flash":73.5,"glm-5v-turbo":96.2,"gpt-6-astra":71.5,"qwen3.8-max":84.3}},"meta|shp09":{"consensus":80.26,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":75.5,"deepseek-vision":81.0,"doubao-seed-2.1":72.2,"gemini-3.8-flash":91.0,"glm-5v-turbo":92.0,"gpt-6-astra":56.6,"qwen3.8-max":91.0}},"zhipu|shp09":{"consensus":44.7,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":45.8,"deepseek-vision":33.8,"doubao-seed-2.1":39.2,"gemini-3.8-flash":44.6,"gpt-6-astra":40.1,"qwen3.8-max":55.7}},"openai|shp09":{"consensus":84.91,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":81.0,"deepseek-vision":72.2,"doubao-seed-2.1":93.1,"gemini-3.8-flash":92.0,"glm-5v-turbo":81.1,"qwen3.8-max":80.0}},"microsoft|shp10":{"consensus":54.65,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":63.4,"deepseek-vision":67.7,"doubao-seed-2.1":43.7,"gemini-3.8-flash":51.2,"glm-5v-turbo":43.7,"gpt-6-astra":50.0,"qwen3.8-max":62.4}},"meta|shp10":{"consensus":70.83,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":72.1,"deepseek-vision":72.0,"doubao-seed-2.1":71.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":67.7,"glm-5v-turbo":60.0,"gpt-6-astra":77.6,"qwen3.8-max":79.8}},"bytedance|shp10":{"consensus":79.58,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":69.9,"deepseek-vision":82.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":93.0,"glm-5v-turbo":97.4,"gpt-6-astra":86.5,"qwen3.8-max":67.5}},"alibaba|shp10":{"consensus":57.0,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":60.1,"deepseek-vision":65.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":43.7,"gemini-3.8-flash":59.0,"glm-5v-turbo":47.7,"gpt-6-astra":64.6}},"google|shp10":{"consensus":54.44,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":74.5,"deepseek-vision":62.3,"doubao-seed-2.1":30.6,"glm-5v-turbo":25.5,"gpt-6-astra":75.4,"qwen3.8-max":57.7}},"zhipu|shp10":{"consensus":37.63,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":46.7,"deepseek-vision":45.4,"doubao-seed-2.1":13.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":30.1,"gpt-6-astra":35.4,"qwen3.8-max":45.5}},"openai|shp10":{"consensus":92.84,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":88.5,"deepseek-vision":77.5,"doubao-seed-2.1":93.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":96.3,"glm-5v-turbo":99.5,"qwen3.8-max":92.9}},"xai|shp10":{"consensus":78.32,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":71.2,"deepseek-vision":79.9,"doubao-seed-2.1":44.9,"gemini-3.8-flash":88.7,"glm-5v-turbo":93.0,"gpt-6-astra":89.8,"qwen3.8-max":78.9}},"zhipu|shp11":{"consensus":43.89,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":46.8,"deepseek-vision":61.2,"doubao-seed-2.1":14.9,"gemini-3.8-flash":29.1,"gpt-6-astra":52.4,"qwen3.8-max":51.3}},"meta|shp11":{"consensus":82.37,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":78.7,"deepseek-vision":82.2,"doubao-seed-2.1":80.9,"gemini-3.8-flash":96.3,"glm-5v-turbo":86.6,"gpt-6-astra":88.7,"qwen3.8-max":65.5}},"openai|shp11":{"consensus":70.34,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":53.4,"deepseek-vision":71.2,"doubao-seed-2.1":62.1,"gemini-3.8-flash":73.2,"glm-5v-turbo":75.4,"qwen3.8-max":78.8}},"google|shp11":{"consensus":62.52,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":67.9,"deepseek-vision":74.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":25.9,"glm-5v-turbo":62.1,"gpt-6-astra":79.9,"qwen3.8-max":71.0}},"alibaba|shp11":{"consensus":80.57,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":79.9,"deepseek-vision":66.7,"doubao-seed-2.1":92.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":68.8,"glm-5v-turbo":69.9,"gpt-6-astra":100.0}},"xai|shp11":{"consensus":89.58,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":83.0,"deepseek-vision":73.2,"doubao-seed-2.1":100.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":93.0,"glm-5v-turbo":88.6,"gpt-6-astra":94.2,"qwen3.8-max":93.9}},"microsoft|shp11":{"consensus":79.31,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":73.2,"deepseek-vision":76.4,"doubao-seed-2.1":56.6,"gemini-3.8-flash":81.0,"glm-5v-turbo":100.0,"gpt-6-astra":75.3,"qwen3.8-max":89.5}},"bytedance|shp11":{"consensus":56.73,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":43.4,"deepseek-vision":45.5,"gemini-3.8-flash":44.7,"glm-5v-turbo":98.6,"gpt-6-astra":64.4,"qwen3.8-max":61.2}},"meta|shp12":{"consensus":75.61,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":54.3,"deepseek-vision":77.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":63.2,"gemini-3.8-flash":92.1,"glm-5v-turbo":93.3,"gpt-6-astra":82.0,"qwen3.8-max":78.8}},"bytedance|shp12":{"consensus":53.51,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":56.8,"deepseek-vision":51.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":32.4,"glm-5v-turbo":68.8,"gpt-6-astra":77.6,"qwen3.8-max":51.2}},"microsoft|shp12":{"consensus":50.79,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":38.1,"deepseek-vision":52.0,"doubao-seed-2.1":36.8,"gemini-3.8-flash":53.4,"glm-5v-turbo":73.0,"gpt-6-astra":63.6,"qwen3.8-max":44.4}},"alibaba|shp12":{"consensus":82.9,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":80.9,"deepseek-vision":69.7,"doubao-seed-2.1":78.7,"gemini-3.8-flash":81.1,"glm-5v-turbo":87.6,"gpt-6-astra":97.4}},"openai|shp12":{"consensus":93.37,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":80.8,"deepseek-vision":88.5,"doubao-seed-2.1":94.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":100.0,"glm-5v-turbo":94.3,"qwen3.8-max":91.9}},"xai|shp12":{"consensus":41.11,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":41.3,"deepseek-vision":52.4,"doubao-seed-2.1":20.4,"gemini-3.8-flash":29.1,"glm-5v-turbo":68.6,"gpt-6-astra":31.0,"qwen3.8-max":41.1}},"zhipu|shp12":{"consensus":45.7,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":49.0,"deepseek-vision":45.4,"doubao-seed-2.1":21.3,"gemini-3.8-flash":44.5,"gpt-6-astra":46.8,"qwen3.8-max":49.9}},"google|shp12":{"consensus":71.74,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":70.0,"deepseek-vision":77.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":48.9,"glm-5v-turbo":83.3,"gpt-6-astra":77.8,"qwen3.8-max":72.2}},"meta|shp13":{"consensus":82.98,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":93.0,"deepseek-vision":76.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":94.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":84.1,"glm-5v-turbo":54.3,"gpt-6-astra":97.4,"qwen3.8-max":83.1}},"zhipu|shp13":{"consensus":34.42,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":39.1,"deepseek-vision":37.9,"doubao-seed-2.1":19.4,"gemini-3.8-flash":26.8,"gpt-6-astra":40.2,"qwen3.8-max":34.8}},"xai|shp13":{"consensus":72.29,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":71.0,"deepseek-vision":84.4,"doubao-seed-2.1":66.7,"gemini-3.8-flash":88.7,"glm-5v-turbo":58.8,"gpt-6-astra":74.3,"qwen3.8-max":61.0}},"microsoft|shp13":{"consensus":79.1,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":72.3,"deepseek-vision":74.4,"doubao-seed-2.1":71.1,"gemini-3.8-flash":90.9,"glm-5v-turbo":76.5,"gpt-6-astra":85.4,"qwen3.8-max":85.4}},"openai|shp13":{"consensus":74.49,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":69.8,"deepseek-vision":67.8,"doubao-seed-2.1":64.4,"gemini-3.8-flash":78.7,"glm-5v-turbo":77.8,"qwen3.8-max":79.8}},"alibaba|shp13":{"consensus":59.62,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":83.2,"deepseek-vision":56.8,"doubao-seed-2.1":13.6,"gemini-3.8-flash":47.8,"glm-5v-turbo":49.8,"gpt-6-astra":94.2}},"bytedance|shp13":{"consensus":70.67,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":73.1,"deepseek-vision":69.9,"gemini-3.8-flash":71.0,"glm-5v-turbo":94.0,"gpt-6-astra":75.4,"qwen3.8-max":64.3}},"google|shp13":{"consensus":67.12,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":70.0,"deepseek-vision":75.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":61.2,"glm-5v-turbo":73.3,"gpt-6-astra":64.3,"qwen3.8-max":61.1}},"openai|shp14":{"consensus":84.24,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":84.3,"deepseek-vision":81.0,"doubao-seed-2.1":76.5,"gemini-3.8-flash":92.0,"glm-5v-turbo":91.1,"qwen3.8-max":78.8}},"microsoft|shp14":{"consensus":67.15,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":55.9,"deepseek-vision":70.1,"doubao-seed-2.1":59.1,"gemini-3.8-flash":56.9,"glm-5v-turbo":93.0,"gpt-6-astra":66.9,"qwen3.8-max":71.2}},"bytedance|shp14":{"consensus":75.56,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":68.9,"deepseek-vision":77.8,"gemini-3.8-flash":81.0,"glm-5v-turbo":93.1,"gpt-6-astra":68.9,"qwen3.8-max":83.2}},"zhipu|shp14":{"consensus":44.86,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":38.8,"deepseek-vision":67.7,"doubao-seed-2.1":34.6,"gemini-3.8-flash":32.4,"gpt-6-astra":43.2,"qwen3.8-max":42.1}},"alibaba|shp14":{"consensus":88.51,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":84.3,"deepseek-vision":75.5,"doubao-seed-2.1":87.6,"gemini-3.8-flash":93.0,"glm-5v-turbo":80.1,"gpt-6-astra":97.5}},"meta|shp14":{"consensus":80.99,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":88.7,"deepseek-vision":83.3,"doubao-seed-2.1":66.5,"gemini-3.8-flash":64.4,"glm-5v-turbo":81.1,"gpt-6-astra":89.9,"qwen3.8-max":89.8}},"xai|shp14":{"consensus":72.57,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":74.3,"deepseek-vision":85.4,"doubao-seed-2.1":33.3,"gemini-3.8-flash":67.6,"glm-5v-turbo":97.5,"gpt-6-astra":66.7,"qwen3.8-max":87.6}},"google|shp14":{"consensus":72.65,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":77.5,"deepseek-vision":82.0,"doubao-seed-2.1":51.1,"glm-5v-turbo":61.1,"gpt-6-astra":85.6,"qwen3.8-max":80.0}},"alibaba|shp15":{"consensus":55.77,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":57.8,"deepseek-vision":45.5,"doubao-seed-2.1":15.1,"gemini-3.8-flash":59.0,"glm-5v-turbo":59.6,"gpt-6-astra":90.8}},"google|shp15":{"consensus":45.79,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":44.6,"deepseek-vision":44.4,"doubao-seed-2.1":27.0,"glm-5v-turbo":71.9,"gpt-6-astra":57.6,"qwen3.8-max":35.5}},"microsoft|shp15":{"consensus":73.59,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":67.9,"deepseek-vision":79.7,"doubao-seed-2.1":32.7,"gemini-3.8-flash":93.0,"glm-5v-turbo":81.9,"gpt-6-astra":90.0,"qwen3.8-max":70.9}},"zhipu|shp15":{"consensus":41.13,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":40.0,"deepseek-vision":44.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":23.7,"gemini-3.8-flash":38.0,"gpt-6-astra":45.3,"qwen3.8-max":45.5}},"openai|shp15":{"consensus":68.02,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":71.0,"deepseek-vision":74.3,"doubao-seed-2.1":42.6,"gemini-3.8-flash":74.3,"glm-5v-turbo":65.4,"qwen3.8-max":77.4}},"bytedance|shp15":{"consensus":62.6,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":54.6,"deepseek-vision":76.5,"gemini-3.8-flash":50.1,"glm-5v-turbo":78.5,"gpt-6-astra":61.0,"qwen3.8-max":67.5}},"meta|shp15":{"consensus":86.52,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":73.1,"deepseek-vision":92.9,"doubao-seed-2.1":100.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":85.3,"glm-5v-turbo":90.6,"gpt-6-astra":72.1,"qwen3.8-max":91.9}},"xai|shp15":{"consensus":61.26,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":59.1,"deepseek-vision":64.3,"doubao-seed-2.1":45.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":43.8,"glm-5v-turbo":66.4,"gpt-6-astra":64.7,"qwen3.8-max":85.1}},"google|shp16":{"consensus":62.74,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":74.5,"deepseek-vision":67.5,"doubao-seed-2.1":67.7,"glm-5v-turbo":48.7,"gpt-6-astra":57.6,"qwen3.8-max":68.8}},"xai|shp16":{"consensus":73.05,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":77.7,"deepseek-vision":78.9,"doubao-seed-2.1":56.9,"gemini-3.8-flash":55.7,"glm-5v-turbo":97.4,"gpt-6-astra":61.2,"qwen3.8-max":90.0}},"microsoft|shp16":{"consensus":73.47,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":77.9,"deepseek-vision":63.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":40.3,"gemini-3.8-flash":67.7,"glm-5v-turbo":88.6,"gpt-6-astra":84.6,"qwen3.8-max":82.2}},"alibaba|shp16":{"consensus":77.91,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":71.0,"deepseek-vision":74.4,"doubao-seed-2.1":83.1,"gemini-3.8-flash":70.0,"glm-5v-turbo":81.0,"gpt-6-astra":83.2}},"zhipu|shp16":{"consensus":45.85,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":52.4,"deepseek-vision":51.1,"doubao-seed-2.1":28.8,"gemini-3.8-flash":40.2,"gpt-6-astra":56.7,"qwen3.8-max":42.4}},"meta|shp16":{"consensus":77.12,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":67.8,"deepseek-vision":78.9,"doubao-seed-2.1":63.4,"gemini-3.8-flash":64.5,"glm-5v-turbo":90.0,"gpt-6-astra":89.8,"qwen3.8-max":86.4}},"openai|shp16":{"consensus":62.22,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":62.1,"deepseek-vision":62.1,"doubao-seed-2.1":53.3,"gemini-3.8-flash":51.1,"glm-5v-turbo":67.5,"qwen3.8-max":66.5}},"bytedance|shp16":{"consensus":60.53,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":65.4,"deepseek-vision":64.3,"gemini-3.8-flash":49.9,"glm-5v-turbo":74.2,"gpt-6-astra":57.6,"qwen3.8-max":64.4}},"xai|shp17":{"consensus":76.4,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":72.1,"deepseek-vision":68.8,"doubao-seed-2.1":60.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":92.0,"glm-5v-turbo":75.6,"gpt-6-astra":92.1,"qwen3.8-max":78.6}},"zhipu|shp17":{"consensus":47.08,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":43.4,"deepseek-vision":53.3,"doubao-seed-2.1":23.3,"gemini-3.8-flash":38.9,"gpt-6-astra":58.6,"qwen3.8-max":62.2}},"bytedance|shp17":{"consensus":62.56,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":54.5,"deepseek-vision":63.3,"gemini-3.8-flash":58.7,"glm-5v-turbo":84.4,"gpt-6-astra":67.6,"qwen3.8-max":64.3}},"google|shp17":{"consensus":64.71,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":60.9,"deepseek-vision":55.4,"doubao-seed-2.1":50.0,"glm-5v-turbo":90.0,"gpt-6-astra":58.5,"qwen3.8-max":74.2}},"meta|shp17":{"consensus":70.31,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":59.9,"deepseek-vision":86.4,"doubao-seed-2.1":42.2,"gemini-3.8-flash":76.6,"glm-5v-turbo":83.4,"gpt-6-astra":74.3,"qwen3.8-max":71.0}},"openai|shp17":{"consensus":81.17,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":82.0,"deepseek-vision":77.7,"doubao-seed-2.1":75.4,"gemini-3.8-flash":92.0,"glm-5v-turbo":55.5,"qwen3.8-max":93.0}},"alibaba|shp17":{"consensus":75.89,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":77.7,"deepseek-vision":79.8,"doubao-seed-2.1":56.6,"gemini-3.8-flash":82.1,"glm-5v-turbo":54.4,"gpt-6-astra":98.6}},"microsoft|shp17":{"consensus":63.88,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":59.0,"deepseek-vision":79.8,"doubao-seed-2.1":28.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":55.3,"glm-5v-turbo":79.2,"gpt-6-astra":77.7,"qwen3.8-max":64.3}},"alibaba|shp18":{"consensus":80.75,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":85.3,"deepseek-vision":77.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":69.1,"gemini-3.8-flash":82.3,"glm-5v-turbo":71.0,"gpt-6-astra":98.6}},"meta|shp18":{"consensus":60.49,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":55.5,"deepseek-vision":55.5,"doubao-seed-2.1":80.9,"gemini-3.8-flash":25.7,"glm-5v-turbo":79.9,"gpt-6-astra":57.4,"qwen3.8-max":68.8}},"google|shp18":{"consensus":48.11,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":42.4,"deepseek-vision":55.4,"doubao-seed-2.1":11.8,"glm-5v-turbo":65.5,"gpt-6-astra":54.3,"qwen3.8-max":60.0}},"zhipu|shp18":{"consensus":28.66,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":35.7,"deepseek-vision":25.5,"doubao-seed-2.1":18.2,"gemini-3.8-flash":13.6,"gpt-6-astra":30.9,"qwen3.8-max":44.6}},"microsoft|shp18":{"consensus":57.78,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":61.3,"deepseek-vision":49.8,"doubao-seed-2.1":37.1,"gemini-3.8-flash":39.0,"glm-5v-turbo":77.7,"gpt-6-astra":62.4,"qwen3.8-max":71.2}},"bytedance|shp18":{"consensus":62.22,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":67.7,"deepseek-vision":48.7,"gemini-3.8-flash":46.7,"glm-5v-turbo":76.4,"gpt-6-astra":70.9,"qwen3.8-max":83.1}},"openai|shp18":{"consensus":64.52,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":55.6,"deepseek-vision":47.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":47.7,"gemini-3.8-flash":80.9,"glm-5v-turbo":76.7,"qwen3.8-max":66.5}},"xai|shp18":{"consensus":78.52,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":81.0,"deepseek-vision":64.3,"doubao-seed-2.1":55.7,"gemini-3.8-flash":93.0,"glm-5v-turbo":91.8,"gpt-6-astra":85.7,"qwen3.8-max":79.1}},"google|shp19":{"consensus":42.64,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":53.0,"deepseek-vision":28.8,"doubao-seed-2.1":28.8,"glm-5v-turbo":51.0,"gpt-6-astra":48.5,"qwen3.8-max":52.0}},"openai|shp19":{"consensus":63.87,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":66.5,"deepseek-vision":31.0,"doubao-seed-2.1":95.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":62.2,"glm-5v-turbo":65.4,"qwen3.8-max":58.6}},"meta|shp19":{"consensus":78.98,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":91.9,"deepseek-vision":44.3,"doubao-seed-2.1":67.8,"gemini-3.8-flash":78.7,"glm-5v-turbo":79.9,"gpt-6-astra":96.4,"qwen3.8-max":88.6}},"xai|shp19":{"consensus":66.75,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":77.6,"deepseek-vision":24.3,"doubao-seed-2.1":32.1,"gemini-3.8-flash":76.7,"glm-5v-turbo":93.1,"gpt-6-astra":76.7,"qwen3.8-max":78.7}},"zhipu|shp19":{"consensus":50.26,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":56.7,"deepseek-vision":38.8,"doubao-seed-2.1":29.9,"gemini-3.8-flash":44.5,"gpt-6-astra":57.5,"qwen3.8-max":70.0}},"alibaba|shp19":{"consensus":68.43,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":74.4,"deepseek-vision":39.9,"doubao-seed-2.1":48.9,"gemini-3.8-flash":92.0,"glm-5v-turbo":77.8,"gpt-6-astra":75.6}},"microsoft|shp19":{"consensus":48.82,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":57.9,"deepseek-vision":27.7,"doubao-seed-2.1":19.1,"gemini-3.8-flash":47.8,"glm-5v-turbo":55.7,"gpt-6-astra":72.3,"qwen3.8-max":60.1}},"bytedance|shp19":{"consensus":74.4,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":76.4,"deepseek-vision":35.4,"gemini-3.8-flash":76.6,"glm-5v-turbo":93.0,"gpt-6-astra":90.9,"qwen3.8-max":92.9}},"openai|shp20":{"consensus":86.24,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":86.3,"deepseek-vision":78.7,"doubao-seed-2.1":80.8,"gemini-3.8-flash":93.0,"glm-5v-turbo":89.6,"qwen3.8-max":85.2}},"google|shp20":{"consensus":76.15,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":73.2,"deepseek-vision":84.2,"doubao-seed-2.1":68.8,"glm-5v-turbo":67.7,"gpt-6-astra":88.7,"qwen3.8-max":76.4}},"bytedance|shp20":{"consensus":69.21,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":64.4,"deepseek-vision":72.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":75.6,"glm-5v-turbo":75.6,"gpt-6-astra":76.9,"qwen3.8-max":66.8}},"xai|shp20":{"consensus":68.79,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":75.2,"deepseek-vision":72.0,"doubao-seed-2.1":44.3,"gemini-3.8-flash":66.5,"glm-5v-turbo":77.7,"gpt-6-astra":69.8,"qwen3.8-max":74.2}},"meta|shp20":{"consensus":93.51,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":92.9,"deepseek-vision":88.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":94.0,"gemini-3.8-flash":100.0,"glm-5v-turbo":94.0,"gpt-6-astra":96.5,"qwen3.8-max":89.5}},"alibaba|shp20":{"consensus":71.19,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":78.7,"deepseek-vision":67.6,"doubao-seed-2.1":53.2,"gemini-3.8-flash":82.1,"glm-5v-turbo":67.5,"gpt-6-astra":75.4}},"microsoft|shp20":{"consensus":64.58,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":72.5,"deepseek-vision":55.5,"doubao-seed-2.1":29.1,"gemini-3.8-flash":73.7,"glm-5v-turbo":66.9,"gpt-6-astra":79.3,"qwen3.8-max":74.6}},"zhipu|shp20":{"consensus":45.41,"raw":{"claude-fable-5.1":42.3,"deepseek-vision":54.3,"doubao-seed-2.1":38.9,"gemini-3.8-flash":32.4,"gpt-6-astra":49.8,"qwen3.8-max":44.4}}}},"note":"画作为网页压缩版（长边 1280 像素）；字节席画作右下角「AI生成」角标已在评图前涂除（评图看到的也是涂除版）。逐图 consensus = 去评委尺度偏移、再做位置校正后的评委均分（诗画榜正式口径）；raw = 各评委原始总分。同门回避已在派单时执行（评委不评本厂画作）。"}